Show notes
Crossing into the danger zone is the second threshold of your story and the end of Movement 2. It’s the “until” in “it’s all fun and games until…”: something external happens that your hero can’t hide from, and it prompts a change inside them. Adam and Devin explain why this may be the most useful threshold for a writer, how threshold guardians work, and how Jumanji and Edward Scissorhands handle the moment in nearly opposite ways.
In this episode
- External event, internal change. The danger zone is an outside threat that forces your hero to realize simply reacting won’t work. It can also be a discovery about themselves or the antagonist.
- Quick dominoes. Approaching the danger zone, the danger zone and the close call follow each other fast, before the story lets everyone breathe.
- Signposts and stepping stones. Without this threshold, the stretch from the start of Act 2 to the crisis tends to meander. Thresholds are like stones spaced across a river: too far apart and you fall in.
- Devin’s three timelines. Story events in the middle, each movement’s own mini hook, call and re-choosal above, and the hero’s internal journey below. Adam adds a fourth: what the audience knows, and when.
- Treat your audience as smart. Track your setups and payoffs from the reader’s side, from small ones a few scenes apart to series-long reveals like Jon Snow’s parentage in Game of Thrones. Feedback from someone who knows nothing about your story shows where you’re losing them.
- Too hot in the hot tub. Your hero has dipped a toe in and pulled it back. From here they move from reacting to responding.
- Threshold guardians. They can be characters, places or even a riddle set up long before it’s solved. Some become allies once the hero proves worthy.
- Set the tone early. Ask the audience to suspend disbelief from the start, as Edward Scissorhands does, not in the last act.
Examples discussed
- Jumanji: Welcome to the Jungle: after the motorcycle chase, the heroes reach a cliff with gunmen behind them. They have to find the courage to jump, and the decision is forced on them.
- Edward Scissorhands: Jim’s flame-striped van and a beer can hitting the pavement announce the danger. Kim crosses two thresholds, the front door and her bedroom door, and Edward, terrified, pops the waterbed. The whole household erupts: Kim is the reaction to Edward that nobody has had yet.
- The NeverEnding Story: at the Southern Oracle, a knight in armor is fried by the sphinxes, and Atreyu has to believe in himself to pass.
- Labyrinth: Hoggle guards the gate and Sir Didymus guards the bridge over the Bog of Eternal Stench; both become allies.
- The Wizard of Oz: the apple-throwing trees.
- Also: A Quiet Place and Gravity (tension through silence), The Ritual (a monster reveal that lets down the audience’s imagination), The Village, Finding Nemo, Westworld and The Hunger Games.
Writing along with the season? Write three pages for your hero’s crossing into the danger zone, and value your own voice: put the pages down, even if they aren’t perfect.
Read the full transcript
Transcribed automatically, so expect the odd misheard word. Sponsor messages are left out.
Adam: In this episode, we’ll be crossing the second threshold of your story into the danger zone. How does this threshold manifest itself? What challenges does your hero face? What’s holding them back from change? Next on StoryOsophy. Hello. Welcome to StoryOsophy. This is Adam Jones. And Devin Halden. This week, we’re going to be talking about the second threshold of your story crossing into the danger zone. Before we get into it, Devin. Yeah. I assume you’ve seen A Quiet Place, right? Yes, I have. I have seen. Really brilliant movie. Because it’s so simple. It’s so simple. It’s like just this family and a farm and a looming villain. And the rest is story.
But that’s the setup. Because there’s no talking in the beginning of that movie for like the first half hour or so, you’re so tense. Yeah. I love it. You’re just holding your breath. Yeah. The experience of it is just crazy. But gravity is the same way. The Sandra Bullock, George Clooney flick. Yep. That first, I think it’s 10 minutes long take of just floating out in space. Yeah. You just tense up. It’s sort of amazing. I found that fascinating, the Quiet Place one, because it’s just because they’re not speaking.
Devin: They’re not speaking, but they also didn’t try to garbage it up with a bunch of score. Right. And stuff like that. Yeah. So it’s like he’s kind of like trying to figure the little movements of their feet sometimes, or when that thing’s going to fall off the shelf. And so it makes it like, oh, because you’re not distracted everybody’s score. I don’t think, and score has a big, is like another character. But them removing the score. Yeah. Same thing with Gravity, where it’s just pitch, silence. Yeah.
It’s just, what? It’s just like, that is, that’s intense. Yeah.
Adam: Yeah. You’re on tiptoe because of the sound. You’re experiencing it like them. Yeah.
Every time there’s a sound that happens, you’re like on edge because it happened. And so, that’s why I think I like it too. It’s very experiential. The way that the film was designed to be experienced helped you to relate to the character’s journey of that experience, which is always impressive to me. But it was really well done that way.
Devin: And when you’re watching that in a theater, or even just at home with other people. Home theater. You pick up on every little noise in the room that you’re in too. Like in the theater, you’d hear the crackling of a popcorn bag or someone, like the straw moving, so you’re just like, what, dude? And you’re like, shut up! But it’s like, dude, I got to eat my popcorn. It’s going to get us all!
Can’t you see? We got to be quiet. Oh, that was a good movie. That’s funny. Or the weekend I watched The Ritual on Netflix.
Adam: Spoiler alert on The Ritual.
Devin: It started out great because it was this group of hikers and one guy gets hurt, and they’re trying to get back to… To civilization, really. They’re in the middle of nowhere. They’re kind of lost. And they’re looking at the map and like, look, either we go this way and we’re still a day out, or we cut through these woods and we’ll sit… We could be sleeping in our own beds by midnight. Clearly, always a bad decision. But I’m like, wow, this is really great. And then they did kind of the Jaws thing where you hear the monster, or you hear whatever it is chasing them, and you see remnants of like they’re hanging these dead deer carcasses and all these trees all over the place.
And so you’re like, wow, what would have been able to do that? So there’s all these things that your imagination is going crazy on. But the payoff of the monster was terrible. And it was like this thing that was just made up. It was like this monster. It was like this monster montage of things. It was like a deer head with moose antlers and an elephant body. But it was like such a letdown because like all of their creativity on leading up to the quote-unquote monster,
Adam: It ended up being a monster. You mean all of your creativity because you’re the one who did the work. The audience member is the one who did the work on what that creature, how awesome that creature was. Yeah. So the suspense part was the audience’s work. Then the audience’s imagination had surpassed the payoff. Right.
Devin: And here’s what I wanted. And this is completely a personal preference. So don’t jump all over me, people, because someone may love the ritual. And this is what I was hoping for. I wanted it similar to like The Village where this monster ended up being something that really could have been, you know, something that wasn’t so far-fetched that you’re like, oh, my God, this thing that would never exist. And so the types of scary stuff I like is a little bit of like one foot in reality and one foot in could this really happen? And so that’s why I give like paranormal types of stories. Like I’m cool with that because you know what?
There’s a lot of people or evidence of haunted stuff. And so I’m like that I can or cannot. Proof this thing that is in the end of the ritual. I’m like, okay, you completely remove me from the story. I’m hoping I was hoping it would be like this monster that all of these like a bunch of people were operating it or something like that. And it was like stay away from our land. Otherwise, we’re going to scare you and then we’re going to kill you. And so that’s it was like, okay, I kind of got and the other person I was watching it with who was like.
We were just disappointed at the end. We’re like, are you kidding me? It’s like, it’s such a, it was almost like their deadline for getting the script was approaching and they’re like, crap, let’s just make it a monster because we don’t have time to actually get really creative on how to end this.
Adam: And the reveal comes off like the Price is Right sound.
Devin: Yeah, exactly. And then they cut, they do the classic where they go to the long dark screen and you’re like, don’t you, don’t you dare, do not put up the credits right now. And then directed by, and they’re like, oh, come on. It was a great concept up until that point because it had a lot of, it had a lot of like paranormal voodoo witchcraft stuff in it, which I can stay involved in a movie or I can stay in that type of a film.
Adam: If there’s one thing I will say, movements and building and why they’re there, especially with this threshold coming up, because it’s to get outside of this trap. It’s like build some better stakes, some better reveals, better antagonism, better characters. You’re going to have to now. Everybody’s seen everything. Before we get too much into the danger zone, I want to framework where we’re at in the story. And if you haven’t been following along, we’ve been doing story event by story event linearly through a story from the beginning, the act one. Now we’re in act two. We break them down. We break them down into movements, which is approximately, when I write, I do approximately 15 pages or minutes per movement to get you a rough estimate. So the first movement coincides with act one. They’re like one in the same. And act one is the known world of your story. Movement one, we like to call from comfort zone to out of comfort zone. Both those, the act one and movement one, are all about getting your hero up and moving out of their status quo.
And into the adventure of the story. So that starts with the hook, then goes to the known world routine, your everyday routine of your hero. Inciting incident, the first domino of your story being tipped. Call to quest, where the story meets the hero and there’s a call to call to quest. Then there’s a debate period, a refusal and choosal of the call. And after it’s been accepted, this quest. There’s crossing the threshold into the unknown world. And that’s act two. So we’re in movement, the first movement of act two, movement two. Movement two starts with the first day of school, where you’re reacting. It’s like Harry at Hogwarts, checking out all the stuff when he first arrived. Next is the watering hole, then rules and tools. Approaching the danger zone. And here we’re at the second threshold, the end of movement two, crossing into the danger zone.
So, Devin, is there anything right off the bat? You wanted to say about this?
Devin: This event is, I would argue, and I only say that because I think you and I may see a little differently. What? Maybe, maybe. But so I would argue that this is an external event that prompts a change in the hero internally. That’s a good, yeah, that’s a good way to put it. Because without the external obstacle, we can’t have the internal change. I think. It’s, it’s our heroes reacting to an immediate threat, but it can also be a discovery event too, which I think is important to while we’re, while you’re writing this is like kind of that economy of the page or economy of your story type of thing where there, it certainly serves a purpose.
I would also say that approaching danger zone, danger zone, close call are very close dominoes to each other. They’re all going to happen fairly, fairly quickly. And so though they’re simply reacting, our heroes are just kind of reacting to stay alive and whatever stay alive means in your story, you can translate that, but they can also discover something about themselves, which is how we’re getting that internal change or the antagonists. And that will be important when they’re faced with the decision to have to re-choose the call to quest or to continue on this adventure or this. And I just want to say that we have to continue on with the story and which is typically going to happen in our next event, close, close call.
Whereas it’s more of a, it’s area to breathe a little bit and, and refocus and things like that.
Adam: So. It’s a, it’s a small recovery scene, the, or event, the, the close call.
Devin: The only other thing to add for thresholds themselves is just to remember they’re good markers for us as writers to show change in, in our hero. Yeah. I probably shouldn’t.
Adam: Should have started with that. The important thing for me about the movements is it’s, it’s one smaller build to a threshold of change, like you said, for the hero, but also a raising of the stakes. Some new discovery, some new corner is turned in the story where you can’t go back and things are a little, I like to call it progressive complications, because it’s not just a complicated thing, like obstacles, your three O’s, Devin, objective obstacle outcome. It’s the progressive obstacles, right? So each of these thresholds help you to measure out at least a place to increase it. If you haven’t done it by now, you should do something here. That’s at least to check in with the, the, the feel of the story. And plus, you’ve just entered the unknown world at the beginning of movement two here of act two. And it’s the first day of school. It’s, it’s, you’re hiding. And we, we also like to use Blake Snyder’s thing for this. It’s all fun and games until dot, dot, dot. So this is the until point. They can’t hide anymore. They’re being forced into a decision or willingly in a decision, but not knowing what to expect. It’s, it’s, it’s time to push forward a little bit. Now, if you look at a mog, a moggler, a model like voglers, a moggler, a moggler, if you will.
I like it. He talks about this entire section of what we would call movement two and three as test allies and enemies. And so you’re learning about these things. If you, if you’re doing that, it’s, it’s good to put in this threshold so that you have some sort of measurement. Because if you look at the examples we’ll do when we talk about Jumanji and Edward Scissorhands later, when we talk through the, when we have talked through the events of movement two up until now. And even this and into movement three, most of it’s going to be broken down into tests, allies, and enemies. You could put all of that into one category and it would work, but you get lost that way. And your story, you can invent all kinds of test trials and things for your character. And it just feels like they’re in a training exercise for 30 minutes. It doesn’t feel like the story is moving forward. And so breaking up that build.
Right. Is happening. Yeah, exactly. Breaking up that build from entering the unknown world in act two to the crisis midpoint by another midpoint. So there’s a threshold that raises the stakes in between. Now, at least there’s some marker that you can use for measurement. You won’t get lost. It’s just an easy, it’s one of the things that I think I’ve discovered for my own self in my writing where I’m like, ah, I have signposts. Right. Once I’m here, there’s this, this, and this. And there’s no turning back. And it’s easier to create that way with a little bit of structure.
Devin: Signpost is a great visual of it because it’s, a signpost just provides you with decisions.
Adam: Right.
Devin: You can go that way, which is quit. You can go that way, which is continue. Or you can stay here and gather intel or gather knowledge or get just go. So I like that. That’s good.
Adam: Yeah, they’re like crossroads. When we’re talking about a threshold, there are many different types. One of the easiest ones to think about is crossing the threshold of a doorway. But as we’ll see in Jumanji or even Edward Scissorhands, the thresholds are different and they’re used in completely different ways, almost opposite.
Devin: Mm-hmm.
Adam: So, but the threshold, sometimes the threshold is guarded by a threshold guardian, an archetype we talk about in season one. And sometimes not. But in these smaller thresholds, like the end of movement two here, we don’t usually, I mean, we don’t encourage or discourage. You can use a threshold guardian at any threshold if you wanted. But here, as Devin’s saying, there’s something externally physical that happens and the hero in the close call, it takes them a bit to recover and actually have an understanding of what happened to grow and change. Whereas later on, that process of learning something new and integrating it becomes quicker. It’s a weird spot, this one, because when you’re trying to decide something, you can overanalyze in the moment.
Devin: The way that I kind of look at this moment, because it happens fairly soon after we’ve arrived into this unknown world. And so it’s that, it’s almost that first test where it’s like, all right, well, we’re going to, the antagonist is going to flex some muscle. We haven’t given you a ton of rules and tools, but you should have a couple of them. And so how are you going to fare? When we throw something, an obstacle at you or a complication at you, and then that’s where it’s that prompts this internal scorecard, if you will, for this person is like, okay, well, I was able to not die, or I was able to not get killed. However, you know, that can just be a, it doesn’t have to be literal. But I also know, which is the raising the stakes part of it.
I also know I am very ill-equipped or not, I don’t have what I need. I don’t have the tools exactly to whether physical or intellectual or educational to get to take this thing on. So I still need to gather some things up. But it was a good first interaction or a first test for, for our heroes at this stage of the game. And I like to visualize like, okay, so if I’m, I like, like the moggler, I, I like to visualize that those, and even the signposts, I don’t know why that’s just, I like to think about things like that. And so I visualize, visualize my Story Blueprint as like a timeline with three parallel levels. So in the middle level, or line, it contains the story events that we’ve been talking about, Hook, Inciting Incident, you know, all of those story events. And above those story events, that timeline, I have the movement.
And with each movement consisting of, below each movement consisting of its own hook, inciting incident, call to quest, maybe a refusal of call to quest, some kind of a debate, and then the rechoosal of the call, it doesn’t have to be so significant, like our initial first act or our first movement, where it was very definitive on certainly the choosing of the call. But there’s this rechoosing someone and this would, the rechoosing here, it kind of overlaps in the into the close, into the next movement, beginning of movement three. But then my third level is dedicated to, to my hero’s internal journey. So their arc or their through line or whatever, however you want to think about that. But it keeps that the plot of my external events connected to the theme of my hero’s internal journey, you’re kind of making sure that while you’re going through this journey, you have, or you’re the writer’s journey, you’re making sure you’re not forgetting about some of the vital, like the internal and external stuff. And you’re kind of making sure that that threshold hits. Okay, well, that’s my third line. So that’s where I’m going to have, I know that my hero somehow is going to, there’s going to be a change in my hero somehow. Whether that’s because of some knowledge gained, or maybe some gained confidence at what just happened with this first obstacle.
Like in Jumanji, they’re like, Oh, wow, I have these secret gifts or powers or strengths. And so there’s this new, a little bit of a new confidence in them there. And I won’t, we’ll talk about that later. But and so that is what allows them to make that re-choosal of the call. Because if they just were thrown into something, and they were already hesitant to get into the unknown world, and then they get into the unknown world, and it’s even worse than they thought, well, what have we given them to allow them to make that call? Well, during that debate, make the decision to continue on the journey, continue on with the quest. You got to give them a little something, got to let them catch the carrot every now and then.
Adam: This is where the payoff, the quick payoffs come after the setups. Yeah, exactly. The beginning of this movement has some really quick payoffs immediately for your audience. That’s them getting the carrot. Exactly. Also, throughout this journey, the whole process is recognizing a mistake or recognizing, a shortcoming or a flaw and transcending that mistake or shortcoming or flaw. So this is the moment when they experience like, whoa, guess I’m not prepared enough. In some capacity. That’s why it’s the danger zone. It doesn’t have to be life or death. It can be in the case of Jumanji, either we’re going to get shot, or we’re going to jump this cliff, rock and hard place forces them to do it.
But it doesn’t need to necessarily be life or death. For Edward, it’s just the anxiety, you know?
Devin: Right, right.
Adam: But once you see it, then you can refine it. And that’s the process of these movements. The threshold is that moment of a little bit more self-awareness, inner space recognition, because of something that happens externally in your story, so that your audience can see it happen to your character.
Devin: Mm-hmm.
Adam: And then they can think like your character inside. They can internally think for themselves and relate easy. But your audience, you’re talking about those timelines that you track. For myself, I have one more, and that’s the audience through line. What does my audience know for sure, where in the story, because— That’s good, yeah. It’s hard to track that a little bit, because you have to just keep zooming out and going, Mm-hmm. Let’s pretend I know nothing from— From page one. Right. Where do I get the first hint of this? Where do I—and see that objectively, which is a hard thing to do. It’s not easy. And usually, you can lay out your setups and payoffs with this knowledge.
Yeah, I like that. This is a good way to map them out, because what the audience wants to know, the payoff, how much sooner do you need the setup for it? How close do you need the setup to the payoff, right? Right. Is it a big story? It’s a big story arc reveal, like Game of Thrones, Jon’s heritage. He’s a bastard, the whole story. And then the end, you find out who he is. So that kind of stuff, it’s a big arc. And then there’s tiny arcs, where it’s like a setup a couple episodes ago, or 20 minutes ago, even.
Devin: Right.
Adam: You have to measure it out. And the effectiveness of those things is, how long can you trust your audience’s memory? You know, without a recap. Treat them as if they’re smart. You got a smarter and smarter audience every year, getting smarter and smarter. I like that. And that’s why we say you can’t just do the ritual kind of story, where it’s stuff you’ve seen before, and you know all the tropes, and the payoff’s not something new.
Devin: We’ve all been there. The story is so clear in your head. But when you give that story to somebody— Who has no idea about what your story’s about, who your characters are, they’re reading everything for the first time, and we’re like, what? You didn’t get that? Well, it’s because you didn’t do that. You weren’t tracking that fourth level that you’re talking about, Adam, that audience level. So if you can consciously think about that fourth level, where you’re like, all right, well, I understand where everything’s going, so sometime this may be an issue where I’m assuming that they’re going to figure it out. But maybe that assumption is going to—is not correct.
Adam: Be subverted.
Devin: Yeah, and so I think that audience level, that fourth level, you do need that feedback from somebody to understand that they—
Adam: Who doesn’t know anything about the story, right?
Devin: Yeah, they’re not following this, but I’m losing them right here. Everybody who’s giving me feedback, this is where I’m losing them. That payoff just didn’t pack the punch that I thought it would.
Adam: Yeah, your brain— It contains all the information about the story. It’s like the internet, and then you’re asking someone, okay, I just want you to read this one little article on the internet.
Devin: Mm-hmm.
Adam: Like, it’s hard for you to decipher what information you know or have or have not put down is actually there and being communicated, because you may read something and the connotation of it brings you through this base of knowledge you have about backstory that’s not on the page. Right. So it’s hard to tell what the audience is actually perceiving. But I will say this regarding your timelines. There’s the events, right, which are the physical tracking the audience can track with something external. There’s the character internal journeys. Yep. And then there’s the audience tracking. Now, if you do it in the right order, it will be effortless. If you figure out what your character is dealing with there, and you make sure it’s reflected in the physical, when you present it to your audience or your reader, the thing— Mm-hmm.
Mm-hmm. Which a lot—I was saying about A Quiet Place. There’s a lot of stuff in there. That’s suggestive, because they’re not using language. They’re using gesture. And so, it becomes something that the audience interprets as well. Mm-hmm. I wrote a little note to myself, and I have to read this to you, because it’s freaking awesome.
Devin: All right.
Adam: I wrote, this particular event or threshold, this is where the hero starts to realize that simply reacting is not going to work. And this is the sentence that I wanted to read. They’re going to need to have to have to have to find their voice, their power. They still don’t know where to start. And this event brings… I know, I was like, what the heck was going on there? But this event brings that into focus for them. Up until now, they’ve not really had to make a strong decision in this special world, in this unknown world of their journey.
Devin: It’s, yeah, it’s like getting into the hot tub. Yeah. You can’t prolong it too, you feel like the story’s good. Don’t say yeah. I was getting my… I love that. Yeah. Just like that. Say what you’re gonna say. I took my first bath in like 20 years. Your first bath? Yeah, I don’t take baths. Oh, baths. Because they’re a waste of time. And I don’t like baths. I don’t like sitting in my own filth.
Adam: Like, I thought you were just talking about bathing and general hygiene. I’m like, so wait a minute, you’re, you’re cooking yourself a thing.
Devin: You’re in that car, and you’re not bathing at all? I shower, like, I love showering. In fact, I shower sometimes just because I’m bored. I’m like, I’m gonna take a shower. Anyway, I digress. This is like that moment where you put one foot in the tub, and it’s scalding hot, and you pull it back out right away. You’re like, okay, I can’t just jump in here. I need to figure out a way to get this water at a temperature that I can at least get in and bear it. That’s what this is.
Adam: Yeah. When you said hot tub, all I could think was Eddie Murphy’s James Brown Celebrity Hot Tub. Do you remember that skit from Saturday Night Live? No. It’s Eddie Murphy does James Brown. It’s called James Brown Celebrity Hot Tub. And it’s just guys on either side of this, like, really elaborate, like, it’s all decked out. It looks, you know, like the way that James Brown dresses with his robe. Like a jacuzzi? Yeah, but it’s a, it’s really elaborate. Jacuzzi. And he’s got, like, horn guys on either side of the jacuzzi, and they’re, like, playing a tune, like, and he walks out, and he just is dancing around, and he’ll dip his toe in a hot tub and be like, too hot in a hot tub.
I do remember that. It is the funniest. I mean, there’s nothing else that happens, except for him dancing around and going, they just have the intro. With these guys with horns. It’s so absurd, dude. I love it. But that’s what I thought of, and I’m like, yeah, it is. Too hot in a hot tub. So, anyway, dialing back from that, one of the things I want to say, too, about this event is, even though there’s an approach to the danger zone, that’s sort of your buildup for the payoff of this. So, in Edward, it was the, him actually fitting into the neighborhood, pretty much. He’s doing well.
Which, our danger zone flips that on its head. And Jumanji. Jumanji, same thing. They’re sort of escaping from the thugs on motorcycles, and they’re doing a good job. They’re actually not doing too bad. And so, the approach to the danger zone is one thing. And this event, the crossing the threshold into the danger zone, there’s usually a ramp up to the threshold. Even though there’s an approach in the previous event, think of this as this really tiny ramped approach. It’s not just the crossing itself. There is something that happens that builds up. Even more, and faster, and more amplified, before the danger zone actually is crossed.
This is the point when they haven’t thought enough, and perhaps after this, they’ll pre-think or pre-pave a little bit more in the journey. This is the big, the first reactive moment, where your hero gets kicked in the butt, and realizes they don’t have everything figured out. In order to survive, or move to the next level, they’re going to have to figure some stuff out, or assimilate. Or start to use new rules and tools. But they can’t just wait to the last minute. And part of the beginning of this is over-analyzing everything. You’re just observing, sitting back, not wanting to get in. So, you’re just watching everything, but you’re not actually doing it.
You’re not actually making decisions. Usually, there’s a mentor or something that is helping make decisions for you, or the map, or Nigel for Jumanji. But, eventually, they’re going to be forced into a decision if they don’t make one themselves. Right. And that’s this threshold. Did you want to talk about Threshold Guardian?
Devin: Yeah, we can do a refresher on what that archetype is and how to utilize it at this stage, at this point.
Adam: Because you may or may not use it. In something like Labyrinth or Wizard of Oz, where you’re traveling and you’re meeting allies and enemies in a path, it’s easier. I would say probably her danger zone is probably the woods where the trees are throwing apples and the witch shows up after she’s met the Scarecrow and the Tin Man. That’s probably the first encounter. And their Threshold Guardian is the trees with the apples.
Devin: The Neverending Story has a good one that encompasses all we’re talking about here.
It’s not the Southern Oracle. He’s trying to get to the Southern Oracle, isn’t he?
Adam: Oh, I’d say that’s probably a little later. I don’t remember when the Southern Oracle… I haven’t seen that movie in a while. I’m a bad reference point for this.
Devin: Well, and this isn’t necessarily at this point at the danger zone. This is just a good Threshold Guardian. But after he’s saved, Alcor saves him from… Is he in the Swamp of Sadness there? But he’s almost caught by the… What’s the beast’s name? The wolf? The G’morg. G’morg. He’s almost caught by him, but he’s saved. And then Falkor… Yeah. And then he ends up at this little hut where the little creatures are. Oh, that’s right. That’s the aftermath. Yep. The actual Threshold Guardian is literally a Threshold Guardian where he watches all of these… He watches this knight in shining armor on a horse… Oh, that’s right.
…try to get past this Threshold Guardian that if you don’t believe in yourself, it literally kills you. It shoots lasers at you or something. But this is one of those moments where it’s a change, an internal change of our hero, Atreyu, here. And so it’s this… We’re getting this… He’s crossing a literal threshold, but it’s also that marker for us as writers or storytellers. We’re like, all right, here he finds something out about himself because he gets past it because he… I think you got to believe in yourself or you have to believe in who you are in order to get past this. And he gets past it.
Barely. They try to zap him. They do try to zap him, which is also good. That’s actually a good point because… Hey, you sort of believe in yourself, kid. Zap. Exactly. He’s getting… He hasn’t completely believed in himself. So, I mean, that’s a good… It’s just a good example of a Threshold Guardian.
Adam: If you’re still going through that threshold, you may not fully be there. You’re not a fully realized… You haven’t realized yourself enough confidence, awareness in that way. That’s interesting. That’s a really good example. You can also have living being Threshold Guardians. Like when I mentioned Labyrinth, you can have Hoggle who guards the gate to the Labyrinth and Sir Didymus who later guards the bridge across the Bog of Eternal Stench.
Devin: Did you just watch all the Harry Potter movies?
Adam: No, I was talking about the feature film Labyrinth. Feature film. The beginning of when she gets into the Labyrinth.
Devin: Oh, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
Adam: Hoggle is guarding the threshold and then Sir Didymus is guarding the bridge across the Bog. Bog of Eternal Stench. And they are physical characters who are Threshold Guardians. And because of the challenge they present, Hoggle eventually becomes Sarah’s friend and an ally in her mission, but not at first. He’s just a Threshold Guardian. Meanwhile, Sir Didymus, once they triumph over him and meet his challenge, he’s instantly an ally. So, just because someone presents a… Block in the path doesn’t mean that they’re necessarily an enemy. Right, exactly. Yeah, that’s a good point. They just block the path. You can turn them into an ally if the hero has worth or value.
They can negotiate. There’s this one thing I read recently, this real quick thought that is brilliant. The only choice you really have with people is to negotiate between two individuals. Because you are either someone’s slave, someone’s tyrant. Or negotiating. And I was like, that’s really cleverly put. Really cleverly put. Because you’re either giving your power away, forcing your power on someone who you see as vulnerable enough to accept it, to be shoved down. Or you’re negotiating your power with someone else. Understanding them. And it could be argued that Edward doesn’t really learn a heck of a lot. You know, he’s still a foreigner by the end of the story.
Yeah. What he has learned is that humankind, especially his neighborhood, really sucks. That’s the moral of Edward’s story. Yeah.
Devin: What he does finally make a decision on his own. He’s now living in that castle because he’s made the decision to live there. And he’s not allowing other people to make decisions for him. But we can get into that. We’ll get into that when we talk about it because I kind of make a point about that.
Adam: That’s a great point, too, though. But like we were saying, all of this is symbolic.
Devin: Yeah, right.
Adam: If you look at Edward’s story, literally, I mean, you start to disassemble it from the first, from the beginning. You’re like, okay, wait a minute. This dude has scissors for hands. Are you kidding me? And he’s got only those amount of cuts on his face? Come on now. He’s been taken care of. So there’s a lot of disbelief, but it’s fun.
Devin: Yeah.
Adam: Fun fairy tale.
Devin: You just raised a great point. By setting the tone. And this is, I will contrast it between Edward Scissorhands and the ritual. By setting the audience expectation and putting them in a place where they’re, they know they’re going to dis, they’re going to suspend belief and they’re going to be okay with that from the beginning is great because then they get, they get past that and they can be involved in the story. They can let themselves sink into the story and be in this world that you’ve created. Yeah. When you. When you. When you decide to wait until the very final act or final event of your story to require or ask your audience to, okay, now suspend.
Suspend disbelief. Everything that you thought this world was about. Now, now, now find a different level of belief then. That’s where you’re like, that’s when you get pulled out of it. You’re like, ah, like I just wasted. It was so good. I had so much potential in that waste of this. That’s a great point, dude. Yeah. I think that, and it just kind of came to me. I’m like, that’s the difference. If they would have. It is. It is. If the ritual would have allowed me to understand the world that I’m in. And I’m like, all right, so I understand, like you’re saying, this dude’s got scissors for hands. I know where, I know what’s expected of my imagination here. And that’s where I’m allowing it to go.
Adam: I have to expect that that’s going to happen. And then it stays within that world. There are a handful of things that may pop you out here and there, but it really does sort of maintain its own world, its own mythology. Yeah. That’s a good point. That’s a really good point.
[Sponsor message]
Devin: One other thing with Threshold Guardians, you can set up a Threshold Guardian well in advance of actually confronting it. Yeah. A lot of times, like fairy tales use riddles. And so you have to, the entire time, the riddle itself is a Threshold Guardian, but they can be trying to figure out the riddle throughout the story and then they finally figure it out. And that’s like the final Threshold Guardian until you get to, you know, moving it into the final act. So if you’re confronting, like the two, the Labyrinth Threshold Guardians you’re talking about, even the one I was talking about with Neverending Story, you’re confronting it and trying to pass it right away.
Like you’re confronted with Threshold Guardian and you need to get past the Threshold Guardian. Right. But it doesn’t mean you can’t set up a Threshold Guardian. You’re going to have to, you may have to pass other Threshold Guardians before you get to the Threshold Guardian, but you can set it up. And a lot of fairy tales use riddles. Like you have to solve this riddle to get past the something, but that’s at the end.
Adam: Right. Labyrinth does it a lot. So does Jumanji a little.
Devin: Yeah. So you can, it’s still a, you’re still trying to figure out the puzzle. But the puzzle itself is also, without discovering the solution of the puzzle or the solution of the riddle, you can’t cross that last threshold, which makes it a threshold guardian. I’m just trying to, instead of making them very physical and intangible threshold guardians, there are also different types of threshold guardians. So it’s not necessarily a character.
Adam: But most of the time, it’s either a physical place, like you’re saying the Southern Oracle, or a person.
Devin: Sure, but it doesn’t have to be.
Adam: Even the buildup of the riddle would lead to something like the…
Devin: It’s still going to get you past that physical thing.
Adam: Right, right.
Devin: Yeah.
Adam: The personality character, the character itself, would present the riddle, or you’d have to present the answer to them. Right. Or the Southern Oracle, the riddle being, you have to have, by this point in your journey, young Atreyu, enough bravery to try to cross this. So we’ve seen enough trial ahead of time to go, okay, is he worth it? We’ve been watching him. I think he’s worth it. He cried for his horse, baby. Right. That’s a really interesting threshold, by the way. You brought it up several times, and I think it just occurred to me this thought. When he’s going there, there is so much anxiety. I remember watching that particular moment as a child.
So much anxiety, because not only have you just seen someone get fried by these very intimidating, and I would probably say is a good bit programmed in our DNA, the Sphinx-looking large stones. The stone Egyptian sculpture-looking thing that is the gate, the Southern Oracle. There’s something very ancient and knowledgeable and maybe even judgmental about it, just sitting there in stone. And you fried this knight, and he’s a knight on a horse in shining armor, and he got fried. So now Atreyu, this kid, like you, is approaching this thing, and you’re like, you’re doing all the math for the entirety of the movie you’ve seen up to that point, right?
Right. You try to think, is he good enough? Is he not good enough? Oh, my gosh. If so, is he going to make it? And then he gets close, and the knight’s helmet flips up, and you see the fried, the totally charcoal knight inside, and you’re like, oh. Like, as a kid, you are, they put you, audience experience-wise, like A Quiet Place. They put you in his shoes. Is he worthy enough? You’re doing the math while he’s doing the math, and trying to go, come on, Atreyu. You got this. Like, it was a very engaging moment in that movie.
Mm-hmm. And very few movies actually get you that wrapped up in the decision-making process, the internal workings of the hero, where you’re thinking with them, along with them, not about what they’re doing, but with them on the same page.
Devin: Right. And there’s something powerful about the answer, or the solution of getting past this life-or-death moment isn’t something physically you have to do. It’s something intangible. It’s something internally. And so there’s all, like, the doubt is still there. Am I truly believing in myself right now, or am I just thinking I believe in myself, and I don’t? Which is something we, you know, you deal with all the time. Like, externally, people look, and we’ve talked about this with other events, is like, externally, our hero wants to be portrayed as something that’s completely opposite than what we’re doing. And what their internal obstacle is, or internally what they feel.
So when you step up to something where you literally need to believe in something, and not just say you believe in something, internally, it’s, there’s something that, there’s that doubt that’s always going to be there, and it’s almost like, you feel like it’s out of your control. Because it’s not something physically you have to accomplish. It’s something you need to look inward for, which is terrifying.
Adam: There’s a Mark Twain quote where he says, Yeah. Only the mastery of it. And when you’re talking about that doubt, even though they do have doubt, the hero still has to make a decision. And in the face of fear, in the face of the unknown, what type of decision do you make? And this is the point not where they start to make those decisions. This is the point when they realize they’re going to have to make those decisions.
Devin: Right.
Adam: This is where they might get forced into a decision and then go, oh, well, I’m going to do this. Okay, wait a minute. I’m going to have to navigate the rest of this story like this. Okay, I get it now. I have to stop being reactive and learn how to make decisions. They’re still not going to make the right decision even in the next movement per se. They may try, but they still don’t have enough information or experience.
Devin: Right.
Adam: The first part is here is getting your feet wet. It’s the too hot in the hot tub, Devin. The next one is. Experience. Like, so this is materialistic in a way. You’re sort of understanding the furnishings of this unknown world. Then you’ve got experience building in movement three and growth in movement four. And so by the end, there’s an execution thing that they bring to the climax from their movement four recovery, you know, growth aspect. And that’s an interesting thing. There is no lack of fear, only the mastery of it. Actually, we should get into examples. Jumanji is a great example of that quote, sort of personified. Jumanji, welcome to the jungle. We’ve just come out of this really amazing payoff scene of all of them using their new rules and tools to fend off the motorcycle thugs to hysterical degrees. It’s one of my favorite areas of the whole movie. It’s so funny. And, and the movie goes downhill after this. No, I’m just kidding.
So I think we’re on the same page. What we consider to be, or I consider the danger zone is when they all burst out of the jungle to the cliff, to the cliff side. And they’re all there at the threshold of this cliff below, very, very far below. There’s all this fresh, clean water and an escape route. They can, if they jump, they’ll live. If they don’t, these guys will either shoot them or kidnap them, capture them. They think. We still don’t know that the rock is a good puncher. Yeah.
Yeah. The, the, the minor skill sets. And that’s more like it’s, it’s, that’s more like the, the first fight I ever got in, it’s sheer panic and your, and your tools serve you well, and you make it out alive. You survive, just out of sheer, like berserker mode. And you’re just reacting. Right. You’re literally just reacting to the circumstances. This is why they realize to pre-think or prepay. In the future is once you’re there, once you’re in a place where you’re reacting too late, it’s too late. If you pre-pave in, and for me, it’s like going to the right area of the playground at the right time.
You know, if I would have pre-thought that better idea, right here, they’re not pre-thinking. Now they’re stuck between a cliff and bullet death from the guys coming behind them. Pre-thought is the thing that will happen in the next, or at least some of it. And, and once again, we’ll vacillate between doubt. And rash decision-making, because that’s the problem. Indecision is generally the problem with your hero here. That’s why reacting and responding, this is a threshold for that. That’s actually a good way to put this threshold too, dude. We’ve talked about this a lot. This is the first real transition between reacting and responding to something. Taking some thought to it instead of just being.
Right. Living out of survival mode or fear-based mode of the unknown. You start to get a little familiar. And so you can take your time and figure it out a little bit.
Devin: It’s also still, we’re still gathering intel, whether that’s tools and understanding rules. Absolutely. Again, because during the approach to the danger zone, our heroes have discovered some things about the, the antagonist here. And primarily in Jumanji, it’s how, how badly our antagonist wants to be rid of them. Or he wants to stop them from ruining his good thing he’s got going on. Ruining his, his new status quo. But they’ve also discovered things about themselves. And also they have transport and weapons. Right. Exactly. Yeah. And so, but, but we were talking about earlier, it’s like they’ve, they’re discovering things about themselves. So they’re gathering all this intel and specifically in Jumanji, there’s, it’s there, they’re, they’re in powers and strengths that I was talking about before.
And then, so now they’re standing at this threshold of the danger zone that Adam so aptly detailed running. They’re reacting. Like we were, we were. Because they’re, they’re just, they’re just trying to stay alive at this stage of the game. But there’s this internal debate and you can argue that all, each of them are having this, their own internal debate. It’s courage here too. Yeah.
Adam: Do, can we jump? Do we have enough guts to jump?
Devin: Right. And I think, you know what the, the other thing about Jumanji is, is from a, if, if you’re like a new, like a newer writer and kind of getting your feet wet, this is actually the type of. Script that is great to write because it’s, it’s an example of a story that has, that has story events that are very clear. Exactly. And in some case, very literal, like crossing thresholds and.
Adam: It’s one of the reasons we chose it.
Devin: Yeah.
Adam: And P and people may criticize the fact that it’s pretty cookie cutter in its format. And we would probably agree with you in that it’s not being experimental at all. Right. I mean, in a few spots it is, it’s just because we can very clearly show you the events of this story. Yeah. And you can take that information and then apply it and make a story that’s even better and even better and even better. It’s a good examination piece. And plus it’s funny to watch. I mean, there’s some great bits in here. I don’t mind watching it. Yeah, exactly. And it’s current. We wanted to pick something that was a little bit internal and symbolic and not so current like a classic film, which Edward Scissorhands now is, and something that is more recent that maybe younger audience.
Members may have watched because a lot of our listener base is fairly young. We have a young listener base, which surprised me. And I think, Devin. So, by the way, if any of you out there listening are seasoned writers and are going, I don’t know why sometimes they feel the need to explain something a little bit further than they should. We’re doing it because there are some of our listeners are trying to learn storytelling for the first time.
Devin: I guess the only other thing I have for Jumanji is that It’s that an external event triggering an internal – that internal debate is a good hallmark of this event, and that’s what happens here. My first point in the beginning of the podcast when it was like – I think of this event as an external – something external triggering or prompting something internal. And so that’s what this is. Even though we don’t necessarily – while they’re all fly through this forest and they come to this cliff, they’re all evading the external event that is right now or they’re reacting to this external event. There is that moment of debate when they’re like, do I jump?
Do I don’t jump? It’s like – so that even though it’s not as profound as it is. Maybe. Maybe in some other stories, but it’s happening.
Adam: They’ve been indecisive and in denial and stalling for the entire first part of this act. This whole movement, movement two for them, they just – they’ve been stalling, learning stuff even for the sake of comedy, like just denial – extended denial period for the sake of mining as much comedy out of this comedy adventure as we can. Now they’re forced to start using these tools in the approach to the danger zone. And now they’re forced. They’re forced to make a decision. Right. It’s not something they’re choosing in this place. Like in most of these times, I think Edward even you could probably argue that he’s not forced but shepherded into the danger zone.
Devin: Yeah.
Adam: You’re sort of – you’re just listening to your mentor or the people that you think know more than you in this world until you realize, oh, shoot, they know only so much, but I’m going to have to figure it out on my own from here. This is that moment where that happens.
Devin: In Jumanji? It kind of reminds me of like say we’re like in Westworld where we’re just like watching this happen. Like we’re in this room of – we’re in the story room and we’re like – or even like what happens in the Hunger Games too where we’re like – we’re watching this. We’re like, all right, well, these guys don’t seem to be moving on their own. Send out the biker gang. We got to force them to start reacting to something. Right. Otherwise, they’re going to sit on top of this mountain and look around. They don’t know where to go. And so a lot of times it takes this antagonistic force or the flexing of the antagonist’s muscle to push them into the story further deep into the enchanted forest or further into the story where retreat becomes less and less an option on that signpost.
And it’s more about, all right, now we got to – we have to continue to move forward. And we’re kind of slowly removing that option. We’re kind of slowly removing that option of retreat or quit as the story moves forward. And not necessarily forcing that. We’re doing that through giving them confidence and giving and letting them realize things.
Adam: That’s the positive way of looking at it. We say don’t take danger zone to be literal because you can have a person who, like Edward, he’s very nervous to go to that barbecue in the approach to the danger zone. So there can be internal anxiety that feels dangerous to your hero. It’s not necessarily life or death. It can be that social. It can be that social anxiety he has of not fitting in. But you want to build to that place where you’re challenging the hero to alter their decision-making process and thus ultimately their belief system, the way they think. So bit by bit you’re seeing it shift and change.
And one of the first places is denial and reaction instead of responding, instead of decision-making. So, Edward Scissorhands, the approach to the danger zone is like I was saying before in the Vogler-Mogler model. It’s a lot of test allies and enemies. All of Movement 2, after he gets back and learns the rules and tools and the watering hole of the family dinner, it’s about assimilating into, or it’s more like the build to this end of the movement meeting of Kim. And part of that is meeting the neighborhood. So, that’s an extended watering hole scene. And a lot of the stuff that happens there sets us up and goes, oh, okay, so the veteran that talks to him and later when he’s condemned to be a demon, calls him a cripple at that point, tells him he has his own affirmity from the war. This is where he connects with him. This is where the housewives connect with him. And if you notice at the end of the movie, it gets flipped on its head.
So, moving out of that, where he’s all accepted and he’s had a great day at the barbecue, even though he’s pinned in to the barbecue. So, moving out of Edward’s danger zone, he’s in bed, been a good day. And the start of the danger zone for me, what lets you know we’re in this threshold crossing is that flaming van that shows up in the neighborhood, like we discussed last episode. It’s reminiscent of the torch-bearing villagers in Frankenstein. It’s very 80s. Everything else has been pastel and gray. And this is like bright and vibrant and destructive in its symbolism. And out pours a beer can. One of the only sounds we hear is a beer can hitting the pavement when Jim gets out. So, we know what Jim’s about. This begins a build of audience anticipation for the crossing of the threshold.
Mm-hmm.
And so, we know as soon as we see her and recognize her from our picture, and they have the conversation about, oh, my parents are fine. They don’t keep their house like a police state. That she’s going to go inside, and we already know there’s going to be trouble. Mm-hmm. We’re already getting anxious from this point. But before we get that, we get this brief introduction of Jim, that we don’t really know him yet. We know he’s the antagonist. We just know. Right. We get a little bit of backstory. All we really need to know, he’s a dude who doesn’t feel like he has any control in his own life at his parents’ house, because they keep all of the stuff that his father considers toys locked up away from him. She says it. I think Kim says the line, my parents don’t run their house like a police state. She foreshadows a little bit of what the crisis is going to be in this story. Edward’s arrest.
Yeah. Yep. She lets you know that his parents, there’s these little things we get. We’ll get a little bit of a hint. But they set up the strictness of his family, how much his family, or particularly his father, doesn’t trust him, like, at all. And neither should we, as they’re hinting at this, we realize, oh, there’s something really base about his human motivations. He’s interested in sex and stuff. There’s nothing more base human emotions than that. Yeah. Survival-based stuff. Kim is part of his stuff. Right. It’s the big thing we take away from this setup. Kim is part of his stuff. And he’s territorially aggressive. These are big setups for Jim. So we already know, just by seeing it in this danger zone moment, or the buildup, this is the slight build to that ramp up I was mentioning to the danger zone, the anticipation of her entering the house and meeting Edward, that’s all the ramp up.
Yeah. So this, even though it’s a slight… It’s a slight moment with Jim. We get all the things we need. He’s a force of destruction versus Edward’s force of creation. We already know that Edward can trim topiaries and things like that. Kim also gets introduced, but we don’t really understand her too much yet. She’s sort of just like the object of beauty for Edward. And a little bit sort of guarded against Jim. In the way that their affection is.
Devin: She doesn’t necessarily do it straight up right away, but you know, through their interaction and how she responds to him. He, though he wants her to be one of his things, he still feels a little like he doesn’t have control of her. And it, you can kind of see that that bugs him that he doesn’t have that. Yeah. Great way to put it. It’s that moment that he, that she walks away from him or he drops her off. It’s kind of like really he’s released. He’s unshackled her into this unknown world. And it’s symbolic of like a hunter setting a trap or releasing their bait to lure in their prey.
Adam: Or like releasing her from feeding off of her energy. It sort of feels like he, he looks after is almost hungrily. You know what I mean? As if it’s possessive or.
Devin: Right. But just from a danger zone situation, it’s, he doesn’t, he doesn’t know about, neither one of them know about Edward and Edward doesn’t know about him. Right. What this moment, the moment is a bit symbolic of he’s literally releasing. That’s, that’s the, Edward becomes his prey. And that, the bait, if you were, the lure in between, between him and because he’s luring Edward in to do this, to, to rob his dad’s house later on. So he ends up using Kim as this bait or this lure to, to get Edward to do what he wants. But it ends up being, you know, it clearly it was Edward’s downfall because, you know, and, and I think from the moment, the moment we know we’re in the danger zone is when Edward sees this, the approach of the danger zone is when we see, sees this beautiful girl who’s safe inside a picture frame. And then that’s when he first sees her, but now she’s standing in front of him, like in the flesh. And literally, if you want to do the, if you want to, the cliff in this is literally her threshold of her bedroom, the bedroom door.
Yeah. Her bedroom. Her bedroom door.
Adam: Yeah. I didn’t want to get too far from, from Jim and Kim yet, but also the front door. And the front door. Yeah. She crosses two thresholds, which, which builds up our anxiety. We’re like, oh, she’s home. Oh, and she closes that bedroom door. Now, now it’s a pressure cooker threshold. Yeah. She’s trapped in a small room with a monster and he, and the same thing for him. It’s a teenage girl. Might as well be a monster. The monster’s afraid of the monster. That’s what’s really funny in this scene. Cause he’s like creeping up and going, oh my gosh.
Devin: What’s important is what you’re talking about. You’re talking about what the, that fourth level is important here. The writer needs to, is, has tracked up to this point. Let’s just hypothetically say this has tracked up to this point. Like I have given the audience everything that they need to know at this point, because the writer’s given us enough background on Edward. So we understand that Edward is, is not going to know how to act or communicate appropriately with her. So that also builds that, that, tension. We’re like, oh my God, we know he’s not going to be able to just be like, hey, I’m going to say, hey, it’s okay.
It’s okay. My, these are my, these are my hands, dude. It’s not a big deal. I’m not going to hurt you. Yeah. That’s true. We know he can’t do that. So it’s going to be even worse. So we’re like, oh God, dude, this is not, nothing is gonna, sorry. I didn’t mean to pull us away from Kim and Jim.
Adam: The only thing I was going to say is you said Edward is his prey and I agree with that, but also Jim is a character. Everything is Jim’s prey.
Devin: Exactly. Right.
Adam: Everything is Jim. Jim is a predator. Everything is Jim’s prey. And everything. Everything is, whereas Edward is always creating and uplifting the neighborhood around him or the world around him with his creation, Jim is tearing it down. Jim is the destructive force, tearing down people, tearing down, like, so it’s a really great first glimpse that you organically as an audience member feel this is the opposite of Edward. This is the antagonist. This is the opposite of Edward’s force. Esmeralda doesn’t feel like that. Esmeralda feels like. Harold. She’s talking about him being the devil, but she doesn’t feel like the antagonist.
Devin: No.
Adam: There’s nothing that’s as strong as Jim so far. So that the beginning of that, you got that little ramp up there, that little intro and the, and the, the continued ramp up, the closer she gets to that bedroom, the more nervous we feel about and, and excited about the interaction that’s going to happen and everything that could possibly happen, happen. So she shuts the door, right? She turns on the light. She takes her, she has two shirts on. She got like a little undershirt, but she takes the top shirt off. So symbolically she’s getting undressed. She’s done. She’s getting undressed. So she feels a little more vulnerable.
Edward’s emotional reaction in this is what the audience is feeling anyway, which is why we start to now find it funny. Cause he’s like, he’s acting like the teenage girl in her bed, seeing a monster have walked in her room. He, the, the, the roles are flipped. And so that’s the humor for us. We’re like, he’s going, Oh no. Oh no. And pulling his, his little scissor hands up. It’s terrified, which is, which is awesome. And of course, at her most vulnerable moment, popping a zit for a teenage girl, popping a zit in the mirror. She sees the monster. And of course his panic, he gets up, he pops. That’s my, my favorite jokes in the whole movie.
Pops the water bed Trying to get up And the entire family erupts in chaos. Everybody wakes up and the entire panic from, I would say the danger zone is from the van outside to the meeting and the panic, then chaos of the family in the hallway. And that’s the end of the danger zone. She gets shuffled off to one room and Bill takes Edward off into the bathroom.
Devin: And then gets him drunk.
Adam: Kevin waters up. Go back to bed, Kevin. Edward comes watering out wet and terrified.
Devin: It’s so good. It’s so good.
Adam: She goes, she goes, oh, there he is. There he is. But what’s great about that as a threshold, as a change is everybody’s disrupted. It’s not just that Kim meets Edward that grows in everybody in the family’s disrupted. And so now we’ve crossed the threshold. The reaction we thought somebody might have to Edward thus far throughout the story, Peg doesn’t have it. Oh, those are your hands. Those are your hands. And she takes them home. And then the neighbors are all fascinated by him because they’re projecting whatever they want as an adventure in their bored lives onto Edward. And so they all love him too. And so we still haven’t got this, but the dude’s got scissors for hands, people.
Right. Do you know what I mean? We still haven’t got that reaction yet. And Kim is the payoff. She’s the danger zone threshold and payoff for that now probably 30-some minutes of build to this joke.
Devin: This is the everything was fine until moment in the story. Like everything was fine until Kim came home. Yeah, yeah. Everything was fine until the biker gang showed up. Yep. Everything was fine until Nemo swims away from the reef and is captured by a scuba diver because it’s kind of like all fun and games until, you know, something like that, until something bad happens. Yeah. It’s a good way to think about it is like, okay, this is the, what you’re just saying, this is the first big disruption within the. Unknown world. This is kind of like, okay, this is where, and it’s good progress. It’s a good marker. Again, it’s, it’s, it’s all the measurements. This is means the story is moving. If when both of these examples, especially when Kim comes home, the story’s moving now, different things are happening. It’s completely, there’s a disruption to this unknown world and all that everything in this next event, close call, where things got to calm down a little bit, where you’re going to breathe a little bit, you’re going to get them probably going to get some more information.
Yeah, rules and maybe get some tools. Recovery moment. I’m glad we picked both these. These movies have good examples for these.
Adam: They really do. They really do. And I was going to say this as far as there are thresholds in each movement. End of movement three, movement four, movement five. This might be the most important movement threshold that we introduce because there’s one from act one to act two. There’s already naturally one at the end of movement one. There’s already one that naturally transitions between your overall act two and your act three. And a crisis happens in your act two, so that’s a threshold in and of itself. But this build between the beginning of act two and the crisis point, which sometimes in movies, the crisis point is delayed.
It gets pushed a little later into the movie. So it’s more like two-thirds of the way through kind of feel. It’s not necessarily your midpoint. If you do that, you even run a larger risk of the beginning of Act 2 to the crisis point sucking. It gets delayed. It gets meandering. It has no focus. The plot line goes away. With this threshold, it really is locking down a very strong signpost or beat or story turn that needs to happen in order to keep your audience engaged. Because if not, because I can tell you this before. Before I started doing more frequent thresholds like the danger zone, I would meander here from the beginning of Act 2.
Because it had interesting information or scenes, but it wasn’t threading the story. And so, this threshold is particularly important because of that. Right. For writing guidance. Not to your story. It can be a minor threshold for your story, you know. But, for you as a writer, it’s one of the best threshold tools.
Devin: They’re like rocks situated in perfect measurement to get across a raging river. Because if you don’t have a, if there’s too big of a gap between, then you could fall into the river and be swept away and never be able to find your way back to that path. That’s my analogy for that.
Adam: But I like that. The stones that are properly spaced. It’s not a bridge. They’re not connected side by side all the way across. Right. There are these stones that you just. Just hop across to make it. Yeah, they are like that. They are like that. Is there anything else you want to say about Edward?
Devin: Oh, so much. So much. But we just don’t have time today.
Adam: Oh, you sneaky dog, you. Oh, no. The conversation could go on forever and ever. Forever. However. Throughout a story, you want a character who’s going to understand themselves better and value themselves. Learn to value themselves. To maybe make the mistake, but transcend the mistake. And understand that failure. Tripping up as part of the process to learning, but ultimately to find value in themselves or their own voice, their own autonomy. And, you know, even with, with, with Edward, it’s the ensemble and Jumanji will find themselves through each other. They’ll find a sort of sense of community or belonging. But Edward, like we’ve been talking about, it’s a little bit more symbolic and, and unfortunately tragic in its theme about autonomy.
And self and sovereignty. One of the reasons we do these episodes event by event is when you listen to it, we hope it inspires you to sit down with a story you’re working on and creating and take, you know, maybe 15 minutes to free write, to play. If not, take the entire day. Work on this event in your story. Even if it’s a rough draft, write three pages. I always like to do three pages as a base for, for each of these events. So that’ll get you about where you need to be page length wise. If you’re doing a screenplay or a novel, it’s going to be a little bit more, but do take the time to do this.
And I want to encourage you all to, to value your own voice. So just like your hero valuing their themselves, value the story you have to tell and put it on paper. Don’t think no one else wants to hear what I have to say, or no one else is going to like my ideas. Have some faith in yourself and put down those three pages. By the end of this season, you’ll have a full story. If you do this bit by bit, it may not be perfect. Your first draft will never be perfect as Devin and I can both attest to. You have a unique voice. Use it, use it or lose it, use it or lose it.
What’s that? I don’t know. My coffee’s wearing off. Please subscribe and rate us on iTunes. Follow us on social media, share with your friends and send us your questions and comments. For additional resources and links to films, series, and books we talk about here, visit our website. While you’re there, sign up for our newsletter for updates on story building tools and special offers at StoryOsophy.com.