Show notes
Season 2 starts here, with structure. For a lot of writers the word means something rigid, a paint-by-numbers kit that boxes in their creativity. Adam and Devin used to feel the same way. In this episode they explain why they now love it, why Devin calls it “blueprinting” instead, and how a bird’s-eye view of your story gives you more freedom, not less.
In this episode
- The stigma. Structure sounds permanent and immobile, and nobody likes being told what to do. But it’s only a perception.
- Blueprinting. Devin’s blueprint is a guide, not something written in stone. Themes, symbols and payoffs pop up during the writing, and the blueprint changes with them. It keeps him from painting himself into a corner.
- Follow your inspiration. Start anywhere: an ending, a scene, a line of dialogue. Write it down the moment it comes, even if that means a voice memo on the dashboard. Some ideas don’t come back with the same vigor.
- Zoom in, zoom out. Dive into a scene or a character dossier, then pull back to the bird’s-eye view and see what should come next. If you get stuck in one mode, switch to another.
- “You don’t make them talk, you let them talk.” Adam calls it the magic zone: he’s not writing dialogue so much as taking dictation.
- Story before theme. Stephen King noticed the blood running through Carrie only after his first draft, then went back and strengthened it.
- The tent poles. Structural milestones and decision points help the audience understand the story so far. Give your characters choices, not victimhood.
- The influences. Joseph Campbell’s The Hero with a Thousand Faces, Christopher Vogler’s The Writer’s Journey, Robert McKee’s Story and Blake Snyder’s Save the Cat. Adam and Devin draw on all of them, but think Act 2 and the ending need a new approach.
- The Act 2 monster. Act 2 is half your story, and it’s where writers end up floating on an inner tube in the middle of the ocean.
- A new age of storytelling. Writers once worked linearly on typewriters; now you can edit nonlinearly, and streaming lets a season play as a ten-hour movie.
- Architecting. Like a house, a story can be laid out any way you want. Architects’ best tool is the eraser.
Examples discussed
- Carrie: Stephen King found the blood symbolism after the first draft.
- Also: Steven Soderbergh’s Mosaic, Stranger Things, choose-your-own-adventure stories, and Stephen King’s On Writing.
Coming up this season: the tools of structure, from scenes and sequences to acts, movements and thresholds, and then the Story Blueprint, event by event.
Read the full transcript
Transcribed automatically, so expect the odd misheard word. Sponsor messages are left out.
Adam: Welcome to StoryOsophy. This is Adam Jones. And Devin Halden. A couple weeks ago, I attended the Virginia Production Alliance State of the Industry event. The VPA, if you will, the abbreviation, the Virginia Production Alliance, is the citizen counterpart to the Virginia Film Office. And so, they throw events where they discuss the industry and the goals of the film office and supply resources to crew and storytellers throughout the whole state of Virginia. They opened a new branch up in Northern Virginia called the NOVA VPA. It’s the NOVA branch, Northern Virginia, which is much closer to where I’m at. And so, it was very exciting. Anyway, I represented StoryOsophy on behalf of Devin and me.
I was at one of the vendor tables, and it was a wonderful experience. The VPA is fantastic. A lot of folks come up to the table, and we were just talking about storytelling. And no matter what their specialty was, no matter what their job was in film or what they aspired to do in film, StoryOsophy is always relevant because it’s all storytelling. And we’re trying to navigate our listeners through the different ways to approach story, how story is built, how you can examine it and dissect it. And this works for anybody from director to director. And so, it’s a great experience. To directors of photography, to actors, to writers, to directors, to producers. Breaking apart and examining a story is important in a lot of ways. Devin and I, some of our listener base are, of course, colleagues and friends that we know, even acquaintances that have seen the podcast in our personal feeds on social media and stuff. And when I’ve run into those folks that I know, they’ve always said wonderful things to me about the podcast, which is fantastic that we have listeners.
And folks that we know who are supportive. But what was really exciting about being at the VPA was I met our first fan that was not someone that we knew face to face. It was very exciting. And so, I just wanted to give a shout out to Emily, who I met at the vendor table. And it was fantastic talking to her and her friend, Kristen, who was not yet a listener, but I’m pretty sure Kristen’s going to be tuning in because we had a fantastic conversation. It was just great. So, I just wanted to celebrate for a minute and give a shout out to not just these two people, but also to the two lovely ladies that I met at the VPA, but also to all our listeners. Thank you for supporting us and listening and actually finding great value in what we’re talking about. We really appreciate that. And if you have questions you want to ask us, if you have comments, please hit us up on social media, ask us questions. We’ll happily address those in our episodes. But anyway, yeah, I just wanted to give a shout out to Emily and Kristen. Thank you, ladies. You made my night.
It was very fun. Great conversation. And to the rest of the folks that I met at the VPA, if you are listening, I would love to hear from you. I would love to thank you, too. Thank you to all our subscribers and listeners. Aside from that, we’ll get into the meat and potatoes of this thing. Welcome to season two, folks. If you’ve been a StoryOsopher with us for a while, we’ve been talking about the basics of storytelling. And in this episode, we start our journey into structure. How do you structure a story? What is structure about? Why do so many people have a problem with the word structure? There’s a stigma attached to it. And one of the first things we want to do before we get too heavy into what the season is going to be about is dispel this myth, this stigma attached to the word structure. Devin?
Devin: When I visualize structure, I think of something rigid or permanent, immobile, something that was built and not intended to move.
Adam: You’re making it sound so exciting.
Devin: Well, that’s why I don’t like the term for it. Yeah, me either. Even though I’m a big fan of what they call structuring, I dislike the term for writing purposes. And I have many writing friends who cringe at the mention of structuring their stories. And I get it. It depends on what image is thrown into your brain when you hear that.
Adam: And most artists don’t like the limitation in any way. They like that freedom to create, and I think that’s the issue.
Devin: Exactly. That’s what it is. You want to be unbridled, especially when you’re the first draft or free writing, or you just want to take the inspiration and put it on a page. And the minute that structuring comes up… It feels a little bit more limited, or even just their thoughts being hampered or hindered, there’s some creative claustrophobia. Just some writers feeling structuring their story hampers or hinders their creativity or imagination, but it doesn’t have to mean that. It doesn’t mean that at all. It’s just a perception.
Adam: For sure.
Devin: Or a perspective, or a feeling.
Adam: Nobody likes being told what to do. It takes the fun out of everything.
Devin: Mm-hmm.
Adam: When you’ve got structure… It’s sort of, you feel like it’s someone telling you to do something a certain way, or that every story has to be a certain way, or that… And it’s all accepted, traditional, and it’s there to stay. It’s sort of the system, the structure to things.
Devin: Yeah, or paint-by-numbers type of thing, where it’s like, this color has to go here, even though you have zero creativity with doing this, but you are physically, take that color, put it there, and then by the end, it’s going to look beautiful. So that’s kind of, as kids, there’s not a ton of creativity. Well, it’s the creative kids that say, no, I’m not going to put that color there. I’m going to put this color there. And then there’s some abstract picture result at the end.
Adam: Or they just make origami out of the paper, the real weird ones. Structure, when I first started writing, structure felt that way to me. And these days, I don’t feel structure like that at all. If anything, I’m sort of thrilled to approach structure. Mm-hmm. For me, it sort of functions like this. Characters are where stories start first for me, always. Like, I’ll have an idea, maybe a scene or two, something like that. But overall, when I start building the characters, that’s when it starts to grow. The structure, what’s great about it is, I can take characters and sort of run them through different parts of the story and see how they react.
If you don’t know what to write, but you know you want to do this character, have this thing, you can sort of run your character through different parts of, or different challenges. Mm-hmm. And you’ve got these great free-write exercises.
Devin: Right.
Adam: If nothing. If nothing else, that structure provides for young writers, it’s, look, think of a scenario where dot, dot, dot. Like, we talk about call to adventure a lot. That’s when the hero, or call to quest, that’s when the hero is sort of invited on or called to the rest of the story, what they’re going to do through that journey. If you can think of, okay, I’ve got this character idea, this is what I want to do with them, and then go, what would be the most interesting or dynamic call to quest? I can give this character, where there’s a big decision point, and I have to, and you just sort of test yourself and go, I’ll think of five different scenarios, just brainstorm a little bit, and then pick one and write it for fun.
Well, that’s a free-write, but you’ve based it on one of these structural events or stages in the development of that hero, and it provides you with a different dimension, a different viewpoint on this character that you’re writing, or the story that you’re writing. Right. It allows you to help track your evolution. Your evolutions in the story, your milestones, your turns and twists and reversals, and especially mine and Devin’s favorite, setups and payoffs.
Devin: My first advice is, even though we’re going to be using the word structure throughout this season because it’s… It’s universal in a way to what what this actually is. I refer to it as blueprinting. So I just removed the word structure from my thought process when when thinking about this part of the the writing journey. And I call it blueprinting. I blueprint my blueprint becomes a guide. It’s something that is it’s thought out, but it’s not written in stone. And things are going to pop up during the quote unquote construction or the writing phase that requires edits and alterations. And adjustments to to that blueprint for any number of reasons. And like, like you were saying, Adam, there’s, you know, that maybe you realize this, the theme is something completely different than than what you thought prior to actually giving what you what you gave the your story in the beginning, or once you dove into this world, all of a sudden, a theme became a different theme became became more obvious to you, or maybe a bit of, of symbolism continues to pop up unexpectedly.
And going back and working that symbolism into other events and scenes and characters will strengthen that symbolism or set up some payoffs will pop out, you know, so that, you know, the point is, blueprinting, for me is this bird’s eye view of the story. And it allows me to see where the story is going. And oftentimes saves me from from following some, some tangent or clear some clutter on the page or stops me from or prevents me from journeying. Into or painting myself into a corner, which during the first couple scripts that I that I wrote, that was like the most frustrating and inspiration killing thing for me was you get onto a tangent, or I started writing and I took it somewhere. And then I realized that that the last three days of writing, they just not going anywhere, going anywhere, even though it was a good, it’s still a good practice and free writing, but I was like, Oh, man, I wish I could have done that.
I wish. So that’s where, again, through my own personal trials and tribulations of, of writing is kind of is where this has evolved for me is, is really, like you said, I get excited and, and love the blueprinting part of this of creating a story because it allows it’s not hindering at all to my imagination of anything. It opens up different corridors and different. Parts of my imagination, because things, things that I’m writing in different parts of a story start sparking, sparking things for, for either a character or because I don’t, I don’t necessarily have a regimented and specific process I follow before writing in particular, but I do have tools and, and, and certain processes that I use that I have that I’ve acquired, you know, and developed over the years.
And so for me, ideas, ideas come to me randomly. But when they do, I try to make sure. I grab them and I write them down and I put them in a safe place so I can revisit them or I can develop them later. And, and sometimes it’s a character, like you were talking about Jonesy. It’s some, you know, sometimes it’s care. Sometimes it’s an entire scene or it’s an event. Sometimes it’s an idea that just quickly manifests into something that I want to start working on. Or a piece of dialogue. Or dialogue. I get a lot of dialogue in the shower for some reason. That’s my dialogue spot.
Adam: You know, it’s weird. There’s, there’s a few things. There’s inspiration, right? You get the dialogue. You’re hanging out. You’re shopping, doing something. And somebody says something or you hear a conversation. You’re like, oh, that’s interesting. I take a little bit of that for inspiration. But when I’m writing dialogue, it’s weird. It’s sort of like I sit down to, when I sit down to script, it’s like the magic zone. You’re an awesome dialogue writer. I appreciate that. You’re fantastic. You’re very good. Here’s the thing. I don’t know that I’m necessarily writing it as much as just taking down dictation. And that’s what I was about to say.
There’s a difference between gathering. Those little like, oh, that person said that that’s really funny. And it sort of makes its way into, if anything, that’s early in the process. Character voice wise. I hear someone say it and I go, that’s who that person is. A speech pattern, a something from the outside world. And it inspires me to a character. But when I sit down in that, like, as I call it, the magic zone. And I don’t sit down into it. Like, I sit down to write, but if I get in the magic zone, it’s like I don’t do anything. I literally just, my brain, my imagination is just going nuts. And it’s almost like I’m just watching this movie and putting it on paper.
So, I hear, and there’s a playwright, I want to say, I don’t think it’s August Wilson, but it might be August. There’s a playwright who, in his earlier days when starting to write, said to a more seasoned writer, how do you make them talk regarding characters and finding a better way to write dialogue? And the answer from the experienced playwright was, you don’t make them talk, you let them talk.
Devin: You listen, yeah.
Adam: And that’s the big thing is, as people, you know, we’re trying to maintain a lot of that. A lot of ourselves and who we are. So, there’s a little bit of a controlling factor going on. But if you’re writing all these different personalities that are not you, and you’ve got your voice in the way, trying to write it down, you’re sort of editing them, these other people. And so, there’s this place where there’s this magic zone. And then there’s this other place where I’m like, okay, I’ve got these free writes, and here, they just started talking. I don’t even know, this scene’s like 80 pages long. What the heck?
Yeah. And through it, you start to maybe understand their relationships, what they do want, what they don’t want. But that scene’s too long. So, you need to break it up and edit it in a different stage. You would edit this scene into things that have movement to them, like Devin’s three O’s, objective, obstacle, outcome. So, you take some of these free writes that you’ve written, you take some of the ideas you have, and as Devin said, key word here, folks, bird’s eye view your story. Okay. When you sit down to write, most of the time, and when I mean write, all this is writing, all of it. When you sit down to script, or put the words on the page, you are approaching it in a linear fashion. As we ended season one, talking about nonlinear storytelling, structure is all nonlinear.
Writing tends to be very linear. You sort of write from the beginning of the scene to the end of the scene. The experience for the audience, same thing. It’s all linear. But this one mode of thought for storytelling. Mm-hmm. As we talked about before, you can, if you know what the end of your story is going to be, plug it in.
Devin: Yeah.
Adam: The funny thing is, the story that I was just working on, I had an ending. It was one of the main parts I knew what I wanted to do with. And then I went back and started writing some of the other places, act one and then act two. And then I realized, oh, I guess the ending’s different now.
Devin: Right. Exactly. Exactly.
Adam: And I’m still in this place where I’m in the midst of this story, and part of the exciting part for me is… I don’t know how it’s going to end either yet, folks. Because I thought I did. Exactly. And then the writing of it took me in this direct… It was almost like watching something. I realized this when I was working on it. I was like, well, I don’t know how this is going to end now.
Devin: Right.
Adam: And I felt like an audience member. But it doesn’t… If you don’t let it limit you, the word and the process itself… Exactly. You won’t be limited. It will actually bring you way more freedom and many more ideas. It’s the opposite. Right. Because as a young writer, you get that. It’s the stigma. You want to just get down and start writing. Everybody wants to get down and start writing. And we’re not discouraging free writing while you structure, but write a little bit. Step back. Take a bird’s eye view. Go back and write.
Devin: The key is when you’re inspired, act. Yes. Whatever is inspiring you, follow that. Your subconscious and your imagination, what’s inspiring you, follow that. And so I’ll start my blueprint. My Story Blueprint from anywhere.
Adam: That’s the doorway to the magic zone, Devin. You’re laughing at me, but that’s the doorway to the magic zone. What you just said. Follow your inspiration.
Devin: That’s right. I’ll start anywhere. Thank you. Like you said, so like in your example, I’ll have a great idea for the ending of the story, but nothing else. So when I get home, if that idea came to me in the car, I’ll try not to try to write it in the car. But the minute I get home, the minute I get somewhere where I can write it down, I’ll write that ending down. And now my blueprinting has begun. And I may just have a broad stroke idea, or I may be inspired to start scripting or free writing. So then I’ll do that. Or maybe I’m not ready to script.
And all I’m going to do is free write. And I’m just going to throw, you know, puke on a page, as they say, and then I’ll do that. But all of that writing is more often than not will inspire something else or a character or characters to be in that scene. And now that I have a couple characters, or at least the character I think perhaps is the hero at this point, I’ll switch to creating a character dossier for that character. And another, which is, you know, another piece of that Story Blueprint. And then I’ll zoom out a bit.
Adam: If you get stuck, you can also switch the modes. You know what I mean? If you’re like, oh, writer’s block, it’s like, no way. Right, yes. You got a character dossier you could work on? You got structure you can play with?
Devin: Zooming in and zooming out. Zooming in for me is diving into a scene or diving into a character. And then I’ll… And then I’ll zoom back out. And now I’m at that bird’s eye view and I’ll imagine how my hero or those characters got to that point. And if I’m inspired with something, I’ll zoom back into that blueprint and I’ll write that scene or I’ll write that event and perhaps script.
Adam: The way you’re saying it is almost like you’re telling yourself to do it, when it’s not really the, I’m not saying that that’s how it is for you. It’s almost like it guides you itself. Yes. It says, do me next. Yes. Fix this thing next. Especially when you can switch gears.
Devin: Yeah, I’ll jump around my story when I’m inspired. Yeah. Follow that inspiration and don’t fight it. And don’t put it off.
Adam: Right. Don’t procrastinate on it either. No, no. The reason why you’re inspired in that moment is right then is when you’re supposed to do it. And this is a terrible, horrible advice, but I’m giving it anyway. Even if you’re at work, if you’re in your car, get a phone recording app and click the record button, put it on your dash, whatever it is. Yeah. But click it, record your idea. Yeah. Do whatever you got to do. Pull over to the side of the road. Some of them, I’m telling you, some of them don’t come back in the same vigor that they first came to you. Write it when you’re feeling the magic.
Devin: And that’s the most frustrating thing when you’re like, when, because I’ve done that where I’ve been in the shower or driving and I’m like, oh, I can’t. You’re like, oh, I’ll get it later. I got to write that down when I get home. And I’m like, what, what exactly? Because there was something that was profound or something that was truly inspirational. Yeah. Nothing. Then I lose it. Mine’s going to sleep at night. And then the other thing too, is like, when, if you have an idea for a good setup and payoff, but you’re, it doesn’t have a place yet, or you’re not quite sure where in the story, the setup will happen and when it will be paid off, you know, have a little, have a little database, setup payoff database.
And when that time comes, you’ll know it. You’ll be like, this is where this setup and payoff goes.
Adam: Organizing these things, as far as like setups and payoffs, a lot of that is in the mythology of my story, the larger, bigger pieces. And how you were talking about theme and symbolism come into play. These are all things that they sort of grow for me. But even this last one I was working on things that were necessities for the story, what you and I would talk about the rules and tools scene, where the heroes get the, the information from the mentor, they get the, the rules of the world and the tools of the, I realized that some of the tools that were being used in and of themselves were symbolic. And we don’t know that yet.
And I was like, Oh, interesting. And symbolism sort of grew out of necessities of my story and the free, right, right, right. It sort of builds itself, it grow, it evolves and grows itself stories. I mean, for me, these people are very real to people in within the stories, right? Especially if it’s film, they’ll become living, breathing actors.
Devin: We talked about in season one to the theme part. So about. Don’t, and I guess probably the main thing we want to say is don’t force anything, just follow inspiration.
Adam: Yes.
Devin: And Stephen King in his book On Writing, which is a, it’s a great book. I recommend, and it’s in our, you can get it on our website too. But he just, he says, it’s always story before theme and, or story before symbolism. And so his symbolism. Yeah, it sort of grows secondarily. Don’t sit down and say, all right, I need to come up with the theme of this story. And then I need to write around the theme because then it’s going to feel forced. Yeah. Collect your ideas first. Exactly. Because his movie Carrie, he just realized at the end of the first draft, he’s like, wow, blood is very symbolic in this story. And so he went back and strengthened certain scenes where there was blood and made. And so the, that symbolism became a little bit more, more prominent for him.
But the same thing. Same thing with theme.
Adam: What you’re saying right there makes so much sense to me because there is a very heavy blood theme throughout that whole story. And it’s, it’s also about coming of age and all these other things. Now that you say that, I can see that just bird’s eye view skimming over the top of that story. I go, oh yeah, of course that’s what he did. Right. Of course that’s what he did. He got to the end and went backwards. Yeah. As far as, I mean, not that I would know that without you telling me, but in terms of the way that I do my process and doing that, I totally understand it.
Yeah. It’s almost like if you’ve ever put up a large tent, like a tent for a party or anything, you put up your corner poles first and then you put up your central pole. There are these basic structural points that you put up and then you put up all the little stuff in the middle. Yeah. In terms of when people talk about structure in act one, act two, act three, especially in terms of filmmaking, scripting and filmmaking, the whole reason those things exist is just to make sure that you’re not wandering in the desert. There are these certain points that help the audience to understand, and I’m going to say it this way, story thus far.
Devin and I do not believe that story is all the stories in the world have been told and all that other hoopla. There are brand new stories on the horizon with the way that the internet is allowing hyperlink. You can do choose your own adventure. Steven Soderbergh did Mosaic, which is another nonlinear, by the way, folks, a brand new type of nonlinear. There are all these different ways that story can be told and has not been explored. But so far, the way that most people understand how to navigate a story, you need those big tent poles, the milestones within the navigation of the story itself as marking points, as ways of understanding, especially as Devin and I would talk about a lot, decision points.
In every scene, in every sequence, act, whatever you want to call them, give your character choices and let them make a decision. Not victim. Give them choices and let them make a decision because then your audience can understand the structure. Then you can start to move outside of the box of here’s stage one, stage two, like the rigidness that people think story is. Now, I don’t want to talk too critically about where story has come from. Everyone that Devin and I have learned from in our growth of knowledge and experience in storytelling are fantastic. Without those folks and explorers. Story to that level and philosophy of story to that level, we wouldn’t be able to stand on their shoulders, the shoulders of giants and look to a new horizon of story.
Where can it go next? So what we will be talking about throughout the second season is the foundation of strong storytelling structure. Now, we don’t agree with all these philosophies. Since learning, we’ve sort of evolved our philosophies beyond this step one, step two, step three stuff into a what if you did? This event differently or for instance, Devin and I, we have a bit of a problem with some of the ways that people structure act twos because it’s such a big thing to cover and it’s what about 50% of your story. And then also the ending, the ending gets a little prolonged, but in a, in a strange way.
And I think it’s, I think I speak for both of us, but I think the ending is more flexible than what most storytelling models, especially mythological or epic storytelling models allow for the people I’m talking about. Who inspired us and who we will be drawing on or have drawn on. And we’ve talked about them in first season as well. And story authors, if you haven’t listened to first season, go back and listen to the basics. If you’re just joining us for season two, we talk about characters and, and plot and subplot and dialogue and subtext and symbolism and theme juicy topics, but they’re the foundation for what we’re going to be dealing with in this season.
Juicy. It’s back. Juicy’s back. Did I say juicy? You brought it back. Juicy topics. Juicy things. Bringing juicy back. That’s all right. I think it had its sabbatical. It had its timeout. It was in the penalty box for long enough. You’re the hockey fan. That’s right. So these gents I just want to mention real quick. Joseph Campbell’s book, Hero with a Thousand Faces. His protege, Christopher Vogler, who expanded on that and wrote The Writer’s Journey. Robert McKee’s Story, which tends to be a little bit more open-ended and philosophical. It’s not as step-by-step. And it has different theories. And finally, Blake Snyder’s Save the Cat, which has wonderful beats and it’s just great for a walkthrough as well. For my taste, I don’t think anyone actually gets it just right for me. I draw on all these folks a good bit and for different reasons. But I think that act one, act two, act three thing is where it sort of gets stuck. The storytelling model, that mythological epic storytelling model, Hollywood has sort of adopted it and then fit this act one, act two, act three thing.
And that’s story on repeat now. You’re just getting the same story model and the same type of story. I feel like the internet might be cracking those innovations. You’re getting more challenging storytellings from different online platforms, Netflix, Amazon, Hulu. We still have to stretch.
Devin: There’s certainly exceptions to all of this. Sure, sure, sure. Yeah, yeah. And I think we’ve highlighted some of them in season one, but I’m sure we’re going to highlight some other examples of people who kind of… Just decided to do it a little differently.
[Sponsor message]
Devin: I think where we both agree, and probably a lot of people or a lot of writers who are familiar with Vogler and Campbell and McKee and Snyder, is that second act for sure is still… It’s kind of like… Everybody has that. That first 25 pages of whatever their first act or the first 15 pages is pretty… It’s pretty tight. There’s a lot of things that happen there that can draw somebody in, can get them engaged in the story. They understand the characters, they understand their world. There’s a lot of information that’s passed to the audience in that first part. And then at the end, people are really good at… It seems that Hollywood or writers in general…
Understand how to try to bump up the pace a little bit and have an interesting climax or an exciting climax. And then the second act of all these stories, it’s because, like you said, it’s so vast. It’s like 50% of your story. That’s where it becomes where writers typically will find themselves, including certainly where I’ve found myself. I feel like I’m floating on an inner tube in the middle of the ocean. You know, like, okay, I can’t see where I came from anymore. And I can’t see where I’m… I don’t know how I’m going to get to where I know I got to get to. And I think that’s where a lot of conversation and philosophy and different ways of figuring out the monster that is that second act.
I think that’s where, Jonesy, you and I both agree that that with what we’ve… Other people that we’ve either read or listened to, that tends to be where it’s still this monster that we have. That you’re trying to tame in order to get to the… The meandering insanity. Yeah, meander, exactly. That’s where I always end up. Oh, now I’m in a corner.
Adam: How did I get here? Okay. Or here’s the other thing. Indecision because of too many options. You get to a place and you’re like, now what do I do? There’s so much you could possibly do that you sort of feel like without instruction, you don’t know where to go next. Or without a guiding post, you don’t know where to go next. And so that’s the benefit of structure. You at least have this roadmap. Can you go off on this other side road and explore for a while? Yeah, of course you can. If you just, the funny thing is if you just create your structure and then stick to that structure, you may have fun. But if the side roads pop up and you go, what if this character did this? And you go, but that’s not in my structure. That’s not in my structure. And you never explore that path, even though your whole self is calling you to go, hey, you should write this scene right now.
That’s when structure becomes that stigma-based word. Where you’re like, oh, structure? Who the hell wants something with structure?
Devin: Mm-hmm.
Adam: Ugh. Then it becomes that limiting factor to you. Then you’re not allowing yourself to explore when you should. And like I said before, Devin said the key word, that the key with structure is bird’s eye view. Bird’s eye view, bird’s eye view. That’s the key word. That’s why it’s different than any other stage in writing. Because writing itself, scripting, the free writing, when you’re just putting stuff on the blank page, get out of your way. Do not. Don’t structure. Do not edit. Don’t edit while you write. Right. Just put it on the page. And then later, like there are certain times I edit better than other times.
Right. When I’m like, ah, I’m not quite in the zone. Let me just review my work. And I can do it from a more critical mindset where I go, oh, that’s not the right word there. Let me just highlight that in red or change the word or whatever. Fix it later. Get the base concepts down first. When you get struck there, when you get struck there, when you get stuck there, the structure itself is fantastic. Bird’s eye view. I said before, you’re like the god of your story. Let me explain a little bit about what I mean by that. So at page 30 in your story, you know the antagonist does this horrible thing. That’s why they’re the antagonist. Right.
They do something that we, the general audience, deem judgeable. Killed someone something. Now, as the author, the storyteller of this piece, you know that at page 80, from that 30 to 80, that person has changed in some way. And at page 80, they actually. Save the hero. They become a completely different person. And so it’s difficult to navigate that story as a storyteller. If you judge your antagonist, we talk about antagonist relatability. This is why an audience will judge them on page 30, but you can’t because, you know, the dynamic change of their person on page 80. And it warms your heart. It thrills you that this person finally found themselves or something, you know.
I hate to use the word redemption. I think it’s sort of a weird word, but that’s the bird’s eye quality of it. And what’s great about it, whether you’re actually a storyteller or not, meaning you want to pursue this as a career, or whether you’re just a person who wants to express something about your life. When you start writing and start looking at it from that angle, you’re able to see everybody, not just the hero’s perspective, but everybody’s perspective. And it gives you a much broader sense and scope of humanity. Right. Because you have to understand this person in order to write them. Reaching out past our writer base, a writer listener base to just listeners who love stories. That’s one of those other things that storytelling is great for.
Devin: Like you said, I guess there’s two keywords for me when it comes to structuring. It’s the bird’s eye view, which is invaluable to me. I love being able to see, basically watch this, understand where the story’s starting, where it’s going to end up and stuff like that. And then maybe, quote unquote, structuring. Oops, I just jacked my. I was doing, quote unquote, physically in the booth here, and I just jacked my mic.
Adam: So everyone, just so you know, in future episodes, when Devin does, quote unquote, he’s actually doing air quotes, even though nobody can see him do it.
Devin: Quote unquote, I’m literally doing it. But to your point, you may be structuring, quote unquote, structuring your story, but it’s your imagination. It’s your inspiration. Inspiration is the other key for me. Yeah. That’s what you’re following. And it’s your inspiration that’s in charge, not some arbitrary parameters. This is your story. It’s your world. That’s right. It’s your characters that are creating. It’s you’re in charge. Write for yourself as the audience member. It’s just you and you. Don’t allow arbitrary parameters to manifest themselves into your psyche or into your imagination because they’re not there. They’re not there. You are literally following inspiration.
And you’re creating characters. You’re creating world. You’re in charge. And what structuring is or blueprinting or putting a puzzle together, however you want to think about it, it’s allowing your inspiration to guide you and jump and throw you into different parts of your story and zoom in and get micro with your characters and get you with the characters and world on a micro level and write and free write and then pull back out and maybe something you’re writing. Something you write before or something you write after is going to completely change that event or that scene or what those characters did in that scene. But at least it led to inspiration to other parts of that story and allowing yourself not to think linearly, like having to write from page one to page 90 or page 120 or page one to 500 and allowing yourself to jump in at different parts of your story.
And being able to zoom out with that bird’s eye view is going to change the way that maybe even the efficiency of writing, but even just the way that your story comes together and characters evolve and develop and things like that.
Adam: So just based on what you just said, this is the reason why when we talk about we’re in a new age of storytelling, folks, this is why. Before computers and word processing programs that allowed you to do nonlinear editing, we had typewriters. So, and before that, freaking stones and rocks and whatever, the point is, in this day and age, it’s not putting a piece of paper in a typewriter and you’re writing chapter one. And if you screw up chapter one, tough, new page, you got to do it all over again. There’s a way that stories may have been constructed nonlinearly, but the way that they were written were certainly very rigidly linear.
And these days, we’re given so many wonderful, brilliant tools to be able to do well beyond that. Beyond what our predecessors have done in terms of storytelling, we can now be writing a piece and be on page 80 or whatever, be near the end of the story and go, oh, shoot. You know what? If I set to pull the Stephen King blood thing for Carrie, if I did this a little earlier or just drop the bit of this in throughout, this ending now has a larger payoff. Well, if you were building a story where you only had a typewriter, it’s less, it’s easier for us to do nuanced stories.
Story, detailed story. That’s why you’re getting such rich stories these days is everyone’s starting to go, oh, we can build like this and we can do more ensemble-based stuff and people will understand it. Everything’s expanding in that way. Whereas before, here’s my thing. Look, if all these genius writers of antiquity could write the works they did linearly, then we should be able to create much better works nonlinearly. That’s my philosophy. Shakespeare, all these fellows. You don’t have to live up to Shakespeare. He’s dead. He’s gone. He’s not with us anymore. For those of you who don’t know. Some people cling to literary history. He lives forever in his writing, Jones.
He does. I know. Don’t call him dead. He’s not dead. I needed that quick scolding. I was getting there. Don’t you dare. We talked about Mr. William the other day. Talking about brevity, soul, wit.
Devin: Yeah, Bill. Yeah, Billy boy. Billy Bob Shakespeare. The great thing about what Netflix started with. All right. Well, this is, it’s chapter based. It could be 10, 12 episodes. 8, 10. 10, 12 episodes. And then we’re going to just give it all to you. And you can consume it however you want. Was it’s doing what we’re talking about. It’s allowing a different way to tell stories. That back in the day when somebody, when some guys from Hollywood sat down and says, all right, what is the amount of time that somebody is willing to sit in one seat in a dark theater and watch a story? And they came up with this metric, this 90 to 120 minutes, two hours tops.
And it makes sense because if you ever tried to sit through a movie that’s over two hours and it’s not really that engaging, it does get, you get a little squirmish. Although a movie that’s not engaging, you could be out of it in a half hour or two. But so there was forever, there was this, well, your script has to be 90 to 100 pages. If it’s over 120 pages, you got to figure out how to cut it down. So there’s a, that was the movie model. And now being able to do, to write a 10 hour movie. Essentially is what is going on with Netflix and Stranger Things.
And even though there’s seasonal and, and, and chapter based, but it’s, they’re basically saying we’re going to give you a 10 hour movie or a 12 hour movie, however many episodes it is. And you can consume it all in one sitting, which a lot of people do, or you can break it up however you want. It’s a really good point. It’s allowing these characters, allowing the writers to tell a story differently than if they would have had to take all of the, all of that information. And all of that entertainment and shove it into 120 minutes or less.
Adam: And coming from where I come from the most like character based or performance, but like actor based, I will relate ability is so key to me beyond plot and all that other stuff. They, if the characters are engaging, people will watch because it’s other people and they’re interested. The ability to be able to grow along with other people that you would never have in your life experience is one of the greatest things about that type of storytelling. Now, I know you’re hitting a different point, which is, you know what, 90 minutes, 120, you choose whatever you want to sit down and when you feel comfortable and we’ll just make stories that are engaging, which is another aspect of how the, how storytelling is like surging forward right now.
Like when I say we’re in the age of new storytelling, I really mean it. We are folks. We, things are surging forward and not just in storytelling, but in, you know, many different other industries and art forms. But it’s that ability to grow. Grow with an individual and do it in your own time. And TV series for the most part have been previous to now a lot episodic based. So you can tune in this week, two weeks later, whatever, and you’ll still be entertained and get it. But that’s not the case as much anymore. Some regular, like you’re made primary networks and stuff. Sure. Cause they’re in time slots.
But when Devin’s talking about these online platforms, they just drop all of their season in one sitting and you are in one. One. One date. One date. Right. And then you. One date. That’s a good way to say it. I was struggling there. And then. And then you choose. But you also get, like I say, you get the ability in these chapter-based scenarios to understand people better. To bring this back to structure, how to use structure well is giving your audience a chance to see this character in different aspects of development. That’s really the key to the structure. And in doing it in larger things, like Devin’s talking about these larger chapter-based things, you have to do it for multiple characters. You have to do it over large season arcs. Everybody’s got an arc. The whole season has an arc. The whole series has an arc. That gets more complex, but that’s where you build to.
Start with something simplified. Start with, like we’re dealing with mainly in this season, is single protagonist stories because you have to really understand. It’s like know the rules before you start. You have to understand the foundation and where folks came from building story before this point to then go, well, what if I did this? I was just telling Devin the other day that one of the scenes that Rules and Tools will talk about later in this season, I had it and I was like, I don’t know what I want to do with this scene. I know it’s a Rules and Tools scene. I know they need to explain the rules of the world and the tools these heroes will be using, but I don’t know what I want to do with it.
And I just thought on it and thought on it. Just that piece of structure itself. And suddenly this light bulb goes off and I go, oh, that’s what type of scene this story needs. That’s what type of Rules and Tools it needs. So it allows you a bit of focus, but not rigidly enough that it limits you. If you don’t have enough focus, if you don’t have some laser beam focus when you’re executing, you’ll end up, it’ll be muddy. It’ll be average. It won’t be specific. It’ll be generic. If you play with some of these aspects of structure, you can hone certain parts of your characters. Like I said, we’re just running into a free write. Our process, how we approach structuring, what it’s useful for. Devin and I approach it slightly differently. There are some things we disagree on, but for the most part, we’re on the same page.
I think our approach, you talk about a blueprint, which I think is a good analogy. It’s also a good bird’s eye view image. I like to think of story as a puzzle, a puzzle that an audience will solve while they’re watching it because you want to really engage their curiosity and their brain on, and for me, deep philosophical levels. I want you to think about life. That’s what I want an audience to think about. Even if it’s a comedy, I want to make them laugh and then go, hey, by the way, what about this question? And you go, hmm. But there’s a puzzle that you’re going to go through and experience and solve in a way. I want the audience to be engaged like a detective.
Now, to build that, I’m going to go through a series of stories. To structure that, you have to build the puzzle, and it’s the same methodology that Devin uses with the blueprint concept. There’s a bird’s eye view, and I need to mark where my setups and payoffs are going to be, where I touch upon theme, where I nail down theme at the end, where I pose the dramatic question, where I answer the dramatic question. All of these things I need to figure out, and so it becomes daunting and overwhelming unless you use structure to your advantage.
Structure is not something that should scare you, especially the word. The word sucks, folks. It’s a sucky word. Devin says blueprint of the actual layout itself. We also talk to each other about architecting. It’s much more interesting for us to think of story structuring as architecting or building because structure has those funky connotations. But that’s really the key is it’s like, look, if you’re going to build a house, you can build any type of house you want. The bathroom can go anywhere. The kitchen can be an open kitchen with an island. It can be smaller in the dining room. There’s so many options on how to architect a house.
Equally, there are many options on how to architect a story. Don’t let structure freak you out. Embrace it. Give it a big bear hug and go, I love you, buddy.
Devin: I think that’s why I like blueprint because, well, I mean, if anybody’s actually worked with blueprint before, you know, you have the… The top page is the house as a whole. And then every subsequent page underneath is like there’s specific rooms. And then within those rooms are the specific amenities or fixtures that, you know, it gets detailed in those specific rooms. It allows you to zoom in. And then you can pull back out and can look at it. But there’s a reason why architects work with pencils and erasers is because they don’t they don’t work with unless they’re in an AutoCAD program, of course. But if they’re just with their hands measuring and drawing this and.
Drawing the house, their greatest tool is their eraser, because if something does all of a sudden they built something here and now this doesn’t work, well, they can erase that they can remove that wall they can, you know, so that’s the same the same idea of blueprinting or. Structuring story is nothing’s written in stone. As your story evolves, as your world evolves, as your characters evolve, things are going to be moved around and shifted and maybe completely deleted or things are going to be added before and after. Whatever you’re working on. And so understanding that in your head, you’re that everything is malleable. Everything can be you can erase, you can change, you can everything can be changed. Yeah. Then that’s where and then once you knowing that once you have this blueprint.
Or this puzzle put together sitting down and actually scripting or sitting down and writing that novel and just rocking through your blueprint can be the second stage of awesomeness of of the of the of the experience. It’s like wow. I know exactly where they’re going to go and because I’m not worried about about this scene and figuring out where they’re going to end up or making sure I’m figuring out how how or not even knowing what’s happening after this you can literally focus on strong dialogue. Understanding those that some of that symbolism and making sure maybe there’s some strong there’s a way to make this theme or the symbolism stronger, you know, there’s other things that you’re that free your mind’s freed up because you you you understand you have that.
And so, there’s, of course, it’s everybody’s different. Everybody has their own process. Things work for them. Things won’t work for them. But it’s about being open-minded. And freeing your mind and following your inspiration is probably the key to all of this is what if you’re inspired, act on it. If you’re inspired about a scene, write that scene doesn’t mean it doesn’t need to fit anywhere specific. If you know how you want to end a story. Just write it. If you know a character, write his dossier, understand who that character is. And then like, like the, the domino analogy we use for a lot of for in the first season of kind of how the story takes off. That’s literally how structuring.
And blueprinting will go to is once you get this one thing down you that you that you were inspired about writing that ending, all of a sudden, when you start free writing on that, or you actually even start even scripting that part, then then it will open up your eyes. You open up your imagination to the characters that are actually in there. And then those characters will lead you down to where they met. Maybe they met breaking into after the threshold from Act 4. Or maybe they meet right at the beginning, right during the hook scene, you know, so it’s playing around with it’s playing around with what you with your imagination, but following the inspiration of your imagination to wherever it leads you.
At some point, all of those pieces will fall into place. You’ll have those pieces of the puzzle. And then you’ll start writing, literally sit down with scripting and writing, and things will be shifting again. Things will be moving around. So, it’s… The bird’s eye view and following your inspiration, I think, are the two main things about structuring. It’s allowing yourself to understand where your story begins, understand where it ends, and then know what happens in between that. Not forcing yourself to write or come up with certain elements of the story or certain parts of the story that you just aren’t inspired to write yet.
Adam: You know, what’s funny, you keep saying inspiration and imagination, and really those are the key things. You gotta follow… Because especially if you’re a young writer or a novice writer, the confidence may not be there, but that will never let you down. Inspiration and imagination. The confidence will come, trust me. When I was first writing, it was just like, what do I do? I don’t understand. I don’t understand how to do all this stuff. And I would just follow my own imagination because it was the joy of the creation. These days, I’m much… It’s probably the thing I’m most confident in is storytelling. Just because I’ve experienced and done it so much, it’s almost like when I sit down to work on stuff, I say…
I sit down with a no-brainer trust. I’m like, yeah, it’s there. It’s going to come. I’ve removed all these roadblocks just by practicing over and over again. So know when you sit down, if it’s fairly new to you, you might have some of those roadblocks, but don’t let that… Whisper of doubt in your ear. Don’t let that part of yourself that is a self-editor and, well, I can’t do this. I’m not good enough. Don’t let that in your way. Those are petty little brats just whispering in your ear, but that will go away. All those fears, all those things, all those nervousness, I don’t know where to go next, that’ll go away.
And if you still have trouble navigating this roadmap of structuring a story, just hang in for season two, because Devin and I planned on making it as easy… And fun.
Limit us. I don’t want to limit us, folks. Seasons three and beyond, we’re going to crack this stuff wide open. So I don’t want to say it’s our favorite yet, but we do really like structure. And it’s, you know, as we both said, it’s taken us a while to get there. Structure sort of feels like someone’s telling you to do it a certain way, and it’s not really the case. It can really help. And part of the reason why structure is most important, we’re going to get into next episode, where Devin and I are going to talk about our processes, the way we approach things, as far as structuring. But the one thing we most certainly have in common is measurement. The measurement of your story. That’s what’s important with structure. It allows you to understand what you’ve got on page versus what your audience is going to take in, how much time, how many pages. It allows you to figure it out and work from the back to the front, the front to the back, from the middle outward. It allows you flexibility.
Because you understand the measurement of your story. And we’re talking about story blueprinting. That’s one of the first things. You got to know the rooms. You got to know the measurements. We’re going to start season two with a lot of the basic tools of building. We’re going to walk you through different story stages and events. But before we do that, we’re going to talk about scenes, acts, sequences, beats, super objectives, pivots, thresholds, all these different tools that you would use to implement in structure. We’re going to start with those. We ended last season with some tools, the basic tools. But this season, we’re going to start with some. We’re going to let you know what’s what. Brothers and sisters, StoryOsophers, word.
Please subscribe and rate us on iTunes. Follow us on social media. Share with your friends and send us your questions and comments. For additional resources and links to films, series, and books we talk about here, visit our website. While you’re there, sign up for our newsletter for updates on story building tools and special offers at StoryOsophy.com.