Season 2, episode 48

Crossing the First Threshold

Act 1, movement 1: Out of the comfort zoneThreshold 1: Into Unknown World

April 26, 201952 min

Show notes

Crossing the first threshold is the climax of Act 1 and the last event of Movement 1 in the Story Blueprint: the moment your hero leaves the known world for the unknown, moving from their comfort zone to out of it. Adam and Devin define what a threshold is, why change and contrast are its essential ingredients, and how a threshold guardian can test your hero on the way through.

They track the crossing through Jumanji: Welcome to the Jungle and Edward Scissorhands, with detours into Labyrinth, The NeverEnding Story, National Lampoon’s Christmas Vacation, The Wizard of Oz and the romantic comedy.

In this episode

  • What a threshold is. Think of walking through a doorway from one room into another. In a story it’s a change of environment, external, internal or both, and often a point of no return.
  • The two key elements. A measurable change or contrast between the two sides, and a decision that sets the crossing in motion.
  • Why the first threshold is usually a change, not an obstacle. It’s often simple or symbolic. The thresholds that come later, in the unknown world, are where obstacles and threshold guardians really earn their place.
  • Threshold guardians. The character, creature or force that says “you shall not pass.” They can be henchmen of the antagonist, mindless gatekeepers who later become allies, or even a mentor who refuses to help.
  • A beat of quiet before the cut. How Jumanji and Edward Scissorhands punctuate the moment of crossing to sharpen the contrast between worlds.
  • One threshold, two meanings. In Edward Scissorhands, the gate to the mansion is first a promise of adventure and, at the end, a retreat to safety: a setup and payoff built into the threshold itself.
  • A writing tip. Instead of forcing characters toward the ending you planned, ask what they would really do in the scene, including your secondary characters.

Thresholds and guardians discussed

  • Jumanji: Welcome to the Jungle: the game pulls the players in, Spencer dematerializes, and a point-of-view “spawn” drops us into the jungle.
  • Edward Scissorhands: Peg passes through the broken gate; Edward’s own crossing happens off screen, marked by a contrasting cut to the pastel suburb.
  • National Lampoon’s Christmas Vacation: the Griswolds’ front door, with the doorbell as a threshold guardian.
  • Labyrinth: Hoggle at the gates and Sir Didymus at the bridge over the Bog of Eternal Stench, who both become Sarah’s allies.
  • The NeverEnding Story: the Gmork as the voice of the Nothing, and Morla as a mentor acting as a threshold guardian.
  • Romantic comedies and dramas: the protective best friend or parent, as in The Karate Kid, The Notebook and Tangled.

Writing along with the season? This is the climax of your first act. Finish this week’s three pages and celebrate.

Read the full transcript

Transcribed automatically, so expect the odd misheard word. Sponsor messages are left out.

Adam: In this episode, we explore the story event Crossing the First Threshold. Now that your hero has agreed to go on the journey, what is the threshold from act one to act two of your story? Next on StoryOsophy. Hello, welcome to StoryOsophy. This is Adam Jones. And Devin Halden. This week, we’re going to be talking about the crossing of the first threshold. That was actually more of an eerie, like, ooh. Oh, oh, I see. I thought you were just excited. This is your climactic event of act one and movement one. For those of you who just might be tuning into us, we are, this season, breaking down structure of storytelling event by event so you can sort of understand how a story can be designed or built.

If you’re a writer, actor, director, it’s helpful to explore these things and sort of understand what you’re trying to communicate to your audience. And if you’re an audience member or a reader, it’s always fun and fascinating to see how something might be built. We sort of are like mechanics doing car talk, except we’re storytellers doing story talk. It’s true. That’s what we do. We’re breaking down structure in this season, how to assemble a Story Blueprint. And we’re right now talking about act one, which is, the known world into the unknown world of your story. Unknown world, being act two and beyond. We break these down into movements so that these are smaller chunks of acts so you can better build your obstacles and progressive complications within your story.

And movement one, our first movement, is pretty much the same as act one, although it may vary slightly. I’m sorry. Movement one goes from the comfort zone of your hero or story to out of comfort zone. Act one tends to be the foundation or essence of your piece. You’re sort of laying the groundwork for what you will reveal or peel back in terms of your characters or your story mythology later in the piece. We’ve gone through the previous events of act one up until now. If you don’t know them, you can always catch back up. We start around episode 40 or 41. There’s a Story Blueprint overview and then we break them down individually.

And those events for act one are the hook known world routine, inciting incident, call to quest, refusal of call to quest, choosal of call to quest and crossing the first threshold. And when we say crossing the first threshold, we’re talking about, we’re talking about from act one, the known world or movement one, the comfort zone into the unknown world or out of the hero’s comfort zone. So crossing the first threshold is a big deal. And there may be other thresholds throughout the piece, throughout your story. And Devin and I like to break, create more thresholds so that you can identify more change within the hero.

One word that will define thresholds is change or contrast. Change new environment, whether it’s internally or externally. That’s my contribution to this episode. Devin’s done here on your own. So let’s define a threshold, a threshold. Think of a threshold this way. When you go through a doorway, you are crossing a threshold. You’re moving from one room to another room, or you’re moving from outside of a house or a building to the inside of that building. You’re crossing its threshold in terms of story. Telling it’s the same mindset, except you don’t want to think of it. So literally when you’re structuring, even though in a lot of movies it is a literal threshold.

We talked about if you haven’t heard our Christmas vacation breakdown episode where we sort of go into depth about Christmas vacation in that the first act of second act threshold is literally the front door of the Griswold home when the older relatives enter and invade the Griswold. Clark, W Griswold’s kingdom. So if you can think of thresholds like that, it helps you to structure different spaces both emotionally, internally and externally, but it also helps your audience to identify change. It’s easier for them to identify that change. And when we talk about the crossing of the first threshold, we say first because there can be many and we usually like to build to them and by the end of a movement so that there’s track, a ball change.

But within the event of crossing the first threshold, as we’ve discussed with call to a quest and other events, there is a build to that sometimes as an approach to the threshold and approach to the gate, if you will, can be part of the experience of the climactic event of crossing a threshold.

Devin: And there’s typically a decision or a choosal before those as well,

Adam: Right?

Devin: Presented with do we continue or not? Or do we turn back?

Adam: Right?

Devin: Or give up?

Adam: And they help to framework that choice because the one previous to this is the choosal moment that helps to framework whether your hero wants to or not. But you can do thresholds in different ways. Some of them can be a gate that you have to enter. For instance, a late threshold in the Wizard of Oz is needing to convince the threshold guardian of the city of Oz to let them in. You it doesn’t have to be only at the end of your first act. It can be throughout the rest of your story too, but, but your first act is important to sort of show that delineate that difference between act one and act two.

And a lot of times it’s trying to get through a gate trying to get through a door. Sometimes you may be leaving the city that you live in comfort wise. And so when that gate or door closes, you don’t have the option of going back. And so the threshold is sort of like a point of no return. The choice is the commitment. But physically as an audience, we can see the character move to a different environment and maybe not be able to come back as is the case with something like Jumanji. And as we discussed previously, most fantasy movies where someone gets transported to a magical land, that’s a lot of what it is.

Once they’re across that threshold, it’s done there. There’s a new, a totally new mission and call for them to get back. You know, they it’s there’s no just turning around and stepping back through that threshold. You can have them be easy, simple, symbolic, like in Christmas Vacation or something that’s more intense, like in Jumanji, where they can’t turn back.

Devin: And Jumanji is actually, it actually is Wizard of Oz. If you think about it, it’s the same exact thing. It’s they find themselves.

Adam: Well, except they’re not gaining allies along the way. That’s the only difference. They start with their allies.

Devin: Yeah. In Nigel. I mean, they have, well, they’re heralds and mentors and I like to think of the rock as Dorothy. Yeah. Blue dress change is good. So I think if we’re looking at like the key elements of threshold change, of course, or contrast from one side to the other. Yeah. In both Jumanji and Edward Scissorhands, there’s a definite contrast in visual and aesthetics, but it doesn’t necessarily need to be visually an aesthetic contrast. It’s just, there’s a, a measurable difference in some way. And then there’s a, in order to pass it, there’s a decision. It’s a decision point. This is kind of like the signpost moment where it’s like, we can go left, right, straight or turn back and all of them would be different thresholds.

Adam: Yeah. They, they do vary some of the options like we’ve just laid out, but we also want to talk about there. There’s an archetype that gets highlighted here. The threshold guardian.

Devin: Ooh, yeah.

Adam: You can choose to have, a threshold guardian in the scene or not in the scene, even though there’s a threshold that may be there, but what the benefit of a threshold guardian, there’s several, but one of the, one of the primary ones is they challenge your hero. They stop your hero from moving forward. And it may be the point as Devin was saying, where they test your hero and they say, okay, you know what? I can’t do this. I got to turn around. And maybe their allies or their team says, no, no, no, you have to, we have to do this once again, right before the threshold call, refusal, choosal, and they can be a willing hero and try to challenge the threshold guardian and go through these events, sort of repeat themselves.

Threshold guardians pose it. They’re basically a character that says you shall not go any further. That’s it. And does your hero have the gall or the bravery to say, that’s not true, or I disagree with that, or I’m going to go through this door anyway. Do they have the assertiveness and confidence within the journey to be able to do that in the act one, this first threshold, sometimes they might take a little prodding. It might take a mentor pushing them along. It might take, like I say, them being shut out of the city shunned ostracized for them to be forced to make that decision. Although they’ve been forced across the threshold, it’s sort of, it’s a variance on it.

You know, the outcast, if you will, threshold guardians are interesting. Labyrinth has several most fantasy movies, or even in Jumanji where there’s the video game aspect laid across the whole thing. Video games are full of threshold guardians. They’re your mini bosses, right? If you’re thinking in video game language, they’re your mini bosses before you get to the big boss. With that being said, they’re also the extensions of your antagonist or forces of antagonism in Jumanji. The main reason why I’m talking about the Jumanji is because the mythology, although we’ve not gotten to it within the course of the story yet in Jumanji, Russell Van Pelt, who’s the villain of the story, has stolen the green gem from the Jaguar statue in Jumanji in the jungle.

And what it allows him to do is have control and command over all of the creatures in Jumanji. So all of the animals that are sort of crazy and violent and vicious, the danger of Jumanji. Of Jumanji in the jungle are extensions of the villain. And a lot of films will do it that way, where your threshold guardians are. And this one doesn’t really have a full threshold guardian, although you might be able to argue that the gaming system itself is, or that the hippo that first eats Bethany is, but they’re not really obvious ones in Labyrinth. Hoggle, who guards the gates to Labyrinth is a threshold guardian and Sarah has to ask.

The right question in order to get into Labyrinth. And she, she finally says, how do I get into Labyrinth? And he goes, ah, and turns around and he can answer that. That’s the, that’s the riddle she has to solve later on. She meets her Didymus who guards the bridged across the Bog of Eternal Stench. And he is again, another threshold guardian. And he fights Ludo and they get passage because enough Ludo’s really brave and they conquer him by. Using the vow that he’s given as ludicrous. She says, what was the vow that you took in order to guard this threshold? And he’s like, none shall pass without my permission.

And so she says, it’s your favorite quote. He’s one of my favorite characters in cinema history. I love Sir. Didymus cause he’s, he’s brave without any reason. He’s just like this little thing. Who’s like, so fierce. But so they, they asked, she asked him, may we have your permission? And he thinks on it for a little while because he’s always been fighting people. He’s never actually been asked and he’s been fighting people off. And so that’s it. That’s the riddle. All she had to do was ask him, can we have your permission? And he goes, yes. He’s not sure if that’s the right answer or not.

He may be some sort of extension of the Goblin King in Labyrinth, but it’s sort of mindless. He just knows he’s supposed to do this task and do this. I bring up those two specifically for this. Reason. These are not enemies, but these are obstacles for Sarah to begin with. And after she’s done sort of overcoming that obstacle, they become her allies. It’s similar to a, although you might not call them threshold, the Wizard of Oz. When she meets her three allies, they’re not necessarily thresholds, but they are obstacles or problems that she must overcome. And then they become her allies. Threshold guardians are interesting. They can either be hardcore, heavy-handed extensions, henchmen, of the villain, or they can sort of be like we’re saying a mindless soldier in the, the, you know, or mindless gatekeeper in Labyrinth and, and become your ally.

Devin: Or they can be, they don’t necessarily have to be a creature or human character. They can be like the Oracle, Southern Oracle and The NeverEnding Story. That’s an obstacle in the way of the real threshold guardian, which is the Wolf. What’s the Wolf’s name in that? The Gmork. Gmork.

Adam: G M O R K. Gmork. I don’t know why it’s Gmork or no GM G M O R G. I don’t remember what it is. It’s either Gmork or Gmork. It’s G M O R K.

Devin: Is it Gmork? Cause he’s essentially the threshold guardian in the film and the nothing is the antagonist. Well, it’s actually, see, that’s, it’s an interesting analysis force of antagonism and then,

Adam: And then a materialized antagonist in its own way,

Devin: Right? The real antagonist is. The nothing. I would say it’s the loss of imagination or whatever. That’s fueling the nothing,

Adam: But that’s what the nothing is. The nothing swallowing up imagination, right? That’s what it’s doing, right? It is. And then Sebastian is supposed to reimagine at the end of the story. So it symbolizes in a way that’s supernatural, something, an idea,

Devin: Right? Cause it’s either, is it swallowing it up or is it becoming stronger because of the loss of people? Like the swamp of, was it Swamps of Sadness when he’s like, he’s telling his horse when Atreyu, who’s telling our texts is like, don’t give up and don’t let it defeat you. And so it’s kind of the, that nothing is,

Adam: I feel like it’s consuming because they, they sort of talk about how it’s overcoming the lane. Like it’s, it’s a consuming force.

Devin: It’s interesting. I’ve actually never really thought of it.

Adam: Like it’s, it’s sort of eating up everything. And I agree with that. Even when the, with the rock biter and his friends get swept away, storm, like, like in a tornado, they get pulled away.

Devin: Yeah. Because it’s getting more powerful. Yeah.

Adam: Yeah. In not identifying it and creating this force, that sort of inexplicable you allow for the idea of imagination going away or imagination being consumed one way or the other for the audience to infer what the nothing is about. It’s, it’s more philosophical because it’s not tangible. It’s sort of slowly, well, in my mind, slowly swallowing things up, but then you’ve got the Gmork. That’s, that’s a physical thing that’s hunting Atreyu down because he’s the, he’s the possible savior that can fix it or he’s on the quest to do it. And so the nothing, yeah, whether it’s, and it’s not clear whether the nothing creates the Gmork or what the Gmork is just part of the, is a creature that’s sort of in league with the nothing.

Like you don’t really get any sort of,

Devin: He kind of explains it, doesn’t he? When they finally face off with each other. Yeah. I can’t remember what they say.

Adam: I can’t remember what he says. Yeah, me either. But it’s, it’s, I, isn’t it that he’s, he’s created by. Yeah, I think he was. The fear of the lack or the, well, the point is. Point is watch that movie. It’s awesome. Even, so let’s say either way that nothing is consuming it or feeding off of it. The Gmork is more of a, it’s, I mean, a scary dark storm. That’s pretty scary. But if you are physically confronted with that Gmork, which is terrifying looking thing, it’s almost like a step up. It’s, it’s a little more predatory in its pursuit of Atreyu. It’s not just generally taking out the land, like the nothing.

It’s specifically there to, to hunt him down. Am I right? Or am I just making stuff up?

Devin: No, it makes, it makes sense. He touched on a point too. The importance of it is the nothing itself, like this, this storm or this cloud, this, this nothingness, this darkness is scary. And it’s in and of itself because it’s, it’s consuming stuff. Yeah. Very elegant way to put it, but for, for story purposes to make something tangible and something that has eyes and can speak like adds another layer of evil and scariness to that. And so it’s, it’s great that the Gmork is a character in here because the Gmork is also the voice of the nothing. Yeah. That’s a valid point too. Without him, it would just be an interpretation.

People, maybe hearsay or people trying to translate what this is and what’s happening. But with the Gmork is I can tell you exactly this is what, this is what the nothing is. And this is why it’s becoming stronger and stronger. And this is why you, you won’t be able to stop it because it’s, you’re at a point where it’s so strong and powerful.

Adam: He’s sort of a final threshold guardian in his own way. The Gmork.

Devin: Yeah. Definitely.

Adam: You, they also leave him until much later in the story. They start out with this mythology of the nothing. And, and we don’t really know what it’s all about. Everyone’s concerned. They don’t really know what’s happening and it grows and grows and people learn. We learn more a little, a little bit more about it, but out of the nothing that we start seeing this charging Gmork in like these quick shots and we don’t really understand what it is. And then when we finally meet the Gmork, it actually talks to us and tells us what the nothing is. So this whole mysterious storm that’s, you know, left to interpretation, it defines it near the end.

So we leave the mystery of it and not defining it until it has a voice and is a reveal in its own way.

We’re always willing to venture off into The NeverEnding Story. And for me, Labyrinth, I love Labyrinth. I love the symbol, symbol,

Devin: Symbolism, symbolism, the symbolism of Atreyu. You almost, when the Gmork is hunting him and he saved by Falkor. And it’s the, it’s that symbolism of a tree. You, you almost being lost to the darkness and then this white is white and dark that good and evil, you know, we find saves only saves them at the last minute. And so that’s like that perfect, you know, the almost black and white light and dark good evil. It’s like that huge contrast.

Adam: Oh man. I remember as a kid too, that that just, but just having those two things side by side, I remember watching it as a kid and you’re, you’re so into that moment. I know. It’s, it’s so intense, so intense. And the music is great. The thing is storming towards them and you’re like, no, no, no. Cause you’re, you’re already busted up over what’s the name of the source. Artax, Artax are, we should have prepared for this episode.

I don’t remember. So, but it’s Artax. Is it okay? Oh, you don’t believe me. Well, I’m not sure we were trying with the Gmork. Well, I, I was pretty straightforward that I didn’t know the name of that guy, but, but that, that moment’s really intense because you’ve got this thing charging towards them and you’ve just seen, you’re sort of set up with the death of Artax to it’s rough. You know, you’re as a kid, you’re like, no, what was his horse? Yeah. And then this thing’s about to get him. And you’re like, no, no, no. And then Falkor comes and we don’t know what it is, but something saves him.

And we’re like, and you get to see the white of Falkor versus as you’re saying, the dark of the Gmork as it leaps out to grab him and it misses. And we’re just like, Oh, thank God. It’s sort of like if we had tracked The NeverEnding Story through events, it’s the crisis and close call, or, or maybe it’s a little, it, well, it’s a variation on that because we’re dealing with a dark night of the soul or all is lost event in the bogs of, I was going to say bogs of eternal stench. I’m mixing my fantasy metaphors and the sadness swamp Swamps of Sadness, whatever the heck it’s called.

What is it called? The never, The NeverEnding Story Swamps of Sadness. It’s been a while since I’ve seen it.

Devin: It’s, and we have the same reaction as bastion does in that. But when he gets saved too, it’s like, Oh, it’s just like collapses.

Adam: Exactly. Cause he represents the audience. Exactly. In, in that before they get to the Swamps of Sadness, there’s your, you don’t really get a threshold guardian per se. You sort of are changing environments. One of the things about an adventure or a fantasy story is, is you’re going to change spots on your map as you journey through your map. And each new quote section of the map is a different environment. So prior to that, you could consider yourself crossing a threshold into that new environment. Even if there’s not a threshold guardian or a specific crossing the threshold moment. Once you’re into that space, that new space, you may encounter an extension of the force of antagonism that still is pretty much a threshold guardian.

Like, what’s the big turtle’s name in the Swamps of Sadness?

Devin: Morla. Morla.

Adam: That’s sort of a threshold guardian, even though you’re really seeking them out as a mentor to get their advice on how to stop the nothing and where to go and what to do. They’re not being helpful. And so that’s a situation where you would combine the mentor and the threshold guardian into one being. They’re supposed to be a mentor, but they’re being a threshold guardian to be in a pain in the butt. The fantasy movies. It’s a lot. It’s a lot easier to, to point out your thresholds.

Devin: Right.

Adam: Sci-fi too. Whether if you’re leaving on a ship to go off and some mission into space, when you’re on your home planet, that’s ordinary world. That’s first act. And when you get them to the ship and you cross that threshold and take off, it’s into a different space.

Devin: If you’re looking for a marker in your story, the best way to identify it is how are the movements characterized from comfort zone out of comfort, out of comfort zone. The minute you throw them out, out of the comfort zone, you know that you’ve crossed a threshold. So maybe once you’re like, Oh, well he’s, he’s out of his comfort zone. If you’re doing a rom-com, yeah, you can do a rom-com. You’re like, wow, he’s way out of his comfort zone. I should. Now I know that he crossed a threshold. Have I utilized this, this moment to the, to the best of the story? Like, can I add some things here that make this, you know, a little bit more important or shy, had a threat, threshold guardian before just throwing them into the comfort zone.

Should there, you know, so there’s, if you can identify when your story has crossed these, well, every event really, once you’ve identified what these events, you know, you, the event is occurring in your story, the refusal or the call to cause refusal, choosal, and then this threshold, then you can always go back and strengthen what happens there, or even add characters, add a threshold guardian where it makes it a little more interesting for them to cross that.

Adam: Let’s say it is a rom-com and let’s say this, a guy meets a girl. He knows where she works, but he doesn’t know anything else about her. The only way he’s going to be able to meeting her and all that, that’s the inciting incident call to adventure is he can’t stop thinking about her. So he wants to go and sort of find her. If he were to go into her place of business, let’s say she’s a business professional goes into her office. There may be a secretary or someone in the lobby who fields, fields, people just coming in random people or a security guard at the front office.

That w can I see your ID or do you have an appointment? And whatever this conversation is with this seemingly insignificant person, because they’re not really part of this guy’s journey, except he needs to get past them to go and meet this girl or whatever the, the conversation they have of, do you have an appointment? Well, no. Well, you need an appointment. Like unless you, obviously you’re too dumb to have understood that you make an appointment before you come here. There’s this whole subtext with the way they do it. This interaction of crossing the threshold. Once they’re in the unknown world, they managed to get into the office.

Now their self esteem is shot. They may have worked themselves up to get to that point, but trying to cross that threshold, that person may have belittled them. There’s a nice reversal bit that you can have in the crossing of a threshold from where that person is before to what it takes to cross that threshold. And the way they react to the world after the fact. So like I said, the threshold guardian can highlight some stuff for your hero.

Devin: There’s different types of thresholds too. So I think the, I think the unknown world thresholds are more of obstacles than this very first threshold, which is more of like a change. Yeah. You can have where, you know, stories where they’re in this particular threshold, this very first threshold, you could have a, they choose the call. All right, we’re ready now in order to get, get into the unknown world. There’s there’s there is an obstacle. So let’s say you can still, I just, perhaps if you’re, if we’re trying to analyze or characterize thresholds a little bit, the more obstacle ones, the ones that have obstacles are probably past this one.

And this one’s more of a change or a bump,

Adam: Like you said. Yeah, I would agree with that. The first one is more symbolic and it’s also, you can have it be stark as we’ll show you in Jumanji. Welcome to the jungle and Edward Scissorhands. Yeah. Sometimes they show the crossing. A threshold. But the point is even if they don’t and it’s off screen, you sh you see that the contrast between act one, the known world and act two, the unknown world,

Devin: Because they’ve already shown an Edward scissor hands. They already showed it to us at one point. It’s just not necessarily at the crossing threshold, right? We just know that they’d crossed that threshold again.

Adam: And I think you’re right in saying that usually this crossing of the first threshold, it doesn’t have a threshold guardian guardian. Most of the time, I would say most of the time, every once in a while, you, you can do it. I wouldn’t discourage people from, from doing it or trying it, but most of the time it’s not, it’s adding more to the equation than needs to be there. When threshold show up throughout the journey in the unknown world, threshold guardians become more interesting. There’s a challenge there. There’s a riddle maybe to get through the door or taking that example that I just was talking about with this person trying to get into an office.

Maybe they it’s after the boy meets girl, boy loses girl. And we’re in the place where boy gets girl back between boy loses girl and boy gets girl back. So he’s trying to go and see them. You’ll see this in a lot of rom-coms actually. And there’s a best friend or a protective entity. Yeah. That will not let that person see them. And so that’s a threshold guardian. Big one for him. It’s actually, that’s probably the biggest staple of a romantic comedy threshold. Guardian the protector of the vulnerable party.

Devin: Yep. The best friend, best friend or parents friend, or the dad, she’s not here right now, son karate kids got a bunch. Yeah.

Adam: It’s, you know, it’s, it’s someone protecting in a weird way. It’s someone protecting one of the major characters during their all is lost fall, the heart wall moments. There’s just this guardian of them to the other person.

Devin: They don’t need to directly confront or get in the way of like physically get in the way of the hero. It like in the case of in karate kid, when the dad, dad just tells her, you can’t see him anymore or even the notebook. You know, the mom is a good threshold guardian in the notebook. If you want to stick on romcoms where it’s, you can’t see him anymore. It was just summer love. You can’t see him anymore. And so even though they, the father has confronted Noah a couple of times throughout the story, it’s her mother is the true threshold guardian. And it’s like trying their best to keep them away or keep them away from each other.

Wow. It just jumped into the notebook.

Adam: Yeah. I’m still trying to figure out how you classify the notebook as a rom-com. What is that classified as? Drama, drama. Yeah. Even on the reverse of that, without someone being the warning entity of you cannot do this. You may have someone who’s going to the apartment, the house, knock on the door, the threshold to make amends. And someone stands in the doorway with a door, partially ajar, having a community, a conversation, which is closed. It’s, it’s not open cocktail. They’re barely given this person information and they’re blocking entry, both emotionally, communication wise and physically from entering to be able to, you know, do that.

And of course you’ve got the, the romantic comedies where the person is like, okay. And they drop their head and walk away. Or you’ve got the one where it’s like, maybe this person is being held prisoner because of an overbearing, overprotective person, like tangled. So, and so I’m coming. And they push, they push the door open and burst through the threshold.

[Sponsor message]

Adam: We’re getting a little far into stories regarding thresholds, but we want to sort of differentiate between this first threshold and how they manifest throughout the rest of your story. Most of the time, threshold guardians show up later in the story and the first threshold doesn’t need to be something that’s a huge challenge to your hero. It doesn’t have to be something they have to overcome necessarily. It just has to be something they cross to get into movement to change. Yeah. And then they can become more complicated decision change. Sometimes you won’t even show the crossing of the threshold. Edward doesn’t except for Peg and her short story.

The intro of the movie walking into Edward’s territory, that’s crossing a threshold and notice she walks through a broken down gate. She walks through this giant looming castles door Avon calling she. So she’s got these thresholds that she crosses. But as we were talking about in previous episodes with, with Edward Scissorhands her, the whole first act is Peg short story. It’s for us to understand the normal world and then be introduced to the outcast of Edward. And so she’s got her own little pieces here and there, but the real crossing of the threshold is off screen for that. And then you have something like Jumanji that embraces it.

It’s a big event.

Devin: Should we just get into the, yeah,

Adam: Let’s get into examples. So we’ve given enough examples of everything other than our two tracking stories. So why not?

We’ll start with the, as usual Jumanji welcome to the jungle. I, this has got a pretty sensationalized crossing of the threshold. I mean, they choose the video game, they press start the Jumanji drums come up and actually Nigel says, first welcome to Jumanji when they press start. And so we know they’re already entering whatever this thing is, right? Welcome to Jumanji is him saying it’s not a threshold guardian, but he’s a threshold Herald at that point. Jumanji drums start happening and everyone starts freaking out a little bit. The machine starts glowing that green that we’re familiar with. And Spencer tries to stop it. He’s banging the console.

He thinks it’s overheating. They suggest to unplug it. He unplugs it. And the, the cord itself starts sparking. And then Spencer starts to dematerialize Spencer. Dematerializing to me is the crossing of the crossing of threshold. The build to that is them trying to stop this momentum from happening that they cannot stop. Each one of them gets sucked into that video game, crossing that threshold in there in this very, they’re all terrified. So it’s, this is not a fun crossing of the threshold. This is a horrific crossing of the threshold for them. And then we pick up with a point of view of someone sliding through leaves, jungle foliage.

And we’re like, what in the heck is going on? The same thing that they would think in their circumstance, what is going on? And that person slides down and drops. So the first thing they show us in the unknown world, and this is all crossing the threshold is something we will never see again. But they give us the point of view of it, which is spawning or respawning. Once you die in the video game, you descend from the heavens and land on the ground. So they show you this from a point of view, because they’re not going to show you that again, they show it to you from somewhat a dot in the sky and it falls to the ground from here on out, but they can afford because you don’t know where they are or what’s going on.

They can afford to show the spawning moment in the video game as a POV, which is kind of a smart move.

Devin: Yeah. I like that.

Adam: And then as soon as that hits the ground,

Devin: But boom,

Adam: And you’re, you’re standing there with the first shot of the rock with his hand on his knee. That’s where I would say the crossing of the threshold stops because everybody else just pops in. We don’t get to see them enter. We literally just get to see it through Spencer’s point of view. But to me, that’s the crossing of the threshold from when the machine starts acting up to right when the rock, I’m gonna call him the rock forever. Can’t help it.

Devin: No, you’re right. And it has all of the key elements of crossing. Yeah. That’s the crossing of a threshold that has the contrast. There’s a difference and an aesthetic. It’s visual. We can see there’s an obvious, we’re in an obviously different place than that dreary cobwebby basement of the school we were just in. And now we’re, we’re here. So there’s the, there’s a change. There’s a contrast. Green and lush, right? There was a decision that was made that initiated this crossing of the threshold. And so we’ve now we’re entered into this, this, this unknown world and in Jumanji here and in very actually similar to Edward Scissorhands that we’ll get to the crossing of the threshold is, is it’s not as drastic in Edward Scissorhands, but there’s a, there’s a, a very different look between where we were in the known world to now where, where we are in the unknown world.

In contrast to what Adam brought up earlier with Christmas vacation, that there really isn’t, everything looks the same, but it feels different. There’s a measurable difference.

Adam: In Christmas vacation, they use the doorbell as the threshold guardian where they hear the doorbell and goes ding dong. Right. And then as we cut to each member of the family, it goes ding dong, like it’s this foreboding thing. And it’s just a sound, but it literally is a variation on a threshold guardian, which is super effective. But yeah, Jumanji is, is great because there is this similarity between it and Edward Scissorhands, that gray, detention room, depressing, no sunlight. And then you’re in this bright, vibrant, green jungle foliage, and you’re in fast motion. You’re just moving. You’re moving. You’re moving. And it’s not static. The interesting thing is in both of these movies, there’s a punctuation right at the moment.

And then they cut to the next world. I don’t remember what the last thing fridge says before. He’s the last one to get zapped into the game in the detention room. And I don’t remember exactly what he says, but, and he did deer dematerializes into the video game. And then it goes and it’s quiet. And we get this wide shot of the video game with just a little green glow. Like it’s done. It’s sucked them all in. It’s done, but there’s a quiet for a moment. And then we’re rushing through leaves in the jungle. So there’s this really punctuated moment where we’re all getting sucked in quiet.

And then excitement again. Yep. And Edward Scissorhands sort of uses the same mode of, you should just come home with me. Boop. She nods quiet. And you’re in the colorful world. So notice that there is this really, whether it’s a little subtle when Edward Scissorhands or in Jumanji, this silence, there’s a punctuation moment, which sets up the contrast, right? It’s like the fulcrum bar between the two places.

Devin: But what I love about the Edward Scissorhands threshold is we watch in Peg’s, mini story. We watch her cross. The main threshold is, is her, the car going over the broken gate that actually goes onto his property. And then her going through that gate in the yard with all the sculpted bushes and stuff. What’s great about that is that’s we know we don’t have to show them coming back and knowing that now Edward we’re moving Edward from his known world to his unknown world. Right. Because we’ve, we’ve already shown them the threshold. We are showing the audience what the threshold is.

Adam: There’s no reason for them to walk down the stairs from the attic all the way through the house. Back to the car. We don’t need any of that. Right. You’re, you’re being selective with what you’re showing for dramatic effect.

Devin: And what I love about that threshold is what it represents to Edward, where Edward is in his known world and he believes he wants to be down there. He wants to be in that town. He wants to be with those people because he’s seen them in magazines or he’s seen what he believes is down there in the magazine. So he thinks the grass is greener down there. And so he wants him crossing that threshold. It’s him believing he’s going to something better or a better place. And then what happens to him throughout the film, he just runs back to get across, get back across that threshold.

And he knows that he’s just, this is where he belongs. He belongs in, in this mansion. He perhaps belongs. He can’t be with Kim, you know, so he has to be, but it’s really beautiful what that, that threshold means to, to Edward. And it’s, it’s, it’s very, it’s a special, it’s a special threshold. I think then some other movies, you know, of course there’s always this road back. Yeah. Of course there’s always this road back, but it’s usually when you go back, the world is better or it’s a, it’s a different place, but it’s better. And you’re a better person. And Edward is, is just more knowledgeable about what that town is and who those people are instead of, and goes back to his same place.

Cause that’s where he, he wants to be and then create snow, obviously. But that’s, that threshold, that threshold is such an important character. The threshold is an important character in the, in the film because that’s like his, it’s safety for him.

Adam: You know, I was going to say that too. The, the first time it’s the promise of hope. It’s the promise of adventure for him. He’s excited. And the next time he encounters that gate, it’s a retreat to safety. So that it, the same threshold from the first, that first threshold at the end of the movie means something completely different. And that’s a really, really brilliant and effective way to use a threat that’s set up and pay off. We talk about it all the time. You, you’ve created that isolated space behind that gate to the, the Gothic mansion. And it leads outward as much as it leads inward, you know, back to safety.

It’s a really good point. D.

Devin: Yeah. I just keep analyzing Edward Scissorhands. I’m like, man, it’s just beautiful. It’s a powerful, it’s a powerful story, but the simplicity of it, it’s really not as simple as, you know, simple as it, as it appears on the, on the, on the surface, on the surface. It’s just, it’s a funny, and it can be,

Adam: It’s the whole story upside down. It uses these things in a straight way, but then it takes the same event, flips it on its head and uses the converse of it in the same event. Right, right, right. Yeah. That doesn’t make much sense now, but I was just thinking about this and rules and tools. And it’s sort of like Edward showing up at the house and the dinner scene with the, with bill the first time he’s like, so Ed, what’s it like up there on that Hill? Good view, huh? And we’re trying to show Edward doesn’t get rules and tools. Really? He gets an outfit from Peg, but it’s more about showing that Edward does not have the rule, the tools that he needs for this world.

That’s the whole point is he’s lacking them the whole movie. And so we don’t give him tools really, except for to fit in like clothes and stuff. And anyway, this is a rules and tools conversation, but I thought of that last night. I caught that and I was like, you, sons of bitches.

Devin: Like it’s, they’re so smart. Well, his rules and tools is actually a flashback to when the inventor is reading him. Like, like you’re saying like those, that old English etiquette books. And like, so he’s trying to equip him with the rules and tools that he would need to, to live a life down there. But then he dies and he can’t finish. He can’t finish him. So he can’t finish him, finish giving him the tools, which would be hands. And he can’t finish him giving him the knowledge.

Adam: Well, and even at the same time, he’s not really, he’s not equipping him well, because this guy is a social, he’s a hermit too. Right. Social recluse. So he’s like, he’s giving him the rules. Isn’t this a clever poem? And it’s like, that’s not giving him any tools to survive in this. But anyway, we’re getting into rules and tools, but you and I both know this man rules and tools. That’s one of those things that you can sort of go rules and tools, part one, two, three, four, and scatter it throughout your movie.

Devin: Right.

Adam: Because it’s useful in that way.

Devin: And that’s, that’s one of those important elements of story of the story that, or event events that you can, is really important to understand what, what does my character need at this moment? Which also translates into what does the audience need to know about the rules and tools of this world right now? So that’s another one of those just to be cognizant of.

Adam: And also asking yourself moment to moment, what would my character, do here instead of going, I’m going to make them do this,

Devin: Right? Yeah.

Adam: Ask yourself logically with they’re in this situation, what would they do? Because if you’re trying to think of, well, I want to make this scene like this, so they’re going to have to do this in order to do, you’re going to limit yourself. But if you ask, what are the many ways they could approach what’s going on in this scene, you’ve now opened your mind up to find better material to mine, better moments from that situation. You want to ask yourself, what does the audience need to know here and now? And what is the character? What does the character really do? Or what are they, what should they do next?

A lot of times when writing you, you’re trying to make a story happen because you have some preconceived, you came up with one idea. That’s a great ending and you’re driving the story to that ending. But because you’re so rigid about that ending, you’re compartmentalizing or pigeonholing things into a cliche, into something that is limiting, limiting what you could be doing with that story. And so always, even after you’ve written a scene, you think the scene’s done, go back and go now, let’s think of this logically and go, if, if they were standing here doing this, how would they really respond? And if you’re not getting anything new for your hero, do it with your secondary characters, because you could add life to that scene just by inquiring about their perspective.

And then, and their choices because you may have neglected it, driving your hero through that scene.

Devin: And don’t solve it by just throwing a tool in their hand. It’s, it’s really more about the character and who they are and what they need to do to overcome these internal obstacles. Cause then you can’t cause you can get lazy. You can, you can get lazy when you’re the one creating the rules and tools. But if you can actually, like you’re saying, Adam, that’s really, it’s actually a very good point is to understand what your character is and what they, what they need at that moment to get past this obstacle. And, and make it difficult still where it’s more of, maybe it’s more of a intelligent, instead of like a gun, shooting a gun and taking a gun and shooting a threshold guardian.

Maybe it’s a way where they retreat and they come up with a very clever plan to get around the threshold guardian. I don’t know how we got on rules and tools, but well, it’s important because they’re kind of, you think they could show up here actually. So,

Adam: And sometimes depending on your story, like if you’re, if you’re in a spy movie, James Bond, something like that, you, you will sometimes choose to go on the adventure and then you’ll go and meet Q who will give you all of the equipment you’re going to need for that mission. And then you embark on the mission. Now that’s not, I would say usually the case, but in some situations like that, you want the setup of the rules and tools to come in between choosal and threshold. So you forget about them. So you’ve got James Bond puts it on his pockets and then we’re off and we start the journey.

And then as a result, you’re like, and then as we get through, it’s like, he’s in a situation at all. Of course, he’s got that wristwatch that shoots darts getting, getting back to Edward Scissorhands, the threshold itself here, it’s all screen,

Devin: Right?

Adam: The crossing of the threshold is really off screen. It’s you could call it him traveling back in a town, but I would consider that first day of school reaction to the unknown world, you know, his response to that. But what’s funny is if you did try to, if you did treat that as crossing the threshold, the threshold guardian, our windows in the vehicle,

Devin: Right?

Adam: He’s so enamored with the kids on the slip and slide and people, it’s just so much excitement. He tries to point and ends up hitting the glass and bumping his face on the glass threshold. Guardian is he wants to get out of the car and go play. And he keeps running into the windows. So if you did have to categorize that moment as crossing the threshold, the windows would be the threshold guardian for Edward, but that’s anyway, that’s a unique way of looking at it. I would say the threshold happens. Off-screen I would agree, but the contrast from gray attic to even though they’re pastel, the colorful suburban neighborhood just showing that, you know, Peg Peg nods, her head and drops out of screen.

And then we’re in the car with, and it’s just, I mean, it’s an instant laugh because she nods you’re coming with me. And then we see him like just totally fish out of water, sitting in a passenger seat with his scissors. And she’s like, drive it along. I’m like, it’s funny. It’s really funny joke. Yeah. So in lieu of the threshold, it has this contrasting cut, which is very funny. This is it. This is the climax of your act. One folks. So StoryOsophers, this is if you’ve been listening and you’ve been doing your three pages a week, you’re almost on your first act. You write your three pages for this week’s episode, crossing the first threshold and you have your first act and you should celebrate.

Yeah. You should celebrate yourself, pat yourself on the back and get in and celebrate your accomplishments as you go. Because writing a story, writing a script, writing a novel, it’s, it’s a long haul. It’s not always a, you know, it’s not a sprint. That’s right. You got to pace yourself. So you get an act and it looks tidy and it looks good. And, and even if it looks okay, continue writing. Now is not the time to really go back and completely fix your act one. If you know you can go back and cut it down, you can see edits by all means. Once you get further into your, your story and your script, you’ll go back to this as Devin and I say, and refine it many times.

I mean, hopefully not too much, but enough to streamline your story. So celebrate the fact that after these three pages this week, and hopefully you’ve gained enough from this one in the variety of threshold guardians, you can try different things with how you want to write your story. And you want to bring your, your character or characters from the first act, the known world into the second act, the unknown world, or most important to consider with this specific threshold from the comfort zone to out of comfort zone. That’s it. Please subscribe and rate us on iTunes. Follow us on social media, share with your friends and send us your questions and comments.

For additional resources and links to films, series and books we talk about here, visit our website, while you’re there, sign up for our newsletter for updates on story, building tools and special offers at StoryOsophy.com.

Where this episode sits in the Story BlueprintPick any event on the curve to hear its episode.