Season 1, episode 4

Character Archetypes (Part 1)

December 1, 201750 min

Show notes

What is a character archetype, and how does it work in a story? Adam and Devin start their tour of the archetypes from Joseph Campbell and Christopher Vogler with the characters who set a story in motion: the hero, the herald, the threshold guardian and the mentor.

In this episode

  • Tools and reflections. Archetypes are tools that get a writer out of a corner. They’re also reflections of the hero, showing the hero’s insides on the outside.
  • The hero. The character who tips the first domino, the most developed character, and the lens the audience experiences the story through.
  • The herald. Brings the call to adventure and sets the domino in front of the hero. A herald can be a letter, a radar screen or a soothsayer warning of the Ides of March.
  • The threshold guardian. Blocks the way at gates, borders and act breaks, testing the hero’s resourcefulness. Labyrinth’s Hoggle and Sir Didymus both end up as allies.
  • The mentor. Teaches the rules and tools of the unknown world. Morpheus does it brilliantly, and lazy writing just recites a list of rules.
  • Mentors who fell short. Adam’s idea: the mentor is a hero who didn’t fully recover from the crisis of their own story and passes on what they learned.
  • Blended archetypes. Gandalf is herald and mentor. Ali in The Karate Kid is herald, mentor and something of a shapeshifter.
  • Audiences are smart. Today’s story consumers have seen it all, so writers have to be more inventive.

Examples discussed

  • Labyrinth, The NeverEnding Story, The Wizard of Oz, Julius Caesar, Cinderella, The Perfect Storm, Armageddon, The Matrix, Star Wars, Rocky and Avatar.
  • Also: Lord of the Rings, The Karate Kid, Gladiator, Wedding Crashers, Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles, Dodgeball and Kingpin.

Next episode: allies, tricksters, shapeshifters and the shadow.

Read the full transcript

Transcribed automatically, so expect the odd misheard word. Sponsor messages are left out.

Adam: Next on StoryOsophy. Hello, welcome to StoryOsophy. This is Adam Jones.

Devin: And Devin Halden.

Adam: So Devin, last episode we were talking about character and character archetypes. And in this episode, we’re exploring more the roles of what character archetypes actually are and how they function within a story. So what defines a character archetype?

Devin: The character archetype basically tells us the role a certain character plays within a story. Great tools to keep in your writing toolbox. I’ve personally used them to bridge a gap in my story that was either preventing the story from moving forward or when a jump from one scene to another felt forced or disjointed. Each archetype gives the writer a way to introduce their characters, provide details about the world or worlds they’re building, and capture the heart of the story. All of this is essential for not only keeping the attention of the audience and their loyalty to writing this thing out with your character.

But it also makes the achievement of the goal at the end that much more gratifying. And that’s why really understanding what each archetype and their role is can really be an incredible tool. Even if you have writer’s block or you paint yourself into a corner, it helps move the story along or get you out of some of those sticky situations.

Adam: I also, for me, when I’m building the characters and looking at them and examining them from different angles, I like to see them as emanations of the hero. As sort of like reflections of what the hero is like inside, outside. Because the audience needs to access the hero’s internal workings in an external way, and so the archetypes allow that reflection of hero to be shown outside. Everybody has different facets to themselves that they could label or define themselves with. What’s great about the archetypes is the different dimensions of a person’s personality, who they are, how they operate, is allowed to be shown externally in the story.

So, as I gave a reference in a previous episode to a hero who is a brave hero, but he has an ally who’s the guy who’s like, I don’t want to go in there, and is the dubious ally. So, it’s a reflection of the hero’s own fear. And so, having that dialogue between the competent hero and the fearful ally allows us to understand the hero’s perspective on that fear. And so, in addition to what you’re saying as being just tools to the writer from a broader perspective, there are also emanations of the hero. They’re reflections of who the hero really is, whether it’s herald, or threshold guardian, or allies, or mentor, or shapeshifter, or trickster, or shadow. They all are some aspect of hero.

And so, that’s the reason why those tools are really effective. You can paint the image. You can paint the inside of your hero on the outside through the characters.

Devin: That’s part of the fun. If you sit down and you’re building the blueprint for your story. Say, for example, you have an incredible ending. It’s epic. It’s going to be a great climax. And you know what the goal is, what the hero wants to achieve. And then you figure out kind of where he’s got to begin. Understanding or kind of reviewing these archetypes provides a bunch of different… It can spawn a bunch of different creative ideas on the actual journey. Just by looking at what these characters do and what the role they’ll play within the story, you can actually start forming the blueprint or the path to that great epic climax by just really understanding where to put these characters.

And you don’t have to use every character. You don’t have to… Or you can use more than one herald, or threshold guardian, or… Things like that. So I think it’s at every stage of the writing process, going back and looking at what these archetypes do in their roles can be incredibly helpful.

Adam: There’s so many ways in which you can use them to refine the story, to move the story forward. And this is the last thing I’ll say before we move on to each individual archetype is there are story events. There’s a structure to… To a story. And then there are character archetypes. And they’re both very different. One is a personality and the other is an action, for lack of a better way of putting it. But both drive the story forward, as you’ve just said, in very different ways. So the event is not necessarily the catalyst. Usually a character is a catalyst for a hero.

Sometimes an event will present a choice, and that’s the catalyst. But events don’t just move the story forward. When we get into season two, where we’re examining structure, every event by every event, so we can mine the greatest of each event. The character archetypes are also not like events, but the same mechanism. They move the story forward. So archetypes and events are very pivotal in a basic toolbox structure. As you said so aptly earlier in the podcast, the toolbox. The toolbox.

Archetypes are a broad term for what we’re going to discuss in this episode. And events are a broad term for what we’re going to discuss in the structural season. Let’s get into each specific character archetype. Number one, the hero or protagonist, otherwise known as the main character. We’ll refer to this character by many, many names throughout our podcast, usually switching back and forth between them. We won’t spend too much time on the hero, because generally the hero is what we’ll talk about while we’re describing events and other things within a story. Before the break, what we’re going to aim for are all of the characters that set up the story, that bring the story into motion.

Now, they don’t necessarily disappear after the story’s in motion, but they’re part of the catalyst. They’re the mechanism in act one of any story. Devin, what would you say to start with defines a hero character archetype?

Devin: Like you alluded to, I think everyone gets, they understand what the hero and protagonist character is. I think that’s probably whether you’re a writer or not, you know, that’s the most. Used term and you understand what character that is. For me, they’re the character that tips the first domino and they get the events of the story moving forward and they do this. Through their decision to accept the call of the quest, which we’ll talk about when we get to the Herald character. But it’s essentially their story that begins the spine or the thread of the story, and they’re the ones that we’re going to follow. And it’s also, from a writing standpoint, the character that needs to be the most developed, since they will be on screen or on page more than any other character.

Adam: And they also need to be, as we discussed in the previous episode, relatable and have a clear want and desire. It’s the character that the audience experiences the story through, through their eyes. It’s an audience’s perspective. In addition, like you just said, it’s also the fact that this character will have the most development and growth throughout the story. We, as an audience, will witness the most change, and hopefully not just witness, but experience along with. Them in an empathetic way, the same journey that that character has. So the key to, I think, a good hero, the growth needs to be mappable, which is why the structure is vital. You can plug in any hero and see how their growth might be mappable.

Devin: Right. The hero is certainly the story we’re following, but it’s more important for us as an audience to also be emotionally invested in the decisions that they’re making. Right. Almost as if the hero is making the decision for both of us. So if the writer can pull off this attached relationship between the hero and the audience, every decision and every good or bad thing that happens to the hero along the journey will have great effect on the audience. We want our audience to feel everything the hero is feeling and want to defeat the antagonist as bad as the hero wants to defeat them. So when they do, when we attain the goal or achieve the mission we set out to achieve, we want the audience to feel everything the hero is feeling.

It is sweet victory. And when the audience walks out of the theater, closes the book, they feel triumphant just as the hero did.

Adam: And this is a totally different dynamic that we can talk about at another point in time, but the tension between the character that the audience is perceiving or experiencing and the audience themselves, the idea that the audience has conflict with the character’s choices is a totally… Right. Once again, it’s a rabbit hole we can go down. Not this episode, but it’s an interesting thing that you pose there. In the last episode, you gave the example of in an action-adventure movie when someone is in a situation, you may not want to be in their shoes. And that’s what makes that story enjoyable. So it’s that conflict between where the audience is and the character is and the choices both are making mentally. And there’s fun in that conflict as well.

Devin: You don’t want the… You don’t want the audience just to lean forward. You want them to squirm in their seats as well.

Adam: Or create the rollercoaster between those two points. Part of what I would call levity and gravity. You want that sort of up and down, that polarity. That’s what makes a story feel like it’s got momentum and movement is the audience experience. The point with the hero, it’s the way in which the audience accesses the story. There are a variety of heroes. There’s not just the classic white knight in traditional storytelling models of epic fairy tale or mythological storytelling, like is detailed in Joseph Campbell’s The Hero with a Thousand Faces or Christopher Vogler’s The Writer’s Journey, both of which we draw on heavily for this episode. They show the example of a very archetypal style of storytelling. The hero has the potential of becoming a greater version of themselves.

Or a lesser version of themselves, positive or negative. It’s based a lot in polarity. And for the sake of the audience, we need to have a clear lens. Now, the hero can, and we will discuss this later, morph into a variety of different heroes. The anti-hero, Walter White from Breaking Bad would be a great example of the anti-hero. There are many different ways in which a hero can be painted. But essentially, the hero is the lens through which the audience sees the story or experiences the story.

Beyond that, all the other character archetypes. Let’s start with the Herald. Devin, what do you think about the Herald?

Devin: I love the Herald character because I love writing the scenes of when the Herald character is introduced. Briefly, they’re either providing a warning or setting up the initial stakes of what’s happening, and they inform the hero about what must happen or be overcome in order to meet the story’s objective. And sometimes, they’ll have knowledge of the obstacles and some information about the antagonist, but not always because that’s often reserved for a mentor character. But as I touched on, I think they’re really one of the more… Maybe that’s just a personal preference, but it’s one of those moments in the story you can suck your audience in and get them emotionally invested in the story. Your Herald character has just showed up and laid everything out on the table. If the antagonist’s force is not stopped or changed or altered, this is going to happen. And these are some of the dangers, but not all of them because they’re not going to have all that information.

The stakes have been set, and although they seem daunting necessarily… Now, when we first hear about them in the story, the Herald will also suggest in some way that it’s going to get worse. So, where the hero knocks over the first domino when they make the decision to go out on the quest, like I talked about before, it’s the Herald character who actually shows up with that domino and sets it up in front of them. They’re the ones that bring the call to the quest or the call to the adventure and say, Look, this is it. Are you up for it or not?

Adam: I was going to say regarding the Herald, that’s the key scene for the Herald. The Herald… Only shows up in the call to adventure. That’s what they’re there for. That’s the purpose of that archetype. We’ll talk about how the Herald can branch out a little bit later in this podcast. But in terms of that, to me, and I don’t mean to get into semantics or anything, talking about as far as definitions of heroes or how events are set into place, we’ll sort of negotiate that regarding our perspectives throughout the podcast. But I think the Herald is the first domino. I think the Herald is the thing that sets everything…

Everything in motion to the hero. The Herald is great for that catalyst moment. The Herald can, of course, as we’re saying later on the podcast, can be different characters. It sets the domino in motion, in my opinion. And I also think that the Herald can have some of the traits, as you were mentioning, as the mentor, but it is strictly for the purpose of bringing the call to adventure, to the hero, for the catalyst, to the adventure, to whatever the situation is.

Devin: The Herald, to me, is a newsbringer. They’re the one saying, this is happening. I’m not the person. Don’t kill the messenger. I’m not them. I have information about what’s going to happen, about what needs to happen in order for this to stop. And you are the person, you, the hero, are the person charged to do that. Like, you’re the only one that can make this happen. I’m going to take this news. I’m going to…

Adam: You’re talking about the Herald in a very specific way. In a very specific scenario, though.

Devin: Let’s broaden the definition of the Herald a little bit. The Herald brings the, if we’re using this domino analogy, brings the domino, sets it in front of them and says, now it’s up to you. Do you want to go on a journey by, do you want to set the story in motion? If you do, then they knock over the domino.

Adam: So the Herald is presenting the hero with the option of tipping the domino, is what you’re saying.

Devin: Right.

Adam: We’re on the same page in terms of that. Because they need to accept the call. You know what? I 100% agree with you. The Herald presents the choice. Right. Clearly, the newsbringer to the audience and hero, and the hero must make the choice to tip said domino. Right. I might not have been clear. This is half our conversations, Devin. I know. We’re trying to articulate philosophy, and then we just end up sort of getting stuck in semantics. But we’re literally saying the same thing. That’s when you know it’s a good point. The thing I wanted to mention about the Herald before we move on is this.

Because you’ve mentioned certain things that the Herald can do. But a lot of those things are attributed to a mentor archetype traditionally. And we’ll get into that in a bit with mentor. We’ll expand on this concept. But the Herald doesn’t always present the rules. They don’t always present the mission. Generally, the stakes they do present, they’re a good newsbringer messenger of the stakes of the story. They’re a great, really great tool for that, as you mentioned. And they can bring those things you mentioned, but those are usually attributed to a mentor. Now, the crossover, we’ll talk about when we get to mentor. For the moment, let’s finish up with some of the other notions that make up a Herald, and also maybe some examples.

A Herald doesn’t always have to be a character, an actual person. A Herald, can be a letter, can be a bit of, as you said, a newsbringer and a bit of new information, an invitation, anything like that, a phone call. That can be the Herald. So it doesn’t have to be a character. It just has to be that catalyst, is the key word, to set the adventure or quest in motion, the story in motion, the main hero’s involvement, the tipping of the domino in motion. So my example of a Herald in Shakespeare’s Julius Caesar, the soothsayer, who in the beginning says, beware the Ides of March. This is not only foreshadowing. The reason I chose this is because it serves different purposes as the Herald. It’s not only the thing that makes the main character, Julius Caesar, aware of what’s happening, but it’s also foreshadowing, which is a really great way to use your Herald.

It’s not just saying, hey, you need to go on this quest to your main character. It’s also intimating to them or the audience, or even overtly saying, here’s what lies ahead. As you were saying, some of the rules, some of the information about the world. But I feel like the Herald is a wonderful place, if you’re focused on writing, to be a flirtatious writer. It’s probably why you like writing those scenes so much. They’re so much fun, because you get to play with your audience a little bit. Tease them a little bit. Give them just enough information and the character to make the decision to join the journey, to stay with the story, to read the book, to watch the movie.

Devin: And in other examples, when you were touching on inanimate objects as being Herald, as I think about that more, there’s an interesting characteristic or element when it is an inanimate object, like the invitation to the ball in Cinderella or

The weather radar signaling. Three storms converging in the perfect storm, or using another radar that indicates an asteroid the size of Texas on a collision course with Earth and Armageddon. They’re essentially… They’re essentially awesome examples of Heralds, I just have to say. Way better than mine. But what’s interesting when you think about them is, when there is an inanimate object as the initial Herald, we’ll say that, there is usually a secondary Herald character that must relay that news to the other characters. So in the form of the radar signaling, the three storms converging in the perfect storm… There’s a newscaster, right? There’s some… Yeah. Or there’s some scientists hopped up on coffee in Armageddon that’s explaining exactly what all of this data that’s coming into their computers is telling them about this asteroid.

So there’s… That’s an interesting… Interesting element, I think, of Heralds and an inanimate object as Heralds. There’s usually other people that take the place of a Herald in order to relay some information to characters.

Adam: You have to consider whether the three storms is the Herald, or that’s the event, and the communicator of the three storms is the Herald.

Devin: Well, I was saying the radar, not the storm. The storm is the antagonist.

Adam: And I hadn’t thought about it, so you just mentioned this. Maybe the sum of all those things is… Is the Herald. It’s not just the radar or the news broadcaster. It’s both. Right. And to think of the Herald comprehensively like that, I mean, that’s exciting to me. I hadn’t thought about it like that in that way. I always think of it in a very specific… You want it to be somewhat cut and dry for an audience. Here, you’re presenting the quest, adventure of the story, and the stakes. It can’t be too convoluted.

Right. And so making it complex in the way… You’re talking is fascinating to me. As a point to the, you know, writers who are working on their scripts now and listening to this, just be sure that when you state something to your audience about what the hero wants and what they’re up against stakes-wise, that, you know, you don’t convolute that too much. But wait, dude, that’s a really interesting point. The third archetype we’re going to explore in this episode is the threshold guardian. The threshold guardian can appear throughout the story, but usually at thresholds to new environments like gates, entrances, borders, and oftentimes at act breaks. That’s my favorite time to use them.

They are an obstacle or a test for the hero before they face harder and greater challenges. They can appear at any stage in the story, but they always block that entrance. That’s why they’re called threshold guardians. Their message to the hero is generally clear. It’s go home, forget your quest, and they’re meant to block the way of the hero. It’s also meant, as a writer, I think, to allow you a chance to show the hero. The hero’s ingenuity and resourcefulness and just the tools that they might have trained on, how to use them. Like you said about the herald and finding the joy in writing the herald, I think the threshold guardian scenes are one of my faves. I love writing threshold guardian scenes.

Devin: Just like a herald character, they can be just as fun because they are raising, they still are raising stakes, but they’re also showing a side of the antagonist their power. No matter what story it is, it’s still, they’re still… They’re still kind of a, either directly associated with the antagonist, or they’re directly guarding something of that unknown world. And so there’s something that you’re being able to explain to the audience about either the unknown world or the antagonist or both.

Adam: A threshold guardian is interesting for these reasons. And like you said, it could be affiliated with a villain, it could not. It doesn’t have to necessarily be. It’s just an obstacle for the hero. And you mentioned… In a very tool-like way for the writer, if you encounter a dead end, if you encounter painted into a corner writer’s block, it’s a great thing to go, okay, well, let’s create a wall here. Let’s create a different threshold to an environment here, a club I have to get into, a criminal’s den if I’m a private eye, you know, different things like that. And you have to, or the hero rather, has to find a way to continue on with the journey.

Now, part of the thing that’s great about this encounter, and rather than look at it as a tool for the writer, I’m going to add to what you’re saying and view it from the hero’s interior, from the hero’s emotional and mental space. So when creating a good and stronger character, the threshold guardian is one of your greatest ways of demonstrating a hero’s skill set or even lack thereof early in a movie as a setup. To a payoff where they might learn that skill better later, the threshold guardian allows you as a writer, as a tool, to show the interior of your hero. Are they going to give up because someone says you can’t go this way? Or are they going to continue?

What’s their fortitude like? What’s their intellect like? A lot of times it’s fantasy, adventure. The Wizard of Oz is a good story for threshold guardians, the guy who guards the gate to the city of Oz. Labyrinth is another great fantasy story about a journey. The two threshold guardians that I want to mention from Labyrinth are interesting in this way. The first threshold guardian that Sarah meets on her way into Labyrinth is Hoggle, who is a little troll-like figure outside of the gates. And she asks him questions and eventually he lets her in to the gates of Labyrinth. He’s a gatekeeper. He’s a threshold guardian.

But she has to find the right question to ask him in order to get him to do that deed. That’s the riddle she must overcome. And later on, Hoggle, as a threshold guardian, becomes an ally. Something we’ll talk a lot more about is how the archetypes cross over. The second example I would give as a threshold guardian comes from the same movie. Sir Didymus, who is the little fox-like creature who rides the shaggy dog Ambrosius. He guards the footpath that crosses the gate. The Bog of Eternal Stench in a place where you cannot escape. It’s the only way out. As a threshold guardian, he has vowed upon his life as a noble knight to not let anybody pass this path.

He’s like the ultimate threshold guardian. And he even fights the biggest monster-slash-ally in the movie to defend his vow. He’s one of my favorite threshold guardians of all time. That character. Because he’s so funny to me. None shall pass without my permission. But the point is, Sarah goes, Well, can we have your permission? And he’s stumped. He’s completely stumped and outwitted because no one’s ever asked him. He’s always fought people away from the bridge. And it’s that sort of fun in storytelling and play of a threshold guardian. You can have so much joy in the way that the hero outwits the threshold guardian. That threshold guardian is instantly endeared to…

Well, Sir Ludo, never before have I met my match in battle. You are my brother. So instantly, he’s an ally. It’s one of my favorite threshold guardian allies example. And you know I love puppetry and fantasy and sci-fi. Give me some thoughts on your favorite threshold guardian moments.

Devin: One of the greatest movies of all time, The NeverEnding Story. If we’re talking about threshold guardians… It’s The Southern Oracle. Oh! Anytime I read or see threshold guardian, I just think of that scene that… So creepy. Yeah, dude. It’s so good. But that movie is an incredible movie to watch just once you’re studying archetype. To find… I mean, they’re all in there. And they’re all incredible characters. So it’s… Oh, yeah. But that would be my… That’s like the number one. Anytime I see threshold guardian or I’m thinking about threshold guardian, I think of that. That’s fantastic. That’s a really good one. Oh, that’s such a good one. It goes to prove what we were saying about the Herald. The one…

Adam: The examples that I chose were very active characters. And the example you just presented is like the letter or the information. It’s an inanimate threshold guardian. Right. It’s interesting that a herald and a threshold guardian, we’ve established that both need not necessarily be a person to be an archetype. Even though we’re calling it a character archetype, it doesn’t have to necessarily be a person. It can be a force. It can be something other than a human being, you know?

Devin: And The NeverEnding Story, the antagonist is even not a person.

Adam: It’s like cooking in a kitchen. These archetypes are great base components for a recipe. Not like some exotic spice, but something simple like salt or pepper. But you’re using them to accent each other and combine them into different flavors. I don’t know why you’re laughing at me, Devin. Not really an exotic spice, but…

Devin: Salt and pepper. I’m sorry, man. That was rude. Go ahead. It’s a brilliant analogy. We’ll be back right after this break. Salt and pepper.

Adam: Do you have a great story in mind? Some great characters? All these cool scenes and you don’t know what order to put them in? What goes here? What comes next? Story Blueprint is an app that provides a powerful and versatile tool to help you, the writer, build a roadmap of your story. Know where your story is going to start, where it’s going to end, and how you’re going to get there before you even begin writing. Once you have your blueprint completed, you’ll have a bird’s eye view of your story, removing the anxiety of the blank page. Story Blueprint is currently available in the iTunes App Store for iPad. Coming soon for iPhone and Android.

What about if you already have a finished script and you want feedback on how to improve your story for the next draft? Maybe you prefer a personal walkthrough to talk your story out one-on-one. Well, StoryOsophers, you can always talk to me. I offer a variety of supportive services from feedback for finished scripts to script doctoring and company consultations. I’ll diagnose your story to make sure all its parts are working toward the whole and strive to find a balance between traditional structure, storytelling innovation, and the writer’s personal voice and lens. I also do ongoing story therapy for writers who are looking for a coach to help build their story.

I ask you the questions that help you find your own story, and we discuss how to mine its gems. Consultation services are also available to directors and actors looking to break down scripts into beats and super objectives, and to production companies looking to refine the stories in their slate. For more information and a full menu of story doctoring options, you can visit doctajones.com. That’s D-O-C-T-A Jones dot com. Links to both Story Blueprint and Dr. Jones Consultations can be found on our website at StoryOsophy.com.

Devin: Your spice analogy.

Adam: I finished the analogy, though.

Devin: I liked it.

Adam: The first part dealt with characters that you would find within the first act, the foundation of your story. And once you cross that threshold, from the ordinary world of that hero’s everyday life into the special world of the adventure or quest they’ve chosen to be on, then there are a different set of characters. And one of the first characters that hero will encounter within that new special world. There are different things that you would call that adventure world that the hero enters. The special world, the unknown world. Devin, you have other names for it?

Devin: I use unknown world. Known and unknown world.

Adam: Yeah. That’s a good broad description of it.

Once you’re in there, you’re sort of, well, let’s say this. The hero… The hero and the writer are both in sort of a no-man’s land. They have no idea what to do. Even if you have an idea as a writer about your hero and the journey they’re going to take, the whole adventure between where they start and the climax usually is a little fuzzy. It’s a little gray area. In terms of where the hero begins their quest, once they’ve gotten the call to adventure by the Herald, crossed the first threshold, and defeated the threshold guardian… What happens next? Who’s the next character archetype that you run into?

Well, of course, it’s the person that needs to teach you about the world. Or as one of mine and Devin’s favorite scenes to play with is the rules and tools scene, which I will talk about in a moment. But it introduces the mentor character, the mentor archetype.

Devin: Well, for the Herald, for me, it’s similar to that where it’s a really, it’s a very important scene, and they’re usually fun to write. But you need to have your stuff together when you’re in this scene, because whether you’re creating a proprietary world like Pandora in Avatar, or you’re simply just doing a present day Earth or United States, you still must make up the rules of this unknown world you’re creating or building. And you need to somehow… Relay all that information to the audience and, or your hero, your hero, like we just talked about, kind of representing the audience. And so you can do this in a myriad of ways. And there’s many examples of lazy writing that have a, some character is in the mentor position, sits down with the hero and just shoves a bullet point scene of rules and information down his throat.

Adam: That’s my vomit noise. That’s my, that’s my, you’ve, you’ve been a lazy, crappy writer vomit noise. In that case, let’s look at Morpheus in the Matrix with Neo. That is the same thing you’re talking about done brilliantly. Right. Because you, the audience, are so enamored and interested in what that mentor is presenting. Even though he’s literally, blatantly going, here are the rules of this world. Right. He’ll do this. That mentor is a herald and presenting the stakes. And it’s such a brilliant example of an amalgam of archetypes. But it’s, it’s not, it’s stating it blatantly, but making it interesting. And you’re right. There are scenarios where someone goes, they just state the obvious. And you, as an audience, you’re pained. You’re like, I’m smarter than what you’re presenting to me.

Devin: I was just going to say that. Today’s story consumers are just too intelligent. Yes. Yes. There’s so many stories out there that they’re too intelligent for you just to sit and throw something out up on a whiteboard. Like, here are the rules. This is what you can’t do, can’t do, can’t do, can’t do. You have to do it creatively. You’re getting what the mentor knows. Like, this is everything I know. This is what I can tell you, but it might not be everything. But I think that, what you said, I think it’s, you’re right. Story consumers are just way too intelligent. They are way too intelligent.

They want creative storytelling.

Adam: Absolutely. The audience has seen so many… So many movies and TV shows, so many, that are based on the three-act structure that’s traditional storytelling. And part of the mission statement of this podcast is, that’s great. We have loved those stories that have been developed on that three-act structure. Absolutely.

And, you know, hundreds of years of dogma of storytelling that says, story is conflict and all these other things. But what happens now that the audience is that educated? The writers need to become that much more inventive. The storytellers need to be that much more clever, nonlinear, multidimensional. Things, Devin, that you and I have talked about personally, that we will explore later in this podcast.

Devin: No, but that’s, it was a good point. It’s a good point. And I think a characteristic of the mentor, the mentor character has had to have lived through either a personal encounter or experience with the antagonistic force, or has special knowledge of it, in a way that other characters don’t. And I, you know, so instead of a mentor character just giving hearsay, or this is what we found out. I mean, obviously, that’s part of it as well. You can, it’s hard. It’s hard. It’s hard to speak generally about some of these without like saying, picking out a specific movie and analyzing a mentor character. But I still think from a, in a generalized characteristic from a mentor, I do feel that there, they should be speaking based on a past encounter or personal experience with the antagonistic force, whatever that may be. Or again, like, or has some special knowledge that they’ve.

Adam: I’m always, as you know, I’m always. I’m always a little hesitant to define the hero by the force of antagonism. I want to define the hero by choice. That’s how I want to move story forward. I feel like a lot of story, history dogmatically treats the hero as a victim of society, of the gods, of whatever. And I’m, I’m agreeing with how you’re defining it. I just want to broaden it a little bit so that it’s not, the hero is not defined or the mentor is not defined by the force of antagonism.

Devin: For me, the one. One of the characteristics of the mentor has to have been impacted somehow by the antagonistic force, whatever it is. And it doesn’t mean directly. And I guess that’s the difference between the herald and the mentor. The herald is the news anchor that you spoke about earlier. They’re the ones that’s, they’re just, they’re just delivering the message. And then the mentor is the one that actually has some, some type of knowledge or experience.

Adam: Or some kind of encounter. Somehow they have they have something that’s valuable to the hero that they can provide, especially in the idea of emanations of a hero, reflections outward, projections of the hero outward. I believe that the mentor represents ultimately in the story where the hero will end up in a, let’s say, a positive outcome, the higher self outcome. The mentor is sort of like a glimpse of that for us as the audience of where the hero will be. Now, Luke doesn’t become Obi-Wan, but Luke aspires to Obi-Wan’s higher selfness, that knowledge, experience, that growth of an individual, countered by, of course, the shadow version of self.

Devin: Right. And I actually think that the hero, though the mentor is a glimpse… Like you said, what the hero can become or may become. I feel the mentor did not achieve what the hero will achieve. Oh, yeah, that’s nice. So the hero is actually going to win where the mentor could not. But the mentor is able to provide enough information. They’re like, I couldn’t do it, but this is what I know.

Adam: And Rocky, Mickey to Rocky is not that exact. He’s not an example, but he’s still a mentor. But what you’re saying is a really valuable thing for a lot of mentors. It’s true. They’ve attempted that thing the hero is setting out to do.

Devin: The mentor, just to bring it back to as a writing tool, they’re a vital tool and a great opportunity to provide those, like we were saying, those rules and tools of the world, not necessarily even beyond the antagonist, the knowledge they may have the antagonist. They’re also providing rules of this unknown world that we found ourselves in. Whether you’re Chazz Reinhold teaching John and Jeremy how to be wedding crashers, or you’re Splinter raising a group of mutant turtles and teaching them how to become ninjas, you are still providing the rules of this world that you’re in and how to navigate it. Right. The first mentor may not necessarily have a ton of information on the antagonist. They may be more of the setting up the rules of the world.

And then the other… The other mentors, if you meet other ones throughout the journey, those are the ones that… Kind of like The NeverEnding Story. The more places he ends up, they have more information about what…

Adam: You’re talking about multiple mentors now. You’re getting into that territory, which is interesting, too. It’s sort of like a Greek god scenario, where a hero goes on a journey, and one god gives them this, and one god gives them this. But they’re serving the same function. They’re educating the hero. They’re weaponizing them and giving them the skills or tools that they need. They’re also telling the hero… Here’s from your normal life the skills you have that you will need to use in this world, but improve. Right. That’s a good job for the mentor as well. Anytime that you can have a character who can blatantly state to your audience in a way that’s not cliched or beat you over the head, but just well-crafted exactly what’s going on in a story, that’s like the greatest tool ever.

Because then your audience knows the stakes. They know what this character wants. If you can have a character… And mentors are great for that. It’s saying, here’s what you want and can’t get. So they literally cut through the baloney. You know, heralds are the same way, which is often why those characters tend to come together in an amalgam.

Devin: Oh, yeah. The fact that one character can have… Can essentially wear a mass of different archetypes.

Adam: Gandalf is a… Not to use the most obvious one, but he’s a great example of the mentor-herald character. Being merged. He comes and says, here’s the adventure. And he’s the guy who mentors the entire adventure. Right. And also, he’s not asking. He’s not calling. He’s going, you will do this. He’s commanding. And so it’s interesting that that mentor-herald has that mix where the herald doesn’t request or just bring news, but they say, nope, it’s you, dude.

Devin: Just because the herald shows up and provides some news, it doesn’t mean they just jump off the page or they just leave stage left. Exit stage left, even. The herald can actually show up and then be by the side of the hero throughout the rest of the movie and then shift from being a herald to a mentor. You’re using Lord of the Rings as an example. I would like to use a much more epic film as an example, and that of the Karate Kid. Lord of the Rings is less epic than the Karate Kid.

Adam: Devin. Okay, go for it. Go for it. I’m in. Take it.

Devin: This is my example for that. Elizabeth Shue’s character, Allie, in the beginning, she’s actually, I’m talking about her in the beginning of the movie, she’s a herald. When they’re on the beach and her ex-boyfriend, Johnny, shows up, who’s a black belt in karate, and just goes up to Daniel and basically is like, all right, you gotta get out of here. This guy is gonna kick the crap out of you. This is my ex-boyfriend. Gives him some information and kind of is like, all right, well, now we’ve just introduced ourselves to the antagonist, or we’ve actually put a face on the antagonist. And though Mr. Miyagi is Daniel’s mentor when it comes to karate, it’s actually Allie who plays the mentor to both of them when she’s explaining to them how a karate tournament works, which is what Mr. Miyagi got them both into.

And so that’s all based on her knowledge of both of them. She was being with the antagonist at some point. She was the girlfriend of the antagonist, or one of the antagonists. So that’s kind of, that’s one of the, another example of moving, shifting.

Adam: I love Elizabeth Shue. Adventures in Babysitting. I love Elizabeth Shue. I adore her. I might take your example and maybe move that a little bit also into the category of shapeshifter. Because she was the girlfriend of the antagonist. And now on the hero’s side, she’s a shapeshifter in a certain way. I would agree with you in ways I hadn’t thought of her being a mentor. She isn’t in a lot of ways, but also a shapeshifter character.

Devin: I think one of my favorite mentor characters is from the movie Gladiator, Proximo. And he’s Maximus’ gladiator trainer. But what’s great about him is he was a gladiator. And he lived through being a gladiator. And he knew what it was like going up against the antagonist and essentially defeating, quote unquote, it or him, you know, the king of Rome. In a way, then that’s how he achieved his freedom. And so Maximus’ situation, his antagonist obviously is Commodus. But in a meeting with Maximus, Proximo tells him, win the crowd and you will win your freedom. And that in one sentence, Proximo the mentor. Yeah. He not only lays out a rule based on prior knowledge, but also gives Maximus his blueprint to freedom. I feel the mentor character has to have some experience or had to have been affected by somehow the antagonistic force that the hero is essentially the kind of building himself up, gaining the knowledge and tools and the rules to go fight this antagonistic force. And so that was one of the really good examples of this guy was a slave. He was a gladiator.

Yeah. And so he almost kind of has a little bit of an allegiance to the same structure that put him – that enslaved him and made him a gladiator. So he’s a very complex – well, it’s a very complex movie, but he’s a very complex character in that way.

Adam: If what you’re talking about, you said he’s a very dark character or almost – sometimes the mentor can be a fatalistic character. And this is the statement that I want to make, and it will make itself clearer as we get through this podcast. I think the mentor is a hero who did not recover from the crisis of their story fully. They sort of did not achieve what they needed to. Something fell short and they couldn’t complete that journey. And so they’re imparting that knowledge to the hero who will complete that journey.

Devin: Yes. I agree wholeheartedly.

Adam: Okay. And I think that’s part of what the mentor is. It’s almost generational passing on of experience knowledge from something that I tried my best, but I didn’t quite get there.

Devin: And they’re almost envious of the opportunity that the hero has, even though they know that it’s going to be a rough journey or it’s going to be difficult. There’s going to be difficulties and obstacles.

Adam: For some reason, Dodgeball just popped in my head because Rip Torn, I love Rip Torn, where he’s just like the broken down guy. Yeah. And he’s the mentor, but he’s a crappy mentor because he’s so abusive. But it’s a comedy. So it’s, you know, it’s off base from what you’re saying. And then I thought of Kingpin, Randy Quaid and Bill Murray and Woody Harrelson. Bill Murray’s the sort of jerk antagonist who, the bowling antagonist, and Woody Harrelson is missing a hand and he gets an Amish kid who can bowl. It’s absurd, but the antagonist is just some sadistic, you know, and the mentor is a person who no longer has the hand to bowl.

And so he instructs someone who is better, but who is naive to the… I don’t know why that popped in my head, dude, but… Kingpin.

Devin: I don’t know either. I was letting you go with it, though. I’ll let you go this time with your Kingpin references.

Adam: Please subscribe and rate us on iTunes. And for additional story-related resources, video, and archived content, visit our website at StoryOsophy.com.