Show notes
If theme is what a story says, tone is how it says it. Adam and Devin explore genre, tone, mood, style and voice. They talk about why genre is mostly a marketing box, why changing tone midway can lose an audience, and how filmmakers from Hitchcock to Tarantino turned style into a signature.
In this episode
- Genre is a box. Devin sees genre as a marketing label rather than a writing tool. Adam agrees, but says you still need it to pitch your story in a sentence.
- Flipping the staples. Tucker & Dale vs. Evil takes horror’s familiar setup and tells it from the point of view of the sweet, terrified “rednecks.”
- Keep the tone consistent. Mood can shift scene to scene, but changing the overall tone midway disorients an audience. Young filmmakers who copy two idols at once often fall into this.
- Painting with the camera. Soderbergh’s color filters in Traffic, a Breaking Bad focus pull, and Hitchcock’s camera angles all show how visual choices create tone.
- Hitchcock and Chaplin. Hitchcock told stories with the camera. Chaplin, coming from vaudeville, told them with what happened in front of a camera that rarely moved. “There is no terror in the bang, only in the anticipation.”
- Versatile voices and signature voices. Rob Reiner and Soderbergh move between genres. Baz Luhrmann, David Lynch, Jean-Pierre Jeunet and Tarantino are recognizable from the first frame.
- Limits breed creativity. Tarantino set most of Reservoir Dogs in one warehouse. Independent filmmakers who can’t throw money at a problem often find better solutions.
- Novels have their own trap. Unlimited pages are like unlimited money: they can let a story lose its focus. Don’t lose your reader in the details.
- Find your voice. Every writer starts by imitating their heroes. Keep writing, and be brave and honest enough to tell the story your own way.
Examples discussed
- Tucker & Dale vs. Evil, Shaun of the Dead, Tremors, Traffic, Breaking Bad, Psycho, Moulin Rouge!, The Great Gatsby, The Fifth Element, Reservoir Dogs and The Hateful Eight.
- Also: Rob Reiner’s Misery, A Few Good Men, When Harry Met Sally, The Princess Bride and Stand by Me, plus Michael Bay, Stephen Chow, Sam Raimi and Cormac McCarthy.
Next episode: stakes.
Read the full transcript
Transcribed automatically, so expect the odd misheard word. Sponsor messages are left out.
Adam: In this episode, we examine tone, style, and genre. Yeah. What is the tone or mood of a piece? What is the overall voice? How are you expressing your story? We answer these questions and more next on StoryOsophy. Hello. Welcome to StoryOsophy. This is Adam Jones. And Devin Halden. This episode, we will be talking mainly about tone. But we will be touching on genre and style and voice and a lot of ways that tone manifests itself throughout storytelling. In the previous episode, we discussed the idea of theme. And the pivotal question being there, what are you trying to say? What is the meaning of the story? Theme is sort of the subtextual philosophical question beneath the story.
And as that last episode dealt with what are you trying to express, this episode focuses on how are you trying to express it? Or how is a writer, a storyteller trying to express it? The how is commonly called the tone of a story. We’re going to talk about that and a sense of storytelling style. But before we get into that, I first want to mention the idea of genre. I think I defined this in an earlier episode, but some of you listeners may or may not know what this means. Genre is a French word which in short basically means a kind. So what kind of story is it? What type of story is it?
Is it sort of what a genre is? A genre is a type of story you’re reading or watching, meaning action, comedy, drama, thriller, romantic comedy, horror, fantasy, science fiction, adventure, superhero, mystery. And the list can go on and on. Those are your basics. The idea of how genre relates to tone. Each genre has its own sort of rules by which you tell it that define it as a genre. The genres dictate some of the tone of how you tell that story. And so I wanted to start off with talking about genre before we moved into more of the overall topic of tone and how you tell the story.
Devin: Genre for me is like one of those attempts at putting everything into a box and it’s more of a marketing thing. I agree. Than an element of writing. I agree. Hollywood has adopted these visual cues to somehow translate to the audience as if they didn’t know already. Based on the story. What genre they’re in. Like The Ring or those scary movies are cold and bluish and dystopian movies are gray and washed out. And so I think this episode focuses a lot more on screenwriting and filmmaking than it does maybe from a novel writing or something like that because a lot of it is a visual thing.
There’s some conventions you don’t need to follow. If you’re in a dystopian film, you don’t have to have the washed out. You don’t have to have the washed out grays and where the – Yeah. The Skies are usually just completely washed out or whites, things like that. So I think, yeah, they help because people relate to that and they correlate that type of a look to this type of a story. But, you know, I think genre is just more of a way for studios to market the film towards certain audiences that gravitate towards genre.
Adam: No, and you’re 150% right. Here’s what I want to say about genre and the reason I want to go into it before we go into tone and the rest. And like I said, you’re totally right on this. It is the box. It is the label. And in this first season, we’re defining the boxes and the labels and the rules so we can blow them up in later seasons. And here’s the other reason why I bring up genre too is if you’re going to the grocery store, you have your shopping list, you’re not a baker, but you know what you want in your bread. And so you needed to say, rye, you needed to say wheat. Now you and I, Devin, we’re bakers. We care a lot about what’s in the ingredients of that bread. And it’s not just boiled down and put into a box. But when you’re a consumer or when you’re the supermarket and you need to sell to the consumer, you sort of need to put it in a box in some way in order to get people to understand and whether that’s the way things should work or not. That’s sort of the way that consumerism works right now.
And so understanding what box or box says, Which we’ll get into later, the idea of plurality in genre and mixing and matching the recipes. Knowing how to label your story to be able to communicate it shorthand to other people is extremely valuable. And so, I don’t want to say that you should know your genre to limit it. But at the same time, the same way that you have 120 pages, 90 to 100 pages. 120 page script or a 400 page manuscript or whatever it might be. You still need to boil it down to an extent to one sentence that lets someone know whether they should open it up and read from 1 to 400 or 1 to 120. And so, a genre is really helpful to get them to know what am I getting into before I get into it.
Creating a logline and a synopsis and boiling something like a even a series or a feature or a novel down to a single sentence is hard and it sort of trivializes it. Yeah. But if you do it right, it’s the perfect delicious pitch.
Devin: I would look at genre the same way I look at theme that we talked about last episode. That, don’t let genre be the first thing you define when you start writing a story, come up with a story that you want to tell. And then by the end of it, you’re going to be able to figure out what type, what, what quote unquote box that’s going to fit into for these ancillary purposes of why you’d want to have, you’d want to define what genre it is because. Again, the same thing with theme. It’s like, if you come up, you say, I’m going to write a comedy. Well, when you start writing, a lot of times the story and the characters are going to lead you in a direction. And it may end up being, you may start off saying, I want to write a comedy and then you fight against all of that to stay writing a comedy.
When maybe it becomes a drama. You don’t want to have that focused in and locked in your mind.
Adam: It’s a valuable point. At the same time, I would say having an idea, just like your theme. When we were talking about theme and we were saying you should have one word for the first draft. What is it about? It’s about love. What is it about? It’s about honesty. Right. One word that sort of keeps you on the, in the same zone. You may get through an entire first draft and you, and then go, Oh shoot. The theme or the, the genre tone of the feel I was going for is not what this story wants. It wants something different. And so then you change everything. I’m not saying necessarily go into it blind, go into it with a color palette, go into it with an idea of what you want to paint.
You don’t have to get specific. And I wanted to mention just something real quick about what you were saying, although this episode is dealing with genre and tone and style. It’s not necessarily about visual. I don’t think we necessarily need to gear it completely in terms of visual media, like television or film, because there are ways of writing in general, just styles of writing that is sort of creates a tone and creates that flavor. Oh, yeah. Tone is just a story element. Yeah. Cormac McCarthy. When you get to that level of how many stories you’ve told, that starts to be called. Your voice or your style. There’s a certain way in which you tell that story. And so tone eventually, I think, evolves into your storytelling voice. But like Devin is saying, whenever you start something first draft, do not limit yourself. Give yourself some rough ideas. Like I say.
In terms of tone, think color schemes. Think I’m going to paint with these colors. You know what I mean? I’m going to paint with these topics, these themes, these feels, these perspectives. These feels. That’s not even a real thing. These feelings.
That’s a thing. Let’s move into the idea of tone first. I brought up genre simply because cutting out the fat, it’s the box that anyone in a commercial market is going to want to place your story in. And for the time being, that’s the way the commercial market functions. However, there’s a lot more cross-genre work happening, which we’ll get into a little bit later. It has to do with people expanding storytelling styles. One of my favorite analogies for storytelling is cooking. There’s all kinds of ingredients. There’s so many ways of doing it. And I think you’re seeing the cross-genre stuff happening because a lot of stories have been told and people are trying to tell new ones.
Devin is completely accurate. It is a box. But let’s examine the larger, broader idea of tone that we will later have to boil down into that box. I think people who care about story really care about tone and theme. And people who really care about making a buzzword. And that’s it. And not about the art of storytelling. The other stuff is what they focus on and they forget about tone and theme.
Devin: The difference between film or screenwriting and, say, writing a novel. In that world, in the novel world, the genre is a little bit more broad, like young adult. And then within young adult are the sub-genres of vampire, romance, and things like that.
Adam: Sub-genres you’re talking about. Very valid point. Like comedy or drama. Comedy or drama or young adult. And then you sub, yeah.
Devin: And it’s important, too, like with everything else. You’re trying to fit it into a box, but I don’t think there’s any story that doesn’t have elements of different genres in it. Even thriller movies.
Adam: Well, these days especially. But the genres were built on certain staples of how the story was told tonally that created that genre. Over years of people telling similar horror stories, there are certain things that we expect in a horror story. Like I say, boxes suck.
Devin: Like Schindler’s List even has jokes and there’s scenes of humor in it. But you wouldn’t necessarily categorize Schindler’s List as drama comedy. So, I mean, you kind of take the thing, the main meats of it or the main meat of the story.
Adam: So, an interesting way of examining genre and tone is one of my examples that I was going to give. Tucker and Dale vs. Evil. So, I’m using a genre which is horror, a traditional genre. And I know, Devin, you’re probably in shock right now that I’m using a horror film as an example. But notice, it’s a comedy. So, any horror movie I give is going to have comedy in it. That’s just the way it’s going to work. This, Tremors, I gave another one. Oh, Shaun of the Dead, they’re all horror comedies. So, here’s what I’m saying about Tucker and Dale vs. Evil. They take the genre staples of a horror movie, innocent and sexually promiscuous college students going on.
Going on a vacation out in the woods and scary evil rednecks hunting them down and killing them, right? Some weird, creepy, it’s a traditional horror artifice because it’s out in the woods. But what happens in this film is, I do love the premise of this movie. Two rednecks finally get their vacation home in the woods, which is a nice cabin. And all these college kids mistake them for the crazy, psychotic horror movie rednecks. And they’re so terrified, these college kids, that they end up accidentally killing themselves, having accidents which accidentally kill them. And the rednecks are freaking out and trying to figure out why all these college kids are committing suicide in front of them. And all the college kids are trying to figure out why these rednecks are after them. And they’re terrified because their friends are dying.
Anyway, it flips the horror genre on its head in the staples that it uses. By mixing up this recipe and sort of Now, many films have done this before. But the point is, the tone of the movie now comes from these two worried rednecks who usually are two-dimensional, nasty horror movie villains. And they’re the ones who are worried and terrified and really sweet and kind. And so, the way you flip and tell that story is the tone. It’s like the character perspective. It’s sort of like choosing to tell… A story, oh, like we mentioned previously, Firefly and Serenity, where we’re telling it from the thieves’ perspective and not the, quote, proper side of the law. So tone has a lot to do with perspective and how you’re telling the story, but it’s even broader than that.
Devin: Besides genre, tone and mood and style, I think they all are kind of interrelated. They’re all connected in a way, and they all play within each other. But I think a big part of tone, when you start with a tone, I think, and when you’ve established a tone, don’t change the tone. Once you change the tone of your story, it can be, that can be disorienting and confusing for audiences. And it’s often incongruous with other tonal decisions made to that point.
Adam: Mood. Mood. What mood are you trying to set? That word you used, we didn’t use it before now, but that’s really appropriate for tone and style and what mood are you setting?
Devin: When you change the tone of the film, all of a sudden, everything that you’ve established up to that point and other tonal decisions that you’ve made up to that point, all of a sudden, they don’t mesh. The story doesn’t mesh. It almost feels like they’re on different planes. And I think that’s where it can be disorienting and confusing to an audience.
Adam: The audience wants to get on the ride. The audience wants to get on the ride, but they need to know what the ride is to a certain degree. They want to have unexpected turns and twists, but if they don’t know what it is, they won’t get on. They need to know what they’re signing up for to a certain degree. And when you twist it, and what you’re saying is really important too, because tone is something you don’t want to deviate from. I’m trying to think, while you were talking about examples where films change tone halfway through and are successful, which I couldn’t think of any offhand, but films that I’ve seen where maybe they were [unclear] at a film festival and by more novice filmmakers who were still trying to find their voice. And so their tone sort of shifts. Sometimes, a lot of it in young filmmakers you’ll see because they’re trying to emulate people that they, or artists that they really admire. And they’ll use two different artists. And so the film will sort of take a turn because they’ve decided to be like this person in the first part and like this person. But it’s not gelled because their voice is not matured as an artist.
They’re still testing it out and trying things and experiment derivative of some of their idols, their heroes, the people that inspire them to want to write or create a story. You’re making an important point. Tone is not something, well, theme as well. Those two things, you don’t really want to change them in the middle.
Devin: This is specific to filmmaking. That’s not to say that you’re not trying to change the mood of any one event to the other and usually done through… Some lighting techniques or music, how mood is a sub element of what tone is. And I think the tone is always going to be the same, but there’s going to be different moods within that tone and usually signified by many different creative and technical things you can do.
Adam: Each scene technically has its own tone and mood, but just much like there is sort of maybe sub themes or things like that. You want to have a main through line.
Devin: Yeah, through line.
Adam: You want to have a spine to every… No matter what these primary components are, you want to have a spine for them throughout the whole story or else it feels disjointed. It doesn’t feel like there’s any construction involved. It doesn’t feel like there’s any linear motion. And storytelling is much like life. Even though you can examine things in your mind non-linearly, the way you experience life is very linearly. And so the story is a replica of life in a way. And so you sort of travel the same. Yeah. So you want that through line. You want that spine and all these core elements. Right, right. Including tone, even if it within each scene has a slightly different color shade or something. And mind you, when you were saying that, I was thinking of your example of traffic a few podcasts back.
Yeah, I have that. I was going to talk about that coming up. That’s not really about the mood. You pointed that out in particular in that episode. It is so much of an artifice of setting and plot, the subplots of the story, more so than it is the mood, which is interesting. Yeah. That’s what I was thinking about when you were talking about it. Because it’s really fascinating. Most of the time you do use lighting for mood and tone. Lighting in and of itself, the way you cast a light on something is tone. Right.
Devin: They interpret words on a page. I didn’t read the script. So that may either Soderbergh interpreted it that way or it was interpreted. It was already interpreted. It was put into the script and maybe the shooting script part of it. But so I’m not sure how that went, but it’s also.
Adam: Yeah, I haven’t. I don’t know the answer to that either.
Devin: Even just look at some of the other Soderbergh movies is he interprets things both from from a script, but then also tonally and mood that he he then uses in post-production and he does stuff with the traffic stuff was actually done in camera. Like he was just using different lens filters and for when he was shooting the stuff in Mexico and then San Diego and then all the East Coast government stuff was just there. He’s actually using filters there. I’m sure it was touched up in post too. But he does. So those are those are things that really great directors are thinking about in a way of how they can they can tell the story and how it would be interpreted by an audience as well.
So that’s which is all part of storytelling.
Adam: Really good directors are ones that are top notch audience members. They know what they would the best way to view this scene. And so that’s how they direct to shoot that scene is so that it unravels in a way that’s full. Of experience, right? I’m going to point out one shot in. I think it’s the Breaking Bad finale that I still remember. That was fascinating to me. Just the construction of the shot because it told a story just by the way it was set up. It was in the foreground was a fence in the background. You see this car’s headlights moving towards you and they’re out of focus.
And so is the fence and the car comes up and it’s sitting there for a second. You’re like, oh, I wonder who this is. Who’s in this car? What do they do? You know, all these questions and mental intrigue. And then. Then in the foreground, they pull focus and a pair of hands comes in and unlocks the padlock that’s been sitting there. And all of a sudden you pull to this person’s perspective. And there’s so much of that visual intrigue that’s interesting about it. Painting that picture is a lot about tone and style and that visual voice. But it does translate also into novels, manuscripts, prose.
For me, at least, I’m coming at it from a film perspective more than anything. But. Storytelling in general. But I think that sort of how does that story make you feel? How does the story feel is really what tone is. It’s the mood. It’s the it’s one of those other intangibles. Theme and tone are your intangibles. Characters, their visual representations right there. The plot. You can see the action evolving. The conflict is evident. Theme and tone are the abstract ones. I think that’s why I like them.
Devin: And I think we were just touching on. I don’t know if we’re moving there right now, but we are touching on like with Soderbergh. We’re kind of touching on style. Like there’s a voice because there’s an individual. When you see when there’s there’s certain directors and filmmakers that you when you are watching it, you know.
Adam: Well, he varies. I know what you’re saying, but he’s he’s talented in his versatility. Soderbergh is just like Rob Reiner. I think he’s one of my other faves in versatility. Their voice is sometimes undetectable. They’re just genius. Right.
Devin: And I was thinking like Hitchcock.
Adam: Yeah, was. Yeah. Okay. And you couldn’t have picked a better dude for tone right there. That dude built a career and a genre off of two. He built thriller, man, right? Oh, I didn’t have it.
Devin: My notes, but Hitchcock dude and even style when you get into style and it’s not necessarily voice. Like he always similar Soderbergh like they were he had different ways of of filming things, but like his way of telling part of the story without using the way he’s positioned a camera on Anthony Perkins, you know, in the big in psycho where, you know, we’re looking up as the audience is looking up at him and you know, there’s different ways there’s different techniques that he was using that became part of his style.
Adam: Well, part of the film lexicon in general, dude, I mean, you could put Hitchcock and you could put who are we talking about Orson Welles, the couple of sets back. Oh, yeah. Those two, they dude, they created film language in so many ways. Mm-hmm. Even one of our faves, Chaplin, I don’t think created film language as strongly as those two did. How do you use the camera to paint the picture? And as far as tone or style within filmmaking, that’s what that means.
Devin: Mm-hmm.
Adam: Right. How do you paint with? How do you paint with the camera? Where? How are you? How are you telling this? What the mood of the music you add the mood of the lighting the.
Devin: And that’s an interesting contrast between Hitchcock and Chaplin, both great directors. But. Hitchcock used the camera. To tell the story and Chaplin used himself and what was on screen to tell the story and a lot of times his camera wasn’t even moving. It was just a stationary camera and then everything that was happening on screen is what was the only way of telling the story.
Adam: Chaplin also came from an era where he was doing his… was theatrical background, vaudeville, things like that. Yeah, vaudeville. And so you basically had the proscenium of the screen and whatever was happening on it. And so he’s made so many films, and I love him. Him and Buster Keaton, I love him. The point is, he came from a vaudevillian performance background, and so the film screen… Well, most of those people did back then, because they… Sure, sure. Film didn’t even exist. Yeah, sure. And if you look at early Alfred Hitchcock stuff it’s very proscenium based. It’s very theatrically presented and produced. Even old Alfred Hitchcock Presents was that one I saw with – it’s one unit set that was built obviously on a soundstage, dressed up really nice. And Hitchcock is smart enough to understand what the tension is in that scene and milk the hell out of it.
Do you know what I mean? Milk it. I meant to say there’s a Hitchcock quote which sums up what you’re talking about with him. He said, when the screenplay has been written and the dialogue has been added, we’re ready to shoot. His main language in film was image and the extreme of filmmaking and tone and style. He approached it visually first. All those shots you’re talking about and the way he created a mood, he worked on shots first, and then it was like, whatever they say is fine, but we need the tension of the shot first. He was a very visual filmmaker.
Devin: Here’s another Alfred Hitchcock quote that fits right into this is, there is no terror in the bang, only in the anticipation.
Adam: That’s it, dude. That is. Yeah, I mean, that’s the core of most really great writing right there, is not knowing what’s going to happen and being excited to find out the outcome. A crafty writer can create that circumstance for an audience, doesn’t matter what medium. But that’s a great quote, great quote from Hitchcock. This is, see, these two things, the past episode and this one, theme and tone, they’re the elusive ones for almost all of us. Every writer, if you understand that and start to just allow them to come in and recognize, just keep track of them, you’ll be above par, more so than most other writers who aren’t paying attention to those abstract ideas. They’re just going to write empty entertainment. To deepen that with theme and tone, you’ll have a rich piece, a rich work of art. Did I go over the top? I’m trying to inspire people. Well, that was good. Very inspirational.
Do you have a great story in mind? Some great characters? All these cool scenes and you don’t know what order to put them in? What goes here? What comes next? Story Blueprint is an app that provides a powerful and versatile tool to help you, the writer, build the roadmap of your story. Know where your story is going to start, where it’s going to end, and how you’re going to get there before you even begin writing. Once you have your blueprint completed, you’ll have a bird’s eye view of your story, removing the anxiety of the blank page. Story Blueprint is currently available in the iTunes App Store for iPad. Coming soon for iPhone and Android.
What about if you already have a finished script and you want feedback on how to improve your story for the next draft? Maybe you’d prefer a personal walkthrough to talk your story out one-on-one. Well, StoryOsophers, you can always talk to me. I offer a variety of supportive services from feedback for finished scripts to script doctoring and company consultations. I’ll diagnose your story to make sure all its parts are working toward the whole and strive to find a balance between traditional structure, storytelling innovation, and the writer’s personal voice and lens. I also do ongoing story therapy for writers who are looking for a coach to help build their story.
I ask you the questions that help you find your own story, and we discuss how to mine its gems. Consultation services are also available to directors and actors looking to break down scripts into beats and super objectives, and to production companies looking to refine the stories in their slate. For more information and a full menu of story doctoring options, you can visit doctajones.com. That’s D-O-C-T-A Jones dot com. Links to both Story Blueprint and Dr. Jones consultations can be found on our website at StoryOsophy.com.
He was such a playful storyteller. Hitchcock, dude, do you remember his introductions? And he would talk about the dark side of humanity. He would just relish in, it’s a story, folks. He would bookend it with this sort of prologue, epilogue of, I hope you’ve enjoyed our story presentation. Right. And as you were saying, he just set up the proscenium and then did his shtick. Shtick, that’s a terrible way to, that’s trivializing Chaplin’s genius. But you understand what I mean. He could stand on stage and just do, it’s like Bill Irwin nowadays. Right. You could watch Bill Irwin on stage or on screen doing his thing because he’s a professional clown. He’s genius at it. He’s slapstick extraordinaire. And the same thing with Chaplin, except it was new then. And so he wasn’t trying to use the camera as much to paint the comedy.
Right. And in later generations, as we’ve gone decades and decades later. The people now, filmmakers use the camera to help paint the comedy. You frame a shot that makes it funnier. It’s interesting that from stage to screen, the way that this tonal lexicon of language for film is created. Once again, that’s all visual. We don’t want to get too far off into that as far as the tone and style of the storytelling too, because we don’t want to exclude prose and novels and novellas.
Devin: Yeah, but yeah, it’s just storytelling. It’s still all part of that storytelling. And so it’s like for novelists listening, it’s more of like, all right, well, how do you take that emotion? Right. And so it’s, they have this extra medium, this way to interpret things and show you it. And it’s just from a writing standpoint, it’s like making the audience that’s reading your story. How do you, you know, making sure you’re doing the same way when, you know, making them feel that. Making those transitions from, yeah, of course, you still have that emotion. That through line, that tone through line or that spine. But then there’s the, those, the scenes that have the different moods and how are you changing those moods? And I think that’s kind of the, and that’s where the brilliance of writing comes in. And some people are better at it than others, but.
Adam: Some stories don’t have a core theme we were talking about. They’re just entertainment. And you can tell when you’re watching stories, these are the stories that are just sort of factory made masterpieces. Produced and the difference between those and the ones that you love, the movies you can’t wait to watch again, your favorite movie. Those, those are strong in theme and tone guaranteed. They know what they’re doing in that. That’s why they resonate with you so strongly.
Devin: Yeah. And I, but I do think there are some of those, those movies too, that they’ll, they’re weaker in theme and maybe weaker in tone, but there’s still this style to them. Yeah. Oh, well, let’s. Shall we, shall we swift gears?
Adam: Yeah. Swift gears. Okay. So style, I would say as a deliberate approach, voice is something that if you were to talk about an author’s work, the way they’ve told their stories throughout their career would be their voice. And it grows and it changes, but usually that voice is pretty consistent. There are very few people who have a very different voice per thing. You would say. I would say, like I said, okay, the two we brought up Soderbergh, his voice is versatile. You can’t necessarily spot a Soderbergh movie by watching it if his name wasn’t on it. And I would say the same thing about one of my, one of my favorite filmmakers, Rob Reiner. I think Rob Reiner is actually fairly undervalued as a brilliant filmmaker because he is so good at whatever genre he picks up, whatever tone, whatever style of story could be a comedy, could be a drama, could be horror, like Misery.
He did Misery. A Few Good Men, When Harry Met Sally, Princess Bride, Stand By Me. These are movies that are so different. I mean, they’re, none of them are really alike at all. He has the ability to be flexible, so he can adjust his style to create a strong story. And then there are other filmmakers who are very, very specific about their voice so that every time you watch a movie and they’ve made it, you know it’s one of their movies from the first moment. I’ll throw down a couple examples here and maybe talk about them. For me, as I talked about in the previous episode, David Lynch, unmistakable, Baz Luhrmann, Stephen Chow, Sam Raimi. I like, I really, if you haven’t noticed, I like really hyperbolic filmmakers. I like things that feel more like big and cartoony and fun and I love that kind of stuff.
Oh, and I would also say Jean-Pierre Jeunet, who did Amelie and City of Lost Children. Also, another one that, whose style I find intriguing. You can tell though, from the first moment you watch any of these, these folks, these filmmakers’ films, who they are. You know who made this movie. We could debate whether that’s style or voice for any of those because they’re fairly well established.
Devin: I think there’s, I think, and that’s why I think style and voice kind of, there’s not a ton of things that, a ton of elements that have, that we’re taught, that we discuss that are just… Just a definitive black and white definition that sits alone, sits by themselves. I think everything kind of, all of these things are tools and these are elements that are kind of meshing to build you, to build from a writer standpoint, who you are, who your style is, who your voice is, what do you, what kind of stories do you like to tell? And I think, and I had Baz too. I think Baz is one of my favorite filmmakers.
Is it Baz or Boz? Am I saying it wrong? I said Baz. It could be Boz Luhrmann. I think it’s Baz. What I appreciate with, with Mr. Luhrmann is his movie, he takes so much time and effort to perfect everything that we’re talking about. His artistic design and sensibilities, he takes so much time. I believe his wife is the set designer for a lot of, a lot of his movies. I know like Moulin Rouge and Gatsby. Really? And of course, also what I think is great about him is how he, he weaves music into the actual storyline. And it’s not just a mood thing.
Adam: It’s a style. It’s artistic design. It’s the style of it. I resonate with him a lot like this. I write with music in mind. And especially repurposing music, like Moulin Rouge, where he takes modern music, pop music, and turns it into the soundtrack, the actual real music, like Lady Marmalade and stuff like that, of the world. Comic book-y, hyperbolically telling stories with brighter colors and bigger moments, more epic storytelling in that way.
Devin: His wife is the costume designer and production designer and set designer and film producer. So yeah, she was the set designer for Moulin Rouge and Great Gatsby.
Adam: And who was the other dude I was just thinking of? Luc Besson, the filmmaker who did Fifth Element, Leon the Professional.
Devin: I love Fifth Element. I actually did not, I was not aware of actually who made that movie.
Adam: One of the primary notions or ideas when it comes to tone in your story is how you’re painting it. If you’re a filmmaker, you’re going to look for that visual appeal. You’re going to look for that stylistic representation. You’re going to look for the way that wardrobe applies, fashion, the artistic design, the artistic sensibilities of the whole piece. If you’re a novelist, you’re not going to rely on other departments to co-create with you and build this finished film. You are going to need to, in your description, have artistry describing the design of a place, the layout of a room. The room you’re in, the details that an audience needs to know in a way that’s tangible and relatable and appeals to them and pops to them.
You won’t have the luxury of a finished product visually showing the audience what they should see. As a novelist, you are the person who engages their imagination to visualize that world that you’ve created on the page. So you must make sure that whatever you’re trying to communicate is on the page. But additionally… Is it having the effect that you want experience-wise for your audience or reader? Can they feel that place? Can they feel it? Tone is a lot about feeling. And if you approach it from that artistic visual landscape and then trying to translate that to a feeling, you’re in the right ballpark as far as when you’re working with prose.
You want to describe something that elicits a feeling placed for your readers.
Devin: Well said. Michael Bay has a very distinct filmmaking style. And I think it’s because he came from an advertising background. His films always use these odd and interesting angles and they’re always shot like a music video. And they all have these signature color schemes. And so I think there’s a lot of… I was watching, I forgot, Transformers. I forgot what movie I was watching. One of his Transformers movies. And I was like, there’s like literally music constantly in the background or just this constant music and movement. And the colors are so rich.
Adam: Well, I was going to say, here’s another major filmmaker who, stylistically, is very specific and interesting. Tarantino. Yeah, yeah. And here’s the way of what I’m talking about with young writers and derivative filmmaking and things like that. Tarantino borrows from everybody and everywhere. And yet his presentation is very specifically Tarantino. And even if you didn’t see the fact that he sort of brands the fifth film by Quentin Tarantino, and he sort of branded himself in a very auteur, indie filmmaker way, which is, once again, the box. He’s figured out his image and brand. There are certain styles or flavors. A tone is sort of like a flavor.
Your genre is a kind of style of movie. When you start to blend some of these recipes of action. I mean, in Michael Bay’s case, comedy and action usually go hand-in-hand, although he adds a lot of drama, romance, things like that. Tarantino is more of a thriller, end of things, or action as well. Character-driven. More character-driven. And a lot of character. I loved Hateful Eight. I loved watching that movie. There was a couple spots where I was like, eh, it’s all right. But most of it, I was like, I really enjoyed it. I also like Walton Goggins. I freaking love that dude. There are some films where I’m like, well, you – and I think this is the case with most artists in general.
They make pieces, and the cumulative work, all of the projects together is what you would consider their voice. It’s the reason why Shakespeare has such a – he’s considered such a commonly universal voice, is because he’s told so many different stories on so many broad themes. He’s not very limited. Whereas some of the other people that we’ve met – That you’ve mentioned are very specific about the way they want to paint things.
Devin: I think that’s also where Tarantino is different than many of the really good directors, like Soderbergh. And I don’t know if Baz writes his own stuff, but Tarantino writes – Baz, Baz – Tarantino writes all of his own stuff. He even writes stuff for other people that you won’t even know. You’d be surprised at some of the other movies that Tarantino’s just written and didn’t direct. So I think from – How he moves that from page to screen is – and it may or may not be a benefit to be able to, while you’re writing, know exactly how you’re going to shoot it rather than reading something and then interpreting it on how you shoot it.
But I think that’s one of those unique things about Tarantino is he writes his own – all of his own stuff and comes up with his own characters and things like that. And so do you, Adam.
Adam: Here’s the thing. There are times when you can write something and you’re sort of pre-visualized. You’re pre-visualizing it, knowing that you as a writer are going to imagine it as a director as well. And so you’re going to have to figure out a way to shoot this. If you have a huge budget at your disposal, you don’t worry about how you’re going to shoot it so much. If you’re working in indie land, you oftentimes are considering while you’re writing, how can I pitch this scene to a line producer, to someone who’s going to budget this, and then present it to an investor so that they realize their money is not going to be – Their money is going to be spent to capture the scene in the most efficient way possible.
And so you don’t go outlandish, crazy ways of capturing stuff. It’s a different mode in that way between – I mean, Tarantino, early in his career as a young writer – When he was working at a video store and consuming great storytelling, and even for that matter, schlocky B-movie storytelling, just consuming media in general, he was conceiving of his first film, which was Reservoir Dogs, an independent filmmaker versus a studio filmmaker, a filmmaker who is within a large production company. When he did Reservoir Dogs, he basically told himself this, I’m going to create a really dynamic story, and I’m going to keep it in a very shootable location, which is one warehouse. And every once in a while, I’m going to pepper in what happened before this warehouse, so the locations that we need to cover outside of this warehouse are minimal.
It’s going to be a car running in the street, a meeting place in a room, a diner in the beginning. When he was first starting out and writing Reservoir Dogs, he understood that the concept of a unit set, and what I mean by unit set is one specific location. A unit set is terminology for a stage play or a television show where the set is built, and it’s where most of the action takes place. So Tarantino was smart enough in his first feature film to center the story in one very easy location of the warehouse that they hide out in after the heist.
So as a young independent… As a young independent filmmaker, he knew what he needed to do to create that sort of achievable, low-budget environment and build the story of characters interacting with deceit and betrayal and conflict, all kinds of stuff going on within that environment. And you as an audience playing detective and trying to figure out what happened. And then as his career evolved, obviously, and more money and overhead was given to him, he created stories which were more visually and stylistically dynamic. But he knew how to write characters, as you pointed out. It’s a warehouse.
Devin: Therein lies the pros and cons of independent filmmaking. From my years as film festival executive director slash film festival programmer, I saw hundreds of films that were, I mean, it’s an accomplishment no matter what, if you’re able to set out to start making a movie and you make a movie. And you finish it. There’s always some things that you’d have to improve. But a lot of times it’s… In the indie world, like you said, you don’t have that money to solve problems. And so a lot of times you have to rely on your creativity to solve problems. Innovation. And in a lot of times, those are 10 times better solutions.
Yes. And I think that’s why a lot of the… Even some, you know, Tarantino, Rodriguez, all of those guys that kind of came up together with… Entrepreneurs and innovators. They figured out a way to shoot their own stuff. So they wanted to be filmmakers and they were filmmakers. They solved things through, like you said, we don’t have a ton of money, so let’s get creative and put it all in one location. And then from any budget, you’re going to be able to see where all much money you’re saving. But doing that makes… All of a sudden makes the story way more intimate. If you’re talking about Reservoir Dogs, it puts them in this pressure cooker, which maybe if you had a lot of money, you would have had them run them around all over town.
And it even translates into novels too. But it’s like that’s… Those are some of the pros and cons of indie filmmaking. Sometimes money is an evil.
Adam: Well, I wouldn’t necessarily call money… Or detriment. A detriment, maybe. A detriment. When you’re working on a story and it’s independent, you know you have these parameters. You try to achieve it practically. You try to achieve it without throwing money at the problem. If you can create a parameter or an environment, a sandbox to play in, it benefits it. It focuses it. If you can always throw money at the problem, it dilutes what… It can be. It homogenizes it in a way. This is something I say to writers when I’m doing consultations. No offense, Hollywood. I love your movies. I really do. But it’s sort of like my little joke.
What’s the difference between an independent film and a Hollywood film? An independent film says, we don’t have enough money for explosions. Let’s just make it interesting. Lazy entertainment is what I’m lampooning, really. I think because independent filmmakers or writers don’t necessarily… Especially in film. I think novelization, you have the ability to write endless world, endless expense. Because it’s a novel. That’s a different landscape. That’s a different medium. There is spectacle and there is story. Spectacle would be things that are big and elaborate and epic, but they don’t really resonate with you as a person. You’re entertained. It was thrilling. The money was worth the experience like a roller coaster.
But you don’t… Remember that roller coaster for years to come. And so I’m not belittling spectacle by any means. It’s a thrill. I enjoy story that persists. And so I love Hollywood movies that are spectacle and story. But because building story and manufacturing in such a day and age, Devin, as we’ve discussed, people just churn out story that is sometimes a little empty. And I’m not saying that’s the studio or independence. That’s all across the board.
Devin: Well, and it’s not necessarily like the instead of being creative with story, they threw money at it. But I think the equivalent, if we were trying to from a writer standpoint, when Tarantino, to use that example, when he’s writing something, knowing that he has $100 million to work with, and that can become the detriment to a really tight, creative story. The same thing, I think, from a novel standpoint is you don’t have a page number that you have to stop at. So I think sometimes when the story kind of can get away from you, if we’re trying to find an equivalent for writers here, and between screenwriting and novel writing, I think, I think the endless page numbers that you can go for, you know, of course, there’s exceptions that if you have a publisher, that’s like, this is the, this is what we want you to come in at. But that’s where, you know, it’s a similar thing to throwing money at a problem rather than in trying to write around a problem.
Adam: The difference between filmed media, meaning movies. Television or film or online series, anything like that. And novel, novel writing, prose writing, short story writing is, as Devin is saying, page length, you have the ability to describe more. However, in a novel, if you’re overdoing it in terms of your description, in terms of your visual landscape, your artistic aspect of the novel, and not balancing that with some of the previous topics we’ve talked about, character, plot, conflict. You’re also not doing an appropriate job of time management for your reader, just as a viewer with film. If you have lost your reader because you’ve gone too far into the, like you’re saying, the ability to describe, which film doesn’t give you, the ability to go in the internal space of a character, which film doesn’t easily give you, you want to make sure you’re not also wasting pages like film would minutes in novel land.
Because if you lose your reader, they put the book down. Just as watching 120 minute, 90 to 120 minute feature film, or a 22, 45 minute episodic television series, or online series, as a novel, if you can’t get them to go on to the next chapter once they’ve gotten to the end of that, and they put the book down and go to sleep, or they put the book down and go to, or they stop in the middle of the chapter, you have to make sure that even though you have the ability to paint a broader picture, time wise, that you don’t lose your audience in the details.
Devin: Right. The goal in any storytelling is to have the audience want to continue to learn more and continue on the journey. So that’s, there’s the rub. There is the rub.
Adam: I wanted to say one thing for anybody who’s starting out. I know we have a lot of listeners who are young writers and not quite sure where to start or, because there’s not a lot of available creative writing courses when you’re starting out. And to try to navigate that is difficult. As a young writer, you may not know what your voice is at first. Early years, I think, are spent imitating your favorite authors and your favorite playwrights and screenwriters and novelists. But imitation is not the name of the game. That’s why you see Devin getting so riled up about genre. You put anything in the box and that guy’s coming out like a pugilist, fighting mad.
You don’t want to put anything in the box. That’s not the name of the game. Originality is. Innovation. Innovation is. Tone and style ultimately should become your voice. What you’re working on, what you’re trying to say in your stories. And a lot of the folks we’ve mentioned throughout this episode, they’ve worked many, many years. And so now you know their voice distinctively. You have to nurture that aspect of yourself, that voice in yourself. What do you as a person? As a human being, have to say to the rest of us. You’ve had an individual and unique experience from anybody else in this world. And so if you’re going to tell a story, what do you have to say? What do you have to say? It’s easy to imitate. I’ve read scripts, which are simply imitations of that writer’s favorite writer, which is fine if it starts derivative. It doesn’t make it a good story. It actually pales in comparison. But you have to start somewhere.
For me, I imitated authors when I first was writing early screenplays. As my buddy Gene Lynch said about theme, what are you trying to say? It’s not just about that. How are you saying it?
Devin: We’ve talked about Vogler. We’ve talked about Campbell on here. And I think it’s important to study and learn about not only how other writers, their voice and their style and things like that. You as a person, it’s appealing to you from an audience standpoint. It’s obviously appealing to a large audience. But it’s also from a process standpoint. And there’s these other things that it’s important to study them. But imitation isn’t going to get you anywhere. And I think as long as you just continue to write and write and write and write, I think your voice will come to you. And I don’t think it’s something to search for. I think it’s actually something that once you start writing enough, that voice will just start coming out of its own shell in a way.
But it’s like Adam said, you don’t just simply imitate. You’re imitating your favorite author or your favorite filmmakers and things like that. That’s, you know, that’s not going, it’s not original. And it’s not going, it’s not genuine. And it’s probably, it’s even harder to maintain a voice that you’re imitating rather than finding your own. That’s all I have to say on that.
Adam: My best advice in terms of this abstract angle of tone and style and voice is be brave and honest with yourself as a person and put that. That’s probably the best advice I can give to any young writer approaching tone or how they’re saying something is say it your way. Please subscribe and rate us on iTunes. And for additional story related resources, video and archived content, visit our website at StoryOsophy.com.
We’ll see you next time.