Season 2, episode 46

Refusal of Call

Act 1, movement 1: Out of the comfort zone

April 7, 201959 min

Show notes

The call to quest is about the journey and the antagonist. The refusal of the call is about your hero. It’s the moment to show the audience what’s holding your hero back: self-imposed limits, fear, the sense that they aren’t good enough or ready. Adam and Devin explain why this is one of their favorite events to write, how the doubt planted here echoes across the whole story, and the many shapes a refusal can take.

In this episode

  • Spotlight the hero. The refusal sets up the internal obstacles your hero must overcome. If they don’t overcome them, they finish the story unchanged, or changed for the worse.
  • Show the doubt, save the backstory. Tell the audience that your hero won’t go near water, not why. Keep the formative moments for later and let the mystery unfold.
  • Doubt turns into debate. The hero argues for their own limitations, weighing everything the herald has put in front of them.
  • Events echo. The refusal ripples out to every later threshold, especially the fall of the heart wall and the now-or-never moment of the climax.
  • Listen to your characters. Devin’s example: a hero you planned as an introvert turns out to be an extrovert wearing a mask, and her refusal changes completely. She says yes in public, then panics alone at home.
  • Confused, more confused, clear. In Act 1, be clear about your hero’s confusion.
  • The key event. A retired cop refuses a kidnapping case, until he learns the girl is his daughter.
  • Mentors. Supernatural aid, an outside mentor, or an inner mentor, and keeping the refusal tight to save pages.
  • Variations from Christopher Vogler. Avoidance, excuses, conflicting calls, positive refusals, willing heroes and threshold guardians.

Examples discussed

  • Jumanji: Welcome to the Jungle: only Martha really refuses, and the denial carries on inside the game once it’s too late to turn back.
  • Alice in Wonderland: a refusal that comes too late.
  • Edward Scissorhands: there’s no clear refusal in the film. Devin offers a theory: Edward’s refusal is his lifelong unwillingness to leave the mansion, while the clippings on his wall are the call. When he tells Peg “Don’t go,” he accepts. Peg is both the herald and the mentor who carries him into the unknown world.
  • Office Space and Liar Liar, for avoidance and conflicting calls.
  • Also: A Christmas Carol, and its adaptations Scrooged and The Muppet Christmas Carol.

Writing along with the season? Write your hero’s refusal as a follow-on to the call you’ve already written. For a warm-up free-write: one person asks to share an elevator, and the other argues every reason not to.

Read the full transcript

Transcribed automatically, so expect the odd misheard word. Sponsor messages are left out.

Adam: In this episode, we discuss the story event refusal of call to quest. Now that your hero has received the call, how do they answer it? Are they a willing hero or do they have doubts and inner conflicts? Next on StoryOsophy. Hello. Welcome to StoryOsophy. This is Adam Jones.

Devin: And Devin. Holden. Devin Halden.

Adam: Holden.

Devin: Devin Halden. Holden. Holden. Devin Halden.

Adam: If there’s one thing that I’ve learned throughout this experience, it’s how to say your last name properly. Hall rather than Hal. Halden. Devin Halden. I’m from West Virginia, baby.

Devin: It’s natural to go the Hal. The Hal route. You know what I figured out? It’s the two syllable first name and two syllable last name that it always just sounds weird. Like Devin Halden. It should be Devin Haldenton. Haldenton.

Adam: Oh, rhythm of a name. There are theories I have on rhythm of a name. If you have a singular syllable first name and then a long last name or a second two syllable last name, it’s fine. If you have a long first name, multiple syllables and a singular syllable last name, it also works in any circumstance because it’s sort of like punctuation or reverse punctuation. Right. But the other ones, they sort of have to have a rhythm to them. Yeah. And I think about this when I’m doing character names too. How is this going to sound? How is this going to sound when someone says it out loud?

Whether it’s mentally as a reader in a book or on screen as a performer. How is it going to sound? You’re in an action movie. It can’t be 80 syllables long. Right. Because it’s got to be short and sweet so you can go, Jen, over here. And it’s got to have strong consonants so that it can sound commanding because that’s all you’re going to say is, run, Jen. Jen, move. So, it’s got to sound action-y. Yeah. But I think about rhythm and sounds of names all the time. It’s a very Dickens thing to do. Their name was onomatopoeic of their personality. Their names sounded like who they were as a person and it’s, I always love, I love Dickens.

We share that affinity, right? Yeah. You love Dickens too or at least Christmas Carol, I know.

Devin: No, I do love Dickens. I do like Dickens. I wouldn’t say that I’m a Dickens connoisseur. I’m not either by any means. I have read Dickens’ version of Christmas Carol. Oh, really? Yeah. I love Christmas Carol. But there’s been so many versions and renditions of that story done that now it’s kind of, I don’t really remember exactly because it’s very, there’s a lot of people have taken liberties with that story.

Adam: Oh, sure. Well, in adaptations, even Scrooged and things like that, they’ve taken the basis of the story. But that’s, I think, a testament to the story itself is the structure of that particular one and the relevance of human connection, especially during Christmas time. They’re all really resonant things for people that continue on. And so that becomes a great work for that reason. But Muppets did it. Bill Murray did Scrooge, which I love that version. The Muppets one’s really good, too. We’re going on a tangent for a little bit. And we talk about this linear, non-linearly. It’s one of the few stories that time-traveled during Christmas about loving people. I mean, it’s the best of all worlds. It’s an early time-travel movie because the ghosts take him to past, present, and future. And that’s a pretty brilliant concept for that time in literature. I mean, really, what, him and H.G. Wells, Jules Verne, who else was doing stuff like, but we don’t realize it because it was so deftly done. You don’t even realize it. It feels natural.

It feels natural because human beings don’t think linearly. We remember stuff. We project into the future. We try to ground ourselves in the now, but oftentimes we’re distracted in either one of those directions, time or anti-time, going backwards in time. It’s not my favorite Dickens, but it’s the most memorable of Dickens for me because of those amazing innovations. Yeah. But Dickens was great for having a multitude of characters and broad worlds, big worlds that were focused on a theme. And now you’re… We’re seeing it a lot with series developing. Mm-hmm. Online series, it’s like we’re allowed to develop with people rather than the specific white knight singular hero perspective on a singular journey or quest. And although we talk about quest in this podcast, we don’t mean it as a literal physical quest or journey that has to happen. We talk a lot about the internal world of a hero too. So if you’re writing an intimate drama or something with nuance, it’s there. Anyway, you want to get into it?

Yeah. Do it, man. Refusal, call. Let’s refuse the call to quest today. Refusal of call to quest. Let’s set this up. So we’re still in Act 1, breaking down the structure of Act 1. And Act 1, as Devin and I talk about it, is the known world to the unknown world of Act 2 and beyond. We break the story across movements. Movement 1 is a comfort zone to out of comfort zone for your hero. Usually… We had an interesting discussion last week……about placement of Movement 1 and Act 1. They’re generally the same thing. It’s the introduction to your story. It’s the foundation, the essence. And the events we’ve covered so far are the hook, which is just meant, obviously, to bait your audience to hook them. The known world routine, which establishes the status quo of your story.

And your hero, and maybe suggests their wants and desires. The inciting incident, which introduces the, as Devin would say, the first domino being tipped in your story, that sends it in motion. And then the call to quest, which is where that, whatever the momentum of the story is, meets your hero, and the hero’s given an invitation. Invitation, whether it’s a question or whether it’s a statement, to join that story. As we discussed, sometimes that inciting incident will shift around, might be your hook, might be part of your call to quest. But when we get here to call to quest, this is one of those stages where it breaks, we’ve broken it down into finer points because we’ve We’ve seen a lot of value in these finer points. So, from call to quest, refusal of call. And Devin, I believe this is one of your favorite events to write?

Yes, it is. He’s not lying on air when he says it’s his favorite event. Every event, he’s like a little kid, every event is his favorite event to write.

Devin: Every event. Especially in movement one or act one is my favorite event. We do agree on that point fully. Like, I love act one too. We kind of touched on it earlier, this like series of events is so much fun to write. We talked about last episode that the call to quest is really about our antagonist. It’s, it’s providing information about the quest or the journey and perhaps the dangers or perils of that journey, but also the bit, a bit about the antagonist. Like this is the reason why we’re asking you, we’re providing you the opportunity to go on this quest. We’re calling you to this quest is because Because this needs to happen. And oftentimes, this is an antagonist. There’s something in the way or something that has stolen something or something you need to get back or someone’s love, someone in the way of the person you love or, you know, there’s something that needs to be overcome.

Order to successfully complete the quest. And that’s the call the quest is focused on the antagonist and the obstacles of the journey or the journey itself. And with refusal of the call, this is where we we really focus on and we highlight our hero. And this is such a fantastic opportunity for us writers to really give our audience the main issues, our hero or heroes in an ensemble piece like Jumanji, give the audience what they need to know about our heroes at that moment, and create a little mystery about our hero. Sure, it’s obvious that that he has or they have some internal obstacles and issues that are preventing them from answering.

But we don’t have to tell the entire background stories, how these internal obstacles manifested inside them. Save those seminal moments that shape our hero for when we feel that our our audience is like, why is why are they like this? And why can’t they just do this? This is what they should be doing? Like what is holding them back? You know, what is their biggest issues? And so we can provide them with a little bit more information about that. But we’re using Refusal of the Call to Quest to really focus on a reason that is who would hold our hero back or some internal reason like their own limitation, their own self-imposed limitation limitations. They don’t feel they’re good enough. Yeah, they don’t think they could ever complete something like this. This is so daunting. They, they, they’re, they don’t feel like they’re ready, or they don’t even want to you know, they don’t want to even embark on something so, so daunting. And so, but it’s real, we’re really focusing on that, because what we’re doing here is setting up the internal obstacles they’re going to overcome during this journey, there’s going to be physical obstacles, the plot is usually what is all the external stuff that they’re going to encounter. But then there’s the internal things that are more important of overcoming than the external stuff that is, is they don’t overcome the internal obstacles, then they will not be able to, they’ll be unchanged, they’ll be unchanged. Correct. Yeah. Or may even be changed for the worst, right? They don’t align with the internal definitely don’t don’t mail this event in this is something we should really think about your character and what they want to convey and what you want to convey to the audience about who they are right now. Because again, the shapes our hero, how our heroes going to react in certain situations in the beginning of the story, in the middle, in the end, in the end.

Middle of the story, and how they must react differently after learning things along this journey in order to be successful. I love this event.

Adam: This event echoes across the rest of your story. And the most important point is doubt. Doubt is this what you’re spotlighting in this event, really, in its own little variations. But what you’ll see it reflected in is every time they’re about to cross a threshold and to change, and you’ll get to see how they approach that change and debate it internally with each new threshold. That’s why we break these up into movements so you can track your thresholds and actually advance your hero in their growth and not just by the end of the story. Because we’re interested in more complicated and in-depth stories and characters these days.

So that refusal echoes across especially the event, the fall of the heart wall. And then the now or never moment in our three part climax. If you haven’t listened, we’ve there’s one Story Blueprint overview episode, a few episodes. Back, which sort of lays out the structure we’re talking about. Worth a listen if you haven’t listened. But these events will will reverb. It’s like ripples in a pond. They’ll reverberate across the story and the ones that there are more resistance against, you’ll get more stronger ripples until it’s solved. And other ones will dissolve like storylines overlapping. And you treat the thresholds as growth points, but allow your story that sort of overlap and these echoes that you’re setting up across the rest of the story from movement one.

Act one. Hopefully that helps to exemplify like why you go back to movement one and refine it. You see you once you develop beyond the essence or foundation of it and you get you get a more in depth with those ideas. Yes, then you can go back and go all I need to tell the audience in movement one in this scene is that they don’t like water period. Not why not how not all this other stuff, but just give the point of interest and make it the most interesting and then unfold that.

Devin: As you go across each new threshold with your hero as they discover the audience discovers and to piggyback on that and the importance of revisiting this entire movement really but revisiting this event in particular and refining it is trust me no matter how much you feel you know your character, especially your hero. When you begin writing, or when you begin building your Story Blueprint, they will continue to change. And they’ll evolve. And it’s important for us writers to be malleable. Open for that change and to listen to our characters and let them tell us what their internal obstacles are and who they are, because you may start writing, you may start writing feeling that your character’s internal obstacle is that they are severely introverted and in this quest is going to force them to have to overcome this introvert this being introverted to be successful.

Then as you continue to build your Story Blueprint and your scripting and your writing every situation your hero has been in. She actually is becoming a little she’s she’s more extroverted in these in these situations you’re putting it them into and in fact her being an extrovert actually makes her a much more dynamic and deep character and and then and and it opens up a ton of possibilities and and and assertive of the internal self and assertive of the internal self right yeah so that all of a sudden you’re like okay so that your characters telling you something that opens up some other possibilities and situations that could be really really funny or moving.

And then you continue to listen to your character and in those she’s she’s more extroverted she has actually taken on a bit of a bitchy tone and demeanor but that’s really funny and maybe maybe she’s using humor as a defense mechanism on the outside and she seems happy and she’s confident and she’s got her shit together but on the inside when she’s alone she’s terrified self-conscious and depressed and maybe she’s always wearing long sleeve shirts and even. In the dead of summer and it’s to hide the scars on her arms from the cuts that she gives herself at night and like holy crap all of a sudden our hero went from this introvert and not really an interesting character to someone with these multiple layers and probably a more interesting and powerful and in somewhat moving character that you could really build a story around and she she’s definitely now has some internal obstacles to overcome but her refusal of the call changes dramatically from when she was an introvert to.

This very layered extrovert and the the event may even mimic how she goes through life right so she is presented with this call to quest and she answers the call to quest immediately because that’s that’s her character that’s the character extroverted character of her because she knows.

That’s the mask she wears and that’s how she wants people to see her. Then when she gets home and she’s alone and maybe she becomes terrified of the prospect of going on this quest. And now she’s painted herself into a corner. And so does she back out and refuse to call the quest or does she like force herself to go on this quest for fear her cover will be blown and her reputation is blown and as fake as that may be. And then it will completely destroy her. So this is like this juicy way to throw our hero into this unknown world now is is she’s just as confusing internally as she is externally.

But but if you would have just stuck with I have this I really want my character to be this introvert and and then I’m going to put her in these situations and then you start writing and you start putting her in these situations and she keeps telling she’s screaming at you like no I’m an extrovert but I’m an extrovert because it’s my mask.

Adam: You start pigeonholing yourself.

Devin: And then yeah right right the refusal of the call to adventure is so important for the depth of our character our hero and to really even even in that example I just gave where it’s like we’re not necessarily giving the audience or the readers all of that information at once we’re not letting them know that when our hero does go home she cuts herself or she’s like like she’s very conflicted and complex we may not have to give them that.

Adam: Or like or like Edwards. Slices through the wallpaper right your example is sort of relevant in Edwards journey throughout the film much later in the film and it’s and he becomes more layered yeah as a character throughout that film which is what you could do with that example I just threw so that’s a perfect parallel from confused to even more confused is sort of Edwards journey nothing is clear right away and so if you’re really going to look at across the three act structure it’s confused more confused clear that’s sort of what you want. To do with a hero’s emotional mental landscape there they’re in a place where their comfort zone is simply there through the known world routine the routine of what they know and then as a story moves along they’re venturing into new territory which is even more confusing and that’s why you have progressive complications or the three o’s obstacles the middle oh you’re sort of tracking that confusion into more confusion and so you just need.

As strange as this sounds, in Act 1, you need to be clear about your confusion.

Devin: No. It makes perfect sense.

Adam: How is your character confused in Act 1 so that by the end, when all of Act 3 is all clarity, because you’re complicating it with confusion in Act 2, you’ve got all these things where people go, oh, you set up the punchline to that joke in Act 1. Right. Oh, you set up that payoff in Act 1, that objective and outcome. As writers, you’re building a puzzle. You seem more well, I mean, you have built it better, but you seem as a better writer or storyteller if you simply do that. But it’s a nonlinear way of building it. So, as Devin was saying, you go back to Movement 1 or Act 1 and you refine those things. Once you get to your climax, you go, oh, okay, this is what I really need to pay off here. I trickle this in throughout the story. You backwards develop in a lot of ways.

Right. As I’m saying this out loud, I’m moving my fingers from right to left and sort of tracking it backwards mentally. Yes, I’m talking with my hands alone in a room.

Devin: In a room.

Adam: Okay, so let’s put it this way. This is the vulnerability point of your hero, your first touchstone to that. In depth, you may have hints of it earlier in previous events to now, but this is going to reverberate into your fall of the heart wall and even the sort of dark night of your soul of your character before that event. Right. There are things like that that happens that stir them up, but the doubt resurfaces because now they have to question it again. And then you find that there’s a bringing forth from the internal to the external for the final, quote, action of your climax, the now or never moment.

And that reverberation, it stems from this doubt. Doubt moment. And we’re so interested in this vulnerable doubt moment because we, the audience, are trying to figure out why. Why is this person like this? Who is this person? Outside a plot, if you’re not looking at what happens next, if you’re really looking at why an audience gets involved in a character, this is why. How and why. And this event is pivotal to the introduction of that. Now, you’re going to peel back layers of the onion that expose more of what this is. And as Devin just walked you through, but this is where we first. See it a good way to sort of embrace this moment. Someone asks you to do something. That’s your call. Someone calls you to do something. This refusal moment, this doubt moment. And we’ll talk about it. It can manifest in many different emotional states. But doubt is a great way to sort of pigeonhole it for the moment. Fear is at the core of it. The best way to turn this into a scene is to think of it as debate. Doubt into debate.

Look at the refusal. I like. This and we’ve all done it. You’re arguing for your own limitations. Something that seems like a little more effort. You don’t want to do something that someone else wants you to do. You don’t want to do your sort of find ways of arguing for the reasons why you shouldn’t excuses. There’s different ways of approaching it. But whatever the doubt is, whatever the fear is, or even the apathy is, you need to argue for it. Even if it’s arguing for your limitations as a hero in this moment. If someone tells you like this new movie that’s out. If someone tells you that you are King Arthur to pull the sword from the stone and defeat an army of evil or whatever it is, you have to have the confidence to be able to do that. The whole point of the call is that’s the question. Here’s the premise. Here’s what we need from you. Here’s what the world needs from you, King Arthur. That’s the call.

The refusal is the hero not feeling like they are prepared for the job and debating that. Giving any reason. Giving any reason why they’re not the right person for the job. Now, in a lot of stories, people don’t argue that. If it’s their job to do that thing, sometimes they’ll step up. Sometimes they’ll have, let’s say in a police drama, the chief says, you’re assigned to this case. And the person goes, I don’t think I should be the person for the job. Why? Because this and that and this and that. No, you’re the best cop on the force. You’re assigned to it. Sometimes there’s this forced scenario.

But do understand there is a small call in there. And that call says, I’m not the right person for the job because I knew that person back when I was in that precinct or whatever. You’ll find the weak link in that refusal moment. And it requires some convincing in some way. There’s a fine line here between refusal and choosal. The convincing happens across both in a way. The catalyst.

Devin: Right. And it’s important also to note that the refusal of a call highlights doubt. And it also highlights internal obstacles. But when they choose the call to quest, it doesn’t mean at all that that doubt and internal obstacles disappear. They carry on until throughout much of the story and really up until that fall of the heart wall event when they actually do overcome it.

Adam: They communicate that vulnerability. They let go of that regret, that guilt, whatever it is that they’re holding on to as a weight. That’s not allowing them to move forward or grow there. That’s where they let go of it. Psychologically speaking.

Devin: That’s right, Dr. Jones. That’s right.

Adam: But it’s worth mentioning, too, the convincing moment, because I don’t know where you – I don’t know that we really talked about this part of it. Where this convincing – there’s a refusal point, and then there’s a convincing of the hero that this is – and I’m not saying it’s an external thing. Someone, like, convinces the hero. I actually am a fan of sort of witnessing the hero figuring that out for themselves and not someone telling them that. Like, the debate allows the hero to find – almost like the mentor is a higher self aspect.

Devin: For me –

Adam: Like, the future version of – yeah.

Devin: I actually put in – I like to stick in another quasi-event in here. So, my series will go, like, inciting incident. Call to Quest, Refusal to Call to Quest, Key Event or Key Incident, and Choosal of the Quest. And that Key Incident is something or someone says something or something happens. There’s something that happens in that moment that there isn’t necessarily a convincing to go on the quest. It’s literally puts – it makes it so personal to the hero that there really isn’t enough. Now, they’re – they have to go on this quest, even though it’s enough to push them to accept the call, call to quest, because it’s so personal.

Like, it’s like – Die Hard kind of is, but it’s like if you’re – somebody gets kidnapped, okay, somebody’s kidnapped. That sucks. Or even taken. You know, someone gets kidnapped, great. That’s the, you know, inciting incident. Someone says, hey, we need you. You’re the best cop in the force. He’s like, oh, I’m retired. I just can’t do it. I just don’t want to do it. I don’t want to do it anymore. Just give it to one of these young, hungry guys. Oh, we didn’t – we forgot to tell you. It’s your – it’s your daughter. Now, it’s like, okay, this is a – now it’s a completely different situation. I have to do this now. Now, I’m going to choose it.

So, it’s kind of – that’s a very broad – very broad idea of it.

Adam: No, because it illustrates each little event at the same time. And I would say what you’re talking about between refusal, choosal is a catalyst event.

Devin: Yeah, yeah.

Adam: Like, there’s something that – something changes. It doesn’t have to be someone convincing. Convincing might have been a misnomer. And I wanted to mention this, too, as we track through this. With the Vogler and Joseph Campbell model, they have something called meeting with the mentor or supernatural aid from Campbell’s model. But what I suggest is there is some force that assists or convinces or moves – like in a Greek myth or something, when a god comes down and says, you’re meant to go on this quest, and here are your weapons, and there you go. So, it’s that sort of mentality.

Devin: Mm-hmm.

Adam: But in our model, what we’re trying to do is make this more about personal choice of a character. Right. And so, rather than have it be about external supernatural aid, it has to do with internal connection to self. Mm-hmm. That’s why the doubt can be shown externally in a debate. The internal doubt’s important to show. So, you don’t necessarily have to have a mentor character here. There’s variations. Right. And you don’t have to have a mentor character here. You can really have someone – imagine this for a second, and this is not going to work as a scene, really, but someone talking out loud to themselves about the situation.

Now, if you add a second person, a second character into that conversation, it becomes a debate. But the person themselves is using two different voices in their head for pros and cons if they were thinking about it themselves. Oh, I can’t do this. I’m too weak. But they told you. Do you know what I mean? You’re sort of weighing it out.

Devin: Mm-hmm.

Adam: It’s not – it’s easier to dramatize that with a secondary external character, i.e. Debate, someone trying to convince and someone trying to say why they can’t do it. But the impetus for that should come from that internal debate, I can or I can’t, I can or I can’t, because we want to see that, because that’s the seesaw of the stakes for the rest of the story for that character, will they or won’t they? Right. In a story or on screen, I mean, in a novel, you can say they’re thinking this, they’re thinking this. But to boil it down to its essence, that can be the case. You don’t need the supernatural aid, you don’t need the meeting the mentor, you can go into your own thought, your own internal space and make the choice rather than have something force the choice. And expanding beyond that, of course, there’s a secondary character who convinces you. There’s a, you know, a group of people that say, you are the chosen one, you pull the sword from the stone.

Like, there’s, you know, there’s influence outside of that. But the base of this, reflected in the later Fall of the Heart Wall scene, the base of this is trying to find that character’s internal place that no matter who you are in the audience, you understand what it’s like to be them. Who cares about the plot points? You can connect with their vulnerability. Yeah, relatability. You have to show it somehow. And so there are lots of variations. Debate, just to be honest, debate’s the easiest one. Have two people on either side of the equation. And if for nothing else, write your first draft that way. Just have people at two extreme sides. This person wants this, this person wants the opposite. Write that. That’s a great refusal free write. It’ll help you understand what your characters do and don’t want.

It’s one of those that seems like it might not be important other than just to say, no, no, thank you. But you can,

Devin: And it’s also page economy and story economy. Don’t waste, especially in screenwriting, don’t waste a sentence. Don’t even, don’t waste a line. Don’t waste a word. And there’s a reason for every scene, every scene, every event that you put into your story is not only should have a reason. It’s your opportunity to layer your story. It’s your opportunity to provide. And to translate story for the reader and, and, and give them information. And it shouldn’t, there, there really shouldn’t be a, a throwaway scene where it’s like, oh, our filler scenes or anything like that. We’re like, well, I have to show them walking around. Like we talked about with known world routine last episode. Well, known world, world routine. If you just look at it on the surface is, well, we got to show him walking around the city, maybe going, doing what he does every day, because that’s, you know, we got to show him.

Yeah. Establish some type of status quo or what, what his normal world is, his normal routine is. Well, you could do that, but you could also take another layer of that and start setting up this refusal of the call or what, or how he’s reacting to the call to quest by showing a little bit of these signs of these internal obstacles or these internal issues or things that could possibly manifest.

Adam: Like being an unassertive person in a, in a, your boss’s boss and you’re around and you’re unassertive. If you just establish that little simple fact, when you come to the call to adventure, are you going to assert yourself? Right. Those little setups that you, you know, you can show in an instant that you can pay off in an instant so that you can. Right. We don’t need to know a lot as an audience at the beginning. If this guy is a billionaire, we get it. Right. If this guy. If this guy is a check to check guy, we get it. Right. You don’t need to over explain it. We just, it’s the whole beginning of Jumanji where they go from household to household and you get 30 seconds, a minute and a half and you’re done. You’re out. They’re just letting you know the only things you need to know.

Exactly. And keeping it tight like that so that you can, it’s almost like the story will start as a bud and bloom. Right. We talk about it as an onion peeling about layers, but you also can think of it as a flower. It’ll start small and then open up. And it just gets better and better and broader, like in its concept and its ideas. It’s helpful to use visual images when you’re working on things to give it flow.

[Sponsor message]

Adam: StoryOsophy. StoryOsophy.

All right, here we go. Examples, people. Jumanji, Welcome to the Jungle, Refusal of Call. It seems, as we talked a little bit about last episode, it seems simple, but it’s not. When they do the call to the adventure, it’s inviting everyone to choose to play the video game, Jumanji. It’s to have them choose an avatar and step into the threshold of the video game. Now, the refusal part, nobody really refuses that, except for Martha. Mm-hmm. Everybody, when asked, is a willing hero in Jumanji.

Devin: It’s actually hard with Call to Quest, Refusal of Call to Quest, and Accept, or an Answer Call to Quest, it’s hard to speak specifically just about one of those, because they happen so, they’re all very linked together, and so I think we covered, it was hard for us even to break it apart last episode, so we’ve actually covered a lot of this already, but I guess we can try to clean it up, and specifically more about this refusal.

Adam: It’s a continued discussion, let’s call it. Yeah. We’ll figure it out. You’ll figure it out with us along the way.

Devin: Although there is something interesting, like at first it. Jumanji is interesting because you don’t know, like you were saying, everybody’s a willing. They’re willing to play the game. Except Martha, but then of course, peer pressure gets her to… But that’s important,

Adam: To point out the one… It is. The one who doesn’t refuse, and what that means with the other ones being willing. The interesting part

Devin: Of that for me, though there is a refusal and a debate, the game will not let them… This is once they’re in Jumanji. There’s a refusal and a debate, but the game won’t let them out because they refuse the call to quest. They must finish the game to escape and get back to the known world. Yeah. However, like the refusal that would happen in a typical known world after a call to quest has been presented by a herald, our heroes still question their ability to be successful. They still need to look within and push on and answer that call to quest in order to finish the game.

So even though they… There’s still an element of the refusal where they all… All these internal issues or even these character-specific elements that we made very clear when we met them. Part of that is coming out here where, yeah, they can’t refuse the call and they can’t, you know, other than if they want to live in Jumanji forever. But that part of the refusal, the doubt, is still there. When they’re in Jumanji and they realize that they have to finish this game. So that was my one main point.

Adam: This is a really unique example. Jumanji is a really unique example. So Jumanji, there’s a… There’s a call to adventure and really what we’re seeing, what it lays out in very clear ways is the call, refusal, and choosal in the video game. And for your first act, it’s really important to keep it this tight. I’m a huge fan of the first act being really tight, like 15 pages. Get into the story. Let’s go. Here’s how they do it, but their refusal is very brief. You got Fridge finds the gaming system, Spencer looks at the TV, they look at each other in agreement. We get this one moment where Spencer’s willing, if Fridge is willing, so they don’t have a refusal.

Because Fridge is gonna get… Wants to get out of work. He’s not interested. He finds this, he’s interested. And Spencer’s game, even though he might mean, lean more in the Martha camp usually, like we gotta do our, we, you know, play by the system rules and pull out these staples. He wants to befriend Fridge. He wants to rekindle their friendship. That’s why he did the paper. That’s why it’s a stakes thing in the beginning for Spencer. So when he has this smile and like, let’s go play for a little bit, he doesn’t have a refusal for that reason. And it’s a, it’s a, just a moment, but it sets up everything about why he doesn’t refuse. They set up the video game. Bethany’s a little curious of what they’re doing because she doesn’t want to be here. She doesn’t want to be doing this.

She’d rather be doing something fun than nothing, than this. And so when they ask her if she wants to join, she says, sure. She just like, yeah, I’ll play. Now, when it, I mean, it also says something about her. She’d rather do the game than the work. And she chooses her avatar. Each person is looking at their avatar. The only person who really says, no, I don’t want to play is Martha because Martha is much more, she’s the, as Devin was saying before, the way that fridge is sitting away from the rest of them on the bench. This is Martha’s away from the rest of them.

This is where she sort of goes, I’m not into the system or what the crowd wants. She sort of rejects peer pressure for like five eighths of a second to just to show. But she does have this refusal moment and she separates herself. Looking just at that, the doubt, the vulnerability moments, when everybody self isolates, when any of these characters self isolates, that’s when you can see that doubt moment, their vulnerability, their refusal moment. Fridge, it’s like, I don’t want to be part of this detention. I’m a star football player. I’m not supposed to be here. This is Spencer’s fault. Martha, it’s like, I’m not, I don’t want to be part of the cool kids playing, you know what I mean?

Or whatever she’s thinking to herself over there. Each of them has a reason for doing it. Now notice all of those things translate exactly into the unknown world via what the principal says. Who are you? The thing that Martha has to do is embrace this. It’s sort of like, I don’t like super bad-ass femininity, inner diva kind of quality. The point is within a movement one here, act one, the refusal is really just a blip on the screen for a purpose, right? Because Jumanji sort of takes that refusal moment. And like I said, this happens in a lot of fantasy places. It’s like, whoops, fell down this thing.

And now I’m in a special world. And how do I get out too late? Yeah. Alice in Wonderland. There’s sort of this refusal. There’s a refusal scene that I might dub the too late refusal. You’re already in the unknown world. And it’s more about coming to terms with the what’s happening and then moving to the denial. You’re moving out of denial and going, okay, this is happening. I’m stuck here. What do I do next? So the first day of school event in movement two, the reaction to the unknown world, that ends up being almost like a continuation of this. This refusal in terms of denial, this can’t be happening.

I must be imagining this. It’s a dream, right? We’re in a dream, right? Like all that stuff that the character needs to go through to finally get the concrete realization. You are stuck here unless you dot, dot, dot. You can’t go back. There’s this brief here. But when we get to movement two and we talk about that beat within the structure of the story, notice how it reflects. None of these are independent. All these events, they’re a chain of events, but they’re also setups and payoffs. All across the board. You can set something up right now and everybody chooses blindly and then boom, the payoff is now what do we do?

So we won’t go into detail about that sort of act two debate or denial. Yeah, not right now, but it’s really where they’ve sort of moved it to. They’ve given you a blip on the screen here and moved that really important story event to make it big. I mean, that thing lasts forever when they show up in Jumanji, the real denial refusal scene.

Devin: Yeah.

Adam: Plus, it’s also the introduction of all of your known A-list or star performers. So they give them this grand entrance in a way. It’s all its own new ordinary world kind of scenario. It’s great. Yeah. That was great. It’s well cast. So moving on to Edward Scissorhands, there’s not really a refusal of call here either. I’d like to, again, create discussion. Oh, you want to amend your previous statement? No, no, no. Because I think there is. But we I thought we had established this. The last conversation. I give you the floor, Mr. D.

Devin: This is more of just a StoryOsophizing than anything. But I was just again, I this entire sequence of events, just because it’s such a atypical story structure with Peg’s, short story and then handing that story off. Yeah, yeah. There may be an interesting refusal to call to quest here. Let me run through this and then you can probably tear it apart. But all right. So typically the refusal of the call will happen. In the present and after a is we talked about before a herald character of some form will present this call to quest to our hero in Edward Scissorhands, his refusal of the call to quest has essentially been his unwillingness to leave the mansion his entire life.

And so the call to quest prior. Prior to meeting Peg is his collection of artifacts and newspaper clippings and magazine clippings from the outside world that he has now has on the wall of his nest, which is basically like calling for calling to him. Prior to meeting Peg is his collection of artifacts and newspaper clippings and magazine clippings from the outside world that he has now has on the wall of his nest, which is basically like calling to him. And so, what we, and what we talked about last episode, when Edward tells her don’t go, you know, after Peg sees him and like beelines him for the exit, that, and I think we both agreed on this, is like, that’s Edward’s accepting of the call to quest.

You know, so he’s, she’s the herald he needed, someone real and not just a picture in a magazine or a newspaper. And, but if, if he, if he wasn’t ready to answer the call to quest, he simply could have just let her leave. And so when Peg shows up, she manifests into this catalyst that pushes him through the threshold into the unknown world. Yes. And that’s Peg’s primary role in the film, is she is this catalyst that literally pushes Edward into the story.

Adam: She’s the mentor. She’s the mentor of the tale. She’s the herald and the mentor, and she hands it off.

Devin: Yep, exactly. I’ve watched this, this part of the film up until the point he’s in the car with her. A million times. Probably 30 times.

Adam: So did I. Just, it’s during this. I actually took the time to write out for myself the dialogue that actually exists in the film versus the way it was originally scripted, because it all changed from the script to this, in the order of how they put it together. And it’s all, they, you know, cut out a few Edwards. And you end up with a title that works with the lines and the word lines and things like that. But one of the things. As you were talking that, that occurred to me is this, we talk about. Call to quest, refusal of call, choosal of call or acceptance of call.

Another word, another great word for it is answering the call. So in this situation, Ed, he’s up in the attic with the hole in the roof, looking down on this town and pining. To adventure there. How? How? He’s wishing upon a star to know what that’s like. You know, that’s sort of the first image we get over the shoulder of him is he’s just watching the town. And so he’s been putting out this call for a very long time. When his father, his adventure father passes, he dies. He doesn’t know what to do next. And he doesn’t venture out because he’s sort of solitary. But he so as you say, when she shows up, he’s like, don’t go is like, don’t don’t leave me here.

I want to go with you. Right. And short, Edward speak. That’s a pivotal moment to begin with, because anything that anytime a character says something, the first thing they say really important. So Peg’s refusal, you have to look at them differently because you’ve got a short story that that transitions into the rest of the feature. They overlap, but they’re very different. Yeah, they’re very different. So her call to adventure to me, that’s her call when he says, don’t go. And there’s and her overlap to me is mmm yeah The refusal period, the debate period for me is slightly before when the inciting incident really happens, when he walks out of the shadows of those knives and she’s like, like, oh, no, I shouldn’t be here. I’m sorry. I’m sorry to intrude. She freaks out from that point forward. She’s she’s backtracking. She’s aggressive. You know, she’s still doing her thing. She’s trying to make a sale and she refuses. Like all of a sudden it’s like, oh, I shouldn’t be here.

So this whole inner debate of I should not have come here and all that. Starts with this turnaround when he says, don’t go. That’s the call. But the majority of that refusal happens afterwards when she’s like basically interrogating him.

She’s figuring that out as part of her refusal. Well, if no one else can take care of you. And so, it’s a brilliantly disguised refusal. Do you see what I mean? Yeah, I do. She’s sort of narrowing down the categories of why it’s not okay for her to leave him here.

It’s cleverly done, but I would say if there’s anything that exists in sort of Peg’s refusal, it’s that is, oh, no, don’t come any closer. Those are your hands. And she has these discoveries and realizations as they’re interacting, which has her let her guard down. And instead of being the person who feels in fear for her life or a victim, she’s now the caretaker. She’s now, and the whole scene turns on her refusal to do what she originally came there to do, which is show this person her makeup. And so we go all the way back to where she now can show him the astringent and how effective it is it tidies itself up really nicely but it’s it’s a It’s a strange way of approaching it, the debate thing. And I don’t know if you would even consider that, you personally, Devin. I don’t know if you would even consider that the refusal part, but I was thinking it’s sort of interesting, that questioning she does with him, the interrogation.

Devin: Yeah. And it’s probably a good, good place to say that you don’t necessarily need a refusal to call. If you just want this willing hero to jump in, like if your story just, you know, you don’t want to fit it in there, that’s fine. But again, like we’ve talked about how, what a great opportunity this event is. To provide some of that inner, inner obstacle stuff. Yeah, I would agree with that actually. And then I would change that catalyst or the inciting incident is actually just that her looking in the rear view mirror, look side mirror, making, and then making that, that decision to go to the mansion is more of like an inciting incident.

Adam: This is, as we talked about this being an entire short story unto itself, if you look at it as Act 1, Act 2, Act 3, or Comfort Zone and then the crisis and the climax kind of situation, her meeting Edward is… Because the crisis and the fall of the heart wall is where they connect. Those are your hands and she touches his face and he feels safe and then you go, let’s put this plan into action and all that, that is a climactic, quote, decision point. And she brings him home, yeah. Or the answering of the call, she brings him home. The end. Yeah, the end.

And so, if you haven’t sort of figured it out, it’s rhythmic. Your story is going to be rhythmic, sort of zoomed in or zoomed out. And if you can get in that mode, things will be easier. You will be able to structure easier and figure out turning points. With Edward, we talked about this before, Devin, there’s really no refusal of call. Really, the call to adventure for Edward, to me, is she says, oh, I think you should just come home with me. And if you were really making it a call where he might refuse it, as I said last episode, you would phrase it in a question. Do you want to come home with me? But she’s realized that he’s not, she’s almost determined that she’s better equipped to make the decision for him. Someone needs to take care. She’s a mother.

Someone needs to take care of you. And she does this. There’s no refusal on his part. And then she just gives that little sweet nod, like, okay, settled. And then she drops out of frame and

Devin: We’re like, and we’re in the neighborhood. At this stage of the story and the hero’s been presented with this call to quest. There is a moment, perhaps it was yesterday, last week, a month ago, a year ago, where they would have refused the call and they would not have done it. And I feel like the hero at this stage of the story, for some reason is just at that point where they are, they’re still scared to death or terrified. And they still have so many doubts, but they are perfect storm or it’s the stars are aligned. Like this is when they were supposed to be presented with this test.

And they are going to take it.

Adam: Or this is the right person, like in a romance story or even this one. Right. Edward Scissorhands with her pegging him. She’s the right person to bring him out.

Devin: And it’s the right time. And so at maybe earlier when he was younger or when looking at his nest and all those magazines and then also the grounds, all the sculptures, those bush sculptures he’s done, you were. You were getting a sense of what his day to day is. And it’s at some point when he was younger, he probably would have hid from her and he wouldn’t have answered the door. And maybe there were attempts at some point for people to that he just hid from them. But right now he felt ready or it was a time at the it was the right time. She’s the right person. That was the moment that he was like, don’t go like this is the first time I don’t want somebody to leave me.

Like I or I don’t want to be alone anymore and things like that. So that’s also something I’m always thinking about when with this stage of the story is like, why are they ready now?

Adam: Exactly. Like, why is he ready for this journey now? Right. And sometimes the hero is not ready for that journey. Exactly. You know what I mean? They’re not ready now and they need someone to push them. But other times it’s like Edward’s situation where he’s ready for it. There’s just not been an opportunity for the for him to embark on that journey. And Peg is it. And he’s like, yeah, I’m in. Right. And that’s. Sort of has to do with the dreamer mentality. If your hero is a dreamer, I would like to be here. So when opportunity shows up, they don’t refuse it. They’re like, I’m in.

And oftentimes that’s the blind spot that they don’t see so that you end up in act two, the special world, the unknown world like Jumanji and you’re in over your head because you were so willing you didn’t think about it, you know what I mean, or didn’t expect it.

Devin: Again, it’s good that we’re highlighting these different ways of doing it because you could have the, like with Edward where he’s willing to do it, or you could also have the other scenario that we talked about where you feel almost with there is no decision because it’s a loved one or, you know, you’re like the kidnapping example where it’s like, hey, I got a kidnapping. We need your help. Nope, I’m retired. Oh, by the way, it’s your daughter. Oh, okay. And now I’m going, I have to go in. You could still feel unequipped, unready, but that love, that love is the catalyst or that whatever that is.

Something compels you, something. Yeah, compels you. Right.

Adam: Exactly. The one differentiation I wanted to make with the Vogler and Campbell stuff, sort of the root of that meeting of the mentor or that, you know, Greek God that descends to the hero in the mythological blueprint. It’s just nice to have it where we can sort of broaden that out to a broader way of looking at it and then go, now, that’s an example of what could happen. If the mentor shows up. If the mentor shows up here, great. But what’s important is there is a refusal. And to me, when we say the choosal, that is the catalyst because the end result is the choosing.

And so the build is that catalyst. The choosing is the catalyst event, whatever causes them to choose it. I mean, we call it the choosal or the choosing or the acceptance. But really, that’s, I mean, it’s as simple as the refusal. Someone could just say no. Will you do it? Yes. Right. That’s the, it’s just an exchange. But in the interim of between no and yes, why? Because that helps to shed light on the character. Just keep it simple that way.

Devin: You can answer that question by it’s either a hero who, who is aware of their internal obstacles or their inabilities or, or things like that, or they’re perceived what they think are their weaknesses. Or there’s a hero who thinks that their stuff doesn’t stink and they’re the greatest. And then they find out during that journey. The internal issues and weakness, all of a sudden. Right. A light is shed on that. And they’re like, holy crap, I didn’t realize that.

Adam: It’s their expectations. Yeah. And the point is just on a writer to audience level, in order to create that effect, you are going to have to set the audience up with them with false expectations to then dash those expectations in act two. Do you need these different simple, subtle setups that are going to get flipped and flipped and flipped again? Yeah. Tracking them across movements, even though you’ve got an act one, act two, act three track, tracking them across these smaller sequential builds helps you to be able to understand where you can overlap those things, where you can set up and pay off, where you can build longer from objective to outcome, build longer obstacles, longer progressive complications, glue them together.

Yep. So in terms of, refusal of call, it just highlighting doubt using debate is your. I’ll give you some variations from Vogler, just so, as I said, I always encourage people to, to give Vogler a read and McKee and Campbell and a handful of others, but those are my three top. I would agree. So Vogler, some of the variations from Vogler on the refusal of call stage, avoidance, what’s the one, office space where he’s trying to get out before his boss asked him to work for the weekend. He’s trying to avoid the, that initial call, excuse me. You know, everyone makes excuses and, and, and I would say arguments for personal limitations, conflicting calls or dual calls, family versus work and like liar, liar, positive refusals.

If it’s a wiser decision to not make that choice, willing heroes, will forego this event as we’ve talked about, although it’s nice to give them a simple, no glimpse as Devin gave with the kidnapping example. Secret door, threshold guardians, these start to show up and maybe in this stage or in the next one, the choosing of the quest, the choosal, but they’ll, there are options, there’s a pathway and the choice must be made and there’s a debate, whether it’s internal or external with a secondary character. Those are some examples from Vogler that may help to spark some ideas as you’re, you’re doing your three pages.

Well, we hope you’re doing your three pages.

Working on whatever story you got brewing, a free write, just take a refusal of a call to quest. You don’t even have to work on your call to quest to write this particular scene if you want a free write. Just go have two people share an elevator. Do you mind if I share this elevator with you? Write a whole reason why this person does not want to share this elevator with another person. Just have a simple call and write character dialogue, debate, argue for limitations. It’s fun to practice. If you are tracking your story and writing these, as we’ve been suggesting, event by event as we go, write this event in connection to your previously written call. Expand on it.

Use some of these examples, these Vogler examples, and even some of the insight that Devin and I learned from each other during this discourse to spark some writing. But sit down between now and next week and write your pages.

Devin: End scene.

Adam: Please subscribe and rate us on iTunes. Follow us on social media, share with your friends, and send us your questions and comments. For additional resources and links to films, series, and books we talk about here, visit our website. While you’re there, sign up for our newsletter for updates on story building tools and special offers at StoryOsophy.com.

Where this episode sits in the Story BlueprintPick any event on the curve to hear its episode.