Season 2, episode 47

Choosal of Call

Act 1, movement 1: Out of the comfort zone

April 17, 201952 min

Show notes

The choosal of the call to quest is the moment your hero agrees to leave their comfort zone. Even a hero who seems thrown into the story, or a reluctant one acting out of obligation, is still making a choice: between staying put and taking on the quest. Adam and Devin cover what pushes a hero over the line, why every refusal and choosal needs a “why,” and the many kinds of mentor who can help, or mislead.

In this episode

  • A choice, not a fate. Look closely at heroes who seem to have no option and you’ll find a decision to move forward instead of standing still or retreating.
  • The key event. Devin likes to add one between refusal and choosal: a piece of information that makes it personal and raises the stakes. The retired cop won’t take the kidnapping case, until he learns the girl is his daughter.
  • Give us the why. Why does your hero refuse, and why do they finally choose? One line can be enough for now; the deeper reasons can surface much later.
  • Events echo. The refusal resurfaces in the darkest-moment events of Act 2, and the choosal returns as the re-choosal of the quest. These echoes get louder as the story goes on, not quieter.
  • Check your Act 1. By this point, have you set up the thematic question, the dramatic question and what’s at stake for your hero?
  • Kinds of mentors. An inner mentor, which suits modern stories; a mentor who tried the quest and failed; a village shaman whose knowledge only goes as far as the woods; or a shapeshifter secretly working for the antagonist. A mentor’s misinformation can set up a great reversal later.
  • Shapeshifters. The two leads in a romantic comedy are shapeshifters to each other, which is where much of the comedy comes from. Dumb and Dumber’s Lloyd and Harry get a smaller version.

Examples discussed

  • The Hunger Games: when her sister’s name is called, Katniss moves through call, refusal and choosal in seconds and volunteers.
  • Jumanji: Welcome to the Jungle: the teens choose to play, and each picks an avatar that reflects their personality, without knowing what they’ve signed up for. Devin sees one extended choosal that wraps around their arrival in the jungle; Adam treats Nigel’s mission as a new call that opens Movement 2, showing how Movement 1’s pattern can be laid over Movement 2.
  • Edward Scissorhands: Edward can’t yet make the decision himself. Devin suggests that loneliness is what speaks when he says “Don’t go.” Peg chooses for both of them with “I think you should just come home with me” and a nod, and the cut to Edward grinning in her car takes him from gray attic to pastel suburbia.
  • Also: The Wizard of Oz.

Writing along with the season? Write three pages for your hero’s choosal.

Read the full transcript

Transcribed automatically, so expect the odd misheard word. Sponsor messages are left out.

Adam: In this episode, we discuss the story event, Choosal of Call to Quest. What causes your hero to choose to go on their quest or journey? Is there a mentor or moment of raised stakes that is the catalyst for that choice? Next, on StoryOsophy. Hello. Welcome to StoryOsophy. This is Adam Jones. And Devin Halden. This week, we’ll be talking about… We’ll be talking about the choosal of the call to quest. It’s what Devin and I like to call it. Choosal or answer. Answer the call to quest. I like choosal. For those of you who might just be tuning in, we’re tracking through the structure of a story.

Whether you’re a writer, actor, director, we’re sort of breaking down how you would approach these things to communicate them to your audience. And even as an audience, if you’re curious… Politician. Or politician, yes. Telling your story. Or even if you’re someone living your life and are sort of navigating things. We sort of break down through our philosophy part of StoryOsophy. The way you approach certain things through a broad-minded perspective. That’s sort of what structuring is. So we’re taking you through the structure of a story. We’re still in Act 1. And Act 1 is the known world to unknown world of your story. Devin and I break these down into movements.

Sort of smaller, compartmentalized builds within each act. And Movement 1, which is also Act 1. Is from comfort zone to out of comfort zone. And Act 1 is generally your foundation or your essence. You’re trying to build as lean as you can the story foundation for the expansion of it to come. And if you haven’t tuned in until just now, you can go back a few episodes and track with us through the order of events. But it starts with Act 1. Starts with the hook. Then goes to the known world routine. Then the inciting interlude. Then the call to quest. Refusal of call to quest. And here we are with this week’s episode, Choosal of Call to Quest.

Devin, did you have anything you wanted to say offhand about this event?

Devin: Well, it’s in the title of the event, really. It’s the… So new. I think it’s important that we call it Choosal of Call to Quest because the hero’s making a decision. It doesn’t mean that we can’t… Throw our hero as writers into a situation without their choosing. But once in that situation… Our hero has to make the decision between stasis or just, just staying, not moving, not, not deciding, just, I want to stay here and I don’t want to, I don’t want to move forward. Expand or grow. Yeah. Or grow or taking on the challenge of the quest. And so there’s, there’s a lot of examples of stories that look like the hero doesn’t have an option. It’s like they’re just thrown into something.

But if you actually analyze a little more, they are at some, they are making a decision to move forward and to not just stand still or to not retreat. And so that’s, that’s one of the key points.

Adam: Even if they’re a reluctant hero, because you can have a hero who sort of chooses, but it doesn’t really want to choose that. And to be frank, that’s a lot of people.

Devin: Right.

Adam: A lot of people choose something for reasons other than their own wellbeing or what they want. Whether it’s to please someone else, especially when we’re talking about between last episode and this episode, this is traditionally mentor territory, meeting of the mentor. If there is a mentor character in your story, this is where it happens. So a lot of times we just don’t want to disappoint someone else. And we make decisions out of obligation or expectation that aren’t necessarily our own best interest. And so that’s a reluctant hero. They may choose to go on this quest. Right. Without wanting to really, and then find that the quest itself opens them up to growth and expansion of self near the end, which is sort of a lot in a lot of stories, what happens.

Devin: Right.

Adam: Out of confusion comes clarity. But in order to get into the unknown world of confusion, you have to be somewhat brave or have someone push you if you’re not. Right. You can have a reluctant hero in the choice, just to make clear that even though it seems like it might be. A little bit of a victim scenario, that person still has to choose to be silent about saying no.

Devin: Right. And that’s why, and I touched on it a little bit in prior episodes, is I like to add an event. I like to add an event I call the key event here. It’s that one piece of information or that one element of the call to quest that makes the decision to answer the call or to choose the call to quest nearly impossible. Right. It’s also that first. It’s that first blip of movement on our hero’s arc, that initial moment that they realize nothing will ever be the same again. The hero’s thinking, I’ll either fail miserably or somehow I’ll succeed. I don’t know how I’m going to exceed because I have all these inner obstacles and this external obstacle seems very daunting, but somehow I’ll succeed.

And I prefer to make the key event its own event, similar to the inciting event. Right. Because I like to remember to increase. The stakes a bit for our hero here. And it’s like the example we discussed in the last episode where it’s, you know, girl, girl gets kidnapped. Protagonist or our hero is told about the kidnapping. Our hero feels bad, but, you know, he, he knows because of X, Y, Z reasons, he won’t be of any help. And, oh, did we, we forgot to mention the girl that got kidnapped is your daughter. And so now it’s personal. Now the protagonist or now our hero digs, has to dig deep just enough at this point.

To choose to go on the quest. So here we can also highlight shine a brighter light on our heroes, the main internal obstacle they may have. And, and also the external obstacles of like, holy crap, this is going to be a, this is a daunting task, but I have to choose. I can choose to not do anything and something terrible could happen to my daughter, or I have to dig deep enough right now to take that first step and to move forward and try to. And go on the quest.

Adam: So Devin, you and I have discussed this off air where we, where we curse a lot at each other for me, I really like to streamline the first act, even if I’m moving a lot of information that you would have seen in traditional films that have like 25 page, 25 minute first acts to a second act. Information or Reveal. Like they sort of do with Jumanji we were talking a little bit about last week. Now, in what Devin’s talking about, it’s that key event, that catalyst moment. In traditional storytelling, a lot of times it’s supernatural aid or the mentor showing up that says, you know, the person, they’re like, oh, you know, you’re meant to go on this thing. No, I’m not. I can’t do it. And then someone goes up and goes, you’re special. You do need to go on this.

And so it’s, it’s helpful to use an archetype so that you can have an outward discussion about the reasons why they don’t want to go and then why they choose it. But it doesn’t have to be the case, especially in modern storytelling. You’re rarely going to have, you know, Minerva descend from the heavens and go here, let me equip you with stuff. That’s not going to happen. Maybe it will. That would be an awesome story. But most people are more pragmatic in their thinking and things. So what you need to do with this moment is find that answer.

So what you need to do with this moment is find that answer. Based on these moments, you’re going to develop a stronger and more depth the story.

Devin: We talked about it last few episodes is the call to quest is an event for the antagonist. It’s even though it’s the it’s a herald character typically presenting our hero or would be hero or hopefully soon to be hero, a challenge a call like will you accept this call? It’s actually about the antagonist. Because the herald has got there’s information about the dangers of the journey. There’s information about what he needs to do while he needs to do what he needs to do to succeed. And it’s where we give our audience a little bit of information about the power or the danger or the evilness of the antagonist. We don’t have to give them again, you give them what they need at that point. And then the refusal of the call is about our protagonist. It highlights his strengths and weaknesses.

And masks, perhaps that they have up and it really shines a light on their internal obstacles. And it’s it’s setting up issues, our protagonists will have to overcome along the journey. And then the the choosal of the call here the choosal of the call to quest. It’s both of our antagonist protagonists and antagonist. It’s an act for both or it’s an event for both of them. It’s it’s our hero is on the fence or has outright refused the call. And then this key event or something, this bit of information. Can provide our antagonist with this chain with this change of perspective for our hero. It’s it’s a it’s a bit of information that changes everything. And it impacts them and some in some case, and it nearly forces them to answer the call to quest. But it’s still about the antagonist and the protagonist because there’s you can still raise the stakes here about what’s at stake because like in the that one example is of the girl being kidnapped is a situation where the hero is being kidnapped.

Where all of those happen in one scene literally in probably five seconds where it’s like, oh my God, this girl’s been kidnapped. I just you know what I’m retired. I can’t do it. I just I wouldn’t be any help that girl’s your daughter. Oh, great. So now I have to dig deep. I have to find enough enough in me right to at least get me to this get me across the threshold to the threshold.

Adam: And do I have enough in me? That question is really important. Do I have enough? In me to do this? Because usually the answer the reason the hero is refusing is because they don’t believe they do. Right. And so showing and here’s the other point. Why don’t they believe? Is the reason why you want to highlight that is give them a reason so that we can understand. It may not even be the real reason. We may not find out the real reason until we echo the refusal in the Fall of the Heart Wall much later. But give a why, too, so we get it. Even if it’s – you have one sentence there that is the why and you give us enough information as an audience to go with the rest of the story and then you build on that or rather peel back the layers of that, what’s buried underneath that.

And the same question applies to the choosal. Why do they then choose it? Because if you know now it’s his daughter, it’s like, oh, he must love his daughter. If he didn’t love his daughter, he wouldn’t – it’s like, you still got to find somebody else. I don’t like her. But it highlights the fact that he loves his daughter. So the why of the situation. It’s the same – your example reminds me of what – a little bit of what I was talking about with Hunger Games. So they’re calling out the names in the Hunger Games and Katniss and her sister amongst all the other people in the poor communities are being chosen and they’re calling out names.

And from – and we’ve seen in the ordinary. The ordinary world, the buildup of Katniss and how she is vital in taking care of her family so she can’t really leave them because she’s important and she loves them and she takes care of them. And then when we get here and they choose her sister, there’s a whole reason. There’s – the catalyst is hearing her sister’s name and this whole mental process with Katniss where she’s making these decisions between this call, refusal, and choosal in moments. Like split seconds. And she volunteers to be the person to go on the quest. That’s how she answers it. And it’s different than the reluctant hero.

This person volunteers and says, I’ll take her place. Notice where the refusal and choosal – where they highlight the – and I don’t want to say what the hero is made of. But however we, the writer or creator of the story or character, want the audience to perceive the character at the beginning, this is where you show where they’re made of in that regard. Because it may not be the full version of themselves and you want to save surprises of, well, if we set them up where they feel a little weak-willed here at the crisis or at the climax, when they’ve found their own empowered strength, we’ve got a journey.

We’ve got an arc now. You don’t want the person to be a certain way the whole story. Their story changes throughout. And that’s why we break it up into movements is so that you can track how their story changes across different – Chunks of your story instead of going, well, I don’t know how to get from act one to act three. I know what they are. My act one and my act three are clear. My beginning and my climax, I see clearly. But I get lost in the middle. Right. The movements are meant to create a space where you don’t get lost in the middle.

Devin: Right.

Adam: And you can track their decision-making and changes and the peelback of the onion layers throughout. As Devin and I talk about in previous episodes, measurement. And having an idea of how to measure how much time you’ve given between this point of setup and this point of payoff or reveal so that you can build it in different ways.

Devin: This choosal moment is only to get them to go on the journey, to go on the quest. Right. That’s it. And so that’s what you’re – they’re not a complete hero yet. They haven’t completed their arc. So they can’t make some of the decisions because there’s going to be essentially three choosals. There’s going to be two choosals of the call or there’s going to be a choosal and a re-choosal and probably another re-choosal. They have to recommit to it. The choosal is to get them across this threshold, get them into the unknown world and get them on the path, get them on the journey. But then once they go through, once they experience things and they discover allies or they discover enemies and they discover rules and tools and they learn more about what’s going on in this world, there’s going to be a moment where they’ve been changing as a person.

And that reason for making the decision or choosing the call to quest in Movement 1 or Act 1, it’s going to be different or more – In depth, there’s more reasoning behind going on. There’s going to be a point where, I don’t want to jump ahead too far, but there’s still another, a re-choosal of the call is going to be when they think that they’ve been defeated or there is no, those internal obstacles that they had in the beginning and they thought they were overcoming during the journey seem insurmountable. And, and so there’s going to be another, but at what they’ve learned on that path of what they learned on the journey is giving them a different perspective and perspective is a key word too for storytelling is like you’re, you’re, while you’re, you’re heroes changing as a person and changing as a character, it’s also their perspective on what’s going on is changing.

And so there’s this point of the story in movement one, right before. They cross this threshold. This is just, you’re, you’re just giving your character a reason to go on the quest to make that choice. And it doesn’t need to be like Adam said, it doesn’t have to be, this is the reason they’re choosing. And this is the same reason throughout the entire story. That reason can still, can all of a sudden become a secondary reason or that re or that reason, the reasoning to go on that, on the, on the quest there can. Actually be fulfilled. They can actually, they can actually succeed. Right. And he can actually succeed in getting his child back from being kidnapped at some point in act two or before the midpoint.

And then all of a sudden it becomes a greater.

Adam: Only to find out that there are other girls in this. Yeah. The other girls kidnapped and he feels a larger call.

Devin: Right.

Adam: Exactly. Through his daughter, through just having initiated himself into that journey to go, I have to make sure that I, or dad, please go and help those other girls is a call from his daughter. A secondary call. Right. Ripple out or reverberate throughout the rest of the story. And what you were saying is really interesting in this, this regard, last episode during refusal, we were talking about how events echo or reverberate throughout the rest of a story and refusal shows up in fall of the, all is lost and fall of the heart wall events later on in your story. Just as choosal shows up as rechoosal of your quest or recommitment to your quest.

Devin: And same with archetypes. Those archetypes are going to pop up. Again, to the, you’re going to need a mentor again.

Adam: That’s why they’re archetypes and not specific characters. Although it may be the same character, it doesn’t have to be. It can be a completely different person representing the same thing, which is generally in life, how things roll. You know, you run into the same characters. They’re just wearing different masks and the, the, the reverberation across these movements or across acts, depending on what you’re choosing or what you’re, what events you’re approaching. Notice. The refuse of the call, refusal, choosal really important because it sets up three different stages of a decision-making process, and you can then repeat it within each movement. There has to be a new decision posed, basically a new status quo.

Where are we now? And then a new inciting incident call refusal choosal. And even looking at that broadly across act one, act two, act three structure. That’s generally how most stories. Go as a broad scope. This is why Devin and I talk about act one or movement one. If you know your, if you know these events, you can build a story easily because they supply you with all of the stuff, all of the ingredients you need to alter them and change them and incorporate them in the upcoming. Much larger explorations of these things. So, and when I say it echoes across the, the subsequent or upcoming scenes and movements and acts, it’s almost like the echo gets louder and not quieter.

Here. It’s subtler, quieter, more minimalistic. You don’t give a lot of information, but as we go across and the hero continues on their journey, more time is invested, more thought and energy and emotion is invested. And so it doesn’t. Grow quieter. Whatever these little subtle goadings are with refusal and choosal, they’re pushing the hero. If the hero’s not changing, they don’t get quieter. They get louder. They push that hero more towards their growth and change. And that’s progressive complications and obstacles and increased stakes. You slowly build that. You think of it that way. But even going back to the Hunger Games, the stakes there, and in Devin’s example of the father with the kidnapped daughter, the stakes increase within a three-line exchange, right? Or a one-statement exchange. They announce Katniss’ sister and it’s like, boom, boom, boom. The stakes instantly just like go way up. They tell him it’s his daughter. The stakes go instantly way up.

Devin: Mm-hmm.

Adam: And it forces them. To make the choice. So notice between refusal and this information that you give is your build to your choosal, like what’s going to make them decide. If you can increase the stakes there or show why it’s important there, you give reason to why they choose to do that thing. That’s the recipe. If you want to really highlight stuff is highlight your stakes here. Highlight your character’s either willingness or unwillingness. Obviously, they’ve already refused or… In situations like we’ve talked about, even Katniss, there’s not much of a refusal, even in Jumanji and Edward, Edward Scissorhands.

Devin: Mm-hmm.

Adam: This is where you can highlight whether they feel like they want to do it or whether they feel like they don’t want to do it or they still do it. They still say yes. The whole point is, this is the moment in your first act where they agree to leave the comfort zone. They may not leave it right now, but this is where they agree. They say, yes, I’m going. I’m going to leave my comfort zone for this challenge quest, whatever it may be. Think about this when you’re at this event, too. Act one is meant to build everything up. Do you have everything set up for your unknown world for the quest ahead?

Your thematic question, have you sort of introduced the idea that we’re supposed to be considering as an audience sort of philosophically outside of the story? Have you set up your dramatic question, what the premise of your story is? Will our hero succeed or not? I mean, as simplified as it gets. What you want to present and stakes. Do we know what’s at stake for the hero? The examples we just showed, it’s sort of obvious, but I mentioned last week, even if you’re approaching a children’s book and it’s an absolute necessity that this character has gum and there’s no gum to be found anywhere. Those are high stakes for that specific story because you frameworked it to be that way.

So stakes can mean a lot of things. It doesn’t always mean life or death. It just you need to create. You need to create the value structure for your hero, what’s important to them and the values that they hold dear so that when we see that that might be in danger, that there might be another option, that there might be a challenge, that it lets us know from the ordinary world or their known world routine, what might change if dot, dot, dot. So act one is your what if act, your what if movement. What if this happened? What would happen afterwards? Well. Dot, dot, dot. And you commit to the journey.

This is the mentor area or if you’re doing that in intimate drama, it’s your inner mentor where you can have a shot of a character and then have a shot of what they’re looking at and we, the audience, will infer all the detail we need based on the information given before. We can tell what they’re thinking inside. Right. That’s a more modern way of treating something that would have been a meeting of the mentor if it were supernatural. There’s a better role aid in traditional storytelling models, the inner spiritual guide, the inner mentor. And I think we’re moving in a lot of ways towards that societally anyway.

And so it’s important to incorporate that.

Devin: At this stage of the story, the mentor that I like to use is somebody with knowledge of the unknown world or with knowledge. They’ve they’ve. They have attempted the quest before, but either failed or didn’t complete it. So they only have enough information, and even their information could be not real accurate on what they’re about to embark on. But it’s enough information to get our hero to feel that they’re equipped with enough of the tools or the rules and tools of the unknown world to choose to go on the quest. And so it’s a little bit of information, but not, again, it’s what do we need to provide the audience with now that doesn’t necessarily have to be accurate.

It could be information that once the hero gets to a point where they’re using some information. It could be misinformation that the mentor gave them. It’s wrong.

Adam: It could be misinformation, exactly. And now you have a story turn because you got misinformation in the beginning. And once again, it speaks to backwards development. You get to this part and you go, oh, wait a minute. If the mentor didn’t know enough in the beginning and told them this instead, I get a surprise from my audience here. And so you nonlinearly backwards develop that idea and put the setup in the first act. Or you can have them. You can have the mentor be a shapeshifter.

Devin: And you feed them wrong information. The mentor comes to them at this stage of the game and it looks like he’s an ally and he’s a mentor, but he’s really working for the antagonist and setting a trap or getting them to continue on with this journey because he’s doing the work of the antagonist or even it could be the antagonist themselves as a shapeshifter. I’m trying to think. I just watched a Disney movie where they have a mask on. They’re able to shapeshift. They’re literally shapeshifting the story and they turn out to be the antagonist. But again, and it’s thinking outside the box with some of this stuff, but it’s being able to go back and maybe put a shapeshifting mentor in.

Even though you started writing, you’re like, oh, this guy is going to be a mentor, straight up mentor, ally. And then you’re like, wow, it’d be really great if after you start writing, you’re further down or you’re like, well, maybe I should. This would be a great setup payoff.

Adam: If if I set it up as a twist, reveal, reversal, right? Reversal. Check this out.

[Sponsor message]

Adam: Even in this stage, the choosal stage, when you if you do meet a mentor. Here you can have different types and I would differentiate them into these two sort of categories. As you said, Devin, one that doesn’t know, one that knows enough, but it’s not been past the threshold to really have accurate information. But they’re the person who knows the most here, right? Right. Let’s say you’re in a village and there’s just woods all around, dark woods, and you got one shaman in the village, right? The wisest person in the village to everyone else in the village. And they say, You can’t go out there because of this.

Well, if you’re going to go on that journey, make sure you bring and they give you information based on what they know. Now, they’re a mentor to the rest of the village and they’re the smartest person there up supposedly, right? They have the best information, but their experience is limited to what they know. And the hero doesn’t know that. The hero can only trust the wisest person in the village. And so there’s a mentor that maybe has not ventured well out into the unknown world.

Devin: Or. In that case, he’s actually lying, lying to them, too.

Adam: Right, well, it’s all showbiz, right? Religion, politics, it depends on what you’re, the way it’s being presented. If it’s just, to be honest, that person may not even know that they don’t know. They’ve just been passed down this heritage of, here’s what the woods is about, and I’m the keeper of that knowledge. But they may not even know they’re ignorant of what actually exists in the woods. It’s just the mythology and the legends that were passed down from the previous shaman. Their belief system is limited, but they can have absolute confidence in that belief system and be very convincing to a hero. But then there’s also the mentor that maybe has, as you were alluding to, been there, and either they’ve conquered the previous version of the force of antagonism, or they’ve fallen short of doing so.

But they have knowledge of the world to come. Whether it’s encouragement or warning, they have some actual information. It may be dated. It may be from the years that they did it, so you’re also leaving these gaps and mysteries in this mentor knowledge base. The mentors can take all shapes and sizes, but figure out what they know and figure out how they learned it or how they know it. And then you have a really strong basis of your mentor and why their passing of whatever knowledge they have is important to the hero. We’re breaking down these other things. That’s a great place to build the reason for your mentor.

But there’s different recipes for mentors. When you were saying that, I was just thinking about a couple stories that I’ve been brainstorming, and the mentors take these different modes. Some know the world, some don’t.

Devin: Yeah.

Adam: As Devin’s saying, this doesn’t have to be your main mentor. This can be, like I’m saying, the shaman in the village. That shaman’s not going to go with this person. It’s sort of like the early mentor, and then maybe they’ll find someone in the known world, or the, I’m sorry, the unknown world, that knows more, and that person becomes their mentor.

Devin: And shapeshifters are fun. And yeah, shapeshifters are. Shapeshifters are fun.

Adam: Shapeshifters, that’s the archetype that every romantic comedy is built on. Each character, the two love interests in your story that are having trouble coming together, they’re both shapeshifters, each one to the other. And that’s the humor and the strangenesses of a romantic comedy is, I don’t understand why this person’s behaving this way. I thought they were going to be like this, and now they’re like this. Right.

It’s what they’re built on. And a lot of comedies.

Devin: Mm-hmm.

Adam: Misunderstanding. Shapeshifters are, they can be devious and not devious at the same time. You know, there can be someone who’s doing it for.

Devin: Dumb and dumber.

Adam: Mal intent. And then someone who’s, you know, it depends on how it’s treated, too. As you say, dumb and dumber. Lloyd and Harry. Lloyd screws over Harry in their backstory with Freda Felcher. And it’s enough to have Harry screw Lloyd over for his new love interest. They’re in the heart-shaped hot tub. Freda Felcher.

Their revenge, jealousy backstory. And it’s so simple in there. It’s really just like this small underthread. So let’s move on to our examples. Jumanji, Welcome to the Jungle, and Edward Scissorhands. Both of these have choosal moments. And as we talked about last week, Jumanji sort of, they split it up and they do a lot of stuff in movement, too, that they. They. They. Sort of skip over in movement one, because in Jumanji, they commit to the quest without really knowing what they’re committing to. So when they choose the video game, they simply just choose to be an avatar. Although they do choose a specific avatar that’s that’s reflective of their personality when they choose that and hit click start.

But once again, this is what I love with the first act is do it quickly. Yeah. Don’t worry about all the rest. Use the denial and the real choosal of the call deeper into the movement, too. But here, let’s get the audience in. Get them in. So all we need to do is show, oh, my gosh, there’s a video game system. Who wants to take a break from pulling staples and do this? I do. I do. I do. I don’t. One refusal, really. And then they all choose.

Devin: And then bookends, they do a lot of this, actually. They have events bookend other events, because the, like you said, the choosal begins in the known world. They each decide to play the game, except for Martha. Right. And they choose to play the game instead of doing what they were told by the principal. But then the choose, the choosal. The Story Blueprint extends into the unknown world when they’re given more information by Nigel. And so, but, you know, this is where they’re choosing between stasis and going on the quest to complete the game.

Adam: And that’s what’s important. Leaving the comfort zone. Choosing to leave their comfort zone.

Devin: Yeah, exactly. So that’s where they’re choosing. And then, but the choosal of the quest bookends the first day of school reaction to the unknown world event, too. Because we have that choosal in the unknown world. And then we have them in the event we’ll talk about next episode, but it’s where they’re reacting to being sucked into the game and being thrown, literally thrown into Jumanji. The threshold. And so that’s, it’s interesting how it does bookend it. And we talked about this last week. Not that I would disagree or,

Adam: Or argue with you on this point, but because it is still a call, but I would mentally, for me, when I’m looking at this, I, I would treat it as simply the, the repeat of one over two. So that it’s sort of like, it’s not the call to quest. It’s the next call to quest. Like we said, that you may get information that makes you choose the quest to begin with. And then once you get into the unknown world, that call changes, or there’s a new set of circumstances that change. To me, the, the, what I love about Jumanji’s first act is it’s so fast and they go click, click, click, call, refusal, choosal, boom. They’re in the game, cross the threshold reaction, the unknown world. And now there’s a new call. Now, once they’re here and out of confusion, they’ve got a new call, but it is, it is almost like you’re saying, or we’re talking about with previous events, they echo across these movements. So I don’t know if it would be the same to me as much as it would be a new call, which I think is a cooler design.

Devin: The reason I discuss it as an extended choosal of the call with a reaction to the unknown world in between is because part of one thing that a hallmark of the choosal of the call for me, or an important key element is a decision. I mean, there’s a decision, sure there’s a decision to play the game, but that isn’t necessarily the call to quest. It trans, it transitions from a call, the call to play a game, not reality. To a call to finish a game in reality in order to get back to reality. And so it’s, there’s this choosal that they need to make to play the game. Sure. But then there’s a choosal. The final choosal is, okay, well, if you, if you guys want to get out of this game and back to your unknown, back to your known world, you have to finish this game.

And so there’s that, there’s the decision between stasis or the decision to retreat and, or, and, or the decision to, okay. We need to figure this out. We need to finish this game. And so that was that just for discussion purposes. That’s how I would try to organize the thought.

Adam: Yeah. I think for me, it’s, it’s important to differentiate between this call that calls them out of the comfort zone and that call that really is calling them to the, the quest of the story. To me, I would treat them as two separate events. One is this call and the other one would be a new call to adventure. Yeah. You’re already in the unknown world. You’re already in the movement too. You’re sort of replacing an event there with a secondary call. And it, that usually only happens in fantasy movies where you’re in a brand new place and everything’s freaky and weird and different. And it’s like, follow the yellow brick road.

So there’s a new quest, right? The, the call to adventure in the beginning of the Wizard of Oz is Dorothy sort of escaping so that Toto doesn’t get, you know, in the, in the tornado and all that. And then she’s in the unknown world. And after dealing with the reaction in the unknown world, there’s a, there’s sort of a secondary call, which says in order to leave this place, you must do this. But I, I wouldn’t personally consider them the same call. And I, I like treating them differently because I think in treating them slightly different, you, you create a different tone and they may echo. I like, I don’t disagree with you on that point at all.

Devin: Well, the call is the same. That’s all. It’s the same call to quest. It’s. You want to play the game. That’s the call to quest. And the difference is they think the, the first version of that call to quest is we’re just going to play a video game. The second, but the same question is, no, you’re actually in here. You actually have to play this game. So that’s why I think it’s the same call.

Adam: And I don’t disagree with you, and there’s a whole rhythm of call, refusal, choosal that happens again to sort of exemplify what I mean when I say take movement one, and if you know act one or movement one really well, and you sort of lay that transparency of events over the second one, you sort of see it repeat. Jumanji is the perfect example of taking that, laying it over the second movement as the introduction to your special world and seeing it repeat in basic event structure. It’s just that Jumanji echoes the call, do you want to play the game, right? No, I don’t. And instead of wanting to play the game, it’s sort of, no, I don’t want to play the game within the unknown world.

And then the, well, you have to in order to get out is the choose, the forced catalyst moment. It’s like, oh, by the way, the kidnapped girl is your daughter. Yeah. Oh, by the way, you’re going to stay here forever unless you do finish the game. Right. And it makes them choose it. And even the events that we will discuss in movement two, which are first day of school. Watering hole rules and tools approached as danger zone and crossing into the danger zone. These can be masked or disguised versions of act one’s base core events just underneath these things. Not that Jumanji plays into those events.

Exactly. We’ll talk about those as we go along in future episodes. But so I’m not disagreeing with you that it’s not the same call, but mentally, if I’m trying to break down my structure to write this script out, I would call, I would do movement two as new call to quest. Even if it was just because they’re in the game and have brand new information from a new Herald, just so that I can see the parallel of one to the other. They link up and they may be continued in that way. But here’s the thing. They’re not exactly the same because there’s new information. And so in order to differentiate why this first one, they say this and why in the second one, the new call.

Or you’re saying the book ended version, the back end, book end, back end, book end, it shows why they choose it here. So you still need to ask all the same questions. Why and how does the call come the refusal and the choosal, because even though the first movements trio, their call refusal, choosal, it’s different slightly than the reasons why and how in the second one, which is great because it helps to highlight the unknown world just by repeating those exact events. Now, those same questions arise in the unknown world, and there’s totally different stakes and reasons and information you could, like you’re saying, you could still consider it to be one piece, but from my mind practically to break them up, it helps to build that event specifically for why it’s in the unknown world, instead of just being a finishing piece to the other one.

So even though it is balancing out and still concluding that, right?

Devin: Yeah, I would, the same reason you’re, you don’t structure it that way. Yeah. I would, the same reason you’re, you don’t structure it that way. Yeah. I would, the same reason you’re, you don’t structure it that way. I think of it that way is the same reason I do. It makes more sense for me to have that. And I, I, what I really like about it is the call to quest goes from a video game, just like it’s, so we went from like old technology to new technology. That was one transition. That was one way of showing the difference, the contrast between the, the hook scene and the known world routine scene. So we, we have that contrast. And then we contrast from.

Yeah, that’s superficial. But when it comes to the quest, it’s do we, or don’t we?

Adam: Will you, or won’t you save Jumanji? Right. Exactly. Will our heroes survive or not? Yeah. And I’m not disagreeing with you on that. That’s really where it comes to light. And we’ll talk about this when we get into Movement 2 too, because I think a lot of the events in Movement, you could literally take Movement 1 and lay it over Movement 2 in Jumanji and it fits. Because your hook is when they show up in the jungle and it’s the reaction scene, the denial. Right. And I agree with that too. The real, like, huge refusal. And then you’re in the known world routine where this is status quo, folks. Better start running because hippos.

They’re going to eat you. Right. The inciting incident, Bethany gets eaten, all that. You could sort of lay Movement 1 over it. And then the call to quest is Nigel picks them up, gives them information. They refuse to do it. Oh, you’ve got a letter. And then, you know, with the information, you have to save Jumanji or you’re stuck here. They choose it. So in Jumanji, it’s really special the way they do it. And like I said, in, if you look at Jumanji, it’s a really streamlined example of what most fantasy movies do. Right. First movement is preliminary and almost superficial. So this is a little comfort zone to out of comfort zone call. And then they’re The first bit of act two is denial and getting accustomed to, well, what do I have to do to get out of here? Call to adventure or call to quest, refusal, choosal, right? If you look at most fantasy movies, they sort of do that. So Jumanji is a good streamlined example. Anyway, on to Edward.

Edward Scissorhands is pretty simple. Edward Scissorhands is a pretty simple choosal moment. She chooses for him, as we’ve discussed in previous episodes. You pose an interesting thought last week where Edward’s choosing, Edward’s been pining to go down to this place by watching it for a long time. And when she comes up and she starts to go because she’s scared of his blades, his don’t go or her arriving is his call to adventure. He wants to leave. He wants that company. And so that’s an interesting choosal moment in its own right, as you brought up last week.

Devin: Here’s what’s interesting. And I keep, man, I’ve watched, I’ve watched the first 15, 10, 15 minutes of this movie. A thousand times the last couple of weeks. And it’s interesting because Edward doesn’t necessarily have the intelligence to make a logical or educated decision on his own. So no, the writers using Peg to make the decision for him. Yeah. And so going back to what you were saying is that when, when he pleads, don’t go to Peg, don’t go. I need someone to tell me what to do. It’s really this feeling of loneliness. It’s the feeling of loneliness. Loneliness. That is what is speaking for him. He knows there’s something he doesn’t like. And so there’s, there’s this feeling. So like a child, he doesn’t know how to understand this feeling, but he just knows he doesn’t like it. And when he sees Peg, and this is, I’m just, it’s concepting or, or StoryOsophizing here.

Go for it. But when he sees Peg, perhaps that feeling left him for a second. And he finally had a companion, even just visually. It’s somebody other than just himself there. And he’s afraid if he leaves, if she leaves that, that feeling again, we’ll come back and haunt him. Because he’s basically been haunted with this feeling of loneliness, but because he’s not human, he’s just, he’s this, this invention for that somehow feels because we understand he feels when he sees Kim’s picture. So there’s, he’s got, he’s, he has all of these feelings throughout this, throughout this story and feelings are things that he doesn’t understand. He just knows that.

When he was with the inventor, he felt this way. And when the inventor died and he was alone, he felt this way. And he doesn’t, there’s something that doesn’t feel right to him. Interesting.

Adam: And then when he sees Peg. He can recognize the contrast, but he can’t define it.

Devin: Yeah. He doesn’t understand. Yeah. He can’t translate. He doesn’t understand what this is. And then when he sees Peg, he, he has this. Yeah. Oh my God. This is, I have that feeling of companionship or somebody else, you know, someone with me. And then I think that, so perhaps that’s why it’s like, just don’t go. And then that’s also his decision is like, I, I’m ready to, like we were talking about in the last episode. I was like, I’m, I’m ready to, I want to go there. I want to go to this town that I’ve been looking at for looking upon for years.

Adam: And what’s great about this, there’s sort of a shared choosal moment. Peg is the mentor for his story. She’s the one that takes care of him and everything. And her little, I think you should just come home with me and nod where she’s like, her nod is her choosal. It’s like, yep, that’s what we’re doing. She, her instinct or even maternal instinct kicks in and goes, I’m not leaving him up here. And he, as you’re saying, he’s not fully capable of making the decision for himself yet. Cause he’s doesn’t understand. And so their choosal moment all happens in one that she’s like, I’m going to take on this guy. And he’s like, yeah, I’ll go with her.

And what’s funny is the choosal moment of this movie is a joke. It’s the cut to comedy. Yeah. I’ve mentioned it in a few previous episodes. And the example is the, I’m not going to marry the monkey. I’m not going to marry that monkey. And it cut to a monkey in a wedding dress and the guy standing next to the monkey. And this, she’s like, I think you should just come home with me. And then we cut to that. She nods, drops out of frame and, and the music goes, and he’s in the car, literally crossing the threshold or crabbing across the threshold and just on his way to suburbia.

The difference between the dark gray attic and the, even the, even, it’s still pastel, but brighter colors. That contrast is a joke. That contrast should make you laugh.

Devin: Yeah.

Adam: It’s funny. All of a sudden, he’s smiling in the passenger seat of her car. It’s where he doesn’t really belong. So, the choosal moment, it’s great in this because they, they use it as a great transition and punchline for, for the, the humor. Yeah. It’s good. And sets a tone for act two. It’s like, you can see now the difference between act one and act two because there’s a, a really stark difference for them. Gray attic, and it’s kind of sad, and he’s lonely. And all of a sudden, it’s like, you’re home with me. And it’s this vibrant sort of change. Yep. But, yeah, I, I mean, it’s pretty simple, the choosal of that one.

Devin: Yeah. It, yeah, the, the movement from, well, movement one to movement two and act one to act two is pretty obvious in that one. And it’s, it’s, again, Yeah. It, yeah, the, the movement from, well, movement one to movement two and act one to act two is pretty obvious in that one. And it’s, it’s, again, Like Jumanji, though, they, it’s, it’s quick. The pacing’s great to get, to get us into that unknown world or get Edward into that unknown world.

Adam: Yeah. I really love the swiftness of both of their first acts. As always, we encourage you to take this event, the choosal of Call, and choosal of Call to Quest, and write three pages, a few pages free write, just while you’re inspired from maybe something we’ve said in this or just been thinking about it. Sit down and write it out. Yeah. Just this week. Next week, we’ll do another, event and free write on that. But if you keep doing these three pages, eventually you’ll have a rough draft and you only have to do three a week. So we’re trying to encourage you to get to that first draft because if you can get it on the paper, it exists. It doesn’t have to be perfect. It just has to exist.

I’m doing it. I’ve been doing the work. Until next week. Toodles.

Devin: Toodles. Toodles.

Where this episode sits in the Story BlueprintPick any event on the curve to hear its episode.