Show notes
Adam and Devin begin a two-part look at resolution: how you tie up loose ends and bring every thread of a story together into an ending that means something. They look at the word’s many definitions, how an antagonist can be defeated without being destroyed, and the difference between a resolution and a cliffhanger.
In this episode
- Tie up every string. When your setups pay off and your arcs are complete, the story’s loose strings become one thread.
- Moonlight and the light switch. Setups are a dark room lit only by moonlight. The payoff switches on the light. Without the moonlight, the audience feels tricked.
- Release. The Latin root of resolution means to release or loosen. In music, it’s discord resolving into harmony; in medicine, a symptom disappearing; on a screen, a sharper image.
- Past meets present. In Just Friends, a man who was bullied as a teenager has to come to terms with his past.
- Defeat without destruction. Guillermo del Toro says it’s more powerful for a villain to realize what they’ve become than to be killed. In Disney’s live-action Cinderella, “I forgive you” undoes the stepmother.
- Every story is a mystery. Treat your characters as mysteries, peel back a layer at a time, and the audience will want to solve them.
- The cliffhanger. Scheherazade survived a thousand and one nights by never finishing her story. Cliffhangers bait curiosity, while setups stay subtle.
- Hooks and cliffhangers. An episode’s strongest moments are its beginning and end, with the cold open as the hook and the cliffhanger as its counterpart.
Examples discussed
- Cinderella (2015), Just Friends, The Shape of Water, Scream, Lost, Breaking Bad and One Thousand and One Nights.
Continued next episode, along with Adam’s trick for keeping an audience hooked.
Read the full transcript
Transcribed automatically, so expect the odd misheard word. Sponsor messages are left out.
Adam: Hello. Welcome to StoryOsophy. This is Adam Jones.
Devin: And Devin Halden. Sorry. I wasn’t prepared for that.
Adam: How are you feeling this week, Devin?
Devin: I feel better than last week. I’m over my sickness. I’m getting over my accident injuries. And I’m just dealing with trying to find a car, which is not fun. So that’s where I’m at.
Adam: Nothing can take Devin down. He’s a machine. I’m sure I speak on behalf of the rest of the StoryOsophers out there who wish you a speedy recovery and also hope that you get a sweet, sweet ride. That being said, let’s get busy. Let’s just jump right into it, shall we? Yeah. I’m with you. We got a lot to talk about. Resolution is part of the structure of a story, and we will talk about that as an ending piece to it when we go into season two with our structure season. What we want to talk about this episode is resolution in terms of how you tie up your loose ends, how you dovetail things together, and how you sort of tidy up your story at the end so it has meaning for your audience.
If you’ve done your work properly as a writer throughout the course, as a story, there are setups and payoffs, as we talked about last episode. And the ultimate payoff would be to weave all of these beautiful elements together into this, what you would call a singularity, boiled down into this place in an ending. And you don’t necessarily, not all endings have to be as simplified as that. But in order for your audience to feel satisfied with what they’ve agreed to be watching or reading, they want to understand that everything that you’ve been telling them has a purpose. Entertainment is a strong enough purpose. I prefer something a little bit more artistic where there’s a deeper meaning to it, where there’s philosophy involved, where there’s change and growth.
And as we talked about a few episodes ago, transformation and catharsis for the characters. Those are the things that I enjoy the most. As usual, we’ll dive into sort of defining some of the words we’re going to use and where they come from. But Devin, did you have anything before? Before we… Get into defining some things that you wanted to mention?
Devin: I agree with everything you just kind of laid out. I think it’s the most important element of the story to execute for your audience. You want to start laying the dominoes down. But in order for that, all of that to have caught your audience off guard and for them to be satisfied with the journey they just took with the characters in your world, you’re going to want to have blueprinted your story in a way that your setups and character arcs blend kind of harmoniously. To kind of culminate into a scene or a series of scenes of resolution and discovery. For the audience that leaves them kind of with that satisfaction that they weren’t tricked and if they do leave satisfied and they’re like, wow, that caught me off guard or you, you know, you did your job.
Your red herrings and your misdirections were, you know, they did their jobs and you left the audience wondering how they didn’t see something coming and I think that’s kind of why this is, the resolution is so important and Adam, you and I were kind of talking off air about a good way to do that is to kind of reverse engineer your resolutions in a way. Yeah, yeah. And maybe not reverse engineer them in the beginning. But certainly when you’re done with your story, go back and make sure that everything is like all your loose ends. Like for me, tie them all up, all of them.
So think of a story, think of your story as like a bunch of loose strings and if you have all your setups paid off and your character arcs are complete and the outcome of your objective or the character’s objective, your main character’s objective is obtained, then structurally, your story’s loose strings will be tied together to create this like one long thread. I look at setups as like this dark room and there’s no light except for like a small amount of moonlight coming through the window. Your audience’s eyes are kind of acclimating and struggling to make out the details of the room and then the payoff is the light switch.
It’s the full illumination of the room where they see the details. And so each setup needs this. Each setup does need a payoff counterpart. And so the moonlight in that analogy is very important because without it, and it’s just black where you’re not giving your audience anything, then there’s no way for them to even use their limited senses or imagination and in this case, like your limited subtle cues or clues to try and figure out what things are or where they are. But with that little moonlight analogy, which kind of represents… Elements of our story that provides subtle clues to the audience, that’s just enough to get us to feel like we have a fighting chance of figuring things out.
Even though when the light does come on, when we do start paying things off or all that resolution does happen, we may be way, way off or we may be wrong or we may have some things figured out, but not all of them. And we may have misinterpreted a quote unquote bed for a desk type of thing. But at least when it was paid off, we thought… Yeah. We had enough subtle clues and elements of the story to at least try to start figuring things out for ourselves rather than where you just throw something in at the end that they had no idea about. There was no way…
You didn’t allude to it at all throughout the story. We kind of as an audience feel a little tricked and it’s like, well, you didn’t even allow us to try to figure anything out. So I think that’s why this resolution is really important as a checks and balances to that. All of those… Really rich elements that we’ve talked about, like setups and payoffs and character arcs and different plot elements are all kind of coming together to make sense or for this really great resolution or payoff.
Adam: You want to make sure the conclusion of your story actually gels the story itself together. They’re not just random events and random choices. It all has meaning. Part of the thing that I think is interesting about story instead of real. Life is you’re boiling it down to just certain events for the purpose of the theme of saying something. You have something that you’d like to…
Before we get into that, I want to sort of talk about the word resolution itself, the concept of it, definition of it. Resolution is defined as the action of solving a problem, dispute, or contentious matter. It’s the action of solving. So what’s a solution? How is it different? The solution to a problem is a way the action is resolved. So they’re just sort of hand in hand. It’s figuring it out. It’s puzzling it. A solution is a means to find an answer, explanation for, or sort of effective dealing with a problem. Resolution, the Latin root word, means release or loosen. If you’re resolving a situation, you’re dealing with it successfully, you’re letting it go, you’re purging it. And we talk a lot about that in Transformation and Catharsis and Character Arc, where the character’s journey is all about discovery. It’s all about them figuring something out for themselves. It’s choice that leads them there. And that’s the beauty of the story.
That specific human being is their choices have formed them as this. It’s like a sculptor, but you’re sculpting your life through choice. The story lets us examine that. One of the things that I thought was interesting in looking up resolution and then solution was resolution has definitions in different disciplines. Music, and the definition there is, I like this one a lot, the passing of a discord into a concord during the course of changing harmony.
I like that. I know, right? I was like, man, that’s so good. So across different artistic disciplines, it’s kind of got, you always want to look at things because it helps you to get insight. The other one was in medicine, and it was the disappearance of inflammation or of any other symptom or condition. So that which has been plaguing you as a character in the story dissipates, it goes away, which is, it’s a great way of looking at it. By the end of the story, the thing that they’ve been facing, or trying to learn or understand is brought to completion and gone. The disappearance of it, the changing into harmony, wherever you’re at as a storyteller, you want to make sure that you’ve got that for your audience. And that those two definitions sort of harken back to transformation and catharsis and character arc, those episodes, you want to make sure those different things all come together, all gel. There were a couple other ones that I thought were interesting. The conversion of something abstract, into another form. So for me, that’s sort of like realizing that’s, that’s the moment of realization for a character, where you make something that was not real, and you take that and you make it real. That’s realizing clarity is bringing something from thought or, you know, it’s tangent now becomes tangible, whether that’s not necessarily a physical, you know, materialist thing, but it’s now tangible within their life. It’s now something that they’ve experienced enough to understand fully.
That change of belief system or whatever it is, like you said the word before discovery, and it’s measurable to right, measurable to the audience. We will talk about measurement a lot in structure too. But the story is a lot about measurement, experience for your audience pacing of setups and payoffs, all that kind of stuff. And the last one was had to do with imagery. And we’re all sort of familiar with this within the digital age, the degree of detail visible in a photographic or television image, you know how what’s your screen resolution, the screen resolution, the stronger resolution, the more clarity there is, that’s a great way to look at your resolution at the end of the story. The more resolution it has in the concept of image or detail, the more clarity and meaning your audience will take from it. If it’s vague and fuzzy, nobody’s going to get anything from it. But you want those things to be focused by the end of that piece, whatever it is.
Those are some of the cool angles I found in the various definitions of resolution that I thought were applicable to storytelling.
Devin: You actually bring up a really important tool for writing in particular is a lot of time, you know, every writer I’m sure sits, has a thesaurus or they’re at thesaurus.com is always up or they have a thesaurus sitting next to them when they’re writing.
Adam: Where they should.
Devin: You know, where they should.
Adam: You can only write run or walk so many times in a script, folks.
Devin: And it’s not about… Finding different words to put in the script, but it’s also important to do, Adam, what you just did. Is take. Take a concept and go and study all of the different definitions and uses of that word, like resolution, because it literally will, understanding all those different terms that don’t necessarily pertain specific to writing or story, can actually, in a way, do. You know, you can’t, they all make, they can help make something make sense to you.
Adam: What also communicates it on different levels to different people, that speaks to someone who knows music, that speaks to someone who knows medicine, that speaks to, so a word that’s got a root word that permeates or that is throughout different disciplines within a language means the root of it was really important. I love the fact that the root word of resolution is release. It’s one of those words where when I looked it up, I was like, this, really? That’s what it meant? To loosen, man, and release. Mm-hmm. Right. That’s not the connotation that I thought of it in. You know what I mean? It’s not really the way that I look at that word, except it makes perfect sense that that is, the conflict is over. Resolution. It’s done. Everything is.
You’re right.
Devin: It’s the perfect word, but. In order to have something loosen or to release, something before that had to tighten or there had to be restriction. There had to be something that caused it to be necessary for that release. You know, so which isn’t, which kind of, which goes back to your, what have you done in your story that has made everything so tense? The tension has risen where at some point there had to be a release. There had to be a resolution, a resolve. Something like that had to happen.
Adam: There’s a let go. Like I said, these, these previous episodes that are sort of setting this one up, transformation, catharsis, character arc, setups, payoffs, all those. I mentioned that for me, the arc of a character is where the past of that character and the present plot, what the character is doing now, meet and are reconciled. In that, that’s a letting go thing. Now that’s not every story, but for me, for a character arc, it is. It is a journey of self-worth. It’s a journey of discovery of self. That letting go, that loosening, that releasing. An example would be this. A lot of comedies start with somebody having some traumatic experience as a kid. Then they’re an adult and we start the movie and whatever that traumatic event was as a kid in the movie, they have, they will confront similar obstacles or finally, you know, get past this person.
A lot of it is they, oh, oh, Best Friends. One of my favorite comedies is with, what’s his head? Ryan Reynolds. And Anna Faris. Just Friends? It’s very funny.
Devin: Isn’t it? Just Friends? Just Friends. You’re right.
Adam: Yeah. It is Just Friends. The point is he starts out as a very, heavy kid in high school and he totally gets made fun of and mocked and he goes away, loses all the weight and becomes a complete jerk. He’s self-involved. He’s kind of, and, and he’s, I mean, we still see that kid we were introduced to in the beginning, but the whole point is he’s trying to come to terms with where he’s come from. Almost everybody that you know in your life has had something as they were. Developing that shaped them into who they are. And some of those things were negative and they didn’t confront them or deal with them and they didn’t let go of them. And so in character arc, the, the best character arcs that I think you can create are those where this really important developmental trip up for them that formed them into this person, this part still not functioning.
This part, the kid in them is still like a skipping record or it’s, you know, it’s stuck there when past and present meet and are reconciled to me, that’s the release of that thing. That’s holding them back. You know, oftentimes when I’m talking to friends and giving advice, I don’t like to tell people what to do in terms of advice. I like to ask them where they’re at and let them sort of voice what they want. That’s the best way you can help with people. I think in, if they are looking to talk, oftentimes I, I will give the comparison of if it feels like you’re walking around with a parachute on.
Like on the ground with a parachute. You just need to let go of that stuff. That’s past. That’s sort of just holding you back. And it’s sort of like the same concept of walking around with an anchor tied to you. And there’s just extra stuff. So the release, the loosening, the letting go of whatever you’ve been putting yourself through, and however that manifests itself in the real world as an antagonist, or, you know, the source of antagonism, or, you know, whether it’s a person or a rough job, or whatever it is, you have chosen to be in that person’s company, you’ve chosen that job. So you need to find the power within to let not that thing have power over you, whether it’s that past event, the antagonist, those are the things that you release or let go of, even if it’s the concept of you just no longer fight the antagonist. Sometimes the antagonist is defeated in a battle, or as I just watched Guillermo del Toro talking about The Shape of Water, and he said he never thinks of an antagonist or a villain as someone who’s actually kind of villainous, like not a nice person. He never thinks killing them is the best way to, quote, punish the villain, in terms of showing up.
He says he thinks it’s way more effective to just give that villain some of these subtle moments throughout the story that show their humanity briefly, so we get it, we can identify for a moment, and then at the end, have them realize that the life they’ve been leading has been villainous, has been antagonistic. And so all those little skipping stone touchstones of humanity throughout the course of the film. Now just, they don’t just smack you, the audience, in the face, they smack, that’s catharsis and transformation in one moment. The character and the audience both have this epiphany, and it’s like, oh my gosh, he’s realizing that his life has been cruelty, his life has been power.
So he deciphers that for himself, the antagonist. In terms of letting go, resolution is not just for your hero. Resolution means the villain. The antagonist, the protagonist, your hero, your villain, whatever you want to call them, your plot points, your setups, your payoffs, your subplots, which we will talk more about in structure, all those things come together. It seems like it’s a hard task, but as Devin said earlier, the most important thing you can remember is this, building it backwards will make it really strong. If you know where you want that story to end, there’s a definitiveness to it. You can say, Okay, now, I know this, this, and this happens.
I need to subvert that, flip it on its head, and put it in act one in that form, so that by the end, it’s the furthest distance this character could have traveled. Like we were talking about in the subtext episode, sometimes you need to write it out first and just agree with yourself that it’s not going to be great. And then once you get it on paper and see the elements, find the strong ones and build backwards or build out from them. Build on your strongest foundations, but you’ve got to sort of test it out first. You’ve got to take it for a test drive.
[Sponsor message]
Devin: You made a really, really good point about what Guillermo del Toro was saying about a great way to defeat the antagonist is not by killing him.
Adam: That’s awesome, isn’t it? I just saw that.
Devin: It’s brilliant because it serves a lot of purposes or it accomplishes a lot of things because it’s, it’s like, it’s strengthening your hero’s character in a way where he, they are not stooping to a level of the antagonist. You’re actually stripping the antagonist of his power, his or her power, its power, whatever it is, kind of taking the high road in a way to the final dagger in their heart is I’m better than you because I don’t have to be like you. And, and the, the movie that came to mind when you were talking about that, there’s a bunch of, there’s, I think there’s a bunch of examples of this happening, but it’s the like last interpretation of Cinderella from Disney, the live version.
I can’t remember what the actual. Resolve resolution moment is in the book, but in this movie, you know, these, the wicked stepmother and her, and her step daughters are so terrible. The Cinderella, everybody knows the mythology of their, the story, but at the, at the very end, after Cinderella, he, the prince comes back and he chooses her after, you know, even though the wicked step sisters and everything, they all wanted to become the new, the new princess. But. But it’s when she turns around and looks at her, her stepmother and just says, I forgive you. And those words are way more powerful than her saying something kind of ugly or what that person really deserves is probably you’re a bitch.
I can’t stand you like, you know, doing something where you’re kind of falling down to the level, those words at the end, that’s the resolution moment of that movie. It’s I forgive you. You were so terrible to me. I did nothing to you, but guess what? I forgive you because I, I feel sorry for you. And in a way, those words dig deep into, they, they’re worse than her destroying her completely because it like literally destroys her. Now she has to live with it. And so I think intelligent and very creative and writers who are at, who actually care about their story have really, really take, take time to blueprint their, what happens up to the resolution.
And then you have some other Hollywood blockbusters where they’re like, all right. And then it comes to this moment where. We get to blow the crap out of this thing and then it’s dead and we’re going to kill everybody. And then, then, and then, and then they’re triumphant, you know? And it’s like, well, sure. There’s a place for that in summer blockbusters and you’re sitting in a movie theater eating popcorn. But if you, from a really good story, it’s, it’s those little things that have a huge impact on, on, on the resolution and where that story and how, how, when, when your audience is done reading your book or when the audience is, is leaving the theater, take it with them.
Like it, it, it. It. Lasts a lot longer. It lasts in the car ride home or last, you know, it’s, it’s a lesson. It’s something that they can, can relate to, or there’s something that they can take with them rather than cool. He just, they, they blew it up or they killed it or whatever it was, you know, kind of, you know, typical big budget Hollywood movies that kind of lack some of that stuff. So I just wanted to, I wanted to make a, bring it back to that a little bit.
Adam: Well, and I want to comment on what you were saying and, and bring it back to subtext a little bit. So that scenario with Cinderella. The, I forgive you. That is, can be a very moving moment if it’s sincere. Yeah. And it was, yeah. I forgive you can also be a very, very passive aggressive piece of subtext. True.
Devin: Yeah.
Adam: I know I can name scenarios and things where I’ve witnessed people who are just, they’re like, they will tear someone down and then say, I forgive you. Well, you don’t get the concept of forgiveness. If you have to do that first, it doesn’t make sense. So that in and of itself is, it’s sort of like a passive, it’s sort of like a kid going, meh, meh, meh, meh, meh. Yeah. It’s the same emotional place. Although I know that from Cinderella’s point of view, that is sincere. I couldn’t help but think about subtext when most people don’t really get what forgiveness is. They’re like, I’ll forgive, but I won’t forget.
Well, that’s not really the concept. The concept is if you forgive. If you don’t forgive, it’s hitting the reset button. So you do forget and say. We’ll go back to zero and start again. That’s forgiveness. Like, you know what I mean? It’s just funny to me, but that’s one of those completely overused phrases that subtextually, and I love you too, these ones that are strong phrases in our society. I love you. I forgive you. Those phrases are two of the biggest subtextual things. With Devin’s example, she’s being very sincere.
Devin: Yes, yes and no. But it plays, she’s being very sincere. Is she being snarky? She’s being very sincere, but it also accomplishes that same level of…
Adam: Self-righteousness. No, I’m just kidding.
Devin: Like you said, it’s sincere, but it’s how that person interprets it. Like, it could, like, I think in this moment, in Cinderella’s scene, is like, there’s a realization of her wicked stepmother. That there’s a bit of a melting of her core, you know, where there’s, and that’s not a good way to say it. The ice, the melting of the ice that surrounds her throughout this, you know, the metaphorical ice that surrounds her throughout the movie. There’s a bit, it kind of, you can kind of see it melt away in her, and when she says this, but it could just drive her friggin’ nuts too, though.
Adam: There’s resentment and anger. And that’s what I’m saying is, if it’s used as a manipulative tool to do that, it is not forgiveness. No. That’s revenge. Cinderella doesn’t do that. Cinderella is not that. Cinderella, the beautiful thing about Cinderella is she is the contrasting element to the evil stepsisters and to the wicked stepmother. She’s still kind and open-hearted and loving despite the way she’s been treated. And you’re right, it does very much parallel that Guillermo del Toro philosophy of not destroying the villain. And I have a similar philosophy to him with that. That’s why I loved that, the way he stated it. I was like, that’s exactly how I feel about it is, the defeat of an antagonist does not have to be their death.
It is way more impacting if it’s their realization, just like the hero. Exactly. You’re right. That’s powerful. Yeah. That’s really powerful. As an audience member, no matter what side you’ve chosen, you’re like, well, that person, like he was talking about those glimpses of humanity, that person is kind or beautiful in this way. Yeah. You know, I can see their heart. I can see them, glimpses of it. So by the end, when they recognize their own heart, that’s the twist or the turn. That’s the surprise. Devin’s three O’s, objective, obstacle, outcome, objective is to just set it up and make it clear for the audience to understand what they’re watching and what’s going on.
Obstacle is these reversals that happen along the way. So it’s exciting. It’s twist turns, ups, downs, and the outcome, another twist turn should not be predictable. You have gone the gamut. You’ve run the gamut of what that objective is. Here are the obstacles to the point where you don’t know what the outcome’s going to be. Once again, one of my faves, Breaking Bad. There are some things where you’re like, I have no idea where this is going. I went into the finale of that series, had no clue what was going to happen. That’s good writing. That’s exciting. You don’t always know where that’s going to be, the resolution. And if it ends with that sort of synthesis of the story gelling antagonistic.
Protagonist and their belief system and perspectives, like the story gives them both realizations. Well, that’s just, that’s high quality, brilliant storytelling.
Devin: And that’s also, and we’ve talked about it before, is the importance of making your antagonist relatable as well.
Adam: Yes, yes, yes, yes.
Devin: There’s got to be glimpses or there’s got to be moments where we understand their objective and we understand their obstacle and we understand what they want the outcome. We need to understand that. They’re human. Even though we’re certainly on the side of our hero, what makes that outcome of our hero being triumphant, which is not always the case, but in some cases, we’re still happy for that and we’ll celebrate that. But there’s also, if you’ve built your antagonist and you’ve developed your antagonist in a very del Toro type of way that we’re talking about, then when he is stripped of that power and he is defeated, that there is a moment of, of empathy where we’re sympathizing with him.
You know, we feel bad for them, but we’re also, we’re like, you got what you deserved. Or we feel triumphant because they got it. They finally got it.
Adam: And so you, you’re almost cheering for them, understanding that that moment you’re watching is the beginning of them becoming a better person. So it doesn’t feel like defeat. It feels like something, and that’s why I love the way he approaches that. It’s, it’s so good. It’s juicy, Devin. It’s juicy. No. Don’t do it. It’s juicy. It is terrible how many times we use that word. We just had to kill it. And it’s one of my favorite words too. Juicy. I like equating storytelling to, to eating because it’s, it’s just essentially exciting for me. Hey, it was fitting, I feel. I wanted to talk about problem solution for a moment. Every mystery story has a problem to solve, whether it’s who committed a crime or this thing that was stolen needs to be found. There’s a sort of a, within that story model, there’s a concrete setup payoff. Now, it doesn’t always work out, but generally, the mystery gets solved.
So, if you think of that basic equation and apply it to your hundreds of pages story, the mystery still needs to be solved. Your character is a mystery. That’s why we talk, when we talk about character arc, we talk about layers. A character’s like an onion, for me, at least. When you’re tracking that character, each sequence, each movement, each act, as they, each scene as they go along, a layer’s being peeled back so that you, the audience, understand more about them. And as you get to know this person more and more and more, not only do you become more involved with them, almost like you’re their friend, or acquaintance, you start to want to solve their problems.
I think, as human beings, when we see someone who is upset or in need, we don’t want them to be that way. We would prefer everyone to be a little better than angry or hurt. I just think that’s the compassionate side of human beings. However, in a story, when you spend a lot of time with somebody, it’s not just seeing someone on the street and going oh, I wish they were better or healthier or whatever. It’s, you now are slowly becoming part of that person’s world, their routine, their life, their choices, their decisions. That’s why Breaking Bad is so wild to me in that way, because you really become part of his world and mindset. But in terms of treating every story as a mystery, it’s probably one of the best pieces of advice I can give any writer. Doesn’t matter if you’re writing a mystery or not, treat your story as one, because if nothing else, it will compel your reader and audience along, bit by bit, step by step. Mystery should be a consideration whenever you’re working on your story, and the resolution should be satisfying to the audience.
Meaning, like I was talking about with Scream last episode, they don’t give you a fighting chance to be a detective and find out who done it. They just don’t. They make everyone suspect, and that’s part of the fun of that movie. But for me, I find it slightly irritating, because I really pay attention in stories, and I want to be the detective. If it’s not satisfying to the audience, it at least needs to be appropriate to the story and its tone, even if it’s not a happy ending, if it’s a tragedy. There is a difference between cliffhanger and resolution. Cliffhanger is oftentimes what we will use, or storytellers will use, at the end of an episode or the end of a chapter. It’s something that leaves you hanging long enough, hanging long enough to come back to the story within the next episode.
It sort of derives from 1001 Arabian Nights, where the concept is there’s a ruler who would marry a wife and kill her the next morning because he was untrusting. He’s obviously dated around a lot, realizes how rough the dating world is, and just doesn’t trust. So he’s like, I’m gonna marry somebody, kill her in the morning. His new bride starts, what she does to survive is tell him a story the night of their wedding night, but doesn’t finish it. He doesn’t kill her the next morning because he wants to know the end of the story. And she tells him the end of the story the next night and starts in on a new chapter, a new story, and doesn’t finish it. And so she manages to live a thousand and some odd nights, a thousand and one, to be exact. That’s sort of the concept of a cliffhanger. You want the audience coming back and coming back and coming back.
And not kill you. And not really hate you. Lost. I was gonna say that. I’ve been bashing Lost so much in the past three hours. And the fact is, I love that series, but I was so angry. I get so involved with stories. I get irritated or upset when I think a storyteller who is brilliant doesn’t pay off properly or doesn’t do their work. That bothers me. So cliffhangers for series often work at the end of an episode. You want this thing where you’re like, oh my gosh, I got to binge the next episode now. And as soon as you start the next episode, you’re in. And so they’ve got you for another 45 minutes.
Right. And then at the end of that, I’ve done it. I’ve watched entire seasons of series. Late at night, I’m working on something. I’m like, I want to take a break. I’m going to watch something. What do you mean the birds are chirping? How many episodes did I just watch? It’s baiting your audience and dragging them along and doing- Thank you, Netflix. The resolution of an episode in a series often has the tidying up of that mini storyline. And that’s the resolution, but it will also continue the overall season arc by baiting you. With a cliffhanger. I just wanted to make sure we talk about cliffhanger and resolution and sort of differentiate them a little bit. They work hand in hand in a lot of ways, but Devin.
Devin: [unclear] Like you said, they just want the audience to come back and see what will happen next. A setup, for me, is much more subtle, and it’s embedded or woven into the story, sometimes subconsciously into the story, and time must go by. If you’re looking at it from an objective obstacle outcome, obstacles are usually what are going by, or things that are happening that almost make the audience forget about it, if it’s done creatively, and then the payoff of that setup is that aha moment, or in the resolution, or it doesn’t necessarily have to be in the resolution, but it has to be further on where it’s not as obvious as, tune in next time to see what happens to this person, because then you know that’s going to happen.
So that’s kind of how I differentiate even. A cliffhanger certainly is a setup.
Adam: The subtlety concept is really important. The setup needs to be subtle in order for the payoff to really have impact, whereas a cliffhanger is much like a hook scene in the beginning of a story, where you’re trying to just grab the audience’s attention. The strongest part of any episode is going to be its beginning and its end. In an episode, you’re… You’re going to have your cold open, and your cold open being that if it’s a comedy, it’s 30 seconds, one minute. In a drama, you can extend that three minutes. Sometimes if you’re well into a series, seven minute openings, and then they pow you with a title. Ba-boom. So you have that hook in the beginning. Well, the cliffhanger is the counterpart to that.
At the end of an episode, if you want your audience to come back, or at the end of a chapter, if you want them to keep reading that book, instead of going to sleep, or going to do the other thing they’re going to do, just keep reading. You bait their curiosity. I promise that we will dedicate an entire episode to just baiting an audience’s curiosity. We’ll talk about mystery, suspense, and dramatic irony, and how all those things are different, and you can toy with an audience’s perspective. The cliffhanger is more a resolution. With a promise of something more to come. I’ll give you an example. I have a little writing trick that I use to keep my audience hooked once I’ve baited their curiosity.
But I will tell you what that is when we continue our discussion on resolution next week.
Devin: Boom. Cliffhanger.
Adam: Please subscribe and rate us on iTunes. Story-related resources, video and archived content, visit our website at StoryOsophy.com.