Season 1, episode 21

Mystery, Suspense, and Dramatic Irony

April 4, 20181 hr 1 min

Show notes

Mystery, suspense and dramatic irony aren’t just genres; they’re tools you can use in any story. All three come down to one question: who knows what, the audience or the characters? Working from Robert McKee’s Story, Adam and Devin define each tool, show how the best storytellers switch between them, and share a quick fix for any scene that isn’t working.

In this episode

  • Three tools, defined by perspective. In mystery, the audience knows less than the characters. In suspense, they know the same. In dramatic irony, the audience knows more.
  • Three reactions. Mystery stirs curiosity, suspense builds anticipation, and dramatic irony makes the audience worry.
  • No danger required. Murder and monsters are the easy way in, but these tools work just as well in a romantic comedy or a drama.
  • Who, how and why. Devin notes that knowing who did it is no longer enough: audiences need the “why done it” too. It’s why antagonists need to be relatable.
  • Hitchcock’s bomb. Devin reads Hitchcock’s famous explanation to François Truffaut: a bomb that surprises the audience gives them 15 seconds of shock; a bomb they know about gives them 15 minutes of suspense.
  • Adam’s trick for a scene that isn’t working. Run it through all three lenses: what if the audience knew less, the same, or more than the characters? One version will play better.
  • Switch between them. David Fincher moves between all three within a single film, and you can apply different tools to different characters in the same scene.
  • Track what the audience knows. Treat it like a measurement, page by page. Most writers can’t tell what’s in their head from what’s on the page.
  • Research makes better clues. Sir Arthur Conan Doyle made Sherlock Holmes brilliant because he knew the science himself.

Examples discussed

  • Sherlock Holmes: we’re Watson, until Sherlock gets ahead of us and explains it all at the end.
  • Se7en: the antagonist does the explaining, on the drive into the desert.
  • The Silence of the Lambs: the SWAT team storms the wrong house while Clarice knocks on the right one.
  • Misery: suspense with Paul, dramatic irony with Annie when he hides the match.
  • How to Lose a Guy in 10 Days: two secret bets, and the audience knows both.
  • Game Night and the Star Wars prequels as dramatic irony.
  • Also: Murder, She Wrote, Columbo, Scream, Gone Girl, Oldboy, The Hangover, The Truman Show, Bates Motel and the Saw films.

Writing along with the season? Take a scene that isn’t working and rewrite it three ways: as mystery, as suspense and as dramatic irony.

Read the full transcript

Transcribed automatically, so expect the odd misheard word. Sponsor messages are left out.

Adam: Toolbox. Next on StoryOsophy. Hello, welcome to StoryOsophy. This is Adam Jones.

Devin: And Devin Halden.

Adam: Okay. Let’s redo that. I clipped big time.

Devin: I’m sure. You did.

Adam: Hello, welcome to StoryOsophy. This is Adam Jones. And Devin Halden. This episode, we are talking about mystery, suspense, and dramatic irony. These are three of my favorite tools to use in storytelling. And we want to make sure that we differentiate between mystery as a genre and mystery applied as a tool. So to start off, we’re going to give some real simple definitions. A lot of what we’re going to be discussing this week is based in Robert McKee’s book, Story. Yes, it’s just called Story. We talk about it a good bit. You’ll hear it on some of the commercial breaks. Audible has an audiobook version of it. I think it’s abridged, unfortunately. But you’ll still get the tidbits that you need. If nothing else, it’s a great book to help with

Devin: Your storytelling toolkit in general. I think it’s actually narrated on Audible by Robert McKee. Which is, it’s kind of nice to hear the voice of the author.

Adam: It is. It always is nice. Just to sell that book in general, it’s one of those books that I go to a lot. I love McKee’s philosophies on storytelling, just like Vogler and Campbell, Joseph Campbell, and a lot of these other folks. Is there anybody else that you would add to that mix, Devin, that you…

Devin: Vogler and McKee are probably the two that I, those are my go-tos. Those are the books that I always have sitting on my desk. So those are kind of my go-to. You like Snyder, Blake Snyder? I like the way that he structures story. I don’t agree with all the elements. He’s good for beats. He’s good for beats in your super objectives. Yeah, he’s really good for that. Yeah. Beat sheet. Yeah, he does the beat sheet. But I like his simplification of story, which I think is very important. And then if you… So that’s kind of like a story 101 course, I guess, would be good to see. They do a very… He has a couple of different books. And he actually has one book that I like better than Save the Cat. It’s Save the Cat Goes to the Movies. That’s when he actually takes actual films and dissects them through his beat sheet. So yeah, he’s good.

Adam: I’m not well-versed in Snyder. I know some stuff just from the beat sheets. They’re just used a lot throughout the industry. So I’ve become familiar with them, but I’ve not actually read a lot of those Save the Cat stuff. And like I said, you can find all these guys that we talk about the Audible link, audibletrial.com slash StoryOsophy. And you can hear a lot of the stories. Regarding Robert McKee, the reason I mentioned him is even if you just get that, just read the section or listen to the section about mystery, suspense, and dramatic irony, it’s really great to add to your toolkit. Now we’re going to explore beyond what he talks about. I’ll give you his definitions or sort of the broader definitions of those first. Like I said, we won’t be talking genre, just those three things as tools. So get out a pen and write down these definitions. If you give me a heads up, this is good stuff to write down. They all deal with perspective. In mystery, the audience knows less than the characters. In suspense, the audience and characters know the same information.

In dramatic irony, the audience knows more than the characters. Here’s why I think these are the most important tools. All of them engage an audience on a curiosity level, and human beings are curious creatures. So each one of these is a different way of viewing the details in the story that you’re either watching or creating yourself. And it’s important to quickly note this too. Those three things don’t require danger in order to apply them. Most mystery suspense genre movies, they do use danger. That’s sort of it’s cops and robbers and murderers. And so danger is a huge element, but you don’t have to use it to use any of those three tools on your writing.

There are some times when you have a story where some characters know more than your audience, and some characters know less or the same. A lot of murder mysteries with detectives, you know the same as the detective, but there are plenty of other characters in the story, i.e. The murderers, who know more than you do. They know all that stuff. The idea is you sync up with the main character, the detective, who’s navigating you through the story. And so it will bounce between a lot of these. It usually thrives on just suspense. You know the same as the detective.

And you’re playing detective with them. Sometimes you’ll know less than the detective. Like you’ll find something and have this look on his face and you’ll go, what does that mean? And then the next scene will sort of pay it off. And it’s just meant to bait you to the next scene, but you’re sort of on the same page. There’s a little mystery there. And a lot of other times you’ll see like a scene separate from the detective where some murder weapon kills someone, but you don’t see the hand. You only see the hand holding it, but not the person. Or a black glove. So you don’t know who done it. And in that case, it’s dramatic irony. I’m not really a big fan of the phrasing dramatic irony, but we’re going to use it because everyone knows it.

But in those situations, you know more than the detective at that point, but probably only for a scene or two before someone goes, Lieutenant such and such or whatever, there’s a new dead body. Here. We think it’s related. Then they catch up and you’re in suspense again. It’s sort of a loose, rough definition. Devin, did you have anything you wanted to, to initially add to, to defining these things?

Devin: For me, mystery and suspense are more lean in types of storytelling where you’re getting the audience to, to more of like the edge of your seat types of storytelling. Whereas dramatic irony is more of a, Hey, sit back and enjoy the show type of story. Though, of course, both, you know, you’re going to have elements of all of like you just touched upon. You’re going to have a lot of times they’re going to be paid off fairly quickly.

Adam: It’s also worry. It engages your worry a lot. The other two are more, they engage your curiosity and dramatic irony amps up because you know more than the characters. If there’s an axe murderer behind that door and they’re creeping down the hall, it engages your sense of worry in that way.

Devin: For the most part with mystery, we’re going, like you said, we’re kind of the right hand man of the antagonist or we’re kind of. With them or not the antagonist, the protagonist, the hero, and we’re figuring it out with them.

Adam: Although the other makes a damn good story.

Devin: Right. But there’s also I feel like there’s always a point at the end of the story where the hero becomes more knowledgeable than we are in almost almost. In a way of like. The heroes kind of telling us like, Hey, I figured this out. I didn’t let you in on it. Oh. And he kind of explains it to you. So that may be very vague.

Adam: I get exactly what you’re saying. You can do it with like any sort of old detective. Yeah. TV show, movie, Columbo, where he figures it out, but you don’t get to know at this point because the whole fun of it for you as an audience member is you get to figure it out now with the antagonist, the murderer, when he exposes them. Yeah, exactly. And so you’re more on there, like what’s going on? I don’t understand what he’s doing. It’s interesting because that example you’re giving, you sort of get flipped. You’re with Columbo or, or Jessica Fletcher from Murder, She Wrote. Yeah. That’s one of my examples. Yeah.

I love Angela Lansbury. More from Bedknobs and Broomsticks, one of my favorite Disney movies ever. Yeah, that’s good. That’s a good one. But in that they are investigating, you’re with them, you get the clues when they get the clues.

Devin: Right.

Adam: Possibly the only difference is the hook scene. You get to see the murder happen, but it’s very vague and some clues are left out. But you know, as much as they do the whole thing, you’re getting clue by clue by clue. And that, that is what I sort of attribute to a mystery, is the clue based thing, the what happened to so-and-so, the who stole the watch McCall it, that stuff. And so you’re questioning and you find these little nuggets and bits and pieces and clues. And then you get to the end. And like you’re saying, right before that big climactic, and it’s a staple in these, these type of shows, these, the reveal.

The climax is the reveal. Reveal of the murderer. And usually the protagonist, the hero, the detective explains it. And so right before they explain it, they don’t tell you anything in the story so that the climax has this drop, this boom.

Devin: That’s the brilliance of like the Sherlock Holmes stories where, and that’s one of my examples, but I can, I’ll just throw the example in now, where it’s where you’re with Sherlock for a lot of it. Because we’re, the audience is essentially Watson in a lot of those stories. We’re with Watson. Yeah, yeah. Sherlock always kind of knows more than we do. And then there’s a point of the story where Sherlock has it all figured out, doesn’t inform us that he has it all figured out, until this end mind-bending monologue. A little bit, every clue and you’re like, oh, oh, oh, and then.

Adam: That’s sort of a staple of all detective.

Devin: Yeah, sure. Murder, She Wrote was the same way.

Adam: Well, in that way, the ones we’ve just been talking about. Yeah. But Sherlock’s the best example because he’s just awesome. Yeah. Do you watch the? The latest with Benedict Cumberbatch?

Devin: No, I don’t. I don’t watch that. I actually, when I was in high school, I read all of them and even went back. I went back all the way to. Oh, wow. To the, the classic short stories that he wrote. I think they’re in like the, the Strand Magazine or whatever, like in the late 1800s, I found them online and they were just, they started off as just short, short. You went the real deal. Yeah. I traveled back in time. Bought a copy of the Strand and read all the Sherlock Holmes short stories in there. Do you still have that copy that you got back in time, Biff?

I do. I do. Yeah. And it was actually autographed by Sir Arthur Conan Doyle.

Adam: Oh, that’s awesome. I just want to say this too. You look at Sherlock Holmes as a character, right? He’s so vivid and real in pop culture in, in your, the cultural archives that some people who aren’t the brightest bulbs think he’s real. They think that’s a real person. Just like, you know, Jack the Ripper. They, you know, it’s the same. Do you know what I mean? They don’t, they, they don’t understand that he’s not, he’s a fictional character because he’s drawn that vividly. And I want to say this, an attribute to writers around the world forever and ever. Sherlock Holmes isn’t that brilliant. Sir Arthur Conan Doyle is.

Right. Exactly. Credit where credit is due. That’s really important to note because you look at him and you’re like, Sherlock Holmes is a freaking. And then you go, somebody wrote this fictionalized story. So whoever wrote the genius has to be more genius in that to be able to have created this scenario where all these little clues and all these little details that Sherlock Holmes observes and knows information about Sir Arthur Conan Doyle, the author needed to know all that information to apply it, which just to me, that’s mind blowing and admirable. I go, this guy’s brilliant.

Devin: All of the science that he uses in that, in those stories is legit. Like, like certain metals that will leave, you can leave a fingerprint on certain metals or like the moisture will like how it reacts to lead or whatever. All that, all the sciences that he uses is like, you look that stuff up. It’s pretty legit. Some of it obviously is the expounds a little bit and he adds a little bit of creativity to it. But a lot of it was, is, is very. Legit. And that’s the thing. It’s not just a, an antagonist tricking or getting or staying away from any clues and like not being picked up and not the, and here are in this case, Sherlock, not just figuring out who he is because of like very practical terms. It’s like literally Sherlock is able that it, it, whatever it would put your fingerprints on it. And you’re the only one that touched that fireplace poke.

Adam: That’s a lot of setup and payoff. That’s like really intricate and minute. And a lot of these, once again, we’re, we’re, Devin and I will sidetrack ourselves in this episode simply because mystery in and of itself as a thing, I am personally obsessed with. It’s, it’s the key to all writing. And I’m sure Devin, I think Devin is on, I mean, that’s why we both love Fincher because he’s a master of mystery and suspense. Absolutely. And we’ll dedicate an episode to.

Devin: It brings up another element that is important in there’s the how done it. And then there’s the why done it. It’s no, it’s no longer just satisfying to figure out who did it, who done it, what’d you say, who done it, how done it and why done it and why done it and how done it or can be interchangeable. Obviously, most of those are in the murder.

Adam: Those are the three, what you said are the three questions. We’re talking genre though right now too, instead of application of tool. Keep going with what you’re saying.

Devin: If you take TV series like Murder, She Wrote and Magnum P.I. And Sherlock, you know, the key component in all these TV series that we’re talking about is primarily the who done it and then followed by. But you see it play out in movies and in like the TV shows we’re talking about and and even video games. But then you also see it playing out in everyday media that tries to make sense of like the school shootings or Bernie Madoff’s Ponzi scheme and that type of storytelling where they’re. Where the audience like our primary objective when we’re watching something like that is like who who done it like who was doing this. But once we know know who that is it’s human nature to need to know the why done it. Well it’s human nature to know the why of human nature like why someone does this thing we need to know that. Yeah it’s cured that’s curiosity.

Adam: Curiosity like I was saying at the beginning of the episode that is the key element to a lot of storytelling. Remember that and it’s employed by the mystery and suspense but curiosity if you can tap into your audience’s curiosity you got them. They’ll watch the whole thing. They’ll watch a Shannon Doherty movie till three.

Devin: Also similar to the importance of making of why it’s important to make the antagonist relatable in a way to the to our audiences because we need to know we want to know why they chose to do something and understand it. Yeah to see if we can fathom doing the same thing if we were in their position. Yeah. Or we need to know why they did something so we can assure ourselves that we would not do that if we were in their position. Yeah. At first I kind of made a note where it was like who done it versus why done it and I’m like no you got to remove the versus because it’s more of like a yin and yang.

Adam: It’s all three. Yeah they’re all together. In any of those scenarios you’re the detective is looking at all three questions. One is the murderer. Two is as you say the how. There’s probably a better way of putting it but and the three is the motive. If you remember those three things in general and apply them at different points they don’t have to go in that order mind you either. Like you can start with the how it was done and know how the whole thing was done. Right. And that’s a lot of murder mysteries you start out with. That concept and then you move on to now who would have done this or why would they have done this that leads to one or the other. And sometimes the who is the surprise to the why they did it or the why is the surprise to who did it. You find out who did it and you’re like what. Like for instance going back to something we’ve been tracking.

Over the past handful of episodes scream. When you get to the end the why they did it is the big question. We’re like we don’t get it. Like why. Why are they the killers. And then you find out through a little bit. Like I said it’s not the greatest setup but they trickle it in a little bit is the it’s the backstory with the mother that that matters the most. For the clues. Right. And not the tricky boots on the sheriff. Right. Anyway I want to say something else about Arthur Conan Doyle before we moved on. Just as a side note, as a writer, it’s important to know a lot. If you’re writing about something you don’t know about, learn it to death. Learn it, read up on it, research it. And we’ve talked about this in research before. It’s fun. You will read a book on something. You will read an article on something that is based in like this character does this and you don’t do that, this profession.

So you read up on it and the details you get about it, you’ll be like, oh my gosh, that scene will be great for this. That scene will work. It will inspire your imagination beyond what you can even imagine because you don’t know it. Setups and payoffs will jump at you once you learn it. Exactly. All that stuff will just, you just start making notes like crazy. But before you even start that research, if you start thinking it’s like schoolwork or homework or something you don’t want to do, a chore versus a choice, research is going to be awful for you because it’s going to be like pulling teeth to get you.

But if you think of it as fun and playful, you’ll absorb all these amazing details that you can apply in your writing. I’ll say this too, just as a quick side note, it’s always important to absorb knowledge as the creator of the world and the characters. If you want them to be really intelligent characters, you have to be smarter than the character or at least equal to in what you’re building. Out of these three different tools you can use, mystery, suspense, and dramatic irony, you can combine them. You can combine them with the other three different tools. You can switch between them. And like I’ve said, we’re sort of in, like we did with the character archetypes episode, we sort of geared it towards or based on Joseph Campbell and Christopher Vogler’s works in story archetypes. In this, we’re sort of basing it on Robert McKee. So there are variations.

We do think a little differently than McKee, but it’s important to point these out. And also to note, there’s a difference between that mystery genre, which is sort of built, and there’s a suspense genre, too, I believe. But we’re talking specifically about applying them to your writing as part of your toolbox, your toolkit. You can switch between, Fincher does it all the time. He switches between all three of those throughout every single movie he makes. So the point is, it’s not just a genre in that term. It’s even though some of the movies that he’s done, Fight Club or Seven or, you know, any of these things, Social Network, Zodiac, all these movies that he’s got, he will switch between all three of those tools. Even though they’re classified as a mystery genre or a suspense genre, he will use these tools. And so specifically, we want to talk about the application of these tools to your writing to enhance it. Devin, did you have something you wanted to?

Devin: Yeah. And just to add on to that, of course, we don’t like to put things in boxes and label things. But when I’m writing mystery or an element of mystery within a story, I’m thinking about where am I placing these, the pieces of the puzzle, that I want the audience to pick up on and try to put together this whole picture. So for me, it’s more of a mental revelation in mystery, whereas suspense or using the tool of suspense is more anticipation. And I don’t think there’s a better explanation of what suspense is. Hitchcock’s explanation of it, it just hits it right on the head. And this is a quote, quote, there is no terror in the bang, only in the anticipation of it.

Yeah, that’s a good one. You said that before. That’s a really good one. That is a fairly well-known quote from Hitchcock. And you can actually unpack it more by using something that he said in one of those interviews with Francois Truffaut in that five-day marathon interview. And it’s actually in an HBO documentary right now. I think it’s on HBO. And I’ll read this verbatim just because it’s, fantastic. All right, this is from Hitchcock. There’s a distinct difference between suspense and surprise, and yet many pictures continually confuse the two. I’ll explain what I mean. We are now having a very innocent little chat. Let’s suppose that there is a bomb underneath this table between us.

Nothing happens. And then all of a sudden, boom, there’s an explosion. The public is surprised. But prior to the surprise, it has been an absolutely ordinary scene of no special consequence. Now let us take a suspense situation. The bomb is underneath the table, and the public knows it, probably because they have seen the anarchists place it there. The public is aware the bomb is going to explode at one o’clock, and there is a clock in the decor. The public can see that it is a quarter to one. In these conditions, the same innocuous conversation becomes fascinating because the public is participating in the scene. The audience is longing to warn the characters on the screen. You shouldn’t be talking about such trivial matters. There is a bomb beneath you and is about to explode. In the first case, we have given the public 15 seconds of surprise at the moment of the explosion.

In the second, we have provided them with 15 minutes of suspense. The conclusion is that whenever possible, the public must be informed, except when the surprise is a twist, that is, when the unexpected ending is, in and of itself, the highlight of the story.

Adam: Tools to the story, Hitchcock basically negates McKee. He’s just grouping dramatic irony in with suspense. In terms of these quote definitions, as you said, neither of us likes labels. Part of the point of this podcast is to define the labels and then blow them out of the water and say, what else can we think about with this? That’s the philosophy part of StoryOsophy. McKee says suspense is the audience and characters know the same. Dramatic irony, the audience knows more than the characters. In terms of this ticking time bomb example, by the way, a ticking time bomb is something that’s a completely different matter that will require its own episode, much like the pressure cooker. These are huge things, huge tools to help. What’s interesting is in this scenario Devin’s just posed that Hitchcock was talking to Truffaut about, the ticking time bomb, the audience is aware of, but the characters aren’t. And so only the anarchist, it’s funny that he used that word.

Yeah, I know. This is before terrorist was popular. He still considers that suspense, even though McKee would define it as dramatic irony. And like I said, I don’t, dramatic irony is sort of just a weird combo of words for what it is to define. Based on what you said, it became very clear to me an easy way to define the application of each of these topics and the result. So mystery, you’re getting curiosity. Suspense, you’re getting anxiety. Anticipation. Dramatic irony, you’re getting worry. These three different emotional responses, reactions from your audience are equal to these tools that you apply to your story. One of the simple things I wanted to mention as I like to give these tricks out when we’re doing these episodes, one of the tricks that I like to use in my work is, so let’s say you have a scene.

Scene isn’t working. Your story isn’t working in this moment. The sequence doesn’t function right. Take the concept. Take the concept of mystery, any one of these tools, mystery, suspense, or dramatic irony, and put it into that scene. Meaning, like we’ve defined, the audience knows less than the characters. Oh, so in mystery, the characters would know the bomb was there and the audience wouldn’t. Does that make your scene better? And suspense, the audience and the characters know the same information. Both characters know there’s a bomb under the table, and we do too, and they’re worried about the ticking time down. Right. That’s their concern. That’s their concern for the scene. They’re aware of the bomb. That’s another thing. That adds anticipation. You’re sweating it out with them. Dramatic irony. The audience knows more than the characters. We know there’s a bomb, and they don’t. So in mystery, the characters know there’s a bomb there, and we don’t. So we’re wondering why they’re sweating it out until we see the bomb. And that lays into the surprise element of what you were talking about via Hitchcock’s quote. He’s talking about surprise in that way.

We don’t know there’s a bomb there the whole time for the two-minute countdown. That’s the ticking time bomb. The characters do. And so we’re wondering why they’re sweating it out. Now, in the case of using my trick, in the case of the ticking time bomb, if you apply that to Devin’s example or Hitchcock via Devin’s example, if you apply that, it’s less interesting than either of the other two. Suspense, where we know the same as the character, that’s more interesting. We know why the character is sweating it out. So we’re wondering why they’re sweating it out. We know what the result’s going to be, and we’re sweating it out, anticipating, nervous. In terms of dramatic irony, if the audience knows more than the characters, this might actually be one of the better applications of these three tools to this scene.

Instinctively, when I’m applying that, dramatic irony seems to be the one that emotionally or intellectually engages me the most in that moment. I go, oh man, that’s crazy. Okay, so they don’t know there’s a bomb there. And I do.

It’s good. I’m glad you gave that quote beforehand. If you apply each of these tools individually to that example, it’s easy to go, well, of course, dramatic irony is the best. We know there’s a bomb there and they don’t. That amplifies the most out of what you can get out of the situation. If you can take that concept and apply it to any scene that’s not working in any story you’re working on, you will mine the best out of that scene, the best tension, the best anticipation, worry, curiosity, anything you’re going to get from it, but test them out. Just play a little bit. I think as human beings in general, not writers, but human beings, we just want to get something done and we want to get there and make sure, oh, make it easy. But if you attempt to apply these templates, these overlays to whatever scene you’ve got, and just think about it for a minute, imagine, play with it in your mind for a little bit. If a scene isn’t working, you can amplify it 10%.

And I don’t mean to just, like I said before, it doesn’t require danger. It just requires a lack of information for your audience or your character. You’re withholding. It’s part of setup and payoff to a certain degree, but you’re withholding certain information to a certain degree, whether it’s from your characters, from your audience. And if you can apply it to a scene, you can really mine some of your better moments. You’ll find stuff, that characters will do, or your audience will do responsibly that you wouldn’t before. So if you got a failed scene, if you got a scene that isn’t working, try one of these three tools.

That’s why I say they’re three of the most important tools to use in a story that I can think of. I mean, Devin, do you? No, I agree. At least in stuff we’ve built, we talk about this like nonstop. These three things, who knows what and how much they know is like every conversation.

Devin: Exactly. I think sometimes, certainly when we first start writing novels and screenplays, you’re so zoomed in and focused on your characters and what’s happening in the story that you neglect the audience perspective. And if you’re putting together a list of development, like the things that we’ve gone through where it’s like, develop your characters really well. Like, build a dossier for them. Understand who they are and how they’ll react in certain situations in your world. Understand the rules and tools of your world and all of that. And we get into that a little bit. A little bit more in depth in season two. But another element of development is what does my audience know? When do they know it? When does that change? Because like we were saying, a lot of Sherlock Holmes stories is the audience is, Watson is really representing the audience. So we know there’s a point where Sherlock leaves us because he knows more. And then we meet up with him again at that final scene where everybody’s in the room. He’s giving this, this reveal monologue of, of how he put it all together, where now we are finally, now we’re figuring out the rest of it with, with, so now we’re back on the same page with him. So there’s, it’s, that’s, it’s just a really good measurement thing, another measurement.

Of where it, you know, from page one, this is how much my audience knows. To the end. This is where, this is how much my audience knows in the beginning and you’re in the middle, all that can change. You can leave them, you can leave them behind. You can push them forward to where they know more, but it doesn’t. So there’s, that’s a really good thing to always keep in mind is, is your audience. Cause that’s, that’s your customer. That’s who.

Adam: There’s a gauge. It’s like a barometer. You have to adjust it. And that’s what I’m saying. If you, if, if something, if someone goes, you know what, I don’t know how I feel about this scene. You get feedback, try adjusting one of these three principles immediately. If you do it, I guarantee you that scene fixes itself because what Devin is addressing, is so important and very few writers actually do. The experiential element of your story. You’re in it. Woods from trees, folks. You don’t really know what your story is communicating and what it’s not. Most writers don’t know the difference between what they’ve imagined in their brain and what is literally on the page. They can’t differentiate. Something may be written on the page and you’ll have a reader read it and go, I don’t understand this. And you go, well, it’s this and this and this. And they’re like, but you didn’t write that.

That’s That’s in your head. You’ve developed it to that point in your brain, but you didn’t put that information on the page properly for other people to get it. If you think you’re going to get the perfect draft in your first draft, hang it up now. You’re not. You got to refine. You have to refine. And part of that second draft, third draft process is, what’s my audience experiencing here? This is part of the reason why, when we, when I, and specifically why I love film and filmed media or series TV based stuff, is it’s a page per minute, writing wise. So one page of dialogue and action, properly proportioned, is one minute on screen. So you can track your audience experience. That’s why I love it so much. It’s easy to track. Well, at 15 minutes, 15 pages, am I theoretically bored as an audience member?

Ask your audience. Answer yourself that question. It’s an important question. Just flip the mystery, suspense, or dramatic irony lens over top your story. It’s a tool. It’s simply a tool.

[Sponsor message]

Devin: You have to Bob Ross your stories, bottom line. Explain. So when you said, if you think you’re going to nail it out of the park, you’re the perfect story in your first draft, hang it up right now. Anytime anybody ever says something like that, I’m like, I always think of Bob Ross. When I used to watch, you know that painter? Oh yeah, how can you not? So he used to have that show, I think it was on PBS, and I used to watch him paint. And there’s always a point like halfway through the show that I’m like, dude, stop right now, that’s beautiful. Like if I could paint that, I would put that on my wall right now.

And then you watch him throw paint on, and you’re like, what are you doing? And then by the end of the show, it’s from a detailed detail he added from the moment I thought it was perfect to now this is truly an incredible painting. Plus he did it in like a half hour.

Adam: That reminds me of Setup Payoff a lot. What you’re saying, it’s like you get along here, you get these setups, and you don’t even understand their setups. And then it’s like, oh my God. It’s just sort of, it starts to feel like convoluted, like I don’t understand why the, and then at the end, boom, everything becomes clear. And you’re like, oh my God, the confusion was part of the journey for me. Yeah. I feel like part of that can be applied to story in the terms, and human beings, how we navigate life. Yeah, yeah, yeah. You think you know what you’re doing, and then there becomes this confusing aspect to it.

And you’re like, I don’t really get what’s go. And then out of the confusion, you’re like, oh my God. Out of the confusion, because you’re trying to, you’re examining, you’re trying, comes the clarity. And so part of that story structure, the way story is structured, is, and like I said, we’ll get into the season two structure, and there’s a moment where the hero is sort of confused. They thought they figured it out midway, and they didn’t. That’s human beings in general. Story mirrors it, and then boils it down to a condensed, or as cooks would say, a reduction.

Devin: What you’re talking about, too, I just watched, I think it was the NBA All-Star Game. It was something. Maybe WNBA. I forgot what it was. I saw it on YouTube. But it’s like this guy on center court, and he’s just throwing a bunch of paint on a canvas. And you’re like, what the heck is he making? And he just, I mean, and he does this. It probably takes him five minutes to do this. He’s actually singing the national anthem while he’s doing this. And you’re like, what? He doesn’t make any sense. And then at the end of the national anthem, he spins the thing around, and it’s a painting of the statue.

Of that. The statue of all the soldiers holding up the flag, or pushing up the American flag. I forgot the name of the actual statue.

Adam: Yeah, yeah, yeah. I know exactly what you’re talking about. So going back to your Hitchcock example, it’s this. What he’s just illustrated is a mystery surprise. Yeah. I’ve seen these things where they paint these things, and they throw freaking sand on the canvas, and flip it upside down, and all of a sudden, there’s this photorealistic thing, and you’re like, what? And that’s mystery surprise.

Devin: And suspense would have been, is he going to pull it off? Is he going to be able to do it? Like, you know that something’s going to happen, and then it’s anticipation.

Adam: Ticking time bomb is a real- A really important tool, another tool, that goes hand-in-hand with suspense a lot.

Devin: Yeah.

Adam: It creates this anxiety and anticipation and suspense.

Devin: Mm-hmm.

Adam: Dramatic irony is a little different, a little stranger, but I wanted to say something about it, and also address the concept I was saying earlier about it doesn’t require danger. Hollywood- Hollywood and most of these movies that fit in these genres, mystery, suspense, thriller, horror, any of these things, they’re very overt, and they use danger because it is one of the easy-

Made, because it’s easy. Keep information and terrify people and throw a lot of blood and guts. A good horror movie, a psychological thriller, something where they’ve actually They’ve actually applied strong structure and a lot of these things we talk about in first season. That’s a different story. But you don’t need danger. An example would be, let’s use romantic comedy, the opposite end of the spectrum. Most romantic comedies are built on these one of these three principles. And it doesn’t seem like that when you first think about it, but it’s true. You start out and let’s a lot of romantic comedies to do this weird thing where it’s like, I bet you can’t do this. And it’s based on a bet. So there’s some stakes involved.

Like literally, because it’s a bet. That’s how transparent that is, folks. That’s writers trying to apply stakes to a scenario so the audience gets it. That’s why you have bets in romantic comedies all the time. So within the romantic comedy, let’s say How to Lose a Guy in 10 Days, right? That’s exactly what the movie I was thinking about. Of course, because it uses… Or any movie with those two. Any of those. Well, it uses it. Well, Fool’s Gold is a little different and… I love that movie too. But anyway, let’s do… How to Lose a Guy. And it’s been a while since I’ve seen it. But the concept is each of them knows something. She’s trying to drive him away and he’s trying to keep her, right? That’s the premise of the bet.

Devin: Yeah, that’s right. She’s doing like an article or something.

Adam: And this is, I mean, this is every romantic comedy. I swear to you, if you understand these three principles for romantic comedy, you got it. It’s easy. The First Kiss, Drew Barrymore, She’s All That. There’s tons of these movies. And it’s sort of based on Taming of the Shrew. It’s sort of this romantic comedy based on the principles of Shakespeare. We know in How to Lose a Guy in 10 Days that he’s vowed to keep the girl no matter what, no matter how nuts she is. And she has vowed to drive this guy bananas by every trick that she can think of to make a man want to just ditch a girl and I’m done. I’m out. I can’t do this anymore.

And so we know both of their perspectives. Now, in some of these scenarios, we may only know one perspective. In romantic comedies, we sort of know both. However, we also know that the other person doesn’t know that. So she doesn’t know he’s made this bet and he doesn’t know that she’s writing this article. So this is a combination of dramatic irony and mystery. The other person is a mystery. And suspense. Well, yeah. And I mean, it sort of minds all three. We know the same as each character. However, each of those characters doesn’t know anything about the other person. Because they’re both presenting a facade, a really big facade in that scenario. The comedy or the fun of the movie for you comes from the fact that you know they’re both trying to outdo the other without the other knowing they are being outdone. When she does something crazy, he accepts it. And she’s like, what? This guy’s the greatest guy in the world. How is he putting up with this?

And he’s, well, he’s pretty much thinking she’s kind of nutso because… And she’s thinking he’s nuts because why would a guy put up with this? But he’s thinking she’s nuts because she’s doing outlandish, crazy stuff to drive him away and he’s not doing it. So the mystery, dramatic irony push and pull here from what we know versus what they know, that’s the key to that whole movie. That’s the fun. The experiential element of the audience for the whole movie. And Devin’s right, there’s a lot of suspense in it, too. But notice that it’s this seesaw. It’s this internal struggle throughout this entire movie, but not for the characters. It’s just for you, audience. The push and pull is perspective-based. It’s experiential. That’s why these three tools are important. They have less to do with your characters than to do with your audience.

Or your audience’s remote, emotional, relatable relationship with your characters. That’s the key to applying these three tools. Danger does not need to be an element in this to make all these three tools work. As a matter of fact, most of the things that I write, no matter what I’m doing, and we’ve said this before, characters are an onion and the layers get peeled back. So as the story goes on, your characters are, we’re seeing more and more of them, who they really are. But like we’ve talked about what they want, what they don’t want. They really want what they’re saying, what they’re really saying or really want to say. Who they are, who they really are. That’s happening throughout your whole story. And the mystery of it, and I think mystery applies mostly to this concept, but with each new layer you’re peeling back, you’re revealing more. You get a clue. You get information. Clue and then information. Much like a murder mystery, it’s a character mystery. So even if you’re not writing something in thriller, suspense, mystery, genre, mystery, applies to every story you can write. Your characters are the mystery, if nothing else. And even your characters can be suspense or dramatic irony. If we know the same as that character and that character is keeping a secret for the whole movie, that’s suspense for us, but in a drama, right? In something that’s not meant to be danger filled. The danger is in the fact that this person is almost afraid of who they really are and presenting that to the world.

There’s something about this secret. And it goes back to the how to lose a guy in 10 days. They finally fall in for each other by the end of the movie. They really do care about each other because they’ve experienced crazy stuff and they’ve been actually, ironically, understanding and compassionate to each other in the most ridiculous of circumstances. Well, that’s what builds a relationship is compassion and acceptance and understanding. And so they figured out that they actually care about each other, but they’ve both built it on a lie. We’re like, gosh, how are you going to resolve this? It’s all lies. And the tension comes from that stuff in romance.

That’s the mystery of it. Well, it’s also the dramatic irony. We know that they’re both lying to each other and they don’t.

Devin: The main element of dramatic irony is the audience has this omniscient point of view.

Adam: Yes, exactly.

Devin: Again, the importance of the writer knowing the point of view of the audience is crucial. But then it’s also from an audience standpoint, all of these points of view, no matter if we’re in a mystery, we’re in a suspense, or we’re coming at it with this omniscient point of view like in Dramatic. It’s a fun place. They’re all fun places to be in as audience members, as long as the writer can pull it off.

Adam: And it’s key to everything. And when you’re doing that with your audience, checks and balancing what you’re writing, what you’re putting on the page versus the experience of it. And when I say page, it’s ultimately going to be screen if it’s film media, but the blueprint of whatever you’re creating, it’s the script or whether it’s a novel, knowing or having an idea of what your audience might be experiencing is important. And a way to sort of check that. It is through these three tools. What do I know versus what they know? And if you ask yourself that question, you’ll start to refine your script better and better.

What Devin is talking about too is, and this is really important, the tug of war between those three. I couldn’t cite a better person to apply it than Fincher. You start with one bit of information. Like I said, so I had these definitions again. Mystery, audience knows more than characters. Suspense, audience and characters know the same. Dramatic irony, audience knows more than the characters. So scene by scene or within a scene, different beats and moments, if the audience knows and then the characters knows and then they both know and then that level of mental game for your audience and participating with the movie, the immersion quotient, it’s through the roof.

If you’re talking about audience experience. Just maneuvering between these tools, the tug of war between which one you’re laying over as a lens is enough to help a story thrive when it’s merely surviving. So you want to hit some, I mean, we’ve done some examples, but we’re not really going this week into examples in depth. They’re more premise-based movies. Devin, did you want to start on examples or?

Devin: Yeah, we talked about several of mine as well. I think Sherlock Holmes, obviously, we don’t have to talk much more about that. We hit kind of all of the main points of that. The other ones, I tried to pull together some that have all three elements that are measurable in each in them. So like the Saw series, they all have the element of anticipation or suspense. And there’s this, there’s also this mystery about what’s going, like, what’s going on. Why is all this happening? We’re trying to figure that out with, with the people that are having to go through these trials or these trying to solve, they actually literally have to solve these life or death puzzles that plays with all, all three of them. And the seven, the movie seven, obviously we’ve talked about this before too, but what I liked about this one, I actually did this as kind of a contrast from Sherlock Holmes, the Sherlock Holmes books and TV and movies is wherein the Sherlock Holmes movies are stories. It’s Sherlock at the end that is basically providing all of the answers and, and, and how, and the, the who done it, why done it, how done it type of answering those questions. And in seven, it’s that scene in the car where it’s actually the antagonist that is providing almost to a point where like you couldn’t, you, you couldn’t figure out who did this. I gave you all of these clues.

So I literally have to turn myself in and then I have to explain it to you, like explain to you why I did this in while they’re driving in the car to go out to the middle of the desert or wherever they are, where it’s in the box. What’s in the box. That’s John Doe has the upper hand.

Adam: No, my favorite line in that movie is when the captain is sitting there and they’re filling him in on the information and the phone rings and he’s sitting at someone else’s desk. He picks up the phone, answers it and says into the receiver, this ain’t even my desk. And then, It’s the funniest moment in that entire movie. That movie’s so good. I saw that in the theater twice and it was one of the most amazing things I’ve ever seen. And it has two. Oh, it’s so good. I mean, forget horror movies. That movie has two of the most horrifying moments in it. Horrifying. Oh, I know which one you’re talking about.

And it’s just because for the most part, they allow you, they allow your imagination to work for one of them, which is lust, the sin of lust. And they allow the shock. Shock of depravity for sloth. Those two moments are just, I mean, not just edge of your seat. It’s like you’re in shock. You’re frozen.

Devin: It’s what’s the guy who’s tied to the bed for a year and he ate his own tongue, but he’s still alive. Yes. Sloth. It’s freaking terrifying. That scene, that scene is when they’re going into that, that, that guy’s apartment and Brad Pitt and Morgan Freeman.

Adam: And all the Christmas trees are hanging. One of the scariest decor. All those. Christmas trees. Those air fresheners. Yeah. It’s a, it, that movie is amazing. Anyway. So yeah, seven is what I agree with you. A hundred percent. That’s one of my examples to fight club to in its own right. Silence of the lambs has all of the elements as well. I have that too. Yeah. It varies between things. It’s a mystery. They don’t know who did it for the most of the, the movie who’d done it in a silence of lambs. And then you get to moments where, where she actually shows up at Buffalo Bill’s door and she asks about the person.

And I’m like, wait, wait, wait, was she a real big fat person? She a real big fat lady? And, and Ted Levine on, on the set of birth. I was working on sets at that, on that film. I was like, oh my gosh. And I also got a chance to work with him on, truth about Charlie, which we did reshoots for, part of the crew I was working on Ted Levine, Buffalo Bill.

Devin: How great is that scene though? That when they have SWAT running up to a house and they have her. Her walking up to a house. That’s so good. You know, you think they’re at his door and then they go to bust it down and he opens it and it’s her.

Adam: They’re not, they’re at the wrong house. Brilliant reveal.

Devin: Oh, it’s so good, dude.

Adam: That sequence that you just talked about in the end of Silence of the Lambs, it uses all three of these elements. Because the SWAT team’s storming the wrong house. You don’t realize that until here. So it’s a mystery. Well, it’s not really. It’s sort of like nobody knows. The storyteller is the omniscient in that. But you get there and it’s a surprise that Hitchcock’s talking about. Surprise, wrong house. Meanwhile, she’s walking in the other one. She’s in the right house. He’s got night vision goggles and it’s dark.

Devin: Oh, God, dude. And he’s just right behind her.

Adam: And so there’s this suspense, dramatic irony stuff where we’re like, oh, my gosh. But that movie is great for all three examples. I had that down on my list, too. I’ll throw out some of these. I have some of them individually, but they also use, they borrow from the other ones. But the premise of the movie is pretty much sticks to one. One thing. It’s a mystery. Gone Girl. Oh, that’s great. Which is an awesome movie. If you haven’t seen it, it’s awesome.

Devin: Who directed that?

Adam: I don’t remember. It was based on a book. And I remember the way that. Well, I don’t want to say. I don’t want to spoil it because it’s fun. And there’s no reason to spoil it for this. But it’s an amazing experience. It was a lot of fun. Fincher. No, he didn’t. Yeah.

Devin: Directed by David Fincher.

Adam: Gone Girl.

Devin: Gone Girl. Written by Gillian Flynn. No wonder. I don’t remember why I loved it. I can’t get enough of Fincher. I just love his colors that he uses in his movies.

Adam: Or the lack thereof.

Devin: Yeah. Just kind of cool colors. Yeah. Tone. Good tone.

Adam: It’s green and blue. Yeah. I like greens and blues. Yeah. Exactly. And grays. Yeah. I also, so I put Murder on the Orient Express, both versions, the old one and the modernized version. I just bought the new one. Clue. And Old Boy was my last example. And that movie’s intense if you’ve never seen it. Whether it’s the. I like the. The original version, although there is an American version. I think the American version is directed by Spike Lee with Josh Brolin. But the original version is subtitled. And it’s. It’s insane. But it’s a cool mystery. It’s about a dude who gets sort of kidnapped and stuck in a room for, I think, 20 years.

And they feed him. But he’s not allowed to leave the room. And then they just let him out one day. Good luck, audience and dude. It’s awesome. It’s so good. You’re like. Why was he in there? It’s all three of your questions you posed earlier. Yeah. Who done it? How they done it? And why they done it? Like, what? Great mystery. Great mystery. So, suspense. These are two I wrote down for suspense. They’re sort of strange. One is obvious. Misery. Done by one of my favorite filmmakers, Rob Reiner. You don’t know what’s going to happen next. But you and the audience. Or you and the characters are pretty much on the same page.

Yeah. So, Kathy Bates’ character takes James Caan’s character captive. And forces him to write a novel. Because she’s his biggest fan. So, we know the stakes right from the beginning. This guy’s trapped. We don’t know what he’s going to do. Every time he tries to escape, the stakes increase. She hobbles him. Meaning she breaks his ankles with a sledgehammer. So, he’s stuck there. So, the stakes keep getting more and more. The sheriff starts to investigate. We know all this stuff. There’s no information that is outside of what we know. We know everything they know. And the only thing that gets a little tricky. And this is one of those things I wanted to address.

With these three topics anyway. The only thing that gets a little tricky is. Near the end, he’s going to fight back. Everything he’s done so far has failed. No one’s come to help him. No one’s saved him. He can’t save himself. But he uses the traditions of his finished novel against her. She knows he likes one cigarette at the end of his. Because he quit smoking. And every time he finishes a novel, he just has one. And he has a glass of some, I think it’s scotch. I might be wrong. I don’t remember what he has to drink. But he has a celebration drink. So what he does is uses the match.

She’s almost like his warden. She’s a jailer. She keeps him prisoner. He uses his one match instead of lighting a cigarette to set the novel on fire. She’s more concerned with the story itself. And when he sets it on fire, she wants to know the ending. And she’s so distracted by that. He uses that as the upper hand to save himself. But we’re suspense almost 100% of that entire story. We know exactly what they know. The only time that differs is when he gets the match and we go, oh, she doesn’t know that. She doesn’t know that. So although McKee defines these as the audience knows less than the characters, the audience and the characters know the same, or the audience knows more. There are certain scenarios where you use them at once. We know the same as him, but we know more than her. So our relationship to her is dramatic irony, and our relationship to him is suspense. So you can use these tools, even in the same scene, applied to different characters. I’m telling you, these are three of the most versatile and amazing tools you can apply to your writing. And the other one I had for suspense was The Hangover, and it’s actually suspense and mystery. But the reason I say suspense is we know the same as those guys, and every clue they get, it’s a mystery. It’s a mystery comedy. It’s one of the few movies that actually does it and does it well without having a murder in it, without having, you know what I mean, without having some death in it. They just want to know what happened to their friend. They got so drunk, they can’t remember the night before. That’s a brilliant mystery premise.

That’s a good one. And the last one was dramatic irony. I had these. The best one is the Star Wars prequels. Not the first three, but the first three. Not episodes four, five, and six, but episodes one, two, and three. There is an enormous dramatic irony relationship. With the audience to that story, because we know at the end of those three, this kid is Darth Vader. So we know more than anybody when we’re watching these prequels. And it’s one of the few unique experiences that we have. I guess Bates Motel, that series with Freddie Highmore and Vera Farmiga. Yeah, that’s a great series, by the way.

It is a great series. And Carlton Cuse, Lost. And Damon Lindelof went on to do The Leftovers, also a wildly awesome series. Very awesome. Yeah, that was. They’re great storytellers. Like I said, as much as I complain about Lost, it has to do with that show was immensely popular. And they busted their humps trying to make it as engaging as possible. And then at the end, it’s like the Coens, they sort of left it with a philosophy. Star Wars prequels, Darth Vader, dramatic irony. We know he’s going to become Darth Vader. We also know that Jar Jar Binks is going to become a secret Sith master. And we also know these three are going to be over soon.

And the only two. I had to add one was The Truman Show for dramatic irony, which we don’t know more than everybody. Again, the misery example. We only know more than Truman. And everyone else knows. Everyone else we’re sort of in suspense with. We know the same information as the producers of The Truman Show and all that jazz. And that one is specifically wonderful because it engages your cheering for him. You feel like he’s trapped in his life. And we are we oftentimes feel the same. And so when this guy is like, I’m going to sail to the edge of my world. Because I’m that much of an adventurer and curious spirit. We go, go, go, go, because there’s something beyond that world for you. So there’s this dramatic irony, suspense. Suspense allows you to cheer for the characters to worry or cheer. And the only one I had recently was Game Night, that film with Jason Bateman and Rachel McAdams that just came out a little bit ago. The premise, I’m sure you’ve probably seen the trailers, but Game Night is about a group of different couples.

That come together for a routine game night, board games and stuff like that. And the host this week decides to, or this month or however the time frame is, decides to kick it up a notch and do sort of a live action murder mystery where they won’t know what’s real and what’s not. Meanwhile, and we know this, dramatic irony wise, that host has gotten into some stuff that he shouldn’t have gotten into. And some armed men burst into his explanation, kick him around, smash up his head. Beat him all to hell and back and pull him out of the house and into the van. And the couples that are left there having with all the glass around, all the stuff around, they’re like, oh my gosh, this is amazing.

They think they’re still part of Game Night and we know they’re not. So the comedy comes completely out of this. They spend the whole night thinking that the guns they’re picking up and they got blanks in them. They’re not real, but it’s a whole, it’s a whole movie that the premise is built on dramatic irony. And there are a lot of comedies that are based in that. Comedy thrives on dramatic irony.

Devin: Chaplin movies, the near misses that always happen in those where you’re like, he goes in one door, the other person goes out the other door, they’re looking for each other and they just keep going in and out. The other dramatic irony one is the one you talked about last week though. The bank robbery, that comedy where he gets on the phone and they’re coming out of the bank.

Adam: The IT crowd. You’re right. That is a really great example of dramatic irony. It’s much, a much better example of dramatic irony when we know everything and he knows absolutely nothing. The, the humor completely comes out of that lens, out of that concept. We, I promise you story authors that we will go back to the concept of mystery as a genre suspense as a genre later in the podcast, because. I mean, Devin and I can’t help ourselves. It’s some of our favorite stuff. It helps with story tension all over the place. But we just wanted to make sure that you knew these tools before we get into season two and structure. We’ll have a handful more tools in the next bunch of episodes, and then we’re going to start season two.

So, if you’ve not been taking your notes about all these basic elements, characters, plot, theme, tone, all these things, you better start now, because we’re going to start applying them and you’re going to have your story soon. Keep that in mind. Keep making your notes. We’ll make this easy for you. We kicked the crap out of these three topics. Please subscribe and rate us on iTunes, and for additional story-related resources, video, and archived content, visit our website at StoryOsophy.com.