Season 2, episode 38

Movement 4 (Act 2)

Act 2, movement 4: Recovery

November 10, 20181 hr 3 min

Show notes

After the midpoint crisis comes the eye of the hurricane. Movement 4 is quieter on the outside and stormy on the inside. The group falls apart, the hero hits bottom, and then rises, re-choosing the quest with a new understanding of themselves. Devin calls it “a writer’s movement,” full of dialogue and subtext. Adam calls it the phoenix movement. Here’s how its events build from crisis to recovery.

In this episode

  • Discovery mid-story, not just at the end. Adam and Devin want the hero’s self-discovery here, so we can watch their new beliefs play out. Today’s naturalistic screen acting lets an audience sit with a character’s inner life, like Walter White’s in Breaking Bad.
  • A movement in two halves. Before the darkest moment, the group unravels; after it, the hero pulls them back together and shifts from reacting to acting.
  • 1. Escape. A chase, a retreat, an exile, a rejection. Joseph Campbell’s “magic flight.” Maverick quits Top Gun after Goose dies; Ron Burgundy flees the newsroom in Anchorman.
  • 2. Aftermath. Take stock and assign blame. The team takes cheap shots and pokes each other’s internal obstacles. People often accuse others of what they fear most in themselves.
  • 3. Hero’s darkest moment. All seems lost, an echo of the refusal of the call: “See, I was right.” Devin drags the hero through the mud for a bigger payoff; Adam prefers to keep it lighter. Either way it’s emotional. Kermit’s campfire conversation with himself in The Muppet Movie is a model.
  • 4. The fall of the heart wall. A “floater” event, often the end of the darkest moment, sometimes saved for the climax. The hero lets their guard down. The name comes from Dr. Bradley Nelson’s book The Emotion Code. Set up the vulnerability here and pay it off in the climax.
  • 5. Reassessment. The campfire scene: little light, a lot of darkness, and the intimacy to reveal inner obstacles. A second herald can bring new information. Then the hero re-chooses the quest, often with a montage to bring the pace back up.
  • From motivated to inspired action. In the first half, characters act because they think they must. In the second half, they act from a sense of their own worth.

Examples discussed

  • Guardians of the Galaxy: Drax summons the villain while drunk; then the team turns on each other, and Peter later distracts Ronan with a dance.
  • Top Gun: Viper finally tells Maverick about his father.
  • Die Hard: John McClane pulls the glass from his feet while Powell admits he shot a kid.
  • Also: The Wizard of Oz, Anchorman, Star Wars and romantic comedies.

Next week: Movement 5, from recovery to climax.

Read the full transcript

Transcribed automatically, so expect the odd misheard word. Sponsor messages are left out.

Adam: In this episode, we continue to break down Act 2 by exploring Movement 4. What are the events that take your hero from the midpoint crisis to their self-fulfillment? Self-realization and recovery. Next, on StoryOsophy. Hello, welcome to StoryOsophy. This is Adam Jones. And Devin Halden. This week, we are talking about Movement 4. Ooh. We’re continuing our conversation about Act 2 in general. And we’re talking about the third movement in Act 2. If you haven’t listened to episodes previous to this, go back and listen to probably when we start talking about movements. One, two, three, and now we’re talking about four. It will give you a better experience in understanding all of it comprehensively as a whole thing.

But if not, you will still love this episode because this is a great movement. It’s one of the movements I think Devin and I, we like everything, man. I mean, Devin and I just really love all elements of story and exploring what you can do with them. The tool, the gear, the aspect of story and how you can manipulate it. But this, I think the reason I like this particular movement, which this is, is crisis to recovery. So that’s sort of where you’re going with this. And I’ll explain how that lays out from the previous three movements as we continue. But I like this particular movement because this is the moment after the midpoint, the tipping point, fight, flight, or freeze, when they’re sort of getting away and they’re, because there’s too much.

The danger zone was a little taste of it and now it’s a little, the crisis that we’ve just experienced at the end of the last movement is, too much. And so they have to reassess. And so this is the, this a quieter spot for me in the story. And I think Devin and I sort of have expanded this a little more than what some folks like Vogler and Campbell do. Although it’s hard to tell because they have such broad stages and we’re breaking them down into more tiny steps of a hero. I like this because it takes the time for the hero to understand what has gone wrong or their flaw or these, these moments that they can reassess and change the goal and it’s amplifies choice as a major part of the design and story and not just the hero being a victim to something or a white knight who’s never wrong.

There’s an aspect where the hero comes to discovery about themselves and then the rest of the story as it plays out, we get to see how that new decision making belief about themselves or the world around them is implemented and then changes that world. So I really like, the, what this whole movement is about in terms of what it does for your hero. It’s also sort of like a karmic wheel. This sort of mirrors movement one a little bit in the start of the adventure again, because something went wrong, failure or success, right? And you’re weighing that. At after this crisis point, but it’s sort of like the window of opportunity for me, this movement. And we’ll talk about that a little bit in a little bit. Devin, is there anything in particular you want to say right off the bat?

Devin: I think of this movement as the eye of the hurricane. So we’ve just come out of something very tumultuous or something dangerous. And now there’s calm and there may be this, not necessarily this like false hope at this stage of the game, but things have calmed down a little bit, but only from an external conflict or external plot standpoint. Because for me, this movement now becomes about the hero and the characters. And things actually can get pretty nasty at this stage of the game with our hero and the allies. Because remember, we just escaped that decision that we made at fight, flight or freeze, or the midpoint. And now we kind of were picking up the pieces of that decision and figuring out what went wrong, perhaps. And maybe we realize at this point that we don’t know what we thought we knew. I think we talked about that in the last movement. There’s a lot of self-discovery here.

Adam: That’s the big part of this movement is you don’t want the person to discover themselves at the end of the story. You really want them to discover themselves here. For Devin and I, we choose to the trigger for that. Because we like to see the evolution more of this inner space with the hero. And to be honest, if you think of today’s entertainment, the naturalistic acting that is required with your HDTVs that you see every pore on every face, these internal changes for the hero are really important now. You can see their decision-making changes. This is why you can put Bryan Cranston as Walter White in Breaking Bad and just let him sit there and think about the decisions he’s making. And the audience is in love with his performance because the narrative set up spaces where all you have to do is let the audience resonate emotionally with that inner space. But we’re sort of stretching this out a little bit.

Devin: This is a writer’s movement. And what I mean by that is because this could be, if you decide to go this direction, a very heavy dialogue subtext movement where we’re starting to learn. And things are starting to, even though things have calmed down, like I said, the eye of the hurricane, as far as the external, plot is considered, the internal conflicts of not only the hero, but also the allies are coming to the surface a little bit more. And even this bond that we thought maybe was a very strong bond between the hero and his allies, that is showing signs of unraveling a little bit. Again, even though things have settled down in terms of action and external plot, a lot is happening in this movement from our characters’ perspectives. And so movement four, we’ll see our hero, our hero is going to hit rock bottom and they’re going to be forced to deal, that inner obstacle that they push deep inside or kept hidden their entire, perhaps their entire life up to this point. And so things are beginning to get pretty intense as far as the group goes.

This movement is actually has a, has a beginning, a midpoint. And then, and then this movement itself is actually in my mind, two can be separated into two. If you use, if you’re using the, this hero’s darkest moment, which we’ll talk about as like the fulcrum bar to this movement, is the movement begin up until the point of the hero’s darkest moment is the unraveling of our group and the second guessing of, of a group. And then they will, our hero will have this darkest moment.

Adam: Which is fun to write too. You know, this whole section is fun to write with allies and heroes.

Devin: Yeah. And then things start becoming clearer. Our hero is starting to transform into an, an actual hero in this movement. And they’re, they’re shifting from a reactionary character to, to one that is taking action after this, their darkest moment. And so they’re kind of like, you know, at, at one stage of this movement, I’m just giving an overview of the movement. We’ll dissect a little better, but they’re kind of at this, like enough of this crap. I’m, I’m the right person to be here. I can do this. There’s no doubt in my mind. This certainly doesn’t mean that the success of achieving the objective or the goal is inevitable by any means, but at least there’s a reassurance. It feels very purposeful for the hero.

Yeah. Well, and there’s a reassurance from us and even the allies, well, us, we’re basically with the allies at this stage of the game for the audience and the readers.

Adam: Yeah, we are the allies.

Devin: Because now we’re in for a fantastic rest of the journey. And of course, obstacles and missteps and underestimations will, will certainly rear their ugly heads again at some point, but our heroes refocus of the objective gives us this confidence that we’re in this fight to the death. There’s been other stages where there’s no turning back, but it’s no turning back because we’re in this fight to the death. The world isn’t going to let us out. Or the antagonist isn’t going to let us out. And at this stage of the game, there’s no turning back because our hero is deciding that that is no longer an option. That right now, that going after this objective or this goal, that is what…

You know, devise a new plan for the strategy ahead. But that’s why when I look at this movement, I see this movement as a two part movement in a way if you’re using that heroes darkest moments of the fulcrum bar, because before that, everybody’s falling, everybody’s pushing each other’s buttons, maybe people are, are taking liberties with internal issues that other people are having. And there’s doubt, there’s a lot of doubt within the group and things are kind of unraveling. And then the hero begins to take over. And he begins to pull the group back, they’re regrouping, they’re reassessing. And then we as audience or as readers are starting, this is where we’re starting to get excited, because like, oh, now, now stuff’s going down, like this, these guys are in it. And so this is going to be a fantastic rest of this, like, I can’t wait, like this is you’re getting another bowl of popcorn at this point, because you’re like, this stuff is going down, or it’s going to.

Adam: Yeah, yeah, yeah. You know, I thought of a really interesting example while you were talking about this. It’s fairly recent. A little bit of a spoiler, but not really. It’s old enough. Guardians of the Galaxy, the first one, when they all meet, and we sort of get it’s a team building movie, because they all first meet. So a lot of what we’re talking about, as examples for these movements, it really applies to that movie. And they also have a midpoint crisis tipping point. Drax calls their enemy because he wants to kill him and says, Here I am, come get me. Yeah, like a moron, because he’s drunk. And so there’s a central battle with the major enemy. There’s then and they find that the object of the movie is the enemy.

They’re taking it to find out more about it. They were just the object they have rather, that’s important is identified, we find out that it’s, they’ve been holding this thing that’s all powerful. All those things happen right in the middle, they discover how much power is within their fingertips. And one of their dumb team members invites the enemy to come and fight them, which is so stupid. But after that, a lot of stuff goes down in the heroes team falling apart in ways. Yeah. Drax has this moment where he realizes, I’m weak. I’m not strong enough to have done that. That was a very stupid, he’s pretty overly confident. And so that’s a big reveal for him. You know, I won’t say what happens with Peter and Gamora, but they each have a moment rocket and group. And that’s another thing in this, this movement that I think is important. If you do have a team, a group of allies, as Devin’s talking about the group falls apart. That’s not the only way to do it necessarily. In talking comprehensively, there are if it’s a romantic comedy, there might be a friend and the person.

And the person is really rude to the friend. And so the friend doesn’t want to talk to them for the moment. So the hero isolates themselves in a way or something. But what he’s saying is the ensemble, but it all falls apart. And there’s this place where everybody has to look at what means something to them, and then reassess together, even if the hero is the catalyst for all that. Like in Guardians of the Galaxy is a great example, because everybody goes through their own separate thing. Rocket and Groot, Groot’s like, tells them, tells him basically, they’re our family. They love them. And he’s like, shut up, Groot. And he’s really angry at Groot about it. Because that’s the growth point for both of them.

Yeah. And then Drax is a growth point. And everybody has a growth point that changes. And then, and this is what we’ll get to in the next couple movements, there’s now a build to the climax. And there’s a lot of stuff that can happen after this midpoint thing. Like, they have to be rescued. Or they have to team up with, in Guardians of the Galaxy’s case, the space pirates who are, you know, they’re sort of not. Completely evil, but they’re not great. So you make allies with people you hadn’t expected before. You see beyond limitation, because something else matters. Just new decisions are being made based on this movement of discovery here.

Guardians of the Galaxy is a good example.

Devin: Wizard of Oz has a good one, too, where they all just start turning, they turn, I think it’s after they get to Oz. And then they have that moment where they kind of start calling out each other’s issues, like the cowardly lion. And then the, I can’t remember it exactly. So I probably shouldn’t even brought it up. But I know there’s a moment where they kind of turn on each other.

Adam: I didn’t think they turn it. I mean, maybe they do. It’s fairly brief. Yeah, I guess they do. Maybe my, I blocked it out because I just wanted to see the positive.

Devin: You’re like the guy who turns off Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer when they’re being mean to him.

Adam: I put it on mute and plug my ears and go, la la la la la. Before we get into the events of Movement 4 intimately, bit by a bit, event by event, I just wanted to track folks to catch them up from the previous three episodes. Movement 1, is also Act 1, is from comfort zone to out of comfort zone. And we cross the threshold into the special world, which is Act 2. And we go from in Movement 2, out of comfort zone for the hero, into danger zone. And Movement 3, we cross the threshold into the danger zone and we start to build towards the central issue or crisis or tipping point of the story.

And that is from into the danger zone or the danger zone to the crisis or tipping point. Or, Devin and I like to think of it as a fight, a flight, or freeze moment in the hero’s journey. And so, in this movement, Movement 4, which is still Act 2, Act 2 is a very long act traditionally. This particular movement is a very long act. This particular movement continues after the midpoint ordeal that’s just happened, whatever that might be. So, the first event in this movement, Devin and I call Escape. Something has happened where the hero is not strong enough or realizes their own limitations. They may have lost a member of the team.

They may have lost a fight or a battle. Misunderestimated the antagonist or the world itself. Did you like that? Misunderestimate. It’s not a word. Does that mean they… Misunderestimated correctly? Escape. You just got to get away. So, even in the example of a high school movie where whatever it is, it’s a relationship, it’s something. The hero sort of gets mocked and has to go away from, like go to the bathroom, and then they cry. There’s an escape moment where you just have to get away from the assault, the situation, the event that is that tipping point, that crisis moment. And I will use crisis a good bit.

Because traditionally, those are big words in story points, climax, crisis, things like that. But Devin and I have talked about this extensively. We don’t really like crisis because it always suggests that it has to be danger and danger only. Like life, death makes you think of a hospital. And it limits where your mind can go about what that central event can be. So, calling it the tipping point where you look at the first three movements as one side of the seesaw. This central point here as a fulcrum bar. We’re tipping to the other side. So, we like to think of it as a tipping point to like a hero’s discovery to just a new aspect of the story.

This first event, escape, is how does the hero get away from this central crisis that has been a big ordeal for them?

Devin: This is my eye of the hurricane analogy, I think, is where this is. And I don’t think I have much more to add to the actual event because you covered it pretty well. And it’s fairly self-explanatory. I think the main thing is remembering that what had just happened before this event. Because we highlighted the antagonist a bit in the event right before this. And again, we underestimated the power of the antagonist. And maybe we don’t know what we need to know. We may don’t have the tools we need to have. Or we may have the tools that we need. But we don’t know exactly how to access them or use them.

It can start with the force in Star Wars. Or those moments when you’re like, you had it in you all along. But they don’t know. We still don’t know that at this stage of the game. We just don’t know how to access or utilize any tools that we have. And we don’t know if we know how to even begin to figure out a plan or defeat the antagonist. Or achieve that or obtain that objective or goal. So I think that encompasses the entire movement in a way. But escape, that’s the beginning of this.

Adam: The arc of the movement, too, is the discovery of all these things that you’re laying out from the midpoint. When we say escape, it’s just sort of like, you know, there’s a vulnerability moment and you need to get away from it. You’re sort of in shock. It hasn’t quite registered what was the cause of all that vulnerability. Whatever happened there. Those questions are going to get asked once you’re safe. And so the whole beginning of this movement is finding a safe place and then examining the reaction that happened at the midpoint. And escape can be a lot of fun things. It can be a chase scene.

So the crisis point happens and, you know, the bad guy… Or the antagonist kills the mentor or an ally. But then a chase ensues. That’s still crossing the threshold of this event happened where a major player, a major character in the story dies. And then the continuation of that event… But the escape sort of becomes a car chase. Joseph Campbell, I believe, calls it magic flight. But he does this later where it’s sometimes an object of quest. And once you get it, the villain or the antagonist comes out.

On that. It’s a great place for a chase scene, this first chunk, great hook for the fourth movement.

Devin: And Top Gun’s a great example of this. Maverick’s inner obstacle, which we’ve talked about at length in previous episodes about his father, what happened to his father, the mystery of his father. He’s flying against a ghost. When Goose dies, Maverick quits Top Gun. And so he’s escaping that. He’s removed himself from that process, from that environment. And he’s now forced, because that’s the hero’s darkest moment for him. That’s his darkest moment. He’s forced to have to deal with the inner obstacle that he has.

Adam: Turmoil. Yeah.

Devin: That’s when he goes and he sees that his mentor, another mentor character comes in, or the mentor character, which is not Viper. Viper. Is it Viper?

Adam: I don’t know. I’m just trying to remember the words you said.

Devin: Oh, yeah. And he just asks, you know, that’s when he finds out about his father. But he gets the answer he needed in order to make the decision to rise from the ashes in a way and regroup, reassess, come up with a new plan. And he goes back and he graduates. And then he’s thrown immediately into the climax against another antagonist. And just actually, the main, the external antagonist, the antagonist of the plot is Iceman. Okay. They’re the ones going up against each other. But then the internal antagonist, which is really driving a lot of his decision is the issues. Yeah. That he has with his father, not knowing what happened to his father and the reputation of his name that he feels is unjustly tarnished.

Adam: Legacy is a good word for it. Yeah. I was thinking about this movement in this regard. When you get to the crisis, sometimes you see or experience something as a hero that is, it’s eye-opening. You don’t know why, you don’t know what it’s all about necessarily, but it gets your attention and it shakes you up. And that’s the whole point of this midpoint is, like I said, last week, we like to sometimes call it the midterm exam, even though we don’t, I don’t necessarily like the framework. This whole thing is a lesson learned because I think that’s annoying. But the midpoint is a place where the hero is tested in a similar way that they will be in the climax, except there’s something that becomes a realization. Realization means something becoming real. So this thing becomes very real.

For instance, if the hero has a latent relationship issue with their father, and that may not be Mavericks, but let’s just take this example. If there’s something that they have not dealt with, and it’s a big deal, it’s stuck in their cross with their father, relationship with their father, and they get to this point, they start to realize that this center point is, oh, that’s the real issue. And this is what I like to call, I mentioned earlier, windows of opportunity, where the boogeyman that you used to, the girlfriend you used to have, the boyfriend, the old friend, the boss that used to drive you crazy, that haunted you, and you’re like, oh, I got to get out of there, and you escape, you run away from that thing.

If you don’t clean that up for yourself internally, that character is just going to come back with a new mask. That character is just going to come back karmically, the circle of karma, right? Come back in just as a different person, but you’re still going to interact with the same type of individual. And so, whoever the villain is, whoever the antagonist is, whatever that deeper thing is with the father, it’s going to be reflected in the antagonistic forces all around this hero. Ice man, it’s the recklessness, you know what I mean? It’s this ferocity, it’s this fierceness to him. And like I say, Maverick gets his father’s recklessness, but Viper even, his commanding officers in Top Gun.

Are all sort of coming down on him. They’re all sort of antagonistic forces. And so, as he’s rebelling against the legacy of his father, with all these people, some of them are competition, Iceman, and some of them are authoritarian figures like his father. And then finally, the scene that helps him to make peace with all of this is with, and I believe you said his name, but it’s been a long time since I’ve seen this movie, Viper, who tells him that he flew with his dad and all this stuff. So basically, that scene with Viper is Maverick acting. Actually having that heart-to-heart conversation with his dad.

It’s the dad he wishes would communicate and have explained everything, that lived long enough to interact with. Viper represents all that. And so he’s sort of making peace with that through this reimagining of a father connection scene. But the father, or the issue he has with his father, is going to show up in his current experience. In the conflict he has in every other character around him. He doesn’t have a chip on his shoulder, like I said, he doesn’t have a chip on his shoulders because of… Of puppies, in the last episode. It’s because of his dad’s top gun status. It’s because his dad was here.

If you said to him something about puppies, he wouldn’t care. If you say something to him about challenging his skill or something about his father, he’s going to blow his lid. Those are his triggers, those are his, you know, sticking points in his life. So this is where the crisis really pokes that spot that needs to be noticed. But it can be the same vibe of the character that you never got over or you couldn’t fix. You’re going to have to make peace with that. And so it comes back in a different form as a new boogeyman, as a new, you know, antagonistic force, which is Top Gun to him, you know, his journey there.

But this escape, even another good example is Anchorman, the legend of Ron Burgundy. When he has this big central failure moment, and it’s very absurd in that movie, he moves to a lighthouse and goes blind. He escapes from the news world. It’s so dumb. Makes friends with a shark named Dobie.

But he is, this is that whole movement. He is, but he escapes from the news world. And sometimes escape, you can, the last thing I’ll say, about this event is like, you can also, it doesn’t have to be escape. It can be rejection. It can be ostracization. You’re kicked out of a place. Banned. It’s not necessarily escape. You can also be ousted. Like everyone turns their back on you. And you’re abandoned in a way. Shunned. Shunned. Excommunicated. All these words we’re talking about right now are also great ways to change up the recipe of the escape to be a different, a variation on it. The Will Ferrell character is, is.

The height of his ego, and then just plummets. And so he’s sort of kicked out of the social scene that he’s used to, or the celebrity he’s used to.

Devin: The main thing for, for this movement is the escape. And just, just remember from a measurement standpoint, you are leading your hero into their darkest moment. And so whatever that escape is, whatever happened at that midpoint, or that midterm exam, that tipping point, whatever they’re escaping from, and escape doesn’t necessarily mean it’s the action of the hero. It could be the actions of somebody else that resulted in that escape. So maybe escape could be a misnomer in a way, but it’s, it’s, but it’s also on your way, you’re spiraling down, the hero spiraling down. And whether it’s all of this movement takes place just with one, your, your hero and one character, or there’s with a team, which is kind of what I’ve been using as, as some of my examples.

It’s all related to, and the measurement is related to. The spiral down of the hero to the darkest moment. Yeah. For me, that’s the main thing I’m thinking about with this movement out of the midterm. Yeah. This movement out of three into four is basically that spiraling down. And it can get nasty. Like, don’t hold any punches back when you’re for this.

Adam: These are good onion peel back moments. Peeling back the onion and showing the best. That’s why he says it’s a writer’s movement, because this is where you get to show your sweet spots for your characters. He moves to a lighthouse and goes blind. Like, what? Exile. Exile. Yes, that’s escape or exile is what event one is. Then there’s the dealing with it, which is event two.

[Sponsor message]

Adam: Event two, we like to call Aftermath. Meaning they managed to get away. They’re maybe not safe and sound right now, but at least there’s no immediate danger. And it’s just like assessing the situation for a moment and going, who’s left? Did anyone die? Are we in the right place? Are they following us? It’s sort of just checking yourself to make sure there are no bullet wounds in the escape. It’s this moment where you’re taking stock of what just happened, but you don’t have time to really reflect on it. You just sort of take an inventory real quick.

Devin: And doubt is overwhelming at this stage of the game because our hero’s inner obstacle or inner conflict is essentially taking over. And in a way, they’re morphing into that inner obstacle. They’re allowing that inner conflict to really transform them. And their allies can, in some stories, the allies will kind of start to barely recognize their hero. They’re like, well, who is this guy? And then our hero will also maybe start to resent all of them. Like everything about this place and the journey and who they are, like this event, this event focuses on our hero and the team, like we said, or this whole movement, but this event in particular and their relationships with each other. And so the hero might be like, who tricked me into doing this? Or who tricked me into thinking I could do this? And so arguments.

Adam: Blame is huge here.

Devin: Yeah, right.

Adam: This is where you have a lot of argument. Like this is where they scold Drax for even calling him like, what were you thinking? Like they, people freak out on each other. They. Because something went wrong.

Devin: And they’re internal and external because like we said, the team’s beginning to turn on each other and the bonds are starting to unravel a little bit. So, and perhaps it’s the moment that our heroes and the allies are starting to take cheap shots at each other. Like we talked about before.

Adam: Cheap shots.

Devin: They’re exposing or poking at internal obstacles or internal conflicts of each other, knowing that they’ll affect them in a bad way. They’re, they’re pushing each other’s buttons. And so, but at least, and their, their, their thing, their thought is, well, I’m deflecting. I’m deflecting away from myself. And so, and again, depending on your story, you can make this, you can make this really nasty.

Adam: Yeah. Hey, I might be to blame, but I’m not going to let them know that I’m not going to want to take the fault here. So I’m going to blame someone else.

Devin: Exactly. Everybody’s defensive.

Adam: Also, subtextually, this is a great place to sneak in people’s insecurities in a very opposite, passive aggressive way. Instead of saying, I feel this way and I feel like I might be to blame for this. They sort of project outward and attack the other person’s weakness. Or even, this is always an, oftentimes a tell with people is they’ll project onto someone else or accuse someone else of the thing that they are the most afraid of.

Devin: Right.

Adam: And that’s literally projection. It’s not pointing out the person’s flaw. It’s actually pointing out their own flaw by accusing the other person of it. I mean, that’s actual conversation and interaction between people. But both of those are very telling for this event, using it either way like that. You’ve got, you know, poking at the flaw or poking at accidentally exposing their own flaw. But as Devin says, there is a, this is a good place for an argument, you know, between, between allies, if you’re in a group. And even if not, it’s sort of going back. It’s a romantic comedy in the heartbreak moment where the person’s like, I don’t want to be with you is a center tipping point or something, maybe. So they go to their friend and say,

Devin: Yeah, they just say something they know is gonna, is gonna dig. They know it’s gonna hurt. Not to hurt each other.

Adam: If they go back to the friend that sort of set them up, they attack the friend. Instead of attack, it’s the same thing as attacking the ally. They also look to the friend and go, I can’t believe you thought that this was a good idea. Blah, blah, blah, cha, cha, cha. But once again, boy meets girl is a different thing. Because it’s more about instead of this movement being particularly long, this movement tends to be shorter. And the courting process of the romantic part of the romantic comedy tends to be prolonged in the beginning. It’s boy meets girl for a very long time. Boy loses girl.

Boy gets girl back. Or vice versa. Girl meets boy if it’s a female heroine. But it’s, like I say, these movements change a little bit. But this is, but this is a place where there’s a falling out is a good way to put it. Aftermath or falling out. Falling out meaning argument as well. Disagreement. Blame. All the stuff that negative interactions with people. As Devin’s saying, cheap shots is a really great way of thinking of it too. You don’t want to say those things, but you did.

Devin: And it’s also a good spot. This is where you’re going to want to really expose the hero’s inner conflict. And really make it.

Series of events to really plan out. Because for me, and I think Adam doesn’t like always dragging the hero through the mud a little bit. But in certain stories, if that’s what you need to do, do it bad. Really drag them through the mud. There’s other ways to do it where you don’t have to. Other stories. That’s not the case. There’s different ways of doing it. But if that type of story that you’re doing is the hero is literally at the depths of despair, really drag them down to the depths of despair. Because then it makes that rising of the ashes such a better payoff or a more satisfying event.

Because we’re really pulling for the hero at this point.

Adam: A good idea to have in mind for this movement is sort of a phoenix concept. Devin keeps saying rise from the ashes. This is like the phoenix movement. And like I said, it goes from crisis to recovery. I don’t want to lose the notion that throughout this thing, there is a huge… Evolution from crisis point to recovery. It’s sort of like finding the wound, examining the wound, recovering from the wound. It’s self-examination in a lot of ways. That’s why we don’t like the word crisis because it tends to be very physical in a way. But we’re talking about a moment that challenges the hero to… To self-examine. And it can be the darkest moment, like he’s saying, or it can be a place where in a children’s story where someone who has agreed to hold something for someone, a special marble that this other kid loves or something, and keep it safe, he loses it.

Devin: Yes. Yeah.

Adam: What do I do? My friend is… Like, there’s a crisis moment that he has to examine himself. I tried my best, and then he admits it to the kid friend, and the kid friend says, oh, I came by earlier, and I got it. I saw it, so I just grabbed it. I meant to tell you, but you were doing this, which is a stupid, silly example of how to do it without dragging the hero. Through the darkest, horrible places, or life or death. It’s a little kid with a marble, but he knows it means something to his friend. All seems lost. All seems lost, right. Leading us into event three, which is, Devin?

Devin: Hero’s darkest moment. All seems lost. I do want to say this about this. Another just reminder for me with this movement is we’re at now three is like the fulcrum point of this movement. And so before this movement, it is dealing with the hero and the allies as a group. And the fallout from the crisis. Yep. They’ve just escaped.

Adam: At least they’re safe for now is what I would call this area too.

Devin: Right. But it’s dealing with the group. And so the group is and then they’ve escaped. They’re taking cheap shots at each other. They’re unraveling. And then we hit this point. And this is primarily between our hero and their inner obstacle. This is a very inner debate with themselves. Because and now they’re going to feel a bit isolated. And they’re alone. But they’re once they rise from the ashes, then it’s them putting is them pulling the group back together. This is such an important, important event in the story is really important. Because after this is the hero taking action, becoming aware of it, too. Yeah. And he’s like, this is me. I am the person that has to be doing this.

And they go through this transformation here. And then they are the ones that regroup. And by regroup, not only just regrouping themselves, they’re regrouping the group if it’s a team based film or story. I can’t obviously I can’t emphasize enough how important this is.

Adam: It’s a big self reflection moment. Yeah, I was gonna say one of the really good example is the original Muppet Movie where Kermit the frog is. It’s a it’s a campfire scene. And he’s out in the middle of nowhere. This journey has failed. He feels like he’s been really in trying to inspire people and speak to his allies and the group’s needs individually. Good leader. You know, strong Kermit’s a good leader, but he’s feeling self-doubt and he walks off on his own away from everyone else. After the aftermath, he walks away and he ends up having an imaginary conversation. I let everyone down. So this conversation is this moment. It’s the hero filled with doubt and failure and at a point where this is the point where the hero says, I’m going to give up or I’m not going to give up. What Devin is saying about taking them to the lowest depth here is because what happens next, it creates a stronger reversal.

It’s like taking your roller coaster cars all the way up to as high as you can so that you can bring them down. Or bring them all the way down so that you can now start to build them back up really high. Which is really more appropriate, the latter analogy there. Taking the roller coaster down to the bottom so that the build, you can now start a really good build. And this build’s going to build from this point to your climax. But it’s that conversation with self. I just don’t like thinking of it as having to make it the hero’s darkest, the most brutal way you can drag a hero through the dirt.

I think… What I love about this particular event is it does, through contrast, put into perspective what the hero really cares about for them. Now, the audience gets to participate in this and really enjoy this, but this is where they might see themselves as a failure and give up. It’s sort of… It sort of mirrors in Movement 1… Movement 4 and Movement 1 are very similar in structure. Very, very similar. This is sort of like the, you know, the debate of refusal of call. The reason why they doubted themselves in that first movement when they refused the call to adventure. Here they go, see, I was right.

I am worthless. I can’t do this. I’m not enough. That’s what this is. And I don’t like embracing that event too much for myself because I don’t like people going too heavy into self-abuse. Devin is joking, but that’s why I don’t like to play this event too heavy. I think the audience can understand this person. And not drag this out too much. And then allow the next event to inspire the audience a lot. But I’m by no means negating Devin’s point of the heavier this is for the hero, the harder you make this, the bigger the struggle, the more the next event will pay off. He’s absolutely right. But my personal preference as a writer is I like to keep my audience.

I don’t like to go too dark, too violent, too grotesque, too terrible.

Devin: And I like to make, I want people crying at this stage of the game. It’s a very emotional, no matter what, however you play it, it’s, it needs to be emotional. Like it’s just a very, and it could be, it’s all emotion actually. Sure. No matter what’s physically happening. Physically happening to your hero. It’s an emotional, it’s a struggle. It’s like you’re saying it’s, it’s, this is the inner debate for sure. Yeah. Inner debate. It’s the, it’s the,

Adam: It’s the reprise of the debate of refusal and choosal of call. That’s what this moment till the end of this movement, when we say recovery, that’s what it is. You’re recovering, you’re, you’re reassessing and recovering. So it’s like the end of movement one, where it’s like, now there’s this delayed refusal of call. It’s like, I can’t do this. And so the debate becomes much more stretched out for the hero. So we can start to understand all this now. And we’ll go back to this hero’s darkest moment as we go through these next events. Because it is, as Devin says, the fulcrum bar of this movement. It is the tipping point of this movement.

And I want to make a comment about this as overall structure. Just as that end of movement three is the tipping point or the fulcrum bar of the entire story, each movement, each scene has a fulcrum bar, has a tipping point, where the scene transitions. So the hero is a different thing, or the understanding of that hero is a different thing from the beginning of it to the end. So in this particular movement, that

Well, they haven’t, but they’re having a moment of, and this is the point of crisis in the middle. The one reason why I do like to keep that word is, think identity crisis. In terms of when you’re trying to plan out your movement four, think of movement three, that central point, as no matter what is the physical event of the movie, the external stuff going on, the internal is an immediate identity crisis. Who that person thought they were is not there. They’re on unstable footing. I don’t know. Didn’t figure it all out. So, and as Devin says, once they get here, they are leaving the storm and going, or the hurricane, and now they’re in the eye. So, not everything’s over, but they’re safe enough, and in this calm, they can reflect, and that’s this hero’s darkest moment.

As soon as the mind and the world around them is quiet enough, they have to confront that inner space. They’re forced to in some way. I think the reason we love this is because this is one of those things as we’re trying to reinvent, not reinvent. Story, but evolve story. We’ve heard stories in a certain way for so long, we want to change them up. This is a great place for introspection, and I think as audience members these days, especially with long-form storytelling where you can develop with a character, another human being, getting to know them deeply and intimately really matters. You can’t just have some superficial character and expect to stick with them forever.

Even the ones that I’m talking about in light-hearted storytelling, like a children’s story, or I often refer to special stories. Spongebob and Patrick. Their stakes are high, but they’re absurd stakes, but we really love them because of their positivity. So we stay with them. But in every other case, you want to have these moments where we can really resonate with the inner aspect of characters, and that’s why we sort of stretch this section out a little bit.

Devin: Hero’s darkest moment is where we’ve now heard all of the relevant backstory up until this point. We’ve been trickling it out throughout the story. [unclear] We’re kind of going to know everything we need to know about the hero’s backstory at this stage of the game because now it’s just all about the future and who they are now and who they’re going to be as they move, as they build towards that climax and build towards achieving their objective or their goal.

We now know what we need to know about their backstory at this stage of the game. Or it bleeds into the next event too, in this floater event that we have in there.

Adam: It’s sort of like the way we treat the inciting incident. The next event we’ll talk about, I think it, like the inciting incident, oftentimes is the hook scene or the call to adventure. Oftentimes the fall of the heart wall happens here at the hero’s darkest moment. It’s sort of the end of the scene.

Devin: Yeah.

Adam: And if not, it will happen, they just go, I can’t give, they don’t really do the fall of heart wall here. They just come up with a plan. They don’t give up and they keep going. But the fall of the heart wall happens in the climax. So you can take it and delay it. Like part one, part two. Yeah. But I think it is, it’s here in hero’s darkest moment as this event. The next event is what we call the fall of the heart wall. It’s when the hero basically lets down their guard on whatever the conflict is. And oftentimes in romantic comedies, they may discover this.

Say to their friend, it was a bet. It was, you know, something. And they just turn to their friend and they go, but I really love her. I’ve fallen for her throughout this thing. So they have a discovery and sort of fall of the heart wall moment. But that’s not really discovered or confessed until the climax when they finally, you know, that person’s been blocking their texts and phone calls and they don’t want to talk to them. They finally find some place that they can get their ear. And so this is the real fall of the heart wall in the climax when they confess their love and they have to do it very bravely now.

It’s not just telling their friend, I’m in love with the person. They have to tell the person. And brave vulnerability. What a great phrase.

Devin: They’re okay with being vulnerable at this point because they’ve just knocked down those walls on those things that have been blocking those blocks they’ve had. Yes. And they’re just like, I’m okay to be vulnerable at this point.

Adam: The reason why this event, which we call the fall of the heart wall is sort of a float or two is because of that. It sort of is the thing that is the result of the hero’s darkest moment. Out of the hero’s introspection here, they have a falling of the heart wall. They disassemble something enough to make it. They disassemble something enough to move forward in the journey and to recommit to it, whether it’s the journey to have a relationship with this person or to save this person or revenge flick, have revenge or an object of the quest to find the object or regain the object like in Guardians of the Galaxy.

There’s a recommittal, but that the fall of the heart wall can also, and it does sort of happen this way. There’s a fall of the heart wall here in the midpoint with Guardians where. Peter saves Gamora in space. And then later there’s a, there’s another sort of falling of the heart wall where it’s like he gets up and the best he can do is distract this guy by dancing. It’s a full brave, like, cause he’s got nothing else. He’s beat to heck and back and he knows this guy can just touch him with his, his staff and he just evaporates. It’s, it’s sort of like, this is all I got left is what my mom gave me is this music and I’m gonna sing it to you.

And I’m gonna…

If you set it up properly here, when you hit that note in the climax, you don’t have to do a lot of explaining there. You just hit the same note and it goes straight to the audience’s heart, and they reconnect with that vulnerable place you set up here. So the falling of the heart wall is a little bit of a setup here and you want it to pay off in the climax With the audience throwing their fist in the air and going yay. You know, you want them to have that moment reflected again, but it’s because we see that And here we have a sense of their failure and then their acceptance of themselves. And that’s the sort of falling of the heart wall. We sort of call it event four, but like I’m saying, it’s a floater.

Kind of the end of event three in a lot of ways. But you can extend it and make it a bigger deal, like in a romantic comedy. I think that was well said. I did want to mention the reason we call it this is there’s a book that Devin and I both really love. If you’re writing characters, it’s fascinating to read. It’s called The Emotion Code, and it’s by Dr. Bradley Nelson. There’s a chapter where he talks about the heart wall. Essentially, it’s where you’ve built up sort of a calloused protection over your heart space, or the place where you would feel vulnerable, like Devin’s talking about with vulnerability and brave vulnerability So you build up this wall and it’s made of and you know any different material that you think your hero or yourself might use to protect their heart. You know, made of wood, made of cinder block. But because it’s a subconscious or psychological concept that wall can be hundreds and hundreds of miles thick because the subconscious mind does not know physical space. And so one of the reasons why we like to adopt that, other than the fact it’s a great read for those of you who have not had a chance, The Emotion Code, Dr. Bradley Nelson, good book, it also helps to really visualize what is happening in this moment. In this moment, whatever they’ve built up around themselves, this hero, or their allies, like in Guardians where they’re all very selfish and self-protecting, they’ll fight someone before they become their friend. This disassembles for all of them in this moment. And the fall of a wall like that, subconsciously, you know, psychologically, socially, any sort of label you tack on to it is a great visual. And Devin and I will always try to name events or talk about events because of the visual nature of it.

The Fall of the Heart Wall. If you haven’t read the book, you should go and check it out, The Emotion Code. The next event, event number five in this mix, we can broadly call reassessment. Vogler refers to sort of like a campfire scene. And Devin and I really love the concept of a campfire scene. And so we will always try to put one somewhere in our story. And it doesn’t necessarily mean that you have a campfire, but it is the feeling in the Muppet movie example I gave earlier, it is. And a lot of movies are like that. As it is, but you want to evoke this.

Feeling where there’s not much there’s not many resources. You’re sort of alone and isolated There’s a little bit of warmth, but it’s only, you know, the rest of it is darkness beyond. There’s a tonal quality to that that I really love, even if you never use a campfire or they’re not camping. And you can actually use that for Hero’s Darkest Moment, Fall of the Heart Wall, even this section which is called Reassessment. But this is a fun movie. It’s a fun stage for it, too, because Reassessment is sort of like, okay, so they had some realization in the Fall of the Heart Wall. Darkest Moment, Fall of the Heart Wall, it’s a reinvention of self.

There’s a total realization. And here is where they start to pick up the pace and take charge again. They’re willing to accept the challenge and pick it back up again. And so there’s…

Devin: Sort of reassessing the whole situation. The campfire scene is one of those floater scenes for me too, because this scene could have actually been an aftermath scene too. Like this aftermath could be a campfire scene because… Sure. And this, again, for writers who love dialogue and subtext, campfire scenes are your jam or your bread and butter. To give you a little bit of a food analogy there. And campfire scenes are, in a way, they’re setups and payoffs for the external action scenes. Because in these scenes, we learn about our characters’ inner obstacles. And just like camping, like if you want to use… Analogy of it, these moments give our characters, like Adam said, a moment to reflect in an environment that’s outside of their comfort zone or that known world. And so this new environment and what we just experienced from that midpoint, that antagonistic force that we just experienced, it causes the characters to reflect or decide to…

Confront or address something that’s inside that has perhaps been eating away at them or preventing them, like their heart wall, preventing them from doing or saying something. And so the campfire scene is a perfect environment for our characters to provide that opportunity for the hero or other characters, I guess, to give us a little more insight. Or a glimpse inside them that answers questions that we may have had throughout this journey up until this point. And certainly things they have said along the way or ways they’ve acted or reacted or decisions they’ve made that we were questioning or we’re wondering why they made a decision where that’s coming back.

And so, it’s peeling back the layers of our character so we can better understand how they’ve acted in the past. And so, we will know that what they must overcome, those inner obstacles that they need to overcome themselves to act accordingly in the future to obtain that objective or goal. So, we kind of understand what they need to fix. Or what wall needs to come down. And that’s kind of what these scenes are really good for. Especially this scene and this position in this movement at this stage is where the hero just basically, all right, everybody come in. Let’s huddle up. I got a new, like I’m figuring this out.

Like, I’m sorry about that. That dude you did that. You just witnessed back there. Sorry. I figured my stuff out. Now I’m the hero. I’m the leader now. All right. So, but don’t worry. I got you guys back. I got this thing figured out. That’s kind of where if you’re, if we’re putting it in this, this position in this movement, that’s basically what’s happening.

Adam: Even if we don’t call this particular event, a campfire scene, and we call it reassessment, what he’s saying is that campfire scene, you can extend from aftermath all the way to this point. And it’s sort of something. That’s what, that’s why I think Devin and I like this event so much. The campfire, the stretchability of it, the playfulness of it, what you can do with it.

Devin: It could even bookend the darkest moment too.

Adam: Yeah.

Devin: You start in the campfire. Somebody says something that knocks him down. He leaves. He removes himself, has a dark moment. He comes back. Right. He’s like, all right guys.

Adam: Although we call it a campfire scene, you can extend it into a campfire sequence. And it covers all these events within this. But the whole point of taking away with that is, it’s a great visual campfire. And it’s also the intimacy of it. It’s more of a type of scene.

Devin: It’s kind of like the rules and tools and watering hole and campfire.

Adam: Yeah. Pressure cooker.

Devin: They’re kind of a type of scene where you’re like, I need to learn more about the hero’s inner demons or inner conflict or inner, inner obstacle per I’ll throw a campfire scene in here. Cause now he can, I put them in an environment with the other allies. If it’s a team type of, That now he can open up a little bit, or as much as I need him to, to provide, to relay relevant information that needs to be relevant at this stage of the game for both the readers and the story and the allies.

Adam: Yeah.

Devin: So, it’s a good type of scene.

Adam: The only other thing I would say about this event here, reassessment. Is, like Devin’s saying, you’re reassessing where you’re at, what needs to be accomplished, and where your team members are at, your allies are at. So, it’s a different powwow, which is great for a campfire. Another thing that can happen right around here is, if you haven’t used a second herald in, like, the beginning of Movement 3, it’s a great herald. Someone comes in with some new information, where they’re like, you know, the antagonist is planning on taking that gold from that stagecoach and robbing the bank, or whatever the heck is. New information comes to the hero, and now they’re like, we have to stop, we have to head them off, and they recommit to it via new information.

So, in this stage, reassessment is a really, as far as using tools of character archetypes, using a herald here is a really smart move. And I wouldn’t suggest doing it all the time. I like a lot of it being discovery. But in order to refocus the hero, sometimes you need to… Have the outside world come back in. And it makes the reassessment or what’s coming next… The reassessment is sort of like making the plan up. And some movies will forego the making of the plan where someone will just go… I have an idea and you don’t see, they don’t tell you what the idea is. You just know there’s a plan to come and you get to follow what the progression of the plan is.

So this was what reassessment is. It’s sort of like the coming up of the plan of the, the plan next. And like I say, guardians of the galaxy is really great for this too. They come up with a new plan on how they’re going to do this thing. And, and you sort of maybe even get to see pieces, of how it’s starting to come together between this and the last event of this movement, which is re-choosing the quest. And you sort of have a reinvigorated hero where as Devin would say from action to, or from reaction in the first half of this movie, the second half, they, there’s a chosen action.

I also like to say, in the beginning, you’re just, it’s motivated action, meaning there’s something that’s telling them to do this thing, or they think they have to do it. And, or they think they have to do it a certain way. And so they’re, they’re doing it, but it’s not, it’s not coming from them. And the second half is inspired action. Meaning,

So the action in the beginning is sort of half-hearted or reactive, and the second half is they have a discovery of worth, true worth, self-value, the worth of their allies to them. Like I say, moving with purpose.

Devin: This is a popular montage. Yeah, yeah. Movies usually throw a montage in here. They’re like, the new excitement or the new vigor, the new, you know, they’re like, all right, well, you know, we’ve seen the, we’re out of the darkness now, and now it’s, they’ll throw a montage in here of them like preparing now with the new plan or whatever.

Adam: Because it’s easy. Yeah. A lot of it is because in this point, because it’s recovery and we’ve slowed down the pacing purposefully, they’ve got to somehow, it’s like the, you know, Flintstones running in their car. It’s like, and then the car takes off. You got to speed up a little bit of the pacing of the movie in some way. And so a montage is a really easy way to like throw out a whole bunch of information that they don’t feel like telling you in a scene and set you up for what will be movement five, the next movement, the build to the climax. They’re trying to speed up the pace with, that’s why you see them often in movies at this stage is they’re trying to get the pace back up.

It all builds. Yeah. It all builds from that place where they’re recovering from the crisis to a recommittal and a re-choosing to the quest that they’ve originally set out on with a better understanding of themselves, their wants and needs, and then the people in the world around them. So it’s a, this movement is great for character transformation and understanding as Devin was saying at the beginning. And the crossing of this threshold, the fourth threshold is sort of what mirrors movement one in. They’ve chosen the quest and they’re reentering the journey. They’re not at the side of the road, sitting around by a campfire, licking their wounds.

It’s time. And in a lot of action movies and stuff like that, they don’t even have enough time to fully lick their wounds and heal themselves up. They have to go in with cut up feet from when they ran across the glass. If you’re John McClane, there’s no heal time. There’s just a breather where he pulls glass out of his feet in the sink. He’s talking to Powell, his sidekick outside. Man. And this is when he, oddly enough, it’s not where John McClane confesses a lot here, but they give that to officer Powell. He says, what’s a guy like you doing behind a desk? And he’s, he’s trying to be playful because he’s having a really dark moment himself.

He just ran across glass, barely survived. He’s pulling it out piece by piece. It’s miserable. It’s hero’s darkest moment. And he says, you know what? They put you behind a desk, just teasing him. And he goes, I shot a kid. I shot a kid. And it becomes very heavy suddenly because Powell’s honest with him. And there’s this connection point where there’s a quieting. And although it’s not a true campfire scene, that’s what that scene is. It’s one of the few moments in that movie where John McClane is actually sitting anywhere. And he, you know, except for the beginning. And he’s sitting there and recovering and pulling out the glass in his feet so he can continue.

So the hero may not even be ready to cross this threshold and get back into the fray. And build to the climax. But at that point, it’s probably a time sensitive. Like a ticking time bomb sort of scenario where they’re pressured by time to keep going or move forward no matter what. There are many reasons why they would re-choose. Discovery and realization being the primary and the center. But I don’t know if there’s anything you want to say specifically about the re-choosal concept.

Devin: It’s pretty self-explanatory. Those thresholds are fairly quick, you know, because they’re kind of moving into the other events.

Adam: Yeah. They’re sort of like cappers too. Just to go back through these events. Event 1, escape. Event 2, aftermath. Event 3, hero’s darkest moment or all seems lost. Event 4, fall of the heart wall. Once again, this is a floater. You can sort of move it into hero’s darkest moment or move it later. But it’s important. Event 5, reassessment. Or we will oftentimes call any of these events 2 through 5 as campfire. And of course, at the end of this, the hero has re-chosen the quest. And is crossing the 4th threshold into movement 5. So this one is from crisis to recovery. Movement 5 will be sort of from recovery to climax.

6 will be from climax to resolution and closure. Tune in next week, when we discuss movement 5 and break it down event by event. See you then. Please subscribe and rate us on iTunes. Follow us on social media. Share with your friends and send us your questions and comments. For additional resources and links to films, series, and books we talk about here, visit our website. While you’re there, sign up for our newsletter for updates on story building tools and special offers. At StoryOsophy.com

Where this episode sits in the Story BlueprintThis episode gives an overview of movement 4. Pick any event on the curve to hear its episode.