Show notes
Rules and tools is where your hero learns the mythology of the unknown world: how it works, what’s dangerous, and what they’ll have to work with. A tool can be an object, a skill or simply a piece of knowledge. Adam and Devin explain why it’s one of their favorite events, how it overlaps with the watering hole, and why the most memorable rules are often the ones that get broken. In the second half they talk about giving and taking feedback.
In this episode
- An overlapper and a floater. Rules and tools can come before or after the watering hole, run across several events, return later in the story, or fill a whole movie, as in mentor tales like The Karate Kid.
- Knowledge is a tool. A mentor, a native of the world, or the love interest’s best friend at lunch can hand your hero what they need. James Bond gets his gadgets, along with rules about how to use them.
- Rules are made to be broken. Gremlins gives three rules and then breaks every one. A rule can also be flipped on its head at the climax: sunlight is what defeats Stripe.
- Put your premise in the rules. This is a natural place to state your log line plainly for the audience.
- Plug plot holes with a perspective. Give a character the doubt the audience will have, and say it out loud.
- The lack of tools. What your hero can’t do in this world can drive the scenes just as well.
- Set up expectations to subvert. Jumanji puts its low point at the midpoint and wins at the end. Edward is celebrated at the midpoint, which makes his tragic ending hit harder.
- Don’t get lazy. Avoid convenient tools that bail your hero out. The cell phone has ruined many horror, thriller and mystery plots, so lose it, break it, or get creative.
- On feedback. Write every note down and look at it a week later. Take right and wrong out of it, ask questions, and listen for the problem even if the suggested fix doesn’t work. When giving feedback, say what excited you and what didn’t work; “it was nice” helps no one.
- Bricklayer or church builder. Are you laying one brick at a time, or building toward the bigger picture you see in your mind?
Examples discussed
- Jumanji: Welcome to the Jungle: Nigel’s rhyme (“If you wish to leave the game, you must save Jumanji and call out its name”), the three lives tattooed on their wrists, and the stats screen with strengths and weaknesses, all setups for later payoffs like Fridge’s cake weakness and Martha’s dance fighting. “You can’t just drive us to the statue?” plugs the obvious plot hole.
- Edward Scissorhands: his rules and tools are subtle, from the clothes and concealer that act as a mask to Bill’s whiskey and straw. The key rule comes at the barbecue: “you need to not take things so literally.” Edward can’t, and it leads to his downfall.
- The Matrix: Morpheus and Neo’s conversation, the bullet-point version of rules and tools.
- The Karate Kid Part III: a false mentor teaches rules meant to harm Daniel.
- Also: Gremlins, Elf and Get Out.
Writing along with the season? Write three pages that give your hero three rules and three tools, and try flipping one of them on its head.
Read the full transcript
Transcribed automatically, so expect the odd misheard word. Sponsor messages are left out.
Adam: In this episode, we discuss the story event Rules and Tools. What are the rules of your story’s mythology? What tools is your hero introduced to to deal with the unknown world of Act 2? Next on StoryOsophy. Hello, welcome to StoryOsophy. This is Adam Jones. And Devin Halden. Episode 51. Episode 51. 51.
Devin: Doesn’t really have the ring that last episode did. It’s like turning 22. It’s like, hmm.
Adam: 51.
Devin: Now it’s just a number.
Not much of a milestone.
Adam: Hey, I just wanted to mention one thing before about our conversation. People or a person, a character even, doesn’t know they’re narrow-minded until they actually realize they’ve been narrow-minded. I know, yeah. You don’t know that next level of belief or thought until you move from that comfort zone of that belief system into a consideration beyond that thing or a journey into… The unknown or special world. Right. And so part of the journey of any character is that you don’t know you’re narrow-minded. You don’t know your belief system or your thoughts are limited until you realize there’s more to it than what you thought. And I was realizing that’s part of the crux of our conversation.
Devin: And if your known world and your known world routine is surrounded by people that have the same viewpoint as you and you only subject yourself or you only listen to the thoughts and ideas of people that agree with you. And so it’s like they’re surrounded by people with the same views. So they’re not really getting any ideas or viewpoints from friends or from people that they may trust beyond political views, which is just perpetuating what their beliefs are, their belief system. And it’s not until somebody comes in And either forces them, somehow they’re forced to get pulled out of that comfort zone and all of a sudden you’re put into an area or a state that has very different views that you may have not even been aware of because your world consists of just the same, everybody with the same like-minded views as you.
And so once you start hearing it from people, but you also have to hear it from people, you can’t hear it because they already have this preconceived notion that they don’t believe them and you know what? There needs to be a pathway. Yeah, there needs to be a connection, which is what we’re talking about, like that Harold character. Or someone that, or it’s pet. There needs to be a Peg with Edward Scissorhands. It’s like there needs to be a Peg for everybody where there’s a trust. So the minute you trust somebody, you’ll listen to somebody, you know? Like… I don’t have the same views as some of these people I was on an ice fishing trip with, but I respected them enough to listen to them and be like, well, like, I get where you’re coming from. And then even trying to reword things, because I think semantics is a big part of politics and things that get strewn and blown out of proportion.
Adam: Also, when you’re locked into something, there’s no maneuverability. There needs to be a right and a wrong versus you can broaden everything out to most people’s needs are simple. Most people would agree on basic wants and desires that they have in their lives, home, family, happiness, like, just basic things, but they’d all agree on this thing. And then you start politics is the song and dance of what we should be thinking about because someone else points at it. It’s, it’s, it’s, it’s no different than show business, right? It’s this, you know, it’s a show business. It’s no different than arts, entertainment, movies. It’s the same thing.
Devin: And business is entrepreneurs do it all the time where you exactly, they don’t know why their company’s not working. They don’t know why their company was for the first two years had had 10x growth. And all of a sudden, they’ve hit this stalemate. And then they don’t understand why. So they they bring in an expert or they bring in people that say, No, you got to change, you know, your branding’s off your brand. Well, I worked for five years on that brand. And then they fight and they fight and they fight. And it’s like, look, you’re so stuck in your ways. You’re so and your belief, like you, you either want these people to come in and just give you money and continue doing what you’re doing.
Nobody wants to be wrong. Of course, and not even that. It’s not even that it’s it’s like, I it is that like, nobody wants to be wrong with this, then embarrassing is the embarrassment thing. Exactly. But it’s also people that don’t, they don’t see the forest through the trees are so narrow minded. Three steps ahead versus right now, reactive versus a building.
Everybody’s going to be delegated to do something and it’s going to be a more efficient company, then the people are gonna start buying your product again. But people don’t see that they’re so close minded.
Adam: It’s control versus co creation, cooperation, co. Of course, everyone wants to control a certain aspect of that’s part of the fun of driving a vehicle being an avatar. You’re Devin Halden, I’m Adam Jones. So we want to do right, we want to have some sort of like say in what we’re doing, but doing it to a degree where you have a stranglehold on something. Where it doesn’t allow it to grow is part of the issue, you know, and that’s even when we’re talking about storytelling with a character navigating, if they’re trying to cling to that comfort zone or belief system that they’ve held for so long, and they can’t see past it, because you have to sort of dictate to your mind, the ability to see past it, right? If you if you think I’m not going to see this, I’m not going to see this, you’re not going to see it because you’ve limited your own possibility of perspective, right? And I feel like that’s what we’ve sort of been discussing is that limitation, people’s perspectives are not as they can be much bigger and broader than people allow a lot of its fear. And what we’re like being wrong, every nobody wants to be wrong. I mean, and everybody gets that. Unfortunately, right now, we’re in one of the worst periods of judgment and shaming in humanity, because we’ve got the internet and everybody’s looking at pictures of everybody else and poking fun and, and praising and nobody wants to feel shamed. Nobody wants to feel judged. And so everybody’s stepping on eggshells, and they, they can’t say this, or it’s inappropriate to do this inappropriate. Depends on your perspective, doesn’t it?
Devin: No, the problem with the government and just in its entirety, Rick, removing all the bullshit of you did this 30 years ago, like all the personal attacks about someone’s character. It’s like, all right, remove all that bullshit. And then understand who you you that you elected officials are and what your job is. Okay, so let’s take your job where it’s like, you’re so short sighted on how do we become rich now? Well, that’s coal, that’s fossil fuels, and that stuff like that. Or let’s do all the things that that in the past have gotten this country rich, right? Either traditionalism instead of like we’ve talked about before about being progressive. Yeah, or looking looking towards the future. And so it’s like writing a story. It’s Story Blueprint. It’s exactly it. It’s like, either there’s two people that could be laying bricks. So one person is laying bricks, and the other person is building a church in their mind.
So one guy’s just going out and he’s doing his job. He’s doing it one brick at a time and all he’s doing is laying bricks. And another guy can’t wait to get out of bed in the morning because every day, at the end of the day, he sits back and looks at what he did and it’s turning him more and more into what his dream is or what he sees in his mind’s eye. And so it’s two different perspectives. It’s like, do you just want to sit down and be a writer and that’s it? So you’re just going to write? Or are you sitting down because you see your story as a big picture?
And design it. And you’re saying, oh my, this brick is here. This hook, this is here, this is here. And I’m building it because it’s going to be this beautiful, deep, symbolic story. And that’s the type of person that I want to be.
Adam: Or even this, are you enjoying the laying of the brick? Are you enjoying writing each scene at a time? Are you doing it for another reason? Are you sort of chasing fame, fortune, or whatever you have in your mind? Or are you interested in the actual building of it?
Devin: Right. Are you writing as a job because you get up and you think it’s a job and you’re looking for a paycheck? Or are you doing it because you’re part of something bigger? A chore or a choice. Yeah. And that’s what it is. It’s something bigger. And so that’s, it’s business. You know, that’s what it is. It’s this country. You should be, we should be thinking about everything. These little things that we’re doing today are for a bigger picture. It’s to make this country bigger and better. But we don’t, like the people that we have in charge just don’t think that way. Right.
Right.
Right.
Right. Like you’re saying, to build that story, to build it. So rules and tools.
Adam: This week, we’re talking about the story event rules and tools. I have to say, this is definitely one of my favorite events, Devin. I know you love this event too, but this is definitely one of my top favorites. Favorite events. I love it. And because of its malleability, it can work as a scene. It can work as an entire event. A blanket, an overlapper. An overlapper. It’s an overlapper and a floater. And it can be a set piece. Actually, a lot of stories I was thinking about this are completely rules and tools stories, like mentor tales, Karate Kid, for instance. It’s all about learning the rules and the tools of whatever you’re doing. Some stories have it early on and it’s sort of a setup. But a lot of, even Jumanji, the video game trajectory of it, the rules and tools are learned throughout. But I love it because it’s all about the mythology of your story and some of the cool stuff your heroes get to use or even think they have as tools or skill sets that you might flip on their head by the end of the story. It’s fun.
Devin: It’s definitely an event that you can go back if you get stuck somewhere and your character needs. And out, you’re like, oh, I’m going to go back to that original rules and tools scene and give them another tool here so I can use it here.
Adam: So just to framework the structure of like where this lies in the way Devin and I are laying out the Story Blueprint here, we break them down from three act structure we’re sort of dealing with, but we’re breaking it down into movements, which are smaller sequences within the acts. This is in act 2 act 1 aka Movement one, for the most part, is your hook scene, your known world routine, inciting incident, which sets your story domino, tips your first domino, sets the story into motion, call to quest, which meets your hero, refusal of the call, where your hero has a moment of doubt, choosal of call, which you’ll find Devin and I like to rhyme stuff for fun. It’s easy to remember, too.
Choosal of call is where the hero actually accepts the call despite the debate or doubt they’ve had and then crossing the first threshold into the unknown world of act two. Act one is known as the known world. Each movement is meant to transition. Movement one is from the comfort zone to out of comfort zone. So your hero’s been going about their daily routine and then they’re moved into the story journey. Movement two, which is also act two, act two is our unknown world and movement, our first movement in that act, is from out of the comfort zone. Into the danger zone. So we’re traveling from the beginning of movement two where we’ve left movement one out of the comfort zone and we’re going to get to into the danger zone. We like to do these crossfades or transitional things across movements so you can track that your character’s actually going somewhere. Because part of the problem with act two, as Devin will attest, is you tend to get lost. So movement two we call it’s all fun and games until or first day of school. And the transition is from out of comfort zone into the danger zone. It’s just our way of tracking. It’s a way of not getting lost in the map of your story when you’re trying to lay out your blueprint. If you’re lost, your audience is lost. Yeah. Be clear about your confusion. If your audience is supposed to be confused, just be clear about with yourself how they’re confused. Don’t be confused and then they’re confused because you didn’t know what you were doing. Be a little bit more in control of that. It should feel confusing in this movement.
As a general statement. Yeah. This is where your hero has stepped into a new world and they’re sort of disoriented. But it’s deliberate confusion rather than you’re so confused and you’re writing it. Yeah. On the part of the writer, on the part of the character, it’s not deliberate. Well, it’s straight up confusion.
Devin: It’s straight up. It’s straight up confusion, dude, for them. I was talking from a writer standpoint is like, yeah, if you’re the if you’re the one that’s confused.
Adam: Confused. You may be off course a bit. Find a buoy. My characters know what they’re doing, but I have no idea. They keep trying to get me to come back. So just a framework rules and tools a little bit more movement to the order of events from out of comfort zone to into danger zone. We start with first day of school or reaction to the unknown world. This is a fun movement, too. I got to say, Devin, this is I really enjoy this movement, too.
Devin: You got to say it. Yeah.
Adam: Actually calling it. I think Blake Snyder called. It’s all fun and games, too. Yeah. But I think that’s super appropriate because as a writer, you get to play here some. And that’s what’s fun about it is you have room to play in the beginning of each of these movements. They sort of repeat. You got a little bit of a hook scene. You get time to play a little bit. And then a choice needs to be made. And you need to like sort of get back to a plot based crossing a threshold of change and choice. But you get to play in each of these movements. If you find the space to do it.
First day of school reaction, unknown world is the first event of movement to. And the next we have is the watering hole, then rules and tools, then approaching the danger zone and then crossing the second threshold of into the danger zone. The one thing I’ll say, as we mentioned before, watering hole rules and tools, they’re overlappers. They can go across several events. As Devin coined the phrase last week. What? My favorite. New word for describing story events. There are overlappers and there are floaters, meaning watering hole and rules and tools. You can you can switch them. And in many stories, they’re in reverse order than we’ve just laid them out.
Rules and tools can come before watering hole. I think the reason we laid out watering hole beforehand was part of reaction to the unknown world. If you think of it as first day of school is coming into the halls, maybe your first classroom, homeroom. Where they announce your name and you’re seeing other people, but then there’s a cafeteria scene. Then there’s a prison movie. There’s a mess hall scene. There’s a there’s a scene where the microcosm, the mini world of whatever the story world is, or the unknown world that you’ve just entered in act two needs to be showcased a little bit. You can expand it. We’re always going to peel back the layers of the onion, right? Grow more and more. But you need to show it a little bit and show, oh, there’s the these.
Factions over here and these clicks of people over here. And so that you understand the community of it. And what’s fun about it is if you have a watering hole where everything goes bad, then the rules and tools seen is required. I don’t know what I’m doing. I don’t know what to do to survive. I need help. And a mentor steps in and goes, look, three rules. Boom, boom, boom. Here, take this gum. When you chew it, I don’t have gum. Every episode for the past five episodes have been talking about gum as a. Plot point that has been going with it. Well, I started it out as a children’s book plot. Like if you if the stakes are gum and you don’t have gum, it’s a big deal. But you know what, dude, you don’t have to explain yourself. Let’s just go with it. I like it. I felt like I felt like I did. I know. I felt like I did. I felt like I was. I felt wrong, Devin. I felt wrong. I didn’t even give you any feedback, negative feedback. So look at that. It had nothing to do with anything Devin said. It was me feeling guilty.
Guilty and paranoid and freaking out. That’s most writers responses to feedback.
So, you can have the rules and tools as a response to almost like being embarrassed in the communal environment, or you can go, all right, we’re about ready to enter the communal environment of the watering hole. We should prepare by dot, dot, dot. Here, make sure you put this on, do this, and get ready because it’s going to be rough in here. And then you enter the communal environment of the unknown world. So, you can do, you can switch those events, which is why we call them floaters, and you can even move these things later on in the story. There are several stories that move these much later, or have reprisals of them. You’ll get new or more rules and tools later, like Rules and Tools Part 2, Electric Boogaloo. It’s an old 80s reference about breakdancing.
Devin: Yeah, I got you. I was burping.
Adam: I got you. I just didn’t think it was funny.
Devin: No, I got the reference, just not funny at all.
Adam: So, rules and tools.
Devin: Yeah, and I think we’re equipping our hero with some specific knowledge of this unknown world that we’re building, but we’re also, and perhaps don’t necessarily have to give them a physical tool, but that knowledge in and of itself could be a tool, or we could be giving them knowledge of a physical tool that they need to find, or they may come across. Yeah. You know, if it’s like an epic journey, if it’s an epic story, like it could be a mentor or another creature of the unknown world with knowledge of that world, or of the antagonist, or of the antagonist forces. In a rom-com, this could be the event where the best friend of the love interest of our hero is meeting him for lunch, or her for lunch, and giving him some pointers on how to act around his love interest.
And what not to say around the love interest, or a secret of love interest, like a passion or hobby that nobody else knows, and it could give him a leg up if he, you know, whatever. It’s just stuff like that we’re getting, this is where we as writers get to, as Adam said, build the mythology or translate the mythology to our audience and say, look, if this happens, this could happen. Yeah. And these guys right here, these, this, they’re, they’re mean, or they’re, they’re an antagonistic force, and they’re not the antagonist, but there is minions, or, and, you know, that’s part of the watering hole, and that’s also why these are kind of overlappers, is because usually we’re getting this knowledge while maybe another event is going on.
And so, you know, in a, in a watering hole example, it would be like sitting at a table at the bar and a guy pointing out, all right, stay away from that. That guy, this, if, if you give him this gum, he’ll explode. If you use this gum, so it’s like that kind of stuff. It’s, it’s, or it’s the, it’s that moment in all the James Bond films that he’s getting all of his cool, cool little tools, his tool belt of mechanisms that will help him throughout his journey.
Adam: You’ll get rules about the tools too. Right, exactly. Like he’ll say, Bond, remember, when you press this watch, you’ll have 10 seconds to, that’s part of the tools thing. Rules in general, what we mean is the mythological layout of the new world that they’ve just entered, the unknown world. A good, a really good example is this, gremlins. There are three rules in gremlins, and that’s the mythology of it. I don’t, I’m trying to remember what they are now. Should have prepared.
Devin: Well, after midnight.
Adam: Don’t feed them after midnight. Water. They don’t like sunlight and don’t get them wet. Right. And you get those three rules for the purpose early on in the movie of, saying, and there are different ways to use rules. In gremlins, they use it, here are the rules. Now watch as we break all of them. Watch as we break all of them. And they’re usually all setups. Even though one of them is going to be the tool they use to win at the end in the original gremlins, sunlight. So even though one of the rules is don’t do this. The using of the don’t do this flipped on its head by the end of it is what they use to kill Stripe or Spike. What’s the freaking name in that one? Anyway, well done, Jones. Good example.
Well prepared. Well prepared. Lazy, lazy preparation. Gremlins is great for rules. Like I was saying a little earlier, mentor tales are usually all rules and tools. Jumanji is an action adventure movie, but it’s really a mentor tale. They’re all teaching each other in their own way. It’s about learning how to cooperate. They even say it in Nigel’s watering hole scene you were talking about last week in the Jeep, the flashback. Yup. Cutscene. They even say it there where it’s like, all of your cooperative efforts, the watering hole is kind of the cut scene, where it’s a storytelling scene where he’s going, here’s what happened in the special world.
But I’m referring to what you’re saying. Yeah. After it, when he’s giving them instructions, he’s like, and part of it is rules and tools overlapping with that watering hole dynamic. Overlapper, overlapper is the fact that he says, all of you must use your combined efforts to save Jumanji. That’s your rules and tools and premise right there. Whatever the tools are, you’re going to use them to escape from here. So you’re getting how to win the game, the rules of the game, but you’re also getting the rules of how, right now their main objective is, how do we escape? Yeah.
Yeah.
Devin: Yeah.
Adam: Yeah. I think we’re ready. Now we’re doing examples. There you go.
Jumanji, Welcome to the Jungle and Edward Scissorhands. Let’s look at the rules and tools. The wheels are coming off. So part of the overlap of the watering hole and the rules and tools in that Jumanji Jeep scene is you’re finding out, they’re finding out as the teenagers what it requires for them to get out of the game. That’s a rule as a broad storytelling thing for them. But they’re also learning the rules of the game itself. At that point, because it’s a video game where you’re refining your rules and tools and how you apply them and all that stuff, as you go, they’re getting a lot of false rules and tools here early.
Bethany dies, but nope, she doesn’t die. She comes back. So we get a respawning thing and we’re like, oh, awesome. They get to respawn only to later on, very shortly after this, after the danger zone, realize that, yeah, they do die and respawn, but it does cost them one, one tattooed life on their wrist and they only have three. They have three lives. So you’re getting the idea that you’re getting that you’re getting as far as the mythology of the Jumanji world, you’re getting the gem. We know through the backstory that the objective is. The rule to Jumanji is the person who takes the gem controls the wildlife of Jumanji.
The person who puts the gem back saves Jumanji and can return home. It’s a premise, but it’s also the mythology of the world. So it’s great here in the rules and tools section to spell out your premise using a conversation about the rules, right? Your log line for your story, what you’re going to use to pitch it to on the back of a book cover, if it’s novel or to an executive who wants to produce and make the film, a log line. This is where you can literally put it in for your audience to be clear about it and say, in order to return, and this, they spell it out pretty blatantly a few times, but Spencer says it even in movement three coming up later, he’s like, we have to Save Jumanji to leave.
The game kind of stuff. Like he starts to sort it out more blatantly. There’s no real subtlety in Jumanji. It’s okay though, but they say everything pretty blatantly.
Devin: No, but that’s what makes it work. Yeah, it totally works for that. Yeah. Like Nigel just constantly saying the mission of the game and mission of the story.
Adam: He’s a great herald slash mentor, but he serves only a very limited purpose as a mentor. As Devin was saying that you can have multiple mentors in a previous episode. He was talking about that.
Devin: That’s what makes this. Rules and tools, how they’re using it in Jumanji, an overlapper. Because it literally starts from the moment they’re reacting to the unknown world through the watering hole event. And then while they’re really up until the point they embark on getting to the bazaar is when we’re getting most of the rules and tools of Jumanji. Because when they touch their left, when they touch their heart, their left pec, then all of a sudden we’re getting big rules where it’s like, these are your strengths, these are your weaknesses.
Adam: And tools, that’s all tools too. What are your strengths and weaknesses? Yeah.
Devin: And tools, yeah. Because we’re understanding, yeah, and we’re understanding, oh, and clearly they’re setups, you know, because, oh, it fridges weakness as a cake. What the heck does that mean? And so it’s just like, I can’t wait till we see the moment where that becomes as weakness. It actually starts making it. And then I think once they get to the bazaar, we’re kind of done. Like we know most of the, as audience, we know most of what we need to know for the rules and the tools of the adventure. But as Spencer points out, while he’s walking, he’s like, oh, this is like a video game.
So basically all I do is play video games. So that means a game like this is going to have levels and every level is going to be more difficult than the last level. And so he’s kind of giving us a little bit more setup too on. So all these initial things that they have to endure, these first levels they need to pass, we know that they’re just going to get, the stakes are going to be raised each level and it’s going to get more hard and more dangerous each level. And that’s actually what’s interesting about that cut scene when we’re getting the backstory of the mission and the rules that Professor Russell Van Pelt, and so what happened when he stole the Jaguar jewel and he assumed that dominion over all the levels.
Right. And then that curse befell on Jumanji. Anyone, and then he says, once Nigel steals it back, he raises the stakes too, he says, this is a really funny, subtle, but really funny cut scene, but it says, when he says, someone give me that jewel and anybody who tries to stop them must be slaughtered. And then, or slaughter anybody who tries to stop them. And then it cuts right to Nigel going, oh, here you go. Gives him, gives Spencer the jewel.
Adam: Just use that moment to illustrate that is the perfect example of cut to comedy.
Devin: Yeah, exactly.
Adam: Because it’s a great trick as a writer to understand if you know what it is. It’s the thing I say about the monkey in the wedding dress analogy, but this is a perfect example.
Devin: Slaughter anyone who stands in their way. Well, here you go.
Adam: Here you go. Just pushes it into his chest like, I don’t want it anymore. So that’s also a tool. The gem is a tool. It’s the object of the quest, but at the same time, it’s important because they have to have it. And later on, they lose it. There’s lots of aspects to it.
It’s a really interesting rules and tools scene. And notice how you get the tools. As you said, they sort of get spaced out. But that one main scene in the field when they’re pressing their… Their chest to get their stats.
Devin: Yeah.
Adam: That’s sort of like the perfect example of a tool scene. It’s as blatant as the matrix in terms of rules and tools. You know what I mean? It’s like, all right, we’re going to take a moment and all we’re going to talk about is setting up those things. And the first glimpse of, I think, tools that we get is when Fridge says, no, that wasn’t a rhino. That was a hippo. They’re blah, blah, blah. And their bite is 21 something neutrons. Yeah. It’s knowledge. And he goes, well, how did I know that? And she… And Martha says, zoology. You know zoology. So now we’re like, oh, okay.
The rules, like the counting on the four of you to lift the curse. The fact that he’s an NPC, non-player character, which is sort of like a useless mentor, herald character. Like he’s literally just like a robot mentor herald for the purpose of this story. And he talks about their complementary skills.
Devin: And they’re really that frustrating when you’re playing a game.
Adam: Yeah. It’s like, thanks for the info. It’s like, oh, Mr. Question Mark over your head.
Devin: And you always go back to them, to the NPCs in a game, and just hope they have different information. They don’t. Information. Yeah.
Adam: They don’t. You’re like, damn it. Kevin Hart says one of my favorite lines in that moment. He drops them off. And he’s like, you know, it’s after he gives them the jewel, like you said. Oh, here you go. And they’re out. And he’s driving off.
Devin: And he goes, you can’t just drive us to the statue?
It’s so good.
Adam: It’s so… Because literally… The journey… The whole purpose of the story is navigating this map and journey. And the obvious thing that your smart-thinking audience member is going to say is, why doesn’t he just drive them to the statue? And so you have a character say it. And the audience goes, yeah, exactly. Yeah, we got it covered. Yeah, exactly. As he drives off.
Devin: You can’t just drive us to the statue?
Adam: So good.
But… Yeah. So if you have plot holes, plug them up with a perspective. Give one character the perspective that the audience is going to doubt and have, and you’re fine. You know, you’ll be fine. It’s an easy fix. Yeah. But he also, the main rule of this one is the rhyme that he gives them. If you wish to leave the game, you must save Jumanji and call out its name. That’s the rule. That’s like the gremlins rules for this movie. He gives him the rhyme so that they have this mythology ingrained in them, which is very video gamey in its rhyme. Well, here you go. It’s so funny. Here you go.
I don’t want to overlook that guy’s performance because it’s brilliant. It’s brilliant. You almost take him for granted, and he’s really funny. He is. You get the tool satchel. The jewel gets put in the tool satchel. The cartography, Bethany sees the map start to develop. So we start to get tools in these little increments. It will continue. And you’re saying, I think you’re right. Most of it is until the bizarre, although there are surprise skill sets. In what’s coming up, the next episode is approach to the… Yeah. Danger zone. This is sort of the motorcycle chase.
Devin: Dance fighting. Is that a thing?
Adam: Yeah. This is sort of the motorcycle chase with the mighty roar and the motorcycles. So before that, they’re standing in the field checking their stats. But rules and tools, as it’s an overlapper, continues over approach to the danger zone and the danger zone when they jump off the cliff. It’s their first close call with the antagonist. So rules and tools spans all of that. And it has a little bit more later. Like Martha learns her kung fu, her martial arts. And then later, much, much later, dance fighting. Spencer plays with the boomerang here, but it never comes back.
Devin: I see that as utilizing the rules and tools that we learned. So it’s kind of like the cake where we know we’ve gotten in this rules and tools event or this overlapper. Oh, it’s set a payoff. Yeah. Set up. Yeah. It’s like, yeah, they’re all set up. So they’re like, oh, and it’s like, because I remember the cake thing. You’re like, what the hell is that going to mean that his weakness is cake? And it was the same thing with her. And they actually point out the events within their own stuff that they’re actually going to be funny. Like he points out the cake. He’s like, weakness cake. And then she points out, she’s like, dance fighting. He’s like, is that even a thing? And so those are the big setups.
Adam: How is strength? It’s my weakness.
Yeah. God, he’s so funny in that role. He’s so funny. You know something’s funny when you watch it several times. I know. And it still makes you laugh. It doesn’t matter how many times you watch it.
Devin: I’m missing the top two feet of my body.
Adam: He’s just so upset.
He’s good at surprising people. A story, even if it’s comedy, you shouldn’t see the joke or the what makes it funny. You shouldn’t see the joke or the what makes it funny. It just makes you laugh coming. It should surprise you, and that’s why you laugh. Same thing with a mystery. You shouldn’t know to predict the ending. But there are moments when Spencer says, you’re Fridge, and I’m Spencer. And he’s sort of pausing, and he’s sort of hovering, and he’s thinking about it, and he’s about ready to say something to Spencer. And then he just, at the top of his voice, you’re telling me that I’m…
And he just catches you off guard because he’s so ridiculous. And it’s those… Every time. Every time those bits… He gets so worked up. Oh my gosh, it’s like a handle. I have a handle. He’s so good.
Devin: No! Like in the water.
Adam: I know. I’m praising the performers in this because they’re really good. Karen Gillan does the… It’s in the next bit when she’s doing the approach to the danger zone. Running through the jungle, and she realizes she can run up a log and do a flip. And as soon as she lands, she looks up like, oh my God. Did I just do that? Like, she’s almost terrified by her new ability. And it’s so funny. Her reaction, I feel like, is so relatable. It is. If you were in the circus, it’s so relatable. She’s like, oh my gosh, I just did that.
Devin: It’s relatable to actually playing video games too. Like that first moment, you know, that in Sonic the Hedgehog, like you could double jump. You could jump while you’re already in the air. It was like a double jump. You’re like, what? I didn’t… I can do that?
Adam: So you’ve got the setup in a quick, tight movement one, and now you’re moving into movement two, going, now we get to play and have fun.
Devin: Right.
Adam: And so, do it. The scenes in this movement in Jumanji, welcome to the jungle. Come on! Are, probably, some of the funniest scenes in the whole movie. Mm-hmm. This movement, their initial reactions to this movement, too. There’s funny stuff later, but this is probably the stuff I laugh at the most.
Devin: And that’s what it can be for most stories, when you’re just… You’re not taking it seriously yet. It all depends on what type of story you’re writing. If you’re doing a comedy like this, you can actually use this as a moment of great humor and a lot of slapstick stuff because they’re just, they’re trying to figure out how to use this stuff. But if it’s also like a horror film, you can use this as like really terrifying things about the, like showing how powerful the antagonist is, you know, but it’s important for understanding.
Adam: Not understanding the rules and tools yet.
Devin: Yeah, exactly.
Adam: Just because we call this rules and tools does not mean you cannot view it flipped on its head. We’re not knowing, and this is a great example. Edward Scissorhands does this to a T. It does exactly what we’re talking about. It flips it on its head where you’re focusing on the lack of understanding of rules, the lack of tools to use in this world. Like Edward doesn’t have hands. That’s the main crux of the movement two of his story is he doesn’t have, he doesn’t have the tools that we take for granted. And most of the scenes we watch him do are how he navigates what we would take for granted.
Sleeping in a waterbed, eating at dinner when he’s trying to pick up one pea.
[Sponsor message]
Devin: For rules and tools events in particular, Jumanji and Edward Scissorhands are good at very different rules and tools. The rules and tools for Edward is very subtle. It’s him getting the clothes or the uniform of the creatures of this unknown world. And him trying to figure out how to put it on. He’s like, what is going on here? And then, you know, so he’s understanding, he’s trying to fit in. And that’s really the entire premise of Edward Scissorhands is trying to fit in somewhere you don’t fit in and you never will.
Adam: Trying to understand the rules and tools. Right. He’s, he’s never gonna get the rules and tools to properly work here. He can pretend the whole time and try to play the game of society’s rules and tools. But Edward’s never gonna make it there. And that’s, and it’s tragic. And it’s sadly tragic.
Devin: Yeah, you’re right. And they’re not really physical tools that he’s getting rather, and rather his scissorhands, his hands are actually just being repurposed for, for the creatures of the unknown world. Right. So he’s, he’s really the tool and his nonconformity ends up actually becoming an asset to the rest of this unknown world. And because he’s trimming everybody’s hedges, he’s giving pets their animals, haircuts or pet cuts.
Adam: But for no reward, just because he’s supposed to, he’s still a machine. He’s still something that’s serving instead of being.
Devin: Right. And what’s great about, what’s interesting about Edward Scissorhands is his, this tool that is an asset. Right. And what’s great about Edward Scissorhands is his, this tool that is an asset to the rest of the creatures of this unknown world is actually what ends up in his non, this nonconformity that is, is looked upon as an asset really becomes the, the thing that forces him to retreat to his, his known world. And there’s, there’s also another, there’s a very subtle, there’s a very subtle rule that Bill gives him at the. At the barbecue. And it’s, if you don’t, if you’re not picking, if you don’t pick up on it, it’s really the entire, the most important rule given to Edward that really is his demise as well.
It’s when Edward’s grilling the shish kebabs and then Bill runs in, he’s like, soup’s on. And Edward just looks at him and he’s like, I thought these were shish kebabs. And Ed tells him, yes, they are shish kebabs. You just, you need to not take things so literally. And Edward doesn’t understand. He doesn’t understand sarcasm or slang. He takes everything at face value. He takes everything literally. That’s all he knows. He knows sincerity, but he doesn’t know the sham and the show. This one rule that Bill has given him is literally a setup for the main event that starts Edward’s unraveling. He can only take things literal. And that’s what really is his downfall, his demise.
Adam: I would recommend this to story authors, not to sidetrack too much, but when you start breaking down movies, like we’ve been doing with Jumanji and Edward Scissorhands, because Devin and I review parts of them as we prepare for the episodes, you find brilliant tricks and tools that you can use and designs and wear threads that, here’s the thing, even the creators of these pieces of work may not have realized they did, but it’s because story is magic in general. That actor did this, this editor did this, the director said this, the writer did that, and all of a sudden it comes together. And this, these moments of, of genius are not because one person did one thing, they’re because the magic happened for that moment.
So just watching it, you may learn stuff that they didn’t even know they put in there. I was watching Jordan Peele talk about the strange theories about Get Out and what it actually is, like a dreamscape or this or that. And it was, it was awesome to watch him sort of navigate that and go, oh, I never even thought about that. That’s, but that’s true. It could be interpreted that way. So the piece of the artwork itself has things that it is outside of the creation of it. Like it lives on for the audience. Edward is, it’s a strange movie, man. Edward is as a character of emotional sincerity in a world that’s all sham and showboat.
And Edward celebrated almost like some strange foreigner came in from out of town and everybody wanted to meet him. Like he’s not some… Strange, abstract monster.
Devin: Inception of the idea of Edward when he’s making the cookies and he grabs the heart and he puts it on the thing chopping lettuce like Edward was. And so he’s like, wow, so that’s the idea. But he just needs to be himself. And then Bill’s saying, don’t take things so literally. But they’re not necessarily rules. They’re basically saying- They’re conflicting. Yeah, he doesn’t know any way else. And so it’s like sometimes you can’t take somebody and put them in a situation or take them out of one world and put them in another. In another world and hope he just conforms or hope he’s accepted or adjusts. Because sometimes literally you can’t, you just, it’s impossible. Though it was her, her want, Peg’s, Peg’s idea of, of helping Edward and bringing him from the mansion, his, his known world into her, her known world was all because she cared for him and she wanted to take care of him.
And his, his idea, his, his decision of- Of leaving his known world and going to her known world, his, the unknown world was because he doesn’t know any better. And he thought because of these magazine clippings and things that he’s, you know, just the way that he’s looked down upon this village, he thinks it’s better for him. And, and until you take your hero or you take this main character, this protagonist and put him through that experience, which is the story- The events, yeah. You don’t really, that’s, yeah, all the events. Yeah. That’s when you start to- You understand that he doesn’t fit in here, but that’s okay.
Adam: The events help you to spotlight different aspects or facets of your character. That’s what they’re, it’s not structure as much as let’s walk this being, this creature through these things where we know what they are and see how they react. And all you got to do is find a handful of character or characteristics and walk them through these events we’re talking about. And you’ll start to discover-
Devin: Right.
Adam: Who they are. Who they are. That’s why when you go back to your second draft of writing something, you then know what to write. Because the first draft, really, you’re just going, all right, let’s walk them through preliminarily, these story events and see what they yield. It’s weird. One of the things I was going to say about Edward that I find really strange is most, when we talk about the midpoint or the tipping point or the crisis in a lot of stories is crisis. Even when we call this out of comfort zone into danger zone, it’s literally a threshold. It doesn’t have to be. It doesn’t have to be danger zone, right? In Edward, most of what happens in Edward Scissorhands, and this is clever, the ending is tragic. The ending, the beginning, middle, end, the end is not a fairy tale ending. It’s a monster movie, Frankenstein horror movie ending.
Devin: Mm-hmm.
Adam: And then the epilogue is the fairy tale, but the ending is tragic. So, what do they do for your crisis or your midpoint, the middle of your story? Mm-hmm. Edward is at the peak of his- His journey. He’s triumphing. He’s not only celebrated as a person for his shrubbery, but also dog grooming and hair. He’s going on TV. Like, he’s being celebrated. Mm-hmm. And we think that’s where he wants to be, which is what he thinks he wants to be via that, the clippings in his nest, you know, and how he relates. And it’s not. It doesn’t work. Mm-hmm. So, in the midpoint, even though it looks like triumph- Yeah.
Yeah. Which is [unclear] the ending, which is not failure, but retreat and tragedy. Right. Most movies, if they have a happy ending, the midpoint is where it goes bad. The midpoint is where they don’t win the game that they do in a sports movie, but they win the championship. They give you no hope here, and they give you hope at the ending. Or they give you hope in the middle and no hope at the end. If you can do a little bit of that- Thank you.
Anyway, I just want to bring that up because we’re building to a different thing than most movies, even Jumanji.
Devin: Right.
Adam: Jumanji is like, you know, more shallow, like, we have to escape from the villain in the midpoint. That’s what Jumanji is. And Edward Scissorhands, it’s a completely different mode of approaching that climax. It’s meant to set you up for the payoff that you get at the end, the opposite payoff.
Devin: Jumanji, there’s specific rules that are obvious rules or obvious tools. And it’s an obvious mission of what needs to happen. So we, as an audience, everything’s kind of laid out for us. And we just, we’re just along for the ride and waiting for all that to happen. Could we understand the setups? We’re not confused. And with Edward Scissorhands, it’s more of a, all of those are there. All of that, all of those elements of that story are there. They’re just, because of the type of story and the setting of the story that Edward Scissorhands is, it’s not bullet pointed like it is in Jumanji. It’s not laid out in particular.
Right. There’s a, there still is a goal. There’s this, there’s a, there’s a premise. There’s a, there’s rules and there’s tools that are, that, that are still being, the writers are, they’re, are still weaving into the story. They’re just not, they’re just a little bit more subtle, but they play a very vital role in, in the storytelling. We understand that he takes things literal, but that, that taking things, that taking things literally is going to be something bad is going to happen by him doing that. Right. Or, you know, it’s like, and it’s like Elf. Elf and Edward Scissorhands kind of have a very similar storyline.
Adam: Character dynamic, main character. Yeah. Fish out of water.
Devin: Fish out of water where he doesn’t understand that you’re making fun of him. He doesn’t understand that he’s so different, but he, I mean, I think Edward Scissorhands understands he’s, he’s different, but he, but they also, some of those endearing character traits are really ends, end up being what gets them into trouble, you know, within the story. And, and so those are just interesting decisions on with, with the writer, Caroline Thompson, how she, she understood that there needs to be rules. There needs to be a mythology of this world that she’s creating. And then how is she going to translate and how are those, those rules and how are those tools going to translate into the actual plot or how are like things that are actually going to happen to Edward that achieve the goal that she set out with what’s going to happen?
We understand where Edward’s going to end up. We understand where Edward begins. But what’s going to happen? What’s going to happen in between that gets, it gets us to that point and of essentially Edward returning home. Being celebrated. What also, like at the very end, returning home. Yeah.
Adam: Yeah. But in the middle of the celebration actually makes the ending feel like more of a rollercoaster. Edward Scissorhands is just more subtle, but also more fantastic or whimsical. And the way it approaches stuff, that’s part of it. Like the concealing cream that she uses, that’s a rules and tools scene. Here’s another, an addition to your clothes. Here’s another clothing.
Devin: Yeah, right.
Adam: Here is a mask that we can help you to make you look like the rest of us. Exactly. Right? And that’s an ongoing thing that she tries. She calls the head of the company at one point. Thank you, Edward. I always wanted to talk to the head of the company, but I never had a reason until now.
Devin: But also that celebration is, like you’re saying, you see the incredible betrayal of everybody who was using him and how he was being used. Right. You know, so I was like, without that, if there was, if it was just this straight line of him not fitting in and then saying, I just don’t fit in here, I’m going home. There’s literally a point where you think he’s going to be the mayor of the town at some point and everybody’s celebrating him and he’s going to be, he’s the most popular person in the town. And then how quickly they take that from him because of, well, he was being himself and he was taking things too literally.
Those two things.
Adam: Story expectations. The main point with what that is, is creating expectations within your story for your audience that you can subvert. That’s one of the most thrilling things you can do with an audience. And no matter how you do it, whether it’s Edward’s at his height almost centrally in the movie versus the end where he’s at his lowest point and Jumanji vice versa. They’re at their lowest point in the middle where it’s like all hope feels lost. The antagonist is now facing us down and we’re doomed. Versus the end. Where they escape the game. No matter what, you create an, oh my gosh, we’re so close to the opposite of what we want.
Or what’s going to happen? So you’ve built this, Devin and I use the word set up and pay off all the time. That duality. The most important tools that you can use throughout your story. So if you know your ending is going to be tragic, change the middle. So let’s say she wrote, Caroline Thompson wrote the first draft of Edward Scissorhands, got to the end and it was a happy ending. Probably not, but let’s assume it. And then she went, well, I like the middle part, but there should be some sort of real exploration of his awkwardness. And so that might end in him leaving or retreating or running away.
Oh, that makes a better ending. Or she knew that ending was the case and the rest of the script was all struggle. So now she has to change it so that it’s like, well, maybe if we do this in the middle, it feels more like a rollercoaster ride. You don’t know how she approached it really, but the point is theoretically in that design, to do that and create a more dynamic experience just by retro designing it and understanding what the simplicity of the points beginning, middle and end are. Middle and end being cooperative components and the beginning being the foundation for that is important. Don’t just meander through the story.
Understand where your middle is and what you’re saying with it and measure it out. Measurement. This whole area is what Vogler calls tests, allies and enemies. And. And Campbell calls the road of trials. Here’s where you’re going to meet your allies or understand them better in the case of Jumanji or start to get to know. Maybe you explore a little bit who’s ally, who’s enemy, because in Edward Scissorhands, you don’t know. Some people seem like allies, but become enemies, shapeshifters. Most of the neighborhood are shapeshifters.
Devin: Except for Jim, Anthony Michael Hall’s character.
Adam: And Esmeralda, Esmeralda never changes her point of view.
Devin: Yeah.
Adam: She’s the harbinger of death, the herald, the negative herald. She is appropriately designed as a character, Esmeralda, because there’s this puritanical mindset of judgment. It’s almost religiously based where it’s like the thing that I do not understand, I will label the devil. The thing that I don’t understand, I will label with the word evil. Right. Something different than me. And so she’s this point of view. She’s this point of view that’s symbolic in the idea of judgment, but relatable. You know what that’s like. Someone who’s limited and the rest of the people sort of accept it like, oh, it’s a new novel thing in our neighborhood.
Isn’t that great? And then they’re sort of like, as they get personally either offended or start to go like, well, maybe he’s not a great person to hang around. Now that he broke into the neighbor’s house and now that this is this and now that they start to demonize him as well.
Devin: Mm-hmm.
Adam: Edward Scissorhands is a strange tale. Symbolically, it’s fun and it’s just a weird movie. Gosh. Drinking whiskey with Alan Arkin.
A rules and tools singer is like, here’s how we deal with teenage girl stress. Have a half a glass of whiskey with this straw.
Devin: And Edward’s like. Oh.
Adam: Imagine a child being given a glass of whiskey. With a straw and they just freaking drink it down with a straw because they trust whoever gave it to them. It’s going to help not knowing what alcohol is. And I’m like, that’s exactly what that moment would be like. Your your eyes are all watered over and you’re like, what is this that I just put in my throat? But it’s a rules and tools where Edward doesn’t work well with learning the.
Pops the waterbed, his first, you know, introduction with Kim is panic. In both these movies, and this is why I love Rules and Tools, the mythology is incredibly important throughout the whole course of the movie. And so the rules never stop being explored. Rules and Tools scene in Movement 2 is generally for the setup. They will exist throughout the rest of your movie, if you’ve done a good movie, because that’s what your main character or characters are exploring. Rules is from some other authority within this world. Are they gonna find their own authority, their own guidance, or inner guidance? Are they gonna trust it? Because Edward is just going along with what people tell him, what he was used to from his inventor father. And now he’s just continuing that. And then he’s going, no, I am finding my own autonomy, even if it’s retreat back to where I was. So rules are important. And tools, it’s like finding the ability to find your own power or, or belief system later in the story. Devin and I were chatting a good bit about feedback and other things earlier when we started recording. So but we decided it’s part of the process now to actually start to examine the work they’ve done.
Whether it’s editing or maybe having somebody read a little bit of something just to see if you’re on the right track. So we thought we’d chat a little bit about feedback before we finish out this episode.
Devin: It’s a good point to talk about this stuff because at this stage of the game, if you’ve been doing your three pages, you might be at a point where you can kind of be like, alright, I got my first, my movement one is done, I just want to get a little feedback on this so far.
Adam: That’s super valid. Super valid. Not just regular valid, it’s super valid. Super valid, yeah. That’s what I strive for. When you start going, okay, so how do I build things, what does it really entail to create something, like day to day, and also what’s the blueprint of the thing, as we’re talking about, the actual blueprint of the story. Here’s how you know if you want to be a writer or not. If you find joy in that, taking your story and running it through the events we sort of talk about across this season. Looking at it and going, oh, I can see, so I can maybe do my scene like this, or this, or this.
You’re taking the tool and applying it, it’s exciting. You put me under the hood of a car and say, hey, I can fix certain things in a car. Do I enjoy the tools and the know-how and the engine of that car? It’s not my passion. But you put me in front of story events and the engine of a story and how does it run, and I’m fascinated. Hearing other people talk about their process, talking about it, building, actual doing the building. Like either last episode or a couple episodes ago, I compared what we do. Yeah. To sort of car talk, where you actually take a car and you talk about how to work.
Right. Popping the hood up and taking a look at the engine of the thing. Okay, so a storyteller does that, but that doesn’t mean that everything else is not built out of the same sort of structure in that world narrative you’re talking about. Whether it’s political or whatever you’re seeing. Right, yep. Someone’s telling a business, someone’s telling a story.
Devin: Everything’s a story. We tell stories all day, every day.
Adam: Now, the question is, are you deliberately telling your story? Or are you passively telling your story?
Devin: You know, Story Blueprint, like we’ve talked about, and we’ll talk about in season three, I think, is what you were alluding to, is you can literally use Story Blueprint to put together a pitch for, or even to put your whole entire brand together. It’s like, all right, well, you need a hook. Like you need something to grab that audience. Even if you only have five minutes with some VCs or you’re giving a speech at like a TED Talk or even a TED Talk. These speeches are, you hook them, you have some type of, and you see it with TV, too.
Adam: You build the basis, the premise. The known world routine is the premise. Right. That and the inside answer. And the quest is the call to action.
Devin: Yeah, call to action.
Adam: When you go, would you like to read the script? Would you like to read the proposal? You got an elevator pitch, you got like five sentences at the most. At the most. Right. And that’s being generous. Right. If they give you more time, great. Here’s the thing. Be interesting. Don’t complain about the fact that people aren’t paying attention to you. Be more interesting. It’s not their fault. They’re not interested in what you’re saying. So condense it. Simplify it. Make it memorable and exciting. Don’t blame the other people because they’re not paying attention. You’re not doing your job if you’re not hooking those people. Right. With your brand or business.
They’ll listen if you’ve got a good idea. Right.
Devin: Hook and follow up. And that’s a mistake a lot of businesses do anyway is they don’t take feedback from, or it’s just getting defensive. And it happens with, we, as a business. Right. With, we, Adam, you and I have dealt with. I’ve dealt with screenwriters before, and I’ve dealt with businesses before, that when you give them feedback, they ask for the feedback, but when you give them the feedback, it goes instantly to defense mode.
Adam: Especially when it’s not critical, when it’s constructive conversation, it’s co-creative conversation, it’s not a criticism. Like sometimes you can understand why people might do that, why they would react that way if they’re feeling criticized, but if you approach it not that way and they react that way, it’s another element in the mix. Ego usually is.
Devin: It’s a bunch of different things. It’s ego, it’s thinking that, well, I’ve spent, and that’s the thing, it’s like, well, we spent five years putting this company together. It’s like, well, thank you for that, thank you for that bit of backstory, but it’s like, guess what? We’re talking about where your company’s at now, or where your story’s at right now. I’ve been writing this story for 10 years. Like, I can’t change it now. It’s like, well, don’t not change your story.
Adam: Because it’s what you’ve grown comfortable with.
Devin: Or you’re dreading just completely dismantling something and trying to build it from, because, guess what? At this time, it won’t take 10 years. And I’m here, we’re here to help you. And so it’s like, let’s literally make this the best story possible. So in order to do that, or let’s make your company the most successful company to do that, in order to do that, you almost got to just let yourself be attacked. And if that’s how you feel, if you’re feeling attacked, then you just got to let yourself be attacked. Or try to understand that people are there, and they’re giving you feedback, because in storytelling, they may not understand part of the story, and they It needs to be clarified. It’s not what it’s not translating from your head and your imagination on a paper correctly. And so maybe someone’s giving you a suggestion to do that. And in business, it’s the same thing. It’s like, you can get so focused in and dug into the ditch of running the company, that you will, of course, get defensive of things that maybe you you’re proud of. But if they’re not translating, and they’re not, your customers aren’t relating to it, or your readers aren’t relating to your audience isn’t relating to it.
To something, then you almost it’s hard as hell, because I’ve happened to me dozens of times when people are like, this isn’t working, like, Oh, my God, that was like my favorite part. But if it’s not working, and you’re, you’re getting that feedback enough, like more than one person is telling you that, then it makes sense to say, All right, well, let me zoom out a little bit and try to understand their perspective. And maybe it’s not that scene that I need to change. It’s the scene before it, that’s actually not making sense. And then once I fix that,
Adam: That will actually, yeah, exactly. Once again, it’s sort of like cars. Once you get something replaced, a part replaced, right? And it’s like, well, it’s still not working. Well, that part let you know that the other part was the thing that was actually malfunctioning. Because now you know, that’s running smoothly. So you can move to exactly. Yeah, it goes back to this a lot. And it’s, it’s unfortunate, but nobody likes to be wrong. When you feel wrong, because everybody from their own perspective is not wrong. That’s really how most people operate. If you, if you take right and wrong out of the equation, you’ll fare much better. And I would say this, just as a side note, I’m glad we’re talking about this. As far as taking criticism, as a writer to story authors out there, if you’re writing something, or even as a live in your life, taking criticism, think of it like this, because I’ve done this when early when I would get criticism, my like my first my first stage play when I was young and in college and writing stage plays. Because, you know, it was something that you could bring from start to finish, you write it, you put it on stage. When I first got it, it was tough in a college environment with as Devin was saying before, people who had different viewpoints, belief systems, cultural growing up, like then where I grew up in West Virginia, you get all these viewpoints, and the stuff you thought was really good, it’s not so good all of a sudden, or you’ve got multiple perspectives. Some of them are coming from people who might be needing to overly criticize to show how smart they are. Some people, may need to do it because they’re jealous, but you can’t just dismiss it and go, well, that’s the reason why you can’t do that stuff. What you have to do is take all of the criticism in and process it. But if you don’t listen to it, you can’t do the second part. If you’re too busy refuting everything you hear, you’re not going to hear the nuggets that you really need to hear to make this piece better.
A neat trick that I learned early was when someone’s giving you feedback on your piece, just write it all down. No matter what, even if you want to argue the point, write it down and you’re going to look at that a week later when you’re distant from it and alone. Then you can process it properly. Now, the purpose of doing that, the criticism thing, of listening to that criticism is not, like I said, take right and wrong out of the equation. Start a conversation. What is it about that part you didn’t like? Then they can explain. So you go, oh, all of a sudden there’s a bit of clarity because they go, well, this happened and this happened and it just, I didn’t like it because it didn’t make sense or it felt too obvious or, well, now you know to bury that into subtext more. Now you know.
But if they really hated it because it was way too obvious, don’t be upset because they had a passionate reaction to it. They had a passionate reaction because they cared about it. So take that into consideration and actually learn why it didn’t work so you can improve it. If you’re feeling right or wrong, even if that person’s coming out of like, I need to be right and tell you what’s wrong with your story, you don’t need to take it in like that. Right. You can be a distant step back and just go, let me hear what they’re saying and be the broader minded person and not play the game of ping ponging back and forth why what you did was right.
Yeah, don’t try to justify it. Yeah, and make excuses. Just adjust.
Devin: And by no means am I saying or Adam’s saying, I’m not going to speak for you, but I have. Actually, yes, I am. I’m going to speak for you right now. Any advice or feedback you get, go and change it. Because that’s not what we’re saying. It’s more of just saying. Weigh it out. Be open to feedback. Try to bring your defenses down and just try to see it from their perspective and be like, okay, okay. So maybe, like Adam said, maybe I just need to add one line of subtext here that really connects that setup to this payoff or it connects this scene to this scene transition.
Adam: Or cut all of the dialogue. Cut all of the dialogue in this scene and leave it a look between two people. Right. That’s tough to do if you thought your dialogue was super clever.
Devin: Yeah.
Adam: Like, oh, their witty romantic comedy banter is so fantastic here. I love it. No, this is when the audience wants them to shut up and kiss.
Devin: Yeah.
Adam: And you didn’t realize it because you were too busy still writing the fun part of witty banter. But because you think overall your banter is really witty, you can’t hear someone say, in this moment, you need to remove the witty banter. And you have a great punctuation. That’s a good point here. Right. Here’s the thing. They may be pointing out something that’s wrong with your story and not have a solution. They just may go, this is something weird here. You still have to figure it out. They may even present you with a solution. Which is always preferable. Well, I don’t prefer that, really.
Devin: Otherwise, they’re like, oh, my God, I need a writing credit now. I don’t. Yeah. Because I totally fixed that for you.
Adam: What? The point is, if you can hear what the problem is, even if they have a solution that sucks, that is no good. You. You can find the solution. If someone else can identify the problem, don’t take offense that there was a problem. Go, good, now I can improve it. And figure out how to improve it. There’s a whole other level of creating, extending, like looking beyond what you saw the first draft.
Devin: Right.
Adam: It’s sort of like walking along a path or walking through a place you’ve seen for the first time. You take in all kinds of stuff. If you go back a second time, you’re going to take in and explore and look into all kinds of. Other stuff. You’re going to get more detail. A second pass. You just do. I know we’re running off on a tangent here, but this is great stuff to consider as you’re working through stuff. Be open to things all around you. Exactly. You can still choose and have preferences, but if you shut out the things around you, you don’t even know what the options are.
You don’t know what choices could be there. That’s sort of the difference between movement one and two is the glimpse of something beyond. What you’ve known and that little weird promise of there’s something else beyond what you thought there was is the coaxing into the adventure of the story.
Devin: And trust me, we’ve all been in that situation where somebody is reading it and they’re giving you feedback and in your head, you’re like, all right, just take it in. Take it in. Don’t say anything. Don’t get combative. And then you thank them for their comments. You take your script and you get in your car and you just look in the mirror and you go, they don’t know shit.
Adam: And then you drive off.
Devin: Because sometimes it feels good just to, or that email. Everybody’s done that email where you write like a page email just tearing apart the other person. And then you just take it, you just sit on it before it and send. And you get up the next day and you read it like, wow, that was, that was dark. That was mean. And then you just delete it. And you’re like, you know what, that’s all I needed. I just had to get that off my chest. And now I’m actually with a clearer head and I’ve removed myself from the situation and everything’s cooled down. I kind of see some of their points now.
I get it. Yeah. It’s just recognizing that it’s happening.
Adam: It usually takes a little bit. It’s worth taking the distance and time to figure out how you want to approach something or what you think. But then in the conversation of it, being open to the discourse. But you have to maintain your own perspective to have the discourse or else what’s the point of the conversation? You know, if you’re just going to stamp your feet or you’re just going to float along with whatever the other person is saying, what’s the point of a discourse? What’s the point of having a conversation?
Devin: Don’t ask for feedback. Don’t ask for feedback if you planned on going in and them just praising everything that you’ve written because that’s not helpful.
Adam: And also, if you’re going to criticize someone else’s work, let’s say you are reading someone else’s work. Here’s the thing you don’t do. It was nice. It’s the worst feedback I’ve ever got. Like, here’s the thing. I don’t want you to tell me what’s nice. I want you to tell me the things that worked for you that really excited you in the story and the things that you didn’t understand or didn’t excite you in the story. Right.
Devin: Right.
Adam: Right. It, and the things that didn’t work for you, what were the problems? If you don’t feel comfortable enough to tell me truthfully what that is, because you’re afraid you’re going to hurt my feelings, but on the other end of the spectrum, you want to bash somebody, those approaches are both pretty useless. Who was it? Chris D’Elia. He was talking to someone and said, when someone asked him, what do you do when you’re bombing? What do you do when you have a bad night? And I’m like, I highly doubt Chris D’Elia has a bad night. He’s pretty funny. But he goes, what I do, because when you’re bombing, he’s like, you just power through it. And the woman who was there talking to him said, I will laugh at a comedian if I feel like they’re uncomfortable, right? If they’re not doing well, I’ll pity laugh. And he goes, that is the worst thing you can ever do, because then I can’t tell whether it’s funny or not. He says, never do that. And I was like, oh, it’s so true on every level of communication.
Pretend to have a reaction, because then nobody ever actually understands. Politeness is a weird thing in its own right.
Devin: And bringing it back to correlate this to business. To earth. That’s the problem that businesses have or CEOs have when they surround, or presidents have, when they surround themselves with yes men or yes people. People that just will always agree with whatever they say. Because CEOs will usually gravitate towards promoting or those people that have challenged them. Because if they’re challenging them, then they’re thinking outside the box, which will bring different viewpoints and ideas to the company. And that’s why in most CEOs, really successful CEOs will say that they just hire, they’ll always hire people that are, that are. Brighter and smarter than them because they understand that they knew enough. They knew what they knew to get the company to this point. But in order for the company to grow and continue to grow, you need people with different viewpoints that are smarter than you. That can be like, thanks. You’re like almost, you’re handing off.
The baton in this relay race that we call life.
Adam: To someone with a better focus or obsession even with that thing.
Devin: Or different, or just different. And it’s like, yeah, I never thought of it that way. And so it’s the same thing with scripts. It’s like, God bless my mom, but I’ve never given her a script or a story or really anything that she’s been critical about. Because anytime I give her a script… Yeah. Anything to reach, oh my God, this is the greatest thing I’ve ever read. I’m like, mom, I already know it’s not. This is terrible. Can you please just tell me what’s working or not working? But that’s how moms work. If I need a little, if I’m feeling a little down and my self-esteem is down, I give it to my mom.
But if I really want good feedback, I give it to someone like, Adam, you give me great feedback. And you know how to give feedback, which is… Something important like you were just alluding to too. It’s like feedback is there’s an art to giving feedback. You just understand what to say, how to say it to get those guards down where they don’t, they’re not taking it defensively because they’re understanding you’re coming from a place of wanting to help. And there’s an art to doing that in any situation. There’s an art to when you’re in a negotiation with somebody to get their guard down so you can get on a level playing field.
You can get on a playing field where you’re like, look, we’re in this together. This is literally just trying to make this story the greatest story ever. And once you can disarm them in a way where they’re not being defensive, even if they’re subconsciously they’re being defensive or they have their guard up and they can understand you, you’re under, you’re on that level playing field. You’re able to literally say whatever you want at one point at some point. And they’re just like, oh yeah, yeah. I didn’t even think about that. Cause you can, and you know, the moment that happens that all of a sudden, that connection has been made and you’re that feedback you’re giving them is literally they’re thinking about it and, and understanding that this isn’t something to be defensive about. You can feel it in the conversation.
Adam: Here’s what I think is the key to, to approaching that. Well, and I do apply this a good bit in other areas of my life, but asking people questions, engaging them in thinking together is one of the easiest ways to get to know anybody or get to talk to them. You can ask people questions that challenge their belief system, or you can push buttons, right? There are those kinds of questions, or there are questions like when talking about a story. So what did you mean to do when the character does this and this, what was your intention? Cause even if you can read it on the page, if they’re describing to you what they think that is, and it didn’t work, you can then understand if there’s a disconnect between what’s on the page, what they’re saying versus what they really want.
Right. In people, and also character and also what’s in the script itself. So that works with people in general. If you don’t come at them with a challenging question, you introduce a philosophical question to them where you’re stimulating their imagination in an open way. That’s not aggressive. Like if you stimulate their imagination, people love to go on that trip. Right. Cause they don’t get to usually, and they don’t get asked their viewpoint or, I mean, in writing that would be it, but sometimes even their opinion on something and to have a discussion about.
Devin: And compliment, compliment the things that are really good about the story too. Don’t just attack the things that aren’t working. It’s like, wow, this is, this character is really strong. I like how you’re using them or like, like the setting is great. I love it. Feedback is, there’s like a negative connotation with it. And I think a lot of times feedback, feedback is only focused on the.
Adam: What’s wrong or what to fix.
Devin: On some of the things that aren’t working. Yeah. And feedback is literally just feedback. Like give them the compliments too. I was actually watching The Profit, that show on CNBC with Marcus Lemonis that goes around and like fixes broken businesses. And they, they brought this guy in was pitching his hunting gear to this potential distributor. And they were giving him all of this feedback, like, oh, it’s, you know, it’s not the right colors. The seats are a little flimsy. You got to fix that. So, and then they. They, they said, but no, I like overall, it’s got a lot of potential. We like it. And then they literally right after that meeting, he’s like, well, what did you get from it? Like, what feedback did you hear? He’s like, he’s like, why? You know, it was all good. You know, they said that they liked, you know, that they’re probably going to want to order. They liked some of the colors they liked. So that guy literally just focused. He, he didn’t even hear negativity. He, he glommed on to any, any positive words or any positive phrases or even positives, positive, voices.
And that’s all he heard. And then his partner’s like, here’s the lit. And she literally pulled out like a two page list from her notebook. And it’s like, here’s the, negatives. This is all the stuff that he’s like, oh, I didn’t even remember them saying that. And so that’s one dude that’s literally just been closed off from getting any type of feedback, which is a big indication on why his company isn’t doing very well. Cause he’s probably been hearing that from customers and distributors or like screenwriters hear it from. Yeah. I’m only hearing the good stuff. You loved that part. I’m like, yeah, I love that part, but I also said that this part didn’t work.
Adam: The word contrast is so important in life and storytelling. It sometimes requires contrast. Change happens or precipitates from contrast. If it’s like, if this guy only listens to what he’s done right, well, you’ve already done that.
Devin: Right.
Adam: So how can you improve as you move forward? Well, these are the things that aren’t working right. Adjust and move forward with them. And I’m all for focusing positively. Don’t get me wrong. I think you can focus positively on problems that are presented, what one might perceive as negatives. I agree. Yeah. And I’ve learned to do that with my own writing. Now, when someone brings me feedback, I’m like, okay, now, how do I fix this puzzle? Like, I don’t get all like, oh, it’s wrong. I didn’t get it right the first time.
Devin: It’s there. You can either be the bricklayer or the church builder. You can either be a bricklayer and then someone’s like, oh my, well, that brick is broken. We need to change that brick. He’s like, well, in order to change that brick, fix that brick, I need to take all these other bricks off in order to do that. And then there’s the guy who is proud about building the church. And he’s like, they’re like, this isn’t working. And he’s like, oh my God, I’m so glad you caught that because this, this church has to be perfect. All I need to do is like, just, I just need to take these off and I can fix that and I can put these back on. It’s not gonna be a big deal.
So it’s, it’s perspective.
Adam: It’s also not going, can’t you just be proud of what I did? Right. Do you know what I mean? It’s a, I know it’s, it sounds bratty, but it’s a very childish mentality because everybody wants approval and acceptance. Can’t you just be proud of what I did? Like for me, and here’s the thing too, and you have to deal with this with writing. This is the tough balance. When you finish something, it’s not going to be perfect ever. And then you move on to the next thing and improve what you learned from the journey there. You apply to the next thing and build it.
Devin: And that won’t be perfect.
Adam: There’s always going to be that progression of learning this and applying it, learning and applying. But if you can fix it in a blueprint or it can be easily fixed to make things work better, of course, consider it. You got to have a balance of drive and vision and ambition to build the church to begin with. I don’t know if we got it on church analogy, but usually we’re on a house analogy for Story Blueprint.
Devin: Well, it’s construction. Yeah. Building. I got to wrap up. Yeah, buddy. Cable guy’s going to be here.
Adam: Cable guy. Write your three pages. Between now and next week, play with some rules and tools. And start it simple. Do three rules. Three is a great number. Three tools, three rules. Three is always good. Yep. Yeah. Absolutely. And you can even play with flip sides of things, like someone teach a false mentor teaching rules against Karate Kid. Part three was on TV the other night, and I forgot there was a mentor who tries to teach a false mentor. It is very important for every sequence, guys, to teach Daniel things that harm him so he does poorly in the competition. So you can always take rules and tools and have them flipped on their head, too. There’s all kinds of stuff to play with.
Devin: And try not to be lazy with them. Because there’s sometimes you throw in a rule or a tool, and it’s just used lazily to get your character out of something. You mean boomerang? Well, yeah. Some cliche. It’s a joke, and it’s over.
Adam: Yeah.
Devin: Yeah. It’s over. It’s like. It’s over. It’s like. You’re like, of course, or you can pigeonhole yourself into, because a lot of times with modern day stories, the cell phone is a really hard tool you can’t avoid. It does.
Oh, I know. If somebody has the cell phone, it’s like, well, call the police, call somebody, call the friend, call Uber, get out of here, like do something with it.
Adam: The cell phone has ruined so many horror, thriller, and mystery stories.
Devin: So if it is a, and if the cell phone is a tool in the beginning, maybe somehow figure out a way where they lose it or it gets crushed or it gets broken where it’s not some simple solution to a problem where it’s like you have to get a little bit more creative as a writer to be like, all right, well, if they don’t have the cell phone, then they have to, you know, use your setups. It’s all about setups and payoffs and just be real clever with them because audiences love a good, those good setups and payoffs, especially if they don’t see the setup and under always.
I already know how it’s going to be paid off later. So don’t get lazy.
Adam: That’s our final word. Don’t get lazy. See you next week. Don’t get lazy. Please subscribe and rate us on iTunes. Follow us on social media, share with your friends and send us your questions and comments. For additional resources and links to films, series, and books we talk about here, visit our website. While you’re there, sign up for our newsletter for updates on story building tools and special offers at StoryOsophy.com.