Show notes
Plot and structure are where most writers struggle. Characters come easily, but getting them from the beginning to the end is hard. Adam and Devin define plot and structure, compare their own approaches, and share ways to cross the desert of act two.
In this episode
- A chain of events. Plot is a sequence of events, each link connected to the next. Structure is organizing those events so the story builds.
- Loglines. Boil your story down to one sentence. Devin writes his logline first, as a test that his ducks are in a row.
- Events and scenes. Each event is a decision point with two options. Sometimes one scene holds the call, the refusal and the acceptance.
- Every scene is a mini story. Objective, obstacle and outcome. An empty scene is a weak link, and the chain is stronger without it.
- Merge extra characters. One of the most common fixes Adam makes when consulting.
- The desert of act two. Everyone knows their beginning and end. Set buoys through the middle, starting with a strong midpoint.
- Puzzle and blueprint. Adam builds stories like a jigsaw puzzle, edges first. Devin uses a blueprint and a clock for spacing setups and payoffs.
- Measure. A page is a minute. Adam looks for movement every 15 pages, and the same idea works for a 500-page novel.
- Goodbye, not farewell. Characters should feel like they keep living after the story ends, like Marge in Fargo, still pregnant at the end.
Examples discussed
- Memento, Fargo, Sully, Twin Peaks and A Clockwork Orange, the novel and the film.
- Also: the Story Blueprint app.
Next episode: theme.
Read the full transcript
Transcribed automatically, so expect the odd misheard word. Sponsor messages are left out.
Adam: Hello, welcome to StoryOsophy. This is Adam Jones.
Devin: And Devin Halden. Yeah, that’s nasally.
Adam: I think you sound perfect. You sound sexy. I know your circumstances. I know where you’re recording and what’s going on, but the listeners don’t. And we’ll clue them in. They don’t know that we’re actually recording in two different locations. We’re hours and hours. We’re hours apart. We’re a time zone apart from each other. We are. And yet, you can still, you can feel, you can hear that love and camaraderie between the two of us. And time zone apart. With this episode, we’re talking about plot and structure. It’s one of the basic elements of story. Plot is, and we’ll discuss what that means for a moment.
And then we’ll talk about structure, what that means, and how you do it properly. How you plot and structure a story well. Or at least many ways to do it so that you can figure out your best means to plot and structure. I feel like, Devin, you probably would agree with me on this. I feel like plot and structure is where most writers have the biggest difficulty. I think character is fairly easy. Observing people throughout your daily life, you can sort of see people with different perspectives and choices and even physical attributes, age, job. It’s easy to sort of… Proliferate characters imagination-wise in your mind. But plotting is much like real life for most people where they’re presented with a choice and they don’t really know what to do.
And so writers, I feel like, come across the same problem. They have brilliant ideas for characters, but they don’t really know how to help navigate them through a story. And I think plot and also the topic we’ll discuss in the next episode theme are two of the biggest tripping blocks for… Most writers. Devin?
Devin: I agree. I think the fun part of starting to develop your story is getting to know your characters and coming up with some of the things that we talked about in the past episodes to kind of go along that building analogy where it’s kind of like you show up to a clean plot of land or a clean site and you have all of the tools and everything you need to build that house, but you don’t know where to put the foundation. You don’t know where to put the studs and everything like that. So you have all of the pieces you need. Now you got to figure out exactly, you got to plot exactly where all of those pieces go and how they’re going to interact within the world that you’re building.
And I know from my experience, I always thought I was, once I went through the character exercises of figuring out who my main characters were and got to know them really well and develop them really well, figured out my worlds. I had an idea of where I wanted to start and where I wanted to end up. I was ready to start writing and I soon found out that that place in between beginning and end, there’s a lot of details that I wasn’t, that I didn’t really plot out. So it’s very important.
Adam: Yeah. And I think for most writers, that’s an early writer’s mistake or not even a mistake. Let’s not call it that. That’s a poor choice. It’s an early writer’s stage. Because for me, whenever I start a script, I usually, I like free writing a little bit. I like observing people, collecting ideas. It’s more of a brainstorming stage. And so you tend to think once you’ve got all those pieces together for a character dossier, you’re ready to go. And you sort of are, you’re really prepared. As you just said, there’s like, whenever you’re approaching any sort of trade and writing is a trade. You want to have tools for your craft.
So, a lot of these things we’ve been, we’re discussing in the first season, they are your tools for your craft. If you know them and you know how to navigate them, you will have blissful fun creating a story. It will be artistic and pleasurable. If you don’t know that stuff, you’re going to feel what traditionally is called writer’s block. You’re not going to know where to go next. And if you know your tools well, inspiration will always lead you. To sort of begin with a plot, and we’re going to talk about two different notions within this episode, and one is plot and one is structure. And they’re very similar, but we want to make a distinction. So, I’m going to start by defining them a little bit. A plot is the events of a piece of work, a play, movie, novel, or similar piece devised and presented by the writer with an intentional sequence.
So, in short, a plot is a chain of events or a sequence of events. I prefer to call it a chain of events because, to me, each link should connect to the next. Devin used a domino analogy throughout this season, and I think it’s very similar. I like to call it a chain of events because each link, scene, or sequence, a link, you know, between them in a chain, it’s important. It’s a good visual.
Devin: It’s a good visual.
Adam: When you say macro, you mean when I say broad, when I’m trying to broaden a definition to get as broad a view as we can get. And I think they’re slightly different. We’ll define them as we go, but I agree with you.
Devin: And maybe using your chain analogy, you know the first link. You have that first link of the chain. You have maybe a couple other links that lead up to the middle link, and then you have the end link that you know for sure that’s how you’re going to end your story. And then it’s getting down to structure and figuring out, all right, now what are the links in between all those links that you know that are going to actually form that chain and everything is going to kind of flow correctly?
Adam: I think starting broadly like that with beginning, middle, end is good. If we talk about that, I think it’s the easiest way to access. Act one, act two, act three, we will pair with those, but we should talk about them independently because they sort of mean different things. And I think the three-act structure is rather specific to screenwriting. Stage plays have an intermission, and even Shakespeare has five acts, and novels are chapter-based. If you get too zoomed in on the concept of three-act structure, you start to miss the concept of beginning, middle, end, which is more important. Plot is a general term for story. It’s basically your storyline. That’s what plot is.
Plot can be boiled down or expanded. I find one of the most frustrating things as a writer is doing a full script for a television pilot, for a feature film, for whatever it is. But you’re telling a story in 90 minutes, in 120 minutes, 45 minutes. And then you still have to be able to take that plot, that storyline, and boil it down to its basics so that you can not just pitch it to someone who might be. Willing to co-create with you or fund it or a studio executive you’re pitching to in logline format. And a logline is basically a one-sentence pitch of your story.
But you also have to have a paragraph, a short paragraph description of it. You may even need a one-sheet, which is a one-page description synopsis of your piece. The reason I say I get frustrated with this is because I used to think it trivialized the depth and the detail and the nuance of the world and the characters. I built in a story the full depth of that story. And then I realized in terms of, especially in a fast-paced world of business, when you’re dealing with production and manufacturing of film or any sort of media, or even the publication of it, you need to be able to describe, not just to the person you want to work with, in brief, here’s the juiciest bit of it. Here’s the hook of it.
And get them interested enough to then describe to them the paragraph or full page or version of the storyline and get them to read the nuanced version. In addition to that, they need to be able to see when they are presenting it to someone who may have a more clout and the ability to green light a project or even in a way of pitching it or presenting it marketing wise to its recipient, the audience. How do they get this in one sentence? How do they get this with a hook? So just sort of like zooming in and out for plot, although the plot is the storyline, of the piece you’re, the whole storyline, the spine of the piece you’re working on, you need to be able to boil that plot down to its essence.
So if you can start figuring out what the essence is of your plot before it gets, you know, into progressive complications, sort of gluing the rest of the pieces of your story to that spine, it all will start to congeal and make sense and be a stronger story. I used to write the story. I used to write the script and then go, now, what am I going to do for a log line or a synopsis? And the way I build things now, I do both. I will start to think about what’s a, what’s a log line that would hook me into wanting to read the script I’m presenting.
And if you need an example of a good log line, just sift through any of your online platforms, Netflix, they’re usually one sentence long, Amazon, they’re one sentence just to whet your appetite. But that one sentence, even if it’s a long sentence, [unclear] And so zooming in and out while you’re playing with plot is important.
Devin: I actually think it’s a good place to start to once you have, again, if you’ve gone through the process of some of the prior episodes where it’s, you know, developing your character and your worlds and, and then you you’re figuring out your plot and things like that. Once you have all of that, if you can sit down and write a really good log line, and that’ll actually start with a log line and you can actually simplify your story and make it riveting and hook somebody in one or two steps. You got it. That’s kind of like the debug, the debugging process of my ducks seem to be in a row here.
And then you can actually go on and expand that into a paragraph synopsis or a full page synopsis and things like that. You can go on from there. But I think that from my standpoint, what works best for me is being so prepared before I actually sit down and start writing even a rough draft or a first draft that that makes the writing process. Way more enjoyable for me that I know where I’m where I know where I’m starting. I know where I’m going. I know what’s happening in between because I did all this this prep work for it. And then while I’m in there, of course, things are going to change or different ideas can come up.
And, you know, another thing that we that Adam and I and Adam’s really good at it. Setups and payoffs are kind of one of my favorite things.
Adam: They’re the juiciness of every story. They’re so juicy. Juicy. I think navigating your story backwards, nonlinearly to figure out your setups and payoffs is the key. What you’re talking about is leading us into structure anyway. And before we get there, I wanted to just define what an event was when we talk about a chain of events. The definition and the use of these individual events is what we will cover in season two of StoryOsophy. We’ll get more into structure specifically instead of basic elements and foundation, which is our. But in this episode, we’ll discuss generally the structural spine of the story. Like we said, beginning, middle, end, act one, act two, act three.
And those are comprised of scenes or events. There are scenes and events. We’ll discuss their flexibility, but sequences would also be extended events or extended scenes. Each event is a crossroads for a change in decision or an obstacle to strengthen some figurative muscle in the hero. So either they’re to alter their way of thinking, which is slowly building a different belief system, or they’re up against something, an obstacle, which they have to figure out and overcome. So it’s still a decision, no matter what, it’s a decision point. Each event should provide a decision point, two options, and the hero must choose. I think for me, that’s what defines an event.
Devin: I would agree. You know, as much as we don’t like boxes, in this season for Foundation, we need to sort of label things just so we have a common ground. I think sequence of events is how I would put it, and then within events, there are scenes.
Adam: Or a scene could be an event.
Devin: Well, that’s what I was gonna say. It could be one scene, which that event is, that scene actually is the event, or it could be a series of scenes that make up the event. And again, it’s, we’ll get much more in depth with this in season two. But just to kind of go over the…
Adam: Just as a brief example of where we both sort of connect on this, where scenes could be events, or events could be scenes, one could contain the other. Oftentimes, you and I have discussed this, we find that what’s called the call to adventure, or the call to quest, and subsequently a stage called the refusal to quest, or the refusal to the call to adventure. And then it’s followed by the acceptance. So the call to adventure, and those, each of those stages is very significant in showing the audience as a setting up for the audience, future growth for the hero. But sometimes, each of those steps is a different scene, and sometimes those steps are within one scene, and so that one scene contains those three events.
And it’s, this is one of the reasons why I love storytelling so much is, it’s like clay. Yeah. You can play with it a little bit and mold it and move it. It’s malleable, and that’s why I don’t subscribe so much to the dogmatic traditional structures of it, because I like to play with it more. I like to mold it and play with it more. That’s probably a good way to put it. The best example that I can use to put it, because I think you and I both have talked about that several times, the call to adventure and the refusal choosal.
Devin: It is. That’s a good example. Yeah, I could, I think you can come up with a bunch of different examples where that call, the refusal. And the choosal, where, then there’s also the ones where, within that same exact scene, all three of those events are happening. And even though they’re all different events, they’re happening within one scene. Hopefully that’s not, this isn’t confusing people right now, but.
Adam: It’s not, because, we’ll edit it and make sure it sounds smart. Oh, okay. Just to, want to take a little bit of time to differentiate between scenes and events, because sometimes they’re one and the same. And sometimes they contain each other.
Devin: One of the big things that I’ve learned through studying other people’s processes and how they write, and how they write scenes specifically, and dialogue and subtext and things like that, was looking at the scene, an individual scene, as also having a beginning, middle, and end. Each character goes into a scene with an objective, whether, for example, the hero is going into. A scene meeting up against the antagonist. So they both have different objectives and there’s an obstacle that both of them have to get across to make, to get to the outcome that they want. And so that’s where the, the real art artistry of writing a scene and actually thinking about those things and thinking about it as, all right, what’s the objective of the scene?
What’s the obstacle of the scene and what’s, you know, what is the desired outcome of these characters? And I think when I started. Looking at the scene structure that way, it really helped me zone in and make sure I’m moving the story forward at a, at correctly and not just have a, have a scene that maybe from a dialogue standpoint is, is rich. An empty scene. Yeah, empty. It doesn’t even need to be there.
Adam: It doesn’t do anything for the story. It might be a cool scene, but it just doesn’t do anything for the. It’s a weak link in the chain of events. If you remove that link. Right. The chain can still exist. Properly. It actually strengthens. If you remove the weak link in the chain, this is the interesting thing about writing. Sometimes you will write something and you will find a scene and be like, I love this scene. It’s great. And then you. Fall in love with it. Objectively look at it and it may be a great scene, but the way it fits in the story, it’s the weakest link in the chain.
And if you remove that link, the, the story itself, the spine, the, the, it becomes stronger. You sort of have to be able to. To understand what is the function of the scene. If it’s not moving the story forward, if it’s not revealing something or giving a realization or discovery, it’s just an observation from the writer. It’s a description, but nothing’s happening.
Devin: And it might’ve been something that we probably could have brought up when we were talking about characters. There’s a similar concept to that too, is where when you’re started starting to write and you’re having a hard time juggling or finding time or finding enough dialogue or, or page time or screen time. For some of these characters, sometimes you just have to take a look at all of your characters and maybe combining character traits of one character to another and make them one character. And so I think that also, we probably could have brought that up when we were talking about characters, but that’s also one of those things that make the story stronger. It’s also something to talk about maybe in a revision.
Adam: Because that’s one of the big fixes in a story. We’ll actually dedicate a whole episode to that. I run across that in almost every script I either write or consult on, is there’s an extra character. And if you take that character’s perspective and voice and just merge it with one of the other characters, the story becomes more focused. And it’s weird because it’s a common writer mistake. I’ve made it in almost every script. And then I go, I need to fix this. There’s too much time here. Oh, I’ll just make this person the same as, and merge these two people. That’s a really important point and something we should actually dedicate an entire episode to. So a scene structure mirrors the general structure of a plot where it has a beginning, middle, end. You had posed that beginning, middle, end sort of in a scene is objective obstacle outcome. I would say for the most part, it’s sort of mirrored in that broader viewpoint as well of a structure of beginning, middle, end, or in some stories or in film land, act one, act two, act three. We can broaden each of those a little bit and say the beginning could be the foundation, the essence. It’s your setup. When I think of scene structure, I tend to think of those three steps as setup, progressive complications, and payoff, which, once again, if you zoom out broadly to a general structure of a plot for a film or a book or an episode of a series or a series arc in general, that also works.
It’s setting up the story.
Sometimes, and I don’t want to put too many labels on beginning, middle, end yet, but sometimes they’re known as… Beginning is beginning. It’s the setup. It’s the foundation. It’s the beginning. But middle is sometimes called crisis, and end is sometimes called climax and resolution. They’re commonly thought of in those ways. Beginning is the foundation, and then there’s crisis, and then there’s climax and resolution. Now, we’re talking about a little more broadly, structurally, with beginning, middle, end, because even though this first season, we are… We’re dealing with the foundation of storytelling. Devin and I view this a little differently than most, and we even view it differently than each other.
I think Devin comes from a more house, real estate angle, and I come from more of a puzzle, jigsaw puzzle angle on the way we approach and build story. But it makes for a fun discussion. Structuring in its basic definition is this. Organizing the events in a build. The story has to build. It has to have progressive complications. And so, if the beginning is the setup, as Devin was using the analogy of the chains earlier, there’s a central… There’s a big link in the middle, the crisis, or the midpoint, or whatever you want to call it. And then there’s a larger link at the end. And so, between those links, the beginning, middle, end, there are builds. And I think calling a story beginning, middle, and end, we tend to forget about the builds.
And so, structuring is making sure those builds… Actually build and work from point to point. Right.
Devin: That’s what structuring the plot is. Well, starting with the definition and the word build is perfect for story because build can mean progress, and it can be… It means movement. It’s actually… It’s starting somewhere, and it’s… You’re building something, but it also means to raise and to rise. And so, with story, not only are you progressing, but you’re also… That tension and that motion, everything’s rising, and it’s going… It’s up. It’s building. It’s building up. And so, that’s a fantastic definition. And I think that’s also why I don’t like… It characterizes Act I, Act II, Act III. I think that’s just way too broad, and even beginning, middle, and end, because…
And I think where Adam and I both agree, beginning and end, no matter if we are looking at Vogler or Campbell or anybody else who we’ve studied in terms of beginning and end, So it’s pretty tight, and they’re fun to write. You understand it. But even in screenwriting, the beginning is typically, if you go by the box that they use for Act 1, Act 2, Act 3, Act 1 is pages 0 to 25, roughly. And then Act 2 is 25 to 75. And then Act 3 can be 75 to 90 or 75 to 100. So, you know, everything’s in 25 pages. Everything’s really, everything’s quick. Everything’s moving. And then all of a sudden, Act 2 happens. And I think Act 2 is more of like this deserted island. You’re in the middle of the ocean, and you look, you can’t see where you came from or where you started from. And then you can’t see where you’re going yet. And so a lot of times in between Act 1 and Act 3, you can lose your, you can lose course of where you’re going. Because if you don’t have that, you don’t have those buoys set up.
Adam: I would call Act 2 the desert or the ocean. You sort of are out in the middle of it, and you’re like, what? And I feel like that’s where almost every writer falls short. They, because they don’t know how to navigate it. Everyone gets sort of their Act 1, and everyone sort of gets their Act 3. But Act 2, they go, what? Right. And they have ideas, but they don’t link together. The chain falls apart in the middle, the chain of events. And a lot of it has to do with what you were saying much earlier in this podcast about, Right. If you do your prep work, that won’t happen. If you do your prep work, like I said, you won’t get writer’s block.
Do you have a great story in mind? Some great characters? All these cool scenes, and you don’t know what order to put them in? What goes here? What comes next? Story Blueprint is an app that provides a powerful and versatile tool to help you, the writer, build the roadmap of your story. Know where your story’s going to start, where it’s going to end, and how you’re going to get there before you even begin writing. Once you have your blueprint completed, you’ll have a bird’s eye view of your story, removing the anxiety. Story Blueprint is currently available in the iTunes App Store for iPad. Coming soon for iPhone and Android.
What about if you already have a finished script, and you want feedback on how to improve your story for the next draft? Maybe you’d prefer a personal walkthrough to talk your story out one-on-one. Well, StoryOsophers, you can always talk to me. I offer a variety of supportive services from feedback for finished scripts to script doctoring and company consultations. I’ll diagnose your story to make sure all its parts are working toward the whole and strive to find a balance between traditional structure, storytelling innovation, and the writer’s process. I also do ongoing story therapy for writers who are looking for a coach to help build their story. I ask you the questions that help you find your own story, and we discuss how to mine its gems.
Consultation services are also available to directors and actors looking to break down scripts into beats and super objectives, and to production companies looking to refine the stories in their slate. For more information, and a full menu of story doctoring options, you can visit doctajones.com. That’s D-O-C-T-A-J-O-N-E-S dot com. Links to both Story Blueprint and Dr. Jones Consultations can be found on our website at StoryOsophy.com.
I think structurally, you were talking a little bit about the build concept, and just for the benefit of our listeners, I’m going to lay out how Devin and I sort of look at things a little differently in terms of structure. I like building stories in a way that it’s like a puzzle that you have to solve. I like… I like peeling layers back from characters, or from a mythology of a story. And so it’s very engaging and immersive for a person, a thinking moviegoer. It’s something where you’re engaging the viewer in that way. And so… When I, the way I structure a plot or a story, I build it in a lot of the same ways as I would a puzzle or a jigsaw puzzle. For me, it starts with the parameters and the edges. Like, I, when I’m doing a jigsaw puzzle, I’ll pull out all the edge pieces first and the corner pieces. And then after that, I’ll move to, because that gives me my framework. Now I know the sandbox or the genre I’m going to be playing in. After that, I start to separate pieces by tones and colors, or if there’s prominent people in it, I start to distinguish my characters, but I look at it more like a canvas and a piece of visual art. At the same time, I use measurement, very specific measurement for myself to be able to track what I’m communicating in that piece. That’s a little bit of what I do, my process in approaching structuring a story as a puzzle type thing. But Devin and I have, and he uses that from time to time. His process is very much into layers. But his primary analogy is architecture, house, a blueprint. Devin, do you want to speak a little bit about the way you, I mean, you’ve, I know you’ve talked a little bit about rooms of a house, but.
Devin: Again, it’s just, it’s not really, they’re not very different. It’s just different perspectives and, and the analogies that we’re using, just how our. They’re helpful in different ways. How can you, it’s more about organizing it in your, in your own mind and how, what works for you? Like how, how are you able to picture what’s going to happen? And I think in the end of the day, the objective is. For both Adam and I is the same thing. We want to have a very well structured story, very creative story, a lot of setups and payoffs and, and deep characters and well-developed characters. And a lot of things are happening, but I think from my standpoint, I like to look at things from a bird’s eye view more.
It’s probably a better way to look at it. And you can do that with a puzzle too, but. And I think maybe a blueprint is a better analogy for me because it’s, it’s making sure you have everything in place before you start. Say, all right, now let’s go build this. Because you’re never going to build anything, a house of building anything, unless you have these blueprints, or you have these, this something laid out where you can look at it from, from. A bird’s eye view and see, all right, we’re missing something here. Like, if you don’t put a beam here, the roof is going to collapse or the second floor is going to fall on top of the first floor.
So from a story standpoint I like to make sure that all of my events are there. Everything’s moving correctly. There’s a good spacing. And that’s kind of what. Adam’s talking about his measurements. I like to have measurements. I like to make sure that my act two isn’t happening hour and a half into the movie. So I do like that spacing, but I also like to make sure. And so the blueprint is one thing. And then I’ll use a, I’ll actually use like a clock analogy for my setups and payoffs. So if there’s a setup at one, maybe a good place to pay that off is at seven or eight.
And so those are, you know, so it’s just using these different, for me, it’s a visual things or it’s these, and I actually have to sit down and look at them, but it’s different visual things that I like to use to space my stuff out and to make sure that my story, there isn’t a, just a too much happening right before we move into act two. And then all of a sudden it’s like barren wasteland of nothing happening. If you can get a good bird’s eye view of it, or you have a good blueprint of your story. You can kind of see where those gaps are.
And then you can, you can get. More creative on putting stuff in there. You can spread some things out. And so that’s from my standpoint, that’s kind of where the blueprint idea and the clock looking at it from a, from a setups and payoffs. I use a, use a clock analogy for that stuff, but that’s just mentally how I make sure that my story seems well, well spread out, well paced.
Adam: I look at a puzzle for me is a very bird’s eye view and a blueprint is similar. You’re looking at a bird’s eye view rendering of something. I, in either of those cases, a puzzle or a blueprint, here’s an important thing to know about structuring. You don’t want to be too concrete with it. You got to be a little bit flexible with it, or else you’re going to end up with the same, the same recipe. When I’m, when I’m doing consultations, let me just do this. As far as measurement, I’m going to comment on measurement this way. I generally work in screenplays or teleplays. And the rule of thumb for those mediums is it’s a page per minute.
So every page is one minute of screen time. In either of those mediums, it is very easy to understand the translation of blueprint to screen because you’re supposed to be writing a page per minute. What’s on page two should be minute two. What’s on page 15 or 25 or 60 should be an hour in, right? It’s 60 minutes, 25 minutes, whatever it might be. So it’s a great medium to sort of understand rhythm and where things are interesting or where they’re not interesting and sort of fix it. There’s two different ways I approach it. Personal writing, writing I’m doing for myself, and consultations for other people. The principles are still the same. I’m a lot more free form than in consultations.
But generally the idea is this, as the beginning is the foundation or the setup, the middle is the progressive complications, and the end is finality. Finality, closure, summary, and resolution, the climax. Most people know characters and they know a few ideas, like where the story gets started. So they sort of know their beginning. It’s rough, but they know it. And the end, and they sort of know where they’d like to go. I have an idea of my end, but generally my end changes by the time I’m finished the writing process, which is one of the things I love about it, is I go, this is how I’m going to end it.
And then the characters do something different and tell me something different. I’m like, oh my gosh, that would be so much of a better ending. So if you’re flexible enough, you sort of can mine these little gems. So when I work on story, I work in measurement and just use the minute, page per minute scenario. And then I’ll sort of open that up a little bit more to other mediums, like novels and things like that. So the way I approach it, page per minute, is this. I know when I’m a movie watcher, if I’m 15 minutes into the movie and this hasn’t happened, or it’s just a bunch of people talking and there’s no hook, there’s no call to it, I’m bored.
And so measurement wise, as a writer and a viewer, sort of both personalities, I can see if it’s okay by page 15, would I be so interested in the story or not? Keeping that in mind, as a viewer, I very much enjoy a midpoint, a defined midpoint. Now it doesn’t have to be your crisis. I sometimes prefer that as like a midterm exam for your hero and the climax is their final. And they might fail that midterm, but they succeed in the final. I kind of like that as a structure. But I think measuring that middle as, okay, here’s where your hero starts in the beginning, and here’s where they end.
Even if you have a rudimentary idea of those two points, pick the middle. And pick something really interesting and strange, maybe even severe in the center. Or if it’s a delayed crisis a little further in act two, closer to your act three climax, your end. Going off what you were talking about chain wise before, there’s a beginning, there’s a midpoint, there’s an end point. And so if you know those three points, the build between them, whatever the distance is between beginning and middle or middle and end, it’s a measurement issue. You just chop that in half and build to that midpoint. So you sort of break it up a little bit so your act two or your middle, that place where everyone has a tough time and drowns in.
Has distinct builds to shorter thresholds. We’ll talk about this in season two, I think. But the technique I use in consultations is the movement technique. I want to make sure there’s movement every 15 minutes or 15 pages or so. So that it’s not a character starts like this and transforms at the end and, oh my gosh, it feels like they’ve had this big journey. Because I feel like people change and decide things every day. So each event, each threshold, each sequence and scene should be some new version of that character. If not, eh, this day and age I feel like you’re being sort of a lazy writer.
So measurement’s important for me so you can track what you’ve written and where the character is. How the viewer or their audience is experiencing it. And also, as you were saying, if I track it in 15-minute, 15-page movements, you can look at minute 20 or whatever as a setup and be able to track it clockwise, like you were mentioning, 1 o’clock to 8, where the payoff’s going to sit and go, oh, that’s enough time. The audience will forget about that setup. And then just bam, you drop the reveal and they’re like, oh my goodness. It allows you to really help to structure your setup payoffs.
Devin: There’s good things and bad things. Well, positive and negative, I guess, I can go with. Of screenwriting and there’s positive and negatives with novel writing. And I think one of the things that are tough, like I started, when I started off in advertising as a copywriter, what I didn’t like about copywriting was having to tell a story in a couple words. And people know what the brand is and what you’re selling. And I needed, so then that’s when I started, I wanted to shift to screenwriting. And screenwriting was good. There’s also those constraints that you just talked about where, let’s go with a typical movie, let’s say it’s 90 to 120 minutes, a page a minute. So there’s some constraints on you, not creative restraints. These are just time or size or length restraints that you have to deal with.
Adam: Language restraints too. Your use of language is important in a screenplay.
Devin: Those constraints that you have in screenwriting can also be utilized when you’re writing a novel. Yes, you have a lot more freedom. You don’t have a page number that you have to hit for the studio to accept it or want to green light it or anything like that. Or you got to cut pages because in screenwriting, that page has a dollar amount attached to it as how much it costs to actually shoot it if they decide to make it. And in novel writing, it’s from a production standpoint, the bigger the book, the more it costs to actually produce the book or bind it. But I think novelists sometimes will lose, they’ll get in those areas where scenes or things or events become so long because they don’t have those constraints on them that they can lose an audience.
So I think, of course, from a creative and business standpoint, there’s positives and negatives. But I think being able to take, say, that framework. The first 15 minutes. And how does that translate into your 500-page book?
Adam: And I was saying before, it’s different with filmed media versus the novel. The same principle would apply, though. You said 500-page novel, so your midpoint’s 250. So you go, okay, my beginning is here, let’s say it’s 50 pages, my midpoint’s 250, and my final is 500. So in between 250 and 500 and 50 and 250, you have to, so you break it up and you go, okay, at 100 pages. At 150 and at 200, there will be significant events, thresholds. You and I use thresholds, I think, commonly. It’s a big change. It’s a sequence of events that builds to a big change. But it is one of the key components to navigating the desert and the ocean of Act II, of the middle.
Right. Because if you create the midpoint, if you measure from the middle out, you have a better sense of how to build your story. Right. That’s why even if your crisis isn’t central, to have a midpoint event that is sort of like the fulcrum bar of a seesaw, that central point that tips the story towards the climax, from foundation to climax. If you measure from that midpoint either way, your story has a nice symmetry to it. And generally, your audience doesn’t lose focus because by the midpoint, they’re like, oh, that’s what we’re up against. You remind them. Right.
Right. When I’ve, because I’ve consulted people with prose as well. And I sort of give that same advice. Just track it. Keep your measurements and track your progress, especially growth of characters. The events, what are the choices you’re placing in front of them? Are they making the same choice or are they actually growing and developing?
Devin: I think it’s important also to emphasize that just because we’re talking about structure and chains and things like that, that’s, that’s a very, it’s, it can, seem very linear. And both Adam and I, and probably a lot of writers don’t really think of story as a linear process. So we don’t think of, we don’t just say, this is where I’m going to start and I’m going to write, I’m going to figure out what I’m going to do. I’m just going to write it beginning, middle, right to the end and write it like that. When I’m driving, I’m in the shower, that’s when I’m coming up with different scenes. I’m coming up with even different characters.
For me, I end up writing an entire scene, even with dialogue and characters that I have no idea where that would go, or even if I will ever use it. But because it inspired me that I made sure I wrote it down, usually end up just giving myself a voice note and emailing it to myself. And taking that and then either putting it into a Word doc or then having to put it into a different folder I have in my email.
Adam: And just as a co-creator, Devin creates amazing notes. He’s so organized for story building.
Devin: But story writing, even though that structure’s involved and there’s these events, and by the time when you actually do finish your story, you do have to do it again. You have a linear story in a way where there is a… Beginning, middle, and end. The story itself, how you design it and how you come up with it and how you build it, that doesn’t have to be linear. A lot of people even start with just their, they know how that movie’s going to end. They know how their story’s going to end. That’s what was inspiring to them. They were driving in the car and they’re like, this would be a great ending to a story.
Now I’ve got to figure out what happens before that that makes that ending that great. Or you may have a great idea for a way to refuse the call to adventure or refuse the call to a quest. And so being able to or having a way to To make sure that you’re noting those things and you’re building your, if you’re Adam, you’re building that puzzle. If me, you’re putting that down on a blueprint, you’re able to do that. And I think that’s a big thing that we want to get across with the podcast is story, even though it can be, there’s good structure to story and there’s events and there’s things that, as Adam pointed out, as intelligent story consumers we are now, we are even subconsciously cued to know that at this point of the story, something should be happening. If it’s not, we don’t feel right or we lose interest in the story. So, you know, you just want to have a good way to take those notes. So writing has to be fun and it has to be creative and you’re building worlds and you’re building characters and you’re introducing these worlds and characters to people. Structure should not take creativity out of anything.
Adam: The structure is meant to facilitate creativity. We say puzzle and blueprint, but it’s the same thing. Mm-hmm. So I think Devin uses a blueprint. There are familiar staples that allow you to build off of what is known. You know there’s a – it’s a two-bedroom house. You know it’s got two bedrooms. You know it’s got a bathroom. Now, how big that bathroom is, what style it is, if it’s got a bidet or not, there’s so many details.
Devin: I actually experienced that for the first time a couple months ago. Oh, man. How was it? It was fantastic. It was good.
Adam: Yeah. I think we both, however, believe in building a story as a puzzle as well where – look, here’s the difference. I’m going to break this down really, really simply. The reason why I look at it as a puzzle is because I come primarily from a writer-performer standpoint. In directing as well, I like to compartmentalize certain things, but as a director, you’re also looking for tone, visual tone of a piece that congeals and gels the whole thing. And tone is something we’ll talk about in this season as well. So I approach it as a puzzle because it’s more of a feeling flavor to the concept of it.
And you’re intrigued by when you get to know somebody, their mystery intrigues you. And so you want to know what they’re about and who they are and how – and so I feel like that’s a character angle a lot when I say puzzle. Blueprint has to do with very specific things that are put together to create a completed piece. But I think they’re virtually the same except the blueprint. The blueprint angle is built more on events. So my perspective is slightly skewed to character and Devin’s is slightly skewed to events. But we both use the other one’s concept of puzzle or blueprint in every process. I’m always looking to how do these events build into a house that is a nice house that people want to visit and journey through.
And Devin looks at characters from a sense of what’s at the core, the secret of this character that we’re going to find out. Play around for a little bit. See which tiny aspects here and there you can draw and make your own process. One thing Devin said that I would absolutely agree with, the nonlinear aspect of blueprinting and creating a story is probably the most important point you just made. The story itself, the product generally is linear. It’s a journey from start to finish. Even if it’s Memento where the whole thing travels backwards, it’s still beginning, middle, end. It’s just a really brilliant take on that concept.
You still are experiencing it as an audience linearly. However, when you are creating, ideas don’t come that way. Linear, nonlinear is really the key. We’re in an age now when multidimensional thinking, hyperlink education where you can just click and move to the next topic. Our storytelling is going to change immensely and it’s going to change nonlinearly and multidimensionally. But it doesn’t mean we forget about the rules that have happened before. They’re a great foundation. But being in a story, it’s going to change. Being able to navigate a story so when you get an idea and you go, as Devin said, he’ll get an idea and he’ll want to write it as a scene.
Well, how do you do it? Where do you put it? I believe now the Story Blueprint app is on the StoryOsophy.com website. Am I correct?
Devin: Yeah. And you can get it through iTunes as well. You can – it’s on the iOS app store as well. Well, that’s the only place to get it. But you can access it through our website.
Adam: This is a great asset, a great tool for helping to – to structure your story when you’re building it. Because like I said, the biggest struggle is generally our brains work nonlinearly. We collect ideas from all over the place. So where do we put them? How do we organize them? And this app, Story Blueprint, it shows you the stages, the events of a story. And some of them are based in traditional and some of them are tweaked a little bit. And each one we will discuss in detail as an episode in season two. But as you’re brainstorming, as you’re collecting your ideas and you don’t know where to put them, if you go, man, I have that great idea.
Be sure to give it a shot. And if you’re doing something new, if you’re like Devin was saying, you just open the app and you go to the climax or the resolution or the final image, and you put it there. And so later when you go back, you can – oh, there, there’s my scene. In terms of how much do you write about that idea when you initially get it is until you exhaust it. Think of it like working out. When you work out, you want to work out a muscle until you feel the burn. That’s when you want to stop. That’s when your muscle has reached its peak. You’re sort of exhausted it. When you get a new idea, put it down on paper and don’t force any more writing than is necessary. Once you go like, man, I sort of feel like I’m out of juice, leave it. And if you keep collecting your ideas like that, especially if you put them in Story Blueprint, There’s my description.
Especially if you plug them in an application that’s meant to non-linearly organize those story thoughts, you will have a novel, a screenplay, a teleplay in very little time because our brains work non-linearly in collecting ideas. But we need, in order to get the final product of story as a linear piece, Story Blueprint is a great app for helping to organize all of those pieces and make it feel effortless. End is the end. End is sort of a bad word. You and I both love the idea of ongoing, long-form, chapter-based storytelling.
Devin: From an audience standpoint, whether we’re immersed with them as if we’re going on this journey with them or we are meant to be spectators, I kind of want to know that I’ve been given the opportunity to spend time with them in this world that you created or these worlds that you created because something big is happening in their lives. But I also know that because of the great development you did with the characters, that things have happened before I’ve joined them. And when I’m done with them, when you’ve decided as a writer that now this is where the story itself, this is where we’re going to depart from this world and depart from these characters, but they’re going to go on living.
And what we’ve just established here changes how they’re going to go on living. And so, end, I feel, is a misnomer because it simply is like, well, it’s the end. And I think that’s just a bad way of doing it. I want to know, even if there isn’t a sequel or there’s not another book or it doesn’t become a series, at least I still have a feeling that when I leave them, they’re going on and living and not just dissolving into the ether. So I like to call it goodbye, but not farewell. There’s other cliched terms you can say, but it’s more like it’s I’m saying goodbye to you, but we may meet again. And we never know. But I know you’re going to go on and I’m going to go on, but this isn’t the end. And who knows? There’s been many books where, or even movies, where the sequel takes 10 years to come out. And then the writer decides to, they want to go spend more time with those characters. They want to spend some time in that world again.
Adam: Twin Peaks is getting revisited decades later. Right. You know, we have no examples in this entire episode because they don’t. Except when you were talking about that, I thought of one and it’s based in your home state of Minnesota. I thought of the film version, not the series, but the film version of Fargo. It’s the most amazing thing about that story is Frances McDormand’s character is pregnant. Now, if you introduce a pregnant character in a story, they’re going to give birth. Why else put them in there? Right. Why else have that aspect of character? Except in Fargo. She doesn’t give birth. She is pregnant from the beginning of that movie. And at the end of it, she’s sitting with her husband and they’re just sort of being a couple and she’s still pregnant. And so the strange thing to me is the Coen brothers took us, they made a specific choice to take a snippet out of this character’s life. And it is very obvious that that life is going to continue because they’re being a couple and getting ready for the baby at the end of the movie.
Right. You’re sort of forced to that perspective you’re talking about where, you know, or you feel there’s continuation well beyond this when it cuts to black and we see credits.
Devin: Yeah, I think if you look at more of like a biopic standpoint, it kind of maybe makes the point a little better because it’s based on a true story. So like Sully, the story about the pilot who landed the passenger airliner on the Hudson River. Right, right. Tom Hanks. So I just watched that the other day. And so that’s kind of what I’m talking about. You’re going. You’re spending time with him during this. And this is the biggest part of his life, the biggest thing that’s ever happened to him and what he had to go through afterwards. But when this when the movie ends, you know, and I’m even you’re even privy in this case, you’re even privy to knowing what happened after that, all the shows he was on and what he’s doing now and things like that.
And so it’s kind of like that where you’re like. That’s the story. That’s the story that we’re being told. But when we leave him, we know that other crazy things are going on in his life afterwards.
Adam: So he’s still living his story. He’s still continuing to tell that story. That’s a unique example. Traditional structures for climactic storytelling function much. Like this, there’s cyclical and build to climax. A lot of stories, Clockwork Orange as a novel, it starts in the same place that it finishes. That’s sort of the cyclical storytelling. Whereas in a traditional, like I’m saying, more of a straight climactic thing where you’re building from a low point. Up to a pinnacle. And then there’s a slight decline, which is sort of like your resolution point.
Devin: Well, is the movie Clockwork Orange? Does it follow the book?
Adam: Here’s the thing. It follows the book fairly well. It does not have the same cyclical feeling that the novel has. The novel’s meant to be a coming of age piece. It’s actually 21, I believe there’s 21 chapters. It’s meant to have that number. Just as a side note, for those of you who have never read A Clockwork Orange as a novel, read it and don’t get the version with the glossary in the back. The whole book is written in a fictitious language. Most of it’s English with a little bit of a Russian Slavic made up slang that Anthony Burgess created for the book itself. The glossary in the back would let you know what each of those slang terms would mean. But the experience that’s so exciting about this book is if you start reading it, eventually you’ll You’ll be able to start thinking in the slang without the glossary because the context of the sentences that he uses, the words surrounding those slang terms, you understand what the slang terms mean. And it’s an amazing language experience for that alone. You’re reading stuff in a language that’s not real and you’re starting to comprehend it.
It’s hard to get that same experience, the time you could spend in the novel versus the page per minute that you need to pay attention to for film or television. That’s sort of where he can afford to chat with you in that language. Whereas in the film, it’s just a little bit of narration. They’re slightly different. Each one is genius. That book and its film adaptation, though different, are amazing. Disturbing, but amazing.
Devin: Yeah, so and this is a good place to end the episode.
Adam: Please subscribe and rate us on iTunes. And for additional story-related resources, video, and archived content, visit our website at StoryOsophy.com.