Show notes
The fall of the heart wall comes right after the hero’s darkest moment, and the two work as a pair. In the darkest moment, your hero recognizes the darkness inside; here they find the courage to face it, the first speck of light in the dark. It’s the turn where the hero with a lowercase h becomes the Hero with a capital H: death and rebirth, and the last time quitting is an option. Adam and Devin also talk about the connective tissue between big events, and where the event’s name comes from.
In this episode
- Keep dancing between events. Like a dancer moving between big moves, the scenes that connect your major events should still strengthen a character, the B story or the world, and are perfect places to tuck in setups.
- Start simple, then polish. Write “it’s a house, two stories, a garage” and let the scene tell you more. Run it through your mind like Tesla building a machine, and play the what-if game: what if the antagonist won this scene?
- Make the audience care first. If this moment doesn’t land, go back and give your hero more dimension. Even one well-placed moment of humor can make a humorless character relatable.
- Courage, not commitment. This event is about finding the courage to face the internal obstacle. Committing to the plan comes in the reassessment and re-choosal that follow.
- The last decision point. Your hero’s choice has narrowed to quitting, and dying, figuratively or literally, or rising to finish the quest. After this, quitting is off the table, though death is still possible.
- The flaw may be a strength. Often the hero doesn’t defeat the thing they’ve been ashamed of; they accept it as who they are.
- The confessional. This event often involves a confession, sometimes to a friend rather than the love interest, as the hero lets their guard down.
- Leave something for the climax. Your hero figures out most of it here, not all of it. Save the last piece for the breakthrough, the way Avengers: Endgame sets up Tony Stark’s “I am Iron Man.”
- Where the name comes from. Adam credits Dr. Bradley Nelson’s The Emotion Code, whose idea of a “heart wall” built around trapped emotions gave the event its name.
Examples discussed
- Avatar: Jake has to confess to the Na’vi that he was a spy. The darkest moment and the fall of the heart wall happen together in one of the film’s most intense scenes.
- Jumanji: Welcome to the Jungle: by the water, Bethany talks with Alex, and Spencer and Martha confess their feelings. Spencer realizes Martha likes the nerd inside him, not his avatar’s muscles, answering the principal’s question of who you want to be.
- Edward Scissorhands: two heart walls fall. Kim’s comes as she dances in the snow from Edward’s ice sculpture, paying off old Kim’s opening story. Edward’s comes in “Hold me.” “I can’t.” Just before, the final flashback shows his inventor dying as he offers Edward real hands. In a tragedy, the realization isn’t triumph: Edward doesn’t belong here.
- Also: The Muppet Movie, Pinocchio’s Blue Fairy, The Wizard of Oz, and the Eels song “Beautiful Freak.”
Writing along with the season? Write three pages for your hero’s fall of the heart wall, or take 15 minutes to free-write the most dynamic one you can imagine.
Read the full transcript
Transcribed automatically, so expect the odd misheard word. Sponsor messages are left out.
Adam: In this episode, we explore the story event Fall of the Heart Wall. What wall has your hero built around their flaw? How did they come to terms with it and disassemble this to find their true self and courage? Next on StoryOsophy. Hello, welcome to StoryOsophy. This is Adam Jones. And Devin Halden.
Devin: Continue with what you were saying when we were talking off air. We talk about it all the time in the podcast. We always say it’s really important for screenwriting because of page count and length. For every story, every scene, there needs to be a reason why it’s there. And there’s no junk or throwout scenes because you’re trying to connect or you have to move the story somewhere. Or you have to change pace because it’s like, and it’s like dancing. You know, where there’s moments of dance, especially like when you’re, well, it could be group dance or duets or just single dance. But when. When you’re dancing the move and then you’re transitioning, you’re moving to another move.
Well, some dancers will just run or dance or run or walk or something. They’ll just physically move to another spot and then they’ll start doing another move of whatever that dance is. But there’s also a story that needs to be told between one move to another move that transition. It’s what you’re doing in between the main. The main event of the, or the main moves that connects the story together. And that’s with story too. You need to, there’s big events that are happening. There’s big things that you, whether you’re with Blake Snyder and you’re going by beats or you’re with us and we have that, we have our default events, our Story Blueprint events.
Or there, you have another outline or you have these things in your head that you’re like, this has to happen and this has to happen. But that doesn’t mean moving from big event one to big event two. You’re just trying to figure out. How to get there or you’re just trying to, you know, you’re just moving the characters from one place to another in between there is another dance. Like there, you need to every scene and every bit of dialogue.
Adam: Needs to have meaning behind it. And the meaning is typically moving the story and connecting the audience to, to the story. Like if you have a symbol or something that is meaningful that, that you’ve imbued with meaning in your story and can be anything from a charm bracelet to a special treasure or anything, right? Your audience has to put their emotional stuff into the thing. Exactly. And so if you can build the. And the character’s emotional states around your symbols, then when you show the symbol, you don’t have to say so much. Your audience is going to feel and think what you’ve set up with the narrative their own way, just through the image of something. You don’t need the people, the actors to express with their faces, how they’re feeling because your audience will be doing that. Right.
It’s one of those things you want to do with the audience all the time anyway, which is engage them in some way in their mind. Questioning things or in their emotional state. And of course, a horror movie fear is easy. That’s the easiest one. Just keep them scared. But there, there are many nuance and emotion that you can connect your audience with or get them involved with outside of just that, you know, suspense and danger and that stuff. And symbols is a great way to do it, but they have to, there has to be meaning connection to not random.
Devin: Almost, you need to have a different perspective of what those are opportunities to strengthen a character or strengthen the internal battle that this character is having with that obstacle inside them, or use it at, use it for some clever subtext to strengthen some other part of the story while you’re moving the story forward to that next, that next big event. Because of course it’s always fun and this season We’re focusing on some of the main events of your story, of the story. We’re talking about the hook and the refusal of the car to call the quest and things like that. So, we’re focusing on that. But in between these events that we’re talking about, you don’t want to stop dancing and walk to those next events, that next event.
Connective tissue. Exactly. And you want to continue the dance from one event to the other. You don’t just want to move from one event to another. So within that. Even though the big dance move isn’t happening, there’s something that needs to be beautiful and something that needs to be moving the story along and taking advantage of that connective tissue to actually further something, to set something up or to strengthen your character’s issues or you can strengthen the B story.
Adam: Or even the world. Or the world, yeah. You could strengthen the world building. So even the connective tissue that he’s talking about. With the in-between bits, you can have something happening that’s world building early on in your movements and the audience will take that for granted. It takes place in a school. So we hear the bell ring and we see kids walk through the hall. It’s a setup shot. It’s a meaningless thing. But if the way the kids come in the school has importance, a pivotal moment in the climax that the, you know, whatever’s happening, someone’s taken for granted. And they use it to their advantage. You can set that stuff up in that connective tissue. Well, we need to show the kids coming into school because we need to know that’s where they’re going.
And so you have an image of, you know, kids getting off the bus. What are your options? But figure out the one that is the most engaging. But you can always backwards develop these little setup connective tissue bits.
Devin: Absolutely. That’s usually how they’re done too. Yeah.
Adam: Yeah, exactly. That’s what we were talking about, you and I, Devin, off-air when we’re storying the – script we’re working on now is some of the stuff that we’ve figured out further in the story that’s strong, locked down. We have to go back to earlier bits and the setups, we have to condense them, reduce them so that they have an essence and we’re done with them. So that you forget about it. And then when they pay off later, you’re like, oh, of course. You’re not expecting it because you’re not paying attention to the connective tissue. You’re paying attention to the muscle. You’re paying attention to each event, the big links in the chain of events.
And so you can plant these great setups in those bits and then have them be part of the bigger payoffs at the end. But yeah, backwards developing is a lot where you build it. But don’t be afraid to write something down like a really stupid description that lets you know, oh, it’s a house. It’s two stories. It’s got a garage. Okay, you can do better. But that’s all the information you need right now. And maybe the scene will tell you what to do next. What type of house it needs to be. And maybe the scene will tell you how many cars you need in that garage. Just know it starts simple.
Devin: And don’t sit there and try to come up with the perfect scene with the perfect dialogue. Get the meat down. It’s almost like a game. What is that game? Plinko? Yeah. Where you drop the thing front and top. That’s how you have to do when you’re writing. You’re like, oh, that stuck me. I’m stuck here. But I’m not going to just sit here. I’m going to bounce off that. I’m going to go wherever my imagination. It’s going until I get to the end. And then I’m gonna go back up. I’m going to do it again. And then I’m going to figure out where, you know, how to make it, you know, stronger and stronger and stronger.
Adam: It is true. There is a repetitive process like that where you you run it back through in your mind. You’re like, okay, does it work now? Does it work now? It’s fun. And the polish is fun. Tesla used to do that. Yeah. Tesla would imagine the entire machine in his mind and where gears needed to be. And for those of you who don’t know, Tesla’s a fantastic inventor. But he would imagine. The way that the whole thing would have to be the mechanism in his mind before he’d even start to draw it. And then he draw out how it needed to be built. And so he’d figure it all out in his mind. He pictured in his mind. And that’s I mean, that’s sort of what you do with story. Same thing. You’re like, all right, let me run this scene through. All right, that’s pretty. That’s basic. We know we need a, you know, an engine here, a rotor here. That works. Okay. And then you run it and you’re like, oh, wait a minute. This is good. And we’re gonna need a belt here. Like you do that with characters. You do that with their intent.
What’s the setting? How many of them are in this thing? Is there intense conflict? Is it or is it a recovery scene? You can sort of run it through in your mind. Play it out. That’s fun.
Devin: Yeah. I like going back. I like the polished part. I like going back and tweaking it. The puzzle, you know, the putting like the tweaking the setups. And that’s always, it’s always fun when you find that perfect setup solution. Yeah. Where you strengthen it and you’re like, yeah, you’re like, oh, this is. Yeah. This would be, this makes that payoff so much better. Yeah.
Adam: Yeah. Even stuff like when we were talking about the story we’re working on, like there are discoveries we’ve made about the story. We think we know the story and then there are discoveries we make and we’re like, oh my gosh, that makes it so much better.
Devin: Yeah.
Adam: And so it just elevates the entire way you’ve been building and you’re like, oh, okay, this is, this enriches whatever that was. But you, that’s the weird thing, man. I love getting to this state where there’s, you’re, you’re immersed enough in the story. You’re immersed enough in the story world. You can have comprehensive conversations about it.
Devin: Right.
Adam: You can talk about the details now, but at the same time, even though that’s fun and it’s very exciting to be there when you’re approaching a new draft, in my mind, you’re never really approaching white pages, blank pages. You’re always approaching structure first. Right. You’re like, okay, let me, let me take my ideas. Let me, my best ideas and make them events. And we’ve talked about this in the podcast. This is helpful. We’ve talked about this before. Is when you know something about your story, you know, there’s a chase scene at the end, or, you know, that you want to start with a chase scene or that’s a good hook. You go, okay, I want to chase. Where do I think it falls in this? Well, just put your card in that movement. Once you have about five cards, approximately, most of them are five, like five events in your movement, that movement’s done in structuring form.
So when you get to the page, to the blank page, it’s not, you’re not just starting with nothing. You’re going with a lot of excitement to that blank page, you know? Yeah, I love this polish stage too.
Devin: And this is usually when kind of what happened to us when we were working on the script yesterday was. This is, once you have a little bit more meat is when you can start playing the what-if game. And that’s always fun too. And I think it’s an important exercise to not be so locked in on the path of your story, the path of your character and say, well, what if, what if all of a sudden this story became about the antagonist?
Adam: And it’s easy to get locked in. It’s easy to get locked in. Yeah, definitely. You’re like, it’s done. I don’t want to think about it.
Devin: Yeah. But then you started asking your questions, those questions, all of a sudden you open up all of these different roads that you can go on. Just even, even if you know, it’s not going to be the route you’re going to go. It’s fun to go and explore down there and say, wow, that really opened up a completely different level for my antagonist. Yeah. You can, or any character. Yeah. You can, you’re like, wow, I can. And then you can use that, that new knowledge or the new insight you’ve gained about your antagonist just by exploring that route. To strengthen him or use it to kind of maybe beef up some of his scenes or some of his, his objectives that, that he’s going after. Cause that’s always fun to the other fine. We’ve talked about this before. Isn’t when you’re certainly when you have a hero versus antagonist scene where they’re sitting at the same table or they’re just, that’s the main, the main head to head scene.
It’s always fun to play at both sides where you are. You’re actually going to turn the antagonist into like, they’re going to get their objective here rather than the hero somehow manipulating or what, you know, whatever, where you just completely change the dynamic of the scene and the outcome of the scene and just see where it leads. Because then you get to understand a little bit more about who, who your antagonist is. You should always put yourself in those shoes at some point and all your characters, you know, like even, even some of the just allies.
Adam: So what if we add this character? What if this character happened to be in this scene? Yeah. Like what if they came with them? Yeah. How does that change? How does that change the dynamic of the scene? Does it improve it? Every once in a while, you’ll get those, those discoveries where you’re like, oh, wait a minute. If the antagonist does win here, this would happen. Or maybe they almost win. And that’s part of the ups and downs in your scene itself. Right. You think this is happening and then it’s this, but you wouldn’t explore that unless you sort of, you’re trying to do one of two things, either expand the idea or connect some dots.
You’re measuring out your equations. If you’ve got a setup for this, you have to have enough of a reminder for a payoff or like we’re saying to track a character’s arc across these movements. You want to think of these movements as great measurement tools. So every movement, the character has some growth point, whether they realize it or not, because the movement we’re talking about this week, movement four is the growth movement, but they may not get it until this movement. And usually they don’t. Movement one is about, you know, moving them out of their comfort zone into the out of comfort zone. And then after movement two, sort of just figuring it out. And movement three is more experienced, but not quite there. And usually tripping and falling and making a pretty hefty mistake. And then that they need to learn from in movement four, this growth point, but you need to be able to track that across those first three movements so that the character doesn’t know yet.
Because they’re discovering themselves. And the audience doesn’t know yet. And so that’s the that’s the connect the dots bit that that really needs to happen. Per the example that this project that Devin and I’ve been working on, we’ve been doing this backwards developing into movements one, two, and three, because, I mean, because first crack of the day. Yeah, baby. I figured it was gonna be you. But no, it was me. Oh, my money was on you.
But you can track that if we backwards develop. So that where we want now, now we’re at a place where we know where we want the characters in our story to arrive, and approximately when. And what I mean by arrive is their arc, they discover themselves. Before that, you’ve got three movements, where the audience and two, I’m feeling very nervous, like a teenager sweating, so that your audience can track the characters choices and understand what the growth point is. So that when you sort of reveal these, this growth bit, they’re like, They’re like, oh, of course, but they didn’t know it and neither did the character.
So we backwards develop so we can sort of plant it all underneath the surface. When we talk about this too with the first draft thing, just write it down, get it on the page, make them say whatever they’re going to say. If they’re going to fight, have them say blatant stuff, but write it obvious. And then second draft, when you’re going through and fix it, push it down beneath the surface, tuck it in so that they don’t notice for the first three movements. We haven’t officially started this episode yet, but maybe we should get to it. This week, we’ll be talking about the event fall of the heart wall.
This is a good one. I like this one, too. I enjoy this event a lot, especially in connection to last week’s event. Yes, definitely. They complement each other. I agree. A quick review where we’re at. We were just talking about how movement one through three are sort of, the character doesn’t really know how they’re growing yet. And in four, they really take that it’s an internal movement, movement four, and they’re taking that into account, and they’re sort of implementing it. Just so we’re all on the same page of how we got here, act one or movement one of your story, act one is the known world, and movement one we call comfort zone to out of comfort zone.
They’re the same thing. You can start to think of that as the same thing. But in a traditional sense, act one is the known world, and act two is the unknown world. So the threshold at the end of movement one is crossing from the known world of your everyday routine and, as we say, comfort zone. Into the quest of the story, the journey of the story, the unknown world of act two. And then we pick up with movements two through four. And movement two is from out of the comfort zone, where we’ve left off, and we take your hero from there to the danger zone. And this whole movement we like to call first day of school.
It’s just learning about the unknown world. Movement three is the danger zone to the crisis, or you can think of it as a build to your crisis. And when we say crisis, there’s many ways to view it, but in traditional storytelling terms, it’s like the climax before the climax. It’s the half-climax. So that’s the traditional term. We use it, but we have many different names for this event. You’re building to this central sort of midterm exam, and the climax is the final. And they can succeed here, but most of the time they fall short, your hero or your hero’s team. And then what happens?
And then what happens? And then we’re into movement four, which is from crisis to recovery. And this is where they start. This is the more internal aspect of your hero’s journey, your hero’s arc. And we use the term hero loosely. We also say protagonist, but it’s nice to think of yourself as a hero. Track your own mind through these events. We’re here in movement four, and zooming into movement four. I won’t do it for the other movements. There’s plenty of episodes starting with 42, 41, 42. You can go back and check out the previous events. But this one is from crisis to recovery.
This one from the crisis, we have escape. Event two is aftermath. Event three is hero’s darkest moment. Event four is where we’re at this week, fall of the heart wall. Five is reassessment, the goal refocused. And then the sixth one crossing the threshold for this specific movement is the re-choosal of the quest, which mirrors movement one, as we’ve been saying. You want to look at movement one and movement four together, because that’s where you’re going to be. That’s where you’re going to be. As we were saying before, find the connective tissue, find the symmetry. That’s the movement that’s a balance for it.
Devin: I think what’s important to keep in mind is this typically is connected, or at least comes very close with to the hero’s darkest moment. I like to do it one right after the other. I think that will usually have the most impact, and it just makes the most sense.
Adam: That’s why our sort of… Base thing is they’re side by side here. You can move these. These are movable floaters.
Devin: Where our hero’s darkest moment kind of marks the darkness within our hero that they must address before they can move on with the quest.
Adam: Yeah.
Devin: Before they’ve been able to push it down, push that internal issue, internal obstacle down. Now they’re forced to address it before they can move on. The fall of the heart wall then marks… The true turning point of our hero becoming our hero. So our hero, lowercase hero, H, becoming our hero, uppercase H, hero. Visually in my mind when I’m writing this, I literally visualize this first, like a speck of light in the darkness that’s symbolizing the true change of my hero. So it’s almost like if we, in hero’s darkest moment, our hero is…
Adam: And sometimes those moments, a specter of the mentor, if the mentor has died, will pop in.
Devin: Mm-hmm. Yeah.
Adam: The fairy godmother in Pinocchio, the blue fairy, like they’ll show up and be like, hey, it’s not over yet. Right. And it’s that little ray of light that you’re saying. If you imagine from Fall of the Heart Wall, if you imagine that ray of light sort of coming through a cracking wall, and then the wall starts to disassemble. Yeah. Yep. That’s the feeling place you want. It’s a dark cave. And then, but that’s a great analogy, that little beam of light. We’ve talked about this throughout the podcast.
Devin: Set this event up throughout the story. This is one of those events that. Oh, yeah. You want to make this moment of, in your hero’s quest, impactful and perhaps very emotional, depending on what your story is. But we want it emotional for the audience. Our audience has been with our hero throughout the entire quest. They’ve learned with them. They’ve learned about them. They should care about them. And should be rooting for them to succeed at this point. And so if our audience does care about our hero, and they do want them to succeed, then the hero’s darkest moment and Fall of the Heart Wall will be transformative for both our hero and our audience.
So they’ll hurt for our hero in the darkest moment. And they may relate to them. You know, they may bring them back to something that makes them a little uneasy and makes them relate. Yeah. This emotional bit. Then we do want them to feel joy when our hero fights that darkness and finds that light. It emerges and emerges and changed. It changed hero or emerges and is transformed. Because in a way, we’re going to kind of feel that way too. I mean, if they don’t, then that’s when you want to kind of, or if you don’t feel that, like as you’re writing this, like this needs to be more impactful.
Or this needs to be more, not emotional. But depending on what it is, but it needs to have an impact.
Adam: Connective, relatable, like it needs to really. Relatable for sure.
Devin: Yeah. And if it doesn’t, then that’s when you go, that’s what we talk about. Go back and be like, how can I beef this moment up? How can I make this moment so much more important and obviously more important for my hero? Go back and polish that up or strengthen that. It’s usually happening when, in those moments when we’ve talked about before. Where we’re highlighting their internal obstacle and that’s kind of that relatability between our hero and our audience.
Adam: If your characters aren’t paying off here, if the audience is not connecting, you need to give more depth and dimension. So you need to basically go back and make your characters a little bit more human so that they are endeared to your audience in some way.
Devin: Yeah.
Adam: Connect, the audience can relate. It’s familiar. Maybe this person is, you know. A humorless, tough guy, the whole story, but you’re like, gosh, I really want something to happen. What if I give them one brief moment of humor, just one in just the right place? You want to layer that in. And now it’s like, oh, I can relate to this, but I thought they were, you almost are starved for that moment with that character because their flaw seems to be that they’re humorless. But if you can give those dimensions to a character. And it doesn’t have to be much. You can do the illusion of an arc just by giving a character two different viewpoints or two different emotional states.
And there’s a simple arc. Right, right. But if you want to drive them deeper, you got to go, well, how? Because human beings are complex. And so if you’ve drawn a really simple version, it’s just give them a different dimension and not arbitrarily. You don’t just go, well, I think that I’ll, you know. Yeah. Or an interesting suit that’s like this connected to your story, build out of what your story needs and try to find a different dimension for it. Because then that’s what we’re saying about the whole connective tissue. You’re weaving the entire story world together. Now, everything is related to everything else. And that’s your viewer, reader, audience is looking for meaning in the story.
Entertainment, sure. Absolutely. But surprise them with a little meaning. Give them something that they can sink their teeth into a little bit. And this area, we’re talking about the hero’s darkest moment into Fall of the Heart Wall. This is where you can do it. This is where you can, you know, I was thinking about this before we, later we’ll talk about the examples Jumanji and Edward Scissorhands, but one thing that popped up for me with this was Avatar, this particular moment, Heroes Darkest Moment, Fall of the Heart Wall. And Heroes Darkest Moment, frankly, is he has to tell this entire tribe that he lied to them. He was becoming part of them, and he’s actually a spy for the military aspect of the people who are trying to take over their jungle. And he has to tell them all that, and he does, and it’s hard, it’s terribly courageous, because he’s being very, you know, that’s a courageous thing to do, especially after the lie, but it’s all going to go to hell, and he knows it.
There’s no, there’s no damage control here. You can’t have him be the only one who understands the military enough to fight back. And so the Fall of the Heart Wall and Heroes Darkest Moment is right here in this showdown with him. Do you know this scene I’m talking about?
Devin: Yeah. Oh, yeah.
Adam: And. Not, I haven’t seen it for years, but. It happened to be on TV, and that area was, and I was like, oh, this is what we’re talking about on the podcast. Let me just watch it. And it’s really well done, because it breaks your heart. Yeah. Because it breaks her heart, because there’s, their romance is, it’s a strong character dynamic. But you’re like, oh my God, he let all these people down, but he’s, he’s brave enough to tell them, and they’re never going to understand. And so the feeling that he is feeling in Heroes Darkest Moment, we’re made to sort of feel with him, because he’s kept this secret with us for this entire tale. And now he has to tell them, and we’re cringing with him. It’s really well done as far as getting your audience to understand.
Yeah. And I was like, ooh, this is a good one. Fall of the Heart Wall.
Devin: Right.
Adam: Or that’s Heroes Darkest Moment, but Fall of the Heart Wall is, it’s almost one and the same in that event.
Devin: Yeah.
Adam: Like, he’s letting it down, and it’s the worst thing that he can do, and it’s the worst thing that can happen to him, but he has to do it. And I think that’s what this is about anyway, is courage. The fall of the Heart Wall is finding courage.
Devin: Well, it is. It’s the courage to finally face. It’s your internal, that internal obstacle, internal fears, internal whatever it is, that keeps getting in the way.
Adam: You’ve recognized it in the last event, and now here’s the courage to face it.
Devin: Yeah. And this is finally where you are fed up. You’re done. You’re done listening to it. You’re done letting it affect you, and so this is where you change. This is really, if you want to cut your character’s story into two, this is the beginning. Of the second half of your character’s story because they’re transforming into the true person that they are, the true hero that they were meant to be, and this is the beginning of that, and it should be noticeable to the other characters if they have their allies or those other characters with them and our audience, so they should both see and feel the change.
They may look the same physically, of course, but there’s something different. I kind of see the next event, the reassessment of, in the goal refocused, is kind of the moment when the hero rejoins the group, if it’s a group thing. So that’s when they’re going to notice it. It’s probably maybe the next, the events coming after this.
Adam: Yeah, like the Kermit Kermit Campfire. Another analogy we were using. Exactly. He returns to the group at the campfire from being alone with his thoughts.
Devin: So they’re different. And arguably, this is our hero’s most important decision point. Because as we discussed in previous episodes, as our hero has been moving through their quest, we’ve been taking away options for them at decision points. In Movement 1, in our hero’s known world, we presented them with a call to quest. At that event, our hero has several options. They can refuse the call and just stay in their known world. They can accept the call. You know, and be brave and move into the unknown world or they could do nothing. And then when our hero accepts that call, they find themselves in the unknown world. They also have several options. They could quit and they could go back to the known world. They could freeze. They could do nothing. Or they could just die in the unknown world.
No, yeah, this freeze and die. Or they could continue on with the quest. And so at different decision points of our story, we’ve been removing these some some choices from our hero, it’s always give up or keep going. And to varying degrees, the choice of turning back and, and, and are going back to the world of status quo. At some point, we removed that I can’t remember exactly where we moved it. But going back, that was removed. So then it left the choices of stasis or which would ultimately end in death. You know, it’s give up.
Adam: Usually the crisis is the final one. Like once that happens, it’s it’s done for sure. Even if it’s not been maybe before that it’s been Jumanji, they are in the game from the beginning, right? You know, so their options get taken out immediately. But they could do the they could do what Nick Jonas does doesn’t play.
Devin: Right, exactly. And then we so then we get to our last this, this event. And I think this is why I probably would say this is one of the more important decision points, but or heroes darkest moment. I guess, in my opinion, it this because this marks the final moment, our hero has a choice between quitting and dying, figuratively or literally, depending on your story, or defeating that internal obstacle and rising from the ashes, and taking on the external antagonist head on and completing the quest. Now, death is still a possible outcome. Death, however, literally or figuratively, but it’s not one chosen by the hero at this point.
Because the fall of the heart wall is that, like we said, that ember in the ashes that transforms our hero into our hero, you know, are you? Yeah, yeah, little h, big H. And so not we now remove the choice of quitting. And the only choice in our hero’s mind is to rise and to defeat the antagonist and complete the quest at all costs. So the possible outcome is different than decision or different than choice. Because right now they at this stage of the game, this is kind of why you can mark it as a choice. You can’t mark this as the second half of your of your heroes, heroes story. So now the only in their mind, the only choice is to defeat this antagonist or to complete this quest at all costs, no matter what happens. And they whether it’s, it ends in success or ends in defeat.
Adam: This event is not about necessarily the commitment to it, because the commitment to it is the sort of the next two events, the reassessment refocus of goal. Mm hmm. This one is just about. Mm hmm. It’s about the rebirth, rebirth, death and rebirth. That’s what the sort of way you want to think about these moments. Yep, that’s a good, good way to look at it. And a lot of what this movement is, too, is like you’re it’s a it’s a it’s a want to return home, but you can’t. So you’re going to have to build that here. And what I mean by home is just the comfort zone, the known world routine. That’s long gone.
Yeah. And right now, you just want a little bit of ease. And so the campfire scene is basic necessities, food, fire, sleep. That’s what this is about, figuratively, in most stories, but some literally like the Muppet movie with Kermit. Like we said, don’t always think of these events, even though when we’re saying they slow down, or this is the growth movement, or don’t think slow, because you don’t have to. Avatar, this is one of the most intense scenes in the whole movie. Because you’re really emotionally wrapped up. And this payoff of he’s got to confess the lie. But here is darkest moment, fall the heart wall. It’s, there’s fights, there’s arguments that like, it’s crazy in that movie. So don’t think it has to be so quiet and introspective. It can be really dynamic.
No, no. In romantic comedies, it tends to be quieter, but
Devin: And just like the movement one, like you’re saying, movement one, movement four, these can happen very quickly, too. Yeah. Like the call to a question. The call to a quest, refusal of the call to a quest, refusal of the call to a quest. They can happen within a sentence. Per your story. And so this can, too. Someone can say something.
Adam: Yeah. Whatever your story, whatever your story needs, whatever it needs at this moment. You can compress an event to like a half page. It can be five pages long. Sometimes you don’t know. Yeah. We’re saying three page approximate because it’ll get you to your desired page length for a finished draft. But you can stretch them or compress them, whatever suits your story. Right. Exactly.
[Sponsor message]
Adam: They’re intuitive. They’ll get it. They can relate to this part because everybody has something that they feel bad about. Meaning they feel like an antagonist. They feel like a force of antagonism. So there’s that dark night of the soul aspect. Even if it feels lost, it’s like as simple as this. I’m a failure. Well, failure is an antagonist. Failure is a villain. And it’s an easy one to fall into if it’s an introspective human thing is you can beat yourself up with self-doubt and failure. And that’s it. It’s all over. That’s what Nick Jonas does in Jumanji. Part of that is just integrating that. So this whole chunk, this really important middle point character arc wise is integrating your shadow. So in archetypal philosophical language, the shadow would be your antagonist.
But we’re referring here to the internal aspect of that. Integrating your shadow. And then understanding I have the capacity to just be weak-willed and not continue with the journey or fail if it’s just as simple as self-doubt. And then something goes, yes, you can. I believe in you. This is why you need to do this. Some voice, whether it’s your own or a mentor character or symbolically represented in the ray of light Devin’s talking about, that’s where you go. I accept the fact that I have the capacity to be sad, be angry, self-doubt. Whatever the internal conflict of that character is. And then step above it. Or here you’re not really doing it, but you’re being willing to step above it. You’re being willing to change.
This is the threshold of change. Dark night of the soul and fall of the heart wall. Here you’ve committed to change internally. And the key word here, like we’re saying, is courage. Courage. Because it’s the catalyst. It’s the transition point is that which I do not know, I’m no longer afraid of. I will be courageous enough to explore and integrate and change. That’s the fulcrum bar, the cliff side here. And it’s almost like a cliff. Here is darkest moment. It’s like leaping into the abyss and having faith in something.
Devin: I think this is where the hero realizes. I go back and forth between this fall of the heart wall and then reassessment or goal refocus. But I think this is where they realize what they really want. This is where that. Perspective changes for them where they’re like, what have I been doing? Like, I’m chasing the wrong thing.
Adam: Yeah. Is it this one or is it the next one? Event wise? Yeah, yeah.
Devin: Yeah. They kind of go hand in hand.
Adam: But that’s why they’re linked. They’re completely linked together. They should connect.
Devin: Yeah. And I think the reason I, and I think that’s the best way to do it. But the reason, I think it, I think they realize it here and then they take action based on what they, that realization in the net, in the goal refocus.
Adam: I would say fall of the heart wall is the internal and the next one reassessment is sort of like stepping back into the real world.
Devin: Yeah. It’s a plot, plot focused.
Adam: Yeah. You step back into the environment in the real world. But yeah, I would agree with that because this is all, these are both internal events, but if it’s happening like an avatar in the present moment, there is not an introspective and then the next introspective, but still internal. Absolutely. That’s a weird one because they, they smashed together heroes, darkest moment of all the heart wall in one thing. But what you’re saying with fall of the heart wall and reassessment, the, the event after it. Yeah. There are times when they, they’ll, they blend together. Yeah. And a lot of these will blend together. And, and like I’m saying, when they compress it in a lot of movies, you see from, but I wouldn’t say it’s from, yeah, from escape to rechoosal. It’s very short. They try to keep that short.
Yeah. Because they don’t want to lose the audience and they’re not inventive enough to figure out a way to do movement forward dynamically, you know? So it’s like, there’s, there’s not a discovery growth point. And, and let’s just say this too. This is a really important thing to point out. This fall of the heart wall discovery stuff between this and. Yeah. Heroes, darkest moment. This is not where it is all figured out. This is just where they figure it out. Right. What I mean by that is in movement six, the threshold between movement five and six is what we call breakthrough. And then now we’re never the breakthrough and now we’re never moment. You want to leave a little bit of a discovery. They almost know everything like 99%. And then the breakthrough moment is where the 1%.
Yeah. So they’re encouraged enough here in movement four that they continue on and like, okay, I got to go into the climax. I got to continue on. But you want to leave some bits unresolved. This is not the end of your story. This is just your hero’s inner discovery.
Devin: No, no, no.
Adam: We may not realize what they have discovered and they may not have figured out everything they need to figure out. There are, you want to set all that stuff up until except for a punchline or a button of what this is, what they’re discovering. Mm-hmm. And it’s as simple as this. For those of you who are Marvel, and I won’t spoil this for anybody, it’s Endgame, because if you’ve read or seen articles, it’s Tony Stark’s moment of, I am Iron Man. Mm-hmm. It’s the climactic breakthrough now or never kind of stuff. Those bits are all set up and woven back through the story. That, they don’t have the impact, the one-liners, the punctuated moments in the climax, if you haven’t done your work here.
Right. Yep. Because you can’t do it. Now you’re at the end and you got to explain a whole bunch of crap.
Devin: Mm-hmm.
Adam: This is where you explain it, but you explain it in such a way that it’s emotionally engaging. It’s not exposition. But this is where you put it, folks. This is where you put the breakthrough now or never stuff. Mm-hmm. Because breakthroughs, it’s sort of like hero’s darkest moment. And fall of the heart wall are… They’re internal breakthroughs. Because our climax, we break it down into three parts. Showdown, breakthrough, and now or never. And breakthrough is sort of like your hero’s darkest moment bit. It’s a threshold where you’re not sure if it’s going to happen or not. And then there’s a discovery. And then in now or never, there’s also a discovery, but it is the courage to push it forward. But that’s all set up here.
Devin: Yeah. Hero’s darkest moment, fall of the heart wall are the hero’s battle. It’s almost like… Let’s pause what’s happening. Let’s pause the plot of the story. And this is when the hero takes on the internal antagonist, that internal obstacle. And this is the fight they have with it. So it’s like this mini climax fight right here when they have with them with internally. And when they defeat it, and they get through it, and they beat it. They’re not wrestling with themselves internally.
They have the discovery. Yeah. And then the breakthrough moment is more of a external antagonist, breakthrough and discovery, where, without having the fall of the heart wall moment without going through that hero’s darkest moment, that breakthrough could not happen, simply because they would never have gotten to that point.
Adam: They’ve danced with the shadow in hero’s darkest moment. So they they sort of understand who they’re up against now in the climax.
Devin: Right. So I think it’s internal versus external when it comes to that, because the end, the movement six is all it’s using the fuel of the of what we’ve learned through this movement. But it’s, it’s all plot driven. It’s all like the external stuff that’s happening, based on what, based on that battle they had, and they, they won within that internal obstacle in these two last, these last two events.
Adam: And we do, we do sort of expand, expand the Yeah. Movement five and movement six. So they sort of play like this. Movement five is build to climax. And so the threshold at the end is the climax itself and, and life or death threshold. And then movement six picks up with the climax and goes to resolution.
Devin: Mm hmm.
Adam: So, because everybody likes to, like, drop the climax near the end. And it’s like, you want the climax to be as close to the end as you can, and not have to do a ton of resolution. Mm hmm. Because if not, you lose. You lose your steam. Anyway, we take this event name, I want to put, give credit where credit’s due, because this book was fascinating to me. The book is called The Emotion Code, and it’s by Dr. Bradley Nelson. We take the, the Fall of the Heart Wall event title from this, because at least when I read this chapter, the Heart Wall chapter that he writes about, it was really impacting. The, the book, the summary of the book is essentially this. If you have something in your life happen, and you, and And you did not properly express the emotion or like you sort of like held it in and didn’t live it in the present moment.
Most of those things get trapped and you repeat those emotional, whether it’s trauma or you repeat it until you let go of it. Anyway, I won’t go into the book as much, but the Fall of the Heart Wall chapter had to do with the people who could not connect with other people, sort of with partners or at large with society. And to relay one story, which was the most interesting to me, he would find that they would protect themselves by building a heart wall, something that would guard them, protect them from something they feared or an emotion that may have been traumatic. One of the clients in the book that he spoke about was a woman who had been abused by her husband and they found out that her heart wall, this is psychological and subconscious heart wall.
Figurative, if you will, that it was built out of metal and they couldn’t find out what metal it was and they couldn’t figure out what it was built of, where it came from. And finally, he discovered that when after her husband had abused her one time and she was watching a program on TV, like some 60s sci-fi movie, and the military was trying to destroy this ship, this alien, this UFO ship, and it was indestructible. So she made her heart wall out. Out of the metal of that ship, that fictitious ship, psychologically. That was a mind-blowing example to me. But every character in your story will build up something so that they don’t have to expose their vulnerability and connect.
And that’s what this is about, is disassembling that. A lot of times it’s ego or a lot of times it’s been whatever loyalty was in the known world of Act One, Movement One. But this is where the splinter, that trapped emotion, that backstory comes to the surface. And they have to… They have to let go of it to move forward and grow. Anyway, I just wanted to give a little homage to Dr. Nelson and highly recommend reading this book. Fascinating.
Devin: Fascinating. Fascinating. It was fascinating. I’m going to read it twice.
Adam: Shall we example? Let’s do it. Both of these examples, they’re moved around a little bit. And that’s why we say these two are floaters. Because they can move to different movements or be spliced up in sort of part one, part two, like Jumanji does a little bit with Nick Jonas’s death. But Jumanji, welcome to the jungle. The Fall of the Heart Wall is the who are you stuff. It’s scenes that answer the principal’s thematic question. And this happens kind of late in Jumanji after they escape from the valley. It’s Bethany and Nick Jonas at the water’s edge and Spencer and Martha on their break. And Fridge interrupts Spencer and Martha to refocus the story for us.
And it’s like, I found the jaguar. He’s all angry. But that’s what this spans is once they escape, like I say, this gets moved a little bit sort of later. Because the refocus of the plan and the goal and all that stuff is sort of like the canyon. Jumanji does smaller. And so you can see in those smaller builds different movement structure.
Devin: What I liked about this way of doing it and just because they’re able to do it because they’re different people in this unknown world is the coming or the addressing of their internal obstacle or what they perceived as their obstacle in the known world. Like I’m a nerd. That thing that kind of has always somehow gotten in the way of Spencer. And Martha that comes to the surface here. So it’s there. This is when they’re addressing it. Like we’re talking about with the fall of the heart wall. This is they’re like, I’m done. I’m finally going to address this. I’m going to tell you how I feel.
Holy crap. I’m going to tell you how I feel. And then they have that really awkward kiss. It’s interesting because of who they are throughout this in this unknown world. Completely different that that contrast is actual actually a physical contrast for them. And then it’s almost like they fight to they fight for that person inside them that they are no matter who they are physically on the outside in this unknown world. They’re fighting for this nerd inside them that they even addresses. He’s like, you don’t like me just because of this all this because I’m this muscular good looking guy. She’s like, no, I love her.
I’m a nerd. I want a nerd. I like a nerd. And so that’s that that addressing that in that internal thing that and in a lot of times. This is a good example of a lot of times that internal thing that that we feel that the hero feels is a detriment or a negative thing to them up until this point. This is where they realize, no, no, this is my strength. This is something. This is who I am. Yeah. And so that’s where I think that’s what actually comes out here is like it’s not necessarily defeating something. It’s actually acknowledging something.
Adam: Yeah. What you just said, that might be the one of the keys to this event. Is it like so the last one is integrating your shadow, your teeth. You know, you got you got to stand up for yourself. You know, you got to stand up for yourself. And this one is about compassion. But it’s it literally is about understanding that maybe the thing that I have been taking for granted with myself, maybe my teeth are good. Maybe me standing up for myself is good.
So from connecting it from the dark night of the soul or the hero’s darkest moment to this. That’s that’s an important connection. But it’s like you’re saying it can be as simple as in this sort of action comedy adventure. Just going, by the way, you’re a nerd. I’m a nerd, too. And the thing that they’ve sort of criticized themselves for accepting who you are. Right. It’s acceptance. And it’s sort of the same thing that happens in Edwards situation is acceptance. Absolutely. Yep. But there’s another thing to this, too, that when you’re saying that, I realize confessional. Confessional. Confessional. The confessional is a big. Yeah. Sort of like we talk about pressure cooker.
That’s sort of what happens in this scene a lot. It’s not always. Yep. And we’ll do this in season three, too. We have we have tons of little names. Devin and I give scenes and tricks and things like that. And we’ll that’s what we’re doing in season three. It’ll be fun. So much fun because we’ll get to talk about tools and scenes and apply them. But the confessional is something that gets laid over for the heart wall all the time. Avatar. Does it example with Avatar, Jumanji does it in this example, and Edward Scissorhands does it. All of them do it, even though, like I’m saying, it’s not every movie, but just so happens that the I mean, it just so happens.
God, man. Three and oh, Devin, you’re killing me. You’re crushing me. Crushing you. But that’s a large part of what happens in this is if you haven’t said it after Hero’s Darkest Moment or All Seems Lost, if you feel like you have lost the romantic comedy love interest, this is when you say maybe not to them because that would be a breakthrough or showdown now or never moment, but to their best friend, I was wrong. I love them. I love them so much. I miss them terribly. Like, this is when you confess to them that you’re letting it all go. Whatever the stuff was in your past, you’re letting that go. You’re letting ego go because the connection with this person becomes more important. So it’s a confessional to someone else, probably not to them, although you can explore it. There’s never impossible. Yeah. Only options. What if? What if? What if it was a confessional? What if and what happens next? You keep asking those questions and you’ll get it right.
Edward Scissorhands, Fall of the Heart Wall. So I would say this has two parts for me.
Devin: Yeah, yeah.
Adam: And this may be for separate characters. And Devin and I tend to do this, especially now that we’ve gotten better shorthand and story building together, designing and building stories together. When we track characters’ arcs, we go, here is so-and-so’s call to adventure, and here is this other character’s call to adventure. So we track on a very complex. Complex level that we’re not really talking about in this season. We’ll talk about that in future seasons. But it’s a way to make sure that every character’s arc is dynamic. So what I would say is that the Fall of the Heart Wall happens for like two people. Fall of the Heart Wall happens for Kim in the ice sculpture scene, and Fall of the Heart Wall happens for Edward once he’s wandered around the neighborhood and has come back, and there’s the holding scene.
Right. There’s a payoff to most of the build this entire movie is him with his scissorhands, and she says, hold me, and he says, I can’t. And that’s the theme, the crux of this. That’s the internal world of this whole story. The psychologist in the crisis point, the escape point, basically gives you the entire plot, the psychological premise of the story. This is the emotional internal premise. Yeah. So much love to give, and yet he can’t do it in ways that these human beings traditionally find it acceptable. He can’t hold. He can’t. All he can do is create, but he can’t relate. Create, but can’t relate. Edward Scissorhands, t-shirts.
Devin: It’s on the poster. That’s it.
Adam: The ice sculpture. We’ve been promised snow from the beginning of the story. It didn’t used to snow here. And here’s where the, that big payoff. So it’s a payoff in Kim’s realization of the heart wall based on her opening narration as old Kim.
Devin: Right. And here’s what’s interesting with Edward, just because it’s a tragedy story.
Adam: Yeah.
Devin: His fall of the heart wall where we were, when we’re, we’re broadly talking about this event, and there’s this, this, the hero’s darkest moment where they become, they fall to ashes. Yeah. And then there’s this ember or there’s light shining through, and then there’s this hope and then this transformation that doesn’t necessarily happen in this tragedy, this story, because that realization for Edward is I don’t belong here. And I can’t, I just, this isn’t where I belong. His realization is I need to go home and I can’t, I want this so bad, but literally I can’t. Like, I can’t hold you. Hold me. I can’t. Yeah.
And so that’s, what’s happening here is he’s, he’s, his realization and his transformation isn’t becoming this hero that we were talking about it broadly with this event. It’s him understanding his place. And that’s the tragedy of it. It’s just, there is no option for him. He doesn’t, he, he just needs to get home.
Adam: I love how these two are great examples.
Devin: Yeah.
Adam: Yeah.
You want the heart wall to be something that’s dynamic for your audience. You want them to feel deep inside that the heart wall is important and valuable to your story. The fall of the heart wall, you want, it’s usually a place where you want self-discovery. I mean, it’s in the title. You can feel it when you say it because everybody’s got something that they’re, you want that to happen. And Edward Scissorhands, it doesn’t really. And that’s the tragedy of this fall of the heart wall scene. Like you’re saying is the thing that he wants and it would confess, I want this. They do. And the result is I can’t have it. And that’s tragic. If nothing is more tragic than that sort of place. But the important part with those two is more for Kim maybe is they let their guards down. And if you don’t get what fall of the heart wall means, that’s a great way to examine it with your hero and allies, with your hero.
And love interest with your hero and family, they’re trying to negotiate. This is it. The confessional, they tear the wall down. It’s letting your guard down to be vulnerable in order to make discovery. Because if not, if you’re not brave enough to fail, you’ll never succeed because you’re going to fail more than you succeed. It’s just the way it is. It’s trial and error. And this is self-discovery these moments. I can’t remember. I should have watched this right before we did this. The inventor flashback, the third and final inventor flashback happens just before Edward is asked to hold her. Am I right?
Devin: Oh, I don’t know. I can’t remember.
Adam: Damn it. Let’s assume it is. So right before this, or somewhere around here, the inventor presents Edward with hands in the final flashback. And so Edward’s backstory or known world routine, all this stuff is in flashback and backstories. And this is, for Edward, probably Hero’s darkest moment. It’s an additional aspect. This is something he’s carried with him. He lost his parental figure, his creator, God, his God, if you will, his only known person. And he also lost the thing that he wants, just like Scarecrow wants a brain and the Cowardly Lion wants courage. He wants hands. And as soon as the inventor gives it to him, the hands slide through his scissor fingers and he cuts them all to pieces. And his mentor’s dead.
And then, and that’s where we would pick up with Edward in the mansion at the beginning of the story is when Peg find him. The mentor’s been dead for a long time and Edward’s been on his own. But they choose to preserve this flashback till later, till right around here. Why? Because the contrast between Hero’s darkest moment and Fall of the Heart Wall, where she says, hold me, and he says, I can’t, has more impact here.
Devin: This is a great example of, like you’re saying, make it impactful and emotional for the audience because they’re like, oh my God, he was actually so close to having hands and everything would be
Adam: Different. And it’s the same scene, technically. Yeah. It’s, he’s so close to being able to hold somebody is the connection. The ironic tragedy there is what breaks our heart. And we know, oh, it’s like, he’s never going to get there. We still hope for him. But once he goes running crazily through the neighborhood and back to the mansion, we’re like, oh no, it’s Frankenstein. They’re after the monster. God, it’s such an awesome movie. Anyway. It is. It’s really awesome. We will continue to praise its weirdness and beauty. Or as the Eels say, beautiful freak. That’s one of my favorite Eels songs. It’s a good little tune, but that’s Edward. He’s one of those beautiful freaks.
That is. As always, we encourage… We encourage you to write your three pages. If something we’ve talked about during this episode has sparked some imagination in you for Fall of the Heart Wall, or even back to Dark Night of the Soul, or even forward, you know what your payoff’s going to be in your climax, breakthrough, or now or never moments. Write it down. It doesn’t have to be a fully fledged out scene. Just write down what you know. And just doing that will encourage your mind. You’ll be in the zone. Things will start coming to you. You’ll build off of that. You at least have a basic structure or basic ideas for when other things come to you. Take some time and sit down and try to write your three pages based on the Fall of the Heart Wall event. You can do it for the story you’re working on. If you’re not working on a story in particular, do a 15-minute free write. Just play for 15 minutes. Think of the best, coolest, most dynamic Fall of the Heart Wall scene you can think of. It may be the genesis of a new story.
Devin: This is when things can start picking up after the next… Start of the next event is when your story can start picking up a bit of pace.
Adam: This is the place to take a breather. We’re still in Eye of the Hurricane. And these next two, Reassessment and Rechoosal, these next two events, are about the hero saying, all right, I guess it’s time to step out of the Eye of the Hurricane. Time to step back into the fray. That’s right. But we’re going to do it with a plan, not reactively. Proactively. Proactive.
Please subscribe and rate us on iTunes. Follow us on social media, share with your friends, and send us your questions and comments. For additional resources and links to films, series, and books we talk about here, visit our website. While you’re there, sign up for our newsletter for updates on story building tools and special offers at StoryOsophy.com