Show notes
Animator, writer and filmmaker Josh Stifter was one of five filmmakers Robert Rodriguez chose for Rebel Without a Crew, a docuseries in which each made a feature for $7,000 in 14 days with no crew. Josh talks about writing and shooting his horror comedy, The Good Exorcist, and what a tiny budget teaches you about story.
In this episode
- Learning by doing. From stealing his dad’s camcorder to animation school, Josh taught himself each part of filmmaking by needing it for the next project.
- Write for your resources. Josh and his co-writer, Daniel, wrote around props they already owned, like a teddy bear and a strange suitcase, so they wouldn’t come out of the budget.
- Muscle and connective tissue. Each scene was its own short film shot in the morning, with the material that ties them together shot in the afternoon.
- Let the script die on set. Keep the character arcs and the point of each scene, and let the actors find the rest. “I always wanted to be a metal detective” was an ad-lib.
- Every scene is a mini story. Start on a negative, turn to a positive, and sometimes leave the audience on uncertain middle ground.
- Constraints as a teacher. No reshoots, terrible audio, a construction crew on set. Josh recommends doing it the hard way once.
- Shoot both endings. The joke Stanley ending was meant for the DVD extras, until the edit showed how much Stanley had grown.
- Setups you feel. Father Trejo strides around a corner. Later, Father Gil peeks around the same corner, terrified.
Examples discussed
- The Good Exorcist, El Mariachi, Robert Rodriguez’s book Rebel Without a Crew, Three Kings, The ’Burbs, The Simpsons and Save the Cat.
Thanks to Josh, and to Jason Lachey for the introduction.
Read the full transcript
Transcribed automatically, so expect the odd misheard word. Sponsor messages are left out.
Adam: This week we are joined by special guest Josh Stifter. Animator, writer, and filmmaker here to talk about his experience on Robert Rodriguez’s new reality docuseries, Rebel Without a Crew. Next on StoryOsophy. Hello, welcome to StoryOsophy. This is Adam Jones.
Devin: And Devin Halden.
Adam: This week we have a special guest with us. He was one of the filmmakers chosen by Robert Rodriguez to be a part of Rebel Without a Crew. Which premieres on El Rey, November the 18th. Right on. Josh Stifter, everybody. Josh, pleasure to have you with us.
Josh: Yeah, this is awesome. I’m excited. I do a lot of podcasts, so I’m excited to be on one. I personally do my own podcast, and then I’ve been on a bunch throughout the years. But doing one about story especially, and being able to talk about filmmaking, my writing process, and whatever, this is going to be exciting, I think. It’s very different.
Adam: So you want to start? Do you want to start by giving us a little background about how you came into film or what you do within film?
Josh: Yeah, so I started in film. I mean, I’m that classic cliche story of, like, kids stealing his parents’ video camera and filming. Like, that is what I did as a kid. Me and my three friends would grab my dad’s camera, which he, you know, it was his, like, baby. So he didn’t want me to use it, so I’d have to steal it while he was at work or try to find a way to sneak it out of the house. And we’d film with it. Yeah. And it’s funny how crude and rudimentary it looks now. You know, it’s like the, right after it went from, like, the backpack VHS camera that you had to carry around on the big, with the big long cord and stuff.
It was right after that, when they finally put the VHS right into the camera. So it was one of those. And I’m a small man to begin with. And as a kid, I was even smaller. So I had to carry this massive thing. Like, it had, like, a shoulder mount thing. It was huge. So me and my friends would run around with that. And that’s how I started. But I really, when I got into high school, and I was actually going into the seminary, which is kind of the exact opposite of what I ended up doing. But I went to a private high school thinking I was going to join the seminary.
And. So about, you know, halfway through, I was like, I’m spending all my time making cartoons. I was really, really into Tim Burton at the time. Of course. And Tim Burton’s way of getting into filmmaking was through animation. So when I went, when I started thinking about it, I was like, well, I don’t have access to a whole crew. I don’t have a lot of money, but I have enough, you know, to buy pencil and paper and start drawing. And I had a scanner through the school, so I was able to just start doing animation through the school. When I graduated from high school and I was debating whether I went, was going to go into the seminary or going to filmmaking, I was like, well, I’ll go to school for animation. With video games, you know, CGI movies were just becoming kind of a big thing. You know, Pixar, the toy, like Toy Story 2 had kind of just come out, I think maybe, or maybe, it was maybe a little post that, but it was around that era when Pixar was really, really hitting their stride. So I was like, you know what, fuck it. I’ll go to school for animation. And that’s what I did.
Yeah. And so animation was just a way to learn everything and especially storytelling because I wasn’t that good at drawing. I wasn’t that good at, I didn’t have a lot of time because I had to work a full time job. So animation is so time consuming. So I kind of crafted this really nasty sort of really rudimentary old school Simpsons or, you know, Beavis and Butthead style that I was able to kind of learn act structure, telling stories, what kind of jokes I wanted to make, what my sense of humor was. It’s something you kind of take for granted. You know, you, as a person, we learn to tell jokes in the way we tell jokes. But when you have to dissect that and try to put it into a story, [unclear]
It’s really hard. So that was kind of what I was learning to do through the animation was that. And then as I’ve gotten older, I’ve just bought stuff as I went along. Like, well, I guess maybe I’ll learn how to do live action for this little film fest. So I bought a camera. Do sound because I want the sound to be better for my animations or for my movies. So I started podcasting to learn how to do audio. We still don’t know how to do that. We still, we’ve been podcasting for… I’ve listened to your guys’ a couple episodes. It sounds good. You guys do a good job. I’ve listened to a lot more where it sounds a lot worse. So…
Adam: It’s interesting to me that your curiosity, it’s almost like Montessori. Your curiosity is what led you to the next stage. Well, I need to improve here. Right. And so let me seek out that skill set and understand it. And it’s like what Devin and I do with story, dissect it a little bit. That’s interesting that you let your curiosity and inspiration lead you to your next stage.
Josh: Well, that’s 100% what it is, is it’s like each time I finish something, each project is learning something. Like I’m trying to teach myself how to do something. Because I don’t, I don’t learn what… Well, like I can’t sit in a class and take a test and it’s like, oh, okay, now I understand. I just have to do it. And I have to do it a lot to learn how to do stuff. Practical, yeah. Yeah, I just can’t. I can’t sit down and just… Like I can’t, I couldn’t learn story by taking a class on story. I couldn’t learn act structure by just reading a book. I had to actually like write out the act structure, figure it out. I had to do everything. And that’s what The Good Exorcist was, was it was my test. Number one, it was my…
It was my attempt at just actually going to film school. Because I never went to film school. So, because what I heard about film school was like each class teaches you how to do a different thing. And by the end, you kind of learn which piece of the process you want to be. And I just don’t, I’m not a, I can’t be just one part. I can’t be a cog in the system. I have to just be my system, if that makes sense. You know what I mean? Like I can’t, I can’t just be a sound guy. I can’t just be a DP. I just, I can’t just…
Do one thing. I want to be a part of everything. And so Rebel was a chance to get in front of people and make an ass of myself and fail. I knew, I thought I was going to fail. I went into Rebel without a crew going, all right, $7,000 movie. These days in the, in the era of entertainment, like it’s good. No one’s going to want to see it. No one’s going to want to watch my movie. I’m going to fail and I’m going to look like an idiot, but at least I can do it with my best friend. And we can kind of go on a, we can go on a dad vacay.
You know? And so that’s what I do for fun. And part of it was like, right. And I was doing it for a reality show. So everyone expected me to fail. Like no one thinks of positive things coming from reality shows.
Adam: Has there ever been anything positive? So let’s framework it a little bit. So our listeners have an idea of what you were, what was going on there. So tell us a little bit about Rebel. Is it Rebel without a crew, the show that’s soon to air? Is it a competition series? Is it a reality series? How did you get involved with Robert Rodriguez and Rebel? And yeah, give us a little background on the show. So our listeners understand what you were doing.
Josh: They call it a docu-series. It’s not a competition in any way. It’s purely five filmmakers and Robert Rodriguez are going to make movies for $7,000. That’s it. Like you have to rely on your skills and abilities. The idea is it’s going back to Robert’s first experience in El Mariachi where he had no crew. All he had was a camera and 14 days to shoot in Mexico. He had a friend like location scouting for him. He was picking his cast on the fly. It was stuff like that. So that’s what we did. We did exactly that.
Adam: Which is insanity. Just so everyone who’s not done it, that’s utter insanity.
Josh: Right. And $7,000 then was a lot. More than it is now, obviously inflation. However, Robert spent his $7,000 almost entirely on film and we got to shoot digitally because he shot on film stock. Yeah. Yep. 16 millimeter. So, you know, we shot digitally, so we saved a ton of money shooting digitally. So we got to put almost all of our $7,000 towards, you know, I paid a thousand dollars for my score. I paid my cast. I paid for a couple of visual effects things. I mean, when I say I paid… Wow, dude, that’s pretty impressive to spread that budget that out like that. Well done. Yeah. I think when all was said and done at the end of the film, what I actually spent on what you see on the screen, not like behind the camera, it was about $800 because I bought a couple of wardrobe things. I bought like garbage bags was one of the most expensive things I had to buy, which is so weird. But like black garbage.
You can’t just buy one. You have to buy a pack. And it’s like I wanted some that were 300 of them. I wanted some that’s like thick enough that, you know, it has like a nice thick quality for the monster because the monster was like a garbage bag with some eyeballs. And then I’d wrap garbage bags around these tentacles I got for like five dollars. So anyway, the garbage bags cost me like 12 bucks and it was like, oh, man, twelve dollars. That’s so funny. Or I think clay. I bought a box of clay to make like fangs for like the there’s like a part where a Bible attacks.
And so I bought a dollar store black book that, you know, I had a Bible. So I just used the Bible that I had. And then I bought a dollar store or I think I think it was like a not a dollar store, but one of those like really cheap stores that cost me like three dollars for this black book that I then put ping pong ball eyeballs on. And then I made like clay teeth for it. And the clay teeth cost me making the clay teeth cost me like twenty five dollars for the clay. Because the clay is so expensive, right? The art, the art supply.
Itself. And that’s what the the clay shows up throughout the movie in like random places all over. You’re like, I’m going to spread this out and make it worth my dollar. Oh, yeah. Oh, yeah, I totally did. I was just like, what do we like when we would try to come up with something? We were like trying to make gross looking soup. And I was like, what do we have that can make gross looking soup? I’ll just use the clay. It looks nasty. I just grab the clay. So it looks like he’s eating like some gross thing that every time I’ve watched the movie, it always gets this like groan.
When people see it, I’m like, guys, it’s clay. Like, that’s just clay. You would never eat that. The magic, the movie magic right there. You know, what’s funny is the actual the actual most expensive thing in the entire movie is something you don’t see. And that is Britney, who plays Maria in the movie, had a birthday. And Daniel, who plays Father Gil, without telling me, went and bought her a birthday cake that cost like forty dollars, like a fancy birthday cake. And the reality show was like, you guys can’t do that. That comes out of your budget. And I was like, God damn it. We could have got like a five dollar cake like or fucking doughnuts, like something cheap.
So that cake came out of my budget. I don’t know if I’ve ever told that story before. You guys just got an exclusive. Excellent. So that’s so funny. They made you claim the cake as part of an expense for the production? Yeah, it was so weird, the things that would come out of my budget. And it was all based on, like, the union rules because of, like, what the union could pay for and what I had to pay for. And how they couldn’t charge Daniel because he, because the show was technically union, even though our movie shoot wasn’t union. So, like, Daniel couldn’t spend his own money on something. I don’t know. It’s all, that’s the thing that Robert, Robert didn’t have to deal with any of the legal bullshit.
Adam: Well, every crew I’ve ever been on, when there’s a birthday, the birthday does not come out of film expenses. Do you know what I mean? Right. It’s a little absurd. That’s so funny. And Daniel. Yeah. Daniel Dagnon. Is that how you say his last name? He’s your co-writer. Yeah. And. He was my co-writer. Yeah. And the lead in the film.
Josh: Yep. So we knew, we knew two things. We knew that I wanted Daniel to be in it because I wanted Daniel to go with. Gotcha. So when we sat down to write, we wrote for him. And then we also knew that we would have certain props. So stuff that I could fit on a suitcase to fly to Austin. So I was. I knew I would be able to bring at least a couple suitcases. So I was like, well, I’ll bring like two pairs of clothes and I’ll just wash them every day. So I’ll fill my suitcases with. Genius. Props that I can bring that I already have. So they don’t have to come out of my budget. I can just write them into the script. So I have some prop guns from old movies. We’ll write those prop guns into the script.
Right. We have this weird suitcase. We’ll write that into the script. We have a teddy bear. So you wrote for your resources. Exactly.
Devin: Yeah.
Josh: Yeah. And, you know, putting yourself inside of that box makes it more fun sometimes where you’re like, OK, what can I do with this teddy bear? Like, how can I make this teddy bear fun to look at? And then I’m not writing around, you know, maybe I would have made the teddy bear monster something totally different, like something that’s way cooler in theory. But when you saw it in the movie, it would have been garbage because I’m not writing around that thing. So as I was laying out when I write my script, I do it. I do the like save the cat method. I do the save the cat method of 40 cards.
I think they talk about that in one of the other screenwriting books too, like the 40 cards for like act one is 10 cards, act two part one is 10 cards, you know, et cetera. So what I did was I just started writing ideas on these cards and then kind of like placing them where I thought they might fit in the story structure. Like non-linearly? Totally non-linearly. I was thinking in like how can I make this scene its own short film? And this scene its own short film? Because I didn’t know 14 days is not a lot of time.
No. Not at all. So when you think about – when I think about that, I was like, well, how can I get one short film? How can I segment this in a way so that each morning I can shoot one of these short films and then the second part of the day I can film structural stuff? You know, like stuff that actually blends those short films together to tell the story. Yeah. Stuff that actually blends those short films together to tell this full story. Oh, that’s clever. That’s really smart, dude.
Adam: So you’re talking about muscle versus connective tissue. Right.
Josh: So, yeah. So each day I would do muscle in the morning, connective tissue at the end of the day. That’s so smart, man. And then – and then I could edit after – like every day when I got home from the shoot, I could edit. So I can make sure that I’m getting enough that at least the movie is coming together. That’s a great strategy, man. Right. And then if I’m like – if I’m there and I’m like, holy shit. This short film. This short film is way harder than I thought. I just cut it. It’s not a necessity. The teddy bear scene doesn’t actually – it gives us character development.
It shows us the terror that Father Gil is going through and how it is becoming a struggle for him. But it isn’t a necessity. It’s only – like I could have said the same thing with a 20-minute shoot. You know what I mean? Does that make sense?
Adam: Yeah.
Josh: So like that card – that card is necessary. I have to show Father Gil. I have to show Father Gil in some peril. But – Do I have a whole morning to shoot this teddy bear sequence, or do I have 20 minutes? I’ll just rewrite on the fly to tell that same idea, to give that same three-act structure of that moment, but I don’t necessarily need it to be so big. So that’s what I did, and some scenes completely changed based on that.
Devin: Right. That’s what I was going to ask you. How much of you actually sitting down and scripting and scripting out dialogue and scenes, was that basically just an outline for you guys, and then you guys basically were flying by the seat of your pants and trying to make days and trying to get everything shot that you wanted to shoot that day, kind of just had to make… Adjustments? And did you take input from the actors, like, hey, man, I should play it this way or I should say this instead of what’s on the script? Or did you guys try to use the script as a pretty good blueprint and map for the production just for efficiency purposes?
Josh: To answer that question, I have to start at the beginning of Daniel and I, I ended up getting on the El Rey network for some animations I did. El Rey, Robert bought them and then put them on the network. Nice. And while I was there, I was actually, I have Rebel Without a Crew in my backpack, the book. It’s my Bible. Like, I live and breathe by that book. So I just had my backpack. They happened to see that I had it with me, and they were like, hey, we’re doing the show. Have you ever done any live action stuff? And I sent them some of the stuff I’ve done, and they were like, oh, man, you’re definitely a candidate. You’re going to be in the show. And you’re definitely a candidate for this show. Like, apply. Let’s see what happens. And I, they were like, but the thing is, you need a feature-length script. And I was like, oh, yeah, I’ve got a feature-length script. I did not have a feature-length script. I was totally lying.
Of course you didn’t. Bold-faced lie. Of course you didn’t, yeah. And I was like, yeah, I totally have a script. And they’re like, oh, sweet. Can you send it to us next week? And I was like, oh, yeah, can I get two weeks instead? Like, I don’t want to send you guys something that’s, like, sloppy.
Devin: Yeah, my printer’s broken.
Josh: So Daniel and I sat down and wrote, yeah. We wrote the whole script in two weeks. Like, we were just sending stuff back and forth. I was like, I got a teddy bear. Can we write this scene? And Daniel’s like, yeah, what if it pukes in my face? I was like, okay, let’s do that. Like, we just kept going with it. And so we were just flying by the seat of our pants from the beginning. And I think I learned, like, a massive, important thing that I never thought about before. Like, this idea that when you write a script, when you get to set, you need to just, like, let that die. Like, you cannot treat that sacredly.
Completely different stages. Yeah. It is. X, Y, and Z. Z is editing. Yeah. Right, right. And then in the edit, you do it again. You totally forget what you shot. You have to just live in the footage. You have to. You have to look at all of it. You have to think about it. So I think what happens a lot of times when I see a script, people are like, well, it’s not reading the same as it reads on the page. What if we just say it differently? And I just let my actors, I’m like, this is the idea. Like, as long as you guys get the idea.
The idea out and you don’t go off the rails and do something completely that changes the character.
Devin: Right.
Josh: You know what I mean? Like, we have to keep the character the same. Stanley has to have the same arc.
Devin: This scene needs to get this point across. So yeah, this is how it’s moving the story. However you do it, this is the rail that we need to stay on.
Josh: Right. But if Stanley says something different, if Stanley, in the script, have you guys seen the movie? Yes.
Devin: Yeah.
Josh: Okay. So in the movie, there’s a scene where Father Gil and Maria are sitting on the front patio and Stanley has a metal detector and he’s like walking around with a metal detector. So that scene was purely in the script. Stanley, Father Gil says like, she’s like, have you seen anything unusual? And he’s like, you mean besides Stanley? And Stanley’s like, picks his nose and he’s like wiping it on a tree and trying to get it off of his finger. And my idea was that that would go on for like way too long and like uncomfortably long. And when we did it, we were like, oh, this is a good idea. And then Stanley’s like, Stanley is a man child, but he, he doesn’t, that just didn’t strike me as Stanley. So Avery was like, what if I use that metal detector you got? Cause I had, I had got that metal detector from, we were able to pick, seven objects from Robert’s, like he’s got like a whole airplane hangar of props. And I just thought the metal detector looked cool. I’m like, I don’t know, maybe Stanley walks around through the movie with a metal detector the whole time.
So I gave it to Avery and off the cuff, he grabs it. He’s like, what if I’m using this? He’s like, he’s, and he literally said to me, he’s like, I think it’s cool because I always wanted to be a metal detective. This was not what we were filming or anything. And I just like burst out laughing. I’m like, just say that. I always wanted to be a metal detective. That’s fucking hilarious. Let’s just roll with it. Metal detective. Yeah. So we just, we, I let the, I let the cast just kind of figure out their characters as they went. And, you know, and then, you know, we work together on stuff. Like one thing that’s super and I don’t know if people really pick it up, but I think it’s really cool is Avery who plays Stanley.
He, as the movie progresses, he actually starts to wear his hair differently. He starts to, like, part it to the side. So you see his character go from, like, the idiot man-child that he is, the creep at the beginning, and he slowly becomes a little bit more… Refinement! Yeah, and so, like, and he’s, it starts at that scene where he goes to dance with Maria, and he, like, parts his hair a little better and tucks his shirt in. And then throughout the rest of the movie, I was like, make sure you’re always, like, kind of parting your hair a little bit nicer to the side. So it looks like you’re actually maybe paying attention to yourself a little bit at this point, as your character is building. And it’s that kind of stuff that we just found as we went, that you never could write that into a script. You’d never think about that.
Devin: Right.
Adam: No, that’s the why. That’s the why of production. X, Y, Z. Right. That’s where production sort of informs its own ideas. Cast brings ideas. Right. Well, you were shooting it, too, but your cinematographer would bring ideas normally. But you were shooting it as well, right, Josh?
Josh: Yeah, but that’s the thing, is, like, I was shooting it. I was literally behind the camera the whole time, but that didn’t mean that I didn’t take suggestions. Like, there were many moments where someone would say, trying to think of something specific, where they’d be like, hey, just, like, would you ever consider doing… Like, would you ever consider doing a close-up on this? Or would you ever consider… Like, people would just throw out ideas. And I think sometimes on set, when you’re, you know, if you have a DP, you have an entire crew, like, they’ve set up all of their lights, everything is so specific, and it’s so hard to move and run and gun like that.
Yeah. That, you know, the whole crew is like, oh, not another shot. That’s a pain in the ass. And we went into it going like, yeah, let’s just do that. Like, we’re just gonna run and gun and figure it out. We used… Yeah. Most of the time, we would set up one light. We would set up one light, and we would use the sun. And that was the beauty of that ranch, is we could get our three-point lighting out of a bounce, a light, and the sun. Like, just using what we could and running like that. Right. But, you know, we didn’t overanalyze it. The beauty of this movie is that when we sit down and we show it to people, it’s always predicated on the fact that this is a no-budget movie. Like, we had nothing. We were just going and figuring it out as we went.
Yeah. The fun of it is that it isn’t pristine and proper. It’s a punk rock… I always say it’s like the equivalent of watching your neighbor’s punk band play in the garage. Yeah, that makes total sense. Right. It’s no less important. And in fact, for me as a kid, like, I would much rather watch my neighbor’s band play punk rock music in the garage than sit and listen to the radio.
Devin: Sure, right. Yeah, there’s something beautiful about imperfection. And the rawness of it, yeah.
Josh: Yeah, totally. So, we just, we, even in the script, we played into the imperfections. We played into the characters. We played into, you know, we knew that Daniel is a terrible dancer and gangly and strange. So, I’m like, dude, what if you danced through the whole beginning of the movie? What if we just had you, like, awkwardly dancing? That was… And he was like, I’ll give it a shot.
Adam: It’s actually awkward to watch that.
Josh: I know, right?
Adam: It’s actually awkward to watch. It’s also, there’s this juxtaposition of a priest dancing to death metal that’s… Pretty funny in its own right.
Josh: And that’s where the edit comes in. Because in the script, it was written for a local Minneapolis, I have a local Minneapolis friend named Jake Badenrad who plays, like, throwback 80s synth. And so, in the script, I had expected Father Gil to dance to throwback 80s synth. And in fact, when Daniel was, like, putting in the headphones, sometimes he was listening to that. And then as I was in the edit, I’m like, I don’t, I’m a metal, like, I’m a metal guy. I like death metal. I like grindcore. I just need to do it. Like, I just needed to go for what felt the best to me. And in the end, I love it. Like, I love that he’s dancing to, like, death metal.
Adam: It’s really absurd. It’s so absurd.
Devin: The extreme is good, going that direction. It’s, like, exactly what you wouldn’t expect him to hear, listen to.
Adam: And that’s what I like. That’s his ordinary world. Right. This is how this dude rolls. This is his setup. This is his, like, comfort zone.
Devin: And he’s on his cell phone. Flip phone.
Josh: And the funny thing is that that moment where he gets, you know, that moment where he gets to the exorcism and he fast forwards to the, like, really heavy doomy part at the end. I put that in there because that’s what I do. Like, if I’m working on a project and I’m like, oh, shit, I’m almost done. Or if I’m on the bus going to work and I’m like, shit, I’m going to be to work in, like, one minute. And this song is three minutes left. I’ll fast forward to the spot of the song that I like just to hear it. I’m like, I’ve got to put that in there.
It just totally makes sense. To amp yourself up.
Adam: Yeah. To get yourself amped. That’s so funny, man. Now, did you think of that during shooting or was that part of the thought process during scripting? Just that discovery.
Josh: Yeah. I thought of that on set, that he would fast forward it to get to the right spot. So we filmed it while we were there. And then, but I thought, obviously, I thought it was going to be to a different song at that point. And I didn’t know if the song even, the song is kind of the same all the way through. Yeah. And then I filmed it because I think that literally happened. I think while I was going to Troublemaker Studios one day, I, we weren’t allowed to listen to music because of the show, because like if we were being filmed.
Right. And one day on the way, so I didn’t listen to music for like two weeks. Like it was some, like not a song for two weeks. And I got to the point where I was driving and the, the cameras in the van, we had, we had cameras in our vans and the cameras had all gone out. I could see that the light had turned off on all of the cameras. And I was like, oh shit, they will have no idea if I listen to music right now. So I turned on, I turned on my phone and was listening to my phone and I was playing grindcore.
And I, I showed up and I was like, fuck, I’m, I’m there. I’m going to fast forward to my favorite part. And I sat in the van, like offset, like away from troublemaker where they wouldn’t be able to see or hear me or know I was listening to music. And I just listened to that song and then drove up and turned off the music. And I was like, I think the cameras went out guys. And then later on, I found out that they also had audio recording. In the van. So they knew I was listening to music all the time. So then I just, I just filmed that scene on the fly. And the scene that we filmed the exorcism of Jill, the dance exorcism, we actually did, I had set that day up. So we were only filming that sequence and it was a half day shoot. And so I, cause it was like our first Friday there. And Daniel and I wanted to get fucked up drunk. So we were like, Oh, we’ll just film a half day this day and really focus on making that exorcism of Jill. Cool. Which kind of sucks because I filmed so many amazing shots that didn’t make it into the movie. And it’s such a bummer that I’ve been cutting them into like trailers and stuff.
These really cool shots, because I filmed way more than I could actually use. That was the only time that happened. But, that, that fast-forwarding thing was just a total, like, eh, let’s film it quick and see, maybe we’ll use it, maybe we won’t. Interesting.
Adam: So wait, so when you say you shot stuff and didn’t use it, is it because of the pacing of the film and the edit that you chose not to? You needed to move the story forward quicker? Or why, why did you choose after shooting that to not use it?
Josh: Yeah, it just, it felt like the, the exorcism of Jill went on long enough. It felt like we got the point.
Adam: Yeah, like, we sort of get the setup that this is his routine. He does this. Yeah. I gotcha. Okay.
Josh: Yeah, so if there was too much of him, like, doing too many moves, too many dance things, and whatever, it would, it felt like it was too, it took too long. It didn’t get to the fact that he’s just good at this, and it’s done. But that’s, that’s one of those things where, you know, like, I wish I could have had a shot of the mom leaning against the door listening. Oh, yeah. And I never got that.
Adam: Because then you can add in whatever sound you wanted to, to create the scene within. Mm-hmm. That’s a smart shot, man.
Josh: Right. And I, it’s just, it’s something that I just, you know, there’s a lot of stuff that I wasn’t able to get, that I was running and gunning too fast, and actually, while we were filming that sequence, that’s when, that’s when Robert showed up to set, and.
Adam: You got nervous. You’re like, oh my gosh.
Josh: Oh, no, the, no, the opposite. I was like, everyone else is nervous now. This totally ruined the vibe of. Oh, I see. How the shoot was going. It interrupted my shoot. Yeah. I was in the middle of a take when it happened. So I actually have footage that I love. And I hope to someday be able to share it with the world. But there’s a moment when Robert, I’m filming, and I say, all right, that was great. Let’s take it one more time really quick from the top. Let’s go. And you hear a knock on the door, and I’m, I yell, I’m fucking filming in here.
And then the door opens, and Robert peeks his head in. Robert peeks his head in and goes, no, you’re not. And I, he was like, no, you’re not. Can you take a break? And I was like, oh, hi, Robert. And you could hear it. And I was like, oh, hi, Robert. Disappointment to literally see my hero. Robert Rodriguez is my hero. And it was like, in that moment, I was like, it was like I was talking to my mom who had walked in on me in the middle of playing a video game as a kid and told me I have to clean my room where I’m like, oh, come on. Like now.
Adam: So how often did he show up to sort of see what’s going on? Like how often were interruptions?
Josh: Yeah, he only showed up to my set once. We were allowed to message him every day. Well, anytime we could message him like we have we have his phone number so we could contact him and text him if we had any issues and he would help us through them. But honestly, I never really had any. Yeah, I never had any issues. So what I would do is I would I would waste my one phone call a day like sending him pictures and stuff like that. So I sent him at one point I sent Robert a picture of Daniel on the floor in a bathrobe with vomit on his face.
Hold his arm around the pink teddy bear with like a demon face. And I said in the text, I sent that to him and I said, Hey, Robert, this is what your $7,000 is going towards. And he sent me back a message, best money I’ve ever spent. Yeah, and the only time I asked for, like the only time, this isn’t, I’m not trying to like brag. I honestly, we’re just running and gunning so fast. I didn’t have time to message him. Like that would have meant taking an hour out of the day to talk to Robert about how to fix something instead of taking 20 minutes to just figure out how to fix it.
So the only time I sent him, I actually asked his advice was with the teddy bear. Because in the script, what I had wanted to do was I wanted to put a cantaloupe into the teddy bear. Like I actually carve out the teddy bear, put a cantaloupe in it and just blow it the fuck up. Like I wanted that teddy bear to just explode. And I wanted to film it at like a slow or like a fat, a slow frame rate or a lot of frames per second so that, you know, you could see this thing explode and do the cliche, like throwback to the 70s and 80s where you see it from like five angles as it just explodes over and over again.
Right, right. And, but they would only let me use my one camera. The idea was to shoot it. Everyone has an iPhone that shoots at 60 frames. So I was going to set up like five iPhones and just show it super quick like that. And they told me, no, they said, you can only use your one camera. You can’t use your iPhones. Yeah. So I called Robert and I was like, Robert, what, how do I do this? And he’s like, well, you could rent a camera. It’s going to cost you whatever, $900 for the day. And you can get it from one shot. You just need to make sure you do it right.
And I would have to hire a pyrotechnics person to blow it up, which I was like, damn it. I would have just had my dad do it and maybe blow a finger off, but who cares?
Adam: So, so wait, so did you have to be charged for the camera that you, your own personal camera that you shot on?
Josh: And you’ll see that on the show. Yeah. You’ll see that on the show. And what did you shoot on too, by the way? We shot on the C, sorry, the C300, but the old one, the 1080p C300. Yeah. So we, yeah. So we shot on the old Canon C300 and we got a lens. We got like three lenses with it. I ended up shooting almost the whole thing on one lens because I like to shoot kind of wide.
Devin: Mm-hmm. I noticed that. Yeah.
Josh: Yeah. I mostly shot with a, it’s like a 16 millimeter to, it’s like 16 to 35 or 21 to 50. I don’t remember what it was. I don’t remember which one it was, but I shot mostly very wide, like 21 millimeter. So, just cause it gives it that throwback horror vibe. That’s how nineties movies were shot a lot, especially comedies. So I wanted to get that like comedy look with a mix of, you know, Dutch horror shots. As well. So I just kind of went with that. Oh yeah. Sorry. Just to wrap my story really quick. So I ended up calling Robert one time to ask what I should do instead.
And he told me to just, you know, blow it up, but maybe rent a camera or do whatever. And then I called him late one night and was like, Hey Robert, what if I Three Kings it? There’s that scene in Three Kings where the guy’s telling the story about shooting the dude and the guy in the, when he tells the story, it’s like super exaggerated. And he like shoots the guy and his head pops off and blood sprays everywhere. And I was like, what if I just do that? But I cut really fast. Like show father Gil, show the head popping off, show father Gil, show the gut spraying everywhere, show father Gil, show it launch across the air.
And then it’s really fast. And when it cuts, then we just cut to Stanley and he’s like, wow. Or something like that. And then in the moment, Avery came up with cool, which was even better. But yeah, so Robert was like, dude, that sounds amazing. Go with that. That sounds like fun. And then you get guts in it. I know how you love guts. Cause I put guts in everything and I just, yeah. So that was my one. My one advice from Robert was just asking for his okay to do it that way.
Devin: Interesting. That’s great. So more towards like your style and type of stories that you’re going to, you kind of gravitate to, is this kind of, if, if like, like, you know, when you’re, when you look at a Tarantino film, like that’s a Tarantino film or that’s a, that’s a Robert Rodriguez film, or you kind of know the hallmark with that trademark look and, and even genre, is this kind of the, the. The comedy, horror or horror, you know, I know you like guts and blood. Is that type of stuff that you kind of will gravitate to if you continue to, when you continue to do more, more movies and stories and, and even animations or, or you just kind of whatever, whatever inspires you.
Josh: You know, I think it, I think part of it is whatever inspires you, but I’m always going to be inspired by comedy with blood. Like I just love, I love comedy stories. I love stories that don’t take themselves. Too seriously, or maybe not necessarily blood, but just like that vibe of dirtiness. So like this last weekend, I watched The ’Burbs. There’s no blood in The ’Burbs, but that’s like my bread and butter. Like there’s a darkness to that movie. It’s dark and dirty, but it’s still funny.
Devin: Yeah. I hadn’t seen that movie for like literally 15 years. I, I, for some reason I saw it on, I, I don’t know why I own it either, but it was on my Vudu account and I’m like, I’m going to watch that. And I was like. Holy, this is such a great film.
Josh: Such a great story. It’s so fun. It doesn’t take itself too seriously. And here’s my, like my big thing with stories and, and movies in general, actually not just movies, almost all art right now takes itself so seriously. There is no like. There is no, every movie at this point has to tell you at some point that you’re not watching a movie. Do you know what I mean? Like there’s that moment of like, yeah, this is real life. This is something that you have to take very seriously, and I am the opposite. Like I love when movies are just like, hey, by the way, don’t forget you’re watching a movie. This is ridiculous.
So I love that, and that’s what I wanted to do with The Good Exorcist, and as I’ve moved forward with Greywood’s Plot, I’ve also done that same thing where there’s moments of like, don’t forget you’re watching a movie, folks. This is fun. This is not meant to be taken as real life.
Adam: We’re gonna take a quick break, throw a couple logs on the fire, and hear a few words about our sponsor. We’re talking to Josh Stifter here on StoryOsophy.
[Sponsor message]
Devin: What you said earlier before about your curiosity for audio and for editing, just for every element and aspect of filmmaking, I think we kind of glazed over it a little bit, but I think that’s really important to emphasize because there’s, for one, I was a director and a programmer for a film festival for five years. So, I watched a ton of movies. And there’s so many great movies that had awesome stories. But you could tell they didn’t really care about the audio or vice versa. Where it was, they were really good with audio and they understood. How to use a boom mic and they understood lenses and even lighting.
But they just didn’t know how to tell a story. And so, I think what’s really important is for someone like yourself where at least knowing enough of those other areas. Even if it’s not the area that you want to focus on. To be able to communicate with them. Where it’s like, look, I don’t necessarily know every lens that you’re going to put on here, but at least you can talk to the DP. Like, this is the, I want this wide. I think maybe in the past I’ve used this lens and I think this looks really good. So I think that’s really important because like in the other thing you’re saying where it’s like you just, and what this, what Rebel Without a Crew or whatever in this show and what you did with Good Exorcist, doing is the main thing.
You just got out there and you did it. And because you had these constraints of time and money, but you just, and you had to, like you’re saying, like you keep saying, you’re like, you had just make decisions on the fly. You’re running. You just have to do, do, do, because there’s a lot of people that are just professional learners. Like you were saying, like you can’t learn from a book and there’s people that you can go, you can probably go to their, their office and they have every single how to be a good writer. How to be a filmmaker book, and they haven’t done one thing.
Right. So there’s something to say about what you, what you were able to pull off with, with the, with the show and with the movie. Do you think, which is the blessing is kind of the constraints, right? Oh, 100%. Whereas like you had this time.
Josh: Yeah. And here’s the thing. Everyone out there can do the exact same thing that I did without having to fail in front of people. So. And also the idea of you can, you can fix more than I could fix. They only gave me 14 days. So at one point, you don’t really see this on the show, but at week two, at the beginning of week two, another show came onto my set and was constantly running their construction crew. They were destroying my entire set. So you can actually see it in the film. If I pointed it out, no one ever sees it. But there’s things on the set that actually change because they changed it.
I had no control over it. And a lot of the audio issues that I have are literally because I don’t, I didn’t have audio. Like I had to fucking figure it out because of the fact that there was beeps from trucks backing up in the background. You don’t have to deal with that. You can do ADR. You can go and read, you can do so many more things and fix the audio. Like you can do things that I didn’t. I didn’t have access to on this project because of the constraints of the show. Now, with that being said, I recommend just. Doing it once. Fail once. Like, do what I, like, if you do what I did, and you don’t let yourself redo audio, and you have to deal with the shitty audio, and find ways to clean it up in post, like, that audio was a thousand times worse, as bad as some of the audio is in the movie, it was so much worse than it sounds when you watch it.
And I just had to figure out how to fix things, I had to figure out how to make stuff work, and, like, how to, like, literally dissect lines from other scenes, and try to, like, chunk them together, where the audio was good, and, like, I had to figure out so much stuff, just based on the fact that I was under these constraints.
Adam: So how much time did you, sort of, give us an idea of how much time you were allowed to spend on each thing? Like, you had a scripting time, then you had production, or maybe… You had pre-production, then production, then editing. So how much… So we sort of understand how the series plays. They gave you the constraints of $7,000, and what was the time constraints, as far as those stages?
Josh: So we had, from the day that we got the news that we had to send in the script, to the day we started the show, was about a month and a half. So we had two weeks… Yeah, that’s not bad. Yeah, I think we had two weeks to… We had two weeks to write the script and send it to them. So they had, like, a draft of the script in two weeks, and then I had a month and a half to kind of rework the script, do some storyboards, you know, figure out how we could do shots. So I was in pre-production kind of all the time for that month and a half. Well, I was working a full-time job, but in the back of my head, I was always thinking, like, okay, if we can’t do that, how… Like, if I don’t get a bed and breakfast, because the original script was written for a bed and breakfast, not a ranch.
So I was like, if I don’t get a bed and breakfast, and instead I just have a house, what can I make this about that still works? Or if I get something else, like if I get a ranch, how can I make that work? Or if it takes place in a restaurant instead?
Adam: So you were, like, weighing out your options in pre-pro so that you could go with the flow when it happened.
Josh: Yep. Or if I was like, man, I didn’t find anyone who could play Mrs. Willows, how do I just cut that character out? Or if I don’t find anyone who could play…
Adam: Or make it a grandma or something, right? Yep.
Josh: How do I change this based on cast? I mean, Stanley in the script…
Adam: That’s smart pre-pro for this.
Josh: Yeah, Stanley in the actual script was written as, like, a short, young, fat guy. Like, he was not supposed to look like Avery looks. So, you know, we kind of retooled Stanley based on, okay, let’s make him this kind of man-child instead of a lazy piece of shit. Like, he was originally supposed to be really lazy, and instead we made him not lazy, just kind of incompetent. And…
Devin: It was a good decision.
Josh: Yeah, yeah. And we just totally, we went with the flow of, like, how this was going, how it would work.
Adam: And Avery, Avery actually nails it. There’s something very Chris Pratt about Avery’s performance. Yeah, Avery is fucking awesome. Just so you know, StoryOsophers, Avery is, he’s actually a fairly handsome and lean guy.
Josh: Oh, super handsome. Yeah, yeah, totally. So he’s the opposite of what he was talking about, fat and lazy. In the script, he’s written as, like, the idea when he’s walking around in his underwear is, like… Like, it’s uncomfortable because he’s kind of ugly.
Adam: Put your pants on, my child.
Josh: Yeah, instead it becomes, it becomes, like, just awkward because he doesn’t even care that he’s not wearing pants. Like, that wasn’t the, yeah, it’s, and that’s just something Avery brought. What does she call it when she walks in on him? Stanley’s sunrise.
Yeah, which has since, like, since become, like, our dream. Drink of choice. We made a drink called the Stanley’s sunrise.
Devin: Stanley’s sunrise.
Josh: Which is essentially gin and juice, but it, yeah, we have the Stanley’s sunrise because it’s, like, my favorite thing. In fact, the Stanley’s sunrise shows up in my next movie, Greywood’s Plot. The drink that the dude is drinking throughout the movie, like, the beer is the Stanley’s sunrise. Oh, that’s awesome. So, yeah. Anyway, yeah, we, so then we had, we had four, we had one week of pre-production on the shoot, which, that’s not really true. It was really reality show week. You know what I mean? Like, it was the week where they showed us our locations, where they were like, hey, pick from this book, you’ve got 10 minutes. And I don’t want to spoil the show too much, so I won’t tell you guys everything that happened, but, like, watch it. We had a week for pre-production.
Adam: Yeah.
Josh: And then, and then we had two weeks to film.
Adam: Pre-pro, like you’re saying, it was sort of like a set-up reality show where they’re sort of occupying your time with the filming of it, right?
Josh: Well, I, I wish they were occupying our time just with the filming of it. There was also, like, photo shoots and all sorts of other stuff.
Adam: So you had what out of that time that, for real pre-pro, for your own personal process? Maybe a fraction of it? Oh, like a, I don’t know, an eighth? Like an eighth of, the eighth of the time.
Josh: Damn.
Adam: Nothing for pre-pro, man. Wow.
Josh: Yeah, a day went to, like, once I, so when you see the show, basically, three days in, we had our props and our cast and our locations locked. But at that point, like, then I had two days to figure out my, you know, how I was going to film in the ranch instead of a bed and breakfast. Because in the script, it’s all rooms. Like, every scene that you see takes place in a different room. Of a house. And then suddenly I got thrown into, you know, having this entire ranch. So I was like, okay, what room is, what, whose room is who? Like, how do I make the Willow’s room that Father Gil walks past into one of these locations on the ranch?
How do I make Maria, who lived in the basement before, how do I make the basement into a different room? So I had, that was part of my week. And then I also had to write up. You know, call sheets. I had to do all of that myself. So I had to do call sheets for my cast. I had to do re-scripting stuff. You know, based on these new, this new cast, I had to rewrite them, their scenes for, like, day one and two, just so that I was prepared for that. So it was a lot. That, that first quote-unquote pre-production week that we had was really crazy.
Plus on top of that, all of the reality show stuff. Photo shoots. They call them OTFs. That’s the stuff where you turn to the camera. And you’re like, today’s been a crazy day. I can’t believe it. You know, I found my cast. This is wild. That kind of stuff. So there was all of that time being consumed. What’s that stand for, OTF? It stands for on the fly. So it’s like an on the fly conversation. So, so we had to do all that stuff. Plus, you know, like meeting with Robert. As awesome as that is, it takes up time. Like it’s time that I could be doing actual pre-production.
And instead I’m, you know, talking to Robert about why I got into film or whatever. So it’s. It’s, there was a lot of stuff like that happening.
Adam: So, and then you had two weeks to shoot it. Yep. We had two weeks to shoot it. And you had mentioned something to me when, when we first chatted about the animation that you were going to implement. Cause you’re an animator.
Devin: Yep.
Adam: And you’ve implemented that into the film, but you said some of it was done during the two weeks and some of it was after and post.
Josh: No, I did all of the animation, like the two animated sequences that you see. Uh-huh. I did in post. Like those two animations were done. Entirely in post. What I did while I was shooting, I would do some quick visual effects. So I was, cause I did all the visual effects myself besides a handful that, my friend Jeremy Wannick helped me with. Well, I mean, I paid him, but we, he did some visual effects as well. But I did, I did most of them myself, but then it was stuff like I would temp in the piano fire. There’s a scene where a piano has a fire that’s coming out of the top and I would just temp something in so we can make sure we had what we needed.
So I’d be doing visual effects at night instead of sleeping. I would do visual effects. And then, I actually, I take that back. I did do some of that animation just to make sure that it was like structurally working. I would do essentially my roughs. So I just kind of storyboarded out the animation while I was on set and snapped photos of it with my phone and just kind of like set it up, which I, you know, it was like an animatic of the animation, but.
Adam: But didn’t they want you to? Did you, for the show’s sake, do some animation during the process so that it could be part of the show?
Josh: Yeah, I guess I did. I mean, yeah, yeah. So, but you never see it on the show, so it didn’t really matter. And it’s technically nothing I even used. So there was a, that’s the thing is the show wants everything. You know what I mean? Like they want, they want everything. And then when they cut it, they go like, oh, I guess we didn’t need that. So there was a lot of moments where I was doing stuff where they’re like, hey, you’re going to do some animation. Would you mind doing it? So I set up some characters and After Effects and rigged them. And then kind of drew them out or drew them out, rigged them up in After Effects and kind of put it together and animated a little bit.
In fact, I think I did that on the same Friday afternoon that I did the exorcism of Jill the first half of the day. Second half of the day, I did some like quick animation stuff, I think. But, you know, they know we didn’t really, I didn’t end up using any of that in the actual movie. What I did all of that in post, which we had. Man, it’s hard to remember the exact November, December, January. I think I had two months to do post-production? Something like that? Around two months. That’s good. That’s nice.
Devin: Yeah, what time of year did you do this? What was the month?
Josh: We wrapped this same week last year. So we shot over Halloween. Our two weeks took place from the week before Halloween to the week after Halloween. And we were there like the week before also for the pre-production thing and then the week after that for just some post stuff. Like we cut a trailer and showed it to Robert and a bunch of random stuff. Gotcha. But it was this time of the year a year ago.
Adam: So let me ask you this. Just in terms of the scripting process, that month and a half you had beforehand.
Josh: Yeah, so…
Adam: Blueprinting it?
Josh: Like I said, we do the note cards and then we work in a program called WriterDuet. The translation across all X, Y, and Z, as you were saying. Or it’s like an online software, I guess, that you can write at the same time as someone else writes.
Adam: So when you’re approaching the scripting process and you’re co-creating with Daniel, tell us a little bit about how you guys work together and how you approach maybe even structuring a script.
Josh: We both are in the script at the same time a lot of the time. And we’re like shooting each other notes on there. We’re writing a scene and then someone will jump. I’ll jump to his scene and look at it and then I’ll kind of like tweak dialogue based on his vomit draft. And then he’ll take that and add a joke to it. And we kind of go back and forth. For the most part, like he’s the one who… I take the vomit draft and he takes the draft one, is how it sort of worked. So I would write out… I understand structure. I understand this scene needs these beats to give us an actual reason to see the scene.
Adam: Like you were saying before, you treat each one almost as a short film containing its own little act one, act two, act three bits to it.
Josh: Yeah, so it starts… For example, the scene… Like… This is a weird one because it doesn’t have any action. It’s just character. But it’s like that scene where Maria and Stanley are in Maria’s room and Maria’s getting high and father walks in and scares them. And then Stanley tells the penis sock hands story. That scene… When I wrote that, I was like, okay, we’re going to start it out as sort of negative. Like they’re talking about the fact that this guy… Is a bad guy and he’s scary or he’s probably up to no good. So we’re starting on a negative and I wanted to find a way to get to a positive of like, this is how we’re going to turn it around.
And I did that by having father Gil come in and sort of give Maria this like hope of like, I understand I’m trying, I’m here for you. So it takes a turn into that. And then I was like, well, but that story isn’t fun to watch. That short film doesn’t have anything. It’s just two people talking. There’s nothing on top of that. So I’m like, well, what if Stanley interrupts it and totally throws the scene off and throws us for a loop and makes it a completely comical, weird scene that is uncomfortable to watch and you don’t know how you exactly exited the scene. And so it allows for Maria and father Gil to bond over how weird Stanley is.
So, so the, so the art goes from like negative to positive. So we have this arc in the sequence, but we also don’t leave. The sequence just like, okay, that was a negative to a positive. It kind of leaves on a weird middle ground of like, was that positive?
Adam: Oh, interesting.
Josh: I like to leave people guessing at the end. Like did, did we learn anything from that sequence or not? So it keeps the audience kind of guessing, especially in something that’s got a sense of mystery. Like what is going on? Where are we going with this? I wanted that. So every scene sort of had this positive to negative, but then somehow ending in the middle. Or negative to positive and somehow ending in the middle.
Adam: It’s interesting that you mentioned that scene because she’s getting high and later on, I believe it’s slightly later, he’s having a cigarette, father Gil.
Josh: Yep.
Adam: And she mentioned something because he says something in that scene about, you know, we all, everyone’s lifestyle or choices is their own life. And then she’s sitting with him and he’s like, yep, I got my cigarette here. Yep. And so there’s sort of this weird stepping stone in their relationship between those two things where she’s like, oh. I see. Which I, threading it together, their relationship growing, I noticed that. And I was like, oh, interesting.
Josh: And that was a huge thing for me is I didn’t want this movie just to be, you know, watch this one adventure of father Gil. Just watch father Gil be, do things. Cause that’s how so many movies kind of are now. Like, I feel like a lot of movies are like, here’s this person. And then here’s the obvious character, character of like, he’s going to fall in love with her. This is going to happen. You could feel everything happening. And I don’t, I didn’t want people to be able to quite understand where these characters were going at any given point. And so Maria was always important that she kind of ended up being the star of the movie. And she kind of is. Like, by the end of the movie, if Father Gil left her there, everyone would have been like, well, that was fucking, okay, so I guess that was that. That’s where it went. Because Maria is, it’s the two, they’re the two sides of, to me, sort of the hero story. Like, and they’re in this weird spot of Maria is trying to find herself. Father Gil thinks he knows himself and doesn’t and is realizing in this that he doesn’t. And they’re meeting in this middle spot of like, shit, we both don’t know what we’re doing. And. Both end up helping each other.
Right. And Father Gil realizes that through Maria. And Maria realizes that maybe she isn’t just a lost child.
Adam: Right. Through Father Gil. The thing that I thought was very interesting about you, what you chose to do with the ending and not, obviously there’s a little spoiler, but the, I’m not, I’m not a huge fan of character redemption, the word itself. But the one thing that, and we are talking about a priest here, so it’s appropriate. But the one thing Father Gil is criticized for is his methods of how he dealt with the demons in the past. And so him, his relationship with Maria is sort of just saying, look, this is my. Opportunity at redemption for whatever I thought I knew about myself now. And I don’t know throughout this journey, I realized I didn’t know about myself.
She’s the path. She’s the. Right. You know, the, the, super, super objective, if you will. And in terms of a, you know, a blueprint.
Josh: Yeah. And I think the big thing for me was like, I wanted to make something that, you know, growing up religious and whatever, I wanted to make this point of. Yeah. The most important thing in this whole, like the most important thing to me is you, you can only be you like you are you. So that was like my go-to at any given moment is like, okay, what are we trying to say here? We’re trying to say you do you, you do your, what you can to be a good person or to just, what’s the. I’m trying to like, I’m blanking on a way to say this, but it’s the like, you are Lisa Simpson moment of, I don’t know if you guys remember.
There’s an episode of the Simpsons where Lisa is like terrified of who she is. It’s episode with Dustin Hoffman as a voice of a teacher and the teacher leaves and she’s terrified because she can’t, relate to anyone else. No, she doesn’t relate to anyone else in life. And the teacher gives her a note and she opens it up. It just says, you are Lisa Simpson. And to me, that’s like impactful. You are you like, that’s all you’ll ever be. And, to me, that’s, that’s what I wanted to get. That’s the arc I wanted to get in the end is Maria is Maria. Father Gil is Father Gil.
And they just have to do the best they can.
Adam: But they do become sort of better versions of themselves by the end of that story. I mean, as far as like, they’ve got growth and evolution, each of them, like. Sure. He helps her by sort of saving her and, and she lets him know it’s okay to have like, like what you’re saying, be you. You had to have failed before because you saved me. So there is a lot. I mean, I mean, arc wise.
Josh: 100%. Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. Totally. Yeah. And same with Stanley. Like, honestly, my favorite arc of that whole movie is Stanley’s. I identify with Stanley most.
Yeah. Stanley’s arc is fantastic where he is a total, like, lost puppy with his parents who’s afraid to move away. And by the end, he’s the one who tells Father Gil, like, you can’t give up, man. Like, this is on you. And to me, that’s, Stanley saying that is like a huge step forward that he even realizes that he feels that strongly about something. So, you know, and then obviously.
Adam: Believing in something outside of himself and his family. Father Gil comes and. Right.
Josh: So to me, there is like these, these, the arc and the character. I mean, like, what’s, what’s the point of watching a movie where someone doesn’t really grow? Yeah. That’s my problem with a lot of, that’s my problem with a lot of the, like, superhero movies is they’re a badass at the beginning, they have their, their tough time, and then they’re a badass at the end. Like, I don’t really get growth. I just get like, okay, you are sort of the same. Or if it’s an origin story where it’s like, okay, he’s weak at the beginning and he’s strong at the end.
It’s like, well, no shit. That was going to happen.
Adam: Right. Predictability.
Josh: Yeah. You already know.
Adam: Yeah.
Josh: But like, I like throwing it. I like throwing it for a loop where it, you know, like, I mean, to be honest, I would have loved to do even more crazy things, but no one would have been happy if I would have done something insane, like kill Father Gil. Like, everyone would have been like, well, what the fuck, man? Okay, that’s too far. You know what I mean? Like, there’s just, there’s things that you have to, there’s balances, especially in a movie like that, that you have to kind of.
Devin: There’s two decisions. I like two decisions you made at the end. One being a production decision, the other story decision. The production decision is I like how you shot that last scene with just the static camera with a wide angle on the house.
Josh: You know what’s funny? That’s the first shot I ever came up with in the movie, too. I knew at the end I wanted a shot of him leaving into the distance. I wanted that shot, that distant shot of him backing up and deciding to make a change.
Devin: Yeah, right. That’s exactly it.
Josh: Because for me, it leaves me going like, oh, this isn’t just a single shot. This isn’t just a single story. Like, this isn’t just one thing. It’s like a bigger, it’s a life. His life is going to go on. It isn’t the happy ending of just like everything’s tidied up in a nice little bow because that’s not the way it goes. But if you can make one, it’s really hard to say this without spoiling it. Did I spoil it already? I don’t know. Whatever. But the, I don’t really care. I honestly don’t care about spoilers, so whatever. But I knew that I wanted Father Gil to take something else into his life and to go on.
The next journey. So that was important to me.
Devin: And so I like, I like how you ended it on. This isn’t the end. We’re just, we’re departing from them. We’re leaving them now, but who knows? We may meet them again later on if something else happens, but it’s just the idea of, of from an audience standpoint, knowing, like you just said, it’s their lives are going to go on, but their lives are very different because now they found each other and they’re together and now it’s going to be, that’s a big, that was a good decision. That was a big, that was a good decision. I like that decision on your part.
Josh: And that was a big thing with the beginning and the end was this, I wanted this to not be Father Gil’s story. Like, he’s the character we follow. It’s his adventure. But he’s gone on a lot of these adventures before and will go on a lot after. This is just one blip in his. This is really Maria and the Willow story. Like, this is, they will never go through this again. This is, I mean, presumably, as you’re watching it, they will never go through this type of.
Devin: Right.
Josh: So I like stories like that. I like stories that are like, this isn’t, this isn’t Father Gil’s life story. This is Father Gil’s. This is just a moment, but this is the Willow’s story. If there was a book written about their life, this is what you would read.
Devin: Right, right. And this, and that’s the other thing. The other thing too, is the way that you hooked the hook scene you have in the, in the beginning, which is basically showing Father Gil just doing what he does. Yep. And you get the sense that he’s done this countless times and he’s, he’s, he’s good at it, but he’s also still alone. He had like, nothing’s really changed. He’s just kind of this lone wolf and he kind of goes off and does his own things like this lone sniper. But that’s, what’s different about this story is who he found during the journey and how they’ve impacted him and how he’s impacted them. And I think that’s, that’s, and then, so, which makes from an audience standpoint, it’s like, that’s why we are watching this story and we weren’t privy to, or we didn’t, we, we weren’t watching all these other times that he’s, he’s been an exercise, you know, he’s exercised demons before.
This is why, because this is a, this is different. There’s something special about this moment. And I think that. Totally. That’s what. Yeah, totally. It totally comes across at the, I just love that the wide angle shot. And then, you know, there’s, there’s character, like the, the husband and wife are on the porch and they’re moving around and there’s all the characters are kind of basically kind of in scene. And then he drives off. And there’s no cut. And then he backs up.
Josh: Yeah.
Devin: And it’s like, oh, I love that scene. I just love that.
Josh: Well, and I will say this. One of the other reasons I shot it that way was because I didn’t know how it was going to end. So, like, in as much as if we watched, if I cut the movie together and I’m like, man, Maria was annoying. Like, she was not fun to watch. I could get rid of her. Yeah. He’s not coming back. She’s not coming back. But if, and I’ll say, not to spoil, I mean, this is a huge spoiler, so if you don’t want to hear it, turn it off, whatever. But the movie isn’t a movie that I feel can be spoiled. You have to just, you have to just watch it.
It’s like a weird experience. It’s like, okay, again, to go throw it back, it’s like listening to your buddy’s garage band demo CD that sounds like garbage. It’s like not that good. But watching them live, it’s way better. And this is like one of those things where if you’re trying to hear it, you’re trying to explain it. It’s like hearing the demo, just not the same. But if you watch it, you’re like, okay, this is the punk of it. You can’t, can’t talk about it. But the, the thing with Stanley at the end, that was a, that was supposed to be a joke. Like that was not, not a joke in the sense of like, it wasn’t supposed to be in the movie.
That was supposed to be a joke deleted scene that I was going to put just on distribution, like for the, for the DVD. So when people saw it, they’d be like, oh, that’s funny. So why did you decide to make?
Adam: Why did you make that your official ending then? What was the?
Josh: I couldn’t cut it, man. I love Stanley too much. I just love him too much that I was just like, I, it’s, it’s worse. It’s, if we don’t, if we leave it as is without that beat, it just doesn’t feel right. Like it just doesn’t feel right. Well, also you feel a little bad for Stanley because he’s like, hey, like, where are you guys going? When I realized how great Stanley’s arc was in the edit. That’s when I realized it because you don’t feel that arc when you read the script, like you don’t feel like Stanley really changes that much.
Adam: X, Y, and Z, man. And as we were saying, script, production, editing, and you have to approach them with a, with the, an untainted viewpoint so you can make those decisions.
Josh: And that’s why, like, if you have the chance to shoot the most beautiful, if you have a chance to shoot a really pretty ending, but it’s going to take you a bunch of time. Or you have the chance to shoot. If you have the chance to shoot two really good endings, I would say shoot the two over the one. Right. Because when you get into that edit, you just don’t know. You don’t know what you’re going to want or how you’re going to feel.
Adam: It’s about giving yourself options in the edit, making sure you bring options to your edit.
Josh: It’s about that and it’s about, like, understanding that you maybe, as a filmmaker, don’t quite understand what you’ve even tapped into. Absolutely. Like, understanding that you may not be. You may not be as clever and smart as you think you are. So, giving yourself the options lets you, especially with indie film, like, if you’re doing it for no budget, you can’t do reshoots, you know you only have this location for one day, just shoot both those things because I never in a million years would have thought the Stanley ending was going to be the ending. Never. I would have told you, like, it’s too silly. Everyone’s going to think it’s fucking stupid.
And I tried it. I even showed the first version I showed my wife. Didn’t have that ending. And she’s like, that’s sad. I was like, what? She’s like, well, he’s just going to, there’s no, there’s no redeeming to him. Like, there’s no thing happening afterwards. And then I showed her the other ending and she’s like, well, that’s the ending. Why the fuck would you use the other one? That’s stupid.
Adam: Let me ask you one final question that we can end on. And I have to know this. Was Father Trejo based on Danny Trejo? Is that how you named him? Yeah. Oh, 100%. Because he looks a little long. He looks very Danny Trejo in his portrayal. Oh, yeah. And I was just curious.
Josh: Yeah. So when I wrote the script, I wrote that in just based on, number one, I’m like, I’m Danny Trejo is one of my favorite actors. I fucking love Danny Trejo. And my dream has always been through the reason I sent the animations to Troublemaker that they bought in the first place was my dream is to do Machete, the animated series. Like, I want to direct Machete, the animated series so bad. And. So I sent that, and I wrote it in there going, like, well, maybe if I put that name in there, potentially they’ll go, okay, we can get Danny Trejo, but he’s going to cost you this much.
Adam: Right.
Josh: You know what I mean? Like, maybe they can work out a deal, or even just get me, and, I mean, here’s the thing, with indie film, if you can get a name in your movie.
Adam: Or maybe he’d be willing to, because you were paying your performers anyway, maybe he’d be willing to do it for that price, for the sake of it.
Josh: He’s, but he’s SAG, so there’s all these rules, I don’t know.
Adam: Oh, I see.
Josh: But in the end, I really just wrote it as, I just wanted to homage Danny Trejo, because, I mean, he’s the fucking best, and the name is just strong, Father Trejo. Right. It just sounds badass, so I was like, okay, I’ll go with Father Trejo, and it fits into the whole Robert Rodriguez world. Right. Maybe he’s Danny Trejo’s brother, you know, like, there’s some, like, element of that. He resembled each other, yeah. Yeah, there’s something to it, and I’ll tell you what, like, if I, if I did. The sequel, which I already, we’ve written the sequel, it’s called Father Gil and the Daughters of Lilith, but if I do the sequel, and I have the option of recasting, or of casting Danny Trejo as Father Trejo, Father Trejo makes an appearance in the movie.
That’s a spoiler, I guess, but Father Trejo makes an appearance in the movie. If they were like, hey, here’s the thing, Father Trejo is in it, but we want you to cast Danny Trejo as Father Trejo, I wouldn’t do it. Mark was so awesome, and came in. So prepared to just, like, help out. Yeah. He was a badass, like, he just shows up, and he just crushed it so hard that I’m like, I can’t see Father Trejo now as Danny Trejo. Now Father Trejo is Mark, and if they wanted Danny Trejo in the movie, I’d be like, okay, then he’s Father Danny, or something. He’s not that same guy, or they’re brothers.
The brothers Trejo, but I need to put Mark as that character again. A funny story about that, too. That scene. That scene is the most aggravating scene in the world to me, because I had planned Father Trejo’s opening shot, which was this low angle of him holding a crucifix and the vial with the windmill. You see, like, one shot of the windmill in the movie, in the background, and it was this awesome shot. I even set the camera up, like, a day in advance to make sure that the shot was right, and I had Daniel stand in for Mark and everything. And I had planned it out, because it was, like, the, it was the first badass shot of the movie.
Like, I wanted the opening on the window, because that just feels Spielberg-y to me, and then the camera pans, or, like, yeah, pans down to the, to the possessed guest. Mm-hmm. That was my opening shot. I wanted that as my opening shot, but then I wanted that to be the first badass shot, and we got to set. It was Halloween. Everything was set up. It was so fucking. It was so fucking cool, and it poured outside. Oh. And I couldn’t film it. So I had to re, I had to change the shot, and I’m like, well, what if he comes around the corner like a badass?
Because we had already filmed the shot. In the rain? We had already, no, because we, well, we show that first shot of him walking up, that exorcist-y type shot of him walking up. Mm-hmm. That was, I had to shoot that from, like, across the street. We had a smoke machine we were going to use that we couldn’t use because it was raining. Like, that whole scene kind of fell apart. Yeah. So when I see it, in my head, I’m like, man, this could have been so much more badass. Like, in my head, it was so awesome. And everyone sees it, and they’re always like, that’s such a badass scene.
Like, no, you don’t see what I see in my head. And,. Yeah. But the cool thing is, is later on, I realized it’s really cool the way, no one else thinks about this, but it’s really funny to me, personally, that we see Father Trejo walk around that corner. Yeah. Like, to go into the bedroom, and he comes out like a badass. And then, later in the movie, we see Father Gil, in the almost exact same shot, peek around the corner, terrified, to see the Bible. And it’s really cool, the, like, juxtaposition between Father Gil and Father Trejo, that one walks around that corner to go in like a badass and dies, and the other one looks around the corner like a total coward, and, like, slowly walks in scared.
Adam: It’s great. It’s a great character setup payoff to show the difference between the two. It really helps to spotlight that point.
Josh: Yeah. And I had a lot of fun with those kind of moments, that whether you notice them or not, they give you a feel. Like, you know when you’re watching the movie, you’ve seen that doorway, and you know you’ve felt someone going into that room. And every time Father Gil walks to that room, he’s always terrified. It’s the teddy bear. It’s the Bible. He’s always scared to walk to that room. And I don’t, originally we had, in the script, I had a moment where he was walking back to his room to find Maria, and it just didn’t make sense. So I cut that scene.
Or actually, we didn’t film it at all. I cut it from the script pretty early on, but that was my, like, threes to use that room with Father Gil. It was going to be one, two, three. And in retrospect, if I had done it again, I think I would have had Stanley come from that door. But the problem is, is we wouldn’t have got that, when he comes to beat up Father Gil, we wouldn’t have got that, like, looks like his mom kind of through the window, that, like, psycho style shot. So, I don’t know. Hindsight’s 20-20.
Adam: For some reason, I thought of the moment where he says, Stanley likes to call it his bachelor pad. That’s all I was thinking about. Oh, God. And then… When you pan to the mattress in the middle of an empty room with lotion and some used tissues, and I nearly died laughing.
Josh: It’s even better because, so, if you rewatch it and you look really closely, you have to look pretty damn close, you’ll see that it isn’t lotion, it’s shampoo. That’s all I had. I didn’t have any lotion, so I just took my shampoo from home and brought it. And it’s also a travel magazine. The magazines laying on the floor aren’t even porno magazines, they’re travel magazines, which always makes me laugh. And the bed actually isn’t a bed. I couldn’t carry a bed in there, so it’s folding chairs that are, like, stacked in a weird way that look like a bed. And I also… Another funny story about that shot is the… so, we filmed that. Then we took a break for lunch, and then we went and filmed another scene really quick. But we always cleaned up at the end of the day. And that ranch that I filmed that is mostly for weddings. And we forgot to clean up the tissues and the bed and stuff, and the dudes who owned the place were showing the place around to people having a wedding and they walked in and found that. Oh, my God. Yeah. Oh, man! Yeah… Oh, my God. That’s great. A similar thing happened with the people showing for the weddings. When we were filming the scene of the teddy bear and the guts spewed out on the ground, they were showing the wedding when that was happening.
And so I was like pulling the guts and filming and we had the teddy bear on fishing line that we then pulled over the guts when it launches through the air. And so Daniel had the teddy bear on fish line and he was getting ready to pull it and the guts were all laid out. And these two women walked by, obviously there to look at the place for a wedding. And Daniel dressed up and the entire priest get up, just looks out at them and goes, he just goes, happy wedding. Hope you like the place. And these women just like looked at us and took off.
They were like, okay.
Devin: Oh, that’s good.
Josh: That’s so funny.
Adam: Yeah, we had a good time. Josh, thank you so much for taking the time to hang out with us and tell us about your experience. Right on. You are an amazingly inventive. Fellow and please everyone, StoryOsophers, watch Rebel Without a Crew. It premieres November the 18th and you get to see Josh and all his glory.
Josh: There’s a lot of silly, trust me. You see a lot of goofiness out of me and my crew. We had a lot of fun. So tune in if you want to see how filmmaking can be fun and also challenging. It’s, it’s a good time. I, the show I’ve already seen the show. It’s really, really enjoyable. I’m very proud of what we were able to show.
Adam: And so the film itself, The Good Exorcist, your film, it will be released after the run of Rebel Without a Crew. So people should be looking forward to that in the beginning of the year, February ish.
Josh: Yeah. January, February, sometime around there. Follow me on social media to find out more. I post a lot. So, my Instagram is at Flush Studios. That’s my company Flush Studios, like flush a toilet and then studios. Then I think on Twitter, I’m, at Josh stifter, follow me on Facebook. I think that, I mean, that’s the social media is right. YouTube, YouTube at flush or YouTube.com slash Flush Studios or Flush Studios.com.
Adam: Fantastic. And also I, just as a brief moment, I wanted to give a shout out to Jason Lachey. He is a mutual friend of both mine and Josh’s and Devin’s. I believe a filmmaker also from Minnesota. You Minnesotans, man.
Josh: Yeah.
Adam: We’re trying. We’re trying damn hard. Jason is a filmmaker as well. Also an, a performer, voice actor. And I just wanted to give him a shout out because he’s the, the dude who hooked me up with Josh to, for this interview. And so we just wanted to give a quick thanks out there to him.
Josh: Right on.
Devin: Josh, what’s, what high school did you go to?
Josh: I went to a private high school in Eau Claire, Wisconsin.
Devin: Oh, in Eau Claire. Okay. I’d heard you went to a private high school. I was like in, in high, in Minnesota. Cause I went to St. Thomas Academy, which is a private high school. So I thought, I was like, maybe.
Josh: No way that we were. No, I know people who went to St. Thomas Academy, but I, no, I went to a private high school in Eau Claire. Gotcha. Cool. Minnesota talk. Right. We’re very, we’re very proud of where, of our Midwest, Northern Midwestern-ness.
Adam: You should be. I love Minnesota. Minnesota is a fantastic state. Everybody I’ve met from Minnesota is awesome. If the seasons didn’t change so damn fast.
Devin: I know.
Adam: Fuck, it’s hard. It’s hard to film a movie here. There is no fall. It’s like a blink of an eye. Yeah. Well, Josh, thank you. Again, we appreciate you, you taking the time. Right on guys. Awesome. Thanks so much, man. Josh Stifter, everybody. Please subscribe and rate us on iTunes. Follow us on social media, share with your friends, and send us your questions and comments. For additional resources and links to films, series, and books we talk about here, visit our website. While you’re there, sign up for our newsletter for updates on story building tools and special offers at StoryOsophy.com.