Season 1, episode 26

Subplot (Part 1)

May 10, 201851 min

Show notes

A subplot is a secondary storyline that strengthens and deepens the main one. Writers’ rooms label them A, B and C stories: the A story is the spine, the B story is secondary, and the C story is often a “runner.” In the first of two episodes on subplot, Adam and Devin explore how subplots reflect the main plot and how to keep them all working together, and they have some friendly disagreements about how to label them.

In this episode

  • Devised and presented. The dictionary says a plot is “devised and presented” by the writer: building the structure, then choosing the tone and what to withhold.
  • The lie detector. Devin pictures his storylines like lines on a polygraph: each does its own thing, but they intersect, cross and support each other.
  • Two ways to see the B story. For Devin, the A story is the external quest and the B story is the hero’s emotional lens: the love interest, friend, child or pet. Adam often uses B and C stories to explore the theme more broadly or show other dimensions of a character.
  • Labels differ. Devin tracks a third line, the hero’s internal transformation; for Adam, that transformation is the A story. They agree the semantics matter less than the measurement.
  • Episodic TV. In a procedural, the case of the week is the A story; a B story about two detectives usually gets about three beats and comments on the case.
  • Subplots can deliver the world’s rules. In fantasy and sci-fi, an innkeeper or a minor character doing their job can explain the world without a lecture, and becomes a subplot if they keep returning.
  • Think in threes. Setup, complication, payoff: every storyline has its own one-two-three, like a waltz.

Examples discussed

  • Die Hard: the B story, John McClane trying to win back his wife, comes before the A story, and putting Holly among the hostages fuses them. Adam counts four storylines: the takeover, John’s marriage, the terrorists’ heist, and Powell outside.
  • Armageddon: an astronaut’s son who doesn’t know his father, a B story that pays off on TV.
  • The Greatest Showman: P.T. Barnum’s need for self-worth, mirrored by Zac Efron’s forbidden romance with Zendaya’s trapeze artist, a cross-class love story like Barnum’s own. The trapeze number and a silent moment of letting go of a hand.
  • Also: Lost, Game of Thrones, The Walking Dead, The Matrix and Before Sunrise.

Next week: Subplot, Part 2, with more examples and the spines of Stranger Things seasons one and two.

Read the full transcript

Transcribed automatically, so expect the odd misheard word. Sponsor messages are left out.

Adam: Next on StoryOsophy. This week, we’re talking about subplot. Oh, I got to do the hello. Welcome to StoryOsophy. Take two. Hello, welcome to StoryOsophy. This is Adam Jones. And Devin Halden. This week, we’re talking about subplot. Subplot being the secondary or subordinate storyline to a plot. Now, plot we discussed back in, I don’t remember what episode it was, early on. It was one of our first handful of episodes. And now we’re going to be talking about how you can use subplot to strengthen or deepen the primary storyline. And once again, we’ll start out with definitions. These are pretty… Simple, but I like to do them anyway, just for folks who are learning for the first time.

A plot, we’re going to go back, is the main events of a play, novel, movie, or similar work devised and presented by the writer as an interrelated sequence. And a subplot is a subordinate storyline in a film, novel, stage play, etc. I like the fact that in the definitions here, it says devised. And presented by the writer. They’re two very different things. We talk about structuring, which we’ll go into much more detail in season two. That’s the devising. You’re building this thing. And then the presentation of it is, what tone do you lay on it? How do you give it to your audience? What do you withhold?

Those two aspects of writing or creating a story, I love those two words that they’re in there for plot. And then also… The concept of an interrelated sequence, that’s exactly what your main plot is, but a subplot that would mirror it or comment on it, it’s also a smaller, separate, interrelated sequence, and these things will, of course, like we talked about in the episode, the episodes about resolution, these things will dovetail together, and these plot lines will intersect and become one. Resolved thing, usually. If not, it’s either a poorly constructed story or a very deliberate choice. When you’re in a writing room or when you’re talking about story, a lot of times the separate story lines, the plots and subplots, will be divided up into A story, B story, and C story.

A story being the primary plot, B story being the secondary, and C story being a tertiary, a third plot that sometimes is called a runner, which is a really short, small, not extremely developed story that sort of runs. Underneath everything. So when we’re talking about subplot, this is the language we’ll be using throughout the episode. A story is what, like I say, is the main plot of it, and it’s got a lot of story beats, and it’s the anchor of the whole piece. It’s what generally is the spine of the story. Sometimes the spine can be an event or a theme. And then the other plots and subplots come off of it, like in the case of, we’ll talk about later, Stranger Things Season 1.

But it’s easier to figure these out because through sort of naming it that, you sort of grade how much time you’re giving to each story. And as Devin talks about frequently, measurement is key, especially in this. That’s how you would determine how much time is being given to each of those plots, a primary plot, and then a second or third plot.

Devin: Measurement is key, but also the B story and A story need to support each other. And some measurement points kind of intertwine or they weave together or they cross paths and then maybe they separate again. But they need to be supportive, I guess. Is the best way or in close proximity, whenever I’m mentally thinking about or trying to visualize A story, B story, C story, I actually am always visualizing a, like, it looks like a lie detector test in a way. And so at some point, they’re all kind of doing their own thing, but at some points. Of the story they’re intersecting and they’re sure. Yeah. The A story is on top and B story, C story. And for me, the, the A story is, is like the quest of the call to quest or the, the adventure of the call to adventure. Like you just said, it’s more of like the plot, just the through line or the, like the main dramatic question of the whole story. Right.

The event that ultimately pulls our hero out of the, their comfort zone into, into the, the unknown world or the comfort zone of their known world into the discomfort of the unknown world. That’s, that’s essentially the, I haven’t used essentially for a while though. So I think that we can let that slide. No, you’re good. You’re safe. There’s like a five episode ban and then you’re good. So you’re good. All right, good. The B story is the emotional lens of the hero. It’s, it’s what adds depth and heart to the story. And it’s typically the story the audience will relate to in a way that makes our hero’s actions in the A story make sense.

And even the, the, the actions of the antagonist for that matter. But it’s, it’s what makes the actions of our hero make sense to us. It’s, it’s like, it’s the love interest or the friend or the buddy or, or, or a child or, or even a pet in some, some stories. And so for me, the B story is just, it’s a little. And it’s more of a metaphor for the A story, but it similar in theme and measurement. And so the, between the A story and the B story, and even the C story, I guess, in some regards, but they should support each other. And so the B story is often introduced. It can be introduced fairly early in within the key or inciting events. And I guess I’ll get.

Adam: In the, in the example, you’re, you’re sort of setting up here. It’s, they can, the B story can sometimes be introduced before even the A story. It can be introduced as the status quo or the ordinary world. Absolutely. The comfort zone. Yep. So like the guy, the person who is having trouble in a relationship and gets a new job and the new job is. It’s the A story, but the relationship they’ve been having trouble in is the B story. Absolutely. That gets resolved. But the way that you’re talking about it also is very, it’s, it’s very specific to sort of dimensions of a, of a character as an A story plot line. And sometimes you can use your B and C.

Stories much broader and more thematic, which it’s where it’s not even. Within the realm of the main character in the A story primary plot, like some of your broader things that are more ensemble like Lost or Game of Thrones or Walking Dead or things like that, you sort of have your A stories and your B stories. A lot of times you can go for more than A, B, and C storylines, but it’s usually long form television, long form storytelling that you get to do that with. But less than that, where it’s just a, you know, a novel or a film, you only have so much that you can do with it, you know, the film, the media in particular. So you’re sometimes in this larger ones, the ensemble, you’ll have what would seem like multiple A stories.

Devin: And even per episode, you’re following different A, B stories, like Lost. That’s exactly, yeah, exactly right.

Adam: So it gets much more complicated with. A season arc, and then you zoom into individual episodes that have their own mini arc that contribute to that larger season. It becomes more complicated. I didn’t want to get too far away from what you were addressing, though, which is the way Devin’s talking about subplot, and you can use it in a lot of different ways. That’s why this tool is, you know, doing tools here at the end of first season. It’s very versatile. You can use it to show various dimensions of a character. So here’s the characters. Here’s work life. Here’s their home life. Here’s the outside world.

Devin: External, internal.

Adam: Yeah, external, internal. And here’s even an unrelated thing where you can show the world that large, where it’s a secondary character and a glimpse into a secondary character or what the main character does affects that person. Of course, you’ve got the family. That’s usually the secondary plot, whether it’s a spouse or a child. Mm-hmm. They don’t have a good relationship with their kid. Well, that’s half the movies you see, and the other half is they don’t have a good relationship with their spouse. Right. And maybe a bad relationship with parent, but they’re working on that aspect while they’re trying to define themselves. And so the A story is generally about the individual, and the B story is about interpersonal relationship in a lot of ways.

But that’s specific to dimensions of a character. If you want to sort of show many facets. If you want to show many facets of your character, it’s a good way to do it.

Devin: Right. My thought process was, in that explanation, was more of a film, one-off film. Right. Not necessarily the series, so.

Adam: Agreed. Yeah, I might have stepped in too deep there. Right. But let’s use that same thing, though, connected to this, and we’ll talk about it in this simple form before we explore that larger ensemble thing. So a good example outside of just the film model that Devin’s talking about are TV procedurals, detective shows, cops and robbers. Where there’s a case of the week. It’s another good way in episodic, not necessarily long-form chapter-based storytelling, but episodic television. Each episode has a contained story, which is the case of the week. And a lot of these shows, because you spend time with the same characters week after week after week, they want to explore them in an arc.

And so the case of the week is the primary plot. And the B story ends up being Lieutenant So-and-so. Lieutenant So-and-so’s issue with one of the other people on the force. And there’s this thing they’ve got to deal with. And it shows up, usually most subplots have about three strong beats. And they have maybe some fill-in here and there, but beyond that you’re starting to create an A story, a larger story. And so you’ll see these things pop up periodically throughout a piece of episodic television or a film, as Devin’s saying. And they’re sort of the underbelly of the A story. They comment on. And you can use it, like he was saying, to show another aspect of character.

You can use it to highlight the theme. So whatever these two officers are going through is somehow relevant to the case of the week. This all has to do with the sub part, the underneath, the subtlety of it all. If you do it too overtly, you, I got to ban that word. I use it too damn much. That’s gone. See you later, overt. See you later. Just for five, just for five. You’re out of here. You’ll never work in this town again, kid.

Devin: And what you’re saying, kind of what you’re talking about is the B story actually deals with the motivation, I think.

Adam: What could do many things. You can use it as commentary on whatever the A story is. Explain motivation. Explain what you mean.

Devin: For instance, you could, like your example of the detective episodic weekly thing. Sure. You were looking at the two detectives and how they’re, what’s going on behind the scenes. They could have completely two different motivations that are allowing them to work together towards that one common goal, which is whatever that goal is for that episode. Which could be, so I mean, you could literally break this down. It almost becomes like molecular. Structure, if you actually want to dissect some of these stories, where it’s like the, you go from the A story down to the B1, B2 story, where there are two different stories, but they’re both B stories.

And then you can even dissect them more into B1, A, B1.

Adam: In that case, you would sort of just go A, B, your C story wouldn’t be a runner. Your C would be a subordinate plot. Yeah, you could actually, yeah, just spread it out. Yeah, you just in, that’s what ends up happening in like writer’s rooms and big, long episodic things. They just, they’ll go A through.

If your brain can handle that level of puzzling, go for it. But you got to make sure you’re tying all these loose ends up together. That’s the point. You know, say, Devin, I think you and I, probably the most we’ve done is A, B, and C in terms of stuff we’ve worked on together. Now, beyond that, I know we’ve done like double A, triple A, all A stories as an ensemble and things. But our heist thriller, that one, you’ve got the primary person of interest, the person that is thought to be the thief, and then you’ve got the person who’s following them, the law. And then the C story is really this underlying criminal element that wants the same thing. And so they’re in pursuit too. Each one comments on a level of the A story. Here are my two main things that I see that you use subplots for.

In one way, I use it for character. If the story’s main focus is a character, I use the A story as their journey and the B and C stories to comment. As you say, a lot of what you’re saying is important with the B story is it’s an emotional reflection. And then the other thing that I use subplots for is to show aspects of the theme at large. You know, an event can be the spine of the story and the theme are all the ways in which that or the I’m sorry, the subplots are all the different ways the plot and subplot are all the different ways in which that theme is explored.

Devin: Right. Or or the way the scenes explain like you. You’re using subplots to provide information about this world or provide these rules and tools, but in order to make it not seem jammed in or forced, develop subplots or sub characters within subplots that can provide that.

Adam: That information. But it seems like it fits. Well, and also what you’re saying there, that’s particularly helpful in the genres of fantasy and sci fi where you have. A world with different rules than we have in earth world, three-dimensional earth world. You need a way of explaining how this other world works and you don’t want to have it be an explanation. I can think of maybe one or two movies where an explanation scene actually worked and was exciting to watch. The matrix is one of them, but that’s probably the only one that comes to mind offhand. Most rules and tools scene, like as, as Devin referred to rules of the world, the tools you’ll use in your, journey in this world, you need to disguise them. You can’t just let them be the writer telling the audience what this world is about. So you have to invent interesting ways. One of the ways is to create a character whose job it is to do this thing in, in this world that’s unfamiliar. As your protagonist or hero negotiates with this person doing their day-to-day job. For instance, if you’re in a fantasy world, an innkeeper or a person who is at an ale house, It’s not a bar, it’s not a pub, it’s an alehouse. So with the questions they’re asking, the things that they’re pouring, all that stuff, all of a sudden sets up a world in a subplot manner with rules and tools, and as we discussed in a previous episode, a watering hole, where you sort of get an idea of the community of the new world that this protagonist is entering into.

So, I mean, that’s not necessarily subplot there, but if there was something to do with the innkeeper became an ally of your hero, and two or three other times throughout the story shows up to assist, that becomes a subplot. That would be the start of your subplot. But it helps to reflect the world sometimes too, as Devin is saying. B and C stories are really great for setting up fantasy and sci-fi, just a secondary job. Usually stories fall into like three major beats. Act one, act two, act three. Even your subplots still fall into these, like, this rhythmic, as Devin talked about, or talks about, his three O’s, objective, obstacle, outcome, or set up, complication, payoff.

Whatever you think of, you want to go one, two, three, one, two, three. Keep this rhythm in your head. And A, B, C, that’s why it’s three storylines. Three is a nice magic number for filling things out.

Devin: Isn’t a waltz three, like three step, three step waltz?

Adam: Yeah, yeah, yeah. That’s… That’s what I was doing. I was waltzing everybody. We were dancing, everyone. We were all dancing. Keep it simple. Three beats with an act, with a story, with a scene, with a subplot. Your A story will be the most in-depth because you’re exploring it more and putting more detail into it. But really strong use of B and C stories and subplots, you’ll have to do less work in your A story. Because you’ll… You can show an aspect or a reflection of your A story without making it preachy because it’s being experienced by another lens. And most A stories, they’ll start and finish either a piece of episodic television or a feature film.

Not always the case, but generally that’s how it works. You know, it’s the through line for your… But you can start with your B story or C story for a hook scene. You know, sometimes that happens. But generally your A story drives the… It’s the engine.

Devin: For me, it’s like you said. The A story is the through line. It’s the plot. B story or B stories are subplots. And then the C story for me is the actual transformation of the hero. And so I actually separate that out into… And more of a… I separate them out more for measurement purposes when trying to make sure that things… More of like a checks and balances. Type of thing. But for me, that’s the C story or it could be the D story. No matter where you’re going to put it. But it’s a story separate that needs to be measured in… And that is the character arc or the transformation of that character.

Adam: I would say that’s the A story for me. That’s the… If they’re driving the story, that would be… The C story for me is usually a runner. It’s very little involvement. A transformation is a big deal. I think… For me, that ends up being… That is what the A story is about. And it needs to be measured like you’re saying exactly. But C story is usually considered a runner. Like a really… Almost to the degree of like being a joke.

Devin: You know, I agree with that. I just… And for me, I guess it’s… Labeling it with an actual letter story is a bit… Could be a bit confusing. Sure. Especially for listeners right now.

Adam: I’m just defining those three as what most writers rooms and things deal with them as. As far as staples. But you’re right. You can proliferate it. You can make more of them.

Devin: And not necessarily make more of them. I think the more you make, it becomes harder to manage. But I think it’s more of the… I just look at the A story as making sure stuff’s happening. Like this is… And less of the… More of an external thing. So the A story is the external events that are happening. B story adds the emotional lens to our here. We see things through the emotional lens. And the C story is an internal thing in the transformation of it.

Adam: If it’s a single hero story, yeah.

Devin: If we’re not specifically talking about a specific story or media, type of media, like whether it’s film, episodic, short, limited series, novel, stuff like that, it’s hard for us to be… We’re talking… Sometimes we’re talking about two different types of stories that are going to have two different A, Bs and Cs. Sure.

Adam: This is what this is about. StoryOsophy, folks. StoryOsophy is about talking about these elements and philosophizing through them and hopefully we come to a new understanding or idea. For right now, what I’m saying is you’ve got this primary plot line. This is what the hero is going through and by the end they’ll transform. A secondary plot line either is a relationship they have with someone else or someone else’s story that informs or reflects that hero. And the third one is usually a more trivial thing, the runner, and it either comments loosely on those things in one of two ways. Either it’s a third or tertiary journey for that main character or it’s a third character that’s informing that main character’s journey.

As far as a solo character’s journey, that’s the way I see it. It has to be, to me, somewhat… It has to show a vision. It has to show a very different dimension of that main character so that those three storylines or the two storylines, a plot and a subplot, can dovetail together for that transformation. So all of them come together for a larger end goal in a way, dovetailing together. But that’s the way I see it for like a single character. There are ways of, I guess, moving it around. You know what I mean? Like for a solo character you can create a subplot out of anything.

But for me, that primary one is the transformation. The A. Because without those other two, the A can exist on its own without subplots. If you’re doing a two character piece and you’re just with those two characters before sunset, before sunrise, something like that, it’s only A story. There’s no subplot because you never leave this primary movement forward.

[Sponsor message]

Devin: In my mind, how I clarify, how I’m clarifying everything is external, emotional, internal. And so that’s where, and it’s literally all just for a measurement thing, measurement purposes for me in checks and balances. I could easily transition into your way of thinking by just implementing my C story into my, just calling it my A for checks and balances purposes. My, okay, there’s the A story that’s external. Stuff’s going on. This is the journey. This is the obstacles. A1 is making sure that that arc is happening. And it perhaps is just a mental thing for me when writing. Or it’s more of a, it’s just a measurement. I just want to make sure, like when I’m thinking about that lie detector test, that’s what I’m trying to think. I’m trying to see what’s happening with A, which is probably like, say that’s the needle on top. Whereas B is making sure that B either stays close to A, but also at some point intersects with A and then maybe even goes above A and that’s when we’re following, follow B a little bit more. And then C also measuring that to actually, follow or be related to both of them. So everything’s in proximity. Every, everything’s supporting the other at some point. And they’re all involved with each other, not just separate storylines.

Adam: The way I’m defining it is not necessarily the way that I would use it all the time. I’m merely defining the way that A, B, and C stories are used traditionally in scripting and building, like in writers’ rooms. This is what they call them, you know, primary, secondary, and runner. I’m not saying that’s the way to do it all the time. When creating pieces, it’s sort of like a lingo that’s most commonly used. Like you’re saying, you can make more subplots, you can dedicate them to specific elements or specific aspects or reflections. Like I say, I don’t subscribe to necessarily that. I’m just defining that via writers’ room stuff.

Exploring that further, I’m a fan of trying AAA stories where you’ve got three protagonists and that reflects on each other. Like, I love stories where you’ve got B, C, D, E, F stories because my storytelling and story-watching brain, I can handle that level. I love that. I love how stories are becoming more about groups of people and not the solo white knight concept in storytelling. Sort of what we’re basing our first season on, this traditional mythological epic storytelling angle, is sort of what we’re talking about right now. Here’s where I run into trouble, where we both run into trouble, is usually semantics. It is semantics. Because we’re trying to explore new concepts and you have to articulate it using the right verbiage.

But a lot of the verbiage has to do with the story. The verbiage has been co-opted and used already by previous philosophers. Aristotle, even writers’ tricks where they got tricks in their little tool bag they can just pull out at any moment and create tension in a scene. Some of the terminology that’s already used, like we’re talking about here with subplots with A, B, and C stories, if you talk to any writer who’s been working in the studio system, that’s how they’re going to define it. Primary, sub, and runner, because that’s the way that the studio model functions. So in order to keep getting recurring work, you speak the same language.

Right. If you’re looking to explore outside of that and try innovation in story and do something really different, you get the concepts and then you sort of turn them off so you can invent a new. The tightrope that we walk here in StoryOsophy is we are talking about storytelling models that have existed for a long time, but we’re philosophizing about where they can go. So we have to repurpose language a lot. In doing so, sometimes that gets confusing. Our connotation, denotation stuff gets a little off. As long as at the end of an episode, Devin has said something that inspires me to a new thought, I’m excited.

And I hope that by the end of an episode, you, StoryOsophers, have at least gleaned one thing where you finish the episode and you go, okay, I hadn’t thought of it like that before. Even if our semantics or connotation, denotation get in the way sometimes.

Devin: Semantics has always been between you and I, that’s always been somewhat where we end up being on different rails. And I think that’s, but that’s also a… I think that’s a big part of the mission behind or why we’re doing something, why we’re even doing this is where we can provide the traditional semantics, but also traditional rules and ways of doing things within the industry. But it’s fun for me to also learn about how other people go about doing things and how, and if it, sometimes it makes sense to me, sometimes it doesn’t. So that’s why I’ll also try to interject. Well, for me, this is kind of the way that I’m interpreting, I’ve interpreted this.

Yeah, yeah, yeah. And then I’m also, but this is how I do it. It may make sense and you may be, or people may be listening and being like, God, this guy’s an idiot. I would never do it that way. I have a couple examples of the B story coming before the A story. We’re introducing the B story before the A story. Oh, let’s do it. Die Hard. Nice. The A story is obvious, the takeover of the skyscraper by Hans Gruber and his German terrorist group. However, the story… Yeah. The story begins through the emotional lens of Bruce Willis’s character, John McClane, with him traveling to California in an attempt to get his family back, who at this point, we don’t necessarily know too much background, but we understand enough that he’s either done something or been someone that they don’t necessarily agree with at this point.

So we’re kind of, we’re, we’re quickly provided with, with the B story, the emotion of, of John McClane’s character, kind of right off the bat. And, and, and that allows us to relate to him quickly and, but also to relate to his family or, or if, if we’ve been in a situation similar to, on any side of the table with, with what’s going on, whether it’s… Whether we’re relating to John McClane’s character or his family or a little bit of both. And then of course the terrorists take over the building and we jump into the A story, the plot, the main plot, the spine.

Adam: It dovetails them together. Yeah. Because the wife is the hostage too, like you’re saying. Right. Because that happens, now your B and your A story become one. Here’s what’s great about that too is your B story starts to show the side of your terrorists because we’re getting it through the lens of the wife a lot of the time. Right, right. Here are the hostage and the terrorists are right next to them. Seeing the bad guys, you’re seeing the wife too, and she’s right in the immediate danger. And then you’ve got the A story which is Bruce Willis just kicking butt to get to the wife and save everybody because he’s an action star.

Devin: Right, and it’s an interesting setup. Agreed. It intensifies the reasoning, I guess, for John McClane’s character. We know John McClane’s character, no matter what, will act. He is, he’s a New York cop or detective. He’s an action hero. He works. He will act. Yeah, he’s gonna take action. However, the writer amps up the tension and the reasoning for him to get involved with his wife being involved as one of the hostages. However, there’s probably maybe this, like a version of it may have been, she isn’t involved with it. She’s at home watching it on TV, but she, so she’s still seeing this side of John McClane that she hadn’t seen before.

Maybe that was the reasoning behind, like, they’re just not getting along or the type of person he is. And so, but by taking him, by taking her and putting her in harm’s way and actually as a hostage, it kind of amps that up a little bit. And I mean, this is a side note and an issue I have with Armageddon, but this is another example of another character besides Bruce Willis’ character in Armageddon and Ben Affleck’s character being, being the A story is, Okay. I wish, now I don’t know the guy’s name, but one of the other characters is, is in a kind of a similar situation to this, but he has his own B story where he shows up and, and he sees his kid who doesn’t know who he is.

And he hands him like this space shuttle. And then this lady comes out and says, you can’t, you know, you can’t be here. You can’t, you can’t show up like this. And he’s like, I know, I know. He’s like, I just wanted to give him this. I just wanted to give him the shuttle. And so clearly ex-wife, that’s his. That’s, or we’re not supposed to know it’s his son right away, but we’re kind of figuring it out. She clearly doesn’t want anything to do with him. And then you switch to the moment where she, she’s on the phone and the kid sees the salesman. She’s cause she called him a salesman.

She said, Hey mom, that salesman’s on TV. And it’s him walking out to the shuttle about, you know, to go up to save the world. That’s when she decides, she’s like, that’s not a salesman. That’s, that’s your father.

Adam: Set a payoff too.

Devin: Yeah, exactly. Yeah. And it’s like, you can actually see the. You could see where, had they made that decision with Die Hard, where she’s just maybe watching things unfold. And then it could, you could have still had that same, you know, the same ending and everything could have been the same. But, but that’s just a way of amping it up for, for that movie.

Adam: By including her in the, in the mix of it. Yeah. So in Armageddon, isn’t that the, that dude doesn’t make it, right?

Devin: Yeah, he makes it.

Adam: Oh, he does?

Devin: She shows up at the end when they get back. With the kid. And the kid runs up to him. Okay. I mean. And, and, and I had a little issue with that because you’re like, oh, the dude’s got to literally go save the planet before you tell your kid that that’s your dad.

Adam: I was going to say this about Die Hard too. Here’s the reason why this whole situation is important. She doesn’t think that he cares about her or the family. That’s the issue with Holly Gennero and John McClane. That’s the issue. That’s her maiden name. So she lets you know, I don’t want to be involved with that dude. But that’s the thing. She wants to know he cares. Die Hard is a groundbreaking action movie, but at the same time, it’s literally the white knight saving the princess. It’s the damsel in distress. It’s this, it’s, it’s the same thing. So to show he cares, I mean, the way I show I, I care to a girlfriend is to kill all the terrorists.

That’s how I do it. But I don’t know how everybody else does it. That’s the way to do it. It’s a good way to do it. Talking about subplot and characters, and it’s good to differentiate between the two. But Die Hard. Almost doesn’t do that. And I’m going to explain. It’s got sort of A, B, C, and D storylines. So your A storyline is the whole action plot of the terrorist takeover and the guy single-handedly taking them out. That’s your plot. Your B story, as Devin says, is John McClane’s personal life. That’s the best way to put it. So his emotional discord with wife and kids, and the kids don’t really know it because they’re young, but the wife is angry that he’s not spending time with her or the kids. He’s not caring or doesn’t pay attention. So there’s emotional discord.

And of course, Bruce Willis is, you know, a hardened dude, per usual. And so his tough guy persona, it’s like, that’s what he’s chosen to do. He’s chosen to do what he’s chosen to do. He’s chosen work over family. A lot of premises for plots. Now, your C and D story, ignoring the concept of a runner, let’s say in a TV show, your C and D story are two things. The terrorists in the building, the terrorist cell, and what they’re doing, and the police and FBI outside. So there’s two other plotlines running. Right. And they all have depth, but they ground periodically. Every once in a while, you get Theo in there, who’s taking care of the electronic vault.

So you know it’s a money heist now. And that plot develops slowly. That subplot develops slowly. That’s the terrorist plot. And Bruce Willis’s wife in the scenario is part of that plotline. So B and C sort of intermingle. And then D, Officer Powell, who’s contending with the FBI and John’s only ally on the ground outside. So Die Hard is a much more complex movie than I think people realize. It was really well put together. Right. People love it. They enjoy it. But I don’t think they realize how cleverly thought out it is. Because you’re right, that writer could have made a lazy decision to have the wife at home and go, oh my gosh, my husband, who’s supposed to be here for Christmas, is stuck in that building. And he’s the only hope they have. That’s interesting, but it’s not nearly as interesting as her being one of the hostages in the building. Much better choice, as Devin said.

Right. Interesting subplots for that one. When you said it, I realized that they do break it up into like four different bits.

Devin: It’s similar to The Greatest Showman that you and I were kind of talking about earlier, where I read so many, even before I saw it, I read so many critic reviews that were not very friendly to it. But for many reasons, and some of them are legit reasons, but one I kept kind of recurring critique of it was there was like zero story. I had no story. What? After I watched it, I was, again, I was like, sure, it’s not going to win. It’s not going to go down in the annals of history of like one of the greatest stories ever written. No, but it has something to say right now that’s important.

Right. And it has a lot of what that we talked about throughout this, even this first season that has a lot of that in it. And I think we see a lot of that B story first with that too. It’s about a guy who thinks he knows what he wants. He gets it. And in this like Wizard of Oz-ian fashion, realizes what he really wanted was in front of what he had all the time. And so, and this blind, this blindness that a lot of people have in stories, but also in life, when they’re chasing after something that they seem to, they can’t, it’s this unattainable thing.

Need to prove something to themselves. Yeah. And so I think, and so there’s like this, there’s a great, there’s a good. There’s a good story there, I think. So I think that’s where I was like, what?

Adam: There’s also a delineated plot and subplot. Hugh Jackman, plot. Zac Efron, subplot. Right. Because Hugh Jackman is driving the show. Literally, he’s the ringmaster and he’s, and you know what? I am going to take this for a little bit just because it’s a good example of what we’re doing in a very simplistic form. So Hugh Jackman runs the circus. That’s the A story, the plot, and he’s trying to be successful. In a way, he’s trying to show up Michelle Williams’ parents. They’re the… Right. Well-to-do family. And I’m not spoiling anything about this movie, but as a child, he was poor and her father struck him across the face and called he and his father poor. So there’s this vendetta. There’s a, it’s almost a revenge plot, even though it’s not dark or anything.

Mm-hmm. There’s a revenge plot in his heart. He wants to prove to them that he is not poor, he’s worthy. And that’s everything that Devin and I have talked about. Number one goal in any story is a character’s self-worth. Yeah. That’s their journey, period.

Devin: Right.

Adam: And so… Exactly. You’ve got this guy who’s self-worth. That’s his main through line. That’s the main plot of it is this guy. And we know he’s worth it already because he’s a dreamer and he loves his wife. Mm-hmm. It’s just he gets blinded by needing to prove that he’s not poor, that he’s of value. Now, his whole journey, ironically, he doesn’t see this about himself to the end of the story, of course. No, not too many spoilers on this one. But throughout the whole movie, he sees the worth and value of every other undervalued person. That’s the irony of his whole story. Right. Is all these people that you would call, quote, circus freaks, the people who are abnormal, the people who are different, the people who other people have kept in shadows, he has such an open heart for that. I mean, guaranteed, is he being exploitative? Yeah, they explore that a little bit. But the fact is, these people are finally able to just be themselves in a family that makes sense to them.

Right. And so, he builds this family of people who are lacking self-worth into a family of worth in not just emotional context and psychological context for these people, but financial context for everybody. Meanwhile, he can’t get a grasp on it for himself until the end of the movie. Now, it is a movie. But, I mean, it’s a really well-built movie. And if it got critical panning, it, you know, it is what it is. It’s a musical. Right. It’s fun. Either you like them or you don’t.

Devin: Exactly. And I’m not a huge musical fan. And I’m also not. I’m also not, but I saw the story right when I was watching it. I’m like, wow. This is a really, they’re hitting it. I mean, they’re, I’m following this and I’m engaged. I was really, I was really engaged. It’s interesting while you were, while you were talking, I was actually thinking about it, how he’s always had a chip on his shoulder. Yeah. And so, when he’s a young, he’s young, he’s poor, it’s almost a revenge or not a revenge. It is where he wants to prove, he wants to prove that he is. Yes. He is worthy of one, his daughter.

Michelle Williams. Yeah. And then he’s going to prove that he can provide her with a life better. I think he even says it better than the one that she had growing up. And so he does that, like you said, with these, with these misfits and these, these freaks, well from the freak show. But then it’s interesting in a way, because then he even leaves them because of the chip, even when he’s successful with them, that chip doesn’t go away because he then meets that Swedish opera singer. Yeah. And what he sees in Jenny Lind is like, this is what I still haven’t obtained this validation. This, she’s my testimony to.

Being legit and this talented businessman that can, that has an eye for true talent. And I’m not just, I’m not just a fake who sells tickets to a freak show in a circus. And then that’s kind of where, through that journey, where he does, he figures out that what he really wants and that kind of, you know, what, you know, it’s, it’s not about this. It’s about them. It’s about my family and boat. And, and it’s interesting too, from Michelle Williams’ character’s standpoint, his wife, and she even, there’s even a song about it. And where she doesn’t care about any of that. She just is like, it’s like true love for him. She’s like, I don’t need this big house. And he’s like, but it’s bigger than your parents, you know?

So it’s like, it’s interesting where they’re not ever on the same level. He never really hears her. And so it’s like, until the end where he’s like, oh, boom, that’s what it is. Like, it’s doesn’t, it’s not about the money. It’s about love. It’s a love and family story. So interesting. An interesting tangent.

Adam: I mean, it’s pretty simple. Like I’m not going to. Yeah, very. I applaud it for it being a terribly original storyline. Not a lot of twists and turns. No, it’s a, I mean, there are, there are good twists and turns, you know, with, yeah, I don’t want to go into the stuff that happens because I don’t want to spoil it. There’s no reason to for this. It’s simple. It’s a man, it’s a man’s ambition versus his family. It’s every other story you’ve seen. It’s not a new storyline, but the way they do it, and it’s a musical, so it’s spectacle. So the spectacle they create, they did a good job.

I, I, there’s two particular scenes in it that were amazing to me. So subplot for this story, that’s your A story. Your B story is Zac Efron. Zac Efron comes in late in the story as a character. So that’s an interesting way of bringing in a B story is your B story comes in to sort of amp up your A story. And in this case, he’s looking for a financial guy who’s also in with the highbrow crowd. And how can I get the high class of society to come to this circus of, you know, freaks and strange people? And, you know, how do I do that? And so Zac Efron debates it. He’s got his own call to adventure, you know, the B story, Zac Efron.

When he comes in, Zac Efron’s story, the subplot, he falls in love with a trapeze artist who is not from high class society. So in that time period, that’s his struggle. He loves this woman, but his parents can’t have it. Okay. Once again, we talk about. About how subplot reflects plot. You have this forbidden love story via class.

Devin: And race.

Adam: High class, low class can’t be together. Well, that’s the main plot, folks. That’s the whole main plot. That’s Hugh Jackman’s entire life. Yeah. Is being a poor kid who can’t measure up to this rich daughter’s approval. And she loves him from the day she meets him. But he can’t get it because he still feels like the poor kid. He feels like the poor kid who was disrespected and embarrassed by her father. In front of her. And so his whole life, he feels like he has to make this up. Well, then you got your subplot, the exact opposite. The guy who is his business partner is the high class guy.

Right. And then the low-class trapeze artist, he loves her. And there is, I can’t believe we went off on this topic because it wasn’t even either of our examples, but it’s so good for this episode. It’s so good. The one thing I would say that there’s two scenes, two musicals, one where he’s trying to recruit Zac Efron, great scene. Just the choreography and the zip of it, it’s so fast and amazing. And the other one is when Zac Efron, and I can’t remember the character’s or the actress’s name who plays the trapeze artist.

Devin: Zendaya.

Adam: They do an entire song on her trapeze rope. And it may just go by and be like, I didn’t like the song or whatever. But if you know anything about film production, you have got to just sit in awe of it. You have to. Because the combination of the rope work they’re doing where they get zipped in the air and they spin around the ring and he jumps onto her. And they, I mean, there’s crazy choreography that goes on with just the trapeze moves and stunts and rope work. So there’s not only that, but now you got the camera following all that, capturing it in a dynamic way that makes you feel like you’re on the rope with them.

And then let’s add on the fact that they got to sing a song while they’re doing it.

Devin: Right.

Adam: And repeat. Go back to one, take two, take three, take 20 million. To get this moment right, even if I’m not a fan of musicals, I can look at that and go, beautiful. What a brilliantly executed piece of work that was. But I mean, there’s performances in there that are great. And even subtextually, when Zac Efron is there at a very high class event, and he’s with the trapeze artist Zendaya, and you just see their hands, their faces are stoic, and their hands touch, and they hold hands. And it’s beautiful. It’s really subtle. Mm-hmm. Yeah. It’s the underbelly of the whole story as far as their love interest. And then his parents notice, and he lets go of her hand. Breaks your heart. It’s a heartbreaking moment.

Devin: Yeah.

Adam: But that, symbolically, that little subtextual, never-spoken moment, which is once again what Devin was saying about subtext translating to screen, that cannot be as strong in a novel as it is on that screen. Right. Exactly. Because the pain on her face that she can’t show anybody else. It’s just in her eyes. It’s just in the drop of her expression. When he lets go of her hand, it’s brutal. Mm-hmm. It encapsulates everything about plot and subplot in just that symbolic moment right there.

Devin: I think the other thing that gets lost in that film, because even in that scene in particular, is the action that’s happening on screen is going along with the music. And sometimes it’s very obvious and deliberate. Yeah. But the words that are being sung by that Jenny Lind, because that’s the scene where that’s Swedish opera. Yeah. All hearing her for the first time. Unbelievable, too. What she’s singing is what’s happening with those two. And so it’s very, and even in the scene you talked about before with when he’s recruiting Zac Efron’s character, the beats, it’s a waltz. Not only is it a musical, but everything they’re doing is in, even just putting the shot glasses down, they’re doing it to the beat of the music.

And so it’s like, there’s a lot of things that maybe at first glance, you’re just like, oh, it’s just a musical singing. But if you actually look at, like you said, the choreography and the work, the amount of work, just appreciate anybody that’s been on a movie set when you, the hurry up and wait and all the hours that people probably don’t realize the amount of time that goes into just doing a scene, a dialogue scene. Imagine the choreography and the timing to do something like that. That’s when you start really appreciating what they’re actually able to, like you said, do on screen, which doesn’t necessarily translate as well in a novel or something like that.

Adam: That is the amazing part of that whole thing is you look at it and you’re like, wow, that was pretty cool. And then if you’re in any way involved in the industry, you look at it and you go, the amount of preparation and rehearsal and timing to make that look so effortless. It just blows your mind.

Devin: They started working on that movie in 2008. Yeah. Like, I don’t know, not necessarily production. Production wasn’t there, but like writing the music and getting together.

Adam: Cast and music and yeah, yeah, yeah. Well, now that we’ve just pulled up one of an example that was neither of our examples. Well, StoryOsophers, we will continue our discussion about subplot next week with more examples on how to juggle A, B and C storylines and an examination of the subplots and spines of seasons one and two of Stranger Things. Tune in next week. Please subscribe and rate us on iTunes and for additional story related resources, video and archived content, visit our website at StoryOsophy.com.