Show notes
What’s the difference between a character’s transformation and the audience’s catharsis? Adam and Devin define both, argue that every story needs a transformation, and walk through some of the most memorable changes in film and television, from mild-mannered chemist to drug kingpin.
In this episode
- Two definitions. Transformation is the thorough change a character goes through from beginning to end. Catharsis is the emotional release, felt by characters and, vicariously, by the audience.
- Every story needs a transformation. Without one, Devin says, it isn’t really a story. It’s just a moment.
- Long-form storytelling. Binge-watched series let you spend hours with characters and watch them change, much like a novel.
- Make the arc dramatic. Vince Gilligan pitched Breaking Bad as a schoolteacher becoming Scarface. Start your character at one end of the spectrum and see how far they can travel.
- Ups and downs. A real arc looks more like a lie-detector readout than a smooth curve. Adam aims for a small transformation every 10 to 15 minutes.
- Starting at the low point. It’s a Wonderful Life opens with George Bailey ready to give up, then shows us how he got there.
- Catharsis in action. Up devastates you in its first act, then lifts you when Carl throws out his furniture to rescue Russell.
- The unconscious becomes conscious. Lester’s last moment in American Beauty and Steve Jobs letting his guard down in Steve Jobs show a character finally realizing what they really want.
- Transformation as a starting point. Kafka’s The Metamorphosis begins with the transformation and explores how everyone copes with it.
Examples discussed
- Breaking Bad, It’s a Wonderful Life, Up, American Beauty, Steve Jobs, The Shawshank Redemption, The Godfather, Lost and GLOW.
- Also: Franz Kafka’s The Metamorphosis, Sully, and Sherlock Holmes and Dr. Watson.
Next episode: character arc.
Read the full transcript
Transcribed automatically, so expect the odd misheard word. Sponsor messages are left out.
Adam: Hello, welcome to StoryOsophy. This is Adam Jones. And Devin Halden. This episode we’ll be talking about transformation and catharsis. And before we get into it too heavily, we’d like to just talk about, as we usually do, definitions. Sort of what do these words mean and how can you look at them. And then we’ll explore how to sort of disassemble that later. But we’d like to differentiate, I think, transformation and catharsis like this. Transformation, in the way we’re going to talk about it, is what happens to the characters in the story from the beginning to the end. You might also call it a character arc. But as far as a dictionary definition, transformation is a thorough or dramatic change in form or appearance.
A metamorphosis during the life cycle of an animal is another definition. And I also noticed there were a bunch of other definitions. Definitions in various disciplines, academic disciplines like linguistics and biology and logic, physics, mathematics. It just goes to show you how vital and important the concept of transformation is in life in general. If it’s used to describe things that are happening within multiple disciplines, it shares obviously a common root word. And so. It’s, you know, transitioning form is really what it is. And just to.
Devin, did you have anything you wanted to start with?
Devin: I would agree with most of that. I think I would agree that the character alone in the story is going to be the, they’re going to have the transformation. So us sitting down and reading, reading the story or watching the movie, we are not going to have the transformation based on this definition. But I do think that characters within the story will have moments of catharsis.
Adam: Agreed.
Devin: I agree that the audience is going to, our moments are within the story are going to be the moments of catharsis. And I think, but I also think while the trans, the full transformation, I think maybe the catharsis moment for a character is part of that transformation of their transformation in the character. I mean, it usually happens towards, towards the end of the story. Towards the end or as maybe a catalyst of that transformation. So that would be the only, my only addition to what you were saying is I think there are, and I have examples once we, once we start throwing out some examples that will probably be good talking points for us regarding this exact point that we’re making.
So where we can actually identify within movies and stories.
Adam: I don’t think we disagree with this at all because I don’t think the audience can have a transformation. But it’s real. I mean, it’s really just an experience where they’re watching and experiencing sort of vicariously. I think characters can have both. I’m only differentiating between this for this purpose. When the character on screen has that ultimate transformation is a cathartic experience for the audience member. And so they have this sort of vicarious transformation. And so I’m just sort of, I’m trying to label things so we can talk a little broadly and going, here’s for the audience and how we feel. And here’s the character. Here’s the characters and how we feel.
Do they cross over? Oh, yeah. All the time. Absolutely. Okay. That’s what I thought. They need to be relatable. I think in our examples, we’ll really get into this. And like we’ve talked about this whole season, we’re labeling things just to be able to talk about them. But neither Devin or I really believe in labels like putting things in boxes because then you limit. Nothing’s absolute. Yeah. Just keeping those definitions succinct so we can talk about them. Right. Right now we’re talking about how the transformation. Of a character affects the audience and both are transformed. And for both, it should be a cathartic experience. If you’re good at it, there are some transformations that don’t give catharsis and some movies that don’t have a huge transformation, but give catharsis.
I think we’re on the same page, but as always, words and semantics and the wordsmiths argue incessantly.
Devin: I will say this, and I don’t know if you do agree with this, but I think every story needs transformation. Transformation. Absolutely. Otherwise, it’s really not necessarily a story. It’s just a moment.
Adam: And some stories do tell that like slice of life moment. For me, I agree with you 100%. A transformation for me is all about growth and change and choice. And those are the stories I find now that I’m watching and that I’m reading. Those are the stories I’m enthralled with. The depth. The depth of all of those aspects of change and growth and transformation is growth and change. And if it results from choices that the characters made, there’s something we can resonate more with. Instead of it being sort of a victimized state, we actually are seeing these more cause and effect things that this. Person’s choice and perspective has an effect on the world rather than the world just, you know, the other way around. A lot of, like, tiny human stories. Do you know what I mean?
That’s what I love about this new revolution in storytelling that I’m seeing, especially long-form storytelling. I love online. I love binge-watching stuff. And so, I love online series that get released all at once. And I just watched Glow on Netflix. I love all the performers in it. And I adore Marc Maron, who also is a brilliant podcaster. And such a funny dude. I just – you get it wrapped up and you get involved. And I think those allow us to sort of understand people and perspectives. And that we’re sort of cresting this age of character perspective. People – we want to know more about the people.
People in the story than we do about all the tricks and twists and turns, especially reveal-wise if the twists and turns are built on those characters. So, a lot of my examples that we’ll talk about in a bit, it’s built on characters. It’s built on their perspectives and how that matters.
Devin: That longer form – not only just longer form, because miniseries or short narratives or whatever, limited series, whatever they’ve – they used to be miniseries and now I think they’re called limited series. But they’ve been around for a while. But if you look at a traditional miniseries, it was still for the next three weeks or for this month, every Monday is you’re going to get an episode. And it gave – from a writing standpoint and storytelling standpoint, it did give more freedom. But with the advent of binge watching where you’re going to release 10 or 12 episodes of – and perhaps that’s the entire series or season, you – from both a storytelling element and also from a consumer or media consumption aspect, you’re really able to – To develop the characters more in that type of a format rather than trying to shove it all into 90 to 120 minutes and trying to get – from a transformation is perfect for what we’re talking about here is you really can see a transformation of a character if you get to know them over 12 hours rather than an hour and a half or two hours.
It’s all about that. Right.
Adam: I was talking to my buddy who’s a stuntman and producer, Johnny Sullivan, worked on a lot of – the big Hollywood blockbusters. And he and I were talking about long-form storytelling. And what I mean by that is it’s not episodic TV. It’s chapter-based. It’s continued. He’s a big fan of The Walking Dead. He comes from a horror background, action background. And he was talking about – it dawned on him watching this stuff. He goes, the reason why he loves the long-form storytelling and especially binge watching it is because you get to spend all this time with these characters. And you get to grow and develop with them.
And – Yeah. And I’m like, yeah, yeah, yeah. This is sort of like the sort of vicarious experience you can live with these people. They’re your friends, but there’s no danger in it if it’s like some thriller or horror thing. You can take moments in series that you’re sort of just chilling out and spending time with these people and understanding how they navigate different aspects of their life. And I think people were playing with it, writers in particular were playing with it, like with The Wire, the show The Wire and Lost. It shows that we’re trying to play with how much quality time can we spend with these people, not just driven by arbitrary plot points, but – that’s it.
I ran out of steam.
So, out of all the different elements we’ve talked about throughout this season, and especially conflict and forces of antagonism, this is where that thing that’s squeezing – or if you’re looking at it from a victimized viewpoint, or the choices they’ve made have come to a very focused point where it’s sort of like coal being pressured into a diamond, except in a shorter span of time. Your hero’s being refined into this thing, whatever the end result’s going to be. In this example, I think we’re talking about transformation at the end. Right, Devin? Yeah. Why don’t you jump in with your examples? Because they’re always pretty awesome.
Devin: I have a feeling I’m going to steal one from you, but I think we’ll be able to expand on it a little more, and I’m obviously Walter White in Breaking Bad. Yeah, that was one of my top ones. Well, yeah, and I just did the quick transformation where when we meet him, he’s at his low point, and so we sympathize. He’s this promising, law-abiding chemist, family man, and then turns into this ruthless, deceitful, drug-dealing murderer. But when I looked at this transformation, it’s actually a good example of the transformation of a protagonist that transforms into an antagonist. Right. And so we sympathize with Walter’s situation in the very beginning and his bad luck and kind of give him a pass on what his master plan is, his illegal master plan.
But then throughout the series, his descending morals and actions cause the audience to lose that sympathy and kind of turn on him in a way. And so I thought that was a pretty good protagonist to antagonist transformation.
That’s actually one of Adam’s favorite shows. So let’s steal that example from him because I know he’s going to use it.
And I knew you’d probably have a way better example of that example than me. So I just was a little tipping point. I’ll take it away and blow my mind.
Adam: You always come up with the best examples. I love – this is part of the reason why I love doing these podcasts and chatting with you to begin with is always discovery. And that’s what I find that’s exciting. You’ll say something. I’ll be like, oh, yeah, that’s really – it’s a clever observation. In writing, you want that discovery too and that transformation, discovery, all that’s part of it. Breaking Bad, I’m glad you pointed out that it was from – well, it’s him breaking bad, going from hero to antihero sort of. And his journey. Obviously, Walter White goes from the mild-mannered science teacher to the crystal meth kingpin, right?
And as you said, he’s ruthless and he’s – but I believe Vince Gilligan pitched it. I can’t remember the reference, but it was a school teacher to Scarface. And so that was his pitch. Well, Sony obviously leapt on it, but that was the pitch. The pitch was the transformation. And I think that’s important to look at because that’s the character’s arc. He just sold it. He just pitched it. He sold it on the character’s arc. And it was just such a dynamic premise.
Devin: That brings up another good point too is when you’re developing your main character’s arc, make it an arc. Like make it dramatic. Even start off way too dramatic, like opposite ends of a spectrum. And then if it’s too severe, kind of start bringing it in a little bit, but make it very obvious to the audience. Yes. He started off, he or she started off here as this person, as a mild mannered law abiding family man chemist. And then, well, what’s the next thing he could do? Is he just going to sell some bags of weed and try to make money selling bags of weed?
No, let’s make him a freaking kingpin of meth. And not only is he selling drugs, but he’s killing people. So, I mean, it’s like, it’s important. Obviously, you don’t have to have it incredibly severe, you know, crazy severe, but it’s a good place. When you’re trying to develop the character’s arc, because the character’s arc, once you, when you’re trying to figure out where they’re starting from, where your hero’s starting from, where they’re going to end up, all of a sudden that brainstorming session brings a bunch of different ideas as to how, what’s going to happen in between there. And so it’s a, it’s kind of one of those fun writing practices or exercises you can do that actually uncovers a ton of other possibilities as far as some events and other things that they’re going to do.
And other things that they’re going to go through during this journey that are going to get them to that arc. So, I think a big arc is good.
Adam: It is. And what you’re saying is interesting. In long-form storytelling, it allows you the ability to map that arc much better than in a feature film. When it’s just, the more time you spend with something, the more involvement you have, the more meaning it has to you. People who’ve watched these epic series that have been going on where it’s like worldwide obsession, like Game of Thrones or Walking Dead, when big moments happen, you’re very… Very involved. You know what I mean? It’s almost like it’s happening to you because you’ve gotten wrapped up in these stories and spent so much time with these people. They’re your friends. Like I say, whether they’re good people or not, you still, if it’s good writing, you understand where they’re coming from. You have a strong understanding of their…
Devin: I think arc is somewhat a bit of a misnomer when you’re trying to chart something. So I think the character arc is the most important parts of that arc are that beginning dot and that end dot. But I think if you’re picturing this straight line of an arc showing it from one point to the other, I don’t think… I think it’s more of like if you’re looking at a lie detector test where there’s a ton of false and truths in between there. So they’re going to go up and down. They’re going to have moments of… Yeah, yeah. There’s moments where Walter White in Breaking Bad goes back to or there’s wanting to be back to get out of what he’s gotten into or…
To get out of what he’s gotten into or that he’s still that family man, but then that leaves very quickly. And then so there’s these ups and downs, but when the story ends where we leave these characters, what is that transformation and where are they? And then it depends on how you want to end it too.
Adam: Well, like you said, hero to anti-hero. There is growth, but there’s not triumph necessarily in Walter White’s case. He grows and you know what, I’ll mention what I jotted down about Breaking Bad too, because I wanted to say, I heard wonderful things about the writer’s room for Breaking Bad, but I know one of their number one. Questions that they asked for every scene.
In doing that, there are transformations. And this is the way I try to do it. Like I was talking to you about measurements and breaking it up into movements. I try to make sure the character has a transformation like every 10, 15 minutes. Decisions get made all the time. And I feel like in stories, a transformation always happens at the end. Now, the big transformation needs to happen at the end of the story. But throughout, we should see, like you’re saying, these peaks and valleys, these bits of transformation, like a roller coaster of here’s where this person had some success in their perspective, and here’s where they didn’t.
And then be able to see them reflecting on that, or in a novel, be able to understand or see or read them reflecting on these moments of up and down so that we can understand their transformation. And transformation, talking more about inner space of a character, just like Devin was saying earlier with catharsis, there’s an emotional thing for the characters, too. In Breaking Bad, I wanted to mention not just Walter White, who has this huge arc and transformation, but Jesse Pinkman, his meth-making sidekick. By the end of this series, he’s sort of become this meth Frankenstein that’s chained up. By the scum of the show to do their bidding.
So, oddly enough, this is like Walt’s chance at redemption for himself. He can’t do it with his family. And even for Jesse and the way things have been going. I mean, he’s influenced Jesse to do this path beyond his worst nightmares. Like even when Jesse’s, like you’re saying, when Walt tries to get out, Jesse’s trying to get out harder. Now, at the end of this series, as far as a transformation, Jesse’s this chained up monster. He’s a monster movie version of himself, chained to making meth. I don’t know how in the heck Vince Gilligan pulled that off, because it was really over the top and pushed.
But it worked, you know, and it was horrifying to us, because we love Jesse. So, he chose this sort of direction of transformation. And then, you know, the resolution is sort of the cathartic experience for us and Jesse at the end of the whole series. And an interesting fact about Breaking Bad, although most people probably know this, Jesse Pinkman. Jesse Pinkman was not supposed to last through the entire series. He was supposed to die at the end of season one. And because Aaron Paul’s performance and their camaraderie was so excellent on screen, they kept him alive for the entire series. That’s awesome. I know, it’s amazing, right?
Devin: Talk about a good decision. I can’t imagine that series without him in that.
Adam: And it doesn’t deter from the primary arc that Vince Gilligan pitched, which was Science Teacher to Scarface. Right. It was like the last episode. We were talking about Fawlty Towers and how John Cleese’s character talks to Basil Fawlty, talks to Polly, and gives her the plan. It’s sort of the same. You need that Jesse Pinkman in this story to be the ally and foil the shapeshifter. He’s sort of Walter White’s shapeshifter. It’s an interesting example, but we should move on, because I use that example so much. I wanted to mention this too, because I used a word before I field over to you. I use the word redemption. And a lot of times that’s used in sort of a transformation from a villainous perspective to, oh, they’re redeemed as a character. But I feel like that also has very, it’s not a very broad definition of transformation. It’s a very, like I say, Western civilization, probably religiously influenced word where you’ve done wrong and you must redeem yourself.
It’s an interesting thing to play with, but transformation is a much broader and comprehensive way of looking at that event.
Devin: Well, we’ve been talking about Breaking Bad, a very, a similar setup, but very different audience. It’s a Wonderful Life. It’s such a great movie. And we’ve used that before too. But I think that’s, I think it’s good to use the same movies when we’re talking about different elements. Did we talk about that before? A little bit. And George Bailey is obviously the main character of It’s a Wonderful Life. We meet. We meet George very similarly that when we meet Walter in Breaking Bad is we’re introduced to George at his low point. He’s about to commit suicide. The difference between, well, Walter, his decision with his position in life and his bad luck is to make meth and hurt other people. But George is committing suicide. He’s only hurting himself. But what you actually find out in that movie is we, the audience, are empathizing with George throughout the story because his story is very relatable.
It was very relatable back when they made the movie, but it was, but in recent years with the job market and things like that, it’s very relatable now. And so the key to George’s continued audience support, I feel, is he retains his humanity. He interrupts or postpones his, his suicide to save Clarence, the guardian angel that comes down. You know, long story short, George feels worthless. He feels that he is a burden to his family and his society and his town. And then Clarence grants him the wisdom. I wish that George wants to have never been born. And then George sees, I’m blowing through this story of what happens. I’m sure everybody’s seen it. But, and then George sees his friends and family would be incredibly worse off without him. He begs Clarence to rescind his wish by telling him, and I might butcher this, the actual line from the movie, but he says, I want to live again. Please, God, I want to live again or let me live again.
And so his moment of transformation is made complete when he reads that copy of the, The Adventures of Tom Sawyer that Clarence sneaks, sneaks to him somehow. And the inscription is no man is a failure who has friends. And so this gives the audience confidence and George will never question his worth or value ever again, nor should we as the audience. And so that’s kind of the catharsis moment for the audience is that full transformation that George Bailey goes through. And we probably could have spent way more time on that example, but I didn’t, I would just, that just was kind of off the cuff thinking about how that’s different than Breaking Bad.
Adam: That’s a good example. And I’m glad you walked the listener through it so that they could actually understand the decision points and where the discoveries were for him that allow him to have a different perspective from the beginning. You really just did an excellent job. Listeners, if you don’t know what a story arc is, back up and listen again. Devin laid out for you probably a really excellent version of a character arc. And I was going to mention, I’ve mentioned this before, but I’m glad I waited until after you said that. A lot of times to develop that character arc, like Devin was suggesting, you want to go to the extremes at the beginning and at the end. And to do that, sometimes it’s helpful to backwards engineer the whole thing. You start in a place, you run your character through to the end, you go, oh, this is a good story. Then you get to the end and you look at, can I make the character at the beginning a little bit more separate from where they end up so that the journey is a little bit more complete.
A little bit more extreme. And you’ll find that you go back to your first act a lot because that’s where most of your setups are happening. And so as you make discoveries throughout your story, you go and you tweak a nut or a bolt in your first act so that it helps to reflect throughout setup payoff wise. It’s good to do that. So you have an arc. Oh, I was going to say George Bailey, he rewishes the beauty of the construct of that story is he wishes something in the beginning. So we know what he wants. And what he really wants, as we’ve talked about that this whole season, is what he re-wishes. I love this example, and I love that you walked us through it so that we could actually see what a transformation is like.
Some of my transformation examples are a little different. They’re about transformation. Franz Kafka, the Czech writer, wrote the novella Metamorphosis. It’s about a man who turns into a bug. And the first line of the story is, as Gregor Samsa awoke one morning from uneasy dreams, he found himself transformed in his bed into a gigantic insect. The story starts with a character transformed, and it’s how they cope with it. So it’s almost like, if we were talking about some of the language we’ve used throughout the first season, the crisis for this character happens at the beginning. And so the transformation is really this huge event that happens.
But it’s all about how this person copes with that transformation. It’s not about really them transforming by the end. It’s about how everyone else reacts to this transformation. And Kafka was very symbolic, and his themes mainly revolved around alienation. I thought that was an interesting example because it’s a very famous novella and all about this, the results of this transformation, which I thought was an interesting take on where transformation takes place in a story.
But I just want to throw that one in there because I thought it was kind of fascinating.
Devin: The transformation is 99% between the ears and 1% of what we’re actually seeing as far as like a physical transformation and how the character carries themselves physically or visually. Right. It’s usually their growth is perspective or perception on how they see themselves within this world and then how that journey and that transformation changes who they are when and if they go back to that ordinary world or that normal, that known world. That we found, that we met them at.
Adam: [Sponsor message]
I like to think of it as changing a belief system. That’s what I look for in a character’s arc. They’ve experienced such a journey. That their thoughts have now, the old thoughts have faded away and new thoughts have come about they have to deal with. And they enter like a new stage of consciousness for themselves. They figure something out for themselves. They have a growth point. And so that to me is the transformation. And the catharsis is the emotional aspect. You have to pair the two of them. And so those coming together are important, psychological and emotional.
One of my other examples, I won’t talk about it for too long, but I just want to throw it out there. Because. It’s great for this. Lost. The TV show Lost. Each episode you were given a character’s point of view. And then you flash back throughout their life while you were watching current events in the present. And so what they were thinking about or feeling in the present sort of sparked these flashbacks that you would go back and see, oh, that’s why they feel that way. And maybe at the beginning of the episode, you think this person’s a dirtbag. And by the end of the episode, you have understanding.
And compassion for them in a way that’s, for me, watching story, it was revolutionary. I loved watching Lost because it was such an experience.
Devin: You always have way more questions than answers at the end of every one of those episodes, which is the brilliance of it.
Adam: I wasn’t going to get into that because I do have some issues with the baiting cliffhanger-y stuff that was going on. But as far as character transformation and catharsis, we’ll talk about flashback as one of the tools later in seasons. But it sort of made flashbacks very fresh again because it used them a lot. You would understand a character’s cause and effect. Their psychological landscape and emotional landscape, you understood because we got a glimpse through their eyes. That’s why they started it with each character having their perspective. I love the way they did that because the same reason we’re talking about Walter White and we take that journey with him.
For these characters, we take the journey with each of them. Right. And sure, you’ll have your. You’ll have your favorites, but you have compassion and understanding for all of them. Maybe I just got a big heart, but even some of the villains, you know.
Devin: No, that’s an important insight, too.
Adam: I think most audience members have a big heart. I think that’s what story allows them to do is have an experiential thing where they can sit back and have a big heart for someone that they couldn’t necessarily if they were dealing with it in real life, you know.
Devin: It’s vicarious. You’re spot on with using flashbacks correctly with us because other people will say if you can somehow bring it up with somehow get their backstory within the present conversation, but I don’t think you would get you would become compassionate to what has happened to all of them who have crashed on this island without actually living with them and actually seeing them interact visually and experiencing them at their home and with their people and where they came from rather than them trying to, okay, let’s set up dialogue between this character and this character sitting against the wreckage of this plane and then somehow having him give insight of his backstory or her backstory or where she came from. I think us traveling back in time and actually spending time with those characters I think was a really smart way to do that where it actually it develops character more but also gives the audience compassion for their current situation as well. So an empathy.
Adam: It also does I think what most people are looking for in storytelling now. It’s it allows you to sort of understand people more. It allows you to get the cause and effect because most people you look at what some of the final words that series is just let it go, right? It’s all about letting things go. And these are people who have all this this baggage and stuff. So they’re negotiating through that. Well, most people I don’t think have figured it all out. And so there are things that still come back. And I think the way that that perspective and thought. Process of the story went as far as unraveling characters, like like I’m saying layers of an onion. I like to think of characters that way. The further the story gets along, the more you get to know and understand and it becomes more complex.
Devin: Let me ask you this. Yeah. When you’re watching that show, was there ever a moment when you were like, I think that would be a kind of cool situation to survive a plane crash with a bunch of people, a couple hot chicks and being on this island. There’s like a romantic element to it in a way. Yeah. I just remember I’m like, man, I would have won. It’d be cool to say you survived a plane crash. But two, you’re like, man, I’m on this island. I’m with you. With some pretty good looking ladies.
Adam: I’m with you. But isn’t that a reality show? Yeah. I would say here’s the thing, though. As you’ve talked about the story, it needs to conflict. So if these guys are all happy about being on an island, it’s Survivor until you start feeding them worms and stuff or whatever they got to eat. Or it’s Bachelor in Paradise. Give me a flower to lay and just let me hang out at the beach. I’m fine. I like the beach. Can’t beat the beach. Everybody likes the beach. I have that on a mug, I think, somewhere. I’m going to throw out another example because I think you’re going to really like this one. This was one of the ones I had for catharsis because for me, this was one of those stories that really I emoted heavily with.
Nice. Pixar’s Up. I know both of us love Pixar. I actually don’t have any Disney Pixar examples in mind. Oh, what? This is crazy.
Devin: I knew one of us would have one.
Adam: Let me just say this about catharsis so that we can get into that a little bit. One of my most cathartic experiences was with Up. I’ve cried in lots of movies, I’ve been moved by many movies. Up, I think what’s interesting is within the first act of this story, they show you the journey of these two children who grow old together and then he loses her. And so you’re sobbing by the end of the first act. Yeah. I mean, you’re sobbing. At least I was. Emotionally affected me heavily. So there’s this huge loss they’ve created for you. And it’s sort of a trick, but they did it so brilliantly and so well that you’re instantly with the old man. You’re sort of grumpy. You’re sort of like, well, that was a crappy way to start because you don’t want to feel bad. And then this kid shows up. And so he kind of bothers you too a little bit.
The way they navigate the perspectives in the beginning of that is a perfect setup for… Forward transformation, catharsis, hand in hand. I don’t like spoiling movies when I give examples too much. I know it’s been out for a while, but there’s always… I think there’s a five-year limit on spoilers. For me, I never want to spoil anybody’s story-watching experience. All right. Earmuffs if you haven’t seen Up. Unless you’re a young person who’s not watched the thing yet. So don’t listen to Devin. What ends up happening at the end is things get complicated after this old man, Carl, and the little boy, Russell, have a friendship. And the little boy goes missing, but the old man’s objective, what he wants, is to get his house, which is floating via balloons, to a magical cliff, a place where he and his wife always wanted to go.
And so it’s a very whimsical movie, and he finally achieves it. He gets his house to this place. He’s lost the little boy that was journeying with him, but he sits sort of content with this. He’s achieved it. And we’ve fallen in love with their relationship and their love at the beginning, and so we go, yes, but why does this all feel so empty? Just like him. And then, I’m going to tear up when I’m talking about this, dude. That’s how affecting it was. And then when he gets up and starts pushing, all of the furniture that were the building blocks of their life out of the house, you’re like throwing your arm up in the air in a fist and going, go get him, old man!
Right, right. You’re so behind that story because such an effective story, that one. But when he goes after that kid, you’re just like, you’re 100% behind the super objective changing from what he wants, getting his house here, to what he really wants, which is love, connection in his life, caring about something.
Right. Who he was and how he was inspired and thrived onto someone else, as you see in the resolution of that story. But that, I think, was one of the most cathartic experiences, and also this very inner realization. Carl has, the old man has this inner space revelation for himself. He’s going, there’s been love during this whole journey, and I was blind to it because I’m so grumpy from having lost.
Devin: That’s a great example. And it covers this. And catharsis with, you know, cleansing or purifying or purification, you know, that covers those two components of catharsis, that emotional component, the strong emotional processing. Purging, feeling, yeah. And then that cognitive, what you just said, that cognitive element or component, which is like the unconscious becoming conscious.
Adam: You just used some words in the description of it, which I think is really excellent to reiterate for our first season. You said unconscious and conscious. And I think that’s very important to point. Because we’ve been talking about want and really want. And I think those words respectively parallel that really well. If your character is usually running after their want in sort of a unconscious way, and then when they come to this realization after the journey, you know, somewhere between crisis climax, their discoveries are made, that conscious realization of what do they really want is what allow, is that point of transformation. Yeah, that positive change.
And hopefully catharsis precedes that for the character. And oftentimes catharsis comes after the transformation for the audience, which is, it’s kind of cool if you can stagger that stuff because that’s audience experience. Just one right after the other, you can keep them on that roller coaster, man.
Devin: No matter what medium, if you’re writing for film or you’re writing as a novel or any medium, I think the essence of catharsis is always the same. It’s this release of some burden. It could be either physical or mental, like a perspective, which in doing so furthers that healing or that cleansing effect. And so I think that’s an important component. That’s not really not a component. But then, like I said, the essence of catharsis is this release of some burden.
Adam: The unspoken or repressed quality. Yeah.
Devin: Yeah.
Adam: Did you have more examples of transformation or just some of catharsis?
Devin: One example. So it’s interesting, kind of what we touched, what I touched on in the beginning, where it’s like catharsis. Catharsis and transformation, they’re not separate of each other. They’re really intertwined and a part of each other. And so one of my examples, I actually had examples and I put this one under catharsis. But American Beauty, that very end scene is kind of the moment of catharsis for Lester. When right before we’re getting a bullet through his head, he’s looking at that picture of his family and realizes his life before this midlife crisis that we followed. Oh, that’s his journey through this thing. It’s just midlife crisis.
The life before that was the real beauty in his life. And it’s not that young girl he lusted for. And so he reassigns his life and makes peace with his wife. He truly appreciates who he is and who he’s become and who he is as a man. And Angela was, even though she was not the beauty, quote unquote, beauty in his life, but she was the important awakening or the trigger. And that domination. That set off that vital chain of reaction in Lester’s life that leads to his moment of catharsis. That leads to him looking at his family and saying.
Like we’ve talked about before, these moments of want, this moment of want, which was, I want this young girl. I’m in this midlife crisis. She thinks I’m attractive, and so I still have it. And then what he really wants is what he had all the time. It’s a wonderful life. It’s all these moves we’ve been talking about. But what he really wants is something he had all along, but without going through that journey, he will never realize it. And so all of that chain of reaction, all those dominoes had to fall for him to realize that. And that leads to his moment of catharsis, I feel, is when he’s looking at that picture. And even though he’s only truly at peace and cleansed for a very brief moment before he’s killed, that’s part of that shared catharsis, I think, between the audience and Lester. So I think that was kind of something that happens at the same time with his full transformation.
And like this catharsis moment.
Adam: Well, it’s interesting, too. You said the full transformation, because as soon as, like, he’s done growing, and then he dies. Right. Like, it’s like, here’s the story of his life. He’s done. He’s reached his, you know, it’s like he’s reached the point of growth for himself that he needs to understand. And we get to be there and witness it, you know, and be intimately a part of that moment, unlike anybody else. Nobody else gets to share that experience. Except for us. Spoiler alert, Lester dies in the end. Devin. Well, I think. I try to dance around a little bit so I can entice people with the idea of the story and not give the specific details. So at least there’s some surprise. It’s like, well, audience, there’s no point in watching that.
We’re talking about story. Well, I’m telling people about these as examples so they can watch them or read them and learn. Hey. Go look at those things and read them and understand them. Yeah.
Devin: Yeah. It is. It’s also a really good movie. And maybe I’m lying. Maybe I’m lying. Maybe he doesn’t get shot in the head. Maybe he lives, you know?
Adam: Maybe that’s true.
Devin: I didn’t tell anybody how, if he lived or died. I said he got shot in the head.
Adam: Okay. Well, now that we’ve over-spoiled that movie, did you have some other examples that you wanted to touch on? The Steve Jobs movie with Fassbender. Oh, I didn’t see that one. I saw the Ashton Kutcher thing.
Devin: Oh. And the reason I used, excuse me, felt like a freaking demon just came out of my throat. Hold on. I got a poltergeist in here with me. I need to exorcise. No. So I thought the reason I brought that up is it’s a little more subtle of a cathartic moment or this moment of catharsis for Steve Jobs. But it’s, I think it’s well done. Aaron Sorkin wrote the screenplay and he’s obviously an incredible storyteller. And I’ll just briefly go over this one. But man. In most accounts, Steve was this tough negotiator, tough boss, tough friend, or more likely it was tough to negotiate against him, tough to be employed by him or tough to be his friend, no matter, depending on what way you want to look at it.
And so through the movie, you see, you see this and it’s brought out. But then there’s these two main moments when Steve puts down his wall, this wall that he’s had up pretty much his entire life. And it’s this emotional confession to John Sculley, who’s played by Jeff Daniels, when he admits that his entire life, he’s known who his biological father was. Nobody knew that he knew who his biological father was. And he would often go see him, but in disguise because he feared that for some reason or another, he would be sued, which is this insight is now shows kind of his paranoia with the world and how he his untrustingness of the world.
Had he come from this like perfect home or with two biological parents who loved each other, never got divorced, gave him everything he wanted, we probably would have never even known what Apple was or much less like the technology that it gave us. Through seeing this, the result is this letting down of this wall with John Sculley. And it serves as this resolution for for Jobs’s alienation or the way that he keeps everybody at an arm’s length. At that moment, it’s almost bringing it’s bringing this other guy in and letting his guard down. And then, of course, the second moment is when he tells his daughter that he named the Lisa after her.
And so all of these things that these people have always wanted to get out of him or they’ve always wanted to help him with and things like that are things that he kept to himself and he never trusted anybody or he had this like paranoia about the world because the world wasn’t really all that great to him. And then there was. There’s these two moments where you finally, you almost see the true Steve Jobs, the Steve Jobs that Steve Jobs knows, and not the Steve Jobs that he lets other people know. And so that was, those are two moments where it was like, there’s a bit of a transformation there. It’s a little more subtle than the other examples, but there’s like this transformation there.
Adam: And there’s, it’s more like the peeled back. Yeah. Like lost has that peel back where you get to, I like those more because now you’re treating the character as a mystery, just like the plot itself. You shouldn’t know every turn and twist. You shouldn’t know every layer of that character right away, get their essence. And then the whole story is about getting to know them. It’s about getting to understand. Them and trying to, you know, figure out who this person is. Right. That’s interesting. I haven’t seen that version, but that’s really interesting that he sort of reveals or shows a little bit of himself to these people in those scenes. You’re saying. Yeah. More cathartic or transformative. Yeah. See, that’s it was a little bit of both. I think it was cathartic for from an audience standpoint.
Devin: That example is very, it’s unique because in any kind of bio is unique because we know the outcome of some of these decisions and some of these events and some of these things that are happening. We know we know something that he that nobody else in this movie knows. We know he’s going to die. And I can’t remember when this happened like the. Whether it was like a year later or I can’t remember exactly, but there’s a very interesting relationship you have with all of the characters that are involved. And it’s you see how Wozniak, I think he’s played by Seth Rogen in this movie, but Woz, who was his partner, who they just they despised each other for a large part of throughout.
But part of us is watching this is like, if you only knew that he was going to not be around for very much longer, would these petty arguments and these petty things that you guys are arguing about, would they even matter anymore? And so, that’s the very unique relationship you have with characters.
Adam: I was just thinking about Sully, the one you were talking about a few episodes back with Tom Hanks. Yeah. That was another true-to-life story. I don’t usually do the biopics. Not usually. Every once in a while, I’ll see one. But I like fiction more. I gravitate towards that. But that’s a good example. I like the biopic or biopics, biopics, whatever. But I think it’s… Potato, potato, baz, baz. We’re going to screw this whole season up with pronunciations.
Devin: What I like about biopics is that interesting feeling. You know what? Here’s what it is. My girlfriend laughs at me because Minnesota Wild, the hockey team in Minnesota, I’ll watch every game and I will tape every game. Even if I’m watching the game, I’ll tape it. And if they win, I’ll watch it again because now all those feelings of anxiousness, like they’re down by two goals or they’re up and I know they’re going to be down and they’re going to win. And over time, like there’s something powerful about knowing the outcome of something, but there’s still something, there’s still a reason I want to watch it.
Adam: The experience of it. The first time the discovery is gone. The first time you watch a story or watch a sporting event, all the stuff’s happened. So the discovery element, the reveal, all that, that’s all gone. And so the second time you go.
Devin: It’s simply for the experience of it. The catharsis, all that stuff, what you’re saying. Yeah. That’s interesting. Well, I feel like I’m laying on your couch right now and you’re hearing my shrink. That was very, that was a very catharsis moment for me right there. I feel very, I feel like I feel cleansed. That felt good. Now tell me a little bit.
Adam: A little bit about your mother. What’s your relationship like with her? Do you guys get along? I don’t know if I would trust the shrink from Alabama. I don’t really have any other examples, dude. If you have more examples. Yeah. The only other, I had one for transformation
Devin: And it’s Michael Corleone from Godfather one and two. When you meet Mike. He’s this decorated war hero and he’s absolutely against and reluctant to join the family business, the family mobster business. And then he becomes really the most ruthless homicidal psychopath that you can see on screen. And then he just. In his mind, it’s business. You know, he murders people because it’s business. And so that one’s kind of a low hanging fruit. Just a good example.
Adam: One of the most important things that you can examine in the story is transformation. Catharsis will come with transformation if done appropriately, because there will be success and. And failure and ups and downs along the way. The reason why transformation is important is because if you can create a story where there is a change in consciousness of the character, you can affect the audience member who may not have ever thought that new thought or that new way of seeing things. And so seeing. The character think through things and make multiple choices until they come to a transformation. That’s what creates this catharsis or even transformation in an audience member, mainly because people there was I was going to mention this before, and I think this is interesting as far as catharsis when you they’ve trained athletes.
They’ve put sensors on their muscles and told them to imagine running the race or swimming the, you know, doing whatever they do. And when they do, the muscles activate. And when they imagine it, their muscles react and activate. Catharsis, vicarious experience of an audience. When you watch something, you believe you are. Participating in it. Psychologically, emotionally. Just like athletes who are imaginatively running a race and their muscles are reacting and responding because they’re thinking about it. Transformative aspects in a story where you get an audience to think in a new way, you are actually opening up brand new neural passageways for them to think a new thought.
That’s why I think transformation is kind of important. Seeing these different levels so someone can navigate it in their own life. Story’s a great teacher. It precedes social change. Art in general does. And we’ve been talking about it a little bit throughout this season. Shawshank Redemption. Yeah. It has a very simple arc in terms of the story. In terms of what needs to happen event-wise. You sort of just have this slice of life with these two characters in prison. And you don’t realize that there’s this enormous turn and twist to the thing. And the way it’s told is there’s a discovery that happens first with the warden discovering.
That Tim Robbins, I can’t remember the name of his character for the life. I remember Red, but Tim Robbins’ character’s cell is empty. Andy Dufresne. The warden goes into Andy Dufresne’s cell that’s empty. And they don’t know where he’s gone. And then the discovery that he’s escaped. He’s carved his way out and escaped. As soon as that discovery is made. Then we get to see how it all happened. And so there’s this big surprise. And then there’s this cathartic experience of the entire narration that Red gives after that fact about he crawled through and then he escapes. And there’s that great shot that’s a bird’s eye view where he reaches up into the sky and the rain pours down on him as a free man.
And we’re in. We, the audience, are all about it. And then we have this sort of wobbly feeling as Red leaves prison. And our knees are a little wobbly because we don’t quite know what’s going to happen. And we see what happened to Brooks. Right. Which is important that they showed that. And Red’s so close to that. And they even have that nice little trick shot. Yep. Yeah. [unclear] Frank Darabont, so brilliant. That screenplay and that film are just amazing. The final moment, this transformation of, in a place where you can’t trust anyone, two friends. Form this fantastic bond between two human beings.
I mean, this is a popular favorite movie with men and women because it’s a bromance, for lack of a better way of putting it. It’s this thing where these two guys really find understanding with each other and friendship and rebirth and transformation at the end. He goes to join his friend and we feel free with them. That last shot is just the expanse of that beach. Yeah. In Mexico. In Zihuatanejo. Working on a boat. Yeah. That’s a great movie. It’s brilliantly achieved moments of transformation and catharsis for us just visually. Let’s just point out the fact that this film also has the, just like American Beauty, it has narration.
You get to compare the narrative, what’s going on in front of your eyes, with someone’s internal voice, the narration. And so you get multiple perspectives. So you get to see Red’s perspective on Andy’s life is really the story of Shawshank Redemption. Right. It’s like. Sherlock and Watson is a similar staple. Where the main character’s life is narrated by the sidekick’s secondary character that becomes their friend. Anyway, Shawshank Redemption.
Devin: Dude, you just spoiled that movie for so many people.
Adam: Please subscribe and rate us on iTunes. And for additional story-related resources, video, and archived content, visit our website at StoryOsophy.com.