Show notes
Acts are the largest divisions of a story, and the classic three-act model has become Hollywood’s formula. The trouble is the middle: Act 2 is half the story, and it often becomes “the muddle instead of the middle.” In this episode Adam and Devin peel back the layers of a story like an onion, from acts to movements to events to scenes, and preview the six-movement structure they’ll build on for the rest of the season.
In this episode
- Definitions. A crisis is a decision point, a fork in the road; the word also names the turning point of an illness, toward recovery or death. “Climax” comes from the Greek for ladder: a steep climb at the end.
- The onion. Acts are the outer layer; beneath them are movements, then events, then scenes. Zoom in and out between the layers as you write.
- Act 1 is too long. The classic model gives it 25 pages. Adam says you have 15: give the audience the premise and the hero’s essence, then send them on their journey.
- Start with character. Building the software’s character module, Devin realized that once you know your hero and antagonist, their flaws and goals, the story starts to tell itself.
- Keep climbing. Most story-arc diagrams end with “falling action,” back on the same plane. Devin sees the hero climbing to a higher plateau, fighting not to slide back. In a TV series, each episode starts from the last one’s plateau.
- Audiences are sophisticated. They spot formulas and predict them. Instead of fixing their stories, studios turned to spectacle. The best of the Marvel films use technology to serve the story.
- A Rube Goldberg machine. Every piece of a story has its own objective, obstacle and outcome. If one piece fails, the machine stops, and you lose your audience.
- Decision points and thresholds. Devin: a plot point is the choice presented; a threshold is the choice taken, a change in the character or the world. Repeat Act 1’s rhythm every 15 pages, from hook and status quo to decision, debate and threshold, and you’ll keep the story moving.
- Thresholds needn’t be beaded curtains. They can be subtle doorways or open-plan rooms.
- Five acts, four acts. Shakespeare’s five acts ran exposition, complications, climax, falling action and catastrophe. A four-act structure puts the crisis in the middle.
- Six movements. Adam treats a 90-minute feature as two 45-minute episodes, with a cliffhanger crisis in the middle. Comfort zone to out of comfort zone; out of comfort zone to danger zone; danger zone to crisis; crisis to recovery; recovery to climax; climax to resolution.
Examples discussed
- Star Wars: the infiltration of the Death Star, which ends in the trash compactor, as a midpoint crisis.
- Also: The Hobbit and The Lord of the Rings returning to the Shire, and Christopher Vogler’s approach to the inmost cave.
Next: a closer look at each movement, starting with Movement 1.
Read the full transcript
Transcribed automatically, so expect the odd misheard word. Sponsor messages are left out.
Adam: In this episode, we discuss acts and movements. How can you use movements to break down that daunting act two? What are the differences between three, four, and five act structures? Next, on StoryOsophy. Welcome to StoryOsophy. This is Adam Jones. And Devin Halden. This week, we are talking about acts. Which are larger divisions of the story you’re telling. And we’re going to define sort of what acts are about and what they’re made up of. What’s inside them. Decision points or plot points. And thresholds. So those two things I think are the primary ingredients to, at the base level, an act. Before we get too far, I want to do some definitions.
Because they’re always, it’s a good place to start. So we’re all on the same page. We know what we’re talking about.
Devin: Excuse me.
Adam: Bless all of you who have stayed with us from season one. So anyway, as you know, StoryOsophers, we like to throw definitions out at the beginning so that we can understand what we’re talking about. Acts are a main division of a play, ballet, or opera. That’s really the classic definition. A more modern definition expands to usually filmed media like television or feature films. Within that, what makes up an act, as we talked about last episode, we were talking about scenes and sequences. And they sort of build acts. Larger pieces. When we get further into this, we’re going to explain a three-act structure. Which is your classic feature film structure.
And even a four-act and a five-act structure. And then sort of talk about what Devin and I believe are advancements or modernizations, building a new model so that storytelling can evolve. What we think about those acts and how they function. So before we get too far into it, I just wanted to say the, the, some of the major events of the story, this beginning, middle, end, the middle is sort of the crisis based on what, how Devin and I will approach this. And the end would be the climax into a resolution. But as always, I found some really interesting stuff when looking through the definitions. Crisis, which would be sort of your midpoint of your story, is a time of intense difficulty, trouble, or danger.
Now, interesting enough, that’s more of a medical end of the spectrum for, as far as an, an, an action or story-wise. The second one is the end of the spectrum. The second definition is really what was applying was a time when a difficult or important decision must be made or a decision point, where you’re posing some situation where your character has to choose between some, one thing or another, a sort of fork in the path, which is really part of the individual part of an act, but also the overarch of a story.
Your midpoint, huge. But it doesn’t have to be built out of danger. It just can simply be a very strong decision point where it forks. In certain genres, it will be horror, action, the ones that are more physically driven. There’ll be physical danger or, psychological danger. So crisis, the third definition, the turning point of a disease when an important change takes place. Again, change indicating either recovery or death. Now, I included this one because even though it’s a little off, when Devin and I talk about a midpoint, after that midpoint, we generally talk about a recovery phase.
And if we’ve, if you’ve heard us in season one, talking about a mentor at a midpoint, oftentimes that’s where the death of a mentor happens. So I just thought it was an interesting definition to include for crisis. And when we say the death of a mentor, it sort of is where the hero is allowed to take on the journey on their own. That’s why that oftentimes happens midpoint. So the middle of the story and the climax, well, of course, it’s sort of like a bigger crisis, the most intense, exciting or important point of something. And culmination or apex is, is what that is at the ultimate point.
And also. And also, of course, an orgasm, which we all know is, well, maybe we don’t all know. Let me just not speculate. But, Jones, steer it back. Steer it back on track. I just did want to point out, though, climax, the idea of culmination, the sort of definition being culmination, that didn’t come about until the 18th century. Before that, it meant ladder. Now, I only bring that up. I only bring that up in this definition section, because if you think of the rising action of your act one and two building to something, and then you get to your act three, which is your climax, and it’s a much steeper, more intense build.
It was one of those images I thought, that’s kind of cool. Instead of a staircase going up or a ramp or a hill escalating with rising stakes, it’s all of a sudden super sharp. It’s a steep climb. It’s really intense. Mm-hmm. The sprint at the end of a marathon. But I thought it was interesting that the word came from the meaning of it was ladder.
Devin: Devin? I look at acts, and I’ll talk about it a little bit more in detail later on, but they’re more of a measuring tool for me or a pacing mechanism. I think of story more of beginning with beginning, middle, and end. But if you take a story— And think about it as an onion. And so the entire story is the onion. The outer layer of that onion is your acts. It’s act one, act two, act three. And so that’s a very zoomed out view of your story. But a more important thing to either remember or identify is beneath the acts, if you pull that layer, that layer, the act layer back are movements, six to eight movements that make up those acts.
And then if you pull the movement layer back, there’s events that make up the movements that make up the acts. And then if you pull that layer back, there are scenes or sequences of scenes that make up the events, that make up those movements, that make up the acts. And so it’s important in all aspects of the writing process, I feel, or at least it is to me, to continually be zooming in and zooming out. And so I like – and we’ve talked about it several times or many times throughout the podcast is thinking about – I like to think about the story as a blueprint because I like that bird’s eye view of my story.
I like to see what’s going on, where it’s ending up, where it’s starting. If I’m fading off into or if I went on some tangent that might end up going nowhere or becoming an issue later on. Dial it back, things like that. But once I want to really zone in on a specific scene, that’s when I’ll go – okay, I’ll identify the movement. I’ll figure out the event that scene is in and then I’m in the scene. And then that’s where what we talked about like in the last episode where everything can be structured into this objective obstacle outcome structure. Yeah, the three O’s, folks, the three O’s.
If you look at the – Yeah. This onion from the – our zoomed out view of the acts of the onion, well, there is act one is the objective or the super objective if you’re specifically talking about the hero. And act two is the obstacles that our hero must overcome in their way of achieving their objective. Crisis. And act three is the outcome. Climax. That’s where our hero either overcomes the obstacles or obtains their objective. And then if you – you can zoom in again to the events and each event is going to have an objective obstacle outcome. Like the call to adventure I think is what we used last episode.
Adam: And most frequently I think, yeah.
Devin: Yeah. And then within the event there’s either a scenes or a sequence of scenes that also – when you’re in a – then we talked about it. I don’t have to – I won’t go back and rehash everything we talked about last episode. But there’s an objective obstacle outcome. So it’s a way of – or a perspective of when you’re writing or developing a story, think about it that way where it’s – the three-act structure is essentially obsolete I feel at least from a perspective that if you write a story using a three-act structure. Which really means your story just needs plot points at, say, page somewhere between 25, 27, and then again somewhere between 85 and 90, then you’ve written this commercial property.
And really all that’s doing – it’s only – there’s nothing in between. And so some confusion may lie with that notion that a story must have a beginning, middle, and end. And like I said before, that’s kind of – I believe that. I buy into that. But that doesn’t in any way indicate. That the beginning is act one, the middle is act two, and the end has to be act three. Because think about all of that stuff that happens, all of those movements, events, and scenes that happen, they can pour over in – a beginning could be act one, and then a middle could be the second part of an act one, and then into act two.
So it’s hard to really box in a story into act one, act two, act three is basically the –
Adam: I agree with Devin, especially in the fact that it’s been – it’s become such a – this formula for Hollywood that anybody trying to quote break into Hollywood is has been building in that model for a very long time. Well, Hollywood is a different animal these days, because it’s mainly tentpole stuff. And the rest of it is the it’s sort of more artistically explored these days. It’s not nearly as formulaic. It’s we’re starting to break the mold, right, which is the purpose of us doing StoryOsophy is to talk about that. Right. But The Act 1, Act 2, Act 3, I think people mentally sort of compare it to beginning, middle, end.
That’s sort of how they put it in their brain, which is fine. But in this format, as Devin’s talking about with the beginning is like 25 pages and the end is like at page 85 or 90, you’re breaking into Act 3 and to the end. That’s the issue with Act 2 is it becomes a muddle instead of a middle.
Devin: It’s the muddle of the story. I love it.
Adam: The muddle of the story. But it’s true. What it’s led to is that, this sort of muddling of the center of the story. And the other thing I would say about the Act 1, Act 2, Act 3 page length concept is Act 1 is generally 25 pages in this classic Act 1, Act 2, Act 3 model. And I’m just going to speak for myself, but I’m pretty sure – no, I’m going to speak for everybody. We’re bored. By 25 minutes, I’m bored. Get to the end. Get to the point in 15 minutes so I know whether to turn it off or not. Let me know your premise.
Get me involved with the characters. It’s not that hard. You got 15 pages. Just do it. Right. Get me wrapped up in it and send them on their journey. And then complicate their journey. Once you give me their essence, once you give me the premise and the foundation of the story, which, as we’re defining Act 1, that’s the key. Just that.
Devin: Right.
Adam: When I do my consultations, there are – I’m not going to do that. There are a lot of stories that I read where the Act 1 is very inflated, and it’s because the writer, they feel the need to let you know every character that’s going to exist in this story right away, or that they expand the ordinary world of the hero much longer than it needs to be. It’s really, like I say, it’s really about essence. You just want to hit it real quick and get out of there. Right. And then when you get into Act 2, now you can – Now you can expand all of those nuggets you just sort of dropped a teeny bit in the beginning, and that’s what makes it exciting.
As Devin gave the analogy of the onion peeling back, I think the entirety of the middle is sort of the onion being peeled back. That’s all of Act 2, which means it’s in layers, which means, as Devin has said, in movement, it’s in these chunks that you can see a transformation and a transition. Between – or rather within the character and the way that character is within the story world. So as we’ll talk about here in a little bit, the main mixing ingredients for that are the character has to be given a choice and there’s a decision point. And then by the end of that movement or sequence, chain of events there, you have a transition where they – they cross a threshold they can’t return from.
New level of growth. And with that, progressive complications, obstacles, new level, new devil. If there’s a new avenue of approach, the antagonist, the way they respond to the antagonist or the way that the environment is becomes more intense. It escalates, rising, the stakes raise. Right. Act three to the end. In breaking it up into smaller increments, much more like television commercial break acts.
Devin: Right.
Adam: Smaller blocks of story. You can then build these sequences and events and scenes as Devin’s been talking about. And to what we call movement, something that’s like, you know, nine to 15 pages. It all depends on what you’re measuring with. How long is it a 22 minute episode, 44 minute episode, 90 minute feature, 120. So when you break it up like that, sort of just being able to build for a small chunk of time into a turning point, a crossing of a threshold in transformation and plot so that you can track it.
Devin: That’s a key point to the process is breaking it up or identifying, you know, breaking it up from acts to movements, to events, to scenes allows you to really focus on making those pieces strong for the story and understanding what they’re meant to do for the story. Like a story. Like a scene. Okay. A scene has an objective obstacle outcome, but the scene itself needs to move the story has to be relevant to the story and it has to move the story. So then you can say, all right, so I have a, I can focus on the scenes, moving the story. And then I can focus on the event within that, that the scenes make up. This needs to move the story. And this event has to, these events have to be combined or they have to make up the movements in each movement because each movement has to be a progression. Each movement shows transformation and each, and then each movement makes the acts and each act, there’s a transformation in each act. And so by breaking it up, especially all the way down to a scene, you’re able to focus on making sure that characters, what’s happening in here, what’s happening in that scene, the dialogue within that scene is all relevant to the story. And if it’s not, then, you know, then you, you’re able to identify that stuff.
A lot easier. And I do want to make one quick sidebar. You were talking about, you were talking about your, your, your character, everything you just said was based on, on your character and something I learned from you, Dr. Jones, but I not until recently, did I have a, a, an aha or Eureka moment and, and then started implementing it into story development was start, start with character. I normally start with an event and then I create and develop characters that I feel I, that I need to tell the story, but I’ve been working on developing software that we’re going to release soon for, for all of our StoryOsophers.
Very exciting software. But I was working on the character development module for, for, for the software. So I’ve, I’m thinking about developing character first in this, in this, for this module and, and, or at least the main character. And I’m realizing that once you develop, once you really start focusing on your main character, the main characters first, the antagonist and the, and the protagonist, all of the other elements of the story start to emerge. And the story almost begins to tell itself.
Adam: That’s a hundred percent true. Yeah, for sure.
Devin: And so if you understand who he or she is, or even it for that matter, and you understand their internal issues or their obstacles, and what, what seminal moments in their past triggered these, these internal issues and, and what are their personal goals or objectives as they, as they relate to the story and then, and then figure out what are the external obstacles that they’re going to pop up that will prevent my, this character from achieving their goal or obtaining their objective. And then you map out this journey. It, it doesn’t have to be written in stone or, or, or over detailed, but, but if you know their objective and their obstacle, and then of course the outcome of the story.
All of, all of a sudden the story starts to tell itself. And so once you have this really good picture of your main character and the obstacles that are in the way of the story, the story starts showing you what those plot points are or multiple plot points or the events. And, and you, you know, what types of scenes that they’re like, oh, this scene is, is essential to the story. And you’ll see how it moves from one act to another. And if, if you do want to use that three act structure to organize the events of the story or beginning, middle, and end. Cool. Do it, but realize that, that a tight story has layers and a lot should happen within each act.
Adam: Using, using movements, the thing that that’s really effective or been effective for me in developing in that way is you can sort of layer in a musical round way. So before one movement ends, you’ve started, you’ve posed another question or started to create another thing. And so you can overlap as one’s concluding, the other is beginning. And so there’s this crossfade aspect that I really like about compartmentalizing smaller units. Although I talk about them being in sort of 15, nine to 15 page chunks, it’s flexible.
Devin: Right.
Adam: The whole point is you just want it to, to change within that amount of time. When you were talking about obstacles, when you’re trying to figure out what your story is, what’s happening in your story based on you’ve got your antagonist and your protagonist, and you’re trying to figure out what’s going on that whole chunk. Just think of options. If you, if you sort of zoom out and, you know, don’t put so much pressure on yourself and go. Let me think of as many options as I can. I’m not going to run with my first idea if I don’t like it, or, you know, I have to come up with five.
And once I get five ideas, I’m done. Create options and the best building of them will show itself. Like Devin’s saying, it’ll show itself. The other thing with the events and the way that things build, as Devin was saying, there’s not, oftentimes you sort of find, it’s hard to find the fluff. It’s hard to find the fat in the story that’s unneeded.
Devin: Right.
Adam: If you can zoom in and out through the layers of the onion, you start, it’s easier to discern and figure out and then get rid of. We talk about plot as a chain of events in some previous episodes, which is a great idea, but I had recently thought, and a lot of storytelling models, you’ll see the arc, and Devin has a comment about the image that were shown in the arc of a story, but oftentimes it starts, you know, low and then goes at a ramp or increasing gradual up to climax. And I was thinking to myself, I thought of myself, for myself, the image of a marble at the top or a snowball or a sledder at the top of a hill instead, in a way that if it starts to go, it just goes.
The inertia, the momentum, and instead of feeling like it’s a, and you can approach it both ways, a climb or a struggle or a build, just whatever the journey into this world is, transformation. You can’t stop.
Devin: If you Google, I forgot what I actually Googled.
Adam: Probably story structure.
Devin: Yeah. And there’s hundreds of images on Google Images that will pop up, and they all have a variation of, like an upside, not upside down, an arc. You know, so you start, act one starts on this one plane. And by the end of the story, you end up further down the plane, but for some reason, always on the same plane, or even if you’re not always on the same plane, you’ve, at some point of the story, the climax, like Adam was talking about, the emotional arc of this, or even the transformational arc, is going down for some reason. Falling action is what some people call it.
And I think it’s because the word arc is. Probably where. Misnomer. The visualization comes from. If I’m visualizing the story, I think of it as you start on one plane, and it’s almost like a, is that a backwards-y? Yeah, maybe a backwards-y. And then it goes, and then everything happens, the build, and then the climax. But the climax doesn’t have to have, doesn’t have to be a fall. Decline. A descent, yeah. A decline. It’s just going up. And then the end of the story. You’re at a, you’re at a, you’ve transformed. You’re at a higher plateau, or you’re at a different plane. And I think that, for me, is a better visual, because that shows true transformation and become, and a higher level of who you were when you started.
What you’ve learned. And you didn’t just, you didn’t just, time didn’t just pass. Whereas, if you’re on the, if you’re on, if you start on, like, some of these arcs where they start on one plane, there’s an arc, and then you end up on the plane a little further. Yeah. And if you’re looking chronologically in life, but you went through this enormous, this, this journey or this experience, but you, you end up, for some reason, you’re on the same plane. And I think of that if, if emotionally or spiritually or, you know, not just physically. And so if you, if you actually look at or visualize a story starting on one plane, the journey and the experience and everything that happens is, is this, is a continual build.
It elevates you. And then maybe after the climax, it levels back out to, now you are this person up here. Yeah. And then it just goes on until something else happens. I guess that’s, for me, a little bit more of a accurate visualization for me as far as how I want the transformation of my character as well as the worlds.
Adam: Well, and a lot of it has to do with the concept of cyclical storytelling. You sort of come back to a reference point that allows you to see. Yeah. The new changes.
Devin: Right.
Adam: That’s why at the end of The Hobbit or Lord of the Rings, they have to come back to the Shire. Right. So you can sort of reference point this journey or whatever. Mm-hmm. I thoroughly agree with Devin. That’s why I was excited when he told me this before we started recording today. Because, and especially apply this to a TV episode. So the story is going to continue. But within that episode, you’ve got a contained story. So the story starts on a plateau, escalates, obstacles, progressive complications, you’re building, and then you reach this new level of realization plateau again. Next episode, you start at that plateau, go up to the next level. And so you’re constantly building. It’s a great analogy for constant development or transition.
Devin: And the hero’s constantly fighting not to fall back to who they were. And so they’re constantly fighting upwards. They’re constantly in this battle to not give up. If they give up, you slide. If you think of it as like a little video game, you give up, you slide back down, and you’re back to where you started. You haven’t transformed in any way. And so that’s where. And then in the middle, in the middle can have different plateaus, like minor plateaus. Where it’s like, this little plateau, this is a battle. Or the zigzag. Yeah, zigzag. Sort of heart monitor. Exactly.
Adam: Rollercoaster. But always going up, I think. That’s the other thing with the model that I find ridiculous is, it’s like, that’s the issue. Like, you look at that model you’re talking about, which you can look up online, and you just see it like this line, foundation, which, by the way, I want to point out the fact, the beginning is not really increasing in stakes that much. It’s a plateau. So that’s why I say, keep your act one short. Keep it short, short, short.
Devin: Mm-hmm.
Adam: Because if not, you’re going to bore your audience, they’re going to turn you off. Then get complicated in act two. Up and down and up and down, and twists and turns, and fun developments. That’s where you get to play. And that’s the issue with that visual image of, you know, act one set up, rising action, complication, climax, and falling action resolution, or whatever you want to call it.
Devin: Right.
Adam: Because the middle, it’s just one, like, do-do-do-do-do. There’s no up and down to that sort of visual landscape of the image, which is why Devin and I try to break stuff up into smaller chunks, like movements, like six to eight movements, each one being like 15-ish pages or less. You have each point, you can go, okay, at page one, we’re like this. Page 15, we’re way off from that. So we’re up and down. Then, you know, 16 to 30. We’re using these as references, you know, but smaller increments. It’s the other direction. So we’re going to tip the scales in another direction. Why? I don’t know. Maybe the hero is compensating for a fear, and so they push it off in a direction that’s unnatural. But you can find that out by, as Devin was saying, clearly finding out your heroes, and then sort of applying events or even larger story ideas. Crisis climax.
Devin: Again, it comes down to two points of this. I believe if you start with character, that’s your story will present itself. And then when you’re thinking about, like Adam said earlier, about options, always play the game, what if, what for? Oh, yeah, that’s good. As a writer, you’re saying, what if this happened? What if this happened? And then you have to, as a writer, jump in the seat of your audience and say, because they’re going to be like, well, what for? Like, why is that happening? So that’s where the relevance comes in. As we’ve stated a thousand times before, the sophistication of audiences is what is antiquating the three-act structure.
And audiences could follow that three-act structure back when, you know, if we’re talking about film and entertainment, like back in the 1910s, 1920s, you know, when film at its infancy. And over, but over the years and decades. The amount of content and movies and books and comics and, and, and music has increased. And so has the, the audience sophistication for identifying patterns. And formulas. Yeah. And once a pattern is identified, an element of predictability. Whether that’s conscious or unconscious in the audience’s minds, it creeps into their psyche. So true. And so instead of looking inward at stories and the stories they were telling and producing, studios looked outward to find technological or special effects ways of entertaining the audience.
So true. And don’t get me wrong, the advancement of technology is incredibly important to storytelling. And we just talked about, we were talking about the Marvel universe before we started recording, and if you look at the way that Disney and Marvel use technology is immersive and it’s part of the story. And so that’s important, but they should be an enhancement or in partnership to great story. And I feel over time, a great story is the foundation to entertainment, or story as… Yeah. Is the building blocks to a good property, kind of took a backseat to spectacle. But now with the… And I’m just very generalizing here, but just to make a point.
And I think with the democratization of digital production distribution, audience voices for great stories is being heard again today by some daring and experimental and influential storytellers, as well as the platforms they’re telling their stories on. Like Netflix. And Amazon and Hulu. And so, you know, we said many times, we all want great story, well told, we want to be told something and we want to be told a great story, but tell it in the right way. And if that means you got to blow stuff up or use AR or VR to tell the story, then let’s do it. I’m all in, you know, but the sophisticated audience these days, they can pick out patterns and start predicting things in a way that they don’t want to be predicted.
Yeah. If you just keep using the same old three-act structure or you’re just, that’s the only thing you’re focused on is making sure you have a beginning, a middle and end and not really pulling the layers back of that onion and making everything, the movements, the events, the scenes, the sequences of scenes, powerful and compelling and moving the story forward and doing it in ways that are experimental and different that is going to keep, it’s going to take them off guard. Because when an audience has sensed something new or experimental, their senses are peaked. And when their senses are peaked, you have their attention. And so, but the problem with story is it’s a little bit like a Rube Goldberg machine.
So, which Rube Goldberg machine is just one of those, it’s like a long, you’ve probably seen them on TV or it’s a machine that’s intentionally designed to be able to do things. It can perform like a really simple task in a very indirect and complicated fashion. So, it’s like, but it’s all, it’s all triggered by one thing. Like a cell phone can fall into something that triggers a arm to go up to knock over dominoes, dominoes go down, knock over pink. And a marble rolls and then dominoes fall and yeah. Yeah. And so, but if, if one element of that machine, that one element of that machine doesn’t work or it malfunctions, the machine stops.
So, if any element of your story malfunctions. Or doesn’t work, your story stops and you lose your audience. So, if you think that you’re like, all right, everything has to, my Rube Goldberg story machine here has to, everything has to fall into place. But each little thing can be so dynamic and have its own story. That detail. Yeah. A detail and be compelling.
Adam: Really focused detail. Like you watch that machine run and when the marble rolls down the track or the dominoes tip. Right. It’s an anticipatory thing where you’ve. Like, like I was saying before, that you’ve got that model of the thing going uphill. Once the story goes in motion, you’re watching this machine to see how it’s going to trigger the next event.
Devin: Right.
Adam: If they’re not triggering the next thing, the whole thing falls apart and the same thing with story. Right. Look, what Devin, everything Devin just said, ditto. That’s all I got to say. It was so brilliantly put. I don’t even want to sort of recap and say anything about it. It’s just exactly period.
Devin: And if you look at those. Rube Goldberg machines, what do they have? They have an objective, they have an obstacle and they have an outcome, a desired outcome. And each little part, each piece of that Rube Goldberg machine has an objective. It has an obstacle and it has a desired outcome. And so that’s, you know, breaking, you could break those things down. That’s how you, there are measurements. It’s a good measurement tool. It’s like, understand, okay, this needs to move forward. This needs to do that, you know? So. I guess that’s part of the onion.
Adam: Cause how long do you want to watch that? If that marble ran down a track that was like three miles long, you’d be like, I’m done. Yep. It needs to roll down a short track and trigger something that we’re like, and what is that going to do now? How does that affect this whole thing? Now what’s going to happen when that gets to the thing where this happened? It’s a really great, that’s a really great analogy, because each part should be unpredictable. If you, if it was literally just each movement was a marble running down a track, and it drops to the next track, and rolls down, and drops to the next track, and rolls down, and drops to the next, for six, you’d be like, I’m done.
Right. I get it. Oh, how boring. It’s, like he’s saying, that’s, I get it. It’s predictable. It’s formulaic. It’s pattern. It’s pattern. When people talk about twists, or turns, or surprises in stories, that’s this disruption of pattern. And the way you turn a story on a threshold, which we’ll get to right after the break, how do you like them apples?
Cliffhanger. Oh, you like that? You’ve got one option of the surprise element, which is disrupting the pattern. And then you’ve got the other. The other element of, so how do you spice up these movements or things to turn them and twist them? Reveals and discoveries, meaning peeling back a layer of character. So, here’s how your events turn or twist. The unfolding of how that character would navigate plot, turn, twist, surprise. Or, a revelation or discovery about the character. As you move along, you’ll learn more about that character, as they learn more about themselves. So, when we come back, we’ll talk about thresholds, decision points, and how to break up those acts, what they really should be about when you’re approaching them.
And sort of dispel the mystery of the middle part and how daunting it can be.
[Sponsor message]
Devin: And we’re back.
Adam: So, when we’re talking about acts. In general, they are just simply ways of, as Devin said, they’re units of measurement. And in a lot of ways, like he was breaking down in the unpeeling of the layers of the onion of structure. You’ve got your base element sort of scenes, beats, moments, smaller things. And they’ll build into these larger scenes and sequences, which is sort of like just a handful of scenes glued together. And sequences probably is the most malleable. I think people, some sequences people will determine are much longer. I like them as shorter chunks, like scenes that fall into like a one, two, three thing, like brief.
But you’re moving to events. They’re sort of like the marking points of plot.
And as Devin was saying earlier, if you know your characters, you can literally just go, okay, I’ve got these three characters and I’m going to put them here. Okay. Plot will tell it, tell you what needs to happen. Here’s an event. Here’s what, here’s a call to adventure. This character gets involved with the journey into the unknown world of the story itself of act two and three, their transformation journey. And then you can zoom even further out and go, now let’s break this up act wise into, as he said, very astutely measurable units, measure, measurable. That’s really the key. So you can determine your pacing and especially in filmed media where it’s a page per minute, you can look at your pages as a writer and do this frequently.
Cause this is really helpful and go 15 pages, 15 minutes, and then look at what events happening on that page and go, would I be satisfied here at 15 minutes? I’m be honest with, be honest with yourself at 15 minutes. Would I be bored with my own story? Yeah, get to the point, man. Let’s go. Let’s move, get into the story quickly, and then see these complication of events where there’s another decision point, and they have to cross this threshold of transformation, whether it’s the transformation of the world or themselves, and so get into it, get in there quick, get to the point, but we should probably talk a little bit about decision, or I keep saying decision points, but plot points and thresholds, and sort of define them, and talk a little bit about them.
So that our listeners have a broader perspective on them. Do you agree, Devin? I agree. Zooming in and out, what you’ve been talking about, that’s the key. If you get the three O’s, storying will be easy.
Devin: Yeah.
Adam: Zoom in and out, at will, on anything, and the three, those three transparencies laid over whatever you’re working on will always work. Yeah. And I think that’s why people go for that three-act structure, and a one, and a two, and a three. It works throughout the rest of it, but when you get that broad in three acts, you sort of drown in the middle, you know? And so, like Devin has been saying in the beginning of this episode, and before, approaching it with this three-part build is great. Yeah. It’s just when you expand it, the middle in a larger format becomes a little more elusive. The way you’re going to lock it down becomes a little more, it’s harder to determine. So compartmentalizing, it helps the understanding of it, and the navigation of it, for that matter.
Devin: It’s almost like seeing the forest for the trees. Yes. And so it’s, you can look at the story as the forest, but let’s zoom in and… Yeah. And I… And focus on each individual tree that makes up that forest. And so if you’re able to…
Adam: Or the path through the forest.
Devin: Or the path through the forest.
Adam: Bit by bit. Right. What part of the forest is being revealed to us as we go through, you know, as we navigate it linearly, whereas the bird’s eye is nonlinear.
Devin: A great way, I mean, everybody has their different, a different way, their process. And some people can literally, they prefer to sit down and just…
Adam: You say it with such contempt. No, I mean, it’s great. I like hearing other people’s processes. It’s the limitation that’s the problem. If your process is limited, yeah.
Devin: But if you, and some people like to, whether it, I don’t know what the outcome is, but they prefer to sit down and write a chronological linear story. They like to start from the beginning and then see where they end up. But for me personally, I love… I love the zoom in, zoom out, zoom in, zoom out type of creation, because that allows me to be as creative as I want and be passionate or inspired for something and then dive in. Me too. And then just be focused on that scene or that event and then zoom out and be like, oh, cool. So that’s there now. How do I get to there? Oh, cool.
Because I just spent so much time and I had so much fun with that part of the story. Now I even, now I know a really good way how I’m going to get to that point. And then you just zoom back in and you start writing it there.
Adam: It’s both freeing and it’s inspiring at the same time. Yeah. That approach. I agree with Devin a hundred percent here because I’ve done the linear approach too. I’ll start at the beginning and write through. So have I, yeah. And you, you trip yourself up a lot that way. You hamstring yourself because you’ll give yourself writer’s block. People suffer from writer’s block because they write that way. If they, if you can sort of have two modes where you’re linearly putting it down, just to make sure it chronologically… Works as an experience, great. But the rest of the time, be wide open. Allow yourself to be free to whatever the story wants you to do.
Follow your, follow your bliss. And I can tell you this has been the case for Devin and I individually and even together working on stories. We follow the thing that is the most interesting or fun topic first.
Devin: Mm-hmm.
Adam: Yeah. Mm-hmm. You do, you get the most joy out of it. You got the ball rolling. You’re in. I mean, Devin, we were talking the other day where even as much as Devin and I both love storytelling, we also have to discipline ourselves.
Devin: Mm-hmm.
Adam: There are times where we’re doing other stuff, we’re, you know, watching videos, watching this stuff, and we don’t want to work because we think of it as work. And yet we sit down and within five, ten minutes, we’re so pumped. And wrapped up in what we’re doing. But there’s this procrastination thing that happens where you’re like, oh, I don’t know how that’s going to work out, or I don’t. And you sort of over-worry yourself before you approach it. If you just get started, it’s going to work itself out, which is the case with pretty much everything in life. Right. It’s the personal resistance that prevents growth. And we’ve said this throughout season one, too, but it’s in reality.
Within each individual person, but if you know that, it’s with your heroes too. So finding these, it’s almost like different excuses your hero might give to prevent themselves from the end transformation are really your different thresholds they have to confront and pass. What new layers of bravery or and bravery comes in all shapes and sizes. Bravery can can be emotionally communicating and confessing something to someone that you are very terrified to confess or converse with. That’s, you know, it doesn’t have to be like, we were talking about the Marvel Cinematic Universe Hawkeye shooting an exploding arrow into some robot’s head. It can be something different. And I said that contemptuously. I love the MCU. I’m just comparing it to like, other things. Anyway, we should talk about decision points and thresholds because in their very basic form, this is sort of the tools of an act. What Devin was talking about before, or maybe he wasn’t, I don’t know. We were talking about prior to this episode.
That what happens in Act One, which we’re going to briefly skim, if you took that and laid that series of events over the next movements, every 15 pages, until you got to your climax, you’d have a really dynamic movie. Because, and basically what that is made up of is a decision point and a threshold of growth. You’re crossing into a new world, a new realm. A new. And there are larger, more epic, more pronounced thresholds at the end of what we would call those act breaks for three acts. But the first act is built of a hook scene, an ordinary world, or the routine of your hero, the call to adventure, which is how an inciting incident, we’ll talk about inciting incident specifically, another point.
But it gets the story, the call to adventure and or inciting. Inciting incident, separate events, gets your story in motion, creating a decision point. Here’s the fork in the road, hero. We usually have a refusal of the call, or you can also refer to that as a debate. The hero doesn’t have enough faith in themselves or something that allows them that growth. The resistant point we’ve just been talking about. And then the acceptance of the call. The making of the decision. And then once that decision is made, you implement it and cross the threshold into a new version of self, into a new aspect of the reality of that story world.
So that rhythm, if you just now go, okay, now repeat. Great. You have this hook scene that’s at the beginning that from the last threshold they crossed, it’s something really exciting that just pops and keeps your audience engaged. Then you have the new status quo. Where is this here? What’s the plateau right now for this hero? And repeat. Decision point, debate, decision made, crossing threshold. So as sort of as we sort of mock models and formulas, I’ve just given you one, but it’s one that really works because it forces you to push your story forward. And not get lost and go, I don’t know what I’m supposed to do here.
Yeah, it’s a compass. But yeah, the primary points are plot points or decision points that call to adventure moment where the hero is given a choice. The choice being made in the implementation of said choice. And then start again. So we’re going to talk for a minute about what decision points or plot points and thresholds are just to define them again. So that these are clear. Because if you get these, you know what you’re building to. So. In your movements, in your sequences, in your acts, you’ll get it. So, Devin, did you want to talk for a minute about the threshold or plot point, either one in particular?
Devin: I look at plot point as the choice presented, and a threshold signifies the choice taken, or a change in the world or character, whether that’s literal or figurative. 100%. So that’s kind of how I…
Adam: I just gave you 100% on your exam.
Devin: Cool. Then I’m going to shut up. No one to shut up.
Adam: No, that’s exact. He couldn’t have said it better. And scene. Yeah. Going off the threshold thing, I looked that up as well for definition, and I thought it was kind of interesting with the blueprint being our analogy for a story structure, that a threshold, of course, you think of a threshold of an actual doorway in a house. Every doorway has a threshold, and it’s that little strip of wood or metal or stone at the bottom of the doorway that when you sort of cross over it into the next room, which is kind of significant. It’s a point of entry or a beginning into a story. Yeah.
It’s a point of entry into a new space. It just marks it. And what we were talking about before Devin off air was when people are reviewing scripts in a commercial environment, they’re always like, where’s your act one? Where’s your act two? Where’s your act three? And it’s like, dude, do you need beaded curtains between each thing so you know it happened? Do you know what I mean? Like, does it have to be that obvious? Can the threshold be subtle and you get it as you go? Like, come on. It’s a point of entry or a beginning or a transformation, whether it’s world or whether it’s experience of a person.
And sometimes those are tight doorways and sometimes those are giant arcs, you know, arcs, arches. What am I talking about? Within a room. And sometimes those are like open room design, right? You got three rooms combined as one. There’s so many ways to do it in a house. Why does it have to be so concrete in a story? And it doesn’t. And then the other the other aspect of the definition of threshold, which I thought was kind of fun to explore, always in another, you know, topic or area of study, the magnitude or intensity that must be exceeded for a certain reaction, phenomenon, result or condition.
To occur or be manifested. So every movement at the end of every movement, there is pressure, there is intensity. There is the it’s what makes coal a diamond gradually, slowly. But you create marking points of here’s a new reaction, phenomenon, result, condition that occurred or manifested within the hero. Whether it’s outer space or inner space, you’re keeping your audience interested because the story is there. You’re interested because the story keeps changing. And these days we’re bored with static storytelling or it needs to be exciting. It needs to be captivating or, my preference, engaging. Engaging me intellectually, socially, emotionally, physically. I get up and dance while I’m watching the movie.
You know, it has to be something where I’m involved and not just spectacle. Like you’re saying. I don’t want a popcorn piece where if I want that, I’ll watch the Avengers movies or the Marvel Cinematic Universe because they’re awesome. Right. They’ve managed to take the idea of spectacle and make it a really fantastic story experience on all levels. And Devin and I, we decided we’re going to do an episode dedicated to the MCU because they’re killing it. They’re doing a fantastic job of storytelling and implementing just proprietary worlds. And intellectual properties on all levels from a creative and a business standpoint. They’re just crushing it. They’re doing so good.
Devin: He means Marvel Cinematic Universe, by the way, by MCU. What did I say?
Adam: Oh, MCU. But I thought I established that near the beginning of this podcast.
Devin: I love the MCU.
Adam: I love the MCU. We all sort of know what acts are. As Devin said, the formula has been repeated on so many levels. And by the way, so many great points that you made earlier, especially in terms of how storytelling and the actual quality of content has somehow been eclipsed or replaced by spectacle. That’s really what’s going on. But that’s also why I’m just applauding the Marvel Cinematic Universe. Well, I think now you could have used MCU. Oh, I can’t do anything right today.
Is because they’re doing both really well. The storytelling and the use of technology is just very exciting. They’re doing it in a way that’s not gratuitous or just for spectacle. As Devin said, it’s meant to serve the story.
Devin: Right. It’s meant to move the story forward.
Adam: I think in the next couple of episodes, we’re going to be delving into what makes up each act. Or I think we’ll dissect further into what makes up each movement that we talk about, because those are acts for us broken down into smaller increments. Yeah. What we’ll end with on this episode is sort of talking about act one, act two, act three, traditionally what they’re known for, and briefly a four-act, five-act structure, what that used to be, and sort of where Devin and I take our story structuring when we personally do it. Or when we’re examining other movies. Even when I do consultations, I do breakdowns into smaller increments.
But I think it’s good to talk about what traditionally these are known as. So when you’re talking to someone within a commercial environment like a studio head or a production company, and they go, so what’s your act one, act two, act three? Even if you built it in more detailed, smaller increments, you have these specific marking points that you can just say to them, and they’ll go, oh, yeah, okay. Right, right. Because a lot of people have just learned that, act one, act two, act three. And that’s what they’re looking for. So speak their language enough to be able to communicate that. But know your detail.
And also know when to…
To zoom in and out with someone. If you’re in an elevator pitch, you only have a sentence. So it’s your act one, act two, act three. Ba-boom, ba-boom, ba-boom. You gotta be done. If you’re in… They are curious and like, let’s have a cup of coffee, talk more, whatever. Then you can expand into what each of those detailed individual builds are. And when we talk about movements, it’s sort of a build. An act is a build, too. It’s a build to a certain transitional point or threshold. It might be a minor threshold, inner space, or a major threshold where your character’s inner space and the outer space of the story journey itself coincide.
And those I sort of… I guess, Devin, that would be the way I would clarify act breaks for me is where you can do subtle things with story or character for these minor thresholds throughout. But when those two things definitely cross paths… When the entire story world is immersed with the character’s decision-making, that’s a big moment.
Devin: That’s a really big moment. Yeah, yeah.
Adam: Act one being the introduction, foundation, essence, objective in the three O’s scenario. Act two being the rising action or the stakes getting higher. Obstacles. Obstacles in the three O’s scenario. I call that… Sometimes progressive complications. And then act three, I call act three climax and resolution. That’s sort of what happens in that for me. But some of the other things, they call it crisis, falling action. Like, these are older models. That’s part of the reason we’re breaking them down right now. So some of it may be strange names or nomenclature for these events and things, or what an act contains. But it is a little bit about picking apart what it means to build a stronger, better, more detailed, nuanced story.
And just to go back to Devin’s analogy of the peeling of the onion, technology and thinking and the way they’re advancing are a little bit hand-in-hand. So not to sidetrack, but this is a bit of a point. I was talking to a mechanic friend of mine. And we were talking about… You can use your iPhone or your smartphone to take a picture behind where your eyes or hand cannot reach or see. With a flash, pull it back up and then zoom in with your fingers to see a serial number on a part that there’s absolutely no way five years ago you could have done. That same concept needs to be explored with story. Zoom in, zoom in, zoom in. Don’t just stick to this basic principle of this is the way a story is supposed to be told.
Because, look, even before that, in Shakespeare’s time, there were five acts. And those five acts were, let me see, I wrote them down here real quick. Act one, exposition. Two was complications. Three was climax of action. That’s in the middle. Act four is falling action. And act five is catastrophe. Well, in our scenario, maybe we’ve switched crisis in the center. For climax with catastrophe at the end. But it’s maybe closer to the way I like to approach story than the modern formula. Because there’s more, there’s changing, there’s more changes in the whole structure of the piece. You know, you got a foundation, change, crisis, recovery, climax, resolution.
Actually, that’s pretty much the way I like a story to roll. In its base format. So, story has evolved from back with Aristotle and the Greeks and then to Shakespeare. And now we got this three-act structure that Hollywood has been sort of proliferating. And it’s, I mean, no offense, I love movies in general. Indies, Hollywood. But it’s stale. It’s predictable. It all needs to be reinvented.
Devin: There’s a four-act structure, too, folks.
Adam: But it’s sort of… It’s sort of like just splitting it down the middle. And it’s easier to navigate than your three-act structure.
Devin: Yeah.
Adam: It puts your crisis centrally. And I believe in that. I like a midterm exam that you either succeed or fail at. And then you sort of recover and prepare for your climax. It’s got a lot more momentum up and down. It’s exciting. I agree. Ditto. Did you run out of things to say?
Devin: No. I just fell into a trance listening to you speak. Because it’s… Your voice is so soothing. It’s so soothing.
Adam: I just listen and I fall asleep.
Devin: It’s sometimes simplification or trying to simplify and be like, well, we’re going to take Shakespeare’s five acts and let’s just make it into three acts. Sometimes that can be detrimental. Because sometimes there’s a happy medium where it’s… And I think that comes from the dissection of… Of story. What we just went through. Where it’s… It’s over… You can… Kind of the oversimplification of it is just thinking of it from a writer standpoint. I’m only going to think that I just need to write a beginning and write a middle. I need to write an end. But I think it’s… It’s understanding the other layers and making them as compelling as possible with…
And understanding your… Your objective, obstacles, and outcome, desired outcome as a writer. Not even just, you know, beyond the… Beyond the story. You know, your objective is to, from a screenwriter standpoint, is to finish a screenplay. The obstacle is taking what’s in your head, the ideas you have in your head, or even the incomplete idea of a story in your head, and putting it on paper in a way that… Is your successful Rube Goldberg machine.
Adam: And also accurately communicated to whomever the reader or audience is.
Devin: Right. And then…
Adam: Which is oftentimes the challenge.
Devin: Right. And then hopefully that desired outcome is exactly that. All of a sudden it’s sold and it’s made. But I think if… It’s just… It’s not overcomplicating it, but not oversimplifying it.
Adam: It’s balance. Yeah, it’s balancing. It’s like anything in storytelling. And when we talk about measurement in terms of measuring your story, it’s about determining diagnostically the pace of it. That’s what it’s all about. It all has to do with the balance of your story. When in a four-act structure, they split it down the middle. Well, when Devin and I are going to talk in these next handful of episodes that come after this, when we break it into movements, we like… I like calling it movement only because… Because it indicates the story is happening.
Devin: Yeah, moving.
Adam: You know, there’s movement happening. There’s even chain of events, things like… The words that I like to play with help to create momentum or not staticness. They inspire a lack of staticness. But we’re pretty much in the same vein of like, if you were to, let’s take a 90-minute film, feature film for an example, because it easily breaks down into two TV episodes, hour-long, like 44 or 45-minute episode, and then another 45-minute episode. When I’m working on a feature, that’s how I look at it. Two episodes. I don’t think of it as a feature. I think of it as a split down the middle, 45 minutes.
Now, it’s easy. I get to build to some really awesome cliffhanger at the center that pivots this story completely and makes you want to come back and see part two. It just so happens that in this scenario, part two is actually glued to part one, and we never tune out. But the momentum of that story, as one continued experience, is just awesome. It rolls. So once you’ve got a split down the middle and you go, okay, so it’s sort of like two episodes. One just is exponentially larger. Than the first part. Then I just break it down into these three chunks. And generally, they roll like this.
Movement one, comfort zone to out of comfort zone, or your ordinary world of your hero into the special world, unknown world of act two, traditional act two. And then act two, part A, in a traditional mindset, is movement two and three. And movement two is from out of comfort zone to danger zone. Which, in that, you’re building to this threshold the character crosses where, maybe at the beginning, oftentimes people will start act two with, it’s all fun and games. So the character’s exploring that act two until something happens. Like, it’s all fun and games until someone gets an eye poked out. And that’s the danger zone threshold. And now, once that happens, it’s sort of like, we can take this a little seriously, whatever this journey is, prepare a little more.
And it’s a build to the crisis, this midterm exam. Generally, if the antagonist has only flexed their muscle a teeny bit prior to this, or you’ve seen some henchmen, or the world, the layer of the antagonist, in a way, metaphorically or literally, this is when you start to get the heat of the antagonist. And oftentimes, in Vogler’s scenario, this would be the approach to the inmost cave. When you go into the lair, or you’re in the lion’s den, the protagonist goes in and infiltrates, and it’s just, you know, not a good thing. Doesn’t really work out. This is Luke and Han and all them trying to infiltrate the Death Star and get Leia.
You know, they end up in a trash compactor. So, not great. Crisis sucks.
And when you get to… The second half of this act structure. So, Act 2, Part B, if you will, on the other side of the crisis, but before Act 3 and the climax, what happens there? Devin and I break this up into, once again, these building of sequences called movements. Movement 4 would be a crisis into recovery. So, you’ve just come from this crisis. You’re probably escaping. There’s, like, what Joseph Campbell might call the magic flight scenario, where you’re sort of running from whatever the event was, trying to just stay alive, into a recovery or campfire phase, where you sort of regroup and try to go, do we do this again?
Do we take on what’s happening? And create a plan. So, it’s… And to me, this is something that often gets ignored, but Devin and I have discussed off-record, very important and vital. To a hero’s journey is failure and recovery and reassessment. Really important part of the journey. Movement 5 is when recovery turns to climax. So, now we’re building to the climax. And at the end of 5, we’re usually well into the climax and sort of the threshold between Movement 5 and 6, 6 being the end of the climax into resolution.
But that threshold between those two is… It’s some amazing pivotal moment in the climax. A breakthrough moment in the climax. It’s a breakthrough moment in the climax. But just breaking it up into those smaller sections, split down the middle, break it up into these three really distinct builds on either side. And that’s, once again, a 90-minute example. You can increase by two more movements and do 120 feature film, but laying it out like that, it helps to understand how you can turn possibly a feature film into a series malleably, easily. You’ve already built it for that structure. And these days, I would suggest if you’re making something and you pitch it commercially, and a production company or a studio or somebody says, this is really exciting, this could be a larger piece, you already understand how that might unravel as a storyteller.
Because you’ve broken it down into these components that can go, oh, 44 minutes is an episode of, an hour-long episode of television, traditionally. And 90… 90 minutes is a feature or two episodes. But it just helps to break up the monotony of the formula, first of all, building it into those smaller increments. And we’ll talk about those more as we continue with this season. That’s actually what we’re going to be getting more and more in depth in. But it’s important for you guys, StoryOsophers out there, to understand the broader strokes. And then, as Devin’s saying, we’ll sort of peel through different layers of the onion and zoom in. I can do any of these events or zoom in here anywhere and know what you’re doing. It’s very freeing and very inspiring. But that’s a quick preview. Those are our six little breakdown chunks. And we’ll go into more and more detail as we get along.
Devin: Boom.
Adam: Yeah, I was going to say, God, I hope Devin’s not dead. There have been so many episodes and I’m like, there’s been a couple where it’s been touch and go.
Devin: Yeah, it’s been touch and go a couple times. It’s either frozen or heat stroke.
Adam: Please subscribe and rate us on iTunes. Follow us on social media. Share with your friends and send us your questions and comments. For additional resources and links to films, series, and books we talk about here, visit our website. While you’re there, sign up for our newsletter for updates on story building tools and special offers at StoryOsophy.com. Those legs go all the way down to the floor.