Show notes
Adam and Devin wrap up their conversation about resolution. Adam shares his trick for keeping an audience hooked, they discuss how Lost lost track of its own questions, and they break down two films whose endings defy expectations: one that brings you to tears, and one that made Adam furious.
In this episode
- Overlapping questions. Like a musical round, Adam poses a new question before he answers the last one, so there’s always a reason to keep watching.
- I smell writer. Setups need to be quieter than cliffhangers. Adam’s warning sign is when the writer’s hand becomes obvious.
- Lost’s questions. Without a long-term plan, Lost posed more questions than it could answer, though its international cast and storytelling broke new ground.
- Rewatching with an expert. Devin admits he’s a “living spoiler alert” when watching movies with his girlfriend.
- Friday Night Lights. The team loses the championship, but the real resolution comes when a father who has abused his son walks onto the field, hugs him and gives him his championship ring.
- The antagonist changes. Like Guillermo del Toro’s idea last episode, the antagonist is defeated by realization, not destruction.
- No Country for Old Men. The Coen brothers kill off the hero offscreen and end on Sheriff Bell recounting a dream. Adam hated it, and says it’s a perfect resolution anyway.
- Resolution without satisfaction. A resolution can be emotional, surprising or deeply frustrating, as long as it’s true to the story.
Examples discussed
- Friday Night Lights, No Country for Old Men, Lost, The Usual Suspects, Shutter Island, Fight Club, Psycho and 2001: A Space Odyssey.
- Also: Peter Berg’s Lone Survivor, Patriots Day, Deepwater Horizon, Very Bad Things and Wonderland.
Coen brothers, we forgive you.
Read the full transcript
Transcribed automatically, so expect the odd misheard word. Sponsor messages are left out.
Adam: Next on StoryOsophy. Hello, welcome to StoryOsophy. This is Adam Jones. And Devin Halden. Right before we started recording, Devin sends me a text. It’s a picture of his breakfast and it looks freaking good. What, what is in that? What’d you have in that? Were they corn tortillas? Breakfast burritos? What were they?
Devin: They’re gluten-free tortillas. I can’t remember. Almond. They’re almond tortillas. What? We get our, our meat from a, from a farm in Wisconsin. So it’s all grass fed. They have the best breakfast sausage. Just, I don’t know. They, what, everything they put into it, but it’s fantastic. And then we get, we get our eggs from them as well. So they actually- You drive there? No, they deliver. Wow. It’s great. And so that, every morning I have the, I make some of the breakfast sausage and that, the one I had today was bulk. It’s like a bulk sausage. So, but we also have, they also have like really good patties. So I make that and I put, two eggs in there. I just kind of scramble it all together. My girlfriend makes our ketchup, mayo, mustard, ranch, hot sauce. She makes all that stuff from scratch because she’s very healthy and gluten-free and dairy-free and everything. So put a little hot sauce on there and make a cup of At Some Effin’ Good coffee. And that’s it. That’s my breakfast every morning until I get sick of it. And then I do something else.
Adam: Is At Some Effin’ Good available right now?
Devin: It will be in about a month. We look forward to it. We’re getting all the bags from Hawaii.
Adam: I expect to have a sampling as a coffee connoisseur. I’m going to tell you whether it’s good or not.
Devin: Oh, it’s fantastic.
Adam: Is it?
Devin: Yeah, it’s really good.
Adam: I like dark roasts like espresso and French roast, like heavier, bolder roasts.
Devin: Okay, we have one of those. That’s our Saturday night blend. It’s not a blend. It’s actually 100%.
Adam: This week, we continue and conclude our discussion about resolutions. So if you haven’t listened to last week’s episode, part one, do it. I promised last week that I would talk about a little writer’s trick I have for keeping your audience hooked, which is simply a rhythm of resolved and unresolved questions. So you constantly have an overlapping question. The rhythm is similar to a musical round. So a musical round, for those of you who don’t know, the idea is you start singing a song and after the first progression, another person starts singing after you. So it’s sort of overlap and overlap and overlap. So by the time this first sequence is done, the other one has started and then the first one ends.
So I like to overlap in stories questions of curiosity, baiting my audience so that there’s a question that’s unanswered. I pose another question that’s unanswered and then answer the first one. So no matter what, there’s always a baited curiosity point in the story. I learned this from a late-at-night B movie, a Shannen Doherty movie about a stalker. That’s a good one. That I watched the entirety of one night and then couldn’t figure out why. And then I realized they just kept posing questions for me to solve and I needed to know the answer. And all they did was overlap them. And it was the simplest trick on a – it wasn’t a great story, but it was well-constructed, really well-constructed to bait an audience.
Using that to an elevated degree was what I sort of determined for myself after watch. I was like, oh my gosh, I don’t know why I’m watching this. I’m not a huge Shannen Doherty fan by any means, but I can’t help it. I have to work in the morning. What’s going on? That’s human nature. Human nature, you want to know the answer. You need conclusion. You need resolution. And talking about the difference, what Devin was saying, set-up cliffhanger, there’s subtlety and then there’s overtness. And the sort of in-your-face element that the hook has or the cliffhanger has is intentional. So is the subtlety of a set-up that is equally as intentional?
Just quieter. And if you don’t plant those set-ups quieter, you’ll fall prey to this heavy-handed thing. This is what I call it. I call it, I smell writer in here. When I look at my script and I’m like, well, that’s obvious. That’s my big joke about overwriting subtlety. The thing with these ongoing long-form storytelling chapter-based series, the kind of storytelling right now that I’m in love with. I love the binge-watching. The binge-watching is the best part. They have to find resolution and still maintain mystery per episode. Meanwhile, they’re building to that season finale resolution. So there’s a resolution within each episode, but they’re also building towards a larger resolution at the end of the season.
Films don’t have that luxury as much. Novels can do it. Each chapter sort of conceptually being an episode. I think you can sort of squeeze that down into a film, a feature film. You know what I mean? Which is sort of what I, when I write features, that’s what I try to do. Is take that concept of baiting and baiting and just squeeze it down into a shorter span of time, 90 to 120. That’s what’s interesting to me when I’m watching binge-worthy stuff is how do they resolve this and still continue it? That’s the art form in long-form series.
Devin: And I think that’s where Lost, just from hearing firsthand accounts of people that I knew spent some time in the writing room for Lost. They didn’t have this story planned out. No. They basically had the first couple episodes planned out or the pilot and then a couple episodes and then they ended up. A season and a half. Yeah. And then they’re like, well, now what? So they would basically piecemeal this thing together, which is, I think, which is why you always had more questions than answers at the end of each of those episodes.
Adam: I also knew someone in the writer’s room. I can tell you this for a fact. So what happened was J.J. Abrams and Damon Lindelof, they were working on building that first series Bible, right? For the listeners who may not know. You may not be aware of what a series Bible is. It’s the episodes laid out. It’s the season laid out. It’s a series laid out so that you understand comprehensively where it’s going to go without the episodes having been written. So each episode has its own little summary. So they had that. J.J. Abrams shot the pilot. He directed the pilot for Lost, which was one of the most expensive pilots at that time.
Now there are a lot of pilots are this expensive. And then he used the pilot to pitch himself as the director for the new Mission Impossible that he was going to do. And then he was gone. And so the building and the really great cliffhanger-y, baiting, sci-fi stuff that he’s so good at, and Damon Lindelof is so good with characters. Well, Carlton Cuse, you know, was part of the picture too. JJ Abrams split, and so they started after that season and a half that they had, which the second season of course starts with Desmond and Hatch, and it’s awesome. I just want to say, that series is so exciting to watch from the start. So exciting.
After JJ Abrams split, they now brought in, obviously, because it was greenlit, a writing team. Damon Lindelof and Carlton Cuse were helming the thing. And they each have gone on to do really wonderful series. And I think at that point, they were sort of just trying to go, what do we do with this television series that’s so impacting and successful to keep people interested? Just to broaden the perspective on this conversation about Lost, Lost was one of the first television shows that featured an international cast. It also showed each main character of the ensemble their perspective in history and in terms of a lot of the characters in their own language.
That was not English, subtitled. Weird for a television show. It’s not become so strange these days, but back then it was sort of like, these are all risky things, very risky. And it just popped because everybody identified with it, and it became an international sensation. Well, they needed to keep up. It changed, it evolved, it became different things. As you said, they started baiting more, they realized what they had, and it was a big, it was an orgy of cliffhangers. Let’s just put it that way. All these questions they posed, they didn’t even remember the questions they’d asked, but their audience did. And they were waiting for answers by the end of the series. And they didn’t get all of them. Some stories I have love-hate relationships with. Lost, I love. I love Lost. I’m not happy with the ending. But Damon Lindelof even said, after watching the Breaking Bad finale, that’s how you do a finale. I don’t think he was fully satisfied with the resolution of the series based on…
All of the proliferated questions. They couldn’t figure out how to answer them all. My problem with Lost was not in that as much as… Spoiler alert. No, doesn’t count. Spoiler alert. Nope, doesn’t need one. They killed one of my favorite characters. They killed my favorite character, and they made me think he was still alive. And for that, I forgive you.
Let’s do some examples. Devin, you want to kick off the examples? Example King?
Devin: Shutter Island and Fight Club. They both have very similar ways of similar techniques of resolution, where it’s like a scene or a series of scenes at the end that kind of takes all of the setups, whether they were subtle or deliberate, and pays them all off, kind of like tipping, like just a quick set of dominoes going down. What I like about that though, especially Shutter Island and Fight Club, as we talked about in a previous episode, it makes the audience want to go back and experience that story again with some omniscience. That omniscient feeling of like, I know everything. I know who these characters are. I know what they’re thinking at this stage of the game. And it’s kind of fun, and it’s really annoying if you’re watching the movie with somebody that hasn’t seen the movie before. Some of these movies where you’re like, hey, did you see that? Did you see that? And then you start pointing all the crap out to them, and they’re like, can I just watch the movie the first time? Like you were able to watch the movie the first time and see it for the first time. I do that with my girlfriend all the time. Oh, did you see it? And I rewind it.
I’m like, here, check this out. Watch this. It’s very subtle. You wouldn’t notice it. And then she’s like, well, how do you notice it? I’m like, because I’ve seen the end of the movie. So I’m basically a living spoiler alert when I’m watching a movie with my girlfriend.
Adam: I’ve been trying to warn you people, this whole podcast about this guy. It’s so hard. The rewatch value of things, the layers. Once you get to that resolution, if there are many layers to that film, you’re going to want to go back and watch it.
Devin: Yeah.
Adam: And one of the films I was talking about before, Usual Suspects, it’s very similar to the one you were just mentioning. In the end of that, you sort of get this big reveal of things. In a lot of movies, you get the big reveal in the last, like, five minutes, if there’s a huge thing that you want to impact the audience with. And so the resolution happens in this very short, compact section of time, but everything is paid off. Everything. It’s almost like getting a rush of resolution or information, all of us. And so you have to rewatch it.
Devin: So I wanted to have an example that isn’t that mind-blowing series of dominoes, kind of like Usual Suspects and Fight Club and things like that. And the movie that has more subtle… Resolution is Friday Night Lights, the actual movie.
Adam: I’ve not seen it, so you’ll have to… You explain it to me as if I’ve never seen it. Perfect. It’s got one of my favorite actors in it, Ryan Hurst. I love that dude. Love that dude. He played Opie in Sons of Anarchy, and I just was like, who is this guy? I don’t remember the character he plays, but I know he’s in it.
Devin: And it’s directed by Peter Berg, who I think is one of the greatest directors ever.
Adam: Oh my God! He’s amazing. Because his stuff is wildly innovative. And he doesn’t apologize for it. He knows how to adapt a book. I love that guy.
Devin: The themes of his movies are very strong and always emotional. He’s very good with emotion.
Adam: Wonderland. He made Wonderland, the TV series. It got canceled, but I watched the first couple episodes and I was like, this is amazing. Of course it got canceled, because it was amazing.
Devin: If you have a real-life event, like a historic event that’s happened, an event, a historic event that didn’t necessarily take place. He’s like the go-to guy, because he did that movie about the oil rig that blew up.
Adam: Yeah, I don’t know. It’s so weird that you’re saying he’s the guy to go to for historic picks, because for me, I remember him from Wonderland. I remember him from Very Bad Things, The Rundown. One of my favorite filmmakers is Rob Reiner, because of the diversity of his filmmaking. He has done so many genres. Peter Berg is equally as talented moving between genres. Very Bad Things is a… It’s a dark comedy. The endings, the resolution of that, not a big fan of. But the journey, until I get to the resolution, awesome. And my example later is the same scenario. The journey’s great. The resolution, I did not like.
But that’s why I chose it as an example. Continue.
Devin: Peter Berg, dude. Friday Night Lights, Lone Survivor, Patriot’s Day, and Deepwater Horizon. Those are the ones why I’m making that statement. Because they’re all real-life things that happen. I believe there’s probably books. He probably adapted them all from novels or books that actually were written about them. But they weren’t these huge events of well-known people that we knew about. He basically takes these crazy events that happened that it would happen to any of us. Like Patriot’s Day, it’s about, you know, of course, it’s about the Boston Marathon bombing. And then Deepwater Horizon is a bunch of just roughnecks out and, you know, working on an oil drill that blows up.
And they’re heroic things. I mean, and The Lone Survivor, of course, you know, is about these guys that get pinned down in Afghanistan. So it’s like there’s these. And then Friday Night Lights is just about a high school football team. He takes these everyday things that people relate to. And it’s like we can put our hand out and touch. And he brings this incredible emotion. He tells the story brilliantly. So Friday Night Lights, based on a book, and it’s based on the town of Odessa, Texas, and this high school football team. Called the. Permian High Panthers. If anybody knows, Texas is like the hotbed of football.
Like football is life down there. It’s a very simple story with a very powerful resolution that you almost don’t see coming. Berg brilliantly depicts this economically depressed town. And it almost feels like when you’re watching it and you’re kind of looking at what’s going on. It feels like this town is almost like quarantined off from the world. And just has been treading water for like a hundred years. And. So the town. And specifically in this movie, he’s just obsessed with high school football and this current group of high school football players. It’s almost to a pathetic level. Grown men, the fathers of these kids, still wear their high school championship rings. And it’s like this badge of honor or the status symbol in the town if you were on a team that won the state championship. And so it’s like you’re looking at it like, wow, that’s just weird.
And so while you’re watching the film, you think you’re watching a movie about a high school football team that is inevitably going to overcome these great odds, and they’re going to win the coveted state championship. It’s kind of like Hoosiers or, you know, these other movies where it’s like, you know, they’re going to overcome and they’re going to become state champions. But as a story unfolds, the football games actually become just events that happen between teams. The true story thread and the true story that’s unfolding, which is the relationship between this town and this football team and the relationship between a father who’s Charles Billingsley in real life, he’s played by Tim McGraw in the movie, and his son, Don Billingsley, who’s played by Garrett Hedlund.
And there’s many intense scenes, but there are these scenes in the movie that strengthen this tension between Charles Billingsley and his son, Don. In fact, there’s one scene. There’s one scene in particular where his son has a girl over and he grabs a football, throws it in his hands, and then he just keeps wrapping duct tape around his hands because his son fumbled the game, you know, at the previous game. And so he just, you know, he verbally and physically abuses his kid throughout the movie. And then there’s the scene right after one of the games where Charles Billingsley, his dad, is so drunk that Don has to drive him home.
And during the car ride home, Charles just like kicks out all the windows of his car. And then he takes off his state championship ring and throws it out the window. But the next morning when he wakes up, he sees that his son, Don, went back and found it on the side of the road somewhere and brought it back, knowing how important this ring is to his father. So it’s like that act of love for his father, who is terrible to him, is just really powerful.
Adam: I didn’t even see the movie and that you describing that is very powerful because it’s not just him finding the ring because it’s valuable. But to his father, it’s his father’s faith in football and him that is symbolized in that ring.
Devin: Yeah.
Adam: That’s some just brilliant story construction. Yeah. If you can describe that to me and I can understand the emotional potential of the whole thing, that’s pretty amazing storytelling. Hey, Peter Berg, if you’re out there listening per chance, high five, brother.
[Sponsor message]
Devin: Throughout the film, you see the strain and this really terrible relationship between father and son. Yet, even though his father is so terrible to him, you can still see in Don that he just wants approval. He wants love. He wants his dad to be proud of him, which a lot of people can relate to.
Adam: It’s all children. Children and parents, that’s a lot of what they deal with, so it’s very relatable. That’s why Star Wars is so relatable. It’s all parents and kids.
Devin: And you can also see the frustration in his father. In high school, you know, these kids can do no wrong. You know, if you play football in high school in Texas, but it’s not exclusive to Texas, you can do no wrong. If you play football, you’re treated like a god in Odessa, if we’re specifically talking about this movie. And the cops will look the other way if you get in trouble. But when you graduate, you’re nothing. And it’s like… It’s like this harsh reminder that time waits for no one. And, you know, it’s like story. You need to constantly be moving forward. You need to be thinking about your next move.
Because if you don’t, you will wake up one day and the rest of the world has passed you by. Which is kind of what’s happened to his father. And like I said before, Berg, there’s so many themes to this story and others like that. Where it’s like, you don’t realize you’re being taught this lesson while you’re watching it. And you don’t realize subconsciously, you’re seeing everything that’s happening on screen. And it’s basically speaking to you. And that’s what’s freaking beautiful about what he’s doing.
Adam: A good story, you don’t see the lesson while you’re watching it. You wait to the end and you get it. You just get it.
Devin: What’s going on in this town, and it’s like this vicious cycle, is like there’s this next class of kids that are always on your heels. So, you know, just like live in the moment, but don’t forget about the future.
Adam: And don’t rest on your laurels. You cannot rest on your laurels either. You have to keep reinventing and building self. And that’s part of that thing is that symbolism with that ring, literally leaning on your laurels, or the concept of this used to be great, and I believe in the idea of its greatness, and I expect that same thing from my son.
Devin: Right.
Adam: Even though that concept – this is going to segue into my example really well, because there’s that illusion for the father, and he keeps trying – Right. He’s sort of overcompensation with the son, and the son’s just looking for the father’s love.
Devin: Yeah.
Adam: And that’s the storyline there, you know, or acceptance or support.
Devin: Right, right, right.
Adam: Realistic support, and not just like idealized support.
Devin: And for his father, Charles, and all his football teammates, they weren’t doing that. And so, for many of them who didn’t make plans to get out of Odessa in other ways other than football, they never get out. Oh. The only thing they have are the memories of these glory days as a high school football player, which is – it’s like, are you serious?
Adam: Now I’m going to have to watch this story. I’m going to have to watch this movie really bad now.
Devin: Through the eyes of his son, Don, and his fellow teammates, like, in the present while we’re watching them, they just want to be kids.
But they also don’t want to end up like their fathers. Again, this isn’t exclusive to Odessa, Texas. This happens, like, in every state in the United States.
Adam: And not just in football. Oh, no, yeah. It’s in different things. It’s like the doctor who wants his children to be doctors, who wants – the lawyer wants his children to be – it’s a passing down of history, tradition, industry. What you’re describing is a – Is a story about generational inheritance.
Devin: The ending of the film is a brilliant execution of confusion, not necessarily misdirection, but confusion and then emotional resolution. Because even up to the last play of the game, we feel that the resolution is going to be the Permian Panther – and they’re in the state championship game at this point. They’re going to win. These guys are going to win the game. They’re going to win. And the town will love them. They’ll celebrate them. And they’ll go down in history. And Don’s father will finally respect him and love him because now he’s a champion like he was. And as we watch the final play unfold, they’re down, but they can win on a touchdown.
As we watch this play unfold, there’s this incredible symbolism of all the important elements we saw throughout the film. We watch the quarterback take the snap for the – he’s the quarterback for the Permian Panthers – takes the snap. He drops back. He’s breaking tackles. He’s fighting his way closer to the end zone. And then his teammates – join him. And they grab him. And they get behind him. And they start pushing him against the other team that’s pushing against him. And they’re all together trying to push him into the end zone desperately with everything they have. As their parents – as they do shots of the parents that are looking – they’re in the stands.
All these people – the dads that won this championship 20 years ago. You know, they’re looking on helplessly. And the kids are in this fight together. They’re there for each other. The way they’ve probably been the – since they’ve grown up and then how they’ve been through this entire story. The anticipation – our anticipation watching this is we just want him to cross that goal line. And so everything will be okay. To the point of us – like when I’m watching it, I was literally yelling at the screen as if I was literally watching this game play out on live television. And then boom. It’s quickly destroyed because he’s tackled literally a foot from the end zone.
Game over and they lose. And so when you’re watching this movie, if you weren’t privy to actually the actual – what really happened in – this happened in 1988, you’re like, what?
Adam: Like, I just watched this entire movie. This is a movie. I’m supposed to have a happy ending. They’re supposed to win.
Devin: Exactly. Like, I just watched this entire movie and the team loses? But then the true moment of resolution, dude. And I promise if you haven’t seen this movie during this point, your tears are – tears will well up in your eyes and they’ll fall down your cheeks because Charles Billingsley walks – from the stands onto the field and just starts walking right towards his son. And instead of yelling at him, instead of hitting him, instead of any act of shame like he’s done throughout the entire movie, dude hugs this kid. He takes off his state championship ring from his finger and puts it on his son.
Adam: Wow. Dude, it is so powerful. It’s subverting an ending. It’s funny because the – like I said, the example that I have is the same concept. A resolution is easy to understand. When you watch a story and you get to the end of it, And everything gels perfectly. You go, man, that was good. That was such a good story. And everything gels resolution-wise. The examples that Devin and I have chosen here aren’t that, because that’s a little more obvious and you can sort of figure that out on your own. But stories that do the same thing, but don’t have the expectation of resolution that you’re thinking are sort of our examples.
Devin: Not to mention, though, that this entire thing, like the minute he gets tackled, the decisions on how he edited that scene are so brilliant, how it’s the slow-mo, it’s the quad, you can’t really hear the, you know, everything’s kind of quiet. And then when he gets tackled, the song Sonho Dourado starts playing, which is like the perfect, like, if you’re going to have a perfect song for that moment at that time, it’s like, that’s the song that I would choose. Just the power. The power of the emotional power of that scene when Charles Billingsley played by Tim McGraw. Tim McGraw plays it fantastic. You know, he finally realizes what’s important. And, you know, it’s his son. And he’s leaving, he literally watched his son leave everything out on the field because he wants to make his dad proud. And anybody who’s played competitive sports or anything like we talked about, but I’ve been in that situation.
You just, like, half of the time, you’re out there for three people. And it’s usually… It’s like a 45-45-10, where it’s like 45% for my teammates, 45% for my dad, and then 10% for me is why I’m doing this. You know, you just want to make other people proud, and you don’t want to let anybody down, including yourself. But a lot of times, it’s like in the back of your mind, it’s like, you know, especially boys, we just want to make our dads proud. And so that’s such a powerful, it’s such a powerful scene. And then, again, the decisions through filmmaking and what they did with how they edited it and the music and stuff.
Like, just added to, like, the waterworks we’re on.
Adam: To sort of tie it back to what we were talking about earlier, that sort of Guillermo del Toro clip that I watched, the antagonist, the Tim McGraw character, for lack of a better way of putting it, he is sort of the antagonist of the situation. It’s the same discovery that Guillermo del Toro is talking about.
Devin: Guillermo.
Adam: You don’t defeat the antagonist by killing him. You defeat the antagonist by them having a realization of change. Like I say, when we’re talking about character arc and even before that in this podcast, if you really want to tell a good story, if you really want to focus on character journey and depth of plot, focus on changing a character’s entire belief system, the whole thing. His father is, he’s relying on this championship to define who he is, and now he’s defining his son by the same standards. And by the end of the story, he’s not doing that. He’s giving his son the ring to show. You gave probably more fight than we did 20 years ago.
The antagonist is defeated by changing, by evolving, by realization. That’s a beautiful resolution for an antagonist. It’s one of the best, one of my favorites.
Devin: Yeah, I agree.
Adam: And for a hero, same thing. You can have a realization. But sometimes stories are just about that villain’s realization. And it’s the hero’s continued will. Like the son, to be, to be, to be, to be. And then the father realizes, oh, that’s just who they are. And so the whole story is about, the resolution of the story is about the realization of the antagonist. And it’s the steadfastness of the hero, the will there. There are a lot of different ways to resolve a story. It doesn’t mean everything is a happy ending. As Devin just pointed out, it’s not a happy ending for the team. It’s a happy ending for that relationship.
Devin: Right.
Adam: In my example, it’s a little different. Right. In my example, it is actually a movie that I both liked and did not like. I love the Coen brothers. Some of my favorite filmmakers ever because they’re so innovative and interesting and they just take chances that nobody else takes. And a lot of their filmmaking delves into philosophy. If you haven’t guessed, with Devin and I talking for the past almost 20 episodes now, StoryOsophy, we like philosophizing about things, especially story. So I’m not, I’m no stranger to philosophy. I love it. I’m going to talk about. The Coen brothers, No Country for Old Men, because I hated the ending.
I don’t hate a lot of stuff, but I hated the ending of this movie. Now, it doesn’t mean it didn’t have a resolution or a proper resolution or a good resolution. It doesn’t mean that it wasn’t a good movie for what it was doing as a story. As an audience member, I hated the experience. So let me explain to you how this plays out so you get it. The first part of this movie is very exciting. It’s almost like a thriller, a cowboy thriller with Josh Brolin’s character Moss who finds money in this. It’s obvious there’s a shootout. Things have gone wrong here. It’s a crime scene.
But he takes the money and leaves. And he gets involved in this sort of film noir thriller. It’s sort of like halfway between cowboy movie and film noir. It’s interesting. And the investigating officer is Tommy Lee Jones. I mean that’s, it’s not Tommy Lee Jones for real. He plays the character. Can’t remember his name though. Tommy Lee Jones playing Tommy Lee Jones. Rated R. So the concept is he’s investigating and he’s this, he rides on a horse. Old school western cowboy dude. Oh geez, Tommy Lee Jones. Tommy Lee Jones. You know, he talks in that low rumble. You know, still sharp, sharp as a tack. Like The Fugitive, smart Tommy Lee Jones played as a cowboy.
And he’s investigating. And he’s sort of, throughout the whole movie, very detached from whatever’s happening. He’s not involved with it. There’s no shootout and chase or anything with Tommy Lee Jones. He just shows up after all that stuff and sniffs it out like an old hound dog. What’s interesting about this movie is somewhere in between, in between all of the, the violence that, Javier Bardem, Javier Bardem’s character unleashes on this cinematic world and Josh Brolin’s attempt to survive and do what’s right and figure things out because he’s sort of a thief anyway. You have this guy who’s just sort of hanging around, Tommy Lee Jones. Not really solving anything. Picking up on clues.
And he, he goes and visits his old friend. He’s played by Barry Corbin. I love this actor, Barry Corbin. Tommy Lee Jones’ character’s name is Bell. Bell is in this, what seems like a western. It’s not a traditional western. But he’s the cowboy. He’s this displaced cowboy lawman who believes that criminals get captured and get put in jail and that’s the way the good old days were and that’s the way the world works. And Barry Corbin is the, is a retired lawman who, in a wheelchair, who was shot by a criminal. I believe that’s the backstory for his character. But he’s not able to move and he’s now really, really old. And they have a scene together.
Tommy Lee Jones says to him, I feel overmatched. And this is when Javier Bardem’s character’s come in. He’s started to kill people. Josh Brolin’s character, who we are, it’s the person we sort of start identifying with the most. The, the story structure itself has a recipe much like Psycho. You identify with Josh Brolin’s character. You go with him for a bit. And then halfway through the movie, Tommy Lee Jones’ character shows up to a crime scene and they tell you that Josh Brolin’s character is dead in a pool. Dead in a pool? They just tell you off screen he’s dead. He died. You don’t see it. You don’t get to see anything happen.
This character just goes, goes away. So the character that you’re used to, as in Alfred Hitchcock’s Psycho, she’s, we identify with this woman, she’s in the shower and then she gets killed. And we’re like, well, who the heck are we supposed to identify with now? Who’s, who’s the person we’re tracking? And for Psycho, it ends up being Anthony, Norman Bates, who’s the only person we have left to sort of identify with as a character. Who’s sort of protagonist, antagonist. In this scenario, we’re left with Tommy Lee Jones or Javier Bardem’s villain, Chigurh. Who is a psychopath. He’s just taking out people who are in his way with a, with a cattle, what do they call it?
Cattle killer? You know what I mean? Do you remember this movie? Vaguely. In the middle of this movie, you’re left with the choice of, do I stick with this person who’s been detached sort of the whole movie, which is Tommy Lee Jones’ character? Or do I stick with the villain who is just this nasty person? So of course you choose Tommy Lee Jones. And you’re looking at the end. Of course, he’s going to catch this guy.
Devin: This old cowboy is going to catch the bad guy.
Adam: Because that’s how these stories work. This is a western. And it’s the same mentality that Tommy Lee Jones has. That’s how the world works. Good guys catch bad guys. And when he goes to have that conversation with the, with the retired lawman, with Barry Corbin’s character. And he says, I feel overmatched. Barry Corbin keeps pressing him about, Ellis, that’s the name of the character that Barry Corbin plays. Keeps pressing him. Why are you retiring? Why do you want to retire? And eventually the, I feel overmatched comes out. The end of the movie is one of the most frustrating. And angering resolutions to a movie that I’ve ever experienced.
Tommy Lee Jones having breakfast with his wife. Now, as I tell this to you, you’re going to get bored. Because it’s the most boring scene ever. He’s newly retired. She’s got to go to work. He’s going to have the day off. He’s thinking about doing stuff around the house. Talks about dreams. She goes, why don’t you tell me about them? And he goes, oh, dreams are only exciting to the ones who experience it. Which is a funny line right before he goes into these monologues. So he says the first line. The first dream is about his father giving him money. And then he lost it. He said, I can’t remember the first dream very well.
But I remember this. And he said, the second dream, I was older than he was in the dream. And he talks about this dream where they’re riding through the night on horses through a dark pass. And his father leaves and goes ahead. And he’s been bringing the embers from the last campfire to build the new campfire. Which is sort of a traditional cowboy thing. And he says, he rode ahead of me. And I knew that once I got to where we were going. The fire would be lit. There would be light there.
Devin: And then he sort of goes, and then I woke up.
Adam: Cut to black. That harsh. Cut to black. Screw you, audience. Cut to black. He doesn’t catch them. Just like the real world, his illusion of being the good guy, bad guy lawman is an illusion to him. It’s just a dream. Screw you. You do not get an ending. Your ending is the fact that you don’t get the ending. And the philosophy of the nihilistic real world, via the Coen brothers, is what you get for an ending. I couldn’t have been angrier. And it couldn’t have been a more artistically appropriate ending to that story. They wanted me to be angry. They wanted me to feel as impotent and overmatched as him.
Meanwhile, I thought I was with Moss. I thought I was with Josh Brolin’s character. He died. Where do I go now? The next best guy who retires. He’s given up because he realizes the bad guys win sometimes. And he’s so exhausted. And he still thinks of that dream. And then the Coen brothers. And then I woke up. Cut to black. You dirty dogs, you. Brilliant filmmaking. Hated it.
Devin: This is going to be a sequel.
Adam: And you know, it’s funny. I watched the interview with Cormac McCarthy about the novel that they adapted it from. And it ends with a dream. It ends with him talking about a dream. The wife isn’t there in the book. They created the wife character in that scenario so that he could be telling someone this useless boy. And we could see someone like us going, is there a point to this? Like, is there, you know what I mean? Is there something that makes me feel good? Or is it just this empty feeling that I’m supposed to be left with? Nope, you’re supposed to be left with that empty feeling. You’re supposed to be left with that empty feeling.
And like I said, the reason why I absolutely hated that movie and the same reason why it’s a great movie. It just because it’s great doesn’t mean a 2001: A Space Odyssey is supposed to be a great movie. There are parts of it I hate, parts of it I love. Great movies I don’t necessarily have to love. They’re just supposed to have some influence on me. The beginning of that movie is like thriller, thriller, thriller. They’re baiting you. They’re showing you that it’s a perfect setup payoff, but the setup’s all exciting, cop, killing, thriller, all that stuff. And then the end is sort of like, it just sort of, it’s a very anticlimactic ending. And it just leaves you as an audience member feeling as impotent as the characters.
So as a filmmaker, translating that tone. I love the movie and the theme of the movie, all these abstract ideas, those philosophical scenes, the setup with the old lawman Ellis, and then the end where he’s like, I am the old man that there is no country for, which is never really addressed in that title until you get to the end and you’re like, that’s why he’s going away.
Devin: That’s why he’s retiring because there’s no room for him anymore. It’s too much. He’s overmatched. Good example. I liked it. I think we did a good job of very different. I think we did a good job of bringing examples of how the resolution can be different. Doesn’t have to be like this series of mind blowing dominoes that fall. It can be very emotional and it’s something you can still be blindsided by it, but it doesn’t have to be some crazy reveal or it can be just really bad and something that doesn’t leave the audience with that satisfaction that we yearn for with a resolution.
Adam: But it’s still resolution. It’s still resolution. You’re right. That’s a perfect resolution of that story, but it was not satisfactory. It wasn’t satisfactory to me. It still works. I gave the finger to the screen.
Devin: No, you should have just said, Adam. What? I forgive you.
Coen brothers, I forgive you. I forgive you.
Adam: I forgive you. Please subscribe and rate us on iTunes. And for additional story related resources, video and archived content, visit our website at StoryOsophy.com.