Show notes
Now or never is the third part of the climax and the first event of Movement 6, the final movement of the Story Blueprint. It’s do or die: if your hero doesn’t act now, they’ll never reach their objective. Adam and Devin preview the rest of Movement 6, explain why the now or never is often a sleight of hand that catches the antagonist off guard, and look at the many ways an antagonist can be defeated without being killed.
In this episode
- Movement 6 at a glance. From climax to resolution: now or never, outcome (objective attained), the road back, the new status quo, resolution (closure and tying up loose ends), and the final image and final words. Resolution doesn’t have to be boring.
- Save a killer payoff. At least one big payoff belongs here: Tony Stark’s “I am Iron Man,” Daniel’s crane kick.
- Sleight of hand. The antagonist thinks they have the upper hand, but the hero has an advantage they never revealed. The antagonist planned against the hero they knew in Movement 3, not the one who changed in Movement 4.
- Use the tool, or reverse it. In Top Gun, Maverick hits the brakes, a move set up early in the film. In Days of Thunder, Cole Trickle always passes high, so his rival blocks high, and Cole goes low.
- Win, lose or bittersweet. If the antagonist wins, it’s a tragedy; if the hero wins, a comedy. In Captain America: Civil War, the villain is captured but has already turned the heroes against each other.
- Defeat without killing. Remove the antagonist’s power, or change them. In the Rankin/Bass Santa Claus Is Comin’ to Town, a gift transforms Winter Warlock. A kick to the face changes how Johnny sees Daniel in The Karate Kid.
- Don’t spell out the plan. In Jumanji, Martha tells Spencer only to get to the statue, and the audience rides along to figure it out.
- Plug the hole with a joke. Devin’s fix for Jumanji’s one logic gap: have Fridge respawn still holding the cake.
- Tangents. Unsinkable Sam, the cat who survived three sinkings in World War II; Mysteries at the Museum; foam statues on movie sets; and Baz Luhrmann’s planning on The Great Gatsby.
Examples discussed
- Jumanji: Welcome to the Jungle: Martha sends Spencer up on a motorcycle, steps into Van Pelt’s snakes with the jewel and tells him, in effect, she doesn’t think it’s over. Bitten, she respawns from the sky, Spencer catches the jewel on his grappling hook and places it in the jaguar, and after a pause, Bethany remembers they have to call out its name.
- Edward Scissorhands: after Jim breaks free, Edward, in a focused rage, stabs him and sends him out the attic window. The blades have been set up as lethal the whole film, yet the moment still shocks, and some viewers may not forgive it.
- Also: Avengers: Endgame, The Karate Kid, No Country for Old Men, Beauty and the Beast, The Maltese Falcon and The Dark Crystal.
Writing along with the season? Write three pages for your now or never, or take 15 minutes to free-write a sleight of hand your hero could play on the antagonist.
Read the full transcript
Transcribed automatically, so expect the odd misheard word. Sponsor messages are left out.
Adam: In this episode, we discuss the first story event of Movement 6, Climax Part 3, Now or Never. What final do-or-die moment brings your climax to a conclusion? Does your hero have an ace up their sleeve or is it the antagonist? Next on StoryOsophy. Hello, welcome to StoryOsophy. This is Adam Jones.
Devin: And Devin Halden. So tell me about this cat. I wish I had the article on me, but so this cat, and I believe it’s World War II, it was initially on one boat for some country. For some reason, I think it’s like Germany or something. And it got torpedoed and like everybody died on the boat or whatever, except for when this other ship was coming through like the wreckage, they saw this cat and they were like, oh my God, we’re going to die. We’re going to die.
And then they saw this cat, like just clinging to a board. So they picked up the cat and they brought it on their boat. And then like weeks or months later or days later, that boat got torpedoed and the cat survived that sinking. And so it was brought onto another boat. I think it might’ve been an American boat or something. But at some point they finally, and it like went through, went through like battles and didn’t die. It didn’t just survive a sinking ship. I mean, I mean, he survived, like, life-threatening, like, really violent battles, and…
Adam: But also changed sides, too. But a cat on the water is also weird, because cats really… Most cats, some do, but most cats really don’t like water at all. Yeah, no kidding. But why would you be a cat and hang out on a boat?
Devin: He must really love action. All those boats had him just for mice. It was like, that’s how they got rid of mice and rats. Like, it’s the same reason, like, people have them in barns. Like, barn cats are like… Oh, yeah, yeah, yeah, okay. Just kind of rodents. I think there was always… They always had cats on them. It was Unsinkable Sam, and it was World War II. It was during World War II. And he survived the sinking of three ships in total. Wow. Sam? You said Unsinkable Sam? Yeah, Unsinkable Sam. Unsinkable Sam. And then he actually ended up getting, like, being discharged or given, like, a Medal of Honor or something like that.
Adam: But, yeah, so it was… The Medal of Honor I could see, but being discharged. You’ve been on three boats, and they all sank. Beat it. Beat it.
Devin: Yeah, yeah. And then he, like, retired. He, like, I think one of the, someone from one of the boats finally, like, retired him. And it was. That’s funny. It was just funny. And then, like, I’ve read, like, one of my favorite shows on TV is Mysteries at the Museum. It’s just brilliant. And they, Dan Wildman, Wildman is actually a perfect name for this guy. But, and then he just finds little pieces. There’s, you, you go to a museum and he finds, like, these pieces of history that probably you’d overlook if you were at the museum. Like, you’re going to go see the dinosaurs and go see these things that are a little bit more well-known.
And, but he takes, like, a, a nail, like, this old rusty nail that’s just sitting there and that you’d probably just pass over if you’re in this museum. But he does the entire backstory about what. Where this nail came from and how it came to be. Oh, it’s such a good show. And I, I think they profiled Unsinkable Sam or Oscar, whatever. Oscar was, like, one of his names too. And one of those versions on, or one of the episodes, but it’s an awesome show. And it’s great for imagination. And here’s the thing. The production value of this show of Mysteries at the Museum is awesome because he starts off.
By introducing the specimen or the asset, whatever it is, whatever you call those. The artifact. Yeah, the artifact. Exactly. And so he, he introduces it, but then there is, like, a really well-produced reenactment of the history of it. So it’s not just, like, documentary style. There’s, they actually do this. And I’m not a big fan of, like, reenactment stuff, but they do a really good job. And even go, like, the time period, like, the set design and the costume design. And, and nobody’s really, very rarely do they actually have dialogue. So it’s usually just a narrator’s voice over the action, the reenactment action. But it works great. And it’s crazy intriguing.
And there’s actually, we came up with a drinking game, some friends of mine, because the host, Dan Wildman, he’ll oftentimes, when it transfers from him introducing the artifact to the reenactment, sometimes he’ll have his mouth wide open. Sometimes I’m supposed. It’s closed. So we do a drinking game. We did it over the phone. It’s like, oh, drink, mouth’s open.
Adam: Dan, like I said, Dan Brown’s masterclass, he calls the object of the quest, the artifact, the main, like, if you discover something, Maltese Falcon would be the artifact. The elixir. Yeah. It’s, it’s the treasure. It’s the. I just watched that movie the other night, by the way. The Maltese Falcon. I’ve never seen it. Oh, you haven’t? Good Bogart. There’s a handful of classics I haven’t seen. You know, it’s, I mean, you got to go through a heck of a list to get them all. You know what I mean? And everybody’s list is always different.
Devin: A safe bet for good films is going to be Hitchcock from this, from like that similar era. And then any like Bogart film. And I’m, I’m very mainstream. Like if you’re, if you think of Hollywood back then, it’s like, yeah, that’s the people.
Adam: Or Chaplin too. Chaplin is, is a good. Chaplin’s awesome. Even if they’re older films, you can see the building blocks of cinema. Yeah. They’re the first people trying to really do narratives with cinematography. Mm-hmm. And it’s evolved so much since then. I was just thinking about it. I started watching the, the first episode of The Dark Crystal on Netflix. I was going to do that, but I didn’t. I barely got into it. Can’t get through it? No. No, no. I barely got into it. Just, I just had other stuff going on. My one observation was. Some of the camera moves that they can do now and like a three-dimensional movement around a space with puppetry.
Devin: Yeah.
Adam: Is what makes it kind of fresh and new because, you know, Jim Henson didn’t have the technology to do like some, you know, crane shot that’s mechanized and pre-programmed. Right. To run the camera around a room at a certain degree and then drop the, he, they were all mechanic, you know, jib arms and stuff like that. It was old school stuff. So to see that is kind of fascinating. Where you can see the world and then we sort of zoom in on bits and pieces and it’s puppetry and then you’re back out from the puppetry and it’s, and most of it is practical world. It’s not, it’s not all CGI.
They only use that to glue things together a little bit, but.
I read something about Jumanji. They have the little notes on the side on Amazon. Yeah. I saw that they were talking about how they built the Jaguar statue. And I was, when I used to be in the scenic department, they built a lot of statues like that. They would take blue foam. Carve it. Glue it together and build the basic structure. Carve down that blue foam and then you put on, it’s a sort of a special chemical combo, but you paint it on. It coats the foam, but it also hardens and becomes this really specific material, but it adheres to the foam. And then you sort of design the piece after that, but it’s all made out of foam.
And I was like, yeah, I was wondering if, I was wondering how they were doing those structures. If they were really big, if they were… There was some stuff like Stepford Wives and other movies I worked on where there were some enormous structures. And of course, in those days, I was in charge of cleaning up all the foam. So it was a nightmare. But it’s fascinating to see the things that look like stone in a movie or like some heavy piece that someone will lift. It weighs nothing. Yeah. It’s crazy. It’s amazing.
Devin: That’s why some people don’t want to see behind the scenes stuff. Like it’s one of the most impressive behind the scenes videos I’ve seen is the Great Gatsby.
Baz Luhrmann’s Great Gatsby. And the amount of green and blue screen that they used is so impressive. But intelligently and strategically. Oh yeah, just brilliant. Yeah, yeah, yeah. And you only, it’s so good. It’s such a good, that’s such a good movie. But the forethought of camera angles and what you had to cover up and what you didn’t have to cover up. And what you had to use for green when you had to use blue. It’s just like, holy crap. That was such a, and all of Baz’s, like Moulin Rouge, Gatsby, all of his productions are so well thought out. And his wife, I think, is the production designer, but a set designer.
But they, if you, if you’ve ever seen any type of backstory or behind the scenes of his process, I mean, it is years, like four or five years that he’ll work on, on, on his movies. And so it’s, and it just, the end quality or the end product is so, so good.
Adam: And he’s very stylistic. Like he’s very stylistic. Yeah. So he needs a lot of prep time. And music is such a big part of his storytelling too. It’s very immersive.
Devin: Mm-hmm.
Adam: This week, we’re talking about Climax Part 3, Now or Never. This is the first event in Movement 6, your final movement in the Story Blueprint. Home stretch, light at the end of the tunnel. Movement 6 is the last movement of your story. Movement 6 is all about the end of your climax, this breakthrough moment, crossing that threshold of final change for your hero and performing a task, we call it now or never. You could also think of it as do or die. Like if you don’t do this thing, you might as well die. Or it happens with mentors and tales a lot. You might as well die.
Let me rephrase that. But for heightening stakes, do or die makes sense.
Devin: And do or, yeah, I mean, metaphorically, it just means you will never obtain your objective if you do not do this. Yeah.
Adam: And just to recap real quick where we’re coming from, Movements.
Devin: A little less dark. Movement.
Adam: Movement one is the comfort zone to out of comfort zone. And that’s act one, which is the known world. We cross the threshold and move into act two. And act two is the unknown world, basically the world of the character’s or hero’s story journey. And that’s comprised of three movements. Movement two, from out of the comfort zone, where we left in movement one, to into the danger zone. Movement three is from the danger zone to the crisis. Movement four is from the crisis to recovery. And then we move into act three. We cross that threshold into the changed world. And this is the act in which the world actually changes.
So at the end of these two movements, it will be the changed world. And movement five is basically from… Recovery to Climax. Movement six is from Climax to Resolution. We like to use some of these broader terms in storytelling just to help folks get their bearing. But we’re encouraging you to look at story by disassembling it into pieces and building it in ways that help you and your story and maybe telling a different story. But if we think of movement five as the build to the climax, movement six is the finishing of the climax. And all of the pieces of the story that we still need to finish up. And a lot of people think of resolution as boring, the majority of the chunk of this movement, but it’s not.
No way. And it shouldn’t be. And if it is, you’ve got some retooling to do because it can be exciting. It should be exciting. It should be. Nothing should be boring. Absolutely.
Devin: But I do agree with you. I know what you’re saying because some people kind of phone it in here.
Adam: So Climax, part three, now or never. Is what starts movement six here for us. And I’m just going to run through the events of movement six so we know where we’re headed when we talk about this. So Climax, part three, now or never, starts our movement six, followed by outcome, objective attained. This is the payoff moment for whatever you’ve set up in movement one, whether they succeed or fail. The next event, we’ll call it different things, but the road back is sort of what you want to think of. The return. The journey home. A lot of times, although the objective has been attained, you do have discoveries and reveals that happen after the fact.
If you think of stuff in your life, this is what resolution is like. An event happens to you and you don’t realize all of it until a few days later. That’s what resolution is. There’s clarity that comes not in the moment of the ordeal, but after. And so. The return home, you have time for reflection and you figure stuff out. And a new status quo, the changed world emerges. So the fourth event in movement six is new status quo. And all that is doing is sort of showing you the reflection of movement one and the known world in this ending, concluding movement to compare it. To contrast.
To contrast it. So you can see the difference. In Jumanji, which we’ll get to later, it becomes obvious. The freak house is not dilapidated. There’s a new status quo once they return. It’s now lively and beautiful. So it’s the known world or even the unknown world changed. And so there’s a lot of discovery and reveal there. The next event in movement six is, we just call it resolution. Closure. And tying up loose ends. I think that might be. My favorite for this event, because if you think of all these threads you’ve woven or laid out, they need to be tied up. You need to tie like a little knot in the end, a little punctuation that lets your audience know, by the way, this is, this is done.
And because leaving them open-ended is a choice, like no country for old men. You can do it, but it has to be a choice. Don’t do it accidentally.
Devin: Everything after the climax, all that until the final image is I kind of have this tie up loose. Ends is over all of that because you can even wait until the very end to do like a final payoff, a final, you tie up the final loose end right before the credits and things like that. So I kind of look at this right after the climax is almost entire. The rest of this movement is basically tying up loose ends. And like you’re saying is like, all right. Yeah. Do I, have I paid off all my setups? And if you haven’t, you don’t necessarily have to shove them all here, but you have to just.
Even as a writer, this is the moment you’re going back and tying up your loose ends. Accountability for them.
Adam: Yeah. It’s almost like the way we deal with a movement to sort of calling that the first day of school, the whole thing, you know, because that’s what it’s about. Right. Exactly. It’s about learning and understanding the world. This is, you’re right. Tying up loose ends is pretty much all of movement six. Clean all your locker. It is sort of like that. It’s like returning your books. Sign in the yearbooks. Yeah. Exactly. When you’re cleaning out your locker, you’re, you’re reviewing the journey of the year you’ve had. There’s stuff in there that you forgot you put in the locker and you find it and you’re like, wow.
Like a sandwich. Yeah. Sandwich. That’s a true story. Sandwich. Oh. Yeah.
Devin: I couldn’t figure out what that smell was all year until I found the bologna sandwich.
Adam: Oh, bologna! Actually, it was fairly unrecognizable at that point. The final event in Movement 6 is just simply final image, final words. And you always want to think about this because that’s going to echo in your audience’s mind as they leave the theater or they close the book. What was I left with? And there are some people that’ll turn to the end of the book and read the final sentence or paragraph and then start reading the book. And I’m like, are you kidding me? But final image, final words. It sounds really simple and short, but it’s really important to consider for the whole, the entirety of your story to make it feel tight.
It’s almost like the image and the words should be symbolic of what the story has been experientially and thematically. And like we were talking about with episodes and things like that. Where it’s series. It’s series oriented. This final image, final word may need to be something that ends an episode, but sets up an upcoming episode, the next episode. So there are different variations that we will talk about when it comes to final image, final words. It’s a big one. There’s a big threshold from breakthrough to now or never. This is the big threshold.
Devin: And you touched on it a long time ago when you were actually first introducing this event in this episode. A long time ago.
Adam: A long time ago in an ancient land.
Devin: Yeah. In most cases, but I guess not all, I suppose, our heroes completed their arc at this point. But that doesn’t necessarily mean we need to show our audience they have completed their arc. So our hero themselves, they know that within themselves something has fully changed. They are a different person. And they can’t wait to show their new self off. But we can wait to pay that off. You can pay it off here, I suppose. But you can also wait to pay that off at any point during this final movement depending on how it lends to your story and how you want to do that. I’ve seen it where the final image is where we really realize that our hero is now the true Little H from Little H to Big H.
So it’s up to you. So it’s up to you how you want to do that. But for your hero themselves, they know that they’ve pretty much completed their arc by this stage of the game. And everything that we’ve put our hero through during this quest has led to this moment. So that’s very important. Don’t get lazy. Don’t get lazy. Like we just said, don’t phone it in because you finally have defeated the antagonist. During this event, that’s what’s happening. But just don’t get lazy. And you should at least have one killer payoff saved for this moment. At least one.
Adam: Yes. This is the big one. This is the big punctuated moment. This is the Avengers endgame I am Iron Man moment. You want it to be emotional. You want it to be something that Edward Scissorhands, it is. Jumanji, it is in its own way. It’s not nearly as like surprisingly emotional. You want this moment for the audience to go, yeah, and cheer for your hero because you’re like, that’s it. You found yourself. You made the right choice. You got it. Like you want them to be as excited about this final. This is the crane kick in Karate Kid. Perfect analogy. It is the crane kick in Karate Kid.
It’s been sitting there brewing in his training. He’s talking about balance. Awesome payoff. Perfect payoff. Perfect payoff. Also great music. Great score to that moment. So the thing with Now or Never, a lot of times what happens with this event is it’s slight of hand by the hero. And Jumanji does it. So does Endgame, Avengers Endgame. So a bunch of movies will use it this way. The antagonist thinks they have the upper hand. When we talk about Jumanji, we’ll get more specific. But they think they have the upper hand. John Doe has the upper hand. This ain’t even my desk. The antagonist thinks they have the upper hand.
And the hero looks as if they may be in trouble. But it’s a ruse. The hero has an advantage they haven’t let the antagonist know about until this Now or Never do or die moment. Right. And both those movies, Jumanji and Infinity Wars, sort of plays on that reversal. It’s a great reversal. It’s a reveal and a reversal. And that’s usually when… And Edward does… Once again, Edward does a subversive version of that. Yeah. But we could tell Jim didn’t expect what was going to happen by the look on his face.
Devin: Top Gun and Days of Thunder both do it because… And you got to talk about both of them because they’re basically the same movie. But like Top Gun is at the very end. The payoff is… The I’m gonna hit the brakes he’ll fly right by well he does it in the beginning when they’re just at Top Gun school but then he’s when they’re actually in the common there in combat at the very end he He says he’s like I’m gonna hit the brakes he’ll fly I don’t think he says it verbatim again, and then Is it Hollywood in the back? You’re gonna do what? He’s like I’m bringing him in closer. He says and then in days of thunder that very same The the race car version of Top Gun is Is Cole trickle always goes high to pass the cars throughout the entire movie and so when he’s got Whatever the the antagonist lined up the antagonist says in the radio. He’s like Cole always goes high I got him and so he pretends he’s gonna go high and then he goes low So there’s the payoff he said so they set up that pay both both of those versions They set up that payoff at some point either multiple times during the story or it’s
Adam: Right, right. It’s kind of interesting to, like, go, look, you can do both those things, and they’re really effective. You need to have forgotten about the brakes in Top Gun to make that work. And then in Days of Thunder, you need to believe that he only goes high. High. That he only goes high. And then you’ve got this reversal payoff. But that’s, you painted two kind of slightly different set of payoffs, which is kind of cool.
Devin: And that’s always a good show of arc to character arc or character change is they’ve learned from their mistakes. So they’ve learned, they’ve, whatever they’ve learned in movement four and five has led to their decision at this moment too. Well, I mean, obviously everything that’s happened to them throughout the entire quest, but specifically during those dark moments in movement four and then them becoming during their, their final moments of change have led to this, whatever the decisions they’re making here. But again, basically, bottom line, have a good payoff here and also trick the attack. And the antagonists should think they have the upper hand, or they know what our hero is going to do, because they don’t realize that they are a changed… They’ve completed an arc.
Adam: They’ve made assumptions. Yeah. They’ve calculated to defeat the hero based on Movement 3 information. Exactly. And Movement 4 has changed the hero, so the hero is a different source of antagonism for the antagonist.
[Sponsor message]
Devin: Come out victorious or decide that your story’s message and perhaps your plans for a series or the option for one is better served by the antagonist winning just be sure to make the reasoning of that decision play out without pulling any punches because this is one of your last chances to yank at the heart strings and the emotion of your audience and so make sure the ending is entertaining, emotional, You know, so they leave, they shut the book or they leave that theater. No matter victory or defeat, there is a reason behind they understand the reason and they get it and they’re satisfied with the decision that you made. Or I mean, again, there’s also many examples of writers and directors wanting you frustrated when you leave, you know, so that this kind of they play with the norms of storytelling in a way where like, well, you think you’re going to be Edward Scissorhands is a good example, I think, where you think it’s going to be a happy ending.
Yeah, you think every you think Edward Scissorhands is going to be accepted and live a mind. He’s going to get his hands, you know, at some point, I think, I think everybody thinks he’s going to get his hands maybe at some point. But no, he’s just going to kill the antagonist. He’s going to live forever up in his mansion.
Adam: Dude, that’s a wild story to begin with. And we’ve talked about a lot is it changes dramatic tone. So you think it’s gonna be a comedy, and it’s a tragedy. It that rarely ever happens in a movie, right? Usually, you know, it’s a tragedy. Or, you know, it’s a comedy, but that hardly ever happens. And then, well, let’s make it a romantic tragedy. Their recipe is so wildly inventive, and creating a world of mythology that only we know. It’s not familiar to you. It’s not vampires and werewolves and Frankenstein. It’s not any of that stuff. It’s a dude who has scissorhands. Good luck with the mythology because you don’t know anything. That’s why, like you’re saying, we go in, we don’t even know if he’s going to get hands.
We don’t know if he’s going to fit in. We don’t know anything about this because it’s so foreign to us. We actually have a better chance of feeling the, quote, monster movie aspect than we do with a Frankenstein remake or a Dracula or werewolf because that’s part of our culture now. This guy is foreign. The dude with scissorhands is foreign. So we sort of step into the arena like the neighbors. How do we accept this guy? Is he okay? Is he safe? Right. It’s a wild movie. Even having watched it a million times like we have for this season, just to lay out events, I’m still amazed by it.
Yeah. It blows my mind. It’s such a brilliant piece. It is really brilliant. This event in particular is where the action or the pursuit of the goal, the objective, this is where it finally ends. The conflict ends. There may be some residual stuff, but either the hero or the antagonist will win. Sometimes it can be both in a bittersweet kind of poetic way. The hero takes a loss but defeats the antagonist. The antagonist has some sort of… Or changes. It’s an Avengers movie where the guy tries to get the superheroes to fight with each other because they ended up killing his family in Age of Ultron. That’s what it is. But I can’t remember. Civil War? Is it Civil War?
Yeah. And the villain is just a normal person who’s managed to… Get them warring at each other. And that was the goal. So they capture him. That was the whole point was he wanted them to fight each other. He was the antagonist and then it turned them into antagonists. But the whole point was he was captured, so they got him, but his goal was executed. And so it was a bittersweet thing. Like he already did the damage even though they caught him, you know? So you can do movies like that, but most of the time it’s either one of them winning. And if you… Have your antagonist win, it’s a tragedy. And if you have your hero win, it’s a comedy. Generally, that’s the definition.
Devin: A lot of children’s shows will have the antagonist ends up seeing the light or they end up changing. Like they’re… I don’t know why I’m bringing this up. They’ve been under a spell. Yeah. There’s like a series of, not claymations, but stop motion. And I think Rankin/Bass probably produced most of them. Yeah. I don’t know.
But there’s Rudolph, Santa Claus is coming to town, and Santa Claus is coming to town as one of those where St. Nick or whatever is battling with… First, he’s battling with like not Jack Frost. Maybe it’s Jack Frost. Jack Frost. But then he ends up giving him a present, and he melts. But then… Oh, dude. Yeah. Okay. He ends up same thing where the the antagonist is stopping him from being from giving the children presents but when he sees the joy or he feels the joy himself from getting a present he changes you know and and i actually i don’t know if that’s the actual i’m using it as an example but i’m not sure
Adam: No, that’s a really good one. Isn’t that the one, I think I saw this like last Christmas, and I’d never really seen it, maybe once in my childhood. It’s a young Santa Claus, right? Like a redheaded… Mickey Rooney. Yeah, Mickey Rooney is his voice. Yes. I was thinking about, it’s great that you brought this up, because I was thinking about how do you defeat an antagonist without, quote, killing them? Yeah. And really the concept there is you’ve killed the monster, but the monster is not the entirety of the person. It’s just an aspect of the person. And if you really want to sort of approach a villain in a way to defeat a villain without just thinking it has to be life or death, that’s a good way, is disassembling the thing that makes them antagonistic. It’s a simplified version of what you stop motion Christmas thing. And it’s like more of a fable and lesson version of that. And the hero and the antagonist have a connection. They have communication.
That’s a lot of times why in third acts, you’ll have a villain speech or a hero speech. To the villain. One of the two. Yep. They explain themselves because they want to be understood and heard. I mean, Van Pelt, we’ll move into examples, but Van Pelt does not have a reason. He’s just like, I love the jewel. I’m possessed. I’m like Gollum. Right. And you’re my enemy. So it’s just straight video game villainy. So let’s do examples. Let’s do it. Jumanji. Now or never. A showdown and breakthrough is them meeting Van Pelt and the elephant coming in, fridge coming in with the elephant. They’re a little bit of like, oh my gosh, is Bethany going to be okay? We’re going to negotiate to the best of our ability. Take me. The rock’s like, I can’t give you the jewel because I don’t have it.
Fridge shows up, saves the day. They stomp Van Pelt and now we’ve got yet another plan. So a lot of times in the climax, you might get plan after plan after plan, even though putting the plan into action in the beginning of movement five. Gets the ball rolling. Yeah, it evolves. The hero I don’t know. Must evolve and choose more frequently. So in previous movements at a threshold, they’ve made a choice and they’ve gone a different path in this, in the climax movement five and, and into six, you really want their decision-making to be like, boom, boom, boom, boom. One right after another. And, and that’s what makes it interesting. So having a new plan fridge, the first plan doesn’t work. Devin’s favorite squirrel scares Spencer fridge comes up with a fridge.
Comes up with another, plan, which sort of works, but there’s complications still they have to overcome.
Devin: I want to meet that squirrel. And a lot of times it’s payoff, payoff, payoff. Like that’s juicy. For sure. I like that. Paying off one thing after another. And Jumanji contrasts with Edward Scissorhands in what you need to do to defeat the antagonist. You don’t always have to kill the antagonist. Edward has to kill the antagonist. No. In Jumanji, it’s just ripping him of the power. And so a lot of times that’s what it is.
Adam: It’s removing the power from the antagonist is a great way to look at it. Exactly. No matter who the antagonist is, you’re removing their power over people or you somehow. Yeah. And that variation. It’s like the Tesseract.
Devin: Yeah. Or it’s like Karate Kid. The kick to Johnny’s face with the crane kick to Johnny’s face, it removed a bit of power that he had over Daniel. You know, so it doesn’t have to be so in your face. It can be abstract.
Adam: Or like you were saying, the thought of power. Yeah, the thought. Exactly. The antagonist thinks they have power. Like I was saying, I think the advantage that the hero has over the antagonist is movement four. Because movement three is where the antagonist lasts really newly. You’re right. Right. Oh, this is who they are. I got this figured out. We’re going to amp it up here, here, and here. And we’re going to crush them next time. And the hero has discovered their own power and already knows the antagonist. And then they have the upper hand for movements five and six. That’s what we keep saying. Although movement four seems to be overlooked sometimes or shortened in movies, there’s a lot of really great substance and writing moments in there.
Real important stuff in there. But perfect for setups and payoffs. You may not know how the hero evolved there, but you’ll know right here in this event.
Devin: Exactly. Right. It all depends on what you want the audience to know and when you want them to know it. A lot of times, even that darkest moment, we don’t see it. Yeah, exactly. You don’t necessarily have to show it on screen. You can actually just know that they’re dealing with something. And then once we get here, we see that they’ve dealt with it.
Adam: You just need to know they’re contemplating whatever was sort of shown there in that darkest moment. It’s like they’ve been thinking about it. They’ve been figuring it out. But this, the now or never is when Martha says, tell Spencer, get to the statue. Yeah. Yep. For Jumanji. She tells him, he hops on a motorcycle, takes off, and she’s already maybe determined that she’s going to use her knowledge and experience to make this happen, but she doesn’t tell anybody. So we get that surprise in a little bit with her one-liner. And this is also good one-liner territory. This is good for those punchlines.
Devin: Which is also a bit of a payoff, because it usually harkens back to something that was alluded to or…
Adam: So she gets the, she jumps in the middle of the snakes, snakes being her weakness, if we remember that bit, and grabs a jewel. And Van Pelt, who controls the snakes, just walks through them and walks up to her and goes basically, hey, it’s over. It’s all done. He’s shaking Bethany and the Jonas, and he steps up into the snakes and says to her, it’s all over. And then he hears the motorcycle and she’s like, I don’t think so. And he understands. And he understands there’s another plan that’s been going on under his nose, right? I’m paraphrasing the whole movie. And then she was like, and then he was like, and then they threw the jewel.
The big payoff there is she’s using two bits of her experience and her knowledge. Her weakness for snakes and her respawning to deliver the jewel to Spencer. So she has a one-liner. She’s like, snakes are my, or venom is my weakness, right? So she makes the snakes bite her and then Van Pelt goes, now I understand what the plan is. And when she drops from the sky, Spencer swings on his grappling hook, grabs the jewel, places it in the Jaguar. And we have a really interesting moment in all the action. We just pause because nothing happens, nothing changes. And then all of a sudden Bethany is like, call out its name.
There’s another part of the riddle that we, you know, we may or may not have forgotten. And they all call it out. And then now or never. Now or Never, Moment Ends.
Devin: And this is a good example of giving the audience enough but show don’t tell type of thing because part of me when I was watching this, I was like, alright, if this chick just told me to get on my dirt bike and just head to the top of the mountain, I wouldn’t really know what she meant by that. Why? What are you going to do? But it’s way better than her saying, alright, get on your motorcycle, go to the top. I’m going to jump up here by these snakes. I’m going to get killed by these snakes. I’m going to manifest out of the sky. And then I’m going to, so it’s like, you don’t, you don’t want to tell them that. So you kind of give them a pass on being like, alright, he figured it out on the way up. He’s like, this, he, Spence is a smart guy. So then he took the grappling hook. He’s like, I get what she’s doing. And so, but it’s also, we don’t really understand from an audience standpoint exactly what the plan is.
And then just watching it play out and see if it plays out. So they’re giving us, they’ve decided this is what we’re going to give you. We’re going to give you a little bit, but you’re kind of going to be on the back of the bike with the rock or Spencer. And you guys are all going to figure it out together as she falls from the sky and figure, you know, so that that’s just an example of that writing decision is what to give the audience. And at that moment, he’s going to be, she’s going to tell him the plan and he’s going to, and Spencer’s going to be like, so what are you going to do?
Adam: Wait a minute. How do you know that you will respond with the jewel and not leave it where you last had it? And she’s going to be like, Spencer, I don’t know. We’ve never, we’ve never experienced that. I guess it’s a guess. I guess it’s a guess, Spencer. But if she, if she told him the plan, he probably would have poked a hole in it.
Devin: And I was actually thinking about that too, because we had this conversation and I don’t know if we had it on air or off air, but I was like, I figured like it would have been really easy if when the, and here’s the, here’s the difference between how. They died. Okay. First of all, before I just, I’ll let you in on what’s going on in my head. How about that? So fridge, when he eats the cake, he explodes. Right. And then when she gets bit by the venom, she like just spins into this like Harry Potter type of thing. So what you should, they could have done is when he falls back, he’s still, he’s holding onto that piece of cake again. And he looks at it and throws it away. He’s like, get away from me. Oh, that’s really good.
But then we would have at least with that. That little bit of, that little bit of a world that we would have known, like, oh, they re when they respond, everything they were holding is in their hand. So then that would have, that would have covered up that hole where it’s like, well, how would she know? She’s like, well, I do know because he had the cake.
Adam: And it’s such a, it’s such a little throwaway moment too, because of the cake. Yeah. Because you’re right. That would have been a great joke, but it also would have been that little bit of information that you needed to, to. And know, know that she knew that. Yeah, that’s really good. I like that cake. Yeah. I like that cake bit, Devin. It’s a good bit. So yeah, Jumanji is pretty simple. The now or never moment. We know what they want. Get the jewel to the Jaguar. That’s the objective. The now or never moment is how they get it there. Once Spencer secured it into the, into the eye there, the Jaguar, they’ve completed the goal. And so that moves us into the next one. So that’s pretty simple, but it’s a, it’s a payoff to the buildup of the entire climax thus far.
And the, and the journey of getting the jewel to the Jaguar. Right. At this point in the movie, I’m always thinking about Kevin Hart. You can’t just give us a ride to the Jaguar.
It’s my favorite line because I love it when there are holes in a plot and a character points them out. It’s my favorite fix.
Devin: Kind of like, this ain’t even my desk. People are like, why’d he even answer that phone? All right, well, he knows it’s not his desk.
Adam: Can’t you just give us a ride? Can’t you just give us a ride to the Jaguar? It’s the greatest line. It’s such a good line.
Devin: It is good. Writers are like, yeah, we get it. We dealt with it. Move on. We’re not going to do it.
Adam: Edward’s climax, the now or never moment, is very short. Yeah. We discussed that parts one and two are basically the buildup of him retreating to the mansion and he and Kim connecting for a moment before the primary showdown of Jim and Kim and Edward all together. They sort of all show down together. Kim, the damsel in distress, Edward, the monster, and Jim, the real monster. Which is sort of the part of this. That matters. And he’s sort of like, you know, in a lot of fairy tales or monster movies, there’s the captain of the guard or the strapping hero who thinks he’s protecting the humans from the monster.
And because of his own self-righteousness, he’s more of a monster. Beauty and the Beast is an example. But there’s this buildup to this moment and the breakthrough we were talking about last week is pretty much when Edward witnesses Kim take the scissors of his hand and put it to Jim’s neck. That she’s willing to go that far because he’s that much of a threat. And Edward’s pretty passive and pretty kind. And so it sort of is a moment that he’s not expecting. So this now or never moment is literally when that, I think Jim kicks her off and gets free. And Edward’s like, I have had enough of Jim.
Devin: Now or never is a perfect example of that. This is my opportunity to get rid of this guy. Yeah, exactly. He’s almost as surprised as all of us.
Adam: Yeah, yeah, exactly. Well, you’re talking about Jim is surprised or Edward, both. I’m talking about Edward too, even.
Devin: And I think because it’s like this emotion that he doesn’t know what to do with, you know, kind of like this adolescence. He first love, he first start feeling feelings for chicks and you’re like, what is this? But he’s felt that throughout the movie for her. And he doesn’t know how to. He’s not only does he not know how to. He’s not only does he not know how to express that or how to deal with it. He can’t be physically can’t like touch her. And he says that he’s like, I can’t hold you as much as I want to. And so throughout this entire movie, like he’s had this frustration and his frustration has grown and grown and grown.
And at this moment, it’s like all of the all of that feeling that anger, all that emotion takes over right here. And almost without thinking, but thinking like he’s doing it on purpose. But but he’s just kind of he sticks them and just keeps walking. You know, it’s almost like he’s a.
Adam: Impulsive, but it’s it’s determined. It’s very focused. Yeah. More impulsive. It’s very focused. Like there’s not like he doesn’t know that he’s doing it. It is a very determined and deliberate action with intense rage.
Devin: And it’s the only thing he it’s the only emotion he can express. He can’t hug out of love. So the anger is what he. Anger is what he can express. And this is how he can express it because he doesn’t need to be delicate with Jim. He is almost like his hands. He doesn’t have hands for this very reason is for is to. To defeat. Jim, you know, that’s why he can’t. Yeah, can’t hug because he’s, you know, so that’s what he’s he’s able to finally express the emotion that he’s had.
Adam: Like we’re saying this event is pretty short. It’s basically when Edward just stabs Jim with his blades and sends him out the window. But every time I watch this thing, I’m like surprised all over again because you just aren’t expecting it. It’s such a turn in tone and think. But it’s not like it’s on. It’s not like it’s not set up. Yeah. And I love how surprising it is because the blades are in the whole movie even cuts himself accidentally cuts a whole bunch of people. And we know that they’re sharp. We know that they’re lethal. But he we know his intent is never that way.
So we take that for granted in a lot of ways. And then we get to see Edwards first real moment of rage in his hero’s darkest moment. Dark Night Soul. When Jim shows up after the arrest in the crisis moment and he goes to scraping his blades down the hallway wallpaper and into the bathroom and he shreds the bathroom. And then Bill. Well, we’ll try to find a way to help you replace the drapes in the towels. But our confidence in you, Edward, is not going to be so easy to replace.
I love how it plays out that way because, as you said before, a lot of times the villain, it’s this is the moment where they’re like, what? I wasn’t expecting that. Like Van Pelt, he’s shocked. Thanos is shocked in Avengers Endgame.
Devin: But again, it’s important. If this is the decision you’re going to make where your hero is going to do something like this, you want that to be, you want to set it up, set up the antagonist as being so vicious. Yeah. And mean and disgusting, whatever, that when you’re in your hero, you want to make him as endearing and has gone through so much that at that moment, the audience forgives him immediately. You know, it’s almost like we get it. Like, we wanted to do that to him too. And so it’s important that you don’t, you don’t make your antagonist where you are, you all of a sudden turn on your hero.
It depends on what you want. Make sure you know how you want your audience to feel about your hero and feel about your antagonist in this moment, because those decisions that you make here are going to be, you know, they’re going to, this is the one moment that all of that is going to be very impactful. Everything that happens here is going to be very impactful on how you want your antagonist and hero to be perceived by your audience. You know, it’s the same thing like in Karate Kid. You have these guys beating the crap out of Daniel throughout the entire movie. And so that moment that he defeats him, defeats Johnny with the crane kick is, is really impactful for the, and emotional for the audience as well as everybody that’s involved. But then you also have the reaction of Johnny kind of like apologizing to him afterwards. You know, he proved himself, all this, whatever.
But so there’s two different, those are two different examples of. Of defeating the antagonist, but one antagonist is dead like an Edward Scissorhands. The other one, you’ve, with a kick to the face, you’ve changed, you’ve literally changed his perception of you.
Adam: That’s how I like to change my enemies to friends. I kick them in the face. Just kick them in the face. Just crane kick them. We’re friends now. That’s a good point. The Edward Scissorhands moment though, every time there’s something weird about it, but it is one of those. It’s a really great and startling. Startling cinematic moment. Right. You could ask anybody about Edward Scissorhands and say, do you remember when he stabs him in the mansion? And they’re like, oh yeah. Like they’ll, they’ll remember it for sure because it sort of catches you off guard. And the fact is whether to, to just counter your point a little bit, whether Jim is an, is an absolute predatory animal of a villain or not, Edward still kills him.
And so there are people whose moral boundaries. Are like, Edward, you shouldn’t be doing this. You’ve been this guy this whole time who’s been kind and, and nice in this. And so that moment’s really sort of shocking to them because even if Jim is that way, Edward hasn’t really been. And so Edward makes a really big choice. And, and like I said, that’s why it’s sort of startling out of that. You know, you may not have set up people getting behind Edward just by Jim being a jerk. Because. Because we actually have gotten really behind Edward’s heart. That’s what we’re, why we’re rooting for him is his gentleness, his openness with everybody he meets.
You know what I mean? He’s not being judgmental or anything like that. Yeah. And then there’s this moment where he’s like, you need to die. And you’re like, whoa, it spins on a dime. Like he does. He turns and you’re like, oh, this is going south real quick. And. Yeah. Even if Jim is an awful person, there is a moral boundary where people may not get behind Edward killing him in that story, just because of Edward’s feeling place.
Devin: I’m sure there’s plenty of people that do not appreciate the ending. Oh, I’m sure, yeah. Why did that have to happen? It was so good! Why don’t you make it where Jim did something that made himself fall out the window.
Adam: Yeah, and Edward tried to save him, and then he fell.
Devin: It’s not really as impactful. That wouldn’t be Burton-esque, though.
Adam: The end. The end. We’re done. This is the end of the Climax, Climax Part 3, and Outcome, Objective Attained is the next event that we will talk about next week. We are so close to the end of your story. Write your three pages, now or never. You may have already figured it out or thought about it, but write them now. If you don’t have a story you’re working on, write a 15-minute free write. Play around with now or never. What would be an interesting moment? An interesting moment where the hero might have a sleight-of-hand experience with or plan with the antagonist. Something they could trick them with. Just play around.
And we’re five episodes out, I think, from the end of the events in story structuring, in your Story Blueprint. If you keep working on these events, you’ll have a wonderful first draft by the end of the season. Please subscribe and rate us on iTunes. Follow us on social media. Share with your friends and send us your questions and comments. For additional resources and links to films, series, and books we talk about here, visit our website. While you’re there, sign up for our newsletter for updates on story-building tools and special offers at StoryOsophy.com.