Show notes
Adam and Devin go through the six traditional types of narrative conflict one by one, with plenty of examples, and show how most stories blend several of them.
In this episode
- Person against self. The internal struggle, and the one to explore first for every character. Performers look for it too: secrets and obstacles to play.
- Person against person. Hollywood’s go-to, from superhero movies to Hatfields & McCoys, which Adam acted in. The other person doesn’t have to be a villain.
- Person against society. A hero who is part of the status quo has to change themselves before they can change their world. District 9 raises the stakes by taking everything from its bureaucrat.
- These rules are stupid. Huck Finn sums up person against society in four words, without ever treating it as a conflict.
- Person against nature. Storms, wilderness and survival, from Cast Away to The Edge, and why so many titles have “wild” in them.
- Person against the supernatural. Fate, gods, ghosts and monsters. Adam likes stories that explain the monster, like Doctor Who and The Babadook.
- Person against technology. Machines failing or turning on us, from Frankenstein to The Terminator. Orson Welles’ War of the Worlds broadcast made it real.
- Mixing recipes. Most stories combine several types. RoboCop blends person against technology with person against self.
Examples discussed
- The Shawshank Redemption, Fight Club, Captain America, The Hunger Games, To Kill a Mockingbird, 1984, District 9, Brazil, The Purge and Tombstone.
- Also: Cast Away, The Perfect Storm, Everest, Into the Wild, Jaws, The Blair Witch Project, Ghostbusters, A Christmas Carol, The Matrix, 2001: A Space Odyssey, Godzilla and Short Circuit.
Next episode: who Adam and Devin are, and how they met.
Read the full transcript
Transcribed automatically, so expect the odd misheard word. Sponsor messages are left out.
Adam: Welcome to StoryOsophy. This is Adam Jones.
Devin: And Devin Halden.
Adam: We’re going to talk a little bit about what are traditionally known as the six types of narrative conflict. We’re going to lay them out one by one, sort of tell you what they’re made of, although most of them are pretty self-explanatory. Then we’ll give you some examples. I have a few, Devin has a few. The first type of narrative conflict we’ll call a person against self. This is a struggle that is internal. It’s usually a person against some aspect of self, self-worth. Like I was saying in the character, what are characters made of episode, their resistant aspect.
This is where that is pivotal. Even if you use another sort of main conflict within your story, any one of the other five, this is a common secondary story conflict, something that’s internal. I suggest exploring this first. If you know this, you know how to build the rest of your story. If you can play with your character’s internal work, you can build a more natural story, but you can also play with the internal workings. Self-sabotage or fear, feeling victim to something is a lot of it, dealing with an addiction, some poor life choices, relationship work. You’re wrestling with an old story, something that used to happen in your past, which relates back to the character development.
You want background and perspective. A lot of stories are about a character coming to terms with something from their past and their present, and that has a lot to do with a mental state. You don’t want to be a victim to a mental state. [unclear] mixture of this particular one, person against self, and an amalgam with one of the other five.
But it’s something they need to get past, let go of, release, move on from, as far as an old story is concerned. I encourage you as a writer out there to create this for all of your characters, not just your protagonist and antagonist, but it’s especially helpful in writing for performers in stage and screen. What performers are looking for in particular are secrets for a character, something that they can have internally and hold, and also obstacles, something that they want and are going against. Generally, that’s what a performer is looking for. I would say that those are sort of the basics of what I would define as that internal person against self model of narrative conflict. Devin?
Devin: I agree. Every character should have a bit of this conflict, this inner conflict. And whether we discover the root of it, is up to obviously the writer and how involved the character is within the story. But every protagonist, I personally feel, has to have some internal conflict, whether at the very beginning when they don’t feel they’re ready or able to accept that call to quest or call to adventure, to knock over that first domino and begin the journey, or the inciting event kicks up something inside them that pushes them, whether it’s anger or some other emotion.
Some internal conflict has to be there in order for them to be, one, to become relatable, but also provide that catalyst for that change as well. My favorite example is, and I don’t know if it’s my favorite, it’s just one that came up when I was thinking about this, is Andy Dufresne in Shawshank Redemption. He’s convicted of murdering his wife and her lover and sentenced, I’m sure everybody’s seen him, sentenced to life sentences and things like that. But he must, his inner conflict is dealing with this, one, the sadness of his wife cheating on him and that betrayal, but then there’s also the anger of what has become of him and how—
Adam: The injustice. The injustice is part of what fuels his anger as well, yeah. Yeah. I love that. That movie. That’s a great example. Although I would also put that in the category of person against society in a way as well, because it’s a prison movie.
Devin: Yeah. And I was going to touch on that, too, where it’s like is usually this person against self is always going to have some other type of conflict involved. It’s because the inner conflict is is always going to be there, but there’s always going to be some external conflict as well. Or and a lot of movies are going to have multiple, multiple types of conflicts. If we’re talking about these traditional six types that we’re kind of going over right here, this there’s some gray area where they kind of meld together.
Adam: You’re talking about like Asian fusion cooking. Right. This day and age, we’ve had all six of them over and over and over and over again. So you want to mix up recipes. Right. You want to see what and a lot of my examples are actually some recipe mixes just because, you know, it’s easy to understand a prime example. But then just like the one you just brought up, Shawshank Redemption, it’s got a few in it. Right. One of my favorite flicks. It’s really simple is Fight Club. It’s probably one of my favorite examples of person against self. Because I love that movie and I love David Fincher’s work to actually create that externally is very awesome person against self. It’s not always the case. And I want to make sure that that’s clear as well. There are some characters who are self-confident, who are assured, and you never really doubt them.
You get a good example is detective characters and mysteries. Most detective characters have that thing [unclear] as a tool for that genre.
Devin: And they’re able to avoid their vulnerabilities, you know, situations that expose their vulnerabilities.
Adam: But then you also have the detective who is the alcoholic in a mystery who has this huge person against self thing or, you know, but I just wanted to mention that there are characters who are self-assured. There are characters who are competent.
Devin: And I don’t think that means. There’s always a mold to break. Self-assurance doesn’t mean they’re without inner conflict.
Adam: Well, I see. I would say it like this. Even if it’s not inner conflict, it’s still there’s a decision-making process going on in their head. And I feel like that is interesting enough for an audience. There’s two things that the person is trying to figure out. There’s choices. But it doesn’t necessarily have to be that they’re conflicted over it. They’re considering it and trying to figure it out. And then there’s an aha moment. And story has a lot of discovery and realization moments. Reveals, if you will. People call them reveals a lot. But person against self, the thing, the last bullet point I wanted to mention, the ultimate question you raise to the audience with whatever this conflict is, is why?
Why is this character against self? Why? What’s the why? And usually that’s when the background and the plot meet. The exposition and the current action meet. And I think that’s a little bit of what we were talking about. What do they want and what do they really want scenario? And what force person against self are they using to stop themselves from getting there? The second type of narrative conflict. Is person against person. Now, this is an external conflict, and it’s usually when characters are against each other. It’s just an individual against another individual. Classic ones are like cowboys and Indians, like gunfight, robbery, cops and robbers kind of thing. The conflict might be in direct opposition to competing ideas or opposing viewpoints. In other circumstances, it might be a conflict between the certain wants of two characters, two or more characters, romance, family, things like that. This type of conflict is pretty common in traditional literature in general.
Devin: I think person versus person is kind of Hollywood’s go-to conflict. Yeah. I think if you look at any of the superhero movies, that’s most often person versus person or hero versus villain. Or superhero versus villain. Again, though, there’s the elements of internal conflict for both of them. Following the theme of superhero movies is probably Captain America. Well, any of them. I wouldn’t even pull one on. I’d probably just stick with that genre where it’s person versus person is kind of the main conflict that Hollywood goes to.
Adam: Depending on what they’re up against, because Captain America against Red Skull as an organization. Right. Is multiple persons like a society instead of a person, too. So, it would depend on what the superhero specifically is up against. Batman and Joker, very simple. That is person to person. Arch enemies like that, arch villains. Yeah. But then you have to look at what kind of technology do they build? Are they bringing an army? Are they fighting that army?
Devin: Right. Depending on the comic book. It’s the one most used by Hollywood. So, I think person versus person, I think everybody kind of understands what that is. Yeah. So, I think that here… It’s a pretty simple one. Yeah. They probably think that one thing that we’re highlighting right now is most movies aren’t going to have just one and only conflict type. Sure. Yeah. The hero may have internal conflict, may have external conflict, may have person versus self, may have person versus person. He might be against nature and society. So, there might be all… The hero might be against all of that.
Adam: I was thinking about the same thing, and it’s sort of hard to talk about them without saying, here are the six, and then let’s cross-example them. You know what I mean? Right. So… Right. But you’re right. I think person versus person is a Hollywood go-to. And most stories, I think that’s what people understand. Because here’s a perspective, and here’s a perspective. And they’re both, well, if properly done, relatable. You have maybe a protagonist and antagonist, but you don’t necessarily have hero-villain all the time.
Devin: Right.
Adam: And that’s sort of important. Like those romances or family adventure or family movies and things like that, most of those are emotional. It’s not being understood within your environment or clan. Or something. You know what I mean? Or by the other person in the story. And it’s still person against person. But the other person is not necessarily a villain.
Devin: Right. They’re just the opposite perspective. And maybe the best way, as we go through this, is more of like, what is the… Though there are several different narrative conflicts within a story, the main theme, the main thematic one, probably, like if you’re looking at Captain America, it’s… Steven Rogers or Captain America against Red Skull or the Nazi-run Hydra research department. Hydra. That’s the main one. And then there’s all these other ones that obviously occur throughout the story.
Adam: Sure. Like the derivative one in the sequels, like Winter Soldier. Right. There’s a… It’s not just an organization. It’s much more of a person versus person conflict than that one. Right. You can proliferate the conflict in each story and have more than one. But yeah, person versus person, I think people, for the most part, understand that. I think my examples were pretty basic. We used the Wizard of Oz a lot, but Dorothy and the Wicked Witch, the Hunger Games is also a really big one, or Lord of the Flies, things like that.
Devin: I had the Hunger Games with another one down the road, the person against society.
Adam: Me too. Anything with a trilogy, anything that’s sort of got multiple chapters in it. Usually it’s still the first two, person against self and person against person, but after that it changes and morphs. So my last one was Hatfields and McCoys. I mentioned that for two reasons. First of all I’m from West Virginia, and I’ve known that story since I was a kid in the history books of the state. And then when the series was being made, I had the opportunity to perform in it. And so I’m in, I’m actually in all three nights. In two nights, I have a featured scene, but I play Walter Wiggins, the owner of the House of Ill Repute on the border.
It’s awesome. And if you listeners, if you want to check me out, I got a furry face in that one. It is a great piece of work. And I’m proud to have met and known the producer, Darrell Fetty. He’s a great guy. And hopefully, once we get through the basics and some of our structure and events, we’ll have him on as a guest. Check it out. Check out Hatfields and McCoys. Shameless self-promotion. I think it’s on Netflix, isn’t it? The last time I saw it was on Netflix, but I haven’t checked in a bit. Whatever, you watch it every night. Do you have anything else for Person vs. Person?
Devin: No, and I actually was kind of laughing at my thin notes on that one because… It’s pretty basic. It’s as simple as it gets. It didn’t move me.
Adam: So, I feel like that one is derivative of the next four we’re going to talk about. And I’ll explain that as we go on, but Person vs. Person is easy to understand. Person vs. Self is, well, for anybody, understanding self. But I think that’s one you have to… You really get to understand how to properly weave a story together with characters that, as we’ve said, you understand their reasoning, they’re relatable, they have a clear desire, and a clear resistance that we’re going to see reflected in the antagonist at some point.
Devin: And I think that’s where a Person vs. Self is where you start. I mean, I think that when you’re developing anything, when you’re developing the story or anything, it’s like that’s where… Yes, absolutely. That’s where you really want to spend a lot of time and you want to know your protagonist and antagonist and any other main characters. You want to know what that relationship is between them and themselves and that inner conflict. And I think that’s kind of where you start. It is where you start the whole development process. And then it’s figuring out where, from a story standpoint, what other specific one for a thematic one you want for another narrative conflict, whether it’s Person vs. Nature vs. Person, Society.
And it’s maybe some other. But I think that’s the biggest one is Self.
Adam: Yeah. Well, let’s move on to the next four so we can actually paint those examples a little better. The third narrative conflict is Person vs. Society. Even when you’re building the nature of that story, Person vs. Society, you look at the individual, what they’re like inside and outside. And then you framework it within the setting or the society that it takes place in. So that you can see why… Why that person has the inner conflict within that specific setting, right? Usually it has to do with not fitting in or not belonging. Usually it has to do with being an outcast. If you’re doing it against society in general, here are some quick ways of breaking down Person vs. Society.
It’s a person fighting their community or a group or groups of people, some aspect of society. So it’s not a person against the person. It’s a person against a larger group. It’s usually sort of a, as I was saying, an outcast, a person making moral choices or decisions against society’s rules. This particular conflict works really well in the sci-fi genre, in sci-fi movies, because in case, just for the purpose of those who may not know the word genre, it is the style or type of story that you’re watching. So sci-fi, action, adventure. It works well in the sci-fi genre because you need to build and paint this proprietary world and this sort of alternate fictional environment.
So your world is defined by the characters and the thresholds and whatever a person’s job is. If they’re trying to, you know, navigate society and there’s a store clerk, that’s a problem. Or there’s a public transportation thing, that’s a problem. Or the characters are still subsets of the society, of the concept of the society, because they’re adhering to the status quo, right? They’re obeying society’s rules, and therefore they’re sort of representing that society. Even though it might be person versus person that you’re using in that scene, there’s still pieces or gears in the machine of that societal world you’re creating.
Devin: I think you just hit the main element of the person-against-society narrative conflict, because I think usually in these types of stories, when you first meet the protagonist, they’re part of that status quo. They’re part of the society, and then events occur that make them want to change. But because they’re part of the very thing they want to change, they first must change themselves. That’s inner conflict out the wazoo, dude. You’re right. They have to go inward. Yeah. But then the other key element for that, too, I think, is that if they succeed, they change that world. They change that society. But then, like pretty much every other story, the world’s also going to have to change. It will also change them.
But I think the key to that is… What you said is they’re part of something. They’re part of that society. So it’s not like they’re coming into a different world or a different society and changing that culture. They’re imposing whatever their culture is, their society, on somebody else.
Adam: Well, they may be, not to be devil’s advocate, but a spaghetti western where the guy rides into town…
Devin: I knew you were going to use that.
Adam: …and needs to change the way that town is. What’s that?
Devin: I knew you were going to use… I didn’t think you were going to say spaghetti western, but I knew you were going to use a western. Because that’s when I was saying it through my head was kind of like what happens with in Tombstone. You know, that’s exactly what they’re doing.
Adam: I’m by no means poking a hole in what you’re saying, because what you’re saying is 100% accurate. What I’m trying to make as an example is you can always take one of the… You know the rules and then break them. The first season that we’re doing here is all about the rules. And then we’re going to talk about how you mix these recipes. And break them and bend them. It’s like that concept of person against society has so many different variations. So many different perspectives and lenses to use. Like I said, I think it works really well with sci-fi stuff. But a classic novel that’s a really great example is To Kill a Mockingbird, one of my favorite books. I love that book.
There’s inner conflict because Scout’s narrating the whole thing and we get to hear it from her point of view, which is just a genius decision anyway, to narrate an entire story from a little girl’s point of view about her father covering a trial. It’s just brilliant. So yay, Harper Lee. Thank you. And the other ones I had were mainly dystopian sci-fi movies, oddly enough, because this sort of fits in that. It may blend with one of our later topics, Person Against Technology. I had 1984, the novel, George Orwell. I had the film District 9, which I happened to catch on TV again recently. And I just forgot how good that movie is.
It’s so good. It is good. So good. And it really… It really, really was a great example of this. As I was talking to you when we were trying to plan this out, I was like, what’s a good example? It came on TV and I was just jumping for joy. I was like, I probably couldn’t think of a more brilliant example of that in a way that also takes South Africa’s apartheid and paints it in a really relatable way. It just was so rich, that movie. And perfect timing. And the last one I had was… Because I love Terry Gilliam. He’s one of my faves as a filmmaker, was Brazil. It’s more poking fun at bureaucratic society sci-fi stuff, where you have to fill out a form for everything. It’s comical in a lot of ways. But like I said, those last three are all dystopian sci-fi. Those are good. We touched on Hunger Games. I don’t think we have to get into the reasons why that’s a good one.
Devin: Not the first one necessarily. I mean, it’s got touches of it in the first one, the Hunger Games.
Adam: Person against society? It shows up more and more through Hunger Games. At first, it’s sort of like life or death, kids in the game, and it progresses throughout the series into opening it up where she sort of challenges the larger view instead of just survival. It’s a nice arc.
Devin: It’s the entire end scene of it, where she refuses to kill Peeta, and they devise that double suicide plan, which forces the authorities to intervene and save both of them. They kind of screwed everything up, and they made fools of them. And like the governments often do, they try to spin it and say that they’ll just be… because they fell in love and things like that.
Adam: That’s your twist. Your twist is the whole thing is like person against person, and it’s survival of the fittest, and then at the end they sort of turn the tables and the ending becomes this person against society thing. Blatantly, she challenged it. What I’m saying is, I think that’s the transition point in the whole trilogy to where those stories start to take on a broader perspective of person against society. It’s a good example, especially for young adult literature.
Devin: Yeah, I actually threw a book in there, too. I actually threw in Adventures of Huckleberry Finn by Mark Twain. Interesting. I like that. It may be a bit more subtle, but… Well, you could put Catcher in the Rye in there, too. I threw in an interesting one, because… Okay, have you seen The Purge? I know you don’t like those movies.
Adam: Well, no, I just am not a huge horror fan, unless it has really good thriller or psychological material.
Devin: So, essentially, The Purge is for one night a year murder and crime. Everything’s legal. You can go out and kill people, and you’re purging. You’re purging anger.
Adam: Yeah.
Devin: Those who decide to participate in The Purge are committing murder. And some other atrocities. And society has actually made it legal for them to do so. So, for that one night, they’re not really person against society until the next day when it kicks back in.
Adam: You bring up such good examples. I love asking you for your examples first, because they spark much more conversation. Mine are just as simple as I can make them, so they’re direct. But you come up with some really clever ones. The Purge, I think what’s interesting is wearing the mask to show the… The truth in a person, what they want to let out, what they want to do. It’s taking these basic conflicts and then putting a turn on it, or viewing it from a slightly different angle, and going, what if that got flipped on its head? And then you have The Purge. It’s a great example. I love your examples, Devin.
Do you have a great story in mind? Some great characters? All these cool scenes, and you don’t know what order to put them in? What goes here? What comes next? Story Blueprint is an app that provides a powerful and versatile tool to help you, the writer, build the roadmap of your story, know where your story’s going to start, where it’s going to end, and how you’re going to get there before you even begin writing. Once you have your blueprint completed, you’ll have a bird’s eye view of your story, removing the anxiety of the blank page. Story Blueprint is currently available in the iTunes App Store for iPad, coming soon for iPhone and Android.
What about if you already have a finished script, and you want feedback on how to improve your story for the next draft? Maybe you’d prefer a personal walkthrough to talk your story out one-on-one. Well, StoryOsophers, you can always talk to me. I offer a variety of supportive services, from feedback for finished scripts, to script doctoring. I’ll diagnose your story to make sure all its parts are working toward the whole and strive to find a balance between traditional structure, storytelling innovation, and the writer’s personal voice and lens. I also do ongoing story therapy for writers who are looking for a coach to help build their story. I ask you the questions that help you find your own story, and we discuss how to mine its gems.
Consultation services are also available to directors and actors looking to break down scripts into beats and super objectives, and to production companies looking to refine the stories in their slate. For more information and a full menu of story doctoring options, you can visit doctajones.com. That’s D-O-C-T-A Jones dot com. Links to both Story Blueprint and Dr. Jones Consultations can be found on our website at StoryOsophy.com. Before we get back to StoryOsophy, I just wanted to send out a special thanks to Rhys McClung, lead guitarist of the band Paper Sleeves, and an old friend of mine. Check out Paper Sleeves’ new album, available now in iTunes.
Devin: When I was thinking person versus society, and I’m not sure if it’s necessarily 100% truth in all cases, but the way that I was trying to categorize something like that is the protagonist, there’s a cost to the protagonist for choosing to take on this conflict. So they have to be risking something, you know, to stand by this conviction. So whether it’s like their reputation, cost of failure, cost of their future. Oh, I see. Once again, stakes. Yeah. And so if society is where they live and breathe, that’s where they’re, where they make their reputation. What happens when they remove themselves from it and fight for what they believe in? It kind of places the protagonist in this have to win battle. But I don’t know if that’s necessarily true for every scenario.
Adam: No, you make a good point. Now I’m going to try to framework it in a slightly broader way of saying it. When you do this, when you’re a person. Versus society, you are taking on, you’re choosing isolation and ostracization. You will choose to no longer belong to the group and fit in. Now, that’s as basic as it is. How you increase those stakes is what you’re saying. How you increase it, we’re going, if this is a high profile figure, meaning reputation, like you were mentioning the word reputation, their choice to do the thing that’s opposite of the society’s status quo, the, you know, the common man’s idea, the more they have invested in the idea of this fictitious society, that is whatever the thing is, the more they have to lose. So what you’re talking about is stakes. Every one of these characters is person against society is looking at isolation or being treated like an alien being, you know, but the more involvement they have had in their life in that society heavily, the more it makes sense.
This is why in District 9, this government worker who is part of the status quo and believes in the system and is a really good clerk in the government. When he’s thrown into an environment for the aliens and the creatures he’s supposed to be monitoring and has bigotry towards, and he’s slowly becoming one of them. It’s nothing more can be taken away. Everything he’s built his life on is that government bureaucracy is that society. It’s sort of a, that’s why the stakes in that movie are so high. Yeah. Put on the head. It’s how much involvement they have reputation wise, business wise in that society when they start is sort of how much leverage and, and, momentum you’re going to get out of that story from start to finish as to where they end up.
Devin: When I was thinking about Huck Finn, there wasn’t a cost. He was literally just being himself. He was just like, I just am done with it. Like, I don’t agree with the constraints of the society I’m living in. He didn’t really, in his own mind, have anything to lose. He doesn’t want to conform. Yeah. He just grabs his friend, Jim, and they take off.
Adam: He doesn’t have conflict. He just has adventure. That’s the thing I’m trying to point out with a certain style of story. It has more to do with a spirited hero, a hero who is adventurous, who doesn’t really view the choice of these paths as a conflict. They’re just like, all right, let’s see what happens. And I’m not saying that’s every hero, but you can do an adventurous type of hero. You don’t have to necessarily have conflict. You just have to have a super objective and progressive complications. That character may or may not react in conflict. And Huck Finn’s a great example. The way that he navigates his journey, his life perspective is not like that. So it makes him this enjoyable hero in the face of conflict.
Huck Finn, I love Twain. Mark Twain’s one of my favorite writers ever. And I love the character of Huck Finn because he just shrugs off society, as you’re saying. You can boil him down to just simply, these rules. These rules are stupid. Exactly, yeah. Whether it’s school or society or the way Jim’s being treated. And I think you can’t get a more boiled down motto for that narrative conflict of person versus society than that. These rules are stupid. Yeah, I agree. The fourth narrative conflict is person against nature, which is also extremely self explanatory. I’ll give you a few examples of what it means just to help out even more. It’s an external struggle with a person against an animal or a force of nature, such as a storm or a tornado or snow, just nature itself. Even being lost in the woods is a form of person against nature.
Also, as a broad epic tentpole Hollywood sensibility, natural disaster movies fall into this category. And there’s always stuff like person against person and person against self within those movies. But the general setup for the whole movie is that it’s a natural disaster about to happen. Devin, I was going to see if you had any examples for this one before I jump into the ones I’ve got down here.
Devin: I have three. Okay. And they’re three of my favorite movies. Cast Away. I had that one. Cast Away is brilliant in so many different ways. But that is probably the best example of a strong person versus self in almost equally person against nature. Yeah. When you’re, you know, picking a friend with a volleyball just to keep your sanity, and then with no hope, you’re kind of in this no hope, just survival mode. It’s not like your regular like my other two are The Perfect Storm and Everest. So it’s not like The Perfect Storm, where it’s this massive storm or these three storms that come together that they’re up against. And they have to survive that. This is essentially like every single day. He just has to survive storms. He has to survive the heat. He has to survive the fact that this island isn’t giving him food or a lot of food. So he’s got to figure out how to beat nature just to eat and to find water.
Adam: And it’s derivative of novels like Robinson Crusoe. And it’s thematic of this. I was going to mention a couple. I was going to mention a couple of things that are in my mind that are close to what you’re talking about with this. Into the Wild with Emile Hirsch and Wild with Reese Witherspoon. Another one was The Edge. They’re up against the bear. It’s person versus person and nature in that one with Anthony Hopkins. You know what I’m talking about? The David Mamet piece. And then even if you look at like a reality TV show like Man versus Wild, notice how many times Wild is in a lot of these titles. Because I think there’s something thematically about these person versus natures where it’s.
It’s sort of like gets a person back to their animalistic roots in a way. And I think that’s part of the appeal of that. I also put down Jaws. One of the things that I was thinking about when putting this together was there’s not a category in this that’s person against God or someone is sort of bucking that concept. I wasn’t sure where that fit. I thought it could be nature, could be supernatural. But I thought we discussed that later. But that was one of those things that I was thinking.
Devin: And I don’t know why there isn’t in the traditional. Six types of narrative conflict list is there is not person versus monster and monster for lack of just for lack of a better term. But Jaws would fit in there that the bear would fit in there.
Adam: My segue example, I was saving it to the last bit until you were done with your examples to move to the next one, because it’s sort of as a combo. Go for it. Blair Witch Project. The first half of that movie is these kids who are being dominated by the wilderness and nature and they’re lost in the woods, even though they’re on a supernatural pursuit. And then the second half, it pivots on when the one goes missing. So the crisis, central crisis, this thing happens and it all of a sudden truly becomes a supernatural. The fifth narrative conflict is person against the supernatural. Now, we were talking a little bit before what you were just saying, monsters. This is it. This is the monster. Anything that has powers above and beyond a human being, this you put in this category. Technically, when I was asking that question about person against God, it’s more.
I was saying more of an apostasy scenario, but it would be considered in this category as well. Something that is beyond natural, supernatural. So it would encompass fate or the fates, God, the gods, the undead, ghosts, aliens, demons, monsters, anything beyond human. Yeah, this is where I would put what you’re saying that that person against monster. But this is a little bit more sort of all encompassing. I do want to talk about your notion of monster. Though, especially in this category, it’s an interesting thing. Monsters and demons. What? Why do people manifest these things in their imagination to put on into stories and on screen? What are monsters? What are the supernatural? Did you have any good examples?
Devin: Yeah, these are my favorite. Some of my favorite movies are the supernatural, and kind of covering, like, the demons and the ghosts and things like that. And I think it’s one of those categories… It’s kind of like UFOs or aliens, where I kind of want to believe so bad in ghosts. And when I’m watching Ghost Hunters and Ghost Adventures and things like that on TV, I really, really want to believe that digital gurgle I heard is exactly what they’re telling me. And then so when I’m watching that, I’m like, they’re like, Oh my God, did you hear that? He says, I’m going to come kill you. And I’m like, I don’t hear that at all. But then they play it over and over and over again. And then I’m like, yes, I totally get it. Now I totally hear that. And it’s the same thing of like, why do I watch Finding Bigfoot? I know for a fact that when I start watching that show, they’re not going to find Bigfoot. I know. Otherwise I probably would have heard about it way before they released this episode. But yet part of me is like, I just love the adventure of something that I want to believe in.
Adam: One of the things we were talking about earlier is the monster is the external version of the hero’s internal conflicts. I mean, for a great example for this, one of my favorite reinvention series, or continuation, Doctor Who. Doctor Who has built a franchise. Out of compassion for the monster. Don’t fear the monster. It starts with this conflict and fear. And then by the end of each episode, they’ve sort of dissipated it. They’ve sort of said, here’s why you don’t need to be afraid of this dark corner. You now understand why it is a monster. To me, if I’m doing person against supernatural, that’s what I want to do. Why is this monster here? Babadook. It’s an externalization of psychological issues, of emotional issues, of abandonment.
Abandonment. That’s the kind of stuff I like in person against supernatural. Instead of just like a slash and hack and slash horror. Some depth to it, I mean.
Devin: Some intelligence to it. Yeah. I had three examples. Oh, go for it. They’re pretty obvious.
Adam: Tremors. I’ll throw Tremors out first. I got to throw that one out and then I’m done. I like Tremors. I love Tremors.
Devin: Exorcist, Poltergeist, and Ghostbusters.
Adam: Ghostbusters. Another one of my faves. Yeah. It’s weird. All of those are very ghost. Yeah, they’re all ghost. They’re all ghost related. I’d say any monster movie fits into this. Anything that’s beyond human comprehension.
Devin: One that was interesting, and this is probably because it’s one of my favorite stories of all time, is A Christmas Carol. You may at first glance think that’s person against supernatural because there’s three spirits that come visit him. And of course, there’s person against self. But I was trying to figure out where I would put that. And I had to almost come up with a different category of man versus fate. Well, that’s supernatural. Fate and the gods and all that stuff. It’s all part of supernatural. I just wouldn’t put it in there, personally. I don’t think it fits in there for some reason.
Adam: They include anything that’s superhuman, beyond human. That’s that category. It may be a different kind of feeling, but what I’m saying is, as far as the definition of what that narrative conflict is.
Devin: Like trying to put it into a box. That’s the box you’d put it in.
Adam: Yeah. It’s trying to put it into a box. That’s the box you’d put it in. Well, like, dude, you and I both know, as far as even this podcast, it’s not meant to label or put into box anything. StoryOsophy is the continued discussion of story and where it goes from here. But we are discussing the foundation and the basics. And so we are talking about boxes that most people have defined things by.
Devin: I wouldn’t put Christmas Carol in supernatural. But again, we’re just, right now, we’re just kind of going over these traditional conflicts that exist that everybody knows about. Yeah. Talking about the boxes. And then we’re going to open the boxes.
Adam: We’re talking about boxes. Let’s just stop. We’re talking about boxes. I’ll leave it alone then. The sixth and final narrative conflict we’re going to talk about in this episode is person against science or person against technology. It’s been dubbed either one. It’s basically the idea, it’s another external conflict where it’s pitting, whether it’s technology failing or, you know, where you’re like Speed or on a plane, if a plane’s going down. So, any of these where it’s a failure against machinery, a plane, train, automobile, spaceship, even computer, a thriller where there’s a person with a ticking time bomb. This lends itself also to the sci-fi and thriller genre, more modern stuff. Actually, a lot of supervillains come forth from this concept because it’s the perversion of science in a lot of ways.
That’s where this genre comes from a lot. And classics like Frankenstein, of course, or War of the Worlds. Even though War of the Worlds is a little bit supernatural, because it’s Victorian England, it’s a lot more people against technology that’s beyond them. Anyway, I had some other examples, but I just wanted to know where your thoughts were at on this one.
Devin: You brought up War of the Worlds, and I’m assuming you’re meaning War of the Worlds, the book. Yeah, the original book. Yep. So, that was one person. Against technology. But if you also take the Orson Welles version of War of the Worlds. Oh, interesting. Where he used radio. To obviously, it was just people that tuned in a little later that didn’t realize it was a show. But the panic that he caused, that was a real life version of person versus technology. It was people listening to their radios and the radios giving them this information. And I mean, it caused crazy panic that some there were there were people running, running into churches and and praying that it’s interesting that you brought that up.
Because that’s, of course, within the book, there’s a there’s a version of person against technology. And then if you actually take the real life event of Orson Welles and his radio show that happened on October 30, I think it was 1938. And that was the technology there. There wasn’t TV, it was people listening to the radio. And if you tuned in late, they didn’t do any interruptions that said this is just this is just a radio show. Even though the radio station asked them to Orson Welles is like, no, I mean, he was just the consummate actor. He’s like, Nope, this is we’re sticking with the we’re not pulling people out of the story now out of this there. If they’re engaged in and then and then the the fallout of it the next day was pretty incredible. But that’s storytelling.
Adam: Like I said, you always give good examples. It’s more like live theater person against technology, the way you’re talking about it. But the idea of catharsis in story, it was something that I always think is extremely pivotal in stories. And that’s it. It’s like these people are purging emotionally and participating. I mean, they’re literally participating in this story. They are involved citizens in what they think is real, but it’s a story. So I mean, that historically is probably one of the most amazing bits of storytelling ever done because of what it was.
Devin: [unclear] Orson.
Adam: Yeah, that’s that’s what kind of launched his career. So genius. I mean, he was very busy. He was doing like 20 radio shows a week or a day or something like that. He was but that’s when he started getting into film. And so I was going to throw out a couple examples here. This one once again, sci fi and fantasy kind of stuff. But I mentioned Frankenstein as probably one of the classic piece of literature that is there probably one of the first where Victor Frankenstein creates a perversion. Of science in Frankenstein’s monster, right? And then War of the Worlds, of course, the Matrix, the Terminator, Battlestar Galactica, 2001: A Space Odyssey, with HAL the computer and Dave. Another one I was going to give, which I thought this one was really fun, was RoboCop. And I don’t mean the 2014 remake, I’m talking about the original 87 film. It takes place in a crime-ridden dystopia.
A lot of sci-fi movies are dystopias. So the premise is a terminally wounded cop returns to the force as a powerful cyborg haunted by submerged memories. And to round out our conversation regarding how you can mix and match a lot of these different narrative conflicts, I couldn’t think of a better example of person against technology or science and person against self to sort of round out our list of the six here. Because he’s wrestling with who he was before he died and was reinvented as RoboCop, as a robotic cop. The original movie is very graphically violent, if you haven’t seen it. And you have a queasy stomach like me, don’t do it.
Just don’t do it. Or have your friend go, turn away now. Put your hands over your eyes now. Because still, just to be able to watch that and have Peter Weller go, drop it, creep, is awesome. I love that movie. I’ve always loved that movie. But it is a good example of sort of the blending of person against self and person against technology. Yeah, that is a good one. Did you have any other examples?
Devin: I just threw down all of the Godzilla movies. And maybe it’s more of like how the main, probably the first Godzilla movie is probably where you start. And that’s kind of an interesting progression from, person versus technology to person versus monster or supernatural. Yeah. So man creates technology, technology creates a monster, and then man must defeat monster or supernatural, whatever. And then I had Automata, which is kind of a robot. They make a robot, man makes a robot, robot takes over the robot, goes rogue. And then man is like, crap, now we got a wrangling robot.
Adam: Oh, Short Circuit, you mean?
Devin: No, Automata.
Adam: Kidding.
Devin: I was like, what are you talking about? Although, dude, Short Circuit, I forgot about that movie. It’s so good. Or what’s that other movie, The Navigator or something like that? Yeah, Flight of the Navigator.
Adam: Oh my God, that movie is so good. Yeah. Great movie. Totally forgot about that movie. I loved Short Circuit because everybody loves a wisecracking robot. Please subscribe and rate us on iTunes. And for additional story-related resources, video, and archived content, visit our website at StoryOsophy.com.