Show notes
For their 50th episode, Adam and Devin take on one of their favorite events: the watering hole. It’s the communal place of your story’s world, whether that’s a bar, a cafeteria, a mess hall, a coffee shop or the family dinner table. After the first day of school, where your hero mostly observes, the watering hole is where they start gathering information and interacting: meeting the cast, sizing up rivals and learning the customs of the unknown world.
In this episode
- From observing to gathering. First day of school is orientation. At the watering hole your hero has to interact, and picks up background on the creatures of this world: what they eat and drink, their politics, who to watch out for.
- Floaters and overlappers. The watering hole and rules and tools can swap places, sit on top of each other, or grow into set pieces that fill a whole movement.
- A whole series in one room. Cheers is built on a watering hole; 2 Broke Girls has the diner and Brooklyn Nine-Nine the police station.
- Introduce your cast. Bring the main characters together, set up their first dynamics, and hint at what’s coming. It’s a pressure cooker: the first time hero and rival share a room.
- The rival. A force of opposition, not always the antagonist. A rival reflects your hero’s fears and flaws and pushes them to change in a way a supportive friend won’t.
- When the world doesn’t change. In a romance or an office story, the unknown world can be a person or a new situation. A watering hole set up in Act 1 can return in Act 2 with a different atmosphere.
- Your premise is a safety line. A solid thematic premise lets you play anywhere and stay attached to your story spine. Edward Scissorhands starts from the universal feeling of not fitting in.
- A lie detector, not an arc. Devin and Adam picture character change as the ups and downs of a lie detector test: a character searching for their truth.
- Tangents for number 50. Screenwriting’s economy of the page, long takes and the crew behind the camera, and music as the final character of a film (Danny Elfman, John Williams, First Man).
Examples discussed
- Star Wars: the cantina scene, where Luke goes from a farm with two other people to a room full of creatures.
- The Jungle Book: the water is so low that predators and prey agree to share the watering hole.
- Top Gun: the bar scene introduces Iceman, Slider, Viper and the rest. Iceman is Maverick’s rival and reflection, while Goose is the supportive ally. The rivals unite when a bigger danger arrives.
- Jumanji: Welcome to the Jungle: the bazaar is a watering hole turned into the central set piece, home to the midpoint and Fridge’s cake weakness. Devin also sees watering hole elements in Nigel’s Jeep ride.
- Edward Scissorhands: the family dinner (Alan Arkin’s deadpan Bill hands Edward a straw for his drink) and later the barbecue, with the gossiping neighbors as the rumor mill that becomes the torch-carrying mob.
- Harry Potter: Malfoy as the rival introduced early.
- Also: The Matrix (the bullet-point rules and tools scene), Notting Hill, Just Friends and The Devil Wears Prada.
Writing along with the season? Write a three-page watering hole scene. Find the communal space in your story, even if it’s just the office break room. Be a storyteller, not a story keeper.
Read the full transcript
Transcribed automatically, so expect the odd misheard word. Sponsor messages are left out.
Adam: In this episode, we explore the story event, The Watering Hole. How can this communal setting place take shape as a character? Cafeteria, mess hall, coffee shop, restaurant, bar, a family dinner, next on StoryOsophy. Hello, welcome to StoryOsophy. This is Adam Jones.
Devin: Hey, I’m Devin Halden. Sorry, Devin Halden. Shouldn’t have had that second cup of coffee.
Adam: Yeah, no kidding. I did the same thing. I’m like,
Like wound myself up like a top, and now I got to sit still and talking to him. I know.
Devin: Oh. Yeah. Happy episode 50. 50.
Adam: Happy episode 50, StoryOsophers. We did it. 50 episodes of complete awesome. Some may disagree, but we think complete awesome.
Devin: Couple I disagree with as well, but typically the first 10.
Adam: Yeah.
Devin: Yeah. It’s a journey.
Adam: If you’re just tuning in to us, we are 50 episodes in, and the first few are a little rough, but that’s a testament to what this podcast is all about. Just get started. Refine it later. You got to sit one foot forward in front of the other. That’s right. And just get moving. Get it out in the universe. People think seeing is believing, but it’s believing is seeing is the principle, which I agree with. I mean, quantum physics and science says your reality’s a projection screen. Your mind is the projector and reality’s the projection screen. And it depends on what thoughts or what reel of story you’re running through that projector will determine what you see on the screen of reality or experience that you have. That’s also why we start, to do our events like characters choosing instead of having stuff happen to them. It’s experiencing things. And then you’re making choices about those things is a totally different way of approaching life and mindset instead of being victim to or at the whim of the gods or all that other jazz.
Right. What is it called? Prometheus Rising. I was just looking it up. It’s not on Audible, so. No, it’s an older book, and it’s pretty esoteric. It’s way out there. Yeah. My friend Adam Lamas gave it to me. It’s not as accessible, reading-wise. It’s a little more academic. Like, you have to, it’s just the way it’s written. It’s kind of like Campbell, kind of like Joseph Campbell, Vogler. Rather than Vogler, yes. Compared to Vogler, yeah. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Sourcefield Investigations may be a better read than stuff similar to Prometheus Rising. I was thinking Wilcox, David Wilcox, or that to, like, Abraham Hicks’ teaching, which is more like focus and inner guidance. They’re sort of more simplified or less academic. Screenwriting, which I do a lot of, the sentences are so short, you’re trying to get as little information into a sentence as possible.
Devin: That’s also the challenge of, like, a novel, novelist. Right. Going and trying to write a screenplay or vice versa, where it’s like, novelist, you’re like, you’re used to that freedom of words. To project, or to describe things and, and tell the story. And then in screenwriting, you’re trying to translate what’s happening visually on a screen on how it, the, the economy of the page and understanding that a sentence, like, what would that translation from what a sentence is and what a page is to minutes and screen time and things like that. It’s. Sure. The very different challenges.
Adam: And the interesting thing is you’re trying to, with screenwriting is, you’re trying to take and make it very condensed. Like, it’s a reduction of everything to the smallest. Like, if you have to describe a setting, you don’t have a paragraph to go, here’s where the house was and the trees and the, you know, on screen, the eye is going to take that in, in seconds. So you can’t take up that amount of time slash space on the screen page because it’s literally not going to take up that amount of time on screen. This week, we’re going to be looking at the story event. The watering hole.
Before we get there, let me just go through where we’re at structurally and we’re navigating story structure or how one would navigate choices within a story for mainly writing, sculpting and building a blueprint, but it’s also accessible to actors, directors, and even just people living your life. You, as you go along and you encounter different obstacles and complications, it’s difficult sometimes to look at the broader view and make a choice. Outside of your limited perspective when you’re in the moment. And so part of structuring and story is zooming way out and looking at it broadly. Actually, I was just saying this to a friend of mine the other day.
One of the pieces of advice I give to people if they’re having an issue or a problem in their life is I say, look, when you get home or when you get to a place where things are a little quieter, find a quieter space and imagine that the day you’ve just had or what you’ve just gone through is an episode of a TV sitcom. That you just watched, pretend like it’s not you detach yourself from it and just go through the day and pretend like it so you can actually laugh at the stupid stuff easily. You don’t get so personally wrapped up in it. So structuring, that’s sort of what you’re doing.
You’re zooming way out so you can go, okay, does this make sense that this person is here or how they navigate these choices? The watering hole story event. It’s about the communal space of the world of the story or your world. Where you might hang out, you know, bar, restaurant, cafeteria, different things like that. It sort of is a floating event in a story. It can happen in different places. In terms of the navigation of our structure, it’s the second event in act two, the way we’re laying this out. So act one of a story, the known world, the events that exist there are the hook scene where you’re grabbing your audience.
The known world routine or status quo. Of your protagonist, the inciting incident of your story, which gets everything in motion, the call to quest where that motion meets the hero, a call is presented in the form of a question or in some scenario, the hero will then go through a debate period of refusal and then choosal two separate events. The Call to Quest, and After Choosing, they’ll cross the threshold into the unknown world of what’s to come in that journey. So like most situations, most of us throughout the day or even our lives, we’re presented with these choices and we have to choose one way or the other, and sometimes we don’t choose well.
Well, this is sort of the point of thresholds. We break each act into smaller movements, and at the end of each movement is a threshold. And the reason why we break them up into smaller chunks, other than the fact that act two sometimes tends to be, as I call it, the desert, and as Devin calls it, the ocean, you tend to get lost in how to structure. And you’ll, and even as an audience member, if you’re a StoryOsopher, you’ll notice that some movies that they’ll start to meander in the middle and you sort of are, you as an audience member are lost and don’t quite understand what’s going on. That’s because it’s not well-structured. It’s sort of meandering itself. So from the writing standpoint or the actor-director building standpoint, we break them down into movements. So once you’re through act one and you move from the known world of the hero, the comfort zone, which is movement one, comfort zone to auto-comfort zone, you’re moving into movement two.
Which we sort of call, it’s all fun and games until dot, dot, dot, or the first day of school. And within this, you’re moving from the comfort zone, from being out of the comfort zone, into the danger zone. So as we spoke about last week, first day of school is the first event. We also call the whole thing the first day of school because that’s really what it is. First day of school for that first event or the reaction to the unknown world. And this week, we’re going to be talking about the water. The watering hole, which happens, well, we’ve placed it here. It doesn’t need to happen right here. The way we have it built is simply this. First day of school, first event in movement two or act two, watering hole, second event, third event.
Third event is rules and tools. Fourth event, approaching the danger zone. And the fifth event is crossing that threshold into the danger zone. Within that progression, there’s a lot of learning, but there’s a choice to be made at the end that will cause your protagonist to move across that threshold.
Devin: Right. Watering hole and the next event, rules and tools, we call them floaters, but they could also be overlappers, so they can happen also within while other events are happening. And another way to distinguish, I think, is when we, the last episode, we talked about reaction to unknown world or first day of school. That’s an observation, observational event that you’re observing, you’re taking things in. A lot of stories. There’s a bit of a sensory overload moment. And then when you move into watering hole and rules and tools, it’s more of a gathering. So it’s observation and orientation. And then it’s, we’re moving in now, we’re gathering information.
We’re gathering a little bit of insight and background of the creatures of this unknown world, their customs, what they eat, what they drink.
Adam: You also may have to interact. Watering hole sometimes requires you to interact. And not just observe anymore. Rules and tools, you might still be able to observe some, but.
Devin: Yeah, because you’re gathering, and the information is typically, you’re gathering information from either somebody, a native of this unknown world. And I say a native of this, and I don’t want to, some terminology may sound like we’re only talking about epic mythology movie, like Hobbit and things like that. But this is like, if you want to go to like a rom-com, this would also be, you’re talking to the best friend. This is the bar. Or the bar, yeah. Someone that knows. About the girl you’re going after. So you’re getting a little bit of background on them, and you still don’t know at this point if they’re an ally or an enemy, but they are also sizing you up on, are you a threat to them, are you a threat to their friend, and things like that.
So you’re getting, you’re still getting information, but it’s a gather, you’re gathering, is like the best way to put it, I guess. I like the visual of things, and so if I’m looking at this like timeline, in a way, of these events happening, you know, I see we’re through movement one. And then, or like dominoes, and you’re, we’re in the first day of school, known reaction to the unknown world, and here’s where it can kind of split. So if you, if we’re looking at it from a dominoes, there can be the watering hole and the rules and tools, or they could, watering hole and rules and tools can be kind of on top of each other in these first several, or the first couple events of the, of movement two, act two.
Adam: Yeah, let’s talk about that, the broadness of them. First, that’s a good way to approach it because they’re much bigger. We do events and some of the ones we’ve talked about in movement one is the choosal and refusal. And these are things that could be sentences in dialogue. They’re that brief, these events. And these that we’re about to get into, first day of school is sort of just a reaction aspect. But this one, the watering hole, and specifically this one and the next one, rules and tools, which sometimes they’re rules and tools come first. We’ll probably talk more when we do rules and tools after we understand watering hole. But sometimes these can be much larger. Like they can be the entirety of movement two. They can open up and become these events that become set pieces, which we’ll see in some of the examples.
And not, before we get too far, let’s sort of maybe give some visuals for people to understand what we’re talking about. Like Star Wars, the cantina scene, when Luke first goes in with Obi-Wan to find a pilot. There’s a lot going on. There’s a lot of different types of aliens and people and beings and creatures. And it’s where they all come together communally. It’s not a certain type of neighborhood. It’s where everyone comes together. I mentioned off air to you, the jungle book, where the water is so low that all of the animals that would normally maybe prey on each other for food, they have a pact where they can all drink from the same watering hole.
Now, that’s a really great visual to understand what a watering hole is. You know, in a bar, you can’t. You can’t come in and cause a ruckus, really. It’s sort of a communal place. And so the weird thing about a watering hole is it can actually become the entire set piece for not just a movement or other events we’ll talk about, but an entire series like Cheers, one of the most famous sitcoms that has ever existed. It’s one watering hole. They centered the entire story on a watering hole. And you’ll see it. What’s Two Broke Girls is another sitcom that’s out recently. It’s around. The diner, for the most part.
Brooklyn Nine-Nine is the police station. But these are watering holes, communal gathering places.
Devin: Another key element of the watering hole is to introduce characters.
Adam: Exactly.
Devin: Like in Top Gun at the bar that night, that’s the watering hole scene when we actually meet Viper or Slider and we meet Iceman and Hollywood. We meet the cast of characters that we’re going to be spending the story with. And we kind of. We kind of also provide the background, a little bit of background, all we need at this point about who they are, but also the dynamic, the first dynamic that we’re going to have with them. Like in Top Gun, we know fairly straightforward that Iceman and Maverick are not going to get along the way that they interact with each other. And that kind of sets the tone for the entire film, gathering information about the environment, the world, and then also the creatures within that world.
And then also if you can put in some, this is also from your, if you’re looking, if you’re story blueprinting this beforehand and you’ve decided to, and before you started writing the events, you wanted to put together a, like a dossier of your characters, but also dossier of like about the environment, about the worlds. This is where you’re like, what is the, if your story calls for it, like what’s the, is there political unrest here? What are the politics here? What are they, what are the foods they eat? What is the? Drink that they drink? And it depends on, you know, of course, what story and if, and if those elements are important things to, to make sure that you highlight in this, in this scene.
But this scene is where you’ll, you’ll give a lot of that information, that, that first impression, but also first experience that your hero is going to have within that world. And with it, with that culture, like with the culture of that world that you’re creating. And of course the creatures that make up that world.
Adam: And the social interaction. Mm-hmm. So whatever the first day of school or the reaction to this new world or this unknown world is, you’re getting only a glimpse of it.
Devin: Right.
Adam: Just the stuff, it’s like, like we’re saying, it’s the hook of your movement too. Like there’s a hook in movement one and act one. This is the hook, the first day of school. Right? That’s the fun part where you get to go, all right, here’s where we’re going to have maybe Harry walk through Hogwarts and see the moving paintings and this and that, and just glimpses of wonder. Things that you can just show something that’s a setup and pay off throughout the rest of your story. These little tidbits. It’s almost like the movement one promises you have, questions and curiosities. Here, we get to see an amalgam of the world. It may not be a full picture, but as Devin said in Top Gun, it’s every one of the academy. And a mess hall, a cafeteria, if it’s a movie about a school, but every one of these worlds that are sort of microcosms or smaller entities like a prison, a school, a work environment like an office, Brooklyn Nine-Nine is a police station.
That’s their sort of, that once again, a unit set like Cheers, that’s a watering hole. That’s, I mean, it’s an exaggeration on it, but that’s where they all go to gossip and talk about each other and figure stuff out. So it is, they treat it like that for comic purposes. It shows a mix of all different types of personalities. I love this one. Yeah. Watering hole is one of my, I know you say it, but watering hole is one of my favorites for sure, because all of the work you’ve done, and this means done meaning after this point. Yeah. With characters and things, developing the world, brainstorming, figure things out. You get to hint at a lot of things. They all come together here. And you can balance a lot of different character voices here. And there’s a lot of play.
Devin: I also get really excited writing scenes of payout, either payoff scenes. I love, I love where I’m like, oh man, this is like, I finally made it to this payoff scene that I set up and I can’t, I couldn’t wait to write the payoff scene. Oh yeah. But also scenes that I’m giving awesome information to the audience. It’s like, Oh, see like this, like the cantina scene in, in, in star Wars or, or the top gun scene where the writer’s like, this is where I, I, the first clash of the antagonist and the protagonist. This is where I put them in the same room. It’s almost in top gun. It’s almost a little bit of a pressure cooker in a way, pressure cooker scene where you’re like, oh, they’re, I’ve got them together. They’re crowded. They’re surrounded by people, but this I’m building stuff.
Like I’m introducing these other primary. Characters and whether it’s antagonist or protagonist, allies, enemies, shapeshifters, people we may have thought was an ally and ends up being an enemy or vice versa.
Adam: All different shapes, sizes, and colors. Yeah.
Devin: Yeah. And you get to explain your world that you’ve created too. And it doesn’t necessarily, again, I, a lot of times I go to these, I just kind of what I like to write with like this, these method, like a Hobbit things or where there’s these definite changes of, of worlds from more of magical. Yeah. Types of worlds, but it works for, for anything like rom-coms where it’s.
Adam: Or even work. You got a new job. Yeah. A new school.
Devin: Yeah. So you get to introduce a lot of great things.
Adam: Follow the rom-com thought because it’s not a space. The rom-coms, it’s not necessarily a physical space. Sometimes it’s a different way of a different world.
Devin: And sometimes it is, sometimes it is a bar. Even if we use it, if you use the bar scene, it’s, or the bar scenario. It’s where our protagonist who has now entered this unknown world. Is gathering information about not only the, the good love interest or the girl he’s after or guy she’s after, but also potential obstacles that are going to get in his way. So there’s somebody, whether it’s a mentor character, or there’s somebody telling them, giving them a little bit of information about this place that, and people, perhaps certain like people to watch out for, whether it’s. Devil wears Prada. There’s a scene in that where it’s, you’re just, you’re getting information about the antagonist, maybe the, just the minions of the antagonist or who you per you at that moment, you perceive as the antagonist.
And you’re getting information about, all right, stay away from them. Stay away from her. If you can get in good with them, get in good with them. You know, it’s that typical sophomore in high school sitting down with a. Freshman in high school, like, stay away from that group. If you can get in with these guys, these guys are good. Kind of give them the lay of the land a little bit.
Adam: This is also one of those places where, so one of our big archetypes that we like is the shapeshifter, and romantic comedy opposites are shapeshifters. I was chatting about that last episode. But the rival is sometimes, and in Top Gun, it is the main force of antagonism to Maverick is he meets his rival, but it doesn’t always have to be. You can find your rival, and the force of antagonism can be something different. You might even be able to divide Top Gun into the force of antagonism is like graduation, right? Moving through the pressure of the system as a force of antagonism. You’ve got oversight with instructors.
Mm-hmm. And your rival. Your rival is Iceman. If you wanted to separate them for the purpose of discussion, you could do that. Some movies, the rival is the antagonist, period. And sometimes, the rival is a totally separate character that may switch to become sidekick or ally at some point in the story. And it’s not the force of antagonism, but it can be if you don’t introduce the antagonist here. Mm-hmm. It’s one of those looming forces of antagonism. Jumanji sort of does this. The rival character can sustain the story, like Harry Potter. Harry Potter, there’s not really a danger in it. You’re riding the curiosity of a boy in an unknown land, and you bring in Malfoy, the Slytherin kid.
Yeah, yeah, yeah. Yeah. So that’s his rival throughout most of the series. And so you bring him in early, so now there’s competition. And it’s not really an antagonist, but it’s a source of antagonism to the hero that highlights the hero’s fears, their weaknesses, their strengths, their knee-jerk reactions to things. And so it’s a nice spot to bring in a rival. You see it in a cafeteria scene or a jailhouse scene in the cafeteria. It’s a nice spot for a rival character. And it’s a variation on that archetype of shapeshifter. Excuse me.
Devin: And that’s what… That’s what they do with Top Gun. Right. Because Iceman isn’t necessarily the antagonist. He’s the opposition. Competition. He’s a force of opposition. Right. But the antagonist is Pete Mitchell’s past that he keeps, and it’s actually spelled out for us in a scene later.
Adam: The only reason why he has an issue with Iceman is because it’s a literal funhouse mirror reflection of Maverick himself. It’s this distorted super ego that he’s competing against. His father, the way he reacts to his father, like all the characters that are either sidekicks or sources of antagonism, allies or enemies, they’re going to highlight something or highlights the wrong word, reflect something about your hero. That’s the whole purpose of having characters is you get to show dimension of your hero. You just don’t know he’s the same.
Devin: Without Iceman, a lot of that stuff doesn’t come to the surface like Pete Mitchell’s character. And so that’s like you’re saying… Exacerbating. Without him coming into Pete Mitchell’s world, he will continue to suppress that stuff. And where Goose is really the only one that understands some of the history of, oh, you’re Duke Mitchell’s kid. They wouldn’t let you in the Academy because you’re Duke Mitchell’s kid. So there’s a lot of things that Goose knows, but without bringing in that opposition, the competitor, those things wouldn’t necessarily come to the surface where they’re not, like you’re saying, highlighted, where we’re shining a light on it. And he’s almost like poking the bear a little bit where all that stuff really comes to the surface.
Adam: Yeah, not to get off on a rival discussion, but one of the points of this is pushing them towards change. And so the rival is a teacher in its own right, because that stuff never would come to the surface if someone wasn’t provoking it. A true, quote, mentor will understand that about the person where they need to go next and sort of… Push them in that direction, but they won’t shove them in that direction or battle them a lot in that direction. A rival will. And it’s over the same kind of thing. It’s like, I don’t like where you’re sitting here. And they’re moving them to the next level. Talk about thinking broadly. That’s a tough one to see when you’re in the circumstance. Hindsight’s 20-20, right?
So you can see this in retrospect at the end of Top Gun. These two are smiling and clapping each other on the shoulders. We did it. We did it. And but they hate each other the rest of the movie. So it’s finding that earlier setup where you can you can make them rivals and then understand how to release it.
Devin: And what’s important about that, another great story element is their rivals, Iceman and Maverick are rivals and competitors and really each other. There’s antagonists until a force of antagonism until they have a bigger, more dangerous antagonist to fight together, uniting them. Yeah. So when it’s just a competition, a top who’s the best and they’re at Top Gun and it’s like, what, three weeks or whatever. I forgot what it was. Six weeks. And that’s their that’s when they’re competing. They’re the only person they can compete against is the person that’s better than them. And they’re the they’re the two best, best people. So they’re. That’s the only competitors they have are each other. And then it gets it becomes an entirely different country where there’s something bigger, more dangerous. And it’s like.
Adam: Respect and cooperation are the priorities instead of competition. Yeah. But you can that’s a really good trick to you. It is a great trick.
Devin: You can introduce a character like that that challenges.
Adam: In a compartmentalized world, they’re in this academy. And once you break up in that academy and put them out in an actual different. And that’s also great for a third act. You take them out of this scenario. So you got your first act, put them in the school, the academy, and then break them out of that and put them in a real world situation for act three. Do you see how act one, act two, act three is sort of like these totally different worlds or or viewpoints on the world? You can. It’s great to create that microcosm of act two. And by the end of it, sort of go. But now let’s sort of bring it back to the real world or or how it more broadly affects things.
Right there. It’s not about the school anymore. It’s now about what they’ve learned.
Devin: It’s just a great use of bringing a character that will highlight the that internal obstacles that your protagonist has. And so bringing him in, it doesn’t always have to be the different trials of the journey. Yeah. It just can be a debate or an argument. It can be a guy who just understands he’s at a higher level. He he can actually Iceman can actually see his flaws. He understands Maverick’s flaws and he understands. He understands how to manipulate him. He understands how to how to, like you’re saying, shine a light on his flaws that other people either who just wouldn’t do that. Like Goose under Goose knows them, but he’s more of an ally. He’s like a friend.
He’s like, I don’t want to I wouldn’t push Maverick in a way that Iceman pushes him to make that will make him better. I’m just going to be in support. I’m just a supportive character to him. Iceman is the guy who makes Maverick better.
Adam: You’ve got these two sort of teachers slash pseudo mentor type things. The ally support. And the rival. But they’re both teaching in a way. One is giving the advice on a calmer level like Goose. Right. Or just understanding. And and also remember this, too. Sometimes the hero needs to express. And so Goose is a good set of ears. Right. If he needs to be as a supportive character. And then you’ve got.
Devin: Right. One’s a teammate. One’s the opponent.
Adam: Right. And then you’ve got the other one who’s like directly pointing their finger at this other person’s this, that or the other thing. So one’s direct. And one can be receptive. Right. They’re really good for character. I know we’re going. It’s not just Top Gun. We’re actually philosophizing beyond that. But these are really good ways of using this archetype. Right. Because this whole section movement to we’re talking about is tests, allies and enemies. I mean, this is what Vogler calls it. So understanding through a series of preliminary tests, who’s an ally, meaning Goose and who’s a rival. Because this is the place. This is the movement to have fun in.
Devin: Right. Exactly.
Adam: The rest of it. Once you get past this threshold, threshold two into the danger zone, stuff needs to become a little bit more pointed for your story or else your audience is going to check out. Here you can play more. And so part of the fun of the watering hole scene is creating that communal dynamic. And we don’t even need to get full-on Iceman or full-on Goose yet. But we do need to get a taste of them and go, oh, we like them for these reasons. Still, continue to bait your audience, but bait them with fun here. In movement one, you tell them exactly what’s happening, you give them your premise.
And here, you expand and start to give them different and broader flavors. The most fun flavors you can give them. Because you set it up, if the premise is good, they’re going to love it. Now, make this so enjoyable, they can’t stop. And then, go back to pointing your story out. Boom, boom, boom. At movement three, four, five, and six, you’re already into the climax. One thing about watering hole, or an interesting variation on it. If you don’t enter, a physical special world or unknown world. For instance, let’s use a job as an example. You’re at an office. And you don’t leave that job and go to another job.
Between act one and act two, you get promoted. Or you get a bit of information. Or a new person is hired. And you fall in love with that person. Right? She catches your eye or he catches your eye. And you’re like, wow. It still is the same physical space. But the, the unknown world becomes that person or thing. The space has changed internally. The way that hero or protagonist views that physical space. So, if you have that kind of story where you’re not changing environments completely. You can start and have your watering hole as one of the scenes of the known world routine or status quo of your first act.
It could just be some place everybody goes for drinks. And that’s just sort of, part of the setup. Then you get into movement two. And that little beat of the watering hole. It’s not a new place. It’s an older place that you’ve set up in movement one. But things are different now. Yeah. Something changes in that, in that environment becomes a totally different atmosphere. And so the contrast of its simple routine aspect of movement one. That’s part of the status quo of the known world routine. Now it’s, you can show that that space is different. And use the watering hole that way too. Like, you’ll see it in high school reunion movies or someone returns home movies.
And the, and the bar that everyone’s used to, we’re going there Thursday night. Someone who hasn’t been there in 20 years is there. And they’re like, hey, did you see so-and-so over there? So the, that watering hole scene can, you can use it that way. As a status quo set up and then pay off in, later in the film.
Devin: Was that movie Best Friend? Or, Just Friends. Just Friends.
Adam: That happens. Yeah. That movie is so funny. I mean, it’s got Ryan Reynolds and Anna Faris. How can you go wrong?
Devin: At all. And then there’s also, I’m trying to think of what movie it is with, oh, Notting Hill. That’s similar, too, where it’s, she’s in town shooting, Julia Roberts is that famous actress, she’s in town shooting a movie, and Hugh Grant’s character, she, somehow he just charms her or whatever, and he becomes like this, he’s in this unknown world because he went from a nothing to… This celebrity’s boyfriend, and then so when she enters his house, like his family doesn’t know how to react to her because they’re just this really small, I think it’s like this little English town, but it’s similar to that where… Where he’s not traveling anywhere.
His threshold into this unknown world is, is him just being discovered. By the celebrity. And then the watering hole is literally him sitting with her in her hotel room. And her, him gathering this information. He’s gathering, he’s gathering things, but he’s also understanding, Oh, the media is bad. So we got to stay away from the media. They’re going to exploit me. And I can’t, I can’t be seen with you. Otherwise it’ll ruin my reputation. There’s all this information that we’re getting from, for, I don’t even know. I haven’t, it’s been probably a decade since I’ve seen that movie. So I don’t want to butcher it, but they’re not, it’s not at a certain place. It’s era.
I mean, I, there are a lot of bar scenes and rom-coms for sure. Yeah. This is what I remember over the, over Christmas. My girlfriend watches every Hallmark movie. So I watch it with, I’m not saying I don’t like them. I’m just saying that they’re all have this, like talk about templates. They just have this, but it’s, it works. And a lot of times it’s, they’re actually. Great films to analyze because they have certain beats. They have these events in them that are basically like, you understand they’re good. Decisions. To turn your brain off and enjoy just enjoy.
Adam: I mean like you it’s like when I’m watching it I’m like they’re establishing this they’re doing this like I’m breaking it down I don’t mean to criticize in that way it’s just I like I like puzzles man I like stories that are cutting edge and challenging and so it. Right not your cup of tea. Well as we’re talking about structure there’s ways of varying it. They get it though man. They got a recipe man.
Devin: The business that Hallmark understands their they understand their audience. Yes they do.
[Sponsor message]
Adam: Movies I’ve been watching recently well even Edward Scissorhands watching it and I’m thinking to myself broadly can you imagine being on set here are cameras here’s the sound guy here’s this guy in a leather outfit. With blades for hands and someone’s touching up his face with makeup not the shot of Peg doing it a makeup professional and there’s three other people here they’re eating sandwiches and they’re and I sort of do that for a second and I’m like yeah but that’s building a movie yeah maybe that’s weird to the audience but me when I think about that I’m like I love that I love imagining that where it’s like yeah there are a hundred people here in a shoestring budget maybe fifty people even.
Less but like a hundred people on the other side of that camera and they’ve all done little aspects here and there to make you believe that and and to me there’s nothing greater on this in this world than that to me storytelling is it right I’m like look at the co creative joyous experience and just for you just for you to believe that that’s a real thing right for an hour and a half or. You know.
Devin: Read of the book I do with like the technical stuff like I’m always wondering with a shot of Mike man is like are they booming that is there a laugh on like it sounds really good shooting and like or or like a camera shot I and I love the long there’s nothing better to me than a long long take no cuts yeah baby the waltz of that with everybody like you’re saying the people behind the camera that have to move the cables out of the camera. Yeah. The way you and I sync up on this so much but there’s a ton of commercials out there now to that they’re doing where they they do the behind the scenes and they go from it’s supposed to happen over time there’s like these this couple and they move in and then they turn and when they’re turning and this is from the behind the scenes there’s like twenty people run in they change the scene the actress is getting her getting a dress pull off or put on another way to wig put on so makes it look older and then it comes back around and nothing is stopped there’s no cuts and then she shows up again comes through a door.
A door a floating door that was I was like what yeah I don’t think there’s nothing better than than that that type of a can’t waltz with the camera and the actors and that dance that’s like oh haunting Hill House and it’s the best what’s the other one I saw we were talking about marvelous Miss Maisel yep they do a lot of that does the same sort of thing reverent did it yeah you and you and I are very similar in this it’s funny the way you watch it because when I’m watching things even on a an observational level.
Adam: I’m. Watching the emotional environment meaning. Dialogue, performers, things they are not saying, their facial expression, the little minutiae of all of that. So technically, maybe I recognize, oh, that’s where they started the push of the camera. But I’m not looking at the tech. I mean, I do think technically, almost second nature, but it’s not my focus. I’m like, I want to create an emotional experience. Well, not just emotional, mental, philosophical, and emotional experience for whoever is watching this. I want to engage their thinking on a curiosity level, like, what’s closing in on that person? Why are we getting close? What’s happening? Right. All those things. And then for them to feel, and you can see it a lot on an actor’s face, the emotional landscape, but also music.
Devin: Yeah, music.
Adam: I mean, I don’t like to be a manipulative storyteller, but you use music and you don’t have to do any work, really, because the audience is experiencing the music and the image at the same time.
Devin: Right. Rabbit hole. You take Danny Elfman’s soundtrack out of Edward Scissorhands, and it’s a completely different movie. Like, even if you have somebody else. 100%. Somebody else score that movie, it’s way different, because especially that first score in the movie. Yeah. When we’re looking at him look down upon that village. There’s magic. It evokes so much emotion, but it actually sets the tone for the movie. The whole movie. Yeah. It’s very magical and whimsical.
Adam: The music is the final character of a film, in my opinion. And you may have the music ahead of time, but if you don’t and a composer comes in, they’re creating this. It’s almost like a parent-like character where it’s overseeing the entire movie. It’s going to be the thread that connects every character, and you may have themes that you develop for certain characters, and then they move into the overall symphony of the entire piece. You can weave in these, especially instrumentations, use a violin for Kim or an oboe for Edward. I don’t know if that’s what they did, but compartmentalizing a little bit so that when you do the overall score, all of the characters come together.
It’s amazing music in film, the way it ties it together. And I don’t think people don’t notice it, but if it’s really good, you don’t notice it.
Devin: Right.
Adam: And if it’s really brilliant, like, for instance, John Williams in Jaws, or like you’re saying, Danny Elfman in Edward Scissorhands, it creates the emotional, philosophical landscape we’re talking about for the experience. Right. Kudos either way. And I just want to say, too, the reason why we’re going on different tangents here is this is our 50th episode. Yeah, yeah. So we’re allowed to do whatever we want, baby. So there are going to be tangents on this.
Plus, I think it’s interesting. Yeah. And we’re going to keep it interesting. Hey, man, from here on out, it’s more and more exploration. We’re at 50 episodes. There’s no stopping us now.
Devin: Right. Exactly. But to go back to the music. Right. And I just noticed this. Recently, I watched a film and I was like, this is so generic. Like, they didn’t utilize the music as a character. And I watched First Man. First Man, dude, have you seen it? Have you seen First Man with Ryan Gosling and I think one of the Apollo missions, Apollo 11?
Adam: I haven’t seen it, no.
Devin: Okay. So the entire, almost the entire movie, there’s this. The score is like just intense. It’s like. But it’s like. You realize when you’re watching it, it’s literally the music that is keeping you engaged because you’re constantly waiting, you’re waiting, you’re waiting, you’re waiting for something. And I’m like.
Adam: Oh, you notice. So you notice the music?
Devin: Yeah. Oh, I, well, I did it. I finally did. I’m like, wow. Everything is so intense about every scene of this movie. Every scene was like this. It was almost an underscore.
Adam: Like a soundscape.
Devin: Yeah.
Adam: It was like.
Devin: I was. I was. I was. I was.
Adam: They use them as separate scenes, but also, like we were establishing before, set pieces. Larger pieces of the overall story itself as part of the world. And Watering Hole is a really good piece of your world. Or you can have several pieces. But in Jumanji, Welcome to the Jungle, they use the Watering Hole as their central set piece for the movie. Trying to get to the bazaar for the missing piece, they’re told. That’s the clue. That’s the video game clue. And so once they get there, all of the stuff that would normally be Watering Hole scene stuff, that’s where it all happens. Rations, drinks, communal environment where everybody from different cultures is there shopping, places to get supplies, learning more about what’s going on.
Like you go there to seek information. And the Herald comes in the form of the boy with the hat. And he’s really talking to Dr. Bravestone. He won’t speak to anybody else. He’s an NPC like Nigel. So what they’ve done there instead of the Watering Hole really being earlier is they’ve said, let’s make it a big set piece. And we’ll use all the tropes and archetypes in a Watering Hole there. I love the fact that they said, you know what? We get how awesome. The Watering Hole can be as an event or a set piece. And like, we’ll make it the center. We’ll make, we will set our crisis at a Watering Hole.
That’s sort of what they did. It was a good choice, a really good choice. They’re stranded in the wilderness and they get to pseudo civilization halfway through their journey. It was actually, at least in my opinion, a smart choice.
Devin: I think I touched on it last episode is the key elements for me with Watering Hole is it’s kind of information gathering. So we’re, after we’re through with the shock of being, of finding ourselves in this unknown world, we’ll finally have time to ask questions maybe and discuss things and get, gather information. And so in this, in the Jeep scene with Nigel, I feel that is the beginning of the Watering Hole or it’s a piece of the Watering Hole. I do agree that the Bazaar is also Watering Hole. But the reason I use this, use the Jeep scene is, is we’re getting, we’re gathering information about the journey.
But we’re also gathering information about our opponent or the antagonist at this stage. And it’s done with that cut scene that they jokingly, basically, they joke about right away.
Adam: And primarily that’s rules and tools. I do agree there are hints of Watering Hole, but primarily he’s giving them information and the tools they need to survive. But it does hint at it because he’s sort of a Watering Hole character. He’s the communal knowledge and the flashback shows the world. And so a lot of the way he’s presenting the rules and tools in his little Jeep trip. Absolutely. Is in flashback and preliminarily setting up what the Watering Hole sort of feeling is. It’s storytelling. The storytelling aspect of it is what you’re talking about.
Devin: It’s rules and tools and Watering Hole are all together here. They’re all, we’re getting rules and tools. But we’re also getting elements in my personal opinion, elements of a Watering Hole is that’s what we’re getting. We’re getting that, that first day of school, you get to the cafeteria. This is, here’s the lay of the land. Get away from, stay, you know, the lay of the land is also a good way, a good way to say that.
Adam: The first day of school to cafeteria. That’s a great analogy. And even, and showing up at the cafeteria, even if you face an Iceman or you find an Iceman and you get it wrong. Next is rules and tools for someone to teach you. Look, you don’t have to deal with that guy. That way. Right. Or it’s like this, though, if the rules and tools come slightly before the watering hole, it’s like, look, before you get to the cafeteria, let me tell you, and that’s sort of the order. But you’re right. If you track from first day of school, thinking of it in it, because most, almost everything.
Everybody can associate this and it’s easy to understand. Even our young StoryOsophers who are just starting their first stories, they get school. So track it like this, man. First day of school, cafeteria.
Devin: Right. And then that’s why we call these, the watering hole and rules and tools are floaters because. They move. Floaters and overlappers. Overlappers! They can move. They can be on top of each other. Why I’m happy that we’re using Jumanji for this is, this is the exact example. Of what, what, what we’re talking about, about being malleable. This isn’t paint by numbers. This isn’t a template. It has to go in this order. These events are important to include in there. So we’re getting, do we have, do you, do you want to tell your audience some of the rules and tools of this world and the journey? Absolutely.
Do you want to have a moment when you’re, they’re gathering information perhaps by a mentor or somebody that with, with knowledge of, of the unknown world? Absolutely. So that’s the watering hole. So you want to have, however you want to rearrange them, interact, then yeah, put them on top of each other.
Adam: You’re not just observing. Now you got to interact with the community. And that’s a lot of what the watering hole is. Rules and tools can still be a private conversation. The perfect example of a rules and tools scene is Neo and Morpheus from the Matrix. That’s like the spot on example of a rules and tools scene.
Devin: Bullet points.
Adam: Right, exactly. It’s like, here’s what the world is about. Here’s what you need to do. Here are your tools. If you think of it like that, and then sort of go, now, how can I make it not seem that way?
Devin: Right.
Adam: Or in the case of Jumanji, where it’s all about a video game, where the whole crux of the journey is learning how to navigate said world via rules and tools, the whole movie’s a rules and tools scene. So every movement and every event and every scene is going to be rules and tools. That’s sort of how you, you, it’s, it’s. It doesn’t just become one scene. It becomes something bigger. If you don’t do that, or like, or for instance, it’s not Cheers, where there’s a watering hole as this whole set piece, they’re going to be right here in Movement 2. And they’re for the purpose, like in Star Wars, of showing you, look, Luke, he was on a farm with two other human beings. Now, this is where he’s at. It’s the contrast.
Right, exactly. You know? Yep. The whole purpose of the communal watering hole thing. So Jumanji, we’ll talk a little bit more about probably the minutiae of the watering hole aspect of the central bazaar area, where the tipping point, the crisis, the midpoint of the movie is when we get to those events, because they’ve used it as a set piece. But some of the things that are important, rations, food, they come to this place for food. And of course, Kevin Hart gets blown up by cake. Which is one of the funniest things in the whole. His weakness is. And we’ll get to this in Rules and Tools. Rules and Tools is not just in the previous event we talked about, first day of school, but- That’s a fun scene.
When they’re in the field- These are all fun scenes. And they tap their peck, and their stats come up. It’s Rules and Tools is throughout this whole movie, Jumanji. Right, right. But we can move to Edward Scissorhands, I think. Because watering hole is something that- We’ll break down a heck of a lot more in the middle of our event structuring here. Edward Scissorhands is sort of strange, too.
Devin: Yeah. For me, it’s the dinner scene. And also kind of when he’s getting wasted.
Adam: Mine is sort of extended. The watering hole for me in this one also is pushed a little later. The watering hole is the barbecue. That’s the big watering hole scene. Now, preliminarily, there’s an early watering hole scene, the dinner scene, between Peg, Bill, Kevin. And Edward. But it’s also- This whole chunk where there’s rules and tools. But like I said before, in Edward Scissorhands, the hard thing to determine is he doesn’t really get tools. He does get the pants. He does get the bed to sleep in. Like, he gets that kind of stuff. But a lot of what the movie’s built on is Edward lacking tools. Edward doesn’t have the tools to fit in here.
Right. And there’s no one that ever explains them to him. He doesn’t have the tools to fit in here. They’re all conspiring and they’re going to the sidewalk. And so the feeling of the communal group or that communal gathering place to me was I was watching the movie like fully through. I was like, oh, they did it as the barbecue and where the community comes together. And I’m like, but they also build to that strangely through the family dinner and then the rumor mill. And then it sort of comes together at that barbecue. But anyway, that was sort of my perspective. They use it twice in a weird way.
Devin: I can see it again for me when I just when I’m thinking about this event and even rules and tools, I’m thinking about like I come up with these just key elements in my head. And the key elements for the watering hole scene again is like understanding the creatures of this unknown world and noticing this new the creatures of this unknown world are noticing this this new stranger or this visitor. And so they’re just as curious about Edward as he is about them and this unknown world in which they live. But then we are also seeing like at the at the dinner scene, we’re seeing the customs of the unknown world.
So we see the attire during the previous event. We see the attire. We see the food, the drink. Father’s wearing a badge. The ritual. We’re getting information about the type of work. Again, we’re and we’re seeing the gender roles with with the gossipy women and the housewives who are huddled on the corner all literally all day and then scattering as the men. Return from a day’s work and then we hear the language and how it’s spoken and and and then the the next morning the next morning all the men leave again, but they’re out with they all have the golf bags, which by the way frame they could have framed that shot that aerial shot a little differently because when you look at the top of the frame, there’s a shot of another development housing development.
That’s all just beige just all beige.
Adam: I had some chakra things too, but I was. Leaving them out of the mix.
Devin: Because in my in your head, you want to believe that this world. Internally, it’s a microcosm. Is in the entirety of the world is pastels. Right? Yeah. So I was like, I could have framed it. Just how he had to do is tilt the camera down a little bit more.
Adam: But mine was when all the gentlemen back out when the husband’s back out of the driveways and it’s it’s all it’s so specifically uniform the whole time and they don’t do it in a rhythmically uniform fashion. It’s sort of haphazard.
Devin: Yeah.
Adam: And I was like, don’t know the choreography. I wish it was sort of like almost felt like it was factory oriented, right? Like they were stuck in a system.
Devin: The other element of of the watering hole is like the curiosity of both the person who’s entered the unknown world, but also the curiosity of the people in the unknown world of that person that’s now in their in their world. This is where we are getting information about the culture of this unknown world. And we’re getting information about the creatures of this unknown world. So like, that’s what kind of makes sense that this is, this is perhaps where Caroline Thompson, this is the scene that she wanted to really show a fish out of water, which is another important element of, of just being in this unknown world.
Adam: That’s all this story is. It’s fish out of water and Frankenstein combined. Much like we were talking about in Jumanji, but not applied the same. The watering hole and the rules and tools are stretched out across multiple aspects of this movie. A lot of it has to do with, does Edward have the rules in his head or the tools to survive within this world? Because Peg has to make the decision for his call to quest in the first movement. Is he capable of understanding the rules? Does he have the tools? To be able to function like a regular person that gets stretched out throughout most of this movement, two, three, four into the climax. He doesn’t, he runs away incomplete and all alone. He goes back to being alone. He can’t quite figure it out. The watering hole, the whole point of the community is that it it’s the force that becomes the mobs with torches chasing Frankenstein, right? The watering hole becomes that. And so going back to Vogler for a second, Vogler talks about tests, allies and enemies as this section, but he mentions that, you know, watering hole is one of the options and, and some other suggestions he has. But Devin and I bring this out. Watering hole is a major event because as in this case, in both cases of our examples and ones we’ve just spoken about, it can not only be a set piece, but really be something that elevates your entire story. If you really know how to use it, the communal opinion or the reputation of someone is really important in terms of the way. So you can have a personal interaction, but if you can get that grand scope, that zoomed out, broadened scope of how this community, this unknown world or known world interprets this person, we now then get a bit of mythology. Because if it’s a weird, weird world where we don’t get all the rules.
Yeah, I know. I couldn’t get that one out, right? What was that? If it’s a world, we don’t understand the rules. If it’s a world that we understand, like the suburbia that Edward’s coming into, and he’s the weird thing, we understand how he’s weird or how these people treat normal because we’re used to their perspective more so than the weird rules of the new world. So Jumanji is a new world. And in Edward Scissorhands, it’s a person, a weird thing entering. The normal world. They’re great, you know, reciprocal elements of each other.
Devin: Like for me, and we’ve talked about this before on the podcast, we always bring up Matrix that, well, they did it this way, and it actually worked, where it’s like, let’s just bullet point a bunch of information. I prefer the more creative approach to that where, and Adam, you just talked about it, where it’s like, we don’t necessarily have to have Peg say, oh, this is the type of people they are. The housewives are like this, and the men are like. We can show them in a different way, or we can have that relayed to both us and Edward, in this case, through a more creative approach.
And so I think that’s, it’s always, if you can, I know Matrix just kind of worked, but.
Adam: Well, the Matrix is the bullet point example. It’s like, if you want to know how to do it, point blank, that’s it. Exactly. But be more creative, because if most other movies, if they try to do it. Like The Matrix, you would go, this movie sucks. Yeah, lazy. The Matrix has a visual landscape you’d never seen before. It was exploring the mind in physical space, so they could get away with anything in that rules and tools scene. Most of the scenes are actually engaging the audience on a level where they associate themselves with Edward and his predicament. And every once in a while, you’ll get clues from Peg or Bill or Kevin, how you’re supposed to react to him.
Right. He’s struggling with those P’s. Bill’s like rooting for him in his, he’s a pretty good natured guy, you know, but it’s so deadpan.
Devin: Well, he has to be. His wife showed up with a dude with scissor hands and he’s just, he’s just sitting at the table with him. That’s my favorite part about it. I know. Alan Arkin is such a great actor. And then he’s like, so, so I had to have a pretty good view up there. And I love the fact that they just missed, they decided they’re like, we don’t have to have.
Adam: We don’t need the denial.
Devin: That conversation that Peg has with her husband. No.
Adam: He’s like, whatever, he’s here. So Jumanji, where they have the whole, like, almost 10 minutes worth of denial to introduce to all your A-list performers, and it’s really fun and funny. Edward, they were like, screw it. We’re not even going to give you, the audience, a chance to go, what? Is this really okay? Like, screw it. We’re skipping that.
Devin: Yeah.
Adam: We’re not interested in even doing that step. It’s so funny because it also warrants that step. Right. And Bill’s just sort of like, well, Ed, you know how girls are. They get the hormones and the…
Devin: He’s just having a cocktail at home, getting wasted.
Adam: He’s so good-natured and… Oh, it’s so funny.
Devin: Gives him a straw to drink his whiskey. Here, here, have a straw.
Adam: Here’s my thing. Talk about some guts in your creativity. Most people would have probably told you this is the most insane and maybe even stupid movie you could attempt to make. Anybody but Tim Burton, they would have thought that. Right. It’s so far out there, maybe it will completely tank. Right. And he just… He and Caroline Thompson built that story and she wrote the script. And he just executed… It’s so brilliant.
Devin: Mm-hmm.
Adam: It’s just so brilliant. It is. That it’s almost magical that that movie ended up being what it is. Between the music and the script and just him bringing his personal childhood to it. Yeah. And everyone’s association with, you know, trying to find a place to fit in amongst others. It’s so good.
Devin: Yeah. It’s so simple. It’s such a simple story, too. Yeah. It’s always a good place to start, though, I think. Like when… Simple. Just understanding the essence of the story and the theme. The premise. Right. What is the thematic premise? It’s like we’ve all felt like we didn’t fit in somewhere and we’ve done… We’ve gone over the top to fit in. We’ve done things that go best our best judgment to fit in. And then we just finally realize it’s like the grass isn’t greener on the other side.
Adam: I need to accept myself. I am fine. I am cool. I’m grateful I am and stuff like that.
Devin: And if you can start there and then you’re like, well… Instead of just making it an awkward kid, let’s make it a freaking kid that somebody invented that has scissors for hands. And then you can just let your imagination go nuts. And then if you have that through line or that premise, that thematic premise, then you understand kind of that can be your true north.
Adam: Yeah. Your safe… I was thinking your safety line. If you’re climbing a mountainside, you got your little safety line. That… If you can come up with a good… That’s a really great observation, D.
Devin: For episode 50. 50.
Adam: If you have that through line, your story spine, your premise, and you know that’s solid, you can build off of it in any direction you want and you still know you’re attached somehow. There’s a safety net. A lot of… Like we talk about with this section we’re entering right now, ocean, desert, whatever you want to call it, you get lost. But if you can figure out a strong premise, you can play and still stick to this story spine that you have. It’s not easy to find a premise. What we encourage is story that has evolution, growth, change, right? Because if not, your audience is going to get bored, to be honest.
You need a growth or alteration or reversals of a character, an arc, if you will. If you can start with where does this person find themselves as your end result, that’s your climax, and then move backwards, you’ve got this through line. And I know it sounds pretty simple and generic, but that’s how we all… Connect. With what you’re saying with Edward, the whole point is, yeah, we’ve all not fit in at some point in time. That’s a universe… It’s know how to connect with your audience. Find the place where you connect with people. Right. Find that aspect and let your story grow from there.
Devin: Right. Exactly. And then imagine however you want. We’ve talked about it before where character arc for us is kind of a misnomer, where just the visual of an arc, it seems like… Exactly. You start somewhere, you go through an adventure, and you’re the… Same person, but just further down the road, and we thought a lie detector test just makes more sense to us, where you’re actually trying to find your truth. You know, the character is trying to find their truth. And so it makes more sense, but it’s also, it’s about ups and downs and ups and downs, and then at some point, wherever you end up, hopefully your character is at a different place, and they’re a different person, and they’re a better person, hopefully, you know, depending.
So that’s, it just makes more sense when it’s, there’s going to be ups, there’s going to be downs, but when they do finish the story, they are a different person, whether they’re a different person going back to the same place and making that, that, that travel home or that known world is going to just look or feel different, or they completely save and change that known world too. And that’s, so they’re a different person within that world.
Adam: The reason why the arc doesn’t quite work for me is when you cross these thresholds, they’re like entering another dimension of experience. For themselves, each new stage of their development, they become something different. And it’s not necessarily going up, it’s going up and down and up and down. It flows more like what you’re saying. The lie detector was a really good analogy because it’s going up and down in search of truth. That’s a really great way of talking about the visual. For episode 50, I’m going to keep saying it because episode 50!
As always, we encourage you to write three pages. Think of a watering hole scene, no matter what story you’ve got, find that communal space. It can even be in an office building, the break room, something simple, write a scene, three pages, just play with it. It can be a free write. If you focus it, it can be part of the story you’re working on. If you do these three page free writes per episode, by the end of this season, you will have a rough draft. So no excuses. If you want to be a writer, be a writer. It doesn’t have to be perfect, it just has to exist. Put it on the page. Put it on the page and then fix it.
Devin: Be a storyteller and not a story keeper.
Adam: Boom! Talk about an episode 50.
Devin: Boom, boom.
Adam: That’s our first episode title, Story Keepers! Oh, bookend! That’s right. See how Devin’s good with setups and payoffs? He’s amazing. Thanks for listening. Thanks for watching. Thanks for tuning in with us for 50 episodes. Here’s to 50 more.
Devin: Love ya. I love ya. Always have. Always will.
Adam: Please subscribe and rate us on iTunes. Follow us on social media, share with your friends, and send us your questions and comments. For additional resources and links to films, series, and books we talk about here, visit our website. While you’re there, sign up for our newsletter for updates on story building tools and special offers. At StoryOsophy.com.