Show notes
The call to quest, also known as the call to adventure, is the fourth event of Act 1: the moment a quest, challenge or invitation is put in front of your hero. It’s one of Devin’s favorite events to write. His take: the call is as much about the antagonist as the hero. It’s where the audience gets a taste of what the hero is up against, while the refusal that follows turns the focus back onto the hero.
Adam and Devin cover who delivers the call, how it sets up the story’s stakes and dramatic question, and how Jumanji: Welcome to the Jungle and Edward Scissorhands rearrange the call, refusal and choosal in surprising ways.
In this episode
- Just enough information. The call gives the hero, and the audience, a glimpse of the quest, its dangers and the force of antagonism. Enough to pique interest, never the whole map.
- Who brings the call. Usually a herald, a mentor or the antagonist and their henchmen, and these archetypes can be combined, like Gandalf as a mentor who also heralds the quest.
- Events have layers. The known world routine hints at your hero’s internal obstacles; the call brings the important ones into focus.
- Stakes don’t have to be life or death. Build them gradually and ask what’s at stake in every scene. In a children’s story, running out of gum can be a major problem.
- Dramatic question and thematic question. The dramatic question asks what will happen; the thematic question is what you want the audience to consider. In The Hunger Games, the call is “Will my sister survive?” and Katniss volunteers in her place; the story’s dramatic question becomes whether Katniss will survive.
- Call, refusal, choosal. Together they’re one decision broken into parts: a choice presented, the debate over it, and the choosing.
- State the call simply. Like the computer in WarGames: “Would you like to play a game?” Save the nuance for the unknown world.
- Thresholds as points of no return. Treating them that way makes the decision matter and raises the stakes.
- Kinds of calls, from Christopher Vogler’s The Writer’s Journey: a herald of change, temptation, disorientation (a friend turns out to be the antagonist), lack or need, no more options, more than one call, and warnings or prophecies.
Examples discussed
- Jumanji: Welcome to the Jungle: the game console is both herald and antagonist. The call comes in two parts: play the game, then, once inside, finish it or stay in Jumanji forever. The film flips the usual order: the teens choose to play right away, and the refusal comes after, once they’re stuck. It’s also full of heralds (the principal, the note that pulls Spencer out of gym class, Nigel) and sets its rules fast when Bethany dies and respawns minutes in.
- Edward Scissorhands: Act 1 is Peg’s short story; her call is the mansion in her side mirror. Peg arriving is Edward’s inciting incident, and his “Don’t go” is his choosal. Her “I think you should just come home with me” is a call stated, not asked, because she sees he needs care.
- Also: The Lord of the Rings, The Hunger Games, WarGames, and Breaking Bad, where we follow a perceived antagonist, Walter White.
Writing along with the season? Write at least three pages for your call to quest.
Read the full transcript
Transcribed automatically, so expect the odd misheard word. Sponsor messages are left out.
Adam: In this episode, we explore the story event Call to Quest. What quest, challenge, or invitation is presented to your hero? What choices? How does it highlight the overall dramatic question of your story? Next, on StoryOsophy. Hello, welcome to StoryOsophy. This is Adam Jones. And Gary Daschle. Gary Daschle. Excellent, excellent. Hello, welcome to StoryOsophy. This is Adam Jones. And Devin Halden. This week, we’re going to be talking about the Call to Quest, the fourth event in your story chain of events. We’d like to thank you for joining us. I think of it as a chain because they’re all linked together.
Devin: Oh yeah, yeah, I like that.
Adam: This one is called the Call to Quest, or as some other texts may call it, Call to Adventure. As Devin will tell you, it’s probably one of his favorite events to write. It is. Oh, it is. It is one of my favorite events to write, the Call to Quest or Call to Adventure. You’ll hear us call it both throughout this episode, but Call to Quest is our preference. I learned on Vogler and Joseph Campbell’s model. For the most part. I read a bunch of different texts. And we talk about these guys in our Audible mid-break.
They are the gurus of storytelling amongst others. But for me, McKee and Vogler were the two that I really, two texts I really kept by me when I was trying to figure out how to sort out structure. Vogler calls it the call to adventure. In some of the conversations you’ve heard about an inciting incident between Devin and I, I wasn’t always sold on the idea of an inciting incident. Because this event, Call to Quest, was the inciting incident for me. We’ll distinguish between the two because Devin has convinced me otherwise in our discourse. But the Call to Quest, what was important to me is in calling it in Vogler’s model the Call to Adventure.
Was it was something exciting for a hero. And if you remember last week, we’ve called it an inciting or exciting incident. So the incident itself is different than what we’re gonna talk about this week. The actual… The actual incident meeting the hero. Now, where this falls in the order of events, we’re still in Act One, the known world, which will transition into the unknown world of Act Two. And as you know, Devin and I like to break up our story into events and movements, movements being smaller chunks of acts and events being smaller chunks of movements. We’re still in Movement One in Act One.
Which, Movement One is the comfort zone to out of comfort zone. Both of these things, Act One and Movement One, and for practical purposes, usually they’re one and the same. Act One and Movement One are the same. They’re the foundation or the essence. And we’ve gone through the events prior to this, the hook, known world routine, inciting incident. And now we’re at Call to Quest. In recapping a little bit, The Hook engages your audience. The Known World Routine sets up the status quo before something exciting or inciting the story happens. And now this event basically is, I mean, it’s in the title, Call to Quest for the hero.
Yeah, you don’t have to jazz it up. You don’t have to jazz it up. Because the concept for anyone is, there’s a calling for you in life. Whether you’ve realized it or not for yourself, there’s something that excites you or calls you to it. Now, in this event, it can either be that or be someone else pushing your butt in the right direction, which a lot of times in stories, that’s what it is. Because remember, we’re moving from comfort zone. To out of comfort zone. And a lot of times, if you’re a teenager playing video games, it’s your mom going, get off your butt and go get this house stink off of you.
That’s what my mom used to say. House stink. Go get this house stink off of you.
Devin: I like that.
Adam: A lot of times, it’s someone telling you to get off your butt and do something. House stink. A lot of times, it’s someone asking you, will you do this thing? It’s someone telling you, you’re the chosen hero. There’s many ways that this. This event presents itself. Yes. But for the most part, there’s three other characters that are involved. Harold, mentor, maybe even villain or a villain’s henchman. But other archetypes usually interact with your hero at this point. Devin, do you want to say a few initial words on what this is about? Other than that, you like writing it.
Devin: I love writing the sequence of the call to quest. The refusal of the call to quest. And then the choosal of the call to quest. Really, call to quest, refusal of the call to quest, much more than the choosal. Why I like them is because the anatomy of each event is important or belongs to different characters. The call to quest is the event that it’s typically focused on our hero. But it’s as much about the antagonist as it is. Our hero. And in my opinion, this event is primarily focused and about our antagonist and the refusal of the call to quest that we will discuss in next an episode in the next episode is more about the hero.
Adam: You sneaky too. I didn’t even think about that. So you just said it. And it’s very intelligent statement. I was going to say, maybe I disagree with you because of the hero centric call. But you made a really valid point. But this is this is great promise for next episode when we get into refusal to go ahead.
Devin: So this event, the call to quest is this is our opportunity to let our hero know what they’re up against. It’s usually a herald character providing a bit. But of course, not not a lot or certainly not all of the information and background about about the quest. Our hero must decide important word decide to embark on. And the antagonist, our hero must defeat to be successful. So like like other events and definitely other events in our early movements here before we cross this threshold into the the unknown world, we want to give the audience just enough to pique their interest and let them know of the quests that they’re going to go on.
Let them know it’s going to be difficult and perhaps it’s going to be wrought with danger, whatever danger means in your story. But our herald character may not know how difficult or how dangerous or every obstacle that in fact, we don’t want them to give them the entire all of that information right off the bat. We want to we want to use it to pique the interest. We want to give our audience just enough to know what they need to know at this stage of the game and our hero hero and our audience. But we want to make sure that we beef up. The in this event, we want to use this event to beef up the peril of the quest and let the refusal and the choosal be about our hero.
So this is our choosal. So the call to quest for me is this is all about the antagonist. This is where we introduce our antagonist. This is where we give them, give our readers or our audience a little taste of how powerful they are, and then also provide a little bit of a roadmap up to a point. So the herald character may have experienced a bit of the journey in the unknown world, or they’re going to have some kind of information, whether it’s directly or indirectly, of what our hero is going to have to endure to get past the obstacles, both external and internal, along the way.
It actually may be more external. And then once we move from this event to refusal that we’ll see later, it changes from being about the antagonist to being about our protagonist.
Adam: It also will depend on your story and what your story requires. So if you’re trying to have a shadowy villain, they may not show their face here.
Devin: Yeah. And I didn’t mean that. Yeah.
Adam: Right. And like I said, there are three archetypes that show up generally in this area, and that’s the herald, the mentor, or the antagonist slash antagonist. Yeah. And like I said, there are three archetypes that show up generally in this area, and that’s the herald, the mentor, or the antagonist slash antagonist. The antagonist’s henchman.
Devin: Or information about the antagonist.
Adam: Right. What’s important to be said here is those three archetypes can be combinations. Right. The mentor can show up as a herald. Gandalf is an example. And just to re-explain herald, herald is someone who brings information, new information, or precipitates a new time or a new path. That’s the herald, which is sort of contrary to the threshold. And the herald can show up as a herald, which is sort of contrary to the threshold.
And we’re building to at the end of Movement One, which is someone who blocks the path. They’re sort of complementary in their own sweet ways. In their own sweet ways.
So… Also, the herald can be the antagonist’s henchman. Right. Like we’re talking about storytelling being recipes, there are all different combinations that you can make of the ingredients to build something that is unique. Everyone says story’s been told. There’s no new story, and that’s untrue. Because there’s new cuisine, you can recombine ingredients and create something that’s new. Also, perspective. What we’re getting in this wave of storytelling, the age that we’re in now, is we’re expanding that perspective through which story has been told. Whether it’s from single protagonist to ensemble perspective, opening up to the different voices that have prior to now been minority voices, we’re getting a broadening.
Of perspective, which is unique to story. So, there’s new recipes. There’s new flavors coming in storytelling. You can always build. Or even following the antagonist
Devin: Through the story, rather than following the hero through the story.
Adam: And let’s say perceived antagonist, because you can be a, quote, bad guy. Walter White, you can be a bad guy, quote, unquote, or doing something illegal. But to the audience, you’re friends with Walter White taking this journey. That’s the… Unique, vicarious experience that story can present itself and help the, in a broader sense, change minds.
Devin: And to add just one more point to this being the antagonist’s event, it doesn’t necessarily need to be the antagonist that is brought to attention either through information or who we – like, Adam, you were just saying the perceived antagonist at this point. And it just needs to be… Or let’s call it a force of antagonism. Force of antagonism. That’s better. And then also a little bit of information about the journey. Because basically all we’re doing right here is we’re giving the hero the opportunity to make a decision. That’s a great way to put it. Hopefully have given a glimpse of some of these internal obstacles that our hero has internal or external in the.
Previous events, we are going to understand how once presented with this opportunity to make this decision, some of the things that could be factors in them deciding to break out of that comfort zone and go and travel across that threshold into the unknown world into that out of the comfort zone.
Adam: Something you just said sparked an idea that I hadn’t quite fully considered before. Known world routine. That is usually used to set up the status quo of the situation. Like. So we know where our hero is coming from to where they’re going. To the decisions being made. I’d never thought of that event as an exciting thing to watch, really, because you’re trying to get your facts down, right? That’s your setup scene.
Devin: Status quo, yeah.
Adam: Right. And so I always think of that as a boring event in my mind.
Devin: Ooh, yeah. That’s usually where I put the internal stuff, or we come up with those internal obstacles.
Adam: But here’s what I just realized with what you just said. The internal stuff for me comes in call, refusal, and choosal. That’s where we can go, zoom in, here’s what we got, folks, but if you look at the Known World Routine, the whole setup and payoff, the whole promise and keeping the promise in the questions of those things, in the Known World Routine, when we’re watching, we’re going, why are we watching this?
Devin: Mm-hmm.
Adam: That’s the question, because it’s our first stuff we’re looking at. And what I love is that, quote, boring status quo, whatever the routine of the hero is, even if there’s not a lot of conflict there, there may be, there may not, we’re going to understand what all those beats and moments mean throughout that scene or series of scenes in that event with the payoff of call, refusal, and choosal. And so now that ordinary world routine, which, and I may not be the only person who thinks that might be a boring event. Because you’re like, come on, let’s get on with it. But the fact that it’s a setup for these very, I mean, very quick to come payoffs of call, refusal, choosal.
Devin: Right.
Adam: And in fact, folks, let’s just call it what it is. This is just the call to adventure. It includes all these three things, but we’re breaking it down for the purpose of examining what each of these aspects of, not just the character deciding, but in general. The decision. The decision-making process. You’re presented with a choice. You debate the choice, which is the refusal. You could also call the refusal the debate. And then the final aspect of it, you’re going to choose. It’s not saying which way you choose. In this case, for a story, you would choose the one that puts the person on the path into the story.
But they could still not choose to do a thing. And that’s their choice. It doesn’t mean that that thing’s still not going to affect them. It’s interesting. This is interesting to me. Look, I’m having an epiphany in the middle of an episode. I’m having an episode. That’s good. The whole point is that known world routine. Let me give you an example. One I’ve used before because it’s great because it’s not a heavy plot driven thing. It’s comedy. It’s character driven. Meet the parents. Opening scene. Ben Stiller’s proposing to an elderly patient in the emergency room. And he’s, we don’t know that’s who he’s proposing to at first.
And a lot of comedies will do this. They’ll give the reveal. He’s proposing. He’s proposing to someone with all his heart. And it ends up being one of his patients. That’s the big joke. That’s the hook. His known world routine is the ordinary world of his job. Being a nurse. He’s going to go home. See his girlfriend who he wants to make his fiance. The whole premise. Meet the parents. We understand once there’s the call to quote meet the parents. Why that initial proposal and ordinary routine scene mattered. So we get this retro. That’s the whole point with setups and payoffs. The retro aspect. It makes the approach to the known world routine.
Once again, as we talk about non-linearly, you get to the end of a story or a scene or an act or a movement. And you go back and you go, oh, shoot, I need to build that better. Right. This whole movement we’re talking about right now and this whole act, act one and movement one. Please rewrite it and revisit it as much as possible. Yes, absolutely. I highly encourage that. As if, you know, if you’re new to us, we have these diversions and I ramble. D, sorry to interrupt the process there, but that was exciting to me. I got very excited because it’s true. That tends to be looked at as boring and it’s not.
It can be really exciting to make these promises and then pay them off in two events later. There’s this those quick payoffs you were talking about last episode. Ask some questions. Post some questions that you can pay off immediately. So that the audience. The audience feels like, oh, I’m going to get answers soon.
Devin: Yeah. Let them catch the carrot every now and then. I think and I think the other thing we probably haven’t necessarily mentioned specifically is these these events all have layers as well. And so for me, the so if we’re taking the known world routine that can typically be boring. Well, that’s one layer. One layer is to show the status quo of our hero. But then there’s another layer to that, and that is to also give a glimpse of our heroes’ internal obstacles. And just a glimpse. And then we highlight them later. And then you, yeah, maybe he’s introverted and stuff like that. And then when you get to, so we’re setting it up there, and then when you get to the call to quest, we reinforce or emphasize or shed more light on.
The important ones. And then as you’ll see, the refusal is even more focused on the hero. Again, this is, we’re showing the antagonist here. And because of this thing that’s shaking up his world, this call to quest, the inciting event that’s shaking up the world, but then this call to quest, they’re like, hey, now you have to deal with it, or you have to whatever, whatever the story is about. Then we’re able to see how that focuses on this is the danger of this, or the journey. Or the journey of this, or the obstacles that you’re going to face. How are you going to deal with it? There’s the decision. Now you have the decision to make. And so setting up, giving a glimpse into our heroes’ internal issues or internal obstacles, even if it’s just really slightly like you just.
Adam: Even just their comfort zone where they cruise control for them right now.
Devin: Yeah.
Adam: In the known world.
Devin: These events aren’t just one thing happening. These events are layers of things happening to different characters and the world that we’re creating.
Adam: That’s a really valuable. Valid point. So it’s not just the hero. It’s the community. It’s the environment that we’re setting up in the known world, whether it’s the Shire and the Lord of the Rings. This is the world itself. But you’re also establishing the routine of the hero, the values of the hero as best you can. Because you just, as Devin is saying, you just need to hint at them. Because these events, especially the one we’re talking about this week, or we will be. The event this week called to quest, they will call into focus the traits that are important for your audience to understand about your hero for the rest of the journey, where they will change, how they will change, what the stakes are. Sometimes in this particular event, you will get the stakes of the story. Stakes are an interesting thing. They sort of are roaming. You build them gradually as you go.
But you should always ask. Event by event, scene by scene, what are the stakes here? I’m not a big proponent of, oh, life or death, oh, money or poor, like materialistic things. You can create stakes out of anything. If it’s a children’s book, and it’s very important for a certain character to have gum, and they’re out of gum, that’s a major problem within the context of the tone of that story.
Devin: Mm-hmm. Right.
Adam: You’ve got to build those out of loss or out of scarcity, which is what a lot of stakes are built out of. But that’s the easiest way to do it. That’s why horror movies, in building it, it’s life or death. You’ve got to survive, period. The stakes are very simplified, and it’s easy for everyone to understand. They may show up here, but they may not. The important thing that you pose here is the dramatic question. That’s why we call it the call to quest. Devin and I talked about this in previous episodes, first season even. Yeah. There’s a difference between a dramatic question and a thematic question. These are two, and the reason why these are important is because they’re questions for your audience, not for your characters. This is outside of story. This is you talking to the people that are going to be receiving this story puzzle to solve. So here are the questions they need to solve.
The dramatic question is, in its basic form, what will happen? So you need to figure out a way to take that question. Mm-hmm. And turn it into a question within the story for your hero. So it’s usually given to your hero, usually. It’s either given to your hero directly or indirectly, but it’s presented. Sometimes it’s something someone says. Sometimes it’s a request, a question. If you’re asking the question, you have this unique capability of asking that question to your audience, too, in a way. Yeah. Will you or won’t you save Jumanji? Dramatic question is, will our hero succeed or not? What will happen next? What will happen at the end? That’s your overall dramatic question.
From where we stand at the beginning of the story, how will that story end? You want to zoom that question into your story so that it’s very specific. We’ll talk about that in these examples to come, but the thematic question is what you’re asking the audience to consider mentally and emotionally for the course of the story. If you’re clever, you can sort of, as Devin said, in Passengers, if you haven’t listened to the theme episode, go back and check it out. It’s pretty fun. But Devin mentioned Passengers, where they actually spell out the theme through a question to the hero, to the protagonist. I mean, it’s a choice. You can do it subtler than that, but sometimes it’s really important to point out the theme and the arc or the dramatic question of your story.
So that your audience can track it. If you’ve got a really complex and well-developed story, that’s an awesome way to start. If you’ve got sort of a thin and very fluffy story, maybe that’s your poignant punctuation at the end of your story. Stories that are like formulaic, horror movies, comedies, things that aren’t well-developed, you can still use that thematic question as a punctuation. A quick example. In the Hunger Games, when Katniss’s sister is chosen for the lottery, this is an internal call that goes off for Katniss. The ultimate dramatic question will be, will Katniss survive the Hunger Games? But here it’s a little different. Here Katniss asks herself, will her sister survive the Hunger Games? And the answer is no.
So Katniss, being a willing hero, doesn’t refuse the call. She chooses to volunteer as tribute and take her place, take her sister’s place. Now, notice this real simple example of the dramatic question being the same dramatic question, but the choice being Katniss over her sister. Will my sister survive the Hunger Games is the call to adventure. That’s what makes Katniss jump to attention and make her decision. But the dramatic question is, will she? Will she survive? Will Katniss survive the Hunger Games? I just wanted to point that one out as a really brilliant way of showing the stakes and the dramatic question by just changing the question a little bit.
Period. Scene.
On to our weekly examples. Let’s talk specifically about how our two trackable films, Jumanji, Welcome to the Jungle, and Edward Scissorhands. I could sing it again. No, that’s good. We’ve had enough of that. How our two films, Jumanji, Welcome to the Jungle, and Edward Scissorhands, exemplify this particular event. So let’s start with Jumanji, Welcome to the Jungle.
Devin: Ooh, I like this one too. And I believe we are probably on the same page as this because we have discussed this a little bit. But I believe it’s kind of a two-parter for me. Part one of the call to quest is when, and this is my opinion, is when Spencer sees the TV. And the opportunity to plug in the game console, which is, for me, the game console is the herald, in this part, part one of this, that Fridge finds. And it continues when each of them is given the opportunity to make the decision to play the game.
Adam: The gaming system is the herald and antagonist combined.
Devin: I agree. Yes. Yep, definitely.
And this part one of the call to quest continues. When each of them is given the opportunity, Fridge, Bethany, Martha, and Spencer are actually, well, yeah, they’re all given the opportunity to make the decision, the decision to play or to continue pulling staples out of the magazines. Now, I call this part one because the call to quest and the refusal of the call to quest happen in both. In both the known world, part one, and after they are sucked into the game, where they are presented with part two of the call to quest. In both parts of the call to quest, though, our heroes, and this is important, they’re given opportunity to make decisions.
Yeah. In part one, the decision is simply to play the game. And part two’s call to quest decision is simply stay in Jumanji forever or finish the game and get back to the known world.
Adam: Now, what you just said is a stakes question. Right. On either side of that threshold from known world to unknown world, from do we choose to the stakes are staples and feel punished. Right. Or choose an avatar and play this game for fun for five minutes, which seems simple, but those are your stakes. Right. And in the unknown world, it’s stay forever in Jumanji in punishment. Or. Or choose to adventure, choose to go on the adventure. Now, there is a, I will say something about this that I came to a conclusion about, but we’re on the same page. Okay. And the order of these events, folks, is way out of whack.
They decided to take the structure and move it all around. Yes, yes. And in such an effective way, a brilliantly effective way.
Devin: And it’s, they do, not even the order of things, just kind of what occurs is weird. So part one is interesting, but because often the Herald character will present the hero, in this case our heroes, with a little bit of information about the unknown world, perhaps the antagonist they will face. Along with even some of the known perils, like we talked about, they’ll, maybe if they have some knowledge of the known perils or obstacles that they’re going to encounter along the way. Here, sure they make the decision to play the game, but they certainly haven’t been provided any information by the game console, the Herald, and the antagonist, that is going to allow them to make any type of educated decision.
They find themselves in Jumanji. Given some information by a second Herald. And even then, they don’t really, they’re not really allowed to make the decision to, I guess they are, they can either, at that stage, they’re making the decision to, well, you can either stay here, your new status quo, or if you want to get out of here, they’re presented with this black and white call to quest of complete the game and get out of Jumanji and get back to the unknown world or stay here forever, your call. So it’s interesting how they’re… How they’re doing that.
Adam: You just opened up like three different avenues of conversation here. But… I love avenues. The idea of the stakes of, one of the reasons we chose Jumanji was because it’s based on a video game, it’s very easy to track events. Yes. It’s so clearly illustrated. And, you know, we don’t want to praise the movie as if it’s, you know, the best movie to come along in 50 million years, because it’s got its faults like any other movie. But it illustrates the events really well. And it plays with them to different degrees. Stakes, this movie has more heralds in it than most movies. The principal’s a herald.
Yeah. The game itself is a herald. The Nigel who shows up in the unknown world is a herald. Even prior to that, the person who brings the note to the gym class that interrupts the gym class and says, Spencer Gilpin, you need to come to the office. That’s a herald. In video games, heralds are prominent. They’re everywhere. There’s always someone with a question mark over their head that you need to go and ask and talk to about new information to move you along the next path. They make use of that in this as a structure. They make use of maps within this as a video game and a cinematic layout of where we’re supposed to go.
So there’s all these things that happen. Now, I want to comment on what Devin just said about the call extends into movement, too, because I thought this originally. And there are a few. The refusal of call extends into movement, too. The whole call to adventure is an extended, super extended event in Jumanji. And I want to say this. I agree and I don’t agree because I debated this in my head when I was preparing for this episode. When I talk about or when we talk about movement one being the movement you have to figure out because it lays out a hook, something that grabs you. It lays out the ordinary world routine.
Here’s the status quo of right now. Then there’s a choice to be made. Then there’s a debate about said choice. And then there’s the choosing of it one way or the other to cross a threshold. That’s the whole layout of a movement, of movement one and act one. But we’re suggesting, or at least I don’t want to put words in your mouth, Devin. I’m suggesting taking that whole movement and using it as a transparency and laying it over. The next movements, the subsequent movements. That being the case, if we’re entering movement two, the new status quo, they’re avatars in a jungle, in a jungle game. The call to adventure is whether they will accept the stakes of this particular movement, this particular act.
And then the debate. And the choosing. And then you lay that over the next one and go through the next. You’re peeling back layers of the onion of doubt in a character until they can find their true self, their true belief, their true new version of self. And it’s the same process really over and over. Once you’ve dealt with that situation, there’s a new choice to be made because you’re, as Edward so aptly puts it, I’m not finished yet. No one’s ever finished. Until they die. That’s when they stop growing. So, each movement is a new choice and a new choice. So, although it feels like this and brilliantly written so, an extended call to adventure and refusal of call and all that, it’s really the second movement in our structure. Just using the recall of those events brilliantly.
Right.
It’s the status quo of the new world, of the unknown world of Jumanji and all that, which we’ll break down in future episodes and I’m sure we will debate and have discourse over. But it’s important that we’re both recognize the same thing happening within the structure.
[Sponsor message]
Devin: Here’s the interesting part that you’ve just sparked to me. Thinking about it differently, perhaps sometimes the change of environment isn’t necessarily that crossing of the threshold into the known, even though they’re in the unknown world now. True. The call to adventure doesn’t, maybe it’s not a part one, part two call to adventure, call to quest. It’s actually, just an extended call to quest that finishes in the unknown world. But the interesting part about interesting element of Jumanji is where a call to quest is typically a decision that someone can either stay or go. They don’t have, they’re not given that decision at all. And so their only decision is to stay in the unknown world. And so they’re not given that decision at all.
And stay within their known world routine or go on this journey, answer that call to quest. But so for here, it’s just, it’s just interesting how they wrote it.
Adam: It’s unique. The one observation I had about this that made it unique to me was simply this, and this is putting it sort of cut and dry, but it’s not really as simple as this. They reversed, and this is awesome in this mentally to me, because I’d never considered doing this. The call to quest and the choosal of the call to quest and Jumanji happen before the refusal, really, in this movie. And that’s the unique changing of events for me that I found fascinating. Because even though there is a refusal, I mean, let’s look at it, Fridge discovers the gaming system. That’s really the start of this. There’s a build to the call to adventure. When we talk about the call, sorry, call to quest, when we talk about the call to quest or call to adventure, there is an initial build.
You don’t start the scene with the call. There’s something that builds to it and the calls within the context of the scene or the event. And so the build to it is they’re left at attention. Everybody’s bored. They’re shuffling around. Martha’s the only one doing work. Fridge finds the gaming system. That’s it. That’s the start of the call. We’ve had the build that we’ve increased the complications. So if you’re looking at this event in terms of a scene or the three O’s or act one, act two, act three, act four, act five, act six, act seven, act eight, act nine, act two, act three, three part system, there’s the boredom. That’s act one. The call to adventure, the inciting incident, all that stuff. Fridge finds the gaming system. He turns to Spencer and Spencer sees the TV. And there’s this reflective moment. I like this moment, by the way, where Spencer looks at Fridge like, hey, remember when we were kids and we used to play games together? There’s this moment of internal shared emotional space that’s…
What? A blip on the screen, man, and says everything without dialogue. Important to note, because it’s kind of a sweet gesture on Spencer’s part. Right. They hook it up, which means Fridge is willing. He’d rather be playing games with Spencer than be pulling staples. Okay? So there’s the call. Now, if we’re tracking, we don’t want to track necessarily through refusal and choose all here now, but it’s, it’s all right here because none of them are unwilling heroes. They’re all willing heroes in this, except for Martha, who is diligently trying to do what she needs to do to get out of trouble. The whole point of the call to adventure here for me in this moment is that they choose an avatar.
It’s the whole refusal, choosal. Aspect. It all happens very quick in this movie. Now, once they’ve chosen it and they get into the unknown world, then they’re like, no, no, no, no, no. We don’t want to be here. What’s going on? We don’t want to be here. Right. So the denial, the debate, the, the refusal happens because they made a rash decision and are now stuck. Right. So what I love about this play on call, refusal, and choosal, they reverse. So it’s call. Choosal. Refusal. But the refusal.
Devin: And then back to choosal.
Adam: Right. Well, in the refusal aspect of this, the denial of being avatars in a video game, that whole sequence is really what Devin and I like to call reaction to the unknown world or first day of school. But they’ve cleverly condensed their first act by moving refusal after choosal. Because the only refusal you get is Martha. Everybody else is a willing hero. Everybody else is a willing hero who hears the call. Let’s play the video game. Woohoo. And they choose their avatar and they’re in. So there’s no real refusal until after the choosal.
Devin: What’s really important for that more enlightening for me is when studying this variance of it is typically when I’m thinking of the order of things, it goes inciting incident, call to quest, refusal of call to quest, choosal of call to quest, cross threshold, enter unknown world. First day of school, that part of it. But it can actually, the threshold doesn’t necessarily have to be the divider between movement one and movement two. This is true. It’s the events that are dividing that. So this can actually be, this sequence of call to quest, refusal, and choosal can literally be overlapped into from known world into unknown world. Because maybe not.
Jumanji is not an example of. Jumanji is not an example of being able to refuse and go back. But there’s plenty of movies where someone could. Edward Scissorhands is one that’s coming up. Get into some, yeah, enters the unknown world, explores the unknown world, and is like, nope, I’m out, peace out. And then goes back. And then goes back to the status quo. So it doesn’t have to be that threshold, which a lot of times if you, in a lot of structure diagrams is always like this divider of act one, act two, movement one, movement two. But it’s really. The events are a little bit more important.
Adam: Yeah, this is a really important point. Yeah. Not to insult Jumanji because I really enjoy it. But as commercial as it is, look how experimental they are with classic structure. They’re not doing the one, two, three here. They’re sort of playing with it a little bit. But you’ll see a lot of this actually in fantasy and some fantasy stories. Especially if it’s someone who starts in the, quote, real world. And is going to a fantastical world like Labyrinth where they cannot return. It streamlines it pretty quick. This is a, there’s a denial phase. Especially if you sort of like, whoops, I didn’t mean to cross that threshold.
It’s good to think of thresholds as points of no return. Right. It’s a good way to think of them. It may not always be the case. But you will increase your stakes if you do try to think of them that way first. Primarily.
Devin: And it makes the decision way more important. Exactly. If you can’t go, if you can’t renege it.
Adam: Once you’re locked out of the city gates. Once you’re exposed. Once you’re in Jumanji. Once you’re, it’s, that’s why thresholds are interesting. Because there may be doors. There may be gates. There may be rites of passage. A lot of the symbology of thresholds is the rite of passage. To have you learned enough. Are you mature enough to go to this next level or this next place in your journey? Jumanji plays with it a lot. And like I say, as simple as some stories seem, they’re taking these elements and rearranging them and playing with them and using the ingredients in a different fashion to get a different result.
As Devin was saying, it sort of carries over. We get this in-game mission from Nigel, who is the overall herald of the entire piece, and sort of mentor, mentor-herald, even though, for the most part, the mentor of the tale is each of the characters internally, individually, discovering themselves, as the thematic question posed is, who are you? This is the kind of story I love more as far as that. The sort of understanding of a mentor is within self, within yourself. Someone else may pose you the thematic question, but you don’t learn everything from the mentor. You learn it from the inner mentor.
Right. You discover it from who you really are. And so, Nigel is as close to a mentor, so is the principal. They’re both heralds, more heralds than mentors, because the mentors are, like I say, that inner self of each of these ensemble heroes. And their hero peers, the three other people they’re sharing the journey with, are also their mentors. The call to adventure in this, the call to quest in this, is very simple. Yeah. It’s just really just the choosing of the video game. Or the question of, that’s actually a better way to put it, the question of, do you want to play this game?
Devin: Yeah.
Adam: It was funny. I was flipping through the TV the other night, and I saw War Games was on TV. The old Matthew Broderick, 1980-something film about nuclear arms race. Do you know that movie? Yep. Yep. So, the call to adventure is really simple. Would you like to play a game? Yes. He chooses to play the game. But it’s a computer asking, would you like to play a game? The call should be clear like that. And Jumanji, it is. Same call. Do you want to play this game? If you state it, obviously, for your audience, the whole reason we call this first act and first movement foundation and essence, state it.
Simply, state it quickly, and then get into the nuance and the detail once you enter the unknown world. That’s where it happens. Right. So, the premise set it up really tight here.
Devin: And they do. And that’s one thing I love about this film, and then also Edward Scissorhands, is they not only introduce the characters, introduce some of their internal obstacles, they even introduce the mythology and the rules of the game very quickly. Bethany’s character, played by… Jack Black, is literally killed within two minutes of her entering that first world. Why? Because we have to show that once you’re dead, you come back. You come back, and you have lives, and it’s just like a video game. And it’s like, they didn’t waste any time to bring that mythology of Jumanji, the unknown world, allow the audience to see that.
Adam: And also, and we’re getting a little bit into the unknown world, but also, there are false stakes. She gets killed, and then two movements later… Mm-hmm….we’re… We discover that you can’t just always die and come back. You die three times, and you’re dead. Right. And so, the stakes seem to be this way in the beginning of the unknown world. Which is a little bit of a payoff. But then you move into a little bit later, and you’re like, we took that for granted. We’re getting ahead of ourselves. Do you want to move on to Edward? Yeah, let’s go to Edward. Okay. So, call to adventure for Jumanji is fairly quick and easy and simple.
Edward Scissorhands, we’ll have to talk about how we define this, because we were talking about inciting incident and call to quest last……last episode, and how it’s sort of a nebulous zone. Let’s talk about this as a build to the call, and the call itself. As we were saying in Jumanji, there’s this whole, they’re working in the detention room, and then they discover the gaming system. And the fact is, that whole build before they discover it is still call to adventure. It’s just the part one of that whole chunk. Last episode, you spoke about what you considered to be……to be the call. You had a very specific moment.
Devin: This is interesting. A train of thought came into the station last night, and I decided to get on. You know what I’m saying? I had some very odd thoughts about this the other night. Edward Scissorhands, similar to Jumanji, it’s a different variation on this. Writer Caroline Thompson uses an interesting twist for the call to quest here. And the refusal of the call to quest, and really the answering, too, is they’re all kind of jumbled up. Jumbled together a little bit in a good way, but we’ll discuss the refusal next episode. So I’ll focus on the call to quest here. I actually had to watch this section of the story over a few times because I felt like something was hiding from me a bit.
And then I think I found it on my train of thought. For Edward, his call to quest happens off screen, okay? When he’s cowering in the shadows and he’s observing Peg, who is also the herald, investigate his space, his known world, his nest that we talked about. And so now here’s why I say this. Edward’s connection to the town, this town below, has only been through magazines and newspapers and pictures of this strange place, this unknown world to him. Besides the inventor, Edward has never seen another human, personally. And so Peg is the herald with this knowledge of this unknown world. But her mere presence gives Edward…
Edward the opportunity to confront her, or the opportunity or decision to stay hidden and just let her leave and go back to his status quo of his known world. Now, before I’m attacked on Instagram, realize that this is just a StoryOsophy, a theory. Because I realize, and I realize that the reason Peg even goes upstairs is she hears the sounds of scissors. And the reason she finds Edward cowering in the corner, not cowering, but hiding in the corner, is because she hears the scissors again. But it’s as if Edward wants to be discovered. And he’s scared of this human, Peg. But he also knows that this could be his way of change, really.
And so in my mind, he’s making a decision to be found by Peg. And for me, that’s like… Is his call… The call to quest is Peg entering his domain or his known world, this mansion that he… This is his entire… I mean, not even figuratively speaking. This is his entire world. This is the only thing that he knows, is that is the mansion and then the grounds around the mansion. And so the call to quest for him is knowing something else is down there, because we know that he’s got these magazines, pictures and everything up in his, like, this nest that he’s created. But the call to quest is, do you want to go there?
Like, are you ready to leave here and go on that journey down there, on that quest to see what’s down there? And Peg showing up is all of a sudden this call to quest. And him allowing himself to be discovered is his decision to accept that call.
Adam: I may have simplified it a little. Earlier when I said, make it a direct question or something like that, it’s helpful to the audience to encapsulate it in a question or a statement. But the overall negotiation of that premise is the scene itself. Going off of what you said, I would discuss it like this. I would say Peg entering the domain is an inciting incident for Edward. -oh, the exciting or insight. No one’s been here and how… However long. Right. And she’s invading my space. He is terrified. I would agree with that. As you said, like, he’s cowering in the corner. He is cowering in the corner.
He’s terrified. He doesn’t know what to expect because he knows nothing of the, quote, unknown world. And a herald in the form of Peg comes into his world and changes what that is. Herald and mentor Peg is in this story. The one thing I would say that’s probably good to examine within this particular, example, is the fact that, as we’ve discussed in previous episodes, this is Peg’s short story, Act 1.
Devin: Right. And she had her own call to quest and acceptance.
Adam: Well, and this is what I was going to address, yeah. So with both of these things, when we talk about these events, the story can have a call to quest and all these things. And each individual character can. And if you want to get intricate with your story, find nuance, find complexity. Find depth. That’s what you do. You take each character through some of these events and find out what they want and where they change.
Devin: Right.
Adam: Even if it’s the main character or several different characters. And they’re going to have different calls to quest, inciting incidents, status quos, known world routines. But the story itself has an overall spine. And in that spine, we look at these events. Broadly. Now, I know that gets a little complex. We’re trying to keep it simple for this tracking through events season. And in further seasons, we will get more complex in breaking stuff down. But I think what’s important to note here, and let me just give my opinion on how this unfolds so that we can sort of discuss. So to me, the inciting incident is Peg coming in.
Devin: Right. I would agree with that.
Adam: And for Peg, we’ve talked. We’ve talked about the call to quest and inciting incident and all that stuff being her seeing the mansion, the gothic mansion, the rear view, and going, I’m going to make a sail there. And she travels off into her short story of act one journey into her unknown world, which is Edward’s castle, Edward’s mansion. So within this, there is sort of a crisis point when she thinks she’s in danger. And then there’s a climax point at the end of the short story where she decides what she’s going to do with Edward and the situation she’s in. And the short story finishes. That’s act one. And she hands the perspective off to Edward for the rest of the movie. Unique way of approaching it.
Mm-hmm. Right, right.
-huh. But Peg doesn’t do that. Peg realizes that he needs care. He needs mentorship. He needs – and so she doesn’t even provide him with the question or the opportunity. She just tells him what he’s going to do. I think you should just come home with me. Right. Those are two big choice moments. Peg decides to stay, even though in the crisis of her short story, she’s in danger from these blades. She stays. Right. And Edward is so excited. He’s so excited to go on the adventure of, I’ve looked down there every night, all day long. I look from the attic and I see this. I want to go there.
Devin: Right.
Adam: He chooses – or he just allows her to take charge of him in a way. And so they each have individual call to adventures, but the story itself has its own call to adventure, which is the attic scene where they both have sort of pseudo call to quest adventure.
Devin: And what’s interesting, you could even argue – not argue. There’s no reason to argue. But you could say that Edward saying don’t go is his choosal of the quest.
Adam: Agreed. Yeah, for sure. In him saying don’t go before she chooses, he’s chosen already. He wants to go with her. Yes. He just is so detached and socially awkward. And mind you, that’s the whole premise of Edward Scissorhands, is turning social awkwardness into a monster. That’s not really a monster. Yes. It’s just timidity. It’s just shyness. Right. And that’s the beautiful allegory of Tim Burton’s tale, personally, from his personal experience. Mm-hmm. He’s made to know beans about feeling estranged from other people socially, you know? He feels like a weirdo. Most of us do. Right. That’s why Edward Scissorhands is a really exciting and captivating fairy tale for the rest of us as an audience, is we all know what it’s like to feel a little bit like Edward.
Right. In both of these examples, we’ve seen – That the events that are these important events, the call to quest, refusal of quest, and choosal of quest, notice they are rearranged and even sometimes unspoken, which is the case with a lot of these – both of these, in a way. But they’re there. You either have a willing hero or an unwilling hero, but you should always consider these three stages to find out what is the hero being asked to do, call to quest. And why does the hero feel like they are not capable of doing it, refusal of call, and who and how – who convinces them and how do they do it for choosal?
They can convince themselves. Someone else can. If you lay those out properly, the rest of the story will make sense to your audience. And like we said, this will all make sense more as we go along with further events, events in the future for Act 2 and Act 3. You’ll realize the importance of this and how you backwards develop.
Devin: Right-o, old chap. Right-o.
Adam: Right-o. Last episode, Devin, we were talking about the inciting incident and what – where it was in Edward Scissorhands. And it ends up being a little strange and bizarre in this one particularly because, as we said, it’s Peg’s short story who we identify with. We get to know her. We understand her compassion. And then she hands it off to Edward, the point of fascination in the story. Each event, when we call it a thing, like call to quest, has a – has a build. So for me, the call to adventure of Edward Scissorhands, for example, call to quest for Jumanji is easy. It’s the do you want to play the video game, period.
Edward Scissorhands, the build is more prolonged. It partly has to do with Peg’s discovery of Edward and her turning points there. But it also has to do with what happens before that final posed. Final posed question or final posed statement. I think you should just come home with me. That whole scene is really the call to quest. It’s the build and then the call question, the call statement. Okay. And I know we had talked a little bit maybe of varying viewpoints. This may be worth addressing. The inciting incident to me is the attic scene. It’s the meeting of them together. And within that, a lot of stuff happens. Call, refusal, choosal. Even the choosal, it’s classically the meeting of the mentor.
Primarily in Edward Scissorhands for me, the whole first act is sort of like prologue, ordinary world, and inciting incident, which is all of those events that happen afterwards. Do you know what I mean? The inciting incident itself is like this big thing that contains the other ones. But I don’t know if you have a different way of segmenting or labeling that a little bit for clarity.
Devin: Edward Scissorhands is interesting because we’ve touched on this before. Where we start off, it starts off as, after the prologue, it starts off as Peg’s story. And then she has a call to quest. She has an inciting incident. She has a call to quest. She has a, she doesn’t, there’s no refusal for her. And then there’s a choosal of the call to quest. She crosses a threshold. The minute she crosses that threshold, we begin to hand the… It kind of begins the handing off of the story to Edward, because then it starts where she enters the house or she enters the, his garden, which is beginning the inciting incident for Edward. And then there’s his call to quest.
Adam: When he, when you’re saying beginning, you’re saying build. Same difference. The build to it. Yeah.
Devin: Beginning. The building to. Building to. Yeah.
And then his, what we’ve just talked about with everything, the very important meeting of the attic is the handoff of Edward to, the story to Edward.
Adam: Right. And I think that whole, what you’re talking about, beginning, beginning and build.
Devin: Yeah. I should use build.
Adam: Well, and it didn’t occur to me that what you were saying was build until you were saying it. So the build though, it’s the build to meeting Edward. We’ve been building it up since, since minute one of this movie. Mm-hmm. Through the credits, through the prologue, through the ordinary. Through the ordinary world, all this stuff we’ve been building to this point. So it’s the big dramatic question of act one is who is the man with scissors for hands in the prologue? And so we’re getting our, we’re anticipating, that’s a great way to sort of think of a build where it is building anticipation for the event to climax, whatever the event may call to quest.
Yeah. The build for me ends in that act. Act one build when we see Edward’s face and he says, don’t go. Because other than that, everything else is mystery. And as soon as he does and says that, like.
Devin: Yeah.
Adam: You get this visceral gut reaction. You’re just surprised by what he’s like, meek and mild and all that. Mm-hmm. So the reversal, especially because they amp it up with the whole horror movie music. Taunted. When he’s coming out of the freaking dark attic with those blades and you’re like, oh. Mm-hmm. Because you feel that anxiety with Peg. Mm-hmm. And how he walks towards her. Yeah. But as soon as you see his face, that build has this payoff of, what did she say in the beginning? Incomplete and all alone. We sort of see it in his face and all that. And so the build to the call and the call itself is sort of one thing. It’s just the call is the punctuation to it.
Both these examples are very, when I started to break these down, I realized the nuance in them. Yeah, definitely. I realized the unique take they have on each of these events and go, wow, they’ve used the event, but they’ve really decided to reinvent it and not leave it as a cliched moment. Right. What we’re laying out for you, story authors, you could take this and write the easiest thing that you’ve seen on television or film or read in a book and build something that’s, you know, paint by numbers and it’s not new. We’re supplying this sort of structural examination because we want to build new worlds.
And luckily, strangely enough, I didn’t think Jumanji was going to do this. It’s a big studio piece, but there’s nuance. There’s all these different things you can do with that structure to invent something new. There are many different ways of approaching a call to quest. And before we sign off for this episode, we just want to run through a list real quick of variations from Vogler. Vogler, Christopher Vogler is one of the folks that… I learned a lot structurally from. Go read his book, Writer’s Journey. It’s wonderful. So much great information. There’s plenty of folks we would promote to read their work. But to run through some of the variations Vogler has, a call to adventure can be a herald of change, which we’ve spoken about.
It can be temptation. Meaning, let’s say your ordinary or status quo life is too much comfort zone. Something that maybe entices you to have a better place, a better station in life, a better mental health, better emotional health, relationships. It just asks you to come to the unknown world. Another that he has is disorientation or discomfort. In certain situations, you can be surprised that someone you considered a friend or a herald is actually the antagonist. That can cause you to jump to action. Most stories I find, and as you will notice as we go through or you listen to this podcast, I’m not a big proponent of using to build it, is lack or need.
When someone lacks or needs something, that’s the start of a journey. Now, that’s a lot of people’s. Start to a journey. But I think you can find something better than the programming of our society of lack or need right now. I think there’s better motivations and things to be found in exploration of journeys. Another one he has is no more options. Yet another is more than one call. And a lot of that happens in Hollywood comedies where it’s like, oh, the business is about ready to seal the deal with some great new client. And your family. So, you’re sort of splitting your character’s journey. Another one is warnings or prophecies.
And this happens a lot. We even spoke about this in Jumanji with the freak house dad warning Spencer. Like I said, if you have not read Vogler, it’s well worth a read. It’ll help you to focus your stories a little better too. And give you some options. As always, we encourage you to take the time after this episode between now and next week’s episode to write three pages at least that is your call to quest. The story you’ve been wanting to write, just sit down for 15 minutes and have fun writing three pages. Doesn’t have to be perfect. That’s what editing is for. But it doesn’t exist unless you put it on the page.
So, we like to encourage you. Write from these events. Write from these episodes. If you feel inspired. Don’t wait. Write when you’re inspired.
Devin: Time for lunch.
Adam: Please subscribe and rate us on iTunes. Follow us on social media. Share with your friends and send us your questions and comments. For additional resources and links to films, series, and books we talk about here, visit our website. While you’re there, sign up for our newsletter for updates on story building tools and special offers at StoryOsophy.com.