Season 1, episode 23

Symbolism-Part 1-Objects and Allegory

April 19, 201850 min

Show notes

A symbol boils a complex idea down to a single thing you can see: a logo, a ring, a fake mustache. In the first of two episodes on symbolism, Adam and Devin explore how stories turn emotions, states of mind and big ideas into objects and characters, and how whole stories can work as allegory, saying something about the world without starting a fight.

In this episode

  • The oldest storytelling. Devin traces symbols from cave drawings through the Knights Templar to the hobo code chalked on mailboxes. Meanings can flip, as the swastika’s did.
  • Symbol versus metaphor. A metaphor compares two things; a symbol carries a bigger, more abstract idea. Devin sees symbolism as the author’s subtext to the audience.
  • Branding is symbolism. The golden arches put the whole McDonald’s menu in your head.
  • Characters give objects meaning. When a character values something no one else does, it becomes a symbol of their passion. In Hot Rod, Rod’s fake mustache stands for his dead father, his stepfather and becoming a man.
  • Allegory says what can’t be said outright. A story can carry a political message without triggering people’s defenses. The Wizard of Oz is often read as being about the gold standard: the Yellow Brick Road, the green Emerald City, “Oz” for ounce. The film’s slippers changed from silver to ruby to pop in Technicolor.
  • Mr. Rogers’ kiddie pool. At a time when pools were segregated, Fred Rogers and Officer Clemmons soaked their feet together. No protest, just an image of how things could be.
  • The Great Gatsby. Gatsby’s parties stand for the reckless new wealth of the 1920s and the corruption of the American dream.
  • Monsters are inner states made visible. A good antagonist embodies the hero’s fear or doubt: The Babadook, Tyler Durden in Fight Club, sailors’ fear of the sea becoming the Kraken. Inside Out makes emotions into characters.
  • The object of the quest is never really the object. In The Jewel of the Nile and The Fifth Element, the treasure turns out to be a person.

Examples discussed

  • Friday Night Lights: the father’s championship ring as approval and a mended relationship.
  • Also: Mother!, Romancing the Stone and Game of Thrones, plus the 19th-century Symbolist art movement and the documentary Won’t You Be My Neighbor?

Next week: Symbolism, Part 2, on symbolism in filmed media: set dressing, wardrobe and more.

Read the full transcript

Transcribed automatically, so expect the odd misheard word. Sponsor messages are left out.

Adam: In this episode, we investigate symbolism and its many forms. Objects, allegory, and how the abstract can be represented tangibly. Emotions, states of mind, mystical ideas, and more. Next, on StoryOsophy. Welcome to StoryOsophy. This is Adam Jones. And Devin Halden. That countdown. I got confused by that rhythm. You started out strong, and then you slowed. That’s my style. With everything in life. Okay, so this week, this week, this week, we are talking about symbolism, which is the use of symbols to represent ideas or qualities. Everybody sort of knows what symbolism is. You sort of get what symbols are. They are objects that are used to represent something.

And in that is one of your greatest tools, tools in storytelling. I think it’s because you can boil down, an idea or a concept, something that’s really difficult to understand into an object or a logo, or something that sort of encapsulates all of the information into a smaller thing. Like the way that a single letter, when you look at it, it contains the information of a sound, you know, it makes this type of sound or that type of sound. So in the same way, the abstract needs a physical, tangible symbol to represent it. Ideas, concepts, something that’s much larger. And I think, Devin, you might, you would probably agree with me on this because it’s so related to the theme of something or a larger ideas that are not able to be expressed in a bullet point or a soundbite, the symbol becomes the soundbite.

And so I find it one of the most interesting things to play with in story or something. That fascinates me because again, it’s one of those abstract tools. It’s one of those abstract elements. You, you can play with it in a way where you can allow the audience to interpret more, you know, leave some room for their personal interpretation, or you can be really direct and, and, obvious about it. The abstractness of symbolism in stories, in novels, in film, media, which they do differ. You know, you’re gonna have visual representation that’s different. I think the abstractness of it, that’s what is the most exciting part of it to me. Devin?

Devin: I would agree. And that was while I was preparing for this episode, which is another reason why I’m really glad that we started doing this, because I’m also, it’s also forcing me to take a deeper look into some of these story elements that I like to use, but never really tried to define the difference between symbolism and theme or symbolism and metaphor and things like that. So I was basically forced to kind of… In order to explain it to someone else, make sure that it was kind of concise and comprehensive and not necessarily transparent by any means, but figure out a way to define the difference between that.

And then I kind of went down this other road when researching symbolism and realized how, of course, they were really the first form of storytelling, if you look back at it, not even just the hieroglyphics, but also in these… In these ancient caves that we’re finding now, even in Minnesota, where it was, before language was language, even they were used to tell a bigger story. And a huge story and a very complex story could be, like you were saying, with just one symbol, but also the important thing with that one symbol was an interpretation by whomever was receiving that symbol, or the author may have intended something, and then there was another interpretation for that.

Right. And then you see it through Templars and other groups like that that used symbol and symbolism in order to secretly communicate. And then even hobos, like hobos even would use… There’s a dictionary of hobo symbols that they would carve or they would write on a mailbox that nobody else knew what they meant, but there’s like this hobo code that they understood that someone… The person that lived there was nice, and they’d give you a meal, or that person would stay away because this person’s a… They’re the law enforcement, or things like that, but they’d use that to communicate. And so I kind of went down this rabbit hole of how symbols have been a huge part of storytelling and communication throughout history, really.

And so that was fun. But I think my main roadblock or conundrum is probably a better way of explaining that would be… The difference between symbolism and metaphor, and I’m actually interested to hear, Adam, what your take on it. But for me, I’m trying to define them as two separate tools. And so like with a metaphor is drawing a comparison between two distinct objects or elements, whereas symbolism, like you’re saying, is more complex, and in many cases abstract. It’s an idea or message that the author is telling through their story. And in many cases… In many cases, I look at even symbolism and subtext being very similar, too, where it’s symbolism, and symbolism is almost like a bigger part of the story, where symbolism is like the author’s subtext to the audience, rather than a metaphor actually being woven within dialogue, within a scene or within the story.

Adam: Yeah, and metaphor is more of a comparative tool, too. Metaphor, and that’s another one we should dedicate. But metaphor is useful for when I talk about contrast, there’s like light and night and day and dark and light. You have these different elements. It’s very useful in delineating those in writing. It helps you to sort of do this sort of measuring out of things for yourself mentally. Symbolism, I would say, and I want to sort of respond to your first notion, like all these different ways you’re talking about.

That symbols were used to communicate, I hadn’t considered, but when I was preparing for this episode, it really fascinates me, these different ways of doing it. And I don’t want to get into them individually, because if we did, we’d have a marathon episode. This is something Dev and I agreed. There are certain topics, usually the abstract ones, we’re going to explore much more in future episodes. These are the basics. We’re just going through the basics and sort of getting our feet wet. And then we’re going to expand and explore more. So… The idea, what I really want to seize on what you said is the idea that there are different things and different ways that people used objects or symbols to communicate something.

Whether it’s, you know, hobos or, what was the other one? Templar, Knights Templar. Right, and would even organizations. Masons, Freemasons. Right, and even the swastika, the Nazi swastika was, they took that from actually, I can’t remember exactly where it came from, but it was not a negative symbol until it became associated with them. Before that, it was a symbol of well-being, and it sort of got flipped on its head big time there. So, the way that a symbol can change meaning, just because of the connotation versus denotation, what you mean, you know, what you interpret from the thing, like we said, what an author might put in a story, and then someone might have a different interpretation of it.

It all is what’s associated with the thing, and different people have different associations. Right. I think the idea of having more, much more complex things be boiled down into something that is, because you understand the complexity of the idea. If you just have a single element that sums it all up, just when you glance at it, you have somehow taken all this, the complexity, or the abstract, and brought it to one singularity. And that’s really the, freaking juicy again, I was going to say. Oh. That word is banned, but it’s stuck there, Devin.

Devin: I think you should just open the thesaurus up to juicy before we start. It’s delicious. Delicious. Moist. This is a very moist point.

Adam: But that sort of concept of boiling it down into a singularity so that you get what the thing is, it’s like when you drive past and you see a fast food restaurant logo. You see the arches from McDonald’s. The whole menu is in your brain. You remember, you know what a Big Mac is, cheeseburger. You don’t have to see anything but two golden arches, and you know what that’s all about. That’s a symbol. It’s branding, which is sort of the business world’s way of telling a story through a symbol, you know, through a single image. It’s the same concept you want to use in stories, except for me in stories, I feel like it has a lot, you can do it about the world or the theme, what you’re trying to say with a story.

But a lot of times it’s interesting, too, that most of the symbols in a story you can infuse meaning into through the perspective of your character. So if your character sees value in something that no one else sees value in, the, here’s a really short example in a moment. But if they see more value in a thing than anybody else, that becomes the symbol of their passion, their love, their this, their that. And a good example is one of my favorite comedies ever. I love it. I love it. Hot Rod. I love this movie. Have you seen Hot Rod, Devin? No, I have not. Oh, my God.

There are two movies now I desperately want you to watch, comedy-wise, because you will pee yourself. I don’t want to get too early into examples, but we’re going to start a little bit. Throw one out. Okay, good. Yeah, throw one out. Seems like a good spot for it. Let’s do it. Andy Samberg and the Lonely Island guys, that’s who make this movie. And it’s hysterical. I love this movie. And I don’t necessarily love everything he or they do. But this is the movie. But this is genius. And I can’t remember who it’s written by. It’s written by Pam. She used to write for South Park. And it’s just a wonderful script and it’s funny.

But it’s about a guy who aspires to be a professional stuntman because his father was. Which you’re questioning throughout the whole thing because his father has passed away. So he wants to become a stuntman and has a moped. And you can imagine the rest. He’s not very good. He’s the worst stuntman you can imagine. His name is Rod. So it’s called Hot Rod. Anyway, whenever he does stunts, he puts on a fake mustache because his dad had a mustache. He can’t grow one yet. So he puts on a fake one. And it sort of embodies this desire to be a stuntman. This mindset for him of being a stuntman.

You know, once the mustache is on, he’s in the zone. And so it’s very symbolic of this missing relationship with his father or the stepfather he has, which is, oh, shoot, what’s the actor’s name? Freaking can’t remember it. He’s in Deadwood. This is good. I’m glad you have a well-thought-out example. It wasn’t. This is spur of the moment, but it’s a good one. Good, good. And it’s a comedy. I’m trying to do more comedies because we always do dramas. And comedies, you can use the same tools in a comedy. And this is a good example. So, he’s got this, and he’s a terrible stuntman. And it is, the way he is bad at it is what’s funny. It’s very slapstick, which is something I love.

At one point, he has his, like, hero’s darkest moment, all his lost moment, and he tears the mustache up into little pieces. And when he revives and goes, I can do this, gets a fresh, beautiful mustache, ready to go. So, even though the bike, his moped and this stuff, he uses for this. He does the stunts all the time. The most symbolic thing in it is really the mustache.

Devin: Right.

Adam: Because it represents not only this connection he needs to get with his stepdad, his new stepdad that he’s not connecting with, but just him. It’s a coming of age. I want to become a man. It’s very obvious about the coming of age. I want to be a man. The premise of it is at one point, sort of the turning point is, he discovers that his stepfather, and they hate each other, he and his stepfather, needs a new… Heart because he’s dying. And he decides he’s going to raise the money by doing stunts so that he can get him a new heart and then kick the crap out of him because he hates him so much.

But he’s not going to beat him up with a bad heart. So, he’s got to make sure he gets better so that it’s a fair fight.

It’s so ridiculous. But that’s the premise. It’s a coming of age story. So, this young boy needs to take on the authority. He’s a pretty male in his life. It’s just funny. It’s a very funny movie. Nice. The mustache is symbolic of his coming of age manhood, all this other stuff, tearing it up, wearing it again. There we go. Brought it back. And by the end, he’s actually able to grow a few hairs.

Devin: So, his transformation’s complete.

Adam: Yes. It’s really brilliant the way that they use the story elements in it. The guy’s name is Ian McShane, the stepfather, and it was written by Pam Brady. She’s a really talented writer. I want to say that. But it’s like a big cast of comedians. Every famous comedian you know is in this cast. So, well worth it. But I wanted to remember his name and give her credit. Proper due.

Devin: Nice.

Adam: It’s sort of like a thing that represents or stands for something else, especially like a material object representing the abstract. So, coming of age, manliness, becoming a man, his mustache. I never thought about it until just now. It’s pretty brilliant writing.

Devin: It’s one of the key, I think the key elements of symbolism is it’s buried subtly. Kind of the main narrative of the story. It’s a tool that we can use in our stories to tell a story through a story, if that makes sense. I guess in search of an example here, you could take subject matter that could possibly be off-putting to certain audiences, but it’s a story you still want to tell. So, you utilize the characters in these world elements to create or symbolize references from a larger, more specific story. And I think, and I have a really good, I have a good example of what I’m talking about.

Adam: Go for it. Do it. We’re going to start doing examples earlier because it makes things easier.

Devin: A good example of what I mean by that is the Wizard of Oz. That’s a good one. The Wizard of Oz is actually a story, a symbolic story of keeping the gold standard in the United States over paper money and silver. Basically. As currency. I’m so glad you did this. Yes, that’s great. Okay, go for it. I learned about this years ago because I’m actually using, the Wizard of Oz is a very big piece of a novel that I’m working on right now. And so, when I read this, I was like, oh my God, it all makes so much sense, all the symbolism in this.

But, so Dorothy’s ruby slippers, she has ruby slippers in the movie. They’re actually silver. In the novel, farmers in middle America, in Kansas, they wanted the value of a dollar to be a balance between gold and silver. And that’s just, this is actually what was going on when, when Baum wrote this. And Emerald City is symbolic of Washington, D.C., whereas Kansas symbolizes typical, typical America. The Yellow Brick Road is the gold standard. It’s this strong and sturdy representation that leads to, it’s leading to power. It’s leading to the Emerald City. You know, this is, that’s, that was the gold standard. And in, in the Emerald City, of course, it’s green, like the greenback or like the paper money. And paper money, who was, back then, it was, its greatness and power were nothing more than this illusion to people that wanted to keep the gold standard.

And then, of course, finally, Oz owes, or ounce, which is the unit of measurement of precious metals. And so, they’re basically, there’s a, there’s a very detailed and in-depth analysis of this, of it. And I can throw it up, we can throw it up on the, on the website, because I didn’t, it’s, it’s, it’s, again, it’s one of those, those things that when you’re watching the movie, before you know it, you see it through one lens. And then when, after reading kind of what Frank Baum, the symbolism and what was actually, and it’s another very interesting thing of, of understanding what was going on in the world when a story was written.

And then under, and then you can somewhat understand, perhaps more symbolism that was used for what character, like what a character represents. And, and, you know, and I guess another, well, I don’t want to jump off this one right away, in case Adam, you want to talk about this one, but.

Adam: No, no, I want, I want to talk about The Wizard of Oz for a second. Yeah. I just didn’t want to interrupt because you were on such a good track with it. First of all, I want to say the time period that it was written in, considering that, what you just said, that’s really important. Because for that time period, this is brilliantly groundbreaking. It’s sort of like, symbolism taps into the subconscious or unconscious in a lot of ways. And especially in this example, where it’s all about the money. And I’m sure there, there are some, there are some listeners out there that are like, what? That’s what that’s about?

Like, this is the first time that it’s come across their radar. But it’s true. L. Frank Baum wrote this for the purpose of expressing something that he, sort of like political criticism in a way, or social, more like, it had more to do with financial, the way finances were being constructed, as Devin was saying. But he could say it, and here’s the interesting part, more of a fantasy or sci-fi world. You can, you can express something that is, that you want to say about the current world in a way that makes it slightly intangible, not nearly as confrontational, and in a way, helps you to, to get an understanding of, of the, the bigger picture of it all, without knowing you’re getting the understanding of the bigger picture of it all.

It helps you to zoom out. Yeah. You know, because how many people love The Wizard of Oz? What a great story. You’re enthralled with this brilliant story. And yet, all of the things, he’s trying to express as a human being experienced that time period, you’re getting to figure it all out. You’re getting, this is why I say, like, the puzzle aspect of story, symbolism is a big puzzle aspect. Probably a little known fact in this, too, is, as Devin said, the original slippers are, are silver slippers. But when they did the film, they started with silver slippers, and because they did that part in Technicolor, this big, bright, vibrant, the silver slippers didn’t play.

You know, you sort of lose them in a shot. And so, they changed them to ruby, so that the bright red pops against the yellow brick road for the purpose of the image, the, the beauty of the painting that you’re looking at. Which is, I did not know this until, like you, learned all about the symbolism behind Wizard of Oz, and went, wow, okay, so ruby slippers weren’t even the, the original concept. It was silver.

Devin: Yeah, that one’s fascinating.

Adam: That’s a rabbit hole, man. Wizard of Oz is… That is a rabbit hole. Wizard of Oz and Lewis Carroll stuff, there’s a whole bunch of stuff that I really love fantasy-wise that is just, got so much symbolism to it, and, but also just… The mental rabbit hole you can go down with all the abstract and weirdness and it’s like the rules don’t work the same here. That’s sort of what’s fun. Pliable reality.

Devin: It just shows the brilliance of storytelling of these storytellers that they realize and you see it every day but you realize that there’s opinions on everything. Everybody has opinion on everything and there’s a way to have a conversation about differing opinions but ultimately it usually ends up in more confrontational or it’s defensiveness. People are getting defensive about their opinions. Taking it personally. There’s a way to express yourself, express your opinion and almost perhaps subconsciously get people to have an open mind to what you’re saying. Yeah, 100%. Through storytelling and through where when you’re in a confrontation with someone, you’re ultimately defensive and turned off. Yeah. Your mind is just shut.

Adam: And it’s not meant to be. There are things that are not meant to provoke a challenge in someone else. You know what I mean? They’re not poking at something. They’re talking about an idea more broadly. It’s the storyteller’s lens. We talk about character perspective a lot but the tone of the story is the storyteller lens. We talked about that a good while back. It was one of our earlier episodes tone, probably 10, 11, somewhere around there. For story authors who don’t know but this is the lens your storyteller is laying over top. Mm-hmm. Of whatever the events are. Mm-hmm. So as Devin was saying last week, you know, with 7 Seconds, you’re given the lens mainly of the frustrated point of view of the family trying to find justice. But you could pull a little more Breaking Bad and have focused it on a lens. And he said it is more omniscient but the point is it is there is a storyteller tone bias to that story. They’re trying to get something thematic across.

But a lot of it has to do with how far out can you zoom with that lens. Story in and of itself is symbolic of life. It’s someone boiling down things from experience or to give you, the audience, the reader, the viewer, an experience of what their interpretation of life is. So it’s their symbolic representation of life or an aspect of life. Mm-hmm. Abstract parts of it because it’s the intangible stuff. It’s sort of like music. You can’t really say what music is. You could talk about how to build a good song, you know, or do things like that. But the magic of it all happens in the abstract. It happens in the ether that you take and realize and put on page. Story in and of itself is symbolic. It allows us to express things. And this is one of those things when I say, when I talk about where I’d like to see stories go, because this podcast, like I say, first season, we’re talking about the basics, the foundation, and then we’re going to move into how to expand on those ideas. And for me, I would like to see stories told that people can imitate in life because that’s most of the time what people do. Woody Allen quote, life doesn’t imitate art. It imitates bad television. I freaking love it. Then these are my little mental notes or my cards I have up for this particular thing. I want to see more magic.

Than tragic. And I want to see more thrival than survival. If we tell better stories, and part of this comes from, I was thinking about this a lot, Devin off air with Mr. Rogers and the type of subversive storytelling he was doing, but his artist lens, his storyteller tone, it was gentle, no matter what the topic was at the time period during civil rights movement when, and this is symbolic. This is something that I was thinking about the civil rights movement when white people [unclear] swimming pools. It’s sort of unimaginable at this day. It’s sort of ridiculous. But back then it was huge, big thing. And Mr. Rogers wanted to, in his own way, protest, but he’s not going to do it in a resistant fashion, right? Because there’s that Buckminster Fuller quote, you don’t change the old model by fighting against it. You make a new model that makes the old model obsolete, right? Because if you don’t change the old model, you don’t change because you’re drawing attention to the quote old model if you do. So what Mr. Rogers did on his show, Officer Clemmons was a black police officer, which is pretty revolutionary in and of itself, because the actor who played Officer Clemmons was nervous when Fred Rogers offered him the role and said, I don’t know, my experience with police officers has not been great. And Mr. Rogers said, that’s why you need to play Officer Clemmons. That’s why I want you to play him. That was a big step enough. But the episode that he did with Officer Clemmons, where they had like a kiddie pool and Mr. Rogers was just soaking his feet in the pool and Officer Clemmons stopped by to visit. And he said, Officer Clemmons, why don’t you come and hang out with me for a bit? It feels awesome to have your, you know, it feels great to have your feet in a pool. And so for his show, he just had the image of a white man’s feet and a black man’s feet in the pool. Nothing aggressive, nothing. It was just this image of this is the way it could be. This is thrival, you know, versus survive. This is not fighting. This is. And so there was a way of presenting this broader thing without making it an aggressive attack against something that had a limited belief system, you know, segregation. That symbolic gesture of this, just soaking their feet in the kiddie pool. I mean, because he was also an ordained minister, Fred Rogers. So it also harkens back to, of course, probably for him, the story of Christ washing the feet of his disciples to show them he was their servant. Do you know what I mean? It’s like, we’re all brothers. We’re all the same. We’re not.

So he was a genius. And I just want to bring him up because also his birthday, just he would have been 90 this time last month.

[Sponsor message]

Adam: That’s how you do it. No, that’s a plug. And now here’s the trailer for the documentary. Documentary on Fred Rogers, Won’t You Be My Neighbor?

Devin: You take all of the elements that make good television and do the exact opposite. You have Mr. Rogers’ Neighborhood. Low production values, simple set, unlikely star. Yet, it worked. Hello. I’ve always felt that I didn’t need to put on a funny hat or jump through the hoop to have a relationship with a child.

Adam: He was always trying to get a message across in every show. A week on death. What does assassination mean?

Devin: A divorce. Some people get married and after a while they’re so unhappy that they don’t want to be married anymore.

Adam: He was radical. I know everyone says that, but he was radical. They didn’t want black people to come and swim in their swimming pools. My being on the program was a statement for Fred.

A neighborhood was a place where at times that you felt worried, scared, unsafe would take care of you. He had a singular vision of kindness and love.

Love is at the root of everything.

Devin: All learning, all relationships, love or the lack of it. Children have very deep feelings, just the way everybody does. There must be times when you do feel blue. I’m not feeling blue right now though.

Adam: Me neither.

Devin: Won’t you be my neighbor? Well I suppose it’s an invitation. It’s an invitation for somebody to be close to you.

The greatest thing that we can do is to help somebody know that they’re loved and capable of loving.

That’s really the interesting thing for me that I’ve become a little bit more aware of when I’m either reading or even watching in older classic films is being cognizant of the times and what was happening in the world when either that novel, that book, or that story was written or that movie was made. And that becomes even more – just as fascinating and as relevant as the story. And one last example that I have would be The Great Gatsby and what Fitzgerald did with that where it was taking a snippet or an aspect of what was happening in America after World War I when the stock market went crazy.

And there was all this increasing – National wealth and new wealth, people that were not wealthy before all of a sudden had all this money. And there was this instant separation between the aristocracy, this old wealth of America, and this new wealth, this new rich industrial – Young money, what you would call young money. Yeah. And so – and then, of course, there’s – you throw prohibition in with that, the 18th Amendment in with all of this. And it creates – It creates this – almost this perfect storm of indulgence and crime and wanting – and this party that was going on. And though there was like all this prosperity of the country, America was also experienced to this like decay of social and moral values during this time, which is profoundly highlighted in the film.

Fitzgerald is using Gatsby and these huge parties that he’s throwing every night. It would be symbolic of this opulence and the recklessness of this one class of people who had this new wealth, which ironically in a way, this unrestrained extravagance and this desire for money and pleasure and indulgence ultimately resulted in the corruption of the American dream, which is the irony of it. And so Fitzgerald – and Fitzgerald uses those characters fantastically as symbolizing those – like Nick and Gatsby symbolized. But those cynical dreamers and the products of those who actually fought in the war and then the wannabe socialites that show up at his parties every week and kind of symbolize that those ambitious speculators or those – the greedy – those that were greedy for wealth and pleasure and they wanted nothing more for this party to last forever.

And so he – again, like Wizard of Oz, like we were talking about before, Fitzgerald is using story. To convey a message to – or tell a story within a story or on top of a story about something different that may be off-putting or may become politicized, you know, in a way where he doesn’t want that to happen or criticized. To criticize or examine it.

Adam: Exactly, yeah. It’s a great way to express a philosophy.

Devin: Exactly, yeah. That’s a better way to put it.

Adam: Because you don’t just get one person. The benefit of story is in life, an individual has an opinion. But in story, it’s a comprehensive, broader look at the thing because like life, you have reflections of yourself in other people. You see different aspects of the whole picture by the interactions and things that you have. Another show we talk about or I’ve talked about a lot on this is Game of Thrones. The one thing with the way George R.R. Martin has approached his novels and the show has been adapted. Is it’s very omniscient storytelling. Although you get intimate with these characters and you get to know their feelings and stuff, the way the story is told doesn’t make you choose sides.

And a lot of these sides, gaming for the throne, are against each other. And you’re like, well, I sort of like aspects of a lot of them. And in that way, it’s an author’s or a filmmaker’s, however you’re interpreting the story. It’s their lens laid on top of it. And symbolism can be used to express something. It can also be used to, I think, just mean something within the context of the story. That symbolism you’re talking about with Wizard of Oz, it’s, I love that kind of stuff. That’s my favorite. It’s like, well, we can’t openly express this or else people will have that knee-jerk, like you’re saying, that knee-jerk brain reaction to a belief system so we can properly express this, you know, in a story.

I don’t know if you’re using this as an example, but I just want to bring it back in. The one that you had a few weeks ago about Friday Night Lights when you were talking about resolution and the championship ring that the father wore, that is also one of those things. I mean, here’s the point. How many children have wonky relationships with their parents? And that kind of movie changes the way they feel because of that championship ring, because of the use of that championship ring in the story. You know what I mean? Yeah. And have an impact. And that’s a totally different way, use of symbolism. That’s it boiled down to the singularity that you represent. This is the, this is father’s pride. And when he passes it on to son, it means that I’m proud of you, right? I mean, that’s the essence, right? I mean, I sort of…

Devin: Yeah, and it’s a mending of the relationship. It’s like this bridge. It’s this new connection, yeah.

Adam: I’m interpreting it that way, but like I said, I’ve not seen it. I got to see this movie now because Peter Berg. But anyway, that’s sort of the difference. So the two there is the worldview of symbolic, like you’re saying with The Wizard of Oz and that depth of complexity. And then something like a singular thing that sums up all of the dialogue and looks and feelings between these two performers in one object. So it allows the audience to infer all of their feelings about connection and love and paternal affection. Approval and all those other things into one thing. So anytime you show that on screen, once again, a visual symbol, the audience knows what they’re supposed to feel because the narrative has set it up and imbued it with this feeling or energy.

And like when you said he throws it out the car window, he’s given up on his son and then the son goes back, finds it and doesn’t give it to him, but leaves it there for him. So there’s not a communication about the starting point. The ring represents it. The son doesn’t go, hey, I found your ring. There’s no communication about it, even at the end when he gives it to him. That was one of those symbols when we were talking, prepping for this episode. I was like, man, that one he gave about the championship ring is still pretty brilliant and simple and easy to understand.

But once again, conceptually, how much this country is filled with football lovers. So if you want to affect people, what do you make the symbol about? And what do you make the relationship about? And, you know, that’s a moving story for many, many people. He knows how to communicate.

Devin: And relatable. Like you said, he’s using football as the conduit to deliver that message. But anybody, any father or son watching that, that like I play, I didn’t play football growing up, but I played hockey and I can put myself in the same shoes. Whereas it’s, it’s, it’s an interesting, there’s an interesting dynamic between father. And I’m not, I don’t want to generalize, but it seems no matter how the father treats the son, the son always just wants to make the dad proud. And a lot of times, or a lot of situations, the kids in playing and growing up playing sports, and even, you know, in high school and college, even into the into the pros, that never goes away.

There is a. There’s a part of there’s a big chunk of an athlete that’s out there, because they love doing they love that sport. But there’s also a huge chunk of that, that is, they want to make their their father proud, or they want to make their family, but they want to make other people, they want to make the fans proud. And so there’s this, there’s this other part of them, that’s, that’s will never, it never goes away. And that’s not, it’s not specific to sports, it could, you know, it’s with school grades and things like that. Right.

Right.

Adam: It’s expectation and approval. That’s something that’s great to explore in a character, as far as if you want to figure out how to build your character. Well. Think of those things. Who are they trying to get approval from? Or how does their behavior affect this person? Like, who do they care about, you know, in all of these things? Because that’s where your conflict comes from and your behavioral patterns of a character is, what are they doing it for? Who are they doing it for? And the sort of expectations they have. Oh, I want to throw in this little tidbit. Did you know that symbolism was an artistic movement?

Like, during the Renaissance? It was 19th century France and Belgium. It was an artistic and poetic movement or style using symbolic images and indirect suggestion to express mystical ideas, emotions, and states of mind. Hmm. A good monster movie, just like a good antagonist in anything, is the projection of the hero’s weakness or fear or doubt, that it’s sort of this manifested negative viewpoint of self or the world. So, this internal struggle they’re having is embodied in the external monster. If you can sort of think of a lot of your antagonists in this way, you’ll get richer stories.

Devin: Mm-hmm.

Adam: Because once the hero sort of finds the want and really want, what the hero wants in a story versus when they get to the end and they have more self-discovery, what they really want, what they really discover. What they really discover is it really has nothing to do as much with the antagonist as it does to do with my viewpoint of the story I’m telling in general right now. Me living this, I’m in the zone. And so, the ability to take out the antagonist becomes a simple solution. David and Goliath, right? Simple things. The monster represents this internal emotional state, like that symbolism artistic movement, sort of a mystical idea.

Yeah. Well, you can’t really show rage or fear on screen, but you can. You can have Ed Norton beat Tyler Durden, right? Fight Club. Mm-hmm. You can show that this is this dissatisfied, rage-filled person by externalizing it, making a symbol of that internal stuff in an external way. And I think that’s one of the biggest things with ways to use symbol. In terms of the monster movie, that’s a great way to show an emotional state, something the person is. Like, what’s the one with the kid and the mother and the book? Babadook? Babadook. The Babadook is a good example of this concept. Yeah. There’s fear of the people involved, and it sort of manifests itself in the thing they’re afraid of.

Devin: Darren Aronofsky, he did that mother movie with Jennifer Lawrence and didn’t necessarily get received well, and mainly because it was a tad confusing to the audiences. It was all symbolic. Yeah. And he was at South by Southwest. Yeah. And for the first time actually in detail explained the symbolism, which the entire movie is just symbolic of Mother Earth and how we treat Mother Earth and how he used characters to symbolize different elements and how we were just basically destroying our own planet. So it was— It’s an upper— It’s fascinating. I was going to actually use that as an example, but— It’s an upper conversation. Yeah.

I would say that it’s a lower conversation for sure. Yeah. You leave it smiling.

Adam: I think Darren Aronofsky challenges his viewers. He’s deliberately provocative in a lot of ways. That’s another great like fully symbolic story.

Devin: Yeah, like it’s more of an allegory.

Adam: Yeah. And there are other ways that symbols get used. Like, for instance, sometimes the symbol can be the object of the quest. Like in the original movies, sort of set Michael Douglas in motion as a star, that he was— He had to produce himself because no one wanted to cast him in this, which was Romancing the Stone with Kathleen Turner. And then there’s a sequel to it called Jewel of the Nile. And it’s a perfect setup payoff reversal. But it’s also one of the ways I want to talk about it. Those movies are so good. They’re great, right? They’re really fun and adventure-y. Oh, yeah.

Devin: Kathleen Turner’s got that smoky voice. Well cast, too. I couldn’t even imagine those movies with two different actors in it. No.

Adam: So, Michael Douglas is amazing in it. And you’re like, why could no one believe in this guy? And you have to, for most people, we’ve said this before, they have to see it to believe it. There’s a lack of, not just imagination, but an attempt to imagine. That’s not the way it works. You need to believe it before you see it. With him, he was like, I know I can hit this out of the park. And he’s charming and funny and tough when he needs to be, but still gentle. He’s brilliant. It’s a great performance. But it just goes to show you, too, if you believe in something, you just, you stick with it.

You know, you go, I believe in this, I believe in me, and eventually people will catch on. So don’t lose sight of that. So the symbol, the thing that I want to talk about with these two movies, and I will bring in the fifth element, just as a comparative to this is, it’s a quest for an object. And we’ll talk about these a little later, like different plot formats you can do. But this is a good one and a fun one, because a quest for an object is never really about the object. It’s about the thing you think that object will bring you. That’s what the story is really about.

And she’s a romance novelist. And she so she meets the swashbuckling adventure guy in this thing. So in the second one, this is the point of the symbolic aspect of it. In the second one, they’re looking for the jewel of the Nile. And they end up running into this third party character. He’s sort of this gentle guy. And he wanders around with him the whole time. And they’re sort of protecting him. And I would say the same thing with the fifth element where you’ve got Bruce Willis, and he’s trying to take care of Milla Jovovich’s character, who’s sort of naive, that he’s going around with her, he’s the tough guy. By the end of these stories, and I’m spoiling both of these stories at once. So ba-boom. I don’t have to tell you that, apparently, because it’s not within five years. But by the end of both these stories, the jewel of the Nile, and the fifth element is not a tangible object that they’ve been looking for the whole time. They find out that it’s this person and jewel of the Nile, they discover.

They discovered that this gentle guy has, is the jewel. There is no rock, there’s no gem. It’s this guy. He’s the jewel of the Nile. And in Fifth Element, when they’re looking for the Fifth Element and they don’t even know what it is, they’ve got four elements and they’re like, she, Milla Jovovich’s character tells Bruce Willis’ character, I am the Fifth Element. And so the symbolic quality of having the Fifth Element sort of being love, I think, is the concept. She’s, she is pure love in a way. And so in order to express that idea as an externalization, much like the monster movie does with fear or doubt or negative emotion, positive emotion is what is expressed through these individuals at the end of this quest.

You know, it’s not fighting against this tough spot, negative energy wise, and that’s the monster. It’s the positive emotion is embodied in a person. And I think another movie that does that really well is, what’s the Pixar movie with the emotions that Pete Docter did? Inside Out. Yes, Inside Out. That’s it. That is a great example of how to do both things that I’m talking about here with the monster movie and the, and the, the person being an embodiment of positive emotion is they show both. You got the angry guy and you got joy and you got sadness. And this is, you know, Symbolic of what you cannot express outwardly, emotion, state of mind, mystical idea that those three things put into an object that is tangibly recognizable. You can understand it. In real life, sailors, they scared of the sea because they didn’t know what it was about. And so they used to come up with tales. There used to be the hafgufa, and it became slowly known as the Kraken, but it was this giant monster that lived in the sea that took down ships.

It was a great way to express. How the sea itself was untamed. It’s, it becomes manifest as this monster. Now they may have, earlier accounts, they may have seen like a giant squid or something. Or a whale. Something that would have scared the crap out of them. And they just all, it became the boogeyman forever. But men’s fear of the uncontrollable, it’s at sea, became a sea monster. Many different sea monsters for that matter. The Kraken just happens to be the most pervasive in literature and mythology, but it can show his fear or positive emotion symbolically. That’s part of the fun for me, I think. Next week, we’re going to explore a different kind of symbolism and how filmed media lends itself to symbolism in other ways, like in…

Like in set dressing, wardrobe, and more. Please subscribe and rate us on iTunes, and for additional story-related resources, video, and archived content, visit our website at StoryOsophy.com.