Season 1, episode 3

What are Characters Made Of

December 1, 201735 min

Show notes

The first of many StoryOsophy episodes about character. Adam and Devin look at what makes a character good or great, where characters come from, and the components every character is built on: background, perspective, desire and choice.

In this episode

  • Relatability and reasoning. Devin needs to put himself in the hero’s shoes and believe the reasons behind every decision. Even villains need reasoning that makes sense.
  • Hero worship. Some heroes, like James Bond and Indiana Jones, are memorable because they handle a situation far better than we would.
  • Background and perspective. Culture, history and environment shape a character’s belief system, and their belief system shapes what they want.
  • Who should your hero be? Not always obvious. Long-form storytelling like Lost and Breaking Bad tracks many perspectives and builds empathy for characters we’d never expect to relate to.
  • Every character has a reason. In screenwriting every line counts, and so does every character, from the sidekick to the antagonist’s minions.
  • Make a side character the hero. Adam’s exercise: imagine another character in the scene is the hero, and let their desire throw the scene in a new direction.
  • Desire and resistance. What the character wants, what they really want, and the doubt and fear that hold them back. The lobster only grows a new shell once the old one gets uncomfortable.
  • Free write your characters. Drop them in a grocery store and listen. Let them say everything overtly in the free write, then turn it into subtext in the script.

Examples discussed

  • Indiana Jones, James Bond, Sherlock Holmes, Iron Man, Superman, Star Wars, Breaking Bad, Lost and Faulkner’s As I Lay Dying.

Next episode: character archetypes.

Read the full transcript

Transcribed automatically, so expect the odd misheard word. Sponsor messages are left out.

Adam: This is our first of many episodes talking about characters. As we are dedicating our first season to the basic components of story, let’s start with some broad strokes. How do you build a character? Where do characters come from? What are they made of? What makes a good or great character? We discuss these topics and more on this episode of StoryOsophy. Welcome to StoryOsophy. This is Adam Jones.

Devin: And Devin Halden.

Adam: So, Devin, what makes a good character and beyond that a great character? Obviously, this is a subjective question per person. But for you, what would you say makes a good and great character?

Devin: First of all, I think it’s the character. For me, the biggest element of a great character or a good character is I need to be able to relate to them in a way where I can actually put myself in his shoes and kind of feel what he’s feeling. Have his same fears, kind of want what he wants from his mission or quest that he’s on. And I need to believe him. I need to believe that he’s actually in this. He’s in this situation and cares about being in this situation. He cares about succeeding in his mission. And I need to believe that his struggles are real.

I need to believe in his reasoning for why he’s making decisions throughout his journey or quest. And simply, I just need to care about what’s happening to him. So, by the end of the story, I’m rooting for them still. And I think that if you go back and you look at some of your favorite movies, you’re like, well, it’s kind of obvious. Like any great hero in any movie that I’ve watched or any story I’ve read, you know, I do that. And it’s like, well, that’s kind of the standing ovation you need to give the writer, because it’s all about how they developed that character and really what they did prior to sitting down at a keyboard or picking up a pen to actually start writing the story.

I feel that that was probably where they spent a lot of their time figuring out who the character was.

Adam: I would actually agree with you. I think that relatability is the number one. Because if you, no matter what type of character you’re talking about, what… If you can’t relate to them, it makes it… I mean, sometimes you have villains which are not relatable, per se. And we’ll get into perspectives and things later. But you still have to understand why they’re doing, their reasoning still has to make sense. As you said, the word reasoning is actually a really excellent word to describe an audience and character relationship. You have to make sure you believe their actions based on their intentions. And that’s a lot to do with writing and development.

I was going to say something regarding heroes in general. You have this sort of hero worshiping kind of concept. So some of the heroes we like that are most memorable are the ones who are larger than life or cooler than you or tougher than you or smarter than you. You got like James Bond. James Bond and Sherlock Holmes. And there are these iconic, but both are obviously these inflated alpha male ego characters. But still, the idea is they have a franchise built on just the character alone. So there’s something that people go, man, I wish I could be that free, that courageous, that this, that fantasy or escapism to it.

Right. So there’s relatability on one end, and then there’s the other end of the spectrum where it has to do with hero worshiping. I wish I were like that person.

Devin: If you strip the armor away from Iron Man or you take the powers away from Superman or you take Indiana Jones and you just, you really just take the core of what they want. You can put whatever exterior on whatever hero you want, but it’s happiness and it’s bliss and it’s wanting something that it’s the feeling, it’s underneath, it’s emotion. It’s… It’s what somebody wants. That’s really the core of what the mission is and what their reasoning is and struggles are.

Adam: Let’s look at what you’re saying there for one second because it’s like the idea of this episode is what are characters made of? What makes up a character? Because we’re not into definitions here necessarily as far as we want to define something as a set thing. We like the exploration of it, but we do sort of want to have an idea of what characters are and talking about the traditional model so that we can then talk and discuss where it goes from here. But characters, that’s to me the number one thing that characters are made of is that want. Whatever they want. And we’ll get into that in a moment. I think the other thing to consider is I think sometimes the heroes we admire, some of the heroes we like the most are the ones who handle a situation way better than we do. It’s not necessarily a struggle for them.

Although they’re faced with an obstacle, they handle it way better than we would. And so we sort of go, man, I wish I could have come up with that one-liner. Man, you know what I mean? Those are the characters we also have fun. Like Indiana Jones, as you mentioned before, when like there’s 50 guys coming at him and he just gives a look like, huh. Actors in that aspect bring a huge part to that character. The performance of something in filmed media is it’s another huge dimension to relatability. But at the core of a character, you have to have that built in as a writer. The writer’s job is to give that character enough secrets, obstacles, depth, background, and an interesting enough perspective, not a passive perspective, but someone who’s an adventurer in a way, to give the tools to actors to perform brilliant roles, you know what I mean, to execute these brilliant. Because, you know, Harrison Ford defines a lot of action adventure genre throughout film history. His performance does. But without the great writing that is the substance of that character, he could not have made Indiana Jones as flesh and blood as he became. And as a spectator, we love that empathy and immersion when he when he gives that look of like, I, my odds suck here, but I’m going to do it anyway.

There’s something inside of you that really says, that’s what I’d like to be like in that moment.

Devin: It’s being relatable, but it’s also you believe in his reasoning into certain situations that, you know. Perhaps you wouldn’t have the courage or or or bravery to do what he’s doing in certain certain situations. So there’s part of that, like being relatable and being able to say, yeah, I can put myself in his shoes. But then there’s also this part that you can relate to the fact that you would not want to be in his shoes or you would not do it.

Adam: That classic definition of tragedy and comedy. Tragedy is when the story happens to you and comedy is when the story happens to somebody else. Same story. You know, you and I have built characters and I say built characters because you literally develop them and build them and they change and alter just like real people. People do throughout the course of the story. But I think what makes up characters, as we were talking about, I think there’s two major components we’re going to talk on in this intro episode to characters. And the first one is background and perspective sort of together because that’s part of the development of the character.

And the other one is desire, want. What does the character want? That’s an important driving tool to the story. That’s the engine. In terms of background and perspective, who should your hero be? How do you decide where a character comes from or who should be your hero?

Devin: You can have more than one. There can be a group of heroes. Sometimes it’s hero and his allies, whatever you want to call it. But a lot of times, the hero isn’t necessarily so obvious when you’re starting your story. And I think you just need to be open-minded to kind of allow a character that could be a hero. Who’s probably has the greatest arc or whose story you may follow from beginning to end more, but allow your characters to kind of provide what could be the most interesting and exciting story and then figure out from there what aspects of their story you’re going to follow or you’re going to use as kind of the thread or the through line. And it also depends on what type of story you’re telling.

Adam: If it’s just a single book or a film. Books are different because you can go into the mind of many different characters. But a film, it’s sort of like, here’s the beginning and here’s the end. If it’s a television or long-form storytelling online series kind of stuff, that’s meant for the character to develop slowly. And so they have these, each episode they have these sort of growth points, but overall there’s an arc for a season. And so it also depends on the length of media and what you, how deep you can push those concepts of, like, for instance, we’re, you know, even going back to who should you choose as your, as the voice of, you know, the navigator of the story.

These days, it’s not as simple as what the traditional model that we’re talking about says. You have groundbreaking shows like Lost, where every episode, you have a different perspective, much like in, you know, As I Lay Dying, Faulkner, where each chapter is a different voice. Filmed media is becoming more daring because the audience is smarter. We’ve seen so much stuff that they take the traditional model and start to twist it and turn it. Who should be your hero is sort of a trick question because Devin’s right. You don’t necessarily know right away. And some of the things we’ve developed, we’ve developed a bunch of characters we really like and sort of want to track all their journeys.

Much like, I think, the way that a lot of shows and films and books and different media are doing nowadays. It’s more about multiple perspective. It’s not the white knight, good guy, bad guy. There’s shades of gray in storytelling where the beauty of, and this is what we’ll get into here with this topic of background and perspective. The beauty of spending time, more time with a character is you start to understand. As a human being. And so long-form storytelling is taking off as a trend in storytelling more so now because of its accessibility via technology. But at the same time, you can track Walter White from being a guy who’s a really sweet science teacher to a maniac.

And be his friend the whole time, vicariously, separated from, you know, by a TV screen or whatever. But you still can understand him. So if you can understand another character. Another person’s perspective. Like I say, vicariously. It sort of helps to open up, like I say, storytelling and social progress, humanity. It’s all connected. So when you start to realize you can relate to a maniacal drug dealer who used to be a science teacher. It’s a little easier to talk to your neighbor. It creates compassion and empathy for things you wouldn’t normally be able to experience. That’s one of the things that I find fascinating about, especially perspective.

Characters are not just sort of a list of physical characteristics and attributes. Characters aren’t just a make, model, color, gender, size. And even in fantasy land, you know, are they an alien, are they this, that, you know, whatever it is. You still have to make that believable. The characters are shaped by their culture, history, environment. And you need to be able to show, a lot of times it’s in the first act, but throughout the piece, where that person comes from. Because once you realize what their history is, then you understand their belief system. And their perspective. Because their perspective is their belief system. How they see the world, how they perceive it.

What this tends to shape is the other larger part of character, which is what do they want. If they come from a place where they have a lack of money and they’re a poor character, money is always something that’s been on their mind as lacking. Right? So they may want it. So their background is very vital in creating the belief system of what they believe in and see. But how do you show that? Well, that’s why we need characters, plural.

Devin: Yeah, so that’s why the character archetypes exist for storytellers. They’re a tool for storytellers. It gives us certain types of characters that play a certain role in story. If it was a story just about the protagonist and no other character, it’s hard to move the story along. And provide details and information and rules of the world. And other important elements of story without some of these other types of characters. Whether they’re allies, antagonists. To pull things from Joseph Campbell, who essentially pulled these archetypes together. Like shape shifters and threshold guardians and things like that. Or just people that get in the way of the protagonist and his allies achieving their goal or achieving what they’ve set out to do.

Adam: The movement forward in a story should either reveal something about your character or drive the action forward. One of the two. And if you’re really good, really, really good, you can generally do that in every scene. The combination of both. The character archetypes, I find what’s interesting for me is this when I look at it. Sort of two points I want to make before we, before we break. If you think of a perspective, let’s say, let’s, let’s treat it traditionally from the classic protagonist, solo hero, like protagonist point of view, where there are other characters that help define the story. There, you almost think of them as reflections of the hero. Aspects. In a mythological way, that’s what Joseph Campbell and, and even Vogler, who we both love his work, what they were aiming for in having a mentor, but then in another archetype, having a higher self, which is the hero at an evolved stage.

In a way. So it’s more like a reflection from within outward, which is what I love about the archetypes, is you get to explore the inside of that character in really unique and powerful ways in the exterior world, the physical action-oriented telling of the story. And so they get to reflect different components. The sidekick might be a dubious character. Oh, we shouldn’t go in there. And so they reflect the doubt of a more competent hero. It’s just nice to have that interaction and dialogue.

Devin: Especially in screenwriting, every line is important.

Adam: Yeah.

Devin: And, because you’re counting page numbers.

Adam: Agreed. Yeah.

Devin: So every scene has to meet, there needs to be a reason for that to be there. And I think the same thing goes with characters. There’s a reason for a character. There’s a reason for every character in a story, whether the sidekick is there, even if it’s just for comic relief. But there’s also the minions of an antagonist. They’re there for a reason. Every specific minion may not be a vital character you need to know background about. But the group of the minions are there for a specific reason. So every character has a reason for being in the story.

Adam: That’s actually a really vital and valuable point you just made. And I want to make a comment on a trick to help mine the best of that. But we’ll talk about that right after the break.

Do you have a great story in mind? Some great characters? All these cool, cool scenes and you don’t know what order to put them in? What goes here? What comes next? Story Blueprint is an app that provides a powerful and versatile tool to help you, the writer, build the roadmap of your story. Know where your story is going to start, where it’s going to end, and how you’re going to get there before you even begin writing. Once you have your blueprint completed, you’ll have a bird’s eye view of your story, removing the anxiety of the blank page. Story Blueprint is currently available in the iTunes app store for iPad.

What about if you already have a finished script and you want feedback on how to improve your story for the next draft? Maybe you prefer a personal walkthrough to talk your story out one-on-one. Well, StoryOsophers, you can always talk to me. I offer a variety of supportive services from feedback for finished scripts to script doctoring and company consultations. I’ll diagnose your story to make sure all its parts are working toward the whole and strive to find a balance between traditional structure, storytelling innovation, and the writer’s personal voice and lens. I also do ongoing story therapy for writers who are looking for a coach to help build their story. I ask you the questions that help you find your own story, and we discuss how to mine its gems.

Consultation services are also available to directors and actors looking to break down scripts into beats and super objectives, and to production companies looking to refine the stories in their slate. For more information and a full menu of story doctoring options, you can visit doctajones.com. That’s d-o-c-t-a-jones.com. Links to both Story Blueprint and Dr. Jones Consultations can be found on our website at StoryOsophy.com. Before we get back to StoryOsophy, I just wanted to send out a special thanks to Rhys McClung, lead guitarist of the band Paper Sleeves, and an old friend of mine. He’s the reason why Devin’s audio sounds less like it’s in a trash can than it did before.

So thanks, Rhys. And check out Paper Sleeves’ new album, available now in iTunes.

At a point when you know your hero, and have written a scene, and you’re trying to refine it and make the scene better, I oftentimes will go back in the scene and look at any of the other characters outside of my hero, my protagonist, who are in it, and imagine, just as an exercise, that they are the hero of the scene, of the whole story. And so I let them drive the scene in my imagination for a little bit, and oftentimes, they’ll say something in this imagination game that I wouldn’t expect, but it throws the scene into an amazing direction because now that character has a desire and a want that is whether it’s competing with the hero or it distracts from the hero because the hero is an obstacle.

Like, it’s a sales clerk who wants to go on their break, and no matter what it is, it creates something. It creates an obstacle. It’s a great exercise, but it also lends to, anytime you want to figure out a character, truly, and expand them and grow them deeper, you really want to look at their desire. What do they want?

Devin: One of my favorite elements of character, and arc, really, it’s a good way to measure arc, it took them having to go on this journey, and through the struggles, and meet who they met, in order for them to realize, they had it all along.

Adam: Let’s talk about that for a second. Story and life. People telling you things and stuff, it doesn’t teach you anything. Life experience is what teaches you. Right. Because it’s all about your individual perspective as a human being. And no matter how many times someone tells you something, or you watch it, or see it, or any of that, until you actually experience something yourself, you can’t determine personally what that’s about. And so the journey is the point. Whether you end up back home or not. It’s like doing this. It’s like going on vacation and being like, oh, well, I know I’m going to go on all these places, but I’m going to end up back home, so I might as well just stay at home.

Well, you’re not going to have the experiences that shape and develop you as a human being into a different or better or, you know, may not be better, better, worse, but it shapes you into who you are to become. In terms of storytelling, a lot of it has to do with contrast for me, which I think we’ll get into in the next episode. But think polarity, positive, negative, in a dynamic for a person, an individual character. There is desire and what I would call resistance. The what is wanted by the character, what they really want, that’s what you’re saying, or what they want. And then the limitations, the feeling of limitation, whether it’s from their background, that they don’t see themselves as that thing yet. Even if the mentor sees Luke, if Obi-Wan sees Luke Skywalker and goes, you’re going to be a great Jedi. Well, from our point of view, not really, not yet. And from Luke’s, he’s like, there’s no way. But there is that so that it’s sort of doubt. It’s all those feelings that you would have that encompasses the characters. Lack of self-worth, fear, worry, anger, depression, reasons why they’re not good enough. This is sort of the inner aspect. You might call it. Inner conflict. You might even throw this in the category of flaw. But I think that takes away from the idea of the character’s perspective or the character being a chooser.

I think a character is made of perspective, desire, and choice. Because you can choose to pursue that desire or not. And so I think that that counterpart to desire, which is resistance, is how much does that hero keep themselves away from it? Because when you talk about want and need, and I would clarify. Semantics-wise for me, what you say need is the question I ask myself this. What does the character want is the first question. But what does the character really want is the twist or surprise at the end of it. And it’s need and that statement and what you’re saying as need, it’s what they were unaware of but really would fulfill them.

And because need, I think, has to do, it connotes a lack to me. Need does.

Devin: The need is actually the journey, or the quest. And I would agree with, I would agree with, and I was actually going to clarify a little better. I think it’s want one and want two, but the way you say it is a little better. I think what they want in the beginning, they realize isn’t really what they wanted, so what they really want. And so what they need is to go through the struggles, or the quest, or whatever that journey is, in order for them to realize what that want is. You need to pull them out of that comfort zone and throw them into a pot of unknown, just like trying to equate it to everybody’s life.

It’s the same thing. It’s like, in order to grow as a person, you need to get out of a comfort zone, and you need to be vulnerable to a new environment.

Adam: I believe it’s the lobster, crustacean of some sort, but I think it’s the lobster, who, when it grows too large for its shell, it leaves the shell behind, goes under a rock, and is safe there until it grows the new shell. But the only reason that this lobster knows to go under the rock and drop this shell, right, is it’s grown too large for the shell and becomes uncomfortable. It wouldn’t know it’s time to change unless it were uncomfortable first.

And so it is this sort of like the sand and the oyster that makes the pearl concept. It’s an irritant. It’s a little bit of contrast to the world that they’re used to that makes the change happen. I think that’s the weirdest thing for people to understand, is change starts from a lack of comfort sometimes. If you’ve grown used to a certain thing over and over and over, and it’s not really serving your future growth as a human being, as an individual, things will change. Things are going to happen that start to stir the pot and get your butt in gear. It’s just the way it works.

That personal uncomfortability is sort of like a personal lack of satisfaction with your intentions, your desires, what you want versus that resistance of it. Resistance is the internal force of antagonism, which will be mirrored by the external force of antagonism as the antagonist or other characters. So when you get to the what do they really need? Part of the equation, that’s sort of when they let go of this resistance and have a personal understanding about themselves and that desire that they couldn’t have had without the reflections of everyone else to that point. But they still have the realization of that, and we may glimpse it as an audience member or reader or viewer or whomever all along.

If it’s been well woven by a very crafty storyteller. You’re going to go, of course, that’s what they become, but it still should feel like a surprise that really want part.

Devin: And a realization, like a specific moment where the character puts the pieces together, or the protagonist or hero, however you want to define it, starts putting the pieces together of what they’ve learned, who they’ve met along the journey. And it becomes. An aha moment for them. They’re like, this is what I really set out to do. Yeah. It’s a fun thing to write for a writer. It’s a fun moment or scene. And it’s also a fun thing when you’re watching, you’re reading something and you discover that with the character. You’re like, that’s this is what they really this is what it was. And some really fun discovery moment.

Adam: That’s something that we should touch on here, too, is because this, I think, is where you mine the most joy out of writing. We were talking about this earlier in the podcast regarding the whether it’s. Important to develop the characters before you write developing characters. Here’s why it’s, it’s important to start that ahead of time. I think Devin and I on scripts that we’ve worked on, we we’ve talked about and just bounced around ideas about what characters would be like, what we want to do with them. And, but they speak for themselves. You don’t make a character talk, really. You let them talk, you sort of let the, you, you figure out what that character is about and develop it ahead of time.

And then the fun of it is taking a traditional structure like the one we’ll, we’ll be discussing and running that character through it and go. Now, if we took this type of person, this human being that we’ve built, because essentially what you’re doing with characters is you’re building a person you’re building a, and even for actors, they’ll build, they’re building that in live flesh. You know what I mean? They’re bringing that to even further life, but you’re building a human being and, or a, if it’s a fictional character, of course. And in that. You’re building that. You can then put them in any of these proposed circumstances. Let’s say, for instance, there’s the beginning-middle-end, right? The foundation, the crisis, the center, and then you don’t have to do it at the center, but let’s say it’s at the center, and then the final thing is the climax.

So that you put a character in a circumstance, they’re going to react differently. So the fun of the storytelling is developing all these different characters, and then putting them in an event together and seeing what they do, and sort of letting them talk, and if you know them well enough, they’re familiar enough, it’s sort of like if you were experiencing something by yourself, and you wished one of your best friends were with you, and so instead you’re experiencing it by yourself, and you can just hear everything that person would have said if they were with you. If they were here. That’s how much you know them. If you can know your characters like that, and then apply them to the structure we’re talking about, the traditional events, it’s so much fun. It’s sort of, as Devin has said to me before, it’s freeing to know that. To have the structure, and then you build these characters, and you just put them in it. Knowing structure is freeing, ironically. And I attribute that to you, Devin, because you’ve said that a lot.

Devin: I think that’s a good checks and balance of, have you spent enough time with your character before? Before you threw them into the story, is when you get to a scene, and you instantly know how this character will react, what he’ll say, his mannerisms, his slang that he’ll use, all of these things that you’ve developed beforehand, it’s a good checks and balances. And it’s also, conversely, if you are stuck, where you’re like, I don’t know how he would react, or all of a sudden you go back and read it, and you’re like, man, it’s just not in line. With this character three pages ago, or in the different scene, then that’s kind of where you know where, at what point, or what elements or characteristics of your character that you need to kind of polish, or you need to, you don’t want that to, all of a sudden you have, you know, a Jekyll and Hyde type of character.

It’s confusing to an audience or a reader.

Adam: It’s not consistent. Right. It’s not consistent.

Devin: Throwing them into these scenes, even before you even start writing, that’s a good, it’s just, it’s a good exercise. To really get to know your characters, and all of your characters, from protagonist to antagonist.

Adam: And there is something to be said, and I want to throw this out there, for free writing. I try to do a free write every day, where I allot myself a little chunk of time, and just write whatever I want to for fun, just to get the juices flowing. And I think, if you’re working on a new script or new characters, it’s fun and fine to pitch them into, you’re like, all right, let’s put them in the grocery store. And just listen. Like, imagine that scene, daydream. And listen to them talk, and how they might interact with each other. That scene is not necessarily going to be in your script.

But the way they interact, and what this, the way this person feels about potato chips, or whatever the heck you come up with, ends up becoming an interesting aspect of their personality. And if it’s, it doesn’t work, throw it away. But you’re starting to listen and give voice to those characters. So, you can write, but I wouldn’t say start writing, I would say keep it in free write land. Until you understand a good bit. Until you understand those things. And I think, just to sort of sum this up a bit, in those free writes, a lot of times what I discover for myself, is I won’t necessarily take the free write and use it, but I’ll mine from it a little bit, in this way.

Usually, if I’m doing something free write like that, they’re speaking very overtly. What you don’t want in a final script. I love you. I love you, too. You want, if they’re nervous to say that. If they’re nervous to say that, they’re going to talk about the chips instead. Subtext. Right. So, you find yourself in the free writes, writing text that you’re going to turn into subtext. At least, that’s what I do when I’m first building characters, is write what they’re going to say inside, out loud, in the free write. So, you know what they want, overtly. And then you go, okay, now they’re not going to ever say that out loud.

You’re going to turn that into subtext and write interesting dialogue over the top of it. Right. But feel free to be. That sincere and overt and all that in that free write. Because it’s just, you dedicate that free write time for just you and you and those characters hanging out with them. And I think that, what I was going to say is those free writes not only generate motivation in terms of what an actor might use to perform said role. That’s where you would find their secrets and obstacles. And you start to grow that stuff so you can place it in strategic ways throughout the structure of a story.

For setups and payoffs. But you’re also, so you’re getting their motivation, which means their relationship between thought or perspective and their desire, what they want. And that relationship is key to what a character is. And subtext is the fun game that writers get to play regarding both those things with their audience. It’s like flirting almost. And so I encourage you to play and write a lot that won’t necessarily end up in your final project, you know, in your final product. Write more pages than you’re going to use and just play. And I think that’s how you find out what characters want or don’t want a lot of times is just playing around. Please subscribe and rate us on iTunes. And for additional story related resources, video and archived content, visit our website at StoryOsophy.com.