Show notes
New direction, also called the adventure opens up, is the third event of Movement 3. Armed with what they discovered, your hero realizes they can’t keep stumbling forward: they need a plan, even if they don’t know yet what it is. The story widens into a new place, a new purpose or a new herald, giving the audience a breath of fresh air before the crisis. Adam and Devin also map out the decision points where your hero’s options to quit fall away.
In this episode
- Markers on the climb. Devin compares Act 2 to free climbers on a rock face who add extra holds where the gap is too wide to jump. The extra thresholds keep you on course through the middle.
- The three O’s at every scale. Objective, obstacle and outcome apply to the whole story, each act, each movement, each event and each scene, like a fractal.
- Write out of order. Start with the ending, or pick five setups and five payoffs and fill in the gaps. Seeing your story from above shows where nothing happens for too long.
- When options run out. Devin traces the hero’s choices: stay home at the call, retreat after the close call, and at the new direction, the last chance to turn back. After that, at the hero’s darkest moment, the only choices left are to give up or to rise.
- Self-doubt is the usual flaw. Find where your hero’s self-doubt lives: love, money, career. Confidence is its counter, defined as consciousness of one’s own power.
- From reacting to responding. Before the crisis, your hero is pushed along; after it, they act from within.
- Measure in pages. At about 15 pages per movement, this event lands 35 to 40 minutes into a 90-minute film. Ask whether you’d be bored at that point, and cut the funny scene that goes nowhere.
- Lessons and knowledge. Heroes get stuck retelling the lesson, the bad thing that happened, instead of taking away the knowledge of what they want next.
Examples discussed
- Jumanji: Welcome to the Jungle: the bazaar opens up the story, a watering hole full of video-game background characters and a rations vendor who repeats himself. Fridge eats cake and explodes, and a boy arrives as a herald: “Jumanji needs you.”
- Edward Scissorhands: Edward moves from hedges to grooming the neighborhood’s dogs and then cutting the women’s hair, to a new Danny Elfman cue. He appears on a TV talk show, and Joyce plans a salon that profits from his work. Devin sees a man who can’t make his own decisions being taken advantage of; Adam sees his most joyful stretch, setting up the fall. The adventure closes when the bank turns down the loan.
- Also: Lethal Weapon.
Writing along with the season? Write three pages where your hero’s adventure opens up, or take 15 minutes to free-write a new direction.
Read the full transcript
Transcribed automatically, so expect the odd misheard word. Sponsor messages are left out.
Adam: In this episode, we discuss the story event New Direction. How does your story’s quest or adventure open up here? How can you use it to provide a breath of fresh air before your crisis? Next, on StoryOsophy.
Hello, welcome to StoryOsophy. This is Adam Jones. And Devin Halden. I do sound a little stopped up, but that’s all right. A little bit. Devin Halden, in nature. Every once in a while, my body gets a little out of whack, pull a muscle, do something. So I go to this place. They deal with everything. It’s called Muscular Skeletal Therapies. Like, I’ve been there a few times. They’ve fixed some things on, you know, tuned up the machine. So I’m going, I’m really stuck here in my right shoulder, and I can’t figure out what’s going on. Usually, I can roll on a tennis ball, pop something into place.
So he says, he’s going along my chest. It goes up to my collarbone. He goes, oh, your collarbone’s out. What? I’ve had a rib head out. You know, the head of a rib. Have you ever had that happen? No. A rib head will pop out, and you can just pop. I might have one now, actually. It’s weird, because you feel like there’s a pain in your back, and it’s the rib head in the front. There’s something that your body’s compensating for the whatever’s going on. Yeah. So he reaches the collarbone, and he’s like, all right, hold on. Like, puts one hand to brace me, and puts his thumb up on the collarbone.
And they’ve popped stuff in and out for me before. And it’s, you know, it’s moderately painful, but not terrible. You know? It’s like, ooh, that one stung. He presses on that collarbone just a little bit, and I swear, like lightning, I grabbed his wrist. Like, ooh. I’ve never, ever done that. It was the most painful thing when he pressed it. And then he’s like, all right, well, hold on. Let’s try this again. I’m like, ooh, I might kill you. I just might. I don’t know. So he presses on it again, and it’s still really hot. I’m like, I can’t. I can’t do that, man. Like, everything else I’ve been able to do but this collarbone.
So he goes out, gets some ice, puts it on there. For a little bit to take down the inflammation. Could you stick to put in your mouth?
Exactly.
Devin: Here’s some rum, whiskey.
Adam: Literally, man, I have a good pain threshold, and this was brutal. So he presses it, and finally he gets to pop in, right? And it feels like, if you’ve ever seen the Lethal Weapon movies, when Mel Gibson dislocates his shoulder. Yeah. I swear, in my mind, that’s what it felt like. It was like. Oh my god. Yeah, my collarbone was out of place.
Devin: I didn’t even think that could happen, but I broke my collarbone once, but…
Adam: They have a little skeleton model? Yeah. I was like, here’s where the bone should be, and then he pulled it up and over, like, the sternum, the bone that connects all the ribs right in that front region. The top, it can sort of slip up over the top. What? And I’m like, how in the heck would that happen? Yeah, how did he… And how would you not feel that? Maybe it’s been that way for years, and I’ve just been living in pain, baby. Living in pain.
Devin: Did he even give you any, like, scenarios on how that could happen? Like, sleeping, maybe? Like, you just sleep on your shoulder, and… Pop it?
Adam: Yeah. I do sleep on my side with my arm under the pillow sometimes. I did that last night, and it felt like I could feel the pressure put on that place again. Mm-hmm. But holy crap, man. So I’ve got my collarbone popped back into place this week.
Devin: Oh, that’s good. It’s kind of like, I’ve separated my shoulder before. There’s a moment when it’s deathly painful, like, almost unbearable, almost pass out painful. And then when it pops in, there’s, like, a moment of euphoria. Yeah. Like, you’re just like, oh, my God, that feels so good. So it’s like… It’s in the right place. Yeah, because everything around it is compensating for something there. And then once you pop it back in, everything’s like, oh, thank God, I can go back to doing what I was doing before. It’s interesting that he’d be able to figure that out, too, without even, like, without x-rays, or he didn’t have to look at anything. He’s like, oh…
Well, you could feel it. You could feel it. Like, it literally felt like a bone sitting on top of you. Yeah.
Adam: Yeah. It’s like a bone sitting on top of the bone instead of in its place.
Devin: Okay, I’m done. Let’s move on.
Adam: This week. We’re talking about the story event New Direction. Oh, we also refer to this as adventure opens up, your adventure or your story opens up, but New Direction, your heroes had enough play time and prep time in the unknown world of your story in Movements two and three, sort of as we said Vogler would call the tests allies and enemies. And I think Campbell calls it the road of trials. [unclear] learned, and one of the more pivotal stages, the center point or crisis of your story. Just a quick review before we get into this event, New Direction. For those of you who are just joining us, we do a linear track through from about episode 41 of your Story Blueprint Overview. It’s how we approach structuring a story, so you can get the idea of bird’s eye view and zooming into different aspects. And we’re now walking week by week through each event, each smaller aspect. An event doesn’t necessarily mean a scene. It sort of means a stage in your story, a stage that’s worthwhile to sort of tick off your structural path, no matter where you put it, because people do flashback stories and chop a story up and place it all over the place.
So some of these things may get moved around, but they’re little puzzle pieces to use. And we’re trying… Backing them through probably the most traditional pattern of a story, act one, act two, act three in regular order. Act one being the known world of your hero, the comfort zone. We break the story down into movements, sort of smaller sequential builds within acts. And act one and movement one tend to be about the same thing. Every once in a while that is different, but we talk about those circumstances. So movement one is from the comfort zone to out of comfort zone, meaning your heroes in their known world routine, they have an inciting incident or some or a call to quest in the story that gets them involved in whatever the plot might be. And they have a debate period whether they choose to do it or not. Choose the quest, choose the story, the adventure. But it requires them to step out of their comfort zone. So each movement is a transitional element.
After this debate period, there is a crossing of the threshold for the hero, heroes, heroine. We usually call it just hero because it’s short and everybody understands. But your protagonist crosses the threshold into the unknown world of act two. And act two starts for us movement two, and we’ll continue having subsequent movements afterwards. But the first movement in act two is from out of the comfort zone, where we’ve just come from, to into the danger zone or the danger zone. This is an important thing to note here. This crossing of the first threshold and that crisis point, that midpoint, that tipping point of your story, there’s a lot of space.
And one of the reasons that Devin and I have developed the movement two and three here is to give more options, to make it not so daunting. And you call it a… I call it middle of the ocean.
Devin: And I call it a desert. Although I came up with a new one, because I was watching this awesome documentary about these guys that free climb… People, any climbers are going to hate me. I forgot what, whatever, one of these mountains and some national park, I forgot the name of it. But the key to doing that is they… Successfully climbing is they put these little markers in, and then they’re trying to figure out, they’re trying to manipulate or navigate the mountain, the rock, to get to the top. But there was a point that they got to that it was like literally, they either had to jump and try to hold on to something or whatever, but it was so big that they couldn’t navigate it.
So they had to find a different route and put smaller… In between that, put two or three other markers. Okay. Okay. That they could hold on to, and then they got over to it. And so I was like, oh, it’s kind of like act two, where you can try to jump and make it to the other side, but there’s a good chance you’re not going to make it. So give yourself a couple more markers to stay on course.
Adam: Signposts, or the rocks across a river, just enough so that you can get across. It’s not a bridge. It’s more like just enough to get across. And those are sort of the threshold moments. Your larger pieces across this arcing… Act two. Because act two gets… You can get a little lost. We built between this crossing of the first threshold and the crisis point markers that will help develop your story, your story’s mythology, your character’s journey, both inside and out. Movement one’s pretty solid and strong. And those events I just walked through, as we’ve said in previous episodes, if you just take those and lay them over top, almost like a superimpose it over top of any other movement, and follow the same pattern of…
Status quo. Like, whew, we just got through that thing. Status quo. Then something new is introduced. There’s a period of debate or approach where you’re like, I’m not sure if I should, I’m not sure if I shouldn’t. And then you cross that decision point threshold moment in the story that, like the skipping stones, that will alter your hero’s new way of thinking. And so that’s what these are for, is to help you to create a more dynamic story.
Devin: Anybody who’s listened to… Yeah. Anybody who’s listened to this has heard me say this a bunch of times, but I like to have that bird’s eye view of like, here’s my story. And then I have those three O’s that we’ve talked about, objective, obstacle, outcome. So I understand from my story point of view, I have an objective, an obstacle, and an outcome of just the story, very high level. And then you go a level down and those are the acts. So I have act one, act two, act three. And so I have an objective, obstacle, outcome for act one, an objective, obstacle, outcome for act two, objective, obstacle, outcome for act three.
But then you go… And that’s where we’ve added the movements to break that down a little bit more in what we’re talking about. And each movement, again, you have the three O’s. You have an objective, obstacle, outcome for movement one, two, three, four, five, and six. And then if you break down those movements, you get to the events that we’re talking about this season. And so each movement has certain events that make up that movement. But as Adam pointed out earlier, those events don’t represent scenes. Right.
Right. And try to maintain that when I’m pacing out my acts, and then I maintain that, I keep that in the back of my mind when I’m figuring out the movements and the events. Then when I get to the scenes, when I’m actually, really, that’s actually, the scenes represent the actual writing, that’s when I know, I’m like, all right, well, I have, I understand what this character wants in this scene, like what their objective obstacle outcome is for this scene, but it also has to work towards the objective Right.
Right.
Obstacle outcome of this event, which has to work towards the objective obstacle outcome of this movement, of this act, of the overall story. So it’s just a way to, it’s more of a checks and balances to try to make sure that you’re staying on course with, and that can all change. It doesn’t, it’s not in stone by any means, but it’s just understanding where you’re kind of, it’s more of a map of a blueprint where you’re, where you’re headed with your story and moving forward.
Adam: I don’t know how well people know what this is, but a fractal where you’re looking at something and the more you zoom in, the more it repeats its own pattern. It’s almost an infinite pattern. If you zoom in or zoom out on a story, you’ll get the same thing. That’s why the three O’s will, will be an overarching thing for the entirety of the story, whether it’s a series, the entire series arc, or the entire season arc, or the entire episode arc, or even going even deeper, a scene as an objective obstacle outcome. Right. At what level you look at the story, that exists. And so you can zoom all the way in, or you can zoom all the way out, and you still have the same pattern.
Right. And that’s why stories are generally set up in like a three act rhythm, beginning, middle, end, that concept. It’s just that middle gets really swollen. It’s big. You can lose yourself in the middle. That’s why we call it a desert and an ocean. In tracking through these, we’re talking through them linearly, but when you look at it, as Devin’s saying, from the bird’s eye view, we don’t suggest building it that way. Right. If you’re looking at it from a bird’s eye view, it almost becomes nonlinear. Now you have these puzzle pieces, and you place whatever events or scenes you know you want in the story. Just pop those in. And then the rest of them will be blank, and those scenes you’ve sort of structured already, or have an understanding of, I really like this scene. The rest of the story will start to build itself around the core ideas that you’ve sort of agreed to. And it doesn’t happen linearly, but we are walking you through linearly so that you can watch a movie along with us, or two movies, Jumanji and Edward Scissorhands, and see how it works, and how different writers or artists, even from just the writing to then the adaptation or how they’ve presented it on screen, how it can be used in many different ways. So it’s a great set of tools, this sort of architectural zoomed out mindset, because you have to practice with your mind and imagination to play in that realm and not think linearly. But we will be tracking linearly for the sake of continuity in the season.
Devin: Another good exercise is to start somewhere and start at a different point in your story. Start with the end, just write an ending, and then try to kind of reverse engineer how you get there. Or start with the setups and payoffs. Just do, I know I want the setups and payoffs, and I’d like to pick five setups and five payoffs, and then fill in the gaps. Fill in like, well, how did I get to this setup? And then from this setup, how do I get to this payoff? And it’s just more of a, you don’t necessarily have to write that way, but it’s a fun exercise to, even if it’s just a short story, you can just kind of play with thinking non-linearly, and then also figuring out the mental picture in your head of looking down at your story and understanding pacing and piecing things together and understanding, well, here’s a big gap that nothing happens, so maybe I have to put a payoff or a setup here.
Measurement. It’s kind of playing with it.
Adam: Yeah. It’s all measurement for sure. And that’s part of the usefulness of this structuring system is you can tell how far apart things are. Like Devin’s saying, there’s a gap here in my story where it doesn’t seem like there are any discoveries or reveals or changes. We’re sort of just on flat track on the roller coaster, you know, where nothing’s really quite happening. Because even on the flat track moments, you can have looming tension, have tension between two people or confessionals, and there’s lots of stuff you can do that’s not big reveals and stuff. To track through act two, where we sort of get lost sometimes as writers, in the unknown world, once the hero steps into this special world, unknown world, they’re not used to, we have a first day of school event, which is the reaction to this new world, followed by watering hole, which is the communal gathering place, bar, restaurant, any sort of gathering of people, so you can show a little bit of the microcosm of your new world.
Rules and tools, where you can play with the mythology and the rules of your story, what the character should or should not do. The next event, approaching the danger zone, ramping up to our second threshold, which is crossing the threshold into the danger zone, and this is sort of like, we call this first day of school, this whole movement, because it feels like that, it’s like, whoa, got too close to the bully, usually your force of antagonism will be introduced at the end of our second movement here, and then we move into movement three, which is from the danger zone to the central crisis or tipping point of the story, and this is the movement we’re in now. The important thing to note is that that break that we’re doing here for the danger zone, that’s the key to all this. It helps you to build two separate sequences from crossing that first threshold into, to your build to your crisis. You’ve got a little bit more ability to measure out when your audience is experiencing things and when they’re not.
So in movement three, danger zone to crisis, we start with the first day of school, we start with the close call, which is sort of like a reaction or gathering oneself after having dealt with whatever the danger zone was, followed by the next event, new discovery, and that’s like a new discovery lesson or information. Sometimes a second herald will show up here. The next event, which is the event for this week, new direction, or your adventure opening up. You can also have a herald here. This is also another place that a herald can pop in. A second herald. So let’s talk a little bit about coming from new discovery, new discovery or lesson or information the hero attains, new direction, how new direction and the adventure opening up results from it.
Devin: Right now, our hero or heroes are thinking like clearly continuing without some kind of a plan is not the way to go. So let’s take this moment of inaction and come up with something.
Adam: It’s a great point. Yeah.
Devin: And the hero, they don’t necessarily hear. She or they still don’t necessarily have all the knowledge of the unknown world, or perhaps they don’t have all the rules and tools. But what they’ve experienced thus far is enough to at least make some educated decision on how to proceed. We can also, again, take this moment to zero in on on some static or friction, maybe between characters in the group, or perhaps our hero is presented with the next call to action, and they have this this another internal debate or external. With with multiple heroes. When I was when I was thinking about this event, I was thinking about these different decision making points of our heroes quest. And I tried to I tried to pinpoint them. I hadn’t I hadn’t done this before. But I tried to pinpoint the decision making moments and when certain decisions are no longer an option.
Adam: Oh, that’s nice. The thresholds are those moments where you you can’t go really back from it in a way, but the decision. Point, right before that threshold, or like, when does it finally not become an option? Exactly. I hadn’t thought about that. That’s pretty interesting.
Devin: This is kind of what I came up with. And it’s this is more of a sparking a debate type of thing. But I came up with a so the call to quest is the do I stay in the status quo of the known world and let the antagonist win? But then, of course, the is that the story continues, the our hero makes the decision to go on the quest. And then it’s the close call event equals. Holy crap. Do I continue on this quest? Or did I make the wrong decision? And I need to retreat, I’m going to retreat, I’m going to go back to the known world and let the antagonist win, because that’s still an option for me. But then they get the story continues, they like, all right, I’ll move on. Because perhaps they got this new that new discovery that we talked about last week gives us gives a little bit more confidence that okay, I’m equipped a little better.
Maybe I’ll continue to keep make this attempt. And then it’s the new direction where we’re at now. And this is the kind of given this new discovery or knowledge, do I continue on with the quest? Or are my internal obstacles too great to overcome? That’s, I’m going to take this last chance to retreat and go back to the unknown world and let the antagonist win. And I think that’s where we’re at now is right now our heroes still have the option to retreat, to quit the quest. And retreat. But this is the last time they’re going to be given this option, because then there’s the hero’s darkest moment. And at that moment, because the retreat option is no longer there, the giving up completely and the death, death in this unknown world, that’s the option. So they can either, they can give up at this moment of the hero’s darkest, this hero’s darkest moment, they can still give up and die within figuratively or literally die, or they can find it in them, they can defeat them.
I can defeat this inner, these, these internal obstacles, the obstacles inside, I can defeat them, the obstacles inside me, and I can rise from these ashes, a new person, and I can continue this quest. And I will either defeat the antagonist, or I’m going to die trying, there’s no other option. And I think that’s where I think those are the stages of decision making for, or the options, decision making and options of the hero. And I think the new direction, this is really that last, last moment, where our hero or heroes can decide to, you know, Jumanji, it’s Jumanji aside, where they’re stuck in a game, but they can just say, Nope, I’m going back to my old life. I’m going back to my, to the unknown or to the known world. If the antagonist wins and defeats and blows up the world, so be it, but I am not the person for this. So this is kind of a crucial, I feel this is a very crucial moment.
Adam: That’s what Jonas does in, in Jumanji. Jumanji, yeah. Yeah.
Devin: Jonas.
Adam: Jonas.
Devin: I think it’s a good thing to track is when options start dissolving for your, or becoming non options for you, for the hero.
Adam: As this is StoryOsophy folks, we’re going to present ideas and we’re going to process them and adjust them and change them if they serve us better in the future. Yes. This is all about exploration and imagination through ideas. You got to bring new ideas. You got to be daring enough to, to explore. But some of the things that it’s like, anytime. You’re even looking at these movements where there are thresholds, the hero only, only knows so much. And then once they reach that threshold, are they resistant to expanding that knowledge because they need to be right? Or do they let go of an old belief system to understand another side of it?
I think I said something a little bit about this in a previous episode. There’s an ideologue who identifies with that which they know. And then there’s a truth seeker who identifies with that which they do not know. And to do either one is not good. To be a broad-minded thinker where you realize you will vacillate between those two states of being where you identify with what you know, and if you don’t understand something, you explore it, understand it, and then integrate it into now what you understand. Right, right. But you don’t want to stay in what you understand, and you don’t want to stay in that which you don’t understand because there’s no grounding place there.
Mm-hmm, mm-hmm. You need to vacillate between both those states. Mm-hmm. What happens in these movements is the hero is learning something new, and at the beginning of this journey, in the beginning of Act 2, they’re not willing to learn. That’s part of the problem is they’re either too standoffish, don’t want to engage, or too arrogant and think they know everything and sort of get up in the danger zone. They sort of get their butt kicked and go, well, I guess we don’t know that. Or Jumanji, they’re inactive. They’re resistant in denial and inactive until motorcycles with missiles come after them, and then they’re like, ooh.
Ooh. Exit stage left, even. A little Snagglepuss reference. That’s a lot of what’s happening for your hero is, and for any of us in life, you’re not going to know everything at first. And what aspect of it is resistance? Because that’s where your source of antagonism shows up. Resistance. That’s it. Whatever you don’t want to change, that’s what’s going to grind at you the most, you know? Right. As you were talking about that decision-making process, I was thinking about this. Most of what happens throughout this whole journey is self-doubt. It’s what happens throughout. All of our journeys is self-doubt. This is usually the number one flaw.
It’s about finding what dimension of self-doubt your hero is experiencing. Is it in love? Is it in money? Is it in career? Is it in, where is it? Like, once you find that, you’re good. And the journey, the payoff of this self-doubt bit, and you can see it reflected really brilliantly in Johnny Depp’s performance of Edward Scissorhands, this intimate, internal self-doubt that finds moments of light and darkness, because he doesn’t say much. Right. Opposite of that, as Devin had mentioned, confidence. Once that hero transitions into sort of, now we’re consciously building something, a plan. Now we… We consciously are doing things. We have confidence in the second half after this midpoint that we’re coming to within the next three events. And in case, confidence gets thrown around as a word a lot, but here’s the definition of confidence. Consciousness of one’s own power. That’s the definition. Which means you just become aware of your own self-worth, countering the self-doubt that is the flawed aspect of character.
So that transition, that’s what we’re looking at. And this midpoint is where they move from basically reacting, like the beginning we’re like of act two, we’ve talked about the characters in reactive mode. And then you move into the second half of your story past the crisis, and now they’re in responsive mode. And I differentiate it like this too. One is motivated action and one is inspired action. Meaning something’s pushing you along, you’re being motivated to do something, but it’s not coming from within. Self-awareness, confidence, consciousness of one’s own power. And the second half, they’re growing towards that and empowering self. Internally, the decision-making process is like that too.
Devin: And I think for writers, it’s important too, and I’m going to really think a little bit more about this decision-making stages and options provided to hero at certain stages. And really kind of hone in on that because it’s important for us to know what options we’re still providing our hero at. At what point and understanding what we want. We as writers want our heroes to continue on with the quest. So what do we need to give them at this moment after, say, the close call? And they just saw the force of the antagonist scares the crap out of them. Self-doubt is high. And so the option they have here is retreat. And what do we need to provide them new discovery to allow?
We need to allow them to give them that confidence to move forward, to continue with the quest. New discovery doesn’t mean we have to give them everything. We don’t have to give them all the rules and tools. We just got to give them enough confidence to move on. Because we still don’t want, at that stage of the game, what I was talking about, close call, new discovery, where they’re still very flawed. And their internal obstacles are registering.
Adam: But they recognize that now. Right. They recognize that they’re flawed too. Yeah. In Jumanji. New information. The simple thing they use is when Bethany goes, by the way, the marketplace, the bazaar, looks like it’s right over there. She just gives them a new, at the end of new discovery, she gives them a new direction. Exactly. Yeah. Or at the end of close call, part of the new direction is, by the way, we’re going to be traveling to the bazaar, right? Right. We’ve been trying to get there. That’s where we know we have the missing piece. Now we know we have to get there or we’re going to die. So the stakes get increased from the motorcycle chase. And within the close call, she says, this is where we’re going next.
So new discovery on their way there. This is when we explore the relationships a little more. We’ll get into examples here in a moment. But talking broadly still about this event, especially Jumanji, they were clever enough to have the villain reconnaissance. They come back and they go, they got away. And he’s like, that’s all right. I’ll send my vulture. And so we know this vulture is looming over everything. We don’t know where, we don’t know when it’s going to find our heroes. We don’t know any of this stuff. But we do kind of have an understanding that. It could be anywhere and we wouldn’t know it in every scene. Now we have all these talky comedy scenes where they push each other off cliffs and they compromise between Martha and Bethany with this little bit of looming danger from the antagonist. And it’s not heavy. It’s not super intense, but it’s something enough in this. We’re still fairly early in the story that will let us ride the tension. Let us ride the danger tension.
Check this out.
[Sponsor message]
Adam: When I’m building a script, when I’m building a story, each of these movements is about 15 pages or 15 minutes in a screenplay format for me, because I want the story to move, and in certain instances, depending on the pacing of the story or whatever, or length, these will increase or decrease, each one individually or all in general, like Devin and I are working on a piece where our movements currently are 20 pages each, it’s not too far off from 15, but the whole point of mentioning pages and minutes for these movements is measurement, specifically measurement. If you know this event happens at page 15, and you want them to forget about this setup that has happened here, you do it 30 pages later, not 15 pages later, because the audience and viewer is probably still thinking about that. So it’s about spacing too. Not that these movements have to be 15 pages, we’re not dictatorial about any of this philosophy. These are more suggestions, but that’s what I stick to for myself.
StoryOsophers, that’s something worth mentioning for navigation purposes. You’re headed towards, at the crisis, if you’re doing a 90-page script, each movement is 15 minutes. At 45 minutes, the midpoint, that’s what we’re building to. So we know this scene, or this event that we’re talking about, New Direction, Adventure Opens Up, is somewhere like 35 to 40 minutes into the story. You can approximate visually seeing, or on-the-page translation script to screen, how it’s going to play. Would I be bored with this? Too little for the hero to be tangling with at 30 minutes in? At 60 minutes in? Because you know, most people will say, well, I don’t really know how to write a story. No, you know. You’ve been an audience member. You know.
Yeah, exactly. You know if you’d be bored at 30 minutes if this happened. You know. You just got to trust that instinct and be willing to cut the things that you think are super funny, but move in the story nowhere. You have to be willing, as Devin and I were talking about a little off-air, you have to fail a couple times. Be willing to fail and be like, nope, that didn’t work. All right. And just be comfortable enough to move past it. And not be tanked by it. Flexibility of learning. And that’s your hero. At this point, when they come to the threshold, they’re building to the threshold, they realize they got to be a little bit more flexible. Because A, they don’t know everything. And B, the solution is not going to be as simple as they thought it might. They can’t just hide and everything fixes itself. They have to now think about action.
Devin: Yeah, exactly. They have to actually have to make a plan based on what they know. Yeah. And they can’t just keep blindly moving forward and hope that they solve this or they somehow. The answer comes to them. They know that they have to make a plan.
Adam: And the next movement, movement four, at the end of it is sort of a re-choosal of your quest and a creating of a new plan, which will become your climax. But here, they know they may have to do it, but they’re not. They sort of take for granted the amount of time or their skill set and being able to put that plan into action. Or they don’t even know what the plan needs to be. They just know that a plan needs to be had. A plan needs to be hatched and created. But they don’t really know quite what to do with it.
Devin: Yeah. It’s almost like approaching a plan. Yeah. Because they know they need to get somewhere and learn and get more information so they can start that plan. But they know now they need a plan. They have to choose. They can’t continue on the way they’re going right now. Otherwise, the next wave of minions that come, they’re not going to be able to escape from. And so they’re going to have to figure something a different way. And then they have to go. So they’re gathering still knowledge.
Adam: Yeah. And they want to prepave, too, and make choices rather than choices by default.
Devin: Right.
Adam: Like, oh, we’re now reacting to something because we weren’t prepared enough or we didn’t think ahead and make choices. Yeah. They use the word victim a lot in the storytelling mode because a lot of times it’s sort of like, what can we punish our hero with from this force of antagonism? And it’s not really about that. It’s about the hero understanding that they are not a victim, that they have their own power. And so that feeling plays here where it’s like we’re at the whim of this world, whether it’s Jumanji or Edward Scissorhands or whatever. We’re at the whim of this thing that feels larger than life, the unknown world.
It’s daunting. Change is daunting. And that’s what story is, change and growth and many other words. But if it’s not changing, if your movements or chain of events are not changing your hero from threshold to threshold, that’s why you have these separate things to examine. So you can figure out where’s, where am I static? Where are my stakes not raised? Are my hero not changing? But this is sort of like that place where they’re, as Devin has said, we realize we need to make choices and create a plan. That’s a big realization moment.
Devin: And it’s always a decision. There’s always, there’s never a point where the hero doesn’t have to make a decision. It’s just his, his options change. And the reason he’s making there, he or she is making that decision is based on what they’ve gone through. And so you, and hopefully what you’ve put them through has changed them. There’s been growth. There’s been realization of, of something they’ve, they’ve defeated those internal obstacles of, and which allowed them to break out of that cocoon and become something different. There, there’s, there’s someone else. And that’s usually that rising of the ashes after that hero’s darkest moment that will, I don’t want to jump ahead, but that’s the ultimate change in this, in this hero. But up until that point, there’s decisions being made, but each decision is also an opportunity to show growth in the character as well.
Yeah. Because there’s some, there’s a reason why they’re continuing. Yeah. They’re making that decision to, to continue on with the quest. There’s a little bit of change, a little bit of change. And so that’s, it’s key to track that, track, track all of that. It helps. They’re all signposts.
Adam: And not that I’m a, I’m a fan of using the, the concept of everything is like a school, like the world is supposed to be school, because I don’t really believe that. But in terms of navigating a story, like lessons, thinking of lessons learned, the hero, this is the way I would differentiate between a common hero. Well, in a lot of, as far as growth is concerned, whatever happens in a place where the hero gets tested and they, they go, whoa, like a threshold moment before a close call or an escape, there is a lesson and there is the, the thing you learned. There’s the, the event, the situation that is the lesson itself. And then there’s the knowledge you take away from that. And this is most people in life where they get stuck too, but it’s, it’s a place where heroes get stuck, where you become more obsessed with the lesson itself.
Lesson and not the knowledge that you can take away from it as to what you want in the future. So people obsess over the situation, the story they tell other people is, well, this is what happened to me. We, you’re just taught telling the story over and over about the lesson. You didn’t take anything from it and go, if you’re repeating that same story, you haven’t said now, well, now I believe this new thing. Now I make these new choices because of said event, because of said lesson. I think that the triumphant hero, the comedic hero, the, you know, not a tragic ending, they come to terms with the knowledge. They’re like, there’s knowledge to be had from this. I don’t need to be right or wrong. If that’s the equation in your story, I don’t need to obsess over the lesson or the event or the bad relationship or the, any of those things that have brought me to this point. It’s just the lesson I’ve learned from that is I want people to treat me better in a relationship. I want to, to have a boss that treats me with more respect in some, you know, instead of obsessing over the source of antagonism, you have an understanding of what you can gain from that lesson versus learned bingo. Okay. On to examples. So we’ll start with Jumanji. Oh, welcome to the jungle. This is pretty, pretty simple. It’s the marketplace. Yeah. The adventure opens up new direction. The adventure opens up. We get this huge panning shot of the marketplace on the hillside. It’s introducing us to a broader aspect of story. It also means they’ve gotten to their first goal. First thing is find the missing piece of the market, but the bazaar at the marketplace. So that’s where they’re at. We’re approaching the in most cave in a little bit that because the missing piece is the thing that they’re supposed to seize the reward, the treasure. It ends up being a little bit different, but we’re getting there. And so the new direction is here’s the marketplace and it’s basic stuff. It’s continued tests and trials and rules and tools and fridge blows up from eating cake.
Devin: It’s one of those watering hole. It’s a water, one of those floater water. So you get to see a little bit more of the creatures that inhabit this unknown world and community for sure. And it’s really, it’s actually a very bizarre scene too, because people are just going about their business. Like the creatures of this place are just going about their business as As these four strangers, and I know it’s because it’s like a video game, but just kind of walk through and go into, like, are there, if you look in the background while the four of them are in this pressure cooker tent with the snake, people are just kind of like walking around doing their own thing when it’s like, oh, they’re actually going to try to take on this black mamba that’s in this, I don’t know, it’s just really bizarre.
And it actually plays in perfectly with the video game theme because, or simulation, because it’s, that’s kind of what happens in those parts of a video game where the one main Herald character that shows up, like that kid, he’s the one that has all of the description and, like, you can see his facial features and things like that in a video game. And then there’s always these, like, simulated inhabitants kind of just walking around for background. And that’s kind of. That’s kind of how they set up this scene.
Adam: And the vendor, rations, get your rations.
Devin: Yeah. That guy. And just does the same thing over and over again. Kind of like when you always have to, in the video game, you go up to them multiple times and once you, like, approach them and they stop and then they say it and you’re like, oh, God, I keep running into this guy.
Adam: This is fairly simple in Jumanji because I think it’s more meant for, all right, we’ve brought you to a new location, this watering hole. And we’re just going to play a little bit since this is a comedy. And we have a little bit of cake explosion moments. And then the Herald shows up, the Herald being this little boy who says, Jumanji needs you. And tells them, you know, we’re going off to find the missing piece. That’s the end of it. Yep. From just the introduction of the marketplace until the kid takes them. Because to me, I think the approach to the Inmost Cave and the Inmost Cave or the crisis point would be this sort of.
You’re sort of set up a little bit. It’s not like what they do is they make you go, okay, they got to defeat this Mamba themselves. And then once they’re done that, there’s a little bit of a celebration moment. Oh, shoot. Here are the bad guys, you know. And so there’s a little bit of a subversion thing where you think they have a win and they think they have a win. And then these guys show up. That’s what’s happening. But that’s all the crisis point. The approach to the Inmost Cave is the whole Mamba build. And that’s next week on StoryOsophy. The point is this is pretty.
It’s pretty short. It’s like the new direction is they’re in a new place, brand new environment, watering hole scene. The story opens up and a herald comes to them and says, I’ve got a new direction for you even more, right? I’m going to take you to the missing piece. Jumanji needs you. Repeat the herald statement. Whenever a herald shows up, they’re always telling you Jumanji needs you.
Devin: Yeah. That was pretty simple.
Adam: Edward Scissorhands is a little bit more complicated as it always is because it’s subverting. He’s subverting and spinning these things on his head. And once again, these are events, but these are several scenes worth of sequential buildup for Edward Scissorhands. So I would differentiate these into new direction. And then the second half of what we’re talking about is more adventure opens up in terms of Edward. And I would basically say that at the point when he starts to become more a celebrated person, a celebrity, that’s when it switches to adventure opens up. Because he does all kinds. He gets on a talk show and he’s a possibility of opening up a salon and all this other stuff.
But the beginning, Edward decides after finishing trimming this topiary, this shrub to trim the neighbor’s dog’s hair. And that’s that this is new direction for me. Then the neighborhood is lined up to have all their dogs trimmed because he’s a genius. Edward is a genius. And when he’s finished trimming Joyce’s dog, Joyce wants her haircut. Edward is like this artist in a lab coat. It’s like he’s hit his stride. Think he’s. He’s finding some confidence. And these builds are. This is fun and playful. And actually, the music is very different in this. It’s one of my favorite parts about the sequence. When he starts to cut the women’s hair, Danny Elfman’s score, it sounds like people understanding their own inner beauty.
That’s how brilliant a composer Danny Elfman is. It’s not like any of the rest of the movie in the. It’s got the same themes, but it’s something that’s amazing.
Devin: The only way I see it differently, I think Edward is getting a bit more attention than he would care for. I think he’s he was just hoping to quietly fit in with this unknown world, but he gets the exact opposite and he becomes the center of everyone’s attention. And we get the examples through this scene. The sequence of scenes is Edwards. One of Edwards characters flaws that was pointed out at the barbecue. And it’s. It will not necessarily point out of the barbecue because that was the don’t take things so literal. But this is his inability to make decisions on his own or for himself. He does.
He’s doing what other everybody else is telling him to do. And so I think part of him is just I don’t know if it’s joy that he’s feeling here or he feels joy because other people are happy because I think that is what’s giving him. He’s a lot. And there is there’s a difference there. And I don’t know if I can articulate it, but it’s. I’m. Getting this feeling that he’s a bit overwhelmed, but his problem is he’s just like I said, he’s doing Peg makes the decision for him in his mansion and drags him down to the unknown world. He’s willing. He’s willing to go, but she’s the one is basically like, I need to make decision for you.
And then throughout the entire story until Edward finally just cuts all the clothes off and retreats back to his mansion. He’s doing what everybody else is telling him to do. And so he’s. Just kind of going going through the motions and thinking this is what they want me to do. This is what I’m supposed to do. I must this must be why this must be how I fit in down here. And I think this they seem to accept him here, though, under the surface, even watching these scenes, we’re getting hints that they’re taking advantage of him and his meek disposition. And you kind of start getting the feeling that this perhaps this isn’t going to end well, even here.
It’s a bit tragic, even watching him where he’s. Not he’s a robot. And so he’s just making decisions on his own. So I don’t know. I guess that’s how I was seeing it differently. I was looking under the surface a little bit more, maybe that of trying to figure out what his where he was at emotionally. And I think he is just so overwhelmed. It’s like when you’re so overwhelmed and people like, go here, go here, go here. And you’re like, OK, I’m going to do that because this is what they’re telling me to do. And he’s not because that’s his one main flaw is he takes things to these two main flaws.
He takes things too literally. And that gets him in trouble. And he’s a need to pleaser. Well, he’s a need to pleaser, but he’s also just does he he does what he can’t make decisions on his own yet. He’s just not making decisions. He’s just kind of going with the punches, rolling with the punches.
Adam: So let me let me offer a counterpoint to that. This is the sequence for me that I think Edward is actually feeling joy. He’s finding a purpose because he enjoys doing even up at the mansion. One of the things he does is he grooms. He enjoys doing that. Yeah. Just as a pleasure thing. And now he’s realizing that here people love the thing that he loves. So it’s like he’s being appreciated for his passion. He doesn’t realize he’s being taken for granted fully, even though Bill is basically does tell him like you can’t work for cookies, dude. He’s pointing out that Edward’s being taken for granted in a lot of ways.
Devin: Just to clarify, I don’t think Edward knows any of that. Like I just. I think it’s more of this. I see it as these people are starting to take advantage of him.
Adam: Well, that’s sort of how this progresses.
Devin: And so it’s escalating.
Adam: Yeah. It’s escalates. But I’m just addressing the concept of his approach is I think he is. I think this is Edward’s more joyful segment. And the only reason I’m saying that is it’s purposefully meant to go. Look, people are liking him. Look, he’s finding his niche. Look, he’s amazing. He’s going to start a hair salon. And. Then we start to hit this. The bank is the first rejection moment. And then we get the crisis, which is his trying going with Jim and Kim and getting caught and arrested. And so the joyful part of him actually fitting in is the subversive setup to our approaching crisis that’s coming.
Right. And so I feel like there is in moments here pure joy.
Devin: Right.
Adam: And some of it’s from other people’s joy, but some of it’s from him feeling like his he who he is, his talent really matches.
Devin: You know, I would agree with, with the point that he’s finally doing something really, really one of the only things he knows. And so he knows how to use his, his scissor hands to do what he does up in his mansion with the bushes. And now he’s found another use for them because he didn’t have people with hair or pets with fur. So he’s finding other uses for what he’s doing, which is, which is good. I was.
And I think that’s what I’m trying to, what I’ve been trying to track throughout this entire, of, well, tracking the story is what are those, those internal obstacles that Edward has? And it’s really tough with Edward because he’s just, he’s a invention. Very internal. And he doesn’t have confidence, but it’s not the same as a human being not having confidence. He just doesn’t know what confidence is. But he, what he does do is he takes things too literally and that’s what gets him in trouble. Yeah.
Yeah. Just kind of lets people make decisions for him, which also gets him in trouble. And I think those are the two, so I, so here I would agree, this is his moment of finally feeling like he’s fitting in. And I would agree this is probably his happy moment, but I also, from a different, different perspective, I can all, you can also see how they’re setting up this escalation and you can, the, the, the town is starting to take advantage of it, of him. And I see that’s where it’s, you know, well, like a perfect part. This is, after this, we’re kind of approaching that in, in most caves.
So I think that’s where I was, my, the analysis was basically stemming from.
Adam: And I would say the two part here with the new direction of him now becoming not just a gardener per se, but a hairstylist or a pet groomer, like that’s the new direction aspect. Yeah. And the adventure opening up more is Edward’s celebrity. Yeah. Just that little bit of information from a writer standpoint, lets us know that it’s not just the town anymore. It’s a little bigger. There are little mini scenes in between the sharpening of his hands.
You know, you know what I mean? Yeah. When he’s at the store and he sees Kim and there’s little moments of setup, his lock picking skills. Once again, these are areas where right before your crisis, if you need to set anything up. Yeah. You got to tuck in these little half page scenes, but the adventure opens up. He’s to the point of celebrity where he’s on a TV talk show now, right before we’re getting to the build of the crisis. And after that, we sort of get the payoff of what Devin’s talking about. Even though Edward may be feeling something, we may sense the fact that he’s being taken for granted in the haircutting scene with the women.
Devin: Yeah.
Adam: And here, when the new salon opening up with Joyce, now we get the payoff. Oh, we see. You’re going to profit from Edward’s genius. Like you’re just going to stand there and greet customers and he’s going to do all the work. We get it. That’s the payoff. That’s the reveal of the taking advantage of or taking for granted. And the payoff for that moment is, of course, the family dinner. Yeah. When he admits to them that she’s taking her clothes off in the back room for him. Yeah. A lot of movies would have taken it. And when he said, then she’d show me the back room where she took all her clothes off.
They’d end on the joke, cut the scene, move to the next sequence. And that’s not what happens in this particular film. They let the awkwardness sit in the middle of a public. Public place in the restaurant. And then Bill guides the story into a new direction. Like with let’s get a loan kind of concept. We lead into the bank. Instead of cutting the scene on the joke, they make it transition into the next piece of the movement. The chain of events syncs up more by the way they structure that scene. That would be for me where the adventure opens up ends is Peg and Edward leaving the bank, having been rejected for the loan.
The promise that we’ve had of this build. There’s a bump in the road. Edward can’t just become a famous hairdresser. It’s not that simple. I would agree with that. Yeah. Next week, we move on to approaching the inmost cave. I do love that. That event starting to get good.
Devin: Yeah. I’ll admit the first act movement one, when every week I was like, oh, this is my favorite event to write. It wasn’t lying. I wasn’t lying. And I’ll say, even though we’ve seen in some of the. The example, like with Jumanji and Edward Scissorhands, the first few events and scenes of Movement 2 are not necessarily long, but they’re important and they’re really kind of hard. This is when the writing becomes, you really got to start keeping track of what’s going on in the story because- You can lose them, your audience. This is where you start, yeah. This is usually when I shrivel up in the fetal position under my desk.
It’s like in my thumb, I’m like, oh no.
Adam: Well, we’re moving out of that stage where Devin is under his desk.
Devin: Yeah. Starting to pick up again.
Adam: Yeah. People can get lost. You tend to mess around in this area and there’s spots to do it and spots to build. And hopefully, if you’ve been listening to the past few episodes or a bunch of episodes in Act 2, Movements 2 and Movement 3, you’ll start to understand where there are moments to play a little bit more. And how to have scenes- And how to have scenes where you can play and still have stakes get raised and still have tension, still have things that keep your audience engaged. Like, especially Jumanji. Jumanji is one of our better examples. Like, for instance, we mentioned in this episode, the reconnaissance vulture from Russell Van Pelt.
He says, hey, go, see if you can find them. And we don’t know when or where or how this vulture is going to find them. So, just that simple question can be laid over some of the- Not track rollercoaster moments of your story, where you’re just, like, getting a breather, letting your audience have a chance to chill out for a second. Because from here on out, it gets pretty intense. And although there is a little bit of another dip in the rollercoaster track in Movement 4 with Hero’s Darkest Moment and Fall of the Heart Wall, it’s still pretty fast-paced. And in most movies, that whole middle part of Movement 4 coming up, the quieter spot, is very brief.
They don’t take a lot of time there. I like to take time there. I think Devin does, too. But a lot of stories will just-
Devin: Yep. Yeah.
Adam: They’ll just burn through that row, especially romantic comedies. They like to have more trial on the front side of the crisis or midpoint and move that midpoint so it’s not really a midpoint, it’s a little later. Yeah. And a lot of movies will do this. Even in Jumanji and Edward Scissorhands, if you look at the time measurement for the movements we’re tracking you through, the beginning, Act 2, is pretty swollen compared to- Where the midpoint hits. And after the midpoint, the story is a little bit more condensed, squeezed down. So it’s not always equal measurements in some of these more traditional storytelling models. The crisis comes later, Act 2.
But I think you deprive- We’ve talked about this before. I think you deprive your audience of some of the ways the hero learns who they become in Movement 4, the recovery movement, after the crisis. But you can make your own decisions. We’ll track you through it in the next bunch of episodes, and you can figure out what you want to do. Right, Dee?
Devin: That’s right. You make your own decisions, just like the hero.
Adam: Well, StoryOsophers, between this week and next week, sit down and write some pages on this event. New direction, your adventure opening up. If you have a story you’re working on, sit down and see if you can get three pages, a decent scene, a start to this event, a scene, a couple scenes that are encompassed by this event. And if you don’t have a story that you’re specifically working on, just sit down and take the- Principles of New Direction, and do a 15-minute free write. Just write as much as you can, a scene that you come up with on this event, or for this event, and write for 15 minutes.
You never know where it can take you. Sometimes those 15-minute free writes, for me, have been the genesis for an entire story. So, take the time, just a lot, a little bit of time for yourself, for your own creative expression, for your own imagination. Write three pages. Do a 15-minute free write. And next week, we’ll be talking about- Approaching the Inmost Cave. Until then. Please subscribe and rate us on iTunes. Follow us on social media. Share with your friends and send us your questions and comments. For additional resources and links to films, series, and books we talk about here, visit our website. While you’re there, sign up for our newsletter for updates on story building tools and special offers at StoryOsophy.com.