Show notes
The hero’s darkest moment, also called the dark night of the soul, all seems lost or all is lost, sits in the middle of Movement 4. It’s the showdown between your hero and the internal obstacle that has haunted them the whole story. Devin calls it the death of the hero with a lowercase h and the birth of the Hero with a capital H. Adam and Devin explore what your hero is haunted by, why facing the shadow matters, and how Jumanji splits this event in two.
In this episode
- Choose the right name. All seems lost suits a hero who still has companions, like Kermit at the campfire. All is lost suits a hero who is left completely alone.
- The midpoint of your hero’s arc. The crisis is the middle of the plot; this is the middle of the hero’s change. Plan it, then go back and set up the internal obstacles that nearly defeat them here.
- What haunts your hero? That’s the source of your antagonism, even if it shows up in the outside world as a different person or force.
- Ask what they’d become. If your hero doesn’t let go of their flaw, who would they turn into? The fall of the heart wall that follows asks how they let it go.
- Cut the anchor. The obstacle doesn’t have to vanish. Your hero may learn to carry it or turn it into fuel, as the Hulk does with his anger or a performer does with stage fright.
- Weak will can lead to villainy. A hero who never speaks up can grow resentful, and resentment can turn tyrannical. This is where they say “enough is enough.”
- Good means choosing it. A person who has no option to be evil can’t really be called good. Show your hero the temptation, like Pleasure Island in Pinocchio, so they can see the contrast.
- Start with self-doubt. It’s relatable and specific, and it’s a strong go-to for this event. Guilt and shame are others, and the details will come as you write.
Examples discussed
- The Empire Strikes Back: in the cave on Dagobah, Luke defeats Vader, and finds his own face inside the helmet: he has the capacity to become the shadow. In Return of the Jedi, he refuses the dark side again and again.
- Jumanji: Welcome to the Jungle: part one comes when the heroes realize Alex, with his 1990s slang, has been trapped in the game for 20 years. Part two comes later, when he’s bitten by a mosquito with only one life left, and true death becomes real.
- Edward Scissorhands: after Jim interrupts his moment with Kim, Edward drags his blades down the hall and shreds the bathroom, his mentors’ property, a setup for what he’ll do to Jim in the climax. At the next dinner, Bill’s ethics quiz shows that, however hard Edward tries, he doesn’t belong.
- Also: The Muppet Movie, Jaws, Super 8, the documentary Blackfish, Black Mirror: Bandersnatch and choose-your-own-adventure stories, and Walter Isaacson’s The Innovators.
Writing along with the season? Write three pages for your hero’s darkest moment, or a 15-minute free write about a character struggling with self-doubt.
Read the full transcript
Transcribed automatically, so expect the odd misheard word. Sponsor messages are left out.
Adam: In this episode, we discuss the story event Hero’s Darkest Moment. How does your hero face their shadow or source of antagonism internally? What is this dark night of the soul really about? Next on StoryOsophy.
Hello. Welcome to StoryOsophy. This is Adam Jones. And Devin. And Halden. This is the first time I’m recording outside of my home studio, StoryOsophers. This is, I’m shooting something, I’m acting in something. And so the production company has put me up in a suite. I like suites, because they got the little kitchenette. Yes. But I don’t know how the sound quality is going to be, because it’s a new setup. So I’ve tried to… You know what, Adam?
Devin: It’s more about your dedication to the podcast that really impresses me. That’s what it’s about. I don’t really care about the quality.
Adam: I did actually pack my little foam screen. And my little windscreen and my mic. I did pack it in the car with, along with my stuff for the week.
Devin: Nice.
Adam: Oh, so I’m in here. I cranked up the AC in the hotel room. And then I realized, I’m like, what is that sound? What is going on around here? And I realized I had to unplug the fridge for the duration of the recording. Because it’s humming in the back.
Devin: I was like, oh, that’s it.
Adam: Oh, I hope you don’t have anything in there. I do. I have a little note to myself to plug it back in. It’ll be all right. The milk’s going to spoil. And I’m hoping they don’t have any rooms to clean nearby. Because there were, 10 minutes ago, there were looming maids and rooms around me. They always show up at the worst time. Yeah, I know. Vacuum cleaner. It’s like me carrying the curse of the lawnmower man from home. We’ll still mess with you.
This week, we’re going to be talking about one of the most interesting parts of a character’s journey. Important. Probably because it goes deep. Deeper than most of the events in general. Because this is sort of introspection time. This movement in general, movement four. We call it Hero’s Darkest Moment. We do have some alternate names. One of my favorites, which sort of goes back to metaphysical or spiritual exploration, the journey of the soul, is the Dark Night of the Soul. And we’ll explain a little bit of this, but also, Devin, I’m not sure if this is the one, the alternate that you like, but we also refer to it sometimes as all seems lost or all is lost. And both those have different connotations. But it’s great to think of that too, as an alternate title.
I think they’re all good. Yeah, they are really good.
Devin: And I think it also depends on the type of story you’re writing. So I think that’s when you kind of want to, which is kind of what we’ve done with some other events where, there it is, puberty right off the bat. Man, we didn’t even get off the launch pad.
Where we have alternate names and the reason we have alternate names aren’t because we’re very indecisive and can’t come up with names for our events. No, that’s not why. Yeah.
Adam: Yeah. That’s sort of the thing. That’s the reason why we use alternate names. Don’t let them fool you. Is every story requires something a little different. And it’s also the reason why when we talk about these movements and the sequence of story events, we say these are not concrete. You can move them around. You can shuffle them. Because that’s what makes a story unique and different. These components are great ingredients for a story. A strong story recipe, if you will. Nice analogy, Jones. Nice analogy. Thanks, man. In certain events, you do want a different flavor. Like, for instance, Hero’s Darkest Moment or Dark Night of the Soul doesn’t really apply to Kermit’s campfire scene in the Muppet movie.
All seems lost is really what that one is. And it’s not all is lost because he still has companions. He still has his allies. Not everything’s lost. All is lost is one of those moments where the hero is like a soul survivor and everybody, all the other allies are eradicated. And so it’s just alone, you know? That’s all is lost. Even though it really is all seems lost because you want that person to pull out of that and recover. It’s a slight variation, but the Muppet movie next to all of your allies are eradicated. Good contrast. Yeah, it was good. So just to review for a moment.
We’re working through Movement 4, the events of Movement 4, talking about the story architecture, story structure, your Story Blueprint, if you will. And I will. And Devin will. I’m just going to do a brief overview. Act 1 is the known world. Act 2 is the unknown world. And Act 3 would be your changed world in essence. So we start with Act 1, Movement 1. And Act 1 and Movement 1 are the same. Movement 1 is the subset. It’s you’re taking your character from the comfort zone of, you know, their normal everyday status quo, their known world routine, to out of comfort zone. Meaning there’s a new challenge.
There’s a new interest. You know, it doesn’t have to be something where there’s danger. It can be like in a rom-com, your hero falls in love or meets the person that they’re going to fall in love with. And hijinks ensue. So Movement 1 will set up your whole story. It’s the foundation. And then move you into Act 2, which is the unknown world. And Act 2 lasts a long time. So we break this up into Movements 2, 3, and 4. Sometimes that will get a little bigger. But we’ll talk about that at the end of Season 2. Act 2, transitioning from the known world of Act 1 and the comfort zone of Movement 1.
We start with Movement 2, which goes from out of the comfort zone and tracks your hero to the danger zone. And that’s just sort of like the stakes get raised a little bit. They have a brush with the antagonist. In a rom-com, the date didn’t go right. There are variations on it you can do. But it’s the first day of school. They’re learning everything about this unknown world or this new person or job or whatever. And they sort of, you know, are observing. Reactive, if you will. We then go to Movement 3. Movement 3 is from the danger zone to the crisis, the midpoint, the tipping point of your story.
Devin, fight, flight, or freeze? Love it. So, when you’re thinking about these, if you’re doing a story, a screenplay rather, think of each movement about 15 pages slash 15 minutes. You can do 20 to that, you know, 20 is a good number, but if you think of each of these events about three pages long, a traditional scene length, and that’ll fluctuate, this is what’s going to get you to your 90 to 120 pages at the end of your writing through these events. If you’re writing, you know, via our Story Blueprint challenge, event by event. At about movement three, if you’re doing a 90 page script, it’s going to be about 45 minutes in. And the whole reason I bring this up is, you’re measuring out how much time you’re spending on things so that you can look at it from that Story Blueprint bird’s eye view and see where things are occurring from an audience perspective. How many minutes in is this to me?
And we put the midranges. The midpoint centrally, even though a lot of stories and films will push that towards the end of act two, that’s more of a traditional Hollywood model. It’s moving that crisis closer to the end of act two. We think that a central crisis is very helpful for a story, an audience, your characters, because of this movement we’re in now, movement four. Movement four is from the crisis, the midpoint of your story, fight, flight, or freeze, to… The recovery part of your story. The events of movement four are as such. Coming from the crisis, usually there’s a big ordeal. The stakes, once again, become raised even higher than the danger zone. And that’s so the audience can track the amplification of the stakes.
So movement four is the escape from that threat of the crisis. Next comes the aftermath, which we spoke about last week. And here we’re at hero’s darkest moment. After hero’s darkest moment in movement four comes fall of the heart wall. Fall of the heart wall, which we’ll talk about in connection to this. And then the story event reassessment, goal refocused. And finally, the threshold for movement four, the re-choosal of the quest. So we’re about, almost about midway through movement four with this event, hero’s darkest moment.
Devin: Yes.
Adam: The point of this movement from earlier movements is the earlier movements are reactive. And as Devin said a few episodes back, we’re moving from reactive to proactive in the course of this movement. This is the last movement. Movement three would have been the movement of experience. They’re gaining experience. This one is the movement of growth. This is a very big internal introspective movement. And it doesn’t have to be boring and deep. And it doesn’t have to be so heavy that your audience is like, geez, Louise, I got to check out of this movie. You can have humor in it. You can do a lot of stuff with this movement.
Devin: Right. Good reveals too. But it’s really important. So it’s nothing to… Gloss over. Even if you don’t, even if it’s not a in-depth or a longer scene or sequence of scenes, it’s important to have planned it out. Because it’s, in my mind, this is kind of the, this is really the midpoint, not midpoint of the story, but the midpoint of our hero’s arc or whatever you want to call it, their change. Yeah. Because up until this point, we have been focusing on… Our hero going through experiences, but their internal obstacles or these internal things that have been haunting them or a unwanted companion their entire lives has always just gotten into, in the way. And our hero’s darkest moment is the, is the climax between the hero within our character that’s been fighting to emerge and that those internal obstacles, it’s, this is the showdown.
And it’s basically saying, Look, I’m either going to agree to live with you and have you interrupt and interfere with my life and me becoming my true self for the rest of my life, or it’s time to, it’s time to defeat you. And so, like I said before, what’s very important here is the setup for this moment. So it can be… You want this to be, you know, depending on what your story is, but you want this to be the, have the most emotional and impactful moments for both the hero and the story. So think about, think about who your hero is going to be after they rise from the ashes of this, their darkest moment, and then go back through your story and beef them up, beef up moments where you can, you know, with this in mind, beef up the moments when you can set up or shine a spotlight on those internal obstacles or struggles that will nearly defeat them here.
And then it makes, it makes that internal debate and this internal, this internal, showdown that they’re having with these things that keep rising to the surface at inopportune times, it makes it a little bit more, impactful to the story and to, and to who they’re becoming. I like to think of this, of it as the, this moment is like the death of our hero. Lowercase H and the rebirth of our hero, uppercase H. And it’s a, it’s an initiation that, that every hero must experience. And it’s one that quite literally takes them from one life to another is the way I try to look at it.
And I, it’s, it’s, that’s fairly dramatic and drastic, but that’s because I want this to be a very impactful moment for the, for our hero and the story. And of course, what’s really died is only the. Illusory identity, you know, it’s not in, it’s the, our hero is, is having an awakening and it’s the death of, it’s the death of the, of the old self and the birth of the true self. If you want to look at it that way.
Adam: The death of the old self is really an important aspect of this. Yeah. You know, because everybody’s got stuff in their life and in their mind, their belief system, their experience that does, it may have served them at some point to. Help them to learn something or move in the right direction. Even if that thing was something negative that repelled them and moved them in another direction, that thing still served them to grow to who they are now. Right. But remembering the lesson rather than integrating that, which was learned is the issue. And so you said a word that is extremely appropriate for this and really good haunting.
What are they being haunted by? That’s a really great way to look at this. Because it helps us to, to broaden this out a little bit and, and look at this in connection to the next event, Fall of the Heart Wall.
Devin: Right.
Adam: Because they really are, they, they, they pair. They, there’s a reason why they’re nearby each other. Even though in some movies, even Jumanji, they don’t necessarily happen right here. They take these and cut them in half and then put part of it here. They do something weird with it, which at least in my, in my notes, in my theory. Analysis. Right. In my analysis. Yeah. Good, good. Good call. Good word. The haunting. And I, I agree. I actually agree with that. Yeah. The, the, the haunting thing. So here’s, here’s the idea. What is the person being haunted by? Good question. Because that’s going to be the source of your antagonism.
Even if that antagonist didn’t even exist. Right. Exactly. That’s where it comes from. It just has manifested in the external world as this conflicting other force or person. Right. Because this person is judgmental. They’re going to pair with somebody who they can judge because that’s the, that’s the equation they’re asking for in the flaw.
Devin: Yes. The internal antagonist is what’s we’re focusing on within the, in this event and the external antagonist, which is more plot driven stuff is not what we’re dealing with at this moment. Not entire, not entirely.
Adam: Because this is like eye of the hurricane. We’re in the middle. We’re settled down a little bit, but that’s why it, even though it seems like it might get slower, this is a lot of this stuff gets heavy. If you, if you’re in a drama, your heroes will, you know, they’ll, they’ll go to the dark place. What, and what does it mean and why is it there? So the, the fall of the heart wall, if you think there’s a common nomenclature for stories where it’s like character flaw, the character’s flaw, right? I’m not a huge fan of that word. It annoys me, but you know what it means.
So it’s helpful to use in this context there, there’s something that will, that the character is using as an excuse to justify not growing, not changing, not fully leaving that comfort zone to become the new version of themselves. As Devin said, lower cage. So if you’ve got a decent story where you’ve got some reveals and discoveries for your character and your audience, this is where your character is going to figure out or come to terms with or see their flaw. And as we talked about an aftermath. Those are often places where if the allies are ever going to turn on each other, that’s around the area, they do it.
So someone might’ve pointed out just a little bit ago, what their flaw is. And now that it’s quote out in the open, now that it’s become physical experience, instead of just this person’s internal struggle. This person comes to terms with it. Your hero will come to terms with it. What is the character flaw is the big question that you’re gonna have plant from the beginning of this story, from movement one. Why are they holding themselves back? That’s it. When you get to the hero’s darkest moment, it’s kind of like posing the question, if my character doesn’t release this flaw, release this aspect, burn off the brush, burn off the deadwood, if they don’t let it go, what would they become?
Mm-hmm. Exactly. Right. That’s an interesting way to pose that. And then the fall, the heart wall is, okay, now the, you know, that same flaw in focus, how do they let it go? Right. What do they do to let it go? When I’m writing, another
Devin: Way I’m just, I’m always thinking about it is, and we’ve talked about this before, the internal obstacle of our hero has to be dealt with at some point before they can deal with the external obstacle of the external antagonist. And so, but up until this point, we haven’t really needed to deal with it or we’ve gotten by with trying to silence it, even though it keeps rearing its ugly head here and there. But now we’ve reached that point where We need to, it’s kind of like this. It’s kind of like, I have two examples. One is interesting, an interesting example. I’ll go with the non-interesting example first. But think about like an anchor is attached to your hero.
Throughout the entire story. They’re able to pull it and they’re able to continue to move forward, even though it’s just always there. And this is the moment where they’ve gotten to a point where like, there’s either they’re too exhausted. They can’t, they can’t pull this anchor anymore. They have to deal with it before they can move on. And so this is them turning around and basically figuring out a way to cut it, to release it from them. Now what’s important about that is, well, let me go to this first example and then I’ll say why I want to make. Sure. I’m making, being very clear of what I mean by that. This, another example is the, there, there used to be, and I don’t know if I saw it recently, but there used to be a, a commercial for anti-depression medicine on TV. That was a really good analogy of what’s happening here.
And it was basically some lady walking around going throughout her life. And I think there was like depression was just always with them and it was just following them. It was like a little, it was like a cartoon character that was representing depression. And they just kept following and following to the point where they just couldn’t stand it enough. And then the problem is with the commercial, they go to the doctor, it gives them a bunch of meds and then they just medicate it. So that I’m not saying that’s a good idea, but this thing, the analogy of it, they do a really good job of, of for people.
That can’t put words to it. They’re like, cause depression is a very, and their depression’s very related to this moment, but it’s, it’s a hard thing for people to explain to other people. It’s an intangible monster. Exactly. And so they put, they make it tangible within this commercial. I’m like, well, that’s a really good way for people to kind of explain is like, this thing is just like haunting me. It won’t leave me alone. And so I had to finally deal with it. Now, what I wanted to say here is remember that as our hero doesn’t have to completely defeat their internal obstacles to a point where they disappear. Right. And they may have a counterweight, some extraordinary real like realization or enlightenment that will make them make those, those obstacles bearable or, or diminish.
A bit, but it could possibly be under those internal obstacles could also be possibly understood by our hero in a way that they can utilize them now as a tool or somehow turn them into a positive, like the Hulk Hulk does it, or someone who has, has like a debilitating stage fright, but as they experience. What do you think? That used to be debilitating for them that would almost make them freeze. And they had to do had to get a different perspective of what it was. It’s all about turning it what it is, what it is now and turning it and what it is going to be or how it should be.
Adam: And part of it, especially if you look at the story journey in general here, and psychologically in everyday life, part of dealing with the fear is exposure. If the fear is something intangible, that is beyond you, fear of snakes, right? If you see if In order to get over your fear of snakes, and I’m not saying you need to subject people to torture because they’re scared of a thing, but the way to get over a fear is there’s no lack, according to Mark Twain, there’s no lack of fear, only the mastery of it. So, to get over a fear or something that is, you know, maybe you’re in denial about it, and that’s usually where the hero is in the case of this, is they’ve sort of shoved that flaw or troubling, haunting thing down to just survive and deal with everyday life, like everybody else does with certain traumas and negative experiences.
You let that go, but usually, in this stage, the character hasn’t truly confronted it yet. And so, per psychology, per laws of the universe, that thing has now become a physical entity in their physical experience, in order for them to be challenged by it and let it go. Not for it to continue to haunt them. The whole story about this hero starts internally here, with a tripping block, with the contrast that is some negative, the hero, there’s a fragment of self that’s living some event in that character’s backstory. And, this is where they sort of face the emptiness of that, where, where, where is it? Like, this is the darker part matched with the fall of the heart wall where they integrate that fractured part, that fragmented part from the past. So they don’t have to live there anymore in that traumatic event, or they’ve, they process it and integrate.
It, it’s not about denial. It’s about allowing it to become part of yourself and then managing that. So if this person is a weak-willed hero in a rom-com where they’re too timid to express their feelings, or they’re too jaded to actually be vulnerable with a partner, this is where they see the repercussions of that. You’re going to be alone the rest of your life, unless you allow someone in, right? And what that does for them is challenges them enough to then go after the girl, go after the guy, which is usually, you know, a lot of rom-com third act.. They become this person who, as you said, is from lowercase h, got it right that time, it’s an uppercase h, from reactive to proactive. You now determine between, like I said, it’s not just this event, it’s between these two events that we’re talking. Devin’s actually being a lot more specific about the hero’s darkest moment key points. And I’m just trying to add in the bit that there is a commensurate part to this. There is a…
Another side to this. It’s like, and he said it really well as well in terms of this. This is your hero’s midpoint. Between this event and the next event is the fulcrum bar of the seesaw, the middle part where your hero is going to transition. This is important, really important. So that fragment of self, they’re integrating. Now, if you have, like I said, a weak-willed hero, this is where they’re going to integrate their teeth. If you’re agreeable, if you’re going to integrate their teeth, you’re a person who’s agreeable. You are not expressing what you truly want or think or feel because you don’t want to, quote, hurt someone else’s feelings. And in doing that, you don’t properly express yourself. And so you end up getting shepherded into situations and belief systems and jobs and things you don’t want to be in. And then you become resentful because you’re not getting what you want or what you think and feel is not being responded to because you’ve not expressed it. But you…
Turn that outside of yourself to whoever you agreed to and blame them for not, you not letting you express yourself. So when a… And this is a big thing with a lot of people. This is a big thing. If you are at a place where you’ve been agreeable and weak, like I’m saying, I don’t mean to call it weak, but a weak-willed hero, meaning they don’t go after what they want. They don’t properly say or express it. This is where they go, enough is enough. And it may not be pretty, This revolution of heroes. But the thing is, if they don’t integrate this part of themselves that doesn’t speak up for themselves and, you know, continues to be resentful of people they’re like trying to agree with and get along with, they’re either going to become resentful is terrible enough, but either resentful or even become tyrannical and be a villain. A weak-willed person can become a villain through that path.
Even your people who don’t have a voice, who are timid, your characters who are timid, notice that there are pathways to the dark side, if you will. One of the biggest examples of this moment is the, and this I think is central in the first three episodes of Star Wars, the original three from the 70s, is because I think he trains with Yoda in, he does, right? Empire Strikes Back is when he trains with Yoda?
Devin: Empire Strikes Back. Yeah.
Adam: Yep. So about in the middle of that movie, Luke faces down Darth Vader in the swamps of Dagobah. He defeats him. And so there’s your major shadow. Darth Vader is the shadow character of this story. I mean, pseudo, the emperor is the true shadow, but he’s in the shadow of the shadow, which is kind of awesome. As far as like a, you know, a puppet, a puppet master, that’s a great way to execute it. But he kills, Luke kills Darth Vader in the swamps of Dagobah.
Devin: Yeah.
Adam: And he, you know, he’s dead. And Luke goes up to the helmet because we all want to know this, if it’s the first time we’ve ever seen these movies. What does he look like under there? That’s why Darth Vader is probably one of the most iconic villains of all time is we want to know, it’s a classic monster showing a little bit of the shark and Jaws. Mm-hmm. Exactly. Yeah. And Super 8, we don’t see the monster right away. Like every good horror movie, suspense movie doesn’t. Mystery. But, so we want to know who it is. It’s one of the greatest moments in Star Wars period, in my opinion.
Yep. I agree. Because we’re so anxious to see, oh my God, we’re going to get to see what it looks like. Yeah. And we still don’t get that payoff, by the way, until the end of Return of the Jedi, when he finally takes Darth Vader’s helmet off. It’s a big mystery for three films. So in this point, the helmet’s off and we’re like, we’re going to get to see him. And it’s Luke dead inside Darth Vader’s outfit. That to me is a perfect example cinematically of Dark Night of the Soul. Luke has the capacity to become the shadow. Luke has the capacity to become evil. And it’s perfect for this. It is absolutely the Dark Night of the Soul for Luke, where he goes, the worst I can become is that. I must refuse at all costs. And that is the thing. I just have to not give in to the dark side.
Devin: You brought up a really good point and a really good technique, I guess, or a good tool you can use from writing, from a writer’s standpoint is, and it’s kind of like Pleasure Island in Pinocchio. Yes, it is. If you want, if you show your hero. A glimpse. It’s almost like you take a moment and we shift to the perspective of the antagonist. And we’re saying, look, you can, I’m not saying this is exactly from the Star Wars example, but this is what I was thinking is, look at all of this you could have. This is what, come to the, come to, come to the dark side. Come to this side of things. Be evil with us because if you’re evil, you get everything you want.
Adam: Hey, that’s biblical. That’s Satan and, that’s Satan and Christ in the Bible too.
Devin: Yeah. It’s temptation. And it’s saying being good isn’t always easy, you know? And so it’s interesting. And I think it’s, it’s important for our, the hero to experience this event, the dark, hero’s darkest moment. To think about our story’s utopia. Okay, so in writing like my stories, it’s not real accurate, but utopia is the world as it as it should be. If things work out the way they’re supposed to be, there’s a utopia, there’s a new status quo, what this new status quo is supposed to look like. And the world, which is basically the world of this devoid of this antagonistic power that has made it off balance, or in some cases of this very dark place. If our hero never experiences the dark place externally, and they don’t experience the dark place internally, there’s nothing for them to ponder what the contrast is. Yes. And so whatever the whatever your your story utopia, your story’s new status quo, whatever it’s supposed to be, if the if your hero accomplishes what they’re supposed to accomplish, they won’t really be able to see that contrast without really understanding what it’s like to
Adam: Live, not necessarily in the shoes of your antagonist, but they need to understand the antagonist and why, why they are as they are. The question I was going to pose to you earlier, spiritually and metaphysically, you are sort of summing up and what you’re talking about. And this is an age old question for mankind. Philosophically, can a person who doesn’t have the option to be evil, be good? Right? No, if you don’t have the choice of being evil, but you’re maybe you’re, you’re quote, a good person, because you behave, that’s not being a good person, a good person is being challenged with the situation, the temptation to be evil, and maintain good. That is a good person. That’s how you would define it. You don’t have one without the other. You don’t have night without day, you wouldn’t know the difference. That’s why contrast in a story is one of your most important tools and elements. Because all you have to do is prime example, like characterizing, I said, I think last episode, Mamet, or maybe I said it off air with you. David Mamet said, you know, in describing a character, you don’t really have to say too much, you, you give them a little bit of something. And then the rest of the story is choices, because there’s nothing beyond what’s on the page. It’s just the choices they’re making. So you could say, this character is a billionaire, and this character is a homeless man, all we don’t even need anything else, our brain starts to go crazy cooking up the differences between the two, and how we already think about those archetypes in society, our prejudice towards one or the other. That question is a very big, broad question. And I said ageless, because it’s gone back through many philosophers throughout time, to the beginning of the concept of philosophy, when people were pondering ideas, which is unique to humanity. All the rest of the creatures on the planet don’t.
Reason, that’s how humanity differs. The monster holds a lot of information, a lot of information, not to go down this bent too far. We talk about spirituality, but not necessarily religion. But in religion, you have the archetypes of God or Christ in God, and Satan, the devil, the ultimate monster in that story. Beyond the fear, of misbehaving and being punished for it, what’s behind the monster? What’s the treasure guarding in fairy tales, epic fairy tales? A dragon guards the treasure. Why? Because you have to surpass the monster in order to get the goods. You have to go through the dark part of yourself to find the truth of strength in who you are as a hero, if you have the option of being good or not. That’s the one, and the Star Wars, again, is a great example, in the climax of Return of the Jedi, when he’s posed with the question, turn to the dark side.
Luke says, never. Your friends are being, he keeps baiting him with stuff that would depress someone or break someone. Look out the window and watch all your friends dying. You should just join us. He’s being tested over and over with these increased things, and it’s like, now your father’s going to kill you. Good luck. And Darth Vader and Luke start fighting, and then Luke refuses to continue fighting him and drops the lights. So, he has choices over and over again to the option to be evil, and he chooses good. He chooses what he thinks is right. There’s a reason why those stories have stuck around in the cultural narrative for as long as they have.
Because they really resonate with people. Another thing psychologically I was going to mention, too, is in this moment, there are two Jungian principles of the psyche. One is the persona, and the other one is the anima. And persona is the ego, or the presentation of self physically, externally. And the anima is the internal, or the soul. And so, this is the point that’s much more internal and soul-oriented. But what it will do is produce a change in the ego and presentation of self externally. As we talk about these archetypes, shadow, they all come from Carl Jung. Because Joseph Campbell drew from Carl Jung as well. It’s all about integrating that shadow, or the processing of the shadow side of one’s self.
In the Swamps of Dagobah, Luke has a moment to go, that could be me? And that’s sort of like terrifying and mind-shattering to him. That he could be me. That he could be Vader. The ultimate enemy to all of them. And so he has time between that movie and the next movie to process all that stuff. They just complicate it with, by the way, he’s your dad, too.
[Sponsor message]
Devin: Like you said, this moment is a shift in psyche, for sure. It’s the thinking that, or the realization of our hero, that they’re not the ones suffering. It’s the world, and it’s this unknown world and its creatures, and he understands that they truly do need a hero. And he has been selected, and he is accepting. You know, this is almost another, you know, another floater. Yeah. Rechoosal of the call moment. Here and then fall of the heart wall kind of too. I know we have another one at the end, but it can be very emotional. Depending on what your story is, it can be very emotional.
But it has to be very impactful, insightful. There is always a feeling, a shift in feeling, whether you’re reading a book or you’re watching it on a screen. When you feel the difference in the person. Yeah. And the people around them, even if it’s an ensemble piece where it’s. The other, your other characters can feel it. They can see it. And then there’s this new form of confidence, you know, again, depending on what your story is. But there’s something very different and changed in our hero. Again, transitioning from hero lowercase H to hero uppercase H here.
Adam: For those of you who are sort of trying to figure out, well, what do I do here? If that’s the question in your mind, I’ll tell you this straight up. Self-doubt for a character. For a character is a fantastic go-to. Start there. Even if it’s not specific go. This is where they confront their own self-doubt. Their own, you know, or if it’s not that, if it’s a more tragic past, guilt, shame, any of those. But self-doubt in particular. Helps you to get internal and specific about one character, not just some broad theme word or value word. It’s very specific to what you’re writing. And if you start with that, even if you don’t know the details, the story will tell you what the details are, and then you can fill them in.
Yeah. And the reason I say self-doubt is because that’s common to almost everyone. It’s very relatable. And it’s easy to relate to. Yeah.
Devin: It’s also a good moment for like a good closure happened and there’s some kind of a piece of closure here. They get that closure or they finally allow themselves to accept maybe the death of someone or accept something where they find this closure, a true closure. And then that’s what allows them to defeat that thing that was haunting them. And it silences it. And it allows them to focus. Just allows them to refocus. Or focus on what’s going, what they have to do.
Adam: You need to clear your mind to approach what’s coming next in the climax. And this is sort of the whole time you do it. And that’s the campfire burning stuff off kind of symbolically. It’s why it becomes intimate and primitive, if you will. Man and fire. But you, this event can sort of manifest itself in terms of, it can be about coming to terms with things that have been lost either in the distant past. Yeah. Or just at the crisis. A character may have died in the crisis. A character may have gotten kidnapped and parties separated in the crisis. But this is where they’re sort of coming to terms with that and what all that means. Deeper question of life. It can also be coming to terms with new information that they haven’t had time to process, which is in the case with Jumanji.
Good transition. The hero’s darkest moment in Jumanji. Welcome to the Jumanji. It’s a very similar to playing video games.
Devin: Yeah. You’re like, whoa, I’ve been playing this for 17 hours.
Adam: Oh, that’s funny. It is true. But he’s the darker, more tragic aspect of this story. And he represents it for all of them. That this dark night of the soul part one, because they’re like, you know, it starts comically, where he’s using words that are very 90s, like fly. And Cindy, he’s talking about Cindy Crawford. Get jiggy with it. And they’re like, what? What’s going on? And then they realize that. It’s the freak house kid, the kid from the hook scene of this whole story. And look at that set of payoff. That’s a nice arc right there. We sort of know it, but that’s when it’s stated and they get it. And it sort of, you know, becomes part of the story.
So that’s part one, but we don’t have time to fully process it because Bethany comes scrambling back and goes, I think she’s ready. And the plan goes into action. It’s great because it’s kind of a cliffhanger moment for that death of the, or a hero’s darkest moment.
Devin: Yeah.
Adam: They set you up, but they don’t really pay it off yet.
Devin: They set it up. The whole goal, the objective is not necessarily changed, but it focuses on getting this kid home. They’re like, they want to get out of the game too. But at this moment, it all of a sudden they’re, they, they understand the gravity of we’ve been gone for, well, I guess this revelation, I guess they, they probably don’t understand exactly how long they’ve been gone. But they know that this kid has been gone for 20 years and it becomes the goal of the group to get him home, to get him out of the game. And that’s the, that’s why this is the setup. We understood the tragedy of him literally being stuck in a video game and missing 20 years of his life.
And then not to mention what’s happened back in the known world.
Adam: And it’s, I mean, it’s a light-hearted comedy. The thing is, learn to be yourself. Who are you? Is it a strong enough theme for this? It doesn’t have to be so, you know, the whole point is…
Devin: Yeah, who do you want to be right now, right here? That’s what the principle…
Adam: The whole point is, symbolically with Nick Jonas, is if you give up on yourself, you will never be anything. You will never go anywhere. He’s just hiding in his comfort zone in the unknown world. Right. He’s not being who he’s meant to be. And they come in and encourage him because they’ve learned to encourage each other as a group, as a mini-community, the four of them.
Devin: Mm-hmm.
Adam: And, I mean, there’s two moments when he’s in the hut and he’s like, I’ve never made it past the transportation shed. I’m scared, blah, blah, blah. And they say, we can do it all together. And then we get to the transportation shed, and this is sort of part of what’s coming up here, and they’re like, pick the vehicle. And he’s like, no, no, no, I got one life. I’m going to do it. I’m going to die. I can’t die like this. You know, I’ve tried this before, and I failed. Yeah. It’s self-doubt in this argument of which vehicle do we choose, aircraft do we choose to get out of here, dude?
Right.
Devin: But it’s also the group. They all had each other, and then they got to a point where they need him. And now that they’re all together, because he’s always like, I don’t know how to… He’s like, I can’t get past this. I can’t get past a black mamba by making him a margarita, which is kind of a funny line. Yeah.
And then that’s when Fridge is like, no, we need a zoologist.
Adam: Yeah. Fridge, man. Kevin Hart’s got great delivery.
Devin: Now that they’re together, they will be able to defeat the game together. So he was just missing four other people, which sucks for him.
Adam: But so the part two of this is when Nick Jonas is bitten by a mosquito and all the characters are faced with this broader idea of what happens when you lose your final life, your last life of the game. It’s not just about dying the first time and you get one tattoo removed. This is so what what’s really going to happen? Does he does the game end for him? Does he go back home or does he die and stay dead forever? You know, I mean, you know, when you finish a game, you sort of the game’s over. And. And you’re back out of the game, but they don’t know any.
They don’t know what’s going to happen. And what it seems to be is when you die, you die forever. Hell and perish. Yeah. And so it could be argued that at any time one of them dies, they experience like a little mini Heroes Darkest moment until they realize, oh, it’s not a big deal. We just respawn. And then that sort of gets taken. And then this moment is sort of the payoff for that for that misleading of the audience. It’s like, don’t worry about it. They always respond. And then he gets bit by the mosquito. And they’re like, oh, by the way, he’s got one life left.
Remember that? And you’re like, oh, no, he can’t respond. What’s going to. So the audience starts running questions and it becomes, I mean, for like I said, for the darker moments of this movie, this is it. This is true death for one of them. Right. It’s this event’s not usually a floater, but sometimes it is. And in this case, they sort of did something unique. And diced it up and split it in two and gave the setup. Then some more action comedy adventure in the helicopter and the escape. And then back to sort of regrouping and finishing out those things.
Devin: Yeah. It’s almost like it’s just interrupted.
Adam: But it’s just a testament to the idea, again, of, look, you can take these events and do that. Yeah. Take your Heroes Darkest moment, split it in two and do that. Wow. That’s a unique way to use that puzzle piece, you know, to make something different.
Devin: Mm-hmm.
Adam: But, yeah, Jumanji’s is pretty simple in terms of what it’s about. Yeah. It’s symbolic. Nick Jonas is the symbol. Yeah. Nick Jonas. I like how they do it. Action hero. The Jonas.
Devin: The Jonas.
Adam: Edward Scissorhands. Heroes Darkest Moment. I like this one. It feels almost inevitable and obvious from the get-go. Yeah. When Peg sees him with his hands coming out of the shadows and they’re just blades. Mm-hmm. And you’re like, yeah, the first thing we ever see of this man is how deadly he can be, how his hands are lethal instruments. We just forget about it almost right away because of who he is. And this scene is, I would say, when Jim shows up after Edward has had his arrest and been released and he’s back home. And Edward and Kim sort of have their tender moment. Mm-hmm. And Jim interrupts it.
And he starts to kind of unravel a bit. Edward, you know, first stares in anger at Jim because Kim goes running out to him, you know, to get him to go and figure things out. But Edward’s just angry. And he turns and he walks down the hall. Yeah. And he drags his scissors along the wall. So he gets to the bathroom. And we’re following, but we’re not with him. And so we know stuff’s going down in that bathroom. And so the anticipation of that is part of this event in that movie. And then we enter the bathroom and he has shredded all of the wallpaper. And he’s shredded the shower.
The shower curtain and the curtains and everything. And the reason why this sort of registers for me as like a hero’s darkest moment, not just because he’s slicing things up, but he’s slicing up Peg’s and Bill’s stuff. That’s where it’s like, oh, wow, he’s not being considerate of. Yeah. Goes to that place that he’s not even recognizing the fact that he’s destroying his mentor’s property. It is unexpected, but inevitable.
Devin: For me, this. All of that. It almost seems very approaching of the inmost cave type of stuff going on in a way. But it’s more like I feel like and I feel like the when he is making this ice sculptor sculpture. I feel like that’s his. And I know you may have that as the fall of the heart wall. But I feel like that is one of his darkest moments. One of his darkest moments. And then he accidentally cuts Kim.
Adam: Fall of the heart wall, I think, is really their their only romantic scene where she says, hold me. And he says, I can’t.
Devin: Mm hmm.
Adam: Yeah. If anything, I think that’s where the most connective because she realizes in that moment he has to go. He can’t stay here. He really can’t. But I want to hold on to him and keep him here. You know, and he wants to do the same. Stay there. And yeah, this is this is. But it’s a tragedy. So. So go go ahead and philosophize, though. I’m interested to know, like, is it because of Jim’s presence or.
Devin: It’s more of the aloneness of that moment where he’s wanting. He starts doing the ice sculptures, but he goes back to something that he knows. And it’s almost like I can’t run away or he’s not running away. He’s stuck here. And so for a moment, he’s able to escape. By doing what he loves doing. And then he’s literally jolted back to reality. And then that’s when he cuts her. And so for for me, there’s there’s a moment. There’s a moment of a somewhat dark moment for him there.
Adam: Yeah. The feeling place I get from that scene is is sadness. I get a lot of sadness, but peace. That’s one of the few sequences in the film. That’s one of the few sequences in the movie where it feels. And it’s part of the music. That’s Danny Elfman, too.
Devin: That’s well, that’s what I was going to say. It’s hard for me to. Because the ice dance is that score is like. And then the beautiful. It’s just beautiful making and making snow. And there’s something pure and happy about that.
Adam: And it harkens back to it’s a payoff to to the the initial prologue with with old Kim telling her granddaughter. And used to get snow here. And and the final image. Yeah. And the final image. And and here is the first magical moment. That’s why I say this feels a little more. I mean, it’s got a mix of everything. But Danny Elfman’s score really is what sells this movie in general. Entire particular. Yeah. I know. Yeah. It’s it’s just so like I can listen to that ice dance track just that that song itself over and over and over because the feeling place of it is so magical.
Yeah. And beautiful. And. Yeah. It’s wild. I thought maybe the the the hero’s darkest moment could maybe have extended from him shredding the bathroom to the following dinner scene a little bit. Because now. Yeah. I would agree with that too. He’s trusted. Have said, Edward, you know, we’re losing confidence in you. You know, we’re a little disappointed.
Devin: We can replace the drapes. But. Yeah.
Adam: I love Bill. Yeah. It’s so funny how he says it. Yeah. Bill is so much funnier to me as an adult compared to when I watched it when I was younger. Yeah. Like, he wasn’t as funny to me then, but now he’s really funny to me.
Devin: That’s funny.
Adam: But, yeah, and then they test him ethically, the whole ethics question, and he fails. He’s like, he just doesn’t belong here.
Devin: But he fails in, like, that view, the beautiful, kind, right on his, perfectly what his character should say.
Adam: Give it to your friends and loved ones?
Devin: Yeah.
Adam: Well, it seems like a good idea, Ed, but, and you can see in his performance, Johnny Depp’s performance, he doesn’t even, he’s trying so hard to get the right answer.
Devin: Mm-hmm. Yeah, it’s…
Adam: In his face. And you’re like, God, he, this is, that’s what I’m saying, this whole part, ironically, this movie being a tragedy, him, stuff in this movement is usually about growth. But this, it’s sort of like, he’ll never belong, is what we’re slowly realizing through these scenes is, oh, geez, it’s not, because it ends tragically. And so, now we start, like, earlier, we were misled in the midpoint, like we’ve been saying. Set it up so you can subvert it. He’s celebrated on television in the middle of this thing.
Devin: Right.
Adam: And then now it’s like, oh, he doesn’t fit.
Devin: Mm-hmm.
Adam: He’s just been sort of going along with the narrative everyone else has been constructing for him. But he’s got a mask on. You know, he’s trying to just do that. So, this is where it starts to disassemble.
Devin: It’s tragic in a way that, that, I don’t know if you ever saw Blackfish or that documentary about the orcas. At the zoos. No, I haven’t. It’s terrible. It’s what they do to those fish. But so, it’s basically how they train the orcas. And they deprive them of, of food. And I’m not saying that’s what they’re doing to Edward Scissorhands here. But it’s that, it’s them trying to do the right thing when they’re training them because they want something, you know. And so, they’re like, I just, and they, but they don’t belong there. Like, they shouldn’t be there. They’re very out of place there. They don’t belong in a pool.
They belong in the ocean.
Adam: And that’s why they eat their trainers periodically.
Devin: Yes. And, yeah. But it’s, so it’s like similar to that. Or even, even if you’re just training your dog, you know, where they, they want so bad to please you. And they want so bad to do the right thing. And you can see it in their face. And they’re like, I don’t know what that means. What do you mean, rollover? I haven’t heard that before. But, so, but, and I’m just equating it to the emotion of something like that. Where you’re, you, like. You’re saying, you, you pointed out that you could see it in his face. That he just wants to do the right thing. Or say the right thing.
But it also exemplifies and shows that he doesn’t really belong here. And he never will. You know. And so, that’s what’s starting to happen.
Adam: The, the themes through this are isolation and, and things like that. But, but, when, social isolation in a way. The, the issue is he doesn’t belong. But he really wants to belong. He really wants. He wants to just be accepted. He doesn’t want to fit in with the, with the, with, like, the gym crowd. Because that’s not what he’s interested in. Gym is, is the antithesis of who he is as a, as a person. But he knows. It’s like I was saying before. With the, the, the, the balance of persona versus anima. The presentation of self versus the internal soul. We see Edward and he’s, he’s trying to present some version of self that’s acceptable to everyone else.
When all he really wants to be is himself. That’s what the, the underlying thematic pieces are to this. Even as far as what Tim Burton has said is the origins of this for him.
Devin: All I heard was he went to Caroline Thompson and was like, hey, I have this idea of a boy that has scissors for hands. Go.
Adam: He probably showed her a picture because he’s, he used to draw and sketch and doodle a lot of his ideas as. You know, visual art as images. Yeah. He was an animator at Disney. Yeah. Oh, I forgot about that. Yeah. That’s interesting. Yeah. Hero’s darkest moment for Edward is he embraces that shadow side of himself by slicing up the bathroom because of Jim. The climax of this story, I don’t mean to spoil this for you folks, Edward stabs Jim in the attic of the mansion and sends him out through the side of the building into the ground. So this moment, the hero’s darkest moment for Edward, is setting up your ending. When you get in the attic and stuff’s going down, you’re like, oh no, I know now what’s going to happen.
But up until that point, Edward, you only have one glimpse of Edward being monstrous with his blade. Being the monster that everyone wants to later brand him as. But he’s never like that the rest of the movie. And then when you get in that attic, you’re like, oh no. And it’s in a split second that you see the flash of the hero’s darkest moment again. Edward just gets a look on his face, marches towards Jim and just picks him up on the scissors and out the side of the attic. And you’re like, oh my God. And it’s intense, but it happens in a moment. And this is the only other moment that sets that up.
Other than, you know, the beginning where Peg, the few horror movie bits and stings that they use to, when Peg discovers him in the attic and he comes out and it’s just blades first. You get a handful of these tiny setups, but the fact that he’s going to use the blades on Jim, and in this moment, the surrogate for Jim is the wallpaper and the shower curtain. That’s the setup for your climax. Next time it’s going to be Jim. This movie, every time I think about this movie and break it down, it’s so brilliantly constructed. And subverting events and doing things, but it is a weird movie. I love it. I totally love this film.
Devin: I love it too. I’ve had a lot of fun having to watch this and look at it through a more of an analytic eye. And I actually have grown to be way much more impressed with the writing and the character development than I was if I, you know, just watching it as a regular audience person.
Adam: Yeah. I would encourage, Devin and I both. We would encourage you, StoryOsophers out there who are looking to expand your storytelling knowledge and try to figure things out, pick a movie you really love, like any movie, and just start to break it down and see how, why it’s effective and how it works and how they built it.
Because the few that we’ve broken down off air, we talk about it all the time, how much it’s helped us to understand application. We talk about the application of these storytelling tools and events for ourselves in our own writing. So I would encourage you guys to pick something and break it down for the fun of it. Just watch it a few times and think about the events and the movements we’ve been talking about and apply them.
Devin: And see how they do it differently. Like we just, like Jumanji, where they break up this, they interrupt this event by throwing some action into it and make us ponder what was just discussed in a more…
Adam: They let it sit with us for a bit too, so we have to think about it, which is sort of clever on their part. And Jumanji, you know, this is a good example too of what we’ll talk about near the end of season two, about variations on these things. They sort of here, just sort of make two, an extra movement in here with a threshold of, because it’s video game oriented, the transportation shed. And once they cross the valley, that’s a threshold. And then they have another threshold going into the climax. They have these pseudo thresholds because they’re trying to create game levels, video game, you know, places on the map they have to go past.
And so that interrupts their format. And plus, you know, being an action adventure comedy, they have to break up. They can’t have a very long hero’s darkest moment and fall to the heart wall. Because we spend most of our time wanting to enjoy this. The trials and tribulations and interactions of these comic actors, you know? So it’s more playful. And in order to do that, you have to framework it with stuff that seems more background, action-y, dangerous, dramatic.
Devin: Like a character who’s trying to write a script, but has self-doubt that they can write a script. Start there.
Adam: Whoa, Devin just went really meta. Whoa, dude. This is like out of body. That’s like… It’s like watching Bandersnatch, Black Mirror.
Black Mirror. Did you see it? Did you see that? Choose Your Own Adventure, Black Mirror?
Devin: No.
Adam: Okay. I’m going to recommend that to you. You told me about it, though. You don’t have to watch any other Black Mirrors, even though they’re better. But Bandersnatch is the one where they did your Choose Your Own Adventure, where you click on screen how the story evolves. Yeah. I read about it, too. Yeah. I’m down. I love that stuff. But I think they just got sued by the Choose Your Own Adventure company.
Devin: It did. And because, remember, I sent you that thing years ago, maybe, because you and I were talking about doing something like that. Doing something like this. And they, like, trademarked it or they patented it. They patented, like, being able to do that. I’m like, that is the worst. That’s such baloney, man. It’s clearly whoever was reviewing that patent application was like, I have no idea what they’re talking about. Sure. Doesn’t sound like it’s even possible. Which is, it’s a crock.
Adam: My issue with that is, someone’s, I hope they, I hope Bandersnatch wins. Yeah. Because you don’t, you can’t have proprietary rights over a style of storytelling. That’s insane. You can’t. You can’t. That’s like free speech stuff.
Devin: That’d be like us patenting, getting a patent on, all right, well, we’re going to patent books, but they’re written from top down left to right.
Adam: You can’t write a book that way. Yeah. It’s like, wait a minute. Wait a minute. All right. So. It’s a really big, it’s a really big deal. Like, I don’t think anything is sort of like, I’m not big into legal battles and stuff, but I was like, wait a minute. This does not seem right to me. It’s not. It’s a joke. You can’t monopolize free speech like that. It’s crazy. It’s a joke. The fact that they even, the fact that they even got the patent.
Devin: It’s crazy! I don’t- I don’t understand. I know. It’s just dumb. Some things that you can get a patent for is a joke. It’s strange that they got the patent. It’s just sort of strange. It is very odd. I’m telling you, I guarantee you, the reviewer had no idea what they were talking about.
Adam: Yeah. They’re just a clerk in an office good. Clunk, clunk with a stamp. The thing that’s interesting to me is I don’t want to, I seriously don’t want to come off as if I’m bad-mouthing choose-your-own-adventure stories because… Oh, no. I think they are one of the greatest inventions of literature recently. It’s the exact opposite of what we’re doing. It’s amazing. I love it. But I don’t think it should become so proprietary that no other authors have the ability to write that multidimensionally because it’s not… Here’s the thing that’s trippy, and I love metaphysical stuff in that way. It’s alternate timelines. Right. It’s alternate dimensions in the same book.
If you choose this, turn to page such and such and… It’s interactive. And it’s interactive. Yeah. You as the audience member, it’s as close to video games as literature gets. You get to make choices. Yeah. And I’ve been surprised that we didn’t have more choose-your-own-adventure stories up to this point. Well, now we know why. But at the same time, they’re hard to construct. You really have to make sure you know what you’re doing and have looked through all pathways.
Devin: There’s a lot of outlining.
Adam: Bandersnatch, they sort of showed how they did it with… Gosh, I wish I could remember the name of the program that they used to map it out. Twine, I think it was. Twine. Which is a… It’s sort of the software that does choose-your-own-adventure-esque things.
Devin: Oh, in real life.
Adam: Yes, yes. Yeah, real life. To map out… Yeah. Yeah, yeah. Yeah. The only criticism Bandersnatch was, every ending is just graphically, darkly violent for the most part. There’s other… You know, it’s still… All of it’s dark, but that’s Black Mirror.
Devin: That’s the brand of that series anyway. It’s cool. I like doing that. I like the mapping stuff, mind mapping stuff too. Yeah.
Adam: Audible, they have, I think, two choose-your-own-adventure audiobooks available now.
Devin: Oh, cool.
Adam: And I don’t… I’ve not experienced them yet to see how that functions. [unclear]
Devin: Examples like YouTube. There’s some YouTube ones that people have done that are pretty fun.
Adam: Yeah. Choose the cereal that this person eats or not. Yeah, yeah, yeah. YouTube has done it.
Devin: Well, I mean, even narrative stuff where it’s, I mean, a ton of work goes into them, but you’re
Facing off against aliens or something, but it’s all real world. Like, and they, so it’s like, do you want to shoot, go this way or shoot that guy, or do you want to go through that door? And you just hit an arrow on the screen, pops up, you’re like, go that way. And then they basically had to shoot that entire, what happens in that scenario. And then they had to shoot when people say that scenario, they shot everything. And then it, somehow they, I don’t know if it was YouTube. I think it was YouTube, but, or they had to use some special, it’s probably YouTube. Cause you can just, you can do, different,
Adam: Boxes and cards. I didn’t see what you’re talking about, but I did see, it was just some guy. It was like his YouTube channel, but he was in a grocery store and you got to pick the cereal that he was going to eat. And it’s sort of what Bandersnatch did because one of the first choices you get is what cereal the kid eats in the morning. And I thought going, cause I watched it a few times through and I’m like, okay, if I choose the other cereal, I bet you that changes the entire plot line. And it doesn’t at all. It’s pretty much like just there for you to understand the
Devin: Mechanism of choosing something early. And I was like, damn it. I w you know, maybe he becomes like
Adam: That would be a lot of work. Yeah. A lot of work, dude. You got to shoot like four movies. So a lot of respect to anybody who builds a, choose your own adventure, but on the YouTube thing, it was literally just the guy in the grocery store. He’s shopping for the cereal. He picks a cereal, he goes home and eats it. And I think one of them makes him sick. And the other one doesn’t was the difference, but you on the screen, this little, if you, you know, when you see the end of a YouTube video, it’s like, if you’d like to subscribe, click the subscribe button and they go, if you’d like another video, that’s like this click in the upper right-hand corner. And there’s a little mini box for that new video. He just used that technology to build a, choose your own adventure channel. And it was, well, I mean, it wasn’t dynamic or anything, but it was awesome that he did it. It was creatively inspiring for him to go.
I’m going to use this technology like this on, in terms of what we’re talking about here, these, these multidimensional things. We’re going to talk a lot more about this and where storytelling is going in season three and beyond right now in the first two seasons, we’re just literally laying out traditional storytelling format and how to approach it with a sort of a command of craft so that you don’t have to be intimidated by wanting to start to write a story. But Devin and I are completely fascinated with where story goes next. Yeah. And a lot of this stuff is exploring the things. He and I have had conversations like this off air a lot.
And even science and human comprehension is starting to realize there are alternate timelines and dimensions beyond human perception. So we’re ready as a culture, as a race, humanity, to explore. Like these fractured storylines. It’s very exciting where we are in, in storytelling history and the narrative of mankind since its inception, you know, it’s become, it’s, it’s a great age for storytelling.
Devin: Yes, definitely. Technology is our friend. A good, here’s a good book. This is a good book to read, or if you’re driving, listen to, because it’s also an audible. It’s, the innovators, how a group of hackers, geniuses, and geeks created the digital resolu, revolution. And it’s Walter Isaacson, who’s awesome. All this stuff is awesome, but it’s, it’s long. It’s like 15, 16, 17 hours or something like that. But it’s, it basically takes us from the beginning of computers, like in the fifties, you know, back way back and then ARPA. Oh, when they’re giant, when they’re like the size of a room. Yeah. Massive. And then they were, and then how the internet came to be and all this stuff, but it’s, it’s, it’s fascinating.
Fascinating. Fascinating. But it’s also good to know that stuff. Cause some people think that, and how quickly things happened, you know, because there’s the, you know, if you go to the industrial revolution and, or the second industrial revolution and you go, you see the big gaps of time that, that in between each of those, the, how long it took for new innovation to happen. And then the digital age came and innovation, even to, you know, of course today you got to get a new iPhone every like two years because it’s completely new, but it just happened. Innovation, innovation, innovation happens so quickly. And things are obsolete and outdated so fast that it’s, you know, you almost wish you could pause, pause the world, pause life and be like, all right, just let me enjoy this little bit of technology for a while before it becomes outdated.
Doesn’t update anymore.
Adam: Time seems like it’s like, oh, history is a long time ago. And your brain sort of, when you’re younger, thinks that way, because you’ve only been in the world for a handful of years, you know. And as you accumulate more years, you’re like, wait a minute, 1776, when the United States was formed, that wasn’t that long ago.
Devin: Oh, yeah, it’s not that long. Yeah, it’s all relative, depending on what you’re talking about. Yeah.
Adam: In the blink of an eye, that’s less than 250 years ago. How fast human beings are developing at this point. Instead of celebrating the triumphs of progress, so many people are, well, you got the people who are manipulating the global narrative of fear and anxiety and danger and all that stuff, and then the people who are believing it.
Devin: Mm-hmm.
Adam: And they’re not looking at, like, look at, like, it’s like, oh, when people say social media is a negative. You know, they’re like, oh, I don’t like technology because of social media. I’m like, if you group it all together, of course, you’re going to have, you’re going to have fatalistic outlook. Because any one thing, any one thing has the capacity to be good or bad, depending on its use, depending on its application. Right. Just like a human being. They can either become the shadow or understand the shadow aspects of self and change. And choose not to be that. Touche.
Devin: Bingo.
Adam: Bingo. As always, we encourage you to write three pages on this event. Just if some of the things we’ve been talking about are inspiring or in particular to the story you’re working on, sit down and write those three pages out immediately. Don’t wait. Don’t say you’ll do it later. If your imagination is jumping, sit down and do it right away. And if not, jot down some ideas, some things that you… You’ve gleaned from this so that if you go to your desk and write later on this evening, tomorrow morning, your time frame for writing, you have those to draw from. If you’re not working on a story in particular, do a free write, a 15-minute free write that just explores, like I said, a perfect go-to for this event is self-doubt is a fantastic go-to.
Just write a scene about your character’s struggle with their character flaw in terms of self-doubt. And all of a sudden, you may have a character grow out of this scene that you’re like, oh, I like this character. Please subscribe and rate us on iTunes. Follow us on social media. Share with your friends and send us your questions and comments. For additional resources and links to films, series, and books we talk about here, visit our website. While you’re there, sign up for our newsletter for updates on story building tools and special offers at StoryOsophy.com.