Show notes
How do you scramble a story’s chronology and keep its spine? Adam and Devin close Season 1 with a deep look at Memento, told backward in five-minute pieces by a man who can’t make new memories. They talk about the difference between a deliberately dissatisfying ending and a story that simply drops the ball, and why nonlinear storytelling works only when the audience trusts you.
In this episode
- Memento backward. The opening Polaroid fades instead of developing, telling us how the story will run. Each segment ends where the previous one began, so the audience is as lost as Leonard is, and nearly everyone is manipulating him.
- Setups and payoffs in reverse. An old man laughs as Leonard drinks a free beer; the scene before shows why. Leonard thinks he’s chasing a man, until the man shoots at him: “Oh, no, he’s chasing me.”
- Two storylines dovetail. Black-and-white phone calls run forward while the color scenes run backward, and they meet at the end.
- A fact built on a faulty memory. Leonard trusts facts, not memory, yet the license plate tattooed on his leg is one he made up in anger.
- Dissatisfying is not the same as broken. Memento’s ending, like No Country for Old Men’s, is meant to frustrate you. A film that leaves a hole in its logic just missed the mark.
- The brain fills in the gaps. Devin’s college professor was “shot” in class, and every student described the shooter differently. When things are disrupted, the brain rushes to restore order with imagination.
- The storyteller’s contract. When you buy a ticket or open a book, you trust the storyteller to make it all make sense. That trust is what lets an audience ride out the disorientation.
- Psychological landscapes. Charlie Kaufman goes nonlinear to explore the mind: Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind plays as fragments of an erased relationship, and Adaptation turns his failure to adapt The Orchid Thief into the story itself.
- Be brave. Audiences want fresher stories, and this is the time to experiment. William S. Burroughs cut up his own novels and reassembled them.
Examples discussed
- Memento, Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind, Adaptation, Netflix’s The OA, No Country for Old Men and David Lynch’s Mulholland Drive, Eraserhead and Blue Velvet.
- Also: Fight Club, Citizen Kane, Kurt Vonnegut’s Breakfast of Champions and the band Alt-J.
That wraps Season 1. Next season: structure.
Read the full transcript
Transcribed automatically, so expect the odd misheard word. Sponsor messages are left out.
Adam: In this episode, we conclude our discussion on nonlinear storytelling. How do you alter the chronology of a story and still maintain its spine? How do you do it without losing your audience? We discuss these questions and more next on StoryOsophy. Hello, welcome to StoryOsophy. This is Adam Jones. And Devin Halden. This week, we continue our discussion about nonlinear storytelling, which is storytelling told out of sequence. The experience is the experience, folks. You have to watch these things to actually get the… Non-sequential stuff, because it’s the whole point. Talking about it’s not going to get you as much there. Right. We’ll get you close to climax, folks.
If you haven’t listened to last week’s episode, I would encourage you to go back and listen to it. This is part two. Okay, on to the first examples with Memento. I was going to start with Memento, because I literally watched it again last night just for the sake of checking it out again. And for those of you who have not seen it, Memento is a time sequence thing. Some of my other ones are… Psychological landscape things. But Memento is… Here’s the logline. A man juggles searching for his wife’s murderer and keeping his short-term memory loss from being an obstacle. The story itself is told backward, in a way.
They’ll tell you about five to five-minute segments. And then they’ll skip back to the segment that would have happened right before that. And that segment ends with the first moment you saw from the previous segment. So you can… You can glue it together. You get it in pieces. And it’s not told sort of like all the whole thing in reverse. People don’t walk in reverse and all that stuff. In the beginning, they sort of… The hook scene is someone holding a photograph, a Polaroid. And they’re shaking the picture, as people would do with Polaroid, to get the picture to come into focus. Except when they’re doing it, it’s getting more and more bleached out.
Meaning the development process, the instant development process of Polaroid, is going… Backwards in time. And you start to get it. They run the credits over it. But what they’re doing this whole time is they’re telling you, this is the story we’re going to tell. We’re going to tell this story backwards. And so once it’s done, he pulls a gun and he shoots a man and kills him. And the guy’s protesting. And then we just skip back. And we lead up to him taking the guy into this place. And the guy’s saying, you know, you don’t want to do this, blah, blah, blah. If you really want to know who you are, let’s go to the basement.
And it’s the big mystery question for the whole movie is, well, what was in the basement? Because he doesn’t go there. He thinks the guy’s lying and he kills him. So we already know he kills this guy, Joey Pants. Joey Pants, Joe Pantoliano, who’s in everything. He’s an actor who’s been around for ages, brilliant character actor. And so he kills him. And then we get to go back in the story. And this guy, it appears, for the first part of the story, is his friend. This guy’s helping him. And yet we know already this guy is killed. The main character kills him in the end. But Lenny kills Teddy. As we go backwards, we’re sort of like him going, well, who can I trust? Can I trust even my own? Because he’s tattooed all of the vital information on his body because he can’t lose those notes. And the one key thing is that he knows this information.
John G., he only knows the last initial of the guy’s name, raped and murdered your wife. And so he has this constant reminder of… I need to find John G. So as we go back through the story, we realize part of the problem with us tracking this mystery to the end, because we see the end first, is we slowly start to realize that almost everybody in his experience is manipulating him because of his memory loss situation. This becomes very apparent at the midpoint when Carrie-Anne Moss, her character, Natalie, who’s been helping him, literally tells him, I can say any… And she… Swears up a storm, just barking in his face and belittling him and saying, you’re stupid. I can tell you anything I want and you’re going to forget in five minutes. And she gets him so riled up that he hits her. She goes outside, gets in her car, waits five minutes, comes back in and tells him someone else did it and motivates him to go after that person.
And so now at the midpoint, like Devin and I talk about, midpoints are a big thing, crisis. And they do theirs about midpoint. They don’t delay their crisis. She pivots the whole story for the audience perspective. We’re like, well, we thought she was the ally because he writes notes to himself on these Polaroids that says, you can trust this person. He writes down on Teddy’s Polaroid something like, don’t trust his lies or don’t listen to his lies. So everything Teddy says from the point he writes that down, he doesn’t believe even if he… Because he can’t remember anything. And with her, he writes down a positive note like, she lost someone too. She will help you out of pity. But none of these are true. We get to the beginning of the story.
Which is the end of our linear progression in the telling. And we really don’t get too terribly many more answers. We get some nice surprise twists. We get to find out that his psychological landscape is a little off. When we get to the end of the movie, Teddy, who he kills at the beginning of the movie, I hope you’re following, that he kills at the beginning of the movie. He tells him, look, man, you’ve already killed John G. You killed him a while ago. You just still think… You just still think there’s John G out there because you can’t remember having killed him in the satisfaction of the revenge. So you’re still on this revenge quest. But there’s no more John G. And he gets so angry at Teddy in this moment that he writes Teddy’s license plate down and says, this is the license plate of John G. Because he’s so angry at Teddy in this moment.
So for the rest of the story, he set Teddy up to be John G by the end. So he kills him. But he’s created this fiction. He keeps creating it and forgetting it and creating it and forgetting it. And it’s trippy because you get to the end and you realize, oh, we don’t even get too much satisfaction. We’re sort of treated like the character. There is no satisfaction in the finding here because it’s already happened. We’re stuck in the same time loop he is. We’re stuck in the same time loop that he’s just been… We’ve experienced in this. Utter confusion. We’re piecing it together. We get it. And what the final reveal is, is you’re never going to get it.
Right. There’s always going to be a new John G. There’s always going to be a new guy you got to target for your revenge because you will never remember having executed your revenge. And it is a very linear story for being nonlinear. But of course, you have the minds of Jonathan Nolan and Christopher Nolan earlier in their career. Jonathan Nolan now is doing Westworld with, oh, what’s her name? They are the showrunners for Westworld. And Christopher Nolan, of course, everybody knows Christopher Nolan. The famous writer-director of these days. And he’s very innovative. It’s very different than some of the other examples that we might have. Even Citizen Kane. Citizen Kane probably is a more linear concept than some of the other ones that…
More linear concept than some of the other ones that I have as examples. But Memento, I remember watching it first and I felt so dissatisfied at the end. I got the puzzle. Yeah, I did. I still did. Second time around. I understood the puzzle. I understood where it went. And I’m like, so this guy’s just stuck here. It sort of gave me… It gave me the same feeling that we talked about before. No country for old men. I’m like… Yeah, it’s frustrating. Is it the perfect ending for this story? Oh, hell yeah. Was I satisfied? No. But here’s the big question. Was the filmmaker trying to…
Right. Or were they trying to disrupt me? And the answer is no, they want to disrupt your experience. They just want to. They don’t care if you’re satisfied. Yeah, because it’s more important that, and this is sort of what I talk about when you’re saying you balance the entertainment versus artistic. The artistic thing that they want to do there is affect you emotionally. If you feel at the end of No Country for Old Men dissatisfied because the good guy doesn’t win. The good guy doesn’t get the bad guy. Well, that’s what he’s dissatisfied about. From the side of law enforcement is you don’t, the bad guys keep coming and the good guys keep getting born.
He just feels like this loop and it’s, it sort of feels futile. Like I say, the Coen brothers have gotten nihilistic in their old age. They’re like, eh, life is life. Yeah. I want to see him do a comedy like Raising Arizona, one of my faves of theirs. It’s the same thing with Memento. You’ve got this. It’s a dissatisfying ending, but it is appropriate for that story. It’s an appropriate resolution.
Devin: The brilliance of Memento is, and I haven’t seen it for probably well over five years, maybe probably even more than that. But is the, I remember how frustrated I was with him watching the film. And of course that was deliberate, but I remember feeling that was one of those where I’m relating to him. I’m like, wow, is that frustrating? It’s so frustrating to try. And it’s almost like. One of those nights you wake up, you’re drunk the night before and you’re kind of piecing, you’re trying to piece your night together with like, all right, well, who’s this number? A number. Have you had many nights like that, Devin?
That’s every day. I know. And then you’re checking text messages. So, I mean, I remember that was one, but it was also, when we’re talking about disorientation, well, the character’s disoriented, and so are we, which is somewhat different than another typical non-linear story, is sometimes the character isn’t disoriented. It’s the telling. It’s the disorientation is for the audience.
Adam: Right. Well, and that’s sort of what I was getting into Memento and with Citizen Kane first, is the other ones are different animals, because it’s the storyteller disorienting you. And what’s beautiful about these, how they maintain a sort of linear motion, is because they’re basing the non-sequential stuff on the character’s perspective, you now have this, you can still tell the story linearly, structurally, but use this technique to sort of bounce around. Mm-hmm. Memento’s unique. Memento’s unique, too, because I wish I would have brought this one up for setup and payoff, because it’s a very unique case of setups and payoffs. I’ll give you two really quick examples.
At one point in time, he goes to the bar where Natalie works, which is Carrie-Anne Moss. She just shows up at his table, gives him a free beer, and says, it’s on the house. And he drinks it. And an old man at the end of the bar laughs hysterically. And then when we get to the next scene, which is obviously the scene before that scene, at the end of that scene, she goes, you really can’t remember anything? And he’s like, no, I don’t. I can’t. She pours a beer, has the old man spit in it, she spits in it, and then she has him spit in it, Lenny, the lead character.
And then he walks over to the table, and she walks up, gives him the beer, and he drinks it. And the old man laughs. We don’t understand why the old man’s laughing at him in the previous scene until we get to this scene, where we see the previous event, and we go, oh, he’s laughing because he spit in it. So the setup payoffs sort of get flipped. They get reversed.
Devin: Mm-hmm. That is interesting, yeah.
Adam: And the other one that was probably my favorite moment in the whole movie. It’s when it flashes back to a moment before the previous one. We’re in the scene that is prior. And he’s running through, like, a trailer park. And he goes, what am I doing? Why am I here? And he’s just running. He’s in the midst of running. And he looks over, and he sees a guy running pace with him on the other side of some trailers. And he’s like, oh, I’m chasing this guy. I’m chasing him. And he turns towards him to go after him. And then the guy pulls up a gun and shoots at him.
And he goes, oh, no, he’s chasing me. Okay. That to me is like, if I could boil down the joy of that story, that’s it. You don’t know what’s going to happen next. Even he’s like, oh, I’m chasing this guy. And then all of a sudden you realize you’re in a chase scene and they’ve just flipped you on your head expectation-wise with that gunshot and going, oh no, he’s chasing me. The way they use classic tools that we’ve been talking about here at the end of first season, set ups, payoffs, mystery, suspense, dramatic irony, all those things. They use them so much to their advantage, suspense, a lot in this movie to get you where you’re going.
The other strange thing about this movie is, it’s all in color, except for these sort of like, interludes, where he’s on the the telephone, and it’s all in black and white with someone. He’s always talking to someone on the phone. [unclear] And he’s explaining a case of some old case he used to work on as an insurance claims adjuster. But it’s relevant to thematically what’s going on with him.
It’s a guy who lost his memory. And so he’s sort of reflecting on this guy and how he didn’t believe him, how it was so hard to believe this guy lost his mind, lost his memory. And at the end, we realize, or Teddy tells us at the beginning, yeah, you keep telling us about Sammy and Sammy. He goes, there is no Sammy. Your wife had diabetes. You killed her with insulin. And so, but we don’t get clarity. Teddy’s trying to explain something to him. He’s not believing him. And so at the end of this movie, like I say, I felt dissatisfied because nothing’s cleared up. If anything, it’s more complicated.
Nothing’s really cleared up here. We just know that Teddy’s not John G. That’s all we know. And the point with those interludes is as the story gets on, the black and white interludes, when the story gets to the, quote, beginning, as it nears its end, everything starts to be told in black and white. And so, chronologically, non-sequentially, it’s dovetailing two separate storylines together. We’re being told the story backwards in color with these interludes of black and white. And then we get to the climax, and that’s about when they change the colorscape. And the phone call stuff meets up with the color stuff being told backwards. Yeah.
And we get the final moment where Teddy reveals to Lenny all that’s going on. Yeah. That’s a brilliantly executed story. It’s wonderful. And I know it’s meant to be dissatisfying. That doesn’t keep me from being dissatisfied.
Devin: And sometimes the satisfaction is in knowing that you still understand the story makes sense, but it may not be satisfying. I think the most dissatisfying thing for me when watching a film is at some point they didn’t fill a hole in the story or something becomes so disjointed that even if I don’t like the ending or I’m not satisfied with the ending, it just doesn’t make sense. Like there’s a, there’s a gap somewhere. I saw it a lot when I was programming the film festival. Some of the, you could tell that they may have not spent a ton, like as much time as probably needed to make sure that the threat or the story made complete sense. And it’s like, well, yeah. And which is always the hard thing, especially when you’re a writer, director.
And certainly when it comes to independent film, where you guys are, you’re writing a film and then you’re going to go out and shoot it with whatever you have. There’s things in your head that you, that makes sense, that may not necessarily make sense on paper nor through execution. And then those are things that usually are caught when, you know, when you’re in Hollywood and some of the, you know, even the independent, some of the, mini major studios. Sometimes not though, too. I’m not saying Hollywood’s perfect, but a lot of times that was my main focus. My main frustration, well, not my main frustration. I think my main frustration with programming the film festival was the lack of attention to audio when making films, but we won’t get to go down that rabbit hole.
Adam: I just had a conversation about this with somebody the other day. Yeah.
Devin: So I think that’s where there’s different dissatisfactions, I think, for me. And one is, I think what you’re talking about, but that was, that was intended. And the other is something just missed the mark and there’s a bit of information missing.
Adam: And that’s the key. You gotta, yeah, there’s a difference between not great filmmaking and nonlinear. Storytelling. Right. Nonlinear storytelling, they’re not dropping the ball. They’re just making deliberate choices and they may not be to you. And then when I am saying dissatisfied with Memento, it’s sort of like the guy who reviewed Citizen Kane. The story’s still great. I just didn’t like what I, what I was experiencing. And so if I were of that mindset, I would have just shut it off and gone, that movie sucked. What didn’t suck. Right. It had me engaged the whole time. It was a great movie.
Devin: You know, it’s similar. Yeah. It’s similar to your other, your, your example with, what’s the band you like? Alt, Alt J. Yeah. Where you’re, and, and this is, I, I find myself dissatisfied a lot with music, especially when it comes to scores, movie scores, when it’s, it’s, it’s orchestral. I’m wishing that they would drop. There would be like a minor fall or there would be, there would be a drop and then they go up again. And so the emotion completely changes. Yeah. And I just want it to be more, more somber. Like, like if I’m thinking about, oh, I want to use this for like a sizzle reel. I want to use this for like a, a proof of concept.
Yeah. And I want it. So the feeling, the emotion I want for that next chord or that next set of chords, I want them to fall and then instead they rise. And so it completely changes the emotion of it. That pisses me off for some reason.
Adam: But that is the key, the expectation and the result. In non-linear, it’s easy to do that. It’s easy to set up an expectation that’s not met and you flip the audience on their head. But if you don’t do it with care and deftness and skill, they’re going to tune out immediately. Yeah. It’s going to be a Bang! You’re Dead scenario where some dumbass cut up a brilliant film and said, this is non-sequential storytelling. No, it’s not. Oh my God. It’s an experiment that caters to your data. Exactly. Junk science. Yeah. But when it comes to the music, and in storytelling in general, you have this expectation of where it’s going to go. And you want that to be subverted or twisted or turned so that it’s like a roller coaster.
When the turn happens, it’s like, whoa. You get shifted to this side and you want some thrill to it, but it has to be legitimate. It has to feel right. And it’s okay that the way the song, you want the song to go, it doesn’t go that way. Yeah. As long as it still is an experience and the thrill of it. Memento. Am I happy with the ending? No, but neither is he. They’re really trying to give you a character-driven perspective story with this guy’s short-term memory loss. They’ve done a genius job of it. You have to sort of measure that out for yourself is what is the artist trying to do with you?
Right. And even if you’re dissatisfied, did you still have an experience that dealt with expectation and meeting it or not meeting it or subverting it? If you know what’s going to happen in a story, in a song, in anything, you will tune out just as much as you will tune out to something that is disorienting to you. If it’s boring, you’re going to turn it off. Keep that in mind for those of you who like to stick to a narrative. If it’s a narrative mindset, that structure that Hollywood has built movies on, like I said, this is second season, coming right up. Act one, act two, act three, we’re looking at the basics and traditional foundations. And we’ll do a little bit of what we do, blow it out of the water like we do in this season, but we’re really going to be examining it and not going too far into philosophical land.
That’s how a traditional story structure can be built, act one, act two, act three, but your audience is smarter. They’ve seen that story so many times, and this is not something new. Act two, that we’ve been saying on this podcast, they’ve seen it so many times, you have got to reinvent the wheel now, folks. Right. Hey, Jeep did it with their X-tail lights. Aren’t they fancy? They rebranded.
Devin: Oh, Jeep. Yeah. Jeep. You know, I’m not a big fan of that X-tail light, but.
Adam: But it sold a lot of vehicles. That little chain sold a lot of vehicles.
Devin: That’s the key. Citizen Kane did it. It’s disruption. It’s disorienting. It’s. Breaking the mold. It’s changing expectation. It’s not changing expectation. It’s disrupting expectation. Yeah. And I think that’s where you can either hit the target or you can miss the mark sometimes with that, but it’s, which that comes down to the storyteller. But it’s brave. Right. And that actually goes into one of my examples. Go for it. This is an interesting example, though. It’s not even a movie. It’s an experience I had.
Adam: Okay. This is already trippy, folks. Anything that Devin has experienced.
Devin: And the reason I used it is because it’s, it plays on this, that disruption and that, that disruption. It’s disorientation. And then it kind of plays with actually what I also learned. Okay. In college, I took a law enforcement class. The entire semester, the classes were structured the same way. There was this, this chronology to them. We would go over an assignment. There would be a lecture. He would answer questions. He would give a new assignment and we would leave. Then one day at the end of the semester, one of the classes at the, at the end of the semester, we’re sitting there. I think we were in the middle. He was in the middle of his lecture. And then a man ran into the classroom from the back door. He shot the professor. Then he quickly ran out. And it was so disruptive, obviously, and disorienting, disorienting, and out of the ordinary that it took all of us a moment to attempt to process what just happened. And so we just were looking around. And then the professor to, obviously, to our relief, he stood up and he told all of us now, he’s like, describe what just happened to what just happened in detail. And he asked us, he said, was it a male or female? What were they wearing? How many shirts?
How many shots did they fire? Where on my body did he shoot? What kind of gun was it? Et cetera. You know, he asked all these questions and we had to answer all of them. And alarmingly, all of our answers ranged drastically. Wow. Every, I mean, from male or female, we all had completely, how many shots were fired, where he got shot, all were completely different. And so because of this event was so. Out of the order from what we were expecting, it disrupted this chronology of our class that we understood, that we were expecting. I was expecting the same thing to happen over and over again. It disoriented us, and our minds quickly started processing and trying to make sense of things, trying to get back to order, trying to recalibrate and get us back to, you know, our brains just want to make sense of things.
Yeah. And so, obviously, with our differing answers, each of us filled in the gaps of what we didn’t know, with what we think should be the facts based on our past experiences, or based on what we’ve already had filed in our brains. And so, what our eyes couldn’t see, our brain was filling in for us. And so, you know, the brain, and then that’s what we were talking about. We were talking about how the brain creates these complex…
Adam: It’s a balance between memory and imagination.
Devin: Yeah.
Adam: If you don’t know, you fill in the gaps with fiction putty.
Devin: Right. Exactly. Totally. And so, it’s like, that’s what we were talking about. We were talking about how our brain creates these, like we were saying before, these complex jigsaw puzzles using bits of fact. And then, in this example, we were able to gather bits of fact through our eyes and ears. And we could access a bit of what we saw and a bit of what we heard. And then, our brain filled in the missing pieces of the puzzle with other bits of this past data that we had accessed. And so, our senses were working with our brain to minimize that surprise. So, when we were surprised, our brain instantly tried to recalibrate and solve where the confusion is coming from. And that’s why, you know, bringing it back to watching a movie or watching something where that feeling of disorientation or this disruptive experience from what we are expecting or the chronology of something, that’s why we feel, we’ll feel satisfied or what we’re talking about is satisfied or dissatisfied.
And we figure it out or it falls into place for us at the end of the story. And so, with the nonlinear stories, like my professor getting shot, these nonlinear stories provide these moments of surprise and disorder. And that our brain instantly tries to recalibrate. And we try to figure out what’s going on, which is the intent of the storyteller is to disrupt that, which is engaging, which also brings us back to that study is the disruption wasn’t, just didn’t make any sense. Right.
And that ends up being not, that’s not storytelling. That’s, like you said, that’s a study structured in a way that they want to somehow have the right outcome for whatever their study was. Somehow have the right outcome for it, for whatever their study was.
[Sponsor message]
Devin: The only reason I was, I made that example was the, from an audience standpoint, that feeling, the feeling of, of, and some people, some people like it, some people don’t, from a storytelling standpoint.
Adam: Let me say this about that versus the storytelling aspect, paralleling it in this way. Your storyteller is your professor. Right. So, it’s particularly disrupting if someone comes in and kills your storyteller. Right. That’s the person who’s telling you everything, leading the, so it’s a total difference. Right. It’s a different type of disruption. Imagine watching a movie and all of a sudden, it’s sort of like, you know, the movies where you, like The Crow, where Brandon Lee died in the middle of it. And so, you watch the movie and you’re like, okay, I know they’re, they finished this movie without him, so how? You wouldn’t do that in a story.
Right. The benefit of a story versus personal experience you had is. There is this thing, there’s a contract that you make when you buy a ticket, when you sit down with a book, that you’re going to get a great story well told.
You’re trusting your storyteller to have it all resolve and make sense by the end. That’s their job. We know, even though it gets disrupted, if we’re an intelligent audience member, that a good storyteller is going to make it all make sense to us by the end. Whether we’re dissatisfied or satisfied, the story is going to be a contained, well-developed piece. It’s going to be the puzzle that they created that we can solve. In your experience, there is no trust. The trust you have is, this guy’s leading the class. Well, that guy dies suddenly in a very scary, traumatic experience. All of a sudden, your storyteller is gone in your scenario.
And I realize it’s a personal experience, but to look at those different situations and go, here’s a storyteller and here’s that situation. The disruption, you don’t mind as much when you’re being told a story because there is this trust. Mm-hmm. In the storyteller themselves that they’re going to weave a tale worth paying attention to. Right. It’s a different bargain, but in a lot of these cases, like I say, more amateur films that are avant-garde don’t have that payoff, don’t have that resolution. Like you’re saying, the ones you were more frustrated with in programming. But filmmakers who are adept in their skills, David Lynch and Christopher Nolan and Orson Welles and my upcoming dude here, I’m going to talk about Charlie Kaufman.
These folks, they’re craftsmen.
Devin: Right.
Adam: They’ve worked so hard to create artistic endeavors that even though they may be non-sequential or non-linear, are innovative. They may be critically panned, but those filmmakers are still very courageous filmmakers intellectually, artistically, emotionally, psychologically. They’re exploring landscapes in ways that the human mind actually works in, but in a way that it’s sort of the way I feel about it. If you want to get a serious point. To cross in a story, it’s the forces of levity and gravity. You make the audience laugh a good bit, have them relax and open up, and then they’re more willing to accept different ideas because they’re in a comfortable place.
In this situation, it’s the opposite. If you disrupt them, they’re sort of on the defensive and almost like, and this David Lynch uses to a T, a scared animal in the seat. Where do I go next? Why is that so scary? That guy’s face and that creepy music and that tone. Those sound effects that sound like a beast. He just uses the techniques of film, capture, lighting, sound effects, music, to create a psychological, emotional landscape that moves you. And I guarantee it’s moved into a nightmarish state in a lot of ways. But he affects you in that way, just by his craft, not necessarily by the linear nature of the story.
I’m up and down with Lynch, but I absolutely admire and love him. I truly do. Even if some of his things, I’m like, ah, it’s a little too strange for my, like, I didn’t dig Mulholland Drive too much. It wasn’t my thing. And I haven’t seen Eraserhead. It took him five years to make that movie because he didn’t have any money and he was working a job at a factory. But that’s one of the reasons I love him. An independent filmmaker who believed in his vision enough to not give up on it. And to this day, his vision is its own brand. Some of them I like.
Devin: You touched on an important element of the film. Yeah. I love nonlinear storytelling with the relationship to the audience. And I think that it’s- Please tell me because I don’t know what it is. Well, because it’s trust. And so- Yes. It’s open-mindedness. So you look at that, that critic with Citizen Kane was, the minute that disorientation happened for him or that disruption of order, he didn’t trust Orson Welles to have it, to bring him back. Or for this, he didn’t trust it. He didn’t say, he didn’t have the willingness to- He didn’t have the willingness to say, I’m just going to see where this goes.
I’m going to keep my mind open. He instantly- And of course, we weren’t sitting next to him. We don’t know exactly what he was thinking. Oh, we know, Devin. We know. I’m guessing that just shut him down. He was just shut off. It was an unwillingness. I think the intelligence of the audiences today lend for storytellers to experiment with nonlinear storytelling. For sure. And not feel that they have to hold their hand and try to connect dots too much or have everything so close together where, you know, so I think that’s the, where as stories evolved, I think audiences’ expectations have evolved, but also their willingness to trust what’s on screen is going to make sense.
They’re going to be satisfied with the story, maybe not necessarily the ending, but- But that it’s it was meant to be it was put put on there with the intent of the storytellers.
Adam: You were talking about your personal experience in that college class, making sense of it and figuring it out and clues and facts and all that. There’s actually a speech in Memento that he gives to Teddy, Lenny, the main character gives to Teddy, where he says, he’s making fun of him because his short-term memory sucks. And he goes, memory is not important. The facts are important. And that’s which is what he tattoos on his body are the facts he’s discovered so that he doesn’t forget them. And he says, that’s what matters. And like you’re saying, if you can, and he actually gives almost the exact same speech that you were saying about that, the aftermath with the class. He’s like, people can make things up. If they don’t remember something, they fill in the blanks. If they don’t do this, they do this.
Now, in the course of this film, that’s the setup for the flip on your head payoff. Because one of his main facts is, he has the killer’s license plate. And he’s about to find out the fact. And one of the first things you find out in the movie is, the guy who owns that license plate is Teddy. Teddy’s his guy. When you get to the end of the movie, the beginning of the story, you find out that he’s so angry at Teddy, he knows he’s going to forget why he’s writing down Teddy’s license plate as the target. He’s so angry he wants to kick the crap out of Teddy and revenge on Teddy right now.
And so the fact that he has tattooed on his leg is him making it up. And so all this speech at the midpoint when he’s talking about facts and how he has to rely on them and that’s what’s important and memory is faulty. He created a fact out of a faulty memory at the beginning slash end of our story. And that story is based on a short story by Jonathan Nolan, Christopher Nolan’s brother, which I didn’t know the first time I watched it because neither of them were as crazy famous as they are these days. But he talks about that.
Devin: That’s the fun part about telling these stories. It’s not necessarily specific to nonlinear. It’s also really good mysteries. Understanding that what you’ve given the audience and what they don’t know, they’re going to fill in the blanks with their imagination. Subconsciously, they’re constantly going to figure that out. And then as the story continues, you give them. The more that imagination that’s filling in the blanks, it’s going to fill it in a different blank and a different blank and a different blank. So it’s like the more you’re giving the even though the audience may not consciously know that they’re doing this, they’re trying to figure stuff out. They’re trying to recalibrate.
They’re trying to to bring it back to order, make make everything back, you know, put it back in order.
Adam: Humanity and curiosity were all detectives.
Devin: When you’re writing, just understand that subconsciously your audience is trying to figure things out. And you can just keep giving them pieces of information and and that can change that. It changes the direction they go and the changes what what file and cabinet in their imagination and in their memory they go into to try to fill in the blanks.
Adam: The other thing is that now we’re getting deep. We should be. This is the topic that we we should be getting deep on because it’s it requires a little more exploration. It’s nonlinear. It doesn’t like in your scenario or in storytelling. You want to figure it out. You want to make sense. Of what happens. You sort of cling to your clues and look for your facts. Nonlinear storytelling has a tendency to as Devin said disrupt. It confuses people and out of confusion can come clarity. But if you keep them in confusion too long, you lose them. You’ve lost them. And here’s how I would technically say to approach this.
So it doesn’t happen. This goes back to setups and payoffs for me. They want to make sense. So the question you pose you want to answer or they want to answer have answered or answer themselves as Devin saying fill in the blank. So. Part of it. You don’t want it to make sense. You’re going to withhold information for setups and payoffs. You’re going to withhold secrets in ways that like I’ve said in previous commentaries. The progression of your story is the character navigating through the present or whatever that story is and the exposition where they’ve come from who they’ve been that being faced dealt with negotiated with in the present to me.
That’s the climax exposition meets present story. And so as long as you. If you have something not make sense, your aim is to have it make sense instead of going at least they’re interested, but you leave them in confusion. It’s symbolism can do this too. I’ve had a lot of friends who write scripts and the symbolism is so cryptic and not understood that it’s confusing. And it’s like, look, I know you don’t want to be too obvious and I know you don’t want to be too subtle, but you got to find that balance that fulcrum bar in the middle where it’s just perfect. And. And the audience goes, oh, even your smartest ones, even your slower audience members, you want those things to work.
But finding that balance, that’s what’s important between not making sense and eventually making sense and not making sense leading into this clouded darkness of confusion for the rest of the movie. So now you’re lost. You’ve lost them.
Devin: And you don’t want to do that.
Adam: No, I did have one current example, but I have to. I do have to give a spoiler for it because I don’t plan on spoiling it, but I just want people to. To note it. The Netflix series The OA. It’s got some mystical elements. I don’t want to go into it if you haven’t seen it because I like it too much for to spoil it. I would say it’s sort of mainly a flashback story. It’s told from this young woman’s point of view about her experiences. She’s disappeared for many years and she comes back. And she used to be blind, but she’s not anymore. And no one knows what happened.
She’s not talking to her parents and she ends up meeting a bunch of kids from school and a teacher, some random folks, and in sort of like a secret club. It’s not really done as a secret club, but it ends up being like this small group of people that regularly meet and she tells them all what happened to her. And she tells them all what happened to her because she needs their help. And so you don’t know what happened to her or why she needs their help. But you slowly get this story. And we have to question the whole time, is she telling us the truth? Much like Holden Caulfield.
Is she in a psychological space that she can, that we can rely on her word? And we think about this throughout the whole story, but I don’t want to spoil what happens. But she gets in to a crazy situation and it is such a thrilling watch. If you loved Stranger Things or the sort of slightly off-kilter, otherworldly kind of things, you’re gonna love this story, folks. I won’t say too much about it because it really is more probably a flashback story, but it’s one of the more interesting recent tales that I’ve been told. I have two examples. I’m not really gonna spend time on them. But as I said, Charlie Kaufman, it’s one of my favorite screenwriters, who did Being John Malkovich, Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind, Adaptation. All of his movies are are sort of, they’re fairly linear, but he does go non-sequential because he explores a psychological landscape.
We’re in Jim Carrey’s mind in Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind, so we get the whole story in fragments, very Citizen Kane-like. But it’s all because he goes into a memory, he wants to erase an ex-girlfriend from his mind so he can feel happiness again. Who doesn’t? Been there. That’s called a flashback. Adaptation is the other one, Charlie Kaufman. Does. And it’s not necessarily, like, chronologically scattered like some of these other pieces we’re talking about. He explores a psychological landscape. I’ll give you the logline for this one. A lovelorn screenwriter becomes desperate as he tries and fails to adapt The Orchid Thief by Susan Orlean for the screen.
I think that’s how you say your last name. Charlie Kaufman, in his own fear and paranoia in trying to adapt this novel that he could not freaking adapt, turned the story into a screenwriter who can’t adapt the story, falling in love with the author and her story. And so, there’s Nicolas Cage playing the Charlie Kaufman, sort of pseudo-autobiographical, more fictionalized, playing that Charlie Kaufman character and imagining this other scenario of what happens in The Orchid Thief, the actual adaptation of the work. And ultimately, in an interesting way of portraying it, he’s able to change the world. Plot subplot and all that jazz we’ve been talking about this first season, he ends up in the world of the author and the orchid thief and all that stuff going on. So strangely enough, it’s very much like a Kurt Vonnegut Breakfast of Champions sort of scenario. So I think this is why I love Charlie Kaufman so much. He’s so experimental, but the adapter of the story somehow ends up in the story he’s adapting. It’s genius. Can you imagine being Charlie Kaufman and going, this is what I did instead? Yeah. It’s kind of like broken window a little bit. He took a chance and just going, this is how hard it is for me to adapt this work. I’m going to write a story about my fears and ineptness and my nervousness about love and my sort of lone wolf distancing of it. It’s so bizarre, but you have to admire the artist who is brave enough to go, this isn’t working. I’m still going to write something that does and just throws that stuff off and blazes a new path.
It’s sort of a wild story. And I like Nicholas. I’m not always a huge Nicolas Cage fan, but I liked him in this because he also plays two. Another thing that Charlie Kaufman does, very Lynchian, is Nicolas Cage plays two characters, twin brothers. And one is the nervous screenwriter and the other one is like a little more loud mouthed and I’ll write that movie. I can sell to Hollywood. Watch me go. And by the end of it, that character is dead. The bravado Mr. Tough Guy version of Charlie Kaufman. Charlie Kaufman split in two as twins dies. So, he’s wrestling with his own psychological landscape. It’s very intellectual. A lot of the non-sequential stuff ends up being so.
I hate to classify it as intellectual, whereas I’d much rather classify it as exploring psychology, the depths of the human mind, which is Lost Highway for David Lynch, you know, or Blue Velvet or any of these strange films where it’s sort of like you’re exploring the darkness of the human mind and the brightness of it. The contrast, if you will, between those two camps he sets up. But I just wanted to mention that, too. A lot of non-sequential, non-linear stuff, like Charlie Kaufman or Lynch’s stuff, it is exploring psychological landscape. But you can do it linearly, like we said earlier, like David Fincher does with Fight Club.
He uses a different structure that makes it feel very, very linear and all makes sense and tied up into a neat bow because he’s Fincher. The non-linear stuff, like I say, is you are dipping more into an abstract, artistic point of view, but don’t let that deter you in terms of, I know, when you’re thinking of selling stuff, writing stuff, creating stuff, entertainment is what is the big thing. But there is a new revolution in storytelling happening right now. Not just in storytelling. Not just in distribution on a global market on online platforms, but in the way we want our stories told. Now, StoryOsophers, is the time to be brave. Play with these concepts that might seem a little daunting to you. We need newer, fresher stories. And I think, as Devin and I have talked about, just in the telling in general, the non-linear, that’s where we’re headed.
As we move now into season two of StoryOsophy, we’re going to be talking about structure and approaching it non-linearly. Okay. One of the jokes I made with one of my friends about Lynch’s storytelling is, it looks like he wrote a script and then just jerked a bunch of scenes out so that this scene cut to this scene doesn’t make any damn sense to me, and then took that scene he pulled out and put it in the beginning, or the end, or wherever the hell he felt like throwing it. So it’s almost like he created a linear progression and then pulled it out and redid it. And he’s not the only one. You’ve got folks like William S. Burroughs wrote novels and then would just tear pages out and reassemble the pages.
Like he’d written a linear thing and then he just moves stuff around. Yank this page out, put it here. What does it make any sense? It makes no sense. But it is someone who’s trying something different. And lo and behold, William S. Burroughs, in his nonsensical, heroin-induced state, created something he’s known for. I know we’ve talked about different bits of drug usage on this podcast, just as the cocaine-fueled king and the heroin-fueled Burroughs. But let me just say, we’re not… We’re not advocating it. And the weed pizza. We’re not advocating it. Officially.
Devin: Hey, whatever helps to access the recesses of the imagination.
Adam: Whatever gives us better stories, junkies.
Devin: Just get me something that’s good. Get me something I can sell.
Adam: I want something that people know. I don’t want this innovative crap. I need to pitch it in a word. I need to pitch it without saying anything. That’s an agent. That’s an agent. That’s how you know if you’ve got a crappy agent or not. Every time they finish a sentence, they go, ha-cha-cha-cha.
Devin: I mean, that would be a red flag for anybody, not even just an agent. I don’t know if I’d keep their company, no matter what their profession was.
Adam: Well, StoryOsophers, this concludes our season one. I know we’ve been talking about it for a while, promising you we’re going to get to structure. But now we are. You’ve got the basics. You’ve got the basic elements of story you can stew on. You’ve got tools. You’ve got tools that you can pull out of your toolbox to use to amplify or elevate your stories to different levels. And we’re about ready to delve into the different aspects of structure.
Devin: And hopefully, we’ve earned your trust and willingness to continue on this journey with us, because it’s been fun. Ooh, that was slick. That’s how I bring it all together, Jonesy. Man, I just rambled and you were like, one line of slick. Concise.
See you on the other side.
Adam: I didn’t know how to end it. Please subscribe and rate us on iTunes. And for additional story-related resources, video, and archived content, visit our website at StoryOsophy.com. I felt it all the way through.