Season 1, episode 13

Stakes

February 6, 201853 min

Show notes

Every writer hears “raise the stakes,” but few can explain what that means. Adam and Devin define stakes as what a character stands to gain or lose, and show how they grow out of what the character wants. They talk about failure, thresholds and the poker table, and make the case for stakes that go beyond life, death and money.

In this episode

  • What stakes are not. Stakes aren’t the dangers or obstacles facing the hero. They’re what the hero has to gain or lose, and why they answer the call to adventure.
  • The poker table. Adam and Devin compare stakes to a card game: everyone antes up, the pot grows, and eventually someone has to go all in or fold.
  • Failure builds character. A hero’s setbacks show how strong the antagonist is and test what the hero does next. Daniel LaRusso loses every fight in The Karate Kid until the end.
  • Thresholds raise stakes. Every point of no return moves the hero deeper into an unknown world with higher stakes.
  • Stakes come from character. Katniss volunteering for her sister in The Hunger Games defines who she is in a single choice. Chart the stakes for every main character, not just the hero.
  • Escalate or change them. In The Lion King, Nala acts as a midpoint herald, showing Simba stakes he had been ignoring. The Wild Geese switches its goal halfway through.
  • Stating the stakes outright. In Fawlty Towers, Basil explains the problem and his plan to Polly at the start of each episode, so the audience knows exactly what will go wrong.
  • Avoid cliché stakes. Life or death, money or debt is the easy option. Adam asks for “thrival” stakes built on what a character aspires to, not just what they must survive.
  • Sharpen them in the second draft. Small changes, like reordering two events, can raise the stakes dramatically.

Examples discussed

  • The Hunger Games, The Karate Kid, Armageddon, Game of Thrones, National Lampoon’s Christmas Vacation, Lethal Weapon, The Wild Geese, The Lion King and Fawlty Towers.
  • Also: Blake Snyder’s “save the cat,” and The Nutty Professor.

Next episode: transformation and catharsis.

Read the full transcript

Transcribed automatically, so expect the odd misheard word. Sponsor messages are left out.

Adam: StoryOsophy. Hello, welcome to StoryOsophy. This is Adam Jones. And Devin Halden. This episode, we’re talking about stakes and how to raise them and why it’s important to your story. I mean, you hear a lot of conversations, especially when I was learning to navigate story and had a lot of mentors, whether they were personal mentors or mentors through reading I was doing, and everyone was talking about raising the stakes, make sure your stakes are high. And when you ask them, sometimes it’s hard for them to describe what stakes are. So, it’s also hard to discover how to raise them. And so, in this episode, we’re going to talk about what stakes mean in a story and what that actually means when someone says, oh, you need to raise the stakes in your story. Devin?

Devin: I think a good place to start with stakes is figuring out what stakes are not.

Kind of similar to what you were just saying, where everybody says you got to raise the stakes. It seems like sometimes, not all the time, people are referring to the dangers or obstacles or the conflict that are fighting against the hero and our characters. That’s not what stakes are. Stakes are more of what the hero or even the other characters as well will have stakes, but what they have to gain or what they have to lose. And the stakes play a very important part into why the hero has decided to go to heed that call to adventure and actually go on the quest in the beginning.

What is that stake for the character? Is it life itself? Is it love? Is it a financial reward? Is it a wish? Is it revenge on somebody? Is it earth? Or is it the universe? Like some of the other elements of writing, you’re going to want to know from a writer standpoint what the stakes are in the beginning in your character as well as the audience or reader. They don’t need to necessarily be spoon-fed what the stakes are, but we should be able to have an educated guess as to what will happen if there’s failure and if the hero is successful and what they’re gaining from that.

I didn’t know if you had anything to add to that.

Adam: I had my earphones turn out, I think, a little too low for you. Hang on. You can’t even hear what I’m saying at all. What? What are you saying? Stakes, I think what’s interesting about stakes in terms of podcasts in our season, earlier in the season we were talking about characters and what characters are made of, and want or desire is the number one. What that character wants is really the most relatable factor to any audience member. And so what that character wants is directly tied to the stakes. Pretty much is the stakes, but there’s an equation involved in this. Stakes, it’s easy to look at it, and we’ll talk about this in a minute, but how stakes is sort of like if you look at it like a card game like poker or something like that. There’s a low stakes table and a high stakes table. There’s anteing up. There’s what you’re putting out, what you’re willing to give up or what you’re willing to bet or bid in order to achieve or attain this other part of the equation.

If someone in your family might be affected, that’s what you’re putting out. If that person has really valuable stakes to someone who cares about their family and cares about that person, if that person is more interested in money, the object, the thing that is a value or the thing that wants to be attained is a different set of rules. And so defining stakes begins with understanding characters. Most things, I think, in stories begin with characters. In this particular case, desire of your character is the sort of foundation of building relationships. What your stakes are going to be in your story and how they are raised in the central point, your midpoint, and how that will pay out or not pay out in the climax and resolution of your story.

I think it’s important to talk about maybe this equation, Devin, what the character desires and then what that character, what’s valuable to that character that they’re willing to give up or risk in order to attain that thing, that other thing. I’m interested in understanding what your sort of notion of the equation is. Because there’s a sacrifice or give up and a reward in a casino setting or in a poker setting. You place a bet with the intention of gaining the larger reward of the win, the odds against the house. And we’ll talk a little bit about odds a little bit later in this episode in regards to stakes, but I’m interested in your notion of the equation, Devin.

Devin: I agree that the main part of stakes is there has to be something that you could lose. And it has to be something that matters to the character that’s big. Because if the stakes don’t matter to the character, to your hero, they’re not going to matter to anybody that reads your story or sees it on the screen. Stakes are so much a part of that decision making after the herald comes to the hero and says, here it is. This is what’s going on. This is what you can do. This is what you need to do or we need you to do or something has to happen in order for.

For this outcome to happen. But if you decide not to do it and go on this quest, this is what’s going to happen. And so the stakes become such a very important part of that scene or that part of the story. And it literally defines what what is going to be gained by the by the hero. But then also what maybe that they’ll personally lose or is it going to be something bigger as in some of these, you know, like Armageddon, where if you don’t go and success. Fully drill this friggin asteroid and blow it up, then we’re all it’s going to be a mass extinction of of of life on Earth.

Armageddon, it’s properly titled this movie. So I think that I agree with that part of the equation where, you know, and I don’t know what the you know, if we actually wanted to define it as an equation, like if X, then Y, if not X, then if you want to do it that way.

Adam: Certain. Things like theme and tone are much more abstract and artistic in a way. And stakes is sort of like it needs to be as obvious as the setting, as the conflict, as the there are certain defined elements that are mechanics and they’re not as artistic in their interpretation. And I think stakes is sort of a little bit of middle ground, because what a character wants is sort of an abstract thing. It’s emotional. It’s how the audience. Relates. But at the same time, if you are using that and showing this force of antagonism and. Having an understanding of obstacle and want, this sort of measurement. And it’s weird. I would say, just as a side note, Devin and I have talked about this a lot, but the story is more about measurement than anything else.

You allow certain things to happen, but once you place it together, it’s sort of just like a symphony in music. You want things to happen and rhythmically work in measurements. And I think to create stakes and understand what they are and then increasing them, you’re increasing the measurement of or disparity between maybe what that character wants and the possibility or impossibility of them achieving it, of them gaining it. And so when you’re raising the stakes, you’re sort of making that chasm between the two a little larger or the illusion of it, you know, in the journey of that discovery.

Devin: I do want to go back to the card game analogy. Okay. I think that’s a really good analogy on many different levels. It kind of encompasses that four-pronged element of story for me. It’s, you know, there’s a goal, there’s stakes, there’s obstacles, and there’s outcome. And I think as it pertains to stakes, you know, you sit down as a character, you say you’re playing Texas Hold’em, where that has much more to do with reading a player rather than guessing on what the deck’s doing for you, like in blackjack. So in order to stay in the game, your character, you know, your character sit down, has to ante up, has to give something that they could potentially lose. And over the course of this game, you know, you sit down, you don’t know, you don’t know anybody, you don’t know their tells, you know, you don’t know these guys from Adam. And then, no pun intended, when the stakes will get continued to get higher and higher, and the more money you’re either losing or winning, at some point, the stakes are going to be so high that the decision is going to be made.

And I think that brings up a really another important part of, of, of actual, the storytelling part of it is, is how allowing or writing in failures or, and failures is such a tough word, but losing or where, where there’s unsuccessful attempts that your character is doing throughout, throughout the, the story. One, it gives you ways to show the power of the antagonist and it shows you, so you can see how, even though your character believes at this point of the, at this stage of the story that they know how to defeat the, the antagonist, they’re dramatically wrong. And so they’re, it’s two steps forward, three steps back for them.

So they fail, but that’s when they’re given that that’s, you know, that’s when their true character is. Is, is shown is what do they do now? Do they say, well, I guess I was right. I shouldn’t have come on this quest in the first place. I won’t be able to defeat this guy or in that defeat. I learned something more about my opponent. I learned something more about the antagonist. And so your character’s character is created through the stakes in a way it’s created through their failure and what they do immediately after that. And so you, you find strength in failure.

Adam: You’re tempering who they are as a person. I generally suggest to most writers who, especially if they’re fairly new to aim for a midpoint or a central crisis for the most part, because I feel like for audience and, and writer, that’s a great place for it. I refer to it sometimes as the midterm exam. It’s what you’re talking about. It’s a moment at the middle of the story where we refocus the audience on what this character wants. And the fact, the fact that they’re not there yet and it doesn’t have to be treated like you’re saying you didn’t want to use the word failure. And I agree.

I think it’s sort of a step along the way. If you look. At an omniscient point of view of 120 pages, at the end, they’re not a failure. It’s just in this moment, they have a learning moment, a decision point, a lesson. And so, creating that larger lesson, for me those lessons are, and I hate the word lesson too, that’s a terrible word, but these moments of discovery is a much better way of putting it. Because it’s all about the person’s choice and self-discovery as a character. So as they’re figuring this stuff out, you have these, and you and I both I think agree on this as far as building a story, thresholds.

There are several thresholds throughout a story, and not just the beginning, the middle, and the end. But in between all those points, there are several other thresholds that you can create in order to give much more movement to a script, so, or a story. Different places for this character to succeed or fail, for lack of a better way of putting it, these decision points. And thresholds. Once they’ve made this choice, they can’t return from that choice. That helps to increase stakes. You get locked inside some place, or get locked out of some place. These are point of no returns. And a lot of thresholds and stakes are, I mean, thresholds are great for increasing stakes.

They’re a great visual tool and a storytelling tool to let your audience know you’re moving into a new world, which has new stakes, or greater stakes. They sort of go hand in hand. And we often look at that initial, what you’re talking about before, the herald’s call to adventure or quest. That’s a big stakes moment. As soon as this hero decides to go on this journey, they have to decide to leave their comfort zone. So what they’re putting up, what they’re getting rid of, what they’re sacrificing or risking in order to move into this Act 2 second part of the story, out of their comfort zone, into a different special world they know nothing about, the unknown world.

That’s the biggest tell for your stakes to your audience. You sort of throw out these speculative questions to your audience and set them up so that by midpoint and climax, they’re not sure how much this character is going to risk, why they would risk it. There’s so many questions you get to raise subtextually. It’s that initial comfort zone out of comfort zone. I just wanted to mention The Hunger Games really quick. When Katniss’s sister, in the beginning, is chosen to be a part of this, she volunteers to take her place. Right off the bat, here are the stakes.

She cares more about her little sister and family than she does about her own life. In addition, we also get to know something about her in this choice. Because we know she’s confident enough that she might win. Because she obviously cares about her own life. That she’s strong enough and brave enough and clever enough to do this. I was thinking this earlier. Stakes amplify choice. This moment, the reason why I think it resonates for me. I mean, it’s great performance too. There’s some amazing performance. In this movie. And Jennifer Lawrence has a very specific way of getting her audience to emotionally resonate with her. She’s a really good actress.

And so in that moment, you feel, you are Katniss. And for the rest of that movie, you’re willing to be in her shoes no matter what happens. That’s a huge testament to knowing what your stakes are and how to handle them. That decision point, in that example, it’s a very, it’s cut and dry. It’s nice to have your initial setup be very obvious. For your audience and strong. Yeah. So that way the rest of the story, they’re learning more about your characters. If your foundation’s good, then you explore your characters. Your audience will go with it. That’s why long form storytelling right now online is so prevalent.

People want to get to know other people in this vicarious way.

Devin: That’s why it’s important for a writer to define the stakes of their hero very clearly. Yeah. From both an audience, from an audience standpoint for sure, because you want them to understand our story. I’m in this battle with them. I know what they need to do. I know what they’re trying to get. I know the goal. I know the stakes now. But even from a writer’s standpoint, knowing the stakes when you’re writing every scene is important because it also allows for great subtext. As long as you know what the stakes are and you know the goal. Then when you come to the, when you have that scene where, not necessarily every scene, but it could be whatever scenes with the antagonist, or it’s with another character that’s an ally that has different stakes that may be at some point of the story are conflicting now with the main character.

But it allows for, and we won’t get into subtext because that’s not what we’re talking about, but it’s part of this, you know, a way to what’s really under the surface of what is actually going on and how, you know, it’s that, it’s a, you know. And I think also from going back to the failure part of it, I think it’s, you know, Or the failings, maybe, however you want to put it. But giving your hero these different failings and failures or these unsuccessful attempts throughout the quest makes that moment. Of triumph so much greater in the end. Daniel LaRusso in Karate Kid, dude loses every single fight he has with these guys throughout the entire film.

And at some point you’re just like, dude, stop antagonizing the antagonist. I mean, he says what he’s doing, but he never quits. He, he always gets back up and he learns from his failures. And so when he does come face to face with the antagonist at the end, he’s prepared to defeat him with the crazy crane kick.

Adam: Have you seen that? It’s an online thesis. It’s a little video essay where it talks about how Daniel is the aggressor and how Johnny is only defending himself. I kind of agree with it a little bit. We’ve talked about the Karate Kid a good bit, and it’s such a great mentor tale. That’s known as one of the better mentor tales of the past, I mean, decades. That thesis is brilliant online. It gets you to think on a completely other vantage point in that. Here’s where that thesis really doesn’t hold water for me. Okay. Okay.

Devin: I’d love to hear this. The, the only reason. The only reason that conflict happens between Johnny and Daniel is because of, I forgot Elizabeth Shue’s character’s name in that. Allie. It’s Allie. Daniel’s just like, hey, this chick is hot. I can juggle a soccer ball, so I’m going to go show off a little bit. And so all he’s doing is very, he has no, no reason to have any conflict with Johnny. Johnny shows up and him and his little dirt bike gang show up. And he is immediately on the offense. With Daniel.

Adam: What, but what does he do offensively? He beats the crap out of him. Daniel’s a little jerk to him right away. He sort of was like, I’m going to stand up for this new girl. Well, not really.

Devin: He, he gets thrown on the ground first. And then he challenges him to a fight to say, well, I’m not a, I’m not a pansy. Like he didn’t want, he doesn’t want to go out like that. And then he ends up, it ends up not working out very well for him.

Adam: I thought he provoked him and then charged him and Johnny tripped him, but didn’t actually assault him. Like just moved out of the way. He beats him up pretty good. After that initial thing. On the beach, he gets beat up. Right. Really bad. I’m talking about the beach incident itself. When it first is started, I’m not trying to defend Johnny by any means. I’m just think it’s very interesting that this whole new thesis, when, when they put it in that light, it’s like the Othello handkerchief argument. It’s a chicken or egg. Did Johnny provoke it or did Daniel provoke it? But after that point, most of the things that happened.

Are, you know, Daniel’s being a, he’s sort of retail it’s through, through retaliation

Devin: In some way. Right. That’s what I was saying is antagonizing the antagonist.

Adam: Yeah. It’s weird.

Devin: Yeah.

Adam: And I didn’t really notice it until that, that person had a different perspective and said, here’s a way of interpreting this story. And all of a sudden I was like, this is fascinating that this person took this perspective on this. Right. Cause I, for years, I’ve been, I’ve been looking at it a completely different point of view and I’m like antagonized. As you’re saying.

Devin: Antagonizing the antagonist. He is. But the, the reason, the reason they get around it is, is that bike scene, he doesn’t do anything to him. And then it’s five guys beating the crap out of one dude.

Adam: I was going to comment on something about Game of Thrones. That, that story is not, doesn’t really have a main character. It has an ensemble of characters that you root for. And so their stakes are all varied and defined in different ways. The interesting thing is because of the title. It’s a story you can’t just announce and let go of in the middle of the year and say, Game of Thrones. We know that they’re all vying for one thing. And so that’s what gels it. So the stakes are in the Iron Throne or the Game of Thrones. But each one of those characters is risking something or has come through something, some turmoil to get to this place in their life. And we’ve been talking, a lot of it had to do with a main character. And you were talking about the stakes of their allies. And Game of Thrones popped in my head when you were talking about that.

[unclear]

And that’s a huge world, Game of Thrones. That’s something that George R. R. Martin has spent a lot of time developing and building. For writers in general or starting out, sit down and play with your words and characters. Don’t aspire to Game of Thrones immediately because it’s taken that man a long time to build that and understand those characters with intricacy.

Devin: The hero doesn’t, isn’t the only character that has, that has stakes. I think it’s important to, well, when you’re sitting down and you’re, you’re developing your characters, your main characters, that you spend time on each one of them and define their stakes. Try charting the stakes of all of your main characters. You may not include those stakes in the actual plot of the story, but what you’ll uncover about each of your characters will become their DNA and, and build the character, uncovering valuable information that will shape how they speak, whether it’s in subtext or through just literal dialogue or how they react to certain situations. And like I said before, you can always pit, you know, you can always pit one character that throughout this, the story has become this favorite or beloved character and you can all of a sudden their stakes come in conflict with the hero’s stakes and it makes for some tension. And like you said at all, stakes enhance or push decision. I think that’s a good way to put it. Stakes is amplify.

Adam: Amplify it. They sort of shine a big spotlight on it for. People. The choice becomes bigger and brighter because you’ve amped the stakes up in the choice. And Game of Thrones is a great example of what you’re talking about, where you love the Starks and you love Daenerys and you love Tyrion. You, you love all these characters and they all come from different sides. And so now you’re like, well, who’s, who do I believe in? Even though they’re all, you know, I identify with so many of them. Right. And I, I feel like we’re moving into an age when that type of storytelling where the stakes are there and you get to see so many.

Yeah. I think. I think we’re moving into a perspective based, a character based story age where it’s not about events and explosions and people want to spend time in long form storytelling with some characters that are interesting to them that are not like them or that would make choices that are vastly different and live vicariously through that character in story. It tends to be quite a bit hyperbolic. Stakes are bigger and more epic. And we were talking about Tarantino a while back. He does that a lot. He, everything’s. Very big. And, and his stakes tend to be a lot of life or death. His is very survival based, very physical material world based stakes. And I, I feel like a lot of stakes are really based in that very materialistic kind of concept of a life or death, money or debt.

Yeah. It’s an easy out for creating an equation for stakes. Right. My issue with the concept of conflict, it being a choice, you’re presented with obstacles and you can be clever about it or you can just choose conflict. In that way, I feel the same way about stakes. I feel like the reason why that is the case, the conflict based mentality is for the same reason that the stakes exist. They’re based almost always in life or death or money or debt, success, failure, but those success failures even are sort of Western civilization ideals of money and power. And I feel like there are more interesting stakes that can be had stuff that’s a little bit more surreal or, or sci-fi or fantasy.

Yeah. You can change the stakes a little bit.

[Sponsor message]

I sort of get bored with life-or-death, money-or-debt stakes that Hollywood has sort of created over the years.

Devin: I think those, a lot of those, well, beyond kind of being lazy and just having to come up with stakes in order to blow stuff up. It is true. Stakes are very similar to what does the character want and then what do they really want? Yeah. Like, with Clark Griswold in Christmas Vac- in National Lampoon’s Christmas Vacation, of course, his, his want is this perfect holiday Christmas with, with his entire family and then, you know, everything falls apart. Everything, he fails so many times in that, in that story, but then in the end, it becomes, you know, what he really wants is just being surrounded by family and like that becomes what his really want is and that defines something for him.

And I think that’s kind of… Yeah. That’s why, that’s how stakes are kind of related with, you know, they’re, they’re very similar to that port, that element of the story.

Adam: What you were talking about, Christmas Vacation with Clark Griswold, it’s less about life-and-death or money-or-debt, it sort of has to do with money, but it’s less about that, he wants that pool for his family, he wants all that stuff, it’s still that Western civilization definition of success.

Devin: What he wants is his Christmas bonus so he can put a pool in, what he really wants and what he finds… What he finds out is he just wants to be surrounded by his family for the holidays, but the stakes are what, what is he going to lose if he doesn’t get that money at first? The stakes like, like want and, and really want will often, will often change or, or the initial stakes can be resolved, but during that quest, all of a sudden new stakes or greater stakes, if you want to escalate them or change them. So there’s… There’s, the way that I look at it is you define the initial stakes, they may or may not be resolved, but you can escalate those stakes at some point, where the stakes at some point even become so high that it appears nearly impossible for the hero to win, or if we’re taking that card game analogy, you could be sitting at a card game, all your money’s in, you, you go all in thinking you’re going to bluff, and someone calls your bluff, and all of a sudden you have a hand that you, that is impossible to win, you got zero. At that stage, all of a sudden, the stakes are raised, escalated a little bit, and you need to figure out how do I increase my bluff, or how do I get this guy to fold without us having to lay our hands down, and him obviously beating me, we may know that he has a pair, and that’s all he has to do. So it’s, you can escalate them, or you can complicate them, and that’s kind of what we were talking about with two different characters having different stakes, and finally at some point there comes a crossroad, or there comes this point in the story where the…

Stakes of each of them are at risk, whether it’s go forward with this hero that we’re following, that storyline, or the other character could decide to disembark and go out on, you know, leave, or kill the hero, because now he wants, it’s, you know, it’s now, it’s all about his stakes, and he’s, the hero’s gotten him as far as he had to do so he could play the hero, so all of a sudden he becomes this shapeshifter. Or the hero just makes bad choices, or choices are have… Unexpected outcomes, or like we were just talking about, you can actually completely change the stakes, where the initial stakes can become resolved, and then during this quest, other relationships are built, and other information is revealed, new or larger stakes, and so, you know, you can be attached to the character in the beginning, and know what those stakes are, but through this transformation of both the quest and the character, some other stakes can be revealed, or the true stakes can be revealed.

In an attempt to kind of correlate, or, or put hand in hand the want and the really want with, with how it’s related to the stakes, I think about different things you can do with stakes throughout a story, obviously you don’t have to do any of that, you can just start off with, these are the stakes of the story, and this is the stakes for the hero, this is what he has to gain, this is what he stands to gain, this is what he stands to lose, and then that’s it, and then…

Adam: And their self-doubt and their confidence and all these aspects of self. We sort of have already predicted the variety of endings that could happen with this character. We forgot about them. We go on the journey and we get to the end and we’re like, oh yeah, of course that’s what they really wanted. And of course that’s, and if you’re a crafty writer, you hide all that. For me, I think stakes get raised naturally for an audience and for the character going on the journey just through time alone. If you’ve in your personal life committed time to anything, a job, a relationship, marriage, a vehicle, a home, anything where you’ve actually spent a particular amount of focus or attention on, it’s more valuable to you.

Now you may devalue it with your focus on it, but it, it still means something. You’ve been there forever. You drive that car forever. You’ve, you’ve loved that person forever or dislike that person forever. The amount of time you spend with something also increases the stakes or meaning of it to a character. And a lot of the want, really want stories are, it was in your backyard before you even started sort of morality junk, where it’s some person who wants to be an executive and their families to the other end of the spectrum. And that’s been going on in movies forever. It’s like, if you want to do a crime or thriller or heist movie, you pick a drug dealer that’s angry because you accidentally got there.

There are so many staples that people have drawn on and just repeated and regurgitated stories, but the stakes sort of become flat because you’re propping it up. It’s an old thing. We’ve already been through those stakes. There are ways of creating new stakes, and a lot of them are. Through character perspectives, it’s nuancing it a little bit more. You were talking about it before. Some of it’s just lazy writing. If you took the time to bust through that cliche and try to think of five other different ways you could approach that cliche, you’ll find one that you go, that’s my own original idea. That’s so exciting.

It’s the first time anybody’s ever done that on screen. If you took the time to bust through that cliche, now you’re original. If you just copy and paste from someone you admire who’s great at what they do, you’re not really finding your own voice. I think stakes are the same way. You’ve got to find details in those stakes.

Devin: That brings up a good point. When you’re defining your stakes, you’re coming up with your stakes.

Avoid the cliche stakes, but also make sure that the stakes matter to your characters. The characters drive the story. So if the stakes don’t matter to them, well, it isn’t much of a story. You’ve just built a house of cards that can collapse with the first inconsequential happening, or breath that’s blown on them. And so if it doesn’t matter to them, it sure as hell is not going to matter to the audience or the reader. And so just remember that the small story is much more important than the big picture or the big story. The stakes must mean something significant to the hero. If it is to mean something significant or relatable to the reader or audience.

For the life of me, I can’t remember the writer. I heard him on another podcast and he said, story is like, going to Target and buying a frame. If the frame is the story, it’s what’s inside it is what really matters. It’s the meat. It is the stakes. And so when you first buy that frame, there’s some generic photo of a family. You have no idea who they are and you don’t care about what happens to them. You really don’t care what happened before. What will you know what’s going on with them now or what you know, it’s not until you take a picture of your family or your dog or your best friends, and you put that in the frame, that all of a sudden that frame is holding something very valuable to you.

That is kind of where this idea of making sure that the stakes of your character really truly matter to them because then it will translate and will relate to the to to your audience or the readers that are also reading it.

Adam: I also like to get a picture frame from Target and just leave the picture that’s in there. In there. And try to fall in love with those people to see if I can feel as much emotion for them as I do my real family or my real dog.

Devin: Or write a story about them. Try to come up with a story about them. It’s a great writing exercise, yeah.

Adam: Stakes come from your characters. This is important to understand. If you are trying to impose stakes on your characters, it’s not going to work as well as going the other way around. Having the stakes evolve from what your characters want and then exploring it from that angle. No matter what, I think anytime approaching writing, especially for the screen, approach through the characters. Because if you’re going to want to grab strong performers to do this script and sell your script, you’ve got to write strong characters. I don’t think it’s just for screen, even though that’s where you would see this performance. Any storytelling. Your audience are a fellow human beings. So if you write human beings or people with traits or characteristics that are relatable, like human beings, whether if it’s fantasy, sci-fi, you’re going to have an audience. But you’ve got to be truthful with yourself and with those people in the writing of it.

I just read something where, Hemingway said, writing is easy. You just sit down at the typewriter and bleed. In this day and age when we need, there’s such a demand for content, there’s some real crap out there. Underproduced or just not really well thought out, lazy writing, bad performance, poorly directed. There’s a lot of crap. But there’s also the ability in that sea of content and entertainment and an art to excel in your storytelling craft. Because the better stories will get recognition, especially ones. And like I’m saying, this is the key. Start with your characters, and discover your stakes. If you find out your character loves, like in Katniss’ case, loves her little sister so much.

And she realizes her little sister would never survive. But she may have a chance. She loves her so much that she’s willing to do that. And so, the stakes and the character literally are one and the same. My point being, rather than the stakes being a part of the plot, [unclear] part of the plot or the conflict. Don’t brew them there. Brew them in the character department. Create your recipe for stakes with the characters. Like you’re saying, if it doesn’t matter to your characters, it doesn’t matter. I’m talking about the character’s character.

Devin: I agree with that wholeheartedly where it, which is also the important part of, you know, your character dossiers or your, when you’re developing your characters before you start writing and you’re trying to figure out who this person is, what they care about and things like that. That’s usually where you can start to see or paint the picture of what the stakes of this character could be. Like what, if, if something was in danger or something, something that they truly cared about was about to be taken away from them or hurt. Then. And all of a sudden your story starts to becoming like Katniss. I think her, her sister’s name is like Primrose or something like that. But say, say the writer, and I’m not saying this is how they did that, but say the writer sits down and figures out who’s Katniss. Katniss loves her sister, family’s everything. She’s kind of the, the main breadwinner. She’s the hunter and gatherer of her family. She does everything. And she’s kind of the protector of her family. And so all of a sudden it comes, if you just started with her, you could say, all right, well, how about they’re in this.

Yeah. She, her sister that she cares about so much gets picked to where she thinks is going to be her certain death. Well, she’s the protector, and so she’s going to, I mean, that’s kind of, obviously, I found this saying, that’s how that story came about. The way you laid it out is very likely the way it could have happened. And you’re right, it does come from characters and not plot. And in fact, I’ll try to figure out where I found this quote or this person’s, I think he was actually talking about stakes too, but he said, Plot is the expression of characters aware of the stakes and who form goals in response to those stakes and who attempt to overcome conflict or obstacles in service of those goals.

And I thought that was a good way to, in one sentence, kind of define, like, this is how these things are different. And these things, this is how they play different parts within the story elements. And we could put that on the website too, and I’ll actually find the person that wrote that and give them due credit for that. But I thought that was a good way to kind of separate those things.

Adam: When you’re writing your first draft, you don’t always have everything ironed out. When you do tone, we were talking about tone and theme and how you should have a little bit of an inkling, but don’t aim for that in the first draft. First draft is a lot about just figuring out who your characters are. Honestly, as many times as I do character dossiers and structure ahead of time, that first draft is still just about figuring it out. Stakes, I find I amplify for my second draft a lot more. I have an idea of them for my first draft, but then I go, oh, you know what? This would be a lot more interesting if this were like this. And I sort of adjust things.

I just recently was doing a consultation where I was suggesting just reordering an event where this person has to do something and then they’re also fired from their job. But if you reverse those events, the fact that they’re fired from their job makes it more complicated and raises the stakes. So you write out a plot and you’re like, oh, wait a minute. If this happens before this, this is way more exciting and way more interesting. So first draft, and this is the best advice I can give about a first draft, just write it. Right. Just write it. Doesn’t matter. It’s not going to be right. I’m going to tell you this right now. If you get a first draft and it’s absolutely correct, you’re a god.

Devin: Really? It happens to me all the time. I just need to find a studio that’s willing to make a 400-page script. Animated script, by the way.

Adam: Yeah, right? You write so much. And then you’re like, I don’t know why they don’t think this whole scene about fart jokes is pivotal to the plot.

Devin: It’s a very important scene. It really sets up. It’s a big setup.

Adam: I mean, I’m sure Eddie Murphy had to pitch that for Nutty Professor.

Devin: Oh, yeah. The dinner scene.

Adam: So first draft, be easy on yourself. Allow yourself to go in without knowing everything. But then when you look back at things, if you have a rough idea, refine it, focus it, hone it for your second draft. Stakes and certain things, it’s okay you don’t get them right the first time. I don’t get them right the first time. It’s about refinement and discovery and also audience experience. Right.

Right.

Devin: Right. Whenever we’re talking about certain elements like stakes and plot and conflict that we’re not like, all right, you got to make sure you know exactly what the stakes are going to be. You know exactly what the goal and the plot is. You know exactly what the conflict is before you even start. Start writing. And that’s just not the case because then all of a sudden you’re trying to force a story into these parameters that you set for yourself. And you’ll kill your creativity. Yeah. And you just allow, if you just allow it to organically appear, like the example with the whole Katniss thing, well, it may have been a completely different story for the first draft and then understanding the characters and spending a little time with them throughout the first crack at the quest and for the first story, then you’ve kind of start figuring out who they are and be like, well, you know what? This would actually be way, way more intense and the stakes would be way better if it was her sister gets… Instead of herself. Instead of herself at the very beginning.

Adam: Yeah. Amplifying the stakes for that second pass. Whoa, what if it was her sister? And then even though that’s a small change in that moment in the beginning, it’s just an act. You’ll go back to act one over and over and over because if you tighten up act one, it will make your story sing. It’s a tidy little cleanup in act one where it’s like, well, what if her sister gets chosen first? If her sister is chosen first, then she’s sacrificing instead of just Katniss getting chosen first. So, I mean, we’re speculating, but just look at that simple one pass review, second pass concept, even if we’re just speculating. The level and depth of that character’s commitment and confidence, that is a perfect definition, Devin’s speculative version there of raising the stakes. Let’s say it was Katniss.

Katniss chosen. Draft two, it’s her sister chosen. That writer has chosen a place to increase the stakes tremendously. And it’s just little decisions from points of view of wanting what the character wants or what’s valuable to them.

Devin: And yeah, not only increasing the stakes, but all of a sudden you have strengthened the character of Katniss of this is the type of person she is. It’s the whole, if you want to go to the whole save the cat terminology or his theory on the hero always saves a cat, Blake Snyder. Yeah. His save the cat theory. It’s like, yeah, it’s, she’s saving the cat. She is, now you want to get behind her. You want her. You want her to be successful. You don’t want her to die. You don’t. So this, that’s a fantastic example of accomplishing a lot of one action in one scene and all of a sudden it escalates the stakes.

The choice. Yeah, it makes, yeah, that choice. It amplifies that choice. It escalates the stakes and now you’ve reaffirmed or confirmed the type of character Katniss is. Brilliant.

Adam: When you examine a character and what raising the stakes means, it’s all about what is valuable to them and what they want. They’re not always the same thing. Understanding odds, what this character is up against and numbers in out of their depths quality. You were talking before about how the stakes can change in a story and maybe you get into the story and these are the stakes that are established and then the story takes a turn and the stakes completely become different. They become a different set of stakes. And this would be dependent, I think, on the super objective of a story. If the mission, if the adventure, if the quest changes to a different goal, sometimes the stakes will change for that reason.

Other times it’s, and this is more of an increased or raising the stakes, like Lethal Weapon where the daughter of Danny Glover’s character gets taken. What’s his name? Murtaugh. You may find that the turning of the stakes happens because of that. It’s now no longer good guy, bad guy, cop. Robber, cop, bad guy. Now there’s another thing that gets added in as a progressive complication to those stakes. And then there are movies like this, and they’re few and far between, but I’m going to cite The Wild Geese. It’s an old war movie where they go on a mission and at the midpoint of the mission, what they’re supposed to achieve, they achieve.

And then an enormous curveball gets thrown their way. Something we, the audience, and they did not expect. This absolute amazing surprise reveal. And so they have to spend the second half of a movie pursuing a second goal, which is different stakes, completely different stakes. And it was, it’s, I found it fascinating because it’s, that takes some guts to change your goal of your movie and your stakes right at the midpoint. Stakes can change.

Devin: I actually, I was trying to, when I was thinking about that, I was actually thinking, and I’m, I’m always trying to come up with examples that aren’t all the same genre, but, and, but then I ended up always coming back to like a Disney movie. I think Lion King is something like that too, where, you know, Simba, his stakes in the beginning, when his father’s killed by Uncle Scar, his stakes are, I just need to escape because I’m supposed to be, supposed to be dead too. You know, the stakes are raised where if, if he doesn’t escape, he’s dead. It’s an interesting scenario because that stake is, changes halfway through, but the overall, the biggest stakes are if he dies.

Yeah. Stampede scene, the wildebeest stampede, then Scar takes over, they deplete the land and then everybody dies or all the animals die. And then he’s able to escape. So those stakes are resolved. He escapes. But then it isn’t until Nala, who ends up becoming like this midpoint herald, explains to Simba that Scar is destroying, depleting the land and everybody’s going to, I mean, it’s going to be the end. End of the pride, end of all the animals that depend on the land. If he doesn’t come back and lead, be the leader he has to be, or he’s supposed to be. So then the stakes aren’t necessarily changed or raised. They’re just presented to Simba in that way. And so it’s interesting the way that that happens because he.

She sort of reminds him. Yeah. And his stakes, because he’s fine hanging out with Pumbaa and.

Adam: He’s become the complacent hero in that scenario. Yeah. It’s, what you just. Played out, dude, was awesome. She, it’s a great example of a midpoint herald too. And I hadn’t even thought of it, but it’s a beautiful example. And not just that, she’s the love interest. She’s a shapeshifter in it. Right. Well, so is Scar, but in a shadow way. But yeah, great example.

Devin: Where the stakes are never changed, but the hero really isn’t fully aware of the stakes until further in. Yeah. And then dude mans up and he takes out Scar.

Adam: Dude mans up. Fawlty Towers. Do you know that British, old British sitcom? It’s John Cleese. And he always had, he ran the hotel Fawlty Towers. Saying this about stakes and the use of characters and even a character trope or sub-archetype. Whenever Basil Fawlty, John Cleese’s character, owns a hotel and whenever, there’s always something that goes wrong. Always. That’s the sitcom element of it. Guests come in and this guest needs this and he has to do. So in the first act of Fawlty Towers. Fawlty Towers. Always. John Cleese will encounter this problem, need to hide it from somebody or fix it in a way so this person doesn’t know. And he turns to his confidant in the hotel, which is Polly. And he turns to her and he goes, Polly, here’s the situation. And he tells her everything that’s wrong. And then he tells her the plan.

So he literally, it’s brilliant, dude. I mean, some of the best writing ever in the world because she’s his go-to to help, she’s the fixer or the confidant. And so he tells you the plot in the first five minutes to Polly. She’s the audience, yeah. I got chills as a writer going, it’s so brilliant. It’s so, that character setup where it’s like, okay, I can’t tell anybody else except for you and the audience. But the way he states the stakes, and of course, we know, because it’s a sitcom, and it’s the wonderful John Cleese, all of that plan is going to go wrong. Right. But you need all those setups in order for the payoffs to go wrong.

He’s telling you, okay, here’s exactly what we’re going to do. And it’s going to work out great. And you’re like, oh, no. No, it’s not. But the stating of the stakes from this character to that character trope or archetype, the confidant, is one of the best examples of stating stakes blatantly and then watching how they increase and unfold. I think it’s a good sort of example of what to do with your first act anyway. When you’re setting up anything, your start, your foundation, your quote, beginning of your story, make sure you do that. Let people know what they’re watching. That’s a really blatant and obvious way of doing it. But that’s also why I appreciate it. If it’s done that artfully and it’s that obvious, it’s amazing.

In closing, I think, I hope these episodes inspire you to just hop off and start writing. Write a scene out. Throw some structure down. Notes about a character. I would encourage you in terms of stakes to think of it this way. A lot of the stakes that you see in stories that you watch or read, a lot of them have to do with the survival-based stakes. Life or death, money, debt, success, failure. And a lot of it’s a very Western mentality because that’s what you’ve been watching. I would encourage each of you to sort of look at stories and try to think of them in more of a thrival basis than a survival basis in determining your stakes. Not what this character has to struggle through to get to this thing.

But maybe a goal or an aspiration that character has, and that’s what they want to achieve. So there’s a slight difference between what a character wants and then the struggle that they’re having. And I feel like there are plenty of stories that are survival-based. I’d like to see some more stories that are thrival-based in their stakes. Devin, did you have any closing thoughts?

Devin: Ditto.

Adam: Please subscribe and rate us on iTunes. And for additional story-related resources, video, and archived content, visit our website at StoryOsophy.com.