Season 1, episode 9

Setting

January 10, 201851 min

Show notes

Setting is the foundation of storytelling. Adam and Devin break it into time, location and world, and show how setting reveals character, sets the hero’s constraints, and keeps an audience inside the story.

In this episode

  • Setting as a character. Like a film’s score, setting is an extra character that’s easy to take for granted.
  • Constraints. If the story is set in the 1920s, nobody pulls out a cell phone. Setting tells the audience which solutions are possible.
  • The set tells the story. From Adam’s years in the scenic department: crumbling paint on a windowsill says everything about a character before they appear.
  • Two worlds. The known world shows the hero’s routine. The unknown world of act two disrupts it, even when it’s the same place, as in Shaun of the Dead.
  • Details matter. Vince Gilligan spent 15 minutes on a curtain in Breaking Bad. Soderbergh color codes the storylines of Traffic.
  • Research isn’t homework. Research floods you with ideas. Cameron researched Titanic down to the silverware, and the stars over the sinking ship.
  • Proprietary worlds. Creating a world like Avatar‘s means building and explaining its rules, often through the characters’ jobs, as in District 9.
  • Two act two scenes. The rules and tools scene, like Glinda giving Dorothy the ruby slippers, and the watering hole, like the Mos Eisley cantina.

Examples discussed

  • Shaun of the Dead, Red Dawn, Super 8, The Crazies, Breaking Bad, Traffic, Titanic, Avatar, District 9, Saving Private Ryan, The Wizard of Oz, Star Wars and Friends.
  • Also: George Lucas, Tolkien and Peter Jackson’s Lord of the Rings.

Next episode: plot and structure.

Read the full transcript

Transcribed automatically, so expect the odd misheard word. Sponsor messages are left out.

Adam: Next on StoryOsophy. Welcome to StoryOsophy. This is Adam Jones.

Devin: And Devin Halden.

Adam: In this first season, we’re talking about the broad strokes of storytelling. We want to learn the rules before we break them. And so we’re looking at the foundation of storytelling, in particular, from a mythological or epic storytelling standpoint. This episode is dedicated to setting. Setting is the foundation of storytelling. Setting is basically made up of time. When is the story set and taking place? Is it in the past, present, future? The location. What city or country is it in?

What planet is it on, if it’s set in another universe? And the world. And what I mean by world, and we’ll get into this, is, is it this universe, or is it some alt universe, where there are different rules, and different mythology, and different type of people, a lot of fantasy or sci-fi, and fairy tale stories? It’s much like that. You have to define those rules of the world. And so those three elements, I think, help to define where and when a story takes place. And we’ll get into each of those in more depth, but Devin, thoughts, initial thoughts on defining story before we continue exploring it?

Devin: I think setting is an important reference for both the writer and the audience, because, you know, it’s a vital element that contributes to the constraints of the hero within the world. So, and usually it’s made clear through a rules and tools scenes of the story. But some constraints can be obvious, as in, well, if the setting is 1920s America, then the audience knows that one of the solutions to a problem can’t be whipping out a cell phone and making a phone call.

And also from a writer’s standpoint, it gives you some of those constraints that you know the audience won’t think that it’s an easily solvable solution if you can, like I said, you can take out your cell phone or not. But it’s also ways where understanding those constraints from a writer’s standpoint that, say, it’s a sci-fi movie, you can actually start playing with your own world and creating your own rules. And maybe that person that pulls out the cell phone, that’s the indication that he’s not from that time period. So making sure that your setting is developed and it’s actually understood by the audience, I think, is one of the vital things.

It’s a vital element of the story and should be a character in and of itself.

Adam: And I agree with you with the character in and of itself. There are two things in film, if you’re filmmaking or television, that I think are additional characters beyond the people in play, and that is the setting and music, the score. But the score is really only relevant to filmed entertainment. But setting is consistent throughout all types of media and writing, whether it’s a novel or a stage play or any of that. Much how we were talking about in the initial characters episode where we talk about relatability, there’s something that music does for people artistically where they resonate with a certain type of music or it makes them feel a certain way, much like how a performance might.

But you can actually have nothing on screen and play a song and have people emote to it. So it’s like this invisible character music is in film. Focusing on setting, even though it’s right in front of your face, you don’t really consider it a character. You sort of take it for granted almost. [unclear] Shades or tone of what the character or the story is about.

Devin: And also to, from a filmed entertainment standpoint or film story standpoint, and you’ll, I’ll start this, but you can obviously expound on this because you have, you have great experience in this realm, but set design and… And keys and cues that are given that aren’t verbally explained by a character, but you, but what you’re seeing, like the types of street lamps and, and other cues that are built into the actual set design and what the audience actually sees are also… Major cues for what, when this is taking place.

Adam: You know, it’s true. And here’s the thing that’s interesting. I did, I will give a couple anecdotes about my time spent in scenic artist land on… I worked on major films for those listeners who don’t. I worked on some… Some major film studio films in New York City in the scenic department while I was… Writing and directing and acting. But I learned so much from that experience because… It goes with the theory Devin and I have. If you want to conduct the orchestra as a director or producer, you want to learn how to play all the instruments. You want to learn how everything comes together. So it was really interesting, valuable time.

I’ll start with one of them. A scenic artist that I know named Peter Miller. Really great guy. And he does the Hasty Pudding show when they do that. He’s been designing that for years and years and years. And he was talking about… Different ways. He’s done theater. Designed in theater. And also worked on a lot of studio films in New York when they come into the city. And what he was saying was… For theater… I’ll start with theater. Sometimes you have a proscenium stage and you have curtains. And you don’t see the set. It’s just curtains. And you’re waiting to see what it is. But in some black box theaters or thrust stages or things like that where there’s no curtain in front of the set, you get to see this set for like 15, 20 minutes before… If you’re early, 10 minutes before anything even happens. And so you’re saying so…

So much about this story and these characters and that audience is literally soaking it up in detail because they’re looking at it. And so he was saying it’s so important to indicate within the set these… It’s a great way to embellish your character. It’s actually like writing. It’s like writing more for the… You rely on, I think, so many different people in an artistic team for film or theater because it requires collaboration, creative collaboration. And you want someone who’s thinking to that level is like, okay, this character is… They don’t have good hygiene, so what’s that say? In the set? How can we tell that? Is there stuff everywhere? Is stuff unwashed?

Even in film, he was saying what he… He loved doing what he did. He loved telling that story through the set and the paint and just techniques and things, but even crumbled paint on a windowsill. In someone’s low-rent apartment. Those little details in film, well, shoot, there could be something outside out of focus, and that’s the thing in focus, but it says everything before the hand comes up and brushes the curtain aside and you see, oh, there’s somebody watching from this window, but there are ways in which… The set and the setting says so much about your… In that case, in particular, I’m talking about characters and how it sort of gives us a lens or a gateway into that character even before we see them or after we meet them and we go, what’s this person about? Well, the set is sort of a layer that you get to see. Maybe they’re introduced…

…away from home and you get to see them enter their own cave, their own home, you know? It’s one of those things I was saying in the last bunch of episodes regarding you want to find ways to paint your heroes’ insides on the outside with your character archetypes and setting is probably one of the best tools for that. I no longer work in the Scenic Department in New York. So I don’t see those folks as much anymore. So the basic elements of setting are when and where. When and where does your story take place? The setting says a lot about a character because it defines if you see their home, their workplace, their favorite place to hang out, what that actually says about them.

When I think about the use of setting in a way to establish a routine for a character, which you’ll commonly see that in a first act, you’ll see them go through their daily routine and understand how their personal world or bubble or microcosm works. And then you can sort of play that again and run them through the same locations in the beginning of act two, if the special world is an event and not moving literally to another world, and you get to understand how has it affected that world. One of the best examples is Shaun of the Dead, where his whole morning routine, he doesn’t look at anybody and everybody moves around like zombies anyway.

And then when the zombies actually take over and he goes through his daily routine, he doesn’t even notice, which is brilliantly comic. But. But setting can be used to establish that sort of thing.

Devin: I think every story is going to have two settings. They’re going to have that first setting where we see the hero or the protagonist in their comfort element. Like, Adam, you said their their their ordinary world routine or their known world routine where we’re kind of getting this information or backlog of this is what this guy does every day. This is his comfort zone. And this is the world. This is the world that that he does it in. It’s also his act one. Right. And then and then it’s when you when he does make that transfer over the threshold, he crosses that threshold into act two, where we’re in an unknown world, even if it’s and you alluded to it, even if it’s the same place.

But now something has completely disrupted it and taken him out of a comfort zone. And he like a magic spell, like a magic spell or Red Dawn, even where their town is taken over. And right. Super 8 or The Crazies. When all of a sudden this small, quaint little town. Right. All of a sudden has these crazy. It’s sort of epidemic in a way. I love our our movie examples and I love our movie examples, how much they differ. And you can kind of tell how we kind of we do watch a lot of the same stuff. But I’m into the kind of war, really messed up horror movie stuff.

Adam: My one horror reference is a comedy. Because I don’t. Right. I like poking fun at things in a jester way rather than seeing people hurt each other.

Devin: And maybe at some point we can we can get to the moment in our friendship when you almost stopped being my friend when you were living with me and we had a double date. And based on the movie I chose,

Adam: I was irritated because it was like, are we all supposed to enjoy this, or are three people supposed to enjoy this and I’m sitting here being tortured? Because I’d rather take a walk. Honestly, let’s take a walk. We won’t get into that right now. I can get riled up about my preferences.

Devin: Bringing it back, though, I think I think for me, the setting is is kind of showing the it’s outlining the constraints to the hero and the and and really anybody in that or that known world. And then it’s it’s also acclimation. It’s acclimating the audience in a way to the story. So they’re settling in. They’re getting they’re getting the rules. They’re getting the. They’re understanding this. So when we do shake it up in in the following following scenes or the following acts and and things like that, then they’re they’re not confused. So those are the two you need to control.

Adam: Like in a scientific experiment, you need to show what is the status quo or the normal or the comfort zone or the routine or what that hero knows. Right. Before you introduce that domino, as you said in a previous analogy, to be. And then the adventure or the journey or the quest to become the next version of themselves begins. And so you need to build the what is this version of themselves, you know, as a hero? Who are they in this particular scenario? Yeah. I will use this example probably forever because I just was enamored like a lot of people were. But you look at Bryan Cranston’s first pilot episode of Breaking Bad where he’s this nervous, weak-willed, mild-mannered science teacher and then you look at him at the end of the series and you’re like, you wouldn’t be able to see that epic journey if you hadn’t established in the beginning that he was this mild-mannered guy who would break bad.

You have to establish that base, that foundation. And not only is act one good for that, but the setting is too. What you’re saying, the known world setting.

Devin: I think, and also putting out and defining the emotional and the physical state of the worlds, both the known and the unknown. And so we, which it falls under acclimation. Who are the main or central characters? How are they working or manipulating this world? How will the attributes of the… You know, the known world itself oppose or create obstacles beyond those created by the antagonist. For instance, weather, nuclear fallout, contaminated water source with The Crazies, or the setting takes place during the holidays and there’s this ticking time bomb related to something has to happen before New Year’s. Right, right. You know, whatever. Or Cinderella, like we talked about before.

It’s like a lot of that stuff is… Is setting related, and so it does not necessarily visually what we see, but also a date or the time on the calendar and not just in linear time.

Adam: No, that’s a really good point that you’re making. And at the same time, there are movies that take place within a certain time frame, like it’s from this particular hour to this particular hour, and what occurs within that tight space. And even though that’s a choice in the storytelling, as far as like the different examples… This is an example of what you’re saying with the ticking time bomb scenario, where we know something needs to happen within a certain time constraint. This is saying we’re going to… It’s sort of like a slice of life choice in setting, where we’re just going to carve out this small chunk of time in, like you’re saying, New Year’s, Christmas, something with sort of a time deadline.

That’s really a setting choice, because if you set it any other time, it wouldn’t make sense. Like anything else, the specificity, the details are… Or what matters. As I just mentioned, Breaking Bad, I’ll use my other little anecdote. Vince Gilligan, who is the creator of Breaking Bad, wrote and directed a bunch of the episodes. He said it’s all in the details. And on set, there’s a story of him being on set and working with a curtain in a window for like 10 or 15 minutes, because it was an important detail in the background. I think it’s the point when Hector has… This confrontation later in the series, which would make sense, because the window is important.

But the idea of that detail meant that someone was outside of the window, because of the way the curtain was. And so he used the setting as a thriller element, which was super cool. I mean, I had not… It got me very excited when I was like, oh, that’s really clever. Because you can sort of tell that that’s the case, but you don’t know it until later. You know? You don’t really figure stuff out for yourself until later on, what’s actually happening. He gives you hints in a lot of his constructions of shots and elements of a scene. And so even those small details within a set, where you see something and it sort of intimates something that you will discover later.

I thought that was cool. He said it’s all in the details. And so you can do broad sets, like we’re talking about the known world and the unknown world, which I think in the next episode or two, we’ll be dealing with a plot or chain of events. Sort of what most… Most people struggle with structure, which is why we’re dedicating our whole season two to structure. Because it needs to sort of be understood a little better. I think people get lost in that sea or desert of Act Two. And so we want to help explore that. But if you know your unknown world, the special world of your Act Two, the journey world, you won’t have as much of a problem.

Because the more you develop that world, as Devin was saying, the more that things come out of that world that present obstacles. To the hero and new characters or allies or archetypes you hadn’t even thought of. They’re sort of at thresholds. But it’s knowing that world. And like I said, when we get into plot and the chain of events, we’ll talk more about that specifically because it becomes a major part of it. It has a lot to do with, you know, once you cross that first threshold from what you know, trying to navigate this new way of doing it and how that person responds to failure or success.

Devin: Moving from that comfort zone to the discomfort zone. Filmed entertainment can be done with visual elements or visual decisions, either on set or also in post-production. There’s different ways you could, Traffic was a really good one, the movie Traffic. Tonally.

Adam: You mean the color tone? As soon as you said it, it popped visually into my mind. That’s how well done Soderbergh’s work is.

Devin: So using the different tones for the, from the drug dealer standpoint. To the police standpoint, government standpoint, to the user standpoint. I think those are some of those, those things that, that are kind of an acclimation type of thing. Like I was referring to earlier, where it’s allowing the audience to understand where they’re at in the story and who they’re with. Audiences today, and we’ve talked about this before, are so intelligent. Yeah. And so it’s not saying that you need to hold their hand by, by literally explaining word for word the setting is. It’s giving little visual cues and, and making sure that they’re, you’re not confusing them with, with different settings, setting decisions, but allowing them to still be able to figure out what’s going on.

Adam: That’s a great example. You always have great examples. In particular, I like that one because I remember the visual, it’s awesome. And I think one of the things that, a way to achieve that is not just use it as a tool or a mechanism, which if you see other things, other pieces of media that have made the same choice. And have not done it artfully, it comes off as clunky or contrived or you’re being beat over the head with it. They were really interesting and subtle decisions, but you knew exactly where you’re shifting to. And sooner or later, you don’t notice it as much as you feel it.

Right.

So just using the color palette in a, on a lens, you know, just a tinted lens or even in post doing that concept of tinting an entire subplot. That’s very cool.

Devin: Yeah.

Adam: And that is setting it, but it’s, it, once again, we’re talking about, you know, now that we’ve, we’ve had all these, you know, different types of industry and high tech has come in only in the past little chunk of time in human history, but the, what it allows you to do with these different settings. All of a sudden in post-production, you can lay a lens or color over it, sort of reinventing setting. And we’ll probably deal with that in later seasons, because right now we’re working on foundations. We talked about Aristotle and, and some of our favorite recent story gurus like Robert McKee and Christopher Vogler and Joseph Campbell, and there’s tons more, but it doesn’t mean that you shouldn’t be thinking about how you might reinvent all of this stuff as we’re talking from its foundation.

Please ask in your mind, what if, what if I did it?

Devin: That’s the greatest question ever. It is. It’s, it’s another one of those elements of story that are so crucial to develop correctly and overdevelop it. So, so you understand the constraints and you don’t end up having these forums online tearing apart your, your movie or your story because you overlooked something that there will go wide. And it happens all the time. It’s surprising is how many stories. Especially Hollywood made stories are made into movies with those, with some of these enormous gaps of logic, common, common logic. Yeah. That, that, that actually get through and are made in and kind of there. And they’re one of those things that will immediately pull someone out of, out of watching it out of that world he created because now you don’t believe it.

They stop and they go, wait a minute. Now they don’t believe the world, the setting, the place. Yeah, they don’t, they don’t believe it because it’s. It’s all about relate, relating to the people that are involved with it to the point where you feel you’re involved and you’re in there. Right. And when something happens where, and I will just use the, the, the cell phone thing. Well, if something happens where you. Say, well, if I’m, if I’m there, I’m going to use my cell phone. Now, if, if, if you set it up where there’s no service or they don’t have this, the phone just broke or something like that, then you can get around those, those constraints that you’ve given yourself for being in this.

Your setting is in a time and place where that technology exists, but sometimes a lot of that is overlooked. A lot of those minute details of setting and technology, especially… Especially technology, what, you know, what, what was around when you decided that you want to do a movie in the 1980s? Well, do your research, research what, what kind of technologies were, were around in the, in the 80s, because there’s going to be people that do know exactly…

Adam: So maybe you’re one of those people who goes, research, yuck, and your mind, you feel like research is frustrating, and you’d rather just get to writing. What I would say is there are, there are times when you go, well, I have to know what this is in order to… Clearly communicate it on the page, and every time I’ve gone to research anything, so many more ideas just flood, because now you’re starting to get into details, you go, oh, that character would do this, and oh, that would be cool to put in their office, and oh, that… Whole world develops for you just by looking through stuff, and you sort of selectively sift, oh, that resonates with me, and that does, and that does, so they start to become these really great and rich elements of your story.

And so don’t think of research as a daunting or like homework, schoolwork kind of mentality, because once you start getting into it, it’s super exciting. It will give you way more ideas. You’ll be able to mine a lot more from your story. So don’t be afraid, listeners. Don’t be afraid.

[unclear] Some great characters? All these cool scenes and you don’t know what order to put them in? What goes here? What comes next? Story Blueprint is an app that provides a powerful and versatile tool to help you, the writer, build the roadmap of your story. Know where your story is going to start, where it’s going to end, and how you’re going to get there before you even begin writing. Once you have your blueprint completed, you’ll have a bird’s eye view of your story, removing the anxiety of the blank page. Story Blueprint is currently available in the iTunes App Store for iPad, coming soon for iPhone and Android.

What about if you already have a finished script, and you want feedback on how to improve your story for the next draft? Maybe you prefer a personal walk-through to talk your story out one-on-one. Well, StoryOsophers, you can always talk to me. I offer a variety of supportive services from feedback for finished scripts to script doctoring and company consultations. I’ll diagnose your story to make sure all its parts are working toward the whole and strive to find a balance between traditional structure, storytelling innovation, and the writer’s personal voice and lens. I also do ongoing story therapy for writers who are looking for a coach to help build their story.

I ask you the questions that help you find your own story, and we discuss how to mine its gems. Consultation services are also available to directors and actors looking to break down scripts into beats and super objectives, and to production companies looking to refine the stories in their slate. For more information and a full menu of story doctoring options, you can visit doctajones.com. That’s d-o-c-t-a jones.com. Links to both Story Blueprint and Dr. Jones consultations can be found on our website at StoryOsophy.com.

Devin: And you can even go way overboard on research like Cameron did with Titanic. Neil deGrasse Tyson actually pointed out in the final scene where the boat’s actually going down that that star constellation on that night, on that date, wouldn’t have been the star constellation that Cameron arranged in the film. And so Cameron went back and made the star constellation identical to what it would have been on that night. No way. Yeah, I mean, I don’t think anybody else would have noticed that.

Adam: I love the visionary, the fastidious visionary like Cameron, who is like so detail-oriented. He has a very specific and refined… And most of those people, they’re fairly nice people, I assume, but most of those people, because they have a very specific vision, they always get branded as difficult to work with. But you wouldn’t have that level of depth. If someone weren’t really the captain of the ship sticking to that. If Cameron didn’t know all of his stuff before he went into that epic film. I don’t mean to imply that Cameron’s difficult to work with. I understand he’s a wonderful person to work with. But I mean, some people who have a very specific preference sometimes get branded that.

I would say they just have to fight for their vision a lot. And so executives don’t dig that very much.

Devin: It brings up another important part of the. The research part for your setting is when you have a true historical event, whether it’s Titanic or it’s Saving Private Ryan, when things actually happened, research is essential. There’s plenty of documentaries and I think probably. You know, there’s probably some behind the scenes stuff with the actual Titanic, the movie, but the amount of research that went in to make that the ship look identical and the silverware is identical to the. The silverware that was actually on there and the architecture with inside and the interior design and what the people were wearing, you know, all, you know, so that’s all of that is part of the setting of understanding your setting and what were the fashion trends.

Again, what were the technologies? Understanding all of that, like you said, all of a sudden opens up many more creative decisions to make. And the more decisions you have to make, the better. But as long as they’re all in place with the time and the setting. And that’s so, I mean, even taking that, so you take Titanic, which is this world that this historic thing that happened and the historical data that he had to research was one, that’s one movie. But then if you take Avatar. Interesting. Yes. He still, I mean, the research that went into that, even though it’s a proprietary world that he created, there’s still a ton of research that he went into the plant life and.

And the technologies that he’s using in that. And so those are two with one, one filmmaker to opposite ends of the spectrum, but both incredibly important to, to develop the setting and understand whether you’re, you’re using historic. Events that have already happened, that type of research, or you’re creating this world, this proprietary world and the things and the plants and the characters and the species that are in it still takes, it still takes a ton of research because you have. To make sure all of those pieces of the puzzle that you’re creating are connecting correctly.

Adam: For you and I, I know this is true. That’s the most exciting part, is building the rules of a world. So, setting is sort of like a… Sandbox or parameters. You’re going to play in this certain arena. We’ll probably deal with genre a little bit later as well, but I want to touch on it here in connection to setting. Much like how the hero is, there’s an internal working with the hero. There’s the external of the character archetypes and the world around them. I feel like the genres, the internal workings of what you see in the setting, so the tone of the movie or the TV show or story or whatever, when you call it sci-fi, you need…

You need to know why it is science fiction. That needs to be built into the way the world operates, or else it’s just fiction. It’s not something that is different from our world. So you need to explain that. Here’s a really easy way to approach it. In a world that’s got different rules than ours, let’s… You can use a starship planet exploration show or a time travel show as a template for it. They may step into another world or be on a planet where there’s no… So there’s all these new rules that you might need to…

Right. You know, so you have to explain those things in a way that is understandable for an audience to, to, that it sinks in. Using your characters and the choice you make for the job they do in that world. Because if you have a society or a structure or a system, a government that’s totally different in this alt world, this fantasy world or whatever you’re doing, you need to be able to show how that system works. And, oh, I mentioned District 9 a couple episodes ago. Perfect example. He’s an employee of this system. You get to see how the entire system functions because he’s one of the members of it.

He’s one of the members of the governing agency. So doing that with your characters and making, having their jobs be really specific to. That proprietary world and its rules or mythology is, is a really good way to introduce the world itself. If not, it sort of seems like you’re, you’re having little vignettes of things where you’re explaining stuff instead of it making it about the hero or their interactions or the people that are their allies or other characters in the story for them, their jobs and sort of building that outward. Not that they would all have jobs, but the point is they’re, they’re focused for a daily activity. What do they do? Where do they go? How do they do it?

You can explain a lot. About your setting. If it’s an alt setting through the character.

Devin: Personal preference is getting the rules of the world of the, of the known world usually can be done through action, visual, visual action. Cause you’re actually can see them do this. A lot of it can be relatable. I think, I think a lot of the, the known world rules can be something that, that the audience is like, yep, I get that. I understand that. So once you cross that threshold into the unknown. And it’s, you know, a mentor or something else, something happens. I think a lot of times that unknown world, because of those, those new rules are oftentimes explained to them. And, and I, my personal preference is get those rules out as soon as possible. And like you said, Adam, don’t, don’t always have something happen. It’s, it’s okay to have something happen, I think. And then explain why that happens.

You’re going to continue to learn as you go. But I think the main rules of the, of the world, like in Avatar, when Sully actually just shows up in, in, in the wheelchair and, and then they kind of give him, you get the lay of the land. So we’re like, we’re learning it as Sully learns it. So we know enough to, to go on this journey.

Adam: It’s a really good example of the hero protagonist character, especially in the traditional model, because he gets two special worlds. He gets his legs and he gets the world itself of Pandora. Right. So it’s an internal, external.

Devin: My personal preference is I want to know as much about this unknown world as possible enough. So things, I feel like I’m still in the story and I’m not asking a ton of questions about, about things that are just aren’t getting explained that maybe the writer, because they’re so involved in the world, they created the world that they overlook it and, and don’t explain it. That happens a lot. Yeah. I do it all the time.

Adam: I mean, you and I’ve done it too. You’ve been in your own world and you’re like, oh shoot, I didn’t explain that rule that I know is very obvious. And the audience isn’t getting it.

Devin: Or, and then, or you get into that defensive, you get into the defensive writer mode where. Oh, where you’re like, it’s in there. I swear it is. Of course he can float right there, dude, because he’s got the shoes on. It’s like, you didn’t tell me the shoes alone. Shouldn’t you know the shoes make him fly. You’re not my audience then, dude. You’re not my audience. Give me back my script.

Adam: We’re using Cameron as an example, just him as a, as a creator for Titanic and Avatar. Showing them side by side. And I will say one of the other things I had heard about, once again, details, you need to know broad when and where, but then once you know that stuff, start to fill in the details because once you do, it becomes very real. Let me say that again. So I don’t sound like an idiot. When you do, it becomes very real. Very real. It’s called very real.

Devin: Very real.

Adam: So what they were saying about him, Lucas did the same thing. George Lucas. So did Tolkien, Lord of the Rings. And Peter Jackson in the film incarnation of it. The attention to detail is everyone talks about those specific storytellers and directors. The level of detail that they care about is sort of mind blowing. For Cameron on Avatar, all of the machinery, all of the weaponized military equipment, he wanted to know where the exhaust was here. Why is this nut here? Why is this bolt here? It needed to visually make sense as a functioning mechanism to him. It wasn’t just rivets for decoration. And I think that’s sort of why his stuff is so immersive is because he cares about that. He cares about those. It’s why all those folks that I just mentioned, they’re huge auteurs. They don’t just direct, they write, they build worlds, the proprietary worlds.

Right. But that’s, like I said, his attention to detail is very similar as what I was saying before about Vince Gilligan.

Devin: It’s details that even the majority of the people won’t really recognize. But one, if it wasn’t there, they would recognize that it’s not there. Or two, that small group of people, even if it’s 5% of the people that knew that the mantles within the staterooms had this ornate architecture on the top, you know, that they will appreciate something like that, or they’ll appreciate the frame that the artwork is in. And that’s just another tool to bring your audience into your story. And we keep talking about filmed entertainment, but just from a story standpoint, even if you were writing this as a novel, explaining what the room looks like and the detail of the room is just as important.

Adam: More important in that way because you don’t have a visual reference.

Devin: Exactly. Yeah.

Adam: That one difference between the novel and the film as far as character accessibility is we have to see it in a performance, in the eyes of a character, in their facial expressions. In the novel, we can go into their mind if we choose. And communicate that to the audience. You know, there’s, I don’t want to just, as you said, I don’t want to just limit this to filmed entertainment. It just so happens that you and I work so much in it that a lot of our references and a lot of the things that I think most people pop culturally can refer to when trying to, you know, get their own writing juices flowing are films and movies.

And we reference some books here and there. I may even from time to time reference some stage plays. I want to make sure in the first season that our references and our sort of this foundation is accessible to everybody.

Devin: It’s key to remember that everything you see in filmed entertainment, everything you see in a movie has originated most of the time from a written word, from a script.

Adam: Yeah.

Devin: And so that’s important too. So it’s still, it’s all writing and it’s just, it’s a director and Cameron writes his own stuff, or at least co-writes his own stuff. So it’s, it’s, it’s, it’s all of that, that descriptive information you’re giving about your setting is going to be read by a director or a producer that’s going to interpret it. The more you, you’ve done your research and, and even from a business standpoint, a producer reading your script that you may, you may want them to option that amount of research you’ve done in development will jump off the page at them. They’ll believe it.

Adam: Wow.

Devin: These guys, they really did their homework.

Adam: Yeah. They’ll believe your story. And it’s not just researching the setting. It’s researching the, the characters as well, because that same reaction is what you want from a performer, from an actor. Exactly. Who reads the script. Because I can tell you when I’m reading a script from an acting standpoint, I want to see different things that I can play. Secrets, because I like the, I like a lot of internal play in acting. And of course, obstacles, sort of something that you can play. And, you know, there’s an objective. We were talking about the known and unknown world and setting and how you can see the differentiation between act one and act two in those different worlds.

And once you get into act two, some setting related scenes or events that we will talk about in season two, but we’ll just drop these in your head before we sign off for this episode. The Rules and Tools Scene and the Watering Hole Scene. The Tools Scene and the Watering Hole Scene. And in brief, I’ll sort of lay it out and then I’ll let Devin make some comments on it. Like I said, we’ll get into this way more in season two, but these are specific to setting in act two. Just as the ordinary world, the routine of your hero in act one is a very pivotal scene.

But that’s sort of self-explanatory. Rules and tools scene is generally when you get into act two and the mentor or some other character or the hero themselves. Generally, it’s the mentor saying, OK, buddy, Glenda, the good witch in The Wizard of Oz, when she shows when she goes, here are your slippers. Here’s the way. Here’s your goal. And it’s what you were saying just before, Devin, about you want you want it to be clear for you what the trajectory of the hero. You may not know everything. The rules of the environment. But you want to know some of them. You want to know the basics so that you can enjoy the story and not be constantly searching for things that should be made evident early on.

Devin: Early on. The rules and tools is great for that. You want to be on the same page as the hero. Right. We’re moving through the story with them. We don’t want to be left out and we don’t want to feel like, well, I guess we’re supposed to know what’s going on or we’re supposed to know what this rule is. But I missed it or something. Being intrigued by something.

Adam: Is different than being confused by something. They’re different questions.

Devin: Creating when you’re when you’re writing and you’re able to create worlds and that’s what you’re doing. It’s it’s great fun. Obviously, but there are some advantages and disadvantages to creating proprietary worlds like like what Cameron did with Avatar. The advantages are you get to create a world and you get to make up the rules you get to create the different species of. Plants or creatures. If you’re writing a movie like a sci-fi movie or fantasy fantasy story, but then you have to explain them, right? You get to create businesses or towns or governments and and create a. Story languages even in like Lord of the Rings or any of the Star Wars and if it’s well done, it’s way more effective to immerse your audience in your story. Now the disadvantages which Adam just alluded to is you’re creating a world dude and you need to come up with the rule.

And so, that’s the advantages and disadvantages of both. And if you’re creating a world that’s previously unknown to the audience, and there really is zero reference, then you must make sure the rules of the world are comprehensive. And if not well developed, and the rules are not comprehensively translated to the audience, it’s easy to lose their attention, because confusion can pull them out of that story.

Adam: If you’re pulling yourself out of a story, the writers dropped the ball somewhere. And usually it’s just because they relied on a cliche. They’ve not bothered to look beyond what’s the easiest choice. Rules and tools, I just want to mention this one. As I said, it’s fairly self-explanatory, but you went into a really great description of it. And especially in regards to proprietary worlds and their rules and tools. Because even the tools, even the equipment, if it’s not from this planet, if it’s not from this world, if it’s something foreign, you have to learn it. You have to learn the tool. But like I said, probably the most basic example is Glenda the Good Witch giving to Dorothy the ruby slippers and then showing her the yellow brick road and going, here’s your tool and that’s your way. Your goal is Oz. It’s nice to have it that concrete and straight up and be presented that way. The other scene I mentioned that we use.

Especially right when you enter Act Two, is when the rules and tools come. And then shortly after, I would call this scene the watering hole. And it is very easy to tell you what the watering hole is. It’s the Star Wars Cantina. It’s Luke walking into an environment where there’s so many different species. He’s not used to being in a bar. He’s certainly not used to being around the likes of Han Solo and Chewbacca, who now they have to enlist. And so it’s a great example of going, look, that world you came from, the known world, it’s nothing like this. And I feel like that’s probably one of the better examples of a watering hole scene, but you’ll see it in Westerns.

Right. It’s especially a Western staple.

Devin: Yep. And you’ll see it in lots of stuff.

Adam: You’ll notice that what Simon Pegg [unclear] So they took the idea of them going to the pub after work and that all of a sudden becomes like the main fortress they decide to hole up in. It’s interesting the different things you can do with setting and scenes. But I did want to end on those two. They’re fun to think about, but they’re great for you to be stirring around in your brain before we get to season two. What’s the communal watering hole is sort of what that means. Where do people congregate? A coffee shop even. Central Perk is the watering hole in Friends.

Devin: And the watering hole in whether it’s Star Wars or it’s a Western is usually a place where the hero or moment when the hero and us are simply observing. Oh, yeah. And we’re taking this all in. We’re like, what are the rules? Now I need to figure out the rules of this place. And so that’s kind of the setup, but it’s an observation moment where it’s really taking everything in. It’s kind of like the first day of school. You know, you’re just kind of sitting back. No, it is. It totally is.

Adam: That’s the cafeteria in a school movie. The watering hole. I just want to say one thing you said earlier about Titanic and the mantle when you were talking about being appreciative. You can either have a critic who’s like, that mantle piece isn’t right. I know everything about Titanic. Or you can have someone who is saying, look at the attention to detail. And from an appreciative point of view, people are so much more apt to criticize than I think appreciate in even in terms of like, well, Cameron’s a, you know, a big blockbuster director. And so you sort of want to because he’s so successful. People want to take pot shots.

And I’m going, look at the level of genius. Even if he’s not your cup of tea, even if you don’t like the movies he makes, you cannot help but admire the craftsmanship. We’d like for this podcast to really. Foster appreciation for the craft and for its continued evolution. And it made me think of that when you were talking about that. There are critics and there are appreciators. You got your choice.

Devin: You spend so much time, whether you’re writing a script or writing a novel, you’re you spend so much time doing that. And it’s just from a from a physically having to find time to write it, find time to edit it. And then whether you’re trying to find a publisher. You’re going to want to self publish it. You spend so much time doing it. Why wouldn’t you want that thing that’s going to live in forever? It’s going to live forever, whether on a shelf or digitally in an audiobook or in the ether. Make it the best thing that you can make it. Knowing that all of the research you did and all the preparation you did prior to sitting down and starting the blank page and actually starting writing the final draft of your year or the rough draft.

That eventually becomes your final draft. You are so prepared and you know the world and you know the history of that world, whether it’s proprietary or something in the present day or past or future, but when you know it so, so well, one, you’re going to find that writing is going to be way more fun and it’s going to go much more quickly. But two, when you’re done with it, you are going to be so satisfied with that final product and know and be excited for those haters and those critics to read it. And be like, I dare you to criticize my, my attention to detail in this.

And I think that’s part of the, you know, I’m, I’m one that I, I’m not a big fan of preparation. And you just like Adam alluded to before, you want to just start, you want to write, you want to finish, you want to have something you can share. You want to be a storyteller, not a story keeper.

Adam: And you want to put it on the page. Well, there’s an old theater adage. If it’s not on the page, it’s not on the stage. You can apply that to anything if you’re not putting it down. And I’ll, and I’ll, we’ll go into ways. To free write and stuff later on in the podcast, but I’m going to give you this little one, two crappy pages a day. That’s it. That’s what, that’s all you have to write. Listeners just write two crappy pages a day. You’re never going to write crappy pages. You’ll write great pages, better pages than crappy. And you’ll probably write more than two. I got a lot more than two pages of crappy writing.

Devin: I mean, I actually tend to use my crappy pages.

Adam: I tend to refine mine.

Devin: In my summation, my, my summation of this wonderful episode is preparation and. Whether it’s… However you want to prepare for it has… I’ve done it both ways right? I sat down and said I’m gonna write a brilliant script and I’m pretty sure I’m on 66 edits of that one and it hasn’t even seen the light of day. So that obviously didn’t work but I’ve also written where I’ve done the research, I’ve prepared, I’ve prepared, I’ve prepared and when I sat down I flew through writing a first draft and it was a way more enjoyable experience than… Than painting myself into corners and figuring out how I’m going to get out of it and things not making sense and…

Adam: I think and I think once you get more and more versed with with structure and scripting and the back and forth and the brainstorming you know where you collect your ideas and how you then put them into notes and then put them into a script and into a structure. There’s different ways of doing things. You sort of find your own approach and your own rhythm, but what Devin is saying is absolutely true. Preparation is key. Setting’s awesome.

Devin: And important.

Adam: And we like it.

Devin: We’re just going to keep talking about it because we like it. We haven’t perfected anything with podcasting, but it is actually figuring out how to stop. It’s kind of like all of my relationships in the past. It’s like we know that this has been over with for quite some time now, but how do I end this?

Adam: I don’t know how to end this. Please subscribe and rate us on iTunes, and for additional story-related resources, video, and archived content, visit our website at StoryOsophy.com.