Show notes
You finished a draft. Celebrate, then get it ready for readers. Adam and Devin split the last stage into two passes. Polishing is reworking scenes and the rhythm of the piece. Wordsmithing is the nuts-and-bolts language pass: word choice, grammar, punctuation and how the words sit on the page. You’re not done writing yet; this is where a lot of the fun is.
In this episode
- Step back from the tree. Devin compares polishing to decorating a Christmas tree: step back, look for holes, spread out the one strand of blinking lights, and come back later with fresh eyes.
- Mark it in red. Read the draft through first and highlight anything that doesn’t feel right, even if you don’t know why yet.
- Push dialogue into subtext. A first draft where characters say exactly what they mean tells you their motivation. Now rewrite it the way people really talk: through implication and suggestion.
- Write it the way it plays. An action scene should be terse, with lots of white space; an intimate scene can be more languid. A screenplay for readers isn’t a shooting script, and “I’ll fix it in post” isn’t an answer to feedback.
- Quick fixes for scenes that don’t work. Turn a cliché slightly to the side. Change one ingredient, like a third person eavesdropping at the end of the bar. Run the three O’s from the antagonist’s side, or ask every character where their head is and what they want.
- Use movements to diagnose. Gray out the movements that already work and focus on the rest. Each movement’s three O’s should differ from the last; the story has to move.
- Don’t fear the cut, or perfection. Your untouched first draft is saved. Devin remembers Bob Ross turning a blotch into a sky. Write somewhere between “for your mother” and “for a studio executive.”
- Page count is a guide. Devin cites Stephen Follows’ study of 761 scripts: a 100-page script ran anywhere from 80 to 120 minutes. Adam writes one page per minute of screen time.
- Wordsmithing tips. Vary repeated words, keep action blocks to two to four lines, pull orphaned words back up a line, turn “is walking” into “walks,” and use sound words to cue the sound designer. Grammar and punctuation errors can get a script set aside.
Examples discussed
- There Will Be Blood: Devin recommends reading Paul Thomas Anderson’s script while watching the film; it matches nearly minute for minute.
- Also: Gilmore Girls’ fast-talking page count, and a writer, maybe Alexandre Dumas, who burned first drafts and rewrote from memory.
Writing along with the season? Read your draft start to finish, mark what doesn’t work in red, then gray out the movements that do.
Read the full transcript
Transcribed automatically, so expect the odd misheard word. Sponsor messages are left out.
Adam: In this episode, we’re talking about polishing and wordsmithing your script. Oh, no. What do you do to diagnose and improve your scenes? Why is wordsmithing, grammar, and punctuation so important? Next on StoryOsophy. Hello. Welcome to StoryOsophy. This is Adam Jones.
Devin: And Devin Halden. H-A-L-D-E-N. Holden. Well done. Sorry, I’ve been having to do that quite a bit on the phone. What’s your name? Devin Halden. Spell that, please. Actually, here’s my, here’s my favorite, here’s my favorite thing, though. I understand if I say my name, like I’m over the phone with somebody. And for the very first time, they’re hearing my name. I’m like, hey, my name is Devin Halden. And they’re like, they don’t, they don’t get it. So they kind of mispronounce it. Here’s what I don’t understand. This, I just got one the other day. I wrote an email to somebody and close it with, you know, thanks in advance or whatever.
Sincerely, Devin Halden. And their reply is, hey, David. I’m like, I understand if you hear something wrong. But you live. But you literally, you literally completely screwed my name up.
Adam: Good customer service. I just had a run in with an online company. I was trying, they charged me for something wrong. And I’m trying to talk to this one customer service representative. And this guy is literally the least helpful customer service representative I’ve ever worked with. Like, he keeps, he’s, he’s terrible for this company. Like, the one thing he did that was bizarre to me is, recently, I paid for a service that as soon as I paid for it, the company told me I couldn’t access a certain part of the feature of the software. But it’s why I purchased the thing to begin with. So I purchased the thing and now I can’t use it.
So I was bringing this up to him and saying, well, either allow me to use the service properly or refund the thing. Like, it’s sort of dumb. And he’s like, are you requesting to delete your account? No. Why are you the most unhelpful and passive-aggressive? You’re asking me if I want to leave before you’ve even tried to solve the problem.
Devin: That exact thing happened to me. But I lost, like, all of the, every service I had. Dude just, like, completely eliminated my existence with that company.
Adam: Yeah, this guy, this guy finally, he sent me that email. And I just wrote, I wrote something simple back. Like, I have never once mentioned deleting my account. Thank you for your time. I’m going to find someone else to help me. Oh, my God, it’s frustrating.
Devin: It’s so frustrating.
Adam: You’re in customer service. Why are you, like, if you’re that miserable, get out. Like, don’t, you’re slapping customers like an idiot. For what purpose? For what purpose, dude? Here we go. I’m bringing us right back in. This week, we’re talking about polishing and wordsmithing. These are the two most important parts of finishing a draft. We haven’t put out an episode in a little while. It’s been sort of a chaotic year, chaos being the key word for 2020. But we did want to make sure that those of you who took the time to write your drafts while in quarantine, have some ways of fixing those. That was me clapping, by the way. Oh, yes. I wasn’t, I was a little nervous. I didn’t want that to be construed as something else. I was a little nervous for a second. I’m like, Devin, we’re on the air.
Yes, it is worth celebrating if you have finished a draft, even if it’s a rough draft, even if it’s a terrible draft. It’s worth celebrating. And this episode is the one you want to listen to. To refine that hunk of junk.
Devin: Oh.
Adam: If it’s rough in places, this is the episode to listen to, to fix it up. It’s not a hunk of junk. I’m just kidding.
Devin: Yeah, I wouldn’t say that.
Adam: So, to differentiate between them, just for a moment. Polishing, I would say, is reworking scenes. It’s refining the rhythm of the piece. Larger chunks, if you will. And the wordsmithing part is just, it’s more like nuts and bolts fine-tuning. Let’s say there’s a joke that you put in there, and you know what the joke should sort of be, but the joke you wrote in is not as funny as you want it to be. That’s a placeholder or a bookmark joke, right? And oftentimes, I’ll put that stuff in red if I know I want to change something when I go back, so that it brings my attention to it.
Yep. A lot of it is that.
Devin: I do that with every piece of dialogue, because I’m terrible at writing dialogue. So, I’m like, all right, well, you got to bring this into the subtextual world a little bit more, rather than exactly what they’re saying.
Adam: That’s a really big point for this episode, too, is this draft you just have written, if it’s anything like mine, it’s super textual. Not subtextual, super textual. Meaning, everything the characters are thinking and feeling is they just… You got to say it. It’s not very artfully done. It’s a first draft. But, as Devin’s saying, you can take that… It’s all in red. All the dialogue’s in… So, you just take it, and you push down… Examine it like this. How you would interact with a person in real life. Chances are, you’re not very open with your emotions. If you are, good for you. You communicate clearly. But, a lot of people…
They communicate in weird ways, whether it’s a fear of this, or shamed about that, or guilty about this, or just socially not fitting in or feeling awkward. You don’t often say what you mean. So, for a first draft, if you can get the characters to say what they mean, now you know their motivation, which is awesome. That’s a great tool to be equipped with. So, you can go back in a scene where they state everything out loud and go, well, they wouldn’t necessarily say this. To this person at this point in the story, what would I say? What would someone that I’m talking to say? In that realm of believability where they want to say it. It’s just under the surface. They’re implying it, suggesting it.
Those kind of things. Implication and suggestion are great ways to think of how to write subtext. Because the intention is there. With those two modes. But the art form is not saying it outright. And so, a lot of that stuff is between first draft and beyond, second draft, and even further. You get those… Subtext is going to be what happens here. This is where you get to invent it. So, you’re not done writing. It may seem like it, but the polish and wordsmithing stage, you’re still writing. You’re actually refining. There’s some fun stuff to do here.
Devin: I just had a little panic attack because I was like, wait a minute, did I really hit record on this? Or did I think I hit record? I don’t know. I’m pretty sure I’m recording. If not, 2020, right? Who cares? I was going to give it a bit of a holiday analogy. So I was thinking about polishing scripts and I liken it to putting up your Christmas tree. Bear with me. So you’ve spent all afternoon decorating your Christmas tree, right? And you think you’ve added the right amount of lights and you’ve put the ornaments that you like in the front spaced out perfectly and then the funky ones that Aunt Bonnie sent you towards the back, the part where you push into the corner. And then before you put that star on the tree though, you want to take a step back and get it a good…
Good view of the tree as a whole. And what you’re doing is looking for holes in the tree where you might have to put more ornaments or adjust branches or if some of the, that one strand of blinking lights that you decided to put on, because there’s only, it’s usually just one strand that you have or that still works from last year. So it’s like, well, screw it. I’m going to try to put it on there. But then you end up having, it’s like just the top of the tree is blinking. Now, or just the bottom of the tree is blinking now. So you’re like, crap, I got to spread this out a little bit. And you’re trying to, trying to give your tree a little balance and, and then you might even completely leave the room and leave the room for hours and just kind of let it go. You were, you’ve, you’ve had your nose stuck in the tree this entire time and you just want to give it, give it some rest and you want to come back to it with a fresh look.
Really feel the fruits of your labor, you know, get, get a good, get a good view of it with a, and come back with a more critical eye. So with polishing a script, it’s kind of like that. You’re kind of stepping back. And a lot of times we’ve talked about it before in the, on the show that a good thing to do, if you’re getting frustrated with the scene or you’re getting frustrated with just the process overall, you’re overwhelmed. The best thing to do is get away from it. Go for a walk, leave it alone for a week. Just, just give it some time so your creative juices can start flowing again by being sparked in different, by different things that you’re, that you’re experiencing.
Adam: And also take that moment when you walk away to sort of put a little wish or intention out there that’s like, while I’m stepping away, I don’t really want to think about it. I want the environment around me and the people I interact with to sort of give me solutions.
Devin: Exactly. Yeah.
Adam: Do it like that too. You’re also freeing yourself up from wrestling with stuff and writer’s block and all that jazz. You’re literally allowing your entire environment to contribute to ideas that would fix the problem. So when you step away, I don’t mean to interrupt them, but when you step away from the work like that, give that intention and the return to the work
Devin: Will be awesome. Right. It’ll be exciting. Yeah. And you’ll be able to find those holes and make sure your setups have payoffs and all of the juicy scenes that you wrote, when you’ve given it some time to come back to it, or even if you just decide to read it for the first time from In front of… From beginning to end, because a lot of times we’ll just go back a couple scenes and then we’ll read into it just to see the flow. And you get anybody who’s tried to sit down and write a novel or a script or even an important email. You have to give it, you, you want to give it time before you hit send or you call it a day because you’re so involved and you’re so close to what you’re writing. A lot of times you’ll screw up.
Adam: Well, you separate it too with, you want to get the information out, whether it’s creative imagination stuff or the, the communication you want to give. And then you want to have time to execute that better. So you’re just getting the ideas down and then refining that is, is those two stages are always going to benefit you no matter what you do, because it gives you perspective too. You’re not, if, especially if you’re writing an email and you’re upset about something, it’s going to give you emotional distance. So you go, you can write something and you’re really angry and look at the email again and be like, Oh man, I sound really angry.
Oh man. So you, you know, then you can rewrite it and go, let me, let me fix this so that I’m actually not being, you know, I can retone it. I can re rewrite the emotional angle of it. And the same thing with a script, mind you, you know, if you’re, if you’re in the mode of like, this is always great too. And when you’re writing those emails and stuff, when you’re really upset about something, right. A scene. Just write a scene. Argue it out with two fictitious characters. And now you’ve got raw emotional energy that an actor can play with. That’s like their potions, their wizard potions.
You know what I mean? They’re working with magic stuff. That’s what they use. Right. And so once you get it down, then you can go back like the next day, a week later, and refine the structure of a scene.
Devin: Mm-hmm.
Adam: But the meat of the emotional end of it is there already. That’s you just puking stuff on a page and then shaping it later. Whenever you’re emotional, rather than lashing out at someone, write a scene. Seriously. It’ll give you perspective because you have to think like the other person, you know?
Devin: And this is also the, in this stage, you’ll actually be able to remember how you were feeling the day that you wrote certain scenes. Right. Because it’ll probably scream out the page at you if you’re in a bad mood that day. Yeah. And you start, and you were writing. So you can, those are things too that you, you either want to, well, you want to polish. That’s what we call it. You want to polish it so it may not seem, so it matches the tone and the emotion that you’re trying to pull out of the story and not necessarily have it, have the story influenced by how you were feeling that day specifically.
But use that. Use that emotion, like Adam’s saying, to, if there’s a very complicated. Paint with that color when you can paint with the color. Exactly. Grab it. And Story Blueprint, our software, it really helps perfectly for doing everything we’re talking about as far as polishing. Oh, it’s primed for that. It’s really a checks and balances of, are all my setups paid off? How are my events, the pacing of everything is there and the theme and the tone and my settings? Am I, is it? Is everything that I want in the story being conveyed the way that I want it to be conveyed? And if you’re not, even if you’re not using our software, at least have a checklist or a checks and balance that you can, that you’ve come up with that helps you when you’re sitting down during this polishing phase to make sure that you’re, like you said, like we’re saying, like the, like all your setups are being paid off and the feeling and the emotion of the story is coming, is being conveyed to you.
Is it, is it where you want it to be? When you set out to write the story, is this, or as it’s changed throughout the writing process, is it where you want it to be when you actually put somebody’s name on a, on an envelope to send it to them to get their feedback? And remember, we want anyone who reads our story to feel the emotions we intend them to feel at the moments we want them to feel.
Adam: Yeah. Not arbitrary sort of. The floppiness in the writing and emotion. Yeah. That’s a good point. You want it to be specific. You want to orchestrate their emotions, not the other, not arbitrarily. Yeah.
Devin: And so when they, when they’re reading your screenplay or your novel, the movie should be playing in their heads. It should be playing in their minds and their imagination. And they should feel, they should feel tense and uncomfortable during that, that pressure cooker scene that you create, that you wrote, or they should be feeling sad or emotional when, when you decide that, that beloved character that they’ve fallen in love with has, you decide to kill them all or they should be happy and elated when, when our hero achieves what she set out to achieve, you know, in the beginning. And so those are, those are things that you’re trying to make sure during this, during this polish, if you need to beef up something to make that last scene have more of a punch or more emotion or more elation, the audience feels like, oh my, it was almost impossible for them to achieve this.
I can’t like, those are the things that you’re kind of trying to pull. Pull out here and trying to polish.
Adam: Also in those big, big moments in the end, you’ll notice that if I’ve got all this at the end, this big moment, I can now look at like earlier in the draft, like the Movement 2 stuff, like early Act 2 things and reduce them is a good way to put it. Just, just, they don’t need as much time or information. They’re just setups. Now that you have all the explanation at the end, now that you’ve gotten there. You’re like, oh, I don’t need that much explanation in the beginning about this. I just need to set up properly or vice versa. You get to the end. You’re like, oh, I didn’t set that up at all.
I need to go back to Movement 2, early time in the script and the story and support that a little more with some retro development and foreshadowing when it comes to screenwriting in particular. And this is a note specifically for screenwriting because storytelling is a little different in terms of like novel. But it’s screenwriting. Screenwriting is a blend of prose and poetry. Prose like narrative description you would find in a novel and poetry like you don’t necessarily need to obey the laws of grammar in a screenplay. That’s kind of why I like writing it. You can write a one word sentence fragment. You can even, I write a lot in sound effects too, just to let, and I mentioned this in wordsmithing later because it’s a big wordsmithing thing I do.
You can describe things with sounds, onomatopoeic sounds and go, this is what this door sounded like. Yeah. You can do all kinds of fun stuff in screenwriting land. And you’re also wanting to see if what you put on the page, is it what the person is reading? Meaning what you intended, is it what they’re getting?
Devin: Yeah.
Adam: In a lot of that, the way that a person reads a screenplay should be the way they experience it on screen. Right. So, if it’s action-oriented, it should be terse and much more white space on the page. You know what I mean? Like, bang, and then he turns, and this. Right. Quick, succinct moments. Whereas if it’s more, you can think of it like music, too. If it’s more ballady, if it’s a longer language scene that’s romantic, or two people having an intimate conversation, Right. You can reveal. Those scenes, you can do more paced, and the language can be longer, or more novel-like. And so, the beautiful thing about screenwriting is that.
It’s going, here’s a scene, with the language I’m using and the way I’m using it, here’s how the scene plays. And so, you can also take, when you’re polishing the thing, see how you’ve written it. You may have just written it matter-of-factly down. Mm-hmm. Here’s what happens in this scene. You can then add a flavor to it. Mm-hmm. What’s the tone of the scene? Let me rewrite the scene by writing it the way it feels now. Instead of just the information, because that’s what was coming to me when I first thought of the scene, was, oh, this matter-of-fact. He moves over here, he opens the door, and on the other side is, well, make it flavorful. You know? Now you can go back and.
Yeah. And remember, this is specific to screenwriters, to not confuse. Yeah. You know? Yeah.
Devin: Yeah. And it’s important for a screenwriters to not confuse your screenplay that you’re sending out for feedback you want people to experience with a shooting script. So a shooting script is just. Or a director’s notes for that matter. Yeah. That’s a production tool that will just break your, that breaks the screenplay down into shots and provides notes, and those notes shouldn’t be in the screenplay, that’ll just distract them. So the screenplay should read and they should experience, I guess the main word is experience it. Yeah. The way that you intend it to be played on the screen, because I’ve read, Adam and I both worked with screenwriters that when they receive the feedback, they say, don’t worry, I will take care of that in post, or we’ll take that when we shoot, when we’re shooting it.
And if you’re getting that feedback from anybody, fix your screenplay. If someone gives you feedback that part of your story doesn’t make sense, then it will most likely bump for others, including a producer, if that’s where your screenplay gets to, and the don’t worry, I’ll fix it on set or while we’re shooting it or in post, that response is certainly not going to be an acceptable answer for a studio or a producer or a line producer. Anybody who’s trying to break down your script to budget it or figure out pacing, like a director who wants to make sure it’s pacing or a studio who’s going to want to make sure it’s in the confines of.
Of commercial acceptability as far as their standards go.
Everything, those are things that need to be taken care of and not just saying, no, I’ll take care of that later. Whether that’s in your screenplay or it’s in a shooting script or director’s notes or whatever, those things should be, your audience should, whoever’s reading it is your audience. And your audience should be able to experience it the way that you intend an audience to experience it on the screen from a screenplay standpoint.
Adam: You want to think of it like this, too. As far as the information you want to provide. And this is maybe sort of next level, but you want to think about this. The screenplay is like writing a score for the various instruments of filmmaking, the various departments. So directing, acting, visual audio, production design, costume, props, stunts, all these different departments are going to have to take that script, this piece of music you’ve written, and pull out of it what they’re supposed to play, going with that analogy. So a masterful writer, a writer who’s… In command of their craft, they’ll put just enough in their work, maybe using one or two words even, to suggest to another creative in charge of some department, of those, you know, departments mentioned, what sandbox they explore, what tone they explore, you know?
And so you can write tersely for people to understand what you want to get from that. Now that may come later in the game it’s not something that we’re suggesting you get a handle on for the first polishing run. If anything, here’s a handful of things I would suggest to sort of focus on. When you’re polishing to keep in your mind, as Devin said earlier about the red, everything in red, if you have something when you’re reading through the script, before you play with it, give it a read-through first, and then just mark stuff in red, like change it to a different color or highlight it or whatever, stuff that doesn’t feel right.
You may not even know what the problem is, but go, I don’t know what I, I don’t know why I don’t like this. Highlight it. So when you go back through to polish, you know the areas to focus on. One of the ways to do it is to, you can sort of measure out with our movements is a great way to sort of see if you’ve got a decent pacing. Because you may find that what you call movement one is like 30 pages. So it means you’ve sort of inflated events. You want to keep the beginning of your story, no matter what, very short and sweet. Catch them, and then expand as you go throughout the rest of the story.
So if your beginning’s really inflated, you know what you’re doing. You know you need to cut back, right? So use the measurement tool, the diagnostic measurement tool that we have talked about throughout the season for movements. Keep it like, if you’re doing a feature film, keep them within like 15 minutes, give or take. And you’ll have a 90-minute piece. But you’ll also have a good rhythm of, as simple as it sounds, stuff seems to be happening in your story. Movement seems to be happening. The chain of events is actually connected and moving. You know, it’s a moving entity. If things aren’t working, like some of the red areas you find, if you’re like, oh, that feels like a cliché, I’ve seen that before, or I stole that from this movie or that thing, or it’s a bad idea, or not your best idea, just turn it a little bit.
You don’t have to reinvent the wheel here. You can literally just turn that idea slightly to the side and look at it from a slightly different angle, and then put that down. Because it’s enough of a change in the thing that you’ve killed the cliché for the person who’s going to be reading it or watching it. That’s a nice little trick for, oh, I’ve seen this before. What do I do? Well, add something inventive that you haven’t seen to that cliché. And suddenly it becomes invented. That’s a good way to fix clichés. Also, another thing I would say that’s a really quick, easy fix is if a scene’s not working, change one ingredient.
A good example is, let’s say, two people having a conversation. Simple scene. Now, add a third person whose eavesdropping at the end of the bar. Now, that whole scene suddenly has just gone tremendously upward in intrigue. You’ve elevated that scene from two people talking and giving you information to a third person trying to extract something from the information they’re exchanging. Now, it may not work in your screen. But if you think that way, you know, what if I added one of the other characters I have in my script to this scene? Does that detract or enhance what this scene is? So if your scene’s dragging, just question the, you know, try out different solutions like that.
Let me add this character. No, that’s a dumb idea. Let me try this one. Oh, wait. They actually have something really important to say here. So when you start playing with parts in the polishing phase like this for scenes that don’t work, your scene’s in red, you open up all these brand new doorways to write the scene almost from a fresh perspective. And you’ll get something from it. You know, you’ll discover something. And all of a sudden, that’s going to be your favorite new scene. Right. So don’t be afraid of the ones that don’t work. Just be honest with yourself when you’re reading through the first time and go, I don’t know why I don’t.
Devin and I do it all the time. We’ll read through something and be like, there’s something wrong with this exchange between these people. There’s something wrong with this scene. We don’t know what it is yet. So we put the best version that we can of that scene. But we mark it in red and go back and fix it. But those are some minor ways to fix the scene quickly or at least to play with it.
Devin: Or change the perspective of the scene that we’ve talked about before, too, where it’s a mystery, dramatic. The three O’s of that scene. You’re using it. What’s the hero’s objective of the scene? There are obstacles. Clearly, the person that they’re, let’s say it’s the antagonist that they’re fighting. The antagonist that they’ve been confronted with. And what is the outcome that we want the hero to have? Well, if we’re getting stuck with it, let’s switch over to what’s the antagonist, what’s their obstacle? What’s their objective? The hero is their obstacle. What outcome do they want to achieve? And it might open up some other questions or creative doors for you.
Adam: And you could do that with all of your characters in the scene and characters who aren’t in the scene. Not just your hero and antagonist, but every character. Where is their head at? And what do they want? You ask those two questions about every character in a scene, even the ones who are peripherally like, let’s say, off screen. You’ll fix your stuff. And even when you come up with these choices, when you’re looking at what do I do, always take the left turn. People want to be surprised. Don’t take the right turn. Don’t take the easy turn. Take the one that veers out into traffic. No.
Take that one. Because that’s the one that’s going to fail. And that’s the one that’s going to fascinate the audience the most is the path least taken. Word.
[Sponsor message]
Adam: It’s good to examine your character’s motivations by movement, and measure your setups and payoffs through movements. When you’re reading, get a sense of when you’ve indicated for the first time something about a character or a setup that needs to be paid off. And also, don’t be afraid to cut stuff. Don’t be afraid to go, you know what? I can say this in two lines, and this scene is super tight and amazing. Well, don’t keep going. Don’t feel like because you wrote two more pages, those pages are so damn precious, you can’t cut them. Because you might be making a mistake by thinking your writing is too precious.
Devin: For me, that’s the fun of the polish part of the process, is looking at, is being first, you’ve, by this point, you’re proud that you’ve actually completed. Writing something. You’re like, holy crap, this is really great. I did it! It is great. And so, part of you is like, I don’t want to break it. You know, you’re like, the minute you go back into it.
Adam: Yeah, you got a computer, that’s why you say first draft, untouched. That’s what that’s called. Then you can always go back and revert if you need to. Shakespeare and even early typewriter folks, they didn’t have that. You got a computer, so don’t fret too much.
Devin: You can save a backup. It reminded me, and I think I talked about this before on the podcast, is like I remember as a kid watching Bob Ross when he would paint on like Channel 2 or PBS or something like that. I can’t remember what channel he would actually have his painting show on. I would see him start with a blank canvas. It would be like an hour-long show, and I remember like 50 times going through it. Oh my god, I would stop right there. That looks so good. Like, I would be so proud of that. And I’m like, why are you throwing more paint on there?
And then he’d throw this blue blotch of crap on there. I’m like, what are you doing? You just ruined it. And then he’d turn that into a beautiful sky. And then you’d throw something else on a bunch of green, and I’m like, oh, you just ruined it. And all of a sudden, you’d turn it into a beautiful forest. And I’m like, and so
Adam: Getting over the fear of ruining what you… And with him, he didn’t have… He had the confidence. He couldn’t save the first draft. He was literally… He could have really screwed it up. Having the confidence to… Even if you do screw up, if you’re like, ah, shoot, I completely… I have deleted entire scenes accidentally on my computer and wanted to die. I know where you’re going with this. Because it was awful. And the only thing I can say is, I had to rewrite the idea of the scene, because it was so good, I didn’t want to let it go. But what I did was, and I think it was Alexander Dumas, I don’t remember what writer it was, but they used to write a first draft and then throw it in the fire, and then write…
The second draft without the reference. And it’s because you’ve already got the gist of it. So now you can really write the thing. Now you can write it with craft and confidence. You know it. And so, that’s part of the thing that Bob Ross has, is he has the confidence of being just a brilliant painter. So even if he does drop a drip of paint on the painting accidentally, he can turn that into a freaking mountain. It doesn’t matter to Bob Ross. And so, just… Know that practice, like Devin’s saying, it’s a good point. What you’re saying is, you know, the practice is what allows you to be confident enough to realize that there’s no such thing as a mistake.
Because you can always change and explore and turn that into something even better.
Devin: Right.
Adam: It’s the place for, this is the place for expression and experimentation.
Devin: The other thing to keep in mind as well is, while we’re talking about polishing it and fixing things, eliminate the word perfection from your psyche and your vocabulary. Especially in draft one. I say throughout the entire process, because you can literally handicap yourself into that script, never seeing the light of day because you are trying to make it perfect. And perfect is just, it’s not. It’s not a thing.
Adam: You paralyze yourself. Ask yourself, perfect for who? Because I guarantee you it’s not for you. It’s somebody else’s voice in your head telling you they’re going to judge you if you don’t get the thing right. It’s not your voice. Your voice is excited about the imagination you’re swirling around and putting on the page. You’ve allowed some editor voice, someone else who, you know, it could be a parent, it could be a boss, it could be a bully, it could be anybody. But don’t allow that editor voice to come.
Devin: I would stay somewhere between you’re writing it for your mother and you’re writing it for a studio executive. Because your mother’s going to accept anything and she’s going to be like, this is the greatest thing I’ve ever read in my life. So you just want to be above that because you know what you’re going to get from her. And then a studio executive thinks they’re looking for something perfect, perfection. So stay somewhere between that.
Adam: When you’re dealing with anything, there’s two poles to it. It’s like a seesaw with a fulcrum bar in the middle of it. Right? You tip too far in one direction and you’re going to falter. Right? You want that balance right in the middle of everything in your script. And if you can find that, because every topic is two topics. The idea of confidence on one side is self-deprecation, on the other side is arrogance. And then in the middle is confidence, that fulcrum bar. Every topic is like that. There’s the two extremes, the two poles, and the moderation, the balance of it. Right? The alignment of it, if you will.
And so that’s sort of the idea with that. It’s like the studio executive couldn’t give a shit about your work. Really. I mean, they just want the next big hit. And your mom thinks it’s like, this is my boy. In terms of polishing, it actually is a fun time in the writing process. And don’t dread it. Don’t be like, oh my gosh, I’m going to go back and try to fix all this. There’s many things you should look at and look over and enjoy doing. But the big one is your setups and payoffs. Are your characters motivated? Do they have a distinct desire and a result in that arc, the pursuit?
Like we said, what they want and what they really want. We talked about that earlier in the podcast. Also, you want to look at objective obstacle outcome, Devin’s three O’s. You want to do that as you’re tracking through. And here’s the thing. If you’re using the movement, if you’re using Story Blueprint and the movement process, you’ll be able to microscopically zoom in and go, now for the first 15 minutes, does this work? And you track through it and you ask these questions and figure your stuff out. If it does work, you just sort of out of sight, out of mind that. Gray that section out and go, it does work.
So now you only have, if you’re doing six movements, five movements to fix, polish, or work on. Now, let’s say you’re pretty confident about your climax and you go over to the end and movement six. And you go, okay. I have all these things, you know, movement five and six, the climax and the ending. This looks pretty good. So gray those out. Now, when you’re polishing, you only have to look at movements two through four. So find the ones that you know work and check them off the list. And then you won’t feel so overwhelmed with what do I have to fix and how am I going to fix it?
Now, the fixes in those other sections, which you may have made red, you know, or may have marked for you. So they may reverberate throughout the other things. And you may have to, you know, go back in and fix movement one or movement six or whatever, but try to go about figuring out what you’ve, what, like, I do use green and red stickers in terms of, like, if it’s green, it means I’ve done, it’s go, it’s good. If it’s red, it means it’s a scene or an event I have to work on still. But you can work non-linearly on these things now that you have a linear layout.
Use the movements to your advantage because they’re helpful in diagnosing where you’re, it’s too swollen, your story, or it’s too lean.
Devin: Yeah. And that’s the, I mean, that’s the, the real benefit of structuring your story either before, preferably before you actually dive into start scripting or, or writing your novel, but is also beneficial while, if you, if you dive into, to writing and with prior to, to structuring something or even a brief structure. And you get stuck. When you get stuck. Yeah. Then you’re able to go back and, and all right. And, and that’s with, like, the three O’s is really good for. Whether it’s scenes or movements or acts. What’s the objective obstacle outcome of, of my entire story? I always start with the entire story. What’s the objective obstacle outcome of the entire story?
If, if you’re just writing as a, as a, in a three act structure way, then you do it for each act as act one. What’s the objective obstacle and outcome of act one, the objective obstacle outcome of act two and objective obstacle outcome of act three. And if you’re using our, our movement structure, you would do that with each movement and then you can go down into each scene and each scene itself might not have an objective obstacle outcome, but there’ll be a sequence of scenes that might have objective obstacle outcome. And those sequences is probably, it’s kind of a misnomer because they don’t necessarily have to happen sequentially in your script or in your story.
There could be a, a B story going on in between that, whether you’re going back and forth, but there’s, there’s the, there’s some connective tissue with a, with a sequel. The thread. Yeah. Sequential scenes that would have that objective obstacle outcome. And then you can actually go into even more micro. Analysis of your, your characters in each individual scene or your characters throughout a story, not even just your, not just your hero, but, take some time with the sidekick that may not have a ton of screen time, but get to know who he is, in a free write. Yeah, exactly.
Cause then you’re going to know how he, how he responds in certain scenes, whether it’s even just a little quirky comment he’ll make, you’ll know, because you know him so well that you spent some time with him in a free write. I know, I know what he would say even here.
Adam: You won’t even need to figure it out. You’ll be right in a scene and his or her voice will pop in your head saying something. You’ll be like, I don’t know you’re supposed to be in this scene. What the heck are you bothering me for? And all of a sudden you put them in the scene. I can’t even tell you how many times Devin and I have been talking about a scene and a character is not in it or something doesn’t even pertain to it. And all of a sudden it’s so clear that should have been the case all along.
Devin: Yeah.
Adam: The, the, you know, the fabric of the story. It’s like, oh yeah, of course he or she belongs in that scene, you know? Yeah. But what you’re saying is dead on. And I would say this too, make sure between your one scene and the next scene, your objective obstacle outcome is different. Even polarized, let it be up and down, give it some movement to that thing. And, and you can have a movements three O’s sort of reflect and acts three O’s. They can be one in the same, you know? But from one movement to the next movement or from one act to the next act or from one scene or one event to the next scene or event, it should be different.
Don’t have the same three O’s for a scene in a row or an act in a row. That means you haven’t, you haven’t listened to the word movement. That’s what the word movement is there to remind you of is the story has to move. It’s the same. It’s static. You’re, you’re not, you’re not playing with your story enough. You haven’t. Brought your character to and across a threshold of growth and development. That’s what those movements are for. At the end of each, there’s a threshold of change. Now in, in older models like Joseph Campbell’s model, that threshold of change happens in the climax. But what we’re saying is people don’t change instantaneously.
People change a little bit at a time. So if you can track those changes across those thresholds five times before a climax, you, an audience can also mentally go, oh, I see their arc. I get what they’re about, what they’re doing. I get what they’re doing. So, the movements, the reason why we encourage it is, think of it like this too. Your plot is a chain of events. Scene to scene, event to event, act to act, movement to movement. That chain, think of events being linked together. Even if it’s a subplot, it’s still informing the main plot or the theme, if you will. But they can be different chains that come in and out. But if you think of that, they’re not just arbitrary scenes that float around and you don’t know how they work together. Each one interlinks with the one before and after.
So, think of your plot as a chain of events that your character navigates through their emotional states. And it’s a bit of an art form polishing. But there are those things that can happen. The word smithing, it’s kind of like fine-tuned nuts and bolts. It’s a language pass. It’s to make sure that you’re not overusing words because that smells of a novice writer. You didn’t bother to go back through and go, oh, I see I’m using the same word three times in this paragraph. Let me vary it. Let me find something that might be more descriptive. You know, overused words, repeated words. You want to expand and broaden.
The imagery of the language by the words you’ve chosen to create more poetry on the page. Different tones and flavors to spark your reader or audience’s imagination.
Devin: It’s really where the art of writing comes in. You know, it’s like people are very creative. The creativity is really what you’re doing in the polishing stage. And the wordsmithing is the art of… A command of language. Novel and screenwriting, there’s different… There’s a different art form. It’s very…
Adam: Yeah, they’re different animals.
Devin: Different animals to deal with. And the other thing, I didn’t want to make this point, is I think, especially when you start… When you very first start writing screenplays, it’s always hounded in on you. It’s like, keep it at 90 pages or 110 pages, like this page count thing. And it’s not… You can’t really call it a myth because it’s still an important… It’s still a measurement… metric. Right. That if… It’s used by us as writers because it’s helping us figure out pacing. And actors use it to figure out how much screen time they’re going to get. And studios use it to make sure you’re fitting in commercial parameters and boundaries and things like that that they need. So there’s still a reason for it. It’s all about the rhythm. Yeah, the rhythm of it. But don’t get stuck on it. And I’ll give you a resource. I’ll link it in the show notes, but I’ll also link it in social media.
You can’t link it in Instagram, but I’ll give the link in Twitter or something like that. But Stephen Follows did this awesome article back in March talking very succinctly and in detail about this very topic of what page count and how it correlates to writing. And he, in a very brief overview of what it is. It’s a fascinating article and it’s very detailed, but he built this data set of 761 scripts that have all been made into theatrically released movies. And he removed like any cover pages and the total page count ended up being about three or four pages last when he removed some of that other stuff. And to measure the effectiveness of this rule, this page per minute rule, he looked at the ratio of pages to minutes. A 50-page script which becomes a 100-minute movie would have a ratio of 0.5, and a 100-page script for a 100-minute movie would have a ratio of one, so one to one. And a 100-page script which created a 50-minute movie would have a ratio of two, and that would be something like Gilmore Girls, where they write more pages and they just speak really fast. Yeah. What he came up with, with all of this analysis, is that a 100-page script of these 761 scripts that he analyzed that were all theatrically released movies A 100-page script could have had a running time anywhere between 80 and 120 minutes, and that’s a huge margin.
Adam: 20-minute difference in either direction. In either direction. It depends on what other creative parties you bring in who enhance a section or expand or can reduce.
Devin: What it comes down to is that action. And Adam and I, we’ve had this conversation many times. You try to get into this 100 or 110-page pages if you want a 90-minute movie or a little over 90-minute movie. But people write differently. They write the action differently. So I’ve read scripts where if there’s zero dialogue and there’s a ton of action going on, someone will write literally over a page of action. It’s very detailed of what’s going on. And I’ve also read scripts where it just says, a fight scene. It just literally says, a fight breaks out.
Adam: Right. And that’s literally five minutes worth of screen time. But that’s given and handed over to the stunt coordinator to write that part. With the director, with someone else, they’re going to create that on set. I want to comment on what you’re saying, too. Because I think this is really important. It does fluctuate. For me, personally, when I’m writing, because I can only attest to the way I do it or the way I use the words, I write, I use my pages as if they are literal minutes on screen.
Devin: Right.
Adam: However long I want a scene to be is how long it’s on the pages, period.
Devin: And I think that’s a good way to do it.
Adam: It’s a great way to do it for yourself to keep an idea. It’s a great idea of how much time am I spending on this. Now, do I think that the scene is going to end up that way from the page to the screen, ultimately? Well, it depends on if I direct it or not, doesn’t it? Right. You know what I mean?
Devin: How it’s interpreted.
Adam: Yeah. Someone could be like, let’s cut that scene and make it just a visual image. We’ll just dolly in. We’ll cut all the dialogue and push in on those two and embrace. They don’t need to say anything. Right. That’s amazing. Maybe they have a set that literally embodies everything you wanted to write in the dialogue, and they don’t need to say anything. So if you’re interpreting your own work, of course you’re going to put it literally. You’re going to do it literally. That’s why I make the director joke.
But if you’re giving it to someone else, they’re going to interpret it and try to make it the best. Trust that the person who’s going to buy the script and make it, if you’re not that person, wants to elevate the script. Elevate your work. They don’t want to denigrate your work. They don’t want to make it worse. They may want to put, quote, their spin on it, but just hope and believe that their spin is an artistic one that wants to improve or make better the things you might have missed on the page.
Devin: Right.
Adam: And just give them the best tools that you can to inspire their imagination. Like I said, the sheet music for every department. And inspire all of their imaginations to create more and better than you could on that page. That is the gift of a masterful screenwriter. That’s what you want to achieve. You’re writing music for everybody.
Devin: Right.
Adam: And even to that effect, in the wordsmithing category, like, I’ll use comic book words. Boom, bang, clank, crack, plunk, all these different words just to show the sound designer, here’s where I want you to make. You need to find whatever this noise is and make it really juicy. It’s not meant to be like, you know what I mean? It’s a signal to them, in one word, this is your time. It’s like saying, you can say a door creaks open and then write the sound of the way it creaks. Is it long? Is it short? Is it like a… Or is it like a long… You get to paint the picture for them, then they can extract the…
And build beyond that.
Devin: A good script to read or…
To read it while you’re watching the movie is There Will Be Blood. And this is a good example of a screenwriter.
Adam: Talk about geniuses all around.
Devin: Yeah, and I think, I’m pretty sure.
Adam: That visually is one of the most amazingly, that movie’s like 80 hours long, and I thought it was an hour and a half when I was watching it.
Devin: You can literally watch exactly what’s happening on screen while you’re reading it. It is amazing how they stuck, and I don’t know if they stuck to the script, or the script that I got a hold of was the actual whatever.
Adam: Page per minute. It’s measurement. I guarantee you, he’s probably pretty, Paul Thomas Anderson, P.T. Anderson, he’s very organized and very, like there are people who like go out there and like play with the idea, and then there are people who come in and they’re like, this is how it’s going to be, verbatim, punctuation, grammar, everything. And they know what they’re making. P.T. Anderson is one of those guys, for sure.
Devin: And that’s what you’re saying. That’s a good example, too, of what you were just saying, is he wrote the screenplay and he directed it. So his interpretation.
Adam: He knew what he wanted to put on the screen per minute. Yeah, exactly. 100%. But if you can get in that mindset, the screenplays you write for others are still going to be superior, because you’ve taken into account that this is how much it takes for this person to say this line, and to move this. And to do this thing. You’ve imagined the execution of the script, not just like a willy-nilly version of the world. You know, beat by beat, second by second, how much time it takes, your script. And so it does speak to how much you’ve mastered your craft in that regard. So in terms of wordsmithing, there are a whole bunch of nice little tricks that I’ve learned that you can use in your toolbox, keep in your toolbox, like the polishing tips. So I’m just going to run through them real quick, just so you’ve got them, you can jot them down in your notes. The wordsmithing phase of tweaking, writing, rewriting, prepping your draft for sharing with other people, this is really the finessing part. Wordsmithing is nuts and bolts finessing. It’s finessing the way that it is expressed on the page rather than, you know, whether the story events translate and link up and sync up and you’ve got your setups and payoffs, all the stuff you cover in polishing. Once you’ve got that worked out, then you can sort of fine tune the tone, the wordsmithing. You can do them both at the same time, polishing and wordsmithing, but we’re separating them to talk about the nuance of them for this episode. I tend to do them together. Polishing and wordsmithing I tend to do at the same time, just because it’s part of my mode of rewriting at this point. But you do want to look at, again, like polishing, editing, or cutting, even if it’s just a word. You can cut words out here and there and make your dialogue pop, make it move faster. You may have, like we’ve said before, a placeholder dialogue that you may have put the font in red just so you remind yourself, this is not what I want to say. You refine that. You write a better version of the line. And if you can’t think of the better version, just write the one you’ve got. It doesn’t matter. You can fix it later. Someone’s going to tell you, I don’t like this line. I thought he was going to say this instead. Well, all of a sudden, some random reader is going to inform the way you fix that line. So don’t worry about everything. Just try to do your best to refine the pieces that are available to you. You can better a joke.
You may have a joke or gimmick, a line of dialogue that’s a dramatic, punctuating line, and you don’t have it quite right. Well, just make it better. Enhance it. Move some words around. You want to look at the poetry. And the rhythm and the visual layout on the shape of the page, essentially. So the way that your words play on the page visually to the eye should be the way that that minute on screen, if it’s a screenplay, plays out rhythmically. So if it’s an action scene, it should be really terse and abrupt and probably more white on the page than black ink of words, where, as we said before, If it’s a more intimate or romantic scene, you may have more languid language.
A good way to remember anything. Shakespeare: brevity is the soul of wit. You want to keep it short. Most important. The most important information. You want to keep it poignant. Full of substance. And you want to keep it cleverly told. So charming, engaging, tonally, the way you’re telling it. You want to approach your punctuation and look at it. Where does the dialogue pause? You want your punctuation and grammar to be correct because if you’re a reader in a studio system and you’re reading a script, any bit of incorrect grammar or punctuation, these are, these are professional readers. And so they’re looking for that stuff. It indicates that you have not gone back over your, your, script to edit it and refine it and make it and correct it. So even if you have somebody who is an English major, that, you know, if they read your script and you go, look, I’m not really interested in your input on the story. I’m just interested in whether my grammar and my punctuation is correct.
That is a worthy pass because incorrect grammar and punctuation can get your script tossed out. I know it sounds terrible, but that’s the way it is. They don’t have time to deal with unprofessional scripts and so they will put them aside. They’ll start to chalk up the demerit board, the demerit marks on the board. There’s ways of rearranging the way you describe something. Wordsmithing. If you reorganize the words, you get a different sentence or stress or emphasis on the sentence. I couldn’t tell you which one is correct, but the sentence is, the customers waiting in line groan. You could also say, the customers groan, comma, waiting in line. You could also say, waiting in line, comma, the customers groan.
So, although it’s negligible, the difference is not… Great. It just lets you know that whatever you want to emphasize at the end of the sentence, for instance, waiting in line, comma, the customers groan, the thing you leave that idea with is the word groan, right? You can reword things and it has different implications. It also has different rhythms. See how it fits within the paragraph itself. Another thing I would suggest in terms of the structure of your script and the way it looks is, don’t have too big a block of text. For novel writing it’s different. You can do paragraphs. For screenwriting, I generally don’t try to go more than four lines for a block of action.
That’s the most. Generally I do two or three. Sometimes I’ll go as far as like six, but to me, once I get to six actual lines in a script of action, of description, I will break that up into two different blocks of action. Now, the reason I do this is, because it helps to break it up for the eye. It makes it easier to read for people. And also, generally, if you only have one action in six lines of dialogue, it’s overwritten. If you look in it, you’ll notice that it’s either talking about two different characters and what they do, or it’s one bit of action and then a subsequent bit of action. And those can be separated into two blocks. You want to think about just how you would put dialogue down for a character, where it says this character, and then this character says this. You want to treat action the same. If it has to do with that character or that movement or that moment, you go, this character dot, dot, dot, dot, dot does this.
Description of action. And if it goes on for a long time, it means you’re really telling the actor, you’re micromanaging your actor. That’s what that means. Sometimes it’s necessary to describe. Big amounts of action, but usually two or three lines is enough for an actor to understand what they need to perform on the screen. So keep your lines brief in screenplays. Also, keep an eye out for orphans, which is one word on a new line. I’m sure most people out there know what that is. If you can fix it where you remove just one word in the sentence somewhere and turn that orphaned word and bring that orphaned word back to the previous line, you’ve now saved an entire line on a script page, which is a fraction of a minute.
It’s a lot of space. I know this seems like minutiae, but this is the wordsmithing part. Try to reduce it so that you don’t have one word. Of a sentence on a line. That’s a misused amount of space. Like I’ve said before, basic word usage. Don’t use the same word in the same sentence on the same or the next sentence. You want to, you want to vary it a little bit. Character names instead of using a character name, each line use he use, you know, vary it a little bit. Also try to limit in screenplays this type of writing. So-and-so is walking. If you find something like that, just try to change it to so-and-so walks.
So that you are doing a lot of writing out loud. It makes it more active. It also uses up less page, space on the page. I know these sound like minor things, but as Devin will attest, that’s some of the ways that I manage to tweak scenes and make them shorter and more dense, more active, more interesting to read is I just remove all of the extraneous detail. I remove the is from the is walking and just walks. [unclear] Right. Everything reads quicker. Everything reads swifter. Right. Those are my best tips for wordsmithing, for a wordsmithing pass, a language pass. Yeah, with that, have fun going through polishing wordsmithing, playing with your draft. Take some time to really enjoy the accomplishment that you’ve, the thing that you’ve accomplished, this creation, this screenplay, this story, and refine it. This is a fun stage. Bye.
Boom, boom, boom. Big concepts and words, look books even. That’s a, you know, sizzle reels, all that jazz. We’re going to talk about that stuff next week and tell you what you really need to have and what the benefits are of each of those pieces. Until then, happy writing. Bye. Bye.