Show notes
Approaching the inmost cave is the last event before the crisis at the center of your story. The name comes from Christopher Vogler’s The Writer’s Journey: your hero is working their way into the heart of the antagonist’s lair, past the guards, with inner and outer obstacles simmering together. Meanwhile, the antagonist realizes these heroes are a real threat and raises the stakes. Adam and Devin cover how to escalate the antagonist, when to hold the villain back, and why these threshold build-ups should have no fat.
In this episode
- From Jung to Campbell to Vogler. Joseph Campbell’s archetypes draw on Carl Jung’s psychology, and Vogler translated Campbell’s work for screenwriters.
- Escalate the antagonist in waves. The first waves are faceless henchmen; each later wave has more character, until the antagonist decides to handle things personally.
- The reconnaissance character. A spy, like Van Pelt’s vulture, puts a sense of danger over every scene that follows, and you can bring it back whenever you’re ready to raise the stakes.
- Withhold the monster. Showing a glove, a scar or a paw lets the audience’s imagination and fear do the work. Just make sure the payoff lives up to it, and never fake a scare.
- Track your levels, but later. External plot, the hero’s internal journey, the hero’s remaining options and what the audience knows are tools for polishing, not first drafts. In a first draft, if a scene is asking to be written, write it.
- Flip it at the midpoint. Put your hero at the midpoint in the opposite place from where they end up. Even a rough draft gains the shape of an arc.
- Plan your antagonist’s ending now. If the villain will be redeemed or humanized at the end, or will get a satisfying comeuppance, set it up here.
- Be clear about your confusion. Surprise drives comedy, mystery and genre-blending stories. If you confuse your audience on purpose, have a plan to pay it off.
- No fat here. Explore in the new discovery and new direction events; keep the approach to a threshold swift.
Examples discussed
- Jumanji: Welcome to the Jungle: the black mamba in the bazaar feels like a cave with a treasure on a pedestal, but it’s only the approach. Fridge’s knowledge defangs the snake and the group trusts him without blinking, his first breakthrough. The others’ moments follow: Spencer’s punch in the crisis, Martha at the transportation shed, Bethany saving Jonas. The Jumanji drums herald each threshold.
- Edward Scissorhands: Jim talks Kim into asking Edward to break into a house (“He’ll do anything for you”), paying off the earlier lock-picking scene. The cave is Jim’s father’s den, where Edward ends up locked inside.
- The NeverEnding Story: the Gmork is seen only in glimpses before Atreyu tells him to show his face.
- Elf: we only hear Peter Dinklage’s demanding author on the phone before the reveal.
- The Wizard of Oz: figuring out how to get into the witch’s castle.
- Also: Molière’s Tartuffe, talked about long before he appears; Lost and Game of Thrones, on payoffs that must match the audience’s imagination; and Raiders of the Lost Ark.
Writing along with the season? Write three pages for your hero’s approach to the inmost cave, or a 15-minute free write. One event at a time, you’ll have a first draft by the end of the season.
Read the full transcript
Transcribed automatically, so expect the odd misheard word. Sponsor messages are left out.
Adam: In this episode, we explore the story event, Approaching the Inmost Cave. What obstacles and complications does your hero encounter as they near the tipping point of the story? How do these challenges build to the crisis? Next, on StoryOsophy. Hello, welcome to StoryOsophy. This is Adam Jones. And Devin Halden. This week, we’ll be discussing the story event, Approaching the Inmost Cave. This is a good one. I really like this one. We take this name directly from Christopher Vogler’s The Hero’s Journey, because it’s perfectly and aptly named. It’s great. And of course, Vogler, he takes his storytelling model from Joseph Campbell. You track these folks back and you start to get to where their basis and their philosophy came from.
And I don’t know if we spoke about this, Devin, but Joseph Campbell’s model, his archetypes come from Carl Jung. Ooh, I did not know that. The psychoanalyst. They’re just certain minds in the world that are so brilliant. You know, they’re thinking… They’re thinking on these such forward-thinking levels. And I always, as you know, you and I both think that way. And so, I’m drawn to anyone who’s like, what about this idea? What about this idea that has not yet been explored? What about this idea? Or, frameworking like we do here with StoryOsophy 2, old storytelling principles or traditional storytelling principles and models updated.
Devin: Right.
Adam: How can we tell stories that are less survival-based things, right? Are there different dimensions of storytelling that we could do instead of the singular hero? The new ensemble cast. Even though Shakespeare sort of was doing it then, it’s very big now, ensemble storytelling. While tracking you, you, StoryOsophers here through these, sort of the architecture of a story, we’re breaking it down using Jumanji, Welcome to the Jungle, the newest Jumanji, which is an ensemble cast, and a classic, Edward Scissorhands, which is a single protagonist, and also a much more internal journey. Before we get to this event, this approaching the inmost cave and tell you what it’s all about, we’re going to do a little bit Let’s do a review of what got us here. Act one of a story, the beginning of a story, is the known world, meaning you’re introducing your audience or viewer to the status quo of your hero.
And how they enter this quest or journey or adventure of the story to come. We break these down into movements. Movement 1 is the same, basically, as Act 1. It’s the same. And that’s from comfort zone to out of comfort zone. We start with the hook scene, something to grab your audience, followed by the known world routine, your status quo of your hero, an inciting incident in your story, the event that kicks your story into gear, and it’s one of these floater scenes. Sometimes it can happen in The Hook. Sometimes it can happen in the next event, which is Call to Quest, where that story event meets your hero.
Sometimes they are right side by side or one and the same. The hero usually goes through a debate period, which we call Refusal of Call to Quest, and separately the event after that, Choosal of Call to Quest. And then, once they make a decision, they’re crossing the first threshold of change into the unknown world of the rest of the story, which is act two, the underworld. World. Act two starts with movement two and its events and then into movement three. Movement two is out of comfort zone into danger zone. That’s the transition that’s happening with your hero in that movement, movement two. The first event is first day of school, which is a reaction to the unknown world, followed by watering hole, which is a communal gathering that shows a representation of the macrocosm of the new world, the unknown world. You get glimpses of different types of people and characters and what this is like. Next, we have the story event rules and tools, which is mythology, rules and tools. Skill sets are things the hero is going to need to help them succeed in their journey. Now, these two events can be swapped, watering hole, rules and tools. As we were discussing last episode and we’ll be discussing this episode, the watering hole sometimes can become a set piece. We’ll talk about that in Jumanji, a larger thing that is over many events. The rules and tools also can be something that lays over the framework of an entire story as we talk about frequently with Edward Scissorhands, but they’re interchangeable and they’re probably some of the more useful scenes to master. I think Devin would agree with me on that. Yeah. Those two, like you can apply them everywhere. Yeah. And we would probably also say that knowing movement one, just as a series of events to be able to lay over the subsequent movements to help your heroes make engaging decisions to your audience, engaging to your audience. Right.
I think that’s another major… Set of tools that you need, or that’s probably some of the better tools to apply to writing. That first movement one, if you know that, you’re good. Because if you lay that over each movement, you’ll have a dynamic story. Yeah. Following rules and tools in movement two, you have approaching the danger zone and finally crossing the threshold into the danger zone. Obviously, things ramp up, something heated happens where your hero has… This is a bit of a threshold where reaction comes into focus and I’m not prepared. It’s sort of the lesson learned. Movement three, from danger zone to crisis, we start with the close call, which is a reaction to what happened in the danger zone, and sort of your hook scene for this movement. Then new discovery, which is a new discovery or lesson or information, followed by new direction, meaning based on that lesson, where does the story go now? New direction where your adventure opens up. And this week we’re talking about approaching the inmost cave, which is sort of inner and outer…
Yeah, inner and outer obstacles brewing together, simmering together. Because we’re not quite there at the crisis. This is the ramp to the midpoint or crisis or tipping point of your story. We call this many things.
Devin: Right. We’re headed towards the most dangerous part of the unknown world or the layer of the antagonist, but we’re not quite there. However, at this stage, the antagonist is going to raise the stakes a bit, realizing that this group, based on what just happened, this… This group has something the others did not, that may have tried to disrupt their status quo. Right now, the antagonist is really feeling the threat that this group is having on his or her status quo, and it could upend or completely destroy it. And so they’re going to stop at nothing to make sure that that doesn’t happen. And so that’s what we showed of the antagonist when he kind of sent his JV squad. I don’t want to get into Jumanji, but that’s kind of what we’re like, the bikers were the JV squad, the bizarre fighters or that those were, you know, those were the piece, nobody can get past these guys and they do. So now everything’s kind of getting a little bit more, you know, that’s where that’s actually in Jumanji. That’s where we’re at right now.
Adam: Jumanji is interesting because if you track the source of antagonism, which is Russell Van Pelt at the center, and then his possessed creatures within the world, and then his henchmen, right? Those are the extensions. Yep. So in movement… Movement two, the beginning of movement two, he’s introduced by Nigel in a flashback story, but it’s not really engaged with our hero. It’s sort of like you had said, a watering hole, a campfire scene, a storytelling event. And then after that, the first time we see him is represented by the biker gang that shows up and chases them in approaching the danger zone in that event. And then they report to him in the next movement, in movement three, and he sends out one of his creatures as reconnaissance.
And I mean, you could argue that at the beginning of movement two, the hippos and all that stuff are his outreach too, but…
Devin: He doesn’t directly send the hippos though, you know, like… No. That hippo would eat her anyway. Exactly.
Adam: So it doesn’t we don’t know it’s an extension at that point So here are the steps that they up the game with just track this really easy because we’re using Jumanji a little early But it’s a good point Devin’s bringing up. Sends the biker gang this extension doesn’t work doesn’t know where they are now though They’re somewhere in the world of Jumanji. So I’m gonna send reconnaissance villain reconnaissance antagonist reconnaissance which is a major tool in your tool belt that brick that reconnaissance character because Like we were talking about last episode it sort of looms over any scene you put after the fact So you can create this sense of tension or danger through this reconnaissance character So, it’s biker gang, henchmen, reconnaissance character, vulture. And then, at the midpoint that’s coming up, right after this event we’re talking about this week, Russell Van Pelt is going to show up himself, in person. Last episode, last event, New Direction. The vulture finds them. There’s the arc from Close Call to New Direction. By the way, that’s a setup payoff.
It’s a pretty simple one, but that’s what that is, over like three events. So it’s a really close arc of a setup payoff, as opposed to like the very end of the movie when they… Use their character deaths and respond to their advantage because they’ve learned that much about their skill sets Yeah, like that’s a long arc of information So it goes reconnaissance leaves tells Van Pelt off screen then these guys show up to fight We’ve got an upgrade in skill set for Spencer and then the main Main dude shows up you sort of have this arc with the villain where it’s like, ah, the the motorcycle gang was good enough Usually for anybody else, but they’re not they get away, right?
Now we don’t know where they are So to buy some time as we develop our characters a little bit let’s throw that vulture out there writer and loom over this and watch and then as soon as we’re ready to To up the stakes we show the vulture again and the vulture flies off. It’s a really good insertion Moment we see the vulture fly away from the bazaar You can take that and Plant it anywhere in the bazaar once they arrive. What’s the opportune moment? It’s still a quarter page scene, but look how malleable that that payoff is So you’re building to where he goes. I have to handle this myself right at the crisis point That’s a nice arc for a antagonist for the first half of your piece
Devin: And you’ll see this a lot in these types of stories like Jumanji where the initial wave of the antagonist is usually faceless or There’s a bunch of them yeah, that’s a good way to put it and then as Different waves and stronger waves or more evil waves or more powerful waves of the antagonist appear. They begin to have more character. So, the second wave, the vulture itself, which is also a good tool to use, is kind of like this all-seeing eye for the antagonist. It’s like that’s his crystal ball is that you can be? Incognito and get the information exactly what it is And then the as the henchmen get in the minions or whatever did this in it?
Waves, they’d be get to take on a little bit more character and Until we actually meet the antagonist face-to-face and in the case of Jumanji where now it’s full This is here’s the antagonist like he like Adam you said If I got to do this myself, clearly my henchmen can’t take care of these guys like they could everybody else that attempted to do this, a.k.a. Jonas.
Adam: And tracking through that, I realized, too, when we were talking about the Nigel and the Jeep watering hole scene where he tells them the backstory, the cut scene in the video game. Van Pelt taking the the Jumanji jewel out of the what is it the Jaguar? Yeah, and then changing everything. I know they’re doing it as a cutscene. They can do it. That’s part of the joke But I it was one of those flashbacks I’m like, ah, not my favorite bit and I think I even posited back then so what if we didn’t see him? What if that story was? Just told right and not seen even though it obviously it’s more dynamic and as a viewer to watch it and You weren’t introduced to him until this moment coming up in the crisis where he just appears out of a fog of smoke and you’re like Oh, that’s Van Pelt. Yeah, even when his henchmen [unclear] Through all of these extensions that the henchmen, the vulture, all these things beforehand, like withholding the monster from any monster movie, you usually show the end result of the monster and not the monster itself for a while.
Devin: Yeah.
Adam: Because your audience is doing a lot of work in their imagination, if that’s the case.
Devin: I guess, now that you raise the StoryOsophy of it all, I think, I do prefer, I think, a little bit more of the mystery. Like, maybe you only see a glove or something that will be identifiable when he shows his entire self.
Adam: It engages you.
Devin: Yeah. And then it makes it really, and then, like you’re saying, your imagination is coming up with all of these ideas of what is behind that glove or what’s behind. That glass eye or that scar that you were only showing them and stuff like that. Yeah. I never thought about that. Like you said, it does work here, but.
Adam: Here’s the thing that I would say is probably the most important for a writer to the audience using this tool. You want to really engage your audience’s imagination and their emotion. Those are two things that, if you can get those things rolling, they’ll do all the work. And as long as you know that the payoff is astounding. As long as you’re as strong as your promises, you’ll be fine. In a lot of episodic television where they write it as they go along, especially older ones like shows that people have criticized as being hit and miss with payoffs like Lost. There are all these questions that are being posed that are really engaging your audience’s imagination.
And if there’s a good story, like Game of Thrones is a prime example. There’s a good story that people are really invested in. You got to be careful with how you tell it. Because their imagination has done. A lot of work. And there’s a lot of them, you know? So, especially now online where people are contributing theories to things. Sometimes what they imagine is way better than the story itself. Because there are more creative minds working on it.
Devin: Right, right.
Adam: Ultimately. And so, you got to make sure that the promises and the setups you have are paying off. And paying off properly. Or else, don’t engage your audience’s imagination to that degree. It’s like emotionally the same thing. Like a fake scare. Don’t fake scare. Don’t scare your audience. They’ll jump, but they’ll hate you for it. It’s annoying.
Devin: And it doesn’t have to be a huge ordeal or a huge thing. But like even Elf. The movie Elf does a great setup. Mysterious. Like they create the mystery when they’re talking to Peter Dinklage’s character. He’s like this brilliant children’s author. And he’s on the phone. And all you can hear is his voice. And he’s like, oh, and I want the temperature of my coffee. And they’re like, oh, yeah, yeah, yeah. And he’s just like scary. And he’s got to have the right plane.
Adam: And he’s on the, you know. He’s a big man. He’s a demanding big man. Quote, unquote. Yeah.
Devin: Yeah. And then it’s the easy payoff. He shows up. And he’s a little person. And he’s, I mean, it’s that that’s the good payoff of it. And so, it can be something like that. But I think now that you’re saying that, it’s like don’t miss that opportunity for a really good setup payoff.
Adam: Reveal and discovery for your audience.
Devin: Yeah. It’s interesting. For sure. I’ve seen video games that do the cut scenes. And it’s the same thing where they still create the mystery. You don’t know until you get to the very last guy. And you’re like, oh, there’s that eye. Or there’s that cyclops. Or there’s that fiery mane that I’ve been seeing. But I didn’t see all of him. Or all of a sudden, he turns into every single villain you’ve beat on every other level. All of a sudden, they like transform into, you know. The dragon, again.
Adam: That you can hold off on. You can hold off on introducing your antagonist. And that’s not new. This is Moliere’s Tartuffe, an older play. I think he waits. I can’t remember really what it is. I know I couldn’t remember last time I mentioned it either. So, he waits till like the middle of the freaking play to introduce the bad guy. And the whole time before that, everybody’s talking about him. You know what I mean? You witness it, but he’s off screen somewhere. And so, all of their perceptions of who he is, and he’s supposed to be like a spiritual advisor who’s taking advantage of the family. And so, the husband’s really into him. He’s like, he speaks truth. He speaks truth. And some of the other people sort of agree, but most of them are like, he is a dirty dog. He’s a scam artist.
And so, you sort of get all these perspectives about the antagonist or the title character, Tartuffe, before he even shows up. And you’re like, you’re trying to figure out what this, what must this man be like? And as soon as he walks on stage, you’re like, okay, now it’s time. And so, you can see through the false piety that he brings to stage, and that’s what makes this scene funny, right? The first, his entrance scene. Because I believe it’s with the patriarch of the family, the father who reveres him. Yeah. And so, we get to see him kissing his butt and going, oh, Tartuffe, are you, do you have, like, and this guy’s in like the greatest suite in the entire house, you know? He’s being treated like a prince, you know? And he’s like, oh, I don’t, I don’t need such trimmings and things, but I appreciate it.
You know, we could see him manipulating it, but they talk about this and you wonder how it’s going to manifest in physical form in front of you. And there’s something that is exciting about that. The mystery, not to get too far off on this topic. But it is important because we’re approaching the moment where the villain or the antagonist will manifest itself, if it hasn’t, he, she, it hasn’t already, directly to the hero. So, it’s important to get the idea of what, which route you’re going to go. And you can ask yourself different questions. How much does this benefit my story to show the antagonist or not show the antagonist? Because with each new story is a different recipe.
Devin: Right.
Adam: Mystery, if your audience doesn’t know something, they will wait to hear the answer. Right.
Yeah.
Devin: Yeah.
Adam: That’s the key to anything for storytelling. So, mystery is pivotal in weaving together events and set up payoffs and introduction of characters. The way you introduce somebody.
Devin: Never Ending Story, again, does this really well with the Gmork. Oh, yeah. Yeah. Where you only see glimpses and pieces of him as his fangs and you see the scariness of him, his paw. And then at the end, when he confronts Atreyu or Atreyu confronts him, he’s like, show your face. And he comes out.
Adam: No. You see him leap out of the swamp. Yeah. You see him leap out of the swamp after Atreyu in that moment, but just a glimpse, too.
Devin: Yeah. Just.
Adam: Yeah. Just his paw. Yeah. Because your imagination will do all the work and make that thing the most terrifying thing you could imagine before you see what it actually looks like.
Devin: Mm-hmm. Yeah.
Adam: Because your fear, you’ll imbue your own fear into the monster or whatever it is until you finally get the payoff. And that’s why when you were talking about Ritual a few episodes back, the payoff of the monster didn’t match. It didn’t match up to the mystery that was created in your imagination.
Devin: Mm-hmm. Right. Exactly. And that’s the thing, too. Make sure the payoff is, like, if the never-ending story, all of a sudden we think that this thing that’s been chasing Atreyu the entire film and it looks terrifying and all of a sudden when you confront someone, Atreyu’s like, show your face. And it comes out and it’s like a little chihuahua. You’re like, wait a minute. What? It’s like, not what I am. Depending on what you, depending on what you’re. For the reveal of the, with the antagonist, if it’s supposed to be funny, like, that would actually be pretty funny. And he’s like, no, dude, you dropped something back there in the, in the Swamps of Sadness. I’m just trying to get it back to you.
Adam: Approaching the inmost cave. We took this name from Christopher Vogler’s model, which is one of the folks we talk about. And you’ll hear us talk about in our audible mid, midpoint. Mid-roll. We like this notion. And you could probably even call your crisis or tipping point or that central point the cave if you wanted to, because it’s sort of this place where it’s becoming more confined. It’s sort of a pressure cooker image in your head. But it also talks about inmost. And so it’s not, it’s sort of like if you’re up against a villain and you’re infiltrating their lair, it’s when you finally get to the center of that lair. And this approach to the inmost cave is when you’re getting your way in, past the guards.
Through the, like in the Wizard of Oz, it would be like at the witch’s castle.
Devin: Yeah. I was just going to say that.
Adam: And they’re all trying to figure out a way to get in. How do we get in there? That’s the approach to the inmost cave. Probably one of the most fun and awesome ones that there is. Yeah. Great example. Yeah. And it happens a little later. That movie is great for thresholds. The threshold into the city of Oz. The threshold into the witch’s castle. And archetypes. Yeah. And archetypes. Your allies are the build to that city of Oz. And each time you meet a new one is like the meat of a movement, really. You know, the witch tests them and she meets an ally. It’s a great rhythm. That’s why the journey movie in general, this Joseph Campbell or Christopher Vogler approach is so popular in its using it structurally.
And they’re fun to write. Yeah, they’re fun to write. But you can also take what they use psychologically, like we were talking about with Carl Jung being the predecessor or who Joseph Campbell was, basically going, here’s psychology. It’s what we’re doing with this. It’s what we’re doing with this in a lot of ways. Here’s psychology. And here’s storytelling. Ancient storytelling myths. And they go hand in hand. Right. Jung’s taking from archetypal stuff from history, your archetypes, and Campbell’s processing it through story. And Vogler basically, being a student of Campbell, is translating it more into cinema space for the most part. He’s novel related. Structurally, he’ll do novels and storytelling in general, but his was applied more toward really applying it to writing.
Whereas Campbell was more of an analysis thing, much like Jung, analysis of storytelling of myths. We just like to use these guys because they were sharp.
Devin: We talked about that, I think a couple episodes ago, that those tracking, those levels of tracking with your story where you have the external plot, that’s kind of what’s happening on the outside, what your heroes are going through and the antagonist sent obstacles. But then there’s below that, you’re also tracking at that same moment, what’s going on. You’re tracking internally with your hero or heroes. You want to track, we even added another thing to track last episode, which is, all right, now at this moment, that’s happening, what’s happening externally, the plot, what’s happening thematically, internally with your hero, and then what decisions are they making at this point and what options are still left for them at this point?
And then we added again to, and what does our audience know at this moment? So you’re almost tracking, you’re kind of tracking three. Or in some cases, you could track other things too, but it’s for measurement, it’s checks and balances to make sure you’re staying on thematically, you’re staying on course, or you’re making sure that your setups and payoffs are spaced where you want them spaced. So there’s a lot to, if you track things on from those different levels and not just what’s happening to your hero and what they’re going up against externally, it helps also to create subtext. And things that are happening, you know, within scenes, so you can, those objective obstacles and outcomes that you have for, you know, your, your movements and your events and your scenes, it’s, it helps to, to at least be thinking about that stuff while you’re writing.
Adam: And you can think of them like, like that, different tracks, like we, I’ve been using the railroad and now, or the railroad, the rollercoaster analogy with ups and downs. Railroad, that’d be really interesting. Railroad, I know.
Devin: Out of nowhere.
Adam: The rollercoaster analogy where you. Especially if you put yourself in the seat in one of the cars, there is a level of story experience that’s different than up and down a two-dimensional drawing on a page. Now you got turns and twists, ups and downs, flat track. I like using this, and this is, this is a testament to you and I discussing stuff like this on the podcast, Devin. This is a new analogy for me. As of a handful of weeks ago, I’m like, oh, this feels much closer to how I want to approach designing a story. But. Mm-hmm. When you start to look at it. When you start to look at it multidimensionally, it’s, it’s not just here is the plot of the story, which is one track and that you can measure two dimensionally.
A lot of these other multidimensional aspects, theme, inner space as an inner growth of the hero, external events, some sort of side tracking where tracking, tracking as he’s saying, your setups and payoffs and what the audience knows and does not know in this point, what information you’re withholding for suspense, mystery, and also what they do know versus what the character knows. Does the character know the same thing? Does the character know less? Is it dramatic irony in that sense? Right, right. I just want to make sure that our StoryOsophers know this does not all have to be determined in your first draft. Don’t get overwhelmed.
Devin: No, it won’t be. It shouldn’t be.
Adam: Yeah, usually your initial ideas are not always going to be your best ideas and your initial ideas are not going to be what are your end ideas necessarily. They may be, but usually you’ll get some editing and revamping and polishing. With the first draft, this is the thing. Just get it on the page. Yeah. Use a model, use a structure to sort of understand it and maybe build it a little bit ahead of time. But if something is saying, write me, write this scene, you can hear the characters talking about stuff, write it. It doesn’t have to be perfect when you’re jotting it down, but if you’re hearing and seeing that scene clearly, that’s the moment it is being asked to be written. And so do it.
Right. And eventually, if you follow that where it’s just play time, you’re like, oh, this scene is, I’m really into the scene. I got to stop for a second, whatever I’m doing and write it down. Right. Or if you’re not in a place where you could do that in a vehicle, pull over, write it down if you have the time. If not, try to remember as much as you can. Go over it and over it in your head so that when you get a moment to sit down and write it, write it. It will write itself organically if you allow the ideas to come non-linearly like that and build them. And they’ll connect. Those dots will connect because your brain is building a puzzle and it’s trying to find a place where all those events connect and become a chain of events.
A plot. So just follow that inspiration for your first draft because you will notice in your second draft, you’ll be like, oh, if I just do this here and change that later, that’s a perfect set of payoff. You can find quick and easy places to fix it. The first draft is just about getting it on the page. And once we get through season two here, we’ll talk about refinement.
[Sponsor message]
Devin: I should clarify. All of that stuff, all of those different levels is kind of at the polishing stage of where you’re like, okay, I got everything there. Now let me make sure I’m tracking. And then if something seems off, you’re like, I don’t want the audience to know. I don’t want them to know that right now or I’m giving them a little bit too much because that’s going to kind of dilute the payoff later. Then that’s when that’s kind of what I’m talking about with tracking and you’re like, oh, okay. And then, and then, oh, maybe I should remove this option from the hero at this stage. Like they, they shouldn’t have this option because then the audience may be like, well, why don’t just go that way or, or go back or go do that.
As long as you’re thinking about that stuff on those different levels. Because again, your audience is going to have. Their, their imagination hopefully is going to be flying high at this stage during your story. Like if you have them where you want them at certain stages of your story, you kind of can be able to direct where their imagination is going or what they’re trying with what you want their imagination to be doing at this stage of the game. If you’re at least. Cognizant, and you’re kind of tracking all this stuff, you can be like, oh, okay, there’s a little gap here, there’s a hole here that I need to clear up, or I got to remove this option from them, otherwise, if I don’t, it makes their decision here a little less important or powerful or dangerous. Polished stage.
Adam: So, examples. Jumanji, Welcome to the Jungle. Jumanji, this is a very important scene for Jumanji, character-wise. Oh, maybe character-wise. I think this might be one of my least favorite Jumanji scenes, but… Ooh, let me take you on my journey. Well, what would you define as this scene to begin with?
Devin: This is the snake scene. Yeah, okay, yeah. This is like the first, and this is also the first moment our heroes are working together, since their decision to work together after the close call and the new discovery.
Adam: And it’s sort of like a pseudo cave. Yeah, yep. Like you, it feels like this should be the cave, not the approach to the cave, but it is the approach to the inmost cave. Because it feels like a cave with a central pedestal, like an adventure movie with a treasure piece. Right. So it feels like the cave moment.
Devin: Here’s why I really, this scene, I think to me is a big scene for the characters is, and it’s an important storytelling angle too. It’s, though there’s a dangerous external obstacle that the group is dealing with, together, this black mamba in a basket. They’re each struggling again with their internal obstacles here. In this scene is our first scene of the, of a big character breakthrough moment. And it’s for Fridge. Because remember that we talked about each of our heroes are essentially like the polar opposites of who they are in the known world. In the known world, Fridge lacks confidence in his intellect. And he sees his only opportunity for success is through athletics and being the cool kid.
So he kind of forces and bullies Spencer into doing his homework. However, when he arrives in Jumanji, all of that athleticism is stripped from him. And his strength becomes this like encyclopedia of knowledge. And it’s this knowledge here, even though they’ve all understand some of their, their strengths, or at least not maybe the extent of their strengths, but they’ve all been, they’ve all had experiences with these. These new found strengths they have. And this knowledge is what saves them from this, this snake. And it’s the first time Fridge feels like one, he’s like, he’s one of the group. And they trust it’s trust him. And they didn’t blink, you know, trust or don’t blink.
And I forgot what that thing was, but, and so this is a profound moment for his character. And what’s also important here is although these new found strengths have, have saved them up to this point. Yeah. They’re all still, like I said, a little bit uncomfortable with them. And so they’re still unsure of their, like the potential of this, but now at this moment, Fridge realizes the extent of his power. And then in Spencer, very soon after this, in the next, in the next event, he realizes his, the extent of his power. And individually, the characters have a moment and the writer has given each character this moment of realization of, of becoming comfortable with who this new person they are. It’s a bit of a lesson for, for each of them, you know, to bring home to the unknown world. And it echoes that what the principles, that principles question, you know, in the principal’s office is like, who do you want to be here? You know, you know, find your strengths and run with them.
Don’t let your internet stop you from achieving your, your, your full potential. And so this moment right here is really that first realization moment of one of our heroes of their full potential here in this, in Jumanji. And, and when he first fridge first feels, feels comfortable with this new him being this intellectual or this having this knowledge, and then also this new feeling of the group trusting him. And… And they didn’t blink, you know, they, he, he pulled the fangs out of the mom bub and they didn’t question him at all. And so it had nothing to do with athleticism. It was all something that he’s, it was very foreign to him in the known world. But here it’s something that he realizes. Once you analyze that and then you see what happens in the next event with Spencer as, as he’s kind, and I don’t want to jump ahead, but just to highlight this point.
Adam: He, he trusts his skill set as well now in the crisis moment.
Devin: But he doesn’t right away.
Adam: No, not at all.
Devin: It’s like, he’s like, oh, he’s like, it’s like, it’s like dodge, dodge, you know, and so he’s kind of going through the fight scene.
Adam: They dramatize his self-doubt. Yeah. By, with, with a line of dialogue, which is, I have to tell you, I think I’m a really strong puncher.
Devin: It’s so sad. You just uppercuts him through the room. And it’s the payoff to having punched fridge against the cliff side wall. Right. Exactly. Perfect set up.
Adam: And it’s a little set up, but it’s a set up to this payoff where Spencer, our main character, if you will, out of the ensemble has a recognition of self-worth and strength and all those things we were talking about last episode. Confidence, consciousness of one’s own power. Yeah. You think this is the crisis, this snake, they got to find the missing piece. And as soon as they triumph, the real crisis is the surprise. Oh, here’s the villain and his henchmen. That’s the sort of big thing.
Devin: It’s, it’s. It’s Indiana Jones shooting the dude with the, with the sword. You know, when you’re like, oh.
Adam: And the chase through the baskets in the city. This is going to be bad. Back to the approach to the inmost cave, the snake scene. So what you ran through, I do understand what they’re doing with it. I just didn’t necessarily like it because I felt like it was a little contrived in places as far as writing wise for me. But I understand what they’re doing. The characters unite, the characters have moments at their, but. The laugh points, the excitement points and the payoff points were not as strong for me as other moments in the movie. And that’s, I’m not saying it’s not effective in what it does, like what it’s supposed to be doing there in the story.
But for me, those moments were not, I don’t know. I, it’s just basically me saying it’s not my favorite scene in the movie. Yeah. You know, cause they get this missing piece and they’re like, what the heck does this mean? It’s a freaking elephant.
Devin: What is, I don’t understand. I’m certainly not saying this is my favorite scene. I was just saying. It’s not a scene to that. It’s not just a throwaway scene. So they’re not using this as a bridge to get to the fight scene. There’s actually a re like, and it’s hard with these ensemble pieces, because as a writing as writing this, you have to, you, you have to pick and choose the moments when you focus on a certain character. Yeah. And in this moment is when they’re focusing. They’re like, all right, let’s, we have to fridge has to come catch up. We have to catch fridge up a little bit.
We have to get them part of the group. But. We also have to have, we, the movie’s almost over. We have to have the, we’re almost to the crisis. We want these guys to understand their, their strengths and their powers before we get into the major battle. And so this is kind of, this is what that scene represented and this is what it did for them for them. They’re like, all right, well, let’s use this as that scene for fridge where he realizes now. So then we can move on and quickly do Spencer and then we’ll do Martha and then we’ll do. Yeah. Bethany, but we’ll, you know, we have to get these guys fully, fully equipped with their rule, the tools.
Yeah.
Adam: The way you just tracked them too, as we go throughout the rest of Jumanji as a story is exactly the order in which they find payoff for their skill sets. Yeah. Spencer in the crisis coming up sets off that motion, but you’re right. It’s just one right after another, they understand themselves. And I mean, well, you could argue that this is fridge is here, but Spencer’s the next one. And then you got, as you said, Mark. Martha and Bethany. Martha’s being the transportation shed and Bethany’s being the saving of Jonas’s life.
Devin: Jonas’s life.
Adam: Basically the whole point of this approach to the inmost cave. They negotiate their skill sets to work together as a team. And this is one of the times a few times we hear the Jumanji drums. Oh yeah. Spencer sneak it towards the snake. So the Jumanji drums, this is a good way to put it for this movie too. The Jumanji drums are the precursor to a threshold. Almost every time. Yeah. Because they before they get sucked into the game their herald. Yeah.
Adam: Before the missile launches past their face and here again, as he’s approaching the snake is perched on the pedestal, the sword and the stone, if you will, the Indiana Jones bag of sand got to switch it out. Treasure grab moment. Yup.
Adam: And Spencer’s like, I don’t wanna do this.
Devin: I don’t wanna do this.. Yeah.. Yeah. What are, I love Kevin Hart’s performance in the scene though. Yeah.
I defanged a snake. How he rifles through like the knowledge of the Black Mamba and what do you have to do to, or what would happen if you get bit, how to get past him, all this stuff. And then like in the same sentence, in the same breath, he’s like, how do I know that?
Adam: Yeah.
Devin: I just love it. I love his character. His character is great in this. It’s perfectly cast. Entire movie’s perfect. It’s well cast.
Adam: Well, I think his character basically is Kevin Hart, which is the thing I was saying.
Devin: Yeah. I mean, he plays the same character in all the movies.
Adam: Yeah. He’s just funny. He’s just the funny guy. But that’s what I was saying about the transition of people from the real world, from the known world of act one, into the video game, into the unknown world. The character dynamic is, so you can see Spencer in the rock. You could see Martha in Karen and you could see Bethany in Jack Black, right? So Fridge, it’s basically like, it’s just Kevin Hart, folks. Have fun. Like there’s not as much Fridge from the known world because Fridge is pretty standoffish and quiet and Kevin Hart talks a lot. He’s like Vince Vaughn. The funniness in Kevin Hart is his Tommy gun delivery.
Devin: Yeah.
Adam: Or like the chasms between where you think that the sentence is going to go, and where it goes. Like that moment when they first get there and reaction to the unknown world, first day of school, when he’s trying to process and you think he’s going to be quiet and then he goes, you’re telling me. And it gets really loud. Like those are things that, they’re very Kevin Hart. Yeah. And so part of me wishes they would have backwards developed and made the guy playing the Fridge on the other side, be a little bit more bombastic like Kevin Hart.
Devin: Yeah.
Adam: Yeah. Kevin Hart makes me laugh. He’s just funny to me. He’s funny, dude. I guess on to- Scissors. Edward Scissorhands approaching the inmost cave. For me, this is pretty simple. Yeah. I think we could start this out with Jim and Kim’s breaking and entering conversation. Yep. You could call that new direction if you wanted to, but really it’s an approach to the worst moment in the movie for Edward. Mm-hmm. Or one of the worst. Jim’s trying to convince Kim to manipulate Edward into doing it for Kim. So this is set up right here after the event when Edward gets arrested and gets out of jail and goes home and all that jazz. And Kim finally sees him for the first time after all this event. And she says, are you okay? And they have a connection point. And he says, I did it because you asked me. When he confesses, he knew it was Jim’s house this whole time. I did it because you asked me. Well, that’s set up here.
Yeah. Jim says, Yeah. You go ask him to do it because he’ll do it for you. That’s exactly what he tells Kim. Yep. And Kim does it because she, at this point, pre-crisis, doesn’t understand the value of Edward. She doesn’t understand the concept that he holds for the idea of trust in relationships. He is trusting because he doesn’t know deceit. He doesn’t know manipulation. He knows none of these things. And so even though he knows it’s Jim’s house, because he trusts or cares for Kim, he will ignore it. But the point is Kim goes into this knowing Kim has a big transition point in this crisis as well.
She does it because Jim asks her to do it. You could argue Kim’s pretty weak willed in this point, but there is an arc across this crisis from this approach moment to that moment when these two love interests, Kim and Edward, see each other again post-crisis. But this approach to the inmost cave, the darkest moment, literally the cave being Jim’s father’s entertainment. So, the build-up is they’re having that conversation. They’re going to manipulate him. Infiltration of Jim’s parents’ house. And that’s a payoff to the setup when Edward unlocks the doors to let Jim and Kim go inside and make out for the afternoon before building. And Peg get back. So, there’s a little payoff there. And that’s only last event.
I mean, it’s maybe a couple scenes back, but it’s the last event of New Direction. It’s one of those little seeds that gets planted in. And that might have also been one of those backwards written scenes. Yep. Yep. You know, we need to show that Edward can pick a lock. So let’s write a scene where he unlocks it for Jim and Kim, and we can add a little bit more meat to Jim being manipulative and, hey, why don’t you keep a lookout, bud, and plant that wherever we want in the previous build.
Devin: It’s also important from a writing standpoint, when you’re writing what’s happening to your antagonist or how your antagonist is acting towards your hero or ally, hero’s allies, is if you know what’s happening to your antagonist or what you’re going to do to your antagonist at the end, how this is going to end up, understand that while you’re writing scenes like this. Because there’s some moments or there’s some stories that humanize the antagonist. At the end where you just feel sorry, you sympathize or you relate to them, even though the hero is still going to win.
Adam: A redemption moment, a redemptive moment.
Devin: Yeah. Or you have moments where you want to make sure you’re setting up this end scene with the showdown between Jim and Edward at the end. You still want to make sure that understanding what’s going to happen to your antagonist and how it’s going to happen and how you want your audience to still feel about it. Make sure you kind of make him a really nasty person here. So it’s, again, another thing to track. Once again, near the midpoint.
Adam: Near the midpoint of your story. Yeah. Set up the opposite or subversive moment for expectation. Not always the opposite or subversive, but it’s a great way to start and go, so this is where we end up at the end. Halfway through, let’s pick the opposite of that. And that’ll be our starting point. Even if we brainstorm beyond that and figure out something that’s not as directly opposite and cliche, use it as your opposite point because if there’s a source of antagonism and you also want character growth across an entire story, if where the character ends up by the midpoint is completely the opposite of where they end up at the arc because of failure, short-sightedness, ego, hubris, any of these things, that it will result in the illusion of an arc for your audience.
Even if you wrote the worst story in the world, a stronger, more comprehensive arc is something where you nuance it a little bit, like draft two or three. You deepen the story. But if someone is just banging out a script in a month, turning it in, it’s going to be sort of empty.
Devin: But it’s a great trick.
Adam: Halfway through, flip the story so that you don’t know how the ending is going to go.
Devin: Right, right.
Adam: And in Edward, they sort of do it in reverse. It’s more of a tragedy as a story. A romantic tragedy.
Devin: A romantic tragedy, strangely. Which is why I think I love – dude, Edward Scissorhands is so twisted in so many ways and that’s why I love it so much.
Adam: It just turns so much. In moments, you’re not – it’s unexpected. It’s the same thing I say about mystery. Yeah. Comedy, right? And also, Edward shares many genres. So you don’t sort of know what genre we’re going to next. Am I supposed to really suspend disbelief? Right. Or am I supposed to really relate here? Or romantically, intimately with these characters? Am I supposed to really go fantasy or really go reality? Right. You know? They play with that. They stretch it around a little bit. If you can pick elements like comedy. Comedy, if you know the punchline to the joke, it’s not funny. So it has to be surprising.
If you don’t know in a mystery, whodunit, it’s surprising. If you don’t know what genre we’re going to play next in a multi-genre fusion piece, it’s surprising. Pick things that are surprising for your audience, but make sure – like I’ve said before, be clear about your confusion. If you’re going to withhold information for your audience, just be clear about what you’re doing with it and not absentmindedly trying to bait your audience for things that you don’t have a payoff for. If you’re going to confuse your audience on purpose, have a plan. As to pay it off and bring him clarity or reveal discovery later in the story.
Bingo. Bingo! Edward’s approaching is not very long either. I would literally consider it just the build up to when Edward gets locked inside the room from Kim and Jim’s plan where he’s like… And this is also another moment where you start to realize he calls him razor blades here. Why don’t you ask razor blades? He’ll do anything for you. He just treats him as a thing and not as a person much like as Devin pointed out with the scene with Jim’s introduction. He treats a lot of things like things. Possession and Kim belonging to Jim or Kim being the thing that Jim cannot possess. And that’s sort of what creates that antagonism here in this story. Short and quick. This one, The Approach.
Devin: Which I think is a hallmark of most stories too. I think this is, these can be fairly brief and more like, all right, let’s get on with it type of things with, but again, economy of the page.
Adam: Usually these approaches and the threshold themselves, these moments are dynamic and no fat. There’s no fat here. That’s why we’re saying before these points, these threshold points in movements, that’s your place where you, if you’re going to have any, fat’s the wrong word, fluff, space. Those are the places that do it. Not here. Not here. Earlier, when you do a new direction or new discovery and new direction, or the previous movement where you’re doing a watering hole and rules and tools, you can explore a little more there.
Devin: But make sure you tack down your major key points in these thresholds and keep them swift.
Adam: As always, we encourage you guys to write three pages, StoryOsophers. Write three pages based on this event, Approaching the Inmost Cave, even if it’s a free write. Do one of two things. Well, let me revise. Either do a three page writing of the story you’re working on or a 15-minute free write that explores this event. [unclear] Do a three page story of this event with that background
If you don’t have a story you’re going to apply it to, this could be the start of a story in the future. Our main goal in doing these three pages or having this little assignment, whatever the heck this is, is by the end of season two, if you have taken each week and- Exercise. Exercise. There it is, Devin.
If you write your three pages per event throughout season two, week by week, episode by episode, you’ll have a first draft. You’ll have a finished first draft by the end of season two, which should be sometime in fall. Awesome. Autumn. Or at the very least, a very detailed treatment.
Devin: It’s blueprint.
Adam: Yeah. You owe it to yourself to write the story you’ve been thinking about. Make some time. And that’s it. That’s all there is to it. It’s a first draft. Don’t sweat it. Till next time. Please subscribe and rate us on iTunes. Follow us on social media. Share with your friends and send us your questions and comments. For additional resources and links to films, series, and books we talk about here, visit our website. While you’re there, sign up for our newsletter.