Show notes
A reversal flips the audience’s expectations: hope, then despair; victory, then defeat. Adam learned the tool from screenwriter Shane Black (Lethal Weapon, The Long Kiss Goodnight, The Nice Guys), who splits reversals into quick twists and slow burns. In this episode Adam and Devin explain both, how they relate to setups and payoffs, and how a reversal can play out entirely in a character’s eyes.
In this episode
- Quick twists. A ping-pong match of false victories and false defeats, all in one scene, often within seconds. The audience knows exactly what the character knows, so it’s pure suspense.
- The haystack game. Shane Black’s exercise: a man falls out of a plane (bad), but he has a parachute (good), but it doesn’t open (bad)… down to the haystack he misses.
- Slow burns. A long fuse: something set up early pays off as a reversal much later. Adam and Devin would just call this setup and payoff.
- Push past clichés. Most stories repeat what someone else did. Don’t write a Tarantino movie; write a you movie.
- Don’t save the engaging part for later. Devin’s girlfriend gives a show a few minutes before reaching for her phone. You can deliver character and setting in an exciting way.
- Don’t telegraph your payoffs. If you show the special move in Act 1, the audience knows it will win the fight.
- Reversals in dialogue. Aaron Sorkin’s dialogue is a series of quick twists: every line is a punch, and every reply punches back.
- Reversals inside a character. In Seven Seconds, the young cop who hit the boy wavers between fear and guilt in near silence, and the audience can’t tell which way he’ll go.
- Great stories keep telling themselves. A story that leaves questions open, like Seven Seconds’ unhappy ending, starts conversations after it’s over.
Examples discussed
- Masquerade (1965): William Goldman’s first reversal. A prisoner finally hooks the keys, and they’re the wrong keys.
- The Long Kiss Goodnight: the daughter’s broken arm, and the matches she hides in her cast, pay off in a freezer at the climax.
- The Perfect Storm: the sun breaks through on the crew’s faces, and it’s only the eye of the storm.
- Chinatown: “She’s my sister. She’s my daughter,” a quick twist that delivers the film’s slow-burn reveal.
- Seven Seconds: a defense attorney turns the prosecution’s mannequin against her.
- Also: The Dark Knight Rises’ opening, Cobra Kai, The Karate Kid and Breaking Bad.
Writing along with the season? Play the haystack game with a scene in your story: good news, bad news, good news, bad news.
Read the full transcript
Transcribed automatically, so expect the odd misheard word. Sponsor messages are left out.
Adam: How do reversals improve the experience of your audience? What is the difference between a quick twist and a slow burn? How are they related to setups and payoffs? We explore these questions and more next on StoryOsophy. Hello. Welcome to StoryOsophy. This is Adam Jones. And Devin Halden. This week, we’re going to be talking about reversals. And everything okay over there? Yeah. Sounded like someone’s going down. I always have a hard time saying my last name. It is sort of strange to me. How long you’ve known me for, you still say it incorrectly. That’s because you don’t even know how to say it. That’s the only reason I say your last name wrong is because every time we get to this part, it’s like a question. Holden, Holden, Halden.
Hey, Holden. If you were to say your name wrong, what would you say?
Devin: Holden.
Adam: Holden. If you were to say your name based on the look of it and phonetically break it down, that’s how I accidentally say it all the time. Yeah. Let’s try it again. All right.
Devin: I’m going to keep it simple. Hello.
Adam: Welcome to StoryOsophy. This is Adam Jones and Devin Johnson. This still doesn’t help with the pronunciation of Howlin. Let’s get into it. We’re going to dive into this right away. Reversals, folks, this is sort of a continuation in a way [unclear] of setups and payoffs. We talked about that a handful of episodes ago, and it’s one of our favorite things. Reversals is an option for a payoff in a way. Reversals is also a great tool.
A reversal is a great tool to use for your audience expectation and helping you to subvert that within the context of the whole arc of the story or within scenes or sequences in and of themselves. Quick flips back and forth. So we’re going to start out with a definition of reversal as such. It’s a change to an opposite direction, position, or course of action. It also is known as like the reversal of fortune, an adverse change of fortune. So once again, it’s an expectation thing. If this is what your expectation is, you flip it on its head, you subvert it. And it has a lot to do with withholding information. And like I said, it’s sort of like an aspect of payoffs. It’s a choice for payoffs, but it’s also like a second cousin of payoffs in a way. We’re going to be talking about two types of reversals. I’ve learned a lot about what I know about this from Shane Black. Shane Black is, he wrote Lethal Weapon.
The Last Boy Scout, Last Action Hero, Long Kiss Goodnight, Kiss Kiss Bang Bang, Iron Man 3, The Nice Guys. And he directed The Nice Guys as well. And he’s got new stuff coming out. Doc Savage with The Rock and The Predator is a sequel to the original Predator, although I thought Predator 2 was. But apparently this is the sequel, The Predator. I’m telling you about his movies in list form there because they’re great to watch to understand this tool well. And also because I’ve learned so much from him. This is my best way of paying him back. There you go. Go check out his flicks. They tend to be action adventure or made in the action and fairly intense. A lot of his movies defined that. That action tough guy. Lots of foul language. You know, it’s not too graphically gory or anything like that. But there’s a lot of guns and cops and robbers and the classic stuff that makes for strong suspense thrillers. He thinks that every movie is a suspense thriller. I say most movies I want to treat as a mystery because I want to engage the audience’s curiosity. But he’s also right in this. You want the audience to be on the edge of their seat trying to figure out what’s really going to happen by the end. Or for that matter, in the next three seconds, in the next three minutes. And so I will derive a lot of the stuff that I’ve learned from his teachings. And I encourage you to check him out because he really nails this well. But we’ll be talking about two different types that he points out, which are quick twists and slow burns. And I’ll explain to you what those mean in a moment.
But before I do, Devin, is there anything you’d like to talk about in regards to reversals before we get into those?
Devin: Yeah, I think it’s probably important to do a minor differentiation between setups. And this is strictly in my opinion, the setups and payoffs versus reversals. And what we’re talking about today, I think, for me, the, the setups and payoffs are kind of the bigger reveals or the payoffs are the bigger reveals to the to the to the setups. And these are tools to keep the audience leaning forward or, or engage staying engaged and use them to strengthening the like a character.
Adam: I think it helps to increase the characters cleverness. It shows how quick witted they are, and how responsive they are.
Devin: In response to how a character responds to different situations. And yeah, and these are all these reversals. And I think what you said earlier, a reversal of fortune is a good way to put it too. But they all involve like an emotional change, oftentimes a fairly severe one in the audience into the into the character like the okay, there’s hope and then well, and you’re because the audience a lot of times in these in in in these types of scenarios are these when when these tools are being used, the audience The difference is that a lot of times it has the same amount of knowledge as the protagonist or the hero or ally that it’s actually happening to.
Adam: It’s real suspenseful.
Devin: Yeah, yeah, correct. The audience is is also hoping, and then they’re also let down or there’s an emotional change in both, you know, we’re kind of on the same page as the as the hero. And for me, these are like mini false victories in a way where something’s given and then taken away for looking at it as measurements. It’s fairly quickly, whereas a setup and beginning of act one can be paid off somewhere at the end of act three. They’re kind of more quick setup payoffs, these reversals. So that’s just kind of how I’ve been differentiating them.
Adam: Let me get into those two things, the quick twists and the slow burns, because what you’re addressing specifically, and what I would really call reversals is the the quick twists part of it. A quick twist is something that happens in and you were saying false victories. I would say it’s a ping pong match between false victories and false defeats. And at the end of that ping pong match, one of them is not going to be false anymore, like you’re either going to get to a victory or get to, but it’s this back and forth and you don’t know what’s going on between the two. Is it, is it a victory? Is it a defeat? Is it a victory? Is it defeat? To me, that’s the quick twist formula. I’m going to throw an example in here. I’ll give you Shane Black’s, what he calls the haystack game. And it’s really simple. You can apply this to any scene you have. That’s why he calls it a game because you can use it and amp up your scene.
So there’s a guy on an airplane and he falls out of the airplane. You’re like, oh no, oh my gosh, that’s bad. No, it’s fine. It’s good because he has a parachute. You’re like, whew, oh good. That’s good. And it’s like, no, that’s bad because it doesn’t open. And it’s like, but that’s terrible. That’s terrible. No, no, no, it’s great. He has a reserve chute. It’s fine. That’s, oh, that’s good. That’s, that’s good. Phew. No, that’s bad because the reserve chute didn’t open either. Oh, that’s horrible. That’s horrible. No, it’s, it’s okay because below him, he can see a haystack. Oh, good. So he’s going to land on something soft. No, because he also sees there’s a pitchfork sticking up out of it with the tines pointing up. Oh, that’s horrible. No, no, no, it’s good. He missed the pitchfork. Oh, good. No, it’s bad. He missed the haystack too.
Devin: Who would put a pitchfork in a haystack like that?
Adam: Well, I mean, it’s a game, Devin. Obviously it’s a little ludicrous, this example.
Devin: It’s very loony-toony. Like that’s, they literally use that. How many times has that happened? Wile E. Coyote when he’s chasing the roadrunner.
Adam: A quick twist is it’s usually a strong, fast-paced action scene. And it’s a lot more, more shock and surprise based where it’s back and forth and back and forth. And a slow burn. And these are, these, like I said, these are terms from Shane Black. The slow burn is what you and I would call a set of payoff. So if you imagine like, it’s just a long fuse on a piece of dynamite, that’s the slow burn. That’s the slow burn concept he’s talking about. So the setup way early in the story pays off much later in the end of the story. And it’s a reversal in the fact that it’s a choice of the payoff. That payoff can simply be a reveal. It could be a discovery. It could be lots of different things. But it, it, this, this specific choice for a payoff is to flip the expectation based on the setup you got a long time ago.
Right. So what I really consider. What I consider to be reversals in this tool format that we’re talking about is the quick twist. What Devin’s addressing. The slow burns, I would still classify as setup and payoff. And the choice to pay it off as a reversal would be that concept. Although you can pay off in many ways. I think the thing that I would probably most like to explore in this concept of reversal is the quick twist. Because it’s a tool that you can use to amp up the intensity. Or pace. Or audience experience and connection to the character in scenes. And so you can sort of crank your scenes up to 11 when you want to. You know. Devin?
Devin: A quick twist. The setup and payoff happens in the same scene.
Adam: Yes. And also within seconds of each other.
Devin: Yeah. Whereas the slow burn, there’s scenes in between. The slow burn and the setup and payoff.
Adam: That’s a great way to describe it. Yeah. Reversals are a lot to do with subverting audience expectations. Or playing with them. And so that’s the main thing tool-wise that’s important. Each little step that builds to a milestone is one tiny reversal here or there. I think that the quick twist and the build to those larger milestones. Like even if it’s just beginning, midpoint, end. I think those milestones need to be much stronger built. Like the slow burns of setup and payoffs. Then quick twists. Quick twists are the approach. Quick twists are the build to the milestones. That’s the stuff we’re going to talk about structurally, in minutia, in season two of StoryOsophy.
Devin: I was thinking about this because it’s oftentimes the hero like in the Sherlock Holmes stories that we’ve been talking about. Where a clue becomes a partial clue until we are presented with another clue. Clue that makes the whole clue, which then provides an answer, though, albeit perhaps a partial answer until other clues arise to provide a full answer or answers.
Adam: Well, it also would depend on how long, how far apart those clues in the second part of the clue happen. If it’s in a scene, boom, boom, boom, boom, boom, that’s a quick twist. And if not, it’s sort of our setup payoff, the slow burn aspect.
Devin: Right. That’s the classic Sherlock Holmes type of model where we’re with him up until a point where he decides to leave us behind. And then we become an audience rather than the detective in a way.
Adam: So you’ve gotten all the clues to solve it. And then you are sort of left out of the solution in order to have him walk you through it and see if you got the same stuff. That structure has affected detective stories to this day. Right. I mean, that foundation of a model for that type of story, people use in procedurals on every show and film you can imagine all the time.
Devin: Yeah, because that’s how the payoff has the biggest punch.
Adam: Imagine Sherlock figures it all out and tells you he figures it all out. And then you go into the reveal scene with the suspects and the murderer, and you just hear the whole thing over again. Like it would be the most boring, idiotic way of expressing that story ever. And so this clever thing, he’s like, you know what? Yeah. I’m going to let you know up to a certain point, Sir Arthur Conan Doyle, thumbs up, buddy. Then you have to be not in the know. That’s, you know, that’s kind of interesting about the quick twists. The audience is in the know as much as the character. It’s what you’re saying. It’s pure suspense.
Devin: Yep. Yeah.
Adam: Now that in the know switches on a dime every three seconds. And that’s the thrill of it. It’s like a roller coaster. The quick twist. They’re safe. They’re not safe. They’re safe. They’re not safe. They’re safe. They’re not safe. They’re going to make it. They’re not going to make it. It’s this back and forth. That makes that tool heighten scenes. Every 15 pages, if we haven’t changed, if we haven’t crossed a new threshold of the character becoming something different or in the story world becoming something different, I’m bored. And that’s just me. Yeah. I’m with, no, I’m with you though. I agree with that. Look, I’ve watched movies since I was a kid. I love storytelling and I’ve seen tons of them.
Most stories are simply someone repeating or regurgitating a format that someone else has created. That they’ve watched on screen. Sometimes it’s even scenes verbatim. The way this scene worked out, I’ll just do it again. An action scene, this or that. Once again, I have issues with the lazy writing, which is not taking those things that once repeated several times become cliches. You can take a cliche and explore it further and make it not a cliche. It just takes a little bit more energy and imagination. And if you do it, you will be thrilled with the results. So I encourage you to push past, push, push, cliches. Try to say that five times fast. Do it, Devin.
Devin: Push past cliches, push past cliches, push past cliches, push past cliches, push past cliches.
Adam: All right, smart aleck. Way to go. Okay. When you push past those things, you can actually find originality. You can use it as a stepping stone and go, wow, I’m inspired by that scene or Tarantino’s dialogue. But don’t try to write a Tarantino movie. Try to write a you movie. Be your own. For me, that wanting to push past the cliche is I get bored with too much setup. And as my mother would say, dilly dallying. And as well, my mother would say that as well. Where you’re just messing around or pussyfooting around.
Devin: Let’s get into it quickly. My girlfriend and I were just watching, I’ll talk about this. This is one of my examples actually for today, but we were watching a new Netflix series and she’s got the attention span of a gnat. We’re going to cut that out because she listens to these. No, but she’ll agree with me. She needs to be, you need to engage her very quickly in either a movie or a series for her to feel like it’s worth her time to her, to give her time to this thing. Otherwise I’ll look over at her. If it’s a kind of a slow developing movie or series, and she’ll be on her phone and I’m like, damn it, we lost her. But if I can get her to a point where all of a sudden everything starts getting good, then she’s hooked. But there’s no reason why you can’t character develop and set scene and set setting and all that stuff in an engaging way. And I think it’s kind of this norm where people or some writers believe it’s a norm where it’s like, all right, the first 10 to 15 minutes is going to be slow because Because I’m just, I’m getting people, I’m giving people information.
They’re going to need to know. But creatively, there’s also a way to give that same information. And I’m very engaging and exciting way and kind of get right into it, get, get right into the, to, to the action. So it’s kind of, it’s similar to what you were talking about.
Adam: There’s no reason why you can’t jump right into it. It doesn’t have to be the first act is the thing you will work on the most. You will never write that first act, right? The first time through, maybe not even the second time through you’ll get closer and closer to refining it, but it’s once you get your ending and your midpoint and all these later things. And you go, well, we sort of explained what I tried to explain in crappy exposition in my first act a little later.
Devin: Yeah, right.
Adam: Dark Knight Rises, the Batman with Bane in it. The beginning, the opening of that, the hook scene of that is packed with quick twist reversals. You don’t know what’s going on. It’s back and forth and back and forth. Like, your mind is blown. Or perhaps he’s wondering why you would shoot him out before throwing him out of a plane. That’s a good impression. It’s my Bane. There are two reasons why someone’s not paying attention. Either it’s boring, or it doesn’t appeal to their sensibilities, which is the one thing I was going to say about your gal. It may not be something that is of interest to her.
True. For you and I, Devin, we could probably watch anything just to examine it. Even if it’s not of interest to us, we go, why is this not interesting to us, is the thing we look for.
Devin: You’re certainly correct. There’s certainly movies. Well, Dark Knight Rises. She’s like, nah, no thanks. Just because it’s just subject matter she doesn’t care about. But then there’s like the series that we just watched on Netflix where- What is the series? Seven Seconds. Oh, yeah. You sent me a text. That was awesome. So good. It’s slow. It’s really slow until the- The third, probably third episode. But then you’re seriously engaged with it, and it’s fantastic, and it’s frustrating, and scary, and it’s all those things. But it’s great. It’s great.
Adam: Great. I think we sort of realize that the slow burn is a lot of what we call setups payoffs. But those are equally important to, if you set it up, if your audience knows it’s going- It’s going to be paid off at the end, it’s not subtle enough.
Devin: Right.
Adam: Because there’s many movies where a prime example is having a story where someone is teaching someone to fight or do something, and they show them a special move in act one, or probably in early act two, in a rules and tools scene kind of thing. Well, you know they’re going to use that special move. I mean, come on. What’s the point of wasting that screen time unless they use it? And so it becomes very obvious.
Devin: Are you alluding to Karate Kid? The crane?
Adam: Yeah, but the crane- But when does he practice- You can’t get yourself to say it. In the Karate Kid. I can. Say it. In the Karate Kid. Do you think I don’t like the Karate Kid? I don’t know. Dude, I love the Karate Kid. One episode. No. Wait, wait. Now I have to know what you’re speaking of.
Devin: You’re kind of blaming everything on Daniel. No. He deserved everything he got because he started it. Not at all. I’m just kidding.
Adam: All I was doing was citing the video thesis that I saw online and asking your opinion about it, and then playing devil’s advocate to the other end of the spectrum. I will play devil’s advocate. I will play devil’s advocate just for the sake of exploring an idea, as you will.
Devin: I know.
Adam: I love the Karate Kid. Are you kidding me? It’s awesome. Did you know-
Devin: Do you know they’re actually coming out with a-
Adam: I know, I know. Let’s talk about that for a second. Okay. All right. We’re going to segue because this is really important. I know exactly what you’re going to say. I’m very excited about this.
Devin: I think it’s on Hulu, isn’t it? A YouTube Red, I believe. Yeah, Johnny is back, and he’s reviving the Cobra Kai, and all I’ve seen so far is just that one teaser. Yeah. I think it might have been a- It wasn’t a Super Bowl teaser, but it was a teaser. It was a teaser. It’s basically Johnny and Daniel LaRusso just standing in a dojo.
Adam: They’re both older men, like fathers, husbands and fathers. Yeah. So this is the log line or the description for Cobra Kai.
Devin: I love the background of the video they have on it. Strike first, strike hard, no mercy. Strike first, strike hard, no mercy, sure. I love it. Anyway, set 30 years after the events of the 1984 All-Valley Karate Tournament, the series focuses on Johnny Lawrence reopening the Cobra Kai dojo, which causes his rivalry with Daniel LaRusso to be reignited. So good. That’s all they give us.
Adam: I don’t know why you thought I didn’t like the Karate Kid. I love the Karate Kid, and I love the- I mean, who doesn’t love Wax On, Wax Off, man? A comedy drama is how it’s listed. Well, but that’s what the Karate Kid would be. It’s funny, and Mr. Miyagi’s hysterical, dude. It’s funny and dramatic at the same time. That’s why you like it. That’s why you like it so much. Because, I mean, you wouldn’t call it a martial arts movie, even though that’s what it is. It’s a mentor tale. It’s probably one of the better mentor tales. It was created by Ralph Macchio, of course.
Devin: Really? That’s awesome. I’m very excited about this. Here’s a better premise. This is a better premise of it. Cobra Kai takes place 30 years after the original film and follows a down-and-out Johnny Lawrence who seeks redemption by reopening the infamous Cobra Kai Karate Dojo, reigniting his rivalry with a now-successful Daniel LaRusso, who has been struggling to make his way to the world. He has to maintain balance in his life without the guidance of his mentor, Mr. Miyagi. The show is about two men addressing past demons and present frustrations the only way they know how, through karate.
Adam: Dude, it’s really exciting. I love these. I love long… I make no beans about this and the whole thing. Makin’ no beans. I’m makin’ no beans. I love long-form, chapter-based storytelling. I love it. Yeah, yeah, yeah. And I’m so excited about this age of storytelling because of binge-worthy watching and you can just indulge in watching a character or a person grow. So I am absolutely in love with series or stories that go, you know what, we’re gonna pick up with these same people, Twin Peaks, 25, 30 years later, and we’re gonna continue to tell their story. Mm-hmm. That, to me, is awesome. I love it. I love it. So I’m very excited to see what happens in this.
Devin: Guess who Johnny’s stepfather is in the show? Ed Asner. It’s gonna be so good.
Adam: We’ve segued a good bit. I love Ed Asner. One of the reasons why this is gonna be a fun episode. This episode is, you have no idea where we’re going next. Neither do we. It seems like we’re gonna get back to the plot of the episode, the story at hand, but we’re not, folks. The title of it. We’re just gonna spin way out of control. Reversals are great for that audience expectation thing, like we said, keeping them in suspense. Set-ups, pay-offs, the slow burn have always been in my bag of tricks. As Devin will tell you, like he and I both, that’s sort of the main thing we focus on.
Is making sure your audience has these really great discovery moments for themselves. Let’s get into some examples. Yeah. This trick or tool, my mentor in it is Shane Black. So a lot of the stuff that I’ve learned, I’ve learned from the way he uses it or where he’s learned that from. He talks about William Goldman, who’s a great, renowned screenwriter, and his movie Masquerade from 1965. This is apparently the first reversal William Goldman ever wrote. That he was really proud of. The main character is trapped in a cage. He’s locked in a cage. He’s desperate to get out and he’s looking across the room and on the wall hanging on a peg are the keys, but they’re obviously out of reach.
He can’t get them. So he takes his shoe off and he throws a shoe at the keys and he misses. He can’t knock them down. He gets this stick. I think it’s a piece of bamboo and it falls apart. He tries to piece it back together and finally gets it. He reaches through the cage and we’re waiting this whole time. Like, is somebody going to come back? Are they going to discover them? Are they? Once again, suspense, thriller, suspense, he gets it. He’s reaching out with this stick and he hooks the keys and he lets him slide down the stick until it gets to him. And then he tries it in the lock and he tries another key in the lock and they’re the wrong keys.
So this entire time that we’re watching and in suspense of this guy, he’s going to escape. Okay, can’t get the keys. Our false expectation is that these keys are going to fix the situation. And even though it’s it’s a thrilling scene to watch. As. You go through. We talk about second viewing second viewing that scene sucks. Yeah, exactly. The first viewing, you know, what’s going on. It’s sort of a trick. You get I prefer things that withstand the test of time. You know, you can watch it two or three times and but this one you realize once he gets the keys, you mean the entire thing.
I’ve just been watching in suspense was a waste of his time. And so the second viewing it’s going to be a waste of your time because you already know the outcome is fruitless. But it’s a great way of showing this happens. Then this happens. It’s not as intense as what I think Shane Black has amped his up to be in general. Those movies. I cited at the beginning. It’s important to like I said note that although he uses them for an action genre to keep the pace of the movie in the intensity of the movie up. It doesn’t mean that you cannot use that in a drama or a comedy or any of these things a prime example outside of the box for this would be Aaron Sorkin’s dialogue is a quick twist.
Reversal. Always every line delivered by someone gets a punch back from the other person and a punch back from the person again. It’s a ping-pong match you as soon as this person says something you can even use Devin’s example of the social network a few episodes back. As soon as someone says something you’re like, oh that was good. And then the next person responds and you’re like, oh damn they got him and then the person responds back with another thing. It’s this unexpected one-upping like I say using that tool of quick twist in dialogue. A slow burn. Reveal or Reversal that Shane Black, I think he’s particularly proud of, and it’s pretty awesome too, is Long Kiss Goodnight.
So that’s Geena Davis. In this movie, Geena Davis is an assassin. She doesn’t know it. She’s living the life at home. It gets triggered at some point and she becomes uber amazing assassin again. It’s in the beginning. Her daughter is skating on the ice and her daughter falls down and hurts her arm. The scene becomes about Geena Davis going, get up, don’t be weak. And this really fierce, ferocious way of mothering. And the daughter is terrified because she’s like, I’ve not ever seen this side of my. And for us, it’s a glimpse into this. Assassin that she used to be that she’s not quite understanding yet. Anyway, in this whole scene, we think it’s about that.
This glimpse into her as an assassin, which it sort of is, but this is a hidden slow burn set of payoff. So when the daughter falls, she hurts her arm enough to get a cast. And so the rest of the movie, the daughter has a cast on her arm. Geena Davis has to leave to go on this mission with Samuel L. Jackson, his character. She tells her daughter, just light a candle in the window for mommy and I’ll come back. Like a vigil. Every night, just light a candle and that’ll let me know that you’re still thinking about me. And the daughter keeps the matches in her cast. Shows the light and she slips them in her cast.
Well, that is the setup. The daughter falling down, banging up her arm, getting the cast. All this stuff is all this subtle setup for the payoff. Because later, Geena Davis and her daughter get stuck and put into a cooler, like a large walk-in freezer, and they’re just meant to be left there and freeze to death. So, one of the things that Geena Davis has done while she’s being kicked around by the bad guys and running away with her daughter is, she takes this baby doll that she finds as a container and fills it with gasoline. So, she’s got all this gasoline, she doesn’t know what to do with it. She comes up with this idea, the way to get the door off and everything, is to use [unclear] as some sort of device to flow the gasoline under the door, the way she bends it.
But she has nothing to ignite this thing with to do what she wants to do. And she’s smacking this iron against the metal floor to try to create a spark. She’s doing everything she can and all of a sudden her daughter, now I have a complaint about this, but all of a sudden her daughter pulls the matches out that she uses to light the candle and says, mommy, will these help? And this, I mean, we’re talking a setup and payoff that’s a slow burn and across the entirety of the second act, it was done in act one and it shows back up in act three. But my one thing is this. Listen, kid, you’ve been watching your mom smack that floor with that metal thing for how long before you decide to pull out the matches?
Devin: In one of my examples, too, I have I have a bit of a logic frustration with it.
Adam: Anyway, that’s a slow burn, literally and figuratively both. But that’s that’s the differentiation. Between like a quick, quick twist is like the Haystack game and a slow burn for him is that. But our slow burn, what you and I, Devin, call it is it’s just simple setups and payoffs.
[Sponsor message]
Adam: Fighting positions! Way out!
Devin: I just don’t know why you’d ever want to bring back Cobra Kai.
Adam: We do not train to be merciful here. Mercy is for the weak. You may know the moves, but none of that matters unless you have balance.
Devin: Are you ready to learn the way of the fist? Yes, yes, yes!
Adam: Johnny, you and I, this, we aren’t done. You and I, this, we aren’t done.
Devin: The seven seconds that I was talking about before, brilliant.
Adam: Do you need to give a spoiler alert since it’s new? I do.
Devin: Okay. Yep, that falls into the, so, spoiler alert. You heard him say it, folks. That’s right. We binged it last weekend. Just the quick premise is a 15-year-old black boy is biking home and he’s killed in a hit-and-run accident, and the guy driving the car was a white cop. It’s in Jersey City. It takes place in Jersey City, and like what’s happening now, it became this huge racial tension, and there’s protests and stuff outside of the police precinct or police departments, and the story basically explores the aftermath of the accident, which includes cover-up attempts by the police departments and a ton of lies and scaring witnesses and killing witnesses.
So it’s pretty intense, and there’s an assistant prosecutor that takes on the case, and she tries to find justice for the boy and his family, and so she kind of goes up against all of this corruptness within the police department. The quick reversal part, that example that I’m going to use, happens towards the end in the actual trial for the case against the cops. So there’s four cops involved, and there’s many times throughout the story where… They finally find evidence to put them away, and then minutes later, the evidence is lost, the evidence is destroyed, someone steals it and gets rid of it, and so it’s just like this up-and-down rollercoaster of frustration.
And the scene at the end, or towards the end, the prosecutor is charging the white officer with both automobile homicide… Autohomicide. Autohomicide, and I can’t remember exactly what they’re called, but some racial crime, racial hate crime. So one of her arguments in the court is she brings this mannequin in and dresses it like the boy, and she was using it basically as a device to add some emotion, and so it’s a physical device or tool that the jury could see, and she’s like, this is basically him, and this is what he was doing. And the officer saw him, and he hit him, and then he covered it up, nobody tried to help him, and they left him there to die.
And then the defense attorney, who’s just a raging biatch, basically takes this tool, like literally right after she uses it to try to add a bit of humanity, or like so they could actually see something, and she takes it, and she puts the hood on, and she ties the hood, and she’s like, you know, when he was found, he had a hood on, right? And he had a hood. It was tied tight, and then she takes it and turns the mannequin sideways, so the jury are now the people that would, they would be in the perspective of driving the car, and she’s like, can you see the color of this person’s, of this face?
And she’s like, they’re like, nope. Instantly, she uses this mannequin against her, basically saying, you know, and then she immediately says, dismiss the racial hate crime.
Adam: Right. That’s a setup payoff, like happening with an instance of each other, is what you’re saying. That’s a setup payoff, too.
Devin: Yeah.
Adam: Yeah.
Devin: Yeah.
Adam: Okay.
Devin: And so for me, my logic, the thing that was frustrating for me was like, so now the prosecutor should have got up and threw the mannequin on the ground, had the jury stand up and stand over it, and say, now can you see the color of this person’s face? Because that’s what happened. Like, he could have got out of the car and noticed it was a black boy, and then decided not to help him. And he still could have been charged with that racial hate crime, but she didn’t. And part of that is character. Part of that’s part of her character, where she was so flustered.
Oh, you’re saying that’s the logic gap? That was my logic gap.
Adam: Well, that’s not necessarily a logic gap. When you were saying it was a logic gap for me, too, I’m like, so he hit the person. It doesn’t mean that he didn’t see what he looked like afterwards and didn’t help him. Exactly.
Devin: And so part of me was like,. If I were in her shoes, this is what I would have done, rather than understanding that she was so flustered and emotionally destroyed, that she wouldn’t have brought that up. But then it was never even brought up later. It wasn’t even addressed where she could have said, well, man, what I should have done, all I had to do was have the jury stand over the boy like he would have and those other cops would have stood there and looked at him.
Adam: But you say the series overall is awesome. You loved it, right?
Devin: It’s fantastic. It’s really, really, really good. Yeah, I would recommend it. And it’s very what’s going on right now with all, you know, the big divide between the police and stuff like that.
Adam: Yeah. Or what’s been, you mean what’s been going on for decades?
Devin: Yeah, exactly. That we just hear about it more because people can now voice their opinion openly without the bias of media.
Adam: God bless the internet.
Devin: If people do watch it, and there’s some things that we’ve talked about before. It’s kind of a side note is there’s brilliant displays of subtext. And it also shows the importance of character development, because all of these characters play their roles and they’re written so perfectly. And especially the main antagonist, D’Angelo, is this terrible, ruthless, manipulating SOB, man. And you absolutely hate him throughout nearly the entire series. Yeah. And the writers brilliantly give him scenes where you don’t think he could be any more terrible and worse of a person than he is. And then he he does it. He trumps in it just is disgusting. It makes the final and the the other thing they did really well was they didn’t. It’s certainly not a it’s not a happy ending. It’s a real life crappy ending is what it is.
And I commend. The writers for for it’s like, this is what happens. So there’s just this frustration.
Adam: You have the same fantastic resolution that we talked about with losing the game. Yeah. The bad guy getting away. Yep. It’s the resolution that is meant more for philosophical purposes than it is for audience gratification.
Devin: Right? It’s it’s it’s almost like no, you’re not listening. People aren’t listening to what’s actually happening in the media and what the media is reporting. And so we’re going to make this a narrative. And we’re going to turn this into a series. And make it where you think you’re watching an entertaining series and all of a sudden you’re slapped in the face with some reality and the message is incredibly clear by the end of the by the end of the series, you’re like, wow, is that really what’s happening and what it’s really doing, which is very important and and something that I think all writers and filmmakers and things like that would love to have happen when people leave or leave the theater, they close the book is it starts discussion.
Yeah, and it’s the discussions and everything that happened happened. Beyond the story, and it shines, it shines light on things that people may or may not have been aware of.
Adam: And this also goes back to a lot of stuff we say throughout season one here, which is there’s a difference between good stories and great stories, good stories, they might be entertaining, but great stories are stories that continue to tell themselves in your mind once you put them down or walk out of the theater, they’re meant to pose quick, they’re not meant to answer all questions, they’re meant to pose questions that you can think about and elaborate on in your own. Mind outside the theater, if you’re not close minded, there’s plenty of people who are going to watch that movie and immediately side with the police, because there’s this mindset that they have to maintain, right?
And so they’re going to find everything that they can do to defend and deny these new thoughts from entering their brain. The way your brain gets programmed in a way is, is sort of strange. If you have a very strong belief system, or the way you’ve been thinking, or a perspective. It’s, it is hard to reprogram that thing, even if you want to, because it’s almost like a survival mechanism, if you start to challenge your own beliefs, you start to feel threatened in a way, when you do it yourself, it’s not nearly as bad, you’re just sort of thinking, but when other people do it in presenting an idea to you and telling you a story and any of these things.
I would love to see what this story has to say. If it’s too preachy, now you’re hearing what the author or the writer has to say.
Devin: Right.
Adam: There are so many stories that I’ve experienced in my life that are just, I can’t even explain the impact they have on me because the end result of that story was a new way of me thinking about or experiencing. My life, like I never thought of it that way before and then changing, but it may not be even the greatest movie, but if it is this one thing that helps you cross that, like any character, cross that threshold in your life, in your belief system to a new place of transformation, it’s impacting. And it’s important.
Devin: The other element of this series, when you’re analyzing it from a story in a writing standpoint, and we’ve talked about it before, is the importance of having your audience relate or empathize with the antagonist.
Adam: Do they do that in this story? I thought you were saying they make him really repugnant.
Devin: Well, they do, but they have moments. There’s moments. She does give him scenes where you see the human side of him, where he has, where he’s really, he really. Cares about, for some reason, this, this cop that is the actual person that hit him. So the cop, the one cop that’s on trial hits the kid and kills the kid and calls him. And he comes and says, just get, get the heck out of here. I’ll clean this up. But there’s other scenes where, where you actually, you understand what’s at stake for him and why he’s doing it. It’s not, you don’t, you don’t necessarily agree with it, but it’s like, if I was in his shoes.
Adam: Reasoning. It’s what you were saying. You at least have to understand the antagonist’s reasoning.
Devin: Exactly. And then there’s all the other cops. Two of the cops have, one had just, the one had just had a baby. They’re just starting families. There’s, they have wives. There’s other people. There’s a lot of, family involved, you know, where, where, you know, so you, you’re seeing both there, they show both sides of the, of the story, which is important. So it’s not just this black boy was killed by these white cops. And we’re only going to, we’re only going to give you insight and, and view of the store of their story, the family story against the cops. You are actually spend a lot of time with the cops and the innocent people on their side, who they’re also lying to the, your line there, you’re lying to their wives and their girlfriends. And they’re, they just have, they have young children and, and things like that. So there’s, you see the, you see both sides of the fence.
Adam: And so even though you do, even though you do, the way you’re describing these guys is they’re still lying. They’re still liars. They’re still, absolutely. That’s sort of my question is the lens on them is still villain, even though the people around them are innocent and we’re getting to see that aspect of their world, they’re not portrayed with a lot of compassion. There’s no, we don’t get to see too much of their compassionate side. We get the lens on them, but we don’t get to see
Devin: Them as still bad guy is still antagonist, right? Their lens. Yeah. The lens on most of them is how do we save ourselves? Like very selfish lens, but then, but the lens on the actual young cop that, that, that was the actual person that hit and killed the boy, there’s a different lens on him. And you almost relate more to him because he just simply made some bad decisions. He called his superiors, his superiors told him to, you know, he, they like get away. And he’s like, and so the entire time, the entire series, he’s incredibly conflicted. And in fact, he’s so conflicted and they don’t give him a ton of dialogue. A lot of his are looks the law. A lot of his on screen is, is, is looking down emotion. So you’re, what you would say is sub subtextual translation on screen. Yeah. And you don’t know.
Exactly what is going through his mind until the very end when he actually, there’s a point I remember telling my girlfriend, we were watching, I’m like, he’s going to, he’s going to roast him. He’s going to come clean. He’s going to tell the truth, because this is eating him up inside. He just had a young boy. Oh, wow. And so he’s relating this. He’s like, I just took somebody’s boy. If somebody took my boy from me. Yeah, yeah. You know, so that’s what I the conflict is inner conflict that he was having. And then he blows it out of the water by lying and saying, nope, it was just me. I hit the boy and I drove I wrote off by myself. And so you’re like, what do you think you had the perfect opportunity to come clean? And he doesn’t do it. So he throws on throws it on its head.
Adam: It’s playing with the audience expectation is. Yeah. Like I say, when I talk about Breaking Bad a lot, that season finale for that show, I literally went into that finale and I had no clue what direction it was going to take. How is this going to wrap itself up? Where are we going? What you have many theories, but because the characters were created so dynamically and they have so many variations on viewpoint, like, for instance, with your your cop here, he’s done this thing. He doesn’t want to get in trouble for it. He does the wrong thing in trying to fix it, cover it up, whatever. And now he’s stuck. But we can see him sweating it out and not knowing what he’s going to do, because we can see he has a doubt in one direction and fear in the other. He’s sort of wrestling between those two points.
Well, that’s great, because an experienced storyteller like you still was going, I wonder if he’s going to squeal. Right. I wonder if he’s going to. And that’s where you really want your audiences. If you’re that strong of a writer or clever of a writer, just to keep even your seasoned writers on the edge of their seat going, it’s set up so brilliantly that either way this guy could go and you’re still able to enjoy that story instead of going, well, it’s obvious it’s going to go this way. It’s obvious it’s going to. Right.
Not exploring your characters deep enough, pushing them deeper, treating them like real people who think a different thought. And here, going back to quick twist reversals, the most dynamic thing that young cop can have going on in his eyes, in his mind as a performer, the translation from the writing to the screen is back and forth between that doubt and fear. I’m so scared that my family’s going to fall apart. And then it’s like. I can’t believe I’m in with these snakes. These guys are worse than I thought.
Devin: Mm-hmm.
Adam: That stuff going on in that character’s eyes, not only is it this, like Devin had said back in the subtext episode, it’s the translation. It’s very specific subtext. It’s the translation on screen. What a performer chooses to do to express the subtext. It’s when I write in a script silence and expect that character to, the actor to do the work. The narrative says, look, this guy’s vacillating and reciting. We’re wrestling between doubt and fear and doubt and fear.
Devin: Yeah.
Adam: That needs to be played off of the dialogue that’s happening out loud. He’s not saying anything. So how does that get played? In that person’s mind is the quick twist. In that character’s perspective, what is happening is that back and forth and back and forth and back and forth. Right. It may not be that the conversation, and I’m speculating about the show because I’ve never seen it. In conversations where the other cops are, would be discussing something like this. Yeah. If he’s quiet and sort of going back and forth. We’re most interested in him, as you said, maybe he’s going to tell the truth, maybe he’s going to come clean. We’re interested in that wrestling match he’s got going on because that’s the quick twist that’s popping in that scene.
Right. And you can do that. Give one character this and then have the scene function in a general way with the other police officers could be speaking and he’s just listening. But where the audience is having the most thrilling experience by our guessing of his internal response. We get to, if there’s nothing else we’re learning from the scene, it’s investigating this guy’s psyche and emotional state a little more just by guesstimating.
Devin: It’s also a fascinating character. It’s a character analysis of decision. Like the story doesn’t even get past the first five minutes without that character making a choice. There’s other, instead of calling the police and say, I accidentally, it really wasn’t a hate crime because he actually did just hit the kid and he notices later the bikes underneath his wheel and he, so, but it’s a decision instead of calling the police and saying, his kid came out of nowhere, I hit him and he’s there, he’s there at the scene and then it’s just a bad accident. Just that it happened. He calls these other cops, these other cops. Then that’s when they start, instead of making things right, they take out their proverbial shovels and just start digging hole after hole and gets deeper and deeper and deeper. And that’s the fascinating part of it.
Adam: It’s a series of poor choices that define what they develop as.
Devin: And they just compound each other. Because you try to cover one up. It’s just like lying. You know, it’s like, it’s, once you start lying, it’s just a slippery slope type of, type of a deal. Because once you, once you tell a lie, then you have to remember that lie. You get a lie for the lie and lie for the lie. And then you have to lie for a lie. And then it’s like, at some point, you, you forget. You make, you make mistakes and stuff like that. So it’s, it’s like one of those things like, why didn’t he just call the police?
Adam: It’s one of my favorite quotes from Mark Twain is, an honest man doesn’t need to remember anything. Yeah. That’s fat. Yeah. That’s great. I do love Mark Twain.
Devin: Yeah. He’s awesome. I only had one, I have one other quick example. Perfect Storm. This isn’t necessarily a spoiler alert because it doesn’t fall within my five year period. And I’m really not talking much about the film. It’s just this one scene that’s kind of highlighting what we’re talking about. But it’s just to set it up. It’s, they’re out fishing. They’re not catching anything. So they decide to go, keep going east to the Flemish Cap. And while they’re there, they’re killing it. They’re catching a ton of fish or swordfish. Well, swordfish, they’re fish. And the news breaks that there’s three separate weather fronts on a collision course off the coast of Massachusetts where they, they have to go back to and they have to unload it.
And so they’re, they’re posed with that, that question of, do we stay put or take on a storm? If they stay put, they’re going to, they’re, they’ll run out of ice and then the catch will rot and they’ll lose that and any money they would make, or they can try to go through the storm and make it back and unload and, and, and make money. And then they, of course they make the fatal decision to, to brave the storm. There’s a bunch of different details during this part. So, so once they start taking on the storm, the color grading that they use becomes very dark and all the colors are washed, washed.
And so it’s, it’s, it’s a, it’s an interesting, and you probably wouldn’t notice it if, if you don’t overanalyze things like I do. And it’s, it’s a bit of a setup too. And so you’re kind of, they’re kind of, they’ve, it’s just threshold. It’s a threshold moment.
Adam: It’s an interesting threshold moment. I like the, I like the color change threshold moment.
Devin: They get into this violent fight with the storm and they’re in this like small fishing boat is being tossed around these enormous waves. And then suddenly they break through. And it’s just calm. The sun begins to, to peek through, through the clouds and it comes through the, the portholes of the, of the boat and it’s on their faces. So their faces, all of a sudden there’s color again on their face and you can see the color of their shirts and it’s, it’s, it’s warm. You know, you feel like they, they did it. They made it. They beat, they beat the, they beat the storm. And then just as suddenly darkness and they don’t show.
So the decision, whoever directed this, the decision to have this moment while you’re looking at their faces: their faces go from sunlight to, you can see the sun just disappear again, and the sky becomes enveloped with darkness again. And they realize that they’re in the eye of the storm. They didn’t make it through the storm; they’re in the eye of the storm. It’s kind of like this false victory, where the storm gives it to you and then takes it away really quickly. For 10 to 15 seconds you feel like, and they all feel like, they made it through the storm, and then it’s taken away from them just that quickly.
Adam: That’s a great reversal. That’s a perfect example of a quick twist reversal. Setup, payoff, boom, boom, right there.
Devin: And different in so many different elements. You’re in all these dark blues, and then for a moment, you have this like bit of light, this hope and warmth. And then the storm decides to kind of confirm its power again. And it rips that hope right from them. And you can see it on their faces as the sun leaves their faces, the emotion on their face, that hope, you can actually see the sun take the hope away with that with it. And it’s amazing. And then it’s you, you kind of realize with them that they’re not. And in fact, George Clooney’s character says it’s not going to let she’s not going to let her.
It’s not going to let us out. And so it’s like you, we all are basically, we’re on the boat with them knowing that we’re going to, we’re not going to make it through. We’ll fight until the end, but we’re not, they all know they’re going to die on this, on this boat. They all die. And so it’s, yeah, they’re all, they’re all dead. Well, there’s no point in watching it now. It’s a true story. It’s all based on a true story. And I was actually out there. I saw where they, where they left. And I actually had a beer at the crow’s nest this summer.
Adam: How does one tell a firsthand account of a true story when everyone died?
Devin: Well, they had a bunch of radio contact with them up until the last minute when radio went down. And so they basically put pieces together and they’re said, we know last time we heard from them, they, they were going out to the Flemish cap. And then the other, other captains were like, why do you like, don’t go out there? Like, you’re not going to, you know, because it happened in, I think it was October. And so it was like, that’s storm season. Storm season in the, in the Eastern seaboard. And cause it happened, they’re out of Gloucester, Massachusetts. Of course, they’re taking pieces of the puzzle and they’re trying to figure out what happened to it. It’s kind of like Everest, you know.
Adam: It’s not autobiographical apparently.
Devin: Yeah. You don’t know the end scene when they’re talking, what they said to each other. Like, you don’t know what was happening on, on the boat.
Adam: That’s an interesting set of reversals. That’s pretty interesting. I like the, I like the fact that the color changed, the tone changed. That’s a good one. It’s subtle, but. That’s a good one. The only one I had left was a dialogue. Well, it’s sort of, it’s plot oriented, but the quick twist aspect to this larger setup payoff reversal go hand in hand. Like, it’s like a slow burn and a quick twist together. It’s by far like the number one example. And I’ll, the only reason I say this is because every screenwriting book that I’ve read, every storytelling book that says, here’s what you do. They always cite this, this movie and this scene. And I’m even, I’m going to tell you this story authors, even when I give you this example, those of you who have not seen this movie, I don’t think, because I’m, I don’t want to spoil any larger elements for anybody in any story. Devin, I like it. We say Devin’s brutal. It doesn’t matter. 20 years, five years. I prefer to dance around it. So you still get to watch it. But this one, even if I tell you straight up, it will not hinder the impact. I mean, you’ll still know ahead of time.
Yeah. But I read the, the analysis of this scene before I’d seen the movie and then watching the movie, I was still in, in all of it, in shock of it. But I am going to give a spoiler because it’s one of the one, a great movie, Chinatown. And it’s came out ages ago, but it’s climaxes. Excellent. I’m going to set this up for you and explain to you what we’re looking at. And most of you who have seen this movie, you already know what I’m talking about. The premise of the movie is that this private eye played by Jack Nicholson. I’ve never seen this. It’s awesome.
It’s like in reverse. Finally, there’s a movie Devin hasn’t seen that I have. Basically, it’s an, it’s a mystery. It’s an investigation. Jack Nicholson’s character gets hired to investigate Hollis Mulwray. Okay. It’s this guy who works at the Los Angeles Department of Water. So he’s investigating this whole thing as a private eye. And the police side of the investigation is Lieutenant Escobar. And they keep sort of, you know, they work with each other a little bit, but they get in each other’s way. It’s sort of the classic back and forth between private eye and police. He’s investigating this whole thing. And Faye Dunaway’s character is Evelyn Mulwray. She plays the widow of Hollis Mulwray, the guy who was murdered. And of course, you’re suspicious of all these people. She’s, she seems like she might be innocent, like she might not be innocent. You’re not sure. Her father, he goes and talks to her father for a bit. And he’s sort of like this very powerful man, her father. And you’re not sure. Is he involved? Who’s involved? What’s going on?
What’s going on? And throughout this whole investigation, he starts to notice this mysterious woman, young woman. And he starts to think that this is Mulwray’s mistress. And he can’t, hasn’t quite figured it out. And he’s got this theory that it’s all Evelyn. And he’s been falling in love a little bit here and there with her. Because, you know, she’s an attractive lady. She’s a damsel in distress. It sort of like sets him up in this. So he finds out that this… This young woman is in Evelyn Mulwray’s house, and he thinks, oh, this woman’s going to die next. Like, she’s in danger. And so he tells Lieutenant Escobar, yo, you have to go to her house. I’m headed there now to confront her. And so the police are on the way, right? So we have this whole scene set up with a ticking time bomb. He’s going to expose her as the murderer, right? It’s this Sherlock scene.
And we know he’s right, because he found her husband’s eyeglasses in her fish pond at their house, but that’s not where the body was discovered. And so he knows he was killed at the house and moved somewhere. All his bets are on the fact that she’s the guilty party. So he goes there to get the truth. He shows up, and the police are on the way, and he just tells her, he goes, I want to know the truth about the girl upstairs. Who is she? Yeah. And the answer is, and by this point, he’s really, I don’t want to just jump into this, because he does slap her around in this scene. He’s been pushing this and pushing this and pushing this, and he’s very angry, and she’s always avoiding questions and not telling him the truth. And she’s been lying to him on and off throughout the whole thing.
So he asks her, who is this girl upstairs? And she waits for a little bit, and then she goes, she’s my daughter. And he slaps her, and he said, I want the truth. I want the truth from you. And she says, she’s my sister. He slaps her again. She’s my daughter. So here are the quick twists. You’re like, what is she doing? What is she doing? She’s just lying. She can’t even stick to the truth. So he slaps her. My sister, my daughter, it’s back and forth, right? She’s frantic. He’s trying to get the truth from her. The police are on their way. And then after he says one last time, I said I want the truth, she screams out, she’s my sister and my daughter.
Silence. And he just lets that sink in with the audience. It just sinks in for the audience and him.
Devin: I was just trying to figure that out in my head.
Adam: And in case you don’t catch on quick enough, she says, my father and I, or is that too hard for you?
Devin: God, that’s messed up.
Adam: So the reversal is this what seems like a lie, back and forth and back and forth and back and forth and back and forth. And all these things and setups and pieces that he’s learned about this mysterious woman, she’s trying to protect her because, and this is a big McKee, if you haven’t read Robert McKee’s story, his concept of the spectrum of the value system of positive, negative, the in-between, what I would call maybe a lukewarm, and then what’s called the negation of the negation, which is the extreme villain, like criminal posing as justice, right? It’s the flip of it all. But I don’t want to spoil this too much because his breakdown of this is amazing.
Within this scene, you get this absolute reversal of the slow burn setup payoff. We’re set up thinking this is it. He’s figured it out. Her father is really the villain. And she was hoping he’d find him and find him out, which he does in this scene. I mean, he doesn’t like the dude when he interviews with him. But at the same time, this is the scene when it all comes. And now the police are on the way. And so it’s this pressure cooker scene when the truth has to come out. And not only is the truth itself a reversal and subverts our expectations of, I completely didn’t expect any of that at all.
One of the best surprise endings or surprise moments in a story ever. The ending is much different. That’s sort of the crisis, I would say. The climax is what precipitates after this. Which is him trying to help. Help them get out of the country. Nicholson’s character. So not only is it a reversal of our expectations throughout the course of the entire story up until this point. But the building of it to the revelation of it, to the reveal, is her back and forth quick twist. She’s my daughter. She’s my sister. She’s my daughter. She’s my sister. And more slaps from him. It’s like, what is going on?
It’s this back and forth ping pong match. And then finally, boom. She’s my sister. She’s my daughter. And you’re like, wow. Yeah. There’s this huge, intense moment of, like I said, it’s amazing. And even though this is sort of spoiling the event itself, I mean, it’s Jack Nicholson and Faye Dunaway, folks. You got to watch it. It’s so good. The description is nothing close to their performances. Watching it is amazing. That’s sort of what I would say combining a long-term slow burn. You know, classic set of payoff and then this quick twist thing.
Devin: A good one.
Adam: I love it because it suddenly makes, and it doesn’t even try too hard. It makes your audience the detective. It forces them to become a detective for that moment. What does that mean? It means that, oh, oh. And they don’t say anything until they have enough of a beat for you to go, did you figure it out yet? And then she says, which I love, it’s sort of like a writer line too, my father and I, or is that too hard for you?
Devin: Yeah, yeah.
Adam: It’s poking fun at the audience members who might be too slow, or is that too hard for you? It totally is. Which I love.
Devin: It’s brilliant. I know you’re all trying to do the math.
Adam: The math. Yeah. But it’s so clever, that line. Or is it too hard for you?
Devin: That was me. I was like, wait a minute, how’s that work?
Adam: That’s it for me for examples. I think we killed this episode, Devin.
Devin: We did. Talk about a slow burn. We got to it, though.
Adam: Please subscribe and rate us on iTunes. And for additional story-related resources, video, and archived content, visit our website at StoryOsophy.com.