Season 1, episode 5

Character Archetypes (Part 2)

December 1, 201746 min

Show notes

Adam and Devin finish their tour of the character archetypes with the characters the hero meets on the journey: allies, the trickster, the shapeshifter and the shadow. Along the way they make the case that every villain is the hero of their own story.

In this episode

  • Allies. Positive reflections of the hero, like a funhouse mirror. Ask what each ally amplifies in the hero and what they get from the deal.
  • When you need a sword to talk, you create an ally. Allies fill a role the hero needs and give the hero someone to talk to.
  • The trickster. Comic relief and the sidekick, releasing tension between intense scenes. Dobby shows how much depth a trickster can have, and why their death raises the stakes.
  • Simpletons and innocents. Chaplin, Buster Keaton, Olaf and SpongeBob: naive optimists who think outside the box and sometimes lead the hero into trouble.
  • The shapeshifter. Questionable loyalty and a hidden agenda. Red Scare builds a whole series on not knowing who the shapeshifter is.
  • The shadow. The antagonist, but never a bland bad guy. Adam’s idea: the shadow is a hero who reached the crisis, failed and turned against everyone else.
  • Know your villain’s reasoning. There’s a wounded human behind the monster’s mask, and it’s who the hero could become.
  • Forces as shadows. The Dark Side and the Nothing are forces of antagonism, not characters, which leads into the next episode on conflict.

Examples discussed

  • Harry Potter, Frozen, SpongeBob SquarePants, Breaking Bad, Game of Thrones, The Wizard of Oz, The Dark Knight Rises, Indiana Jones and the Last Crusade and Red Scare.
  • Also: The Lion King, Gladiator, Star Wars, The NeverEnding Story, Cast Away and Charlie Chaplin.

Next episode: conflict and the forces of antagonism.

Read the full transcript

Transcribed automatically, so expect the odd misheard word. Sponsor messages are left out.

Adam: Welcome to StoryOsophy. This is Adam Jones.

Devin: And Devin Halden.

Adam: Talking about the basics of storytelling in this first season, we continue with conversations about character archetypes. What becomes very valuable after the mentor archetype leaves is archetype number five, which are allies. Other people to help. The mentor usually does not stick with the character because it’s very important that the hero’s journey is their own. Right. We’re not going to spend a lot of time on allies here because they will show themselves more in structure. They’re very simple in this way. They’re reflections of the hero in a positive light. What the hero wants, what they desire, and where their intentions are, what their quest is. These people are supportive of that.

They’re loyal teammates.

Devin: Allies, I almost question them as an actual archetype because some of these other archetypes actually fit. A herald, like we just talked about, a herald can be a mentor. They can all be allies. And trickster, which we haven’t talked about.

Adam: Yeah, they’re all tools.

Devin: Yeah, and it’s like if you need a sword to talk, you create an ally. Well, this sword isn’t going to do anything. This sword is only going to kill something, but I need some kind of dialogue here.

Adam: Wait, say that one more time.

Devin: When you need a sword to talk, you create an ally.

Adam: That’s fantastic.

Devin: They fill the role within the hero’s quest somehow. They’re there to help. But sometimes you need more than a sword. You need to talk to somebody.

Adam: When you go into a funhouse, a funhouse filled with warped mirrors in different ways, where one makes you look like the fat guy, and the other one makes you look like the super skinny guy, and the other one makes you look like a beefcake, and the other one gives you a fat head, they’re all still you, but distorted reflections, amplified reflections of you. In that same light, I feel like all of the character archetypes are that of a hero. They’re emanations of a hero in the same way. Allies in particular, because you can still do that funhouse reflection and keep all those reflections playful and positive amongst the hero’s mindset and perspective.

Still not enemies. The hero’s bravery, and you have someone, the obvious sidekick who’s like, let’s not go in there. It’s very, it’s overdone, but it’s a perfect example. That’s why it’s done so frequently. The brave hero with the nervous sidekick. And so you’re showing a bit of how that hero, by showing the opposite of the hero’s intentions, how they respond or negotiate doubt, positive, negative.

Devin: Well, and in that example too, don’t go in there, that character, that’s also, an ally can also become a voice of the audience.

Adam: The trickster archetype. It’s really great for that. Sort of subverting the audience’s expectations. Or if the audience has a really, I call it fiction putty. There’s a big gap in logic. And so you just have the trickster come in and go, I’m going to smooth this over with some fiction putty. And they literally just say the problem. They sort of just show it. The audience is like, well, at least one person’s thinking. You know, at least one person’s got sense. Right. Although it’s the, you know, the fool of the group. Allies in their basic form. Before we get into too much into tricksters and shapeshifters. They are, the allies are the extensions of the hero, not just in reflections of their internal personal things, but also what the hero needs.

Right. Whether it’s someone. It’s the tools, the skill sets. Why are they working with or journeying with the hero? Is it payment, promised payment for skills? Is it a bargain? Is it a contract? Are they chained together? Is it a mutual cause or an agenda?

Devin: Or just straight up loyal? Right. Or just completely loyal to the hero?

Adam: When thinking of allies, what purpose do they serve to amplify the hero, to show some different aspect of the hero? That’s the number one question. And the second one is, what is their relationship to the hero? Meaning, how are they attached? What’s the symbiotic relationship? What do they get from the hero, and what does the hero get from them? Now, allies can come in all different shapes and sizes. I think some examples. There are a lot of examples. There are a couple that I thought were kind of interesting to pose, especially with popular shows these days. In Breaking Bad, Jesse Pinkman, Walter White’s partner, but the ally, sidekick, he’s a subservient ally.

It starts that they’re working together, but you slowly realize that the one is manipulating the other because he’s turning into a shadow. And so, he’s an interesting ally. Also, one of my faves that I think you and I talked about before was… From Game of Thrones, Bronn to Tyrion Lannister. Because Tyrion is so rich, he’s promised much riches, and this guy’s a great swordsman. In that regard, that contract is very direct and overt. You know exactly what he’s getting, and you know exactly what he’s providing. And a lot of times, that’s when you’re dealing with allies in a story, when you’re building a team. That’s how clear you want to make it.

What is at stake for this ally? Just as the same as, what’s at stake for the hero? Well, in a more subplot way, what’s at stake for the ally?

Devin: Wizard of Oz. I mean, the Tin Man and the Scarecrow and the Lion. I mean, those are allies to Dorothy. And they also ask that question that you just posed. It’s like, what’s in it for them? What are they getting out of the deal? And there’s very definitive answers for that.

Adam: That’s a great one. The Wizard of Oz is great for, what’s their bargain? That’s a really fantastic example. Other than that, I think we’re good on allies.

We’ll define allies in a future podcast more specifically. But they’re basically the helping hand of the hero. That’s as simple as we can put it. They’re the positive. Hand and mindset and heart of the hero. Yep. Now, the remaining character archetypes are questionable. The next one we’re going to step into is the trickster archetype. Devin, what’s the trickster archetype all about?

Devin: Comic relief. That’s the short answer, I guess. And sidekick. They’re often the sidekick of the hero.

Adam: Yeah, sidekick too.

Devin: They’re releasing tension after some of those real intense and emotionally charged moments. And so, if you look at a story as sprints and marathons, or probably better as just action and recovery, we need to give our characters and our audience a break every now and then to reflect on what just happened and regroup and focus on what’s still to come. And the trickster can be a very complex and deep character. Though on the surface, of course, they’re… They’re the funny comic relief. Yeah. Taking things a little less seriously. But oftentimes, as we learn about them as we go along, we gain compassion for them. And I don’t think there’s a better example of that than Dobby from Harry Potter.

Adam: Uh-huh.

Devin: When we meet Dobby, he’s not much help. And he provides a lot of moments of humor. When we first meet them, the trickster character, it seems fairly simple and innocent. And so… In a way, they kind of… They’re almost… And we’ll talk about shapeshifters later. But they’re very much so shapeshifters. And Dobby may provide comic relief at times and give the story some of those breaks of intense action. But deep down in his background, as we learn about his background, he was a slave. Or he is a slave. And he wants nothing more than to be free of his masters. And Harry can relate to that.

I think… The audience, in ways, can relate to that. But there’s also parts of Dobby that are extremely different. And things that we cannot really relate to that make us feel this extreme compassion for him. And so I think an important element of the trickster is this devotion to the hero and the allies. And in Dobby’s case, he was a slave. Then he met Harry and his allies, and they never treated him as such. His loyalty throughout the entire story is unwavering. And so when Dobby is killed in the first part of Deathly Hallows, he’s killed protecting Harry and his friends, and his new friends, his allies. And the audience immediately feels intense, true emotional sadness for him. Because we’ve grown to love him, and the character he is, and what he believes in, and what he represents.

Yeah. Had he not captured our emotions from the very first time we meet Dobby as being funny and carefree, and then he captures our hearts as we learn more and more about him and his life and his background, his death would not have been so sad and impactful. And throughout that impact, J.K. Rowling, obviously the writer, accomplished two goals. We lost a character that we loved. And so it is an intense part of the story for us. But in turn, we’ve increased our hatred of the antagonist. How could you take this character away from us? How could you do something so bad to someone that’s so great?

Though on the surface, he seems like the comic relief comedian. He’s innocent. He’s got everything. Everything’s kind of figured it out. It’s very simple. He’s very simple-minded. But really, there’s… That ends up being a mask. And he ends up having a very either tumultuous or tough background. And when we get to find out, you know, when he becomes more vulnerable throughout the story, we’re able to find out a little bit more about them. And then that’s truly when we become very compassionate for them. And then when they are taken from us, we’re extremely sad.

Adam: As you know, I love the Trickster character. As we’re talking about blending… I love the archetypes. I love Trickster heroes. I love the happy-go-lucky, innocent Charlie Chaplin, Buster Keaton. You and I both love Chaplin. That hero is my favorite. That’s my favorite hero because they don’t take anything seriously. And part of the Trickster, you could call the Trickster archetype also the fool, like the court jester. They’re sort of a character that’s comic relief, but they also are used to poke holes and lampoon. And social structures, like if the king needs some straightening up, the jester would make jokes at his expense, his, you know, the queen’s expense. And just to keep the ego in balance. There’s that function of a Trickster as well. A good Trickster ally was Olaf from Frozen, because he’s just fun. He’s just silly fun. And if you hurt Olaf, you would be upset.

Right. They’re the innocent in some way, even though it’s called Trickster. The archetype name is sort of different than what the character… Is truly about. It’s someone who’s really outside of the box so much that it’s almost humorous. It’s absurd. It’s funny. It’s playful. I think that both Patrick and SpongeBob, they’re Tricksters. They’re Trickster heroes. Right. That’s what they’re all about. You know, that’s their whole day. That’s their whole daily life. I was going to say, too, this, the tool used, as you say, with the Trickster archetype, of, they bring brightness or they brighten up a scene. When you have this sort of climactic event, you need to give a pause or reflective environment. The Trickster is great for setting that up tonally. And what I would call, and we will deal with this in another podcast, the forces of gravity and levity.

The forces of seriousness and humor, which you need to balance throughout any script so the audience has a ride. They’re perfect for when that recipe is a little off. Like you say, when you paint yourself into a corner writer’s block wise, if you feel like you’re like, oh my gosh, man, am I heavy handed, man, am I beating the audience over the head? Have the trickster step in and say something that’s almost as equivalent to, I know you’re getting beat over the head with this information. Have them poke fun at it just for a moment. Right. And sometimes it’s a little campy. Sometimes it sort of throws off the suspension of disbelief. But if your story is really unbelievable, it’s sometimes a good idea to have a trickster. Oftentimes they’re the character who will turn to the camera and say, hey, I’m talking to you, audience, and break that fourth wall too. They have that ability as a hero.

Devin: A lot of times you can use the trickster to do something, not in a way, but because you, you know that character so well throughout the rest of the story, you know, they just did it because they’re kind of idiots. You know, they’re not really, they just, they’re not playing with a full deck, but then it’s a way to, it’s a way to raise the stakes. It’s a way to transition to, from one place or the other.

Adam: You’re talking about if the trickster has a low intelligence level, like if they’re not terribly intelligent, they can accidentally, without malicious intention, lead the hero into an, into an obstacle. Or they’re just clumsy, you know, or they’re.

Devin: You know, they could be brilliant, but they’re just clumsy and they just, they’re.

Adam: Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. Simpletons. Right. It’s what you and I like to call simpleton characters. We love them. They’re innocents. Exactly. That’s what it, they’re, they’re innocents. I would prefer to call that archetype something like that more than the trickster. The, the part of the hero that’s so naive that they, that they are gullible. They fall into the trap.

Devin: And the audience gives them a pass because, and because they have so much compassion for it. And they, they truly. Absolutely. It’s like, yeah, I, you know, and of course they’re, they’re relatable too. They’re like a hero. People can relate to a trickster. People can relate to somebody that has a bad, bad things happen to them or has some bad luck or is clumsy or something like that. People can get that.

Adam: Like I said, you and I both have this obsession with Chaplin. It’s the optimist. It’s the naive optimist. It’s the simpleton. It’s the, it’s the part of you that’s gullible, that really wants to, that’s trying their best, but is. A little naive. Right. As a writer, using the tool of that naive, innocent character and their death, the audience is then doing all the work for you. You created a character that they really care about and that character is taken away. And now they hate the, the entity that took it away, which is the villain. Right. It’s a great tool to help to amplify support for your hero. And I mean, I, I hate, I hate it. I hate the death of a trickster.

Devin: And it’s also, and it’s also a good event to happen that is almost kind of moving into your climax or this year. Like this was the light you, this was the last straw. We’re done. We’re done messing. Yeah. Now we’re, this is when it gets serious. Yeah, exactly. Now this is serious.

Adam: Literally, if the death of the jokester or the trickster is, is when stuff gets serious.

Devin: No more fun and games. It’s over with. Now we’re going to defeat you.

Adam: It’s basically in summation, the sidekick. The comic relief, the, the naive or innocent in a story. They’re a lot of fun. They’re, they’re, they’re some of your favorite characters, but they, they think outside the box.

Devin: I didn’t even think we were going to spend that much time on trickster, but now, but since we’re talking about, I’m like, wow, he’s an awesome character.

Adam: I think we’ve given some good examples, right?

Devin: I wanted to pay a little tribute to Dobby. That’s all.

Adam: Devin loves the Dobby. So moving on to the, seventh archetype shapeshifter, the shapeshifter blurs the line between ally and enemy. They’re a good counterpart or antagonist in a romantic comedy. They’re good as the hero’s shadow in a romantic comedy because they’re constantly changing their mind. Appeal and danger they bring together.

Devin: When I’m, when I think of a shapeshifter, I kind of automatically for some reason go to a dark character. Hmm. They’re the wolf in sheep’s clothing, which is kind of a, has a, obviously a negative connotation or a dark connotation, but. Yeah, that’s good. I feel like they always have a different. Agenda. They mislead the hero and some of the other characters by hiding their intentions or loyalties and they’re constantly plotting and they do their best to fly under the radar, but they’re also doing these things to falsely validate their loyalty enough to keep their suspicion away from them. So I guess it doesn’t necessarily, I mean, some of that is dark, I guess. Different agendas doesn’t have to be dark.

Adam: They can be holding a secret. Yeah, right. You can be, I think a shapeshifter can be holding a secret that’s not necessarily negative, but if the hero knew it would be, they would be treated as the enemy, but we, the audience, share it with them. And that’s a little bit of like dramatic irony in the mix, but it’s true. They don’t have to be bad guys. Yeah. But there is something that is secretive and lying. And so in a sense, it’s an emanation of the hero’s negative psychological aspects.

Devin: There’s something nefarious, I think. Yeah, yeah. One way to look at it where one character in the beginning of the story is a herald and then they’re a mentor and then they’re, you know, they’re switching archetypes. I don’t necessarily, that’s not really shapeshifting. That’s more of just switching a role.

Adam: I’m glad you clarified that too, because I think I misspoke earlier and I’m glad you clarified that.

Devin: Yeah. So maybe the shapeshifter is a little, like we point out, there’s a nefarious element to it. They’re very selfish. They have their own agenda there, but they’re very cunning. And they can mislead. And I think the best example is probably Catwoman in Batman. Oh, that’s nice. And specifically Anne Hathaway’s character in Dark Knight Rises. She’s a fantastic shapeshifter throughout that film. Because we first meet her in, you know, she snuck her way up to Bruce Wayne’s bedroom. And she shifted between a maid who’s lost her way or she doesn’t, she’s not supposed to be there to a thief, like within seconds. Yeah. And then there’s a moment at a bar when she shifts from a blackmailer to a screaming victim when the police arrive. So she has her own agenda and she knows how to manipulate everybody around her enough to avoid suspicion. But there’s a nefarious element to what, to who she is.

Adam: That’s a great example. And I think that it shows really well the idea of what a shapeshifter is truly about, which is questionable loyalty. They don’t even know, we the audience, and not even the shapeshifter. Knows how they truly feel about that situation. And so they, they bounce back and forth. And that’s the key to it. Another one was the third Indiana Jones movie, the third in the, in the series, where Elsa betrays Indy.

Devin: Yeah.

Adam: It’s another great shapeshifter thing. I mean, to me, that’s a kind of, now, I wanted to mention something that’s really interesting that that sort of exemplifies how you can exponentially increase the value of a shapeshifter in your story. I, there’s a series on Vimeo online called Red Scare. And it’s, the basics of it is really simple. It’s during the, the Red Scare in American history, communism, and there’s a, a bomb threat. And so they all, a group of people go into a bomb shelter, and they’re trapped in this bomb shelter. And then they find out. After the first night, that one of them is a vampire, but they don’t know who it is. And so every episode of this web series is someone else gets picked off. And so you, as an audience member, are treated as a detective, where you got to figure out who’s the person who is killing everybody off kind of thing per episode. But what’s brilliant is they take the episode, the, the archetype of the shapeshifter, and literally use it as the lens, the tone of the entire series. And I thought that was really interesting. Everybody’s a shapeshifter through the audience’s perspective, because we don’t know who it is. And you can take just a, that’s just an example of what you can do with these archetypes, where if you know the rules, you can break them. If you know what a shapeshifter archetype is, you can create an entire series where every character is a shapeshifter.

In addition to that, it also is comprised of one of the components or scenes or events that Devin and I really enjoy, which is called the pressure cooker. Environment where you have multiple people in a small space and a lot of tension. It’s a really great example of how that’s mined. And Shapeshifter is perfect for that. If you’ve got a small group of people and you know one of them is a Shapeshifter, one of them is not an ally in a group of allies, you can mine tension throughout an entire story.

Devin: Yeah. You’re always trying to find them all. And I think the Shapeshifter character is usually the character when we’re watching a movie where everybody’s trying to kind of figure them out or they’re like, I got this guy figured out. He’s definitely not who he says he is. That’s kind of one of those characters that everybody’s – they’re playing detective and trying to figure out whose side this guy’s on, what’s this guy’s story, what’s his motivations that are different.

Adam: You said the word detective and that’s a key. Because what it’s doing is it’s mentally engaging the audience. When you get the audience thinking for the story, you’re not spoon-feeding them, but doing exactly what you just laid out, that is great writing. When you’re not spelling it out for them, but you’re giving enough of the clues that they – I often like to think of storytelling as building a puzzle that an audience will solve. That’s the excitement of story writing, storytelling. But that’s also the fun of experiencing a story as the audience is unfolding that puzzle. Each of these archetypes is one of the major pieces or tones or vantage points.

Do you have a great story in mind? Some great characters? All these cool scenes and you don’t know what order to put them in? [unclear] Next? Story Blueprint is an app that provides a powerful and versatile tool to help you, the writer, build the roadmap of your story. Know where your story is going to start, where it’s going to end, and how you’re going to get there before you even begin writing. Once you have your blueprint completed, you’ll have a bird’s eye view of your story, removing the anxiety of the blank page. Story Blueprint is currently available in the iTunes App Store for iPad, coming soon for iPhone and Android. What about if you already have a finished script and you want feedback on how to improve your story for the next draft? Maybe you prefer a personal walkthrough to talk your story out one-on-one. Well, StoryOsophers, you can always talk to me. I offer a variety of supportive services, from feedback for finished scripts to script doctoring and company consultations. I’ll diagnose your story to make sure all its parts are working toward the whole and strive to find a balance between traditional structure, storytelling innovation, and the writer’s personal voice and lens. I also do ongoing story therapy for writers who are looking for a coach to help build their story. I ask you the questions that help you find your own story, and we discuss how to mine its gems. Consultation services are also available to directors and actors looking to break down scripts into beats and super objectives, and to production companies looking to refine the stories in their slate. For more information, and a full menu of story doctoring options, you can visit doctajones.com. That’s D-O-C-T-A Jones dot com. Links to both Story Blueprint and Dr. Jones consultations can be found on our website at StoryOsophy dot com.

Do you have anything else you want to say about Shapeshifter?

Devin: I had another example, but it’s pretty— Do it. Okay. Right now? Sure. It’s hard to speak broadly or generally about some of these. Every time I’m talking about one of these archetypes, I kind of have a specific type of story in mind, and it’s usually an epic fantasy story, or it’s like Gladiator or Harry Potter or something like that.

Adam: Well, to be fair— We are basing this off of a certain traditional structure that is based in mythological storytelling. Yeah. We’re talking about Joseph Campbell’s book, The Hero with a Thousand Faces, and Christopher Vogler’s book, The Writer’s Journey. So we are basing it in a very specific type of lens for storytelling. It is mythological and epic. And we are going broad with these first episodes in the first season. So, you know, explore that and then we’ll examine, we’ll zoom in further and then challenge those perspectives.

Devin: When we’re doing examples of movies, I’m trying to pull in different genres. And so, Catwoman is one, Batman, Catwoman and Batman obviously is one genre. But the shapeshifter in Lion King, you know, just a children’s movie, is of course, Scar. Oh, yeah. Who is the brother of Mufasa and- That’s great. He pretends he’s loyal to Mufasa, he pretends he loves Simba, and he misleads Mufasa and really the majority of the pride in the rest of the jungle, except for his minion hyenas of that loyalty. The entire time he’s plotting to take down Mufasa and kill Simba so he can be king. And in fact, actually, the earlier example of Gladiator.

Commodus, obviously the antagonist, is also doing a lot of shapeshifting. Throughout that story as well.

Adam: You dirty dog, you. You managed to segue into our last archetype right under my nose. You dirty dog. One of my favorite things about the crossing of archetypes, the shadow is a deeper topic than some of the other ones, because it deals with a source of conflict, forces of antagonism, the source of antagonism. But they still need to be, they can’t just be some bland, bad guy.

We’re too evolved for that kind of storytelling. You need something that is shades of gray or hues of the shadow. When the hero is wavering or vacillating on a decision point, which is what a lot of stories are built on, is different decision points and choices, it generally has to do with whether they’re going to go a positive way or a negative way. Are they going to be an evolved version of themselves, a higher self? Are they going to join the dark side? Well, of course, as we move into the eighth and final archetype we’ll be talking about as an emanation of the hero, it is the shadow.

The shadow, the antagonist, the bad guy, the villain, the person that everyone needs to dislike in order to feel happy for the hero. But we don’t want a two-dimensional hero. We create a bad guy or a shadow, and that’s why we often call them the antagonist, because the protagonist, the opposite, the hero, has one point of view, and the antagonist has another. In terms of mythological storytelling, the shadow is the polar opposite of what the hero’s higher self is, where the hero, we hope, is an audience for all our inspiration and joy in supporting the hero. Is the antagonist. We want the hero to end up.

We want them to be their higher self, just as we want the same for ourself. We want growth and positivity and development. Well, the shadow represents not just—we were talking about the mentor earlier, and a mentor is a hero, sort of speculatively, we said this, that the mentor is a hero that, after the crisis, didn’t really recover. They sort of hit this place where they just didn’t pick themselves back up fully. They resigned from the quest that the hero is now on. And as you said, it’s sort of reflective of the forces of antagonism. They have experience with them. They know more about, more knowledge about the force of antagonism the hero is facing.

And so in a similar equation, the shadow is a hero who got to the crisis and also failed, but then turned completely against self and others. Didn’t just shell off and become a hermit like maybe the mentor did in Obi-Wan’s case, but decided not to continue to make choices as a hero, but somehow create the scenario where the forces of antagonism blame, anger, and hatred. Any of these other negative emotions, if you will, are projected onto everyone else. I’ll pose two extreme people that we tend to villainize, Darth Vader and Adolf Hitler. These are two I’m going to mention as huge shadow archetypes in our lives. One in pop culture, one in reality and history.

Now, I’m just going to sort of suggest that always the antagonist or shadow is a hero. So in your story as a writer, you need to come to a place of compassion for that individual as a, as their own hero. You may not agree with their viewpoint, but you need to have the audience access it because it gives a dimension to the hero that other storytelling doesn’t. Darth Vader is probably one of the most iconic pop culture villains, just even an image. You barely have to see the silhouette and you know it. It’s iconic. Darth Vader, however. This wounded, misled, like some of us have been in various aspects of life, but it’s someone who’s turned in on themselves. And at the end of the episodes three, four, and five, when Darth Vader is dying, and you remove Darth Vader’s helmet, there is a completely different relationship with the shadow than you have had in almost any other. It’s not black and white.

And so, even though the term is shadow, remember that there is a wounded human being behind the mask of the monster. And it is that which the hero could become if the hero loses sight of self. And to me, as far as defining what a shadow is before we even get into how the hero and the shadow conflict, that to me is vital. It’s not just a bad guy. It’s easy to do a bad guy. So, look at Hitler’s life. What a venomous man. What a vengeful, angry, crazy venomous man. But let’s zoom back to his earlier experiences in life where he wanted to be an artist. He was a painter. And someone basically said, you suck. You have no potential. Someone denigrated his self-worth.

Now, cart before the horse, chicken before the egg, I’m not trying to say anything wonderful about Hitler. I’m simply trying to pose a scenario regarding how we define villainy. How we define antagonism and shadow. There’s always, if you do not know, as Devin put in one of our first episodes, the reasoning of your characters, you don’t know your characters. And that includes your villains. If you don’t know where someone hurts and becomes the villain, where someone thinks off a different path or is influenced by someone who is also a shadow, a dark mentor, then you don’t know your villain. You can’t judge them. You have to understand them. You have to figure out their reasoning.

Devin: Just as it’s very important to develop and understand your hero, it’s vitally important to understand and develop your antagonist. But what’s important between that relationship is the hero at some point in this journey is going to be faced with the fork in the road. [unclear] The fork in the road that they’re either going to decide to go down that same path or they’re going to decide to be a hero and do differently and do what’s right and make that decision. And so in order for that decision to have the greatest impact on the story and in the audience, we need to understand that back story and that background.

Of why the antagonist chose to go down that road. Because at some point, the hero is going to have an opportunity or decision to have that same vindictiveness or that same anger and go down that road or give up like the mentor before him. And that decision and the impact of that decision is going to be either exponentially increased in a good way or a bad way. Right. How much we understand and the audience understands the decisions of the antagonist in his background or his history. And I think that’s where the true defeat of the antagonist comes is I’m better than you. I’m not going to do this.

I’m not making the same mistake you did. And now I’m going to defeat you. And that’s – and then you’re essentially removing all of the power away from them.

Adam: Again, it’s hard for me to – It’s broad. You’re talking broad. And everything. Everything you’re saying is awesome. Instead of trying to get – trying not to get too involved with the minutia and the details and the nuance of what we’re talking about and really trying to do the broad strokes for season one so that at least our listeners are all on the same page in knowledge base. And then when we take each of these things – because I guarantee you, listeners, we’re going to get more involved with each of these character archetypes. We – they’ll – so much to mine from each one. In terms of what the Shadow is, as you mentioned before, I don’t want to steal your example of The NeverEnding Story, but we will deal with that in a minute.

I just wanted to state this as a primary point for the Shadow. The Shadow doesn’t necessarily have to be a character. It can be a Force, it can be an Energy. The Dark Side of the Force from Star Wars. Darth Vader’s a bad guy. Darth Vader’s a shadow, but this force of antagonism is much larger than he is, so it’s not. Right. There’s also, as you mentioned with The NeverEnding Story, the Nothing. The Nothing, so brilliantly and appropriately named, is the force of antagonism that is devouring. In the next podcast, what we’re going to do is talk about conflict, and a lot of those conflicts are like this.

Person against self, person against technology, person against nature. So, we will go into some of the basic, what are agreed upon to be some of the basic examples of conflict, sources or forces of antagonism. It’s a storm, it’s being stranded by self, it’s an asteroid. So, even though it’s not a character, the archetype is the asteroid. Now, if there was some, for as silly as it sounds…

Devin: Well, it’s still a character, it’s just not a human character.

Adam: I was going to say, if there were a spokesperson for the asteroid, that would be a character. In that sense, the shadow is a force of antagonism or a source of antagonism. Usually, in a fairytale environment or a fantasy environment, the shadow is this. Even if there is the Nothing, okay, even if there’s the black cloud coming over the fairytale land, there’s a witch or a sorcerer or something. Or some king with a curse that’s caused it. There’s a character at the core of the thing.

Devin: Not all the time, though.

Adam: Not all the time. No, no, no, no, no. I’m not saying by any means all the time. In a fairytale environment, usually. They can get away with a lot more, too, because a cloud of smoke is… It helps. It’s sort of like this. When you’re on a film set, and you’re doing a scene, and it’s a dialogue-less scene. It’s just action. Just looks from people and stuff like that. If what is occurring in that scene… If what is occurring in that scene is not being communicated to an audience, an intelligent director, a really good director, is going to say to the writer, Give me a line for that moment.

Because it’s not being communicated, and they need it articulated so the audience can follow. That’s why in TV shows or movies, you’ll see someone go, Let’s use that door! It’s obvious, but it’s helping the audience to follow the story. I would say this is the same way. You want the indicator. That’s what’s important.

Devin: And we’ll obviously get into this in the next podcast, but I’ll just touch on it. There’s a different plan of attack and a different way to defeat the antagonist if they’re a character, like a physical character that you’re defeating, or something inanimate like a storm or weather or nature. Because essentially, it’s survival is what defeats the something that’s versus nature. It’s surviving. The Nothing is an anomaly of an example that we could spend hours on. Supernatural. Supernatural. Larger than life. With Cast Away, the antagonist really is his situation. It’s weather and it’s all of the hardships that he has because he’s stuck on this island. His thing is, so his way of defeating it is survival and coping and figuring things out and making friends with the volleyball and things like that.

But from a mental standpoint, that keeps him in check. So that’s, I guess, I don’t want to get into it because this is one of those things that could go down a rabbit hole.

Adam: As a performer, as a writer, as a director, as all these different facets, what’s important to me is tracking from a performer point of view that hero’s or character’s inside journey. So part of this podcast too is not just for storytellers and writers and audience and listeners and just lovers of entertainment, but also for performers. We’re tracking a character on their way from what they want and their super objective to the end of their journey and whether they achieve that or not. I feel like the desire and the resistance, the desire and where you hold yourself back, because most people’s worst enemy is themselves. I think that a hero’s inner resistance, meaning what they hold themselves back from, The negativity or lack of confidence they feel about certain things, their animosities even, their hatred, is emanated outward in the actions, the physical, visible actions of the story’s shadow, antagonist, villain.

Because you don’t quite see the resistant part of the hero internally. And the shadow is the extreme. And so you’re trying to understand what that hero’s seesaw struggle is between higher self and shadow. And I don’t want to do too cliche Star Wars, but the fact is that franchise has been around for a long time. It had a reinvention years ago and now is starting a new reinvention for later chapters. And it has a strong effect on people around the world. And it’s not just because of the storytelling, but the philosophy behind it, which is the reflection of self, whether it’s the hero, as I said before, earlier in this podcast. The emanation of the hero as a higher self or the hero as projection of self, as in Star Wars, the initial episode three, where Luke encounters Darth Vader in a cave when Yoda’s training him, kills him, defeats him. And when the mask comes off, it’s actually Luke. As a child, that’s extreme. When you first watch that movie and try to comprehend that, you’re like, you mean he’s the bad guy? And spoiler alert, at the core of the beauty and brilliance and passion and ambition of a hero is the resistance of that hero, is that which they lack.

Before we end this episode, and particularly this segment on archetypes, I wanted to just say one thing, and I’ll throw out an example, regarding the many different ways you can blend together, the amalgam of different archetypes you can put together and create something. One of our favorite shows that we’ve been watching as a culture, you know, in this country, is Breaking Bad, where a mentor character, a science teacher, that we really think is an endearing person, we watch that person turn shadow. That’s his journey. We can understand him. I mean, look at the recipe. It’s so transparently there. Shadow, mentor, shapeshifter. And they’re basic archetypes. Yet it had a fresh take that paired with, like I’m saying, that flesh and blood moving performance, where you see this journey, this arc. And so I think the way we look at shadow is different than the way we look at shadow.

I think we’re allowing our own monsters to have compassion for our own monsters, for each other’s monsters. Learn your archetypes. Learn the rules before you break them. And even if you know the rules, fellow writers, experienced writers, it doesn’t hurt to refresh yourself. Do something different.

Devin: Dude, you sound like you’re falling asleep. That was some juicy stuff.

Adam: [unclear] related resources, video and archived content, visit our website at StoryOsophy.com.