Season 1, episode 6

Conflict!

December 20, 201738 min

Show notes

“Story is conflict” is one of the most repeated rules in writing. Adam and Devin take it apart. They agree the heart of story is choice, then argue, in true person-against-person fashion, about how much conflict a story really needs.

In this episode

  • Where the rule came from. Aristotle’s agon, Plutarch, and how “story is conflict” became a soundbite. Conflict is one of five basic elements, along with character, setting, theme and plot.
  • Story is choice. The hero has to choose to go on the quest and choose to keep moving forward. Conflict is what pushes back.
  • The chunk of beef. Devin’s analogy for an antagonist: you can work around it for a while, but to finish the arc, it has to go.
  • Contrast is the crossroads. For Adam, contrast creates the choices, and conflict is only one of them. Stories can also be built on growth, competition and progressive complications.
  • Antagonists are opposite perspectives. Protagonist and antagonist stand on opposite sides of the theme. From the minions’ side, the villain is the hero.
  • Relatable antagonists. Serenity gives its government agent reasoning you understand, until you realize your heroes are the riffraff.
  • Firefly’s origin. The story of Joss Whedon, a Star Wars novel pitch and C-3PO.
  • Catharsis over conflict. Aristotle’s more important word, Adam argues, and why fables and parables are built on contrast instead of fighting.

Examples discussed

  • Firefly, Serenity, Heat, Star Wars, superhero movies, horror movies, fables and parables.
  • Also: Aristotle’s Poetics, Robert McKee’s Story, Christopher Vogler and Joseph Campbell.

Next episode: the six types of narrative conflict.

Read the full transcript

Transcribed automatically, so expect the odd misheard word. Sponsor messages are left out.

Adam: Continuing from last episode’s conversation about the shadow, we’re broadening the definitions of what conflict and sources and forces of antagonism are. Next on StoryOsophy. Welcome to StoryOsophy. This is Adam Jones.

Devin: And Devin Halden.

Adam: We’re talking this episode about the concept of conflict in stories and broadening the definition to sources of antagonism, forces of antagonism. There’s a phrase that’s bandied about in story, which is, story is conflict.

And I’ve always felt like this is a very limiting way of viewing story. Anything boiled down to that degree is fairly limited. But we will explore the nature of conflict in storytelling throughout history and how it helps to define storytelling and characters. And originally, I think it derives from, although he does not necessarily use this word, Aristotle’s poetics, which outline what a piece of work, whether it’s dance, drama, theater, literature, what makes it function as it is, sort of what StoryOsophy is about. We’re sort of doing what Aristotle did ages ago. Where can story go now? And when he was describing it, he was talking about tragedy in particular.

And he referred to the force of antagonism as agon, which is literally one letter away from agony. But it was applied specifically to tragedy. Now, he apparently wrote a second volume on comedy, but it’s been lost. And later on, Plutarch, another philosopher. Discussed the need for conflict within a story. It’s interpreted nowadays and sort of like soundbited into a story is conflict. But we’re going to examine that further in this episode because it’s one of the five base defining features of what makes a story. There’s characters, conflict, setting, theme and plot. With that introduction to the concept and history of conflict within story philosophy. Devin, let’s talk about the foundation of conflict and sources of antagonism in a story.

Devin: This has been one of the areas between Adam and myself where I think semantics gets in the way a bit. But we just have different perspectives on some things and they’ll come out at different episodes. And I think this will be the first one. And that’s why we called this episode Conflict. Yeah, it’s aptly named. But I think what we do agree on in this is the story. The story is conflict concept is bogus. I think it’s a misnomer. But I think maybe it was supposed to say story has conflict. But to me, in my perspective, story is a lot of things. And I think at the real heart of story, it’s choice.

Agreed. And so I think, you know, the hero or protagonist must choose to go on a quest. Yeah. They must choose to keep moving forward in the face of conflict towards their goal or their objective. Yeah. And so conflict is simply an element of story, though an important one, that pushes against the protagonist. Conflict is. Yeah.

Adam: We’ve combined also in this episode forces and sources of antagonism and conflict, and they are slightly different topics. When you’re talking about an antagonist or the source of antagonism, you’re talking about the thing itself, not the back and forth between protagonist and antagonist, which is conflict.

Devin: An antagonist is essentially like a chunk of beef lodged in your throat.

Adam: Okay, well, maybe you can expand on that analogy.

Devin: If you can’t defeat that chunk of beef lodged in your throat, you will die. It’s an extreme, but the concept is there. It’s funny, I love it. You can avoid the antagonist, you can trick them, and you can get around them, but the only way to truly complete that transformation, the arc, complete the arc of the protagonist, you have to defeat it. And it doesn’t have to be life or death like a chunk of beef lodged in your throat. But in order for that transformation to happen, it has to go away, or it has to be chopped down enough where it’s not going just to rear its ugly head.

So a lot of times there’s false achievement, obviously, in movies with sequels and things like that.

Adam: I would say in terms of a traditional storytelling model, yes. But in today’s terms, the way we approach stories as individuals, we aren’t always fighting against something to overcome it, life or death. My only thing is it’s creating stakes that are life or death in terms of conflict is it keeps a story in a very specific realm and very specific genre and stake wise, you know.

Devin: The life or death thing isn’t to be taken literal. To complete the arc, whatever that antagonistic force is, must be overcome in order for that arc to happen. And in order for that… That full transformation to happen. And it’s whether one of these traditional six types of narrative conflict that we talk about later coming up, it’s overcoming something. And it doesn’t have to be life or death. And again, a lot of times when we’re explaining things, it seems like we’re stuck on a genre or something that’s one extreme or the other.

Adam: I’m just trying to broaden the definition in this way. I don’t think it’s always about overcoming. I think it can be about achieving. And that’s not overcoming a thing. That’s continuing a journey in growing. Growing and developing. That’s not conflicting or fighting against an obstacle. It’s learning and growing and doing that. But it’s not doing it in a way that’s fight oriented where there’s a person against a person or any of these other scenarios. We’ll talk, like you said, we’ll talk about here. I feel like you can build a story on the journey, the objective, and then the different crossroads of the path. Now, when I talk about contrast, and you’ll hear me talk about contrast a lot.

Because I think it’s the main thing in a story. Story thrives on the concept of contrast, as does our everyday life. In the past episodes, we talked about character archetypes. If there weren’t the mentor, and then the shadow, and then the herald, and then the threshold. If there weren’t these reflections or different things to look at. Now, again, that’s not polarized, like contrast indicates. Where there is a black and white, a left and right, you know, a day and night. Right. The reason why I say that contrast is at the crux of it all is it is what creates the idea of protagonist and antagonist. Here’s a person who thinks this, and here’s a person who thinks from the opposite perspective of that.

There’s contrast. That’s where you’ve built a differentiation of personality, of viewpoint, of objective, of all that stuff. They do not have to fight each other, have conflict, in order to make that story. It can literally be, as an example, a healthy sense of competition, contest. What I’m saying is, I think the way that story has been defined comes from an age of man where it was all about survival. And so, I feel like conflict was sort of built into the story instead of what you’re talking about, which is probably the most important word, choice. In all of these six type narrative conflicts we’re going to talk about, it’s all about some.

Someone against something, or in a lot of cases, it presents a person who is in a victimized state. A lot of horror movies, I mean, that’s the crux of any horror movie, is a person in a victimized state. So, I think the paradigm is shifting storytelling-wise, just as much as it is in any other large dogmatic institution, science, spirituality, religion, any of those, government. That’s all shifting. I think people are exploring new ways of telling story because with the advent of the internet and online storytelling, where… You can do chapter-based development of people and characters and human beings. I feel like people are more interested in that, solving the puzzle of the person’s growth.

And it doesn’t necessarily indicate the traditional model of… This person fights against this person. And I’m not, I don’t, I don’t by any means mean to discount the idea of like an unambiguous villain in a story where it’s like, this is good guy, this is bad guy, and that’s fun. Like superhero movies, you know what I mean? I don’t mean to discount that. I just don’t want to limit the definition of how you create antagonism or an antagonist, because I feel like broadening it, you can invent new ways, you know? Contrast is merely, for me, just the crossroads. Contrast equals the decision point in a story. And so you have to create different options for a character.

Devin: For me, contrast is, is a change in emotion from one extreme to the other. So when we first meet the hero, to be very, very extreme to the other, say he’s sad, say the hero’s sad, and then throughout this quest, he becomes happy. It’s very, I know it’s very dumbed down, but it’s, or despair into hope or becoming happy. Yeah. Like nature, monster, machine, another human, but it can also be internal and character versus self, I think is in, it should be in every hero. I think every hero needs to have this conflict of self. And I think in many stories you can have.

You’ll have moments where the protagonist comes face-to-face with forces of each, internal and external conflict. There can be a story where I think the hero must deal with or defeat one or the other, internal or external. But personally, if there’s a hero without internal conflict, they’re boring and perhaps not well-developed. So in order to have that contrast or the change of emotion from that one extreme to another, something or some things must happen in order for that transformation to occur or the need for that transformation to occur. So conflict and the overcoming of or defeating of that said conflict, whether internal or external, becomes that catalyst.

Conflict is the cause of the conflict. The one initial emotional extreme. So when we first meet our hero, whatever’s conflicting them, whether that’s internal or external, that’s the cause of it. Once that hero makes the decision to go on the quest, they are also deciding that they are going to battle the conflict, whether internal or external, in order to achieve that goal or to achieve that contrast, that change from one extreme to the other. Whether it’s from sadness to happiness. They’re sad now. They want to achieve that happiness. So that’s kind of where, that’s my perspective on how contrast and conflict are really working in harmony in story.

And one’s more of like a cause and effect. Or one’s a cause of achieving the contrast. And that’s looking at contrast as an emotional arc or the arc of the character.

Adam: Yeah, I’m not referring to contrast in that way. I would call that, it’s positive-negative polarity shifts. It’s what McKee talks about. It’s what McKee talks about a lot. Robert McKee’s book, Story, another book that Devin and I both very much like in terms of story structuring. Another one of the giants, along with Vogler and Campbell. But he talks about the need for a shift in what he calls a value structure, polarity, negative to positive, positive to negative. I’m not talking about contrast in that way. Contrast is literally standing at the crossroads and seeing the paths. That’s contrast. You need to be able to see left path from right path to make the choice.

Without that, without seeing the difference between mentor and shadow, there is no story. You just need choices. Contrast creates the choices. Conflict is simply one of the choices. You can choose to go down the right path of conflict or the left path of realization of that thing that you’re, quote, up against and the releasing of it. There are so many times in life where whatever that is, you don’t beat it to the ground and conquer it. Most of the time, that’s not what happens. You learn a lesson and you figure out a different way of circumventing it or improving or growth. I think that story for me, if you had to define it by that story is dot, dot, dot scenario, I would say story is growth. That would be my story is evolution. Story is expansion. If you can track that. When you’re talking about like having a character at the beginning of a story be, and I’m using your example, I know it’s rudimentary, but the sad at the beginning should be happy at the end, right? Going from one extreme to the other.

Devin: Or they just be changed. They’re a different person.

Adam: And change is the other huge thing. It’s catalyst. Story could be also story is catalyst. Story is change. These are all great words for story. The idea of conflict is to me simply a choice within a story. And I’m not saying it’s not one to choose to make a sensational story. It’s a, it’s a great choice. I think if you think on those levels of story is all those things, you’ll have a fantastic story. I just wanted to talk a little bit about the idea of antagonism, the opposite view of a protagonist and looking up the sort of nature of conflict. I noticed that antagonist was also had definitions in biochemistry and anatomy, which I found sort of fascinating. So I was like, Oh, I’m going to look what they mean instead of an antagonist. Sometimes it’s called an agonist in those particular categories, but in biochemistry, it was a substance that interferes with or inhibits the physiological action of another.

I thought that was really fascinating. And the other one in anatomy is a muscle whose action counteracts that of another specified muscle. It wasn’t necessarily about the conflict, but just the complimentary aspect. That’s what I mean by contrast, these two forces should exactly compliment each other. It was a couple episodes ago, talking about character and what makes them up. The idea of inner resistance is sort of what we’ll talk about as person against self-conflict, but I call it resistance because once the hero lets go of the stuff that’s holding them back and it’s not another person, usually it’s their own stuff, but they’re projecting it onto the opposing point of view. And so that person becomes a source of conflict. What’s the relationship between a protagonist and an antagonist, even if that antagonist is a force of antagonism or a source of it, not necessarily a character. Devin, in a broad stroke, what is the antagonist to the protagonist? And I think you kind of touched on it, not polar opposite.

Devin: Not the opposite of the protagonist. They’re the same person, but want different things. And so they’re the, I don’t want to keep using light and dark. They’re opposite sides of the theme. Yeah. And I don’t want to be used light and dark.

Adam: Yeah. We’re right and wrong. It’s sort of limited as well. Right and wrong. Yeah. Opposite viewpoints. Just opposite perspectives on the same topic or theme is really how you create antagonism.

Devin: They’re both the protagonist and their allies and the antagonist and his allies or minions, however you want to categorize them. Depending on what side of the fence you’re on is who the protagonist is and who the antagonist is. So if we were the minions, we would understand what the antagonist, what his goal is. And we would believe in that. And he would be the hero. And the protagonist in the story would be the person that’s going up and stopping them from achieving what they want. And then, and so vice versa.

Adam: It leads into one of the examples that I had too, exactly what you’re talking about. Keep going. You’re hitting it right on the head. It’s true. It’s all perspective. Who’s good guy, who’s bad guy.

Devin: Right. And I think it’s perspective and it’s, but it’s also important from a writing standpoint to have the audience understand the motivation and the goal of the antagonist. And to, and to also relate to that side of the, of, of the fence, you know, it’s this, it’s the Jekyll and Hyde of all of us where it’s like, we get it, man. We understand why the antagonist wants that. We understand some of those, you know, the, the greed and some of the other things that happened, but. We also will feel a lot better about going on this journey if we choose the hero, our hero, you know, who’s doing the right thing. That’s why those are two characters that are really very important to be well-developed, are both those, the protagonist and the antagonist.

Adam: If your story is lacking in something, explore your forces of antagonism. It’s all pressure towards development. As the story gets further along, the character has invested more time in whatever journey they’ve decided to participate in. And so, it means more. You’ve invested more time. It’s more meaning. It’s—your belief is stronger in it. You’ve built it up, and characters should feel that way. I was going to mention something about the definitions of both protagonist and antagonist. A protagonist being the leading character or one of the major characters in a drama, movie, novel, or fictional text. And an antagonist, a person who actively opposes or is hostile to someone or something.

An adversary. An adversary is something that’s, again, a broad term. It can be competition, contest, challenge. It doesn’t have to be you want to murder life or death the other person. Those tend to be high stakes and very intense, those kind of stories. But you can paint the opposite perspective of your protagonist as the villain if you want to. But that’s a choice. You still have to understand their reasoning and all of those pieces. The monster movie, where the monster is literally the physical embodiment externally of the hero’s internal conflict. Right, right. And that’s sort of like a really strong example of hero versus shadow. Or hero and shadow being one and the same, as you were saying.

The two types of antagonists to keep. In mind are relatable and redeemable. A good example of a relatable antagonist. And what I mean by that is you understand their reasoning. And you don’t think of them as, quote, the bad guy. They’re just the opposite side of the spectrum. In Joss Whedon’s feature film finale to his sci-fi fantasy series Firefly, the movie Serenity. He gives you access to the antagonist’s reasoning. He’s a government man with strong principles. He’s there to do a job and keep the riffraff out. And you realize. Holy crap. We’re friends with the riffraff. We’re friends with the thieves. You basically create an antagonist where he’s relatable.

And you’re like, well, he’s not really a bad guy at all. He just happens to be on the other side of our heroes and the law. There are lots of movies that play on that line. Heat just popped in my head. Where there’s this sort of interaction between the extremes. You know what I mean? Actually, I want to tell you an interesting fact about Firefly and Serenity. I don’t think I’ve told you this before. And it’s really kind of fascinating. As far as where it came about. Do you know its origin? I do not. Nor have I seen it. Oh. I will tell you a little bit about that right after the break.

Do you have a great story in mind? Some great characters? All these cool scenes and you don’t know what order to put them in? What goes here? What comes next? Story Blueprint is an app that provides a powerful and versatile tool to help you, the writer, build the roadmap of your story. Know where your story’s going. Know where your story’s going to start, where it’s going to end, and how you’re going to get there before you even begin writing. Once you have your blueprint completed, you’ll have a bird’s eye view of your story, removing the anxiety of the blank page. Story Blueprint is currently available in the iTunes App Store for iPad.

Coming soon for iPhone and Android. What about if you already have a finished script and you want feedback on how to improve your story for the next draft? Maybe you prefer a personal walkthrough to talk your story out one-on-one. Well, story-osophers, you can always talk to me. I offer a variety of supportive services from feedback for finished scripts to script doctoring and company consultations. I’ll diagnose your story to make sure all its parts are working toward the whole and strive to find a balance between traditional structure, storytelling innovation, and the writer’s personal voice and lens. I also do ongoing story therapy for writers who are looking for a coach to help build their story.

I ask you the questions that help you find your own story, and we discuss how to mine its gems. Consultation services are also available to directors and actors looking to break down scripts into beats and super objectives, and to production companies looking to refine the stories in their slate. For more information and a full menu of story doctoring options, you can visit doctajones.com. Links to both Story Blueprint and Dr. Jones consultations can be found on our website at StoryOsophy.com.

Before we get back to StoryOsophy, I just wanted to send out a special thanks to Rhys McClung, lead guitarist of the band Paper Sleeves, and an old friend of mine. Check out Paper Sleeves’ new album, available now in iTunes.

Just before the break, I was mentioning the origin of Mr. Joss Whedon’s television series Firefly and the finale movie Serenity. So here’s the thing, you probably won’t ever find it officially on record where Firefly came from. When Star Wars first came out, he got very excited, and they were doing expansions of the Star Wars universe, and he was a young writer. And he wrote a sample piece of work to submit so that they would greenlight him writing a novelization of the Star Wars universe. And he got word back from them, and they said, yes, we want you to write. We want you to write in the Star Wars universe. We want you to write C-3PO.

And he was like, C-3PO? I don’t want to write C-3PO. That’s not what I sent in. That’s not what I wrote. I’m paraphrasing, but he was like, you know, he didn’t want to do it. Yeah. He didn’t write the C-3PO novelizations. But he did, I believe, adapt his original adventures into a series called Firefly, in which Nathan Fillion’s Mal is Han Solo, and Adam Baldwin’s Jayne character is Chewbacca, which is awesome. Very cool. Very fun. Whedon’s awesome. What you try to find or build with an antagonist, polarity is very helpful. If you know what your hero wants or who your hero is, and you, as Devin said earlier, you’ve really gone deep and started to explore that hero and understand them.

If you literally just think of the opposite of that and start to build a character that’s based on a lot of the principles from another point of view, you’re going to have a natural conflict. Make sure you give equal time to either perspective when developing. Don’t just create polarities, good and bad, and demonize one side or paint them as a villain. Try to understand their reasoning and why they’re doing it. I would encourage you to care about all your characters and not create a villain that you judge, because you’re going to have a tough time writing that character, and it’s going to smell of judgment on your page.

So even if you don’t like what a character does, try to understand them and their… Or else you’re not going to have a very accessible character. I would encourage you not to examine conflict in such a literal way, but like I said before, that’s not even the word that Aristotle used. If anything that’s attributed to him that’s really vital for the art of storytelling is the word catharsis. And I think that’s really the point, is getting to a place where you’re pressured or where you’re changing or things are uncomfortable. It’s not just a catharsis for the character. It’s not just a change. It’s not just a change or a release for the character by the end of the story. But the audience should also identify. They should emotionally connect and then have some sort of discovery.

I like to think of stories as a puzzle that an audience has to solve. And so layers of character get discovered as it goes. Reveals of the story events happen as it goes. When they learn something new… Here’s the thing. You and I both talk about this regarding acts, where the character grows and develops and learns something through the course of the story. Good or bad by the end. It may end positively. It may end negatively. But they have experience. They’ve invested time in something. And so has the audience. And so to know your character’s super objective and their obstacles and have the audience go with them on that is really the key.

But try to think about opposing points of view. Because you don’t have to have people fight to have something be entertaining and tense. And sometimes it’s about what they don’t say. And the conflict there of them being… Silent when they shouldn’t be. There’s tons of ways to mine that stuff. But don’t just think of it in one way, conflict. Fables. Parables. There are a lot of types of storytelling that aren’t loaded with conflict. They’re simply loaded with contrast. Like I said, parables. Christ told parables for spiritual teaching. But there’s not a lot of conflict in them. There’s a lot of comparison and contrast. Stories come in lots of different forms.

It’s just the ones we’ve been most privy to in Western society are derivative of the idea of conflict. And I think that’s one of the things that we need to think about when we’re talking about conflict. And so, just as sort of stepping outside the box, always make new recipes. That’s the art of storytelling and entertainment.

Devin: I would agree with don’t take conflict literal. I think that was well put. This episode was started with the story is conflict concept that is out there, and I think… Out there? It’s out there in every sense of that term. I don’t agree with it, but I do agree that story has conflict, and I think all stories have conflict. Not the literal fighting conflict, but the internal person versus self conflict. And the way that I kind of, I personally look at it is the story starts at point A, and the story is going to end at point B. Whatever is preventing or in the way of the protagonist.

The antagonist getting to that point B is essentially the conflict.

Adam: I’d like to expand on that thought for a quick second, because there was one thing I was going to say. You’re talking about that thing that prevents the hero from achieving the goal and getting to point B. The source of antagonism is truly an illusion, and it goes back to that concept I was saying with characters and resistance. If a character is feeling like something is preventing them from achieving their goal, or not allowing them. Even though there may be… Something that is an obstacle. If the character is in the mindset that they have no power over that thing, you have a victimized hero and not a choosing hero.

Because it has a lot to do with self-worth. I think that that’s most characters journey are finding the places where they’re lacking. Like we said, what does the character want and what do they really want? And I think we’re getting more and more into storytelling where it is internal. Or the internal is explored externally. So are they a victimized character? Who’s that? Do they give their power away to? Something is pulling that person’s strings. Who’s pulling that person’s strings? Or are they choosing things in your story? A character who’s choosing things is way more interesting than the other, because you get to participate in the decision making.

Devin: The hero, no matter what, if they feel something’s preventing them getting from point A to point B, I don’t see that portraying them being a victim at all. I think they’re still making choices to go on the quest. They’re making choices to keep moving forward. They’re making choices to team up with allies. They’re making choices to learn.

Adam: Maybe a little semantics. It might be a bit of semantics. What I mean is, I like choosing characters. I like characters who make decisions consistently, scene by scene. And this is a writer end of it. Don’t be a writer who does stuff to your character because you think they need conflict. The victimization mindset of a character in a story, in storytelling, I think comes from they have to do something to their character. Because that’s how most writers feel about life. Things happen to them. They don’t really dictate their own life. So it’s reflected in the story in a certain way. And I like to encourage characters who make choices. Nowadays, especially, you can access their decision making process. And it’s exciting.

Devin: Yeah, the protagonist has to be a choosing character for sure. They have to choose to go on the call. They have to choose to answer the call. Yeah, they have to choose to keep moving forward. I definitely agree with that. It’s boring if it’s not. If you have a passive character, it’s really hard to keep it. And it’s also boring if you don’t have anything pushing up against it, pushing against that character or preventing them to getting from point because then there’s really nothing. Then what’s the point of the story? Then we’re just hopping in and hanging out with the guy for the length of the story. And he’s just walking towards whatever he has to get and he’s going to get it. So that’s the going back to conflict. That’s where I was saying the conflict is the pushback, whether it’s technology, whether it’s some supernatural force, whether it’s only self.

Or it’s another person that’s that conflict is there to provide meaning. For this journey, and to provide something that’s getting in the way of it.

Adam: This is where we actually may have a disagreement in philosophy, what you’re calling pushback. And that I would say does not have to be there. I would say obstacles and progressive complications is a broader way of putting the whole thing. And you can choose the conflict, and the pushback. But the whole point is, just the journey itself, as long as obstacles doesn’t mean conflict. It just means there are twists, turns, revelations, ups and downs. And same thing with progressive complications. It doesn’t get simpler, more times invested in the journey itself becomes more complicated. A roller coaster doesn’t have conflict, but it is a linear experience. It has ups and downs, it has opposing forces. But there’s no conflict. And so it’s still a ride and an enjoyable ride, but it doesn’t have conflict. And at the same time, from an opposite point of view, let’s look at action movies that are fairly empty. They’re not well constructed, maybe, that are nonstop start to finish conflict. It’s an action movie. That’s what it’s built on.

If story were just conflict, those movies would be genius. But it’s not. It becomes boring after the 14th explosion. Unless you’ve got characters you care about or reveals or discoveries within your events and your stories that make the audience excited to know what happens next, I didn’t expect that. Subvert their expectations. I think if people focus on that along with the sources of antagonism, you start to develop progressive complications for a character who’s developing. Think of children’s stories, cartoons. A lot of times it’s, there’s an idea. There’s an adventure. They go on it. It’s not necessarily conflict, it’s just obstacles to the goal. I feel like there’s a great way to view a story like that. Fables, parables.

Devin: There’s something preventing. The antagonist. So you, do you think you can have a story without antagonist?

Adam: Yes. What if the antagonist is not the antagonist? [unclear] Protagonist is self-doubt. That’s an obstacle. Conflict, I don’t think, is necessary to thrive a story. That’s my premise. Even though we spent the episode discussing the boxes that you would put story conflict in, I think new storytellers should push past those boxes, ignore the concept of story as conflict, and invent the idea of polarity forces. It doesn’t necessarily have to be conflict. Story is choice. I think we both agree with that. It’s choosing. There’s choices.

And growth. I think story is choice and growth. Yeah, and growth. Yeah, I agree with that. It’s expansion and evolution of a… You’re growing and changing a person by showing different aspects through events and other characters. And I find that to be the puzzle that’s fascinating with story. I don’t need two people fighting to enjoy that. All the examples you keep using are people fighting against each other. I don’t need people fighting against each other.

Devin: So I think, and I don’t see conflict. But that’s the word, though. Conflict means fight. But fight isn’t physical, though. Conflict is disagreement, too. And it’s dispute. So it doesn’t mean it’s physical confrontation. It’s something with a…

Adam: It’s against. It’s something against something. That’s what conflict is. Against. Right. I’m not disagreeing with it. An argument is still a fight. It’s still the same thing.

Devin: Do you have examples of movies that you feel devoid of conflict?

Adam: Children’s stories, cartoons, fables, parables, probably good for another episode. I don’t have any off the top of my head where I would pull good examples. I’d rather feel a little more prepared. One of the reasons why I get so adamant about this particular conversation is, no, I don’t see enough of them, dude. I’ve seen some and I’m like, oh, this is a really cool way to tell a story. And only a handful of writers dare to do it. I think it’s sort of fascinating and I’d like to see more people try. It is not the status quo, you know? Try something different.

Devin: Being conflicted in a story, whether it’s inner or outer, internal or external, I see it as a ball of twine, just a mess of yarn. And throughout the story, you’re untying that. Sure. And you’re making it… So that’s what you’re doing.

Adam: Progressive complications is what I would call what you just described, the ball of yarn. It’s not conflict. It’s just more complicated details. And you can choose the conflict.

Devin: Story has conflict. Life has conflict. There’s conflict in everything we do from the minute I get up to the minute I go have breakfast. There’s decision and there’s choice and there’s things like that. And conflict is an element of story. Story is growth. Story is making choices. Story is changing, is change. That’s what story is to me.

Adam: What makes something compelling to watch? Is a story more compelling if there’s a lot of conflict and fighting and all that, you know, an argument and it’s intense? Yeah. But all I’m saying is not… Not every story has to be rife with conflict. So I don’t… It’s just defining it more broadly is all. And trying to do it based on the framework of here’s the foundation of what we’ve been talking about, which is what is the traditional nature of conflict within a story? And then saying, okay, those are the boxes. I don’t believe fully in those boxes. You can choose to do extreme conflict between opposing forces, but I don’t think they have to be opposing forces that are in conflict. It’s two different ends of the coin.

It’s two different ends of the spectrum. It’s contrast. And then you can examine how they function with each other, meaning opposition against. So it’s defining those opposite sides of the spectrum.

Devin: So in this episode, Adam and I provided a great example of person versus person.

Adam: Poor people listening to this episode. Please subscribe and rate us on iTunes. And for additional story-related resources, video, and archived content, visit our website at StoryOsophy.com.