Show notes
The breakthrough is the second part of the climax and the fifth threshold, the end of Movement 5. In the middle of the showdown, your hero has an aha moment: the last piece of the puzzle falls into place, even if it isn’t in the puzzle yet. Adam and Devin explain how the breakthrough pays off what your hero half-realized in Movement 4, why almost every setup has to pay off here, and how a single symbol can carry a whole relationship into the climax. They open with two very anticlimactic ghost stories.
In this episode
- Showdown, enlightenment, application. The three-part climax is the confrontation, then the aha moment, then putting it into action in the now or never. Or think of it as aha, then surprise.
- Set it up in Movement 4. The darkest moment and the fall of the heart wall plant the realization, subtly. The breakthrough is when it strikes like lightning.
- Pay it off or cut it. By the climax, everything should pay off except a little something saved for the final image.
- Clues converging. Breakthroughs often come when separate storylines or teams bring their pieces together, as in Stranger Things.
- Resurrection. Christopher Vogler’s term for when the antagonist, or the fear, seems to come back from the dead for one last scare.
- Symbols carry emotion. Set up what a symbol means, and in the climax you can say everything with it, like Goose’s dog tags in Top Gun.
- Short arcs and long arcs. The Karate Kid’s crane technique is set up early and pays off at the end; “wax on, wax off” pays off within one movement.
- The unknown is the threat. Adam heard a cow crying in the night; teenage Devin crept up to a supposed cult on Grey Cloud Island and found an old farmer feeding chickens. Once you see the thing you feared, it loses its power, which is what the crisis does.
Examples discussed
- Jumanji: Welcome to the Jungle: as the elephant runs past, Martha tells Spencer to start the climb. Only she knows the plan: she has two lives left, a fact the story quietly lets us forget, and will use a snakebite and respawn to drop onto the statue with the jewel. Adam and Devin note one logic gap: how did she know she’d keep the jewel after dying?
- Edward Scissorhands: in the attic, Kim tells Edward she loves him. When she puts his blades to Jim’s throat, Edward realizes what has to be done. The scissor hands, a symbol of danger the whole film, finally live up to it.
- Days of Thunder: Cole Trickle, silent and scared after his crash, drives through the smoke of an identical wreck and starts talking again.
- Top Gun: Maverick disengages, then grips Goose’s dog tags and re-engages.
- The Karate Kid: Daniel’s crane kick, the ultimate symbol of balance.
- Also: Ferris Bueller’s Day Off, Talladega Nights, Tender Mercies, Stand by Me and The Lord of the Rings.
Writing along with the season? Write three pages for your hero’s breakthrough: what could they use that the audience took for granted? Or take 15 minutes for a free write.
Read the full transcript
Transcribed automatically, so expect the odd misheard word. Sponsor messages are left out.
Adam: In this episode, we discuss the story event Climax Part 2, Breakthrough, Crossing the Fifth Threshold. What pivotal revelation does your hero discover? How is this aha moment reflected within previous events in your story? Next on StoryOsophy. Hello. Welcome to StoryOsophy. This is Adam Jones. And Devin Halden. I stayed up late writing last night. And like 3.30 in the morning, there’s a pasture across the road from us where cows are normally. And I love cows. I hear this. I’m like, what in the hell are you doing up this late at night? Yeah. I don’t hear that regularly when I write late at night. And it just caught me off guard.
And then I hear it again. And it just keeps going. It’s not stopping this time. Yeah. And I grew up on a farm. Yeah. Sometimes stuff like that is a baby calf being born.
Devin: Yeah. That’s what I was thinking. Yeah. Did you go check it out?
Adam: Well, here’s the thing. It’s not my property. It’s right beside the road. So, cars are zipping past here all the time. Not to mention, like, I’m in the middle of a field with no cover walking around at 3.30 in the morning. So, it was just a weird thing. I was like, all right. Found a little headlamp. And I got this really powerful flashlight. And I headed out into the field. Wait.
Devin: So, you got a headlamp and a flashlight? Yeah.
Adam: Because I didn’t. I mean, I can’t see anything out there. Okay. I can’t climb the fence because I don’t want to do it by the roadside. So, I go up around. And this is my neighbor’s property. There’s a house up on the hill. Ooh. Hill house. There’s a creek that runs through there. So, I’m going along the creek because I used to walk this with my granddad. And I knew the path well enough. But I’m, like, walking on someone’s property. I didn’t call them because I don’t have their specific number. With a flashlight at 3.30 in the morning. That’s awesome. And so, I get close enough so that I can hear it’s in the barn, which is within fence upon fence upon gate within their property.
Devin: Yeah.
Adam: Yeah. So, I know it’s contained. I know it’s not a lost cow. It’s not a cow, you know, that’s giving birth. If so, they’re within earshot. [unclear] The fear of it, the anxiety of it is what’s going to happen on the other end of it.
Devin: Yeah, yeah.
Adam: What is that thing? The anticipation quality that builds a lot of horror movies and a lot of, you know, suspense thriller type things. That’s it.
Devin: The unknown.
Adam: Yeah, it was a weird little adventure.
Devin: In high school, I think I was in high school, yeah. There was these urban legends of, there’s this little island. Now, I can’t remember the name of the island, but there’s an island that actually has houses and there’s actually a community out there. Grey Cloud Island. And it was in my city that I lived in, but I didn’t go to school in my city. I went to school in another city, so I didn’t know. The only people I knew that lived in my town or my city were the people I went to grade school with. And then they all went to the high school, and I went to a different high school.
But I was hanging out with them. And it was like this time of year during late fall, or I think it was like right after a football game. So it was like fall, late fall. And they were telling me about this urban legend, and nobody ever wanted to go across this like rickety, straight out of a horror movie, rickety bridge that gets you to this area called Grey Cloud Island. And I’m sure like during the daytime, it’s just a regular bridge, and people live over there. So it’s like, it can’t be that freaky. But there’s supposed to be some cult. There’s like a cult at the very end of it.
Of course there is.
Adam: Yeah.
Devin: And so I was like, get in the car. We’re going to go check this out. So everybody got in my car. And of course, we were with some girls, and I’m showing off, even though I’m scared out of my mind driving over this bridge. But it was, we got to these like areas. It was a cul-de-sac. And then there was like one dirt road, dirt driveway that went through these like big oak trees. You couldn’t see what was. You know, beyond the oak trees, and we’re like, that’s as far as anybody’s ever gotten was to the end of the cul-de-sac. And so we did this, basically what you did. We had some little crappy flashlights, and every step I took on that dirt road towards, like, this area where this cult is supposed to be, my conscience was like, what are you doing? Turn around. You’re being an idiot. She’s not that cute. You know, all that stuff. All that stuff was going through my head.
But we got to this, like, the top of this, like, hill, and like I was saying, it’s like all of, like, the trees were talking. You could hear stuff. I don’t know of it.
We kept losing people. People were like, nope, I’m out. Turn around. And until it was like just me and this other dude. And we went up to the windows and we couldn’t see in one window because it was like a frosted window. We’re on the back and we look in and it’s like this 75 year old guy feeding chickens. That’s it.
Is this dude feeding chickens? Oh, God. And so we turn around, and we just don’t want to scare this guy now. Now we feel bad. We’re trespassing. And while we’re, like, scooting around the side, the wife comes out. She’s like, hey, who’s there? I called the cops or whatever. I’m like, oh, great. And while we were leaving the cul-de-sac area and we’re flying and we’re trying to get off this island, like, three squads pass us, and, like, they flip a U-ey and pull us over, and they’re like. You guys got to quit messing with those guys. I mean, we know you, everybody thinks there’s a cult out there. There’s just some old people that live out there. I’m like, yeah, we know. We know now. We got to see it with our own eyes.
Adam: For some reason, I love the idea of he was just eating chicken. Because it, for some reason, this image just vividly popped in my mind. And it’s so funny to me. You’re like, all the anticipation. It’s a great story, too. All the anticipation. And when you get there, it’s just an old man eating chicken.
Devin: No, he was feeding chicken. He was feeding, he had a little chicken coop and he was just feeding the chickens. And he was in a barn.
Adam: Oh, okay. I thought you said he was eating chicken, like sitting at the table, like eating bits of chicken. Oh, I’m sure that’s what his wife was doing. That’s so funny.
Devin: There was like an old farmhouse on the left. And then there was like another, and then the dirt road went to this like barn and he was in the barn. And he was just like total cliche farmer, like overalls, coveralls, whatever, overalls. And then he was just, just old guy, just feeding, feeding these little chickens. You know, and I’m like, oh man, I feel bad now. But when you’re leaving and you’ve, you’ve debunked the myth, you’re kind of sad that you did that. You know, it’s kind of like if you, if you stay up to try to catch Santa Claus and you realize it’s your parents and you’re like, I wish I wouldn’t have done that now.
Because the, the magic of, of not knowing or the fantasy of not knowing that was actually better, that feeling was better than the truth kind of thing. Yeah. It was like, now I know it’s not a cult. Like now that’s, Grey Cloud Island isn’t this like spooky thing that hopefully someday you’d get up the courage to go and check it out. Now it’s, you know, it’s like, it’s like going to see the dead body and stand by me.
Adam: You’re right. And that’s your personal experience. But for everybody else who still believes it, that story is still alive and well in that, in that way.
Devin: Right.
Adam: We told the most anticlimactic ghost stories ever just now. I know. Mine was a sad cow and yours was. It was a farmer feeding chickens. The whole point of that journey is the anticipation is that the hook, the first moment that happens, you’re like, let’s go see that cult down there. Let’s, what’s this first cow moo. Right. And then you build an, and it’s a lot to do with the approach when we have those events that are like approaching the inmost cave and things like that. That’s a lot of what matters is how does it build, you know, and yours is great because you got that approach to the crisis because you don’t know.
They’re supposed to be a cult. You get there and the crisis is people start bailing. The team starts disassembling and there’s only like two of you left. And the thing that’s a problem, the thing that is the threat, and this is why we do the comfort zone out of comfort zone, is the beyond. Mm-hmm. That which is not known, the unknown, because you don’t know what it is. You, you, I mean, half the party feared it and left. And two brave souls, Devin. You and another brave young man. Yeah. Found the chicken feeder. You did have an interesting sort of climax in this regard because the crisis would have probably been finding him at the barn and then the wife catches you and you are, have to escape.
Devin: Yeah. And the extension of them would be the police stopping you as you, as you try to race away. It was like when you’re laying in bed or you’re lying in bed and your imagination makes your, makes the coat rack and what’s in the hat that’s on the coat rack come to life until you flick the light on and you see it’s just a coat rack. And I think that’s basically what happened was we finally flicked the light on to the urban legend and it wasn’t what we thought it was going to be. We thought it was a bit disappointing.
Adam: Well, and that’s, and it can still be scary too. It like, if it were something scary, let’s just say he was chopping the heads off chickens instead. He was, you know what I mean? Like it could be something really terrifying and you’re like, what? And freak out a little bit. The whole point is once you see the crisis, now you know what you’re up against. It’s not unknown anymore. And that’s why it’s sort of the midpoint of act two for storytelling, you know, because you, you go, okay, I know what it is. It, I still can’t defeat it or it still scares me, but I know what it is.
Devin: Right.
Adam: And then in the movement for recovery, dark night of soul and fall of the heart wall, you come to confront that within yourself. And why was I afraid of that? Because it’s reflected in me in some way. Here’s what it is. You know, whether it’s being vulnerable or something like that. It’s just a lot of stories. It’s as simple as that. They’re vulnerable in this way. They feel vulnerable in this way. But then you get to the, you know, the climax where we’re at here in movement five, the showdown, the episode we did before this, and you come face to face with that thing. So you may still be scared. You may still have misgivings or worries or doubts about things, but you know what you’re up against. You know what to expect. And so you can sort of, as we’ve been talking about, be proactive now instead of reactive.
Couldn’t have said it better myself. This week, we’re going to be talking about the last event in movement five. Climax, part two, the breakthrough. I always got to leave room for your hoots and hollers. I forget, and then…
Devin: Well, this one deserved it because it’s always accomplishment when you get to the end of a movement. Yeah. And have a movement.
Adam: That’s part of the fun of breaking up into measurements like this is if you’ve written five events and finished that movement, you can sort of check it off your list. That’s right. And work on the other things. Getting to the end of one is always great. It’s always great for hero decision-making time, too, because it’s a threshold. It’s the fifth and really sort of final threshold. The end is actually the final threshold, but you’re not really continuing on to something else. But this one is the place where all of the characters’ resources and skill sets come into play. This is where they figure out what they’re made of and how to apply the things they’ve learned that they maybe didn’t know throughout the course of Act Two.
Yeah. In the learning part of the journey. So once this sort of breakthrough moment happens, you could also think of it as an aha moment. Yes. That’s a really good way to think of it because it really gives you that character feel that you want to get out of that. It’s like, I know what I have to do. It’s sort of like the idea happens here. They planned in the beginning, and the plan’s gone a little awry, and maybe they’re doing all right, but something needs to happen for them to triumph. And here, it’s this perfection. Yeah. This fresh new idea that goes, boom, of course, now I know.
Devin: Yeah, they found the last piece of the puzzle. They haven’t put the last piece of the puzzle in the puzzle yet, but they’re like, here it is. Now we just have to figure out a way to place it into the puzzle and complete the puzzle. Yeah.
Adam: Right off the top of my head. No, it’s true. And a lot of times what that’ll end up being is like two parts of a puzzle, like two different, like say we were talking about subplots and A, B, and C stories. This kind of stuff will go into more detail in Season Three. Season Three. But they’ll intersect, and here they intersect, so a lot of times it’s two different pieces, two parts of a map that come together and you figure out the ending. It’s two clues that two different detective teams, Stranger Things does it all the time, all the time. That’s how they dovetail these storylines together with the, you know, they’re all picking up bits of information, then they contribute together at the end.
Yeah. And that reconnection of parties and sharing of information is what sets off like the showdown breakthrough now or never. But you’re right, it’s puzzle pieces. It’s little, and there should be aha moments for your audience in this bit too, not just your character. Unless the surprise of what the character’s going to do is important, then you don’t give them the aha moment for your audience here. You would do it in the now or never when they execute this brilliant idea that they’ve had. That’s the case with Jumanji, which we’ll talk about later. She gets an idea, but she suspends her, just get to go up to the top of the mountain to the jaguar.
I’ll get the jewel to you.
Devin: Yeah, the elephant runs past them, and they both kind of have the breakthrough aha moment. Because she’s like, elephant, begin the climb. Then that’s the breakthrough for them.
Adam: Even though I feel like they have not gotten this elephant puzzle, this elephant riddle right yet. They’re like, the missing piece, the elephant. Yeah. They climb, and Spencer gets scared by the squirrel. Devin’s favorite squirrel. I promise this is the last week I’ll use this clip, StoryOsophers, but Devin finds a lot of enjoyment out of it.
Devin: Okay, first of all, I know it’s not a real squirrel, okay? I’m not saying they train the squirrel to scream perfectly like that. I’m just saying, as a character, that squirrel, that is the number one best squirrel scene.
Adam: He thinks he’s salvaging himself instead of digging a hole deeper. But we all know. I love that squirrel. And they only give you a glimpse of him, too. I love it.
Devin: Yeah, he’s like. He just screams at him. So, he’s just. I love when that moment when both people are as surprised to see one another. They’re just like, oh. And then the different reactions.
Adam: That’s one of my favorite types of scenes.
Devin: One of my favorite ones like that is Ferris Bueller’s movie. I love it.
Adam: I love it. And then one of my, one of my favorite ones like that is Ferris Bueller’s Day Off with the principal and the sister in the kitchen. Yeah.
Devin: They jump around the corner and they go, ha. Yeah, and then she screams. She like triple kicks him in the face.
Adam: I remember when we first watched that, my brother and I backed that scene up over and over and over because of how fun, like the kicks when they jump cut and she does it real quick. We thought it was the funniest thing in the world.
Devin: It was so funny.
Adam: It is good. So breakthrough, a lot of times this will, we talk about how a lot of these events, they reverberate throughout your story. So they’re set up in the beginning. Then you see touches of them. They have touchstones across act two, sometimes at thresholds, but it’s pretty much anywhere. You can drop setups throughout all of your movement builds. And then you have this, when you’re in five and six, act three here, the climax is where these, almost everything needs to pay off. You need to save a little bit for your resolution.
Devin: Right.
Adam: And like your final exclamation point or your button of your story, the end of your story, whether it’s a clincher or something poetic or whatever it is, save a little something there, but everything else needs to be solved here or else you’ve dropped the ball. I either cut the thing that’s not paid off or pay it off. Those are your options, but this is where everything needs to connect.
Devin: Breakthrough slash payoff, because that’s, man, nine times out of 10, I guess I can’t even think of an example where the breakthrough isn’t set up prior to this has to be a payoff, I think. Yeah.
Adam: Part of what it is too is we’ve just seen in movement four with Dark Night of the Soul and Fall of the Heart Wall, between those two things, that is where they’ve realized something, but it’s not a full realization. So they’re not afraid necessarily of, let’s put it this way, the force of antagonism is not dark anymore. It’s not in the dark. It’s known now. It may still feel stronger. You may still need to conquer it in some way, triumph, but the hero’s not afraid of it. Right. The hero has an understanding about themselves internally. So the aha moment is set up here, and we may get a little bit.
It should be clear enough for the audience that when it happens later, we, of course, as well go, aha, with the character. But when you get to the breakthrough, it’s that one little kernel of knowledge or expansion for that character, growth, change, new thought, the one little thing they hadn’t considered. And here, it just, it pops into their brain like a bolt of lightning. And it’s like, yes, okay. So you need to set it up back there in Dark Night of the Soul, Fall of the Heart Wall, and you want to do it usually with a lot of subtlety. But that, again, is reflected back in Movement 1 with the call to quest, the refusal of the call, and the choosal of the call.
Doubt and, and I hate this term, but character flaw, the classic term of a character flaw, character flaw, their weakness, their vulnerability is set up there. Once again, subtle. And then they come to terms with it in Movement 4 after some trial and tribulation of Movements 2 and 3. And in Movement 5 is when the, like, the lesson is learned. That’s, they figured it all out here in Breakthrough. And the now or never moment is applying all that whole arc. So hopefully now you can understand a little bit why Devin and I break this down. To three parts. One is the showdown, the actual confrontation. The second is the enlightenment.
And the third is the application.
Devin: Right.
Adam: And it’s, and look at his three O’s. It’s right there too. Objective, obstacles, outcome.
Devin: A good example of this is Days of Thunder, which is one of the greatest movies ever. And which basically is just Top Gun and race cars. But they have a three-part climax.
Adam: Yeah.
Devin: I’ve never seen Days of Thunder. Oh, you’ve never seen Days of Thunder? No. How dare you? Well, then I’ll walk you through the three-part climax. Do it.
Adam: Yes.
Devin: I don’t want to set up too much. But so he, Cole Trickle, played by Tom Cruise, has a really terrible wreck in one of the races. And he kind of goes blind, temporarily goes blind. And he’s, it’s a long road back through his Movement 4 and him coming to grips with who he is. And so there’s leading, all that leading up to this three-part climax. Where the showdown is, and I believe it’s the Daytona 500. I’m pretty sure it’s Daytona. But the showdown is literally the showdown of the race. And it’s the first time he gets back in the race car. And so he’s a little, he’s scared.
He’s timid. He doesn’t know what’s going to happen.
Hairy. Shake and bake.
Adam: Shake and bake, man. Shake and bake. No, it’s not. That’s still a… I know. I just, that’s all I can think of when you’re telling me this suddenly. It’s like… Go ahead.
Devin: Continue.
Adam: Freaking Talladega Nights.
Devin: Which is basically just a mockery of Days of Thunder. So Robert Duvall’s character, Harry Hogg, is like, all right, well, I don’t know how this is going to end up. He fixes the car up for Cole. He shouldn’t be getting back in the car. But so the whole showdown is the first however many laps he’s in the Daytona 500, he’s not talking. And he’s freaked out. And he’s… They’re trying to talk to him over the radio on the car. They tell us you’re okay, tell us you’re okay. And he doesn’t say anything. He’s just like, just frozen. But he’s racing in this race. And then there’s a wreck that’s exactly the same as the one that messed him up.
Oh. And so that’s the showdown. And he’s going towards it. And he’s like, they’re like, just drive through it. You can drive through it because if you drive straight at the wreck, by the time you get there, they’ll… Cars will be gone, whatever. And so it’s like pretty intense for him. And then he goes into this smoke and you can’t see him. So you don’t know if he’s going to crash again or he’s going through it. And so the breakthrough is he gets through the crash. Oh, nice. And immediately once he gets through it, once he passes it, he starts talking again. And you go, that’s his breakthrough.
He’s like, all right, I’m out of here. And he drops it. He drops it in gear and he just takes off. But there you go.
Adam: The threshold is the cloud of smoke. It’s the crash. Right, right. And a lot of times, you know, when we talk about Vogler, Vogler does the resurrection. There’s that event or stage in his story, which he calls the resurrection, which is when the antagonist sort of pops their head back up. Like, we thought they were dead, but they’re not dead. A lot of times that’s sort of like they do it in Jumanji with the… Like Van Pelt shows up in the midpoint crisis and that’s the confrontation. They escape with the magical item, which is Nick Jonas. We think it’s an elephant. And then they get to the climax and he’s…
It’s the big showdown. That’s sort of his resurrection moment. So, a lot of times the showdown can be the resurrection moment. Right. And resurrection, to be clear with how he’s using it, StoryOsophers, it’s not in a Western religion, biblical sense, like Christ-like. It’s meant just the resurfacing of, because he’s using it in reference to the antagonist of a story, Vogler is. So, they just… They seem to come back from the dead. And have one last scare for the villain. And in Tender Mercies with Robert Duvall, it’s alcoholism. In Days of Thunder, it’s the wreck itself, apparently. And so, the resurrection moment is just the re-confrontation with the thing that scared you to death.
But anyway, I want to know how this ends. I’m now caught at the breakthrough. I paused your story for Days of Thunder at the breakthrough with the cloud of smoke.
Devin: So, he gets through the cloud of smoke and then… And he drops the hammer and he says, I’m out of here. Because now it’s… And it’s literally almost the same. Like I said, it’s Days of Thunder is Top Gun and race cars because there’s the same type of scene in Top Gun at the very end when he’s actually in the dog fight. And I think it’s Night Rider or Sundown or Night Rider.
Sundown. I forgot who’s real or who’s the guy in the back of the plane in the very end. When he’s yelling at… He’s yelling at him and he’s like, get back in the fight. Get back in the fight. Because Tom Cruise, or Maverick, he’s like, oh, it’s no good. It’s no good. And he pulls out of the fight. And meanwhile, Iceman is like being shot at by like three or four MiGs and they’re all over him. And so, you can hear Iceman like screaming for help over the radio. You can hear… Oh, it’s not Sundown. It’s Hollywood. I think it’s Hollywood in the… Yelling at Maverick.
To go fight, go help out, go help Ice. And Maverick is just like trying to figure out, get through this. And then he looks at… Something happens. He either looks at Goose’s… Something with Goose or something. But… And then he has this breakthrough where he’s like… And he gets back in the fight and he does… And he takes out like three fighters and they actually say it.
Adam: Do you remember exactly what the breakthrough moment? What I mean is, let me clarify that. The trigger, the catalyst, the thing that he looked at or the thing he remembered, that was the breakthrough. I’m curious.
Devin: I think it’s like a photo. It’s either a photo or he just… He’s… I forgot. But… Well, there’s actually a herald moment where there’s a guy that’s on the aircraft carrier that’s like, Maverick’s disengaging, sir. And he’s like, damn it. I knew I shouldn’t have sent him up there. And so, when he’s disengaging, that’s kind of right before the breakthrough. And then after the breakthrough happened, the herald comes back and he’s like, Maverick’s reengaging, sir. And he gets back in the fight and everybody’s cheering and stuff like that. So, there’s a moment. I can’t…
Adam: Remember… That’s the resurrection where when he’s about ready to pass through the smoke and the crash and days of thunder is Maverick disappearing and disengaging. Yep. Because whatever the enemy is, that source of antagonism that they wrestled with in Movement 4 in both movies, Tom Cruise wrestling, the thing that he fears comes back to sort of flash its face one more time, come back from the dead, resurrect itself. A skeleton in the closet, a demon, any of these things that’s internal. It’s represented in these moments.
Devin: All right. I got it. He’s holding on to Goose’s dog tags. So, he’s holding it. He’s got Goose’s dog tags in his hand and he’s just saying, talk to me, Goose. Talk to me, Goose. That’s all he needed. And then he turns the corner and he gets back in the fight.
[Sponsor message]
Adam: Captivating and exciting. And each end of Climax one, two, or three should be these really amazing turning points. Right. And they can be short, like Edward Scissorhands we’re talking about. They all happen within the attic scene and it’s fairly brief. Or it can be a Marvel movie where the showdown is literally 20 minutes. Which is the entire third act. Right, exactly. Like it’s almost an hour of act three or 45 minutes of act three. So that’s why this is sort of broken down is at least you’re hitting the key points. Right. Whether you’re doing a Marvel-sized movie or even a TV series where the arc at the end needs a more prolonged climax. Or a feature that’s a rom-com where all this sums up. Still, if they’re trying to sneak into this party to talk to this person because they have to confess their love and there’s people blocking them from doing it. And then when they do meet them or talk to them, they’re rejected again. They’re like, I told you, I never want to speak to you, blah, blah, blah. Then there has to be a breakthrough moment where the person goes, yeah, but here’s what you didn’t know, dot, dot, dot. And the now or never is then after that when they sort of confess the love. And here’s what you didn’t know, blah, blah, blah. They were lying. They did this, blah, blah, blah. Or whatever their reasoning is. And then they go, I do love you and here’s why. And that person then understands. So that’s a classic little rom-com, really short way of climaxing.
And you could do it a million and one ways. What you said about Top Gun that’s really important is, and you and I are both into this, when he’s holding Goose’s dog tags, that’s the symbol. Maverick feels like a loner. He’s like the lone guy in the whole movie. He’s Maverick. And Goose is the only person who’s like his support system. And that just gets taken away. So now he doesn’t have that support system. He sort of collapsed inside, you know. And when this last bit happens up in the skies, all the people that he was fighting against the whole time, the rivals, as we talk about in archetypes, all of his rivals and even allies, they work as a team.
And so this catalyst with him in the breakthrough, they use a symbol, the dog tags. Symbols are really powerful for climax moments. Because if you set them up to mean something, their friendship, Goose and Maverick, and then Goose passes away and dog tags are of course used to remember on grave sites and with loved ones, the passing of a serviceman. So we all know what that means. And so when he’s got him in the plane with him and he asks him for help, all that relationship that you’ve built up is just in dog tags. It’s in the dog tags. And symbols are really awesome for use in climax. You can see why we break it down into these three pieces. There are three really strong components. And a lot of times, no matter what you’re doing, scene, event, act, movement, whatever piece of the story you’re working on, a one, two, three rhythm is always nice.
Even if the two seems a little longer, but the one, two, three, like set up, complication, payoff, objective, obstacle, outcome, that will not fail you in story building.
Devin: A good example of a setup and payoff for this is, just because we’ve talked about Karate Kid a bunch of times in the past, is when Daniel sees Mr. Miyagi doing the crane earlier in the movie. And he’s like, well, what were you doing out there? And just right before he karate chops the tops of the beer bottles off the guys that were just sitting by his truck.
And then in the end, the breakthrough moment is a little bit… The moment with Mr. Miyagi after his leg was like thrashed or whatever. And so he has to do his special Miyagi trick with his hands. Daniel ultimately says, this is the time I have to use the, this is when I need to use the crane move. One of the greatest endings of all scenes, of all movies.
Adam: And also one of the greatest pieces of symbolism, as you pointed out, like a few, sometime mid season two here, we were, we’ve been talking… And how we talk about how Daniel’s journey is all about balance in his life. Yeah, right. And the crane being the ultimate symbol of, even when you’re off balance, dot, dot, dot, you know. But earlier on, he’s practicing it on that pillar. It’s the image they have on the poster. Right. Like he learns, he sees it from Miyagi and it’s the unknown skill that he’ll need at the end. But the balance aspect I thought was interesting. And he says it at one point, Miyagi, I think he’s like…
Life feels out of balance. Like he mentions balance to Daniel.
Devin: It’s the entire, it’s the entire scene when he’s laying on the, before he does his magic hands thing. Is he’s like, I’m not going to have balance, not with me, not with Allie, if he doesn’t go out and fight. Because he has to finish it. He has to go out and finish the fight. He can’t just stop now.
Adam: Right.
Devin: And that’s the entire thing is about balance, about Daniel wanting balance in his life. And so you’re right. That’s, and then he goes out and then the ultimate balance move is what he uses to actually finish the fight. Right.
Adam: And also with a cool… Twist to it. We don’t know if he can pull that off.
Devin: Right. Because we haven’t seen him use it yet.
Adam: Well, that’s the now or never. That’s the breakthrough and the surprise.
Devin: Right.
Adam: That’s another good thing is, so breakthrough is aha moment. Now or never is surprise. That’s a great way to look at it too. Because… Yeah, yeah. They have, he has the idea of Daniel, you know, is going to use this crane move because he can’t stand on that foot. And so they think he’s weak. He’s lured them into some trap in a way only to surprise them. Yeah. And they do it in Jumanji. Jumanji is the same thing. You know, Van Pelt thinks he has the upper hand until the breakthrough in Now or Never moments, and then he realizes, they got me. Like, they outsmarted me. And that’s a lot of what Now or Never is, is breakthroughs the idea, and Now or Never is the actual application, the outsmarting of.
Right. That’s the way to sort of break them up a little bit. So, aha and surprise are helpful ways of, it’s always good to think of these events with more than one title. If it benefits the story to look at it from that title’s angle, use that. And I wanted to mention something about the Karate Kid 2 that’s interesting, because it’s a training movie. The most of the, it’s a mentor tale. And the idea of setups and payoffs, sometimes you set them up in movement one and go to the end. In the Karate Kid, one of the most satisfying things along the journey is, the journey in Act 2 for this is, there are more frequent, even though the crane is from the beginning to the very end, that’s the arc of it. It’s got a long arc.
The wax on, wax off scene doesn’t. It gives you this awesome and immediate payoff for that sequential build. Right. Because he’s like making him do all this work, and you’re like, oh, he’s taking advantage of this kid, which is what Daniel starts to think. And so, you sort of trust him, sort of not. And then when it gets to the payoff of wax on, and he blocks it. He blocks his hit. Wax off, and he blocks his hit. And the setup payoff is very short. It’s within one movement. So, you can have, we talk about this a lot, setups and payoffs, because that’s what story, that’s what storytelling, to me, that’s what it really is, is you’re connecting points from deeper meaning.
Right. And so, it’s not just some random, we’ve all been told a story by someone who is just meandering with no detail, or with maybe too much detail and no sense of structure or direction to where the story’s going. And then we’ve met people who got the first perfect one line for the story, and everybody’s wrapped up in it, and they build it, and they build it. People are looking for meaning. They’re looking for engagement, a little mystery, as we were talking about with our sad cow and chicken-feeding farmer stories. The build of those stories is great. The payoff is…
Devin: Very anticlimactic.
Adam: You’re throwing your popcorn away and leaving the theater. It’s like, you mean the dude was just feeding chickens? Yeah, the whole time, just he was feeding chickens. No cult? No cult. No cult. You should have seen my movie. The cow was just sad.
Devin: Just a sad cow. The cow was just sad.
Adam: So, let’s move on to examples. Jumanji, Welcome to the Jungle. The breakthrough here is… We kind of already covered this. We sort of did last week, but we’re going to reiterate, because in case people are listening for these specifics.
Devin: We kind of did already today, too.
Adam: The breakthrough moment is… The elephant. Yeah, the elephant bit, but also… Really, when Martha says, start the climb. Aha, start the climb. That’s really it. So, the elephant shows up, Martha turns to Spencer, and she says her thing, and so Spencer starts up. So, the breakthrough moment is putting a new plan into action. There’s a new plan that… Apparently, Martha’s the only one who knows in this circumstance, but there’s a new plan. That’s the moment. We’ve got an idea. This event for Jumanji ends before Martha gets bit by the snake. Okay. Martha getting bit by the snake is sort of the threshold, because she’s going to respawn and drop from heaven.
A threshold we’ve never thought someone would use to their advantage, which is the fun trick of the end of this movie, the climax. She uses a trick, the respawning, that we don’t really think is a tool they’ll use, because it’s usually been to their detriment. So, I would say that’s a breakthrough. Breakthrough is from her plan starting to her getting bit by the snake. And the now or never becomes her falling. With the jewel and giving it to…
Devin: Yeah, I would agree with that. Yeah, it’s pretty short.
Adam: But it’s important, because everybody’s working together, and Bethany is freed, and everybody’s skill set comes into play. The Rock is proficient in a lot of action hero stuff, and Fridge is the zoologist. And Bethany and Nick Jonas, they’re sort of just like Stomp Van Pelt for a moment. But you don’t really expect… Martha, although she is a clever gal from our first introduction with her in the beginning, she figures out two things. I’m going to use my weakness as a strength, which is a clever way to spin the setup of that from movement two. And also the whole rules of the game, respawning drops me from the sky. So I immediately go to the top of the thing.
So she figures all this stuff out in the aha moment, but we don’t know what she has planned really until the next event now or never.
Devin: For me, it was, I kind of forgot she, cause whether it’s by design or not, we, I forgot that she had two lives left. Like I wasn’t necessarily really keeping track of people’s lives, but I did know because we just saw the rocks character, Spencer lose. Like he knew he was down to one life and we knew bethany was down to one life and we knew jonas This was, that guy’s been on one life for years. So, but there’s like all of these, I didn’t really infringe and things like that. So, I don’t know if they just didn’t really bring it to our attention.
Adam: It doesn’t register with you.
Devin: Because she’s been kind of in the background a little bit. Yeah. And so, I was like, oh, wow, she’s the only one with a life left. Which I’m assuming was they wanted to raise the stakes a little bit. Because if we all knew she just had a life left then it at that moment, then, you know, we would know that she’s, even if she gets bit by the snake, she’s gonna
A shortcut. Yeah. Shortcut.
Adam: Yeah. Shortcut to the, to the goal. But, you know, here’s another thing with setups and payoffs in reversal in a way, setting up your audience expectations. So that the result is different and they should have known that all along. Cause I forgot that Martha had two lives too. I think you’re, it’s designed, the story is designed for you to forget that. And that’s why it happens at the end of movement two, around 30 minutes at the danger zone. She’s the first one that gets shot. And that’s the only time she ever gets shot. So you forget about it because there’s everybody else is getting shot and killed and knocked off cliffs and blown up by cake. And so there’s all this stuff that’s happening.
Right. And you, you’re trying to keep track of how many lives everybody else has. And you, and the last thing they pointed out to you, as Devin just said, is Spencer’s only got one life. Fridge has only got one life. We all only have one life. Spencer is what he says back to him. So they plant this subliminal stuff to let you, you know, to let you assume that they’re all riding on one life. And we haven’t done the math for Martha. Right. It’s brilliant set of payoff, like sort of a reversal in that way.
Devin: It’s also important that the being surrounded by a bunch of snakes doesn’t. It doesn’t necessarily mean you’re going to die. Like it doesn’t necessarily mean Fridge would die. It doesn’t necessarily mean Spencer would die because they’ll, sure they’ll get bit, but maybe they can run through it. But venom is her weakness. And so it’s like, it doesn’t matter. She can only, even if she gets bit just once, that’s going to kill her. So that’s part of it too.
Adam: How did she know in the video game rules that she would maintain possession of the jewel when she dies? Right. I thought that too. I was thinking about that too. Yeah. You get killed and your stuff gets left in a pile where you died. Right. So why did she assume that would be the case? And I feel like that was one of those little setups that might’ve been helpful to fill that logic gap. It would have been an easy setup too. They were sort of like, no one’s going to ask that question except for the guys from StoryOsophy. They’re the only two guys.
Devin: I was thinking that too. And then I was also thinking, I’m like, God, it would have been a really easy setup. Someone who died didn’t necessarily have to be holding on to the Jaguar. I, whatever the hell, whatever that thing is. Jewel. Yeah. But it’s an eye, isn’t it? It’s like Jaguar eye. But whatever. But they could have been holding on to something when they died and then fell and they’re still holding on to it. Because then we’d be like, oh, so everything that was part of everything you were holding on to or everything was part of your, your person, your effects also come back.
Adam: When Kevin Hart eats cake, explodes, drops down from the ceiling, he can still be holding the cake.
Devin: Cake. That’s what I was thinking. I guess every time he fridge dies, he does come back like the backpack and everything. But I guess that’s what I was thinking. I guess that’s part of his character. So he has to come back.
Adam: Yeah. I don’t know. Now we’re going deep. Now we’re going deep into Jumanji. The movie that requires deep, deep thinking.
Devin: The movie that I’ve watched 65 times since we started this damn thing.
Adam: Jumanji is sort of really blatant. It’s really obvious and easy to track. And Edward Scissorhands usually subverts everything we say. It does, yeah, which is nice. How can we take these events and flip them on their head and make them work for this story? There’s two storylines. There’s a romance storyline and there’s a fitting-in bully storyline. The bully was the boyfriend of the love interest and that’s how they intersect. And so here is where it intersects because Kim has confessed her love of Edward, I mean, to the degree that she really does care about him. She says, I love you. Yes.
Devin: She tells him. I think it’s right before Jimbo shows up. That’s a good spot for it. I think the breakthrough is what’s happening between Edward and Kim. That’s the breakthrough. Her confession to him? Yeah. And I think it ends with her. Okay. It’s all, everything that’s involved with Kim. So it ends when Kim grabs his hand and puts it to Jim’s throat. And I think then it quickly transitions to now or never part of the climax, which is quickly over with after he stabs him, pushes him out the window.
Adam: Yeah. I said the now or never for me is the stabbing and the breakthrough for me is the, like you’re saying, when she puts Edward’s blades, uses, he just grabs his arm and hand and puts them to Jim’s neck. Edward in that moment realizes that even though she’s doing it here, this is what needs to be done. Yeah. I would agree. I agree with that. He just knows it. This is the moment he starts to go, oh no. So the aha moment is not as inspiring as something like Jumanji.
Devin: Oh, I get it. I know what you’re saying.
Adam: It’s a little bit more taking on the mantle of responsibility of something that is very heavy moment. He’s like, oh, I get this. And part of it is in fear. And transition of that. But it’s hard for me to place. I mean, for me, I think that the showdown starts when Jim arrived. The whole thing with Jim is the showdown to me. To me, I like the roof collapsing, all that stuff.
Devin: I watched it again and I was like, all right. So for me, the climax won the showdown. One of the hallmarks or one of the ingredients of that is really the face-to-face, the final face-to-face with the antagonist. Yeah. I’ll revise my idea of what the showdown, because I had my showdown, the showdown starting as Edward was running away from the horde or the village, the villagers. And so I will, I, that, I guess, as far as using that criteria of being faced, finally face-to-face with, with the antagonist as part of the climax one showdown, I would agree that it’s when Jim shows up. I, and then after that, from then until the minute Jim’s on the ground dead, everything happens very quickly. And so it’s, there is a breakthrough moment and then there’s a now or never moment, but everything is kind of happening. I do believe there’s overlapping with, with all of that.
Agreed.
Adam: I think there’s some overlapping that happens with, with all of that. And, and also when, when we talk about these, remember, this is always good to think for any event, just because the event says. Showdown or breakthrough or now or never. Remember the beginning of that event is going to be build to the showdown. There’s, you want to set something up so that when stuff happens, that is the event of the showdown or the breakthrough that it feels like something has evolved. Even if it’s two pages, three pages. I mean, most of the climax and Edward Scissorhands part one, two, and three exists in about six minutes of time, maybe.
I mean, maybe two to three pages for each bit of the climax. If that, they probably stretch out showdown and breakthrough and now or never are pretty punctuated and brief because they’re, they happen fairly immediately, especially now or never. Now or never is like, oh, Jim’s dead.
Devin: I say the writer, Caroline Thompson was using like our Story Blueprint model. To write Edward Scissorhands, hypothetically, I think she would basically say, well, I just need this. This is this is showdown. This is the climax. I don’t I’m not necessarily breaking them up. So she’d probably delete and just make it one thing is the climax. Although there are elements of that stuff in there.
Adam: We are breaking it down via three distinctive parts when we’re examining it. But at the same time, it’s like, let’s look at it what you were talking about before. So the first part of it is Edward and Kim together. That’s first part of this thing. The second part is Jim shows up. That complicates the thing. The third thing is Kim saves the day, but Edward gets incapacitated because she flicks the gun up to the ceiling and collapses the roof on Edward. So now that her ally or the person who might be strong enough to deal with Jim is incapacitated and Jim is angry with Kim and he, you know, he starts beating up on Edward. She hits him with a beam. And yeah, and look, you can you can even take the first three events of Movement 5 and place them over the showdown or the climax. There’s a plan. Things go wrong. Enemies gain ground or antagonist gains ground. And then now or never triumph or failure. Absolutely. Yeah, you just lay it over the climax again, you know, just in a more concentrated pressure cooker kind of way.
And then finally, Kim decides to take charge, even though Edward has been and uses his knives to Jim’s throat. The big object in the movie are the scissors or the scissor hands. And it becomes a symbol throughout the story of the first one Peg meets him. She’s a little scared of him. He ends up cutting himself on the face and we realize, oh, this is slightly dangerous. And then the Christmas party comes along and he cuts Kim and he cuts Kevin and he cuts Jim and this frantic moment of trying to save Kevin. Well, we know these things have been looming around the whole time, these deadly blades, but Edward would never use them to hurt a fly. And so this symbol of like, people are afraid of him because he’s different and dangerous. In this last moment, the now or never, the thing we’ve never thought would happen, happens. They are dangerous.
Right.
Devin: Because I guess we’re, I don’t want to overlook or not talk about what happens after he kills Jim. She makes the decision. She’s like, I need to, I need to protect you now. You protected me. I need to save you. And that’s when she grabs the old scissors that aren’t his and uses them as evidence that he’s dead. So that like, just to extend your analysis of the scissors, they ultimately end up saving his life. Yeah. You know, so, so he, she just stands there and I think that’s the end of the climax.
Adam: What she’s done, what she does, that would be outcome, objective obtained to me. He’s, she’s created that new boundary along with the cop, like he’s dead. And it continues into it, but I think that’s it. It’s like, she’s obtaining that treasure that like him needing to be alone is the most important thing. And she understands it. So she gives that to him. Yeah. She helps him to obtain that. She helps him to obtain that, even though she has to let him go. But anyway, we’ll get into these in the, in the next few weeks. The climax is over at that point. Yeah. That’s all I’m getting to. Yeah.
Devin: Yeah. And then it moved. And then we’re, we’re, we’re now into, we’re transitioning from movement five to movement six. Yeah. So then it goes to her. We go back to her sitting in the chair as an old, old woman.
Adam: I think anytime in a, in a, in a story in act three, when the villain dies, like the… That’s the end of your climax, generally, because the threat has been stopped. Now, in Edward Scissorhands, like you’re posing, the minions, the JV squad that are the gossiping neighborhood, the catty women who love Edward and then hate Edward, the neighbors who, the veteran who rejects him, all those people who are JV squad, they’re still coming. The mob with the torches for Frankenstein, they’re still coming. So… Right. They’ve, he’s defeated the main antagonist, but they’re still… There’s still a little bit of the force of antagonism, even though it’s much, it’s weak.
It’s like if you’ve cut, like if you cut off the head of the monster, you’re done. And that Jim is sort of like the most threatening piece. The rest of them are sort of cowardly in that way. But they still need to be contended with. In some way, which is an interesting sort of leftover quality to the source of antagonism. But usually, like I’m saying, usually once the antagonist is dead, that’s it. And there’s resolution, there’s understanding of what you’ve accomplished or attained in the journey and resolution, tying up loose ends, final image, final words of a story. So, there’s some things that happen afterwards, and don’t worry, StoryOsophers. Those things, although they seem like they may be boring, don’t have to be. They can be just as exciting as other parts of your story.
There are stories that have had some abrupt endings, bad endings, even prolonged endings, like the Lord of the Rings. People made jokes about the fact that it felt like it had three or four endings, just one right after another. This event is the… This is the final event of Movement 5. We crossed the threshold, and next week we’ll be starting Movement 6, which is the completion of the Climax. So, this is your cliffhanger moment, this aha moment between this movement and the next. What happens next? If you have a story you’re working on, sit down and write your three pages for this event. Play with some ideas for a breakthrough moment. What’s something cool that a character could use to their advantage that we might have taken for granted in the telling of the story?
If you don’t have a story that you’re working on right now, just sit down and do a 15-minute free write. Play around with the idea. You never know where it’ll lead you, but at least keep the imagination flexible, malleable, play with it a little bit. If you do do your three pages, by the end of Season 2, you’ll have a first draft. It may not be perfect. As Devin says, it probably won’t be, but you at least have something to work with, some clay to mold. We’ll talk about how to deal with that. We’ll refine that clay in the remainder of Season 2 and into Season 3.
Please subscribe and rate us on iTunes. Follow us on social media, share with your friends, and send us your questions and comments. For additional resources and links to films, series, and books we talk about here, visit our website. While you’re there, sign up for our newsletter for updates on story building tools and special offers at StoryOsophy.com.