Show notes
What is a story really about? Adam and Devin dig beneath the plot to find theme, the central idea that glues a story together. They explain why a theme is not the same as a moral, why it usually shows up during the first draft rather than before it, and how a thematic question pulls the audience into the hero’s shoes.
In this episode
- The oyster and the pearl. Plot is the shell, character and action are the body, and theme is the pearl. Like grit irritating an oyster, conflict disrupts the ordinary world and forces the change that creates it.
- Theme versus moral. A moral tells the audience what to think. Theme is broader, and audiences today would rather discover meaning than be preached to.
- Let the first draft find it. Start with a single word such as love, sacrifice or betrayal, write, and sharpen the theme in later drafts so every scene supports it.
- The thematic question. Adam and Devin prefer a question to Lajos Egri’s premise, because a question demands an answer. Passengers asks it outright, and Arrival asks whether you would change anything if you could see your whole life.
- Disney’s “I want” songs. Howard Ashman brought the Broadway moment where the hero declares what they want into Disney animation, from “Part of Your World” to “I’ve Got No Strings.”
- Be careful what you wish for. Pinocchio and Passengers share a theme: wishing another person into your life, even if it puts them in danger.
- The holographic image. Adam pictures theme as an object in the middle of a circle of characters. Each one sees it from a different angle, and the protagonist and antagonist stand on opposite sides.
- Meaning left to the viewer. David Lynch builds moving paintings rather than messages, leaving the meaning to each viewer.
Examples discussed
- Passengers, Arrival, I Am Legend, Cast Away, The Little Mermaid, Pinocchio, Frozen, The Nightmare Before Christmas, Alice in Wonderland and Little Shop of Horrors.
- Also: Lajos Egri’s The Art of Dramatic Writing, Pixar, and David Lynch’s Twin Peaks, Blue Velvet and Lost Highway.
Next episode: tone, style and genre.
Read the full transcript
Transcribed automatically, so expect the odd misheard word. Sponsor messages are left out.
Adam: Hello, welcome to StoryOsophy. This is Adam Jones. And Devin Halden. This episode, we’re talking about theme. The theme of a story is the central idea or belief of the story. It’s oftentimes in a more classic literature way called motif. A motif is a distinctive feature or dominant idea. In an artistic or literary composition. It’s also, in visual art, a decorative design or pattern. In music, it’s a short succession of notes producing a single impression. And so, with those different definitions of motif and theme, I wanted to bring up motif because I think this day and age, theme is somewhat overused as a word. With websites and decor and things like that.
And so, we wanted to specify what theme actually is in relation to a story. It is not plot. It is not conflict. It’s not the chain of events or the sequence of events, the plot, the storyline. And it’s not the forces of antagonism in opposition. It’s something that’s different.
Devin: Right. Theme is what lies under the surface. One way I like to look at story is as an oyster. Right. And so, if you look at… If you look at an oyster, the plot would be the shell kind of encompassing everything. On the insides of the oyster is the organs, the muscle tissue, etc. This represents your characters, the actions, the movements of the story. Then, if you look deep, under all of these surfaces, you’ll find a pearl. And this pearl represents the theme of the story. And so, the thematic DNA of the story is… Often focused on a question the hero is struggling with, and their answer becomes what the story is about.
So, if we really unpack and examine our oyster analogy, we will find that it’s remarkable how symbolic it really is of storytelling. So let’s, if you actually take a look at what actually happens for that pearl to be created within an oyster, essentially a piece of sand or grit finds its way into the oyster, and it becomes an irritant and an antagonistic parasite to the tender flesh of the oyster, disrupting the oyster’s ordinary world. And so in response, the oyster takes action by building up layers of, of calcium carbonate around the, this alien element, gradually growing the pearl. Usually takes years to grow the pearl, but that’s, that’s what, that is what is happening. That’s the broad strokes of what’s happening.
So had this bit of conflict and irritation not disrupted the oyster’s ordinary world and forced it to take action, that beautiful pearl would have never been made. So to try to bring this all together, our characters need a reason, a very important reason to take action and go on the quest. And without something disrupting their ordinary world, there’s no compelling reason for them to change, which is the most important.
Adam: The pearl, I would consider that if you’re using an analogy, the pearl of wisdom, that would be the, the, where the theme actually registers with the viewer. You, you go through the entire story to get to something where, as we’ll talk about a little bit later, one of the primary aspects of story where you get to catharsis, not just the characters who’ve gone through the events, but you, the audience who’ve gone through the events with them gone through this, there’s a cathartic experience. And then there’s something that. Something that you glean from that on the other side or in the depths of it, if you will, in the, the oyster analogy.
And it’s this pearl theme is, is tied into a lot of, I would say the concept of wisdom. A lot of times theme will in more moralistic things, it will come off as a moral, you know, if you do this, then this will happen. That’s a really preachy sort of theme and you’ll see it in sometimes in fables or in. Older stories that they’ll, at the end of it, they’ll say, here’s the moral of the story and it’s really the theme, but it’s from a very straightforward. Yeah, it was straight. Well, moral, it’s very specific morals and it’s a very specific way of looking at a thing.
And so it’s very, it’s very, it’s sort of limit. A moral is limiting a theme. The theme is a little broader than the moral, but a lot of people will make it one of the same. And for me, the stories that I really identify with the stories that I love have a strong theme that sort of glues it all. It’s not just a series of events that’s super entertaining and things blow up or they’re thriller moments or there’s some depth to it.
Devin: And I’m glad you brought up fable. Cause I think from a, if you’re actually looking at it from a writing standpoint, you’re sitting down to write and we’ve talked about the important development process of story, whether it’s character development, understand your characters before you start writing, understand kind of where you want to end up, where are you going to start and how are you going to get there? Or how are you going to start? Where? You want to end up, how are you going to get there? But unlike those elements of story where you want to have a good grasp on them and within the development process, theme is something that you don’t necessarily want or need to have to know exactly what your theme is about.
I think, I think let the story tell you what the theme is because you kind of run the risk of, of if you start with a theme becoming all these mini fables that are strengthened, they’re trying to confirm that theme. Or become your scenes throughout the story. And we could, could sound preachy because you’re trying to confirm that message in every scene. You may or may not be.
Adam: I mean, that’s, well, I would say you’re probably right. And most, most of those stories are preachy. That’s how they read because that’s the intention that they were written with. I know it sounds weird, but I feel like this day and age of storytelling and humanity, people are interested in discovering things for themselves. There’s a lot of information available because of the internet. Worldwide. And so discerning and choosing and thinking is a huge part of the human experience these days. When back then there wasn’t so much of the pervasiveness of information or communication. And so you relied on someone who knew more teaching you to survive and be safe and stay.
So fables were great for, and a lot of sort of even religious teachings were great for those time periods because they were trying to evolve and teach people. And things have changed a little. But so the storytelling style, I believe more people would like to experience than be told what to do in their stories to be preached to.
Devin: You’ll see these press junkets with the writer, the director, usually, usually not the writer. Writers usually don’t get that kind of credit. But when they’re, and the press will ask, you know, what’s this about? And everybody tries to find these deep meanings and they try to put everything into a box. Like this movie, this is exactly what that movie’s about. And I think theme is one of those awesome story elements where it’s interpreted by the person who’s consuming that story. And who, and how, what, whatever happened in their past and whatever happened with them and where they’re at right now watching it is how that theme is being related, is relatable to them. And I think even if you watch, you know, you watch a Disney, we’ll talk about later how great they are a theme, but if you watch a Disney movie when you’re a kid and how that relates to you, and then you rewatch it as an adult after going through all these different experiences, all of a sudden this theme to you and what that, what that story means and what it represents is can be very, very important.
And so I think theme doesn’t necessarily have to, you don’t have to.
Adam: Well, you’re talking, that’s layers too. Right, right. That’s something, and a lot of cartoons and animation and children’s family fair kind of stuff has those layers because if you’re going to be watching it with your children, you, the parents should absorb it and find some cathartic experience on their level, you know, so it should have a growth point for themselves as well. Right. Usually there’s so many layers in movies like that, that appeal to a universal audience. A broad generational audience.
Devin: That first draft, you let the story tell you what it wants to be. You figure out what that theme is. And once you’re confident in what that is, you can then go back and make sure your characters and the events that happen in every scene strengthen or confidently interprets that, that idea or that ideal.
Adam: I would say this too. For those of you out there listening who are parents, it’s a lot like good parenting. You observe or you just allow your child to develop in their formative years and you watch. Watch where their interests are. If they’re more artistically inclined, if they’re more physically inclined and you, you sort of help to nurture or support them in that direction. So you don’t figure it out at first. You let them figure themselves out. And I think if you treat a story as organically as a human being and go, it’s just going to become what it is. And then you can help to shape it to be that the best version of itself.
It can be by its own standards or once. I think the first draft is sort of, as you’re saying, you just want to play. Mm-hmm. Yeah. I tend to, in my first draft, bounce between structure and scripting. And so my second draft, I, in between, structure something and then execute the second draft. But by then I figured out what my theme is. The second draft, before I start that, it’s really important for me to understand what the theme is. Because the theme is what glues everything together. It’s invisible. It’s invisible glue, but it gels the entire story together. Mm-hmm. Even if all of your characters. Especially when you have a large ensemble cast and it’s hard to keep track of everybody because they have all these different perspectives.
It’s easier to understand, well, that person feels this way about the topic that everyone has some perspective on. You can navigate characters easier and you start to understand what everybody wants. And when you’re looking at theme, when you’re writing theme, even if you do decide to start writing in theme early, because I’ve figured out my theme in my first draft and sort of written, played around with it in there. But I think. I think it, it congeals, it solidifies a little better in later drafts.
Devin: Right.
Adam: When you, when you’re trying to execute your theme, when you’re trying to figure it out, when you’re trying to write, you don’t want to get too judgmental or moralistic. Those are words that we’ve been using, but you don’t want to approach it like that in your way of thinking about the theme. You want to leave that up to more narrow-minded characters.
Devin: Mm-hmm.
Adam: But for you as a writer, try to see every possible perspective. Mm-hmm. Because if you, you can, and I’m not saying that you shouldn’t use, those perspectives, you can have a character who has that perspective. But if every character has that same perspective based on theme, it’s a very narrow-minded, story. It’s a very narrow-minded point of view. So be the broad-minded writer and allow yourself to explore that mind space and give perspectives to different characters.
Devin: The way I look at, at it is the theme of the story is defined in part by the conflict or the obstacles that the hero will face in the story, which we went over.
Adam: Devin said it as succinctly as you probably can. Plot is what’s on the surface. Theme is what lies underneath the surface. A story’s theme oftentimes is summed up in a single word, love, death, betrayal.
It sort of boils down to a common central idea, sort of like if you were to put your characters in a circle around the idea, it’s the central part. It’s the hub, the spoke. I mean, not the spoke, the hub, not the axle. What’s the center part of the wheel called? Not the fulcrum, but- It’s a hub. Axle.
Devin: I’m over it. I’m over this analogy. I saw you floating out there, but I looked around and I didn’t have a life raft.
Adam: You know, common themes are just things that a lot of people, human beings in general, humanity, deal with. And that’s sort of what a theme is in its basic form. Now, we’ll talk a little bit later about the writer, Lajos Egri, who wrote The Art of Dramatic Writing. And in that, he describes a premise, which is, it’s the same thing as a theme, really,
Devin: The way he uses premise.
Adam: But it is more of a statement rather than a single word. Some of the common themes are sacrifice, friendship, loss, despair, honor. Freedom. There are so many different ones you can choose from, but a theme is usually built from countering ideas, which assist in growing your forces of antagonism. A lot of which, what Devin was talking about before, is conflict is not the theme. But when you choose the theme, you know the fulcrum bar of the seesaw- There you go. On which either side of that force will sit. The fulcrum bar is the theme, and then you’ve got a protagonist whose point of view we’re telling the story from, and an antagonist whose point of view is opposite of the protagonist.
So opposite sides of the spectrum, opposite sides of the stick.
Devin: I think if you want to start theme, that one word that you’ve just described, like love, friendship, revenge, unity, relationship, sacrifice, loss, that’s a good place to start. And then from there, you can define. That thematic question that is a little bit more story specific to your, to that story. Because the way, and we will get into thematic question in a bit, but the way that I look at theme is it’s defined by that, that the conflict or the obstacles that the hero is facing throughout. The story. And we went over conflict a couple episodes ago. And the thematic DNA of the story. Is answered through this thematic question that, that you derive based on, on what, what your hero is going through.
And so office focus, office focused on that thematic question of the hero is with the hero struggling with, and their answer becomes what the story is actually about. And I, so I think that’s, it’s a good place that, that one figuring out that one word theme of, of.
Adam: It’s a good first draft place to start. It is. Yeah. One word. Yeah. It’s, it is. So the plot has a super objective for the protagonist, the hero, the main character. And that is what we would call the dramatic question. Will they succeed in said objective or not? That’s the dramatic question of the plot. Devin and I, in order to help to streamline the way we navigate theme, because it is such an abstract notion in story, is we have the thematic question.
Devin: You can start with that one word that’s encompassing your theme, and then from that, you, you actually look at your story and your characters and what’s going on, and you develop that, that thematic question, which is often simply just asked by the writer to the writer, and translated through… Philosophically. Yeah, it’s very more, yeah, and translated through the characters and their actions on screen or on the page, but can also be literally asked within the story. You had a good example for that.
Adam: I have two examples of that, and we’ll, we’ll give a spoiler alert to one of them. Let’s define what the thematic, what the purpose of our thematic question is. In terms of writing, because theme gets, it’s the, out of the major elements of basics of storytelling, your toolbox, theme is the one that most writers drop the ball on. They don’t, because it’s fairly invisible. It’s abstract. So the thematic question, the reason why we use this for each other and within scripts and consultations and development, is it poses a question which requires an answer.
Devin: Right.
Adam: And Devin and I are very much in a set up and pay off, because that’s, I mean, that’s the human experience, folks. We’re curious about something, and we want to know the answer. We ask, and we find the answer. Problem, solution, puzzling, it’s just human curiosity. So if you build the question in, you have… You have to answer the theme. And I think this is very much like the example you were about to give. I love this example when he mentioned it to me. I was like, oh, it’s so dead on.
Devin: Right. And I think just before I get to the example, I think the thematic question is how we as writers pull the audience in, and we put the reader or the audience in the shoes of the hero or the main character. It’s, you know, what would I do if I was faced… The minute that thematic question is asked, it’s… Either subconsciously or consciously, the audience almost instantly asks themselves the same question that the main character is having to ask themselves. It’s like, what would I do if I was faced with the ultimatum of accepting the call and going on the journey or allowing fear or my current character flaws to get the best of me and retreat from that situation except to call the request?
Adam: You spark something in it when you said subconsciously and consciously. And I would say… Yeah. That was a great way of posing the whole setup payoff spectrum. At first, it is subconscious to character and audience, that philosophical question. And by the end of the story, that’s the pearl that you get is the conscious understanding of… Right. You have this personal, like, realization moment, and it’s… Like I said, it’s catharsis. It’s personal experience. But you said it perfectly right there. At the beginning, it is subconscious. It is subtextual. It is subplural. It’s sub. It’s under the surface. And by the end, it becomes a conscious realization for both character and audience.
It’s great words. Perfect words for setup payoff.
Devin: And it’s that question. Like you said, the question has to be answered. Consciously. Right. And if it gets to the point where the question is posed and the question that the hero decides not to answer that or not to do it, then you, you know, cue the Price is Right fail horn. There’s no story to tell anymore.
Adam: So it’s like, all right, well, that’s over with.
Devin: It’s like… So…
Adam: Well, and real quickly about the thematic question, the answer to it. A lot of times it’s not overt and the audience actually answers that question in their own mind or in their own, you know, essence, the way they feel about it. They don’t necessarily… It doesn’t even have to be spoken out loud. Or like music, broken down to be understood, you feel it. That’s what’s beautiful. I think this is why I like the theme so much is it’s a very experiential part.
Devin: Right. And I think it’s really the, it’s the creative umbilical cord or the theoretical umbilical cord that actually connects the audience to the story. And if it’s a really well done theme and it’s well, it’s posed really well, then there’s, it becomes a much more personal journey for that audience member. And a good example of thematic question stated openly in the story, like stated, literally the main character says this out, you know, openly. It doesn’t necessarily have to be the case, but in Passengers, Chris Pratt’s character, basically he wakes up way earlier than he’s supposed to on the ship that’s going to this new planet. And he realizes that for the next 99 years, I think it’s 99 years, he’s going to literally be alone.
So by the time all these other people wake up and they’re in these pods that keep them alive. Hibernation pods, right? Yeah, kind of dormants them. And so by the time… They won’t age at all. By the time they get to this new place, they can, the computers will release them and then they can start this new colony of people. But Chris Pratt’s character wakes up too early, his pod malfunctions, and he realizes that he’s going to spend the rest of his life alone. And he’s young, he’s in his 30s, and so he’s going to spend the rest of his life literally alone, but surrounded by people in these pods.
And so he finds himself with the only person, there’s this droid or this robot bartender that has become his only friend. And it’s an AI, which is, that’s another theme or another interesting part of this where, yeah, he’s a robot and he’s a very intelligent robot, but it’s not a human. So there’s this still, this yearning to be with another human. And so he literally asks this bartender, you find this perfect woman right in front of you, but she’s completely out of reach. You’re trapped on an island all alone. And you had, so if you’re trapped on an island all alone, and if you had the power to wish someone there with you, but knowing you were sentencing her to life on the island to say you found a way to make your life 100% better, but it was wrong, and you couldn’t take it back. How do you do the math on that?
You know, sometimes it’s a selfish, the answer is a selfish answer to this theme. But it’s this question that’s, the story has posed to him, but he’s actually posing it to, you know, to himself as well. It’s like, I could wake this person up and we could, I could have this human companion and we could live together and I would be able to, you know, it would make me happy. But in doing so, I’m doing, doing that knowing I’m bringing her, it’s a death sentence. I’m actually taking her and waking her up. And she’s also going to, and then it’s just, just going to be the two of us that are going to live for the next 99 years alone.
Adam: And what if she doesn’t like me in this futuristic Adam and Eve story? Yeah, it is. What if she doesn’t like me? It’s so good. Can you imagine like just staying on the only person that you have companionship with and you just don’t get along? It would be terrible. I mean, you got 99 years to try to figure it out, I guess, but. So he poses the thematic question, but that movie by its conclusion answers. However, those two characters end up by movies. The end is your answer. And so in that circumstance, we won’t spoil it completely, but in that circumstance, the setup is not a subconscious implied question.
It’s, it’s almost flipped on its head in that way. The thematic question to set up is a very conscious, overt philosophical statement to a bartender who is, which is clever. And then the ending of the movie becomes the subconscious or implied answer. How it turns out is the thing that, do you know what I mean? It’s unique in that way, how it addresses theme. Like I said, Devin is always listeners. Devin has the greatest examples, always great examples.
Devin: And what’s great about that thematic question that’s posed uniquely posed directly, like openly and stated openly within the story is it instantly makes you think, what would I do in this situation? What if? Yeah, what if? What if I was in that situation? And you’re like, man, it brings you into the story is what I’m saying. Instantly, you’re, you’re, you are part of Chris Pratt’s character. You are like, wow, I’m there with him. And now I feel I’m feeling this. And because they do, the story does a great job before he makes this decision to wake her up and take her out of the pod. They do a great job of showing the loneliness of being on this ship and how he’s trying to cope with it.
And trying to, you know, it’s, it’s very similar to I Am Legend with Will Smith, where he’s, he’s alone in this dystopian future where I think it’s New York or I forgot what city he’s actually in, but maybe Chicago, New York, but he’s in the city. And so he has this routine to keep himself sane in a way. And he’s has this, his companion, his only companion is his dog. And, you know, he has this routine where he goes and he talks to mannequins within the store. And, and, you know, so there’s. There’s these coping mechanisms that can only last for so long. And then in the case of Chris Pratt’s character in Passengers, it became too much where he just needed that human connection.
Adam: Both those examples and even Tom Hanks in Castaway. Anytime you have like a solo performance, usually the performer has to be really charming and captivating as an individual, which all those are perfect example. All three of those people are, but they endear you to them just by their presence. Right. And Chris Pratt is awesome for that. He’s, he’s great. He’s the, he’s the new everyman. He’s, everybody can relate to him very easily. Right. But it’s sort of interesting in that way too, is sort of you, if I were in that circumstance, what would it be like for me? And if you can. Feel how those performers are portraying that role for yourself and go, yeah, yeah, yeah, I get it.
Devin: Yeah, the second example I had is from Arrival. This is another spoiler alert, right?
Adam: Neither one of these is really spoiler alerts. It’s the end of it. Yeah, but it’s… It’s the end of it. But I won’t… End of a movie I consider a spoiler. I had someone do that to me the other day. They were like, hey, by the way, let me tell you the ending. I didn’t tell you spoiler alert first. You just ruined my viewing.
Devin: I’m only going to give the thematic question with this. I won’t even give any background on it, but it’s just the question itself. Oh, yeah, you could do it with that one. Yeah. Yeah, yeah. So the thematic question in Arrival is, if you could see your whole life laid out in front of you, would you change anything?
Adam: Especially if, or in the case of whether it’s positive or negative. Right. Whatever that prediction of your life may be, yeah.
Devin: So basically what those examples are is really good ways of posing something to your main character. But it’s… It’s also posing it to the audience. And then that’s what’s kind of, you know, makes them one with that main character. And I think, you know, and I think we’ve all thought about that. It’s like, if, you know, that’s why people go see psychics and things like that. You know, they… Do you want to know that? Do you want to know what the future lies? And if you do…
Adam: Well, once you believe it, believing is seeing, right?
Devin: Right.
Adam: What the thinker thinks, the prover proves. Believing is seeing. Right. Those are two very overt themes. And generally, the theme is implied. Do you have a great story in mind? Some great characters? All these cool scenes and you don’t know what order to put them in? What goes here? What comes next? Story Blueprint is an app that provides a powerful and versatile tool to help you, the writer, build the roadmap of your story. Know where your story is going to start, where it’s going to end, and how you’re going to get there before you even begin writing. Once you have your blueprint completed, you’ll have a bird’s eye view of your story.
Story Blueprint is currently available in the iTunes App Store for iPad. Coming soon for iPhone and Android.
What about if you already have a finished script and you want feedback on how to improve your story for the next draft? Maybe you’d prefer a personal walkthrough to talk your story out one-on-one. Well, StoryOsophers, you can always talk to me. I offer a variety of supportive services from feedback for finished scripts to script doctoring and company consultations. I’ll diagnose your story to make sure all its parts are working toward the whole and strive to find a balance between traditional structure, storytelling innovation, and the writer’s personal voice and lens. I also do ongoing story therapy for writers who are looking for a coach to help build their story.
I ask you the questions that help you find your own story, and we discuss how to mine its gems. Consultation services are also available to directors and actors looking to break down scripts into beats and super objectives, and to production companies looking to refine their script. For more information and a full menu of story doctoring options, you can visit doctajones.com. That’s D-O-C-T-A Jones dot com. Links to both Story Blueprint and Dr. Jones consultations can be found on our website at StoryOsophy dot com. You have to be pretty crafty as a writer to make sure that you bury your theme in front of everything.
If you’re going to say it blatantly, When a theme is usually the thing that you, it’s the buried treasure, it’s the pearl. If you’re, if you’re going to say it overtly, make sure it’s strong or make sure your setup payoff scenario in the theme is strong. Because if not, once again, preachy and moralistic.
Devin: If you think about passengers, actually, I love the way that they posed it openly and him talking to this droid, you know, just the symbolism of him. His only companion is a, is a robot. The robot can talk back and forth to him. It’s kind of going along with lines of all this huge AI boost of the world where everybody thinks we’re going to have these robots or whatever. It’s like, but guess what?
Adam: We are going to have robots.
Devin: You can make a robot as smart as you want and intellectual and be able to, to have a, true conversation, but it’s never going to be a human. It will never be another human. And there’s something that you can’t get from a robot that you have to, that you need from a human. And I think that’s, so even with passengers, like they stated openly, but there probably would have been a way where the audience still would have been asking themselves that question. And the main character still would have been asking that question without having to state that.
Adam: That’s a moral question. That’s an ethical question that he asked himself. Is it okay? Right. Is it a bad thing? I mean, that works in that circumstance because it’s, it just does. But in general, I think trying to narrow down your theme to a question of, is it good or bad to do this? Is it right or wrong to do? Is it correct or incorrect to do this? Is a terrible place to start. Right. Because then you’re going to create a side, which you believe in, and then a bad guy.
Devin: Right.
Adam: Instead of.
Devin: And it always comes down to, if you, if you have to ask the question, you probably know the answer.
Adam: Right. So you don’t want to sort of, is it right or wrong to do this? You want to, you want to say stagnancy leads to ruin is a statement. It’s that sort of, this is more in the Lajos Egri vein of premise, but.
Devin: All of the things leading up to say, we’ll stick with passengers, Chris Pratt’s character and how endearing he is and how they, how the writer has made his character, you know, showing him how lonely he is and things like that. If you do that well. Him making that decision, which is a terrible decision to make. It’s literally like a prolonged murder. You’re on board with him. Yeah. You’re kind of like, I get it though, man. Like I, he needs, like, I feel so, you feel so bad for him. So it’s like, there’s.
Adam: Well, not just, not just feel so bad for him, but you also like him so much. You want him to have companionship. Right. Exactly. I wouldn’t want to be that way. It’s empathy. I wouldn’t want to be, feel that way. I wouldn’t want to be in that circumstance. So I wish for this. Zero. Generally what you wish for most people in life, you wish them well.
Devin: Right.
Adam: You know? And so you’re like, oh my gosh, I wish he had this, you know, mate. I wish he had, do it, do it, risk it. Right. It’s sort of like you’re cheering for him at a certain point and still nervous.
Devin: And if the writer, the writer made a good decision to not, to give this, I mean, there’s years in between him waking up early and him making this decision. If he would have woke up and within a couple of days, he’s like, screw this, man. I’m not going to do this alone. I’m going to wake her up. She’s hot. Then all of a sudden you don’t have that empathy or you don’t have that sympathy for them. You don’t have any of that for him. But the fact that he went years by himself, it was a good pick, by the way, Jennifer Lawrence was a great, great pick.
Adam: Story may have several themes, not just one theme, but sometimes a story much like how a plot is differentiated between the main plot and subplots in a storyline. Themes should have similar distinctions. If you do have several themes. There should be a main theme and then supporting or subordinate themes, themes that, help to, to compliment that main theme. I’ll tell you a good way that I approach theme and this will connect with the next episode that we’re going to do, regarding tone and style and genre. A friend of mine, another, film production friend of mine, Gene Lynch, he’s a master electrician on, on films.
I worked with him in New York when I was working up there. He also had worked in cinematography. He’d shot a lot in, Los Angeles and some other locations. And he was always very interested in what, what, what on screen, what you were trying to say. I, I had written a script and I was pitching him a scene that I was very specifically visual. And he asked me when I’d finished pitching to him, he goes, what are you trying to say with that scene? Basically, what is the meaning of that scene? And I did answer him. He was surprised that I had a good answer.
He said, most people don’t know what, what. What they want to say with it. I always know whatever I’m saying in a scene, whatever I’m saying visually, I know what I’d like to communicate in regards to that. And you should ask yourself that. What are you trying to communicate to your audience? What do you want them to understand? Even if it’s not overtly speaking, what do you want them to experience? And if you ask yourself that regarding the theme, like what, what is this story saying about this topic? What is it saying? I think that’s a great way to sort of help to narrow down the focus of, of theme.
It’s a good question to ask. I’m not saying that that should be your thematic question, but that question will help you to find your theme. Gene’s great. I, he taught me a good deal about navigating story. And I learned so much from my time in, film production in New York from just all the different departments. Like we’ve talked about before, Devin, if you want to conduct the orchestra, producing, directing, writing, anything. That’s a broad viewpoint. Learn the departments, learn all the pieces that make it come together because it is a collaborative and co-creative, industry film manufacturing.
Devin: If you want to be involved with, with anything, really understand, you don’t have to be an expert in every department, but you should have a good general knowledge.
Adam: You have to know how the violin is played. You don’t just pluck it like a guitar. You know, it’s got a bow and you know, it’s, you know, know enough to be able to communicate to your artisans and craftsmen. Exactly. Yeah. I’ve worked in every department in film and I’m, I’m not saying I’m brilliant at it by any means, but I’ve dabbled in it in small student films.
Right. You have to be respectful of those, you know, your fellow workers and, and artisans, craftsmen.
Devin: And that’s also why there’s a lot of actors that move into directing are really good directors because they know both sides of that camera and, you know, some things that they wish they had from a director.
Adam: Then they’re people persons, a lot of them. Mm-hmm. And so they’re good for being directors. They can, they understand this person is different than this person. So you communicate with them in this way. They’re malleable, they’re versatile.
Devin: I think probably the main theme of that whole scenario. Is understanding. It’s understanding what other people do that, what the, the complications that are involved with their position and things like that. That’s, that’s understanding. That’s being, that’s so you, it makes for a cohesive film and with film related is a cohesive production and understanding that, you know, some things you can’t, some things you ask for may be impossible to get.
Adam: It’s understanding and it’s, and it’s asking people to think beyond this thing. And so you don’t really. And we’re off on a bit of a tangent, but working with people within the industry, you don’t just want to say, do this thing you want to say, here is the goal. And have parameters to the goal, but you want them to use their creativity and expertise and their genius to bring this thing to a more improved, better level. You may dabble in departments, but you are not a DP. You are not a, if you are great, but my, my point is allow that person. And their, their ability.
Devin: In terms of, of writing, that concept is the same way. Like some people are really great at character development and they’re really good. Like I will be the first to tell you, I, my dialogue writing is not on par with some of the greatest dialogue, right? Not on par with Adam and really understanding, you know, trying to bring in subtext and things like that. But I, you know, from a, from a broader standpoint and from a story structure standpoint. I feel that’s where my, my, where I’m really, what I’m really good at, but I need just saying, man, I don’t really, I’m not going to learn.
I’m not going to try to try to learn more about subtext and writing dialogue or character development or having a good plot. Like you got to know that stuff to write and you may have a strength. You may be stronger in some areas and some elements of, of this story, but with it, you still want to make sure, you know, enough where if you’re writing with a partner. Or you’re giving it to an editor, you know, that, you know, you want to find an editor or a writing partner that is strong in some of those other areas. And then that’s where, you know, so you, you’re making the story as strong as possible.
Adam: And be comfortable with your own limitation in that way for that. The limitation is a bad word. I don’t like that word, but understand that bringing confidence in what you have and not a lot of people in working together. If, if they’re, they’re deficient in something, they tend to be defensive or nervous. Or if you’re comfortable with that part of yourself, then handing the reins over to someone who is much smarter in that area is easy. You don’t feel, you know what I mean? You don’t feel as guarded and it’s weird. Creativity is a strange arena, but we’ll, we’ll get into more of this stuff when we talk about co-creation and different stages of writing and the writing processes.
Just so people, if they want to do further reading and reference there, I mentioned earlier. For Lajos Egri’s book, The Art of Dramatic Writing. And so I just want to mention something about it real quick. He refers to a premise, which is the central idea of a dramatic piece of work. The theme is, it’s virtually the same thing. Although I think you can expand on theme more than what he calls premise. Still, it’s worth purchasing and reading that book. Like all the other books that we’ve mentioned throughout and authors we’ve mentioned throughout this first season. Because that’s how we’ve broadened our perspectives and viewpoints on stories, by reading multiple viewpoints. In his book, he also has a really great character dossier sort of example. But some of the premises that he, you know, lays out there, his are more a cause and effect sort of equation. That’s how he lays out a premise. That’s not necessarily my go-to, but he’s one of the few people that actually addresses it.
And some examples are like, honesty defeats duplicity, foolish generosity leads to poverty, ill temper leads to isolation, bragging leads to humiliation. Now, these are not necessarily all universally true, but it is a statement that the story is built around. That is not a plot. It’s the philosophical statement. Now, as I said, Devin and I prefer a thematic question because I feel like it, first of all, it inspires more creativity. To have a question, because you have to answer it. Having a statement, I mean, I don’t even know sometimes where to go from there. It’s not sparking anything for me.
Devin: Right, right.
Adam: I’ll talk a little bit more about how I angle themes in a minute, but I wanted to get into some of the examples that Devin had. I wanted to say this in regards to sort of theme and plot. Just how a character has what a character wants and what a character really wants that you find out by the end of the story. We’ve talked about that in previous episodes. A story has its plot. And then it has that much more deeper, meaningful aspect that gets you immersed and evolved. That’s the glue, like I said, that holds your characters together. The variety of perspectives. It glues them to the plot in which they make choices through these events.
Devin, I know you had some ideas that you, or some really good examples you had talked about. And just to preface this, Devin, I’m a, I wanted to work on this. I wanted to work for Walt Disney as an animator when I was a child. And I, that, you will never find a bigger Disney fan than Devin Halden. Devin is the, one of the biggest Disney fans you’ll ever meet. And I’ll let him speak.
Devin: No, I totally am. There’s a, there’s a bit of a nostalgia, obviously, with, with Disney. But then if you, when I actually started writing and getting involved with film, it was from a creative standpoint, you see, you know, from Walt all the way, you know, from Eisner who helped turn that company into Disney. And Iger now, there’s this incredible grasp of story and what connects with audiences that they’ve always had. There was in the 80s there, there was some experimental things going on there that led them a bit astray, but. Once Eisner came in and Katzenberg and they…
Adam: Hey, everybody experiments in college, man.
Devin: Right. It was always the 80s, 80s. Everybody was experimenting, no matter what you were doing.
But they came in and they turned, you know, with… While I was thinking about… You know, part of it was… Part of it, when I was thinking about Disney, I’m like, man, they’re really great at that. What Adam just talked about is that main character defining to the… Or yelling to the audience what they want and or… And then figuring out what they really want. And it was once… Like I said, Eisner came in in the 90s with Katzenberg and then they brought in Howard Ashman and Alan Menken who were very… Well-known on the Broadway and doing Broadway plays. And I know they both worked on the Broadway Little Shop of Horrors, but did you say that Alan was involved with the film too?
Adam: I believe he did the music for the film. And they wrote that one extra song. For the film version, the Frank Oz film version. You know, the end of the movie, The Showdown? Yeah. That’s not in the original musical. That’s one of my favorite songs too. Yes. And many, many… Many other, what, Little Mermaid as well, and so many, many other ones.
Devin: Yeah. So they brought in Howard Ashman and Alan Menken.
Adam: They did Little Mermaid, right?
Devin: Yeah, they brought them in, and that was actually the first one they worked on, but they did, yeah, they did pretty much anything, the entire 90s is when they, yeah, they turned everything around at Disney, and they brought in this Broadway tone and structure to the movies. But Howard Ashman pointed out that in every Broadway show, there’s always a scene where the main character is declaring to the audience what they want. And they brought that into the Disney movies and especially the animations. That scene is often done in the Disney animations through song. And like the Little Mermaid, it’s the scene where Ariel sings Part of Your World. In Frozen, it’s Let It Go. And I don’t know if you’ve heard that song. It’s a pretty good song. You should check it out.
In Nightmare Before Christmas, it’s Jack’s Lament. And Alice in Wonderland, it’s In a World of My Own. And Pinocchio sings I’ve Got No Strings. And so they’re singing the theme, essentially. And all of these moments are both telling the audience what the main character wants and declaring the theme. And so this under-the-surface DNA of what the story wants and what it’s truly about is expressed with the Disney song through this theme. The themes often involve this level of vulnerability or even sacrifice. So with the Little Mermaid, Ariel wants to be a part of this world that she currently, it’s impossible. She’s a mermaid and she can’t be human.
And so she makes this deal with the antagonist, Ursula, to trade her this beautiful voice she has for three days of being a human and being able to experience this unattainable world and be with this guy that she’s fallen in love with as she has watched him. While she’s in the water. And so on the surface, the plot, we see is what’s going on in the movie. But below the surface, no pun intended, the theme, we see a much more complex set of decisions that most of us have to deal with. Or that thematic question, what we have to answer in our own lives. And the minute Ariel makes this deal, we consciously or subconsciously ask ourselves that same thing.
Would we give up something that important to us, like our voice, to chase what we want and try to find love? And so Little Mermaid is kind of the epitome of what we’ve been talking about.
Adam: In terms of her voice and the bargain she makes, this sort of deal with the devil. Anytime there’s a deal and a time frame, like three days is the ticking time. Cinderella. Yeah. It’s all stakes again. What’s at stake? Her voice in three days. Yeah. I mean, think of how silly that is as stakes from a general movie or story standpoint. She gives up her voice in three days. But that’s the stakes. Those are the stakes of that particular story because her voice is the most valuable thing of that story. And so she’s giving up the thing that to her is very valuable, but she sort of takes for granted in a way. But Ursula Seawich sees it as valuable.
Right. Stakes, which we will cover in another episode, like a couple after this one, they’re unique. And if you can find your stakes. Yeah. For the audience, it’s easy for the audience to track your story, your setup. But those are very clear ones. She is sacrificing or giving up that thing, bargaining for that purpose.
Devin: Right.
Adam: You’re so right, man. There is what she wants and what a character wants and what a character really wants. And the theme is the sort of summation of that equation in a way implied.
Devin: Yeah. I’m actually using part of Pinocchio, the book, in a book I’m writing right now. And so I’ve been kind of entrenched. I’m kind of entrenched within this world of Pinocchio for the last year. And when I was thinking about the theme, I’m like, man, Pinocchio is a fantastic example for, and again, it’s expressed through, the theme is expressed through songs. I’ve got no strings. And so on the surface, Pinocchio wants to be, actually, Geppetto wants Pinocchio to be a boy. And so he actually makes a wish to make Pinocchio a real boy. And below the surface, the theme is that be careful what you wish for in a way.
Right. And in Pinocchio’s situation, sure, the wish comes true, and he’s now a real boy, but his naivete and his overtrusting, because he just doesn’t know how to be a real boy, it leads him into the clutches of Honest John, who brings him to Pleasure Island. And so it’s kind of this, if you look at it as, it’s just this classic story that every fall when high school grads leave their nests for the first time to go on to their, to go on to college.
Right. College. We no longer have these strings of home in our ever-watching eyes of our parents, but we don’t know what we don’t know. And our ignorance and naivete for this new world and the experiences oftentimes gets the better of us. And without the guidance of our parents, or the strings that we need, our geppettos, we find ourselves partying in on the sinful pleasure island that we, you know, through college parties and bars and things like that. And so there’s like this- So Pinocchio and Passengers actually have a very similar element of theme. And both Geppetto and Chris Pratt’s character answer the similar, a similar and somewhat selfish thematic question. If I could make another human and endure life with me, I would no longer be alone, even though in doing so I’m tearing them from a safe place and putting them in potential dangerous positions or dangerous place. So I thought there was a good connection there.
Adam: It is interesting. That is interesting. And I was going to say, even in your Pinocchio example, the idea of what we’ve talked about before of known and unknown world regarding setting and even the journey into plot. Pinocchio is kind of unique. Geppetto is the main character when we start, really. But Pinocchio ends up being the one we follow. So it has so many thresholds from known to unknown world. So good. Because Geppetto creates Pinocchio. And that’s a known to unknown world. Here’s the lonely man who creates the puppet boy and the puppet boy becomes a real boy, you know, or the puppet boy becomes alive, first of all, which is a crossing into a new threshold. And then as soon as that’s done, that character goes off on a journey into the unknown world for them.
Devin: They don’t give him control of his conscience. They give it to a freaking cricket, which is just great because now he’s-
Adam: Dude, it’s such a great story. Well, the Disney version is the cricket, right? The book is not-
Devin: Is there a cricket? Disney version, yeah. Jiminy Cricket did not exist in the book version. But since we were talking about Disney version, I was like-
Adam: Anyway, I just wanted to mention that there are several thresholds from known to unknown world right in the beginning of that story. Like, boom, boom, boom. And you’re like, holy. It’s one of those stories that, even though it’s an older story and a classic, many people- When you experience it for the first time, it has so many unexpected turns. Right. It really does. Right. It has so many different turns and twists to it. And you don’t really recognize it because they’re so fun and fantastic. How many more Disney examples do you have, Devin?
Devin: I’m stopping with those two. But you could literally- If you wanted to take any of these Disney, Frozen or Nightmare Before Christmas, Alice in Wonderland, you can take any Disney movie and they’re- Essentially, the whole reason why I went off on this Disney tangent was if you’re looking for really good examples of the things that we were talking about with theme and even- Even story structure in general. Disney’s really good at not only kind of making them stand out a bit, but the way they do it fits well within the way they tell the story.
Adam: Well, and especially in the musical version, what you’re saying about theme and stating the theme openly, your examples of openly stated theme-
Devin: Right.
Adam: Are good. You’ve got the musical, you’ve got the overtly asked thematic question. So musically, that’s- Disney excels in that. But also, even though it’s not really musical, Pixar is really good at-
Devin: Right. Yep.
Adam: Having a really strong theme and not necessarily- They’re really good at almost stating it overtly through their dialogue, but it’s always implied for them. I love Pixar movies. I love them.
Devin: Yeah.
Adam: Such craft. I wanted to mention something before we conclude this episode. For me, how I approach theme for myself, I use the analogy oftentimes of a holographic image. So if you imagine, like, let’s say some big item in the middle of a circle of characters, and they’re all staring at this thing. And that thing, that central hub, is the theme. Now, you can call it love. You can call it betrayal. You can call it innocence, revenge, sacrifice, law, whatever you want to call it. But each one of those characters is looking at that from a different vantage point or angle, all looking at the same theme of the story.
Yeah. And I like to think of that central object as a holographic image in this way. If I’m standing in character A’s shoes, like the main character, and looking at this thing, I see that central topic a very specific way. However, if I were to move just to the side into character B’s shoes, I would see that same central image from a different angle and would see a completely different image like you would in a holographic image. It’s just something completely different just from the angle you’re looking at it from. The way that I define protagonism and antagonism around that sort of central object is they’re just on opposite sides of the object.
They’re not seeing each other clearly because they’re staring at their perspective only. And so, you know, just like you would anything, characters are facets of the theme. The theme is like the emotional landscape, the philosophical landscape of a story. And so I feel like you can use characters. To paint different tones, different shades of that theme. In the next episode, we’ll be talking about tone and genre and style. And so I just wanted to round off this episode with, as Devin and I say in the first season, know the rules. It’s all about foundation and rules, the basics. And in season two, we’re still doing some basics and structure, but we’re going to blow the rules out of the water.
And so to end with this episode of theme, I just wanted to bring up a different style of approaching theme or meaning within a story. And I’m going to use David Lynch as my example. I love David Lynch. There are David Lynch pieces that I enjoy more than others. I think Twin Peaks might be my favorite. Blue Velvet, I also love. Lost Highway. But the interesting thing about David Lynch, and he’s very straightforward about saying this. I used to do a really good David Lynch impression. So maybe I’ll break that out at some point. He does not make a story with meaning. He does not put a theme into his story, really.
He’s creating a moving painting, a dreamscape, a thing for you to experience, for you as the audience member to attribute personal meaning to. And it’s a very unique way of approaching theme. A lot of artists do that. I want to say a lot of your indie or avant-garde, film makers, that’s where you’ll find a lot of that. I was going to say Jim Jarmusch is another guy in that department, coffee and cigarettes. But Lynch is particularly, he does it on purpose. He’s painting a painting. He’s creating a moving picture for you to experience from start to finish. And he’s not attributing meaning to it. There are connecting points.
Just like in a painting, it’s all about composition. It needs to feel composed properly. But as far as the meaning, he wants you to look at the painting and for you to have some sort of experience from it. And I sort of love the fact that he’s that. That free, even though he’s very specific about what the things look like, he’s not really specific about what he needs to say to you as the listener or the viewer. He’s very interesting in terms of theme and the meaning of his things. But we’ll get into him a little bit more in the next episode when we talk about tone and style and genre, because he’s more, he comes from that school more so.
I thought about him because I’m watching with tons of other people, the Twin Peaks, The Return. And I love it. I’m eating it up. I love it.
Devin: Yeah, I’m tempted to get Showtime. Did they release Twin Peaks all at once like they do on Netflix?
Adam: No, they did not. It’s weekly on Sundays. Kyle McLaughlin is killing it.
Devin: He is so good, dude. He’s so good.
Adam: I actually didn’t.
Devin: I never even watched the first one. I don’t think.
Adam: Watch it. Don’t watch this without watching the first one because it will be useless to you. Useless. I’m pretty sure I maybe saw a couple of episodes. Here’s why I like Twin Peaks. David Lynch pairs with Mark Frost. So he’s co-writing this with someone. And Mark Frost is much more interested in, even though it’s quirky and weird and funny, having it sort of grounded in some way. And so it’s a much more narrative version of Lynch. It’s easier to access. I’m telling you, you got to watch first season to understand what’s going on in this season and to end to actually sort of reconnect because these are all characters you’re seeing.
Like 25 years older. And so you want to know them when they’re younger and then see the evolution. Right? Right. So I wouldn’t suggest watching it until you watch the first part.
Devin: The fact that they’re bringing this back and this won’t ever happen with, but the show you turned, you turned me on to it. I think it was right when we first met during the film festival, Carnivale on HBO, how great that show was.
Adam: Because they worked the mythology and the mood and the tone, the tone. That’s a good tone show.
Devin: Yeah. The tone is fantastic.
Adam: Please subscribe and rate us on iTunes. And for additional story-related resources, video and archived content, visit our website at StoryOsophy.com.