Show notes
Nonlinear stories skip around in time, moving sequences out of order so the narrative has something different to say. Done well, they engage the audience like a puzzle; done badly, they lose them. In the first of two episodes, Adam and Devin explore the artists who have taken this risk, from Orson Welles to David Lynch, and where storytelling could go next.
In this episode
- Admire the risk-takers. Nonlinear work won’t be for everyone. David Lynch treats film like a painting with a runtime, a psychological landscape more than a plot, and became his own brand by never trying to do Hollywood.
- Order from disorder. Disrupt the expected order and an audience’s senses kick in; they try to make sense of what they’re seeing. But give enough clues to keep them oriented, or you’ll lose them.
- Citizen Kane. One of the first films told out of order: fragments of Kane’s life, connected not by chronology but by memory, the way our minds actually work. A critic at the time complained that Welles left the audience to assemble the pieces, which is exactly the point.
- Slaughterhouse-Five. Kurt Vonnegut’s hero bounces between timelines, from war in Germany to an alien planet.
- Different sells. Napoleon Dynamite was a hit because it was unlike anything else that year. With fewer gatekeepers and binge-able seasons, there’s room to experiment.
- Imagination. Clear your mind and let ideas come; inspiration is everywhere. Forcing yourself to work when you’re not inspired is being a “busy idiot.” David Lynch’s Catching the Big Fish is about meditation and creativity.
- Rhythm instead of a line. Like the band Alt-J, whose songs go somewhere unexpected, a nonlinear story without a single throughline needs a rhythm. Devin pictures a fork in the road with six paths that all come back together at the end.
- A study that misses the point. Devin takes apart a study that scrambled Hitchcock’s Bang! You’re Dead and concluded that people prefer linear stories. Chopping up a well-built film doesn’t make it nonlinear; it’s like smashing a Rolls-Royce and asking people what car it was.
Examples discussed
- Citizen Kane, David Lynch’s Lost Highway and Twin Peaks, Slaughterhouse-Five, Napoleon Dynamite, Fight Club and Terry Gilliam’s 12 Monkeys.
- Also: Lucy, Westworld, Black Mirror and the avant-garde filmmakers Stan Brakhage and Maya Deren.
Next week: Nonlinear Storytelling, Part 2, a detailed look at Memento.
Read the full transcript
Transcribed automatically, so expect the odd misheard word. Sponsor messages are left out.
Adam: Next on StoryOsophy. Hello, welcome to StoryOsophy. This is Adam Jones. And Devin Halden. This week, we’re talking about non-linear and non-sequential storytelling, meaning stories that are told not in a progressively linear fashion so that you understand it. It might skip around a bit. It might move different sequences out of order so that the narration has a different, something different to say, a different vantage point. But this is going to be, we’re going to examine some artists who have explored this territory and we are going to explore beyond that in regards to where we can see it going and also commenting on where we’re headed next in season two.
With structuring, which we tend to do in a non-linear fashion anyway. As we round out season one here, this conversation is really kind of important for season two. Before we kick into it, Devin, did you have anything you wanted to say?
Devin: I think there is some confusion. Already? Between non-linear storytelling and our previous episodes of Flashback Flashforwards.
Adam: Oh yeah, differentiate.
Devin: That’s a good idea. Hopefully, with this, this discussion that we’re about to have, maybe the last three episodes or last episode in this episode, there’s hopefully there’s going to be a little bit more clarity. And then there’s people that just completely don’t understand it altogether, but we’ll get to that.
Adam: Well, and we’ll do, I mean, we should start out with some definitions, although I’m anxious to get more to examples this week. Because I think the examples speak for themselves. I kept thinking about sort of where this comes from in preparation for this. This week, the word avant-garde kept popping in my head because I went. Where I went to school, Bard College, the film department is very avant-garde. It’s not UCLA. It’s not those places that are geared towards more of the narrative-driven storytelling. It, you know, they went really avant-garde. Stan Brakhage, Maya Deren, they taught the films of the people who inspired David Lynch or any of these folks we’re going to talk about this week.
The, the groundbreaking films that you probably have never seen and some of you may never see, but they’re the films that, you know, and even Scorsese, he knows all of these films because he’s a, he’s just a film connoisseur. He’s just soaks it up like a sponge. But I always had a difficult time with the concept of avant-garde because even the definitions, I looked them up just to, you know, because I like the definitions. This is the definition of avant-garde. And until I had the definition of avant-garde, I didn’t know what avant-garde was. Now, right there, I’m, I’m turned off. I love intelligent people, but anytime you call something intelligentsia, I’m like, hey, you’re already leaning towards pretension.
But an intelligentsia that develops new or experimental concepts, especially in the arts, they particularly quote the film industry. Now, an intelligentsia in and of itself is an elite group. It’s like people that, that bond together over a common interest. And what we’re talking about, these non-sequential or non-linear. As Devin said, they’re not always for everybody, but you have to admire the artists who choose to take those risks because they know that it’s going to fail with a lot of people. It’s too new. It’s too different. It’s not it. Plus the linear progression of the mind. It’s not, you know, it’s not the way we live life.
And so you’re looking at it as a piece of art much. And I’ll get into this a good bit because I think the king of it is David Lynch. But it’s because he. Approaches it more like a visual arts, artistic canvas, like a painting than he does a film. It’s patchwork, it’s pieces, it’s tones, it’s colors. The linear progression is just sort of if you were looking at a painting where your eyeball would go next to look at the entire painting. And he just does that sequentially because that’s the way moving pictures work. But he’s not a lot of his stuff. He doesn’t approach in a linear fashion.
And so he knows he’s a niche artist. He knows that only certain people, especially other artists, are really going to admire his bravery. But a broader audience that Hollywood might capture with just straight up narratives, he knows he’s going to miss them. And kudos to him for not caring and doing this anyway, because he is now Devin talks about be your own brand. David Lynch is his own brand and it’s unique and strange and weird. And I think people are afraid of being pigeonholed. And to, oh, they’re different than everybody else, but that’s what makes someone special. David Lynch is David Lynch because he didn’t try to do Hollywood.
He did David Lynch for his whole life and now he is an icon of this type of storytelling, this nonlinear, non-sequential storytelling. So I, even if I don’t like the films in their nature, because I, in certain ways I have complaints or whatever. I absolutely praise and admire the experimental aspect of it all. I love the brave people.
Devin: And the disruption of storytelling. Yes. And I think that’s the, that’s the key to going into a, in a film setting, going into a movie, not having any idea of what the movie’s about. But because there’s so many films that are chronologically told or linearly told the minute that something like what Lynch does or something disrupts what we’re seeing. Yeah. If we’re talking about something that we think is going to happen, whether it’s even that’s primarily subconsciously where we feel that the story is going, then instantly our senses are kicking in and we’re trying to make order of disorder. And I think that is the key to nonlinear storytelling.
Which is also, it’s, it’s the, the great thing. And then, then the very difficult thing from a storytelling standpoint, because you need to make sure that the clues that you’re giving are enough to keep everything jointed. Keep it, so it’s, you’re not, you’re not leaving, you’re not making it so confusing that an audience is pulled out of it, you know? So that’s the, I think that from, from non-linear storytelling, I think if I’m looking at some characteristics of non-linear storytelling that I enjoy as, as an audience, as a member of the audience, it’s that feeling of, okay, something just happened that is very unexpected. There’s, there’s disorder now to the story that I, that I was making, was, I was trying to figure it out as my, and just, just how our brain works, trying to figure out what’s going to happen and making sure that everything stays even keeled.
So the minute that we’re disrupted, we start trying to figure out what is going on. And I think that is the, one of the main characteristics of, of really well-told non-linear stories. And then that’s also where some stories that are attempting to be non-linear become a bit too confusing maybe, or they’re, they’re so disjointed or it’s so disorderly that that’s when you can lose an audience. So that’s, it’s playing with. It’s, it’s a, it’s certainly a very, not, not difficult, but it’s, it’s the development process and all the things that we’ve talked about before and understanding your characters and, and your world and the rules and the tool, like all of that becomes so much more important when you’re providing information and you’re providing, providing glimpses of things that are out of order that still need to, it still needs, the story still needs to feel like it’s a, like it’s, it’s, everything’s threaded, everything’s pieced together, even though we don’t know everything.
We’re confident that we’re following the story and, and at some point we’re going to, all of that’s going to be paid off at the end. We are going to, we want to be able to leave that theater satisfied that we understood what happened and things like that.
Adam: The key word with what you’re talking about too is orientation, the orientation of the audience from whatever you’re putting on screen, if they get too disoriented, you’ve lost them.
Devin: Yeah.
Adam: But the whole point of the structure is it is disorienting.
Devin: Mm-hmm.
Adam: One of the watching is that, but if you don’t have a balance between that and like you’re saying, just sort of losing the thread that glues everything together, or in Lynch’s case, like the overall canvas, you lose your audience. And so it’s pointless anyway. You want them to lose themselves a little bit without you losing them because they’re so used to this linear progression of life, this narrative. They tell their story just the way that most Hollywood narratives or most independent narratives. Run. And so that’s what they’re used to. But if you disrupt that, how do you keep their attention? In Lynch’s case, it’s a lot of, like I say, he treats it more like a painting.
The emotional experience you’re having to the image and the moment that’s built on sort of a weird loose narrative in a lot of cases is the thing that he wants that you find your own meaning. Like I said, if you think of David Lynch as a filmmaker, as a painter, you understand everything. David Lynch, the way he had started doing films as of late, he had a book on transcendental meditation called Catching the Big Fish. It’s a great book. It’s really fantastic because he talks about calming and focusing your mind and then the artistic and creative process simultaneously, which is great because in gathering ideas for anything you’re working on, you need to be able to keep your mind open enough to, as Devin’s saying, you want your imagination to be wide open and play in that.
You need to be open enough to. Accept the ideas coming and allow them to sort of fit their own place into the story or be able to edit the ones that don’t work. In Catching the Big Fish, by the way, if you do check out this book, you should get the audio version where he narrates it just to hear his voice. But he talks about, oh, shoot, of course I don’t remember the actor’s name. The guy who was in Warriors and Twin Peaks, he plays Ben’s brother, Jerry. I remember the character’s name. Can’t remember the actor’s name for the life of me right now. That’s kind of reverse.
Of course, of what usually happens. I know, right? Weird. But it’s David something, I can’t remember the rest of it. But I think that was the actor he talks about in the book, where one of these, you know, they’re on set, they’re working on some stuff, everybody’s got downtime, you know how people goof around. Well, he turns around and looks at David Lynch and then pushes out like a small red light bulb from his mouth and just holds the end of it with his teeth and lips, but there’s this light bulb sticking out of his mouth. David Lynch loved that sort of moment with the burst of color and all these things. It just got included in the project they were working on. At least I believe that’s the story. That’s the version I took from the book.
It’s your interpretation. That’s my interpretation. It never happened. I made it up. But in that case, he’s not as orderly about tying up his loose threads. A lot of Lynch is not even interested in that. And his more narrative stuff, Twin Peaks and things like that. But in his ones that are more like psychological landscapes, he really doesn’t care about too much of a linear progression. There is, and we’ll talk more about him later on, because we want to do some examples first.
Devin: I’m actually going to start with a quick example. And it’s not really an in-depth example. It’s more of a setup. Go for it. Citizen Kane. And that was perhaps one of the very first films to ever tell the story non-linearly. It’s true. Because of how new it was, that type of… Oh, storytelling? It’s true, I said. That’s true.
Adam: Thanks. Yes. Thanks. I got my fact checker over there. Everyone who does not know the most famous film in film history said, that’s true. That’s really what he said.
Devin: Go ahead. So, because it was a bit groundbreaking, as far as the storytelling goes, there was critics on both sides of the fence. And for those who haven’t seen it, it’s basically the stories told through a series of flashbacks at different times. During Charles Foster Kane’s life. And we, as the audience, are given incomplete glimpses of Kane’s life. And then Orson Welles is basically giving the audience his confidence that we’ll be able to connect the dots at the end of the film when all of these clues have been provided. Which, scientifically, actually mimics how memory in the brain actually works with our senses to complete complex jigsaw puzzles or attempts to make sense of disorder.
And granted, with Citizen Kane, there are some things that… Aren’t paid off completely. And if you’ve ever watched any analysis of film history, Citizen Kane will also be picked apart with some things that just… They seem like inside jokes in a way that Welles put in there. But, nonetheless, it was certainly a groundbreaking film in terms of storytelling. And also how an audience is now tapped to solve a puzzle. Rather than just sit back and watch and be entertained. It was a little bit more of a… Try to solve a… Engaging. Yeah, engaging. Exactly. And, again, like we’ve talked about before, there’s… Some people enjoy that type of a mental jigsaw…
Puzzle. The game that we’re trying to put together. Yeah, a puzzle.
Adam: I mean, that’s how I see it anyway. A story is a puzzle that the audience solves. The storyteller builds it for the audience to solve. Yeah. If it’s not on that level, to me, it’s fairly flat. We want that little bit of a challenge. To try to put things together. Even if it’s a tiny one in, like, a sitcom. Exactly. Where it’s just like, what’s gonna happen next? If that’s the only question, that’s a solid question. If you can keep your audience asking that, you’re great. That’s enough. It’s just some of these non-linear folks. The what’s gonna happen next, they just exponentially increase it. Right, exactly.
They don’t give you an opportunity.
Devin: So, one of the critics, I think he was from Argentina. I think Borges wrote a review in the… In Washington. In one of the magazines after it was released, after Citizen Kane was released. And he criticized Welles’ choice to include so many of these fragments of Kane’s life in the out-of-chronological order of the story and expressed his frustration about how Welles relied on the audience to combine those fragments into a cohesive narrative on their own. Which is like, okay, I understand. I understand when this was written, but I’m like… You treated your audience with some intellectual respect?
Adam: Yeah. Like, come on, man. This is the exact brilliance of the storytelling and the way that Welles decided to do that. That’s cutting edge. That’s the cutting edge. Some people don’t get the cutting edge when it happens.
Devin: And how many times we’ve talked about, during this podcast, the audience is intelligent, and they don’t want to, they don’t want to feel like you don’t think they can figure this out. Right. And Welles, through this, showed his confidence in the intelligence of the audience to do just that and take what they are given out of and put the pieces together and engage them, like you say, rather than just tell them a story. But it also, like we talked about before, it also shows how important the story development and the structure and the execution is in order for the audience to feel satisfied when they leave the theater because they were able to follow it.
There was that thread, there was that glue somehow that put it together. Now, again, Citizen Kane isn’t the perfect example. And it wasn’t this perfect film put together. You know, there are still some things that were a bit disjointed.
Adam: It is a pretty perfect example for this episode, to be honest. It’s a perfect example, but yeah, not a perfect film. It’s true. That’s true. It’s true. That’s true. It’s not a flashback narrative like the ones we were talking about last week where you, like, whether it’s Princess Bride, The NeverEnding Story, Catcher in the Rye, Forrest Gump.
Devin: Yeah.
Adam: You’re in a place and you go backwards. This is not that way. And it didn’t, I almost had it for an example, and I didn’t put it down. And I’m glad you took it because it’s been a while since I’ve seen it. Here’s the key to that movie and why it’s the best example. Because he flashes back through the guy’s life, but not chronologically. He flashes back through the guy’s life through the connection of memory, whatever this person is trying to piece together themselves. And it’s just how we think of memories, folks. You can be your age right now. You can be a child. You can be in your teens. You can be this age right now again, back to your whatever. You can time travel through your memories. And you can change them. When you think back, you can, if you can’t remember that thing, well, that’s suddenly a red car. Your mind is such an interesting contraption in that way.
Right. And so he didn’t go back and go, let me tell you the story of my life and narrate it to the end. He’s trying to piece together meaning in his life. As he’s dying. And so you have to piece together meaning in his life. Right. He’s such a genius filmmaker because he brought you to the level of his own puzzling. That’s how brilliant Welles is. Like you’re saying, this reviewer, he didn’t get it, you know, and you can’t blame him. There’s a certain level of things, like most audiences, you’re used to this. You’re right. What do audiences want next? Well, you can’t tell because you got to give it to them before they get it.
Right. They’re not the story. They’re not the storytellers. You are. Once it happens, they may not even understand the level of it until they’re enjoying it and into it. And it’s challenged them on some other level. Most of the ones we talk about in this episode are people who challenge so much that sometimes it sort of alienates the status quo. And I hate to say that because I don’t think that’s the case anymore. Lynch is like part of the film vocabulary these days.
Devin: Right.
Adam: He’s been such a groundbreaker that now it’s a counterculture. It’s now part of the main culture. And that’s great. I love that. These filmmakers are more like renegades.
Devin: This critic of Citizen Kane, you’re right. It’s like, especially because of Citizen Kane was one of the very first films to kind of take this type of nonlinear storytelling and put it on a screen. Oh, yeah. But he went into the theater and the minute that the story became disorienting, that probably wasn’t enough for him to all of a sudden become very- He got guarded. Very critical, too, of what’s going on. I don’t, this doesn’t make any sense. And then- It does. Instantly, he’s already taken out of it. Yeah.
Adam: When we don’t understand something, we get defensive. That’s how most people operate. Right. The wise people go, I have something to learn here. The people who are a little bit scared to grow or stuck in their own patterns, they don’t ask those questions. They don’t look, they don’t open their mind up more to go, what can I find out?
Devin: Yeah, they’re not trusting.
Adam: Yeah. But like we said last episode or a few episodes ago, it’s- And we’ve touched upon this. Yeah. In general, talking about the forces of antagonism is there’s an idea of what we do not know becomes a monster. What we don’t know becomes the devil. What we don’t know becomes bad because we don’t understand it. And so even in this very simplified version, this guy’s watching this movie and you’re, Devin, I would say you’re probably, I didn’t live this dude’s life, but 99% right. The 100%, we’re going to give you 100% right. That’s a first. This guy’s sitting in this theater and all of a sudden, he’s a film critic. He knows everything. He’s versed in film. He’s a connoisseur. And this brand new thing he watches is confusing. Well, he can’t question his own lack of knowledge or even say, well, this is an artistic endeavor beyond that, which I’ve seen before. It just becomes, he, it becomes guarded. He becomes guarded.
And it’s like I’m saying, it’s sort of off-putting. If you don’t understand, you tune out. I mean, I get it. If it’s not catching your fancy, you just, you know, turn your attention to something that is. It’s not necessarily for everybody. It’s, I would say a lot of it is very exciting to progressive, artistic, creative people, people who are looking to what’s, what can someone invent next? Right. It’s something I’d like to see more of, the non-linear, non-sequential. And you hit it. Chronology is really the key of defining these things. Like flashbacks and flash-forwards. Right. They’re from a point backwards or forwards and then back to the present point. But these, they sort of like, it’s scattered.
Devin: Mm-hmm.
Adam: They spread you throughout time. And, you know, the other example I was going to use, just a novel, I try to pull out as we both do, novels as examples, was a Vonnegut’s, a Kurt Vonnegut’s Slaughterhouse-Five. It’s a guy who is bouncing between timelines and it is not sequential at all. You start in one place, you go to the future, you come back to that place. You go to the past, you go, and you bounce between all these timelines because part of it has to do with extraterrestrials and part of it has to do with war in Germany. And so this guy sort of, as we talked about last episode, the flashbacks via PTSD or LSD, like some psychological trippy experience.
You don’t need those influences to have your mind bounce around. But this becomes trippy because you’re not sure if the future is the future. Or if he’s narrating from the present into the future, he’s just sort of being whipped about through time. And it’s a really innovative novel. It might be confusing or scary to folks in certain ways, but it’s, it’s, I don’t know, I can’t remember when it was published, but it was, it was a while ago. Enough that like with Citizen Kane to go, it probably came out when people weren’t ready for this.
Devin: People weren’t ready for Napoleon Dynamite. And so there were some people that understood that, that type of storytelling and thought it was hilarious. And then some people were like, that’s the worst film ever. And then there was other films that came after that, that had that similar type of storytelling where it’s a little drier and it’s just, it’s, it’s really, it’s, it’s funny, you know.
Adam: It’s, that movie’s funny as hell to me. The, the one thing with that I would say is, and, and I, it’s weird that you brought that up because I talk about Napoleon Dynamite in terms of innovation or audience appeal when I talk about film. Mm-hmm. Yeah. The thing that’s amazing to me about that film is, it says everything we say throughout this entire first season. There were comedies and there was all kinds of stuff coming out that year. And so this film was the number one comedy hit. What? Like, this is a no-name independent out of nowhere.
What the, what? And it’s because. Because it was different and people wanted different. That’s exactly the point. It, it, it was so stylistically specific and unique in its own brand and different than anything else that came out that year that people were like, oh, this is a. Like, ooh, what’s this? Everybody wants a different flavor. If you keep feeding them the same flavor and the same commodity, Hollywood, you, they’re gonna, it’s gonna get, all get homogenized. Nothing’s gonna, it’s all gonna seem the same. Nothing’s gonna feel different. Part of the fun of the content creation in these days is you can’t create enough content to satisfy your audience.
It’s, it, it’s now a global market and everybody’s got their own favorite thing. Even marketing wise, people find this. Their own stuff. Like, they’ll search for the stuff they want to see. Even if it’s difficult for them, they’ll find it. And to that degree, that’s exciting.
Devin: And there’s less gatekeepers. Exactly. You can aggregate online for just a fee. Back in the day, it was, if Hollywood, if it didn’t tell the same story and the same structure and the same pacing and the same amount of time limit that Hollywood wanted to put in theaters, they wouldn’t put it in theaters. If the book didn’t do the same thing in terms of a literary piece of media, like a book or a novel, then a publisher wouldn’t publish it and then it would, no one, it wouldn’t get to the masses or wouldn’t find an audience. Now, you can tell a story in any interesting way that you want to, and Netflix has been great with this longer form that we’ve talked about, longer form storytelling or chapter-based storytelling, where you can really develop characters and you can…
You can play with different things like nonlinear storytelling in very interesting and exciting and experiential ways.
Adam: But they’re still sticking to pretty linear stuff, Netflix. They’re not really pushing too far off into the abstract or avant-garde. Most of the platforms aren’t.
Devin: I’m just saying they’re opening the opportunity for a storyteller like an Orson Welles or a Lynch or somebody who wants to disrupt this linear storytelling to take it with this chapter-based stuff. Like you said, we haven’t necessarily seen it yet, but it’s a different way. So it’s not this 90-minute to 120-minute segment that you have – that before, that’s what you had to do unless it was television. Then television was like the 22-minute or whatever. But – With this new form of binging – They’re changing the rules. Well, the rules of the type of media, the length of the media. And they’re like, all right, well, if this is an eight-hour story you want to tell, then do it.
We’ll dump it all out on the same day and let people consume it how they want. And then that allows us to – and we’ve talked about it before. It allows us to really dive deep into character and backstories and really develop a world that – Yeah. In a way that probably is intended when you start – when you first develop – start developing your story. But then you have to figure out a way to shove it into 90 minutes and try to make sure you have all that information in. And it’s a specific type of story that you may have a hard time shoving all that information and the rules and the tools and the character development into a 90-minute space to make it seem like it’s just not shoved in there or forced in there.
It’s some different opportunities that – for storytellers.
Adam: Check this out.
[Sponsor message]
Devin: You and I are kind of – I like the darker horror movie type stuff. And then I’m a real big fan of Disney. So I’m on – I like to jump on. Jump from one end of the spectrum to the other.
Adam: And at the same time, I’m like – it’s not that I don’t enjoy watching dark stuff or psychologically. Like I like Fincher. I like Black Mirror. Like there are tons of stuff that I like. Breaking Bad. But if it doesn’t have a depth of character, if it’s just this fatalistic point of view as a series, I don’t want to watch it. I’m not interested. I want to see something that’s really great storytelling if I’m going to venture into that, into something that’s dark or heavy. Because – I’d prefer to see something – my bread and butter, my favorite stuff is fantastic stuff like fantasy, sci-fi, exploration.
And I love that stuff. I like that too. And I also like infusing, like we talked about in the previous episode, levity and gravity. I don’t want to see some movie where it’s like it’s all dark. It’s all depressed. I’m like, does anybody in this world have a sense of humor? Because even in my darkest moments, there’s always somebody who’s funny. Yeah. I like the balance of that. I like that stuff for the most part.
Devin: Now that you said that, I think what’s really interestingly weird is I prefer to write the fantastical and the magical. Yeah. But for some reason, I prefer to consume dark. Horror films, things that that tap into a different area of the psyche that perhaps most of us have never ventured down that path before. So I don’t know. Most of us. And maybe that’s just part of my R&D for writing my research and development. Research what you don’t know.
Adam: I bungee jump into that stuff all the time. With acting and performance, it’s sort of like it’s part of the palette. It’s part of the paints you use. My entertainment, I like to laugh. I like to be thrilled. I like suspense. But it’s got to be really good. And most of the time, it’s sort of like just regurgitated stuff. That’s why the stuff that I do quote, as far as like darker stuff that I love, like Fincher and Breaking Bad, Game of Thrones, they’re so good. Westworld, all these, there’s such brilliantly told stories. They’re so well woven. The graphic stuff, that’s not my thing. I just don’t like gore stuff. But I’ll watch that story even when it has it if it’s brilliantly told. I just won’t seek it out if it’s not great. If it’s not great storytelling, you’re not going to get me with shock and awe. Violent storytelling doesn’t do anything. Just pure action and horror. It doesn’t do anything.
Devin: Part of it is like, I love really great storytelling. But then if I see something that is like, way out of the box, like it is like, what are they doing here? And I think that’s fantastic. I’m like, wow, they’re really experimenting. They’re experimenting. It’s working.
Adam: I would agree with you on that. I get enamored with those two. The abstract or the experimental, even if it’s like, even if it’s a disjointed or non sequential story. And most people will be like, what the heck am I watching? I still want to understand how they’re structuring, why they’re structuring, why they’re structuring. They’re using those colors there. You know what? Like, I love, I love that stuff. That abstracts though.
Devin: Is it Terry Gilliam?
Adam: Ah, I love me some Gilliam.
Devin: That’s the Monty Python guy, right?
Adam: Yeah, yeah.
Devin: Like 12 monkeys and like some of those frick weird frickin movies. And you’re just like, like, where does this come from? Like, that’s the stuff that fascinates me. So I’m like, whoa, who? And a lot of it, of course, is the, you know, the writer and, and then it’s the, the combination of the written work. And the interpretation on screen. But man, some of that stuff is like,
Adam: For me, it’s the imagination quotient. If you take the time, a lot of people don’t even know what meditation is. But if you take the time to meditate for a moment, you will mind that stuff that other people go, how in the heck did they come up with that? You clear your mind from all of the references from all of the things you’ve seen from all the things you want to copycat. You just clear your mind and go, let me see if ideas come to me. And at the same time, just going through your daily routine, and events and things will happen. The person in front of you in line at the store you’re at will say something that’s so funny to you. And you’ll be like, I get that has to be a line.
And you’ll build the whole scene around this person’s personality, and way they speak and use that line as the punctuating thing for the scene. It all happens organically if you allow it. But if you’re trying too hard, it’s what Devin calls, being a busy idiot. Forcing yourself to work when you’re not inspired is not the way to do it. Inspiration comes everywhere like we talk about throughout this entire first season, collect it, write notes. And then you’ll organize it and create a linear or nonlinear experience for your audience to have it’s, you got to keep your imagination open. Don’t limit your brain on what it can think up. And you’ve now programmed it to think beyond.
But if you think, oh, there’s a lot of stuff around here and you’re too busy, think about it. So be kind to yourself. Don’t compare yourself to anybody else who is brave enough to say, oh, there’s only one way to do it, then you’ve just locked your brain off to 10% usage, and that’s it. We’re getting smarter, folks. If you haven’t seen Lucy… And I haven’t. You haven’t? No. I just watched it twice in a row this weekend.
Devin: I’ll watch it. What did you watch it on? TV, big TV.
Adam: Big TV, Devin.
Devin: Is it on Netflix? Is it on Amazon?
Adam: No, it was just on TV.
TV, big TV. You will love it. I guarantee you’ll love it. I watched it. No, it was on… I can’t remember if it was on FX or something like that. It was just on TV, and it’s interesting, too, because they segue between storylines. TV, big TV, Devin.
Devin: Like, I give a shit what device you watched it on. You’re asking for platform. Yeah, like, what, was it on Netflix? So is it free? Did you rent it? No, just TV. I can’t watch movies on TV, like, with commercials. I just can’t do it.
Adam: I can’t either. I can’t either. But every once in a while. But if it’s a good movie, I get sucked in, dude. It’s probably on Netflix. I will say this. The audience is ready. As much as the storytellers are ready to explore worlds and people in depth. Yay, Westworld.
Devin: Yeah.
Adam: Depth of character and depth of world and expansion of world and scope. The audience is ready to consume it that way. Everybody’s starting to understand, even the most resistant folks, are starting to understand that the world is now a village. It’s not some big scary place anymore. If you can Facebook friend someone in the country that is the enemy country, it’s a village. Make friends around the world. It’s a village. So, as the world, quote, gets smaller, we start to be more comprehensive thinkers about the different types of people. Diversity. Acceptance. And this is the way I feel about it. The stuff that Mr. Rogers has been telling me my whole life is starting to happen.
Right. Everybody’s your neighbor. Just chill out, everybody. Don’t have to go crazy. Everybody can do their own thing and it doesn’t affect you. It’s cool. Yay, Mr. Rogers. But I think the world is ready for that level. And to get us back on track with topic, I think the world is ready for that level of storytelling, depth of humanity, and exploration of individuals, much like Dickensian chapbooks in that era. It’s just weird the way I just said era. I heard it echo. Era. It’s like I’m a Kennedy all of a sudden. But the world is also shifting into abstract, nonlinear storytelling that is like, I look at cartoons, dude.
Just on TV. There’s some I like to watch, but some are just like on Cartoon Network, random. I mean, that stuff is so bizarre and random. It’s totally derivative of this kind of storytelling. There’s a slight narrative, but most of it is just like kids do. They goof around. And so it just leads in one direction. There goes that story. And I was amazed at the level of influence that, I mean, I get it.
In children’s play, there’s a lot of abstract and non-sequential. And non-logical movements in story, but… Trippy. It’s trippy. Some of those cartoons…
Devin: It’s a lot of trippy cartoons.
Adam: Man, those cartoons are freaking me out.
Devin: I have. I babysat for a buddy, and he’s got two boys. And I’m like, I wanted to watch a hockey game, but clearly they did not. So they just grabbed the controller from me, and they put on… God, what was the name of it? It was… I wish I could remember the name. But anyway, this cartoon tripped me the F out. And I kept looking at them, and I’m like, what is going… I thought maybe the pizza we had had… Maybe it was a special pizza that accidentally I grabbed out of the fridge. That sounds like my kind of pizza. It was crazy, because these kids were…
I could not get them to sit down for the life of me. They were all over the place. We were playing football in the house, baseball in the house, everything. I just wanted to watch a hockey game. The minute I put this on, or they put it on for themselves, it was like they were in a trance. And they didn’t… I mean, the youngest one, I think he was… At the time, he was like two years old or something. He was holding this football, and I look over at him, and he’s like in mid-throw for like 20 minutes, just holding this football and staring at the TV.
Adam: And I’m like… There’s so much focus for younger kids, because they’re coming into this world, and they’re like, with a different springboard than we did. Every new generation does. And so, they’re internet-wired brains. They’re multi-think. They think broader than we trained growing up, you know? And so, something that is random, that is completely unexpected, that is bizarre, they don’t know what’s coming next, dude. Because it’s so random, they don’t know what’s coming next. And so, the whole predictability of act one, act two, act three, we all know what’s happening. I’m sort of making fun of what we’re going to be doing second season, but…
But we’re also showing how to tear that apart. It’s a surprise. Everything is a surprise. If you know this is not going to be a linear thing right at the end, it’s like, oh, I guess we all learned a lesson. You don’t know where it’s going to go. That in and of itself is fun. One of my favorite bands right now, musicians, bands. I’m well aware of what a band is.
Devin: You know what a band is, Devin? They are musicians. You’re like, one of my favorite bands? Those are musicians. They play instruments and they sing songs. Anyway, back to bands.
Adam: One of my favorite bands, Alt-J is the name. What I love about them is they’re sort of a little, they draw on a little bit of prog rock, but they are, when you’re listening to a song, when you think the measure is going to turn to something that is familiar to you, it just goes somewhere else. I mean, it’s almost like they just glued another song to that. It’s so disparate and it’s in the tone. And I love how they sort of throw you around. It’s like, you know, we know you think it’s going to go here, but that’s not where we’re going to take you.
That’s awesome. And so it’s sort of nonlinear in song construction in a way. And of course, they have an introduction, a verse, a bridge, a chorus, a verse, a bridge. So there’s a rhythmic quality to the structure of the song, but it’s not linear. It’s rhythmic. So if you’re doing these kinds of stories, because there’s no line through the whole thing, there’s no spine that sort of gels it all together really well, you have to rely on a rhythm. You know, you have to sort of change things up every little bit to give that surprise of, well, we don’t know what’s going to happen next. And that we don’t know what’s going to happen next is we literally just don’t know where the perspective of the character or the omniscient storyteller is going to drop us.
Devin: You’re saying that there isn’t a thread, and I agree with that. In my mind, I’m trying to visually think of the best way to explain what the quote unquote thread is in some of these nonlinear stories. And the best thing I could think of was, you come to a fork in the road, but maybe there’s like six different ways to go. But you’re going to at some point go on all of them, but they all could be happening at the same time, and it could be happening different times. But at some point at the end, hopefully, all of them are going to be coming together again.
So all of them are going to make sense, even though it’s not. Linear. Somehow they’re going to be, you know, somehow they’re tied together in a way.
Adam: You want them to. You want that resolution. In most of the examples I have down here, even Citizen Kane, there’s resolution. But in Lynchian movies, sometimes there’s not a linear. That’s what I’m saying. It’s more a psychological landscape. Some of his stuff trips me out. I mean, a lot of stuff trips me out. But it’s because he goes for that raw, like in a performer, you have to sort of embrace that. Ugly, gritty, dirty part of yourself, the parts where you’re like, oh, I felt like a douchebag then. I felt like a jerk then. You still have to play a character like that if you get cast as a character like that.
Right. You have to embrace those things and not be judgmental of it. And I think what he does with his storytelling is he psychologically is willing to explore those darker spots with the mix of other emotions. Like if there’s love, there’s guilt. If there’s bravery, there’s fear. If there’s, and, and, but he paints it. If you will, as a psychological landscape that has a runtime. It’s a painting with a runtime. He’s sort of just laying ideas out. And, and, and I guess the, the one that I’m thinking of when I’m talking about this is Lost Highway, which is in a certain way, linear. It’s more linear. I mean, it’s more linear than some of his things.
But when you get to the end, you start to realize that these three. Guys who are in this mix together, there’s sort of one man trying to come to terms with his own guilt. And so he’s telling a story of this guy psychologically. It’s sort of like, here’s what I would say. What David Lynch does in a lot of his stuff loosely or less pointedly is what David Fincher does with exact precision and fight club.
Devin: All those decisions to even stop a storyline. So I don’t want to, I don’t want to mix up what I’m trying to say with payoffs, setups and payoffs. Right. Everything, everything, every part of that story at some point is paid off at the end. And so you understand what’s going on. I’m just saying every one of those decisions, every, every branch that they decide to go off on, whether it comes to an abrupt stop, and that’s the end of that. That storyline, there’s a reason for that in part of that story. So if you want, and I guess it’s hard to, it’s hard if we’re not dissecting a specific film, I guess it’s hard to even try to make my point with this. Well, let’s do something where you see this game was a good place to start for this, because it leads into today’s thinking. And so I was reading an article and I don’t, I don’t, I won’t use the professor’s name in this using by name. He’s a professor at the, at a California English department. We’ll just say that, but call him out. He stays. So it’s well, cause I don’t want to. So it’s H. Porter Abbott.
He’s a professor emeritus in the, English department of the university of California, Santa Barbara. And in this, in this article I was reading and it was in the Atlantic, it was the article I was reading. He states that the preference for linear storytelling is a fundamental. So according to him at about age three, our brains begin to compartmentalize sensory information from, from the world around us into components of ongoing narrative with each of us at the center. We view our lives as a series of actions, causes, and effects that together form an ongoing story. So that was part of, that was. His interpretation of how, when, and when, and where we start developing this, this preference for linear storytelling. And then the article presents this study that was done. I’ll try to maintain composure until the end of this, but the study, and it was published in PLOS ONE.
And psychologists took a group of participants and showed them either an intact version of Bang! You’re Dead, Hitchcock’s short film about a young boy who finds a gun, goes around town shooting it because he thinks it’s a toy. Or they were given a version that was cut with the scenes completely out of order, just scrambled. Both groups were told to count how many times they heard the word gun spoke in the film. Now, the study showed that people who viewed the intact version did considerably worse than those who viewed the scrambled up, cut up version. One professor describes that their goal for the study was to give the audience.
Their own goal to maintain throughout the screening of this highly engaging kind of suspenseful film, but noted her confusion on even though they viewed the exact same content, the fact that they disrupted the order of the content meant more disengaged from the film. But those who watched the intact version of the film were drawn in and completely forgot about what they were doing. So, their conclusion, which is utterly ridiculous based on this study, in my opinion, was it illustrated humans’ innate preference for linear narrative, stating the audience watching the intact film were more engaged in the story, and because they were so engaged with the story, they either missed several times the word gun was spoken, or they simply forgot the task.
While those who watched the scrambled version, with essentially zero narrative at that point, couldn’t follow or find any story. So they weren’t engaged and they focused on the story. They focused on the task of counting the word gun. Well, no bleep and bleep, dude. So like that has nothing to do with nonlinear versus linear storytelling. And the major flaws in this ridiculous study are glaringly obvious. So they took a well structured, well scripted, well executed. Story that was engaging Hitchcock carefully and deliberately edited to have those scenes occur and precisely those times of the of the film. And then they chopped it up into a bunch of friggin images that make zero sense when they aren’t in the order that they’re meant to be. So this this isn’t nonlinear storytelling. This is taking like a.
Beautiful it’s like taking a Rolls Royce destroying it into pieces throwing it on the lawn and asking people to tell you what kind of car it is no one’s going to know what kind of car it is and no one really cares and no one’s going to want to watch it or look at it because it’s a it’s a mess I mean because the the film isn’t isn’t told in sequential chronological order doesn’t mean for a second that the audience won’t be engaged so this. Like we’ve said before, the storytelling genius is when a story that isn’t linearly told can still engage you and suck you in.
Adam: It’s constructed as artistically.
Devin: Yeah.
Adam: StoryOsophers, this study really infuriates Devin. You’ll hear us both. We’ll get a little heated or passionate about certain topics because we really believe in it. And like, we wouldn’t be doing this podcast if we did not want to see story evolve and not be stuck in some of the ruts it’s gotten stuck in, formulaically, structurally, even exploratively with characters. That’s why, like, I keep preaching long-form storytelling. I love storytelling. I love that you can familiarize yourself with someone non-judgmentally. You don’t have this immediate confrontation. You’re sort of eavesdropping on their life. And so, our acceptance of humanity in general grows. I love this. There’s so many things to explore with this. The study itself, what a bunch of baloney. That’s my opinion of it.
Yeah, it is. Just to sort of comment on the nature of it. If you’re watching something linearly, you’re wrapped up in it. If you get disoriented, right? You’re watching this thing they chopped up into a bilge. And you’re like, you’ve already checked out? Well, of course, it’s easier to start going through the list of how many times they say, gun. Yeah. Because there’s nothing else drawing you through the stupid story except this task they’ve given you. Exactly. I was going to say this about, this is a very interesting concept in general, whether people know this or not. When you’re talking about those two, your friend’s kids who you were watching TV with.
Devin: Mm-hmm.
Adam: Television itself. Is a hypnotic device. And I’m not saying this randomly. Folks, whether you know this or not, here’s news. I’m a licensed hypnosis therapist as well. So, I’ve explored a lot of information on hypnosis. And I believe this study that I’m going to talk about comes from David Wilcock’s book, The Source Field Investigations, which you’ve read as well, Devin, right? Yeah. I think it’s from this book. I’m not quite sure. Whether or not, I’ll pimp David Wilcock’s work out, you know, because he’s amazing. He’s just a great thinker. So, they hooked people up to television sets in this manner. When their brainwave state became in a hypnotic state, the television would shut off. So, they would turn the TV on, have people watch it, and whenever they would get hypnotized, the electromagnetic feedback from whatever they were hooked up to, like a lie detector test, it was reading their body rhythms and their brainwave.
They had a little, one of those fancy helmets on, and the television would automatically. Automatically shut off once they were, quote, hypnotized. Not a single person in that experiment, the television was on for less than 60 seconds. So, within 60 seconds, everybody was in a hypnotic state, brainwave-wise. That’s why people, when you watch TV and they look like they’re a mouth-open zombie, they’re hypnotized.
Storytelling is hypnotic in its own right, but the actual television itself, you sort of just tune into it and you’re there. Yeah. This is why, if you haven’t noticed, you’ll sit there. If you haven’t noticed, you’ll sit down to watch 15 minutes of TV and be there for way longer than you anticipated. There are reasons.
Devin: Right. Or, I don’t know if this has ever happened to you, have you ever been running on a treadmill watching a really good movie? It gets to a point where you’re so engaged that you stop running and you fall off the treadmill. It happens to me. I had to stop. I can only listen to music now when I work out.
Adam: What has happened to me is this. I get so engaged in the movie. I don’t realize I’m still, and sometimes I’ll do a bike. I’m still on the bike. So, I get off and I’m like, oh my God, my legs hurt so bad.
Devin: That’s good. At least you kept pedaling then. Yeah. You kept working out. Yeah. Oh, that’s good. I just stop. Stop doing everything and I’m hypnotized into the-
Adam: Just crumpled into a ball and rolled off the back of the treadmill. Well, StoryOsophers, we will continue our conversation about nonlinear storytelling next week. We will do a detailed episode. Exploration of Memento. Please subscribe and rate us on iTunes. And for additional story-related resources, video, and archived content, visit our website at StoryOsophy.com.