Season 1, episode 18

Setups and Payoffs

March 16, 20181 hr 6 min

Show notes

Fresh from a car crash, Devin joins Adam to talk about one of their favorite storytelling tools: setups and payoffs. They explain how to hide a clue in plain sight, why the distance between setup and payoff matters, and how great twist endings reward a second viewing. Spoilers ahead.

In this episode

  • Foreshadowing. A setup plants something in the audience’s mind. They forget it, and it returns as a reveal, a reversal or a discovery.
  • Rewatch value. Good setups make the audience go back and watch again, and the second time they see the story through a different lens.
  • Give the audience a fighting chance. Adam wants viewers to feel like detectives. Scream frustrated him because it never gave the clues needed to solve it.
  • Measure the distance. Put a gun in a drawer, and the audience has to forget it before it comes back. Adam plans setups and payoffs in 15-page movements, and Devin maps them on a clock.
  • Red herrings. Misdirection makes the payoff more satisfying.
  • Jokes are setups and payoffs. From “Take my wife, please” to “That is not my dog” in The Pink Panther Strikes Again, comedy shows the tool at its tightest.
  • Hidden in plain sight. Fight Club and The Usual Suspects hide their twists in front of you. Adam spotted Keyser Söze from the way a character handled a lighter.
  • Shutter Island, twice. The first time, you’re with Teddy. The second time, you notice the laughing nurses, a fumbled holster and a glass of water that isn’t there.
  • Dramatic irony. In The IT Crowd, Roy doesn’t realize he’s the getaway driver until the robbers take off their masks.

Examples discussed

  • Fight Club, Se7en, The Usual Suspects, Shutter Island, Scream, Jigsaw, The Pink Panther Strikes Again and The IT Crowd.
  • Also: Shane Black, Mitch Hedberg, Steven Wright and The Cloverfield Paradox.

Next episode: resolution.

Read the full transcript

Transcribed automatically, so expect the odd misheard word. Sponsor messages are left out.

Adam: Welcome to StoryOsophy. This is Adam Jones. And Devin Halden. Between Devin almost freezing to death and last episode, him catching the monster cold, which obviously… And we’re not even in the same place, and I caught it, apparently. That’s how strong that cold is. And then this week, between last episode and this episode… So, Devin?

Devin: Yeah, I got toasted in my car. I was actually not even moving. So, I’ll give you a brief explanation of what happened. So, everybody’s probably been driving on a highway, and you’re getting off the highway either to get on another highway. So, there’s like that area, that section where people are coming off one highway on and on, like a loopy off-ramp. You’re going to get on an on-ramp. And so, there’s always like a little bit of congestion. People getting off one, getting on the other, and vice versa. And so, I had slowed down. I was going to a stop, full stop, because people were kind of zippering, like taking turns on getting off and getting on.

And then I just happened to look up in my rearview mirror, and this huge Ford F-150 was not stopping. I mean, and going… The state patrol said he was probably going around 60 miles an hour when he ultimately destroyed my car. And I basically watched the entire thing unfold in my rearview. And I’m like, for some reason, it was one of those things that, like, I just couldn’t take my eyes off it, knowing that, I’m like, this is really going to hurt. And so, I just basically braced myself for this and ended up, like, my… I mean, it was pretty violent. And so, I ended up going to the hospital or the ER.

And haven’t been since last… That happened Friday. And since Friday, I have barely been able to move from off the couch, just because I’m so… Lazy? Sore.

Adam: Oh, sore.

Devin: Yeah, I’m just lazy, yeah.

Adam: At least you’re here with us again this week. I’m sore. Even if you’re sore. And Devin explained to me before we started up also that he doesn’t take painkillers. He refused, because he’s such a tough guy.

Devin: I don’t like putting that stuff in my body, in my vessel.

Adam: He’s rock and roll, Devin.

Devin: My earth vessel. I’m only here for a short time.

Adam: Although he’s known to have a drink or two, because he’s a little Irish, aren’t you? That’s a little in the DNA.

Devin: Oh yeah, that’s way different. I’ll have a cocktail. I just won’t take meds. I may be a bit ill-prepared for this episode, but I think once we dive into it, my brain will start clicking again.

Adam: This week we’re talking about setups and payoffs as one of mine and Devin’s favorite things to use in a story. To start off, I just want to say, in this episode, we’re probably going to give spoilers. Now, most of these examples, I’m sure Devin’s trying to use his five-year rule, and for me, I’m trying to do the same thing.

Devin: No, you’re not? No, and I actually do have a couple of spoiler alerts in here. What an animal. No, but my rule is we cannot talk about them. We have to give a spoiler alert. A spoiler alert has to be… Initiated if it falls within that five-year period. Okay. That’s all I’m saying. We can talk about movies that came out last weekend that we saw, but they would warrant a spoiler alert.

Adam: Yeah, I just saw The Cloverfield Paradox, and I wanted to talk about it, but there’s too many things in it that I want people to experience, and I’d rather I can use other things for examples. Wait, give it some more time. So just as a preemptive spoiler alert, there you go, folks, from the beginning. If you hear us talking about something, let’s just allowed it. We could provide that as an example. Let’s just come with that as an example, and let’s move on to a thing that I think even videos season two or the second season, we’re probably going to spoil it, because if we’re talking about payoffs, proper payoffs happen, in your end of second act, third act at the end of a movie, and so that’s sort of spoiling it.

I think set ups and payoffs are pretty self-explanatory in the concept, but within the nature of writing or storytelling, for me a setup is foreshadowing. That’s another word that’s really commonly used in the literary world for what a setup is. [unclear] The payoff can come in lots of different varieties, but it’s the end result of that subtle thing you’ve planted in the viewer’s mind or the reader’s mind, and then they’ve sort of forgotten about it, and it comes back later in the form of a payoff or a reveal, a reversal, some sort of discovery for your audience or your character.

So there’s lots of different ways to pay something off, but most stories with a twist ending or like a big sharp turn or a big reveal, that requires a lot of pre-paving, a lot of backwards development in foreshadowing land so that when the surprise happens for your audience or a big twist or turn, they go, oh, I should have known that. The clues were there the whole time. That, to me, is sort of the crux of a really good setup payoff. Even if the story does not have a twist ending or, you know, some big reveal or something like that, even subtle versions in like a family drama or per last episode, we were talking about the breakup, really subtle internal character payoffs, a realization, a self-realization, self-awareness.

That’s, I would say, probably the number one for any character arc is that self-awareness that sort of like happens in end of Act 2, Act 3-ish, like moving into Climax to the end of the Climax, like the resolution. So as far as… Basic definitions. Devin, did you have anything you wanted to add to that? Just an initial what you define setups and payoffs as. Before we get into sort of exploring that further.

Devin: What’s great about setups and payoffs, I think, is that they can be laid out in a story through dialogue or actions. And that’s whether on screen or even in the written word. And I think something that is… Seen on, through screenplays and through movies, where that brings a different element beyond, like we’ve talked about, a written screenplay is then translated by a director if they haven’t written it. And then on screen, there are these other subtle cues and things that they can do on screen that are setups and payoffs that are brilliant directors like Scorsese. Yeah. Fincher’s probably one of the best with this stuff.

Adam: Yeah, he’s strong.

Devin: Yeah, so that are kind of translated… Visual versus literary. And if you… I’m not saying that if those aren’t in a book or they’re not written in the screenplay, but it’s the way…

Adam: But it’s the reader imagining it rather than the director.

Devin: Yeah. And it’s just how it’s interpreted from the director and how they translate it onto screen is some of the more brilliant filmmaking examples, I think. Like that, when it comes to setups and payoffs.

Adam: How they visualize that. Like we were talking about in tone and style, like how the story is told, the voice of it, the way that visual landscape plays out. You were going to say you had examples regarding that?

Devin: One example in particular that really combines, in almost every scene, how dialogue, actions like the performance of the actors, and then also the visual cues that are placed in the scene. All of them work together. All of them work together for a setup. And the other thing I wanted to add, too, is really good setups and really good payoffs are like the reason or the tool that filmmakers use to get people to have to go back and watch their film again. A rewatch. Yeah, rewatch value. And you’ll see them in a different lens from the first time you watch it to the second time you watch it.

And usually really good movies like that, you’re almost watching it from a different perspective. Like a lot of times you’ll be the first viewing. You’re actually in the perspective. You’re in the perspective of one character. And once you’re privy to the payoff, like you understand everything, all the reveals, and you go back and watch it again, you’re almost watching it from the perspective of either a different character or just a different lens. And that is when you’re like, wow, you didn’t hit the nail on the head with it.

Adam: StoryOsophers, this is why we decided to do StoryOsophy. For conversations with Devin like that, that is really interesting to me. I hadn’t quite looked at it that way. For me, I would say it’s sort of like this too. Layers. You’re viewing it each rewatch. The rewatch value is in the story having many layers. Like you’re saying, when you watch the second time, there’s a lens to it. There are layers to a story, layers to a character. And once you get to the end result of that storytelling journey, when you rewatch, it’s what you’re saying.

Devin: Like a lot of psychological thrillers are almost, it’s almost necessary to watch it twice. It’s fun to, it’s fun to do it too. And it’s not just because you’re like, oh, I love the story. I want to go back and watch it again. You literally see it completely differently. And you pick up on all of these cues. You’re like, oh my God, I didn’t even, you know, I didn’t pick up on that. And it makes, it’s one of those where literally from one viewing to the next viewing, it’s almost like watching a new movie. It’s like, it’s like watching a completely different story unfold.

Because now you’re, you’re, like you said, you’re kind of looking at it through a different lens and you’re kind of privy to a lot of stuff. And you’re like, everything just pops out at you. You’re like, oh man, how did I miss that?

Adam: A film that’s, that is a prime example of that. What he’s talking about is Fight Club. And I’m not going to talk about it right now because it’s not one of the examples I had, but. I have that. Yeah. Okay. So that in and of itself, just that movie is the perfect example of watching it once. And then as soon as you’re finished, you’re like, I got to watch that again.

Devin: Right.

Adam: Because now more information than you had before. And so you go back and you want to examine what you just watched because you sort of got played a trick on. In movies where you’re viewing something and all of a sudden it’s like this too. This is another good example is simply a murder mystery. You don’t know who done it. And so when you get to the end and you know who done it, I can speak proper English. You go back to the beginning and sort of track through it and go, oh, the clues for that person were here, here, here, here, here. And if you sort of mark your story as you’re going through, like I do, because I love story.

I sort of pick up on little bits and pieces here. You’re sort of want to prove it to yourself. So you even rewatch in your own mind, you know, you go, you track back through and go, wait a minute. Was that like that or this like this?

Devin: Those are the films too, that when you go back and watch it, they’re so obvious to you. And then there’s also the movies where I’m like, how come, how come I can’t think of that?

Adam: Hidden in plain sight. A good setup is a hidden in plain sight thing. The nature of setups and payoffs is the subtlety of the setup. You want to sort of hide it. You want to bury it enough so that if people are paying attention.

I like to write setups and payoffs for my audience the way serial killers tease police officers with their future murders. Like, I’m like, I want you to be smart enough to figure out the setup so that when you get to the end, you’re excited that you saw the clues and you figured, you know what I mean? Like, you knew the answer. Right. Because that’s thrilling for someone in a detective story or a story with a lot of puzzles or mystery to it. When you get to the end and you got it, you’re so excited that you’re like, oh, yeah, I figured it out. I want my audience in any story that I write like that to get the clues so they feel as triumphant. And if they don’t, they’re just going to go, oh, and have this big moment of surprise at the payoff.

Devin: Right. And that’s, you actually, you make a very, very important point to set up some payoffs. It’s a little creepy. Yeah, that your serial murder part is a little creepy.

Adam: We were talking about Fincher.

Devin: No, but you make a very important point about setups and payoffs is they, when you do the reveal, there needs to be a thread that connects it to that setup. So you don’t just like make a setup and then a reveal because you didn’t want them to figure it out that it’s not, it’s just disjointed and not connected at all. Because then it’s not fun for an audience. They’re like, well, of course I wouldn’t figure that out. Like you didn’t do, you didn’t show me this or like, you know, or. Or all of a sudden your payoff has to do with this like flashback of the, of you putting it together that wasn’t involved in the beginning of the story or that wasn’t involved in the setup.

Adam: Or you weren’t given the clues to be able to figure it out. Like you’re saying that, that irritates me. I’m like, you just tricking me throughout the whole thing, but you haven’t even given me a fighting chance to understand as a viewer. No, you’re right in this. You know, I felt that way about Scream, the original Scream, because if you go back through that movie, you cannot figure out who. It is. There’s no way that you can track it. Right. And yet they criminalize everybody. Like the sheriff’s got the same boots. I found myself really irritated with being treated sort of unintelligently as an audience member. Like I wasn’t given the clues to be able to solve it.

Right. And although I loved watching that movie, because I’m not a horror movie guy, and that was sort of like horror comedy, it was fun for me. And, and it was thrilling movie to watch. And obviously it like hit big with audiences. But that was my one complaint with that movie is they don’t even give you a chance to, except for in the plot about the mother. No, you’re right. You know, that’s all they give you. Yeah. And it’s very little. You’re right. But there’s no, you can’t figure it out. And I mean, it’s fun for the ending. You’re totally blindsided by everything because you don’t, you’ve not been given a chance. But yeah, it made me think of that because I really didn’t enjoy that part of it.

Devin: You’re right. It’s like playing in the game of Clue. But then when you go through the entire thing and you say, I think it’s this person. This person, this person, this person.

Adam: These are the facts I’ve been presented. So based off that.

Devin: This character using this, using this. And they’re like, nope, it was this character. And it’s like, that character wasn’t even part of the game. Yeah, that’s exactly. Well, you didn’t get it right. That’s not fun.

Adam: And I’m not saying that Wes Craven’s film is not a really great, enjoyable piece, but he was trying to do this in particular. But a lot of poor writing, bad writing, people don’t mind the depths of the story or where the audience’s mind is going to go. They just stick with their first writer instinct and the audience is going to delve into that story well beyond that. So if they lay out these surfacy pieces where they haven’t explored it or it’s like, oh, surprise, here’s where the audience is going to be really disappointed in your story, construct the way it’s been constructed. You need that depth. You need. I feel like especially we talk about at the beginning of this first season, how intelligent the audience has become just worldwide, not just like within this country.

But now you’ve got global platforms and everybody’s seen the. Three Act Hollywood blockbuster so many times. So how do you reinvent that? How do you and we’re sort of heading back, I think, in film land close to the 70s when all those auteurs came into play, TV had taken off and cinema wanted to return. And so they got like Lucas and Spielberg and Coppola and Scorsese, all these guys with very unique voices came forth. But now it’s so prolific with platforms and content. You’ve got all of these amazing. Creative voice opportunities from various perspectives to come into play. So I’m very excited that the depth of storytelling is going to get better. There’s going to be some crappy stories here and there, but I think they’re going to get weeded out pretty simply because of the way that storytelling and film media has become democratized and interesting setups and payoffs.

Like we’ve been talking more non-linear stuff, which we should have a conversation about that, an episode about that. And before we get into second season and talk about like linear, non-linear sort of mosaics, Soderbergh stuff, before we get into like straight up linear.

Devin: Non-linear is a tool of a setup and payoff. So one example, and I don’t, this isn’t one of my, the examples I use, but I just saw this movie and I thought it was brilliantly written and executed was Jigsaw, which is. Oh, right. You were telling me it was good. Of course, those movies are kind of over the top gory, but if you actually look at the writing and there’s a ton of setups and payoffs and it’s actually a very complicated story that they weave. And I’ll make this one brief because it’s a really, really complicated movie if you actually get into the story of it, but they’re using a non-linear tool as a setup and a payoff without.

Just knowing that we’re in a non-linear film. And so it’s not until you get to the very end, the payoff that you realize it’s an, you were watching a non-linear story unfold because you thought the entire thing was just chronological. And so they’re using, they’re using flashbacks when you don’t know their flashbacks. You think those, that’s what’s actually going on because he’s actually recreating something from a prior movie. Yeah. He’s recreating the exact same setup with, with lookalikes. Yeah. But we. We don’t know that. And so it’s, it’s phenomenal. The writing is phenomenal. And it’s one of those things where it’s like, there’s, there’s going to be, there’s, you’re in one or two of two camps. You’re in, I get it. That’s brilliant. Or I don’t get it. It’s too complicated. I don’t want to even try to figure out what, what actually happened. So it took, it took me a while and it took me another showing. Like I had to see it again to, to really understand what was going on there.

I think that’s where more stories are going to go.

Adam: I love what you’re talking about. I think sort of simply put is that chronology is the big reveal. You don’t, you don’t know anything about this. And at the end of the movie, the big twist, the big turn is the chronology is, is to, or time, the way time is, has been presented to you is the surprise. Time. Yeah. Okay. Yeah. I’ve seen just a handful of movies like this, like a couple, not a lot. And I feel like there are more to come. That’s what we were talking about. How you can apply setup and payoff as a tool on any real category. Yeah. You can use those, those things as tools, setups and payoffs in character arc, in plot, in theme, in tone, like you saying visual tone, like Fincher does. It’s not something like the rest of them where it’s, you can apply it to all aspects of your story, which is why I think you and I, and I won’t speak for you, but I love it so much. But I know you have said we both really dig setups and payoffs.

Mm-hmm. That in and of itself, that’s one of those things. That’s one of those reasons is you, you, it’s like a, within your toolkit, they are the tools rather than the things you’re applying them to that. And that’s really important.

Devin: I really think they understanding setups and pay, like how to implement them into, into your story really separates a good story from a great story. Yeah. Agreed. And it’s also from an, from a reader or from an audience standpoint, it becomes the, one of the more satisfying things of the experience. When there’s a really good one, like we’ve talked about before, some of the tools that are, that you can really take advantage of to strengthen character, strengthen world, strengthen theme, strengthen some of these other elements of story, setups and payoffs are like the tool to do all of that very creatively. And in a way that will become something that strengthens the experience of, of your audience.

I think that, I think they’re paramount to it, to a great story.

Adam: It also, it helps to frame the story in the world, especially setups do with foreshadowing is you, you get these teeny nuggets sort of buried right in front of you because you’re still just, you’re just trying to take in information. You don’t know what’s important information right away or what’s not. And so you’re sort of trying to sift it into camps and going, what should I be paying attention to? And a smart filmmaker writer is going to point out what the things you need to know, like you, like Devin saying in a very creative way. And if they do it subtle enough. You collect this information, you’re watching the rest of the story sort of distracted by its forward momentum.

And then one of these story elements pops back up in a fresh new light as a payoff. And you go, oh, I was given the information, but I’ve been so distracted and involved with just enjoying the story. I forgot about that. And so you get these sweet, it’s like eating a blueberry pancake. The payoffs are these sweet little pockets of surprise to happen all throughout the experience. You’re like, oh, blueberry, oh, blueberry. It made me hungry.

Devin: Speaking of juicy. Another important element of setups and payoffs is that a setup doesn’t necessarily, the payoff doesn’t necessarily have to be a reveal of a setup. No, no. It can be an effect or, or something that has been built up. And if we want to go back to our, that one, what we’ve been using for the last couple episodes, that, that one line where in that novel that we were talking about where she wanted to say something and she swallows it to go live with the, with the rest of the things that go unsaid. Perfect. That is a setup because we’re kind of, we’re setting it up that, nope, she’s not ready to say something now. So we’re building, we’re building to a point where the payoff.

That she will eventually. Exactly. She’s, that payoff is her exploding in some way, you know, metaphorically, like getting like where all of a sudden that’s the payoff is going to be towards the end of act two or in the, in somewhere in act three.

Adam: You can have sort of a double setup when you have the foreshadowing of something. And we need to probably start getting into examples here. In a minute, because we’re sort of talking around the thing, but there are just a couple of things I wanted to mention that helped to think about how to look at setups and payoffs. But first I just wanted to say this. So you have this initial setup, then you can have a mid point. What I would say is it’s, it’s sort of a reveal, but in setup land, it’s like a reversal because the setup here in the beginning with the foreshadowing of set event in the middle, the event happens and you’re like, oh, I didn’t expect it to go that way.

And now your brain is set up to think that’s where this is at. And so another reversal will happen by the end. That is the actual reveal from the original setup. If you think on that level of like setup, reversal, reveal for a story, that’s really great. But also if you can think about that for in terms of a scene, your scenes will start to pop. We should talk a little bit about reversals at another point. I don’t, right now it’s not, I don’t think the appropriate time, but. Yeah, they get a little complicated. Who was I thinking of? Shane Black, who wrote. Shane Black wrote the Lethal Weapon movies and The Nice Guys recently, he loves reversals and he talks about how when he builds his scripts, that’s what he aims for in a lot of stuff. But in order to do that, you have to be proficient with the setup payoff tools because that’s what it requires.

I would say regarding before we get too into these examples, one of the main things to focus on concerning setups and payoffs is measuring them. This is sort of the key. Yep. Yeah. And the concept. The concept would be this really simple example. If you’re ever introduced to a gun in a story or a weapon, and then that weapon is like put in a drawer, that weapon’s going to come back by the end. Guaranteed. It’s just going to, there’s play on it. But you have to forget that element as an audience member in order for that payoff to be a surprise. So distance experientially within the story, how many pages, how many minutes between the setup of the gun being put in a drawer.

Plenty of murder mysteries or scenes happen where someone puts a gun away in a drawer. And then we forget about it because we’re so wrapped up in the rest of the story. And that’s, I think, what’s exciting about stories. You get so distracted by the excitement of the experience, you forget those setups, especially if they’re really subtle and brief and brilliantly, cleverly done. Right. And the classic is by the end of the movie, suddenly some person you had, it’s a double reveal. You know whodunit because the person whodunit pulls out the gun and you’re like, oh, the gun. Right. The gun. I forgot about the gun. And so you get this double reveal and you’re like, oh, this is really, I mean, as I’m recording this, I’m sort of hitting myself on the head going, oh, the gun, the gun. Like I should have known that. That’s when you know you got a really strong setup and payoff for your audiences when they go, oh, I should have known that. It was there in front of me all along. Unlike the scream example I was giving where I was like, how was I supposed to know that?

Yeah. The journey was fun, but I wasn’t treated with that respect to be able to say, I wasn’t given the position of detective in this mystery, just spectator. Right. And I like detective more, me personally. And set up some payoffs, that’s all what it’s about, mystery and.

Devin: Right. And an important element to a setup or to get people off the scent, if you will, or misdirect them is the red herring, whether it be a character red herring or it be like a weapon. And I think so those aren’t, those are some of the other tools and the writer’s tools. To throw the audience off the scent of it and to also strengthen and or, or to have them forget about that gun in a way where, or make them believe the gun really isn’t that important, or maybe they think that the gun is supposed to be a misdirection.

The more red herrings or the more misdirections you have to throw people off ultimately makes that payoff so much more revealing and exciting for, for an audience and, and kind of spurs that, ah, I gotta go back and watch this again. Knowing this now and see if I should have picked up on that.

Adam: Yeah.

But what you’re saying is absolutely right. You have to have that. And what I mean by measurement, when I said it earlier, is you have to have the setup and the payoff far enough away from each other to be effective. You want your audience to forget about the setup by the time the payoff comes along enough to have it be a surprise. And so space is what it requires. Part of this, we’ll get into season two, but I have my movement system to do it, where I look at, you know, as we were talking about before, page per minute in film, media land for a script, you can tell that at 15 minutes, this is going to happen. So if I do this thing at 20 minutes, the audience wouldn’t have forgotten about it. So it’s not a surprise to them. This event, that is the payoff, needs to happen 30 pages, maybe 45. They’ve definitely forgot about it. And then boom, all of a sudden, you bring this thing back in. And they’ve been so wrapped up in the present activity of the story, that it’s a surprise to them, but the pleasant surprise, right? So measurement is important in that. And even in novel writing, think of it in chapters, if you have to space it out a little bit that way. But there’s setups and payoffs within scenes. It’s what Devin had said last week, the three O’s, objective, obstacle, outcome. Look, I did learn something from you last week. That’s setups and payoffs. Your setup is your objective, and your payoff is your outcome. The last thing that I wanted to say regarding just before we get into examples was, a great way to understand setups and payoffs is through the concept of jokes. Because jokes are boiled down more, not storytelling jokes. What I mean by jokes is stand-up comedians, people who are actually telling jokes. Proper comedies where every line, that one-liner, is a setup and payoff. It can be from one character to another, or from a single character having a sort of setup and payoff in one sentence.

Comedy writing happens that swiftly, and everything is tight, and as Devin and I would like to juicy. I thought that word was banned. It was banned. Devin and I have to ban certain words because we overuse them, but juicy has been one of them. Imagine a joke where the punchline comes way later. You’ll see it in a lot of stand-up comedy routines, some of these specials on Netflix and things like that, where they’ll lay some groundwork with a simple joke in the beginning of their bit. And then by the end of it, the last… The button of the show is that thing. They pay it off with this one-liner, and you’re like, oh, they brought it all back together again. That’s classic setup payoff. And a joke, like a scene, is a smaller version of that larger arc for setup payoff. And so I just wanted to touch on joke for a second because it’s sort of like the prolonged punchline that’s a surprise, and I wanted to give just a couple examples. One, and this is a classic stand-up, this is way years and years ago. He had this joke where, you know, when you’re trying to give someone an example or an explanation, you go, take my house. He’s talking about, he’s doing all these jokes about his wife. And this is the joke. This is about as short a setup payoff punchline as you can get. He goes, take my wife, please. You expect him to go into a story talking about the example of his wife, and he totally flips you on your head by saying, please. And you’re like, oh, you mean… And he’s like, I don’t know. I don’t mean take her away from you. Even though it’s sort of like in modern day comedy, a cheesy joke, because you know what I mean? A little bit cheesy. In that time period, it was really clever, but it is a short version of setup payoff. And it’s got the twist element to it, a reversal, something you don’t expect. Most great jokes have that. If you want a great experience on one-liners that will spin on a dime, Mitch Hedberg, anything Mitch Hedberg has done, and he’s one of my favorites.

Ever. All of his jokes are that way. They’re one-liners and they’re simple. Steven Wright also is another comedian who does that sort of thing. My last example was from one of my favorite comedies in jokes, which is The Pink Panther Strikes Again with Peter Sellers. And he goes into an inn to get a room. And for those of you who’ve not seen any Pink Panther movies, they’re hysterical. He goes into this inn where there’s this old man, and he gets this room after a lot of trial and error and a lot of miscommunication. And then he’s starting to leave the room. And he goes down and he sees a dog. And he says, does your dog bite? And the innkeeper goes, no. And then he reaches down to pet the dog. And the dog almost chews his arm off.

And he goes, I thought you said your dog did not bite. And he goes, that is not my dog. That is one of my favorite bits in that entire movie. But it’s, for comedy, setups and payoffs, it’s all the time. It’s almost every other line or every line is what you want rhythm-wise for setups and payoffs because they’re all jokes. But when you’re thinking of setups and payoffs, even in drama, even in mystery, horror, anything, try to think about it in the framework of a joke. Setup and payoff, every line. So it’s the same concept of a joke. It has to be short and tight to keep the audience laughing. But you want to apply that to your scenes, your stories as a broad thing, whether it’s just an episode or a series or a chapter in a book versus the entire novel.

Just try to think of as much as you can. Back and forth and setups and payoffs as you can throughout. And not just like, okay, there’s the beginning, which is the setup, and there’s the end, which is the payoff. When you first start writing, that’s definitely the place to start, at least there. But between that, start to go, okay, there’s the beginning and the middle setup payoff. And then from the middle setup to the end payoff, you can start to proliferate your setups and payoffs. So there’s depth and layers, like what Devin was speaking about before, so that when you watch a film again, you can watch it from a different lens or perspective. And have a completely different experience because you’ve sort of leveled up and get to watch the movie through this new exposed layer. But if you apply the concept of setup payoff, you’ll get it. Just stretch it out. Stretch out the time between your objective and your outcome, that balance. How much time does it take for the audience to forget this point so that I can excite them with it again later?

[Sponsor message]

Devin: I use a clock, like I physically make a circle and then I’ll do at this point is when I have a setup. And as to all my setups, and then I can see on the clock, which is the entirety of the story, where I think, and then I have all the notes of what’s actually happening, you know, around the clock, kind of my, where, with all the events that are going on and the, and the different points of the story. And then I can kind of gauge where that, that, like. So, what do you think?

Adam: It’s all about measurement. It’s all about measurement and timing. Yeah, absolutely. These particularly, this is the tool for that. And as Devin was saying before too, the way to use this tool is non-linearly. That’s the key to setup and payoffs, is non-linear use of it. Meaning, if you know the movie’s going to end this way, backwards develop where the setup’s going to be. Right. Start with your payoff and figure out a good setup. You start with your payoff or as you’re doing the whole thing, you’ll find yourself navigating across the thing over and over and over, like flying across the top of it, like a bird’s eye view of the whole thing.

Because you don’t just start and go linearly. Sometimes in free writes and first drafts, you’ll do a little bit of that. But if you want to make your first draft and drafts accurate and easier to execute, as we say frequently, plan your structure. Play a little bit, but while you’re doing it, make sure you plan out your structure before you start to assemble that first draft. Part of that assembly is just looking at it. And as Devin was giving the analogy of a clock, I use a system of columns for myself, and I separate them into movements. So even though the traditional structure is in acts, I do it by 15 page, 15 minute movements. So I can track and make sure that my story is moving. That’s why I call it movement, doing something every 15 pages at minimum. And in that, I also try to track across it for characters.

I want them to be a new character every 15 pages or so, even though my milestones are going to be at the midpoint and the end for trackable development. In between, I don’t, I mean, I’m so used to seeing characters just do the same thing for a whole thing. I want them to advance and explore a new self consistently. Right.

But the whole point is, we both have figured out a way to use the clock as measurement, pages as measurement, to go, if I were an audience member, would I be satisfied at this point watching it or reading it? Right. It’s tracking it on both sides of the thing, because as a writer, sometimes you get so into it, so involved, you could be writing a bunch of baloney and not know it. And so if you can be accountable on the other side for what you’re writing in terms of what you’re experiencing. Right. You will write stronger material for sure. Because you’re going, you know what, although it’s great that they talk about this, I might get a little bored. It’s like, then be decisive and cut it. Treat your audience with some respect.

Devin: Or take that information that is in that scene and try to figure out a creative way to make, to relay that information differently, more creatively, more concisely. Maybe it doesn’t, maybe you don’t need a five minute scene of dialogue. Maybe that can all be achieved with a really strong creative setup that takes 30. 30 seconds. So I guess it’s trying to, if it’s really vital information, figure out the most creative way to relay that to the audience, I guess is the main thing I’m saying.

Adam: It’s true. And also think about your medium when you’re doing it. I’ll give you an example. For a stage play, which I, one of the stage plays that I’ve wrote, there was a monologue. And when it was adapted to a screenplay, it doesn’t fly. There’s a lot of dialogue that happens in the script. And there’s one scene when one of the two main characters just starts talking about it. And it plays really well on stage because that’s the medium for it. You want that you have words and this person delivering them in front of you and you’re supposed to connect with that. Whereas on screen, it’s different. Instead, the monologue, I completely removed it and left him with just moments of silent introspection when we, we have to participate with him telepathically, empathically, emotionally.

We project onto him based on the narrative we’ve seen so far, his feeling state by feeling it ourselves, much more effective on film than on stage, right? You can’t get intimate with a character on stage like that. But film, the best way to deliver that moment emotionally for the trajectory of the story is to remove the monologue completely, right? Which is a surprise to me as I’m doing it, but I’m like, okay, I guess that’s the way that works. Strange. So you sort of have to listen a lot of times to what your story is telling you.

Devin: Right. That’s the best way to, to set, set that character up for that transformation later on, which is obviously the payoff of that, where, you know, that, that scene, how it’s, how it’s done on screen is a strong setup for the performance that is, that’s almost like a, a juxtaposition or a, just a, the transformation from that character then to the character that will be, that we see later on in the story.

Adam: Let’s get into some examples, because as. Devin said it’s easier for us to understand. It’s easier to understand setups and payoffs with some examples. He, he, he thinks and I concur. So Devin, you want to do first example? Do it, boy. We already talked about Fight Club a little bit and I had that.

Devin: That’s one of my favorite movies ever. Fincher is awesome. He’s a genius. I love Fincher. Actually, two of my, my examples are Fincher movies, Seven and Fight Club.

Adam: You know, I thought about both of them when we were talking at the beginning. I didn’t write them down, but as soon as we talked about it, I’m like, oh yeah, both of those. So good. I’m good. You’re talking about two of my. Favorite movies. I love Fincher and these are two greats. So yeah, I’m very excited. And Fight Club.

Devin: Is a watch it twice film for me because can we go through the movie in one looking at it through one lens and then after we figure out everything that that Norton Norton’s character Jack or like the narrator. I think is what is his official title, I guess, is that’s just who we think. We’re in his head. We’re in his head with everybody else that’s in that movie. We’re just basically in his head because he’s in this like, we meet him in this like mundane, boring life that he hates and despises. And his apartment. Is full of like all of these material things. He has insomnia. He hasn’t slept for six months. And then he, he goes to the doctors and, you know, he wants some medication to help him sleep. He tells the doctors that he nods off all the time and wakes up in strange places. And so that’s like one of those.

It’s like, that is Tyler Durden, this alter ego or this like this disassociation behavior he has, or this character, this altered alternate personality he’s conjured up in his head. That essentially is Tyler beginning to come out. When he meets Tyler Durden in the airport, you know, of course, we think Tyler Durden is just someone that he’s meeting. It’s a different character of the story. But then, of course, throughout the movie, we find out that Tyler Durden is just someone that’s in his head. And so it’s one of those reveals where there’s like all of these setups. And then it’s a it’s at the end. It’s one of these like quick montages of reveals to you’re like, oh, my God. Oh, he was fighting himself outside the diner. Oh, you know, like it was.

Like, oh, he was the guy making the soap.

Adam: He is Tyler Durden. Right. He is Tyler Durden. Yeah. It’s just some conversation he’s having in his brain. It’s like, what?

Devin: And then there was something interesting. And I don’t know where you where you’re at with this, Adam, but there was. There was a theory. And this is one of those movies that I love going on and on like different forums and hearing people’s theories and about what is actually going on. But a lot of people thought Marla is also in his head. And that was something. I didn’t really pick up on right away. She might be. I actually thought Marla was actually a character because there’s, and, and one, one blogger actually pointed out this specific scene of when they’re at the laundromat and she’s pulling all of her clothes out.

Out of the dryer. And they’re all men’s jeans. They’re all men’s. It’s all like stuff that he would be wearing. That’s interesting. And I was like, wow, that’s a really good pickup. But yeah, I mean, I don’t, of course I’m not, don’t know what camp I’m in.

Adam: So what you just. Said is the reason why you need to explore depth of story nowadays, especially in building layers, because if people are going to rewatch and examine something, that’s a great story, like Fight Club to that nuance detail minutia. It’s important to know what you’re right. Writing. You can’t just write a first draft. Well, I guess this works. Story requires more respect and dedication these days. We’ve seen it. It’s done. We’ve seen it. So do I subscribe to that theory? You know, here’s here’s what I would say. There’s no way. All to determine whether that’s the case or not, simply for this reason, the focus has been on Tyler Durden being in his head and not the others. So there’s no real payoff resolution to discover that if they did Fight Club 2 and his world started to disassemble more in his support.

And all those things, you start to realize, well, those are fabrications in his mind as well. Then you could get it. But theoretically, it’s interesting. I never thought about it, but absolute possibility just because of the psychosis that he has. I love that movie. And it’s a great example for, it’s one of those movies like, I won’t go into this one because it’s a very similar concept, but The Usual Suspects. It’s very, there’s one of my other favorite, that’s the neo film noir I was talking about. That film is amazing. If you watch, you can understand the setups and payoffs throughout it. But the mystery is, who is the mystery person? There’s this phantom criminal that haunts the criminal underworld and it’s slowly set up throughout this backstory.

It’s very similar to Fight Club in its reveal structure. And once again, it’s on the reveal of the whodunit, who is it, who’s the person sort of concept. Although I think Fight Club is a little bit more inventive because it’s almost like a projection of psyche that you’ve been watching this whole time, and that’s… So much fun. It’s so much fun, that movie. It’s the J word.

Devin: Yeah, I think Fight Club’s a little more complex than Usual Suspects, because Usual Suspects, in its brilliance, is in its simplicity.

Adam: Yes.

Devin: Because it’s literally, the payoffs are hiding in plain sight the entire movie. Keyser Söze, the name, it’s on the mug, it’s on the pictures. He’s getting, he’s building his story based on things that are in the detective’s office. And so, it’s not until you go back and…

Adam: Yeah, but you won’t get any of that stuff in the first viewing.

Devin: Oh, no, that’s what I’m saying. It’s hidden in plain sight.

Adam: Yeah, yeah, yeah. It’s, again, like Scream. They don’t give you the clues to really get it from that. And here’s the thing, and I’m proud to say this, because I don’t always figure out every movie’s endings. Like, Crazy, Stupid, Love, didn’t see that coming at all. But Usual Suspects, I got it. And it’s because I was really paying attention to stories at that point, and when I first watched it. And I noticed, this is from my mom, whenever we’d watch something on TV, there would be something being shot. And she’d be like, something’s going to happen at that window. There’s too much play on the window.

Devin: Yeah.

Adam: And so, I grew up with her being a storyteller and loving that, to going, okay, so when I’m telling the story, I need to tease or set up or hide in plain sight that. And sometimes it needs to be overt, like the play on the window. But with Usual Suspects, it’s the gold watch. It’s the… It’s all the stuff that he’s wearing as Keyser Söze. Mm-hmm. It’s the lighter. It’s the fact that he lights a cigarette in our hook opening scene with ease and grace and almost like this snaky, seductive weirdness. That’s the creepy villain. And then when you get to the interview, the guy who’s being interviewed can’t even use a lighter.

And I was like, eh, got it. That was for me. Right. It was that easy for me, because that might have been too obvious a setup for me. Right. But for most people, I think… I think it was just subtle enough. But that was my guess. That was my big guess.

Devin: My other example, there’s something very similar to that. Example two, Devin. This movie is brilliant. And this movie is also one of those movies that really divides… What I’ve found has divided people into two camps. Ooh. One is they get it. Two is they don’t get it. And I’m not saying they don’t get it because they don’t understand what’s going on. They don’t get the brilliance of it. And the movie is Shutter Island. After this movie, I read some reviews that said this is Scorsese’s, or Scorsese, however you pronounce his name, one of his worst films or his worst executions. And I’m like, then you don’t understand the brilliance and the little, tiny, subtle nuances of this movie and how well thought out every single piece of this film is.

This is, again, this is one of those movies that you have to watch it twice. Yeah. I enjoyed it. If you haven’t seen it yet, you just don’t pick up on the brilliance. It’s that it’s matter throughout this entire film if you’re saying that it’s not that great of a movie.

Adam: It’s hard with twist endings anymore because you really, really, really, really, really have to bury your stuff. Right. Because people are onto it. They’re waiting. They’re looking for it. So it’s hard.

Devin: Right. So this falls under the you have to watch it at least twice because you will… And this one, you really see it through two different lenses. And so the very first lens were kind of in the shoes of Teddy Daniels, who’s played by Leo DiCaprio. So for those who haven’t seen it, I’ll lay it out. A little bit so you can kind of understand what’s going on. But it’s basically two U.S. It opens up on two U.S. Marshals on a boat traveling to this island, this spooky fog covered island. That’s the home to this mental hospital or this insane asylum. And we begin to gather information as there as him and Mark Ruffalo’s character, Chuck, they’re the U.S. Marshals are heading over there.

And so they’re they’re there to investigate. They’ve taken the assignment on to investigate the disappearance. The disappearance of a patient who’s there for murder. And she’s recently escaped. OK, that’s a good setup. Good setup. One of the subtler things in the execution of the film, but probably also in the written word of the film is, is this beautiful symbolism of fire and water. During his hallucinations, there’s always fire and that’s present. It’s always there because that’s the illusion that he’s that he’s created for himself. And then water represents the death of his former self, which it’s his wife. His wife. Drown his children. And throughout the film, he’s kind of got this aversion of water that he gets seasick on the boat ride.

And by him, I’m talking about Teddy, Teddy Daniels. And this is Leo DiCaprio’s character. And so throughout the film, he has an aversion to water, but getting seasick. And then there’s also this like terrible storm that’s going on the entire time. That’s not allowing him to get on a ferry to get off the island when you’re first watching it. It seems fairly black and white. It’s it’s it’s a psychological mystery thriller. And like I said before, you see, we the first time. You. Watch this movie. You’re going to see it through the lens of Leo Leo’s character, Teddy. And we are trying to as an audience member, we’re kind of trying to solve this mystery with him.

And we’re trying to to put the pieces together like any good mystery thriller. Now, towards the end of the story, we find out through dialogue of the doctors and takes maybe two or three scenes that we find out that Teddy is not a real person. And this entire story leading up to this point has been just a big charade. And so we realize that we’ve also been tricked. Again, this first viewing we’re in, we were basically Teddy throughout this first screening. But there’s still a piece of us during this first screening that we don’t know if we’re believing these doctors because it seems like he’s been, they’ve been at odds, they’ve been the antagonists the entire time. And so we don’t know if we believe this, that this is just a charade. So we’re still, we still will always have like one foot in with Teddy until the very last scene in the lighthouse when we finally realize that Teddy is actually a patient and he’s part of this elaborate mental experiment to try to, to try to cure him, to try to bring him back to the person he was before he walked in on his wife, murdering their children in the water. And so they’re putting him in a role playing scenario that basically puts him into a place prior to the moment of his murders and hoping that, that he’ll block out everything after that. And they can kind of like, he can pick up where he left off. Otherwise, he’s got to get a lobotomy. And basically, because he’s dead, get a lobotomy.

So the second time you watch, this, knowing this. Oh, yeah. You pick up on all the brilliant, subtle setups throughout this movie that leads to this like massive payoff. And one example in particular that jumped out at me is on my second viewing is the scene where Teddy is interviewing the staff nurses. And he asks if anything unusual occurred the night the escape patient, if there’s anything unusual that occurred the night that she went missing. And one of the staff nurses basically just says, it’s a mental institution, Marshal. And then they give him a big laugh. And then the rest of the nurses laugh. So the first time you watch it, you’re just like, wow, there, it’s just a simple, it’s just a group of nurses that are, that are annoyed with them interrupting the routine. And they’re kind of giving them sarcastic answers and like a ribbing.

Snarky. Yeah. And they’re, they’re just not taking this seriously. Right. And then the second viewing, you see that they’re all doing this because they’re playing their part in this charade. Yeah. And they do think it’s bad. They think it’s probably really weird, this is stupid, that this guy is crazy, he doesn’t know he’s crazy. Some dude in a nightgown with messy hair is asking us questions, pretending to be a marshal.

Adam: Where the illusion is gone and you’re like, oh, he’s just a crazy dude asking us questions as if we’re being investigated. It’s funny to those nurses to a certain degree. That’s definitely a sweet layer.

Devin: And similar to your, the usual suspects, the lighter, there’s something similar to that in this movie. And it’s when Teddy and Chuck, when they first get off the boat in the beginning, and one of the big security guards comes up and says, you got to surrender your firearms. And Chuck, who remember now, he’s actually a doctor playing the role as a U.S. Marshal because Teddy was a U.S. Marshal. So he’s pretending he’s his partner for this experiment.

Adam: I was going to ask you, I couldn’t remember what Mark Ruffalo’s character was all about, but you’re right. Okay, doctor, got it.

Devin: And so he’s playing the part as this U.S. Marshal. But when they ask him to give, when they ask for their firearms, he struggles to figure out how to remove the gun from the holster. And so instead, he just like fumbles and just takes his entire holster out and gives them both the holster and the gun. And Teddy in that moment is looking at him like, you’re a U.S. Marshal. You don’t know how to take your gun out of a holster. And we’re looking at him the same way. So like, again, that first viewing, we’re literally with Teddy on this. Like, we’re in your boots, man.

Like, this guy’s suspicious. Like, who is this guy? And of course, it makes sense later after it’s revealed that Chuck, like everyone else, you know, aside from the patients, they’re all in on this experiment. And he’s just a doctor. So of course, he doesn’t know how to handle a firearm. And so that’s just like one of those, that’s one of those subtle things that’s so brilliant when you see it first time. It’s one thing. You’re with Teddy. The second time, you’re like, oh, my God. Like, he’s a doctor. Of course, he can’t figure this out. Right. And then there’s just one other thing. One other scene that I just thought is freaking brilliant that is obvious the second time and not obvious the first time.

It’s the scene where Teddy’s interviewing the patients individually. And you see armed security guard. Behind the patient. And you see one armed security security guard behind Teddy. But there isn’t an armed security guard behind Chuck. So at first watch, you think they’re there to protect Teddy in case one of the patients tries to hurt him. But on second viewing, you realize that they’re there to watch Teddy and the patient. For Chuck. They’re both the patients, yeah. From each other, right? Yeah, exactly. Make sure nothing happens to Chuck. That’s clever. In that same scene is where the brilliance of Scorsese comes in. And so it’s when Chuck brings the glass of water to one of the patients that Teddy’s interviewing.

And so when we see Chuck come into the scene, we… We’re at the camera point of view. So we have Teddy off to the right, we have patient off to the left, and then we’re watching Chuck come in. So we’re sitting as the camera. Then we switch to Teddy’s point of view. And when the patient goes to drink the glass of water, her hand is empty, and she just basically pantomimes herself guzzling this… Glass of water. And then we switch to a over-the-shoulder shot of the patient. So we’re off of Teddy’s view, and now we’re over the shoulder, and then we actually see her put a real empty glass down onto the table. And so because he has this aversion of water, he’s blocked it.

Mentally. He doesn’t see it. He blocks it. Wow. And this scene is a huge setup scene. It uses dialogue, it uses performance, it uses camera positioning, it uses directorial decisions to build up to this huge lighthouse scene where it all is like boom, boom, boom. Like this is what happens. This is the reveal. And it’s nuts. And there’s like little tiny things like that throughout the entire movie. Like even when they’re taking a tour of the island and they’re like, yeah, we’ve been looking at, we’ve been looking for her ever. All the guards have been looking for her. And then when you actually look at the guards who are supposedly searching for.

None of the guards are actually searching for anything. In fact, a lot of them are just sitting down. They’re talking to each other. They’re kicking, they’re kicking rocks around and they’re just sitting around as if they were staged there. That’s funny. Again, first viewing, we’re like, wow, these guys are just inept. They’re lazy. Of course they need these marshals there. Like there’s something going on. I think all of these people are in on this, this person’s escape. Yeah. And you watch it again and you’re like, because they’re all part of this like elaborate experiment. Yeah. Oh my God. It’s so good, dude. That movie is, it’s one of those, you got to watch it twice. Again, you’ll see it in completely different lenses each time you watch it.

Adam: You just helped me to watch it twice through your examples. Cause I remember these moments and I’m like, Oh yeah, that’s, that’s really clever. But I love, I will say this too. I’m a sucker for, and a lot of people were like, I hate it when it was all just a dream. And I’m, I love that stuff. I love exploring. Psychological landscape through the story. Yeah. I love seeing the inside of someone’s brain through the story we’ve just seen. And I don’t mind. I mean, sometimes it’s sort of like not a fun ending. You know what I mean?

The way it ends is sort of like sad or desperate because we’re all locked inside this person, the prison of this person’s mind. But sometimes I enjoy that thing because I like the expression of psychological or emotional state in some physically represented way, like story. It sort of is a similar thing to Terry Gilliam’s movie Brazil. It’s really fun and wild. So let me just do my last example because I have one example. And it’s a comedy when we rarely do comedies. And it was a show that I’ve seen years ago. It’s called The I.T. Crowd. It’s a British sitcom by Graham Linehan. And it stars one of the stars of it is he’s the love interest in Bridesmaids. And he’s also in the new The Cloverfield Paradox movie where he’s the only person I actually.

Is recognized as a named person in that movie, which I was excited about. I love when they cast lesser known actors so that the story thrives. I love that. But he was he was one of the only recognizable folk in it. Anyway, he plays one of the leads. I’ll set up the premise of the show, but it’s one episode in particular because I. Swear to you, I almost died laughing, and that’s not a joke. I literally almost died choking to death because it was so funny to me. I watched it probably seven times in a row. I swear. And I would recommend even if you don’t watch this series, folks, just watch this one little piece because it’s very funny. So the I.T. Crowd is about an I.T. Department in.

a corporation, Reynholm Industries, and it is comprised of two guys, and Chris O’Dowd’s one, Roy, who’s like this goofy Irish guy who’s he’s always trying to get the girls and drinking a lot. And the other guy is a much nerdier guy who doesn’t quite get it. So when you’re trying to get him to be quiet and don’t say that. He doesn’t get the social cues, but he’s really. Funny as well so these two guys have the i.t department and the premise of the series is

Anyway, there’s an episode where these two nerdy guys, the episode is in season three, episode two, and it’s called Are We Not Men? And it has to do with them questioning their masculinity. And so they find this football or soccer site where there’s quotes so they can sound like they know what they’re talking about sports-wise to the manlier guys they interact with in the company. And they end up getting wrapped up with this group of guys playing poker. Roy, played by Chris O’Dowd, loses money. And the guy’s like, oh, you know, forgive him. Don’t worry about it. You don’t owe me that money. And so he thinks this guy’s great.

The guy asked him on his lunch break, hey, would you mind coming to give me and my friends a ride? We had a guy and he bailed on us. So can you, is there any way I can help you? Is there any way you can help us out? And he goes, yeah, sure, sure, sure. So Roy goes down to be friends with these manly guys. He’s hanging out. And the guy’s talking about, yeah, we just need you to drive us around for a couple hours. Here’s the car. He’s like, oh, it’s an automatic. I drive an automatic. In the background, as they’re having this very simple conversation, the two other guys are putting on ski masks and checking their weapons. But Roy doesn’t see this.

Okay, so we, the audience, are sort of let in on the fact that he’s about to be the driver in a robbery. And the setup is the dramatic irony that we know and Roy doesn’t. And so him being a nice guy, because this guy’s like, oh, yeah, forget that, you know, the 200 pounds that you lost to me in poker. This makes us even. Roy’s like, this guy’s great. He’s fantastic. It cuts to Roy driving them. He pulls off and he goes, you’ve reached your destination, like some nerdy chipper guy. And we know the whole time that these guys are going to be the drivers. So he’s just being himself. Roy, the IT guy, trying to fit in with the manly guys. And he pulls up to the curb. And as he pulls up, they’re like, just wait here. And so they put on the ski mask, pull their weapons, get out of the vehicle. And he’s fiddling with the radio. He doesn’t, he’s not even looking at the fact of what they’re doing. And he’s like, oh, how do you get the radio to work? And he’s like, oh, no, I got it. And as he looks up, he’s just into the song and they walk into the building. He doesn’t even see it happen.

So he calls Moss. The other guy in the IT department and goes, hey, what are you doing after this? You want to come meet me and the guys? They got this place down at the gasworks. And Moss is like, wow, they really are manly, aren’t they? And then Roy looks to the bank next to him and he goes, Moss, there’s a robbery going on right now across the street from me. And Moss goes, call the police, call the police. So Roy hangs up the phone quickly and calls the police to report the robbery. He goes, yes, police, there’s a robbery. I’m right on Danbury Road. It’s a bank across the street. And this is and he’s telling him about it. And he goes, oh, no, they’re coming out. They’re coming over here. Oh, no, they’re getting in the car. And as soon as he says they’re getting in the car, they take off their mask. And he realized that they’re all the guys that he brought here. And his expression is one of the most amazing acting comedic acting bits I’ve seen in forever. I laughed so hard because he he literally like pushes the phone down his chest and into his lap so they don’t see it.

And he’s like, oh, and they’re like, drive, drive. And he’s like, oh, he shoves the phone into his crotch and starts driving. And he’s got the sheer look of panic on his face. It’s so funny, man.

Devin: Now he’s the accomplice is what he called the cops on.

Adam: The payoffs in this episode are phenomenal. But that’s my favorite payoff. I’d laughed so hard because just the way he performs it because he’s in shock and he’s like reporting this crime. And then he’s shrunken down the seat. And then as as he’s watching them run around the car, and then they all get in and slam the doors and take off the ski mask. And his face just panics. But it continues because he has never called Moss back. Who’s the high pitched guy? He never called him back. He just said, meet us down at the gasworks. So he’s there with this pallet full of money. And these two guys arguing over how the cops get there so fast.

And Moss walks in the door and he’s like, so tell me about the big robbery. When they’re arguing about whether to trust him or not. It is such a funny episode, but it’s a setup payoff in a different way. We know what he doesn’t. So it’s dramatic irony. And we’re waiting for it. Right. I was gonna say that. Yeah.

So I could watch it again. It’s when he’s cowering in the seat.

Devin: I can’t. I’ve had a headache since Friday. It’s so annoying.

Adam: Because of the thing?

Devin: Yeah, because my head and my head hit that steering wheel and then my head flew back and hit my step back in my seat. So I probably jarred my brain a little bit. So I’m just been like.

Adam: So I should probably just let you go instead of asking more about the how the head hurts. Because that’s probably the smartest thing to do in this scenario. I’m just gonna go lay down. The past three weeks, it’s been touch and go. Thanks, folks. I don’t know what to do to keep him alive. It’s been an adventure. Please subscribe and rate us on iTunes. And for additional story related resources, video and archived content, visit our website at StoryOsophy.com.