Season 2, episode 64

Re-choosal of the Quest – Fourth Threshold

Act 2, movement 4: RecoveryThreshold 4: Re-choosal of Quest

October 1, 201950 min

Show notes

The re-choosal of the quest ends Movement 4 and Act 2, crossing the fourth threshold into the climax. After the darkest moment, the fall of the heart wall and the reassessment, your hero rises like a phoenix with a new perspective, and recommits to the quest, or chooses a different one for different reasons. Adam and Devin explain why this is the biggest threshold since the first, how it mirrors the choosal of Movement 1, and why your antagonist is reassessing too.

In this episode

  • The mirror of Movement 1. In Movement 1, your hero accepted the call partly by ignoring their doubts. Now, having faced those doubts, they choose again as a changed person, the Little H hero becoming the Big H Hero.
  • A new quest or a new reason. The re-choosal may be the same goal with a different reasoning, or a different goal altogether, sometimes one the audience should have seen coming.
  • From development to choice. This is the move from the traditional Act 2 into Act 3, from the unknown world into what Adam calls the changed world. Make sure everything the climax needs is set up, and end Act 2 with a bang.
  • Dark doesn’t have to mean heavy. Kermit’s talk with his higher self at the campfire handles self-doubt in a way children can watch. Die Hard compresses Movement 4 into Bruce Willis pulling glass from his feet.
  • The rom-com walk. In a romantic comedy, this is often the hero walking alone in the rain, watching a happy family through a window, and realizing what they really want.
  • Never the same again. Your hero knows they won’t be the same, and neither will their world, even if they go home. Others should sense the change.
  • What’s your antagonist doing? The antagonist is reassessing and planning too. Knowing what they want gives you a stronger climax.
  • A three-part climax ahead. Adam and Devin split the climax into the showdown, the breakthrough at the end of Movement 5, and the now or never at the start of Movement 6.
  • Tangents. Devin’s snoring app, early WWF wrestlers in a St. Cloud armory, and respect for stunt performers and Tom Cruise.

Examples discussed

  • Jumanji: Welcome to the Jungle: Movement 4 runs twice. Alex puts on his sunglasses and says “I’m in,” flying them out of the transportation shed after Martha’s dance fighting distracts the guards. Later, after the riverside scenes, they re-choose the approach to the jaguar. Learning Alex has been trapped for 20 years gives the group a new reason: get him home too.
  • Edward Scissorhands: reassessment, re-choosal and the plan are compressed into Christmas preparations: Bill rolling out fake snow on the roof, and Peg hoping the party will make everything normal again. Edward’s re-choosal is a different quest. He no longer wants to fit in, and he cuts off the clothes he was given in Movement 2. The flashback to the inventor’s gift of hands plays in the middle of his embrace with Kim.
  • Also: The Muppet Movie and Die Hard.

Writing along with the season? Write three pages for your hero’s re-choosal: how is it different from their first choosal? Or take 15 minutes to free-write the coolest re-choosal you can imagine.

Read the full transcript

Transcribed automatically, so expect the odd misheard word. Sponsor messages are left out.

Adam: In this episode, we talk about the story event, Rechoosal of the Quest, Crossing the Fourth Threshold. How does your hero re-engage in their quest or journey? What is the threshold? What are you doing Act 2 and Act 3 really about? Next, on StoryOsophy. Hello. Welcome to StoryOsophy. This is Adam Jones. And Devin Halden. That was a sigh of relief, I think. I don’t know. It’s been a week.

Devin: I’ll just say that. I have a sleeping story, too. So Christine, she insists that I snore. And I get it. Sometimes I do. Sometimes I’ve woken myself up when I snore. It’s just like, it depends on what I’m eating. Like if I’m eating gluten and I get stuffy. I don’t know. If I’m eating gluten and I get stuffy, it is what it is. Or if I have a cocktail, it is what it is. Are you denying it even though she has proof? Yeah. I mean, it’s. But here’s the thing.

Here’s the thing, though. So we were, we were at a cabin a couple weeks ago and she insisted I was snoring. Yet I was awake. No, but I was awake for one of these moments. And I just laid, I laid there and I just was living. That’s all I was doing. I was just breathing. Like, I have to. I have to. I have to do in order to live. Were you nasally? Like. No. Oh, no. It wasn’t even me. I was like not even barely making a peep. And so I go up stairs after and there’s like 20 people in this cabin and clearly I’ve already been thrown under the bus because everybody’s like, oh, how did you sleep?

Did you snore? Whatever. Whatever. And I’m like, well, here’s the thing. I wasn’t snoring. I was living. I was breathing. And she is such a light sleeper that that bothers her. So she got up and left the room. So we got home and there’s this. There’s an app that I found is called Snore Lab. And you basically set up by your phone by your bed stand. You turn on. You just go to sleep and it will like monitor. I’m assuming it’s just picking up the decibels of your snoring, but it will monitor your sorry. And then you get up and they will tell you like, oh, you should try this and this might help because, you know, whatever.

So I did it the other night. I turned it on and woke up and it’s like, oh, you had eight hours of sleep and zero snoring. And I’m like, boom, like bright in her face. Like, there it is. There it is. Like zero snoring. Here’s the other thing. She then turns on her video, pulls up the video she made. And she’s like, no, that app doesn’t work. And I’m like, OK. Still, she over exaggerates. I do a little bit, but she over exaggerates it. So it’s a wash on who’s right and who’s wrong. Yeah.

Yeah.

Adam: Right. Who’s wrong? She listens to these podcasts, Devin. Yeah. Well, you’re stirring the pot again, buddy. That’s fine. Bring it. My father, that guy can clear an entire… So my dad in the military, he snored so loud in a barracks that all of the men picked his cot up and moved him to an entirely separate barracks alone in the middle of the night. That’s how bad my dad snores. That is bad. And he didn’t wake up, so he’s a heavy sleeper. This episode we’re talking about the last story event in movement four and the end of act two rechoosal of the quest And with this event, we will cross the fourth threshold of your story. And this is a really important threshold from not just movement four to movement five, but from act two into act three, which is moving out of your developmental stage into your choosing stage, if you will.

The characters learned enough and now they’re choosing things.

Devin: I feel like we keep, I keep saying this over the last couple events, but this is kind of the commencement of our heroes transformation from little H to big H. Little H to big H.

Adam: Little H to big H. Did you water the tulips? And little H to the big H.

Devin: I feel we’ve, it becomes a little brighter. The story has a little bit more positivity, perhaps. Yeah. When we hit this mark, because. And renewal. Yeah. This also marks, we’ve talked about before, that rise of the Phoenix moment, because, because, again, like our, our, our last two events, Heroes Darkest Moment and Fall of the Heart Wall. And then Reassessment. But certainly the Heroes Darkest Moment. Well, yeah, all three of those. They’re pretty intense internal battles and debates that the, our heroes have. With himself. They’re, they’re hero focused, primarily independent of perhaps the group. If there’s a, if he has allies, because remember we discussed how those two events, but I guess three with Reassessment kind of mark the moment in the story when our hero must go head to head with that, those internal obstacles.

Yeah. And. They must defeat them in order for them to even think about moving forward and taking on or, or trying to defeat the external obstacle or the antagonist. So now with Rechoosal, our hero has done that. Right. So, and they, they have this new perspective about, about, well, everything. So they have this new perspective. They’re emerging from this kind of, and I, I look at it as a dark moment, but of course we kind of threw some examples out where. Heroes Darkest Moment, Fall of the Heart Wall, Reassessment. There, it could be a very quick thing. It doesn’t necessarily have to be this really dark moment where we drag our hero to the depths of despair necessarily. But there’s this, there’s a definite contrast between that moment they were in there where it was perhaps the, that one last time they made, they could have made the decision to quit or give up or die or defeat that in those internal obstacles and then move forward.

Move forward and rise like, rise like the phoenix they are. So they had, they have those new perspectives about everything and, and specifically what they really want. Yeah. So that perspective has changed.

Adam: Even though we call this the Rechoosal of the Quest, here is a place where a lot of times what you’ve built with your hero, they will now choose a different quest. Or if they choose the same quest. A different reasoning for it. It’s like the realization has come from Heroes Darkest Moment and, and Fall of the Heart Wall, which, by the way, Devin, I just wanted to tell you, I didn’t mean to throw Reassessment in there. Your point is more about Heroes Darkest Moment and Fall of the Heart Wall. But Reassessment is that place where it’s almost like structuring the Reassessment event. You zoom way out.

So you’ve had this really intimate experience. With those two events, those two heavy events. And then Reassessment, you sort of zoom out and you sort of look at the broader picture before you reapply in, in this event, the Rechoosal. Or, as we’re saying, the, the approach to what you want or the reason you approach what you want differently. That’s been the revelation of the, the, the epiphany in this movement in particular, especially in the middle of Movement 4. We should probably review for a sec just so you know how, how. Yeah. At least the listeners know how we got here. This movement is from crisis to recovery.

So at the beginning of this movement, you’re escaping and sort of seeking shelter from the crisis, whatever event has gone on in the third threshold, the crisis. And you have some sort of internal introspective moment. And near the end of this movement in Reassessment. And then this story event we’re talking about, Rechoosal. You come out of that introspective thing and reapply what you’ve learned from the reflection there across the previous three movements to how you’re going to approach the climax or the next two movements. And that’s really important because even though your character isn’t fully changed yet, this is something where they recognize they need to, even if they haven’t figured the entire equation out.

Like in Jumanji, which we’ll talk about later in our examples, they don’t get the approach to things right the first time. In this video game environment, they lose lives to figure it out. So just because the character has understood something profound about themselves internally doesn’t mean that they know how to apply it in the continued journey or quest they’re about to reinvest in. Devin. Devin brought up the fact that this is sometimes a much more bright or positive threshold into the climax. And I would say a good example of that, of movement four of this reflection sort of movement is, and I know I’ve talked about this across the previous episodes, but the Muppet movie, the original Muppet movie, Kermit being at the campfire scene with his allies and wandering off because he’s supposed to be the leader.

And he’s failed them in several ways. He doesn’t know how to continue the journey. And so when he wanders off, he’s sort of dealing with self-doubt and failure, but it’s not dragging your audience through the dirt because the version of him that appears to have this fictitious conversation, him talking to himself is like the specter of Kermit’s higher self talking to him. So Kermit. Is the lowest we go Kermit’s feeling of defeat and, and self-doubt and failure in that moment as low as we go, because the counterpoint is this uplifting voice, his own voice. It’s one of my favorite actually of sort of a movement, for example, because you can do it, even though this seems like it’s like, you know, there’s an event called heroes darkest moment, but you don’t have to make it heavy and dark and brutal.

And you can do it that way per that example. And, and once again, it’s the audience is, universal children and adults. So you want to include children. So you don’t want to go too dark. And that one provides an example of look, what’s the, one of the worst things that any person, character, individual creature frog can deal with self-doubt and, and recovery from that. Like, well, how do I do it now? The way I’ve been doing it didn’t quite work out. I need a new plan. I need a new approach. I need to change. Change what I’m doing. Even if you don’t, they don’t change fully within this movement.

They recognize the change through the reassessment event. And now the event we’re in the re-choosal, this is where you, you reinvest in the, in the quest itself. And it can be in line. It can be a piece of dialogue and image. A lot of these, events that we’re talking about moving for a lot of movies will compress them so that movement for is very short and quick. But. We suggest stretching them out a little bit because you can find a lot of gems within this exploration and it will help you to, even if you do keep it short and sweet, backwards develop some of your character arcs, their flaws, their wants and really wants.

Right. So explore this movement, even if it’s short, you know, romantic comedies are probably the, and dramas are probably the ones who extend it the most. Yeah. Most other movies. Most other movies try to keep them real short. The movement for, and die hard is, is Bruce Willis pulling the glass out of his feet in the bathroom. It’s short. It’s one scene and we’re, we’re out of there.

Devin: In rom-coms, it’s always the, that moment when the, our hero is, is alone. Something, something’s happened and they’re really turning internal. They’re introspective. They’re, they’re, they’re just walking about the city, hands in their pocket. It could, it’s probably raining, but they don’t have an umbrella. Like they just don’t care about them. They don’t care that much because of their head, their head is, is elsewhere. And they’re looking in windows and watching, or he’s watching this happy family get along. And he’s like, you know what? That is, that’s what I want. That’s what I threw away. I was so worried about being seen as this eligible bachelor.

I pushed away that one woman who would have given me what I really want. I really want a family. I really want kids. And structure like that, or I don’t know where I’m going, but that’s this, that’s the scene.

Adam: I don’t know where you’re going either, but it touched my heart. Hey, it registered with me. It felt like my story, Devin. I was talking around it. It is your start, but by the way, yeah. Listen, this is the intervention. Right in the middle of the podcast. Sorry, buddy.

Devin: Yeah, let’s talk about this. I guess the only other thing I have to say, and you touched on it, but it’s good to reiterate it just because we’ve been doing a lot of showing how Movement 1 and Movement 4 kind of work together. Our hero in Movement 1 had to decide to accept the call to quest, and that signaled our first threshold. Again, the crossing of that threshold from Movement 1, Movement 2, from the known world into the unknown world. And re-choosal is also a choice that our hero must make, but this time that decision marks a change in our hero. Right. And the threshold crossing signals the movement of our hero.

Hero from little-H hero to big-H hero. Little-H to big-H. Little-H to big-H hero. They’re a real hero now. It puts them on a collision course with our antagonist. This is kind of that mirroring image of the choosal of the call.

Adam: Yeah, for sure. And it’s also like, how does the hero re-engage this quest? So they chose it last time in Movement 1 because either… The mentor has maybe given them some pressure, or there’s another reason. Right. Maybe they didn’t want to do it. There’s a debate involved. And so this choosal is, it’s almost like during the course of this Movement, Movement 4, the crisis to recovery, they revisit that original debate and go, yeah, but I was wrong.

Devin: And they decided in this movement to defeat it rather than they just ignored it in the Movement 1, which was enough to get them… To cross that threshold and move them from known world to unknown world. But once we got to hero’s darkest moment, that option of either ignoring or pushing that feeling or pushing those obstacles down or pushing them away, that was no longer an option because they’re going to either continue to get in the way and ultimately be the demise of our hero and their allies, or the hero must address them and must shine a light on them and not ignore them and give them credence in a way.

Like, you do exist. But now I need to take charge. Like we said, you’re not getting rid of them, those obstacles.

Adam: There is no lack of fear, only the mastery of it.

Devin: Exactly.

Adam: That’s that Mark Twain quote I was saying. It’s really about being willing to confront your need for change or your fear. You don’t have to face your fear every day. You just have to disassemble the fear of it by understanding what it is. And a lot of times that’s what the antagonist is built upon. You know, in a romantic comedy, the real villain of the whole thing is vulnerability. Nobody wants to be vulnerable enough to intimately connect with another person because of previous dot, dot, dot, whatever your character flaw or backstory is. That’s the fall of the heart wall. That’s the hero’s darkest moment kind of stuff in a rom-com because it doesn’t get too terribly heavy.

But the heaviness is in connection, you know, with other people and things like this is a really important threshold. I just want to say that, too, about this. Because it’s a really important threshold. Because it’s not just the threshold from movement four to movement five because we’ve been tracking in these sort of flowing sequential build movements to help the story authors, you guys out there, to build stories that have better structure, that builds and payoffs. This is a really important transitional moment because we’re moving from the traditional act two in the traditional act three of screenplay or a storytelling format. You’re moving out of your developmental.

And so if you haven’t set everything up for your climax, you need to go back and build it. And also, how do you end this act, this movement with the re-choosal, with a bang, with something that pops, with something that is enough of a cliffhanger so that you promise enough for movement three is going to be even better than what you’ve just seen, than what you’ve just read. All right. It’s an important threshold for that purpose because the only other time we’ve had a threshold this big is between act one and act two, from the known world to the unknown world. And then when you get into the end of act two and to move into act three, it’s from that unknown world of exploration of who the character is going to become or what they’re going to experience into the changed world is what I like to sort of refer to act three.

Yeah. It’s when the hero finally applies the transformation they’ve been seeking.

Devin: It’s also an understanding with that our hero has or a there’s a bit of a enlightenment to them. They realize they are never going to be the same, nor is the known world ever going to be the same. So when they even if they go back to. The same place, same time. They took some time warp and were able to come back a minute before they left the story in the known world in the very beginning of the story. It’s going to be a completely, they’re going to be a different person. They’re going to be a different person in the world and the world is going to be different from what they’ve done on the quest. And so this is that moment they’re realizing that. And I think we said it last episode, it’s the butterfly out of the cocoon moment.

Rebirth. There’s a rebirth and we see it as an audience. Our allies see it as this, they’re like, wow, who is this person? Even though they don’t physically have to look different, there just has to be an aura. There’s a new confidence or there’s a new something, depending on your story, but there’s something new about them that you can contrast between now and before Hero’s darkest moment. So that’s kind of the main contrast. Yeah. And it’s also the, the antagonist would also probably realize at some point, not now, but.

Adam: Well, no, the antagonist is really important too, because if you’re exploring their, their end of the story specifically, they’re doing the same thing the hero’s doing, right? So at this point they’re doing reassessment, they’re doing refocus, they’re doing the next event in the beginning of movement five or act three, putting the plan into action. So in Jumanji. That’s going to be Van Pelt sending motorcycle guys to prevent them getting the, the jewel to the Jaguar, right? So when you think of these events, you, it’s a really helpful to go, all right, what about my antagonist too? Let me think about how they’re thinking about this specific event. Oh, I didn’t get the, I didn’t get to kill the heroes in the, you know, that’s their regret and hero’s darkest moment. You know, I didn’t get to kill them.

I got to kill him. So if you think about the antagonist, you’ll start to build a better climax. Because if you’re not, if you’re clear what the hero wants, but not what the antagonist wants, there’s not going to be much of a force of antagonism. And if you start to explore that a little bit, you’ll mine all these details and twists and turns and the reasons why Devin and I, people call the climax a thing. And Devin and I sort of stretched out. We expand our climax into three separate events. Climax one, two, and three. And we do climax one being the showdown face to face with whatever the source or force of antagonism is. And then the threshold of movement five is climax two, the breakthrough. It’s a nice little cliffhanger threshold there in the in the middle of your climax. And then the first event in movement six, the climax part three, is now or never, where your hero makes, implements the change immediately in the now. It’s not just contemplated, it’s executed.

Devin: If you want to win an Academy Award, here at the Hero’s Darkest Moment is where you drag your hero through the dirt. Yep. And you make them come out, this wonderful person on the other side and make it emotional. You want people crying.

Adam: This threshold can be internal or external, can be very intimate for your hero or physically external. You can do it either way. My suggestion would be to do both. Try to create something that shows your audience through action, through in the external physical world, that there’s a threshold, a big change happening. And something that the hero has come from in that the introspective bits of movement for, glue them together, make this threshold specifically, not just the actual. Not just one or the other, but both. Because it’s your act two to act three climax.

Devin: This kind of reminds me of like, WWF moment, at this point of the story, when your hero’s theme song kicks in, and then movement five is them basically walking to the ring, kind of gathering, getting the plan of what they’re going to do once they get in the ring with that antagonist, which is then movement six. Oh, yeah. Yeah, little macho man. That’s what this is. I was just talking, I had this conversation with somebody at an event that I was just at. I went to, I remember going to the St. Cloud, Minnesota VFW, or it was the Armory, whatever. Fold out chairs in an auditorium, and it was WWF.

It was Jake the Snake Roberts, The Rockers, Superfly Jimmy Snuka, all those guys in the armory. There’s probably 500 people there. And I saw them and then it was like, maybe like within a year or two years later, they were on TV and then they were selling out like the Met Center and selling out those stadiums. But yeah, I saw those guys. I was like, those original wrestlers, man, I don’t know how they did it. I don’t know how they got up for that just to go jump around in VFWs. And people still do that.

Adam: Hey man, same thing with stuntmen and women. You’re like, what?

Devin: Yeah.

Adam: They’re like, okay, so you’re supposed to roll down this set of stairs. Got it, cool. And they want to do that.

Devin: And then that guy’s going to get the credit for it. Right. Okay, cool.

Adam: That’s why you always like the stars who bring up their stunt people, especially in like a superhero movie to say, hey, by the way, the reason you like this is because this person’s amazing.

Devin: I will say this though, the minute I see the high fall or something and they fall and there’s something in the foreground, like a couch, or there’s something that they fall behind and then they pop up, I just know what happened. So I’m like, oh, that person was waiting there, popped up. Like the actor popped up after the stunt double fell behind the couch. I’m like, I just know that. That’s why I give mad props to Tom Cruise for the stuff that he does. No kidding. It is incredible.

Adam: People are really critical of him. And I’m like, look, as far as his dedication to storytelling, hats off, man. Standing ovation.

Devin: Yeah. That guy knows how to fall out of a helicopter.

Adam: That guy knows how to jump and break his ankle on a building.

Devin: Yeah.

Adam: Rechoosal of the quest. It’s not a complicated event, but it is an important event. Right. It’s a way for you to focus your heroes, what they really want, what they think they want in the beginning and what they really want now, what really matters to them that they’ve discovered across this movement.

[Sponsor message]

Adam: Jumanji. Welcome to the jungle. As we’ve been talking about across these previous events, Jumanji takes sort of movement four and almost replicates it and runs two movement fours. One would be from Nick Jonas’ hut in the jungle, Alan Parrish’s hut.

Devin: Yeah.

Adam: Across the threshold of the canyon when he has to fly them in the helicopter. And then… Once again in our build to the climax when they get to the trail for the jaguar. These are very similar rhythms. It’s good to see this and understand this because if you have something action-adventurey, shorter build, shorter movements to lesser thresholds or moderate thresholds helps to keep the story moving. So you could say the re-choosal of the call is once Bethany’s trained Martha. Yeah. On how to seduce men. So she can go in there and deal with the threshold guardians of the transportation shed. They get in there. They got to find the aircraft.

Nick Jonas doesn’t want to fly, but he’s the only pilot. Fridge offers to fly because he’s had too many margaritas. And… Because they have… They sort of left that joke behind a little bit. And then they bring it back up because he’s like rambling. And you’re like, you’re drunk, aren’t you? You’re drunk, Fridge?

Devin: Oh my God.

Adam: But, so, part of the re-choosal is Nick Jonas popping on a sunglass and saying, I’m in. And so, that’s part of what’s happening. They all get in the aircraft and fly away. But, it’s also, once they’ve all had their connection points later, after they’ve crossed the canyon, Spencer and Martha and Nick Jonas and Bethany, they re-choose to approach the Jaguar. They’ve had a recovery bit, and then they re-choose. So, it happens twice, this whole rhythm of events. And the re-choosal is, you know, Martha walking up to the guards and talking to them and dance fighting them, and the other one’s sneaking in and choosing the aircraft, and boom.

And notice that, even though we’re calling that a re-choosal in its own way, there is still a debate that builds to that final choice that’s made. Nick Jonas. Nick Jonas doesn’t want to do it. So, they try to convince him, and then it builds to the final, we’re going to fly this helicopter out through the side of a transportation shed, which, you know, I’m not really sure if the helicopter would make it. But, I’m just saying, maybe it’s just for video games.

Devin: I would agree with most of that. I think, or all, I agree with all of it. And I think there’s two re-choosals. I think there’s the re-choosal of Jonas, and then there’s the re-choosal of [unclear]. I have other people, like, I have support, and I have people with other skills. These other players have joined the game with me. I’m ready to, I’ll re-choose it, and I’m back in the fight. And I think the four heroes are Fridge, Martha, Bethany, and Spencer. I keep going back to this, but I think it’s all, this is one of those moments, this is a really powerful moment, is when they, that realization that he’s been in the game for 20 years, and they realize that they, their re-choosal, in a way, is, yes, we’re going to, we’re going to win the game, and we’re going to beat the game because we want to go home, but now we’re going to really beat the game because we have to get him back home, too. So I think that was part of their re-choosal.

Adam: No, it’s really important. It’s a big moment, and it can cross across several events because it is a larger, and it continues until she gives him CPR, gives him mouth-to-mouth.

Devin: Yeah, CPR, right.

Adam: So you can also look at the re-choosal. I think a really powerful part of this as when they’re approaching the Jaguar, they’re sort of, this is where they’re back on track again. Just as Jumanji splits this into, like, these two almost separate little mini-builds that chop the events in half and go, all right, we’re going to do half of it here and then half of it over here, Edward does something completely different with what it does with its re-choosal, and it’s brief, but it squeezes all these events, like, into one little short segment of it. Do you want to move on to Edward? Yeah. So this area in Edward Scissorhands is compressed. Like I say, in a lot of movies, they’ll compress it. But the re-assessment, re-choosal, and putting the plan into action events are all sort of squeezed down into, like, the Christmas party preparation.

Peg and Kim have an exchange. They’re decorating the tree, and she says, are you sure we should still be having this party, Kim says to Peg. And Peg says, it’s just what we need to calm things down, and everything will just go back to normal. Okay, that’s the plan. That’s the plan. So even though it seems like it sort of goes under the radar, you don’t really notice it, that’s them talking about the plan, as in re-choosal, figuring it out, re-assessment, same thing, and putting it into action while they’re talking about it. They’re hanging ornaments on the Christmas tree. Bill’s on the roof.

Devin: A Christmas day in the morning.

Adam: As all three ships come sailing in on Christmas Day.

Devin: That’s what I’m saying. Such a great song to use there.

Adam: It’s so silly. That’s a great shot, by the way, to show us the transition between Act 2 and Act 3. It seems summery. They’ve had a barbecue earlier in the movie and all this stuff. And now we’ve got a shot of the roof. We’ve never seen it before, ever in the whole story. And Bill’s up there rolling down snow, and it says, like, Merry Christmas or some stuff on top. We not only crossed the threshold of, we’re moving Act 2 to Act 3. It’s a new time of year. We’re pointing that out immediately, almost like a sharp cut from one to the other, like a slam cut.

Because you’re in this place, and all of a sudden we’re on the roof, and there’s fake snow being rolled out. Fake snow, mind you, to set up the story and the prologue and the ice sculpture scene. And then, you know, we cut from that to the decorating of the tree. So everybody’s preparing. We’re preparing for the Christmas party. No matter what’s gone down, everybody’s recommitting to Edward belonging to the neighborhood. So the Christmas party is the symbol of that thought process, that desire or choose of. So Edward choosing to come down to the neighborhood and Peg choosing to bring him is to have him fit in and find community.

And so this is the big symbol of, if everyone comes to the party, we know things are okay. All right. If people don’t come to the party. We know that it’s a tragedy. We know that Edward has to leave. Per the conversation Peg and Kim have later on the couch when she’s like, maybe it’s just better if he goes back up, honey. It’s funny because in this movie, the plan is very simple and very subtle. And it’s almost set dressing in a way. And the way it falls apart is very quiet and disappointing. Because the antagonists gain more ground than the heroines. The antagonists gain more ground than the hero in this story.

It’s a tragedy. They chase the hero, Edward Scissorhands, out of town. That’s what happens in the climax. And then the last person to follow him out, Jim, he has a showdown with. But the plan goes to complete hell in this story. And very quickly. Then the next bit, we were talking about the fall of the heart while possibly being the ice sculpture. And you were saying hero’s darkest moment. Because the look on his face. When he’s carving that ice sculpture is pained in a way. Pained, if you will. You don’t really know what’s happening. But it’s intense. And it’s not the joy and intensity of cutting people’s hair or grooming the pets.

It’s a little bit more intense. And then Jim shows up and it all goes bad after that. So the plan lasts like five seconds. But it’s a backdrop, the Christmas party.

Devin: It’s also Edward’s re-choosal. In a way to fitting in again. Because he goes back to.

Adam: Yeah, I don’t want to stay here anymore. Yeah. So it’s not what he originally wanted. Pining over the town and wanting to be there. That’s what he’s wanted for so long. He got it. And now he’s like, I don’t want that. What I really want is to feel value and worth. And I can’t do it when everyone around me is judging me because they think I’m a monster.

Devin: And what’s interesting about this is. His re-choosal is actually choosing a different objective. Yeah. So in a way. Yeah. He’s kind of. In the beginning, he wants what he has decorated in his nest. Right. Everything that he’s seen in the magazines. The limited information he’s gotten from his inventor. The town that he can literally look out his window and see people moving about and being together. And having companions. And companionship and love and things like that he wants, he believes he wants that and so his objective is to get that and then at the end, his objective is to get get away from that. Yeah. And even though he still he still he still I think longs for love, he still longs for companionship, but he’s come to the realization that he it’s it’s not there and he doesn’t fit in.

And so that’s his re-choosal is literally. A different choosal. Yeah.

Adam: But that’s what I’m saying between act one and act four here is you can have the same goal be refocused as we call it the re-choosal, right? But one of the things you can do is a nice little subversive act is have them choose something different that we should have known from the very beginning. Right. There you go. Of course, he’s not going to fit in because people are judgmental. They’re not going to accept him. They’re going to be fascinated by him. And then they’re going to find fault in him like they do with most of the other people in their lives. You know, most people, the journey to find self comes from other people’s expectations and not exploration within.

And so, of course, that’s human beings greatest flaw, really possessiveness and judgment judgment. But it’s going to, it’s going to sort of fall on Edward, you know, Joyce can’t have Edward. She can’t possess Edward in a way. And so, you know, in other people, he makes mistakes. And of course, they’re not, they’re not willing to deal with it. They can’t do it. So he chooses something completely different, but it’s different than, but, and it’s all condensed. You can sort of, you’ve said it across several episodes, the symbolic moment of him choosing to, to return, even though he comes back to the house, which is, it’s a strange sort of build they’ve got going on here.

It might be one of the weirdest or most disjointed parts of the movie, as far as build is concerned. But when he slices off all his clothes, storming through the neighborhood, that’s it. That’s the threshold. That’s it. Because. Because he’s going across the same threshold he entered, passing through the neighborhood in the car with Peg, you know, so fascinated and excited and knocking his scissors into the window and almost slicing Peg. And, and now he’s passing through the same area and taking off the uniform from the earlier rules and tools scene in Movement 2. This is the costume you’re supposed to wear in this world. And he’s like, I’m not doing it anymore. And he pulls it off.

Devin: And like. Like we just talked about, it’s that contrast between who they are now and who they were before the hero’s darkest moment. But also they understand that even, and this is a good example of it. They understand that even though not a ton of time has passed, when they return to the known world, they’re going to be a different person. And that, that world will be, will be different. So it becomes the changed world. Yeah. Will be changed. Yeah.

Adam: They’re either changed or the world is changed. Yeah. It is one in the same thing. If, if a piece of it has changed, if you, and like we’ve said across this podcast from the very beginning, change is story. Story is change. Story is growth. If you don’t have something that arcs or changes across your story, you need to go back and develop it because that’s what it’s about. If not, there’s, well, frankly, your audience will turn it off or put down the book because it’s static.

There’s nothing happening. There’s no realization and discovery, whether the character is doing it or the audience or both together at the same time.

Devin: Right. And that’s why we always talk about when we talk about season one is a movie or a story is usually us as an audience and the writer dive diving into the world of this character at a time where it’s, it’s, there’s a lot happening to them. The most exciting time in their life. Exactly. So that it could be. It could be static and boring for 20 years and then they get this boyfriend, something’s happening. It’s like, now’s the time to, we invite everybody to watch. Right. And so we bring it in and then even afterwards, once we leave them after final image, it could go back to being boring or it could go back, you know, we’ll get to final images.

We’ve, Adam and I’ve had many discussion about, about that event.

Adam: We talked about fall of the heart wall a while back and, and Edward, and we were saying it’s when he actually. He connects with somebody and she says, hold me. He says, I can’t. And he comes back to the house and she actually holds him and he sort of holds her. And I couldn’t remember when the flashback to Vincent price, the inventor who created Edward Scissorhands happened, but I knew it happened somewhere around there to sort of beef up the, the heartfeltness of that moment, sort of tugging on your heartstrings. And I watched again, just to make sure. Strangest thing. The flashback happens in the middle of the hold.

Ooh. So he holds her and they push in on the two of them.

Devin: Oh yeah.

Adam: Yep. And then it goes into Edward’s face and he flashes back and has the, the inventor gifts him with the hands and he cuts them apart. It’s a perfect part to put that. But let’s face it. Okay. They were pretty shitty hands anyway. Because if Edward ever decided to try cooking in his life, they would. Yeah. They’re pretty fresh. They were pretty rough. So, I mean, God bless Vincent price, the kind old inventor, but he was probably a little senile if he gave him wax hands. He managed to create actual flesh on the rest of the, he gives them wax hands.

Devin: What a joke. So there you go again.

Adam: Sometimes, sometimes man, I get all worked up. What’s interesting is that hold, cinematically, lasts for a long time. Because it lasts during the flashback. And so I thought I was like, oh, I’ll go back and just check because I don’t want to be talking about it and not know what I’m talking about. And I was like, oh, that was a weird choice. I remember it being rather strange. And couldn’t quite place whether it happened before or after. It’s because it happens during the hold. It’s a good spot for it, though. And it’s an odd spot for it, but it works because you spend that hold, you spend that hug, that embrace.

And you show that, tragically, the things he would use to hold her is the thing he’s remembering now. In the midst of it. I wish I could.

Devin: Well, and all the other flashbacks are triggered, right? They’re triggered, like the flashback in the kitchen. Well, so is this. That’s what I’m saying. That’s why it’s perfect. Oh, yeah, yeah. It’s the hands that he needs to hold her. Right. And before, it’s the, I forget, there’s a kitchen one, the other one where there’s… It’s the can opener. Something he doesn’t have. Yeah, there’s something he doesn’t have that triggers what he wants and things like that.

Adam: I think the can opener one, she starts it up and it zooms in on him.

Devin: And he looks, he’s like, what? When he cuts back to the inventor’s workshop, I believe they open a can.

Adam: Don’t they? Like, it’s a can opener. It’s the same mechanism. And dumps something into the bowl and… Yeah, yeah. So, it’s like he’s thinking about his fellow robots or fellow mechanized…

Devin: You would think I’d know, by now, I would have this movie running perfectly in my head, but I don’t.

Adam: I feel like a fool, Devin. I feel like a fool.

Next week, we’re going to be talking about… The beginning of Act 3, your climax. Heading into your climax. Movement 5 being the build to your climax.

Devin: Movement 5!

Adam: And the threshold of Movement 5 into Movement 6 is actually the heat of your climax. It’s the meat of it. Movement 5 is from recovery to climax. So, coming out of Movement 4, it’s the build to the ultimate moment in the story. And Movement 6 is from climax to resolution. So, it’s the… Ending of the meatiest part of your story and then whatever loose ends you need to tie up, that’s Movement 6. To end your story. Boom. So, the first event in Movement 5 we’ll be talking about next week is putting the plan into action. That’s going to be the first event of Movement 5. And it’s when, obviously, through the title you can tell, it’s one of the first moments after the re-choosal that the hero, allies, antagonists really choose to do something.

It’s not just reactionary at this point. It’s dedicated focus. And land ho, we’ve made it across the ocean. Ain’t that the truth? If you’ve gotten to this point in your story, don’t sweat it too much. Now, there may be stuff backwards in Movements 1 through 4 that’s not quite stable. But when you get into Movement 5 and 6, you’ll recognize it. You’ll be like, oh, wait a minute, they can’t do this because dot, dot, dot happened in Movement 2, Movement 3. And then you know what to fix. It’s a blessing if you get stuck. If you get stuck, go back and look at what happened prior to now that would have set this up properly.

And you’ll fix your story in sort of set up payoff mode. But this is the time when that kicks in too. And this is one of the things Dev and I love the most. The mirrored parts of the story. Here’s where you set up this little bit. And here’s where it pays off in a revelation, a discovery, a twist, a turn. As always, we want you to sit down and take a little time for yourself with your story. If you don’t have a story you’re working on predominantly, take 15 minutes. Just do a free write. If you do have a story you’re working on, do three pages based on this event.

Rechoosal of the quest. What’s different between Movement 1’s choosal of the call and Movement 4’s threshold rechoosal of the quest? Has their quest changed? Is it the same? Is their reasoning different? Think about these questions.

Devin: Sit down with your story and just write something.

Adam: Dedicate a little bit of time. Three pages, 15 minutes for a free write. And put this down in your story. And if that’s not happening, jot down some ideas. Play an imagination game with yourself. And say, what would be the coolest rechoosal I could think of for a quest? And out of this event, you may create an entire story. That’s it. That’s our assignment. Stick to it. If you’re doing your three pages, in a very short amount of time, you’ll have a finished first draft. And that’s half the battle, getting it on the paper. Once you get it on the page and you start generating ideas and imagining, the story will come to you.

But you have to sit down, have a little bit of discipline, and put your butt in the seat, and play. Write. Or stand, if you have a standing desk. See you next week, StoryHouse fans. All right. Please subscribe and rate us on iTunes. Follow us on social media. Share with your friends and send us your questions and comments. For additional resources and links to films, series, and books we talk about here, visit our website. While you’re there, sign up for our newsletter for updates on story building tools and special offers at StoryOsophy.com.

Where this episode sits in the Story BlueprintPick any event on the curve to hear its episode.