Show notes
Last episode covered where a character starts and ends. This one covers everything in between. Recording from freezing rooms with the heat turned off, Adam and Devin map the character arc: the internal journey that runs alongside the plot, measured in thresholds where the character starts to think differently.
In this episode
- Not really an arc. A rainbow shape is too simple. A real character journey is a roller coaster of reversals, or as Devin puts it, “the process of change.”
- Internal and external. The arc is the internal journey, and it can’t happen without the external one: leaving the comfort zone and facing the unknown world.
- Thresholds as milestones. At each threshold, the character tries on a new way of thinking. If nothing has changed in a while, the story drags.
- Three adjectives. Adam describes a character in three words, then writes their opposites. There’s your arc.
- The point of no return. Walter White watching Jane die in Breaking Bad is where many viewers stop rooting for him.
- One sentence that does it all. A line from a novel, “she was a breath away from saying something, but decided to swallow it,” shows who a character is and where she is on her arc.
- Writing silence. Adam writes “silence” into his scripts and trusts actors to play the moment. Novels can show a character’s thoughts, but film relies on performance and the camera.
- Speaking your truth. Andy and Red both change in The Shawshank Redemption. Red finally speaks his truth to the parole board, and he’s set free.
- Past meets present. For Adam, the best arcs come when a character’s backstory meets the present story and is finally reconciled, as when Darth Vader turns back to his son.
Examples discussed
- Breaking Bad, It’s a Wonderful Life, The Shawshank Redemption, Star Wars, Erin Brockovich, Forrest Gump, I Love Dick and Ace Ventura.
- Also: Sherlock Holmes and Dr. Watson, and a lesson from the Royal Shakespeare Company.
Next episode: dialogue and subtext.
Read the full transcript
Transcribed automatically, so expect the odd misheard word. Sponsor messages are left out.
Adam: Next on StoryOsophy. Hello, welcome to StoryOsophy. This is Adam Jones.
Devin: And Devin Halden. Dude, I cranked the heat up so high, I’m sweating. Just so I’d survive.
Adam: I have the podcast. Oh, and I’m like freezing during the summer when we’re recording. I’ll usually turn, I’ll usually kill the AC. So I don’t have the AC in the background. And then of course I have my recording booth. And there’s been a couple of times when I’m literally taking my shirt off. Like by the time I leave the booth, I’m just in my boxers. I’m just dripping. Oh my God, I gotta turn the air back on.
Devin: I was doing the same thing. I’m like recording in like shorts or boxers. It’s like-
Adam: I picture, what is it in Ace Ventura? When he gets stuck in the rhino?
Devin: That’s what I felt like. Dude, that’s totally what it was like.
Adam: This is sort of different. It’s like, I hope that we finish recording before it gets too cold. Listeners, if this podcast just goes blank at the end, it means we’ve died. Yeah. Last episode, we talked about transformation and catharsis, which is the end result of what we’ll be discussing this episode. Character arc. The journey of the character. In particular, the inner journey throughout the course of the story. Character arc is sort of a broad term. And transformation is basically the same thing. But last episode, we actually addressed the sort of like beginning and end result.
And this episode, we are focusing on the in-between. The gradual progression, that arc which leads from beginning to end of that, the ending of which is transformation.
Devin: It’s actually more of a checkmark.
Adam: Character arc?
Devin: Yeah, because an arc actually doesn’t show a depths of despair portion of a character. So if you go, if you start at the first part of the checkmark, and then you have your darkest moment. For a character, and then they shoot up and then hopefully become better. Than where they started, that’s a check mark.
Adam: I mean, that’s one arc. You can do different arcs. I know, some, yeah. And they could actually turn that around. The term arc itself, I don’t like. Mm-hmm, I agree. Because the visual of it is, I don’t like it. It is this rainbow shape. Right. And for me, I enjoy stories that are sort of, got a lot of reversals. So it’s up and down, and twists and turns. Right, yeah. It’s sort of a broad term. But for the purposes of how we’ll be talking about it, it’s traditionally called a character arc. I would call it a character road, or a character journey, or something that doesn’t let you visualize a specific way of navigating it.
Because each story’s different. You might have this, Mm-hmm. This sort of like, Mm-hmm. Lie detector test result, up and down, jagged thing that’s a roller coaster. Or a roller coaster, rather, where it’s got smooth curves. But, and what you were talking about earlier is mapping out a character’s journey. You sort of have this bird’s eye view road map. And when you look at it, by the end, there’s twists and turns all over the place.
Devin: Mm-hmm.
Adam: And so just as your plot will have these twists and turns, and reveals, and discoveries, and setups, and payoffs, so does your character. Your character starts one place, ends up transformed by the end of the story. And the arc would be the journey in between, from here to there. That mappable milestones, what you and I call thresholds. The thresholds are sort of your measurement of plot and character, and where they sync up, at least for me.
Devin: It’s the character transformation. And it could be they come out a better person at the end, or they don’t, Mr. Michael Corleone.
Adam: Per last episode. If you haven’t listened to the last episode, it’s good to listen to that one first, if you’re newly joining us, because that leads into what we’re talking about here. We’re sort of expanding on the idea of an end transformation or cathartic experience, and we’re talking about the mappable journey in between, start to finish. The middle of a character transformation. The process of change. That’s a great way to put it.
Devin: Is the middle part, yeah. Thank you.
Adam: Yeah, the process of change. You know what? That’s even better. I call it progressive complications, but that’s an even better way of putting it, because that also doesn’t limit it to the way you can imagine their story. And that’s, I think, why I object to the word arc, is because it really limits your visual of how the story should look. But it serves its purpose. I mean, it’s a label, like we talk about throughout the rest of the podcast. Labels are not our thing, but.
Devin: Yeah.
Adam: And the character arc is the label of what everyone refers to it as, so.
Devin: The character arc is the. Internal transformation or process of change. And I think it coincides with the external journey, because without the external journey that begins with the decision to embark on the call to quest or call to adventure, that change can’t happen in a story. So the characters, or your characters, our characters, must be removed from that comfort zone of the known world and thrust into the journeys and trials and obstacles. And conflict of the unknown world to begin that arc of change, if you will, and ultimately be transformed into someone that’s different than when they started the journey. Whether they’re a better person or worse person is up to you and how you’re telling your story.
But I think that’s, I think the kind of koan, you can’t have one without the other.
Adam: What’s the difference between character arc and plot is a really kind of interesting question to talk about. But I think you just addressed primarily what that is. If you think of it external versus internal. But I’d say some external things happen with character, but for the most part, you are talking about that internal experience of a person. And if that’s the case, when you’re sort of viewing the mappable journey of that person or any of the people within a story, but we’re primarily talking about like a singular character conceptually. When you’re mapping that journey out, the transformation, like we were saying in the last episode, is a transformation of belief system.
Or consciousness, belief about themself, about the world around them. Generally, that’s what the change or growth has to do with that. It’s an evolved state of self. And so the arc, not necessarily the beginning point and the end point, like we were talking about Breaking Bad, mild mannered school teacher, chemist to meth kingpin. It’s dynamic. That’s the end point, book ending here and here. But the character arc is what happens in between.
Devin: It’s the journey from what the character wants in the beginning to the realization. What they really want at the end of the story.
Adam: What I’m addressing with this is the sort of the change in consciousness, the change in their and how they think or who they are. Each threshold that they cross, each milestone that they’re going to meet along this journey is an introduction to a new idea or new thought based on previous experience. So milestone to milestone, they’re experiencing things and then they usually reach a threshold where they cross this thing and think differently. Or do something. Or do something differently than previously they had thought. It’s like trying on a new piece of clothing you’d never tried on before. It’s brand new. It’s fresh. And so they’re a new individual slightly and subtly at each threshold.
To me, that’s a juicy story. I love watching that. But it’s ultimately going to build to that end character result that who they become and are transformed into by the end of the story. That’s where it’s ultimately going. But they are a changed individual at each little threshold. And we’ll talk about that. And structure and plot more. But for me, that’s movements. I have measurements of it. But it’s just the same as an act one, act two, act three. At each stage, you want to see that. And then Devin and I will break those up into smaller increments to be able to track that character’s arc or their milestones or thresholds as we are either constructing or writing or organically while we’re watching something.
You sort of know when the story is dragging. Nothing’s changed. Nothing’s happened. This character’s belief system hasn’t been challenged in this. Or the way they… Function here has not been, it’s not a new experience, it just feels static.
Devin: That highlights the importance of character development before, I’m getting better at liking it, but the development process of it, but doing character profiles and character dossiers and actually trying to spend time understanding what, who, whoever main character is, and so you know how they will react in different situations and at different points during their arc. The development process, though it can be a bit laborsome and it can, you feel like you’re not doing anything and you really want to start writing, it actually is, the more great characters you develop and you understand who they are before you start writing, it helps a ton. But, and again, characters are going to continue to develop while you’re writing a story too, but kind of knowing who your characters are before you start writing and the amount of detail you decide to build within that process.
Profile’s up to you, but it helps to truly understand your character, so when you’re writing, you know exactly how they’re going to react at different times and in different situations throughout the story.
Adam: Well, when I start out, like, sort of developing characters and then implement, like, them into plot and all that, I generally just write down impressions, like, even if it’s single word adjectives that I can lay down and go, okay, this person is this, this, and this, because then I do this, because nobody’s a certain thing all the time. That’s just not the way it works. Everybody’s in flux. And so, if I write down these three adjectives or more, you know, just a simple example of three adjectives, I just write the converse of that. I write what the opposite is of that thing and go, well, there’s an arc, period.
And so, if I can identify a character with very simple dynamic traits of three adjectives at least, that’s a start of, quote, developing a character, right? It’s very simple. And then on the other end of the spectrum, you can quickly just go, now, what is the contrasting thing? What’s the thing of this? What’s the day to that night? You know, what’s the black to that white? What’s the opposite end of that spectrum? And then go, now, do I want to start them here or end them here? How do I move them through this? Or do they even reach that complete opposite end of spectrum? Because sometimes it’s sort of like you start a character at a certain place, they move to the complete opposite space, and then they move back to a general space.
It’s like starting at status quo and returning to status quo or ordinary world and returning to ordinary world.
Devin: Mm-hmm.
Adam: Mm-hmm. Through something that changes the viewpoint. There’s a realization, something that is a tested belief or idea within the mind that gets realized for them by the end of the story, brought into their reality and made more concrete. So that’s the inner world of a character. They’re working through new thoughts, new ideas, a new evolved version of themselves internally. And the best way for us to sort of witness it is via the plot, external events that show us when this character is presented.
And not just what do they do in general, what do they do here? What do they do now?
Devin: Mm-hmm.
Adam: Because as one of the examples we’re going to talk about later, at least I am, Breaking Bad, when you look at Walter White in episode one, he is not the same guy that in episode, spoiler alert, lets Jesse’s girlfriend die by choking to death. Spoiler alert. Lets her die. Well, it’s a big. It’s a big moment. That’s one of those I don’t want to remember. Because he watches her dying and he can help. And because he’s gone to a place, and especially in manipulation of Jesse, he just allows that event to happen. And you go, that’s not the same guy as when we first met him, or as when his story devolved into the cancer and all that. And so, the point is, they’re very dynamic milestones. And then in between, there are these subtle moments of character, these secrets and things that they’re stirring around. And then you go, oh, it’s not him going from mild-mannered science teacher to meth kingpin there. That threshold or that moment, that beat, there’s something where he’s just a monster. And I hate to use that word, because this is the brilliance of Bryan Cranston’s performances. You can see the humanity in every nasty thing he does. There’s tenderness and fear and confusion behind his eyes.
And then there’s anger. And there’s so much stuff he brings to it, it’s different. But you can see the difference between mild-mannered science teacher and, in the end, meth kingpin in the middle. There’s this, and I think in a lot of writing and people discourse about this, that’s one of those moments where people say, this is where Walter White crosses the threshold. And doesn’t come back. This is where we watch him now from a distance, and we’re not his friend as much anymore, because most of your viewers detach from… This is where he’s broken too bad for them.
Devin: Mm-hmm. That’s a good example. That’s a really good example.
Adam: I know I jumped into an example early, but it was sort of, I think, appropriate.
Devin: Very appropriate, Adam. That was a good time to put it in there.
Adam: Thanks, Devin.
Devin: You’re welcome. Brilliantly timed. There couldn’t have been a more proper opportunity.
I think television series or novels allow for a stronger or more or a deeper character arc to be developed because you have more time to spend with them.
Devin: It reminded me of something and I was going to and I still will talk a little bit more about this when we talk about subtext or even like if we could talk more about writing processes in a way. But what you’re just saying about novels where it’s like, but it goes with screenplays too, but you should always be thinking about reinforcing where your character is on their arc throughout the story. So this is just a quick example. Okay, so I was having lunch with a writer friend the other day, and she told me about an author that she just recently discovered that blew her away with how creatively descriptive she was, even outside of the quotation marks.
And so she shared one bit of writing in particular. And it was just one quote. One sentence that instantly gave me a snapshot of who this character is, at what point they were in their arc, and then possible vision of who she will become when she completes her arc of the story. My interpretation of this one sentence may be a little bit off, but it is brilliant writing. So the line read, and I’m not completely butchering this, but it may not be verbatim what’s actually in the book, but it was something along the lines of she was a breath away from saying, something, but decided to swallow it and send it to live with the rest of the things that go unsaid.
And I was like, holy crap, that’s beautiful writing. But more importantly, the writer decided that instead of just saying something like she was going to say something, but instead decided not to, or something along those lines, they nailed the opportunity to reinforce this character’s place on their arc. So without ever reading the book, I can picture this like shy, timid woman who struggles. She struggles with self-worth or confidence, and she’s obviously been here before. This isn’t the first time she wanted to say something, but held it in. So perhaps she’s in an abusive or controlling relationship, whether that’s professional or personal. But I also surmise that we are nearing maybe the midpoint of the story, because we can tell that this isn’t, you know, she was even closer than maybe before of saying something.
So I’m thinking maybe they’re at the midpoint of the story. It could perhaps be just entered. The unknown world, and she’s yet to experience some of the trials and obstacles that still lay ahead of her, that will start to build that confidence and self-worth to the point of her transformation, which it appears that she’s nearing. And then at some point, when all of a sudden that something or all of those some things that she’s been suppressing will just come rise from the ashes kind of a thing, where they’ll just be released. When I was thinking about this, like that’s an example from a novel where, like you’re saying, there’s a world.
So creatively, you can get a little bit more in depth with the character arc and even descriptions and things like that. But even say the scene or this moment in a scene, which is perhaps a better way of putting this segment, is played out on screen. The screenwriter may write that verbatim in the screenplay, but this would be one of those instances that the director would want to interpret the writer perfectly on screen in like a show don’t tell way. And I think like Fincher or Hitchcock would nail this because like every element of the story would be important. Like the score and the camera angle, the lighting, of course, the actor, and so instead of reading, like she was, instead of the actor on screen reading, of course, she wouldn’t, she was a breath away from saying something, decided to swallow it and send it to live with the rest of the things that go unsaid, the character on screen would like they would show the inner conflict in their facial expression, maybe like a bead of sweat, the director could use like a dolly zoom and the editor, like maybe mute the sound around her and we’d focus on her breathing or, and she may even hear her breathing.
Right. Maybe at this stage of the story, like the audience is cheering for her to say that, say that something, but the writer is reinforcing that character stage during this arc that swallow the writer or the director, you know, the people are making the story are saying, Nope, not yet. She’s not ready yet. Like, so she still is going to go through something like it’s in, you know, it’s in, it’s something so simple, just one sentence in a novel or one bit of action in a screenplay, but holy crap. Does it achieve a lot in terms of, like, reinforcing a character’s, not only their traits, but where they’re at during their arc on this journey?
And so, again, I talk about it a little bit more, and I wanted to talk a little bit more about during, because there’s some subtext to that, too, but it kind of jumped out at me when you said, when you were talking about Breaking Bad.
Adam: I just want to comment on that, that the brilliance of the example you just gave with the swallow in a novel. Here’s the luxury of a novel. Well, here’s the lack of luxury for a screenplay or a teleplay. It’s timed, folks. Every page is a minute. Mm-hmm. That’s the rule of thumb when writing a screenplay. So, however long the piece is going to be, if it’s a show that’s 22 minutes, 45 minutes in traditional television, or somewhere around there for online media, you know that it’s a page per minute. That’s the rhythm of it all. In a novel, it’s sort of like going, la-di-da, let me talk about the clouds as well. And so, you can do whatever you want in a novel. But when it comes to a novel, you also can do this. You can write the phrase, they think, dot, dot, dot, whatever you want. You can tell the audience what’s inside their mind. In a film, the only way you’re really doing that is narration.
Devin: Mm-hmm.
Adam: Narration’s different than narrative. Narrative is the story, and the narration is the commentary on said story. Like a voiceover. Yeah. If they’re saying the same thing that you’re watching, there’s no reason for narration. Forrest Gump philosophizes on a deeper level in his narration than he experiences in the events of his life we witness. He’s got deeper things to say from that park bench, that narration state. So, within a film, you can’t. You can write in a script what Devin suggested.
The moment that this writer has created, which is written well, the use of words, the wordsmithing of it is. It’s exciting to read or creatively inspiring so that a performer reads that and gets an emotional response to it from the poetry of the words. And screenplays aren’t – you don’t put the flowery language in. You put a mix between that and stage direction of a play. Right. Where here’s what needs to happen and here’s the feeling visual landscape for all the other departments artistically and performers to add on to. So, you can’t – you’re relying on an actor mainly. To show that silence, if you will.
But, as Devin just pointed out, as genius as he is, if you give that a gulp, if you give that moment an auditory swallowing of the words, it’s a great way to translate that moment internally, externally for a film. So that you show, don’t tell. You were talking about camera moves, things like that. These are ways within filmed media to mine those moments of silence. Right. Just putting a camera on someone and watching their behavior over time is worth its weight in gold as long as the narrative of the story is clear. Good one. Steven Soderbergh doing Erin Brockovich with Julia Roberts. He set up the story and then he just had shots with her just sitting there thinking or working on something.
And you, the audience, you’re doing all of the character arc work for her. You’re thinking, oh, she’s going to do this next. It’s what happens with Breaking Bad too and Walter White’s head. Right. The difference between a novel where you can actually blatantly say it and filmed media where you were sort of sharing a mindset or a telepathic relationship with whomever’s on screen when they’re not speaking, you can only guess or try to read their mind.
Devin: In a novel, you can, everybody who purchases that book and reads it, it’s their interpretation. And a screenplay, we’re kind of relying, anybody who watches a movie is relying on the interpretation of the people that made the movie. Yeah. And we’ve talked about it several times where there’s like the pros and cons of novel writing and then pros and cons of screenplay writing. But it’s all about the economics of the page too.
Adam: Yeah.
Devin: You want to use every bit of, whether it’s a novel or a screenplay, the economy of the page is much more important for many different reasons. But even with novel writing, it was like, oh, she could have just said, like I said, where she decided to say something we did not do. And then the reader would have just blown over that and went on with the story. But taking that time to use one sentence to literally like, I am reimagining. I am reinforcing where she is at in the story and who she is. And she has not, she hasn’t transformed yet. If she would have said something and this was the time that the author decided this is when she’s transforming from not having confidence or her self-worth is overpowering her to now she’s ready to say something.
Then you would know, then the reader would be like, okay, well, she’s moved. Like, she’s moved from here to here in that arc.
Adam: You clearly show a person in a certain state here to show them here, here, here, here, the subtle milestones, but definitely by the end having some clear space, but it’s marking it for the audience and for yourself. Don’t try to be too subtle, but don’t beat your audience over the head and treat them like they’re idiots. Yeah. Everybody’s seen a million stories. They know the format. They know the rules. Most people know what we’re talking about in this first season organically. It’s just, they don’t, they can’t maybe necessarily articulate it. And so don’t treat them stupid because they’re not. No, no. They may, they have a lot of intuition, a lot. They may not have the know-how or the craft of storytelling behind those intuitions, but they know it. They feel it. They’ve seen stories and been told stories since they were a kid. And so don’t treat them stupid. Challenge them a little bit.
Treat them as if they know. Treat them as if they know something, but make sure you mark those spots.
Devin: Mm-hmm.
Adam: If you mark it, they’ll go, got it. That’s what we’re doing. Got it. And they’ll go along with you in whatever story you’re doing, but you, it’s like telling someone to go from this destination to that destination and not giving them a map or a GPS and going, good luck.
Devin: Mm-hmm.
Adam: You need to give them some milestones or some map to travel along so they can enjoy the journey, not be confused by the journey, because that’s not really the point, but enjoy it. Mm-hmm. And also, I think that what you were saying, that statement in and of itself, just as a statement, is something that everybody can identify with, wanting to say something and not.
Devin: And almost getting fed up at yourself or getting frustrated with yourself that you just never, you don’t say something. And knowing that you’re going to feel that same regret that you didn’t say something when you leave that room. Yousef, you know my friend Yousef?
Adam: Mm-hmm. He was telling me a bit about, at the Royal Shakespeare Company when they were talking about things, and one of the directions that he had gotten, because when he started, working there, he was getting smaller parts, background parts, parts with a handful of lines, but they’re some of Shakespeare’s peripheral plays. And then he’s gotten better and better parts as it’s gone along. But one of the times the director asked him, and of course, I’m going to paraphrase this story, so the gist of it will come out. So he said, he was in the background, and I guess the director felt like he wasn’t doing enough or something. He says, Yousef, what are you doing right now? And he goes, I’m waiting for this person to do this thing. He goes, no, you’re not. He goes, you’re not.
You’re listening. And you have many, many, many, many things you want to say right now, but you’re not saying them. And why is your action? And I was like, oh, it’s so juicy. Do you know what I mean? Yeah. Yeah. Because you’re not, it’s not a person being silent or waiting for their next cue. That’s sort of like, in writing land, that’s sort of like not treating your supporting characters with any respect at all.
Devin: Right, right.
Adam: If you go back and look at a scene and go, well, that person hasn’t said anything in a while. And you say, Why? Not that they have to speak. Yeah. But if they’re not speaking, why? And then you go, well, they think this and this. Holy, like this, they should be part of this conversation. Why are they being silent? So you either choose to make them silent and create the reasons why, or you realize in questioning that, that they really have something to contribute to this scene, to this dialogue that’s not being said. And you need to write new perspectives coming from them. Because that person all of a sudden gives voice in a scene. Their arc improves because there’s marking points then. But you also have given more juice to the scene itself. These other characters who might be in discourse for it now have to comment on what this person’s perspective is.
Maybe it’s the sidekick who has a really great idea for a plan, you know, and they’ve been ignoring them and ignoring them and they’ve just been listening and all of a sudden they go, but what if we do this? And all of a sudden the scene pivots on the idiot’s suggestion. Because it’s the best plan. There’s so many things you can do with that. So why are they being silent, right? That’s a big thing. And in terms of just as far as a technical note for myself when I’m writing, I mentioned this to a writer friend of mine because they were going, you know, I have trouble with screenplays when they’re doing something or saying something and you don’t want to write the dialogue.
You really want to play it out. You want to trust your actors to do this, to figure out the moments. Because a really good actor is going to build that character. They’re going to take your written cues of what that character’s about and build it and connect all the dots. That’s what their job is. So, a lot of times, I trust actors because I come from a performing background a lot. I write silence. That’s all I write. Silence, period. One line, plenty of space, so that whoever’s acting in it, if they’re a smart actor, if they’ve got a good craft, they’ll realize that that silence is meant to be played.
Even though it says silence, you play the moment. Outside of that, if I feel like it needs more detail, this is screenplay, mind you. I’ll do this. So-and-so gives so-and-so a look, double dash or dash, and then write, are you crazy? Question mark, exclamation point, all in italics. That’s what they’re thinking. Every once in a while, I give a dialogue or line reading to the brain of the character that way. So that the audience sees that they give them a look or that sort of thing. And the look is, because then that gives the performer in filmed media a chance to play overtly with their face or facial expressions and stuff. That which the novel gets to say in its language. Here’s what they’re thinking. It’s sort of a way of me giving.
Sort of doing dialogue via thought in a screenplay. But that’s the only way it translates for me in terms of that inner space of the novel versus the filmed aspect of television or cinema or film. That’s the only way I’ve learned to translate it properly is like give the actors breathing room or give them. Something to say with their expression in some way.
[Sponsor message]
Devin: When you can, in a novel, you can use a bunch of different writing mechanisms to translate the tension of the scene and things like that. And from a screenplay, I mean, without saying, you know, there’s obviously the same, you can use some of the similar descriptive words. But translating tension in a screenplay the way that you want it to be translated by the person who’s going to make the movie is difficult, if it’s not going to be you. I mean, if you’re writing a screenplay and you know exactly how you’re going to execute that scene, what direction you’re going to give to the actor and like, you know, using different filmmaking techniques, whether it’s through editing or actually in camera, where camera positioning, stuff like that.
I think the amount of tension that you want to translate. I think the amount of tension that you want to translate into a scene is an art form in screenplay, in screenwriting. And you’re good at it.
Adam: Well, I appreciate that. You are. What’s really difficult is this. And we’ve experienced this a good bit, too, is you meet a lot of directors who go, oh, you’ll see it on screen.
Devin: I know.
Adam: And that’s fine because you can’t visually show what’s in their mind. That’s what the storyboards are for, technically. And presentational artwork, sample artwork, it may not be the finished result, but this is what it sort of looks like. That’s what that’s for. And at the same time, you need to have… You need to have on page what it feels like. There are also differences between what people call a reading script and a shooting script. And a reading script is meant to grab everyone’s attention, much like a novel. And a shooting script is meant to implement a lot of the visual aspects or specific shots that are required to capture that mood, tension, et cetera, et cetera.
The moments where a character transitions or crosses a threshold, these mapable points of a character arc, they need to be obvious within those stories, no matter whether you’re doing a screenplay and it’s terse language or whether you’re doing a novel and you can expand more. Think of this, the end of a scene, the end of a chapter. Those are your thresholds. Start thinking that way. Because if you look at a broad structure, it’s beginning, middle, end. That’s a story. Each scene, each chapter, each what I call movements within the way I write or act within a story or anything like that has a beginning, middle, end.
And so within that structure of beginning, middle, end, the character has become a new version of self, and you just repeat, repeat said process. Repeat said process. New platform of who they are and how they’re thinking from this threshold. Now they start with the beginning again. You think of it as a beginning. It’s the same thing with how you would imagine each of us in our ordinary day individual lives. Each morning is a beginning, middle, end. Each morning you have a fresh start and you either pick back up on your old vibe or you take the day anew and go, there’s a rhythm to it all.
And so the same thing with storytelling. It’s just if a screenplay is or a teleplay is 22 minutes, 45 minutes or pages, 90 pages, and a novel is 200, 300, you know what I mean? However many pages it is. You have to measure out the growth of that character across whatever span that is so that it is satisfactory to the audience. If the character does not grow, if the character is at point A in the beginning of the story and at the transformation point at the end, or it’s not just like they transform at the end. And that’s the story. Although I feel like most fair that I watched, they’ve written it in that way. Well, they start here and they beat their head against the wall until the last page. To me, I find that completely annoying and I hate watching stories like that. I love watching reversals and developments every 10, 15 pages. Don’t drag out some stupid thing till the end and then all of a sudden it’s resolved. Show me that the attempts at resolution, the ups and downs, as we were saying earlier, the idea of, arc, maybe not the best visual. Rollercoaster, spikes, sine waves where it is up and down and up and down rhythmically. But an arc doesn’t really describe that process because each story, one may be more erratic than another story-wise, and the other one may be more paced and internal and easy.
But creating that across the span, you have to look at is the development. And that’s really the key word, I think, when we’re talking about character arc. The development of a character over time is really about this. Observing their perspective and behavior across time. Or in the case of a writer, across pages. As a viewer or a reader, it’s still across pages, but as a viewer, it’s across time. In terms of arcing, I think it’s a little different, but finding those thresholds, act one, act two, act three, ends of scenes, ends of chapters, they’re an ending and a new rebirth and springboard for that character’s next stage of development before they get to the final, the end of the story.
So for me, it’s mappable. That’s the key to a good character arc, is mapping their development.
Devin: I would agree with that. Process of change. Transformation.
Adam: So you want to hit some examples?
Devin: Yeah, let’s do some examples.
Adam: I threw one out earlier, Breaking Bad. We’ll talk about that in a minute, but Devin, have at it.
Devin: I’d like to go back to It’s a Wonderful Life a little bit, just because it’s a classic. You love this story. I do. And I think it’s because when you study the story, really has a ton of story elements that we talk about. They’re kind of like Disney movies with theme. This movie has very, not obvious is probably not the right word, but like George Bailey’s character arc, you can see it. And in fact, it’s told in an interesting way through this story because we actually are introduced to George Bailey at his all is lost moment, like his darkest hour and ready to commit suicide on Christmas Eve. And then we’re taken back to the known world and allowed to see him, see George in his everyday life and what he’s doing.
And, and who he is in his known world. And then follow him as he gets to this point of where we actually met him. And it’s during this time that we’re able to spend time with him that we empathize with him. And throughout the movie, he maintains his dignity and humanity and his commitment to those he loves and family and friends and, and even those he doesn’t know. And it’s that compassion for others that always seems to get in the way of what he wants or what he thinks he wants, which is to travel the world and get out of Bedford Falls. That’s where you we really understand who he is. And then when we get to the point where we actually met him, he even postpones his own suicide to jump in the water and save Clarence. Then we’re on this journey with with him and Clarence. And he after he wishes that he had never been born, he gets to see his life and how it would be without him. And I think we’ve talked about before, but and then Clarence shows him how important he is to the town and family.
We talked about this in the last episode, catharsis and transformation. We everybody knows the story, probably. But then after seeing this, Bailey, literally, and in many ways, metaphorically, says, I want to live again, please, God, let me live again. And so his arc or his transformation is is complete when he receives that copy of The Adventures of Tom Sawyer with the inscription, no man is a failure who has friends. And so that gives him, you know, that gives George and as well as the audience, this, this reassurance that he’ll never question his value again. But it’s, it’s brilliantly told, obviously, that, you know, the way that we’re introduced to him, and then we get to understand how he got there.
So I thought, I like how it’s told that way.
Adam: You hit a very important word. And you’ve said it, you’ve said it sort of twice throughout this thing, but it is really, truly the key to a great character arc is a person’s exploration and final understanding of their self worth or value. That is probably, I can tell you this for a fact, for me, that is the number one objective of every story I write. Every character, that’s their journey. So, a character arc, unlike a plot, character arc for me is the number one objective.
I would agree with that. The reason why I feel like that’s at the core of every story is this, you can try to reach a broad audience, trying to get everybody, but you’re going to have to zoom way out and sort of paint broad strokes. And so it’s not specific, it’s different. But my feeling is when you’re writing a story, the way to really get your. Your audience involved is zoom way, way, way, way in, in inward to yourself, inward to those people and speak to them individually and not broadly, not all of them, but each of them. That’s sort of the difference. Speak to each audience member instead of all of them.
If you can get that concept, you get it right, because you’re talking to who they are. So even if they’re watching next to someone, they’re having their own very specific. And this is what we talked about last time. Cathartic experience. You’re really speaking to them internally. And so the core thing, I think, for all of us in life is the traveling through time, that which is life, to understand things more and more, to explore, to develop, to grow. And very relevant to self-worth and self-value, too. That’s sort of what I think is the new stage of storytelling, the internal exploration. And it’s not mainly about here are the events in sequence.
We’ve seen it. We know it. It’s mechanical. We know at this point. So what more can we do? Well, what’s beyond what we’ve told before in stories? And most of that is the lack of exploration in inner space of people. That’s really the key. We sort of see the external influence of something, but we don’t always see the internal journey of a character. And so one of the reasons why I think long-form storytelling, especially binge-watching, is happening right now is we’re in a very specific age of humanity where voices are diversifying. The voice of female writers is becoming stronger and stronger and finally getting the breathing room to express itself, much like diversified voice in terms of minority.
Places where stories haven’t been told from before are now finding an open arena now to express themselves or that voice. So when we say every story has been told, that’s a huge bunch of malarkey. There are so many stories that have not been told. But been processed through the lens of someone else telling a story about that group or person or thing. There’s all these different ways of expanding that internal world of a character. I was just watching the series on Amazon, I Love Dick. With Kevin Bacon and Kathryn Hahn and Griffin Dunne. I don’t know if you’ve seen it or not. I haven’t seen that, no.
The creator of, I think, Transparent was involved, Jill Soloway. And it’s based on a book, but it’s so innovative and awesome and funny and heartbreaking. It’s just amazing. It’s a really great dynamic show. And the title is hysterical. Kevin Bacon plays the character Dick. Kathryn Hahn’s character sort of develops a thing for him, even though she’s married. And it’s just a wild story. But there are new ways of expressing internal stuff in shows like that. It’s very abstract. The show has moments where it’s very abstract and strange.
Devin: I have one other example. Yeah, I have one other, too. I think I’m minutes away from hypothermia, so I’ll make this one quick. Shawshank Redemption. We talked about this before, too. We did. And I tried to bring them back because we talked about different elements of these stories.
Adam: I think we talked about this last episode in Catharsis and Transformation. I think that’s sort of why we continued this episode, is because there’s a lot more to say about the character, because it’s all about character.
Devin: This one’s interesting because it’s an example of two different characters that you can actually follow their arc. It’s not uncommon at all to have two characters that you can follow their arcs, but this is just one example. Tim Robbins’ character, Andy Dufresne, he’s ignorant and naive when he gets to prison, and he must navigate. He must navigate his way through that completely different life, which is finding allies, which he does in Red and some of the other guys, but he certainly has his own. There’s a myriad of antagonists. And so he has to go through these trials and obstacles and conflicts, but he’s smart enough, he’s very intellectually gifted that we find out in certain elements of life.
And so he learns how to devise a plan to manipulate the warden and plan his escape. Spoiler! And he takes his hands. No. It doesn’t fit my criteria. And then he escapes. So I think that one’s fairly obvious, but Red also has a large transformation. So when we meet him as a prisoner, he’s already come to terms with the fact that he’s going to be trapped in Shawshank forever. And we see throughout the movie during his parole board hearings, he simply tells the panel what they want to hear in a very monotone, ungenuine way. Yeah. But once he meets Andy and he learns from Andy and he watches Andy and he sees Andy take his life into his own hands and he doesn’t let society steal this, steal or hold hostage his freedom, he feels that he’s kind of been freed too.
Like you’re saying, he kind of finds his self-worth and his value and his clarity. Clarity is another. Element of transformation too. And so with this new feeling and emotion, you see Red transform in front of our eyes when he’s. In front of the panel and with like this emotion and conviction, he tells the panel who he is and his truths and things like that. And then all of a sudden he’s set free as well.
Adam: When he speaks his truth, when he finally has self-recognition and speaks his truth, right? Yep. That’s a great example. And actually we talked about that in the last episode too. But what you’re saying in this one is different in terms of the means of it. Like the rhythm of it, like especially with Red finally openly saying, here’s my truth. Yeah. These are unique stories. Shawshank Redemption is sort of told in a way much like the Sherlock Holmes stories are, where Watson narrates Sherlock’s life, Red narrates Andy’s life. So it’s about a perspective of someone on someone else’s way of living. Yeah, yeah. And oftentimes in life when we run into people, our story gets affected by someone else’s perspective.
Or point of view or perspective. We go, oh, I never thought of it that way. And that’s how we change our direction or have new thoughts or ideas, which is what I’m sort of saying about thresholds, end of scenes, end of chapters. Those are those moments. And it doesn’t have to be narrated like Red does or like Watson does Sherlock. But ultimately that’s what you’re looking for in character interactions or a character’s observation of outside stimulus that brings them to their ultimate viewpoint. So – For me, I think a character arc, I always try to explore this. Everybody’s got bumps. Everybody’s got history. Everybody’s got things that wounds, maybe things they haven’t dealt with. They may be in a comfortable space, but there’s this one thing that’s holding them back. As far as a character arc for me, what I like to see is when past meets present and is reconciled.
That’s great. That’s beautifully put. You know, I’ve tried to say that a million times, Devin, and I don’t think I’ve said it as succinctly as I did just then.
Devin: That was great.
Adam: I think that’s it. Everybody’s got baggage. Everybody’s got, quote, exposition in a story, their backstory. Here’s the thing. I think most writers make the mistake of trying to tell the character’s backstory in the first act. And for me, that’s what the story is for. The story is for us to understand how where they’ve come from is melded with whatever is occurring in the present, almost like it’s like this. This is metaphysical stuff, too. If you don’t deal with something, you will experience it again. If you just try to shove something down and ignore it, you will find in your life that you will experience it again in order for you to sort of purge said thing.
And maybe even five or tenfold. Bingo. Because if you didn’t hear it the first time, it gets louder. Oftentimes, if we’ve ignored something or we need to develop, and I said this about the lobster when it has to leave its shell, it’s uncomfortable being in its shell. So it sheds its shell, goes under the… The rock and then grows a new shell. But it doesn’t know it needs to change unless it feels uncomfortable. Shell’s too small. That’s sort of the catalyst for a person. There’s something that is… And as you say, when Red speaks his truth in the end of Shawshank Redemption, he’s actually vocalizing it.
There’s something about yourself that needs to be expressed or released that you are somehow strangling yourself. You’re not allowing yourself that growth. And part of the source of antagonism… And you were saying this before. Most people’s worst enemy is themselves, except they’re projecting those feelings onto someone who is actually mirroring that. So that becomes an antagonist. But it’s sort of like before the antagonist gets defeated in a scenario like that, the person must defeat the inner editor, the inner antagonist, the inner limitation. And then the outward expression of such manifests in the story, manifests in the climax where they overcome. So between the crisis midpoint where they might trip up and fall, if that’s the nature of that story, they find sort of like a recovery stage where they then go, Aha! I know what I need to do better, or I’m disappointed in self for this. And that provides a springboard to that next stage in development.
And if you didn’t hear it… So it’s like this. If you didn’t hear it in the first act or the second act as a character, the crisis kicks in. It kicks you in the head and says, did you hear it now? And then you sort of go, now, if I didn’t hear it in those things, or those little lessons I learned in development or growth in the beginning, the later stage, the second half of this, is me understanding who I am to become.
Devin: Right.
Adam: The first part is sort of making peace with who you are or who you were. And the second half is that. And at the end of it, you really are merging that and going, ah, that’s who I was? Wow, I’m so different now. And I feel like that’s why I love story to begin with. It sort of shows people, you can reinvent yourself. You can think differently. And I like dynamic stories with a strong arc.
Devin: I’m so cold right now.
Adam: I was worried for a little bit that you might be dead.
Because I was talking for a while, and I thought, Devin’s dead.
Devin: I’m going to choosal my feet off this chair. It’s like, get out of here. And it’s good, because we wanted to keep this episode short, and we’ve only been recording for an hour and a half, so that’s good.
Adam: Oh, trust me. When I cut out all our stupid moments… It’ll be like 20 minutes. 20 minutes. It’s funny. Most of my examples, both of my examples I’d written down were protagonist to antagonist as far as an arc. It was Breaking Bad with Walter White, who I won’t get into because we’ve spoken about that last episode and on several different ones. But the other one was really simple, too. The journey to which was different was Anakin Skywalker’s journey to become Darth Vader.
Devin: Nice.
Adam: From when he’s a child to when he becomes, and here’s the interesting thing about this, not just the most fearsome and one of the most iconic villains in storytelling history at this point, not just that, but then he dies as Darth Vader, and he’s not that even at the end. So his milestones and transformations, when he’s at the end and Luke takes off his helmet in the end of episode six, you are looking at an old man who is beaten and defeated and has been hiding behind anger and hate for a very long time, looking on the face of his son and his son looking back on him.
Even though he starts as a kid, pod racing, and then he becomes this pupil who gets seduced to the dark side, then he gets maimed and turned into this half machine, half man who becomes this child. Just fearsome beast of a villain. And then at the very end, he’s this old man who saves his son. He pushes past the anger and the hate and the fear and all the stuff that the dark side is made of, all the stuff that seduces you into feeling there is power there. He lets that go. He actually, he doesn’t let it go. He throws it down a pit. He throws it away.
He takes the emperor and throws that animal down a hole. And dies because of it. All the energy that, but the last moment is him looking on his son and his son having, and his son has compassion for him the whole time. He still believes in his father, even though he knows he’s evil. He’s like, he keeps trying to connect. And it’s funny because even in, if you’re not in the sci-fi fantasy universe, even how many people try are trying to connect with their father, with their parents. Do you know what I mean? There’s so much depth to this fantasy. Fantasy sci-fi world. And that’s why I think people still love that franchise, man.
Even though it takes place in a galaxy far, far away, inside, we know what that feels like. It’s been exponentially increased by the concept of the force and the fact that we’re like metaphysically again, it’s all, we’re all one thing. We’re all the same, made of the same quarks and atoms and all that stuff.
Devin: It also shows the importance of how environment and circumstance can have a. Great impact on who your character is at the beginning of the arc. And in a way, what defines them is something that they couldn’t control. And then through this realization that they can control their destiny and they go on this journey and this process of change by the end of it, they can change their circumstance and environment where before I don’t think they could have. So, or they don’t think they could have.
Adam: Interesting. So, so as a quick side note, when I talk about an, or in many other earlier episodes. Victimized storytelling versus a choosing hero. This is what I mean. There’s sort of a difference between they feel like they have no effect versus self-empowerment, self-worth, self-value. So that’s what I mean by the victimized state where it’s like, oh, well, it was me. The world is the, the world is a problem versus I can affect or influence that world. As long as I do not feel I’m subjective, subjected to it and its rules and its systems and its models. And. I think that’s part of the reason why I like sci-fi so much is because of the fact that you can create an alternate space.
That’s commentary on social interactions. Now give more perspective in that way. Human beings individually are extremely powerful. And yet I feel like as, as individuals, we don’t believe that or know that yet. And it has a lot to do with systems and the way we tell our own stories and the stories we’re told. So I love the fact that you, that you’re actually talking about this, the arc of a character or the development of a character being. Their understanding of, I am not at the will of something, I am understanding my own will. I’m understanding my own internal workings. Will is a good way to put it too.
Yes. Yeah. I’m so cold. It’s starting to get cold here. I did want to say this too, and this is the last thing. Character arcs are much more easy to track and, and I think more fascinating and at least for me, especially in film, the media that is ongoing, long form storytelling, especially binge-watching. Binge-worthy seasons of things, a film doesn’t allow the time, a novel is, is great for it, but I feel like I’m seeing a new revolution in storytelling via binge-watching long form. It’s, it’s like a novel in filmed entertainment. It’s chapter based.
Devin: Exactly. That’s what I was going to say. Yeah. What you get to do is grow with a person over time.
Adam: That’s the benefit of those mediums versus film. Character arcs, you’re going to see more and more dynamic. You’re going to see more dynamic character arcs. What I mean by dynamic is they, you will, Devin, are you still alive? Yeah, yeah. A person will be that person who’s gone through every different type of thing that every person could have gone through. And then you, so you’ve seen this arc, you’ve seen them go through all the, instead of just one thing they’re up against, feature film, they’re going to lose their job or their marriage, wah, wah, wah, every comedy for the past 20 years, just kidding. But that’s it.
It’s like family life or career, because we don’t know any other stakes than that. It’s going to get different because after one episode, you can’t just have those stakes anymore. They either solve it or they don’t, and if they don’t solve it, they’re weak-willed, and if they do solve it, then you need to move on to something else.
Devin. Well, StoryOsophers, I think Devin is dead. I think he is frozen to death in Minnesota because we both have to turn our heat off in order to record without interruption. So, I guess we’ll have to wait and see the next episode if he’s still alive. Devin. Please subscribe and rate us on iTunes, and for additional story-related resources, video, and archived content, visit our website at StoryOsophy.com.